2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › EITC Counterplan Links
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
EITC expansion is making headway in many states, and many see it as a plausible stepping stone toward a guaranteed income policy. Managed through the tax code, the EITC is a tax credit designed as a cash refund to low- to moderate-income families with children. Several states are looking to expand who can qualify for this credit by raising the income threshold for qualifications to include caregivers, students, and couples who don’t have children (Economic Security Project 2018). Advocates estimate that qualifying families could receive a credit up to $1,200 annually (Economic Security Project 2018). More cash in people’s pockets is always a great benefit to low-income families, and many advocates are calling for EITC to be dispersed monthly, which, as described above, can provide much-needed support to help families meet their basic needs. Additionally, EITC expansion would only benefit families at the low end of the income ladder, rather than providing a blanket stipend to all families.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › Jobs Guarantee CP Links
Zamora, 2017 - postdoctoral sociologist at the Université Libre de Bruxelles [Daniel, December, Jacobin “The Case Against a Basic Income” Translated by Jeff Bate Boerop, TA]
Today, one still commonly sees UBI advocates resort to neoclassical platitudes about employment. We can only be astonished, for example, at the dubious claims made by Van Parijs and Vanderborgh in their recent book Basic Income: A Radical Proposal for a Free Society and a Sane Economy, such as: “where the level of remuneration is and remains firmly protected by minimum wage legislation, collective bargaining, and generous employment insurance, the result tends to be massive losses of jobs.” We shouldn’t be starting from the premise that too-high wages generate unemployment by disrupting the economy’s optimal equilibrium: that’s precisely the idea we should fiercely challenge. Indeed, recent studies seriously undermine these claims. Contrary to neoclassical predictions, countries that tax work the most have the highest employment rates because income taxes fund social services, which promote labor market participation, especially for women. Who Works? Still, imagine that it was mathematically possible to establish a UBI high enough that none of us would have to work. Suppose we could have this generous basic income and still have a strong welfare state. Certainly it would be a game changer. Yet even this utopia rests on two problematic assumptions work. First, it assumes that unemployed people don’t want to work or would be just as happy to receive a generous monthly check. But what if that’s wrong? The notion that we should reduce the demand for jobs rather than fight for full employment fails to consider that many people do want to work. As Seth Ackerman has argued, it assumes that the despair expressed by unemployed people amounts to false consciousness, a problem that can be mitigated by propaganda campaigns promoting non-work. This is a faulty explanation of what’s at stake with the question of work. There’s something deeper at play: work is more than a means for earning money. That’s not just due to “pro-work ideology,” but also to the objective conditions of a society based on a large-scale division of labor in which everyone contributes individually to collective production. This system generates a certain income distribution as well as a certain distribution of work. People are obviously worried about income inequality, but aren’t they also worried about job inequality? As Ackerman writes, “so long as social reproduction requires alienated work, there will always be this social demand for the equal liability of all to work, and an uneasy consciousness of it among those who could work but who, for whatever reason, don’t.” That’s why a universal job guarantee and a reduction in work hours still represent the most important objectives for any left politics. Collectively reducing work time is politically and socially preferable to creating a socially segmented pool of unemployed workers, a situation that would have serious consequences for the employed. It’s not hard to imagine how this situation could foster divisions within the working class — as it already has over the last several decades.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › Jobs Guarantee CP Links
Tsai, 2022 - Lecturer in Business and Law, Toronto Metropolitan University [Daniel , July 27, The Conversation “Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream” Acc 6/13/ 23 TA]
With the current cost-of-living crisis resulting in dramatic inflation, higher interest rates and a looming recession, people have been searching for solutions to the economic crisis. A universal job guarantee may just be the answer we’re looking for, especially since Canada lost 43,000 jobs in June. While most people are familiar with the idea of a universal basic income — the notion of giving every citizen a basic income, irrespective of their income level or need — few are familiar with the idea of a universal job guarantee. Instead of a guaranteed fixed income, a universal job guarantee policy provides jobs — and wages — to people who aren’t able to find work on their own. In theory, a universal job guarantee could help stabilize inflation by providing stable, full-time employment, addressing unemployment, enhancing economic productivity and reinforcing price stability. Job guarantee programs are crucial for a number of reasons. They keep people in the labour force, alleviate poverty, improve health and well-being, add meaning to people’s lives and help the most vulnerable. They also provide crucial non-monetary benefits that have historically been associated