Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Perm Do Both

Both UBI and JG are needed to ensure welfare for the lowest class as well as job opportunities. The combination solves any critiques on either side.

Fitzroy & Jin 18 --- Felix FitzRoy is professor emeritus of economics at the University of St. Andrews. Jim Yongtao Jin is a reader at the School of Economics and Finance at the University of St. Andrews.

["Basic Income and a Public Job Offer: Complementary Policies to Reduce Poverty and Unemployment." Journal of Poverty and Social Justice. 03/17/18. . Date Accessed: 6-20-2023.]

Current and pending problems in most labour markets, such as persistent underemployment, more precarious and non-standard employment, stagnating real wages for the majority, and a perceived, growing threat from automation have revived discussion of the old idea of a universal basic income (BI) — an unconditional payment to all citizens as a basic right — with the first nationwide pilot study now underway in Finland, following successful trials in Canada and developing countries. The fundamental rationale is to provide a minimum standard of living and freedom for all citizens, regardless of their ability and willingness to work. BI may reduce labour supply by some low-wage workers, due to the income effect when recipients have other priorities such as child care, but this would increase social welfare and put upward pressure on (low) wages. For many with low incomes, even a modest BI would provide an alternative safety net to various uncoordinated, current forms of targeted social assistance such as job-seeker’s allowance or social credit, which inevitably generate a poverty trap as benefits are withdrawn with increasing earnings. Replacing all welfare programmes with BI,as suggested by Murray (2013), however, would impose immense hardship on some of the poorest. Most proposals would combine BI with some other welfare measures, but neglect the additional benefit of a job guarantee (JG). In the UK combining disability and housing benefits with a modest BI would bring major welfare gains but fail to alleviate the additional misery of persistent, involuntary non- and under-employment. The much less discussed alternative of (local) government as employer of last resort, providing a JG for all, could thus be an important complement to BI. However, a JG would also require minimum standards of attendance and performance, so we shall refer to a job offer (JO) by local authorities, or other organisations with public funding, open to all who are able and willing to meet such standards. The combination with a JO seems to be the only policy which might realise, at relatively low cost, the goals of decent employment for those who seek work, and an end to poverty for all in developed economies facing a future of increasingly precarious labour markets and even secular stagnation. Proponents of either BI or JG have usually criticised the alternative policy, and neglected limitations of their own preferred policy (including the need for sanctions to ensure performance in a job‘guarantee’). Frank (2014) proposed to combine a BI ‘that is far too small to lift an urban family from poverty with an open offer to pay sub-minimum wages to those willing to perform useful tasks in the public sphere’, because a BI above the poverty level would be politically infeasible, even when beneficial to a majority. However, the benefits of combining a modest BI and JG have been neglected by subsequent writers. Here we develop a detailed, general case for the complementarity of these two very different welfare policies, further explain the problems with either on its own, and offer illustrative numerical examples mainly for the UK, and a few comparisons with Germany. The future of employment and the failure of targeted welfare As automation threatens to accelerate the ‘hollowing out’ of middle classes and the demise of even non-routine white-collar jobs, non-standard employment or alternative work arrangements combining low pay with irregular, contingent or on-call work and lack of job security have already proliferated everywhere to create a new ‘precariat’ (Standing, 2014;Temin, 2017). At the same time, forms of under-employment have persisted at much higher levels than official unemployment in most economies, including involuntary self-employment with low and irregular earnings, and part-time work, for those unable to find adequate full-time jobs.The OECD (2017a) estimates an average labour underutilisation rate of 15 per cent of the workforce for 2015, including those who are officially unemployed and discouraged workers who are no longer searching for jobs. The full-time equivalent (FTE) UK employment rate average is only 60 per cent of the labour force, nearly 10 percentage points below the average for the most successful Nordic economies. The latter in turn have much lower average working hours per worker than the UK and US as well as among the highest life satisfaction scores (Bruenig, 2017). In comparison with the OECD average, the FTE employment rate in Britain (GBR) is slightly higher, long-term unemployment is slightly lower, and headline unemployment is about half, but this conceals major problems in the labour market. Research by the New Economics Foundation (Wheatley, 2017) shows that only about 60 per cent of workers hold ‘good jobs, which are defined as permanent jobs, or voluntarily temporary, or self-employed earning the Living Wage’ (_£8.45 outside London). In other words, about 40 per cent are in ‘bad jobs’ with inadequate earnings. Moreover‘two thirds of Britain’s children in poverty are in working families’. More than half the self-employed earn less than the living wage, while the rise of self- employment and‘zero hours’contracts, many of which fail to provide adequate hours, helped to lower unemployment. Including those in the workforce who are inactive but would like to work, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF, 2017) estimates an underemployment rate of 18 per cent in the UK. The JRF and an Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR, 2017) Interim Report recommend many sensible policies to reduce poverty and improve employment and welfare, but with no mention of either BI or JO or their combination, which, as we show below, is a cost-effective and essential complement to standard policies.This would also give workers the bargaining power and resources to demand better jobs. A recent report estimates that there are 6.8 million unpaid carers in the UK economy, whose work was valued at £132 billion, almost as much as the NHS budget (Buckner and Yeandle, 2015). Need will rise rapidly as the population ages and the incidence of chronic conditions such as type-2 diabetes and obesity increases. Home care by local authorities has been cut as part of the Conservative government’s austerity policy, forcing families to provide more unpaid care themselves, averaging over 1,000 hours a year. Meanwhile, growth has mainly benefited the rich, in particular the top 1 per cent in the UK and US. Concern over rising inequality and the failure of‘trickle down’ economics has fuelled populist movements in many countries (Lastra-Anadon and Muniz, 2017). Labours share of GDP has been declining in most industrial economies, while real wages of lower-skilled workers have remained flat or declined. Average real wages in the UK have been declining since 2007, the longest such decline for more than a century (Cooper and Whyte, 2017; Wren-Lewis, 2017). The expected impact of Brexit has likely also helped to end the ‘jobs boom’, with falling employment by the end of 2017. On the other hand, in the near future there will probably be an increasing shortage of low paid service workers in the UK due to Brexit, and the gap may not be easily filled by private sectors without local governments’ support. Traditional targeted welfare has become increasingly ineffective, with rising rates of child and in-work poverty, as well as long-term un- and under-employment particularly in the UK and US. Increasingly popular in-work benefits for low earners do not help the jobless, including those who have dropped out of the labour market. At the same time, effective marginal tax rates for low and part-time earners can be 70—90 per cent, as welfare payments are tapered or withdrawn: a widespread ‘poverty trap’ (IFS, 2010; Cooper and Whyte, 2017). In Germany, disposable income for the lowest 10 per cent of incomes declined by 8 per cent from 1991 to 2014. The bottom 40 per cent experienced essentially no growth, while the top 10 per cent benefited from 25 per cent real income growth (DIW, 2015). In the US, median full-time male earnings have declined since 1972, while the income share of the top 1 per cent has more than doubled to around 20 per cent, an extreme concentration last observed in the 1920s. Wealth inequality is even more extreme, exacerbated by tax havens (Shaxson, 2011; Zucman, 2015), and by growing levels of personal debt of the poor.Thus, the poorest half of the German population owned only 1 per cent of total wealth in 2012, compared to 4 per cent in 1993 (Bertelsmann Stiftung, 2017).The debilitating effects of growing inequality on almost all indicators of social welfare have been documented by Dorling (2017) and Wilkinson and Pickett (2010). The return of basic income In these circumstances it is perhaps not surprising that the old idea of a universal basic income has recently become the focus of intense interest and discussion. The related ‘negative income tax’ to ensure a minimum income for all had been suggested by Milton Friedman and James Tobin from opposite ends of the political spectrum in the US during the 1970s. Similar ideas were espoused earlier in Britain, but were then largely forgotten until the occurrence of rising poverty after the financial crash of2008/9. However, so far only Finland has introduced a nationwide pilot BI scheme in 2017, with more local trials planned in Canada, Scotland, Spain and the Netherlands. The OECD’s new ‘Policy Brief on the Future ofWork’ provides a detailed survey of ‘Basic income as a policy option: Can it work?’ (OECD, 2017b) covering all OECD countries. Painter and Thoung (2015), Reed and Lansley (2016), Standing (2017), andTorrey (2016) make compelling arguments for a modest BI of around £4,000 pa in the UK, with caveats discussed below, leading Van Parijs andVanderborght (2017) to recognise JG as a supplementary but minor complement. Straubhaar (2017a; 2017b) suggests replacing Germany’s generous €900 billion social security budget and complicated tax system with a €12,000 minimum income for all citizens, and a 50 per cent or 40 per cent flat tax on all incomes and value added. However, several problems with this proposal are not addressed.The high VAT would cause substantial price rises, reducing the real value of the minimum nominal income. A four-person household with a 131 of €48,000 and facing a 50 per cent marginal tax would likely drastically reduce labour supply, inciting resentment among the growing single population, and making such a generous NIT unlikely to be acceptable. Adults living alone with disabilities will be worse off. Reliance on indirect taxes to fund public expenditure would make the tax system more regressive. A more plausible reform might offer a BI of €6,000 pa at half the cost, plus a JO below the minimum wage, say €12,000 for full-time work. It would keep singles above poverty, and allow additional targeted benefits, to ensure that nobody is worse off. In the UK, with less than half of German social spending per capita, a BI of around £4,000 pa for most adult citizens, possibly less for children and more for elderly (pensioners), could replace some but not all existing cash transfers.This is about the maximum unemployment benefit (job-seeker’s allowance), but is less than half the poverty level for an adult living alone. Current cash transfers are spread across the first four income deciles, while the poorest decile pays a higher proportion of income in tax than the richest. However, due to the complexities of current tax and welfare systems, many in the bottom income deciles, particularly those with disabilities, lone parents and those receiving housing benefits, would be substantially worse off under such a BI which replaces all targeted benefits. Similar problems are found in other EU states (OECD,2017b). Thus, some means tested benefits need to be retained, but importantly, without downgrading many disabilities and reclassifying recipients as employable, which has caused great hardship. Housing benefit also urgently needs improvement to keep up with exorbitant rents and growing shortage of accommodation in SE England. This implies that monitoring of recipients will have to remain, so the simplicity of a ‘pure’ BI is unattainable. However, BI would replace the repressive and misnamed new ‘universal credit’, and abolish sanctions to punish unemployment benefit recipients for minor infringements (Patrick, 2017). Reed and Lansley (2016) and others estimate costs and benefits of such a modest BI.They suggest slightly higher top tax rates, and abolishing the Personal Allowance. Then BI roughly offsets the extra tax liability on the first 12,000 of income, so is ‘clawed back’ from higher earners, and most of the gains go to those with lower incomes, while the resulting fiscal surplus could fund still-required, means-tested benefits (and the JO discussed below). One advantage of BI (usually viewed as a potential problem, even by advocates of BI) is the income effect, which tends to reduce labour supply, raising populist fears about ‘subsidising idleness’. On the other hand, mitigation of the ‘poverty trap’ caused by means-tested, tapered benefits should encourage greater labour supply by low earners. Particularly in households with multiple job holders, or lone parents, with a high opportunity cost of time at work, the income effect will allow more leisure and parental time for children, with potentially important welfare gains. Moreover, even if BI reduces some individual labour supply, there is evidence that shorter hours can increase productivity. In fact, extensive studies of lottery winners show quite small reductions in average working time, partly due to more time between jobs and searching, so presumably resulting in better job—worker matches (Cesarini et al, 2016). Furthermore, BI should encourage self-employment and new start-ups with the possibility of further