Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Answers To › A2: Automation DA

Non-unique - Automation occurring now – ¼ of the work force will be automated by 2030

Bai ’22 [Edwin; September 1; Graduated from Arcadia High School; Los Angeles Times, “Opinion: Automation is Bad for the Workplace,” , CM]

In today’s world, jobs are slowly becoming more and more automated, with machines replacing workers by the millions in the U.S. every passing year. This replacement of human labor is so rapid that a 2021 report by McKinsey Global Institute predicted 45 million Americans — one-fourth of the workforce — would be automated by 2030, as reported by Slate. Over time, it has slowly become apparent that human labor is gradually becoming less important as machines take over our jobs and occupations with more sophisticated technology. It’s undeniable that more and more jobs are being lost to automated labor, but how exactly does this affect workers and workplaces? The rise of automated labor is related to the enormous benefits it brings to corporations. It’s cheaper, more efficient and doesn’t complain about working conditions or low wages; it does what it’s programmed to do and that alone makes it so much more valuable than human labor in the eyes of corporations. For instance, automation company Tray.io states how automation is so much more profitable to corporations than human labor. Not only does automated labor bring more profit to corporations, but it also increases efficiency in the workplace, where companies are able to do more in less time compared to human workers, as touted by another company offering automation, N-ABLE. On top of these benefits, automated labor is also cheaper than manual labor in the long run. As calculated by ARNOLD machine, another automation company, the cost-benefit of automated labor quickly becomes apparent after the second year, illustrating how replacing human workers with automation is much cheaper for corporations.  Not only that, but the rise of automated labor also creates new jobs while encouraging higher education for higher-level work. As automation replaces manual labor, there need to be more workers who are able to develop, run and maintain automation technology. This demand for high skilled labor opens up more job opportunities for higher educated workers. With this in mind, corporations are able to maintain high levels of productivity and profit from automated labor while attracting highly skilled manual laborers, which would reduce the amount of low-skilled workers in the workforce. Evidently, automated labor has incredible value to corporations and those looking to make a profit. But how exactly does automated labor impact the working class and workspaces? Although automation greatly benefits the bourgeoisie and corporations, it has the opposite effect on those in the working class. First and foremost, automation reduces the number of jobs available to low-skilled laborers. As previously mentioned by Slate, more and more jobs are gradually being replaced by automated labor, meaning that low-skilled workers are laid off in exchange for cheaper and more efficient automation. Job shortages can severely impact the working class who are looking to make ends meet. Most members of the working class are forced to work low-skilled jobs, but if those jobs are being replaced by automation then these people will start losing money, which would contribute to the cycle of poverty that entraps so many Americans. Another downside of machines replacing human labor would be the loss of value of human creativity, such as using one’s own personal touch to incorporate human traits into work. An example of the importance of this human touch is food. Robots can make food quickly and efficiently, but they lose out on creativity and design in the process, as well as being inflexible to custom orders unless they are extremely advanced AI. As a result, every product and creation done by AI is repetitive, bland and mundane without the addition of human creativity. Humans are adaptable, artistic and can learn and grow from previous mistakes that robots may never adapt to. As such, automating human labor would have a negative impact on human creativity, an essential aspect of any workplace.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Answers To › FMW reduces Social Services

Federal Minimum Wage increase cuts tax expenditures – reduces reliance on public services

Roberts ’21 [Lily and Ben Olinsky; January 27; Lily Roberts is the managing director of the Economic Policy Team at the Center for American Progress; Ben Olinsky is the senior vice president for policy and strategy at the Center; Senior Fellow; Center for American Progress, "Raising the Minimum Wage Would Boost an Economic Recovery—and Reduce Taxpayer Subsidization of Low-Wage Work", ] PS

Paltry pay with ever-decreasing purchasing power ensures that many people who work full-time for minimum wage pay rely on programs such as SNAP and Medicaid to provide food and health care for their families. This effectively means that the federal government is subsidizing low-wage employers for their labor costs while their workers barely scrape by. CAP has a body of work demonstrating how minimum wage workers use SNAP to keep food on the table for their families—requiring taxpayers to subsidize corporations who underpay their workers.

A by University of California, Berkeley economist Michael Reich and Rachel West found that a contemporaneous proposal to raise the minimum wage to $10.10 per hour would reduce SNAP enrollments by 3.1 to 3.6 million people, resulting in an annual decrease in program expenditures of nearly $4.6 billion.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc – Crowd Out - ! Poverty

Government stimulus weakens the incentive to work and increases reliance on federal spending, trapping people in poverty and stunting innovation.

Millsap ’23 [Adam; August 6; Senior Fellow for economic opportunity issues at Stand Together and Stand Together Trust; Forbes, "The High Costs Of Too Much Government Spending", https://www.forbes.com/sites/adammillsap/2021/08/06/the-high-costs-of-too-much-government-spending/?sh=40d4aa04ad67]

Too much spending reduces economic mobility  via transfers and redistribution. In-kind and cash transfers reduce the incentive to work, and when coupled with sharp means-tested phase out rules—so-called benefits cliffs— and , such transfers often . Government aid, preferably cash transfers that empower people rather than micromanage them, is sometimes necessary to help people get back on their feet. Such aid should be timely, targeted, and temporary, and state and local governments, not the federal government, should play the lead role. The current social safety net is broken and , not more money to feed a system that prevents people from succeeding. Bottom-up ideas that leverage private philanthropy and cutting-edge market-tested solutions are the keys to sustainably reducing poverty and expanding opportunity. Too much spending hurts the environment by using resources inefficiently. Building stuff releases emissions and other pollutants that can damage the environment. As policy analyst Marc Joffe  “During the construction process, new greenhouse gases are produced as steel and concrete are poured, and as vehicles operate at construction sites. Once...finished, those additional carbon emissions need to be factored in...” To mitigate waste and environmental damage, it’s vital to build stuff that people want and will use. The signals of profit and loss can help us determine the value of infrastructure projects, but these signals are often ignored when governments are involved. This results in more waste and unnecessary pollution. Notable examples include the , which has never met its ridership projections, and the  in California that cost taxpayers nearly $200 million despite never being completed. California’s high-speed rail line is  and behind schedule, but supporters are hoping that taxpayers will get the project back on track through federal subsidies in the current infrastructure bill. Each of these projects, and dozens of others, failed to meet the needs of potential users. This means that whatever environmental impacts they had were avoidable. We must be prudent about what we build and not just build for building’s sake. Finally, too much spending encourages a dependency on government that . Government spending financed by higher taxes reduces the incentive to start a new business or expand an existing one. Government redistribution often fosters a culture of dependency and discourages risk-taking. Eventually, an appreciation of innovation as the driver of economic progress is eroded and individuals take fewer moonshots. Countries such as France, Switzerland, Norway, and other Western European countries have high taxes and , which are privately owned startups with valuations of $1 billion or more. It’s clear that France and similar countries no longer have the desire, capability, or both, to harness the ingenuity and creativity of individuals in the private sector to achieve remarkable things. As Adam Thierer , “There are no European versions of Microsoft , Google , or Apple , even though Europeans obviously demand and consume the sort of products and services those U.S.-based companies provide. It’s simply not possible given the EU’s current regulatory regime.” Despite our policy challenges, America has the most innovative and dynamic economy in the world. We must protect it while simultaneously working to improve policy to encourage even more innovation. The dangers of too much government spending are being ignored. Countries and empires throughout history have used vast building projects to justify high levels of taxation and spending. But while adequate roads and bridges help the economy function, it is the people in the private sector who make it grow. It's imperative that government spends prudently so more resources remain in the hands of the entrepreneurs who are the true drivers of innovation.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 1nc Crowd Out NB