with universal basic income, including improvements to “health, education, social cohesion and productivity.” Economic stabilizer There are a few unique barriers that undermine universal basic income and its ability to be implemented. As we have seen with government support programs related to COVID-19, government stimulus in the form of direct cash can cause inflation. These programs reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. Like the Canada Emergency Response Benefit, universal basic income might take away the incentive to work for some, resulting in a labour market bereft of workers. This would result in a vicious cycle: employers would raise wages to attract those willing to work, which would increase inflation and cost of living, causing businesses, in turn, to raise costs to be able to afford higher salaries for their workers. Government stimulus programs can reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. (Shutterstock) The effects of cash stimulus without controls can be far reaching. To take the resulting steam out of the economy, policy-makers often resort to blunt counter measures like increasing interest rates, which can lead to a recession. In contrast, a universal job guarantee would generate revenue for the government through taxable income, thereby reducing the cost of the program while simultaneously enhancing other sectors of the economy, such as the environment or infrastructure. It would ensure that people are able to earn money and, therefore, be able to spend money.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › Domestic Violence CP Links
Niess-May, 2019 - Executive Director of SafeHouse Center [Barbara, October 22nd, The Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty, https://www.safehousecenter.org/the-intersection-of-domestic-violence-and-poverty/#:~:text=Poverty%20is%20a%20primary%20driver,a%20survivor%20of%20domestic%20violence. EP]
To truly end domestic violence and its intersection with poverty in southeast Michigan (and anywhere else for that matter), we must vote for public policy makers that will prioritize: Creating and supporting public policy that addresses the root causes of poverty, such as effective living wage work force development, directing public funds to innovative poverty solutions and affordable quality childcare. Creating and supporting public policy that holds assailants accountable–from encouraging reporting from survivors, trauma informed and academically supported interventions for assailants as well as law enforcement and criminal justice training. Resources to provide high quality services for survivors including crisis intervention help and shelter as well as transition services for long term stability such as housing and workforce assistance. With these resources, we can address reducing the mutual impact of domestic violence and poverty.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › AT Carework
Gheaus, 2008 – political philosopher at the Université Catholique de Lille [Anca, Dec, An International Journal of Basic Income Research Vol. 3, Issue 3 “Basic Income, Gender Justice and the Costs of Gender‐Symmetrical Lifestyles” TA]
In spite of sending the message that oneʹs social value should not be entirely dependent on whether or not one holds paid employment, introducing a BI would lead to further public devaluation of care‐based lifestyles. It has already been argued that a BI would result in improvements with respect to the ability to choose between paid and unpaid work, as well as between different types of work (Robeyns, 2001). This consequence, welcome in a world where men and women have equal bargaining powers and where preferences are formed under structurally just circumstances, would in fact perpetuate the traditional gendered division of labour resulting (as already mentioned) in a drop of womenʹs participation in paid work. A BI would, all things being equal, lower the costs for individuals to pursue their preferences. It is precisely this feature – which makes it attractive to liberals (and, of course, to libertarians) – that should worry feminists. As long as most men will resent doing care work as demeaning, tedious, and unimportant, or otherwise regard it a threat to their masculinities, a BI will also perpetuate the devaluation of care. Thus, given the pressure that social environments put on individuals, for the more gender conservative groups the existence of a BI would raise the costs for individuals (of both sexes) to engage in gender‐symmetrical lifestyles. Moreover, gender‐unjust norms would be more deeply entrenched – and here comes my next argument.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › AT Carework
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
Given gender roles, historical patterns and tradition, it is possible for a man to find a wife who will support his career by exempting him from childcare and household management. However, given the same gender roles, historical patterns and traditions, there is hardly any chance for an ambitious woman to find a man who will support her career and become a houseman. In this example, two constraints affect woman differently than men. First, the supply of male partners willing to sign for the household role is very limited, while this is not the case for female partners. Sec-ond, the labour market is arranged around the assumption that for many jobs, one is child-care and family commitments free, which in our gender structured society limits women more than men. Or, as Kymlicka (1990, 249) puts it: "Even if this economic vulnerability [from the current gender division of labour] were removed, by guaranteeing an annual income to everyone, there is still the injustice that women are presented with a choice between family and career that men do not face." At this point, the distinction between internal and external conditions for au-tonomy can be helpful (Nussbaum, 1999a, 296). Internal conditions are related to being able to bargain, plan your life, reflect about the consequences of actions, etc. External conditions are related to the option set one has. If an individual's choices are to be made in reduced circumstances in comparison with other individ-uals, then the external conditions for autonomy are not fulfilled. Real free choice requires fostering internal autonomy through thoughtful and careful education and raising of children, and public support for external conditions of autonomy by trying to enlarge the option set for all individuals, especially those with limited options. The feminist critique on basic income can thus be summarised that the gender-related character of some of those internal and external conditions is not recognised.