Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Patriarchy Impacts

The patriarchy enforces structural violence against women in myriad ways

Mazurana and McKay ‘01 (Dyan Mazurana, Susan Mckay, Daniel J. Christine, Deborah DuNann Winter, Richard V. Wagner, Mazurana, PhD, is a Research Professor at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy where she co-directs the Gender Analysis and Women's Leadership Program, “Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology for the 21st century”, Prentice Hall, Chapter 11, 2001, https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/u.osu.edu/dist/b/7538/files/2014/10/Chapter-11-Women-Girls-Structural-Violence-Mazurana-McKay-xu91z1.pdf l)-CSC

The denial of girls’ and women’s right to food, health care, education, and life, as well as the undermining of their political, economic, and social rights are some of the most damaging and egregious forms of direct and structural patriarchal violence. Women and girls deserve to have their human rights recognized and enforced. The global community must reject all efforts to justify abuse on the basis of culture. While global women’s movements have had some effect in confronting violence and reducing inequality, structural violence against women and girls remains pandemic (Basu, 1997). Peace cannot be achieved until both indirect and direct forms of violence are dismantled. As we have seen throughout this chapter, patriarchal systems that discriminate against women and girls contribute to the eventual expression of direct violence. If we are serious about achieving peace, then we must be committed to women’s empowerment. As a result, research and activism on women’s issues are key elements of any serious peace agenda.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Prostitution

Poverty forces many women into prostitution. Economic structures present women with No Choice – its prostitution or starvation. Sex without true consent is Rape. A UBI prevents the sexual exploitation of women.

Story, 2017 – writer for Basic Income.org [Rae, Breaking the Vicious Circle: Basic Income and Sexual Exploitation March 18, TA]

I had an abusive boyfriend once. He lured me in with promises of provision and vindication. But he was a perfidious son of a gun, because the initial half of his Janus face was insidiously torn aside, to reveal his deft capacity for creating insecurity, isolation and intellectual dissonance. My boyfriend, my great, devastating, intoxicating love, was prostitution. Yes, like any other lover of an abuser, I was hooked in by his exaggerated claims of support and potential for actualisation — “I will empower you! I will make you free!” — smoke screening an undercurrent of exploitative tendencies. For me, for others, by the time we understand this, we have become trapped. Some people may wince at my comparing prostitution to abuse. I have been usefully informed, on a number of occasions, that it is a simply a job as any other. That it is not sexual exploitation, because women choose to enter into it freely. But even if that were so, what if the same women can’t manage to leave when they decide they have had enough? How many times, after that point, must they be utilised for sex effectively against their true will, before it becomes a violation? Being trapped in prostitution, relationship violence and cycles of survival sex can indeed be crushing to a person’s sense of capacity and the “outside” world can look increasingly hostile and difficult to negotiate. Coercive control, which often operates in these situations, is manipulative and extremely sophisticated. It tells you that you are not capable of surviving — let alone thriving — in any other way, just as it depletes you. It is like living with a blade at your throat, but being told it is for your own protection. What does all this have to do with Universal Basic Income (UBI)? Because as with all of the most effective manipulations, it contains a kernel of truth. If a woman is told by her abuser or her pimp — or by the propaganda of living in prostitution — that she could not survive without them, that voice is solidified by the material experience of structural inequality that poor women suffer. The crossroads between class and sex-based oppression is, indeed, best exemplified by a woman having to make a daily decision between sexual or domestic abuse, and poverty. So if our toxic situation has been the source of our “income” — in exchange for domestic, reproductive or sexual labour — what do we do if we want to leave? Refuge recommends that women escaping abusive or exploitative situations should seek out emergency accommodation from friends or family, but often abuse victims have been systematically disenfranchised from such social support and, as with high numbers of women in prostitution, have come through the care system, many didn’t have it in the first place. Women’s refuges are suffering from closures and on average 155 women are turned away each day, according to Women’s Aid. Shockingly, women escaping domestic violence are not automatically considered in priority need for social housing. That is even before you even get to prostitutes; an even less likely group to be considered a “worthy” cause. Indeed, our current welfare system is based on nebulous arbitrations of “need” and “worthiness,” which are often further gunned through the dubious prism of abstract bureaucracy. The Conservative government has seemingly decided that it cannot trust the word of doctors in assessing someone’s capacity for work and so subject often extremely vulnerable people to further “assessments.” Women who have been in prostitution or domestic violence often suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other psychological fragilities. For them these processes can be intimidating, due to the fear of being judged, blamed and dismissed as “undeserving.” This is even before we even get to the trials of unemployment benefit, not available to anyone whose partner works more than 24 hours per week — not much good if said partner has a predilection for controlling every aspect of your life. And if you’re under 35 and have no children you cannot suddenly decide to no longer submit to unwanted sex with men you don’t know, because you are not eligible for housing benefit contributions for your apartment. Or because you cannot find another job, due to your lack of experience or your anxiety, or both. Yes, I’ve seen many a woman make her Great Escape from abuse only to find her road blocked at every turn. Back she goes, to her hard fisted boyfriend or her brothel pimp — now more vulnerable and more convinced of the absolutenesses of her “destiny.” What is the first thing a woman escaping violence needs? To not have to “explain herself” to society — to beg even — to get the ticket out of her situation. Because asking such people to make the case for their right to freedom from abuse is an extension of that abuse. She has already had to try to explain to her “lover” why he should allow her to sleep safe that night, or to her pimp why she cannot work because her vagina has become torn and bruised. The idea behind UBI is that every member of society gets a basic monthly amount, irrespective of their social circumstances or their assumed worthiness. I am not going to make a more general case for UBI, as those arguments can be found elsewhere. However, it has instigated the twitching of my feminist ear because as a policy it has, under the right conditions, the potential to give victims of domestic violence and sexual exploitation a slightly easier out. In the 1970s there were a lot of debates about whether or not women should receive wages for housework, but many feminists felt that this would crystallise the idea that domesticity was women’s work. UBI on the other hand is a basic economic sustenance that is paid to a woman by virtue of her humanity, not her femininity, which is in any case a social imposition demanding of her submissive agreeableness. Of course UBI is not the full answer to the question of women’s exploitation. But because it does not require women to be the perfect victims, it is at least starting to ask the right questions.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Poverty

Poverty makes domestic violence worse

Barbara Niess-May,, 10-22-2019, SafeHouse Center Executive Director "The Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty," Safe House Center, https://www.safehousecenter.org/the-intersection-of-domestic-violence-and-poverty/

