Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › AT: Wage Inflation

Unemployment not needed to fight inflation

Pavlina Tcherneva, June 2020, Tcherneva is an American economist, of Bulgarian descent, working as associate professor and director of the Economics program at Bard College. She is also a research associate at the Levy Economics Institute and expert at the Institute for New Economic Thinking, Kindle Edition. The Case for a Job Guarantee (1st ed.). Wiley. Retrieved from https://www.perlego.com/book/1504079/the-case-for-a-job-guarantee-pdf (Original work published 2020)

Even central banks with a dual mandate prioritize fighting inflation over fighting unemployment. And if the policy priorities were reversed, there is little reason to believe they could pin the unemployment rate at the “desirable” level, much less create conditions where anyone who sought work could find it. What central banks could do for the labor market is adopt a do-no-harm approach, abandon the NAIRU, and stop pumping the brakes on the economy in order to slow job growth. As the next chapter will make clear, there are no economic, social, or moral reasons for using the unemployed as a bulwark against inflation. Fiscal policy hasn’t done a good job of tackling unemployment either, even though it has more tools at its disposal. It was demoted in the post-Reagan era and paired with deregulation, wage suppression, and trickle-down policies that masqueraded as sound economic policy. The result was the greatest transfer of wealth to the top and the slowest payroll employment recovery rates in the postwar era. But the earlier postwar “Keynesian” fiscal policies did not do the trick either. Government stimulus policies failed to generate the conditions that would ensure a job for every jobseeker. Traditional fiscal pump priming typically prioritizes stabilizing investment over stabilizing employment (the latter being regarded merely as a byproduct of the former). This is done via loan guarantees or contracts with guaranteed profits, subsidies, and bailouts. Indeed, fiscal policies often help stabilize and increase corporate profits in the midst of a recession, whereas jobless recoveries have become the norm. By contrast, the Job Guarantee is a straightforward response: the policy solution to someone unable to find paid work is to provide them with an employment opportunity.  Today, a guaranteed retirement income and public education have become fundamental components of the policy landscape. And just as we do not target either some “natural rate” of retirees who are uninsured or a certain illiteracy rate, it makes little sense to target a given rate of involuntary unemployment. In a sense, the government chooses the unemployment rate by insisting that the NAIRU must serve as a policy guide. Even the presumed benefits of managing inflation by taming changes in demand do not justify keeping people out of work. As the next chapter will explain, the Job Guarantee replaces the NAIRU with a powerful automatic stabilizer that delivers full employment and price stability. It also brings a range of economic and social benefits without inflicting the unbearable costs of unemployment on society. Tcherneva, Pavlina R.. The Case for a Job Guarantee (p. 41). Wiley. Kindle Edition.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › AT: Wage Inflation

High employment doesn’t cause inflation

Pavlina Tcherneva, June 2020, Tcherneva is an American economist, of Bulgarian descent, working as associate professor and director of the Economics program at Bard College. She is also a research associate at the Levy Economics Institute and expert at the Institute for New Economic Thinking, Kindle Edition. The Case for a Job Guarantee (1st ed.). Wiley. Retrieved from https://www.perlego.com/book/1504079/the-case-for-a-job-guarantee-pdf (Original work published 2020)

And yet economists regularly talk about unemployment in these terms – as something that is not only inevitable, but also necessary for the smooth functioning of the economy – and formulate policies on the premise that there is a “natural” level of unemployment. This was succinctly put by Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell in January 2019: “We need the concept of a natural rate of unemployment. We need to have some sense of whether unemployment is high, low, or just right.”1 What is the “right” number of people who are struggling to find paid work? Many economists fear that if unemployment is “too low” and labor markets are “too tight” then firms will have to raise wages to attract workers and in turn raise prices to recover those costs. Low unemployment, the argument goes, could cause high or even accelerating inflation, producing one of the clunkiest concepts in economics – the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment (NAIRU). Inflation-fighting central banks then aim to finetune the economy around the NAIRU.2 Countless think tanks, academics, and government institutions spend valuable resources on trying to identify this elusive “optimal level” of unemployment, while the actual number of unemployed people yo-yos around as the economy grows and slows down. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has maintained that the “natural level” throughout the postwar era was between 4.5 and 6.5 percent, and yet here we are today with official unemployment at 3.5 percent. It is no consolation that Chairman Powell recently admitted, under oath, that the unemployment–inflation relationship has collapsed.3 The search for the NAIRU continues. Top economists vigorously defend it and the Fed’s explicit objective is to manage inflation by slowing down the rate of investment and hiring when unemployment gets “too low.”4 The trouble with this fine-tuning approach is threefold. First, the NAIRU is a myth.5 Economists (and the Fed) cannot figure out the nature of the unemployment–inflation relationship, nor whether it is even a causal one.6 Second, on its own admission, the Fed has no reliable theory of inflation either.7 Third, despite failing to pin down the NAIRU or the inflation target, Fed officials have been insisting at least since 2014 that the economy has reached full employment. Many will remember a similar experience in the 1990s, when experts kept warning that the economy has reached maximum employment, even as the unemployment rate kept breaking through every new official NAIRU estimate, with no accelerating inflation in sight. And like a scene from Groundhog Day, with NAIRU warnings on repeat, the unemployed people are caught in a jobless trap with no way out. This problem is worse around the world. In 2012, the Annual Economic Forecast of the European Commission claimed that the natural rate of unemployment in Spain was 26.6 percent – the economy simply could not do better. Tcherneva, Pavlina R.. The Case for a Job Guarantee (pp. 25-26). Wiley. Kindle Edition.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › AT: Wage Inflation

Wages don’t affect overall inflation and lack of consumer spending will cause a recession anyway.

