Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › UBI Solves Innovation

UBI solves innovation – it fosters entrepreneurship and aversion to risk

Kaye 17 --- Leon Kaye has written for 3p since 2010 and become executive editor in 2018. His previous work includes writing for the Guardian as well as other online and print publications. In addition, he's worked in sales executive roles within technology and financial research companies, as well as for a public relations firm, for which he consulted with one of the globe’s leading sustainability initiatives. Leon’s an alum of Fresno State, the University of Maryland, Baltimore County and the University of Southern California's Marshall Business School. 5/31/2017 (“Can a Universal Basic Income Inspire Innovation? Mark Zuckerberg Thinks So.” Triple Pundit. https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2017/can-universal-basic-income-inspire-innovation-mark-zuckerberg-thinks-so/17071. Date Accessed: 6-24-2023.)

The surge in automation is driving a decline in the U.S. manufacturing sector. Jobs in sectors like ridesharing are only temporary for workers, as companies like Uber have big plans to develop fleets of self-driving cars. And white-collar jobs are hardly immune; artificial intelligence has started to replace some white-collar workers in Japan. Despite the good macroeconomic statistics, finding and keeping a job is what keeps millions of Americans awake night after night.

Can a universal basic income help solve future problems as jobs become scarcer? One minor party candidate for California’s governorship has suggested such a policy; and pilot programs are underway in Canada, Finland and Kenya as more citizens have become receptive of the idea. But the concept is still in its nascent stages, as not everyone is convinced a UBI can provide enough answers. Last summer, Switzerland’s citizens rejected a referendum that would have paid every national a $2,500 monthly supplement.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › FJG Hurts Innovation

Federal involvement in jobs backfires – ruins innovation and productivity.

Standing ’13 (Guy Standing, "Why A Basic Income Is Necessary For A Right To Work." Basic Income Studies 7:2. 2013. October 09, 2020. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269594683_Why_a_Basic_lncome_ls_Nece ssary_for_a_Right_to_Work)

The economic system that came closest to giving every adult a "job guarantee" was the Soviet Union, which even regarded anybody not in employment as "parasitic". It is not a model that leaps to mind as one to be emulated. If everybody is guaranteed a job, it becomes extremely hard to dismiss anybody for tardiness or low productivity, and it discourages voluntary mobility, as well as putting a block on technological innovation. In a market economy, it is generally recognized by economists that some unemployment is necessary. Many economists believe that there is a "natural" rate of unemployment ground out by the structural characteristics of production and employment. Its closely related concept is the NAIRU, the "non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment". One can dispute the methodology for conceiving and measuring these concepts but, at the very least, ever since the origin of the Phillips Curve in 1958, it has been accepted that if unemployment is pushed too low, inflationary pressures will become intense. If price rises and wage rises accelerate, economic problems multiply. In other words, guaranteeing everybody a job would create huge economic costs. That is not the end of the matter. If the government guaranteed everybody a job, how would that be translated into practical policy? Would the person not given a job to his or her liking be able to sue the government for compensation or for a job? What right of refusal would be allowed? Alexis de Tocqueville (1848) long ago put his finger on the ultimate dilemma, when he pointed out that guaranteeing every person the right to a job would mean either that the government would have to spread until it had taken over almost the entire economy (which he saw as communism) or it would be obliged to force employers to provide jobs and penalize them for not doing so (which he saw as socialism).

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › INNOVATION DA › FJG Hurts Innovation

The plan ruins innovation in the name of ideological projects.

Harsanyi ’18 (David. "Democrats' Universal Job Plan Would Be A Socialist Disaster." Reason. April 27, 2018. October 09, 2020. https://reason.com/2018/04/27/democrats- universal-job-plan-would-be-a/)

Of course, it's more likely that our state-run workforce would be deployed for ideological and political priorities rather than economic ones. If history is any indicator, it would be used to prop up politically useful projects and keep failing industries afloat, undermining creative destruction, innovation, and long-term growth. You do have to wonder, what would happen if local communities that share President Trump's "priorities" were to demand utilizing this state labor? What if they were to want to build sections of a wall on the southern border rather than make solar panels, or whatever progressive priority Sanders has in mind? We'd be hearing about a rise of fascism in no time. Then there is the mission creep. No doubt the Washington, D.C., bureaucracy that would emerge to run this project would be both nimble and competent. But why only $15? Who can live on $15 an hour? Well, not a lot of people. Surely, these hardworking public servants who keep the infrastructure from crumbling around us deserve a genuine living wage. How about better pensions? As this workforce grows, it wouldn't possess any special ability other than being able to corral huge numbers of people to demand more.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › AT: Immigration Turn

A UBI would push past racial exclusions – historically proven. The risk of exclusion does not eliminate the need to adopt a UBI

Warren, 2017 – Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute [Dorian, May 3, Boston Review, “Reparations and Basic Income Basic income could function as reparations.” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

Rogers is spot on to warn us that basic income could be “designed to serve white nationalist ends.” We know this from our own historical experience. Seemingly “universal” social policies, from the New Deal to the Great Society, have had intended and unintended consequences of maintaining or exacerbating existing racial and gender inequalities. Many supposedly “universal” policies ultimately were not. But Rogers’s rightful skepticism and warning about a white nationalist basic income comes down to a question of political power. President Franklin D. Roosevelt compromised on his New Deal programs because southern Democrats insisted on it. The race-based occupational exclusions of agricultural and domestic workers were ultimately included in Social Security, the National Labor Relations Act, and the Fair Labor Standards Act to appease political elites protecting the southern Jim Crow racial and economic regime over the protests of racial justice organizations. Black workers were excluded as a result of this previous iteration of white nationalism and populism. But advocates for a truly universal social policy did not give up, eventually winning racial inclusion in Social Security but not the other two major New Deal policies. Similarly we should not limit our political imaginations about the promise of a basic income because of the very perilous questions around race, immigration, and exclusion. Quite the opposite. We should imagine a robust basic income that advances racial and gender justice while simultaneously addressing the ills of twenty-first-century capitalism.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › AT: Immigration Turn

A UBI includes undocumented migrants and non-residents

Standing 2019 - research associate at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London [Guy, 6 June 2019, “Why ‘Universal Basic Services’ is no alternative to Basic Income” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

So much for the limitations of what is actually proposed under UBS. But the proponents go further in provocatively presenting UBS as preferable to ‘UBI’ (Universal Basic Income). Before considering this claim, I want to make it clear that sensible advocates of basic income do not or should not use the word ‘universal’, because in practice some people would not be entitled to it – non-resident citizens and short-term or undocumented migrants. Presumably something similar would apply with UBS. That pragmatic matter aside, services and basic income have different objectives and justifications. Therefore, different criteria should be used to assess their desirability.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › AT: Costs

Turn – Revenue will increase after a UBI is established by 100-200 billion annually.