We do know that poverty disproportionately affects women and single mothers. What many do not know is how the intersection of poverty and domestic violence can 1) exacerbate the impact of the abuse, 2) cause an exceptional loss of resources for the survivor and 3) lessen positive outcomes for a survivor. In short, being poor further entraps the survivor in the abuse, and often lengthens any process she may go through to escape—as well lengthens entrapment in poverty. The intersection of poverty and domestic violence further endangers survivors, their children and our communities as a whole. Outcomes for women of color and immigrants are even more grave because safety net systems often ignore their unique needs. And programs like SafeHouse Center see a disproportionate amount of survivors from these populations.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Work

The status quo does not recognize labor traditionally done by women as work

Mazurana and McKay ‘01 (Dyan Mazurana, Susan Mckay, Daniel J. Christine, Deborah DuNann Winter, Richard V. Wagner, Mazurana, PhD, is a Research Professor at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy where she co-directs the Gender Analysis and Women's Leadership Program, “Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology for the 21st century”, Prentice Hall, Chapter 11, 2001, https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/u.osu.edu/dist/b/7538/files/2014/10/Chapter-11-Women-Girls-Structural-Violence-Mazurana-McKay-xu91z1.pdf l)-CSC

Structural patriarchal violence is apparent in economic and labor systems worldwide. Women make up more than half of the world’s population, and perform 66 percent of the world’s work, often in jobs more physically demanding and time-consuming than jobs held by men. However, women “earn only 10% of the world’s income and own 1% of the world’s property” (Elliott, 1996, p. 17), and they account for “70% of the world’s 1.3 billion absolute poor” (United Nations Development Fund for Women [UNIFEM], 1995, p. 1). Why? Women’s (Invisible) Work One of the primary reasons women are poor is that the majority of women’s work literally counts for nothing. Feminist economist Marilyn Waring (1988) has demonstrated how most governmental accounting systems do not recognize the majority of women’s labor because the rules of the 8 United Nations System of National Accounts (UNSNA) only count that which passes through the marketplace, i.e., anything that has currency-generating capacity. All countries wishing to be members of the United Nations, or borrow money from the World Bank, or acquire a loan from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), must adhere to rules set down in the UNSNA. Yet these systems’ economic policies place no value on peace, the preservation of natural resources, or unpaid labor, including that of reproducing and nurturing human life. Important decisions are made using figures generated from the UNSNA about whose needs are met, how to allocate taxes, which programs receive support and which do not. Some of these decisions literally determine who will live and who will die (Waring, 1988). While states may not publicly acknowledge women’s labor in informal economies, they nevertheless rely upon it. For example, the Philippine’s 2000 plan, a joint project of the Filipino government, the IMF, and the World Bank, relies on Filipino women staying in their jobs in the garment and electronic industries, sending home foreign currency from their jobs overseas as domestic and contract workers, and working as prostitutes or exotic dancers. For example, with the closure of U.S. military bases, the Filipino government is now counting on Filipino prostitutes and exotic dancers to switch their client base from soldiers to tourists and international businessmen, in order to continue the flow of foreign currency (Largoza-Maza, 1995). Thus, we can see that governments are often reluctant to challenge patriarchal structures of violence against women because economic and political systems rely on them.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Dependence

Economic dependence increases domestic violence against women

Asha DuMonthier and Malore Dusenbery, October 2016, "," institute for women’s policy reserch, - Annie

Violence affects survivors’ economic security in many ways (Shoener and Sussman 2013). Abuse can force survivors to take time off from school (Breiding et al. 2014) and decrease survivors’ longterm educational attainment, creating a disadvantage for future earnings and stability (Adams et al. 2013). It can also negatively influence survivors’ ability to obtain or maintain employment, leaving them at risk of unemployment and financial insecurity across the lifespan (Borchers et al. 2016; Crowne et al. 2011; Lindhorst, Oxford, and Gillmore 2007). Many domestic violence perpetrators use economic abuse to limit partners’ options and make them financially dependent on the abuser. Research indicates that economic abuse is highly prevalent. One study of 120 IPV survivors found that 94 percent had experienced some form of economic abuse, including employment sabotage (88 percent) and economic exploitation (79 percent; Postmus, Plummer, and Stylianou 2015). Common tactics include: withholding access to or information about finances, generating credit card debt, destroying property, committing identity theft, or purposefully ruining credit scores (Adams et al. 2008; Postmus et al. 2012). Some perpetrators prohibit survivors from working, interfere with their jobs, manipulate vital resources like child care and transportation, or increase abuse in response to survivors’ employment (Borchers et al. 2016; Brush 2003). Economic abuse is correlated strongly with other forms of IPV and is associated with a decrease in survivors’ economic self-sufficiency (Postmus et al. 2012). IPV also affects survivors’ economic security by leading to negative health outcomes and housing instability. One in five (20.0 percent) female survivors report one or more PTSD symptoms due to abuse (Breiding et al. 2014), which can affect their ability to maintain employment or complete an education. In addition, survivors may have to relocate to establish safety, be unable to pay other bills after paying rent, or face eviction due to the abuse or lack of economic resources (Baker, Cook, and Norris 2003; Pavao et al. 2007), and 38 percent of all survivors become homeless at some point in their lifetime (Baker, Cook, and Norris 2003). Survivors may also face significant out-of-pocket costs from having damaged or destroyed property, obtaining security equipment, and securing new technology, accounts, and routines

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Impact

Domestic Violence is a product of the Patriarchy, not a cause

Shore 19

(Jennifer Shore, October 2, 2019, “The Role of Patriarchy in Domestic Violence”, https://www.focusforhealth.org/the-role-of-patriarchy-in-domestic-violence/) Myra

