Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT EITC CP

Expanding EITC does not address racial and gender wealth inequalities because it excludes people who are not part of the federal tax system like the incarcerated or undocumented communities.

Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]

It is difficult to ascertain how EITC expansion on its own can address racial and gender wealth inequities. It is true that a large percentage of those who will qualify for the expansion are families of color. However, the amount of the credit along with the fact that the credit will most likely be used to cover basic life expenses point to the conclusion that while EITC expansion is greatly needed, it will probably not make a dent in curbing racial or gender wealth inequities. A larger benefit needs to be considered in order to help those with little to no wealth to actually begin accumulating wealth. Another drawback to the EITC is that it also excludes those who may not be a part of the federal tax system. There are many people who choose not to file taxes for numerous reasons. For example, many workers are part of the informal economy, including those who have been formerly incarcerated and can’t find traditional work due to employer discrimination as well as people who cannot afford to have their paychecks garnished by the government to pay off unjust criminal justice debt. Also, about half of our undocumented population don’t file or pay federal income taxes as many live in constant fear of interacting with the government in any way (Campbell 2017). For these reasons, EITC expansion should be considered a great tool to alleviate abject poverty, but it does not take us far in the discussion of racial and gender wealth equity.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Jobs Guarantee CP

A UBI solves gender oppression better than a jobs guarantee – a permutation of the two solves best.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

Welfare policies in the United States reinforce sexism, racism, and classism, and thereby oppress women. When discussing alternative policies, scholars and political players should not just consider economic consequences. They should also emphasize the social consequences of potential policies, namely how effectively they would combat women’s oppression. In this paper I consider two proposed policies, federal jobs guarantees (FJG) and universal basic income (UBI). I use the framework established in Justice and the Politics of Difference by Iris Marion Young and her explanation of the five faces of oppression to evaluate how FJG and UBI may help or harm women. I also analyze recent public opinion polling and FJG and UBI pilot programs to determine the likelihood of the U.S. implementing similar policies. This paper answers the following questions: Which policy, FJG or UBI, would more effectively lessen women’s oppression? Which is more likely to be implemented? Should those concerned with women’s oppression favor UBI, FJG, or a combination of the two? My theoretical analysis shows that UBI would more effectively combat women’s oppression, but public opinion polling and international pilot programs suggest that FJG is more likely to be implemented. This presents a dilemma for advocates who wish to prioritize vulnerable groups’ needs while focusing on realistic goals. The social justice framework I adopt in this paper helps to resolve these conflicts. Using this framework, I conclude that UBI should remain a long-term goal in our transition to a more just society because it more effectively combats women’s oppression. Still, political advocates should take seriously other policies such as FJG which still account for women’s needs and reduce harm done to them. These conclusions contribute to ongoing debate over these policies and demonstrate how researchers and advocates can analyze policies within a social justice framework that prioritizes the needs of our most vulnerable populations.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Jobs Guarantee CP

A UBI and FJG are not mutually exclusive – they would work together to combat oppression.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

United States welfare policies oppress women. They reinforce gender roles; treat women differently based on race, class, and marital status; restrict poor women’s freedom; and dismiss women’s contributions to society. Partly due to these policies, women continue to face injustices such as poverty and violence. Two policies that may help ameliorate these injustices include a Federal Jobs Guarantee (FJG) and a Universal Basic Income (UBI). Under FJG, the federal government would guarantee every adult a well-paying job that provides medical benefits and adequate pay for rent, transportation, and food. UBI offers an alternative to a jobs-centered approach to poverty alleviation under which the government would give every adult a sum of money unconditionally. These policies are not mutually exclusive. Some, such as journalist Sean McElwee, suggest that we should implement both.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Jobs Guarantee CP

The permutation solves better – a basic income keeps a jobs guarantee focused on meaningful work.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

If the UBI proposal was relevant for racial equality at the time of MLK and the Black Panther Party and remains relevant today, it is primarily because unemployment, underemployment, precarious employment, and bad jobs disproportionally affect the lives of people of color. This is true because of discriminatory practices, still, and also because of broader inequalities in access to education, training, and opportunities (Shelby 2012). Interestingly, both MLK and the Black Panther Party were arguing for guaranteed income or guaranteed employment. They saw the proposals as interchangeable to some extent. After all, both policies are indeed designed to restore dignity by alleviating poverty. Guaranteed income can also help keep job guarantee proposals in check. This is because, with a high enough UBI, recipients would only be willing to take on “decent” jobs that provide them with more than just an income. If caring for a relative, volunteering in their community, or starting a business seemed like better options, then they will not be compelled to accept the jobs under the guarantee plan. This comment mirrors Standing's (2013) response to guaranteed-jobs proponents who oppose UBI: The right to an income is a prerequisite of a meaningful right to work.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Jobs Guarantee CP

A UBI is better than a jobs guarantee because it provides a more stable income and avoids disemployment in menial jobs.