Cheng & Maass 20 --- Alex Cheng & Andreas Maass. Writers for Berkeley Economic Review 2/25/2020 (“Unboxing Universal Basic Income”. Berkeley Economic Review. https://econreview.berkeley.edu/unboxing-universal-basic-income/. Date Accessed: 6-22-2023.)

Another consideration against UBI is how the state will pay for the $4.3 trillion program. Yang’s proposal for funding the Freedom Dividend includes the reduction of some current welfare programs and a Value Added Tax (VAT). Essentially, Yang argues that a monthly income of $1,000 would be more beneficial to many welfare recipients than the United States’ current programs. Thus, he would offer those on welfare the opportunity to choose between their current welfare programs and UBI, predicting that the vast majority will elect for the cash influx. This shift is projected to save nearly $500  in revenue for the government. The second arm of this funding plan is a VAT, which has been  in more than 140 countries worldwide, including every other economically advanced nation, and is projected to generate between $100 and $200 billion for the US in annual revenue. Essentially, the VAT taxes the value that each member of a product’s supply chain adds to the final cost of the product. As a result, the VAT is deemed a highly effective method of redistributing wealth, as it taxes corporations at every step of their involvement in a product. Finally, the economic growth that the UBI is predicted to foster will lead to a general increase in sales tax revenue and income tax revenue for the federal government. This tax revenue will be the final piece in UBI funding and account for . Putting these funds together, the money is in the budget for this type of federal expenditure, but it definitely puts a significant stress on other welfare programs and would likely lead to the eradication of many of them.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › AT: Solvency Deficits

c. Loss of worker productivity.

Gulker ’18 (Max, PhD and Senior Research Fellow American Institute for Economic Research, “The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis,” October 18, 2018, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee.pdf)

Market Jobs versus Mandated Jobs A federal job guarantee as proposed in the CBPP and Levy reports eschews the essential characteristics of labor markets as we know them, including competition, negotiation, and a price (wage) mechanism. These radical differences are evident in the way jobs are created and filled. Most employment in our economy, whether in the private, public, or nonprofit sector, is mutually beneficial, as shown in figure 1. It starts with an opportunity for an employer to create value if it hires the right worker. A worker is willing to do the job for a certain wage. If the value they create together is enough to pay the worker at least what they are willing to accept and to leave some profit for the employer, then a job is born. Rather than cooperative, work arrangements in a job guarantee are a series of three interlocking mandates, as shown in figure 2. An individual mandates that the federal government provide a wage and benefits, the federal government mandates that some government agency (local, state, or federal) identify or create work for this and other individuals, and that agency mandates that the individual perform certain work. Problems with this system multiply very quickly with size. A centralized office, even for a locality rather than the whole nation, cannot possibly process all the information and knowledge that is dispersed among millions of individuals. Markets make use of all of this dispersed information and knowledge by allowing each individual to act on their own. Without the critical information conveyed by markets, resources go to the wrong places, and even seemingly small mistakes can pile up and multiply throughout the economy. Hayek (1945) famously illuminates this point. But chapter 1 of virtually any introductory economics textbook makes clear the centrality of this view to the field. For example, Mankiw (1998) writes: Prices reflect both the value of a good to society and the cost to society of making the good. Because households and firms look at prices when deciding what to buy and sell, they unknowingly take into account the social benefits and costs of their actions. As a result, prices guide individual decisionmakers to reach outcomes that, in many cases, maximize the welfare of society as a whole. A federal job guarantee, in which wages (prices) and competition have no role, turns its back on these modern economic fundamentals.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › AT: Solvency Deficits

a. Private sector crowd-out – turns the aff.

Bourne ’18 [Ryan; April 24; Evan Scharf Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato; CATO Institute; “A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster,” https://www.cato.org/blog/jobs-guaranteed-economic-disaster]

Democrats are plugging new energy into an old idea: a federal “Jobs Guarantee” program. Senator Cory Booker previously introduced legislation for a pilot in high unemployment communities. Now Senator Bernie Sanders will announce a plan guaranteeing a job or training paying $15 an hour and health‐​care benefits to every American worker “who wants or needs one,” in a host of public infrastructure, care giving and environmental upkeep projects.

The scheme, seemingly based on a recommendation from the Levy Economic Institute, comes with grandiose purported benefits. It would, we are told, eliminate involuntary unemployment, deliver a living wage, boost GDP, reduce the cost of recessions, raise labor market standards, reduce environmental degradation, reduce racial inequality, and much else besides. If it sounds too good to be true, that’s because it is. There are severe problems with this idea, which can be loosely grouped under three “c’s”: costs, crowd out and corruption.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Mental Health

CP alleviates worries that people with mental health issues face

Peterson, 20 – Mental Health Nurse

[Ashley L. Peterson, “Benefits of Universal Basic Income for People with Mental Illness,” Mental Health @ Home, 11-23-2020, https://mentalhealthathome.org/2020/11/23/universal-basic-income-mental-illness/, accessed 6-23-2023]

Support for UBI from a mental health perspective comes from multiple perspectives, ranging from the , Canada’s major mental health non-profit organization, to the anti-psychiatry-leaning site Mad in America. UBI may help to prevent mental illness to some extent by influencing the . The stress associated with poverty is an important risk factor for mental illness, and guaranteeing people an income to meet basic needs would allow people to shift from a focus on surviving to finding ways to meet higher-level needs in Maslow’s . For people with mental illness who are able to work, having the safety net of UBI could be important if illness necessitated a period of time off since many workers don’t have much (if any) paid sick time. I used to work at a well-paying unionized job with pretty good sick-time benefits, but when I was hospitalized, I ran out of sick time and had to take unpaid leave. UBI could also alleviate some of the worries about what might happen if the illness progresses to the point that working just isn’t possible. Applying for disability benefits can be a stressful process, particularly if an appeal is needed. process definitely has certainly had a negative impact on my mental health. Luckily, my application was approved, but my total monthly benefit is less than the average monthly benefit in the city where I live. If I hadn’t paid off the mortgage on my home while I was still working, I would have to a) move out of my city to somewhere that rent is cheaper, and b) rely on food banks to eat. Work on a limited basis For some people with mental illness, regular employment might be out of reach, but working on a casual basis could allow them to remain in the workforce longer. UBI could make that feasible from a financial perspective.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Mental Health

A UBI program can decrease the underpinnings of some mental health issues by ensuring basic needs are met.