Many professionals explore the dynamics of interpersonal violence and speculate the reasons abusers abuse their partners. The theory is that abusers may feel a need to control their partner because of low self-esteem, extreme jealousy, use of drugs or alcohol, difficulties in regulating anger, or feeling inferior to their partner in education and socioeconomic standing (their female partner is smarter and/or more successful than they are). Conversely, women stay with abusers because they have low self-esteem, have been raised or conditioned to tolerate abuse, naively believe their partner will change, or are caught up in the cycle of relationship violence. Violence against woman has been present in society since times immemorial. Calling it “domestic” violence perpetuates the notion that the violence is an interpersonal issue between two dysfunctional people. Reframing domestic abuse and intimate partner violence as patriarchal violence more accurately explains the roles of sexist ideology and male domination in the pervasiveness of violence against woman. Structural gender inequality imposes too many barriers for women when they try to leave abusive relationships. Despite the general sentiment that women should leave their abusers, they are actually at an increased risk for violence after they leave or attempt to leave. Women are 70 times more likely to be killed in the two weeks after leaving than at any other time during the relationship. Nearly half of all women who are murdered die at the hands of their current or former partners. In 70-80% of intimate partner homicides, no matter which partner was killed, the man physically abused the woman before the murder. The courts and the police offer little protection. The most common response to domestic violence by the police and the courts is a restraining order, or a protective order; a document that identifies the perpetrator as a potential threat to one victim (not to society in general) and instructs the abuser to have no physical or verbal contact with the victim Though the information is inconclusive, 11% -25% of woman (depending on the study) had active restraining orders at the time of their murder. Though there is some evidence of long-term benefit to a restraining order, initially there is a 21% chance of an escalation in violent behavior after an order of protection is issued. What we do know conclusively about restraining orders is that they can’t guarantee safety as much as putting the perpetrator in jail. Less than 2% of abusers ever receive any jail time. In many cases, there are very few places women can go that ensure family safety. Single women with children are more likely to live in poverty under normal circumstances but add the complications that domestic abuse may bring (lack of access to bank accounts, inconsistent work histories, fear of requesting child support, complex post-traumatic stress disorder) make the realities of leaving almost impossible. Half of all homeless women and children in the US are fleeing domestic violence. Though domestic abuse shelters are a temporary option for many women and children, women still fear retaliation from their abusers and consequences from the system; a system heavily steeped in patriarchy (a system of society or government in which men hold the power and women are largely excluded from it). Gender inequality and reinforcement of patriarchal ideology is demonstrated with the treatment of domestic violence victims by the police, the family and criminal courts, and child protective services. Often women who seek protection from their abusers are at risk for losing their children. Many states have policies that punish women for failing to protect their children when they live in homes with domestic violence. The women can be held responsible by Child Protective Services (CPS) for subjecting their children to witnessing domestic abuse, even when they are the victims of the abuse. This extreme scenario of victim blaming accepts the notion that women are equally responsible for the violence because of the fact they are not leaving their abusers. To add further insult to injury, though CPS guidelines vary by state, parents can be charged with neglect when children are living in poverty. A mother’s decision to leave an abusive spouse, which results in her child living in homelessness and poverty, puts her at risk for having her children taken from her. Many women stay in abusive relationships to protect their children from abuse. An estimated overlap of 30-50% between spousal abuse and child abuse (men who abuse their partners are more likely to abuse their children), yet despite this, many abusers are successful in getting unsupervised access and unrestricted custody of their children. A 2012 report by the American Judges Association states that, “batterers have been able to convince authorities that the victim is unfit or undeserving of sole custody in approximately 70% of challenged cases.” Researchers speculate that men who are abusive to their partners typically have parenting styles that have detrimental impact on children as well. Family courts tend to downplay or ignore the abuser tendencies of the father and accept the believe that the domestic violence is an unhealthy pattern between both parents. Courts tend to overlook a father’s history of spousal abuse and will applaud what they see as a positive attribute- their interest in being a part of the child’s life. Abuse survivors recognize this interest for what it is; an attempt to retain control over their victim by using their children. The conversation about Domestic Violence must be elevated from “why doesn’t she leave” to “what are we doing to perpetuate and tolerate objectification and subordination of women?” It has been consistently demonstrated that men who accept very patriarchal beliefs about gender roles have a higher likelihood of engaging in violence against women. To resist patriarchal ideology we all, men and women, need to explore our beliefs and actions to bring consciousness to what we are doing to condone toxic masculinity, male privilege, and gender inequality. Toxic masculinity is what can come of teaching boys that they can’t express emotion openly, that they must be tough and can gain power through physical strength, that being like a “girl” means they are weak and inferior. Gender violence has its roots in the socialization of men to be more powerful than women and that they are taught to gain power by dominating others. Toxic masculinity hurts everyone, including boys. Rigid traditional gender stereotypes prevent male victims of sexual assault to come forward, men who are in domestically abusive situations to seek help (1 in 7 men have experienced physical violence from a male or female partner) and has been linked to adult male depression and substance abuse. The perpetrator and the victim are both a symptom of the larger problem, patriarchy and gender inequality.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Impact

Abuse entrenches patriarchal systems of control

Hill 20 (Jess Hill, reporter, “Patriarchy and power: how socialisation underpins abusive behaviour”, The Guardian, 3/7/2020, ) - CSC

Coercive control is a very particular kind of domestic abuse. It’s not a “reaction” to stress, nor is it triggered by alcohol or drugs. It’s an ongoing system of control, in which the abusive partner seeks to override their partner’s autonomy and destroy their sense of self. The end game – whether the perpetrator knowingly sets out to achieve it – is to make their partner entirely subordinate; a “willing slave”. To do this, they isolate, micro-manage, humiliate, degrade, surveil, gaslight and create an environment of confusion, contradiction and extreme threat. The feeling victims have, as the British survivor-advocate Min Grob tweeted the other day, is that the rug has been pulled from under your feet. “You become disoriented, hyper vigilant, confused and most likely sleep-deprived. You are walking on eggshells. Afraid you’re going mad. Afraid to make them mad. Afraid. All the time. Sometimes not even knowing why you’re in fear but the panic is there. Always.” This abuse can also be incredibly hard for the victim to detect, because it happens slowly, bit by bit. It’s the total mental dislocation of coercive control – which Amnesty International has classified as torture – that is the hardest thing to recover from. Coercive controllers may use extreme physical or sexual violence; or, as was reportedly the case with Rowan Baxter, no physical violence at all. For more than 40 years, women and children have been saying that except for extreme violence, the coercive control is the worst part. In fact, one of the most common refrains from victims of coercive control is “I wish he’d just hit me”. So many reasons, but in cases of coercive control, I think it boils down to this. Many women don’t know they are experiencing abuse until they are already in situations that are incredibly dangerous – partly because coercive control is so poorly understood, but also because the perpetrator makes it invisible. By the time victims realise the danger they’re in, many believe no system will ever be powerful enough to keep them safe. If they do report to police – if something reportable actually occurs – they are making a terrifying gamble. Will they get an officer who’s sympathetic and proactive? Will reporting their partner make him more dangerous? What if child protection gets involved? What if he contests for custody? There are absolutely no guarantees that they (or their children) will be protected. Their suspicion that the system is not powerful enough to protect them is too often correct. The justice system is not only full of holes; too often it actively colludes with the perpetrator (especially the family law system). So they stay, even after they want to leave, and know it’s dangerous. They stay because it may be even more dangerous to leave. Until the justice system properly assesses and responds to risk, and as long as women are made to be responsible for their own safety, we will continue to see an intractable domestic homicide rate. How do some men come to feel so entitled to their power over women? Thousands of years of patriarchy has laid pretty good groundwork for this – and it’s not so long since a wife was considered her husband’s property, and had no legal rights whatsoever. It was only in the 1980s that new laws against marital rape recognised that men didn’t have the right to demand sex with their wives anytime they wanted; prior to that, consent was considered to have been given on the wedding day and never revoked. Today, we still live in a society that entrenches women’s subordination at every level – from the home, to the boardroom, to our parliament. Even in the courtroom, as we see so often. As the Harvard psychiatrist Judith Herman writes: “The legal system is designed to protect men from the superior power of the state but not to protect women or children from the superior power of men.” I’m sure any survivor reading this will know exactly what she’s talking about. Men don’t abuse women because society tells them it’s OK. Men abuse women because society tells them they are entitled to be in control. In fact, society says that if they are not in control, they won’t succeed – they won’t get the girl, they won’t get the money, and they will be vulnerable to the violence and control of other men. It says that if they fail to assert themselves like “real men”, they will end up poor and alone. But we don’t just see men being entitled to power over their partners; some women identify with this, too. That’s because “having power over” is valued within patriarchy – much more for men than it is for women – but nevertheless, it is regarded generally as a sign of strength to claim power over others. To add more complication, in many perpetrators who have had trauma or attachment disruption in their childhoods, you get another layer of entitlement: as one perpetrator told me “I never had any control over anything as a child, and I vowed that I would never let that happen to me again. I would always be in control.”