Lawhon and McCreary, 2020 - profs of Geography at Universities of Oklahoma and Florida State [Mary and Tyler, March, Antipode – A Radical Journal of Geography “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” TA]

Recent public discussions about a Green New Deal (GND) in the US explicitly draw on ideas of a Just Transition and form a useful example for us here. While as yet a nascent platform, the GND broadly proposes that jobs will be created through investments in green infrastructure and includes provisions for worker training and a “Jobs Guarantee”.1 Our concern with a Jobs Guarantee is that it is disconnected from changes occurring to employment in North America and globally. As noted above, technological disemployment will change the types of jobs associated with new employment possibilities and many activities may well be done more safely and cheaply by robots. Those trained to work in high automated facilities are highly skilled; few can conceivably transfer into this type of work with a few months or even years of state-supported training programs (for a wider analysis of the limited success of retraining programs, see Selingo 2018). In this context, it is likely to be cheaper, safer, greener, and more socially beneficial to provide incomes rather than jobs for many workers (see Schuppert 2019). We are mindful that a UBI is unlikely to match the current incomes of workers in many extractive industries, particularly those in the global North. Frankly, we do not believe a truly sustainable transition can stabilise everyone’s incomes at those levels if we are to reduce overall global economic throughput. However, we are hopeful that new coalitions can be built around UBI, reorganising the economies of resource-dependent communities. Currently, within such communities, there is a broad consensus around the necessity of extractive industries as the primary source of community livelihoods, as families, service sector workers, and even local governments rely upon the recirculation of industrial workers wages. A UBI ruptures this dynamic of dependency, redistributing income to people who do socially reproductive work, both in the service sector and the home, and enhancing the relative autonomy of this population. The work of raising children, cleaning, and cooking food continues to be disproportionately done by women and racially marginalised people globally—a population that is rarely focal in the literature on Just Transitions. In currently resource-dependent regions, a UBI has the potential to delink local communities from their reliance on the recirculation of industrial workers wages, creating new alliances between people who do undervalued or unrecognised work, as well as those who have been abandoned by both the old industrial economy and its emergent automation (see Marais 2018). Thus, we suggest that the ultimate goals of a Just Transition (the provision of livelihoods for displaced workers and support for the economies that depend upon them) are likely to actually more effectively and efficiently be achieved through adoption of a UBI.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Jobs Guarantee CP

UBI solves better for gendered oppression than FJG

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? ] EP

Based on this analysis of UBI and FJG, each policy’s respective ability to undermine the faces of oppression largely depends on the precise terms of policy that are ultimately implemented. Upon a closer look at the logic underpinning them, it appears that UBI would do a better job at confronting the faces of oppression that affect women. FJG’s downside is that it may exacerbate marginalization and exploitation, and it does not do a particularly good job of undermining any of the root causes of women’s oppression. UBI, on the other hand, does not exacerbate any of the faces and directly combats the causes of women’s marginalization and cultural imperialism. Overall, UBI is more closely aligned with the social justice framework and would do more for women than FJG.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Means Testing CP

A UBI is better than a Means Tested UBI – it builds trust because it allows individuals to choose how they spend their money

Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]

While the universality of the benefit is very attractive to many, the effects of the benefit greatly depend on where a family sits in the economic ladder. For single mothers and families of color who disproportionately live paycheck to paycheck (Bhattacharya and Price 2018) and struggle to make ends meet, a monthly installment allows them to use the cash benefit as a way to pay for basic household costs, such as rent, food, and utilities. It can serve as a buffer in times of income volatility due to circumstances out of their control like a change in shift hours or a cut in pay. It can also provide a sense of agency to low-income families—a feeling often reserved for those in higher income brackets. An unconditional cash benefit allows people to make the best decisions for themselves and/or their families on how to spend the money, rather than solely suffer through a paternalistic, means-tested public benefit that often strips dignity and aims to control behavior. Unconditional cash gives the message that we actually trust people and doesn’t restrict people’s behavior in the ways that many other public benefit programs do. These gains should not be taken lightly.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Means Testing CP