Wallace, 6/13 (Alicia, CNN, “CPI report: US inflation is coming back down to Earth,” June 13, 2023, https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/13/economy/cpi-inflation-may/index.html)

Inflation within that category has been an ongoing source of concern, because it has greater potential to be “sticky.” Because labor costs are more heavily weighted in services businesses than goods, the tight labor market and wage increases have a greater potential in keeping inflation elevated. Numerous studies have shown there’s no evidence of wage growth driving inflation; however, some economists have expressed concern about how a strong labor market and resilient consumer spending could result in demand-side pressure on inflation. “Food Away from Home price inflation posted a 5.8% annualized growth pace for the month; Leisure & Hospitality employment gains have slowed this year and overall employment in this collection of industries remains well below pre-pandemic levels,” Kurt Rankin, senior economist for PNC Financial Services, wrote in a note. “So, wage growth pressures remain due to lack of labor supply and Food Away from Home price gains will likely be unrelenting as summer spending kicks consumer spending on recreational activities into overdrive.” PNC economists, as well as others, continue to predict that a mild recession is in store for the United States later this year. “Inflation’s inability to reach the Fed’s average 2% year-over-year target as a result of persistent consumer demand will provide cover for keeping interest rates high, which in turn will eat away at business activity and increase costs on households as they accumulate more high-interest debt in support of their spending habits,” Rankin wrote. “These forces will ultimately combine to force a slowdown in consumption, which is the prerequisite for any US recession.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › AT: Wage Inflation

High wages don’t cause inflation.

Dr. Roy Cordato 18. Senior Economist, Emeritas. “The Myth of “Wage Push” Inflation” John Locke Foundation. 10-25-18. https://www.johnlocke.org/update/the-myth-of-wage-push-inflation/

Now, this doesn’t mean that we may not be seeing increased inflation over the coming months or years. For well over a decade, the Fed has been pursuing a policy of easy money. That’s what the talk of interest rates approaching zero and so-called “quantitative easing” has been all about. The fears of inflation that are all the chatter among the business commentator class are real and justified. What is wrongheaded is the explanation that it might be caused by increased wages. This also doesn’t mean that rising wages in certain sectors couldn’t be part of the story of how the new Fed-created money is working its way through the economy. New money flows from the Fed through the banks and into the economy unevenly. Therefore, prices and wages are also bid up unevenly. So, as different sectors of the economy receive the new money, possibly through new investment stimulated by the artificially low-interest rates, wages will rise. This, in turn, may lead to those wage earners having more money to spend on goods and services, which will drive up prices generally. But the higher wages are not the cause of the inflation but a symptom of it. The idea that higher wages can cause inflation is simply bad economics. It is part of the same discredited Keynesian analysis that tells us that government budget deficits create economic growth and that increased saving reduces it. As a wise graduate school professor of mine once told me, to ignore changes in money supply when trying to explain inflation is the equivalent of ignoring the eruption of Mount Vesuvius when trying to explain the destruction of Pompeii.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › AT: Phillips Curve

Their estimates for the Phillips Curve are wrong – the economy can handle much lower rates of unemployment without increasing inflation

Justin Holt, March 2023, Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Labor Review, “A nonlinear Phillips curve: wage rigidities, unemployment, and inflation,” https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2023/beyond-bls/a-nonlinear-phillips-curve-wage-rigidities-unemployment-and-inflation.htm, mm

The Phillips curve is an economic model positing that an inverse relationship exists between unemployment and inflation. This inverse relationship provides several potential guidelines for central bank policy. One such guideline is that an equilibrium unemployment rate corresponds to a stable inflation rate, all else held equal. In “25 years of excess unemployment in advanced economies: lessons for monetary policy” (Peterson Institute for International Economics, Working Paper 22-17, October 2022), Joseph E. Gagnon and Madi Sarsenbayev argue that central banks in the world’s 11 most advanced economies have overestimated the equilibrium rate of unemployment for the past several decades. The authors find that estimates of the equilibrium unemployment rates in these countries are commonly incorrect because of the hypothesis that the Phillips curve is linear. Gagnon and Sarsenbayev argue that the Phillips curve is nonlinear because of downward wage and price rigidity. More specifically, wages tend not to decrease, even during economic contractions; prices are less rigid, but they also tend not to decrease, especially on average and over the long term. Wage and price rigidity causes the Phillips curve to flatten when the unemployment rate is above its equilibrium rate. The curve was steep and linear in the 1970s and 1980s, when inflation was high. Since the 1990s, however, with inflation averaging about 2 percent (before the pandemic), the Phillips curve has had a negative slope when unemployment rates are low (below the equilibrium rate) and a much flatter slope when unemployment rates are high. Accordingly, the Phillips curve is nonlinear over its range. The authors argue that if the Phillips curve is flat when the unemployment rate is above the equilibrium rate, then the equilibrium rate is difficult to estimate. A flat portion of the Phillips curve will contain different unemployment rates corresponding to the same inflation rate. For example, if the Phillips curve is flat above 2-percent unemployment, then the inflation rate will be near zero when the unemployment rate is above 2 percent. As such, there will not be a unique unemployment rate that corresponds to a close-to-zero inflation rate. Gagnon and Sarsenbayev argue that because central banks rely on a linear Phillips curve model, they overestimate the equilibrium rate of unemployment. As a result, many economies have higher levels of unemployment than are necessary for price stability. The authors provide empirical data to show that the unemployment rate was above the equilibrium rate in the 11 advanced economies for the past 25 years. They estimate that the “true unemployment gap,” the difference between the unemployment rate and its corresponding equilibrium rate, ranged from about –5 percent to nearly 20 percent for different nations. Gagnon and Sarsenbayev recommend that central banks allow the unemployment rate to move below the estimated equilibrium rate. The authors find that exploring lower unemployment rates is needed to discover the actual slopes of a nonlinear Phillips curve. In addition, allowing the unemployment rate to move lower may help central banks meet their inflation rate targets. Many of the 11 nations have an inflation rate that is commonly below target. Finally, Gagnon and Sarsenbayev find that the increase in inflation in 2021–22 was due to exogenous shocks (especially the recent pandemic). Thus, they argue that low inflation will likely reappear once these shocks abate.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › UBI Good

A UBI wouldn’t spur inflation – empirical and theoretical evidence proves otherwise