Smith, 20 – Professor in Health History

[Matthew Smith, “Universal basic income could improve the nation's mental health,” Conversation, 4-27-2020, https://theconversation.com/universal-basic-income-could-improve-the-nations-mental-health-123816, accessed 6-23-2023]

Many are talking about (UBI) these days. Giving everyone a guaranteed income could be the solution to many economic woes. But one factor that hasn’t been mentioned much in discussions of UBI is how it might improve our mental health. in the mid-20th century showed that mental illness was often caused by , and . Responding to such findings, the US Joint Commission on Child Mental Health published in 1969. The report was the work of 500 child mental health experts. One of its chief recommendations to prevent mental illness was to provide all Americans with a “guaranteed minimum income”, or UBI. Crisis in Child Mental Health was distributed widely to politicians, policymakers and physicians. But its message about UBI wasn’t heeded. Could it be revisited today? Poverty One of the main arguments for UBI is that it would . Recent research has linked the of poverty with in the brain, leading some to suggest that could be the solution. But what about eliminating poverty altogether? UBI could be set at a level to ensure that everyone’s basic needs are met. This would reduce much of the stress faced by the working poor or families on benefits. Today, these families are often forced to use or go into debt to pay for necessities. The working poor often have to rely on food banks. Andy Rain/EPA People today are also vulnerable to changes in the benefits system that may make them ineligible for benefits. The introduction of the in 2013, for instance, was . The consequences of these rule changes were also highlighted in . Since UBI is universal, there is no means testing. It would increase in line with inflation to ensure that people were kept out of poverty. Other measures could also be introduced alongside UBI to prevent inflation. Governments could create schemes to provide better access to affordable fresh local food. Providing free public transportation in cities would also mitigate against people’s expenses increasing too much. Rent controls would help curb inflation, too. Getting rid of means testing would also free up those running the benefits system. Benefits workers are typically gatekeepers – as is powerfully portrayed in I, Daniel Blake. Their time is spent screening out the ineligible, not helping those who need it. I have personal experience that is comparable to this situation. During the late 1990s, I worked for a charity as a youth counsellor and career advisor in Edmonton, Canada. Although those were my job titles, I spent precious little time counselling or providing career advice to young people who were not in school or work. What I actually did was determine whether my clients met the criteria for government funding to go back to school. The complexity of the application process and the numerous rules recipients had to follow to keep their funding prevented me from doing much else. My time would have been much better spent helping these young people overcome the numerous barriers they faced. Many had psychological problems, had been victims of abuse, had criminal records and addictions. These problems tended to be ignored until they flared up and jeopardised the client’s funding status. One of the reasons we persist in this gatekeeping approach is that the benefits systems in the UK, Canada and elsewhere retain the Victorian idea that there are . This idea inspired the (1834), which introduced the workhouse system depicted in . It persists in television programmes, such as Channel 4’s . Benefits workers should instead be redeployed to help people deal with difficult, intractable problems, including mental illness and addictions. They could also provide people with career guidance and counselling. Such work would serve to improve mental health, not worsen it. UBI would also help people, usually women and children, to . Domestic abuse occurs more often in poorer households, where financial means to escape. makes it for women to leave abusive situations. Similarly, UBI might prevent believed to lead to mental illness and other problems later in life. experiencing violence or abuse, or having parents with mental health, substance abuse and legal problems. Behind these problems are often poverty, inequality and social isolation. Inequality Inequality also encompasses a lack of opportunity, class bias, disenfranchisement, low self-worth and often racism. It results in hopelessness that can trigger depression, anxiety, addictions and other health problems. Inequality has featured in recent studies on . This includes Pickett and Wilkinson’s and . Pickett and Wilkinson show that rates of mental illness are highest in . Although mental illness is diagnosed , the authors also found that socioeconomic inequalities lead to higher rates of drug abuse, obesity, infant mortality, teenage pregnancy and other social and health problems. Put simply, . UBI can erode inequality in many ways. Unlike benefits, UBI is provided to all, regardless of class or income. There would be no stigma or shame associated with receiving it. UBI would also help with social mobility. It would facilitate further education, entrepreneurial activity, artistic endeavours and career changes. People intent on leaving unrewarding jobs could rely on it while they found something more meaningful. Above all, UBI would prevent some of the hopelessness and shame associated with deprivation. It would help to prevent so-called , which include suicide, chronic liver disease and drug and alcohol poisoning. Social exclusion Social psychiatry showed that social isolation is bad for mental health. This was regardless of whether a person lived in or . The link between UBI and social inclusion might be more subtle than that for poverty and inequality. But that doesn’t make it less important. The COVID-19 crisis highlights how important social connections are for our . We all need to love and to be loved. Alone time can be great, but being lonely can make life seem bleak and purposeless. UBI could give people the means to focus more on engaging with their communities, rather than simply earning an income. This would include carers, parents and volunteers. A UBI provides proof to such workers that their labour is valued and appreciated. UBI would shift our focus from economic growth, which doesn’t benefit everyone, to social and emotional growth, which would. It would allow people to reassess what matters most to them and give them a platform to live more meaningful lives. To explore it further, I would suggest two ways forward. First, those should explicitly measure mental health outcomes. often emerge out of such pilots, but they should be automatically assessed from the outset. of improved mental health could well outweigh the cost of implementing UBI. Second, mental health professionals and charities should advocate more strongly for socially progressive policies to prevent mental illness. UBI is one possibility, but there are others as well. Mental illness is caused by many factors. Many of these, such as childhood sexual abuse or other forms of trauma, are very difficult to prevent. The illnesses that emerge out of these experiences are also hard to treat. UBI could ease the burden of mental illness faced by health services. It could allow researchers and mental health professionals more time to deal with more intractable cases.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Racial Inequality

A UBI reduces racial inequality because it disproportionately benefits minorities and it addresses felon disenfranchisement.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

Racial Injustice In Where Do We Go from Here: Chaos or Community [2010 (1967)], the last book of Martin Luther King, Jr., the guaranteed income proposal is introduced as the simplest and most effective solution to poverty. MLK welcomes what he sees as a “cultural change” from old times, when we would see poverty as a result of individual inability or immorality, to new times, when we understand it as stemming from market failures and discriminatory practices that force people into unemployment. Because of this shift, he hopes that we may come to accept radical proposals like guaranteed income as a response to the poverty endemic to our economic systems. In October 1966, the guaranteed income proposal also appeared in the Black Panther Party ten-point manifesto under the second commitment of the program. It was envisaged as a compensation for involuntary unemployment among African-Americans stemming in part from discriminatory practices by white businessmen. The proposal was radical: If it cannot ensure a decent income to its citizens, the federal government ought to return the means of production to the community to guarantee a good living standard to its members. Decades later, the Movement for Black Lives also endorses a form of UBI as part of the economic justice platform of their manifesto. If the UBI proposal was relevant for racial equality at the time of MLK and the Black Panther Party and remains relevant today, it is primarily because unemployment, underemployment, precarious employment, and bad jobs disproportionally affect the lives of people of color. This is true because of discriminatory practices, still, and also because of broader inequalities in access to education, training, and opportunities (Shelby 2012). Interestingly, both MLK and the Black Panther Party were arguing for guaranteed income or guaranteed employment. They saw the proposals as interchangeable to some extent. After all, both policies are indeed designed to restore dignity by alleviating poverty. Guaranteed income can also help keep job guarantee proposals in check. This is because, with a high enough UBI, recipients would only be willing to take on “decent” jobs that provide them with more than just an income. If caring for a relative, volunteering in their community, or starting a business seemed like better options, then they will not be compelled to accept the jobs under the guarantee plan. This comment mirrors Standing's (2013) response to guaranteed-jobs proponents who oppose UBI: The right to an income is a prerequisite of a meaningful right to work. The contemporary proposal for UBI on grounds of racial justice comes from Dorian Warren (2016) in the Movement for Black Lives' manifesto. Under most UBI proposals [excluding those that would overall reduce the benefits available to the worse off, like Charles Murray's (2016)] those most disadvantaged stand to benefit most. Since black families in the United States are disproportionately found at the bottom of the wealth and income distribution, and since unemployment is twice as high among black workers as among white workers, black families stand to gain most from the policy. Warren (2016) also argues that the proposal's commitment to universality would make it harder for governments to exclude felons and ex-felons from the safety net. Under a system designed to target the deserving and screen out the undeserving, those tied up in the criminal justice system would be more easily excluded. This is important for racial justice given the overrepresentation of people of color in prisons, and given the discrimination experienced by ex-convicts in the labor market.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Unemployment

