Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Warming turns conflict

Climate change causes huge resource wars [and nuclear prolif]

Klare 2006 (Michael Klare, professor of peace and world security studies at Hampshire College, March 10, 2006, “The Coming Resource Wars,” http://goo.gl/sPH9D)

It's official: the era of resource wars is upon us. In a major London address, British Defense Secretary John Reid warned that global climate change and dwindling natural resources are combining to increase the likelihood of violent conflict over land, water and energy. Climate change, he indicated, "will make scarce resources, clean water, viable agricultural land even scarcer" -- and this will "make the emergence of violent conflict more rather than less likely." Although not unprecedented, Reid's prediction of an upsurge in resource conflict is significant both because of his senior rank and the vehemence of his remarks. "The blunt truth is that the lack of water and agricultural land is a significant contributory factor to the tragic conflict we see unfolding in Darfur," he declared. "We should see this as a warning sign." Resource conflicts of this type are most likely to arise in the developing world, Reid indicated, but the more advanced and affluent countries are not likely to be spared the damaging and destabilizing effects of global climate change. With sea levels rising, water and energy becoming increasingly scarce and prime agricultural lands turning into deserts, internecine warfare over access to vital resources will become a global phenomenon. Reid's speech, delivered at the prestigious Chatham House in London (Britain's equivalent of the Council on Foreign Relations), is but the most recent expression of a growing trend in strategic circles to view environmental and resource effects -- rather than political orientation and ideology -- as the most potent source of armed conflict in the decades to come. With the world population rising, global consumption rates soaring, energy supplies rapidly disappearing and climate change eradicating valuable farmland, the stage is being set for persistent and worldwide struggles over vital resources. Religious and political strife will not disappear in this scenario, but rather will be channeled into contests over valuable sources of water, food and energy. Prior to Reid's address, the most significant expression of this outlook was a report prepared for the U.S. Department of Defense by a California-based consulting firm in October 2003. Entitled "An Abrupt Climate Change Scenario and Its Implications for United States National Security," the report warned that global climate change is more likely to result in sudden, cataclysmic environmental events than a gradual (and therefore manageable) rise in average temperatures. Such events could include a substantial increase in global sea levels, intense storms and hurricanes and continent-wide "dust bowl" effects. This would trigger pitched battles between the survivors of these effects for access to food, water, habitable land and energy supplies. "Violence and disruption stemming from the stresses created by abrupt changes in the climate pose a different type of threat to national security than we are accustomed to today," the 2003 report noted. "Military confrontation may be triggered by a desperate need for natural resources such as energy, food and water rather than by conflicts over ideology, religion or national honor." Until now, this mode of analysis has failed to command the attention of top American and British policymakers. For the most part, they insist that ideological and religious differences -- notably, the clash between values of tolerance and democracy on one hand and extremist forms of Islam on the other -- remain the main drivers of international conflict. But Reid's speech at Chatham House suggests that a major shift in strategic thinking may be under way. Environmental perils may soon dominate the world security agenda. This shift is due in part to the growing weight of evidence pointing to a significant human role in altering the planet's basic climate systems. Recent studies showing the rapid shrinkage of the polar ice caps, the accelerated melting of North American glaciers, the increased frequency of severe hurricanes and a number of other such effects all suggest that dramatic and potentially harmful changes to the global climate have begun to occur. More importantly, they conclude that human behavior -- most importantly, the burning of fossil fuels in factories, power plants, and motor vehicles -- is the most likely cause of these changes. This assessment may not have yet penetrated the White House and other bastions of head-in-the-sand thinking, but it is clearly gaining ground among scientists and thoughtful analysts around the world. For the most part, public discussion of global climate change has tended to describe its effects as an environmental problem -- as a threat to safe water, arable soil, temperate forests, certain species and so on. And, of course, climate change is a potent threat to the environment; in fact, the greatest threat imaginable. But viewing climate change as an environmental problem fails to do justice to the magnitude of the peril it poses. As Reid's speech and the 2003 Pentagon study make clear, the greatest danger posed by global climate change is not the degradation of ecosystems per se, but rather the disintegration of entire human societies, producing wholesale starvation, mass migrations and recurring conflict over resources. "As famine, disease, and weather-related disasters strike due to abrupt climate change," the Pentagon report notes, "many countries' needs will exceed their carrying capacity" -- that is, their ability to provide the minimum requirements for human survival. This "will create a sense of desperation, which is likely to lead to offensive aggression" against countries with a greater stock of vital resources. "Imagine eastern European countries, struggling to feed their populations with a falling supply of food, water, and energy, eyeing Russia, whose population is already in decline, for access to its grain, minerals, and energy supply." Similar scenarios will be replicated all across the planet, as those without the means to survival invade or migrate to those with greater abundance -- producing endless struggles between resource "haves" and "have-nots." It is this prospect, more than anything, that worries John Reid. In particular, he expressed concern over the inadequate capacity of poor and unstable countries to cope with the effects of climate change, and the resulting risk of state collapse, civil war and mass migration. "More than 300 million people in Africa currently lack access to safe water," he observed, and "climate change will worsen this dire situation" -- provoking more wars like Darfur. And even if these social disasters will occur primarily in the developing world, the wealthier countries will also be caught up in them, whether by participating in peacekeeping and humanitarian aid operations, by fending off unwanted migrants or by fighting for access to overseas supplies of food, oil, and minerals. When reading of these nightmarish scenarios, it is easy to conjure up images of desperate, starving people killing one another with knives, staves and clubs -- as was certainly often the case in the past, and could easily prove to be so again. But these scenarios also envision the use of more deadly weapons. "In this world of warring states," the 2003 Pentagon report predicted, "nuclear arms proliferation is inevitable." As oil and natural gas disappears, more and more countries will rely on nuclear power to meet their energy needs -- and this "will accelerate nuclear proliferation as countries develop enrichment and reprocessing capabilities to ensure their national security." Although speculative, these reports make one thing clear: when thinking about the calamitous effects of global climate change, we must emphasize its social and political consequences as much as its purely environmental effects. Drought, flooding and storms can kill us, and surely will -- but so will wars among the survivors of these catastrophes over what remains of food, water and shelter. As Reid's comments indicate, no society, however affluent, will escape involvement in these forms of conflict.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Warming turns conflict

