Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC No Impact – Slow Growth

No impact to slow growth- it won’t cause war, countries remain cautious

Acharya 18 - UNESCO Chair in Transnational Challenges and Governance and Distinguished Professor of International Relations at the School of International Service, American University (Amitav Acharya; “The End of American World Order” Second Edition; pgs. 157-161; Accessed: July 8, 2018)/

To sum up, I do not suggest that a multiplex world will be free from conflict and violence. Rather, my argument is that just because American dominance is declining, it does not mean the world is catching fire. The US and other Western countries will remain engaged in conflict control around the world, not due to any liberal altruism, but to protect their own homelands from the spill-over of regional conflicts in an increasingly globalized world. The emerging powers may seek to reform the current order, but most of them, including China, India, Brazil, South Africa, and Indonesia, are not seeking to destabilize the world. On the contrary, they are increasingly engaged in peace operations under the UN auspices. There has been a marked reversal in the contributions of developed and developing countries to the UN, with all the top ten contributing countries in 2013 coming from the developing world, compared to the situation in 1990 when seven out of the top ten were from the developed world.45 China's contribution to US peacekeeping missions jumped 20-fold between 2000 and 2010, and China is the largest contributor to UN peacekeeping troops among the Permanent 5 members of the UN.46 India's contribution exceeds China's; it is historically the largest contributor to UN peacekeeping, having participated in 48 of the 69 UN peacekeeping missions until 2015.47 As the emerging powers and other non-Western countries bring more resources and influence to the table, there is a growing opportunity for shared leadership between them and the West in addressing the world's trouble spots. Yet, instead of recognizing and advancing these opportunities, the West is busy complaining and lamenting about the erosion of the American World Order, and even pining for its restoration. The reluctance of the US and the Western powers to accept the decline of the American World Order and seek out new pathways to cooperation and peace may prove in itself to be a major challenge to global stability. Let me conclude with a few observations that might help the international community, the US included, to manage the transition to a multiplex world. First, stop pining for the return of liberal hegemony, by which I mean the post-World War II international order created and dominated by the US and centered around Western interests, values, and institutions. That order might have delivered much good (and lots of bad) for the world, and some of its institutions (such as the UN system) will continue, but the particular historical circumstances behind the rise of liberal hegemony are gone. The global power shift is for real and here to stay. In a multiplex world liberal internationalism will not disappear. But it has to come to terms with other ideas about and approaches to world order. At the same time, while China and other rising powers may be tempted to push for a "world of their own making," or a "parallel" global order, with their own institutions and linkages, I doubt if this can be substantially delinked from the remnants of the liberal order. These different worlds will have powerful incentives to collude, not just collide. It is this complex dynamic of parallel and intersecting orders that will be a defining feature of the emerging multiplex world. Second, unless and until the Trump administration radically changes course or is replaced, prepare to live without significant US support for multilateralism. Under Trump, US support might come selectively and sparingly, but its absence should not deter international cooperation if other major players participate or offer support. Third, avoid undue pessimism and learn from past mistakes in understanding conflict and conflict management. Despite claims about the world catching fire, some forms of international violence are on a long-term decline. Moreover, many of the signs of "anarchy" today, including death tolls in the Middle East, are the result of failed but avoidable policies pursued by the US and its key Western allies. Fourth, give due credit to the contribution of non-Western actors to the marketplace of ideas for global cooperation. Neither hubris nor cynicism about the role of the emerging powers is warranted. Most of the emerging powers, notably China, India, Brazil, and South Africa, are neither status-quo nor revisionist powers, but reformist ones who are willing to contribute to peaceful change in world order. Fifth, encourage pragmatic globalism, in place of ideologically charged liberal internationalism, a term that is deeply associated with Western hegemony and hypocrisy. History provides many examples: the drafting of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the 2008 financial crisis, Libya till the Anglo-French regime change, fighting terror, and the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, of practical, non-ideological, issue-based cooperation

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC No Impact – Slow Growth

“Slow growth” is a myth with no impact

Shaffer 17 – Leslie Shaffer, Senior Writer at CNBC, “Slow Economic Growth? Global Bank Asks, 'Who Cares?'”, CNBC, 8-24,