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › AT Escape Domestic Violence
Gheaus, 2008 – political philosopher at the Université Catholique de Lille [Anca, Dec, An International Journal of Basic Income Research Vol. 3, Issue 3 “Basic Income, Gender Justice and the Costs of Gender‐Symmetrical Lifestyles” TA]
3. The Increased Privatization of Care If a BI will lead, as some critics fear, to a serious shortage of labour supply in the caring professions, care might become increasingly (re)privatized. Given current cultural norms, it is likely that women will be expected to shoulder the burden of private care, especially if they will indeed gradually be more excluded from the market. The privatization of care and the confinement of more women to domesticity fare badly for gender justice for a number of reasons. Economically, women will lose skills and social capital, making their re‐entry in the market increasingly difficult – ultimately, many will have no substantive exit right from domesticity. Socially and culturally, the privatization of care may lead to the perpetuation of domestic violence and gender stereotypes. Psychologically, all blame for bad care will (continue to) go to women and this, in turn, will perpetuate the misrecognition of women. A general consequence of the privatization of care will be that the economic, social and psychological costs of individuals engaging in gender‐symmetrical lifestyles will become increasingly higher. It is important to emphasize that the costs of leading a particular lifestyle are economical but also psychological. Social expectations, together with oneʹs own internalized expectations, as well as even more elusive factors such as peopleʹs ability to respect women and whatever is associated with the “feminine,” carry the imprints of and perpetuate gender injustice. A discussion of BI’s effects on gender justice will benefit from feminist psychology theories that locate the origins of women’s misrecognition in the traditional social arrangements – in particular the feminisation of child care – and their valuation and representation, which structure our earliest human interaction, our moral emotions and our ability to value women and the feminine (Benjamin, 1988). Feminist theorists have shown how the feminisation of childrearing combined with the generally low status and social powerlessness of women is at the root of womenʹs misrecognition (Ruddick, 1989). Far from being a merely individual choice devoid of any social implication, womenʹs domesticity, particularly when work and family conflict structurally, is a significant symptom and future cause of gender injustice (Williams, 2000). If many women drop out of the labour market and care becomes more privatised, this will generate self‐perpetuating spirals of gender discrimination. A BI would eliminate the economic dependence that spouses with precarious careers would have on their working partner. Such dependence is one of the main incentives women currently have against centering their lives on marriage and (domestic) caregiving. If some women would continue to be expected to marry and center their lives around care‐giving, and this choice would be perceived as less risky than it is now, some parents would have incentive to invest more resources in furthering the careers of boys.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › AT Escape Domestic Violence
Kangas et al, 2023- a Research Director at the Department of Social Research at the University of Turku in Finland [Olli, with Minna Ylikännö "Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 3, ProQuest, https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/basic-income-status-women-established-gender/docview/2774904198/se-2, doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031733. EO]
Koslowski and Duvander [43] discussed UBI and gender equality in Sweden from a theoretical perspective. They asked whether UBI has empowerment effects and whether such effects would be different among men and women. Unfortunately, they were unable to empirically test their ideas. However, this is possible in Finland, where basic income was experimented with from 2017–2018. When the Finnish centre-right government decided to start the UBI experiment in 2015, its interest was ultimately in the employment effects of UBI. The secondary interest was in the well-being effects of UBI [44,45]. Based on previous research, we already know that in the Finnish experiment, UBI had neither positive nor negative effects on employment when looking at all receivers of UBI [40]. In this study, the interest is specifically in the gendered effects of UBI on employment and in how UBI is potentially linked to recipients’ perceptions of their possibilities and capabilities.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Divides Women
Zelleke, 2019 - Prof of Practice in Political Science at NYU Shanghai [Almaz, May 16, Phenomenal World, “Feminist Theory, Gender Inequity, and Basic Income” Interview by Hana Beach, Acc 2/23/23 TA]