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Impact

DV feeds into the patriarchy

Shore ’19, Executive Director, Focus for Health

“The Role of Patriarchy in Domestic Violence,” Oct 2, 2019, - EC

Gender inequality and reinforcement of patriarchal ideology is demonstrated with the treatment of domestic violence victims by the police, the family and criminal courts, and child protective services. Often women who seek protection from their abusers are at risk for losing their children. Many states have policies that punish women for failing to protect their children when they live in homes with domestic violence. The women can be held responsible by Child Protective Services (CPS) for subjecting their children to witnessing domestic abuse, even when they are the victims of the abuse. This extreme scenario of victim blaming accepts the notion that women are equally responsible for the violence because of the fact they are not leaving their abusers. To add further insult to injury, though CPS guidelines vary by state, parents can be charged with neglect when children are living in poverty. A mother’s decision to leave an abusive spouse, which results in her child living in homelessness and poverty, puts her at risk for having her children taken from her. Many women stay in abusive relationships to protect their children from abuse. An estimated overlap of 30-50% between spousal abuse and child abuse (men who abuse their partners are more likely to abuse their children), yet despite this, many abusers are successful in getting unsupervised access and unrestricted custody of their children. A 2012 report by the American Judges Association states that, “batterers have been able to convince authorities that the victim is unfit or undeserving of sole custody in approximately 70% of challenged cases.” Researchers speculate that men who are abusive to their partners typically have parenting styles that have detrimental impact on children as well. Family courts tend to downplay or ignore the abuser tendencies of the father and accept the believe that the domestic violence is an unhealthy pattern between both parents. Courts tend to overlook a father’s history of spousal abuse and will applaud what they see as a positive attribute- their interest in being a part of the child’s life. Abuse survivors recognize this interest for what it is; an attempt to retain control over their victim by using their children. The conversation about Domestic Violence must be elevated from “why doesn’t she leave” to “what are we doing to perpetuate and tolerate objectification and subordination of women?” It has been consistently demonstrated that men who accept very patriarchal beliefs about gender roles have a higher likelihood of engaging in violence against women. To resist patriarchal ideology we all, men and women, need to explore our beliefs and actions to bring consciousness to what we are doing to condone toxic masculinity, male privilege, and gender inequality. Toxic masculinity is what can come of teaching boys that they can’t express emotion openly, that they must be tough and can gain power through physical strength, that being like a “girl” means they are weak and inferior. Gender violence has its roots in the socialization of men to be more powerful than women and that they are taught to gain power by dominating others. Toxic masculinity hurts everyone, including boys. Rigid traditional gender stereotypes prevent male victims of sexual assault to come forward, men who are in domestically abusive situations to seek help (1 in 7 men have experienced physical violence from a male or female partner) and has been linked to adult male depression and substance abuse. The perpetrator and the victim are both a symptom of the larger problem, patriarchy and gender inequality.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Increasing

COVID worsened domestic violence due to economic risks and lockdown

Council on Criminal Justice, February 24, 2021, “New Analysis Shows 8% Increase in U.S. Domestic Violence Incidents Following Pandemic Stay-At-Home Orders”, - Myra

A released today by the shows that domestic violence incidents in the U.S. increased by 8.1% following the imposition of lockdown orders during the 2020 pandemic. The findings are based on a systematic review of multiple U.S. and international studies that compared changes in the number of domestic violence incidents before and after jurisdictions began imposing stay-at-home restrictions early last year. The studies draw on a wide range of data, from logs of police calls for service to domestic violence crime reports, emergency hotline registries, health records, and other administrative documents. While describing the evidence of an increase as strong, the authors say the precise dynamics driving the trend are less clear. They believe that lockdowns and pandemic-related economic impacts likely exacerbated factors typically associated with domestic violence, such as increased unemployment, stress associated with childcare and homeschooling, and increased financial insecurity, and that the increased use of alcohol and other substances as a coping strategy also may have elevated the threat. In addition, the authors note that by isolating parents and children in their homes, the pandemic separated potential victims from the network of friends, neighbors, teachers, and other individuals capable of reporting signs of abuse and helping those at risk escape a dangerous environment. “

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Increasing

COVID worsened domestic violence due to economic risks and lockdown

Council on Criminal Justice, February 24, 2021, “New Analysis Shows 8% Increase in U.S. Domestic Violence Incidents Following Pandemic Stay-At-Home Orders”, - Myra

A released today by the shows that domestic violence incidents in the U.S. increased by 8.1% following the imposition of lockdown orders during the 2020 pandemic. The findings are based on a systematic review of multiple U.S. and international studies that compared changes in the number of domestic violence incidents before and after jurisdictions began imposing stay-at-home restrictions early last year. The studies draw on a wide range of data, from logs of police calls for service to domestic violence crime reports, emergency hotline registries, health records, and other administrative documents. While describing the evidence of an increase as strong, the authors say the precise dynamics driving the trend are less clear. They believe that lockdowns and pandemic-related economic impacts likely exacerbated factors typically associated with domestic violence, such as increased unemployment, stress associated with childcare and homeschooling, and increased financial insecurity, and that the increased use of alcohol and other substances as a coping strategy also may have elevated the threat. In addition, the authors note that by isolating parents and children in their homes, the pandemic separated potential victims from the network of friends, neighbors, teachers, and other individuals capable of reporting signs of abuse and helping those at risk escape a dangerous environment. “