Scott Santerns, 11/22/2014, Medium “Wouldn’t unconditional basic income just cause massive inflation?” https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-income-just-cause-massive-inflation-fe71d69f15e7, mm

By far, the most common concern in regards to my first article on Medium about the idea of an unconditional basic income was that all prices would inevitably go up as a result, immediately reducing the value of each dollar and essentially creating a new zero. Let’s call it the “New Zero Argument” against basic income. The New Zero Argument: Although a noble idea to give money to those in need, no one would actually be better off as a result of basic income due to everything costing more — especially rent — and therefore the policy idea is entirely pointless because the only thing it would attain is a new zero. In economic terms, this concern is the fear of inflation or even hyperinflation, and it is possibly the most common reflex to the notion of just transferring more money to the lower and middle classes. So how grounded in reality is this concern? First, a quick three minute about inflation and deflation. Now that we know more about what gives money its value, and how we actually want a small amount of inflation, we need to understand that basic income is not the idea of printing $3 trillion new dollars every year and dropping it on everyone from helicopters. (Although there are arguments to be made that to a lesser degree this could be done on a temporary and varying basis as economic stimulus according to perceived economic conditions as a kind of “quantitative easing for people” instead of banks) The money for a basic income guarantee would be already existing money circulated through the economic system. It would not be new money, just money shifted from one location to another. This means that the value of each dollar has not changed. The dollar itself has only changed hands. It is also important to note the observation that even when money supply is vastly expanded, the effects on prices need not be extreme. For example, the Fed’s quantitative easing added over four trillion new dollars to the U.S. money supply, and the results were not enough inflation, as defined by the Fed. “But even with the trillions of dollars pumped into the economy, the Fed has been perpetually unable to get inflation up to the 2 percent level it aims for, except for the occasional brief period. There is good news in that predictions by many Fed critics that Q.E. would unleash vicious hyperinflation have come nowhere close to materializing. But neither has it been enough for the Fed to reach its self-imposed goal. In an economy trying to get out from under an overhang of debt, where excessive unemployment is the leading problem, too-low inflation can be deeply problematic and hold back growth. Q.E. has not been powerful enough to generate as much inflation as the Fed says it wants.” So even though basic income would not be printing new money for everyone, even if it were, inflation would not be a guaranteed result. With that understood, to then understand how much we should actually fear rising prices as a result of redistributing existing money from one place to another instead of printing new money requires some studying, but the short answer is that capitalism not only still exists with basic income, it is enhanced. By enhanced, I mean there is growing evidence from where basic incomes have been actually tried that it increases entrepreneurship. We also have actual examples of partial basic incomes, that we can examine for inflationary evidence. Aside from this evidence, we also need to understand how increased demand leading to higher prices isn’t as simple as we might think it is, and how when it comes to housing prices, in a future where everyone has basic incomes, we are likely to see some very interesting market adjustments. Meanwhile, fears involving unearned income and increased velocity require a closer examination. Because of all the above that needs to be understood in order to more fully examine the question of basic income and inflation, I have split off the above information into four separate smaller articles. Let’s call them Exhibits, A, B, C, and D. If you wish to learn more about each collection of evidence, just read the attached sub-article before moving on. Or you can just keep on reading. In 1982, Alaska began providing a partial basic income annually to all its residents. Until the first dividend, Alaska had a higher rate of inflation than the rest of the United States. But ever since the dividend was introduced, Alaska has had a lower rate of inflation than the rest of the United States. A partial basic income was also provided in Kuwait in 2011, when every citizen was given $4,000. Fears of increasing inflation were rampant, as Kuwait already had high inflation. Instead of bad inflation getting worse, it actually got better, decreasing from record highs to under 4 percent. Elsewhere, where basic income experiments have been actually tried and studied, the result in each case is increased entrepreneurship. People use their basic incomes to invest in themselves and their futures, creating new businesses and helping to drive the economy beyond what would be possible without it. This means more people competing for basic income dollars, with better goods and services and lower costs. All of this represents real evidence to counter any fear of inflation. To further inform inflationary fears on a more academic basis, it’s also important to understand the basic variability of supply and demand and how it applies to various goods and services. Where demand already exists and supply is already paid for, demand is unlikely to change as basic income simply replaces one method of payment with another. E.g., replacing food stamps with basic income is unlikely to make people buy more milk. It just means people will likely buy the same amount of milk with cash instead of SNAP. Where demand is actually increased, depending on the good or service, supply can also easily be increased, be increased with some investment in capacity, or not be increased. It is this third case where prices can rise, and points more to increases in prices for luxuries, and not basic goods and services. All of this represents academic evidence to counter any fear of inflation. Rising rent is a particularly worrisome fear for many when first introduced to the idea of basic income. However, two very important things in particular need to be understood when it comes to housing. There are five times more vacant homes than homeless people in the United States today. This represents a large unused supply that need only be made available. The reason many people are not living in these homes is because they were at one time but couldn’t afford to keep them. Basic income rectifies this and puts people back in homes. Technology represents a major factor in future housing prices, especially a future where everyone has a basic income. Everyone will receive a monthly check to afford rent, and will want to spend as little of it as possible on rent. Meanwhile, owners will want to compete for this money with other owners. Those offering the lowest rents will win. One example of this would be Google deciding to create Google Homes and leasing them out to people for a fraction of what people are paying now. Another example would be super affordable WikiHouses. For these two reasons in particular, in combination with the ability of everyone to truly live anywhere for the first time in history, a nationwide market for ultra-affordable housing will be created, and smart businesses will step into this space in hopes of dominating it. All of this represents theoretical evidence to counter any fear of inflation. Two lesser known economic concerns among those who know of them, are possible differences in how we perceive the value of money depending on how it was received, and how quickly it is spent. There is a popular conception that unearned income is perceived differently than earned income, and therefore spent more spuriously. Because people are considered more likely to spend money they didn’t earn, the fear is that people will pay more for goods and services with basic income, and therefore increase prices. This is a misconception though, and not backed by evidence, with the opposite observed in Alaska, where the dividend is treated virtually identically to earned income. The frequency with which a single dollar is spent in the economy — known as the velocity of money — is another variable in the inflation equation. The faster the velocity, the higher inflation can get. However, velocity as measured by the entire money supply is currently lower now than ever in U.S. history. And as measured by the real money supply, it has been crashing since 2007. We want higher velocity for a healthy economy, and the fear that unearned income has less value is unsupported. All of this represents economic evidence to counter any fear of inflation.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › Job Guarantee Good