Stigmatizing the undeserving poor asserts racial and gendered superiority – it excludes some from the dignity of work.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

Many scholars have traced America’s work ethic to the Poor Laws of Elizabethan England. These laws were based on categorical distinctions which divided people based on whether they were the “deserving poor,” such as the elderly, children, or the infirm, or the “undeserving poor.” The former received relief in the form of cash or food, while the latter faced punishment including whipping, jail, and even execution.118 This differentiation between the deserving and undeserving poor spread to America “where it married with our country’s deep sense of individualism and our cult of self reliance.”119 The result is a national culture in which we blame poverty on individual failures because the work ethic obscures structural obstacles. America’s work ethic thus rationalizes exploitation and legitimizes inequality,120 particularly on the basis of race and gender. The exclusion of some from the dignity of the work ethic makes it more attractive to others because this racialization and gendering of work provides an avenue through which Whites assert moral superiority and legitimate their economic privilege over others.121

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Means Testing CP

Means testing harms women because it violates their privacy rights, requiring them to establish the maternity of their children to receive benefits.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

Welfare recipients have also been forced to sacrifice their privacy rights.69 Going back to mothers’ pensions, relief for single mothers has involved bureaucratic supervision of recipients to determine their eligibility based on means tests and their morality. These bureaucrats search their clients’ homes and judge their sexual and romantic lives. The more recent requirement that women help the state establish their children’s paternity exemplifies this. Because states want men to take responsibility for “their” women, they require single women to “cooperate in establishing the paternity of her child and in obtaining child support payments.”70 This forces women to reveal their sexual histories and makes them more vulnerable to potentially abusive men they may not want in their or their child’s life. It also results in punishment for men who fail to pay support, even if they are absent or impoverished.71 Meanwhile middle-class families receive public subsidies through social security and tax breaks without a similar impact on their privacy rights.72

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Intersectionality K

A UBI empowers women because it removes the stigma and poverty of care work and it is an intersectional approach to oppression.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

A second comment has to do with heterogeneity among women. It is important for this debate to start from an assessment of the situation of the most vulnerable women and whether UBI would benefit them, rather than focusing the debate on whether UBI can further the more abstract goal of gender justice. For many women, lack of formal employment is actually not the main problem. The problem is rather the inability to perform the care work they want to perform without being stigmatized or condemned to a life of poverty or dependence. For some women, the problem is overwork—that they are combining several low-paying jobs to support their children and end up left with too little time to spend with them. Too often socially invisible, many domestic workers are bound to abusive employers by a lack of exit options. Lacking the economic security needed to have exit options also makes sex workers more vulnerable to abuse. The Sex Workers Open University (2017) in fact demands UBI on the basis that “[i]f every person in the UK was entitled to a universal basic income, no one would be pushed by absolute poverty into selling sex.” The conversation on whether UBI should be endorsed on grounds of gender justice should be dependent, at least to some extent, on what UBI would do to empower the women who are currently most economically insecure and most vulnerable to domination. One last comment concerns the need for all-things-considered judgments in political theory. One is rarely only committed to gender equality, since the egalitarian principles that underpin feminism also underpin racial equality, the fights against ableism, class hierarchies, etc. So it seems important to arrive at an all-things-considered judgment on whether UBI is desirable on egalitarian grounds. UBI may be second or third best as a tool of gender equality, for instance, but it may also be the only safety net that consistently appears at the top of the list of adequate tools to achieve a variety of other egalitarian goals. This should be a central consideration for political theorists who are committed to ending oppression in its various forms.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Intersectionality K

A gendered lens for a UBI would transform societal structures away from patriarchal paradigms toward intersectional solutions

Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]

