Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve – Medicare for All

Evidence of spill up to federal reform post state action.

MICHAEL LIGHTY JANUARY 27, 2022 States Now Hold the Key to Making Medicare for All a Reality https://inthesetimes.com/article/medicare-for-all-single-payer-healthcare-california-new-york

Winning single payer in key states like New York and California could help demonstrate that the system works and compel Democrats in Congress to act. This is a political strategy reflecting the reality that Medicare for All advocates face federally. State organizing helps build the base that will be required to ultimately win guaranteed healthcare for all. And, perhaps surprisingly, we now have strong opportunities to do just that.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve – Medicare for All

States can solve – multiple examples of successful initiatives.

MICHAEL LIGHTY JANUARY 27, 2022 States Now Hold the Key to Making Medicare for All a Reality https://inthesetimes.com/article/medicare-for-all-single-payer-healthcare-california-new-york

A significant but under-reported story in the field of healthcare reform is the growing effort to establish Medicare for All-type systems at the state level. Across the country, elected officials and movement organizers have joined forces to make single payer a reality. And they’re building momentum. In New York, after years of conservative control of the state Senate, progressives who campaigned in 2018 in support of the New York Health Act — a bill that would create a Medicare for All-style system — were elected to office. With these victories, a majority of legislators in both the state Assembly and Senate have now co-sponsored the bill. But in May 2021, a combination of privately reluctant legislators and some resistant unions, along with a lack of gubernatorial support, convinced the Democratic leadership not to bring the bill up for a vote in either house of the legislature. In response, the Campaign for New York Health — a coalition organizing for universal coverage — has promoted stories of people denied care because of insurance company practices and costs, conducted canvasses in key legislative districts, and reached out to unions and union members to address their concerns. The bill’s authors are also considering further amendments, and plan to continue their fight to pass the legislation. In California, a nurse-led campaign has moved the single-payer bill AB 1400 onto the floor of the state Assembly for a vote in late January. A broad labor-community coalition — Healthy California Now — has organized petitions, letter-writing campaigns, and events around the state to urge Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-CA) to fulfill his campaign promise of enacting single payer, universal healthcare. This month, he proposed to cover all undocumented people through the state’s Medi-Cal program. And in April, Newsom’s universal healthcare commission is expected to recommend a ​“unified financing” (akin to Medicare for All) healthcare system. Advocates in Washington State, meanwhile, are currently recruiting petition captains for a signature-gathering effort to put a Medicare for All-type healthcare system on the November ballot, in a campaign called ​“Whole Washington.” Also in Washington, the organization-based coalition Healthcare is a Human Right is urging the state’s task force on universal healthcare to adopt a single-payer approach as it advocates for a bill to rein in health entity mergers and acquisitions that restrict access to care and pad the profits of corporate healthcare providers. In Oregon, Health Care for All, a coalition of advocates, unions and community based organizations, is organizing to move the state’s universal healthcare task force toward a single-payer model. In November, Oregon voters will consider the HOPE amendment, sponsored by the coalition, to establish healthcare as a fundamental right in the state. Rhode Island activists, working with the Providence chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America, have helped organize testimony in the state legislature, social media campaigns and pressure on state legislators to pass a state single payer bill, and are now building awareness around the effort to reach working people through the institutions they participate in, such as unions and faith organizations. In Minnesota, advocates led by labor union leaders — in particular the Minnesota Nurses Association — are signing up legislative supporters in preparation for favorable majorities in 2023 to move single payer legislation, which was considered this year in a House committee but has since been blocked by the Republican majority in the state Senate. In Massachusetts, advocates are organizing ahead of the November 2022 ballot, which will ask residents whether they want local officials to back single payer, in districts where state representatives aren’t currently supporting a Medicare for All system. This effort is intended, in part, to inform constituents if their official is not a cosponsor of the current single payer bill in the state, and to help them take action, educate the district about Medicare for All, and demonstrate the wide support for universal healthcare. Strategy shift In the context of the stymied efforts to expand Medicare at the national level, these state efforts show where the real action is. If we include the recent successful voter-led efforts in states such as Montana, Missouri and Maine to expand Medicaid, the terrain for winning universal, publicly-financed comprehensive healthcare looks increasingly favorable. The current dichotomy between state and federal prospects for Medicare for All style reform reflects a difficult truth that motivated progressives in 2016 and 2020: it takes a president who champions single payer for it to have a chance politically at the national level. In its Build Back Better bill, the Biden administration has not even fought for the modest, incremental promises of the president’s campaign, such as lowering the Medicare eligibility age to 60 and including a public option. Instead of legislative action to expand healthcare as a public good, the administration is allowing private equity and other for-profit entities to have an expanded role within Medicare, continuing a ​“direct contracting” program begun by former President Trump. In fact, the most popular elements of the House-passed Build Back Better bill are Medicare expansion and prescription drug price negotiations. Medicare for All polls at around 70 percent support among Democrats, majority support among independents, along with a good plurality of Republicans (mostly lower income). Yet not even a deadly pandemic has moved federal lawmakers closer to passing guaranteed healthcare for all. The Covid-19 crisis has revealed long-standing healthcare inequities based on race, exposed inadequate workplace protection and safety measures, made clear that employment-based health insurance is not reliable and shown the need for a more robust public health system. And still, we have the continuing disconnect between the need for a Medicare for All system and the lack of legislative action on it in Congress. But the problem is not just the lack of strong leadership from the White House or Democratic leadership. The movement for Medicare for All at the federal level has also not yet created sufficient alliances with other movement groups and the electoral leverage and working-class organization necessary to overcome the money and power of the pharmaceutical companies, the insurance industry and the corporate hospital chains. These are the key institutional players that dictate health policy. Private equity has become a major stakeholder in the healthcare industry and a powerful lobbying force, leading to Wall Street control over our access to healthcare.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve – Medicare for All

States can solve – universal coverage examples exist and more are on the way.