A jobs guarantee breaks down inflation barriers- it generates revenue through taxable incomes

Tsai 2022

Daniel, Lecturer in business and law, Toronto Metropolitan university, Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream, The conversation US, https://theconversation.com/why-a-universal-job-guarantee-beats-the-basic-income-pipe-dream-186793

There are a few unique barriers that undermine universal basic income and its ability to be implemented. As we have seen with government support programs related to COVID-19, government stimulus in the form of direct cash can cause inflation. These programs reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. Like the Canada Emergency Response Benefit, universal basic income might take away the incentive to work for some, resulting in a labour market bereft of workers. This would result in a vicious cycle: employers would raise wages to attract those willing to work, which would increase inflation and cost of living, causing businesses, in turn, to raise costs to be able to afford higher salaries for their workers. A 'Now Hiring' sign hanging in the window of a building. Government stimulus programs can reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. (Shutterstock) The effects of cash stimulus without controls can be far reaching. To take the resulting steam out of the economy, policy-makers often resort to blunt counter measures like increasing interest rates, which can lead to a recession. In contrast, a universal job guarantee would generate revenue for the government through taxable income, thereby reducing the cost of the program while simultaneously enhancing other sectors of the economy, such as the environment or infrastructure. It would ensure that people are able to earn money and, therefore, be able to spend money.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › Job Guarantee Good

A universal jobs guarantee solves inflation- provides wages to those in need

Tsai 2022

Daniel, Lecturer in business and law, Toronto Metropolitan university, Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream, The conversation US, https://theconversation.com/why-a-universal-job-guarantee-beats-the-basic-income-pipe-dream-186793

With the current cost-of-living crisis resulting in dramatic inflation, higher interest rates and a looming recession, people have been searching for solutions to the economic crisis. A universal job guarantee may just be the answer we’re looking for, especially since Canada lost 43,000 jobs in June. While most people are familiar with the idea of a universal basic income — the notion of giving every citizen a basic income, irrespective of their income level or need — few are familiar with the idea of a universal job guarantee. Read more: A guaranteed basic income could end poverty, so why isn’t it happening? Instead of a guaranteed fixed income, a universal job guarantee policy provides jobs — and wages — to people who aren’t able to find work on their own. In theory, a universal job guarantee could help stabilize inflation by providing stable, full-time employment, addressing unemployment, enhancing economic productivity and reinforcing price stability. Read news coverage based on evidence, not tweets Job guarantee programs are crucial for a number of reasons. They keep people in the labour force, alleviate poverty, improve health and well-being, add meaning to people’s lives and help the most vulnerable. They also provide crucial non-monetary benefits that have historically been associated with universal basic income, including improvements to “health, education, social cohesion and productivity.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › LINK ANSWERS › Job Guarantee Good

A job guarantee makes monetary policy more effective – allows the Fed to focus on combating inflation without creating unemployment

Mark Paul, William Darity Jr., and Darrick Hamilton, 3/9/18, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “The Federal Job Guarantee - A Policy to Achieve Permanent Full Employment,” https://www.cbpp.org/research/full-employment/the-federal-job-guarantee-a-policy-to-achieve-permanent-full-employment, mm

Improving workers livelihoods as the Federal Reserve manages its dual mandate. As noted above, the Federal Reserve has a dual mandate—maximum employment and price stability. Through its use of monetary policy, the Federal Reserve plays a vital role in promoting full employment; however, monetary policy has proven insufficient for eliminating involuntary unemployment. Historically, the Federal Reserve has had a significant role in increasing unemployment as a result of combating any inflationary pressures that may exist in the economy. With a job guarantee policy in place, the Federal Reserve can conduct monetary policy without promoting rising levels of unemployment. In this scenario, the job guarantee program can maintain employment and consumption expenditures while the Federal Reserve employs monetary policy to reduce private investment in order to cool the economy. Thus, U.S. workers would be less vulnerable to the Federal Reserve not adhering to their responsibility of a dual mandate appropriately due to their cultural over-emphasis—a function of their close ties to the financial sector—on price stability.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Economy Down

Non-Unique: Economy declining now because of poor consumer spending

Conference Board ’23 (The Conference Board is the global, nonprofit think tank and business membership organization, For over 100 years, our cutting-edge research, data, events and executive networks have helped the world's leading companies understand the present and shape the future. “Economic Forecast for the US Economy,” June 09, 2023, )