Climate Turns it- newest studies prove.

Stanford University, 6-12-2019, "Does climate change cause armed conflict?," Stanford News, , Xoxo 7/14/2020

Intensifying climate change will increase the future risk of violent armed conflict within countries, according to a study published today in the journal Nature. Synthesizing views across experts, the study estimates climate has influenced between 3% and 20% of armed conflict risk over the last century and that the influence will likely increase dramatically. A new study synthesizing views from experts across several fields indicates climate change will have an increasing impact on the risk of armed conflict. In a scenario with 4 degrees Celsius of warming (approximately the path we’re on if societies do not substantially reduce emissions of heat-trapping gases), the influence of climate on conflicts would increase more than five times, leaping to a 26% chance of a substantial increase in conflict risk, according to the study. Even in a scenario of 2 degrees Celsius of warming beyond preindustrial levels – the stated goal of the Paris Climate Agreement­ – the influence of climate on conflicts would more than double, rising to a 13% chance. “Appreciating the role of climate change and its security impacts is important not only for understanding the social costs of our continuing heat-trapping emissions, but for prioritizing responses, which could include aid and cooperation,” said Katharine Mach, director of the Stanford Environment Assessment Facility and the study’s lead author. Climate change-driven extreme weather and related disasters can damage economies, lower farming and livestock production and intensify inequality among social groups. These factors, when combined with other drivers of conflict, may increase risks of violence. “Knowing whether environmental or climatic changes are important for explaining conflict has implications for what we can do to reduce the likelihood of future conflict, as well as for how to make well-informed decisions about how aggressively we should mitigate future climate change,” said Marshall Burke, assistant professor of Earth system science and a co-author on the study.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › A2 We Can Adapt to Warming

Adaptation fails

JRC 16 (Joint Research Centre is the European Commission's science and knowledge service which employs scientists to carry out research in order to provide independent scientific advice and support to EU policy. August 11, 2016 https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/08/160811101332.htm)