, JD, PhD 2019 States as Policy Laboratories: The Politics of State-Based Single-Payer Proposals 2019 November; 109(11): 1511–1514. Published online 2019 November. doi: PMCID: PMC6775896 PMID: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775896/

Although single-payer proposals at the national level have only recently received their first congressional committee hearing, there are several states in which single-payer proposals have received serious consideration. Vermont, for example, enacted legislation in 2011 that put them on the path to single payer (although that effort was eventually dropped in 2014). Colorado voters considered (but defeated) a single-payer referendum in 2016, as did voters in Oregon in 2002. More recently, the California state senate passed a single-payer bill in 2017 that garnered the support (at least during the campaign) of that state’s newly elected governor, Gavin Newsom. And in New York, single-payer supporters saw a window of opportunity after the November 2018 election results in which the Democrats took control of the state senate, following several years in which a Republican senate had blocked an assembly passed single-payer bill.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve – Federal Jobs Guarantee

States can use local funds to promote job and industry growth

Malkie Wall & David Madland, 21, (Malkie Wall and David Madland are both senior fellows at Center for American Progress, 2-9-2021, 6-16-2023, Center for American Progress, < https://www.americanprogress.org/article/11-things-state-local-governments-can-build-worker-power/ > Blucas

Each year, state and local governments fund millions of jobs through spending on contracts, grants, and loans, as well as through tax breaks and economic development subsidies. This spending can fund many things, including the construction of new roads and bridges, maintenance of public buildings, and in-home care for the elderly and people with disabilities. Policymakers should attach standards to all forms of government spending to ensure that taxpayers and workers get the best results. For example, state and local governments could use prevailing wage laws to ensure that government spending levels the playing field for employers who take the high road by paying good wages and benefits, upholding industry standards, and not undercutting union wages;45 they could also encourage the use of registered apprenticeships by setting targeted hire requirements and establishing preapprenticeship initiatives.46 In addition, governments can help prevent labor disputes and encourage equitable access to high-road employment by requiring project labor agreements and community workforce agreements on large public works projects as well as labor peace agreements on key projects that are at risk for labor disruption.47 Compliance with these and other workplace laws should be required before contractors can receive government funding. For example, governments should employ responsible bidder laws, require contractors to submit detailed cost breakdowns in proposals to discourage artificially low bids, and—when necessary—temporarily debar contractors who fail to comply.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - Green New Deal

States are key to overall climate change efforts — they fill the federal void.

Bromley-Trujillo and Holman 20 — Rebecca Bromley-Trujillo, Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science and Research Lab Director of the Judy Wason Center for Public Policy at Christopher Newport University, former Assistant Professor at the University of Kentucky, holds a M.A. and Ph.D. in political science from Michigan State University, holds a B.A. in political science from the University of Texas, and Mirya R. Holman, Associate Professor in the Department of Political Science at Tulane University, former Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at Florida Atlantic University, holds a Ph.D. in American Politics and Public Policy and an M.A. in Public Policy from Claremont Graduate University, holds a B.A. in Political Science and History from Loyola University, 2020 (“Climate Change Policymaking in the States: A View at 2020,” Publius: The Journal of Federalism, Volume 50, Number 3, Summer, Available Online at , Accessed 08-24-2020)

Climate change policymaking has stalled at the federal level in the United States, particularly during the Trump administration. As a result, conflicts over policy have shifted to subnational governments, accelerating the race to the top and the bottom that already exists in state environmental regulation. While the Obama administration made some concerted efforts to address climate change through the president’s powers as chief executive (see Konisky and Woods 2016; Cook 2018), the Trump administration has largely dismantled these actions (Konisky and Woods 2018). Since President Trump’s inauguration, he shifted the course of national climate change policy in the United States. Among these changes are President Trump’s announced withdrawal from the Paris Climate Agreement, a rescinding and revamping of President Obama’s signature Clean Power Plan, and rolling back planned reductions in fuel economy standards. In addition, the Trump administration has indicated opposition to certain state efforts to address climate change; for example, the federal government is seeking to curtail California’s ability to set stricter automobile emissions standards.

While the federal government has often evaded or struggled to adopt meaningful climate change legislation, state and local governments have been quite active in the climate policy sphere (Rabe 2011; Bromley-Trujillo et al. 2016). Since the early 1990s, state and local governments moved to fill some of the climate policy void left by the federal government’s inaction (Rabe 2011; Gilmore and St. Clair 2017; Boussalis, Coan, and Holman 2018, 2019). The 2010s are no exception: U.S. policy activity on climate change has largely taken place via state and local governments.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - Green New Deal

State lead on warming can sustainably reduce emissions — creates momentum and signals international commitments.

Graham 18 — Sarah Graham, former lecturer in US foreign policy at the United States Studies Centre at the University of Sydney, postdoctoral fellow at the Center for International Studies at the University of Southern California, 2018 (“THE STATES OF THE UNION: US FEDERALISM AND THE TRUMP POLICY AGENDA,” United States Studies Centre, August 9th, Available Online at , Accessed on 08-14-2020)

Trump’s longstanding environmental policy prioritises winding back or narrowing environmental regulations, reducing the mandate and funding of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and withdrawal from the Paris Climate Accord — goals that can all be accomplished without Congress. The appointment of anti-EPA crusader Scott Pruitt to head the agency was an important symbol of this agenda. Pruitt’s recent resignation amid ethics scandals is unlikely to bring about any alteration to the administration’s policy agenda, however.

In June 2017, Trump announced the United States’ withdrawal from the Paris agreement. The following October, leaked documents revealed administration plans to scrap the Obama-era Clean Power Plan, which limits CO2 emissions in US power generation. Climate change is no longer listed as a threat under the latest National Security Strategy and has been expunged from other Trump administration documents, such as federal emergency management plans. The administration has also lifted regulations on hazardous air pollutants and pesticides, and has announced plans to open up the entire US coastline, with the exception of waters around Florida, to oil drilling.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - Green New Deal

States key to climate change — address 89% of national emissions and a majority of global emissions.