The Conference Board forecasts that weaknesses emerging in some parts of the economy will intensify and grow more diffuse over the coming months, leading to a recession. This outlook is associated with numerous factors, including, persistent inflation, Federal Reserve hawkishness, dampened bank lending amid the banking crisis, reduced government spending due to the debt ceiling deal, and underlying trends in consumer spending and income, and business investment. We forecast that real GDP growth will slow to 1.0 percent in 2023, and then fall to 0.0 percent in 2024. Consumer spending has fallen in four of the last six months. However, a large spike in January and a smaller spike in April offset this weakness. While spending on services has continued to gradually expand, spending on goods has been volatile. Recent PMI data suggest that the services sector is beginning to cool, and we expect high interest rates to further dampen spending on goods. We forecast that overall consumer spending will grow in Q2 2023 but anticipate a contraction in H2 2023. Two trends underlie the recent persistence in consumer spending, but both are likely fading. First, excess savings associated with federal government checks to households amid the pandemic period buttressed consumer balance sheets , but our assessment of these savings show that they are being depleted and will likely runout before the end of the year. Second, gains in disposable personal income have outpaced inflation since last summer. However, tightness in the labor market is moderating somewhat and wage gains are slowing. We expect this trend to continue as the economy cools and unemployment ticks up. Another notable drag on future consumer spending will be the reintroduction of mandatory student loan repayments in September. Meanwhile, business investment continued to cool in Q1 as high interest rates and concerns about the future weighed on companies. These trends will likely worsen under the weight of high interest rates (we believe the Fed is done raising rates but don’t expect to see any rate cuts until 2024) and weakening consumer demand. Additionally, commercial and industrial lending by banks continues to slow in the wake of the US banking crisis. Residential investment, which is highly sensitive to Fed policy, has already contracted significantly as interest rates have climbed. We don’t expect a recovery in this sector until rates begin to fall next year. Government spending represented one of the few positive growth drivers for 2023 as federal non-defense spending benefited from outlays associated with infrastructure investment legislation passed in 2021 and 2022. However, reductions in discretionary outlays ($1.5 Trillion over 10 years) detailed in the Fiscal Responsibility Act (which averted the debt ceiling crisis) will limit overall government spending and act as a drag on growth later this year and early next.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Long-Term Inflation Inevitable

Inflation is High now- geopolitical events bottleneck supplies

GlobalData 2/24/23

GlobalData, GlobalData Global Economic Slowdown Looms in 2023 Due to High Inflation and Borrowing Costs According to GlobalData; https://www.globaldata.com/media/business-fundamentals/global-economic-slowdown-looms-in-2023-due-to-high-inflation-borrowing-costs

The global economy is facing significant challenges due to slowing but elevated inflation, high borrowing costs, and lower external demand. These factors are expected to have a profound impact on private consumption expenditure, investments, and economic activities. As a result, major global economies are projected to experience slower growth or even recession this year. Against this backdrop, the global GDP growth is expected to slow down from 3.2% in 2022 to 2.1% in 2023, forecasts . GlobalData’s latest report, “Macroeconomic Outlook Report: Global (Q1 2023 Update),” reveals that the global economy witnessed a solid economic recovery from -3.7% in 2020 to 5.9% in 2021 before slowing to 3.2% in 2022, due to the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war. However, the reopening of the Chinese economy and vaccination efforts across the emerging economies are anticipated to alleviate some of the strain on global supply chains in 2023. Maheshwari Bandari, Economic Research Analyst at GlobalData, comments: “The year 2023 will be challenging for a large portion of the global economy as the primary drivers of growth—the US, and Europe are expected to experience a slowdown in activity. A considerable slowdown in large economies would also have an influence on external demand in emerging and developing countries. Increased financial vulnerabilities in large swaths of the world could increase the risk of a hard landing at a time when governments in many developing economies lack the policy space to support activity if needed. As a result of increased borrowing rates on funds to fight inflation, several economies will likely shrink.” Asia-Pacific is projected to be the fastest growing region in the world with real GDP growth forecast at 3.7% in 2023. The growth will primarily be aided by the expected robust growth in India (5.7%) and China (5.2%). Middle East & Africa (MEA) (3.2%) is projected to be the second fastest growing region followed by Americas (0.8%) and Europe (0.2%). GlobalData forecasts the global inflation rate to remain at an elevated level of 5.3% in 2023, although it is forecast to decrease from the 8.1% the previous year. Inflation in all regions is projected to ease in 2023. On the external side, countries with export-led growth will face a greater challenge in 2023 as external demand slows. Exports and imports (in value terms) by G20 nations contracted for the first time in two years by 1.3% and 1.1%, respectively, on a quarterly basis in Q3 2022, according to the OECD. Bandari concludes: “The global economic outlook in 2023 is influenced by the greater uncertainty in geopolitics. The expected easing of supply-side constraints with the lifting of lockdowns in China and the easing of price pressure may prompt central banks to signal a softening bias from the second half of 2023, which may revive investor interest and market sentiment and create a relatively optimistic outlook for 2024.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Long-Term Inflation Inevitable

Climate change and aging populations will lock-in high inflation for decades

Matthew Klein, 5/10/23, Vox, Why inflation isn’t going away anytime soon,” https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/23717600/high-inflation-cpi-climate-change-population-aging, mm

The inflation surge of the past two years is a warning about what can happen when sudden changes in the things we want collide with massive disruptions in our ability to make them. While current inflation slowed to 4.9 percent in April according to Labor Department data released today, after more than a year of Fed interest rate hikes, it’s likely to fade eventually as the Covid-19 pandemic and its associated policy responses continue to normalize. But this victory may ultimately prove fleeting: compared to the relative stability we’ve come to take for granted over the last few decades, price changes in the decades ahead could be far more volatile, while underlying inflation could be faster and more persistent than in the recent past. That’s because we’re poised to endure at least two major social transformations this century that will reshape the economy — and heighten inflation risks. The first is the compounding effects of climate change, which will require massive investments in everything from sea walls to electric transmission lines to clean power generation. We’ll also need to find replacements for traditional plastic and discover greener ways to produce cement, steel, and meat economically. It’s a transition that, all together, will require trillions of dollars in new investment. And we will have to do all of this as worsening fires, droughts, and floods — along with climate-related migration flows — threaten to destabilize many societies and destroy productive capacity. This “green transition” is set to coincide with another unprecedented threat to social and economic stability: an aging and eventually shrinking population. By the end of the century, high-income countries and China, which together have consistently produced about 80 percent of the world’s economic output since at least 1960, are projected to lose more than 40 percent of their working-age populations — even as their elderly populations are poised to rise by roughly 60 percent. This “gray transition” will be extremely costly, requiring fewer people to work harder and longer to support a growing number of non-working retirees. Handled badly, either of these transitions alone would be enough to generate years of unwelcome price increases as businesses and consumers struggle to adapt to massive changes in the mix of goods and services we need, changes to the ways we produce, and impairments in our overall ability to produce anything. Together, they’re a recipe for prolonged and painful inflation.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Inflation High