Global change will strike the oldest and most complex ecosystems of the world hardest, regardless of their past stability. This alarming finding is reported in a JRC-led article published in Nature Communications. The authors hypothesized that invasive species, the warming climate and environmental degradation have altered natural habitats so deeply that species adaptation to historical conditions may not be helpful under these new circumstances. Interestingly, the authors found independent support for this hypothesis from both computer simulations and real-world data. Starting from a single ancestor digital organism, the authors let artificial life communities evolve for hundreds of thousands of generations under different, stable environmental settings. These simulated communities included both free-living and 'parasite' digital organisms that helped researchers investigate how biodiversity and ecological networks develop over time, under different environmental conditions. Over several generations, both hosts and parasites diversified, and their interactions became more complex. The authors then investigated how these communities would respond to different scenarios of biodiversity loss. They found that when species become extinct in a sequence consistent with their degree of adaptation to the 'natural' environmental conditions within which they had evolved, their extinction has only a limited effect on the overall diversity of the community. Any deviation from this pattern however, may trigger extinction cascades, eventually leading to the collapse of the entire network. The tendency of consuming species to rely and specialise (develop in a way most suited to the environment) on dependable resources has enabled the evolution of complex systems. This basic mechanism may have doomed many species to extinction -- the authors demonstrate it by comparing the results of their artificial life simulations with several empirical host-parasite networks of different animal groups. Resources that had been largely available in the past are now becoming increasingly scarce, putting at risk the species that rely on them.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › A2 Warming inevitable

Not inevitable – cuts now have an IMMEDIATE effect

Desjardins 13 (Cléa, member of Concordia university Media Relations Department, academic writer, citing Damon Matthews; associate professor of the Department of Geography, Planning and Environment at Concordia University, PhD, Member of the Global Environmental and Climate Change Center, “Global Warming: Irreversible but Not Inevitable,” http://www.concordia.ca/now/what-we-do/research/20130402/global-warming-irreversible-but-not-inevitable.php)

Carbon dioxide emission cuts will immediately affect the rate of future global warming Concordia and MIT researchers show Montreal, April 2, 2013 – There is a persistent misconception among both scientists and the public that there is a delay between emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) and the climate’s response to those emissions. This misconception has led policy makers to argue that CO2 emission cuts implemented now will not affect the climate system for many decades. This erroneous line of argument makes the climate problem seem more intractable than it actually is, say Concordia University’s Damon Matthews and MIT’s Susan Solomon in a recent Science article. The researchers show that immediate decreases in CO2 emissions would in fact result in an immediate decrease in the rate of climate warming. Explains Matthews, professor in the Department of Geography, Planning and Environment, “If we can successfully decrease CO2 emissions in the near future, this change will be felt by the climate system when the emissions reductions are implemented – not in several decades." “The potential for a quick climate response to prompt cuts in CO2 emissions opens up the possibility that the climate benefits of emissions reductions would occur on the same timescale as the political decisions themselves.” In their paper, Matthews and Solomon, Ellen Swallow Richards professor of Atmospheric Chemistry and Climate Science, show that the onus for slowing the rate of global warming falls squarely on current efforts at reducing CO2 emissions, and the resulting future emissions that we produce. This means that there are critical implications for the equity of carbon emission choices currently being discussed internationally. Total emissions from developing countries may soon exceed those from developed nations. But developed countries are expected to maintain a far higher per-capita contribution to present and possible future warming. “This disparity clarifies the urgency for low-carbon technology investment and diffusion to enable developing countries to continue to develop,” says Matthews. “Emission cuts made now will have an immediate effect on the rate of global warming,” he asserts. “I see more hope for averting difficult-to-avoid negative impacts by accelerating advances in technology development and diffusion, than for averting climate system changes that are already inevitable. Given the enormous scope and complexity of the climate mitigation challenge, clarifying these points of hope is critical to motivate change.”

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block Climate Overview (Warming = Ext)

Any delay in implementation puts us at risk

March 15 2023 Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2023/03/15/bipartisan-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisma-political-unicorn/?sh=5e657edc68df

As other low-emission countries begin to use the CBAM, any delay in implementation could put US trade at a considerable disadvantage. Joining the CBAM initiative would place the United States at the forefront of global climate leadership and set a strong example of a modern sustainable economy while countering the environmental impact of global emissions from industrial production. This shared initiative would also likely strengthen diplomatic and trade relations with the EU by streamlining trade and climate policy in the transatlantic region. As the EU is virtue signaling its stalwart support for CBAM, proposing it in the US may also make it a valuable bargaining chip in future trade talks with Brussels.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block Climate Overview (Warming = Ext)

Irreversibility is the metric for weighing impacts- any other impact has a chance of the world returning

Sunstein 2007 Cass R.—Professor in the Department of Political Science and at the Law School of the University of Chicago (“Worst-Case Scenarios”, Harvard University Press)