Since UBI stays after getting a job unlike other programs – it removes the reason people don’t want to be employed & allows more business

Tal, 20 --Publisher at Quantumrun

[David Tal, “Universal Basic Income cures mass unemployment,” 9-14-2020, https://www.quantumrun.com/Prediction/universal-basic-income-cures-mass-unemployment, accessed 6-23-2023]

In fact, it should sound familiar considering that senior citizens receive essentially the same thing in the form of monthly social security benefits. But with UBI, we’re basically saying, ‘Why do we only trust seniors to manage free government money?’ In 1967, “The solution to poverty is to abolish it directly by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.” And he’s not the only one who has made this argument. Nobel Prize economists, including , , , among others, have supported the UBI as well. Richard Nixon even tried to pass a version of the UBI in 1969, albeit unsuccessfully. It’s popular among progressives and conservatives; it’s just the details they disagree on. At this point, it’s natural to ask: What exactly are the benefits of a UBI, aside from getting a free monthly paycheck? UBI effects on individuals When going through the laundry list of UBI’s benefits, it’s probably best to start with the average Joe. As mentioned above, the biggest impact a UBI will have on you directly is that you’ll become a few hundred to a few thousand dollars richer every month. It sounds simple, but there’s way more to it than that. With a UBI, you’ll experience: A guaranteed minimum living standard. While the quality of that standard may vary from country to country, you’ll never have to worry about having enough money to eat, clothe, and house yourself. That underlying fear of scarcity, of not having enough to survive should you lose your job or get sick, will no longer be a factor in your decision-making. A greater sense of well being and mental health knowing your UBI will be there to support you in times of need. Day to day, most of us rarely acknowledge the level of stress, anger, envy, even depression, we carry around our necks from our fear of scarcity—a UBI will lessen those negative emotions. Improved health, since a UBI will help you afford better quality food, gym memberships, and of course, medical treatment when needed (ahem, USA). Greater freedom to pursue more rewarding work. A UBI will give you the flexibility to take your time during a job hunt, instead of being pressured or settling for a job to pay rent. (It should be re-emphasized that people will still get a UBI even if they have a job; in those cases, the UBI will be a pleasant extra.) Greater freedom to continue your education on a regular basis to better adapt to the changing labor market. True financial independence from individuals, organizations, and even abusive relationships that try to control you through your lack of income. UBI effects on businesses For businesses, the UBI is a double-edged sword. On one hand, workers will have far more bargaining power over their employers, since their UBI safety net will allow them to afford to refuse a job. This will increase the competition for talent between competing companies, forcing them to offer workers greater perks, starting salaries, and safer working environments. On the other hand, this increased competition for labor will reduce the need for unions. Labor regulations will be relaxed or voided en masse, freeing up the labor market. For example, governments will no longer fight for a minimum wage when everyone’s basic living needs are met by a UBI. For some industries and regions, it will allow companies to reduce their payroll costs by treating the UBI as a government subsidy for their employee salaries (similar to today). On a macro level, a UBI will lead to more businesses overall. Imagine your life with a UBI for a moment. With the UBI safety net backing you, you could take more risks and start that dream entrepreneurial venture you’ve been thinking about—especially since you’ll have more time and finances to start a business. UBI effects on the economy Given that last point about the entrepreneurial explosion the UBI could nurture, it’s probably a good time to touch on the UBI’s potential impact on the economy overall. With a UBI in place, we’ll be able to: Better support the millions pushed out of the workforce due to the machine automation aftermath described in the previous chapters of the Future of Work and Future of the Economy series. The UBI will guarantee a basic living standard, one that will give the unemployed time and peace of mind to retrain for the future labor market. Better recognize, compensate, and value the work of previously unpaid and unrecognized jobs, such as parenting and in-home sick and elderly care. (Ironically) remove the incentive to stay unemployed. The current system punishes the unemployed when they find work because when they do land a job, their welfare payments are cut, usually leaving them to work full-time without a noticeable increase in their income. With a UBI, this disincentive to work will no longer exist, since you’ll always receive the same basic income, except your job’s salary will add to it.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Unemployment

UBI allows job sharing and mothers to join the workforce.

O'Callaghan, 20 – Founder and CEO of Globis Insights

[Karl O'Callaghan, “UBI Is the Only Defense Against Mass Unemployment,” GLOBIS Insights, 8-18-2020, https://globisinsights.com/purpose/values/ubi-saves-capitalism/, accessed 6-23-2023]

Lack of demand has brought global economies to their knees. Several governments have offered short-term solutions to help their citizens start spending again, but Spain’s is the most far-reaching. On May 29, a “minimum vital income” for 850,000 of the country’s most vulnerable families (2.3 million people, or 5% of the population). The measure will cost €3 billion per year and promises each eligible family at least €462 per month. The Spanish economy is expected to shrink 12% this year, with unemployment hitting 20%. So a measure like this is needed to help those who find themselves out of work. The country learned a hard lesson from its 2008–2014 financial crisis, when unemployment topped 25%. The program is a bold move that will help those who need it most. But it doesn’t go far enough. Universal basic income isn’t a new idea. Outmaneuvering both coronavirus and automation will require more than temporary bolstering of demand. In fact, long before Spain, there have been in many parts of the world. Alaska and Manitoba are commonly cited North American examples, while there have also been experiments in India and Africa. The idea of universal basic income (UBI) is not new. Some say it originated with Sir Thomas More in his 1516 book, Utopia. Others go further back to Ephialtes’ citizens’ income reform in ancient Athens. In 1967, shortly before his death, that “the solution to poverty is to abolish it by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.” In 2016, when Black Lives Matter published a list of demands for change, for “a guaranteed minimum livable income.” UBI acts as a social dividend. UBI is a return on the investment that we all make in society through our learning and labor. It is universal: everyone receives it. It covers basic needs, so it’s not a disincentive to work. And as a right, it is an unconditional income. According to , UBI aims for “capitalism with baseline income maintenance.” UBI provides a level of freedom. We cannot be effective citizens, workers, learners, or providers when we worry about how to pay for shelter or food. UBI provides a buffer against this psychological burden. Unlike the initiative in Spain that will reach only the segment of society deemed most in need, UBI goes to all citizens, not just the designated head of household, ensuring one family member doesn’t hold financial power over another. Furthermore, a guaranteed income allows us to work fewer hours if we choose. This option provides better work-life balance and opens up possibilities such as job sharing and more mothers back in the workforce part-time.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Inequality