Andreen et al 08 — William Andreen, Professor of Climate Change and Environmental Law at the University of Alabama, J.D. from Columbia University, Robert Glicksman, Professor of Environmental Law at George Washington, J.D. from Cornell Law School, Nina Mendelson, Professor of Law at the University of Michigan, J.D. from Yale Law School, A.B. in economics from Harvard University, Rena Steinzor, Professor of Law at the University of Maryland, J.D. from Columbia University, and Shana Jones, Professor of Government and Environmental Services at the University of Georgia, J.D. from the University of Maryland Law School, 2008 (“Cooperative Federalism and Climate Change: Why Federal, State, and Local Governments Must Continue to Partner,” Center for Progressive Reform, May 29th, Available Online at , Accessed 06-13-2020)

The United States is the largest contributor on a per capita basis to the greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate change. Thirty-four of the 75 largest greenhouse gas (GHG) sources in the world are located within our borders.7 Texas is the seventh largest emitter of CO2 in the world; California is the twelfth. 8 Our ten largest cities account for 10 percent of total U.S. emissions. 9 During almost a decade of federal inaction on climate change, beginning with the Bush Administration’s decision to walk away from its campaign promise to participate actively in Kyoto treaty negotiations, state and local governments have led the way in adopting programs to control these harmful emissions. 10 A recent analysis of those actions found that a “growing number of these states are every bit as engaged on multiple policy fronts as counterparts in European capitals.”11 These efforts have set the stage for future progress, accomplishing significant emissions reductions.

Every state in the country has adopted some kind of policy or law to deal with climate change.12 “As of January 2008, 33 states and many more localities, representing a majority of U.S. GHG emissions, have either completed climate change action plans or will complete them within the year.”13 Reflecting state needs, these plans reduce GHG emissions by means of a wide range of policies and programs. State plans generally consist of 50 to 75 policy measures, including codes and standards, market-based systems, renewable portfolio standards, financial incentives, and technical assistance. 14 These “portfolios” of policies result in emissions reductions “that are best suited to the unique economic circumstances and needs of each state.”15 Such a “portfolio” approach is also “crucial to gaining political support for any climate-related action, as it provides an enormously flexible range of choices by which potential conflicts may be resolved.”16

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - Green New Deal

States solve and action spills up to be federal

Sierra Club, last updated 2023 A Green New Deal Is Already Underway in States and Cities https://www.sierraclub.org/trade/green-new-deal-already-underway-states-and-cities

Momentum for a continues to grow. Over 100 members of Congress have endorsed the and polls show broad support for this bold plan to tackle the climate crisis and pollution, create millions of high-paying jobs, and counteract systemic injustices. The policy changes envisioned in the Green New Deal resolution are not hypothetical. In fact, many are already happening at the state and local level, where broad local coalitions of labor, environmental, and racial justice groups are winning pro-climate, pro-jobs, pro-equity policies that help lay the groundwork for a national Green New Deal. In addition to more than that have already committed to 100 percent clean, renewable energy, here are just a few examples of state and city initiatives that offer models and momentum for a nationwide Green New Deal.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - UBI

State programs can help alleviate economic injustice against immigrant populations

Shriver Center on Poverty Law, 22, (Economic Security Project, 4-13-2022, 6-16-2023, Economic Security Project, < https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/ > Blucas

Guaranteed income programs and other state-based cash transfers represent the greatest opportunity to create economic justice for immigrant communities that have long been excluded from federal programs. Throughout history, racist rhetoric and policymaking98 has led to the exclusion of undocumented immigrants from federal programs such as SNAP, TANF (and its predecessor AFDC), Medicaid, SSI, and others, with only limited availability to other immigrant groups who are “lawfully present” in the United States.99 In 1996, federal welfare reform created two categories of immigrants for benefits eligibility purposes: “qualified” and “not qualified.” Some groups of immigrants who are “qualified” for federal programs include legal permanent residents (LPRs or green card holders), asylees, refugees, people fleeing abuse, or survivors of trafficking. However, even these categories of immigrants can face additional restrictions or “wait periods”, such as the 5-year federal ban on benefits for qualified immigrant groups who must be present in the U.S. for five years or work.100 For “not qualified” immigrants, such as the 10.5 to 12 million101 undocumented immigrants in the country, federal programs are largely unobtainable. This structural inequity, coupled with decades of cruel immigration policies, has made it harder for immigrants to obtain economic stability. States have an opportunity to provide needed support and progress toward economic and racial justice for immigrant communities excluded from the social safety net by ensuring robust immigrant eligibility for state-funded cash transfer programs. Some states provided benefits both before and during the pandemic, to try to address some of the shortfall of federal programs and federal relief passed in response to COVID-19. California established a $125 million fund to help undocumented workers who cannot access unemployment insurance. Oregon added $20 million to the Oregon Worker Relief Fund which was created to provide temporary financial relief to undocumented workers. Connecticut provided a total of $3.5 million to aid undocumented families with rent relief and direct financial aid. Lastly, in Fiscal Year 2021 Illinois began providing Medicaid coverage for low-income seniors regardless of immigration status, making it the first state to cover older undocumented immigrants.102 Nothing in federal law would prevent states from providing state funds to immigrants in the form of a guaranteed income or other cash transfers, and offering long-overdue support to immigrants who are critical to the success of our communities.103

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - UBI

States definitely have the ability to create their own programs from scratch

Shriver Center on Poverty Law, 22, (Economic Security Project, 4-13-2022, 6-16-2023, Economic Security Project, < https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/ > Blucas

States can also lean on their existing benefits-granting agencies to administer a guaranteed income alongside other core means-tested programs like SNAP, TANF, and Medicaid. For example, in California, the Department of Social Services (“Department”) is funding new guaranteed income programs created by units of local government and other eligible entities.52 In 2021, the California state legislature added $35 million to the state budget to fund guaranteed income demonstrations over the next 5 years, prioritizing funds to pregnant mothers and youth aging out of the extended foster care system at or after age 21.53 The Department will accept applications from entities seeking to create a program, and will work with stakeholders to create program methodologies, select mechanisms for payment distribution, and establish a process by which recipients can receive counseling on the impacts of receiving a guaranteed income on other benefits. Unlike the majority of states, California utilizes a county-based benefits system that delegates administration of programs like CalFresh (SNAP), CalWORKS (TANF), and Medi-Cal (Medicaid) to county governments. With this benefits administration structure, therefore, it is consistent for California to lean on counties as units of local government to create guaranteed income programs subject to approval by the state. However, states who utilize state-based benefits administration could use a similar method of creating a new state-level guaranteed income program and administering it through state-run local offices that already oversee SNAP, TANF, and Medicaid. A potential advantage of creating a new guaranteed income program administered by traditional benefits granting agencies is the potential for information sharing. Because a guaranteed income is targeted based on income level, some data showing an applicant’s income will be necessary to assess eligibility. For many no- and-low-income households who may be accessing benefits, the agency may already have information needed to assess eligibility for a guaranteed income and could adopt a system of “categorical” or “express lane” eligibility – where participation in one means-tested program verifies income eligibility for guaranteed income, and makes application processing easier.54 A new guaranteed income program could also be integrated into combined applications for benefits, allowing applicants’ eligibility for multiple programs to be assessed at once. Lastly, benefits granting agencies may be better positioned to assess and relay the potential consequences of guaranteed income receipt on other benefits.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - UBI