Most worst-case scenarios appear to have an element of irreversibility. Once a species is lost, it is lost forever. The special concern for endangered species stems from the permanence of their loss (outside of Jurassic Park). One of the most serious fears associated with genetically modified organisms is that they might lead to irreversible ecological harm. Because some greenhouse gases stay in the atmosphere for centuries, the problem of climate change may be irreversible, at least for all practical purposes. Transgenic crops can impose irreversible losses too, because they can make pests more resistant to pesticides. If we invest significant wealth in one source of energy and neglect others, we may be effectively stuck forever, or at least for a long time. One objection to capital punishment is that errors cannot be reversed. In ordinary life, our judgments about worst-case scenarios have everything to do with irreversibility. Of course an action may be hard but not impossible to undo, and so there may be a continuum of cases, with different degrees of difficulty in reversing. A marriage can be reversed, but divorce is rarely easy; having a child is very close to irreversible; moving from New York to Paris is reversible, but moving back may be difficult. People often take steps to avoid courses of action that are burdensome rather than literally impossible to reverse. In this light, we might identify an Irreversible Harm Precautionary Principle, applicable to a subset of risks.' As a rough first approximation, the principle says this: Special steps should be taken to avoid irreversible harms, through precautions that go well beyond those that would be taken if irreversibility were not a problem. The general attitude here is "act, then learn," as opposed to the tempting alternative of "wait and learn." In the case of climate change, some people believe that research should be our first line of defense. In their view, we should refuse to commit substantial resources to the problem until evidence of serious harm is unmistakably clear.' But even assuming that the evidence is not so clear, research without action allows greenhouse gas emissions to continue, which might produce risks that are irreversible, or at best difficult and expensive to reverse. For this reason, the best course of action might well be to take precautions now as a way of preserving flexibility for future generations. In the environmental context in general, this principle suggests that regulators should proceed with far more aggressive measures than would otherwise seem justified.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block Climate Overview (Warming = Ext)

Warming outweighs the case---its irreversible and exacerbates biodiversity loss, conflict, disease

Torres 16 (Phil Torres; author, Affiliate Scholar @ Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, founder of the X-Risks Institute, published articles for Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, Salon, Journal of Future Studies, and the Journal of Evolution and Technology; 7-22-2016, "Op-ed: Climate Change Is the Most Urgent Existential Risk," FLI - Future of Life Institute, http://futureoflife.org/2016/07/22/climate-change-is-the-most-urgent-existential-risk/, accessed 8-9-2016)

For example, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the effects of climate change will be “severe,” “pervasive,” and “irreversible.” Or, as published in Nature and authored by over twenty scientists puts it, the consequences of climate change “will extend longer than the entire history of human civilization thus far.” Furthermore, in Science Advances confirms that humanity has already escorted the biosphere into the sixth mass extinction event in life’s 3.8 billion year history on Earth. Yet suggests that we could be approaching a sudden, irreversible, catastrophic collapse of the global ecosystem. If this were to occur, it could result in “widespread social unrest, economic instability and loss of human life.” Given the potential for environmental degradation to elevate the likelihood of nuclear wars, nuclear terrorism, engineered pandemics, a superintelligence takeover, and perhaps even an , it ought to take precedence over all other risk concerns — at least in the near-term. Let’s make sure we get our priorities straight.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block – Internal Link Extension – Solves Warming

Bipartisan support for a carbon border adjustment mechanism and it will incentivize reductions in emissions, solving warming.

March 15 2023 Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2023/03/15/bipartisan-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisma-political-unicorn/?sh=5e657edc68df

A Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) allows a country to impose a price on carbon emitted during the production of goods in the country of origin as import fees, thus incentivizing greener manufacturing. This has been a perennial aspiration of environmentalists for decades that once languished in obscurity but is now rapidly becoming policy. Now, this step forward in climate policy may be legislated with bipartisan support in the US Congress, with far-reaching implications not just for the environment but the international economy.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Block – Internal Link Extension – Solves Warming

The PROVE IT Act will elevate climate leadership and reduce global emissions

March 15 2023 Bipartisan Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism - A Political Unicorn? https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2023/03/15/bipartisan-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisma-political-unicorn/?sh=5e657edc68df

As other low-emission countries begin to use the CBAM, any delay in implementation could put US trade at a considerable disadvantage. Joining the CBAM initiative would place the United States at the forefront of global climate leadership and set a strong example of a modern sustainable economy while countering the environmental impact of global emissions from industrial production. This shared initiative would also likely strengthen diplomatic and trade relations with the EU by streamlining trade and climate policy in the transatlantic region. As the EU is virtue signaling its stalwart support for CBAM, proposing it in the US may also make it a valuable bargaining chip in future trade talks with Brussels.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Medicare For All