US inflation is up now- more than double the historical average

Tiffany Lam-Balfour and Arielle O’Shea 2023

Lam-Balfour was a senior financial advisor and sales manager. O’Shea is a retired investment planner. Current Inflation Rate: What It Is and Why It Matters; https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/inflation

Looking at CPI for the 30 years from 1989 to 2019, the average annual inflation rate was 2.5%. The Federal Open Market Committee, the arm of the U.S. central bank that makes decisions about managing the nation’s money supply, targets a 2% rate of inflation over time. The prices of different goods and services can rise at different rates. For instance, education and health care costs are generally subject to higher inflation rates than the average inflation rate. According to finaid.org, a site that offers financial aid advice, tools and information, U.S. tuition rates are typically more than double the general inflation rate, and on average, increase about 8% each year. And according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, national health spending is projected to grow at an average annual rate of 5.1% between 2021 and 2030. The impact of inflation is felt throughout an economy. As prices rise, what you can buy now will lessen over time. Being able to combat, or at least keep up with, inflation and sustain the purchasing power of your money is one of the main reasons to invest your money. Consumers care about inflation because it affects costs and their standard of living. Businesses carefully watch the price of raw materials that go into their products, as well as what wages they need to pay their employees. Inflation affects taxes, government spending and programs, the level of interest rates and more. A low, steady or predictable level of inflation is considered positive for an economy.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Inflation High

Inflation is high now due to the Ukraine War and COVID pandemic.

Entrepreneur 23

Editorial Staff, Why Is Inflation So High Right Now?, Entrepreneur,

Keeping that base knowledge of inflation in mind, here are two key reasons inflation is so high. 1. The Covid-19 pandemic. The pandemic caused a classic case of demand-pull inflation. A few factors can cause demand-pull inflation; however, in this case, it is mainly caused by household spending. Throughout history, demand-pull inflation often happened after wartime. For example, when World War II ended, the country's economy experienced a boom it was not quite expecting. Because people were celebrating the war's end and living more carefreely, they began to make more purchases than they had in previous years. This caused a rapid shift in the economy as demand soared above supply. A similar phenomenon occurred when lockdowns were lifted, and people became more comfortable resuming everyday life as the pandemic began to wane. People began buying again, but the purchases happened more rapidly than the slowed supply chain could handle. And when the demand is that much greater than the supply, shortages and price increases occur. 2. Russia's invasion of Ukraine Politics aside, foreign and domestic conflict affects the functions of the world's economy. Russia and Ukraine supply the world with essential commodities, and because of the supply chain disruption the war has caused, sanctions were imposed and higher prices became inevitable. With these two countries at war, significant shifts and shortages are happening worldwide. There are four key areas where the world is seeing the harshest effects: Food: Russia and Ukraine supply the world with one-fourth of its wheat, one-fifth of its cornand coarse grains and 80% of its sunflower oil. Because of the conflict, global food prices have increased by 17%. Transport: Russia is one of the world's foremost suppliers of palladium, mine production, platinum, titanium and fertilizer. These commodities contribute to significant industries like automobiles, aircraft and farming. Energy: Russia is a massive contributor to the world's oil and energy industry. In June, the price of Brent oil surged to $120 per barrel, and overall energy prices have increased by 30%. Energy used in the U.S. accounts for 7.6% of the CPI, leading to further inflation and a global energy crisis. Financial Markets: When stocks are unpredictable, like during a conflict, global stock prices generally see adverse effects due to tentative trades and divestments.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Inflation High

Corporate greed is driving the current wave of inflation

Joseph Adinolfi, 3/23/23, Market Watch, “The Fed has it wrong: Corporate greed is to blame for inflation, not rising wages, SocGen analyst says” https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-fed-has-it-wrong-corporate-greed-is-to-blame-for-inflation-not-rising-wages-socgen-analyst-says-e1236056, mm

Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell has repeatedly said undercutting wage growth for American workers is essential for tamping down the worst bout of inflation in the U.S. in more than 40 years. But a raft of data suggest that robust corporate profit margins — not wages — are having a much bigger impact on rising prices, according to longtime Société Générale strategist Albert Edwards. Edwards calls this dynamic “greedflation”: the notion that corporate price gouging is helping to keep inflation robust at a time when commodity prices, which were initially blamed for the price shock, have actually fallen over the past 12 months. West Texas Intermediate crude oil CL00, -3.82% was trading at roughly $77 a barrel on Thursday, compared with $115 a barrel one year ago, according to FactSet data. Prices of other important industrial commodities, including copper, have also declined during the same period. In his latest note on the topic, shared with MarketWatch Thursday, Edwards questioned why the Fed has been so insistent on targeting wages instead of pointing the finger at corporations: “the primary driver of this inflation cycle is soaring profit margins. Rather than calling this out as the primary cause of high inflation, central banks have instead chosen to focus on rising nominal wages as threatening to embed higher inflation – the so called ‘wage/price spiral’.” Often, corporations are raising prices of goods and services not because they need to due to rising labor and raw materials costs, but because they can get away with it by blaming inflation, something that consumers have been primed by media reports to expect, Edwards said. Blaming wage growth for inflation seems particularly misguided considering that workers’ wages haven’t even kept pace with rising consumer prices, Edwards said. Meanwhile, corporate profit margins have climbed to near-record highs. Profits for non-financial companies rose to nearly $2.1 trillion in the third quarter, a record high on a nominal basis, according to Commerce Department data. They have risen sharply since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020. This isn’t the first time Edwards has explored this topic in his research shared with Societe Generale clients. He examined the issue of price gouging in a note published back in November. The chart below, which shows how corporate profits as a percentage of GDP have risen to record highs, is from that previous note. While workers’ earnings have generally increased, they haven’t kept pace with rising consumer prices, which means that, when adjusted for inflation, workers’ earning power has actually declined. Average hourly earnings increased by 4.6% year-over-year, according to the latest monthly jobs data released by the Department of Labor. That’s less than the headline year-over-year increase in the consumer-price index, which stood at 6%. Moreover, Edwards showed that U.S. workers’ earnings compared to the costs of the goods and services they help to produce had been declining for years, tracing the start of the trend to when China joined the World Trade Organization in December 2001. Using an example taken from Howard University economics professor William Spriggs, Edwards pointed out that if wages truly are the driving inflation, then the cost of food at restaurants should be rising faster than the cost of food consumed at home because of the cost of labor. But the opposite is true, according to the consumer-price index, a closely watched gauge of inflation produced by the U.S. government. The cost of food eaten at home has risen by 10.2% during the year through February, according to the latest CPI data from February. By comparison, the cost of food consumer away from home has increased by 8.4%. “If wage inflation was pushing prices higher, food at home would exceed food away from home,” Edwards said. Therefore, “wages are not the problem.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Inflation High

Non-Unique: Inflation is persistent and still high – perception triggers the link in the status quo.