Government spending crowds out private sector investment and reduces innovation. Millsap ’23

[Adam; August 6; Senior Fellow for economic opportunity issues at Stand Together and Stand Together Trust; Forbes, "The High Costs Of Too Much Government Spending", https://www.forbes.com/sites/adammillsap/2021/08/06/the-high-costs-of-too-much-government-spending/?sh=40d4aa04ad67]

Too much spending reduces innovation by private sector investment. Estimates of fiscal multipliers are typically less than one, meaning that a dollar of government spending results in less than a dollar’s worth of economic activity since the private sector curtails activity in response to greater government spending. Resources used by the government cannot simultaneously be used by the private sector, and researchers have found that private sector investment and consumption by government spending. Private sector investment is the key ingredient in a growing economy. Less investment means fewer new businesses, fewer expanding businesses, fewer job opportunities, and less innovation. The products and services we rely on today—smart phones, amazon , safer cars, , and more efficient home appliances—would not exist absent private investors willing to take risks. If done well, some government spending can complement private sector activity, e.g., highways that facilitate the movement of people and goods. But this complementarity relies on the government staying within its proper role and not doing what the private sector can do better. Moreover, the federal government is not the appropriate level of government to provide many of these complementary goods and services. State and local governments of all infrastructure, including the entire interstate highway system, all the sewer systems, all the water systems, and 98% of all streets and roads, so they should take the lead on infrastructure.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc - Now Key

Invisible threshold – only a crises will indicate when debt has eroded economic stability too far – must stop expanding entitlement spending now

Bogie and Paris 19 [Justin Bogie and Benjamin Paris; June 14 2019; Bogie is a Former Senior Policy Analyst in Fiscal Affairs, Paris is a Policy Analyst, Regulatory Policy; The Heritage Foundation; ; CP]

Monetary institutions also feel the pressure: As of The Heritage Foundation said, fiscal irresponsibility encourages loose and corrupt policy from the Federal Reserve and drives it out of independence. Already, Fed Chair Jerome Powell has made Federal Reserve “crisis policies” , choosing not to sell off the glut of assets it purchased during the recession. Although the propelled strong economic growth and decades-low unemployment rates, current economic growth does not mean the debt is irrelevant. High debt causes an erosion of economic stability and government’s ability to act in times of crises, until, as Goldwein said, “like the frog in boiling water, we may not notice it until it’s too late.” What does “too late” look like? A spike in interest rates or another kind of shock to the bond market could likely cause a crisis to top the Great Recession, according to Goldwein. As David Ditch of The Heritage Foundation notes, the “looming bankruptcy” of Social Security and Medicare could require the government to drastically increase deficits over a short period, possibly precipitating such a crisis. These programs are popular, but, as Ditch said, a typical American makes $50,000 annually, “getting up in the morning, going to work, putting in [a] 9-to-5 grind, getting up the next morning and doing it again for an entire year.” Entitlement spending and other high expenditures are pushing deficits to $1 trillion, which would be “20 million people’s worth of effort” added to the debt: a high and dangerous human cost that politicians rarely acknowledge and voters rarely act on. To defend against the risks of high national debt, the country must be protected from the federal government’s proclivity for unfunded spending. Ditch likened the U.S. budget process to an “all you can eat buffet” of deficit spending and argues that the government needs a proverbial diet. Boccia highlighted like those in Switzerland, Sweden, and Germany as examples of how such a “diet” might work. The restraints work, she said, because they stick to it and allow flexibility to deal with crises, and they could work here too if Congress is willing to abide by their terms, the panelists said. Unless significant are implemented now, before America’s fiscal position becomes too treacherous, the only option available to lawmakers could be to drastically increase taxes, cut government services, or both, the panelists said. More spending now means higher taxes and a poorer quality of life for future Americans. It is up to all of us to save the country from its Achilles heel. If America cannot stop its debt from destroying its economy, then it will be condemned to the same fate as Achilles at Plutus: remembered only for its timely and deserved demise.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc IL – Econ Growth

Government debt crowds out private investment and chokes economic growth – sky rocking interest rates and cratering economic activity

Stern 6/2/23 [Richard; 6-2-2023; served as a policy staffer for the Republican Study Committee, where he was the staff lead for their Budget and Spending task force and spearheaded their work to create their FY 2020 and FY 2022 federal budgets; Heritage Foundation, "We Traded a Debt Crisis for an Inflation Crisis, and Now We Have Both",

Instead of dealing with the real issue—runaway government spending and power—we quietly traded the specter of a debt crisis for the slow burn of an inflation crisis. Today, however, we have both. Instead of casting the money printers into the fire, the Federal Reserve revved them up and paved the way to the present economic crisis. With the debt ceiling debate, we have the same choice before us today—and we may not get a third chance to save the country. This time, we must push for robust spending cuts and begin dismantling the woke and weaponized federal bureaucracy. At this critical moment, it’s vital to be clear about exactly how our upward spending spiral imperils the well-being of each and every American household and worker. It is easy to point to what governments support. It is much harder to picture all 130 million households whose hard labor is siphoned off to support that government. It’s even harder to point to the entrepreneur who will never go into business or the innovator who will never discover a technological breakthrough because of this siphoning. Hard as it may be to see these missed opportunities and their costs, they are the very real results of ever-expanding government. Regardless of whether a government funds itself through taxes, borrowing, or creating money, it’s at the expense of your future and you being able to use most of the money you earn. The Left has now successfully used every method to fund its priorities and reshape our society. Once federal taxes reached a large share of the economy, depressing real wages and job opportunities, the government shifted to a less transparent funding mechanism: borrowing. When a person or business takes out a loan, their borrowing is limited by their earnings from providing real value for other people. Government borrowing, however, is only limited by how much of the fruits of your labors it will take in the future. That’s why governments don’t really “borrow”—government debt ultimately comes out of your wallet through future taxes or inflation. When governments use this unmatched power, they also crowd out private borrowing. This means families can’t get a mortgage and businesses can’t expand and provide new job opportunities or invest in innovation. A debt crisis happens when a government has borrowed so much that it has sucked the oxygen out of financial markets. This process starves the economy, adding the government’s arbitrary demand for funds to the legitimate needs of the people. As a result, this sends interest rates skyward, creating an increasing interest cost spiral for the government and cratering economic activity. This is when we run into the other limit on government borrowing—when it has bled the nation dry, and investors finally lose confidence in the government and nation. There is, on paper, an easy solution for governments: to create the money they borrow. However, as with any solution that seems easy on paper, this one hides a brutal deal with the devil. The Fed kicked off our inflationary spiral in 2008 when, with federal crowding-out of borrowing on the path to a breaking point, the Fed stepped in to start the most insidious redistribution of wealth from the people to the government: the creation of money out of thin air. This money creation always sets off a cancerous inflation as the new money, divorced from the real production of goods and services, quietly enters the system and begins to unravel the delicate relationships that make up our economy. By muddying the value of the dollar that we use to measure economic activity, this blinds us to what is happening. The price level is only the tip of the iceberg. What flies under the radar is the distortion of economic activity away from what is truly productive and toward what the government wants. In a desperate attempt to cover federal deficits between 2008 and 2021, the Fed increased the monetary base (i.e., printed more money) by more than 650%, while the nominal gross domestic product (the annual sum of all the goods and services produced within the nation’s borders) only grew by 63%—a classic inflationary case of more dollars chasing fewer goods and services. By December of 2021, 87% of all U.S. government-issued dollars had been created as recently as 2008—with nearly half having been created in the first two years of the coronavirus pandemic. That sent inflation rates to 40-year highs and caused the Fed to panic and stop covering federal deficits by slamming on the monetary brakes—in other words, by stopping printing new money and increasing interest rates to attempt to slow down inflation. With federal deficits at record levels and no new money being pumped into the system, interest rates spiked as the government aggressively crowded out the ability of the private sector to borrow. In just 10 months, mortgage rates spiked from 3% to over 7%, adding over $330,000 to the lifetime interest costs of a mortgage on an average home. In short, the Fed is holding the wolf by the ears. Any attempt to tame inflation will starve the economy as the government has its fill at the buffet. Any attempt to ease the government’s crowding-out of borrowing means inflation continues to grow and imposes an indirect but very harsh “tax” on American families. The Fed has lost control because of the magnitude of money—your money—the government is spending. Instead of buying us time, the Fed’s 2008 trade of a debt crisis for an inflation crisis boiled the frog in the pot. The only solution to a government that demands more and more of the fruits of your labors is to cut government spending and power.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc IL – Econ Growth