States can utilize large public funds and pay dividends from it – Alaska proves the state model works

Shriver Center on Poverty Law, 22, (Economic Security Project, 4-13-2022, 6-16-2023, Economic Security Project, < https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/ > Blucas

Another model for statewide implementation of a guaranteed income would be declaring periodic dividends from a state government managed sovereign wealth fund. One prominent example is the annual dividend from Alaska’s Permanent Fund. After oil was discovered in Alaska in the 1960’s, the Prudhoe Bay Oil and Gas lease sale in 1969 brought in $900 million in state revenue.47 Following the completion of the Trans Alaska Pipeline in 1974, the state grappled with how to invest its anticipated oil royalties. In 1976, Alaska residents voted to amend the state’s constitution to allow the creation of the Alaska Permanent Fund, in which at least 25 percent of all the state’s oil revenue would be placed.48 The following year, the Fund began with an initial deposit of $734,000. In 1980, a state law created the Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation to invest and manage the fund while also creating the Permanent Fund Dividend Program which has paid Alaskans an average of $1600 annually.49 Since 1980, the fund has grown exponentially from its initial investment with a 2021 value of nearly $82 billion.50 Administered by the state’s Department of Revenue, every year each Alaskan submits an application, largely to verify their residence in the state, and then receives a check in an amount determined by the state legislature based, in part, on the performance of the fund’s investments. Although the Permanent Fund Dividend is distributed to Alaska residents regardless of their wealth or income, other states could conceivably embrace a guaranteed income model over a universal model and create income and wealth thresholds for determining eligibility for dividend payment.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - UBI

State based UBI lays the groundwork for other wealth-building initiatives

Shriver Center on Poverty Law, 22, (Economic Security Project, 4-13-2022, 6-16-2023, Economic Security Project, < https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/ > Blucas

A guaranteed income is a direct and effective strategy to ensure that everyone can meet their basic needs and reduce unconscionable levels of income inequality. However, even wider disparities exist when it comes to wealth. Available data shows that guaranteed income allows people to save money, pursue additional education and training, and improve their employment situation, all of which can increase a household’s opportunity to invest and accumulate wealth, but states should strongly consider wealth building strategies that are more direct to complement a guaranteed income. One such model is baby bonds. The basic idea of a baby bond is that children in eligible families would have an initial deposit placed into a government managed trust that would guarantee growth of the investment until the child turns 18. Upon their 18th birthday, the child is able to access the money – which will have appreciated significantly – and, in most models, is limited to using it for specific purposes such as pursuing higher education, buying a home, or starting a business.104 However, states could adopt and modify such a policy, remove restrictions on how the money is eventually spent, and pair this asset building strategy with cash transfers like guaranteed income to produce even greater outcomes.105 In 2021, Connecticut became the first state in the country to pass a statewide baby bond program106 while state legislators in other states, like New Jersey, Iowa, and Maryland, have also introduced proposals.107 Local governments have been invested in baby bonds programs as well. Since 2017, the City of Oakland has funded Oakland Promises’ Brilliant Baby program – a College Savings Account program – for Oakland families under 200% FPL, where $500 is placed in a qualifying child’s 529 account108 and can be accessed when they turn 18 and used toward college tuition.109 The District of Columbia has also recently created a municipal level baby bonds program for eligible D.C. families under 300% FPL where, similar to other proposals, an initial deposit of $1,000 followed by annual deposits based on income will be placed into an invested trust fund that children can access when they turn 18 to pay for education, buying a home, or other qualified expenses.110 Most baby bonds models consider a household’s income when assessing eligibility. Just as a guaranteed income is targeted to households based on their level of income, wealth building policies may be more appropriately targeted based on a household’s wealth (assets and resources) rather than income. As discussed above, cash transfer policies like guaranteed income could be extremely potent in mitigating disparities in income, but matching cash payments with policies that build assets in a targeted manner could better address the massive disparity in intergenerational wealth transfers – especially for people of color – which is a critical piece in promoting both racial and economic equity.111

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - UBI

States act as policy labs – testing and crafting laws that help translate to federal adoption – solves the aff

Shriver Center on Poverty Law, 22, (Economic Security Project, 4-13-2022, 6-16-2023, Economic Security Project, < https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/ > Blucas

At the federal level, the expanded CTC being debated as part of President Biden’s American Families Plan represents a form of guaranteed income for 39 million households.7 Unfortunately, federal conversations around nationwide cash transfer programs – like an expanded CTC – have been underwhelming. As of December 2021, the Build Back Better Act does maintain the fully refundable nature of the expanded-CTC, allowing low- and no-income families excluded pre-pandemic to continue to receive a credit, but only a temporary extension is being considered for the increased amounts families received during the pandemic. While the Build Back Better Act has not yet passed, the stimulus checks and expanded CTC have moved the needle, breaking down barriers to moving cash policies at any level of government. We now have a much better sense of what is possible when it comes to distributing monthly cash payments, and we have data and stories of the impact these policies have in the lives of low- and middle-income earning families. In light of the current limits at the local and federal level, there is an opportunity for state governments to explore ambitious, publicly-funded cash transfer policies that: promote dignity and greatly improve the lives of their low-income residents; add to a growing body of research with assessments of larger scale positive impacts across geographically and racially diverse areas; utilize the revenue raising powers of state government; and could be a model for a permanent federal program. We need a permanent federal guaranteed income, but political gridlock and polarization threaten to frustrate attempts at a federal program in the immediate term. States have an opportunity to push closer to that ideal with large scale, publicly funded, permanent programs of their own that will provide essential data and experience toward the realization of a federal program. This guide seeks to arm state-level advocates and policymakers with information regarding the choice points in program design, the positive impacts shown by existing research, and special considerations for states including options for guaranteed income implementation, interactions with existing public benefits programs, opportunities for public funding, and promoting racial equity.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › Extension › States Solve - General