Horsley, 6/13 (Scott, NPR, “Cheaper eggs and gas lead inflation lower in May, but higher prices pop up elsewhere,” June 13, 2023, https://www.npr.org/2023/06/13/1181686474/cheaper-eggs-gas-lead-inflation-lower-in-may-but-higher-prices-pop-up-elsewhere)

But as Tedeschi and his colleagues acknowledged in a recent blog post, inflation around the price of services "has remained elevated in recent months and is unlikely to be resolved by lessening supply chain frictions alone." The Fed's aggressive rate hikes have put the brakes on some of the most sensitive parts of the economy, such as the housing market and manufacturing. But other industries continue to grow, and robust consumer demand is keeping upward pressure on prices. Even if Fed policymakers don't raise interest rates this week, they could signal their intent to do so, by forecasting higher rates later this year. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell could also stress during his post-meeting news conference that rates will remain elevated until inflation is under control. "I think they have an opportunity here for a hawkish pause or skip or whatever you want to call it," Patterson said. "And I believe Chair Powell is going to emphasize just how long they're going to remain at whatever level it is that they get to, given the need to get inflation back down." A survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York suggests Americans have come to view inflation as a less acute but more stubborn problem than they once did. People's guess at what inflation would be a year from now was the lowest since May of 2021, when rising prices were just beginning to take hold in the U.S. But people's longer-term forecasts were somewhat gloomier than they had been, and on average they don't expect inflation to return to the Fed's 2% target anytime in the next five years.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Rates Rising

The Fed is still hawkish – more hikes are on the way

Jill Goldsmith, 6/14/23, Deadline, “Federal Reserve Sees More Interest Rate Hikes Coming This Year After June Pause; Dow Dips,” https://deadline.com/2023/06/dow-media-stocks-nosedive-hawkish-fed-interest-rate-outlook-no-hike-for-june-1235417289/, mm

The Dow Jones nosedived this afternoon as the Federal Reserve – which has raised interest rates ten times since last year – held them steady for June but indicated that more hikes are on the way. A pause in the aggressive increases meant to stem inflation was expected, but hawkish commentary in a statement out of today’s Fed meeting wasn’t. A majority of governors are in favor of raising rates again this year and two more increases are expected. The Fed gave a target 5.6% terminal rate, or where it wants the number to settle. Chairman Jerome Powell just wrapped a press conference to take questions on the Fed’s thinking. The DJIA reversed course on the news, turning lower by nearly 400 points midafternoon. It’s off its lows. The Nasdaq and S&P 500 — both off by about half a percentage point on the announcement — also recovered somewhat but were jittery as Powell spoke. In its press release today, the Federal Open Market Committee said, “Recent indicators suggest that economic activity has continued to expand at a modest pace. Job gains have been robust in recent months, and the unemployment rate has remained low. Inflation remains elevated.” Hikes are increasingly controversial, however, especially after some of the nation’s biggest bank failures ever this year starting in March and related to high interest rates. Also, annual inflation cooled in May to 4%, the slowest growth in more than two years, raising market hope the Fed might lay off interest rates beyond June. Still, core inflation is still double the Fed’s target of about 2%. Powell said July would be “a live meeting.” “We have to get it down to 2% and we will. But we just don’t see that yet,” Powell said at the presser, talking of inflation.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Rates Rising

The economy is locked in a wage-price spiral – the Fed will inevitably resume rate hikes

Nicole Goodkind, 6/14/23, CNN Business, “American workers are becoming less productive. That’s bad news for the Fed,” https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/14/investing/premarket-stocks-trading/index.html, mm

Federal Reserve officials are widely expected to announce on Wednesday a pause in their regimen of rate hikes. After 10 consecutive hikes, investors are pricing in a 94% chance that the Fed will leave rates unchanged for the first time since January 2022, according to the CME’s FedWatch Tool. But a pause is not a full stop. The labor market, which policymakers believe to be a key driver of inflation in the dominant services sector of the economy, is still remarkably strong. Now there’s a growing consensus on Wall Street that central bank officials could restart the hikes, meant to fight elevated inflation, as soon as July. But what does the Fed mean when it talks about labor markets and their impact on inflation? A lot of it has to do with a troublesome slowdown in productivity. At its most basic level, labor productivity is a measure of the value of the goods and services produced by a company compared with the amount of labor used to produce that output. Productivity moves in the opposite direction to wages and so if it remains depressed, there will be upward pressure on labor costs — and ultimately on inflation, said Lisa Shalett, CIO of Morgan Stanley Wealth Management. That’s a big deal to Fed officials who have spoken publicly about their fears of a wage-price spiral — the feedback loop that drives inflation higher as people make more money and go out and spend it. “The crosscurrents for the Fed are complex. Big bets about the pace of the hiking path are ill advised,” said Shalett. During the Fed policy meeting in May, participants expressed worry that even though the pace of wage growth has been gradually slowing, it is still “running at a pace that, given current estimates of trend productivity growth, was well above what would be consistent over the longer run with the Committee’s 2% inflation objective,” according to minutes from the meeting. Productivity in the United States has been steadily declining since 2005, but the post-pandemic landscape has accelerated that downturn significantly. Labor productivity decreased 2.1% in the first quarter of 2023, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported earlier this month. That was the worst reading since 2007, according to the BLS.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UNIQUENESS ANSWERS › Rates Rising

The Fed will still raise rates BUT the economy is resilient.