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Increasing

Overturn of Roe v Wave increased reports of sexual DV

Santhanam 6 28, Health Reporter and Coordinating Producer for Polling for the PBS NewsHour, Data Producer

“Why post-Roe abortion restrictions worry domestic violence experts,” PBS, June 28, 2023 - EC

In the past year since the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization ruling reversed Roe’s protections, calls about reproductive coercion have nearly doubled, Justice said, and more than 27,000 people overall reported non-consensual sex with an intimate partner. “Denying the individual the right to control their own body is now a tool,” she said. “And now, because of these laws and what wound up being the Dobbs decision, [abusive partners] have even more power and control, because survivors have even less options and increased barriers to obtain that care.” For years, a majority of Americans have opposed the elimination of Roe v. Wade. The Supreme Court’s decision to remove federal protections for abortion rights did not change those attitudes, according to the latest PBS NewsHour/NPR/Marist poll. Another poll from April found that people were more likely to oppose laws against abortion when they lived in states where heightened restrictions are in place, compared to people who have not yet lived under those measures. Even before the Supreme Court handed down its decision a year ago, states were already restricting access to abortion, making it more difficult for pregnant people to get the services they needed, and for providers to offer those services. After Dobbs, trigger bans went into effect, leading to more restrictions on abortion-related services. According to the Guttmacher Institute, a reproductive health research and policy organization, laws in 13 states have banned abortion. In nearly a dozen more, the institute reports that abortion access is ensnared in legal turmoil or only available during such a narrow window of pregnancy to be functionally off-limits for most people. In Aurora, Colorado, Dr. Michael Belmonte has noticed a 50-percent uptick in patients coming to his OB/GYN clinic because they have nowhere else to turn after the Dobbs decision was finalized. Some of them are arriving later in their pregnancies and with more complications. One patient had crossed state lines, driving while hemorrhaging after she had been told she could not receive care, Belmonte said. Some experts, like Jacquelyn Campbell, a professor of nursing at Johns Hopkins University, are concerned that states with abortion restrictions will see a rise in maternal mortality and deaths among pregnant and postpartum people due to homicide, suicide and overdose. “They’re all connected with domestic violence,” she said.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › DV Increasing

Assault against women is only increasing

Wright 22 (Andrew Wright, December 8, 2022, “U.S. domestic and sexual violence crisis only getting worse”, ) - Myra

According to a recent study on emergency department visits for sexual assault, visits were 15 times higher (1,533%) in 2019 than in 2006 in the U.S. According to CNN, the total emergency department visits increased only 1.2 times over the same period. These findings drastically outpace the growth in law enforcement reports of sexual violence. Although reports to law enforcement did go up, they were merely a fraction of those seeking treatment. The recently published study, which was conducted by researchers at the University of Michigan, found the cause for this increase to be a combination of population growth, the rise in social justice movements, and a change to the International Classification of Diseases (or ICD) code. Before 2015, the ninth revision of the code (ICD-9), there existed only one code for adult sexual assault. However, ICD-10, which was adopted at the end of 2015, includes codes for suspected sexual assault, confirmed sexual assault, and forced penetration. It was also found that hospital admissions have been on the decline: Roughly 95% of those survivors are discharged from the department without hospital admission. Although it’s still unclear why that is, it’s all the more concerning considering the fraction of those who seek out care and treatment after an assault. One study published in 2012 found that only 21% of rape victims would seek care afterwards. Likewise, only 40% of assaults and rape were reported to law enforcement in 2017, which dropped to 25% in 2018. Rape incidents have also been increasing by 2.9% annually.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › Advantage Extensions › Structural Barriers

Squo Governments fail to respond to patriarchal structural violence

Mazurana and McKay ‘01 (Dyan Mazurana, Susan Mckay, Daniel J. Christine, Deborah DuNann Winter, Richard V. Wagner, Mazurana, PhD, is a Research Professor at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy where she co-directs the Gender Analysis and Women's Leadership Program, “Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology for the 21st century”, Prentice Hall, Chapter 11, 2001, https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/u.osu.edu/dist/b/7538/files/2014/10/Chapter-11-Women-Girls-Structural-Violence-Mazurana-McKay-xu91z1.pdf l)-CSC

The male bias inherent in (patriarchal) democracy has led to forms of patriarchal structural violence that relegate “women’s issues” to the “private” realm where they become “private matters” that the state does not address. This bias is perhaps nowhere clearer than in the issue of domestic violence, where male bias greatly impairs the ability of police, judges, and lawmakers from recognizing the violent behavior in the family. “The view that ‘as a family matter’ battery is less important, is based on men’s, not women’s perceptions” (Murray & O’Regan, 1991, p. 45). The multiple forms of domestic violence that women suffer have profound physical and psychological effects (Herman, 1992; Kelly, 1993), prompting international calls for domestic violence to be recognized as a form of torture (Copelon, 1994). Governmental support of patriarchal structural violence through its inattention to “private” matters is apparent throughout the world. Until 1991, the murder of a wife in Brazil was legal—it was considered an honor killing and was done to preserve the family’s honor because of a woman’s transgression. In many areas of the world, men are free to rape their wives with no threat of legal repercussions (Mertus, 1995). Other examples of government-sponsored patriarchal structural violence include laws and systems that condone particular forms of violence against women, deny women control over their bodies, provide no assistance with child care and maternity leave, make no attempt to remedy child support defaults, and fail to provide unemployment protection to women who work within the “private” realm in domestic service or farm work (Waring, 1988; Murray & O’Regan, 1991). Because governments rarely address patriarchal structural violence or fight for women’s rights, progress for women is largely made by women working for the recognition and enforcement of women’s rights. As a result, in countries such as Australia, Brazil, Britain, Columbia, India, Sri Lanka, and the United States, violence against women in the home has been identified and some forms of it criminalized (Fineman & Mykitiuk, 1994).

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Framing

Gender analysis informs decision-making – our method come prior to plan.