Inequality and effects are solved by a UBI program

Tereshchenko, 23 – Politologist & Journalist

[Sofia Tereshchenko (Contact Author), “The Global Importance of Universal Basic Income (UBI) Manifestation,” SSRN, 2-23-2023, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4368245, accessed 6-24-2023]

Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a policy proposal that has gained increasing attention in recent years as a potential solution to address the economic, social and political challenges of our time. The idea behind UBI is to provide every citizen with a regular cash payment, unconditionally and regardless of their employment status, with the aim of ensuring a basic standard of living. The importance of UBI lies in its potential to alleviate poverty and inequality, to enhance individual freedom and autonomy, to promote innovation and creativity, and to enable greater social and economic stability. By providing a basic income floor, UBI could help reduce poverty and inequality, and provide a safety net for those who fall on hard times. This would enable people to better pursue their goals and aspirations, and allow them to take more risks, such as starting a new business, pursuing further education, or engaging in creative pursuits. Furthermore, UBI could lead to greater social and economic stability by reducing the precariousness and insecurity of the current labor market, which is characterized by precarious and low-paid work, job insecurity, and rising levels of automation. UBI could help to redistribute wealth and power more equitably, providing a more balanced distribution of economic resources and opportunities, and enabling greater social cohesion and trust. Overall, the implementation of UBI would require a comprehensive and coordinated approach involving government, civil society, and the private sector. However, its potential benefits for humanity are significant, making it an important policy proposal to consider in the pursuit of a more just and equitable society.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Inequality

UBI solves inequality and insecurity – it people will receive enough money to pay rent, feed themselves, and invest in their future

Nettle 18 --- Daniel Nettle is Professor of Behavioural Science at Newcastle University. 11/09/2018 (“How Universal Basic Income Solves Widespread Insecurity and Radical Inequality”. Evonomics. https://evonomics.com/nettle-daniel-defense-universal-basic-income/. Date Accessed: 6-23-2023.)

Twin spectres stalk the land, and help explain the gap between what our grandparents hoped for and what has materialised. These are the spectres of inequality and insecurity. Insecurity, in this context, means not being able to be sure that one will be able to meet one’s basic needs at some point in the future, either because cost may go up, or income may fluctuate. Insecurity is psychologically damaging: most typologies put security as one of the most basic human emotional needs.[3] Insecurity dampens entrepreneurial activity: one of the big reasons that people don’t follow up their innovative ideas is that these are by definition risky, and they worry about keeping bread on the table whilst they try them out. Insecurity deters people from investing in increasing their skills: what if they cannot eat before the investment starts to pay off? It encourages rational short-termism: who would improve a house or a neighbourhood that might be taken away from them in a few months’ time for reasons beyond their control? It also increases the likelihood of anti-social behaviour: I would not steal a loaf of bread if I knew there was no danger of going hungry anyway, but faced with the danger of starvation tomorrow, I would seriously consider it. [4] Insecurity is a problem that affects those who have little to start with especially acutely: hence the link between insecurity and inequality.

Big problems require big ideas. Our current generation of politicians don’t really have ideas big enough to deal with the problems of widespread insecurity and marked inequality. Big ideas come along every few decades. The last one was about forty years ago: neoliberalism, the idea that market competition between private-sector corporations would deliver the social outcomes we all wanted, as long as government got out of the way as far as possible. Interestingly, neoliberalism was not such an obviously good idea that politicians of all stripes ‘just got it’. It took several decades of carefully orchestrated deliberate communication and advocacy, which was not at all successful at first, to eventually make it seem, across the political spectrum, that the idea was so commonsensical as to be obvious. [5] don’t think any of the early advocates of neoliberalism could possibly have dreamed that after thirty years of implementation of their big idea, available incomes would have stagnated or declined for the median family; public faith in corporate capitalism would have seeped away; even the UK Conservative party would have to concede that market mechanisms did not really work as envisaged[6]; or that the major UK political parties would both be advocating government-imposed price- caps in an area, the supply of energy, where the neoliberal market model had been followed to its logical conclusion. It feels like we are washed up on the end of one big idea, waiting for something else to come along.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Inequality

A UBI is needed to solve issues of income inequality

Wignarajaet al., 20 -- Kanni Assistant Secretary-General, UN Balazs Chief Economist

[Kanni Wignaraja, Balazs Horvath, “Universal basic income is the answer to the inequalities exposed by COVID-19,” World Economic Forum, 4-17-2020, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/covid-19-universal-basic-income-social-inequality/, accessed 6-22-2023]