Medicare for all would have to compete with fierce lobbies and political interests opposing implementation – the financing alone will generate massive controversy

, PhD 2019 November; 109(11): 1497–1500. Published online 2019 November. doi: PMCID: PMC6775897 PMID: Lessons From the Long and Winding Road to Medicare for All https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775897/

Cohering the byzantine, fragmented collection of governmental and private insurance programs into a single national plan is an extraordinarily formidable task. Each piece of our health care patchwork has influential political interests that are fiercely protective of the status quo and resistant to the major disruption in current arrangements that Medicare for all would require. Moreover, the proliferation of alternative coverage sources means that moving to a single federal plan would require more than 200 million people, many of whom are satisfied with their present arrangements, to change insurance. Even Medicare beneficiaries are subject to political attacks against Medicare for all that claim it would threaten their existing access to medical services. Single-payer reform would also require, if employer-sponsored insurance is to be substantially displaced by a government plan, supplanting private with public financing. Although single payer has efficiencies that could produce considerable savings, those savings do not obviate the enormous political challenge of substituting highly visible (and high) taxes for often obscured employer premium contributions.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Medicare For All

Medicare for all will be intensely controversial – its empirically proven.

, PhD 2019 November; 109(11): 1497–1500. Published online 2019 November. doi: PMCID: PMC6775897 PMID: Lessons From the Long and Winding Road to Medicare for All https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775897/

Second, proposals to establish a federally run national health insurance program, with the important exception of Medicare, have consistently failed to come anywhere close to passing Congress. Their repeated defeat underscores the daunting barriers that have long stood in the way of single-payer plans, including intense opposition from health system stakeholders, Americans’ ideological ambivalence about government, fear of socialized medicine, and fragmented political institutions that make enactment of ambitious reform legislation difficult and give opponents multiple opportunities to block reform.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Medicare For All

Medicare for all implementation would be a political firestorm.

David Rosenbloom, PhD, is a professor at the Boston University School of Public Health. September 07, 2020 HUMAN RIGHTS The Precarious Path to Universal Health Coverage https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/health-matters-in-elections/the-precarious-path-to-universal-health-coverage/

Medical care policy is controversial because it is redistributive. Those of us who are healthier and wealthier help pay for the care of those who are sicker or poorer. Often the transfers are not transparent and therefore rarely set off political firestorms. A majority of hospitals in the country report they lose money or barely break even on Medicaid and Medicare patients. However, hospitals typically make about a 30 percent profit on employer-sponsored insurance to make up for these losses—an invisible redistribution. Progressive federal and state tax regimes redistribute wealth when some of that tax money is used to pay Medicaid expenses. Those of us with higher salaries pay more in Medicare payroll tax than lower-wage workers, but we are all entitled to the same benefits. As soon as the Medicare for All debate among Democrats got into the details of how it would be paid for, the redistributive aspects became transparent and open to political attack as “socialized medicine.” Other factors will also shape the health care policy debates in 2021: COVID-19, past policy choices that determine how—and how much—we pay for medical care, and efforts to address systemic health disadvantage among Black and brown Americans.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Medicare For All

Massive resistance and fierce stakeholder opposition to passage of Medicare for all

, PhD 2019 November; 109(11): 1497–1500. Published online 2019 November. doi: PMCID: PMC6775897 PMID: Lessons From the Long and Winding Road to Medicare for All https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775897/

Can Medicare for all move from aspiration and slogan to legislative reality? Single-payer reform would entail an extraordinary degree of change in US health policy and centralization of insurance coverage, financing, and provider payment under the federal government. Such disruption may be justified given the myriad pathologies of American health care. But that does not make any easier the political task in a nation whose political institutions and health care system both have powerful biases toward incrementalism. The political hurdles that tripped up national health insurance in the 20th century endure. Moreover, the ACA has become another obstacle to single-payer reform because it too is now part of the status quo. Both the politics, replete with formidable barriers and fierce opposition, and history of health reform, dominated by failure and incrementalism, are stacked heavily against Medicare for all. The ACA won enactment partly because it embraced incrementalism, built on the status quo to reduce stakeholder resistance, and minimized disruption for the already insured.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Medicare For All

Huge political obstacles to Medicare for All. The division is powerful and sustained.