Hearn, et al. 22 (Jeffery Richard is a British sociologist, and Research Professor at the University of Huddersfield, and Professor at the Hanken School of Economics. Sofia Strid is Associate Professor of Gender Studies at Örebro University. Anne Laure Humbert, PhD, is a Reader in Gender. and Diversity and Director of the Centre for Diversity. Dag Balkmar is Associate Professor (Docent) and Senior Lecturer in Gender Studies at Örebro University. “Violence Regimes: A Useful Concept for Social Politics, Social Analysis, and Social Theory.” Theory and Society, vol. 51, no. 4, Feb. 2022, pp. 565–94, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11186-022-09474-4. Accessed 14 July 2023. //dre)

Violence, and gendered and intersectional forms of violence, are an extensive global problem connected to power, inequalities, health, economy, crime and security, impacting all societies (Krug et al., 2002). Violence can also be a point of departure to examine and intervene in social life, whether the focus is on social politics,Footnote1 social analysis or theoretical development (Hearn et al., 2016). Indeed, as a driving principle, analyzing and understanding violence is key for its reduction, as a fundamental link between theory and society. The range and depth of both violence and research on violence are immense. Within this range, there is considerable research that examines the co-variationFootnote2 of and interconnections both amongst and between forms of violence (for example, homicide, child abuse, civil conflict) and further aspects of violence (political organizing, policy development against violence, knowledge production, measurement, definitions/inclusions/exclusions). However, much research on violence remains fragmented in different disciplinary and with substantive focuses on different forms or aspects of violence. This paper addresses two linked questions: the extent to which research literature reports on how different forms and aspects of violence co-vary and interconnect, or not; and the need to work towards a more inclusive, more comprehensive conceptualization of violence than more partial approaches. Specifically, the paper addresses two key research questions: How can the extent to which specific forms and aspects of violence co-vary and interconnect, as reported in research literature, be usefully conceptualized and theorized in a more inclusive, more comprehensive way? What difference would a more inclusive, more comprehensive conceptualization of violence make to social politics, social analysis, and social theorizing on and against violence? We address these questions by arguing that the concept of violence regime (Hearn et al., 2020; Strid et al., 2021) – that is, the governance and production of forms and aspects of violence – constitutes a more inclusive and more comprehensive approach to such interconnections (or lack thereof), and a way of dealing with tensions and limitations in more partial frameworks. We also hypothesize that forms and aspects of violence co-vary with each other to constitute a violence regime. Furthermore, we hypothesize that such co-variance is likely to be greater than with other inequalities and measures that are often assumed to ‘cause’ violence: in this view, a violence regime is relatively autonomous rather than merely a subset of other inequalities. In line with Davenport’s (2021) recent call for “integral violence studies”, this paper aims to contribute to overcoming the fragmentation of policy and politics, empirical research and theoretical development on violence, and its different forms and aspects, and to further interdisciplinary research on violence. These are important issues for social politics, social analysis, and social theory. Accordingly, we see violence regimes as a policy concept, an empirical concept, and a theoretical concept. But, there is an immediate problem: namely and simply, what is violence? There are multiple contestations of what violences are – physical violence, assault, sexual violence, coercive control, homicide, genocide, as well as less directly physical violences, such as cultural, symbolic, epistemic and systemic violence (Bourdieu, 1998; Žižek, 2008). Violence includes, but is not limited to, state violence, economic violence, terrorism, interpersonal violence, gender-based violence (GBV), violence against women, anti-lesbian, gay and transgender violence, intimate partner violence, gang violence, hate crime, cyberviolence, and stalking. So, is violence a set of material bodily actions and effects? A range of discursive constructions? Is violence more structural in character, as, for example, through institutions or structural inequalities? Or all of these, intersectionally gendered? In this paper, we use illustrative examples from GBV, whilst not restricting discussion to gendered violence regimes.Footnote3 In this text, violence and violence regimes are understood as material-discursive, including how violence is defined, what is included and excluded as violence, in knowledge production on violence, and as operating across micro/interpersonal, meso/institutional, and macro/(trans)societal scales. Theoretically, we locate ourselves in debates on the close relations of materiality and discourse, such that recognitions and contestations of violence are part of the problem of violence. Indeed, the problem of what violence ‘is’, and how violence is named, defined, limited, understood and explained, is a key question across many realms: everyday life, social politics, social analysis, and social theory more broadly, albeit unevenly. Knowledge production on violence, who gets to define violence, contestations on definitions, are part of violence regimes, thus engaging with wider theoretical debates, such as on regimes of truth (Foucault, 1980). Violence as an open-ended, but not relativist, concept that refers to multiple ways in which humansFootnote4 can be attacked, transgressed, harmed, destroyed, materially-discursively. Violence certainly involves direct physicality, but it is more than that, as with physical harms without direct physical violence. The violence regime approach brings a focus on violence, and re-centres violence – that it is not only concerned with specific ‘types’ of violence but sees violence as both cause and consequence of social realities. As such, this paper draws on and develops the very long tradition of feminist theory, practice and research on violence (for example, Brownmiller, 1975; Hanmer and Maynard, 1997; Hester et al., 1996; Kelly, 1988; MacKinnon, 1982; Moran and Sharpe, 2004; Gordon and Meyer, 2007). We consider uses of violence regimes as a heuristic analytical tool for social politics, social analysis, and social theory. Building on earlier empirical, policy and conceptual work (Hearn et al., 2020; Humbert et al., 2021; Strid et al., 2021), the concept of violence regime forces consideration of different understandings of what is to count as violence, from direct killing to forms of violence often not recognized as violence at all, such as violence to non-humans, colonial violence, slow and environmental violence. Following this introduction, we continue by examining how studies on violence are subject to disciplinary fragmentation, as a precursor to examining five inspirations and ways of moving towards a broadened, more inclusive conceptualization: violence regime. The following section focuses on the notion of regime more directly, building on earlier work, and spells out the violence regime concept. The latter parts of the paper consider three applications of violence regimes – in social politics, social analysis, and social theory. In the first case, violence regimes address and inform politics, policy and policy development, labeled here as social politics, around violence, such as gender-based violence, violence against women (VAW), intimate partner violence (IPV), anti-lesbian, gay and transgender violence. Extending understandings of violence is important for policy formulation, development and implementation, whether working at the UN scale, regionally as in, say, the Council of Europe, nationally or locally. More comprehensive analysis of the complexities of violence is likely to demand transcending both disciplinary and policy area boundaries, with policy responses often depending on where within state (or parastate) machinery violence policy is located, for example, war and militarism in ministries of defence, violent crime in ministries of justice. Second, violence regimes, and indeed intersectional gender violence regimes, are part and parcel of social analysis, including the analysis of the place and relation of violence to societal contexts, broadly based structures of inequality, governance, welfare state regimes, gender regimes, and social movements, and empirical data thereon. Third, violence regimes engage with social theory. One may ask: what assumptions on the construction of the subject, for example, ‘rational’ or individualist, pertain in different social theories, in relation to violence, and the experience of being violated? Specifically, social theory is partly constructed by, through and in relation to violence, including the frequent exclusion of the knowledges of the violated, sometimes but not only through killing. The concluding section discusses further implications of the conceptualization of violence regimes.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Framing

Framework is key to this debate – advocating a basic income by incorporating a feminist perspective is critical to changing patriarchal norms and avoiding the negative solvency turns.