States can play a huge role in fiscal redistribution in order to resolve inequality

ELIZABETH MCNICHOL DECEMBER 15, 2016 | How State Tax Policies Can Stop Increasing Inequality and Start Reducing It https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/how-state-tax-policies-can-stop-increasing-inequality-and-start

Nearly every state collects more taxes from poor families than high-income families, relative to their incomes. States (including their local governments) also generally collect more taxes from middle-income families than high-income families.[7] These disparities increase income inequality by reducing the after-tax incomes of low- and middle-income families more deeply than those of high-income families. No single decision resulted in this inequitable treatment. Rather, in a series of policy decisions reaching back more than a century, state policymakers have tended to choose tax policies that favor the wealthy over the poor and favor corporations over workers. Many major state taxes were first put in place in the first half of the 20th Century, a period in which many Americans (especially African Americans in the South) were barred from voting, and in which urban areas in many states were underrepresented in state legislatures. Moreover, right up to the present, a small number of legislators and staff typically construct tax policy in most state legislatures, often with the input of corporate lobbyists. And state tax policy is sufficiently arcane that many policy decisions do not receive the broad attention they deserve, particularly when their immediate revenue effects are modest. As a result, state tax codes are regressive, meaning low- and middle-income families pay a bigger share of their income in taxes than wealthy families. In 2015, the poorest fifth of married, non-elderly families paid twice as large a share of their incomes in state and local taxes as the wealthiest 1 percent of such families, on average (10.9 percent versus 5.4 percent).[8] One major reason is that most states rely heavily on sales taxes. Sales taxes disproportionately affect low-income families, largely because they spend (rather than save or invest) a larger share of their income than higher-income families do. Property taxes also generally hit low- and middle-income families more heavily than high-income families. The income tax is the one major state revenue source that typically reduces inequality, but many states have weak income tax systems that do too little in this regard. A graduated-rate income tax, which taxes higher incomes at higher rates, affects high-income families more than low-income families, and in a few states this balances out the effects of sales and property taxes. But many state income taxes are flat (meaning all income is taxed at the same rate) or nearly flat, and a few states don’t have an income tax. As a result, some states do much more than others to reduce inequality through their tax codes. Many states have made their tax systems even more out of balance since the late 1970s, even as inequality has risen, by increasing their reliance on sales taxes rather than income taxes. For example, the sales tax rate in the typical state has doubled since 1970 while the top income tax rate has remained unchanged.[9] (See Figure 4.) The shift away from states taxing the wealthy has continued since the Great Recession hit. In the depths of the downturn in 2009 and 2010, for example, a number of states raised taxes as part of their response to recession-induced revenue declines, but while they raised both income taxes and sales taxes, the income tax increases were almost uniformly temporary while half of the sales tax-rate increases were permanent. Some states have cut income taxes as the economy recovers. States can reverse these trends and use tax policy to reduce income inequality by taking the following actions. Strengthen their income tax’s inequality-reducing impact. Tax increases on high-income individuals — who are best able to afford the higher tax and least likely to spend substantially less as a result of the increase — can reduce inequality directly while raising revenue to invest in a more broadly prosperous future. Policymakers can raise taxes on high-income households by raising income tax rates at the top end and by capping itemized deductions and other tax breaks for high-income taxpayers. Establish or expand taxes on inherited wealth, such as the estate tax. Only the very wealthiest taxpayers pay estate taxes — just 2.56 percent of estates, on average, in the states with the tax. Some 18 states plus Washington, D.C. have an estate or inheritance tax. States with an estate tax can avoid increasing inequality by resisting calls to reduce or eliminate the tax. States without an estate tax can reduce inequality by adopting one. Eliminate costly and ineffective tax breaks for corporations. State corporate income taxes are declining; the share of tax revenue supplied by this tax in the 45 states that levy it fell from nearly 10 percent in the late 1970s, to only a little more than 5 percent today. Many profitable corporations pay nothing in state income taxes in some states where they do business. States can strengthen taxes on corporations by carefully examining and eliminating costly tax breaks. They can also establish strong minimum taxes — a floor on the amount of tax owed each year. In addition, states that have not already done so can adopt a reform known as combined reporting, which nullifies three of the most common state corporate tax shelters.[10] Evidence does not support the claim that these kinds of changes will drive large numbers of affluent people and businesses to other states.[11] Broaden the sales tax base. States can make their tax systems fairer by broadening the sales tax base to include more services that high-income families consume, such as investment counseling or country club memberships. While this would shift more of the responsibility for paying the sales tax to wealthier families, the effect would be relatively small; states should accompany such changes by other measures that go further to reduce inequality. Enact state earned income tax credits. States can boost the incomes of low- and moderate-wage working families or offset the impact on these families of other tax changes by enacting or expanding a state earned income tax credit (EITC). Many states have created EITCs to build on the strengths of the federal EITC, which offsets low-wage workers’ payroll taxes, supplements the earnings of low- and moderate-income families, and helps families move from welfare to work. [12] Over half of the states with an income tax and one state without an income tax — in all, 26 states plus the District of Columbia — have established EITCs.[13] Avoid costly tax shifts and tax cuts aimed at the wealthy. Public discussions about strengthening the economy often center on tax cuts, despite growing evidence that they don’t create many jobs or promote broad prosperity.[14] Maintaining and improving schools, transportation networks, and other public services shown to generate growth will require resources, both now and in the future. As state revenues slowly recover from the Great Recession, some states, such as Louisiana and North Carolina, have considered extreme tax changes such as replacing the income tax with a higher, broader sales tax. That would sharply raise taxes for low- and middle-income households and threaten the state’s ability to maintain many of the services necessary to assist families left behind in the current economy. Other states, such as Kansas, Mississippi, and North Carolina, have deeply cut income taxes for individuals and businesses without replacing the lost revenues, which over time will force drastic cuts in services like schools, transportation, and public safety. Many states have enacted less extreme but still costly income tax cuts that benefit individuals at the top and profitable businesses but do little or nothing for low- and middle-income households and damage the state’s ability to invest in more effective ways. If these trends continue, they will tilt state tax systems even more against low- and middle-income households. States choosing to cut taxes as the economy grows can do so while reducing the impact of their taxes on low- and moderate-income families by enacting tax credits targeted to low-income taxpayers or by raising the personal exemption or standard deduction, rather than cutting top income tax rates or capital gains taxes.