Rising debt undermines economic growth

Pettis ‘22 [Michael; 2-8-2022; professor of finance at Peking University’s Guanghua School of Management, where he specializes in Chinese financial markets, formerly served as a member of the Board of Directors of ABC-CA Fund Management Company; Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, "How Does Excessive Debt Hurt an Economy?", https://carnegieendowment.org/chinafinancialmarkets/86397]BG

The problem is more concerning when debt rises faster than the country’s real debt-servicing capacity. This occurs when debt boosts the demand for goods and services without directly or indirectly causing an equivalent rise in the production of goods and services. This can happen for a variety of reasons. For example, rising government debt in an economy without excess labor and capacity may fund additional consumption (through welfare payments, for instance), be poured into defense spending, or go toward nonproductive investment in wasted infrastructure (a particular problem in China); ballooning debt could also encourage speculative spikes in prices in the property sector, the stock market, or other assets as demand is boosted through the wealth effect.

In these cases, rising debt increases ex ante demand for goods and services relative to ex ante supply. But because demand must always equal supply, this requires some adjustment mechanism to equilibrate the two (some of which I list above). The first of the three problems with rising debt, then, is if and when the implicit or explicit transfers associated with the adjustment undermine growth directly.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc IL – Debt key Growth

Rising debt will destroy growth - the “Achilles heel” of US economy

Bogie and Paris 19 [Justin Bogie and Benjamin Paris; June 14 2019; Bogie is a Former Senior Policy Analyst in Fiscal Affairs, Paris is a Policy Analyst, Regulatory Policy; The Heritage Foundation; ; CP]

Our economy is strong, but so is the possibility that it may have an Achilles heel—the national debt. That was the consensus of participants in a recent panel discussion at . The unmatched power and recently strong economic growth of the United States masks a dangerous hazard that could lead to our collective downfall, the panel agreed. And if left unchecked, debt could threaten the prosperity of future generations. It’s a bipartisan issue, the panel pointed out. Americans agree, in overwhelming numbers—as in 94% of Republicans and 92% of Democrats, according to recent by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation—that future generations will be better off if the national debt is managed. Marc Goldwein, senior vice president and senior policy director at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, said at the event that national debt crowds out investment as investors purchase government bonds rather than buying private assets or otherwise investing in the private sector. Over time, he argued, that could result in “slower wage growth, slower income growth, and a smaller overall economy.” Deficit spending tends to promote consumption, whereas the private investment Goldwein believes is crowded out otherwise would go toward elements of economic growth, such as “buildings, equipment, tools, software, and education.” Every bond issued by government might mean a factory that doesn’t open, a building that doesn’t get built, a worker who doesn’t get trained, Goldwein said. Meanwhile, deficit spending most often feeds less productive parts of the economy, such as public housing, college funding, and entitlement-based consumption. The debt also exerts pressure on the U.S. government. Goldwein said spending on interest on the debt will exceed Medicaid within a year. In just five years, it will overtake all defense spending, creating a potential threat to national security. In 30 years, it is to be the single-largest federal expenditure. Monetary institutions also feel the pressure: As of The Heritage Foundation said, fiscal irresponsibility encourages loose and corrupt policy from the Federal Reserve and drives it out of independence. Already, Fed Chair Jerome Powell has made Federal Reserve “crisis policies” , choosing not to sell off the glut of assets it purchased during the recession. Although the propelled strong economic growth and decades-low unemployment rates, current economic growth does not mean the debt is irrelevant.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc IL – Debt key Growth

Debt key threat to growth – increasing interest payments push US over the brink

Ditch 19 [David Ditch; November 4 2019; Senior Policy Analyst, Hermann Center for the Federal Budget; The Heritage Foundation; ; CP]

The most significant threat to our national security is our debt.” That’s what Adm. Michael Mullen in 2010. Back then, Mullen was chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. And the federal debt totaled $13 trillion. Now, nine years later, the debt is on the verge of reaching . To make matters worse, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office expects annual deficits of starting with the current fiscal year and continuing for at least the next 30 years. This will be the case even without a recession, a major war, or the addition of new programs. Mullen’s 2010 warning did not imply that debt would sink the country the next day. Perhaps that’s why our political leaders have largely ignored this threat. But that reckless mindset endangers our security and prosperity. It is urgent that lawmakers rein in the debt before it is too late. Our deteriorating fiscal position is one of very few challenges large enough to threaten ruin for the United States. And it threatens on two fronts. First, as the national debt grows, so too will interest payments on the debt. These payments far faster than our total economy, increasing drag on economic growth. America’s economic might was crucial to defeating the axis powers in World War II and to outlasting the USSR during the Cold War. Slow (or no) economic growth means fewer resources are available to ensure national security. Second, the lack of responsible budgeting threatens to needed funding for . As interest payments and non-defense programs further federal spending, pressure rises to restrain overall spending by slashing the military budget.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 2nc IL – Defense spending key

US defense spending strength key – China abuse vulnerability and invade Taiwan.

Gordon ‘6/23 [Susan M., Michael G. Mullen; 6-2023; principal Deputy Director of National Intelligence until 2019, prior to that role, she was the Deputy Director of the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency; retired United States Navy admiral, Previous chief of Naval Operations, Mullen was the highest-ranking officer in the United States Armed Forces and diversified the top ranks of the Pentagon; Council on Foreign Relations, “U.S.-Taiwan Relations in a New Era” https://www.cfr.org/task-force-report/us-taiwan-relations-in-a-new-era?gclid=CjwKCAjw44mlBhAQEiwAqP3eViAaynolioS2NYyzMV4mKr1G54y4CB_deVo2ayRczQ3GpYW_fUumlBoCqHsQAvD_BwE]BG