, JD, PhD 2019 States as Policy Laboratories: The Politics of State-Based Single-Payer Proposals 2019 November; 109(11): 1511–1514. Published online 2019 November. doi: PMCID: PMC6775896 PMID: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775896/

Despite the gains generated by the Affordable Care Act (ACA), more than 30 million Americans remain uninsured, and millions more delay or defer needed medical care because of high deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs. This ongoing policy challenge prompts an increasing cadre of progressive Democrats to call for a comprehensive overhaul of the nation’s health care system, dramatically reducing (or perhaps completely eliminating) the multipayer private insurance health insurance industry and replacing it with comprehensive publicly funded coverage for all, referred to generally as a “single-payer” insurance model.1 Although the focus for most single-payer advocates is Washington, DC, where the rhetorical movement for Medicare for all animates the presidential campaigns of numerous Democratic candidates, there are also efforts in a handful of states to enact a state-based single-payer program that could become a model for federal policymakers.2 The political obstacles to the single-payer movement are obvious.3 First, the interest group opposition is fierce, wealthy, and influential. Opponents include private insurers worried about being forced into bankruptcy, providers worried about lower reimbursement, employers worried about higher taxes and lost control over employee benefits, unions worried about losing dollars generated by their health benefit programs, and of course a variety of conservative and Republican advocacy groups. Interest group support for single payer is far weaker, more fragmented, and less wealthy. Single-payer proposals also raise concerns about the appropriate role of government and the division of labor between the public and private sectors. These concerns are especially powerful here in the United States, where an antigovernment ethos resonates strongly with much of the population and where the view that government is less competent than the private sector is deeply engrained. This context makes any effort to dramatically raise taxes to fund a single-payer system even more difficult, even when economists point to administrative efficiencies, long-term system savings, and the elimination of insurance premiums. The odds of overcoming these obstacles are better at the state level than in Washington, DC.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Green New Deal

Green New Deal discussions breed partisan clash – empirically proven.

Susan Davis March 26, 2019 5:01 AM ET Heard on Morning Edition Senate Blocks Green New Deal, But Climate Change Emerges As Key 2020 Issue https://www.npr.org/2019/03/26/705897344/green-new-deal-vote-sets-up-climate-change-as-key-2020-issue

The Senate failed to move forward with Democrats' "Green New Deal," but the partisan clash over the controversial environmental plan is likely to be a continuing theme ahead of the 2020 election. The measure needed 60 votes to advance but was blocked when all Senate Republicans and four Senate Democrats opposed it. The rest of the chamber's Democrats voted "present." Senate Republicans forced a vote on the proposal Tuesday as part of an ongoing effort to turn the provocative climate change resolution into a wedge issue in the 2020 elections. Democrats say the GOP gambit carried its own political risk of mocking an issue that is a priority for a growing number of Americans. "I think it's a real stupid political move for them to show how cavalier they are about climate change by playing games with the Green New Deal," said Sen. Chris Murphy, D-Conn., ahead of the vote. "If they don't like the Green New Deal, fine, put up your own idea. It smells so disingenuous, especially to young voters. I think it's a really dumb move for them to mess around with this." All 53 Republicans oppose the Green New Deal. Most Democrats decided on a strategy to vote present led by Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. "I'm for it, but I have no problem voting 'present,' " said Murphy. Schumer wants Democrats to run more aggressively in favor of climate change policies going into 2020, although he conceded in earlier this month that the exact legislative form that will take is still up for debate. "It's going to take us a little while to come up with a consensus that works," he said.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Green New Deal

Green New Deal is extremely controversial – decks bipartisanship in Congress.

GRACE SEGERS MAY 13, 2021 / 2:47 PM / CBS NEWS Green New Deal advocates see imprint on Biden's climate agenda https://www.cbsnews.com/news/green-new-deal-influence-american-jobs-plan/