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, ]

Thus feminists might be expected strongly to support the introduction of a basic income.34 Yet this is not the case. Some feminists are critical of the idea because they fear a basic income would reinforce the existing sexual division of labor and women’s lesser citizenship. They argue that the provision of an income without having to engage in paid employment would, in light of women’s position in the labor market combined with lingering beliefs about the proper place and tasks of women and men, give women an even greater incentive to undertake more unpaid caring work in the household, and, conversely, men would have another incentive to freeride. A basic income, that is, would reinforce existing limitations on women’s freedom.35 This objection illustrates the importance of the reasons advanced for supporting a basic income. The probability of feminist fears being borne out is higher, for example, when the argument is made that to avoid weakening the “incentive to work” a basic income should be below subsistence level. This “incentive” is promoted with men and paid employment in mind. A basic income at this level provides no incentive for wives to “work” (i.e., enter paid employment); rather, it would encourage them to do more unpaid caring work. Again, to support basic income on the grounds that it would improve the living standards of the poorest sectors of the population does not promote consideration of the structural connections between marriage, employment, and citizenship, and the private and public sexual division of labor. Without the debates about basic income being informed by feminist arguments, and a concern for democratization (and genuine democratization necessarily includes women’s freedom and standing as citizens), the discussion will revolve around ways of tinkering with the existing system rather than encouraging thinking about how it might be made more democratic. Putting democratization at the center requires attention to institutional structures, especially the institutions of marriage and employment. For instance, Ackerman and Alstott remark in The Stakeholder Society that the “case for stakeholding does not ultimately rest on its effects on employment, marriage, or crime. It rests on each American’s claim to respect as a free and equal citizen.”36 However (leaving crime aside), the respect accorded to women and men as free and equal citizens has a great deal to do with the institutions of marriage and employment. It is not possible to understand women’s lesser citizenship, as Ackerman and Alstott show in their discussion of social security, without understanding the relationship between their position as wives and men’s position as workers.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Framing

The aff is a tactical reduction in patriarchy – policymaking is good when gender is prioritized. A basic income would benefit the most vulnerable women.

Juliana Uhuru Bidadanure, 2019, Assistant Professor of Philosophy and, by courtesy, of Political Science, at Stanford University as well as the founder and faculty director of the Stanford Basic Income Lab, "The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income," Annual Reviews, https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-polisci-050317-070954, KL

There is no clear way to settle those discussions, but I offer three comments to conclude this conversation on gender and UBI. First, it seems that the outcome of this debate now largely depends more on empirics than on values (Robeyns 2008). The feminists discussed in this section roughly agree that gendered social norms must be challenged and that care work must be revalued, but they disagree in their hypotheses about what would happen under UBI. This disagreement sets a research agenda for those experimenting with UBI throughout the world. They must find out, for instance, what the precise combined gender and labor effects of UBI would be in different institutional contexts. Since many jobs are alienating and precarious, it is not clear that finding a drop in employment rate among women would necessarily be regrettable, all things considered. We would need to find out more than just how many women are likely to drop out of the labor market. As Weeks (2011, p. 124) points out, “slavery to an assembly line is not a liberation from slavery to a kitchen sink.” We would need to know precisely which women are likely to give up which jobs, and to do what. To help move this conversation forward, empiricists must also look at the concern that UBI would contribute to the defunding of public goods and find out how reasonable it really is. This would require also studying the framing of various UBI proposals and their reception (to find out whether progressive proposals are more popular than regressive ones, for instance).

A second comment has to do with heterogeneity among women. It is important for this debate to start from an assessment of the situation of the most vulnerable women and whether UBI would benefit them, rather than focusing the debate on whether UBI can further the more abstract goal of gender justice. For many women, lack of formal employment is actually not the main problem. The problem is rather the inability to perform the care work they want to perform without being stigmatized or condemned to a life of poverty or dependence. For some women, the problem is overwork—that they are combining several low-paying jobs to support their children and end up left with too little time to spend with them. Too often socially invisible, many domestic workers are bound to abusive employers by a lack of exit options. Lacking the economic security needed to have exit options also makes sex workers more vulnerable to abuse. The Sex Workers Open University (2017) in fact demands UBI on the basis that “[i]f every person in the UK was entitled to a universal basic income, no one would be pushed by absolute poverty into selling sex.” The conversation on whether UBI should be endorsed on grounds of gender justice should be dependent, at least to some extent, on what UBI would do to empower the women who are currently most economically insecure and most vulnerable to domination.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Solvency

BI addresses gender-biased discrimination, breaks dependency, challenges social norms, and is an essential part of in the workforce without economic risks.

Flanigan ’18, Jessica is an assistant professor of leadership studies and philosophy, politics, economics, and law at the University of Richmond, “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income,” SLATE, Jan 25, 2018, -EC

The case for a basic income, a policy that would give all citizens cash payments at regular intervals throughout their lives, is gaining traction. Prominent tech entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, academics across the ideological spectrum from Philippe Van Parijs to Charles Murray, labor organizers like Andy Stern, and policymakers such as Michael Tubbs, the 27-year-old mayor of Stockton, California, support basic income policies as a way of reducing poverty and mitigating the negative impact of unemployment due to automation. But they understate the feminist case for giving people cash. Proponents of the UBI would do well to acknowledge the gender implications of the policy, and feminists, in turn, should throw their support behind the movement.

Here are the top three reasons UBI is a feminist cause:

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Solvency

Basic income reduces gendered violence in relationships by reducing dependence on abusive partners and freeing women from exploitative jobs.