job-creation. Another aspect of BI which has worried some observers is that BI might allow some workers to accept lower wages for otherwise attractive jobs, and undermine minimum wage legislation. A job offer, discussed below, would put a floor under the total utility from employment, improving on a minimum wage, the benefits of which are often undermined by increased stress or unpaid overtime imposed by employers. While modest BI would not abolish poverty, particularly for the unemployed living alone, the alternative of a generous BI at, say £8,000 in the UK would require substantially higher taxes. Note that a single adult with an income of £8,500 was at the 10th percentile of the 2015/16 UK income distribution, while the median or 50th percentile income for a single individual was £16,800 (DWP, 2017).Thus, doubling our suggested BI would still leave singles well below the standard poverty definition of 60 per cent of median income, or £10,080 for a single adult. Politically, a more generous BI is unlikely to be feasible in the near future. As argued by De Wispelaere (2016), the popularity of BI may not be sustainable due to often incompatible motives of supporters from opposite ends of the political spectrum. A modest BI combined with a JO is more likely to be achievable than just a generous BI, partly by attenuating widespread opposition to ‘something for nothing’, and importantly, because BI alone would fail to provide the widely-recognised and documented, essential second component of psychological wellbeing for most people (Mitchell and Fazi, 2017), namely ‘dignity of work’. This dignity — the vital importance of meaningful employment for life satisfaction — is not provided by many ‘bad’jobs, and even a modest BI would increase worker bargaining power and their ability to reject such jobs. However, but usually ignored by proponents, a modest BI would thus only ameliorate but not eliminate growing problems of un- and underemployment as well as poor quality, non-standard employment under increasing automation and globalisation.The alternative of providing free Universal Basic Services (UBS) proposed by the Institute for Global Prosperity (IGP.2017) also neglects these problems.Thus, we turn to the radical and, we argue, actually complementary policy alternative of a job offer or government as employer of last resort. A job guarantee, or a local public work offer? Government employment for those unable to find regular work was much discussed during the Great Depression of the 1930s, and put into practice on a limited scale in various ‘New Deal’ programmes in the US and in other contexts elsewhere. However, it was only mobilisation for the Second World War that finally achieved full employment and ended the Great Depression. In recent years the formerly popular goal of‘full employment’ has been largely abandoned and indeed becomes difficult to define precisely under modern labour market conditions with the growth of nonstandard employment.Thus the goal should be to eliminate or minimise long-term under-employment and involuntary unemployment — including growing numbers of discouraged workers who have dropped out of the labour market. (Shorter spells of non-employment while searching for a new job are of course unavoidable). Partly for this reason, BI has attracted far more attention than the idea of a JG, though the latter was proposed by a few prominent economists such as Layard (2009/10) after the financial crash (but without BI). Gregg (2009) reviews experience with public job creation programmes in the UK and US, and notes problems with the ‘lock-in’ effect which reduces job-search, and the need for long-term training and meaningful work experience. The German ‘One Euro Jobs’ scheme was supposed to help the long-term unemployed return to regular work by offering work experience for a limited time with pay at only €1 per hour, but had no explicit training programme. This kind of work experience has been found to reduce subsequent job chances, but refusal to accept an offer may be sanctioned by reducing long-term social assistance payments known as Hartz IV (Groll, 2016). In contrast, Atkinson (2015, 140) argues that an important component of policy should be government ‘offering guaranteed public employment at the minimum wage to those who seek it’. He also favours a ‘participation income’, which is 131 with conditionality — a requirement for recipients to engage in some socially useful activity. This might increase political acceptability, but also raises serious issues about the definition and enforcement of the threshold for ‘socially useful’. Painter and Thoung (2015) and Dalzell (2017) also propose adding a JG to 131. While public work programmes have often been successful, they are generally limited in scope and hence not directly comparable with a JO, a policy which, like BI, has never been implemented on a national scale.Tcherneva (2012) reviews the successful Argentinian Plan Jefes, a form of local JO in response to crisis. In the US, Harvey (2012; 1989), Mitchell and Muysken (2008) andTcherneva and Wray (2005) made early cases for JG and public work for full employment. Mitchell and Fazi (2017), Paul et al (2017) and Spross (2017) recently argue that a generous JG paying at least $23,000 pa and rising to about $30,000 pa at the hourly ‘living wage’ of $15 (twice the federal minimum wage), would eliminate poverty and unemployment and cost only a small fraction of a generous BI. Paul et al (2017) suggest 14 million jobs could be created at a total cost of nearly $800 billion pa, but this obviously utopian plan offers little detail on the jobs and has other problems (Matthews, 2017). In particular, proponents of a JG do not address the problems of work incentives, support for those unwilling to work, and resulting job loss in the private sector. Spross (2017) argues that the point of a generous JG ‘is to wipe out low-pay private employment’, but this can only be a long-term goal. He notes that 131 could usefully complement a JO but offers no details.The combination of modest BI and low-pay JO discussed below would be far less disruptive, and also facilitate self-employment with generally greater autonomy and job-satisfaction, which would not be directly helped by a JO alone (Alvarez and Sinde-Cantona, 2014). As Keynesians have frequently pointed out, major fiscal expansion is urgently needed for several reasons. Public infrastructure and other investment has been neglected in most advanced economies, long before the financial crisis of 2008/9, and massive investment in renewable energy and efficiency is essential to avert catastrophic climate change, which could also help to approach‘full employment’with a‘Green new deal’, as proposed by the Green New Deal Group (New Economics Foundation, 2008) .The large fiscal multiplier in economies with under-utilised resources (including underemployment) is now recognised by the IMF, and would dramatically reduce the final cost of these investments (Tily, 2017). Such a programme could have generated rapid recovery from the crash, in contrast to ‘quantitative easing’ which mainly benefited the rich by inflating asset prices, with little effect on under-employment and most wages. Additional spending on BI and a JO programme would also imply a fiscal stimulus, and lower ultimate cost. Another policy instrument for reducing unemployment which was widely practised in the early 1930s in the Great Depression in the US, is work-sharing by working-time regulation (Lajeunesse,2011).Though often disparaged by economists, work-sharing was remarkably successful in Germany after the financial crash in 2007/8. Though GDP fell by nearly 7 per cent, one of the largest declines in the OECD, average hours of work were reduced by about 3 per cent mainly through short weeks, with lost wages largely replaced by unemployment benefits, while unemployment only rose by 0.5 per cent, much less than in the US (Arico and Stein, 2012).The goal of ‘full employment’ should thus certainly include work-sharing through reduction of standard work weeks as in Nordic economies, part-time work opportunities for all, including skilled workers, as in the Netherlands, and meaningful sanctions for employers who try to cut costs by demanding unpaid overtime. A large public sector providing employment with good conditions, flexible work time and at least the minimum wage would put pressure on private sector employers to match these terms, and is indeed essential to provide the high levels of public services, including affordable child- and eldercare, that only the Nordics currently provide, and must be funded by higher taxes on high earners (Diamond and Saez, 2011; Partanen, 2016). The public sector should of course provide training for all who need it, and offer opportunities for those with various degrees of partial disability. Even such a large public sector, however, is not the same as a JO for all who seek work, since some workers may still be unable to find adequate jobs as automation and globalisation continue to undermine traditional employment, particularly in the declining middle class. Even in the early post-war decades when un- and underemployment were low and usually short term, some long-term unemployment and poverty still existed. There would obviously be substitutability between a large Nordic-type public sector and the need for a JO, which is currently much greater in the UK and US with their underfunded public services, weak welfare provisions, long hours, low wages for most, and under-employment for many. Moreover, even some Nordic economies face very high unemployment (particularly in Denmark and Finland and mainly due to macroeconomic policy errors), rising (though still relatively low) poverty rates, and very high participation tax rates for entering employment. An unqualifiedJG literally implies a right to be‘employed’and paid,but no reciprocal obligation on employees to perform tasks to any required standard, a problem which proponents have generally neglected.The critical but essentially favourable review by Roth (2017) does mention the need for sanctions. An absence of any sanctions would provide a strong incentive for shirking, so wage cuts for missed hours or targets, or (temporary) suspension of those unwilling to work effectively, would have to be in place. This is not workfare since 131 is unconditional, but only a qualified JG, or job offer (JO) for those who are able and willing to work, would be feasible. A JO at a wage well below the legal minimum following Frank (2014), would greatly increase the bargaining power of labour even when unions remain weak, and establish an effective ‘floor’ under wages and working conditions for those in low-paid and precarious employment, but maintain an incentive to seek regular work. As shown below, combining 131 and JO could replace ineffective minimum wage legislation. A very generous JG without sanctions as proposed by Paul et al (2017) and Spross (2017) could not ensure work performance, and would discredit the programme, destroy many marginal jobs where employers couldn’t match JG conditions, and also lead to substantial price rises. Too large a take-up of JOs might exceed the scope for useful local public employment, and lead to direct competition with the private sector.JOs are obviously of primary relevance for the long-term jobless including discouraged workers no longer in the labour force, usually a small share of those in temporary and search unemployment between jobs, so Standings (2017) claim that most JG advocates ‘ignore the fact that market economies need some unemployment to function’ does not apply here. While some may be critical of low wage public employment, there should be broad agreement that such workers need to be offered career and wage progression opportunities. Lack of training and progression has been a major failing of‘direct job creation’in Germany,‘One Euro Jobs’and other‘workfare’schemes (Eichhorst,2015). These opportunities will require careful and sensitive management because rewarding short-term, measured ‘productivity’ in service provision, for example, for the most vulnerable and elderly, may lead to neglect of other aspects of caring activities.These include simply taking the time to listen to the concerns and worries of those who suffer from loneliness and disability. Since lack of social interaction is a major cause of ill-health and unhappiness, efforts to provide such interaction will also generate long-term material benefits in the form of reduced healthcare costs. Some have worried that 131 may discourage low-waged women from participating in formal job markets. On the other hand, there are many traditionally — but not exclusively — female occupations, including some in self-employment and part-time or non-standard employment, with relatively low productivity and earnings, and little security, but which are nevertheless socially valuable and provide job-satisfaction. In combination with BI to compensate for low pay and insecurity, such occupations may offer more job-satisfaction for some (both men and women) than JOs, which can only offer a limited range of tasks to minimise costs and direct competition with the private sector. In particular, over 6 million unpaid home-carers, mostly women, would be major beneficiaries from BI, but difficult to employ formally with a JO (though they should certainly be supported by JO services). Indeed, all women who work at home (including child carers) would gain a measure of independence from partners and spouses with BI. Some of them should gain from a JO as well.Therefore, several large groups, likely to grow with the trend towards more non-standard employment, automation and an aging population, would benefit from a combination of BI and a JO. BI+JO In spite of the limitations of either BI or JO on their own, the benefits of combining these two complementary policies are rarely mentioned — notable exceptions are Atkinson (2015), Frank (2014),Painter andThoung (2015),Dalzell (2017) and Spross (2017), but these authors offer little discussion of the details. Only the combination, together with improved housing and disability benefits, could bring most workless and under-employed people into employment and above the poverty level without major tax rises, as we show in the following UK example. This does not deny that major tax reform and redistribution is urgently needed on equity grounds, as Atkinson (2015), Diamond and Saez (2011), Stiglitz (2013) and