A conflict between the United States and the People’s Republic of China (PRC, or China) over Taiwan is becoming increasingly imaginable, a result of China’s growing military capabilities and assertiveness, the emergence and coalescence of a separate Taiwanese identity, and evolving U.S. calculations about its interests at stake in the Taiwan Strait. If deterrence fails and a war erupts, the result would be calamitous for Taiwan, China, the United States, and the world, resulting in thousands of casualties on all sides and a profound global economic depression. The United States has critical strategic interests in the Taiwan Strait. If China were to successfully annex Taiwan against the will of the Taiwanese people, doing so on the heels of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, it would severely undermine international order by again demonstrating that countries can use coercion or force to unilaterally redraw borders. If China were to station its military on the island, the United States would find it far more difficult to project power, defend its treaty allies, and operate in international waters in the Western Pacific. U.S. influence would wane because its allies would question U.S. commitment to their defense and either accommodate China or pursue strategic autonomy. A war in the Taiwan Strait would also halt the production and shipment of the majority of the world’s semiconductors, paralyzing global supply chains and ushering in a severe economic crisis. Finally, if China were to take control of Taiwan, it would spell the end of a liberal democracy and have chilling effects on democracies around the world. The Task Force thus finds that it is vital for the United States to deter China from using force or coercion to achieve unification with Taiwan. The Task Force assesses that although China is developing the military capabilities it would need to annex Taiwan and is determined to subjugate the island, it has not yet decided to pursue a nonpeaceful resolution and deterrence remains possible. Although war is not inevitable, unless the United States moves with urgency to bolster deterrence and shape Chinese leader Xi Jinping’s decision-making calculus to raise the costs of aggressive action against Taiwan, the odds of a conflict will increase. Reinforcing deterrence without provoking the conflict that it seeks to avoid is no small task. Indeed, some argue that, given the risk, the United States should lessen its support for Taiwan. Such a course, however, fails to adequately reckon with what the world would look like the day after a successful Chinese assault: markedly less safe, less free, and less prosperous. Beyond deterring Chinese aggression, the United States also has an interest in enhancing its unofficial relationship with a top-ten trading partner, a fellow democracy, and a like-minded force on global issues. The Task Force finds that the political framework established more than four decades ago, whereby Taiwan, China, and the United States all embrace different conceptions of Taiwan’s relationship to China but do not explicitly challenge one another’s position, is becoming more and more brittle. This reality, paired with Xi’s unease with the status quo and his determination to make progress toward unification, increases the risk of a conflict. In particular, the Task Force finds that the prevailing political framework has allowed for peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait while enabling rapid economic growth in both Taiwan and China; the status quo is under increasing strain as China, Taiwan, and the United States reevaluate whether the long-standing political formulation continues to serve their respective interests; the likelihood of resolving cross-strait differences peacefully is steadily decreasing; as the prospect of achieving peaceful unification grows more remote, China will increasingly employ coercive tools against Taiwan; and the chance of a conflict will rise as Xi Jinping approaches the end of his tenure and the basis of his legitimacy shifts from delivering economic growth to satisfying Chinese nationalism. The Task Force analyzed how Taiwan’s role as the primary producer of the world’s semiconductors, including nearly all of the most advanced chips, would affect deterrence and China’s calculus. The Task Force concludes that although China’s reliance on chips manufactured in Taiwan would raise the costs of a conflict, it does not act as a “silicon shield” that can protect Taiwan from an attack. The greater danger is that China will be able to leverage economic interdependence to deter countries from coming to Taiwan’s direct or indirect defense. The Task Force finds that Taiwan’s critical role in global supply chains—above all, semiconductor production—acts as a brake to hostilities but does not diminish China’s desire to gain control over Taiwan; in addition to the devastation for the people of Taiwan, a conflict would also trigger a global economic depression and open-ended era of hostility between the world’s two leading powers; Taiwan’s dependence on trade with China provides Beijing with leverage over Taipei that could reduce the latter’s options during a crisis; U.S. and allied reliance on semiconductors produced in Taiwan raises the stakes for the United States and the West in a conflict; and U.S. and allied economic interdependence with China would complicate efforts to resist Chinese aggression against Taiwan and impose costs on Beijing. The Task Force asserts that the United States has not only legal but also vital strategic reasons for maintaining the capacity to come to Taiwan’s direct defense. At the same time, however, China’s rapid military modernization, Taiwan’s underinvestment in its military, and U.S. military gaps mean that the United States cannot assume that it would be able to decisively intervene on Taiwan’s behalf. The Task Force finds that deterrence is steadily eroding in the Taiwan Strait and is at risk of failing, increasing the likelihood of Chinese aggression; China does not yet have the ability to invade and seize Taiwan in the face of U.S. intervention, but, barring a significant transformation of Taiwan’s military and sustained focus from the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD), it will likely gain the capability to do so by the end of the decade; despite some progress, Taiwan is still not doing enough to address critical shortfalls in its defense and civil resilience; the United States has major military gaps that it is addressing but that would nonetheless make coming to Taiwan’s defense difficult and costly; and support from allies and partners will be imperative for a U.S. defense of Taiwan, but the level of assistance the United States can expect is largely unknown. The Task Force recommends that U.S. diplomacy focus on preserving the political foundation that has worked for decades but has become increasingly challenged by all sides. U.S. diplomacy should aim to deter Chinese aggression, signal to China and Taiwan that it opposes unilateral changes to the status quo, and ensure that any future arrangement between China and Taiwan be arrived at peacefully and with the assent of the Taiwanese people. In support of these objectives, the United States should maintain its One China policy, recognizing the PRC as the sole legal government of China and eschewing formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan while fulfilling its unique legal commitments to the island, and emphasize that such a policy is predicated on China pursuing a peaceful resolution of cross-strait issues; avoid symbolic political and diplomatic gestures that provoke a Chinese response but do not meaningfully improve Taiwan’s defensive capabilities, resilience, or economic competitiveness; explain to the American people why Taiwan matters and why they should care about its fate; create additional international and multilateral forums that allow Taiwan to have its voice heard and contribute to resolving global issues, in a way that does not suggest Taiwanese independence; and promote people-to-people ties between the United States and Taiwan. The United States should assist Taiwan in reducing its economic dependence on the PRC and bolstering its integration into the global economy, which would improve Taiwan’s ability to withstand China’s economic coercion. In addition, given its heavy reliance on Taiwan for semiconductor manufacturing, the United States needs to ensure that Taiwan remains a trusted economic and trading partner. In particular, the Task Force recommends that the United States negotiate a bilateral trade agreement with Taiwan; diversify supply chains in critical sectors to reduce the risk from potential Chinese economic retaliation; build resiliency in global semiconductor manufacturing; raise awareness of the economic consequences of a Chinese blockade or attack on Taiwan with allies and partners and coordinate with them to prepare sanctions on China; and work with Taiwan to reduce the PRC’s economic leverage and respond to its economic coercion. The Task Force maintains that deterring Chinese aggression against Taiwan should be the United States’ top priority in the Indo-Pacific. As a core objective, the United States should ensure that every time Chinese leaders look across the Taiwan Strait, they conclude that a blockade or invasion would fail and that pursuing such a course would make it impossible for them to accomplish China’s modernization objectives. Achieving this goal will be difficult but doable with the correct mix of policies. To accomplish it, the Task Force recommends that the United States prioritize Taiwan contingencies as the DOD pacing scenario and ensure DOD spending supports capabilities and initiatives critical to success, securing the United States’ ability to effectively come to Taiwan’s defense; fundamentally shift U.S.-Taiwan security relations to build Taiwan’s self-defense capabilities; seek greater clarity from allies on the assistance they would provide during Taiwan contingencies and work to improve their capabilities and define their roles and responsibilities; place the U.S. defense industrial base on a wartime footing now to ensure that the U.S. military has the capabilities it needs to deter Chinese aggression and prioritize arms deliveries to Taiwan; and conduct a joint study with Taiwan of its war reserve munitions, ability to produce weapons during wartime, and stockpile of essential goods. U.S. policy toward Taiwan needs to evolve to contend with a more capable, assertive, and risk-acceptant China that is increasingly dissatisfied with the status quo. Making long overdue adjustments will be difficult, but a failure to adapt is far more dangerous. The future of the world’s most economically critical region could very well hinge on whether the United States succeeds in deterring China and maintaining peace in the Taiwan Strait.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 1nc Debt NB