It is time to add a new element to the policy packages that governments are introducing, one we know but have abandoned: Universal Basic Income (UBI). It is needed as part of the package that will help us to get out of this yawning pit. The naysayers, and there are plenty, will point out that it won’t work because no country can afford to regularly dole out money to every citizen. They will argue that we will run unsustainable deficits, which cannot be financed. This is a valid concern. But the alternative – not strongly addressing COVID-19 repercussions – will result in a greater surge in inequality, increasing social tensions that would cost governments even more and open countries to heightened risk of societal conflict. The pandemic that began in China has raged across Asia and beyond, exposing inequalities and vulnerabilities of huge populations in the region. This includes informal workers – – as well as migrants, with almost 100 million dislocated, in India alone. If a large part of an entire generation loses its livelihood, with no social safety net to catch it, the social costs will be unbearably high. Economic instability will follow the flare-up of social tensions. During these times, when we need to kickstart sputtering economies, the payoff of social stability would be tremendous, making an even more powerful argument for UBI. So a new social contract needs to emerge from this crisis that rebalances deep inequalities that are prevalent across societies. To put it bluntly: The question should no longer be whether resources for effective social protection can be found – but how they can be found. UBI promises to be a useful element of such a framework. Countries like the United States and Canada are already making such plans. Alaska, in fact, has been making annual UBI-type payments, to every state resident, for decades. Canadian prime minister , for the next four months, to workers who have lost income due to the pandemic – a short-term form of UBI. Now we need to expand it and make it work in the long-term, and we can. We must approach it differently from how we have in the past. We should neither view it as a hand-out, nor as a Band-Aid solution to add on to systems already in place. Instead, we should use the current twin crises to re-evaluate where we are “still digging”. To make UBI fly, we will need fair taxation. Countries will have to work together, exchanging data across borders, to stop people and corporations from evading taxes. Simply put, we must all pay our fair share. With good conscience, we can no longer privatize profit and socialize loss. Then stop the subsidies, notably fossil-fuel subsidies, which hinder the path to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals – especially climate-change targets. This would benefit us all, while generating financial resources not just for UBI, but also to support affected fossil-fuel companies. Warren Buffet and Bill Gates, among the richest people on the planet, have both advocated for the rich to pay more in taxes, the lack of which has led to a growing and enormous disparity. According to , 10% of the world’s richest own 85% of its wealth. According to some research, Europeans were already in favour of UBI prior to coronavirus. Multinationals too are not paying their fair share. Apple, Amazon, Google and Walmart to name just a few, generate mind-boggling profits and pay limited amounts in taxes, after taking advantage of all the wrinkles in tax systems. If the top 1,000 corporations in the world were fairly taxed, it would allow for a modest UBI to be tightly and reasonably dispensed in countries across the world. Something is simply wrong and broken when governments are deprived of funds they should justifiably have to construct a better state. Lest the naysayers think this is a theory from the left, the idea of tax competition has been touched upon, for years on end, by the Organization of Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Its members include the US, Canada and Western European countries. This is what its fiscal policy experts say: “To work effectively, a global economy needs some acceptable ground rules to guide governments and business. Such a framework can help business to move capital to locations where it can optimize its return, without impeding the aim of national governments to meet the legitimate expectations of their citizens for a fair share in the benefits and costs of globalization.” To achieve “acceptable ground-rules” and “a fair share in the benefits and costs” will require global coordination; because if one country begins taxing this way, highly mobile capital will flee to countries that do not. There is no question that UBI will be hard to get going. It is important to impartially consider the pros and cons, the reasons why it has not been implemented at scale so far, and what modalities would make it workable. A key complicating factor with implementing UBI – beyond its fiscal cost – is that it would not arrive in a vacuum. It would need to fit into and complement the existing set of social programmes, both insurance-based and needs-based. And rules would be needed to prevent double-dipping of benefits. Moving to such a system would need to ensure that the incentives to have a job remain intact. That is relatively simple to do: A UBI should be sufficient, to sustain a person at a modest minimum, leaving sufficient incentives to work, save, and invest. Finally, good arguments can be made for having very selective conditions – for instance, some that relate to public goods, like vaccinating all children and ensuring they attend school. Such selective conditions would not undermine the main purpose of eliminating poverty and allow low-income people to take calculated risks, to try to lift themselves out of poverty. DISCOVER What is the World Economic Forum doing about the coronavirus outbreak? Show more The alternative to not having UBI is worse – the rising likelihood of social unrest, conflict, unmanageable mass migration and the proliferation of extremist groups that capitalize and ferment on social disappointment. It is against this background that we seriously need to consider implementing a well-designed UBI, so shocks may hit, but they won’t destroy.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Poverty

Basic income eliminates poverty

Timothy Roscoe Carter 2014 (Basic Income Earth Network, The One Minute Case for a Basic Income , http://basicincome.org/bien/pdf/montreal2014/BIEN2014_Carter.pdf)

The one minute human rights case for a basic income: Poverty is not a natural tragedy like cancer or earthquakes. Poverty is a human caused tragedy like slavery or government oppression. Slavery is caused by societal recognition of humans as property. Government oppression is caused by governments punishing people for their beliefs or characteristics, and without due process of law. Poverty is caused by property laws that deny some people access to necessities. These types of tragedies can be ended by recognizing that humans have the right not to be subjected to tortuous conditions imposed by other humans. Humans have a right not to live in slavery. Humans have a right to be free of government oppression. And humans have a right not to live in poverty. A basic income is not a strategy for dealing with poverty; it is the elimination of poverty. The campaign for a basic income is a campaign for the abolition of poverty. It is the abolitionist movement of the 21st century.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Poverty

CP solves poverty while avoiding economic downturns.

Keely, 22 – Head of media relations

[Alistair Keely, “Basic income could cut poverty to lowest for 60 years at no net cost, according to new research ,” University of York, 5-20-2022, https://www.york.ac.uk/news-and-events/news/2022/research/basic-income-could-cut-poverty/, accessed 6-24-2023]

A new universal basic income model could cut poverty by more than half at no net cost, reducing it to its lowest level for 60 years, according to a report co-authored by a University of York academic. The report indicates a basic income could reduce pensioner poverty, as well as child poverty and working-age poverty. On the 80th anniversary of the historic Beveridge Report, the by the Basic Income Conversation and Compass represents the most substantive attempt yet to assess the impact of a basic income (UBI) scheme and the greater income security it provides. The fiscally neutral scheme involves no additional calls on the public finances and no net increase in taxation: the cost of the extra payments would be exactly offset by the extra revenue from internal changes in tax rates and National Insurance Contributions, the report’s authors say. Changes Under the model, compared to the current system: Child poverty falls by more than a half to 12.5%, taking it to below the level of 14.0% in 1977. Working-age poverty falls by just over a quarter, from 19.4% to 14.9%. Pensioner poverty falls by 54%, from 16.7% to 7.7%. This takes the level of pensioner poverty to well below the lowest post-1961 rate of 14% in the early 1980s. The Gini coefficient – a summary measure of inequality – falls by 12.5%, taking it back towards the peak equality achieved in the 1970s. The gains are concentrated among the poorest and the losses among higher-income groups. The model involves two broad sets of changes to the existing tax and benefit system: A guaranteed set of weekly payments which provide an income floor. These are £41 per child and £63 per adult of working age, making a guaranteed payment of nearly £11,000 a year for a family of four. A series of tax adjustments pay for the weekly basic income: the changes involve lowering the personal allowance to £750, a rise in existing tax rates of 3p in the pound and a change in the current system of National Insurance Contributions. As well as ensuring fiscal neutrality, these changes ensure that the gains are concentrated among the poorest, the report concludes. Evidence Professor Kate Pickett, from the University of York's and one of the author’s of the report, said: "Here is the evidence that a Universal Basic Income is affordable and beneficial - imagine how good it would feel to be tackling child poverty while enhancing everybody's financial security. This could be a giant step forward to a better post-Covid world." Neal Lawson, Director of Compass, added: "At a time of skyrocketing poverty, this report shows universal basic income can take us back to the lowest level of child poverty in over 50 years at no net cost to the Treasury. "In showing universal basic income can deliver record low levels of poverty with no extra burden on the nation’s finances, this report makes transformative change a political decision not an economic one."