Clark ’21 (Rebecca L Clark, doctoral candidate in political theory at Nuffield College, University of Oxford, “Should Feminists Endorse a Universal Basic Income?”, University of Oxford, 3/18/2021, CSC

I now turn to a second criterion for gender justice enhancement, which I deem to be highly plausible: Anti-Exploitation Criterion: all else being equal, a reduction in gendered exploitation is gender-justice enhancing. I consider a form of exploitation to be gendered if it is systematically the case that, in a given type of exploitable dependency relationship, the subordinate agent is a woman[11]. Fraser identifies three common types of exploitable dependencies: on a family member, on a boss, and on a state official.[12] A UBI would mitigate the exploitation of each of these types of dependencies, which are plausibly construed as gendered, and hence is prima facie gender-justice enhancing. Firstly, consider the exploitable dependence of wives on their husbands in many traditional heterosexual marriages. Their relative lack of economic independence renders these women exploitable by their husbands with respect to the allocation of unpaid housework, the satisfaction of sexual desires, the provision of emotional labour, and more. A key advantage of a UBI is that it is given to individuals rather than households; this reduces the exploitable dependence of women on their partners in two ways. First, it gives women a credible means to leave emotionally or physically abusive relationships, thereby directly lessening their exploitation. Second, even if this exit option is not in fact utilised, its mere existence lessens the asymmetric vulnerability of women within a marriage. Secondly, a UBI would reduce gendered exploitation in the market for intimate labour, defined as “work that is done primarily by women with intimate parts of their bodies or their intimate physical capacities in exchange for money, favours, or goods” [13] such as sex work or commercial surrogacy. Many women undertake intimate labour solely due to economic deprivation, a concern which a UBI would alleviate. Moreover, even a UBI set below a livable wage would meaningfully improve the negotiating power of women who perform intimate labour, giving them greater freedom to turn down more dangerous clients such as those who insist on having unprotected sex. Thirdly, the undemocratic discretion of state officials opens the door to the exploitation of welfare recipients. Due to its unconditional nature, a UBI would protect individuals from low-income households from being as vulnerable to the whim of bureaucrats. To the extent that welfare recipients are disproportionately women, this would mitigate gendered exploitation.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Solvency

BI would transform gender relationships and empower women

Beth Goldblatt ‘20, University of Oxford, Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Technology Sydney; Visiting Professor, School of Law, University of the Witwatersrand. “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights,” University of Oxford Human Rights Hub Journal, 3.1 - Annie

Economic inequality has profound gender dimensions. As Oxfam’s 2020 report notes, the global ‘economic system is built on sexism’.77 The major burden of caring in all societies falls on women who largely provide this work without pay. This work impacts on women’s access to paid work and other economic opportunities and contributes to the gender pay gap found across the world. 78 Oxfam estimates the value of women’s unpaid care work at $10.8 trillion annually which is three times the size of the world’s tech industry.79 Sexism is a key driver of wealth inequality and also impacts directly on women’s income. Women are likely to fill the most precarious and poorest paid positions in society and to earn significantly lower wages than men.80 Technological and other drivers of un- and under employment are thus likely to impact harshly on women workers. At the same time, austerity policies and service cuts disadvantage women and girls more than men as the burden shifts from the state to the household.81 Feminists have long recognised that the capitalist system profits from the unpaid labour of women through the social and biological reproduction of society.82 It is this fault line, premised on women’s biological difference but deeply embedded in social structures, that hampers women’s progression in the job market and economy. The challenging global context and long-standing impact of sexism have important implications for the forms of social protection that can both mitigate the effects of gender inequality and contribute to its eradication. There is an emerging acknowledgment of the need for such measures. The UN’s Sustainable Development Goals, one of which is aimed at achieving gender equality (Goal 5) targets the recognition and valuing of ‘unpaid care and domestic work through the provision of public services, infrastructure and social protection policies and the promotion of shared responsibility within the household and the family as nationally appropriate.’83 Which social protection policies will best address gender divisions of work and care alongside the broader challenges of poverty and inequality facing the world is a key question. Basic income, posited by many as a solution to the challenges of inequality and work, has been of interest to feminists grappling with the sexual division of labour in the home and workplace and its dire consequences for women. Proponents of a basic income suggest it has value for women in delinking social security from work given the disadvantages faced by women in the job market.84 Work interruptions to have children and fulfil care roles result in shorter careers, lower wages and smaller accumulation of retirement savings for women, making them more dependent on men and vulnerable in old age. A basic income could enhance women’s freedom to make life choices, including allowing them to live independently of men at different stages of their lives. 85 This is an important consideration given the economic vulnerability facing single mothers and single older women in many countries, worsened by austerity and economic crisis. A basic income would enable women to leave violent relationships if they were assured of income for themselves and their children.86 A basic income has also been supported as a necessary means of enhancing women’s democratic citizenship. 87 By focusing on reciprocity across the society, the debate about a basic income can open up conversations about reciprocity within the household. 88 A basic income recognises unpaid and affiliative work as socially valuable and thus has the potential to change understandings of social citizenship. 89 The shift from work to citizenship as the source of income thus increases the possibility of transformed gender relations. Nancy Fraser’s transformative model of citizenship, ‘the universal care-giver model’, sees all members of society participating in paid work and unpaid care with social institutions restructured to support this.90 A basic income, or some variant of it, might enable this change leading to a more equal division of care and work.91 Cox suggests reframing basic income as a ‘universal social dividend’ since this would ‘redefine such income as produced by valuing wide-ranging unpaid contributions to collective social well-being and counter some of the materialist gender inequities of economic models’.92 The challenge to decommodify human activity so that ‘affiliative’ work is valued must be built into policies aimed at achieving gender equality.93 Pateman points out that a feminist lens reorients the basic income debate away from economic questions to ones related to democratisation since it focuses on issues of citizenship and institutions including the workplace and marriage.94 While the debate is often concerned with ‘free-riding’, those who choose not to work while depending on the income of others, a feminist understanding shifts the examination of free-riding to men who continue to expect women to perform the bulk of social reproductive work within their households even when both partners are in paid employment. The idea of a basic income paid to individual women as a citizenship entitlement rather than to the household where it may not be shared equally is important for feminism and democratisation.95

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Solvency

The plan is fundamentally feminist.

Nick Srnicek, 2015, lecturer in Digital Economy in the Department of Digital Humanities, King's College London, Alex Williams, "Post-Work Imaginaries", Chapter 6, Inventing the Future: Postcapitalism and a World Without Work, Verso Books, ISBN: 9781784780968, KL

Finally, a basic income is a fundamentally feminist proposal. Its disregard for the gendered division of labour overcomes some of the biases of the traditional welfare state predicated upon a male breadwinner.118 Equally, it recognises the contributions of unwaged domestic labourers to the reproduction of society and provides them with an income accordingly. The financial independence that comes with a basic income is also crucial to developing the synthetic freedom of women. It enables experimentation with different forms of family and community structure that are no longer bound to the model of the privatised nuclear family.119 And financial independence can reconfigure intimate relationships as well: one of the more unexpected findings of experiments with UBI has been that the divorce rate tended to rise.120 Conservative commentators jumped on this as proof of the demand’s immorality, but higher divorce rates are easily explained as women gaining the financial means to leave dysfunctional relationships.121 A basic income can therefore enable easier experimentation with the family structure, more possibilities for the provision of childcare and an easier transformation of the gendered division of labour. Moreover, unlike the demand for ‘wages for housework’ in the 1970s, the demand for UBI promises to break out of the wage relation rather than reinforce it.