Key to ensuring this gendered human rights approach is the principle of equality and non-discrimination informed by the concept of substantive gender equality which requires far-reaching, structural and transformative responses.21 The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in its General Comment No 19 on the right to social security has noted that non-discrimination and equality between men and women pervade all the obligations in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)22 which ‘prohibits any discrimination, whether in law or in fact, whether direct or indirect’ on a range of listed grounds including sex ‘which has the intention or effect of nullifying or impairing the equal enjoyment or exercise of the right to social security’.23 The Committee has explained that it is not enough to simply remove formal discrimination if substantive equality is to be achieved.24 In some instances special or positive measures will be needed to overcome persistent discrimination.25 The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women has a broad conception of substantive equality that requires a systemic approach. It says that: The position of women will not be improved as long as the underlying causes of discrimination against women, and of their inequality, are not effectively addressed. The lives of women and men must be considered in a contextual way, and measures adopted towards a real transformation of opportunities, institutions and systems so that they are no longer grounded in historically determined male paradigms of power and life patterns. 26 A substantive gender equality approach is thus deeply contextual and attentive to historical and current differences in the experiences of men and women. It is multidimensional in requiring that inequality overcomes distributive disadvantage and status-based harms and must ensure participation of women in developing responses to inequality that are appropriate, as well as transformative, leading to structural challenges to patriarchal relations.27 In the context of social protection this requires particular attention to women’s location in relation to paid and unpaid work and their responsibilities for providing care to a range of groups including children, the elderly, people with disabilities and illnesses, as well as also being members of these groups.28 A gender equality rights-based approach thus, in addition, requires measures to take account of intersectional disadvantage. Intersectionality, formulated in the context of US anti-discrimination law,29 is now well entrenched in international human rights law.30 Social protection based on human rights must take account of how various disadvantaged groups such as women with disabilities or women of colour are differently affected than other groups of women and require policy responses that are designed to address these complex inequalities.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Intersectionality K

Our framework is best for discussing a UBI because it endorses an intersectional approach to addressing injustice.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

It is crucial to discuss the social, not just the economic, costs and consequences of these potential policies. Recognizing the relationship between the economic and the social, rather than prioritizing the former, is necessary for a proper discussion of UBI and FJG. I adopt the premise that economic injustice necessarily coexists with social injustice, and vice versa.1 It is essential to discuss these forms of injustices from an intersectional perspective which accounts for the ways in which multiple axes of oppression impact women—particularly those who are not heterosexual, White, or well-off. Due to their positionality within a society characterized by white supremacy, heteropatriarchy, and classism, these women will experience qualitatively different forms of oppression than do more privileged women.2 Those concerned with justice for all women must adopt an intersectional approach when addressing injustice and strive to ensure that policies’ material aspects are not considered separately from their social consequences. Based on this premise, this paper emphasizes the importance of centering vulnerable groups’ needs, with a particular focus on women due to their unique experiences under American welfare policies. I do not attempt to provide a detailed plan to implement UBI or FJG, which other writers and commentators have addressed. I instead ask how advocates and political figures should discuss and evaluate public policies. Which policy—FJG or UBI—would most effectively combat women’s oppression? Which is more likely to be implemented? Should those concerned with gender injustice advocate for UBI, FJG, or a combination of the two? Advocates for UBI and FJG fall into three camps—those emphasizing poverty, freedom, and democratic citizenship rights. Philippe Van Parijs has presented what has become the most popular argument for UBI. He argues for a “real libertarian” approach that focuses on “real freedom for all.”3 Real freedom requires security, individual self-ownership, and the opportunity to do whatever one wishes. He argues that if income is as important as we think, real freedom depends on both rights and one’s means. This includes the ability to purchase or consume and to live as one pleases. UBI would secure this freedom.4

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Anti Blackness K

A UBI is necessary to address racial and gendered economic inequality – this threatens everyone’s economic security

Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]

Race- and gender-based wealth inequities are two of the greatest failures of the American economy. Economic policy choices and practices put forth by those in power, such as the GI Bill and redlining, created wealth-building opportunities for white men but established barriers for everyone else. Implemented in tandem with the rise of corporate power by which profit is revered over people, these racist policies have resulted in racial and gender economic stratification that have reached epic heights. Today, approximately 160,000 households in America own more wealth than the poorest 90 percent combined— the highest concentration of wealth since 1962 (Igraham 2017). Without bold, visionary action and policies to address these issues, the chasm between those who are economically secure and those who are not—mainly Black, brown, and Native American communities and women—will continue to grow, ultimately threatening our nation’s ability to finally achieve our promise of freedom, dignity, and security for all. A growing group of progressives is committed to tackling racial wealth inequities head on (Newkirk II 2019). Once seen as fringe, “pie in the sky” ideas, a number of seemingly progressive economic policies have entered the public discourse, including a governmentfunded cash benefit program. Often referred to as “guaranteed income,” this big idea is a no-strings-attached direct cash benefit from the government that would provide a basic floor of living regardless of employment status or income by offering people a regular cash payment (Marinescu 2017). With that context, this issue brief will explore to what extent and under what type of design a program that is usually discussed as a way to boost regular incomes could make a dent in racial and gender wealth inequities.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Anti Blackness K

UBI addresses racial patriarchy – it disproportionately benefits black women.

Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]

This will be perceived by many as a high standard to live up to, and any UBI will have to be rolled out carefully and progressively. To what extent could UBI redistribute wealth and challenge structural inequalities? In the context of the United States, UBI has been proposed by some as one element of addressing racial and gender-based injustices stemming from settler-colonialism, slavery and contemporary drivers of wealth extraction from communities of colour, including through mass incarceration. UBI has a history of support by Black women’s grassroots movements: In the 1960s-1970s, they viewed it as providing a way out of low-status, poor-paying jobs and allowing more time to care for their children, a privilege that white middle-class women had long enjoyed. More recently, Black scholars have advocated for a “robust basic income that advances racial and gender justice”, in the face of pervasive structural discrimination in employment. In 2018, Black women employed full-time in the United States earned just 65 per cent of the income of their white male equivalents. White women earned 82 percent as much as white men, and Black men earned 73 per cent as much. If financed through taxation on high-income earners, UBI could potentially reach all individuals equally, but with disproportionate benefit and a redistributive effect for already-disadvantaged groups. However, in the context of UBI for Indigenous Australians, critics have emphasized that it “does not account for the violence, displacement of nationhood and denial of sovereignty” of Indigenous people, and there is a risk that recognition of the ongoing dispossession of Indigenous communities’ land and resources and resistance to it may be silenced or elided if UBI is seen as adequate ‘justice’ for this suffering, or if UBI governance structures reinforce the power of the state over Indigenous autonomy. UBI should therefore not be seen as a “technical fix” to devastating social and economic inequalities and intergenerational trauma. Furthermore, more research is needed to compare the redistributive potential of UBI to that of other forms of social protection, and better understand how UBI could be situated within much broader efforts to address systemic racism, challenge the root causes of income inequality, and bring about social justice.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Capitalism K

Permutation – do both frameworks – a Marxist Feminist approach would adopt a UBI to provoke post work imaginations and freedoms.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

Kathi Weeks echoes Parijs’s calls for freedom, but from a feminist and Marxist perspective. She argues that we should implement UBI because of its power as a critique, reform, and provocation. UBI would critique the link between family or household form and income and reject women’s dependence on wages or marriage. As a reform, UBI would address the quantity and quality of waged labor, unemployment, underemployment, and reduce our dependence on work. The demand for UBI also points to the future and serves as a provocation to freedom. Unlike Van Parijs, Weeks defines freedom as the time and space for invention. Implementing UBI would provoke our imaginations and desires, allowing us to envision a postwork world and admit our longing for more money, more time, and more freedom.5

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Capitalism K

Our framework is Marxist – it criticizes how capitalist exploitation of women requires stratified work roles within the home, which extract value from women – a UBI addresses this.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

Exploitation Young’s articulation of exploitation relies on the Marxist theory of exploitation. Under this theory, class domination in capitalist society exists because “some people exercise their capacities under the control, according to the purposes, and for the benefit of other people.”111 This process generally occurs in the context of unpaid or paid labor, because profit “comes from the difference between the value of the labor performed and the value of the capacity to labor which the capitalist purchases.”112 Thus, profit is only possible because the capitalist “extracts benefits from workers.”113 This is oppressive because it entails distributive inequality and “enacts a structural relation between social groups” that involves power and inequality.114 Exploitation does not only involve class differences. Feminists have shown that “women’s oppression consists partly in a systematic and unreciprocated transfer of powers from women to men” that makes possible men’s “freedom, power, status, and self-realization.”115 This transfer occurs primarily within marriages where women perform disproportionate amounts of emotional and domestic labor and in workplaces where women are wage workers. Race exacerbates these problems, as women of color are exploited due to their racial and gender identities.116 Black women may face exploitation in the home, exploitation when they work in other communities’ businesses and homes, and exploitation through their performance of menial labor for the general benefit of White-dominated society. Because this aspect of oppression entails more than distributive injustice, redistribution of material goods cannot undo it. Justice will require the “reorganization of institutions and practices of decisionmaking, alteration of the division of labor, and similar measures of institutional, structural, and cultural change.”117 This understanding of exploitation directly challenges the American work ethic, which tells us that subjecting oneself to exploitation is a necessary part of being a dignified and productive member of society.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Postwork K