AZ: Occupy was the movement that brought the “one percent” into our lexicon. It got people talking about the distribution of wealth in our society. For example, there’s this sound bite that gets repeated that, since 2008, every year the top 1% of Americans get richer and the lowest 50% of Americans get poorer. We’re talking about these figures this way because of Occupy and I think that’s informed the basic income debate. Now, I don’t think there will be a women’s movement for basic income. The issue with women’s movements in general is that women are dispersed throughout society. So much about the condition of a particular woman depends on the class they are born into. I don’t think we can really mobilize women until we have an individualized system of taxation. Our household reporting of income obscures the distribution of wealth that takes place within families and couples. I think a separation between men and women in taxation could mobilize women in the way that other individually based concerns like the wage gap have. The problem, of course, is that the wage gap is only one part of the economic reality of women. It only affects women who are actually earning wages.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Small UBI
Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]
This article responds to these suggestions by exploring the intersections between basic income, gender and human rights. Basic income has long been the subject of disagreement amongst feminists, some of whom see it advancing gender equality in the workforce and society while others are more sceptical or even fearful of its potential negative impact on women’s lives.19 However these debates, occurring in fields such as politics and economics, have remained largely outside of the human rights law space. This article considers how a gender rights lens might deepen the debate about a basic income and contribute to the development of social policies that address gendered poverty and inequality. A human rights approach that is attentive to gender suggests that a basic income is likely to assist women who are disproportionately poor and vulnerable in all societies. But on its own it will not address the complex and structural inequality that they face. A basic income will need to be accompanied by measures such as the provision of childcare and support for sole parents, alongside changes to the labour market and tax system. It will also have to be of adequate size to make a real difference to inequality. The form of a basic income, its likely impact and its desirability as a policy solution is contingent on the political and economic conditions of the particular country in which it is being considered and should be subject to democratic deliberation. Human rights principles informed by gender will help to ensure that any basic income proposal is carefully evaluated within the context of that country to advance rather than impede substantive gender equality.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Small UBI
Koslowski and Duvander, 2018 - prof of Social and Political Science, Univ of Edinburgh and prof of Sociology, Stockholm University [Alison and Ann-Zofie, Working Paper 2018:05 “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?” Acc 1/28/23 TA]
McLean (2015, p. 2) notes that ‘basic Income is in some ways a microcosm of wider feminist controversies regarding how the state can recognise the unpaid work women largely do without reinforcing existing inequalities, also known as Wollstonecraft’s Dilemma (Lister, 1995; Pateman, 1988)’. Indeed, feminists involved with policy making sometimes find themselves falling into one of two camps: that of a more pragmatic approach and that of a more idealistic approach. The former aim to take the situation they see at a current time in front of them, such as mothers doing most of the childcare, and to support women in that situation. The latter might rather take issue with the root imbalance of this situation and aim to create a new situation where fathers are doing more childcare. Arguably, many aspects of the current Swedish welfare state are more radically ambitious than the idea of basic income in that it seeks change to the gendered division of both paid and unpaid work. The implementation of a basic income would be gender-neutral and so, in theory, fathers and mothers would have the same support. In practice, however, and especially given the likely low level of basic income, this policy might have the (unintended) consequence of encouraging a return to the breadwinner model of parenting, with one parent better able to stay at home, but another parent still needing to remain firmly attached to the labour market. Once again, we have a political movement, which has not fully embraced the challenge from radical feminism to move us beyond the ‘fundamental biological condition’ as observed by Shulamith Firestone (1970, p. 1) towards an equal distribution of care work.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Home / Work
Kangas and Ylikanno 2023 - Research Director, Department of Social Research, University of Turku and senior specialist at the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment [Olli and Minna, January 23, 2023, , Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, .] EP
However, there are strong arguments that UBI permanently locks women in their caring obligations at home rather than liberating them to work outside the home, struggle for gender equality, and to have more influence on their own life projects [13,14,15]. Thus, some would argue that UBI would be ‘a trap for women’ [16], in fact squeezing women’s degrees of freedom in their life choices rather than being an emancipatory force liberating them to act and increasing their capabilities in the Senian and Nussbaumian sense [17,18,19].