other prominent economists have emphasised. In the UK, progressive taxes on capital gains and housing services are essential, in place of highly regressive council and other taxes, but there are advantages to separating these issues as far as possible and concentrating initially on the most politically feasible. It would clearly be difficult for one country in the EU to introduce such a BI+JO scheme without attracting large inflows from other member states, so eligibility restrictions to native citizens and long-term residents would be required for local pilot schemes, which in turn would be needed to attain broad political support, before nationwide implementation. BI pioneers Van Parijs and Vanderborght (2017, 48) admit that guaranteed employment and training might ‘operate as modest complements’ to BI, which they convincingly argue is essential to avoid the coercive workfare implications of aJG as the sole safety net for the unemployed. By contrast, Standing (2017) only considers the workfare implications of aJG on its own, and neglects complementarity with BI. Chadi and Hetschko (2017) show that satisfaction with income from benefits such as unemployment insurance is much lower than satisfaction from earned income, even when controlling for income magnitude, confirming the well-known stigma of involuntary unemployment, which is only partially compensated by more free time. A modest 131 in place of some targeted benefits would improve welfare, but is unlikely to remove the stigma of unemployment and cannot ensure that the satisfaction of regular employment is denied to no-one. A few people might indeed rely on a modest BI to choose casual, untaxed work or housework, instead of taking up a JO. However, the existence ofJOs does provide a form of insurance against the failing attraction or feasibility of alternative lifestyles. A JO with training and career progression would have many more advantages for the long-term workless, which are usually ignored by BI advocates. Precisely because BI is unconditional, an additional JO does not have any workfare implications, though it does offer less freedom to some than a generous 131, as in Straubhaar’s (2017a; 2017b) proposal discussed above. Most 131 proponents do realise that this can only be a longterm goal, politically infeasible in the foreseeable future, so some targeted housing and incapacity benefits are still needed, though they could be partially replaced by a JO. We consider a simple example for the UK.The National Living Wage (NLW) which replaces the minimum wage, will be about £9 per hour in 2020, and is assumed to provide‘full-time’pre-tax earnings of £16,000.This implies 1,778 hours, annual‘full time’, say 47 weeks of 37.8 hours, higher than the official ‘full-time’ average, classified as over 30 hours a week. To simplify we only consider annual earnings henceforth. We assume pre-tax BI of £6,000 pa (with more for pensioners to match current state pensions, and possibly less for children), and a basic tax rate of 33.3 per cent (just above 32 per cent for existing NIC and 20 per cent basic rate income tax, chosen to simplify numbers) on all income, including BI, up to the threshold for the next higher rate (currently £45,000 for the 40 per cent rate), so dropping the Personal Allowance. Some higher earners would thus be pushed into higher rate bands, including those currently earning between £41,000 and £45,000. Then the NLW worker with BI has net income of £14,652, and BI is essentially ‘clawed back’ from higher earners, while lower earners will be better off and no longer face the very high effective marginal tax rates of the ‘poverty trap’. Assume full-time pre-taxJO earnings of £12,000. Combining BI with theJO, and 33.3 per cent basic tax, leaves total net income of £12,000 pa for a full-time single adult JO worker, well above the poverty level of £10,080 for a single adult, especially when combined with housing benefits. But this is also well below the NLW workers £14,652, and so maintains an incentive to seek regular work. For a brief look at budget implications, total cash transfers in the UK for 2014/15 were £258 billion.With £108 billion for pensions unchanged, and additional revenue of £80—90 billion from abolishing the personal income tax allowance, this leaves £230—240 billion. A net BI of £3,000 for 9 million children under 12, and £4,000 for the remaining 44 million non-pensioners add up to £203 billion, leaving a surplus of nearly £40 billion, to finance JOs and remaining necessary social benefits such as incapacity and housing. Of course, the current crisis in the NHS, with substantially lower — and declining — real per capita funding compared to many EU countries, as well as decades of neglected infrastructure investment, all imply an urgent need for substantially greater public spending. In contrast to widespread misunderstandings, this does not initially require higher tax rates, because a money-financed fiscal expansion will generate higher growth and greater tax revenue as long as there are underutilised resources in the economy, with little risk of additional inflation. Net BI at £4,000 pa is roughly equivalent to the maximum job seekers allowance, so means-tested housing and disability benefits would still be needed. A household with two unemployed adults and two young children would still be below the poverty line of £21,000 for this class of household with only £14,000 net basic income, but above poverty after adding .£8,000 net JO earnings for one adult, and perhaps additional housing benefits (DW1J 2017). Under the current system with 20 per cent tax rate on income over £11,500, and employee NIC (national insurance contribution) at 12 per cent of income over £8,000 pa, our full time NLW worker is left with £14,140, which is less than the £14,652 obtained above with BI+JO. Someone earning £8,000 with no tax or NIC currently, would in our model with BI and 33.3 per cent tax on all income gain £1,324 in disposable net income, and someone earning £6,000 currently would gain £2,000. Some such workers may also benefit from choosing (slightly) shorter hours with more time for family and leisure, and thus enjoy additional wellbeing. Note that a moderate increase in the JO from £8,000 to, say, £10,000 net for full-time work would provide £14,000 with BI, almost the same as £14,140 with the NLW under current taxation.Thus BI+JO could replace minimum wage and NLW legislation by providing a similar income and utility floor under the package of pay, hours and working conditions that regular employers could offer, assuming (obviously essential) good JO working conditions, something that a minimum wage or a modest BI alone could not achieve. Since regular employment offers a much wider choice of occupations than JOs, it would remain the preferred choice for most, even if wages were lower in some cases but total utility matched or exceeded that of BI+JO. Our proposed 33.3 per cent tax on all income below the higher rate threshold, combined with the BI, might induce some marginal workers,particularly those below current tax thresholds to work less or remain at home and thus provide better care for dependent children or elderly relatives.This would probably increase welfare, and also work opportunities for the otherwise under- or un-employed, since aggregate demand should be maintained by the BI, or even augmented, as the redistribution raises incomes of those with a higher propensity to spend on consumption. A lower basic tax could be funded by higher taxes on the wealthy, including a land value tax and capital gains tax, again perhaps a long-term goal. As mentioned earlier, all this is unlikely to reduce total employment significantly due to the substitution effect. The biggest unknown in this proposal is the resulting number ofJO employees, which depends crucially on the magnitude and success of other employment and fiscal policies such as a ‘green new deal’.There is also possible substitutability for JO workers to contribute to ‘green’ or infrastructure investment under the proper supervision, in a form of apprenticeship. The long-term unemployed, about 30 per cent of all unemployed in the UK, are obvious candidates for full-time JOs, as are discouraged workers no longer looking for work, while many under-employed could benefit from part-time JOs. No doubt some will choose casual or housework or even idleness with 131, rather than a JO, raising uncertainty about final uptake. For example, 1.5 million full-time equivalent JO workers (likely to be spread among many more part-time workers) would initially cost 12 billion in net wages, plus administrative and other costs. However, this extra expenditure would be offset by lower benefit payments, and generate higher incomes and tax receipts by the Keynesian multiplier effect, so little or no extra taxation would be required. Since they would mainly supply personal services, capital costs would be low. Provision of urgently needed services will alleviate widespread misery, and saves long-term health care costs as fewer patients will need treatment and hospitalisation. Our example of 1.5 million FTEs compares with just over 1 million FTEs currently employed in UK social services.These services are so overstretched that already over a million people are not getting help needed to remain in their own homes. Their care home accommodation would cost around _£45 billion, but is not available as the number of care homes is declining, due to underfunding! In the meantime, overcrowded hospitals have to retain patients without home care (Collinson, 2016). Doubling current social services personnel might be a reasonable medium-term goal in the face of growing demand. Helping the elderly to remain in their own homes as long as possible and reducing the need for costly care home accommodation would yield substantial financial returns as well as welfare gains. Supporting the many unpaid and overburdened home-carers would be another important task for expanded services with additional JO workers. Many job seekers (especially women) who have raised children but have little formal qualification for regular employment, would be well suited for these caring tasks that multiply with aging populations, including help with housework, shopping, transportation and many other tasks which do not require qualified nursing skills, and are far beyond the capacity of currently overstretched social services. Expanding urgently needed nursery and day care at low cost to help working parents would be desirable. The low JO wage would encourage labour-capital substitution, countering the prevailing tendency. Many of the services generate direct benefits to private households and could merit modest fees, so JO workers are paid jointly by the government and private customers.This will lower the total cost ofJO and also create a potential long-term partnership between the public and local councils. Unskilled job seekers could also work on repairing and maintaining roads, parks, public buildings, conservation areas and other local public goods, with appropriate organisation and supervision, and help to meet seasonal demand in agriculture, tourism and other areas. Frank (2014) suggests also ‘removing graffiti from public places; painting government buildings; recycling newspapers and aluminium and glass containers’.There is an urgent need for more energy efficient homes, and insulation and upgrading of older houses, so the construction sector should expand employment, including apprentice/helper positions, learning on-the-job under supervision, with the incentive of progression to higher pay and more skilled work. Some of these tasks are currently undertaken by EU migrant workers, so alternatives will be required after Brexit. Government support will be needed for necessary training, as well as extra financial rewards to make such jobs sufficiently attractive to natives. Comprehensive training would be an important part of JO schemes, best implemented by local authorities, but with funding from central government to redistribute income from wealthy to poorer areas with high under-employment. It would obviously be necessary to integrate and coordinate JO systems with local social and other services.This would facilitate promotion of the most proficient JO workers to higher pay grades in the regular services, while maintaining continuity of care and other personal relations without disruptive job changes.Thus, in contrast to previous public job creation schemes (Eichhorst, 2015; Gregg, 2009), success of our proposal should not be measured in terms of transitions into private sector employment, but rather by quality of services provided, and by progression to higher skill and pay levels within the same area of public service provision. Local job and community centres could be developed to coordinate JOs and match supply with demand. It will be important to prioritise useful JO activity and avoid ‘make work’ tasks which would bring the programme into disrepute. Local ‘bottlenecks’ may arise for various reasons, such as inadequate funding for all JO applicants, and then JO rationing may be required, with means-tested priority for the poorest households. On the other hand, demand for JO services may exceed supply in some areas, so JO worker mobility may be required, as well as priorities for those with the most urgent care needs. Local pilot BI+JO schemes are surely needed to develop new organisational and managerial skills and experience for local authorities in these uncharted areas, and gain public acceptance. A BI could replace some but not all existing cash transfers, and provide much-needed support for the growing numbers in non-standard employment, and unpaid home carers, without the coercive sanctions which often accompany targeted or conditional welfare benefits. A little-noticed benefit of BI is that it should encourage work-sharing by (slightly) reducing desired working time for many employees. On the other hand, only a JO with appropriate training can provide employment in satisfactory jobs for all who are willing and able to work, which is a major component of life satisfaction. Thus, even with fiscal expansion in place of austerity, a combination of these two measures remains the most effective policy to end long-term unemployment, the insecurity of non-standard employment and the injustice of unpaid or failing home care, fragile safety nets and frequent sanctions.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Perm Do Both