US-China war goes nuclear---any other scenario is too optimistic

Boot ‘4/17/23 [Max; 4-17-2023; historian, best-selling author and foreign-policy analyst who has been called one of the “world’s leading authorities on armed conflict” by the International Institute for Strategic Studies. He is the Jeane J. Kirkpatrick senior fellow for national security studies at the Council on Foreign Relations and a columnist for The Washington Post.; Washington Post, " In the U.S.-China competition, the real ‘existential’ danger is nuclear war", https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/04/17/china-united-states-nuclear-conflict-danger/]BG

I keep thinking about the comment that Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-Wis.) made at the first hearing, back on Feb. 28, of the House select committee on the Chinese Communist Party (CCP): “This is an existential struggle over what life will look like in the 21st century, and the most fundamental freedoms are at stake.” The committee chairman was right, but not in the way that he meant. A leading China hawk, Gallagher claimed: “The CCP is laser-focused on its vision for the future — a world crowded with techno-totalitarian surveillance states where human rights are subordinate to the whims of the party.” While it’s true that the Chinese Communist Party has created a system of “techno-totalitarian surveillance” in China and is happy to sell its surveillance technology to other countries, there is scant evidence that it is conspiring to export its system of oppression globally. Gallagher’s vision is merely an update of the old Cold War paranoia about a supposed Soviet plot to take over the world, which missed the fact that Soviet leaders were driven primarily by defensive concerns about their own security. But Gallagher is right that the United States and China are locked in an existential struggle, because this new cold war, like the original Cold War with the Soviet Union, has the potential to turn into a nuclear conflict. This is a danger that China hawks — and the U.S. public in general — do not pay sufficient attention to. President Biden, for example, repeatedly says that the United States will defend Taiwan if it’s attacked, without any mention of the potential consequences of a conflict with China. “It seems odd that war with China over Taiwan seems a comfortable assumption for so many when the U.S. and NATO remain cautious about Russia’s war in Ukraine precisely because of the perceived risk of nuclear escalation,” John K. Culver, a CIA veteran and former national intelligence officer for East Asia, told me. Even many worst-case scenarios about China are too sanguine about the outcome of a conflict. In March, for example, House Republicans took part in a U.S.-China war game organized by retired Rear Adm. Mark Montgomery, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. After the exercise was first reported by my Post colleague Olivier Knox, I reached out to Montgomery to ask how it unfolded and whether it included a nuclear exchange. He said, “The war game ended up with China having a lodgment on Taiwan, but not having defeated the Taiwan Army.” The United States suffered “significant casualties” and Taiwan “awful casualties.” Montgomery explained that the scenario “did not escalate to nuclear, although that is certainly a possibility in this sort of contingency.” The lack of a nuclear exchange is quite common in U.S.-China war games, at least those conducted at the unclassified level. (A senior defense official told me this is no longer the case with top-secret Pentagon war games.) A recent war game organized by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), like the congressional war game, had the United States and its allies defeating a Chinese invasion of Taiwan. Victory came at “high cost” — “The United States and its allies lost dozens of ships, hundreds of aircraft, and tens of thousands of service members” — but not at the highest cost: i.e., the destruction of U.S. cities. CSIS senior adviser Mark F. Cancian told me that, although he would pursue “a follow-on project that looks at nuclear operations,” he wanted to focus specifically on conventional operations. That’s a perfectly legitimate choice, but it inadvertently risks reinforcing assumptions that a U.S.-China conflict could avoid nuclear escalation. Even a New York Times op-ed in February written by an Australian scholar, headlined “A War With China Would Be Unlike Anything Americans Faced Before,” focused on cyberwarfare and economic warfare — not nuclear warfare. And yet China is in the midst of a rapid nuclear buildup. The latest Pentagon report on Chinese military power projects that its nuclear stockpile will grow from 400 warheads today to 1,500 warheads by 2035. The report also warns that, while China nominally adheres to a “no first use” policy on nuclear weapons, “Beijing probably would … consider nuclear use to restore deterrence if a conventional military defeat gravely threatened PRC survival.” Given that a failed invasion of Taiwan could threaten the CCP’s power, it’s reasonable to worry that China could up the ante by going nuclear. The risk of nuclear escalation is all the greater because, as a senior U.S. admiral explained to me, it would be difficult for the United States to win a war over Taiwan by attacking only Chinese ships at sea and Chinese aircraft in the skies. The United States could find itself compelled, as a matter of military necessity, to attack bases in China. China, in turn, could strike U.S. bases in Japan, South Korea, the Philippines, Guam, even Hawaii and the West Coast. Culver, the former intelligence officer, told me, “Even if Beijing announced that its retaliatory strikes against Hawaii or the West Coast of the U.S. were conventionally armed, it would risk immediate U.S. escalation. Can a U.S. president refuse to launch in the 30 minutes between missile launch from China and impact in the U.S.?” When two nuclear-armed powers attack each other’s territory, it would be difficult to keep the conflict contained at a conventional level. Both sides, admittedly, would have an incentive to avoid “mutual assured destruction,” but countries often act rashly in the heat of battle, particularly after they have suffered significant casualties and feel the need to ensure that their troops did not die in vain. For a sense of how destructive a war with China could be, read “2034: A Novel of the Next World War” by retired Adm. James Stavridis, a former supreme allied commander in Europe, and Marine combat veteran Elliot Ackerman. It ends — spoiler alert — with nuclear devastation in both countries. Stavridis told me: “If the U.S. and China manage to sleepwalk into a conventional war, the chances of it escalating into a nuclear exchange are significant. Two great powers who face each other in combat are unlikely to avoid using tactical nuclear weapons, at least at sea. Once that threshold is crossed, it is but a short step to a much broader nuclear conflict. Think 1914 with nuclear weapons at the ready.” 1914 with nuclear weapons? Now that’s an existential danger.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 1nc Debt NB

Such cuts weaken US national security and emboldens China – no other financing options will be available as debt deepens

Shultz ’21 [George P, John F. Cogan and John B. Taylor; 2-23-2021; US Secretary of State (1982-89), Secretary of the Treasury (1972-74), Secretary of Labor (1969-70), and a fellow at the Hoover Institution; senior fellow at the Hoover Institution and a faculty member in the Public Policy Program at Stanford University; former under-secretary of the US Treasury (2001-05), is Professor of Economics at Stanford University; Project Syndicate, "America’s Excessive Government Spending Must Stop", https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/risks-of-excessive-us-government-spending-by-george-p-shultz-et-al-2021-02]BG

Congress may be tempted to reduce defense spending to help close the deficit, as it often has done in the past. But these previous efforts demonstrably failed. Rather than reduce the budget deficit, Congress instead used the savings from lower defense outlays to finance additional domestic spending.