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Poverty

UBI can solve poverty studies prove

Greenwell 22 --- Megan Greenwell is a journalist in New York. She is writing a book about private equity and how it affects workers.

["Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?" Washington Post. 10/24/2022 . Date Accessed: 6-22-2023.)

Now, though, as the country emerges from the pandemic, the guaranteed income movement sits at a crossroads. The pilot programs have created like Everett’s about how a small amount of money led to massive change in a recipient’s life. And a growing based on the experiments shows that guaranteed income works — that it pulls people out of poverty, improves health outcomes, and makes it easier for people to find jobs and take care of their children. If empirical evidence ruled the world, guaranteed income would be available to every poor person in America, and many of those people would no longer be poor. But empirical evidence does not rule the world, and it is far from clear that there is a political path forward for guaranteed income on a large scale. The city-level experiments cannot last forever: Stockton’s lapsed in early 2021, a few months after Tubbs lost his reelection bid to a Republican successor who showed no interest in trying to keep SEED going. On Capitol Hill, too, political momentum for handing out cash has waned. At the end of 2021, an extension of the expanded child tax credit — which was seen by many advocates as a key steppingstone to guaranteed income — was representing the state with the sixth-highest poverty rate in the country. Early in the pandemic, some in the guaranteed-income movement had begun to whisper about accelerating the timeline for taking their efforts nationwide. America’s most progressive social policies have always grown out of economic crises, so maybe covid would bring about a guaranteed-income policy in the next few years. But the failure of the expanded federal child tax credit diminished some of that optimism; many of those same advocates are now looking toward the long game. “You have to be willing to fight for something to the end,” says Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott, who recently launched a guaranteed-income experiment, “even if it doesn’t happen, even if you only push it a few feet further, even if it means that you die doing it.” Without a radical solution — like, say, giving people money with no strings attached — America will continue to be home to one of the worst rates of income inequality of any rich nation in the world. And from city to city, there is massive energy and momentum to keep expanding this experiment. But true believers also harbor a sense of anxiety about what the future holds. “I’m worried,” says Sean Kline, the associate director of Stanford University’s Basic Income Lab, “that these guaranteed income demonstrations are going to sunset and then it’s just going to go quiet.” For as long as America has had a poverty problem — which is to say, for its entire history — a small group of dreamers has proposed guaranteed income as a solution. The idea dates to the year the country was founded: Thomas Paine proposed a type of basic income in his 1776 pamphlet “Common Sense.” In the mid-20th century, it gained traction among Black American thinkers: In 1966, the Black Panthers’ Ten-Point Program demanded “employment or a guaranteed income” for everyone. A year later, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. wrote in his last book — “” — that government aid programs all have a “common failing: they are indirect. Each seeks to solve poverty by first solving something else. I am now convinced that the simplest approach will prove to be the most effective — the solution to poverty is to abolish it directly by a now widely discussed measure: the guaranteed income.” The first official proposal for a federal basic income program, though, came not from a paragon of progressivism, but from Richard Nixon. In 1969, Nixon introduced the Family Assistance Plan, which would have provided additional cash to poor families through a negative income tax — cutting checks to the poorest Americans instead of them paying the government — of $1,600 (about $13,000 today) for a family of four. The proposal was motivated by Nixon’s desire to replace the welfare system, which was unpopular with White blue-collar voters, but it never made it out of the Senate Finance Committee. Many skeptical politicians and voters feared that giving people cash would allow them to quit their jobs, stop looking for work or work less. Around the same time, a series of negative-income-tax experiments benefiting about 7,500 people in six states appeared to confirm those concerns: In Seattle and Denver, where the two largest programs took place, married men worked an average of 7 percent fewer hours after three years of the program, while married and single women worked 17 percent fewer hours. And while researchers didn’t look at any other measures of stability — whether participants were more likely to seek medical care, for example, or whether their children missed fewer days of school — they did observe a modest increase in the divorce rate. Those two factors were enough to destroy widespread interest in guaranteed-income experiments for several decades. Over time, however, interpretations of the 1970s experiments have morphed. Participants don’t seem to have dropped out of the labor force entirely, suggesting that the money may have given them the luxury of waiting a little longer for the right job to come around instead of rushing into the first available option. And working less sometimes means getting more education, which is almost always a net positive for the economy. An uptick in divorces can be a good thing too: Studies show that financial insecurity is a major contributor to keeping women in failing relationships, as in Everett’s case. In retrospect, the legacy of the first significant guaranteed-income pilots was a whole lot of complicated questions and limited information with which to answer them. If empirical evidence ruled the world, guaranteed income would be available to every poor person in America, and many would no longer be poor. But empirical evidence does not rule the world. Meanwhile, the concept of conditional cash-transfer programs — in other words, paying poor people for desirable behavior — was gaining steam in middle-income countries like Mexico and Brazil. In 2007, New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg launched a program called Opportunity NYC, which rewarded parents for tasks like taking their children to the doctor and completing job-training courses. The experiment had a moderate positive effect on families’ overall finances but did not boost academic performance among elementary-schoolers or increase families’ likelihood to seek preventive medical care, researchers found. Bloomberg did not extend the program when it expired in 2010. Among many poverty scholars and activists, conditional cash transfers are seen as a step in the right direction, but only a small one. To maximize the impact on poor people’s lives, they say, money must be a right, not a reward, because that’s the only way to empower people to make their own choices. “There are positive outcomes from conditional cash, there are positive outcomes from unconditional cash,” Kline says. “But I think for me, making it conditional misses a really fundamental value around trust, dignity, agency, freedom.” The word “dignity” comes up a lot among guaranteed-income advocates. Research shows that the vast majority of people don’t “waste” cash on vices like drugs and alcohol, but rather use even small amounts to improve their life circumstances dramatically. In a 2019 working paper, Nobel Prize-winning development economist Abhijit Banerjee and two co-authors concluded that the distribution of unconditional cash in low-income countries had positive effects on “income, assets, savings, borrowing, total expenditure, food expenditure, dietary diversity, school attendance, test scores, cognitive development, use of health facilities, labor force participation, child labor migration, domestic violence, women’s empowerment, marriage, fertility, and use of contraception, among others.” Banerjee is part of the research team studying the world’s largest basic-income program, which is midway through a 12-year run across 300 rural villages in Kenya. For about 5,000 people, that means an extra $22 a month for more than a decade. Thus far, the researchers have found, participants have been less likely to get sick or go hungry, and more likely to start a business. Advertisement In the United States, which has the world’s largest gross domestic product, the basic-income calculus is different than in places like Kenya, where a significant minority of people live on less than a dollar a day. But America has its own unique factors, like that inequality rate and a history of racist policies that have left a disproportionate number of people of color at the bottom of the income scale. Indeed, Tubbs and his counterparts frame basic income as something akin to reparations — a way to alleviate harm done to marginalized people by decades of biased and ineffective policy. The SEED recipients were struggling to survive because society had let them down, Tubbs argues, and the conventional methods of helping them were paternalistic and inadequate. In Baltimore, where more than 1 in 5 residents live below the federal poverty line, a new guaranteed-income pilot gives $1,000 a month to 200 recipients, all of them parents in high-crime neighborhoods. “We’re like the birthplace of racial redlining, right?” Scott says. “You’re not going to erase inequality, inequity that was caused by policy, without creating policy to do the opposite.” The notion of guaranteed income as a government-backed corrective for decades of racist policies has spread to dozens of cities, many led by young, Black mayors. Scott, 38, consults regularly with St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones, 50, whose city launched a guaranteed-income pilot in December 2021. St. Paul, Minn., Mayor Melvin Carter, 43, serves as co-chair of Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, and is a mentor to Tubbs, 32. According to Tubbs, guaranteed-income programs in Columbia, S.C.; Shreveport, La.; and Atlanta were the result of a Black mayors’ group text shortly after George Floyd’s murder in which he evangelized for King’s approach to solving urban poverty, before sending everyone a copy of “Where Do We Go From Here.” It’s no coincidence that these are the people plotting the future of guaranteed income in America, Scott argues. Many of them grew up in families that would have benefited from guaranteed-income programs. “We’re the first group of elected folks who actually lived through all of the s---,” he said, looking up from his phone for a rare moment during a 30-minute interview at Baltimore City Hall and drawing out the vowel sound in “lived.” “We lived through crack and heroin. We lived through . So all the stuff that folks are now talking about, we understand it in a way that no one else will.” The most basic objection to guaranteed-income programs is about cost. Providing $1,000 a month to every American regardless of income — which some scholars argue would make the policy more palatable than one targeted to people in poverty — would cost $3.1 trillion a year, nearly half the federal government’s entire budget in 2021. And yet, the adage that it is expensive to be poor applies not just to individuals, but to their governments. A mountain of evidence shows how tightly income inequality correlates with crime rates, education levels, drug abuse, incarceration, intimate-partner violence, and physical and mental health, which together cost billions upon billions of tax dollars. Numerous studies, for example, have found it would be cheaper to give homes to unhoused people than it is to cover all the costs associated with allowing them to stay on the streets, but progressives have faced an uphill climb to convince policymakers and voters that providing free housing is a worthwhile strategy. While there isn’t yet research on the potential economic benefits of guaranteed income specifically, studies of similar initiatives have shown that pulling people out of poverty generates a huge increase in tax revenue as well as savings on public assistance programs. First, though, the guaranteed-income movement had to show that its idea worked at all. When the current wave of experiments kicked off, the goal was to drown opponents in data demonstrating that the simplest idea for alleviating poverty was in fact the silver bullet it appeared to be. Of course, whether something “works” depends on the definition. Obviously giving people more money makes them less poor, but the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration team set out to show that as little as $500 a month — not nearly enough to replace actual income — would have a multiplier effect, allowing recipients to improve their employment prospects, their physical health and mental well-being, their children’s education, and their overall stability.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
UBI CP – CNDI 23 › Solvency › S – Growth