Combing UBI and JG is key – doubles the solvency.

Lu, 21 – Associate Professor of Law and Co-Director, Economic Justice Project, CUNY School of Law [Lynn D. Lu, “From Stigma to Dignity? Transforming Workfare with Universal Basic Income and a Federal Job Guarantee,” CUNY Academic Works, 2021, https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cl_pubs/344/, accessed 6-25-2023]

This Article examines reinvigorated proposals for universal basic income (UBI) and a federal job guarantee (JG), both of which seek to reduce poverty, income inequality, and the widening racial wealth gap.8 It assesses the potential these reforms have to put more money into the hands of those most likely to use it while also ending involuntary unemployment and boosting labor conditions for all—but especially Blacks and people of color with less access to generational wealth, higher education, and protection against employment discrimination.9 It concludes that both UBI and a JG are necessary, but each is insufficient on its own to achieve greater economic security and mobility with dignified work for all. Crucially, a universal minimum income untethered to any work requirement is essential to break the racialized and gendered stigma that conflates economic need with welfare dependency. Equally important is the guarantee of public employment at a living wage for those who voluntarily choose to avoid gaps in earned income and employment history but have historically been excluded from the best work-life options.10 Together, UBI and a JG form vital pillars of social support for withstanding potential crises— large or small—and creating a secure future. Part II of this Article describes the main features of UBI and JG proposals and canvasses the diverse range of concerns that have motivated policy makers past and present—some more explicitly focused on racial justice than others—to consider their adoption. Such concerns include simplification of bureaucracy, prevention of job loss, valuation of carework, reduction of stigma, and worker empowerment. Part II concludes that, even in times of deep political polarization, unprecedented economic inequality and concentration of wealth may create common ground for enacting UBI and JG reforms with enduring impact. Part III nonetheless identifies persistent ideological beliefs and societal assumptions about race, work, and personal responsibility that have limited the potential of even modest UBI and JG proposals in the past, either through political compromise and policy drift or due to logistical challenges on the ground. By examining lessons from income proposals and work programs in U.S. history dating from the New Deal era to welfare reform, Part III illustrates how concerns about cost; fraud; waste; and, most importantly, disincentives to work productively diluted the potential of such projects.11 Part IV analyzes contemporary examples of local UBI and JG reforms to highlight further opportunities for restoring the dignity of basic support and work choices through a combined federal UBI and JG. In particular, Part IV examines Argentina’s governmental Plan Jefes y Jefes de Hogares program as a move toward a JG; Stockton, California’s 2019 UBI program, funded through private donations solicited by then-mayor Michael Tubbs, as a promising pilot program; and New York City’s implementation of state constitutional mandates to provide aid and support to the needy within the constraints of federal workfare directives as an ongoing experiment that could lead to a robust voluntary jobs program with a broad social safety net. Finally, Part V proposes not a magic-bullet solution but a starting framework for effective implementation of UBI and JG programs that leverage federal tax administration and oversight while empowering community-based organizations to maximize public participation in program design. Part V also highlights the need for further research to identify reasonable and realistic steps toward transforming workfare with less stigma and greater dignity.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › COMPETITION › AT: Perm Do Both

Inclusion of the jobs guarantee causes crowd-out, unproductive, corruption.

Gulker ’18 (Max, PhD and Senior Research Fellow American Institute for Economic Research, “The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis,” October 18, 2018, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee.pdf)

We must approach any discussion of the impact of a federal job guarantee on the wider economy with an abundance of caution. Our sample size for evaluating a program that the Levy report’s authors term a “radical transformation of the labor market” is zero. Even countries with much larger public sectors do not operate under the mandated system of a job guarantee. However, economic theory and lessons from history can inform our understanding of the likely impacts of a federal job guarantee. Both reports’ authors are confident that in addition to benefiting program enrollees, a federal job guarantee would be an unequivocal positive for the larger economy, offering macroeconomic stabilizers and perhaps even paying for itself. Neither report concerns itself with the potential negative consequences that flow from basic economics, issues ranging from large distortions in the information and incentives provided by markets to opportunities for special interests to manipulate the programs to their advantage. Each of these issues could potentially result in substantial net harms to all Americans, including program participants. In appendix 2, we briefly evaluate the claims both reports make of benefits to the economy beyond the program enrollees themselves. The CBPP report touts some benefits but is short on details, while the Levy report makes highly problematic use of macroeconometric forecasting models. The remainder of this section focuses on the potential economic harms of a job guarantee. 6.1 Labor Market Disruptions Both reports’ authors treat the ten million or more enrollees in a federal job guarantee as somehow cloistered from the labor market at large (which includes both private and government employers). The Levy report envisions a “buffer stock” of job-guarantee workers that will grow in times of downturns and shrink as more workers rejoin the traditional labor market in better times. One does not have to go deep into economic theory to see how this purportedly clean flow of workers would break down. Neither report takes account of harm to the private sector caused by their proposals. In addition to the de facto minimum wage and benefits set by a job guarantee, one must consider the contraction in private labor supply that would result if a sizable fraction of the many millions of currently employed workers at the lower end of the wage distribution chose to leave their jobs and enroll in the federal program. The immediate result of more pay and benefits for the working poor is something everyone would like to see, all else equal. But the process would divert workers from the places in the economy where they are most productive to a labyrinthine bureaucracy, where even finding enough work to assign would be a challenge. This could greatly weaken the productivity of the overall economy, potentially leading to declines in output and even greater job loss. Contrary to the stated goal of not competing with the private sector, some industries could become entirely nationalized. For example, 875,000 home health aides and 1.3 million teachers’ aides currently employed by the private and public sectors earn less on average than proposed jobguarantee wages. One might myopically say these workers deserve a raise, but turning these industries from conventional jobs into tasks assigned on demand would almost certainly result in poorer service to the young and elderly. 6.2 Impact on Worker Incentives Neither the CBPP nor Levy report has established how the work under a federal job guarantee would help build the workers’ human capital. In fact, the very existence of the program might strongly disincentivize workers from going out and acquiring the skills that lead to real, value-enhancing job creation in the labor market. By forcing workers mostly at the low end of the skills distribution to work by mandate and earn a fixed wage, a worker would have to derive enough value from education or other human capital acquisition to leapfrog ten million or more other workers. It would cost about $330 billion to send ten million workers currently counted among the U-6 unemployed for full trade school degrees,27 a fraction of the cost of a single year of a federal job guarantee. While we do not support such blanket solutions of any kind, this number puts in perspective the benefits to investing in, rather than simply sustaining, people. 6.3 Rent-Seeking and Corruption A federal job guarantee, no matter how well intentioned, would also serve as a magnet for corruption and corporate influence peddling. Especially when administered on a local level, the opportunities for corruption become vast and difficult to monitor. For example, one need not be particularly imaginative to see opportunities for a local building contractor to get free labor by giving kickbacks to officials in charge of placing enrollees in jobs. Corporations and other interest groups do not have to resort to corruption per se to gain control of the millions of subsidized laborers in a job guarantee. Rent-seeking, where corporations or other incumbent interests compete for influence over government to further their own objectives, is a well-known phenomenon.28 For example, the regional manager for Walmart might get in touch with a local government about the condition of its store’s parking lot and the grounds around it. Sales have been falling, and this expense might tip the decision to move to a new location in the next town. Couldn’t the town provide some of its laborers to improve the look of the store’s grounds? Where there is free labor to be had, private businesses come knocking. Both with and without breaking the law, influence peddling would be an inevitable consequence of a job guarantee.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › COMPETITION › AT: Perm Do Both

Perm fails – JG is based on job status, increases carbon footprint and creates surplus jobs

BIT 19 --- Basic Income Today was created to provide news and information and to further the discussion and debate about Universal Basic Income. 6/13/2019 (“An Anarchist Case for UBI.” https://basicincometoday.com/an-anarchist-case-for-ubi/. Date Accessed: 6-24-2023.)

First off, let’s start out by deconstructing the common alternative solutions before diving into the criticisms of UBI. The traditional solution to poverty wages comes in the form of minimum wage laws. In the past, I’ve written about why the Fight for $15 movement is misguided and how minimum wage laws merely serve as a distraction while effectively only offering a temporary bandaid to our problems at best. Such sweeping laws only serve to benefit some workers at the expense of others who are priced out of the market for various reasons.

Of course, a federal jobs guarantee would solve that issue, right? A higher minimum wage would have a net positive effect if no one could be priced out of the market due to the government guarantee of a job. And sure, there are absolutely lots of jobs that need to be done. Creating green energy jobs, infrastructure jobs, and the like would open up a lot more opportunities for work, but enough to guarantee a job for every single person? Between the prevalence of “bullshit jobs” in existence currently and increasing automation, it seems highly unlikely that there would be enough productive work to provide a truly universal job guarantee. As such the only ways to do so would either be to produce to such excess that we create a surplus of waste or to run production so inefficiently as to require extra labor and with it a larger carbon footprint, both of which are counterproductive to their proponents’ claimed environmental goals. Besides, no one feels truly satisfied when they know their work is pointless.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › COMPETITION › AT: Perm Do Both

A UBI alone solves better – it unlocks innovative labor opportunities and avoids federal bureaucracy.

Frl ’20 (Tom, Contributor to Incomer, "Why Universal Basic Income Is Better Than A Jobs Guarantee," 3-24-2020, )

A Universal Basic Income (UBI) is when the state distributes a flat amount of money to everyone as a right of citizenship unconditionally, unlike welfare programs which often create dependency. A job guarantee is a policy proposal aimed at providing a sustainable solution to the dual problems of inflation and unemployment by promising to hire unemployed workers as an employer of last resort. A job guarantee as a socialist policy, would not allow the labor market to function independently, therefore it would create a large amount of useless job positions which would only be there just to satisfy the unemployment numbers, while they would not price any real wealth. A Universal Basic Income on the other side, as a policy similar to Alaska’s oil fund program which is very popular and created millions of jobs would reduce unemployment the right way and grow the economy by $2.5 trillion. “In the next 12 years, 1 out of 3 American workers are at risk of losing their jobs to new technologies—and unlike with previous waves of automation, this time new jobs will not appear quickly enough in large enough numbers to make up for it. To avoid an unprecedented crisis, we’re going to have to find a new solution, unlike anything we’ve done before. Andrew Yang is an entrepreneur and 2020 Democratic presidential candidate, he has many and meaningful policies, but the boldest of them is the Freedom Dividend, “a universal basic income of $1,000/month, $12,000 a year, for every American adult over the age of 18. This is independent of one’s work status or any other factor.”, a the site mentions “It all begins with the Freedom Dividend, a universal basic income for all American adults, no strings attached – a foundation on which a stable, prosperous, and just society can be built.” “I find the Freedom Dividend vastly superior to something like the federal jobs guarantee”, Andrew Yang mentioned in an interview A Universal Basic Income would instead of giving the 100% of the tax revenue to the government, give a percentage of it directly to the citizens, while a job guarantee would only give better imaginary underemployment stats, a technique often used by socialist and authoritarian countries, Universal Basic Income seems to be the best wealth redistribution option for a democracy.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › COMPETITION › AT: Perm Do Both

UBI alone solves – the perm causes private crowd out

Ip ’19 (Greg, Wall Street Journal Reporter, “The Problem With a Federal Jobs Guarantee (Hint: It’s Not the Price Tag),” May 2, 2018, https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-problem-with-a-federal-jobs-guarantee-hint-its-not-the-price-tag-1525267192