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal Impacts
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
2.8 Decrease of Human Capital and Expected Income in the Long Run 93 Studies on the division of labour between partners do not always recognise the long-term effects of this specialisation. Specialisation can indeed be optimal in the short run, but it can lead to unwanted dependencies in the long run (Wunderink-van Veen 1997). Human capital depreciates when it is not used. As a consequence, when re-entering after some years out of the labour market, the potential wage will have decreased. The total expected income over the lifetime cycle will therefore decrease by three sources: the lack of income during the period that no paid labour is done, a decrease of the expected wage in case of an eventual return to the labour market and smaller personal pension rights. If the human capital of a woman erodes because she didn’t have a job for some years, the probability of financial distress in case of divorce or death of her husband increases.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal Impacts
Koslowski and Duvander, 2018 - prof of Social and Political Science, Univ of Edinburgh and prof of Sociology, Stockholm University [Alison and Ann-Zofie, Working Paper 2018:05 “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?” Acc 1/28/23 TA]
Sweden is known to be a particularly normative society, in that it is perhaps more difficult than in less normative societies (all societies are normative to some extent) to live outside the accepted ‘best practice’ norms. This currently shows up for those outside the normative universal worker model. Would a basic income exacerbate this existing social divide between those remaining on a low level of income and those on more average or higher levels of income? Would it create a two-tier system: a ‘them and us’ of lower income groups reliant on basic income and top up benefits and the higher income groups (who possibly resent paying for it all whilst having less ‘free’ time)? So, the Swedish ‘universal worker’ model, or ‘work line’, which is such a core principle of many policies which are generally agreed to support gender equality, is possibly going to rub along as an awkward partner with a basic income. There seems to be a fundamental ideological conflict between the two ideas, a conflict much deeper than economic considerations of state budget, often expressed in the ‘right to work’ and also to meaningful work, not least by the trade unions, which may undermine the universal worker model, bringing its existence into question. If the universal worker model did not continue to hold firm, this would likely undermine related efforts to reduce gender inequalities. Sweden is a good case indicating that structural interventions based around a universal worker model are needed to reduce gender inequalities still today and probably far into the future. It is not clear that a basic income payment would challenge gender inequalities. Indeed, it may reinforce a (male) breadwinner model even in a country like Sweden where norms are clearly moving towards gender equal sharing; the gender wage gap would likely prevail, and we may see a tendency towards women (in particular mothers) quitting labour market work in favour of living on a basic income.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal Impacts
Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, . AC]
But even with the rise of the 'dual‐earner' household model, women have still had a much more precarious and undervalued relationship with work than men. Indeed, once women are cut off from the wage‐subsistence relationship, they face additional direct and indirect risks of segregation, subordination, and dependence based on asymmetrical income relations.[16] For instance, less work means fewer and smaller pensions and social insurance. Therefore, welfare benefits and public services often have to be accessed through the husband or male partner.[17] Yet, this institutionalised disadvantage is unlikely to be challenged substantially by the implementation of the UBI, which risks deepening the dependence on men for income, and of reinforcing both the gender pay gap and social poverty gaps in the long term. Furthermore, UBI could well reduce women's space for formative and rewarding work by creating an incentive for women to remain at home, intensifying gendered social segregation and isolation. The consequent alienation could reduce the chance of joining political movements and trade unions, which are still fundamental formative institutions for political engagement in a capitalist society. The points outlined above indicate how the negative effects of UBI on women have largely been ignored in most analysis thus far. Put in another way, it is clear that there exists a general lack of understanding of the potential consequences of UBI. We lack an analysis that, for instance, would assess comprehensively the intergenerational consequences of UBI in the long term. UBI may make small changes to people's lives during a time of crisis like the one in which we are currently living, and can relieve pressure from gendered poverty in the immediate term. However, if the causes of such poverty—such as gender‐based discrimination, wage gaps, an androcentric welfare system, unequal care responsibilities and lack of job opportunities—persist and remain embedded in the dominant social relations of production and reproduction, the UBI has achieved nothing of any lasting value. Furthermore, rather than expanding women's bargaining power, UBI runs the risk of diverting attention from the actual source of structural gender inequality. UBI, by oversimplifying the material complexities, as well as the social differences between work and labour, could reduce women's political space for claiming back their rights to self‐determination.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