2023 SDI Counterplan
MSDI States CP › 1NC

States solve - they are primary vehicles of fiscal redistribution and can have a massive impact on the significance of economic inequality

ELIZABETH MCNICHOL DECEMBER 15, 2016 | How State Tax Policies Can Stop Increasing Inequality and Start Reducing It https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/how-state-tax-policies-can-stop-increasing-inequality-and-start

Over the last three and one-half decades, income gains in the American economy have accrued largely to the richest households, while many middle- and lower-income Americans haven’t shared in the nation’s growing prosperity. This has reduced opportunities for working people striving to get ahead and weakened our overall economy. Though the growth in inequality reflects a host of long-standing national and global economic trends that are largely outside state policymakers’ control (see box below), state policy choices can make matters worse or improve them.

For example, virtually all states collect more taxes from moderate- and lower-income families, as a share of their income, than high-income families (see Figure 1). This increases inequality by reducing after-tax incomes more deeply among low- and middle-income families than high-income families.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › War Turns Structural Violence

AND, the impact’s not universal---nuclear use reproduces spatial injustices through targeting procedures.

Jacqueline Foertsch 13. Professor of English at the University of North Texas. 08/30/2013. Reckoning Day: Race, Place, and the Atom Bomb in Postwar America. Vanderbilt University Press.

More broadly speaking, one’s location in the American landscape when the bomb exploded—that is, during America’s early atomic/cold war era—intersects with one’s “place” in the American social hierarchy in significant ways. For the bomb presented Americans, especially those who have always enjoyed more freedom of movement, with a series of spatio-ethical dilemmas: where to go if the bombs should fall, who and what to leave behind. While the suburban boom of the immediate postwar period had myriad causes, one significant reason was the strong sense that America’s cities were the easiest and most likely of nuclear targets. Elaine Tyler May has examined the leafy, low-slung, spread-out qualities of American suburbs and has persuasively observed in these a response to atomic fears of urban verticality, congestion, and entrapment. For May it was especially the hunkered down, ranch-style home that “exuded this sense of isolation, privacy, and containment” (94). In atomic fictions of the period, the city is depicted as the site of conflagration; those characters lucky enough to find themselves in the suburbs or on the farm on “X-day” fare better and depend less on which way the wind blows during the fallout period. While the suburban choice—again, for the white middle-class, for whom such choices were exclusively provided—seemed obvious, the decision with respect to whether or not to go underground, to build a bomb shelter and prepare to survive there in the atomic aftermath, was always a more fraught proposition. In the enmeshed social setting of the suburbs, how would it look to build a shelter when no one else was doing so? Kenneth D. Rose suggests that the lone suburban shelter-digger might seem not only eccentric (violating the cardinal rule of conformity) but also “immoral.” “At issue,” says Rose, “was controlling entry to one’s personal or community shelter . . . to keep out radioactive fallout but also ‘to prevent exceeding the maximum capacity of the shelter’” (93). How did one build to suit one’s immediate family but not spaciously enough to include neighbors and passersby, or even parents, in-laws, aunts, and uncles from the “old country” (i.e., the urban birthplace)? The pointlessness of resurfacing in a ruined, depopulated post-nuclear environment may have dissuaded many from taking the plunge in the first place; others sought the furthest reaches of American civilization (and beyond) in their understanding that the key to nuclear survival was location, location, location. We attach extremist notions like nuclear survivalism to a specific racial, classed position in the US—white (sometimes white-supremacist) lower-class place-holders who take to the hinterlands in order to reject not only the nuclear jeopardy in which America has placed its citizens from the cold war to the present but also much of what America represents (see, e.g., “Religious Group”). Such outward-boundedness positions one near the bottom of America’s social scale, while downward-boundedness (bomb shelter-building) was a distinctly suburban (and, to some degree, urban) phenomenon and thus associated with America’s middle class. In short, there was less stigma attached during the cold war to digging down than to lighting out, despite the seemingly more bizarre nature of the downward-digging: while survivalists thrive on the US’s geographic and ideological margins into the twenty-first century, today no middle-class suburbanite would construct a bomb shelter in his backyard, so unorthodox an act would it be, and the two-hour commute has become more and more the norm. Perhaps, sixty years ago, a move to the suburbs was deemed so eminently respectable that included with the purchase of one’s private lot was the right to go a little crazy in one’s fenced-off backyard—to prepare for a post-nuclear life underground no matter how objectionable it was to some. In America’s “burnt out,” “bombed out” urban cores, locales we have tagged with post-nuclear adjectives since the postwar period,1 remained America’s “undesirables”—African, Asian, and Latino Americans and other ethnic persons or immigrants with low incomes; poor whites; the elderly; gays and lesbians; the mentally disturbed; the otherwise socially delinquent. Ironically, their lives in inner city high-rises positioned these postwar Americans “at the top,” while everyone understood that such physical superiority carried neither privilege nor security. If anything, the last place one wanted to be at this moment was up, and yet this particular sector of the American population had few other choices: the suburbs were closed to them, rural ties had been severed generations earlier, and the atomic threat found many of America’s persons of color trapped at ground zero. Questioning “the Negro’s relative exposure and immunity to nuclear annihilation” for Negro Digest in 1963, the sociologist and black studies founder Nathan Hare praised African Americans’ emotional fortitude and resistance to physical travails—even the anticipated intense heat of atomic blast—due to their “cotton-chopping, cotton-picking backgrounds in the Southern sun and long years of tending ovens and furnaces in white kitchens and factories” (31). Yet Hare is intent on critiquing the demographic patterns of postwar society that have trapped the black community in northern ghettoes “near the centers or bull’s-eyes of our big cities” (28). Citing racial residency patterns at that point, Hare notes that “a 10-megaton bomb on Washington, DC, or Chicago . . . would just about take care of the Negro community” (29). Hare’s observations are echoed today by Katherine McKittrick and Clyde Woods, who decry America’s long history of “uneven geographies,” wherein “black and poor subjects are disposable precisely because they cannot move or escape” (3). This insight crystallizes the crisis faced by atomic-era African Americans, thought to deserve their fate for failing to meet the criteria for admission to the suburban safe haven. Philip Wylie’s novel Tomorrow! is a nuclear preparedness/survival fantasy that includes a map of the fictional sister cities that are its setting; these surround a “Negro District” that is dead-center during the climactic nuclear explosion. The story ends with its surviving characters, all of whom are white, viewing a scene of pristine, suburban-style rebirth. This vision resonates with those of postwar urban planners who could not but associate the bomb, despite its frightening implications, with their growing desire to revamp city life, specifically to “save the American city from ‘the blight . . . gnawing at its innards’” (qtd. in P. Boyer 152). The National Paint, Varnish, and Lacquer Association produced a fright-mongering public service announcement in the mid-1950s that has achieved cult status in the intervening decades, The House in the Middle. As it opens, a disgusted narrator harangues against the combustible trash and rotting wood “you’ve seen in too many alleys and backyards—in slum areas” and crows about the destruction suffered by cluttered, littered, unpainted frame houses subjected to H-bombing at the Nevada Proving Grounds, images of which accompany his voiceover. Only the paint job of the lucky middle house saves it from the same fate, itself racialized, since “light colors” and “white” are recommended as the most light- and heat-reflective shades. Implicit in such texts, therefore, are visions of the nuclear-induced “urban renewal” that recent thinkers such as Martha A. Bartter and Dean MacCannell have broadly denounced, while Michele Birnbaum incisively reads the constructedness of racial identity thus: “we can describe one [race] only in terms of the other—a kind of Heisenberg principle of race in which racial difference is situational, provisional: it depends upon who is looking and who is next to whom” (3). As whiteness depends for its significance upon its position with respect to blackness (and vice versa), we see this supplemental relation repeated in the demographic shifting of the postwar US: African Americans, forced to remain in rapidly declining inner cities, maintained these locales as viable (i.e., populated) nuclear targets, creating in turn the relative safety of the “uninhabited” white suburban sanctuary.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › War Turns Structural Violence