The persistent belief that global economic growth is "dangerously slow" and fragile is just a myth, DBS said in a note on Thursday. "If you're worried about slow growth today, get used to it. It's probably going to be slower five years from now and slower yet five years after that," David Carbon, chief economist at DBS, said in the note. In the July update of its World Economic Outlook, the International Monetary Fund forecast global economic growth of 3.5 percent for 2017 and 3.6 percent for 2018, unchanged from its April outlook. The IMF report urged countries to pursue structural reforms, such as commodity exporters diversifying their economies, amid concerns about "shocks" upsetting the apple cart. But Carbon said economic growth wasn't in the danger zone when it's "looked at the way it should be: in per-capita terms," with slower gross domestic product growth due mainly to slower working-age population growth. "Per person of working age, growth doesn't appear to have slowed at all since 1980," he said. "To the extent that slower growth results from slower population growth, the response should be: who cares? It's growth per person that matters — your income, my wage — not growth in the aggregate." Carbon noted that the working-age population growth was falling much more rapidly than population growth overall. He pointed to Japan, where the population as a whole fell by 0.2 percent in 2016, while the working age population fell five times more rapidly, by 1 percent each year. Europe and the U.S. changes weren't quite as stark, but still showed the same pattern, Carbon said, noting a 0.1 to 0.2 percent decline in Europe's working-age population, while in the U.S. that group was growing at 0.4 percent a year, down from 1.2 percent a year a decade ago. That translated into simple math suggesting much slower economic growth, he said. "Since GDP growth is the sum of labor force growth (in simple terms, WAPG) and growth in output per-person (i.e., productivity growth), a one percent drop in working-age population growth brings an equivalent one percent drop in potential GDP growth," he said. That meant the potential GDP growth in the U.S. was now less than 2 percent a year, down from 3 percent more than a decade ago, he said. It also indicated that global economic growth was running at or above potential, Carbon said. "Where's the crisis? Where's the danger? Why should governments pull out all the stops to raise it further? And would it do any good," he asked. "Odds are, it wouldn't." Indeed, Carbon noted that while Japan's economy was widely considered a laggard, on a per-capita basis, it would become the world's best performer, alongside Germany, with growth twice that of the U.S. and France. "Whether judged over eight years or 16 years, Japan and Germany are the global growth leaders. The U.S. is a distant third. And France has performed every bit as well as the U.S.," he said.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC Link Turn – JG Solves Inflation – Wage Floor

Link Turn – expert analysis proves FJG’s wage floors stabilize price levels and bound deflation.

Mejia and Albrecht 22, Jackson Mejia, research Fellow in Macroeconomics & Finance at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity; Brian Albrecht, Brian Albrecht is Chief Economist of the International Center for Law & Economics (ICLE). Brian’s research focuses on price theory, information economics, competition and innovation, and political economy. He has published in both academic journals, such as Contemporary Economic Policy, Public Choice, PLoS ONE, Journal of Macroeconomics, and the Journal of Economic Methodology, as well as popular media like the Boston Globe, Star Tribune, The Hill, and City Journal. Brian also writes the Economic Forces newsletter. He earned his PhD in economics from the University of Minnesota in 2020. He previously earned his M.A. in economics, also from the University of Minnesota, and an M.Sc. in economics of public policy from the Barcelona Graduate School of Economics. He received his bachelor’s in physics and political science from St. Olaf College , “On Price Stability with a Job Guarantee”, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, April 28, 2022, //IS