Unless policymakers abandon their misguided beliefs about budget deficits, cutting defense expenditure now would produce the same result. More importantly, it would be a grave strategic mistake, weakening US national security and emboldening the country’s foreign adversaries – particularly now that China is flexing its muscles in Asia and investing heavily in its military.2

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 1nc Debt NB

Expanding government spending causes backlash against defense spending – destroying military readiness

Ditch 19 [David Ditch; November 4 2019; Senior Policy Analyst, Hermann Center for the Federal Budget; The Heritage Foundation; ; CP]

First, as the national debt grows, so too will interest payments on the debt. These payments far faster than our total economy, increasing drag on economic growth. America’s economic might was crucial to defeating the axis powers in World War II and to outlasting the USSR during the Cold War. Slow (or no) economic growth means fewer resources are available to ensure national security. Second, the lack of responsible budgeting threatens to needed funding for . As interest payments and non-defense programs further federal spending, pressure rises to restrain overall spending by slashing the military budget. For example, a recent New York Times called for going after defense activities to (partially) fund an expansion of the Medicare program. is the root of the problem. In contrast to media reports blaming today’s deficits on the 2017 tax cut, the reality is that federal tax revenue is close to the historical average and expected to rise. In contrast, spending is already well above average (especially outside of major war or severe recession), and will soon reach levels not seen since World War II. The surge comes from many directions, including spending limit “” to grease the skids for annual appropriations and unchecked (such as often-questionable “emergency” spending) to the limits. However, the largest factor by far is entitlement programs such as Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. These programs will account for of the expected spending increase over the next decade. The vast majority of Americans receive from programs such as Social Security and Medicare than they paid in lifetime payroll taxes, which means that without reforms, younger workers would face much higher taxes to keep these programs solvent. Despite the $23 trillion federal debt and the enormous challenge to reform Social Security and Medicare, there is to America’s fiscal problems. The Heritage Foundation’s contains hundreds of policy ideas. The plan covers taxes, national defense, major entitlements, wasteful programs, welfare program reforms, and much more. Yet merely having a plan is only a first step towards solving the problem. Enacting the plan will require political leadership and courage that has been sorely lacking from both parties. Most politicians want to avoid making difficult choices on taxes and spending; it’s easier to just pile up debt. Until they face political consequences for doing so, they will keep passing the bill for today’s bloated government on to future generations. Members of the public can arm themselves with cold, hard facts by turning to another Heritage Foundation resource: , which presents vital, up-to-date information through streamlined graphics. It is time to stop shirking responsibility and tackle the debt head-on. America’s economy, national defense and children are depending on it.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › 1nc Debt NB

No defense budget cuts now – GOP pressure sufficient

Bolton ’23 [Alexander Bolton; 2-12-2023; Alexander Bolton is a reporter at The Hill; Hill, "Chinese spy balloon has GOP saying no cuts to defense", ] LG

A growing number of Senate Republicans are saying that President Biden and Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) should take defense spending cuts off the table in their negotiation over the debt ceiling. The Republicans are digging in their heels after receiving a classified briefing on a Chinese spy balloon that floated over sensitive military installations. “The entire civilized world should recognize that communist China is probably the greatest threat we’ve ever faced, more severe than Soviet Russia was because of its economic integration into the West,” said Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) after receiving a briefing from senior administration officials on the spy balloon. “We should take every step we can to try to reduce our dependency on China [and] try to build stronger military deterrence against them. “I do not think that we should be talking about cutting the defense budget at all right now. If anything, substantial defense increases,” he said.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › Federal version - Avoids Elections DA

Low- and middle income households favor increasing the minimum wage

Davis and Hartig, ’19 – Leslie Davis is an intern at Pew Research Center and Hannah Hartig is a research associate at Pew Research Center (“Two-thirds of Americans favor raising federal minimum wage to $15 an hour,” Pew Research Center, 7/30/19, https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/07/30/two-thirds-of-americans-favor-raising-federal-minimum-wage-to-15-an-hour/)//CTP

Majorities across all income levels favor a $15 federal minimum wage. Nearly three-quarters (74%) of those with annual family incomes of less than $40,000 favor this increase, as does a narrower majority of those with family incomes of $75,000 or more (61%).

At least eight-in-ten Democrats across all income levels back this increase. In contrast, lower-income Republicans are more likely than those with higher incomes to support this proposal: 56% of Republicans with annual incomes of less than $40,000 say they favor raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour, compared with 34% of Republicans with incomes of $75,000 or more.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Net Benefits › Federal version - Avoids Elections DA

Raising minimum wage popular, even among Republicans

Kinder 22[Molly; November 13; Senior Fellow at New America and Director of Research, “Even a divided America agrees on raising the minimum wage,” https://www.brookings.edu/articles/even-a-divided-america-agrees-on-raising-the-minimum-wage/]

While Florida’s split vote may seem counterintuitive, in fact, recent polls suggest it is consistent with widespread public opinion. Two-thirds (67%) of Americans surveyed last year by the Pew Research Center expressed support for raising the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour. Now, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, this position has grown significantly, especially among Republicans and independents. A pair of surveys conducted in February and August showed a surge in support for raising the minimum wage. In the August survey, a majority of Republicans backed raising the minimum wage to a level where full-time workers earn more than poverty wages. Overall, more than seven in 10 respondents supported raising the minimum wage.

Minorities and women favor raising the minimum wage

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Unions

Increase of FMW has wide support – improves favorability of unions and worker rights

Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]

Our analysis has investigated the interplay among labor unions, minimum wages, news coverage, and public opinion. Unions have advocated extensively for recent minimum wage increases. In the wake of recent minimum wage legislation, we find that union membership has tended to rise among individuals in the first half of their careers. We use this setting to differentiate among several models of membership in unions or other interest groups. We find support for the idea that minimum wage increases benefit unions by improving their public image as effective advocates. Following minimum wage increases, we find that workers whose wages are not affected become more likely to both join a labor union and to have favorable views of labor unions. By contrast, the direct beneficiaries of minimum 41 wage increases become less likely to join. The latter finding points to the relevance of free-riding concerns that have been emphasized in past research on the effects of Right to Work legislation. Finally, we analyze news coverage of political and legislative moments in the minimum wage movement’s recent history. This analysis provides evidence on a potential mechanism behind the minimum wage’s effects on union membership. We find that the passage and enactment of minimum wage increases predict increases in newspaper coverage that discusses both the minimum wage and key players in the labor movement. Inspection of the underlying articles provides suggestive evidence of a successful public relations strategy. That is, analysts in the labor movement help shape news coverage by disseminating analyses as journalists write stories about the enactment of minimum wage increases. Improved access to analyses may, in turn, shape the favorability of news coverage. At a minimum, by making their analyses accessible, advocates can increase the likelihood that news coverage conveys their point of view. An understanding of the relationships among interest groups, news coverage, public opinion, and public policy is important for understanding the democratic process. Our analysis illustrates how groups can gain influence by developing reputations for being effective, publicspirited advocates. Groups’ competition for voters’ loyalties may thus occur, at least in part, through media strategies and demonstrations of effective advocacy. More research is needed, however, to understand the mechanisms through which such strategies might work and to explore their generality.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Unions

Increase of FMW expands unions beyond direct beneficiaries – raises public and private sector unions

Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]