But the big thinkers behind the federal jobs guarantee have their eyes on a bigger prize. That 4.1% only represents the 6.6 million who are unemployed under the Labor Department’s official definition. Another 5.1 million don’t meet it but want a job, and 5 million work part time because they can’t find full-time work. Eradicating these last vestiges of un- or underemployment “would fundamentally transform the current labor market,” write Mark Paul, William Darity and Darrick Hamilton in a paper for the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a left-of-center think tank. Their proposal, which forms the basis of Mr. Sanders’s bill, would “significantly alter the current power dynamics between labor and capital” by forcing all employers to match the federal standards for pay and benefits. Yes, a job guarantee would cost a fortune, but ignoring the obvious political impediments, the price tag isn’t the catastrophe some critics claim. To hire all the official and unofficial unemployed and half the involuntary part timers at $15 an hour plus $3 an hour for benefits would cost around $450 billion, or 2.3% of gross domestic product. The actual cost could be much lower: Many of the unemployed won’t take up the federal offer because they expect to get something better, don’t like what’s being offered, or face some sort of obstacle (family, disability, etc.). Also, some of what gets spent on salaries will be saved in reduced Medicaid, tax credits, unemployment insurance and other safety net outlays. Five scholars at the Levy Institute, a think tank, have advanced a plan they say will cost just 1% to 1.5% of gross domestic product. The federal government spends three times that on Social Security and twice that on defense. The price tag would jump in recessions as laid-off people flock to the program. That’s a feature, not a bug: By automatically injecting public money into the economy, it would prop up spending, private employment and tax revenue, lessening the recession’s severity. And unlike universal basic income, another fashionable idea for reducing inequality in which everyone gets a check regardless of whether they work, a jobs guarantee gets the taxpayer something in return: workers. That, however, is also the problem. Here’s why. According to the Economic Policy Institute, 39% of the workforce, some 54 million people, now earn $15 an hour or less. All would have an incentive to quit and join the federal program. Of course, most wouldn’t because their employers would, grudgingly, raise pay to keep them, then pass the cost on to customers, a de facto inflation tax. Indeed, advocates say the job guarantee accomplishes the same thing as a $15 minimum wage without the job loss. Nonetheless, potentially millions of workers would end up on the federal payroll instead of in the private sector. And there’s the rub. Utopians would argue jobs exist to give people dignity and a decent standard of living. The reality is more mundane: Jobs are how people, as producers, satisfy their needs as consumers. Low-paid work such as brewing coffee, cleaning hotel rooms and flipping hamburgers gets a bad rap but it satisfies a genuine demand: People want coffee, clean hotels and hamburgers. A federal make-work program would crowd out many of those private services. Crowding out is fine when the government is providing something more valuable, Roger Farmer and Dmitry Plotnikov, economists at the University of California at Los Angeles, wrote in 2010. For example, military spending crowded out private consumption during World War II, when the U.S. “was fighting for its survival.” In ordinary times, that is a harder case to make. A 2011 study by ​Lauren Cohen,​ Joshua Coval​ and Christopher Malloy of Harvard Business School found that when a member of Congress takes over an important committee, his state often enjoys an influx of federal spending. But that benefit is offset by a contraction in private investment and employment, evidence of crowding out.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › AT: UBI Causes Inflation

The idea that UBI causes inflation is false – it eases the aftermath of inflation as well.

Ensuring Everyone, 22 – Advocate for UBI

[Ensuring Everyone, “Basic Income – Will it cause inflation?,” UBI Works, 8-24-2022, https://www.ubiworks.ca/blog/basic-income-inflation, accessed 6-23-2023]

But among some newcomers to Basic Income, there’s a false concern that it could cause inflation – a mistaken belief that building a guaranteed income floor for those who need it could somehow reduce the purchasing power of our dollars. There are many things that can cause inflation, but there is no evidence that Basic Income is one of them. In fact, the data shows quite the opposite. Basic Income would ease the pain of inflation – lessening its impacts on Canadian households – by ensuring everyone has the money they need to meet rising costs, at a time when wages are barely keeping up. Basic Income puts existing money to better use. Basic Income would put billions of dollars already in our economy to better and more productive use, rather than introduce new money into the market. It redirects money to help those in need and who will spend it on basic necessities, which stimulates our economy, creates jobs, and supports local businesses. As Basic Income advocate : “Contrary to what misinformed fearmongers might suggest, a basic income could ease inflation. Most economists agree that inflation is caused by introducing new money into the market, not by redistributing it… A basic income would not cause inflation; it would help families facing rising costs.” We’ve shown without taxing the vast majority of Canadians or printing new money: by funding it with contributions from our financial sector, fewer tax breaks for large companies, and fewer subsidies for the wealthiest. This is how we can build a ‘trickle-up’ economy that encourages economic growth while lifting millions of Canadians out of poverty. Existing Basic Income-like programs haven’t caused inflation. We already have a Basic Income in Canada that works and has not made life more costly for Canadians: the (CCB), a Basic Income for families, contributes over $46 billion a year to our economy, creating more than 450,000 jobs, while lifting over 250,000 families out of poverty. For every $1 given to Canadian families, $2 is generated in economic activity. There’s no indication that the CCB has caused inflation. Instead, it has reduced the number of households facing and has been hailed as for reduced poverty and income inequality in Canada. In the US, 132 economists in 2022 calling for the extension of the Child Tax Credit (CTC) – their version of the CCB – saying it would not “meaningfully increase inflation”, but would help families “keep up with the everyday costs of keeping a family afloat”. Basic Income expert that the CTC has functioned “as a protective shield against inflation.” Seniors benefits like Old Age Security and Guaranteed Income Supplement have been instrumental in drastically reducing poverty among our elderly (although there is still much work to be done to eliminate it entirely), with no evidence that this has caused inflation. Similarly, data shows that CERB and other emergency benefits contributed to the largest one-year reduction in poverty . Unconditional cash lowers prices in the US In Alaska, where there is universal dividend for every resident, funded by their natural resources, it’s common for when the cheques roll out to capture this extra spending capacity. That’s right – prices go down when the cheques go out. Interestingly, with the introduction of this dividend in 1982, Alaska went from having the highest rate of inflation in the US to the lowest. (Source: by Scott Santens) For Alaskans, unconditional cash meant less inflation, not more. Some businesses offer sales when the Alaska dividend cheques go out all residents. Basic Income means more entrepreneurship – and more competition. One more reason Basic Income won’t cause inflation: it doesn’t reduce competition between sellers of goods and services. Businesses would continue to compete for our money by offering high quality at reasonable prices – with or without Basic Income. In fact, Basic Income would actually increase competition in many sectors by fostering entrepreneurship. It would act as seed capital for countless entrepreneurs who would otherwise be stuck in dead-end jobs or unable to take the risk. have shown that Basic Income increases people’s ability to start or expand a business, increases interest in starting a business, and boosts local business revenues. As : “where basic income experiments have been actually tried and studied, the result in each case is increased entrepreneurship…This means more people competing for basic income dollars, with better goods and services and lower costs. All of this represents real evidence to counter any fear of inflation." Basic Income helps ease the pain of inflation. There are many factors causing life to become increasingly unaffordable – global supply chain shocks, inadequate housing policy, and automation melting wages, to name a few. Basic Income has been shown to help ease the pain of inflation, reducing poverty and helping with affordability when jobs are no longer enough. So the next time you hear the false rumour that Basic Income causes inflation, remember that the data has already proven the opposite: Basic Income makes life more affordable, not less.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › AT: UBI Causes Inflation

A UBI program that collects taxes is not inflationary or its inevitable

, 20 – Writer for People’s Policy Project

[, “Understanding Claims About Basic Income and Inflation,” People's Policy Project, 3-18-2020, https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/03/18/understanding-claims-about-basic-income-and-inflation/, accessed 6-23-2023]

A variety of elected officials are currently proposing that the federal government send cash payments to every person in the country (sometimes called a “universal basic income” or “UBI”) as a way of responding to the recession. These calls have resurrected claims that a UBI is inflationary. Such claims circulate widely among advocates of workfare and in certain niche internet circles. But these claims are nonsensical and deceptive. In this post, I walk through these claims to promote better understanding of the issue. Deceptive Language Many people who claim that UBI is inflationary also belong to the Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) community. One of the key rhetorical moves of that community is to talk about government spending as if it separate from government revenue (e.g. taxes). This way of speaking goes against convention and therefore tends to mislead people who are used to conventional ways of talking about government programs. It is precisely this rhetorical move that is behind the claim “a UBI is inflationary.” What they actually mean when they say that is “disbursing UBI payments without collecting offsetting taxes is inflationary.” But they never explicitly say the “without collecting offsetting taxes” part because, as mentioned already, they have all decided to talk about spending as if it is separate from taxes. This is a fun semantical game to play I suppose, but that’s all it is: a game. Everyone who advocates for a UBI as a permanent fixture of the economic system also advocates for using some set of taxes or other revenue to fund it (or, in MMT language, “offset it”). For those advocates, the taxes are packed into the word “UBI.” Thus when those advocates say “a UBI is not inflationary,” what they mean is that “a UBI with offsetting taxes is not inflationary.” If you’ve followed along so far, you see now that everyone has actually wound up at the exact same spot. Both claims are true: A UBI [without offsetting taxes] is inflationary. A UBI [with offsetting taxes] is not inflationary. Everyone is just talking past one another, primarily because the MMT people are using an idiosyncratic way of speaking while being opaque about doing so. Transfer Payment Nonsense In addition to the word games above, there is another strand of argument that circulates in this MMT world that is just straightforwardly nonsensical. Though they rarely spell it out so clearly, the argument goes like this: Transfer payments are inflationary. A UBI is a transfer payment. Therefore, a UBI is inflationary. Right off the bat, you can see that this argument also contains within it the rhetorical move where you assume that “transfer payments” or “UBI” are being done by themselves with no offsetting taxes (i.e. being done with seignorage). But more than that is going on in this particular point. Transfer payments are payments governments make (almost always in cash) to various populations as part of the welfare system. Social Security and SSI payments are transfer payments. Unemployment benefits are transfer payments. Pell grants are transfer payments. Food Stamps are transfer payments. And so on. All transfer payments are “inflationary” in the same way that MMT people accuse the UBI of being inflationary. Many people don’t realize this because, though you can find this point buried in various MMT writings and presentations, the popular advocates are very selective about when they bring up inflation. A proposal to increase transfer payments via a UBI will always cause MMT people to talk about inflation. But a proposal to increase transfer payments via an increase in Social Security benefits won’t. There is no theory-based reason for this selectivity: all transfer payment increases cause inflation, so defined. But it’s a political calculation they make. When accusing transfer payments of being inflationary, the MMT people very often also say that government spending on public employee wages is not inflationary. This becomes a key reason why you are supposed to favor a job guarantee, which pays people “wages,” over more conventional transfer programs like unemployment benefits, which pays people “transfer payments.” This is completely nonsensical of course. Government spending on public employee wages is inflationary, so defined. It is no different than government spending on transfer payments in this regard. In both cases, the government gives an individual cash that they then go out and spend on goods and services. It makes no difference for inflation if the person who received the cash sat at home and watched TV (“transfer payment”) or instead raked leaves in the park (“job guarantee wages”). The inflation (again, so defined) comes when they spend the money trying to buy good and services. The reason some JG advocates don’t seem to understand this is because their minds have been captured by a very literal interpretation of and the . Put simply, there is a general notion that inflation occurs when there is more money chasing the same number of goods. With that notion in mind, it is then observed that public employee wages are counted in the national accounts as output, meaning they boost GDP. But transfer payments are not counted that way. So, the reasoning then goes that public employee wages increase output and therefore lead to “more money chasing more goods” (not inflation) while transfer payments do not increase output and therefore lead to “more money chasing the same number of goods” (inflation). This is simply confused. To understand why, consider the case of public school teachers. There are a little over public school teachers in the US and they collectively receive a little under . In the national accounts, that $200 billion will be counted towards GDP and reasonably so: teachers probably do produce about $200 billion worth of educational services each year. But the government does not charge students or their parents for those services. It does not collect any revenue from those services. And because it does not collect any revenue from the users of the service, those $200 billion of wages are not offset at all. They are purely inflationary just like an unemployment check would be and just like JG wages would be, which is why we need taxes to fund public schools (or “offset the inflation caused by teacher wages” to again use the special language of MMT). If you press some of the high priests of the MMT world hard enough, they will sometimes admit this point. For instance, in 2016, Rohan Grey (a second tier MMT advocate) pushed Randy Wray (one of the high priests of MMT) to address this directly. Grey raised the point this way: If you put $1 trillion into solar panels and those solar panels were just installed — they weren’t sold, they were just given away. That $1 trillion is now out there in people’s pockets and presumably private sector demand is going to absorb that. It seems to be that the product of the job guarantee, unless its sold, is not necessarily absorbing the purchasing power demands being created by the income that’s being given for it. Wray responds to this point, not by trying to show that through some magic JG wages won’t be inflationary, but instead by saying that a JG program would actually be very small, something like 1 percent of GDP. And so while JG wages would be inflationary (just like UBI payments are inflationary), the inflation is not something to worry about because the program is simply not very big. Hyman Minsky, who is revered in MMT world, also acknowledged that the JG (or a public jobs program more generally like the WPA) is clearly inflationary unless its output is sold to generate government revenue: If the WPA output is useful and is sold, WPA-type relief for the unemployed is less inflationary than unemployment insurance. If the WPA output is useful even if it is not sold in a market, then it makes a contribution to the well-being of those who find the output useful, and, presumably, a tax or user’s fee offset to all or part of the WPA spending could be collected. So in summary, this particular version of the argument that the “UBI is inflationary” is really just an application of the broader argument that “transfer payments are inflationary.” And while it is true, under the way MMT people use words, that transfer payments are inflationary, it is also true that all other government spending is inflationary, including spending on public employee wages and including spending on JG wages. The whole line of critique is one big head fake.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Politics