Rugaber, 6/14 (Christopher, AP News Journalist, “Fed Chair Powell sees progress on inflation, though not quickly enough,” June 14, 2023,

In a surprisingly hawkish signal, the Fed’s policymakers issued projections Wednesday showing they envision as many as two additional quarter-point rate hikes before the year ends. (In Fed parlance, “hawks” generally favor higher rates to quell inflation, while “doves” typically advocate lower rates to aid a healthy job market.) Before this week’s policy meeting, Fed watchers had expected the policymakers to signal just one more rate increase this year. In their new projections, the members of the Fed’s interest-rate committee were less divided than many economists had expected, with 12 of the 18 policymakers foreseeing at least two more quarter-point rate increases. Four favored one quarter-point hike. Only two envisioned keeping rates unchanged. The policymakers also predicted that their benchmark rate will stay higher for longer than they envisioned three months ago. Powell noted that wage growth has slowed and cited some signs that the job market is cooling. Those factors, he added, should reduce inflationary pressures. “I would almost say that the conditions that we need to see in place to get inflation down are coming into place,” Powell said. “But the process of that actually working on inflation is going to take some time.” Inflation dropped to 4% in May compared with a year earlier, down sharply from a 9.1% peak last June. And many economists expect it to decline further. Rental costs are falling, and used car prices, which spiked in April and May, are also likely to drop. Yet Powell underscored that the Fed will need to feel confident that inflation is moving steadily closer to its 2% target. “We’re two and a quarter years into this, and forecasters, including Fed forecasters, have consistently thought that inflation was about to turn down ... and been wrong,” he said. “We want to get inflation down to 2%, and we just don’t see that yet.” At the same time, Powell stopped short of saying the Fed’s policymakers have committed to resuming their hikes when they next meet in late July. At one point in the news conference, he referred to Wednesday’s decision as a “skip,” which would imply that the Fed planned to raise rates at the July meeting. He then corrected himself: “I shouldn’t call it a skip,” he said. But Powell emphasized that the Fed wants to move more slowly after its breakneck pace last year, when it carried out four straight three-quarter-point hikes, followed by a half-point increase and then three quarter-point hikes this year. The Fed’s aggressive streak of rate hikes, which have made mortgages, auto loans, credit cards and business borrowing costlier, have been intended to slow spending and defeat the worst bout of inflation in four decades. Average credit card rates have surpassed 20% to a record high. “Given how far we have come, it may make sense for rates to move higher but at a more moderate pace,” he said. “It’s just the idea that we’re trying to get this right.” Should inflation come down further, some economists think the Fed may not actually have to raise rates again. “With inflation set to moderate noticeably, we are skeptical that the Fed will resume hiking interest rates,” Ryan Sweet, chief U.S. economist of Oxford Economics, wrote in a note. “Our baseline forecast is for the Fed to remain on hold through the remainder of this year before gradually easing in early 2024.” One reason why Fed officials may be predicting additional rate hikes is that the economy has remained surprisingly resilient this year, with more persistent inflation that might require higher rates to cool. Their updated forecasts show them predicting economic growth of 1% for 2023, an upgrade from a meager 0.4% forecast in March. And they expect “core” inflation, which excludes volatile food and energy prices, of 3.9% by year’s end, higher than they expected three months ago. Powell and other top policymakers have also indicated that they want to assess how much a pullback in bank lending might be weakening the economy. Banks have been slowing their lending — and demand for loans has fallen — as interest rates have risen. Some analysts have expressed concern that the collapse of three large banks last spring could cause nervous lenders to sharply tighten their loan qualifications. The economy has so far fared better than the central bank and most economists had expected at the beginning of the year. Companies are still hiring at a robust pace, which has helped encourage many people to keep spending, particularly on travel, dining out and entertainment.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Povery/Inequality

Inflation turns wages

Iacurci 21, Personal Finance Reporter (Greg, July 27th, “Wages are rising, but inflation may have given workers a 2% pay cut,” CNBC, , Accessed 11-06-2021)

Workers saw their hourly pay in June jump at the fastest clip in more than a decade. Yet some of them saw those gains erased by high levels of inflation. “Real wages” — a measure of income after accounting for the cost of goods and services people buy — fell by almost 2%, on average, last month compared with 2020. Senate Republicans said Wednesday that Americans were getting a pay cut as a result. “The staples of American life are increasing exponentially,” according to Sen. Tim Scott, R-S.C., who cited examples like higher prices for gas, laundry, airfare, moving costs, hotels, bacon and TVs. The thrust of the argument — that inflation eats into rising wages — is true, according to economists. Still, there are many nuances, they said. For one, whether a consumer got a pay cut or not depends on their individual earnings and the things they buy. “If prices are growing faster than wages, then people are getting inflation-adjusted pay cuts,” according to Michael Strain, director of economic policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank. “Ultimately, this varies dramatically for every individual.” Plus, inflation has been volatile and may prove temporary — meaning a reduction in buying power could be short-lived, economists said. Inflation and wage growth Average hourly earnings rose 3.6%, to $30.40, in June compared with the same month in 2020. That’s the biggest spike since January 2009, according to data compiled by the Economic Policy Institute. Meanwhile, the consumer price index, a measure of inflation, jumped 5.4% over the same period — the most since August 2008. Together, this amounts to a 1.7% loss in buying power, on average, when factoring in seasonal adjustments, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Inflation is a tax,” said William Foster, a vice president at Moody’s Investors Service. “That’s the best way to think about it.” Inflation most impacts lower earners, who spend more of their average dollar on gas, food and other items that may be rising in price, Foster said. Wealthier individuals, who tend to hold more financial assets like stocks or homes, may be better able to offset the impact of inflation, he added.