War Turns Structural Violence.

John Horgan 12, Director of the Center for Science Writings at the Stevens Institute of Technology, 2012, The End of War, Chapter 5, Kindle p. 1600-1659

Throughout this book, I’ve examined attempts by scholars to identify factors especially conducive for peace. But there seem to be no conditions that, in and of themselves, inoculate a society against militarism. Not small government nor big government. Not democracy, socialism, capitalism, Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, nor secularism. Not giving equal rights to women or minorities nor reducing poverty. The contagion of war can infect any kind of society. Some scholars, like the political scientist Joshua Goldstein, find this conclusion dispiriting. Early in his career Goldstein investigated economic theories of war, including those of Marx and Malthus. He concluded that war causes economic inequality and scarcity of resources as much as it stems from them. Goldstein, a self-described “pro-feminist,” then set out to test whether macho, patriarchal attitudes caused armed violence. He felt so strongly about this thesis that he and his wife limited their son’s exposure to violent media and contact sports. But by the time he finished writing his 522-page book War and Gender in 2001, Goldstein had rejected the thesis. He questioned many of his initial assumptions about the causes of war. He never gave credence to explanations involving innate male aggression—war breaks out too sporadically for that—but he saw no clear-cut evidence for non-biological factors either. “War is not a product of capitalism, imperialism, gender, innate aggression, or any other single cause, although all of these influence wars’ outbreaks and outcomes,” Goldstein writes. “Rather, war has in part fueled and sustained these and other injustices.” He admits that all his research has left him “somewhat more pessimistic about how quickly or easily war may end.” But here is the upside of this insight: if there are no conditions that in and of themselves prevent war, there are none that make peace impossible, either. This is the source of John Mueller’s optimism, and mine. If we want peace badly enough, we can have it, no matter what kind of society we live in. The choice is ours. And once we have escaped from the shadow of war, we will have more resources to devote to other problems that plague us, like economic injustice, poor health, and environmental destruction, which war often exacerbates. The Waorani, whose abandonment of war led to increased trade and intermarriage, are a case in point. So is Costa Rica. In 2010, this Central American country was ranked number one out of 148 nations in a “World Database of Happiness” compiled by Dutch sociologists, who gathered information on the self-reported happiness of people around the world. Costa Rica also received the highest score in another “happiness” survey, carried out by an American think tank, that factored in the nation’s impact on the environment. The United States was ranked twentieth and 114th, respectively, on the surveys. Instead of spending on arms, over the past half century Costa Rica’s government invested in education, as well as healthcare, environmental conservation, and tourism, all of which helped make the country more prosperous, healthy, and happy. There is no single way to peace, but peace is the way to solve many other problems. The research of Mueller, Goldstein, Forsberg, and other scholars yields one essential lesson. Those of us who want to make the world a better place—more democratic, equitable, healthier, cleaner—should make abolishing the invention of war our priority, because peace can help bring about many of the other changes we seek. This formula turns on its head the old social activists’ slogan: “If you want peace, work for justice.” I say instead, “If you want justice, work for peace.” If you want less pollution,

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › War Turns Structural Violence

War turns structural violence

Joshua S. Goldstein, pub. date: 2001, Prof. of IR @ American University, Washington D.C. He is the author of a broad range of research works on international conflict, cooperation, and political economy, with a central focus on great-power relations and world order, War and Gender: How Gender Shapes the War System and Vice Versa, Cambridge University, pp. 412

First, peace activists face a dilemma in thinking about causes of war and working for peace. Many peace scholars and activists support the approach, “if you want peace, work for justice.” Then, if one believes that sexism contributes to war, one can work for gender justice speicifically (or perhaps among others) in order to pursue peace. This approach beings strategic allies to the peace movement (women, labor, minorities), but rests on the assumption that injustices casue war. The evidence in this book suggests that causality runs at least as strongly the other way. War is not a product of capitalism, imperialism, gender, innate aggression, or any other single cause, although theses influence wars’ outbreaks and outcomes. Rather, war has in part fueled and sustained these and other injustices. So, “if you want peace, work for peace.” Indeed, if you want justice (gender and others), work for peace. Causality does not run just upward through the levels of analysis, from types of individuals, societies, and governments up to war, It runs downward too. Enloe suggests that changes in attitudes towards war and the military may be the most important way to “reverse women’s oppression.” The dilemma is that peace work focused on justice beings to the peace movement energy, allies, and moral grounding, yet in light of this book’s evidence, the emphasis on injustice as the main cause of war seems to be empirically inadequate. 10