UBI support is high and only growing on all political spectrums.

Schulte, 20 – Producer, Writer, and Video Editor at The Hill

[Gabriela Schulte, “Poll: Majority of voters now say the government should have a universal basic income program,” 8-14-2020, https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/512099-poll-majority-of-voters-now-say-the-government-should-have-a/, accessed 6-23-2023]

A majority of voters believe the government should have a universal basic income program, up from 12 percentage points in 2019, a new Hill-HarrisX poll finds. Fifty-five percent of registered voters in the Aug. 2-5 survey were in support of universal basic income, while 45 percent were not. The Hill-HarrisX poll found support for the program has gradually grown in the past year. In a , 43 percent of voters said the government should have universal basic income and in a , support grew 6 percentage points to 49 percent. The survey found an increase in support across demographic groups, primarily among younger voters and Democratic voters. Sixty-nine percent of voters ages 18 to 34 and 35 to 49 were in favor of universal basic income, a 14 percentage point and 16 percentage point increase, respectively. Support has not yet reached the majority among older voters in the survey, however, it grew from 21 percent in February 2019 to 34 percent in August 2020 among voters 65 years old and beyond. Seventy-one percent of Democratic voters and 56 percent of independent voters believe the government should have a universal basic income program, a 15 and 12 percentage point increase from last February, respectively. Among Republican voters, support grew from 27 percent last winter to 34 percent support in August 2020.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Politics

UBI is politically supported by voters and politicians – pandemic spurred backing.

Mcnair, 21 – former editorial assistant for LendingTree

[Kamaron Mcnair, “72% of Americans Support Some Form of Universal Basic Income (UBI),” MagnifyMoney, 9-20-2021, https://www.magnifymoney.com/news/universal-basic-income-survey/, accessed 6-23-2023]

At least 7 in 10 Americans support some form of universal basic income, with 35% “definitely” favoring the policy and 38% supporting it under certain conditions (i.e., income, citizenship and employment). Support for UBI in some form significantly decreases among high earners, men and Republicans. Among those not in favor of UBI, the No. 1 reason is a fear that the policy would remove the incentive to work (noted by 68% of opponents), followed by the possibility of higher taxes (53%). Those supportive of UBI largely believe in its ability to lift people out of poverty (60%). The same percentage (72%) of those who support UBI believe we should guarantee that all Americans have enough money to afford basic needs like food and shelter. However, the majority of consumers think UBI shouldn’t go to every adult in the U.S., but rather citizens and/or those below a certain income threshold (both 43%). 22% of Americans say they need UBI to make ends meet, and this figure climbs even higher among women (25%) and parents with children younger than 18 (28%). 2 in 3 respondents say they’d spend a hypothetical UBI on living costs and other necessities. Majority of consumers support some form of UBI Politicians looking for a popular initiative could be advised to explore legislative options for universal basic income. UBI in some form garners approval from 72% of consumers. While 38% might change their mind under certain circumstances, a strong 35% of folks support UBI in any form. Each demographic breakdown of UBI support tracked by the MagnifyMoney survey bolsters the finding that higher earners are less likely to back the idea. A 2018 Grinnell College poll found Republicans on average have higher incomes than Democrats, with 26% of Republicans earning more than $100,000, compared with 20% of Democrats. While the policy idea wins a majority approval on both sides of the political aisle, Democratic voters are more likely to support UBI than Republicans: Democrats: 88% support, 12% don’t Republicans: 53% support, 47% don’t Independents: 72% support, 28% don’t Democrats (28%) are more likely than Republicans (18%) to contact their elected officials about UBI, but those calling aren’t necessarily in favor. In fact, 7% of both Democrats and Republicans report calling their representatives to oppose UBI. Additionally, 11% of independent voters have made calls to oppose the idea. Those earning $100,000 annually or more are significantly less likely to support UBI than any other income group, with 64% saying they would endorse some form. Folks earning less than $35,000 support UBI the most, with 76% in favor. Support for UBI drops slightly among the middle income brackets, but hovers within a few percentage points among each group earning less than $100,000: Less than $35,000: 76% support, 24% don’t $35,000-$49,999: 75% support, 25% don’t $50,000-$74,999: 72% support, 28% don’t $75,000-$99,999: 75% support, 25% don’t $100,000 or more: 64% support, 36% don’t Men — who on average than women — are less likely to support UBI than women: Men: 69% support, 31% don’t Women: 74% support, 26% don’t And when it comes to age, baby boomers — the wealthiest generation — are the least likely to support UBI, deviating from their younger counterparts by 13 to 25 percentage points: Gen Zers (ages 18 to 24): 83% support, 17% don’t Millennials (ages 25 to 40): 81% support, 19% don’t Gen Xers (ages 41 to 55): 71% support, 29% don’t Baby boomers (ages 56 to 75): 58% support, 43% don’t According to MagnifyMoney senior economic analyst Jacob Channel, younger folks tend to make less money, so they logically would be interested in this form of government aid. For baby boomers, Channel says the culture in which they came of age plays a role. “On top of that, because they’re wealthier than younger generations, baby boomers tend to be a little bit more conservative with money,” Channel says. “They’re more concerned about things like inflation and higher taxes than younger generations are, largely because those issues would be more likely to negatively impact them.” Pandemic inspires more UBI support The coronavirus pandemic and the resulting economic fallout inspired many to rethink how people have their needs met — and whether it’s the government’s responsibility to meet them. The stimulus payments offered a glimpse into possible UBI outcomes, as the checks allowed many families to pay off some debt or cover necessary expenses. As a result, 45% of consumers say the pandemic made them more supportive of UBI, versus just 14% who say the crisis made them less supportive of the idea.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Freedom

UBI benefits the economy by increasing labors flexibility and workers productivity, while mitigating the harms of bureaucracy and automation

Scott Santens 3/21/2017 (“This is Why Experts Think All People Should Have a Universal Basic Income,” https://futurism.com/why-experts-think-all-people-should-have-universal-basic- income/)

Simply put, a basic income improves the market for labor by making it optional. The transformation from a coercive market to a free market means that employers must attract employees with better pay and more flexible hours. It also means a more productive work force that potentially obviates the need for market-distorting minimum wage laws. Friction might even be reduced, so that people can move more easily from job to job, or from job to education/retraining to job, or even from job to entrepreneur, all thanks to more individual liquidity and the elimination of counter-productive bureaucracy and conditions. Perhaps best of all, the automation of low-demand jobs becomes further incentivized through the rising of wages. The work that people refuse to do for less than a machine would cost to do it becomes a job for machines. And thanks to those replaced workers having a basic income, they arent just left standing in the cold in the job markets ongoing game of musical chairs. They are instead better enabled to find new work, paid or unpaid, full-time or part-time, that works best for them. 1

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Freedom

UBI means freedom to pursue what one wants

David Calnitsky and Jonathan P. Latner 2017 (University of Manitoba and Bremen International Graduate School of Social Sciences, Basic Income in a Small Town: Understanding the Elusive Effects on Work , http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/~dcalnits/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Calnitsky_Latner_Social_Problems_BI_in_a_small_town.pdf)

According to a leading proponent, Philippe Van Parijs, the objective of basic income is to transform the deprivations linked to non-employment and poorly remunerated employment into real freedom (1995). Real freedom requires that individuals have not just the abstract liberal right to freedom, but the financial resources to make freedom a lived reality. Furthermore, by securing individuals power to say no (Widerquist 2013), basic income reduces the vulnerability of poor and working people to exploitative relations in labor markets.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Small Business

Small businesses are key to the U.S. economy – economic growth, diversity, and adaptability

Duplain ‘23 (Rachel Duplain - experienced content, marketing, and business professional at Podium, the premiere marketing and communications platform for local businesses. “Small Business, Big Impact: Why Small Businesses are Essential to Our Economy.” Podium. 3/3/23. https://www.podium.com/article/why-small-businesses-are-essential/)