2.1 Labour Supply Effects If a basic income would be introduced, what would be the expected labour supply reaction of men and women? Neo-classical economic analysis concludes it to be theoretically impossible to predict these labour supply effects (Atkinson 1995; Nelissen/Polk 1995) .• As far as I am aware, there are two studies estimating women's labour supply changes after the implementation of a basic income (Kesenne 1990; Nelissen/Polk 1995). Both studies, modelling monthly basic incomes amounting to 360 resp. 390 Euro, found that a basic income would make women want to work less hours. However, if enough (small) part-time jobs would be available, only few women would withdraw totally. Nelissen and Polk also found that especially low skilled women would withdraw. However, a recent social policy change in Belgium, al-lowing parents career interruption premiums (around 300 Euro monthly) to raise small children, shows that this opportunity is predominantly used by high skilled mothers (Szabo 1997). 1 There are many more first and second order effects. I have tried to list all effects relevant and important for a gender analysis. Hence, the studies available do not predict that women will withdraw en masse, but they do indicate that some women will become less attached to the labour market, either by working less hours, or by withdrawing. The direction of the female labour supply effect is clear, but the magnitude is uncertain.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal
Gheaus, 2008 – political philosopher at the Université Catholique de Lille [Anca, Dec, An International Journal of Basic Income Research Vol. 3, Issue 3 “Basic Income, Gender Justice and the Costs of Gender‐Symmetrical Lifestyles” TA]
Societies worldwide are characterized by significant gaps between women and men with respect to political, economic and educational achievements, and by a division of labour – paid and unpaid – which is most often deeply gendered. Additionally, women and femininity are culturally devalued, and this devaluation is deeply rooted at the level of individual psychology. Should the introduction of a basic income (BI) be welcomed by feminists as an emancipation force in womenʹs lives and in the relations between genders? Would it ultimately promote gender justice? There is a prima facie reason to believe that the introduction of any redistributive scheme, hence also of a BI, would benefit women, and would redress at least some of the economic injustices connected to gender. But there are also reasons to worry that such a policy will have unintended consequences such as the worsening of womenʹs access to the market, the confinement of at least some women to domesticity to a higher degree than it is currently the case in most Western countries and, ultimately, the perpetuation of unjust gender norms and expectations. Overall, I argue that, given the currently existing gender injustice, feminists should be wary of the introduction of a BI. At best, they should see it as a complement to other institutions of the welfare state (for arguments in favour of the latter position see Lister, 1995; Robeyns, 2001).
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal
Koslowski and Duvander, 2018 - prof of Social and Political Science, Univ of Edinburgh and prof of Sociology, Stockholm University [Alison and Ann-Zofie, Working Paper 2018:05 “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?” Acc 1/28/23 TA]
A basic income could potentially reduce unhealthy dependencies both within personal relationships and with employers. A worry however is that a basic income might be seen to reinforce barriers to the labour market for those who might most benefit from it (drawing upon the universal model of inclusion). Linked to this, there might also be less political pressure to safeguard routes into training essential for social mobility and integration (e.g., of migrant workers) (Hassel, 2017). Gender income gaps related to the differential return to work of mothers following childbirth may also become less of a political concern. This may also enhance social class and other differences between groups in any given society, calling for an intersectional analysis. Whilst individualised basic income payments could well be an instrument of freedom to live individually for some, it is likely that many of us would still be living in households, and that many decisions (such as the division of paid and unpaid labour) would still likely be made at the household or wider extended family level. Whilst a basic income would provide women with unconditional income and thus recognise the social value of (gendered) caregiving (Fitzpatrick, 1999; McKay, 2001, 2005; Zelleke, 2011), it might also risk reinforcing gendered practices, and thus further entrench gender inequalities and maintain financial dependency within personal relationships (Robeyns, 2001). A basic income could contribute to poverty alleviation and personal independence for some, but it might also reinforce withdrawal from the labour market and public life for certain groups, such as mothers of young children, in so far as financial decisions were still taken at household level (Fitzpatrick, 1999).