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › SV Doesn’t Escalate

Structural violence doesn’t escalate

Robert Hinde and Lea Pulkkinnen, Cambridge psychology professor and University of Jyväskylä psychology professor, 2000, DRAFT Background Paper for Working Group 1: HUMAN AGGRESSIVENESS AND WAR, 50th Pugwash Conference On Science and World Affairs: "Eliminating the Causes of War" Queens' College, Cambridge, http://www.pugwash.org/reports/pac/pac256/WG1draft1.htm

People are capable of perpetrating the most terrible acts of violence on their fellows. From before recorded history humans have killed humans, and violence is potentially present in every society. There is no escaping the fact that the capacity to develop a propensity for violence is part of human nature. But that does not mean that aggression is inevitable: temporary anger need not give rise to persistent hostility, and hostility need not give rise to acts of aggression. And people also have the capacity to care for the needs of others, and are capable of acts of great altruism and self-sacrifice. A subsidiary aim of this workshop is to identify the factors that make aggressive tendencies predominate over the cooperative and compassionate ones. Some degree of conflict of interest is often present in relationships between individuals, in the relations between groups of individuals within states, and in the relations between states: we are concerned with the factors that make such conflicts escalate into violence. The answer to that question depends critically on the context. While there may be some factors in common, the bases of individual aggressiveness are very different from those involved in mob violence, and they differ yet again from the factors influencing the bomb-aimer pressing the button in a large scale international war. In considering whether acts which harm others are a consequence of the aggressive motivation of individuals, it is essential to recognise the diversity of such acts, which include interactions between individuals, violence between groups, and wars of the WW2 type. We shall see that, with increasing social complexity, individual aggressiveness becomes progressively less important, but other aspects of human nature come to contribute to group phenomena. Although research on human violence has focussed too often on the importance of one factor or another, it is essential to remember that violence always has multiple causes, and the interactions between the causal factors remain largely unexplored.

2023 SDI Negative
Basic Income – Poverty – Negative › Impact Framing › Cant solve structural violence

Their conception of violence is reductive and can’t be solved

Boulding 77 Twelve Friendly Quarrels with Johan Galtung Author(s): Kenneth E. BouldingReviewed work(s):Source: Journal of Peace Research, Vol. 14, No. 1 (1977), pp. 75-86Published Kenneth Ewart Boulding (January 18, 1910 – March 18, 1993) was an economist, educator, peace activist, poet, religious mystic, devoted Quaker, systems scientist, and interdisciplinary philosopher.[1][2] He was cofounder of General Systems Theory and founder of numerous ongoing intellectual projects in economics and social science. He graduated from Oxford University, and was granted United States citizenship in 1948. During the years 1949 to 1967, he was a faculty member of the University of Michigan. In 1967, he joined the faculty of the University of Colorado at Boulder, where he remained until his retirement.

Finally, we come to the great Galtung metaphors of 'structural violence' 'and 'positive peace'. They are metaphors rather than models, and for that very reason are suspect. Metaphors always imply models and metaphors have much more persuasive power than models do, for models tend to be the preserve of the specialist. But when a metaphor implies a bad model it can be very dangerous, for it is both persuasive and wrong. The metaphor of structural violence I would argue falls right into this category. The metaphor is that poverty, deprivation, ill health, low expectations of life, a condition in which more than half the human race lives, is 'like' a thug beating up the victim and 'taking his money away from him in the street, or it is 'like' a conqueror stealing the land of the people and reducing them to slavery. The implication is that poverty and its associated ills are the fault of the thug or the conqueror and the solution is to do away with thugs and conquerors. While there is some truth in the metaphor, in the modern world at least there is not very much. Violence, whether of the streets and the home, or of the guerilla, of the police, or of the armed forces, is a very different phenomenon from poverty. The processes which create and sustain poverty are not at all like the processes which create and sustain violence, although like everything else in 'the world, everything is somewhat related to everything else. There is a very real problem of the structures which lead to violence, but unfortunately Galitung's metaphor of structural violence as he has used it has diverted attention from this problem. Violence in the behavioral sense, that is, somebody actually doing damage to somebody else and trying to make them worse off, is a 'threshold' phenomenon, rather like the boiling over of a pot. The temperature under a pot can rise for a long time without its boiling over, but at some 'threshold boiling over will take place. The study of the structures which underlie violence are a very important and much neglected part of peace research and indeed of social science in general. Threshold phenomena like violence are difficult to study because they represent 'breaks' in the systenm rather than uniformities. Violence, whether between persons or organizations, occurs when the 'strain' on a system is too great for its 'strength'. The metaphor here is that violence is like what happens when we break a piece of chalk. Strength and strain, however, especially in social systems, are so interwoven historically that it is very difficult to separate them. The diminution of violence involves two possible strategies, or a mixture of the two; one is Ithe increase in the strength of the system, 'the other is the diminution of the strain. The strength of systems involves habit, culture, taboos, and sanctions, all these 'things which enable a system to stand lincreasing strain without breaking down into violence. The strains on the system 'are largely dynamic in character, such as arms races, mutually stimulated hostility, changes in relative economic position or political power, which are often hard to identify. Conflicts of interest 'are only part 'of the strain on a system, and not always the most important part. It is very hard for people ito know their interests, and misperceptions of 'interest take place mainly through the dynamic processes, not through the structural ones. It is only perceptions of interest which affect people's behavior, not the 'real' interests, whatever these may be, and the gap between percepti'on and reality can be very large and resistant to change. However, what Galitung calls structural violence (which has been defined 'by one unkind commenltator as anything that Galitung doesn't like) was originally defined as any unnecessarily low expectation of life, on that assumption that anybody who dies before the allotted span has been killed, however unintentionally and unknowingly, by somebody else. The concept has been expanded to include all 'the problems of poverty, destitution, deprivation, and misery. These are enormously real and are a very high priority for research and action, but they belong to systems which are only peripherally related to 'the structures whi'ch produce violence. This is not rto say that the cultures of violence and the cultures of poverty are not sometimes related, though not all poverty cultures are cultures of violence, and certainly not all cultures of violence are poverty cultures. But the dynamics lof poverty and the success or failure to rise out of it are of a complexity far beyond anything which the metaphor of structural violence can offer. While the metaphor of structural violence performed a service in calling attention to a problem, it may have d'one a disservice in preventing us from finding the answer.