Permutation – do both frameworks – a Marxist Feminist approach would adopt a UBI to provoke post work imaginations and freedoms.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

Kathi Weeks echoes Parijs’s calls for freedom, but from a feminist and Marxist perspective. She argues that we should implement UBI because of its power as a critique, reform, and provocation. UBI would critique the link between family or household form and income and reject women’s dependence on wages or marriage. As a reform, UBI would address the quantity and quality of waged labor, unemployment, underemployment, and reduce our dependence on work. The demand for UBI also points to the future and serves as a provocation to freedom. Unlike Van Parijs, Weeks defines freedom as the time and space for invention. Implementing UBI would provoke our imaginations and desires, allowing us to envision a postwork world and admit our longing for more money, more time, and more freedom.5

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT UBI Minus DA

A well designed UBI avoids cuts to current social programs and services – it supplements them.

Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]

The design features necessary for a feminist universal basic income Debates remain largely hypothetical given that there are so few full-fledged UBI schemes, and because where they do exist they are usually not evaluated for gender impacts. It is clear that the extent to which UBI’s potential for reducing gender and other inequalities will be realized depends critically on its specific design features, including the level of benefit provided, its financing mechanism and its interaction with existing tax and social security systems. Without parallel investments in quality public services and strengthened support for workers’ rights, UBI could have detrimental effects for gender equality and social justice. However, well-designed UBI that is integrated into a comprehensive system of social protection, public services and labour market regulations could strengthen women’s and transgender and gender diverse people’s income security, lower poverty rates and go some way to redressing inequalities in wealth and income. This will be perceived by many as a high standard to live up to, and any UBI will have to be rolled out carefully and progressively. Extending the reach of existing social protection schemes aimed at particular groups—such as social pensions and child and disability benefits—and ensuring that these are unconditional and universally available could be an important steppingstone towards achieving universal income security for all. The main recommendations for States considering UBI are as follows: • Follow a rights-based approach to social protection when designing UBI schemes. This includes following the principles of progressive realization and non-retrogression to safeguard against the rollback of existing social security and labour protections. Like all other social protection schemes, UBI should be anchored in national legal frameworks. • Ensure that UBI is accompanied by parallel investments in quality public services, including care services, health care, education, housing and food security, and with attention to the rights of women and transgender and gender-diverse people working within these sectors. • Develop sustainable and redistributive financing mechanisms for UBI. The cost estimates for UBI at national poverty level are substantial, and fiscal trade-offs are likely to arise, especially for low-income and highly indebted countries, with implications for gender and other inequalities. These should be assessed and discussed in a transparent, participatory manner during the design phase. • Ensure that UBI schemes address the needs of groups facing multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination. UBI implementation should be inclusive of incarcerated, migrant, LGBTIQ+ and unhoused individuals, and should be embedded in a broader system of support that addresses the additional needs of people with disabilities, pregnant people and the elderly. • Design UBI through national dialogue involving government, civil society, social partners and community representatives to discuss potential benefits and trade-offs and build societal consensus on the form of the UBI and its integration into broader social protection systems. • Close current gaps in evidence by strengthening monitoring and evaluation of UBI and other cash transfer schemes from a gender perspective, including analysing their impact on groups of women and transgender and genderdiverse people experiencing different intersecting forms of discrimination.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Economy DAs

The prioritization of economic impacts reinforces inequality and environmental collapse – feminists support a UBI because it undermines the patriarchy and promotes cargiving

Hermann, 2021 - MA Candidate in International Affairs at Hertie School [Katrin, Sept 28, Path for Europe, “Reimagining Care: Feminist degrowth and UBI” Acc 1/16/23 TA]