The Green New Deal has been a cause of controversy since it was first introduced in 2019, with progressives touting it as a last-ditch effort to stave off a climate disaster, and conservatives decrying it as government overreach. In right-wing circles, the Green New Deal has become shorthand for supporting socialism. Although Congress has never voted on the legislation, it nonetheless has an outsized influence in shaping other, more moderate climate change measures, as well as President Biden's ambitious climate agenda. Senator Ed Markey and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the bill's two lead Democratic sponsors, last month. While it may not advance in Congress, the proposal has become a blueprint for Democrats as they look to address the threat of climate change. The companion measures introduced in the House and Senate by Markey and Ocasio-Cortez are "simple" resolutions, meaning they would not require the president's signature or carry the force of law. The call for creating a Green New Deal over the next 10 years, harkening back to the flurry of legislation pursued by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Great Depression. The Green New Deal has several ambitious goals, including a reduction in greenhouse gas and toxic emissions to keep the planet under 1.5 degrees Celsius of warming, creating "millions of good, high-wage unions jobs" and investing in sustainable infrastructure. In a statement to CBS News, Ocasio-Cortez noted that "the dozens of bills that have sprung from this resolution since we introduced it two years ago" all include provisions first introduced by the Green New Deal. The plan also addresses issues of equity, saying the goal is "to secure for all people of the United States for generations to come: clean air and water, climate and community resiliency, healthy food, access to nature and a sustainable environment." The resolution insists that the Green New Deal must "promote justice and equity by stopping current, preventing future, and repairing historic oppression of indigenous peoples, communities of color, migrant communities, deindustrialized communities, depopulated rural communities, the poor, low-income workers, women, the elderly, the unhoused, people with disabilities, and youth." "Our country and planet are facing a number of intersecting crises," Markey said in an interview with CBS News, citing the COVID-19 pandemic, "economic inequality, racial injustice, [and the] ever worsening climate crisis." Conservatives are quick to point out that the Green New Deal includes provisions that may, on the surface, seem unconnected to climate change. The resolution says that certain steps need to be taken to achieve the goals of the Green New Deal, including providing universal health care and "affordable, safe and adequate housing" for all Americans. It also calls for creating "high-quality union jobs," and guaranteeing a job with "a family-sustaining wage, adequate family and medical leave, paid vacations, and retirement security" for all Americans.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Green New Deal

Massive opposition to the Green New Deal in Congress – in previous attempts, no one has voted for it.

Ted Barrett, CNN Updated 9:50 AM EDT, Wed March 27, 2019 Green New Deal stalls in Senate after largely political debate https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/26/politics/green-new-deal-vote-senate/index.html

Senators had a spirited debate Tuesday over the merits of the , a broad policy proposal from liberal Democrats to battle climate change and other social ills but in the end, no one voted to advance the measure and it stalled. Four senators who caucus with the Democrats joined all 53 Republicans in voting “no” because they object to the far-reaching plan, which Senate Majority Leader labeled “a socialist makeover of the entire US economy.” The overwhelming majority of Democrats voted “present,” because, while they are generally supportive of the ideas in the nascent Green New Deal, they were unwilling to vote for or against it before it was written into final legislative language. Democrats were also wary of getting stuck in a political trap Republicans made clear they were laying for them: GOP leaders were trying to lure Democrats to embrace a plan Republicans believe is outside of the mainstream, and then use it against them on the campaign trail. “The Green New Deal is chockful of utopian ideas but completely devoid of concrete plans to implement any of its overreaching policies,” said Sen. John Cornyn, a Republican from Texas, who complained it is a “radical environmental policy” that includes “Medicare for all, free college, and guaranteed jobs.” “You might as well throw in free beer and pizza,” Cornyn added. Sen. Joe Manchin, a West Virginia Democrat who voted “no” Tuesday, said that he wanted to focus on “real solutions that recognized the role fossil fuels will continue to play.” “We cannot successfully address our climate challenge by eliminating sources of energy that countries are committed to using,” Manchin said in a statement. “Only through innovating and developing new technologies that reduce carbon emissions will we truly make a difference.” McConnell, a Kentucky Republican, has been upfront for weeks about his intentions in forcing the vote. He wanted to put Democrats, especially those running for president, on-the-record about their support for the high-profile and controversial plan, which was authored by two progressive Democrats, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Sen. Ed Markey of Massachusetts.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Green New Deal

Green New Deal is extremely controversial and divisive, even within political parties.

Michael Grunwald is a senior staff writer for Politico Magazine. The Trouble With the ‘Green New Deal’ January 15 2019 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2019/01/15/the-trouble-with-the-green-new-deal-223977/

Determining the substantive details of a Green New Deal is already exposing political divisions. Ocasio-Cortez and other lefty firebrands see it as a vehicle to not only address the climate emergency but to root out inequality and transform capitalism; she has described it as “the Great Society, the moon shot, the civil rights movement of our generation.” More mainstream Democrats would prefer to focus on cutting the emissions that threaten the planet, arguing that transforming energy use will be a heavy enough lift as it is. Meanwhile, few Republicans even acknowledge there is a climate emergency, and the ones who do are skeptical of an aggressive Big Government mobilization to address it. “The Green New Deal is not an ideal name if you want to attract bipartisan support,” says Rich Powell, executive director of the group Clear Path, which pushes conservative solutions to climate change. “There’s a lot of distrust of these home-run giga-packages. It’s been a lot more effective to try to hit some singles and doubles.” The fault lines, in other words, resemble the fault lines of 2009. That debate produced a bill that was substantively groundbreaking for clean energy but politically debilitating for Democrats.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Universal Basic Income