Because a job guarantee program is a novel policy, we start with an overview of the program from the MMT perspective. Like most macroeconomists, MMT economists express concern with maintaining a stable price level and full employment when assessing policy.3 What makes their policy recommendations unique is that they recommend a JG program not only to achieve full employment but also to stabilize the price level. The JG, operated by the government through federal agencies, would unconditionally offer a guaranteed job to all who want one at a fixed nominal wage (Wray 1998c; Mitchell 2017; Tcherneva 2020). 2. See (Thompson 1982; Glasner 1989; Hendrickson 2018) for a related proposal, the job guarantee under monetary policy, which has many of the same properties as a nominal GDP target. 3. We will use terms such as "MMT policy," even though there is a distinction between the positive theory and the normative policy proposals. "MMT policy" should be read as shorthand for "a common policy proposed by MMT economists." 3 There are two different models of how a job guarantee program might work. The first would call for something akin to the New Deal’s Works Progress Administration and entail centralized administration and decision-making. The second, worked out in detail by Tcherneva (2012, 2018), calls for centralized spending grants to states, municipalities, and various NGOs and non-profits, which would then make their own decisions at a decentralized level. According to advocates of the program, the JG would primarily work to produce public goods, particularly in (green) community investment or community art (Forstater 2006; Tcherneva 2018, 2020). Tcherneva (2018) describes the MMT proposal as allowing for guaranteed jobs in the arts, building green infrastructure, performing child and elder care, and food desert relief. More specifically, Tcherneva (2018, p. 21) gives examples of typical jobs: I. “A local artist collective employs painters, actors, musicians, and stagehands to run year-round productions for the community. They organize school outreach programs, run summer camps, and offer free art and music classes and literacythrough-the-arts courses for special needs youth. They collaborate with local schools in offering art enrichment programs.” II. “A former coal mining community experiences city blight, mass unemployment, and a high incidence of health problems. The JG organizes a comprehensive program for restoring the natural environment using the abandoned coal mine, based on existing best practices.” Hence JG output will typically go unpriced since the program will tend toward producing public goods. Neoclassical economists may stress the need to finance such a program after looking at the government’s intertemporal budget constraint. Financing does not present a difficulty to MMT economists, mainly because, in their conception, governments with sovereign currencies can afford anything; their only constraint is an inflation 4 constraint (Mosler 1997; Wray 1998b; Bell 2000; Mitchell, Wray, and Watts 2019). A government can "afford" anything that does not generate inflation by printing money. Therefore, even though the size of the JG may shift endogenously as conditions in the labor market change, the government can afford it. To grasp the fiscal magnitude of the program, Tymoigne (2014, p. 526) argues that a JG program would cost somewhere between 2 percent to 5 percent of GNP for an economy that faces unemployment rates around 4 percent in booms and 11 percent in busts. While one could advocate for the JG merely because of its social safety net property, MMT economists emphasize its ability to stabilize prices. Mosler (1997, p. 168) argues, "In addition to eliminating involuntary unemployment, the [JG] policy can be shown to provide price stability" (emphasis added). Mitchell (2017, p. 60) agrees, writing that a JG "would provide a macroeconomic stability framework designed to deliver full employment and price stability" (emphasis added).4 Indeed, MMT economists pitch the JG explicitly as an inflation management tool to replace the Phillips-curve-based non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) system employed by central banks today. Theoretically, the JG would stabilize prices in two main ways. First, in the background, as an automatic stabilizer, workers migrate in and out of the JG sector endogenously, and the fixed nominal wage and guaranteed job promote price stability. By setting a wage floor and a guaranteed job, there is a floor on nominal income so that if a recession occurs, the government can bound deflation. Hence the government ensures that nominal income cannot fall too low. The outside option of a JG for workers and the large pool of JG workers from which to draw for employers helps discipline the wage bargaining process such that wages cannot rise as quickly as they otherwise might during booms 4. It is not that the JG is a good policy that has an extra side benefit of stabilizing policy. The JG is explicitly a tool for stabilizing prices. In a blog post responding to critics, Wray (2019a) "MMT does have another tool to maintain price stability. It is the JG approach to full employment. It has always been a core element of MMT." 5 and cannot fall as quickly as they might during busts. From our perspective, this is functionally the same as our current system, with unemployment insurance serving as the primary automatic stabilizer. Note that we discuss this and other automatic stabilizers in greater detail in Section 4. Moreover, although the JG program is the primary policy option for achieving stable prices, it is intended to complement other price stabilizing policies including regulation, addressing "bottlenecks," price controls, and using taxes to temper aggregate demand when necessary (Fullwiler, Grey, and Tankus 2019). For example, when economies are in boom phases, tax revenues rise as a consequence of greater profitability, which can automatically act as a mechanism for slowing private and moving workers to the JG sector, consequently anchoring prices (albeit with sufficient fiscal support). For this paper, the relevant price stability mechanism of the JG is the one purported to replace the dual mandate of central banks. MMT economists frequently contrast the standard non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) concept with their own innovation, the non-accelerating inflation buffer employment ration (NAIBER) (Mosler 1997; Mitchell 2017; Mitchell, Wray, and Watts 2019). Under the NAIRU approach, which is dominant today, central banks manage inflation via interest rates, using some form of Phillips curve reasoning to increase unemployment through higher interest rates when inflation gets too high and vice versa. Under the NAIBER approach, defined as the ratio of JG workers to total employment consistent with stable prices, the government manipulates some policy lever to ensure that the buffer employment ratio (BER) remains consistent with stable prices, analogous to the NAIRU. However, this mechanism should not be understood as Keynesian fine-tuning; Wray (1998c, p. 543-544) notes that the critical difference is that, rather than fine-tune the economy as a whole, policymakers would only fine-tune the BER. In contrast to the prevailing policy regime, the policy lever for manipulating inflation 6 resulting from wage pressure under MMT is not interest rates. MMT economists argue interest rates should be set at zero (Mosler and Forstater 2005). Hence MMT advocates instead for fiscal policy as the proper lever for manipulating the JG by using it to move workers from the JG sector to the non-JG sector. When inflation rises, the role of the fiscal authority is to manipulate fiscal policy settings "to reduce the level of private sector demand. Labour is then transferred from the inflating private sector to the fixed wage JG sector and the BER [the ratio of JG employees to the total labor force] rises" (Mitchell, Wray, and Watts 2019, Ch. 19). Mitchell and Mosler (2002, p. 250) concur: "If inflation exceeds the government’s announced target, tighter fiscal policy would be triggered to increase the BER, which entails workers transferring from the inflating sector to the fixed price JG sector. Ultimately this attenuates the inflation spiral."5 Mitchell (2017, p. 70) agrees: "The value of the JG is that the government always knows that if total spending levels come up against the real capacity of the economy, then they are able to tighten fiscal policy without creating unemployment. In normal times, the JG would be a very small program but essential to those who would otherwise be excluded by private employers." In a foundational paper, Mitchell (1998, p. 552) describes the mechanism similarly: [I]f the private labor market is tight, the non-buffer stock wage will rise relative to the BSE [JG] wage, and the buffer stock pool drains. The smaller this pool, the less influence the BSE wage has on wage patterning. Unless the government stifles demand, the economy will then enter an inflationary episode, depending on the behavior of labor and capital in the bar- gaining environment. . . In the face of wage-price pressures, the BSE/ELR approach maintains inflation control in much the same way as monetarism—by choking aggre5. MMT economists exhibit substantial optimism in the ability of policymakers to use taxes to manage inflation. See Wray (1998a, p. 8-10), Bell (1999), Nersisyan and Wray (2010, p. 14), Tymoigne and Wray (2015, p. 26-8), Wray (2016, p. 10), and Nersisyan and Wray (2019, p. 8-9), all of whom advocate using taxes as one policy tool to fight inflation. While these authors do not explicitly argue such, we assume they mean a discretionary increase in taxes since they never mention an entirely mechanical, rule-based tax system. 7 gate demand and inducing slack in the non-buffer stock sector. In private correspondence, Warren Mosler says that "if a shrinking ELR pool is not answered with demand reducing measures, other prices will rise relative to the ELR wage and old fashioned inflation can follow." These "demand-reducing measures" turn out to be some form of policy. "As the BER rises, due to an increase in interest rates and/or a fiscal tightening, resources are transferred from the inflating non-buffer stock sector into the buffer stock sector at a price set by the government; this price provides the inflation discipline" (Mitchell 1998, p. 552). Numerous similar explanations appear throughout the literature. From the perspective of MMT, the JG is superior to relying solely on either unemployment benefits or UBI for several reasons. First, the JG is seen as a better tool than either one because it has the unique property of allowing people to remain employed in some capacity and thus maintain work skills and habits while they continue to look for non-JG work. On the other hand, if unemployment benefits or UBI are used, then people may become idle and drop out of the workforce entirely. Second, while all three entail large government expenditures, only the JG has some prospect of producing public goods. Neither the UBI nor unemployment insurance has any hope of producing goods and services, except perhaps funding job search for the unemployed. However, this property does need to be traded off with the JG’s apparent production of public goods; presumably, JG workers will have relatively little time to search for private sector work. However, MMT economists do not preclude the continuation of unemployment insurance alongside the job guarantee program. Third, the UBI has no inflation-fighting properties, and MMT economists generally disparage the inflation-fighting properties of unemployment as socially unproductive since it relies on an “unemployment buffer stock” (e.g., Mitchell (2017)). As Mitchell (1998, p. 552) points out, "The disciplinary role of the NAIRU, which forces the inflation adjustment onto the unemployed, is replaced by the compositional 8 shift in sectoral employment, with the major costs of unemployment being avoided. That is a major advantage of the BSE [JG] approach."