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend – Labor Withdrawal
Kangas and Ylikanno 2023 - Research Director, Department of Social Research, University of Turku and senior specialist at the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment [Olli and Minna, January 23, 2023, “Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9914593/ UP}
There have been attempts to bridge the gap between the two opposing lines of argument. While UBI, when generous enough, provides women with the opportunity to choose between family and work, it simultaneously reshapes patriarchal gender norms around paid work and unpaid care, especially as no person is relegated to being a masculinised ‘breadwinner’ or feminised ‘caretaker’ to attain income security. Combined with the provision of affordable quality care services, UBI could potentially facilitate a more equitable distribution of care between genders [5,6,10,34,35,36]. In most cases, the motivation to introduce UBI is related to perceived problems and shortcomings in existing welfare systems: holes in the safety net, poverty, overly low take-up rates, and stigma attached to means-tested programs. Furthermore, it is argued that social insurance-based transfer schemes typical for most welfare states disproportionally benefit males with longer working careers and higher incomes compared to women with care duties at home and longer absences from the labour market. While social insurance-based social security schemes provide inferior benefits to those who do not participate in full-time formal employment, UBI would treat everyone equally, regardless of participation in the labour market or length of working career [34,35,36,37]. However, there is an obvious weakness in this argumentation. The further the equality of women and men has progressed in the labour market, the weaker this motivation for basic income. This applies first of all to gender-equal welfare states. Thus, our main hypothesis is that in a well-established welfare state, UBI would not be a strong policy measure for female emancipation. In our case, emancipation is rated as empowerment, that is, people’s capacities for action in their own lives in line with Sen’s and Nussbaum’s theories on capabilities [17,18,19]. According to them, people must have the capabilities to master their own lives and participate customarily in the society they live. Nussbaum [19] separates two different forms of capabilities, while the first one, i.e., the internal capability, is linked to the individual’s own agency, and the second one, ‘combined capability’, is related to societal institutions enabling individuals to use their internal capabilities. The proponents of UBI argue that UBI is a policy measure that fortifies both forms of capabilities. Thus, UBI is a device for emancipation. Our main goal is to analyse if that hypothesis holds or not. We ask: (1) Whether UBI enhances emancipation? (2) Whether UBI enhances employment? (3) Are there gender-specific effects? UBI has not previously tested in a well-developed welfare state with residence-based basic social security, comprehensive social insurance programs and universal social services. The Finnish experiment was the first one in such a context. There are no previous studies that have analysed Finnish experimental data to decompose the possible gender effects.
2023
MNDI
Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › --Extend - Insufficient
Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, . AC]
Whilst sympathetic to the proposal of a UBI, Daniel Sage details more targeted responses to the problems it raises. These include 'expanding parental leave for both mothers and fathers', 'incentivizing people to work fewer hours', 'enabling people to take periods of leave from employment', targeted 'guarantee income schemes' aimed towards the young or over‐fifties, and 'encouraging more people—especially men—to fulfil caring responsibilities without significant economic penalties'.[21] These could work in concert with equal pay and better work conditions, which enable a more inclusive breadwinner model. In general, more specific targeted measures to deal with gendered redistribution of unpaid labour around the activities of social reproduction and care provision are needed. A differentiated system of child benefit in the UK has created significant gains for women, but is still unaffordable for the most marginal and precarious at work—both men and women. Put on a proper footing, all of these measures promise to confront the crisis of social reproduction—and the crisis of the welfare state behind which it is concealed—in a more effective and practical way than the UBI. Indeed, even were we to accept that the latter can do what it claims, UBI can only carry through on its potentially emancipatory promise when accompanied by more systematic state interventions that acknowledge the complexity of work, life and wellbeing in contemporary capitalism. UBI will not create a system able to reconstruct social norms, but a more targeted social welfare system could. From this perspective, the full‐blown implementation of UBI schemes in the near future should not appeal to those for whom gender equality is a primary goal, unless it is complemented by a comprehensive set of public social infrastructure reforms that create a social contract based on solidarity.