So, how important are small businesses to the economy? 3 Reasons Small Businesses are Essential to Our Economy Small businesses are the lifeblood of the U.S. economy as they create new opportunities. That’s new opportunities for jobs, new opportunities for innovation, and new opportunities to serve niche communities. Operating with agility and the ability to adapt quickly, small businesses have an important role to play in society. 1. Small Businesses Drive Economic Growth With the recent onset of a recession as a stark reminder of how important a growing economy is, small businesses play an essential role in keeping things running smoothly as they are responsible for 44% of U.S. economic activity. This economic success doesn’t only benefit business owners but also leads to team expansion and new roles. In fact, 62% of the new jobs created between 1995 and 2020 were created by small businesses—more than large enterprises! That’s a staggering impact that benefits the people in the local community. As well as supporting the local community with the creation of jobs, small businesses often source their supplies from the local community, boosting the local economy once again. This is an easily traceable and low carbon footprint supply chain that larger businesses that operate on mass just can’t compete with. Speaking of large enterprises, small businesses keep them on their toes. While well-known brands tend to have better brand awareness, recognition, and trust, small businesses are still strong competition. They have a unique perspective that drives innovation and are more personable, enabling them to build strong relationships with customers. Due to small businesses innovating, large enterprises have to innovate too if they want to maintain their market share. This produces better options for the target market all around. 2. Small Businesses Offer a Diverse Range of Products and Services By nature, large enterprises operate on a large scale. So, they won’t implement changes unless it is appealing to a broad customer base and viable across area-wide, state-wide, nationwide, or even international locations. They are often limited to being generalists meaning they can’t appeal to the locals in the same way small businesses can. That’s a major pitfall as about 50% of customers have switched to a competitor that was more relevant and met their needs better. Small businesses can leverage the power of niching by focusing on meeting the needs of, marketing to attract, and nurturing their relationship with a specific target audience. That could be a local community with specific needs that brand names aren’t meeting. Or they could leverage globalization and digital transformation by appealing to a niche market that doesn’t have large numbers locally but does on a wider scale and will interact with the business online. A niche market that has grown in demand recently is eco-conscious shoppers. Big supermarkets tend to be slow in the uptake of new innovations like sustainable products. But by looking online these consumers can find plenty of options for making their home more eco-friendly such as Bee’s Wrap, which offers sustainable food storage options to cut down on plastic usage. Specificity is profitable. You only have to look at the rise of personalized marketing, enabled by the technological development of data-driven segmentation, as evidence of this. In the age of information that can lead to marketing overwhelm, direct marketing that speaks to a certain niche cuts through the noise. By adding diversity to the products and services on the market, small businesses give consumers the power of choice. 3. Small Businesses are Resilient and Adaptive Small businesses can use their small scale to their advantage. They can adapt to changes in the market, come up with an action plan for overcoming economic downturns, and meet new demands with speed and efficiency that isn’t possible in a large enterprise. This agility was put to the test during the Covid-19 pandemic. While 9.1 million jobs were lost in the first two quarters of 2020, small businesses created 5.5 million jobs in the following four quarters, recovering 60% of jobs lost. That’s quite the bounce back, and it shows how well small businesses can adapt to new circumstances and return to serving their customers. For example, Battery Watering Technologies only had 50 employees at the onset of the pandemic. They were able to keep all of them working by using the equipment they had to operate in the battery sector to start making face shields which they sold through an e-commerce website. It was a massive success that led to sales of 6,000 face shields a day. Such adaptability leads to a high level of resilience. It’s not just once-in-a-lifetime pandemics that resilience protects the business against, but the fast pace of technological developments as well. To keep up with innovation and continue to meet customer expectations, digital transformation is a commitment all businesses need to make and small businesses have the advantage of implementing developments much faster.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Small Business

Job guarantee will undermine economic growth by crowding out small businesses

Earle ‘18

Peter C. Earle, 'Federal Jobs Guarantee' Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats, Investors,

Two other factors: both the CBPP and LEI plans fail to account for the potential disruption to existing businesses — mostly small businesses, the engine of economic growth in the United States — which will inevitably occur when workers earning less than $15 per hour leave their private sector jobs for higher-paying employment with job guarantee placement. At present, more than 40 million Americans earn less than the proposed guarantee wage of $15 per hour, which could trigger a major shift of the U.S. workforce away from private employment, on to public rolls. It would also effectively force small businesses to compete directly against the federal government on the labor market.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › ! – Innovation (China War)

Revitalizing innovation is key to restore deterrence and prevent post-pandemic US-China nuclear war- miscalc likely now

Flournoy, 20 -- former U.S. Undersecretary of Defense for Policy (2009-2012)

[Michèle, "How to Prevent a War in Asia: The Erosion of American Deterrence Raises the Risk of Chinese Miscalculation," Foreign Affairs, 6-18-2020, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-06-18/how-prevent-war-asia, accessed 6-29-2021]

How to Prevent a War in Asia

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › ! – Innovation (China War)

Innovation key to out-compete China

Wheeler, visiting fellow in Governance Studies at The Brookings Institution, Chairman of the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) from 2013 to 2017, ‘20

(Tom, “Digital Competition With China Starts With Competition At Home,” )

The United States and China are engaged in a technology-based conflict to determine 21st-century international economic leadership. China’s approach is to identify and support the research and development efforts of a handful of “national champion” companies. The dominant tech companies of the U.S. are de facto embracing this Chinese policy in their effort to maintain domestic marketplace control. Rather than embracing a China-like consecration of a select few companies, America’s digital competition with China should begin with meaningful competition at home and the allAmerican reality that competition drives innovation.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › ! – Innovation (Space Col)

Space colonization solves extinction.

Konrad Szocik 17. *Department of Philosophy and Cognitive Science, University of Information Technology and Management in Rzeszow, Poland. **Tomasz Wójtowicz, Institute of Security and Civic Education, Pedagogical University in Cracow, Poland. ***Leszek Baran, Chair of Internal Security, University of Information Technology and Management in Rzeszow, Poland. "War or peace? The possible scenarios of colonising Mars". Space Policy, Vol. 42. November 2017. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0265964617300371

The main benefit that could be provided by colonisation of Mars would be an opportunity to save the life of humanity when it is life on Earth will be endangered. It seems that the greatest possible source of dangers is the humanity itself, but beside it, the another greatest danger is probably the asteroid impact. To provide survival of humanity, the easier and the less costly project, as Impey points out, can be an attempt to reduce threats on Earth, and taking more care for proper conditions for human survival on Earth [12]. If we treat the idea of Mars colonisation as an alternative for an opportunity of survival of humanity, the mentioned running out resources are only one of possible threats for maintaining life on Earth. If we take into account such possible threats, it is worth considering Mars as perhaps the unique solution for further survival of humanity. Among possible threats on Earth we can enumerate such of them like nuclear war, environmental catastrophes, incurable epidemic, asteroid impact, or uncontrolled development of artificial intelligence that could be deleterious for humanity [12]. Of course, the concept of the human outer space colony as a way to solve human life could be applied probably only to some small part of the entire humanity, for instance, for these ones who survived one of the mentioned catastrophes. Consequently, the current work on preparation of the manned mission to Mars can be treated as a work to provide the future further living of the human species whose further existence on Earth in the next several hundred or several thousand years can be really endangered.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › ! – Innovation (Space Col)

Getting off the rock is possible --- extinction guaranteed otherwise

Everett 16 [Sean, CEO of Prome Biological Intelligence, a global biotechnology company, editor of Medium’s news outlet dedicated to space colonialization titled “The Mission”, BS Mathematics & Actuarial Science, MBA from UChicago, 2016, “Humanity’s Extinction Event Is Coming” https://medium.com/the-mission/humanitys-extinction-event-is-coming-c0f84f1803f]

But the reality is that an asteroid impact, a change in our magnetic field, or the rising temperature of Earth’s climate are all events that we currently cannot escape. There is no back-up plan. We are, for better or worse, tied to the fate of this planet. As history has shown, that’s not a good fate to be tied to. In fact on September 7, 2016 a 30-foot asteroid flew between the Earth and the Moon. Our most powerful instruments only detected it with two days notice. Two days. If the asteroid was only 1000-foot wide, it would destroy all human life and we’d have no back-up to get out of it. Even the White House is worried about it. Five, yes five, major extinction events have occurred on our planet that we know about. We’re due for another. And when that happens, what’s our alternative? You can’t move to another house. You can’t buy survival, even with a billion dollars in the bank. The only way out, is up. We must find a way to become multi-planetary if we want to save humanity, your family, and yes, even yourself. Only this can restore the honor we seemed to have lost from the brave days of the 60s, while also ensuring our survival. It’s for the species, folks. And as a species, we have not allowed ourselves the opportunity to blast off for the stars. Only the space race in the 60s when we were afraid enough of a self-inflicted global extinction event (read: nuclear) that we put forth the funding required to launch into orbit and onto our moon. We didn’t have calculators back then, and now we have supercomputers in our pocket, but no one is allowed out of our atmosphere, save for a few communication and spy satellites. Doesn’t that make you mad? It’s not some oppressive government that tells us no. It’s us. We pay our taxes. We elect leaders. Those leaders choose Defense as the primary budget line item, but forget about defending against the forthcoming apocalypse. Funding for NASA in the United States has decreased from 4% of the national budget in the 60s to about 0.5% from 2010 onwards. That’s just the money side. But in order to move past this threshold from our home planet to space and then onto other planets, we need to do two things: Travel there. Survive. Luckily, we can simplify the problem of passing this barrier by sending machines in our place. Like TARS from Interstellar, they can go places humans cannot and explore the environment for habitability and resources, even in particularly hostile conditions. Maybe not black hole hostile, but definitely Mars hostile, as the Curiosity Rover has shown. Only now, with a few bold, private startups are we beginning to see a re-emergence of the space industry. We are about to pass a few very important tests that allow us to explore and visit the cosmos. The first is launching physical things into space. This is the catalyst that will jump start a new space race. Prices of sending cargo are falling dramatically, down to nearly $500 per pound of payload with SpaceX’s Falcon 9 heavy re-usable rocket. Note that the re-usable part is key. We can’t throw away our “space car” every time we Uber it. And once that becomes standard and cost-optimized we might be able to get that down to $10 per pound. Imagine what could happen when it costs the same amount to ship something across town as it does into space. The second, and this is just as important, is the wave of autonomous machines. Tesla has popularized the notion of self-driving cars. SpaceX lands their rocket onto a small barge in the ocean autonomously. Companies are buying startups in the space. Self-driving will be our gift, our talisman, on the quest to save the species by becoming multi-planetary. II. Shipping Ourselves to Space The graph below is from the Founders Fund manifesto, showing the decreasing cost of launching something into space. It begins with the 1960s US-versus-Russia space race and extends to the present day SpaceX-versus-Blue Origin reusable rocket race. The cheapest method we have today is SpaceX’s Falcon series rockets. With the Falcon 9 Heavy, it’s predicted launching cargo into space will be cheaper than ever before, at $750 per pound of payload delivered to low earth orbit (LOE)on an expendable rocket. You have to note here, however, that these statistics are as cheap as possible. It costs more to deliver payload on a non-reusable rocket, and on something that’s further out than LEO, like geosynchronous orbit, or to Mars. For example, based on SpaceX’s published pricing, it would be at least 4x more expensive to deliver far less cargo to Mars. So what happens when we reduce that cost to $10 per pound? Namely, an explosion of startups, much like iOS. Instead of pushing to production for your continuously deployed web and mobile app, we will see future developers push to production by deploying physical things into space. “STAGE” takes on an entirely new meaning for software developers when it means your automated regression tests fail, it could blow up a rocket and hurt people on board. That’s why SpaceX and Blue Origins exist. To make this continuous-deployment-to-space process as cheap and fast as possible. By Elon’s calculations, every 15 minutes. III. Self-Driving Space Explorers The most successful products for space, at least in the beginning, will make money by pushing this stuff into orbit. Things like science experiments and new 3D printers. A company called Made in Space creates a number of these products, including the empty box you see below used for sending things up with Blue Origin. The box shown in gray is a specialized 3D printer that works in zero gravity. Remember how most 3D printers work. It squeezes out a single layer of liquid ooze, and then another, over and over again until it builds up enough vertically that it creates an object. This can be simple plastic or more esoteroic metals. But when you’re “dripping” something, held down in place by gravity, the entire process has to be re-imagined for space. Things in zero-G would just float away. Enter these chaps. There’s also the very real need for oxygen, food, water, and shelter from the harsh elements. Funny how we will end up recreating Maslow’s Heirarchy in every new voyage or planetoid we want to colonize. And space mining is off to the races with the recent announcement of Deep Space Industry’s Prospector-1: Their vision is to extract water from asteroids and use the chemical components to hydrate us, but also as oxygen (breathing) and hydrogen (fuel). To do that, you have to identify candidate asteroids, physically get to them, land and attach, and then do surveying, prospecting, and extraction. In short, you’re going to need some level of self-driving capabilities to make this happen. And wouldn’t it be nice if it “just worked” right out of the box. Unfortunately, in space you don’t have fleets of these space craft, millions of miles of training data, maps, or an internet connection to the cloud so how the heck are deep learning algorithms going to work? I don’t think they will. And that’s what I believe we need a better approach

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › ! – Innovation (Space Col)

Tech innovation is key to get off the rock.