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC Link Turn – JG Solves Inflation – Revenue

A jobs guarantee breaks down inflation barriers- it generates revenue through taxable incomes

Tsai 2022

Daniel, Lecturer in business and law, Toronto Metropolitan university, Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream, The conversation US, https://theconversation.com/why-a-universal-job-guarantee-beats-the-basic-income-pipe-dream-186793

There are a few unique barriers that undermine universal basic income and its ability to be implemented. As we have seen with government support programs related to COVID-19, government stimulus in the form of direct cash can cause inflation. These programs reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. Like the Canada Emergency Response Benefit, universal basic income might take away the incentive to work for some, resulting in a labour market bereft of workers. This would result in a vicious cycle: employers would raise wages to attract those willing to work, which would increase inflation and cost of living, causing businesses, in turn, to raise costs to be able to afford higher salaries for their workers. A 'Now Hiring' sign hanging in the window of a building. Government stimulus programs can reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work. (Shutterstock) The effects of cash stimulus without controls can be far reaching. To take the resulting steam out of the economy, policy-makers often resort to blunt counter measures like increasing interest rates, which can lead to a recession. In contrast, a universal job guarantee would generate revenue for the government through taxable income, thereby reducing the cost of the program while simultaneously enhancing other sectors of the economy, such as the environment or infrastructure. It would ensure that people are able to earn money and, therefore, be able to spend money.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC Link Turn – JG Solves Inflation