In this section, we present evidence that speaks to the plausibility of alternative theories of interest-group membership. We do this by presenting analyses that divide the population into subsamples that (1) are directly affected by the minimum wage, (2) may be indirectly affected by 11 These variables come from the State and Legislative Partisan Composition Database from the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL, 2020). 28 the minimum wage, or (3) are not plausibly affected by the minimum wage. We also present evidence on the relationship between minimum wage increases and union wage differentials. Analyses of Subgroups of Workers In this section, we provide evidence on which types of workers and demographic groups are more likely to become members of unions in the wake of minimum wage increases. The subgroups we analyze differentiate between individuals who might be directly impacted by the minimum wage, who might benefit indirectly from the minimum wage, and whose employment and wages have no plausible connection to the minimum wage. To be more specific, we distinguish between public- and private-sector workers, between high- and low-education workers, and between workers employed in high- and low-wage industries. We first explore the relationship between minimum wage increases and public- versus private-sector union membership. This distinction is relevant for two reasons. First, public- and private-sector unions have been on different paths for decades; private-sector unions have declined, while public-sector unions have retained their strength. Second, minimum wage increases tend to affect neither the wages nor the employment of public-sector workers. We estimate our full sample regression using dependent variables that differentiate between public- and private-sector union membership. These specifications are designed so that our overall estimate can be readily decomposed into public and private components. The estimates, which appear in Table 6, imply that public-sector union membership accounts for roughly half the overall increase we observe. For further context, note that public-sector union membership accounts for roughly half of all union membership among individuals age 16–40 at 29 baseline, but less than 15 percent of this group’s employment. On average across these broad groups of workers, the minimum wage has a weak correlation with wages (Panel B). We next add an education dimension to our analysis of both public- and private-sector union membership. Specifically, we analyze the relationship between minimum wage increases and public- versus private-sector union membership among individuals with at least some college education. We analyze this sample to further probe the evidence that minimum wage increases cause increases in union membership among groups that are not directly affected by the minimum wage. The estimates in Panel B of Table 7 reveal, as should be expected, that minimum wage increases have no impact on these groups’ wage rates. The estimates in Panel A reveal that minimum wage increases quite strongly predict increases in these groups’ rates of union membership. Together, these results provide evidence that a comprehensive theory of union membership will need to include nonmaterial factors. Our next piece of analysis focuses on individuals employed in minimum-wage-intensive industries. Specifically, we focus on the food-service and retail industries. We present this analysis in Table 8. Panel A presents estimates of the impact of minimum wage increases on these individuals’ union membership rates, while Panel B presents estimates of impacts on wages. Each column presents an analysis of a different subsample, with individuals differentiated based on age and education. The estimates in columns 1 and 2 focus on individuals who are employed in food-service and retail industries and who are between ages 16 and 21. The estimates in columns 1 and 2 of Panel B reveal that these individuals’ wages are quite strongly impacted. On average, a $1 increase in the minimum wage predicts a wage increase of around 32 cents for these individuals. 30 The estimate is modestly larger in column 1, where we do not include controls for macroeconomic covariates, relative to column 2. The estimates in columns 1 and 2 of Panel A reveal that young individuals in low-wage occupations are less likely to belong to unions following minimum wage increases. Note that this sample consists of individuals who are employed and who experienced wage gains due to minimum wage increases. The sample thus contains the minimum wage’s direct beneficiaries. The decline in this group’s union membership thus appears inconsistent with theories that view membership and payment of dues as a form of reciprocity. While the evidence in columns 1 and 2 is inconsistent with a reciprocity-oriented theory of union membership, it is consistent with “free riding.” The free-rider problem has received attention in research on the effects of Right to Work laws on union membership. Right to Work laws tend to reduce union membership because they enable workers to benefit from unionnegotiated wages without paying dues (Baird, 1998). More generally, these laws allow workers to sidestep union restrictions on who can work. For young retail and food-service workers, a minimum wage increase and union membership can be viewed as substitutable sources of bargaining leverage. Consequently, the minimum wage increase reduces the direct material benefit these individuals might obtain from joining a union. Among moderately skilled individuals in minimum-wage-intensive industries, we find no evidence of changes in union membership. Interestingly, while the estimates lack statistical significance, we tend to find a positive relationship between minimum wages and union membership for older workers in these industries. This is of interest because these individuals may benefit indirectly if minimum wage increases result in increases in employers’ skill 31 requirements (Clemens, Kahn, and Meer, 2020). Because the estimates are imprecise, however, the evidence is less strong than the evidence we see elsewhere. Estimates of the Relationship Between Minimum Wage Increases and Union Wage Differentials In this section, we present estimates of the relationship between minimum wage increases and union wage differentials. Effects of minimum wage increases on union wage differentials may shed light on the relevance of direct material interests for individuals’ decisions to join unions. That said, our estimates must be interpreted with caution due to concerns linked to selection. That is, we have shown that minimum wage increases predict increases in union membership rates. Observed changes in union wage differentials may thus be driven by changes in the composition of which workers are in unions. Our estimates of the relationship between minimum wages and union wage differentials are in Table 9. In column 1, we estimate that the relationship between minimum wages and the union wage differential is negative across all employed workers. In columns 2 and 3, we estimate the relationship separately for private- and public-sector workers. Columns 4 and 5 focus on workers in low-wage industries. Finally, in columns 6, 7, and 8 we analyze sub-samples that are differentiated by educational attainment. The relationship between minimum wage increases and the union wage differential is positive for workers in the food-service and retail industries, but negative in all other groupings we consider. In most specifications, we observe a negative relationship between minimum wages and union wage differentials. This provides additional evidence that a narrow notion of material interest is unlikely to be the primary driver of changes in union membership. A key caveat to this 32 interpretation is that union wage premiums may shift due to changes in the composition of union workers. This may explain the positive relationship we observe in column 4 of Table 9, for example, since the analysis in Table 8 revealed that young workers in the food-service and retail industries become less likely to be members of unions following minimum wage increases. That said, our evidence on union wage premiums has implications that are consistent with our earlier subsample analyses. That is, we see no evidence to suggest that increases in union membership among high-education individuals are driven by material benefit in the form of higher wage.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Unions

No alt causes – minimum wage raises increase union membership

Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]