UBI stimulates the economy by increasing individual spending and aggregate demand – that leads to economic growth

Nikiforos 17 et al. Michalis Nikiforos, Marshall Steinbaum, Gennaro Zezza, [Michalis Nikiforos is a Levy Institute research scholar working in the State of the US and World Economies program.] ”Modeling the Macroeconomic Effects of a Universal Basic Income,” Roo-sevelt Institute. rooseveltinstitute.org/modeling-macroeconomic-effects-ubi/08.29.17.

How would a massive federal spending program like a universal basic income (UBI) affect the macroeconomy? We use the Levy Institute macroeconometric model to estimate the impact of three versions of such an unconditional cash assistance program over an eight-year time horizon. Overall, we find that the economy can not only withstand large increases in federal spending, but could also grow thanks to the stimulative effects of cash transfers on the economy. We examin[ing] three versions of unconditional cash transfers: $1,000 a month to all adults, $500 a month to all adults, and a $250 a month child allowance. For each of the three versions, we model the macroeconomic ef-fects of these transfers using two different financing plans - increasing the federal debt, or fully funding the increased spending with increased taxes on households - and com-pare the effects to the Levy model’s baseline growth rate forecast. Our findings include the following: • For all three designs, enacting a UBI and paying for it by increasing the federal debt would grow the economy. Under the smallest spending scenario, $250 per month for each child, GDP is 0.79% larger than under the baseline forecast after eight years. The model finds that the largest cash program - $1,000 for all adults annually - expands the economy by 12.56% over the baseline after eight years. After eight years of enactment, the stimulative effects of the program dissipate and GDP growth returns to the baseline forecast, but the level of output remains permanently higher. • When paying for the policy by increasing taxes on households, the Levy model forecasts no effect on the economy. In effect, it gives to households with one hand what it is takes away with the other. • However, when the model is adapted to include distributional effects, the economy grows, even in the tax-financed scenarios. This occurs because the distributional model incorporates the idea that an extra dollar in the hands of lower in-come households leads to higher spending. In other words, the households that pay more in taxes than they receive in cash assistance have a low propensity to consume, and those that receive more in assistance than they pay in taxes have a high propen sity to consume. Thus, even when the policy is tax- rather than debt-financed, there is an increase in output, employment, prices, and wages. Levy’s Keynesian model incor-porates a series of assumptions based on rigorous empirical studies of the micro and macro effects of unconditional cash transfers, taxation and government net spending and borrowing (see Marinescu (2017), Mason (2017), Coibion et al (2017), and Konczal and Steinbaum (2016)). Fundamentally, the larger the size of the UBI, the larger the increase in aggregate demand and thus the larger the resulting economy is. The indi-vidual macroeconomic indicators are (qualitatively) what one would predict given an increase in aggregate demand: in addition to the increase in output, employment, la-bor force participation, prices, and wages all go up as well . Even in a deficit-financed policy, an increase in the government’s liabilities is mitigated by the increase in aggre-gate demand. Specifically, the Levy model assumes that the economy is not currently operating near potential output (Mason 2017) and makes two related microeconomic assumptions: (1) unconditional cash transfers do not reduce household labor supply; and (2) increasing government revenue by increasing taxes levied on households does not change household behavior. Other macroeconomic models would make different, likely less optimistic forecasts, because they would disagree with these assumptions. Estimating the macroeconomic effects of UBI is a critical component of any policy eval-uation, as what would appear to be a zero-sum transfer in static terms (where money is transferred from some households to others) turns out to be positive sum in the macro simulation, thanks to the increase in aggregate demand and therefore in the size of the economy