A Feminist Degrowth Perspective Degrowth stresses the need to move away from economic growth as a sole political objective. Instead, the focus should be on “well-being, social justice and ecological sustainability”. Within the degrowth movement, the feminist perspective is slowly becoming more prominent, with the Feminisms and Degrowth Alliance (FaDA) network launching in 2017. Feminist scholars have criticized capitalist production and consumption patterns for not taking into account the invaluable nature of care work for individual and societal well-being. This approach specifically envisions a society with diverse gender roles, where paid and unpaid work is distributed fairly among all members of society. Degrowth carries potential to rethink the growth-centric economy and lends itself well to feminist economic thought, which seeks to undo patriarchal power structures, which in turn alleviates the undue double burden placed on women at home and in the labour market. Indeed, Kallis, Demaria and D’Alisa have stated that “the degrowth imaginary centres around the reproductive economy of care”[3], with other central proposals of the degrowth school (e.g. work-sharing) emphasizing care as well. Corinna Dengler and Birte Strunk have examined the impact of the current growth paradigm on gender and environmental injustices. Their analysis is based around the ICE model developed by Jochimsen and Knobloch (see Figure 1) which relegates caring activities and ecological processes into the ‘maintenance’ economy, which the formal ‘monetized’ economy largely ignores. Dengler and Strunk’s analysis acknowledges that an increase in women’s labour participation will not necessarily further gender equality. As examined, this creates a double burden of paid and unpaid work for most women, and even when this work is outsourced to care providers, there still exists a divide, but now between the more vulnerable and those who profit. Thus, Dengler and Strunk suggest work-sharing proposals that focus on the working day rather than working week. Since women are most often the ones that are in charge of daily household activities (e.g. caring for other family members), a shortening of the “first shift” for both women and men could allow for a reduction in women’s double burden and a more equal division of these daily activities amongst genders. Though by no means flawless, this proposal is meant to emphasize the potential for feminist economics and the degrowth movement to pave the way for a caring economy and potentially alleviate certain gender injustices. Figure 1: ICE Model The feminist degrowth movement is centred around regeneration – in this sense policies geared towards reforming the care economy are meant to encourage this sector to thrive. In order to do so, redistributive measures should be introduced to ensure that carers are adequately compensated. Consequently, both feminist scholars and degrowthers have been examining UBI (Universal Basic Income) as a potential alternative. Feminist degrowthers have more specifically supported a Care Income that builds on basic income proposals and emphasizes the recognition of unpaid care work performed by women. Universal Basic Income through a feminist lens A Universal Basic Income (UBI) has been supported by degrowthers, with the feminist branch specifically calling for a Care Income as proposed by the Global Women’s Strike and taken forward by the Green New Deal for Europe. This involves the payment of an unconditional regular income paid to adult members of societies, regardless of work status, level of income or living arrangements. Though convincing arguments in favour of a basic income scheme have been made, it has yet to be fully introduced into any modern welfare state due to the objections that it undermines the incentive to work and unsustainably increases public expenditure.[4]

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Economy DAs

Basic income debates must focus on gender consequences – a purely economic focus reinforces women’s oppression

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

Welfare policies in the United States reinforce sexism, racism, and classism, and thereby oppress women. When discussing alternative policies, scholars and political players should not just consider economic consequences. They should also emphasize the social consequences of potential policies, namely how effectively they would combat women’s oppression. In this paper I consider two proposed policies, federal jobs guarantees (FJG) and universal basic income (UBI). I use the framework established in Justice and the Politics of Difference by Iris Marion Young and her explanation of the five faces of oppression to evaluate how FJG and UBI may help or harm women. I also analyze recent public opinion polling and FJG and UBI pilot programs to determine the likelihood of the U.S. implementing similar policies. This paper answers the following questions: Which policy, FJG or UBI, would more effectively lessen women’s oppression? Which is more likely to be implemented? Should those concerned with women’s oppression favor UBI, FJG, or a combination of the two? My theoretical analysis shows that UBI would more effectively combat women’s oppression, but public opinion polling and international pilot programs suggest that FJG is more likely to be implemented. This presents a dilemma for advocates who wish to prioritize vulnerable groups’ needs while focusing on realistic goals. The social justice framework I adopt in this paper helps to resolve these conflicts. Using this framework, I conclude that UBI should remain a long-term goal in our transition to a more just society because it more effectively combats women’s oppression. Still, political advocates should take seriously other policies such as FJG which still account for women’s needs and reduce harm done to them. These conclusions contribute to ongoing debate over these policies and demonstrate how researchers and advocates can analyze policies within a social justice framework that prioritizes the needs of our most vulnerable populations.