We investigate the relevance of these threats to our estimation framework through a standard set of best-practice robustness checks. To investigate the relevance of preexisting trends in union membership, we use event-study estimators to check for such trends directly. We find no evidence that trends in union membership had diverged before the enactment of minimum wage increases. We also investigate whether we obtain similar results if we implement synthetic control methods. These methods are designed to ensure that “treatment” and “control” states followed similar trajectories before the implementation of minimum wage increases. We find that synthetic control methods yield results similar to our more basic, baseline approach. We further investigate the relevance of economic shocks that might shape both union membership trends and preferences over minimum wage increases. When we control for proxies 4 for macroeconomic conditions, we find that the relationship between minimum wages and union membership rates strengthens. Further, we find that variation in minimum wages is uncorrelated with changes in other labor market regulations. Our results are also robust to controlling for the partisan composition of state governments. Finally, we implement a simple matching approach to check for the relevance of differences in states’ baseline union membership rates. Our findings are robust to using these alternative methods. Taken together, our initial analysis finds robust evidence that recent minimum wage increases have led to increases in union membership rates. We next take our analysis further in an attempt to differentiate among alternative theories of the causes of union membership. To do so, we begin by investigating which groups of workers become more likely to be members of unions following minimum wage changes. To analyze the mechanisms through which minimum wage increases shape union membership, we consider three distinct groups of workers. The first group consists of individuals who are directly affected by minimum wage increases. The second group consists of individuals who may be indirectly affected due to their employment as high-skilled workers in minimumwage-intensive industries. The third group consists of individuals in industries that are unlikely to be affected by the minimum wage. Our proxies for these groups involve differences across industries, between the public and private sector, and between high- and low-education workers. As we show through analyses of wage data, high-education workers and public-sector workers have wages that are not affected by the minimum wage. Wage data reveal that the minimum wage’s direct impacts are concentrated among young and low-education individuals in low-wage food service and retail industries. 5 Our analysis reveals that minimum wage increases affect union membership rates among the groups we analyze in distinctive ways. First, we find strong evidence for gains in union membership among workers with high levels of education, in particular when they are employed in the public sector. Second, we find declines in union membership among low-skilled individuals in low-wage industries. 3 This second group contains the minimum wage’s direct beneficiaries. Importantly, this second group thus consists of workers for whom a minimum wage increase may substitute for the bargaining power associated with union membership. Finally, we assess several mechanisms through which alternative theories of union membership might work. First, we investigate whether minimum wage increases predict increases in union wage premiums. We find that they do not. Second, we find that news coverage tracks key moments in the legislative histories of minimum wage increases.4 Minimum wage changes predict spikes in the number of articles that jointly discuss the benefits of minimum wages and key players in the labor movement. Further, we show that events in the legislative histories of minimum wage changes do not increase total coverage of organized labor, but shift the character of that coverage towards articles about minimum wages. Finally, using polling data, we find that minimum wage increases predict increases in the favorability of public perceptions of labor unions. 3 Notably, this is true of a sample of individuals who remain employed in those industries, implying that they experienced direct positive effects of minimum wage changes. Indeed, we provide direct evidence that this group’s wages are quite strongly and positively impacted by the minimum wage changes we analyze. 4 Using counts of local news articles assembled using LexisNexis, we find that minimum wage increases are associated with increases in articles about the minimum wage, including those that quote labor advocates or otherwise discuss key players in the labor movement. We also observe increases in counts of articles about the minimum wage at crucial stages in the legislative process, including the months in which state legislators introduced minimum wage legislation and the months in which such legislation was passed. 6 Our findings relate to several literatures of potential interest. First, we add to a long history of work on the determinants of union membership. A relevant slice of this literature considers Right to Work laws. These laws enable workers to benefit from a union’s presence without paying dues, which raises free-rider considerations (Lumsden and Petersen, 1975; Ellwood and Fine, 1987; Moore, 1998). Our emphasis on the role of unions as participants in social or political movements connects to Freeman (1998), who analyzes the “spurt” of union membership growth connected to society-wide economic change during the Great Depression. In our analysis, we find evidence that union membership rates can be shaped by the enactment of popular labor market policies with which unions have actively associated themselves. That said, we also find that the free-rider considerations raised by studies of Right to Work laws are a relevant concern, as the minimum wage’s direct beneficiaries become less likely to join unions following minimum wage increases. Second, we contribute to the literature on the question of what unions actually do. This question is perhaps most famously associated with the aptly named “What Do Unions Do?” by Freeman and Medoff (1984). Much of this literature focuses on estimating union wage premiums (Freeman and Medoff, 1981; Hirsch and Schumacher, 2001) and assessing how changes in union density affect wage inequality (Card, 1996; Card, Lemieux, and Riddell, 2004; Farber, Herbst, Kuziemko, and Naidu, 2018). Some work in the economics literature has focused on the role of unions as “a voice both at the work place and in the political arena” (Freeman and Medoff, 1979). Our analysis of news coverage provides evidence that the labor movement participates in the political process, in part, by shaping news coverage of minimum wages. In this news environment, minimum wage increases predict increases in union membership and improvement in public sentiment toward unions. 7 Third, we relate our evidence to potential channels through which an interest group might accumulate members and influence. One channel, for example, is for a group to work towards the material benefit of its members (Buchanan, 1965; Olsen, 1965). Interestingly, we find that the minimum wage’s most direct beneficiaries become less, rather than more, likely to join unions. As noted above, this finding is consistent with models that emphasize a classic “freeriding” concern. In addition, we find that increases in union membership are prevalent among high education workers and public sector employees, neither of which benefit directly from the minimum wage. This finding is consistent with models in which membership is responsive to an interest group’s reputation for effective, public-spirited advocacy (Clark and Wilson, 1961; Wilson, 1973). Our analyses of news coverage and public opinion polls provide suggestive evidence on the mechanisms through which these effects might operate. Finally, research in political science and political economy has long analyzed the interplay between interest groups and policy. Within this broad area of inquiry, a relatively small set of papers has focused on the impacts of policy on subsequent politics.5 Research in this vein has focused primarily on cases in which policies created constituencies out of their direct beneficiaries.6 Anzia and Moe (2016) analyze a case in which policy directly shaped the potential influence of an already organized group — namely, public-sector unions. They show 5 Research on the activities of interest groups and other political factions has tended to focus on characterizing their effects on the political process rather than on the drivers of their membership prospects. Relevant theoretical studies in the political economy literature include work by Baron (1994), Grossman and Helpman (1996), Persson (1998), Besley and Case (2003), and Dewan and Shepsle (2011). Empirical evidence consistent with important roles for interest groups is somewhat sparse. Anzia (2019) argues that the literature’s lack of evidence on the importance of interest groups may reflect its lack of focus on subnational politics, which can yield more opportunities to execute credible empirical strategies than can research focused exclusively on federal politics. 6 Perhaps the most famous example involves the enduring constituency created by the Social Security system (Campbell, 2003). Schattschneider (1935) similarly emphasizes the interest groups created by the Smoot-Hawley Tariff of 1929. More recently, Clinton and Sances (2018) and Baicker and Finkelstein (2019) have analyzed the effects of access to Medicaid on political participation. The latter analyses find nontrivial but transitory effects. 8 that changes in public-sector labor law nontrivially shaped future politics and that legislators’ votes on these laws suggest a sophisticated understanding of their long-run effects. In our analysis, we find that minimum wage policy influences the subsequent fortunes of the labor movement. We provide evidence that labor groups can attract members by contributing to policy victories and shaping media narratives, which can elevate their status in public opinion. Our analysis thus connects to a broad line of research on how the efforts of organized groups can shape policy, public opinion, and their own future prospects. 7 Our paper proceeds as follows.

2023 MNDI Counterplan
Minimum Wage CP – MNDI DMP › Solvency › Solvency – Unions

Minimum wage movements empower unionization – effective advocacy bolsters esteem for union leadership

Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]

Over the past decade, labor unions have emerged as advocates for historically high minimum wages. Since its inception in 2012, the “Fight for $15” movement has received substantial union support, ranging in intensity from simple expressions of solidarity to financial and organizational aid. 2 Over this same period, the public’s view of labor unions has become more favorable. Against this backdrop, we analyze the interplay among labor unions, minimum wages, news coverage, and public opinion. We assess what factors might drive participation in groups like labor unions, and how public policy and interest groups affect each other. We document that recent minimum wage increases have preceded increases in union membership. Over the past decade, a one-dollar increase in a state’s minimum wage predicts a 5 percent increase in union membership among those ages 16–40. As detailed below, we assess the case for interpreting this link as causal and find that case to be relatively strong. Increases in minimum wages predict a greater likelihood of union membership among groups of workers that do not benefit directly from minimum wage hikes. Why might this be? We find that minimums wage increases lead to news coverage that links minimum wages to key players in the labor movement. Higher minimum wages also predict higher public esteem for unions. Union membership may thus rise in the wake of minimum wage hikes because individuals value affiliating with groups that deliver “effective advocacy,” even if they do not 2 The AFL-CIO’s website, for example, includes “restoring the minimum wage to a living wage” in its statement of policy priorities for improving pay and benefits. (Accessed at the following link on May 5, 2020: https://aflcio.org/issues/better-pay-and-benefits). The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) has been relatively public regarding its operational and financial support for the Fight for $15. In a representative statement linking the fortunes of unions and the Fight for $15, SEIU President Mary Kay Henry wrote in 2019, “This movement will not stop until workers across the country win the $15 an hour and union rights they’ve demanded since Day One.” (Accessed at the following link on April 10, 2020: http://www.seiu.org/2019/01/seius-henry-fightfor-15-and-a-union-is-winning-for-americas-working-people-changing-whats-possible.) 3 benefit personally from the outcome of that advocacy. We also find that minimum wage increases reduce union membership among the workers who are most likely to benefit directly. This finding is consistent with a classic free-riding hypothesis, since unions and the minimum wage may be substitutable sources of bargaining power in the low-wage labor market. Our effort to isolate the causal effect of minimum wages on union membership faces three standard but nontrivial challenges. First, it could be that union strength was already rising in states that enacted minimum wage increases. That is, the correlation we observe may reflect reverse causality. Second, the correlation could arise from factors, like strengthening labor markets, that might simultaneously stimulate employment, union membership, and preferences for raising minimum wages. Third, states that are favorably disposed toward high minimum wages may, perhaps by chance or perhaps due to other policies, have been affected by other factors that increased rates of union membership.