UBI programs are tremendously politically challenging to implement

AND SEPTEMBER 16, 2021 7:00 AM EDT Inside the Nation's Largest Guaranteed Income Experiment

But the window to enact major change closes quickly. Republican lawmakers have raised concerns that Biden’s $1.9 trillion stimulus package is feeding inflationary pressure and inciting labor shortages. It remains unclear whether Democrats will have enough support in Congress to make the assistance efforts they passed this year last beyond 2021. And despite the proliferation of guaranteed income pilots, cementing them beyond experiments funded through charity is proving tremendously politically challenging amid fears that such policies keep low-income Americans on the government dole.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › Links – Universal Basic Income

Bipartisan opposition to a universal basic income

Program for Public Consultation, School of Public Policy, University of Maryland Major Report Shows Nearly 150 Issues on Which Majorities of Republicans & Democrats Agree https://publicconsultation.org/defense-budget/major-report-shows-nearly-150-issues-on-which-majorities-of-republicans-democrats-agree/

Defying conventional wisdom about a polarized electorate, a report based on in-depth surveys of more than 80,000 Americans shows that majorities from both parties agree on nearly 150 key policy positions across more than a dozen top policy areas. The research suggests that Americans are eager for their elected representatives to cross party lines to start tackling the nation’s toughest problems. The , released at an event organized by two nonpartisan organizations, and , is based primarily on more than 30 in-depth surveys conducted by the at the University of Maryland. In the surveys, respondents were given in-depth information about the policy issues and legislative proposals under consideration in Congress, and evaluated arguments for and against each policy option before coming to their conclusions. The content was reviewed by experts at both ends of the spectrum of opinion on the issues. “What’s striking is that when citizens think through the issues and hear both sides, they often find common ground–clearly, much more so than Members of Congress,” said Steven Kull, president of Voice of the People and director of the Program for Public Consultation. The positions on which majorities from both parties agree span a broad swath of America’s most important and contentious issue areas, including police reform, immigration, poverty and jobs, social security, budget and taxes, health care, trade, energy and the environment, nuclear weapons and government reform. “On issue after issue, Americans agree across party lines and are ready to get things done – all these positions are also supported by majorities from both parties in the reddest and bluest Congressional districts, and by primary voters who are typically more partisan,” said Jillian Youngblood, Executive Director of Common Ground Solutions. At the nationwide release event, CNN’s Senior Congressional Correspondent Manu Raju discussed the findings with Amy Dacey, Executive Director of American University’s , and Kristie De Peña, Vice President for Policy and Director of Immigration at the . Financial support for the multi-year study was provided by the Democracy Fund, the Hewlett Foundation, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, the MacArthur Foundation and the Circle Foundation. A SELECTION OF COMMON GROUND POSITIONS Social Security To address the projected Social Security shortfall and head off reductions in benefits, very large bipartisan majorities favor making reductions in benefits (reducing benefits to the top 25% of earners, gradually raising the retirement age to 68) and increasing taxes (raising the payroll tax from 6.2% to at least 6.6%, and raising the cap on income subject to the payroll tax to $215,000 or more). These steps would eliminate two thirds of the shortfall. A more modest bipartisan majority would eliminate the cap on income subject to the payroll tax, which, together with the other steps, eliminates the shortfall entirely. Immigration A large bipartisan majority favors giving immigrants who were illegally brought to the US as children legal status and a path to citizenship. A bipartisan majority would go further and provide a visa and path to citizenship to all undocumented workers who have been in the US for an extended period. Very large bipartisan majorities favor increasing the number of work visas. Bipartisan majorities favor more immigration judges to deal with asylum applications. To deter further illegal immigration, there is not majority support for a stronger barrier on the southern border – but a large bipartisan majority favors requiring employers to use the E-Verify system to establish the legal status of all their employees and all new applicants. Poverty Programs Large bipartisan majorities favor increasing SNAP benefits (aka food stamps), but do not want them to be used for sweetened sodas or candy. Bipartisan majorities also favor: making pre-kindergarten available to all 4-year-olds in low-income families raising the minimum wage to $9 an hour expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit major federal jobs programs in the event of an economic downturn. There is bipartisan opposition to a universal basic income of $1,000 a month, and to providing every child with a bond.