Senjuti Mallick & Rajeswari Rajagopalan, 19 (Senjuti Mallick is pursuing an L.L.M. in International Law at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Graduate of ILS Law College and Rajeswari Rajagopalan is a Distinguished Fellow and Head of the Nuclear and Space Policy Initiative at the Observer Research Foundation, Technical Adviser to the UN Group of Governmental Experts on the Prevention of Arms Race in Outer Space, former Research Officer at the Institute of Defence Studies and Analyses and Professor at the Graduate Institute of International Politics at National Chung Hsing University, 1-24-2019, accessed on 10-17-2021, Observer Research Foundation, " If space is ‘the province of mankind’, who owns its resources ", https://www.orfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/ORF_Occasional_Paper_182_Space_Mining.pdf, HBisevac)

Why Mining? Technological innovation—primarily brought about by commercial players such as Elon Musk[2] and Jeff Bezos[3]—is changing the landscape of space exploration. Leading the way in this new-era race are the startups including Planetary Resources, Deep Space Industries, Ispace, and Kleos Space.[vii] Research into the feasibility of human and robotic missions to asteroids is being conducted by both governmental organisations, like NASA and JAXA (Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency), as well as private companies such as Planetary Resources.[viii] However, for realising affordable space travel and space industrialisation, it is essential to find extraterrestrial materials such as metals, minerals and water that do not have to be transported from Earth. Thus, the first objective in carrying out asteroid mining activity is to obtain elements that are critical for basic sustenance on Earth. It has been identified that the asteroid belt in our solar system contains eight-percent metal-rich (M type) asteroids and 75-percent volatile-rich carbonaceous (C type) asteroids.[ix] The second incentive for celestial mining companies is to haul precious minerals and cargo raw materials to Earth to fuel its fast depleting resources. This would significantly increase the mining company’s valuation and greatly impact the global economy. According to a 2012 Reuters interview with Planetary Resources, a 30-meter-long (98-foot) asteroid can hold platinum worth somewhere from US$25 billion to US $50 billion.[x] These metals are highly useful and valuable, both on Earth and in space.[xi] Third, asteroids give humans the potential to create tools in space, since iron, nickel and cobalt are in abundance.[xii] Chris Lewicki, Planetary Resources CEO, has said, “Using 3D printing technology one can grab material off asteroids and 3D print something that never has to be on a rocket. Tools, machines and even habitats can then be built off Earth, reducing the cost of exploration even further.[xiii] Fourth, resource extraction is also becoming a focus for many Middle Eastern nations.[xiv] The Middle Eastern oil states, such as Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates are investing heavily in this industry as they are looking at space as a way to diversify out of the earthly benefits of fossil fuel.[xv] Fifth, countries such as India and China are looking to mine the Moon for extracting Helium-3, which is considered a clean and efficient form of energy. It is thought that this isotope could provide safer nuclear energy in a fusion reactor, since it is not radioactive and would not produce dangerous waste products.[xvi] Finally, the water available in outer space could be used to make rocket propellants. According to scientists, since water is abundant in outer space, in some or the other form, it could be extracted and electrolysed to derive hydrogen and oxygen, the key ingredients of rocket fuel.[xvii] Thus, instead of carrying one’s own fuel all the way, asteroids could serve as extraterrestrial/orbital “gas stations” for fuelling future deep space missions. This would simultaneously make space travel more cost-effective and productive. Such ventures are also seen to be intrinsic to further science and discovery, in addition to revolutionising commercial development in outer space. The mining of asteroids could also provide a near-infinite supply of the precious resources for Earth to use. [xviii]

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › UBI Solves Innovation

UBI ensures risk taking those results in innovation in the tech sector

Santens, 17 – Writer for Evonomics

[Scott Santens, “Universal Basic Income Accelerates Innovation by Reducing Our Fear of Failure,” Evonomics, 02-12-2017, https://evonomics.com/universal-basic-income-accelerates-innovation-reducing-fear-failure/, accessed 6-24-2023]

It’s almost impossible for many people to accept that everything around us, including our own lives, could ever be the result of trial and error, but that’s what the scientific method has revealed. Mutations happen. Some of them work better than others depending on the environment. A longer beak here and a longer neck there can be the difference between life and death. Successful mutations are passed on. Iterations continue generation after generation. Discovering this process of evolution was one of the great accomplishments of our species. It’s also possibly the most powerful reason to support another world-changing idea — an unconditional basic income. Let me explain. Markets as Environments Our economy is a . Much like how nature works, markets work. No one central planner is deciding what natural resources to mine, what to make with them, how much to make, where to ship everything to, who to give it to, etc. These decisions are the result of and it’s all made possible with a tool we call “money” being exchanged between those who want something (demand) and those who provide that something (supply). Money is more than a decentralized tool of calculation however. It’s also like energy. It powers the entire process like the eating of food powers our own bodies and the sun powers plants. Without food, we starve, and without money, markets starve. A sufficient amount of money for all market participants is absolutely key to the market system for it to work properly. If you’ve ever played Monopoly this should be apparent. The game would not work if all players started the game with nothing. Some wouldn’t even make it once around the board. Additionally, if no one received $200 for then passing Go, the game would end a lot sooner. Ultimately the game always grinds to a halt once everyone but one person is all out of money, . No money, no purchases, no market, no game. Game over. Supply and Demand as Trial and Error With sufficient money however, markets adapt and evolve based on trial and error. Someone thinks of something to create or do. If people like it, it does well. If people don’t like it, it goes away. What does well is modified. If people like the modified version, it does well. If they don’t, it goes away. If they like it enough, the original version goes away. Survival of the fittest we call it. This is the evolution of goods and services, which runs on supply and demand, which both in turn run on money and one other thing — the willingness to take risks. Risks as Genetic Mutation Taking risks is equivalent to random genetic mutation in this biological analogy. A new product or service introduced into the market can result in success or failure. The outcome is entirely unknown until it’s tried. What succeeds can make someone rich and what fails can bankrupt someone. That’s a big risk. We traditionally like to think of these risk-takers as a special kind of person, but really As a prime example, Elon Musk is one of today’s most well-known and highly successful risk takers. Back in his college years . Why did he do that? He figured that if he could successfully survive with very little money, he could survive any failure. With that knowledge gained, the risk of failure in his mind was reduced enough to not prevent him from risking everything to succeed. This isn’t just anecdotal evidence either. Studies have shown that the very existence of food stamps — just knowing they are there as an option in case of failure — . A study of a reform to the French unemployment insurance system that allowed workers to remain eligible for benefits if they started a business found that . In Canada, a reform was made to their maternity leave policy, where new mothers were guaranteed a job after a year of leave. A study of the results of this policy change showed a due to women basically asking themselves, “What have I got to lose? If I fail, I’m guaranteed my paycheck back anyway.” Meanwhile, entrepreneurship is currently on a downward trend. Businesses that were less than five years old used to comprise half of all businesses three decades ago. . Businesses are also closing their doors faster than new businesses are opening them. Until recently, here in the US for as long as such data had been recorded. Startup rates are falling. Why? Risk aversion due to rising insecurity. Growing Insecurity For decades now thanks to advancements in technology, and we have simultaneously been actively eroding the institutions that pooled risk like trade unions and our public safety net. Incomes adjusted for inflation have not budged for decades, and the jobs providing those incomes have gone from secure careers to insecure jobs, part-time and contract work, and now recently even gig labor in the sharing economy. Decreasing economic security means a population decreasingly likely to take risks. Looking at it this way, of course startups have been on the decline. ? None of this should be surprising. The entire insurance industry exists to reduce risk. When someone is able to insure something, they are more willing to take risks. Would there be as many restaurants if there was no insurance in case of fire? Of course not. The corporation itself exists to reduce personal risk. .Reducing risk aversion is paramount to innovation. Failure as Evolution So the question becomes, how do we reduce the risks of failure so that more people take more risks? Better yet, how do we increase the rate of failure? It may sound counter-intuitive, but . It’s only through failure that we learn what doesn’t work and what might work instead. This is basically the scientific method in a nutshell. It’s designed to rule out what isn’t true, not to determine what is true. There is a very important difference between the two. This is also how evolution works, through failure after failure. Nature isn’t determining the winner. Nature is simply determining all the losers, and those who don’t lose, win the game of evolution by default. So, the higher the rate of mutation, the more mutations can fail or not fail, and therefore the quicker an organism can adapt to a changing environment. In the same way, the higher the rate of failure in a market economy, the quicker the economy can evolve. There’s also something else very important to understand about failure and success. One success can outweigh 100,000 failures. Venture capitalist Paul Graham of Y Combinator has described this as . When it comes to truly transformative ideas, they aren’t obviously great ideas, or else they’d already be more than just an idea, and when it comes to taking a risk on investing in a startup, the question is not so much if it will succeed, but if it will succeed BIG. What’s so interesting is that the biggest ideas tend to be seen as the least likely to succeed. Now translate that to people themselves. What if the people most likely to massively change the world for the better, the Einsteins so to speak — the Black Swans, are oftentimes those least likely to be seen as deserving social investment? In that case, the smart approach would be to cast an extremely large net of social investment, in full recognition that even at such great cost, the ROI from the innovation of the Black Swans would far surpass the cost. This happens to be exactly what was thinking when he said, “We must do away with the absolutely specious notion that everybody has to earn a living. It is a fact today that one in ten thousand of us can make a technological breakthrough capable of supporting all the rest.” That is a fact, and it then begs the question, “How do we make sure we invest in every single one of those people such that all of society maximizes its collective ROI?” What if our insistence on making people earn their living is preventing those one in ten thousand from making incredible achievements that would benefit all the rest of us in ways we can’t even imagine? What if our fears of each other being fully free to pursue whatever most interests us, including nothing, is an obstacle to an explosion of entrepreneurship and truly huge innovations the likes of which have never been seen? Fear as Death What it all comes down to is fear. FDR was absolutely right when he said the only thing we have to fear is fear itself. Fear prevents risk-taking, which prevents failure, which prevents innovation. If the great fears are of hunger and homelessness, and they prevent many people from taking risks who would otherwise take risks, then the answer is to simply take hunger and homelessness off the table. Don’t just hope some people are unafraid enough. Eliminate what people fear so they are no longer afraid. If everyone received as an absolute minimum, a sufficient amount of money each month to cover their basic needs for that month no matter what —  — then the fear of hunger and homelessness is eliminated. It’s gone. And with it, the risks of failure considered too steep to take a chance on something. But the effects of basic income don’t stop with a reduction of risk. Basic income is also basic capital. It enables more people to actually afford to create a new product or service instead of just think about it, and even better, it enables people to be the consumers who purchase those new products and services, and in so doing decide what succeeds and what fails through an even more widely distributed and further decentralized free market system. Such market effects have even been observed in universal basic income experiments in and where local markets flourished thanks to a tripling of entrepreneurs and the enabling of everyone to be a consumer with a minimum amount of buying power. Basic income would even help power the sharing economy. For example, imagine how much an unconditional monthly income would enable people within the Open Source Software (OSS) and free software movements (FSM) to do the unpaid work that is .