A universal jobs guarantee solves inflation- provides wages to those in need

Tsai 2022

Daniel, Lecturer in business and law, Toronto Metropolitan university, Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream, The conversation US, https://theconversation.com/why-a-universal-job-guarantee-beats-the-basic-income-pipe-dream-186793

With the current cost-of-living crisis resulting in dramatic inflation, higher interest rates and a looming recession, people have been searching for solutions to the economic crisis. A universal job guarantee may just be the answer we’re looking for, especially since Canada lost 43,000 jobs in June. While most people are familiar with the idea of a universal basic income — the notion of giving every citizen a basic income, irrespective of their income level or need — few are familiar with the idea of a universal job guarantee. Read more: A guaranteed basic income could end poverty, so why isn’t it happening? Instead of a guaranteed fixed income, a universal job guarantee policy provides jobs — and wages — to people who aren’t able to find work on their own. In theory, a universal job guarantee could help stabilize inflation by providing stable, full-time employment, addressing unemployment, enhancing economic productivity and reinforcing price stability. Read news coverage based on evidence, not tweets Job guarantee programs are crucial for a number of reasons. They keep people in the labour force, alleviate poverty, improve health and well-being, add meaning to people’s lives and help the most vulnerable. They also provide crucial non-monetary benefits that have historically been associated with universal basic income, including improvements to “health, education, social cohesion and productivity.”

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AT Off › Inflation DA › 2AC At: Wages Link

High wages don’t cause inflation.

Dr. Roy Cordato 18. Senior Economist, Emeritas. “The Myth of “Wage Push” Inflation” John Locke Foundation. 10-25-18.

If you have been a viewer of any of the cable business channels, here’s what you are likely to have heard. In this environment where growth in the (mislabeled) “supply of jobs” is outpacing the (also mislabeled) demand for jobs, there is (and will continue to be) upward pressure on wages. I point out that the terminology is wrong because it is so often used. There is no such thing as a supply and demand for jobs. Rather, there is a supply of and demand for labor. So, to be accurate, what they are actually saying is that the growth in the demand for labor is outpacing its supply. And when this happens to any good or service its price increases. In this case, the service is labor, and the price of labor is what we call wages. But, as noted, instead of seeing this as the good thing that it is, we are told that these gains are likely to be ephemeral. This is because higher wages will push up production costs, which will push up consumer prices. This old song, long gone from most economics textbooks, is a remnant of discredited Keynesian economics and it is, in fact, called “wage push” inflation. So why has this particular theory of inflation, like other aspects of Keynesian analysis, been discredited? After all, it sounds pretty logical, right? Why wouldn’t rising wages ultimately result in higher business costs and therefore higher prices? The reason is that it begs the most fundamental question. If all wages, the cost of production, and prices are going up, i.e., if there is inflation, where does the money come from? Given a growing economy, there cannot be overall increases in the price level without new money being created to support it, regardless of what happens to wages. In an environment where the money supply is stable, price increases in one place would have to be offset with decreases in prices someplace else. For businesses, it could be reduced costs of technology, computer equipment, or any of the other inputs into the production process. Whatever it is, simple arithmetic tells us that without increases in the supply of money, spending more in one place means that you have to spend less elsewhere. So, where does the money come from? It is “created” out of thin air by the Federal Reserve via the banking system. Now, this doesn’t mean that we may not be seeing increased inflation over the coming months or years. For well over a decade, the Fed has been pursuing a policy of easy money. That’s what the talk of interest rates approaching zero and so-called “quantitative easing” has been all about. The fears of inflation that are all the chatter among the business commentator class are real and justified. What is wrongheaded is the explanation that it might be caused by increased wages. This also doesn’t mean that rising wages in certain sectors couldn’t be part of the story of how the new Fed-created money is working its way through the economy. New money flows from the Fed through the banks and into the economy unevenly. Therefore, prices and wages are also bid up unevenly. So, as different sectors of the economy receive the new money, possibly through new investment stimulated by the artificially low-interest rates, wages will rise. This, in turn, may lead to those wage earners having more money to spend on goods and services, which will drive up prices generally. But the higher wages are not the cause of the inflation but a symptom of it. The idea that higher wages can cause inflation is simply bad economics. It is part of the same discredited Keynesian analysis that tells us that government budget deficits create economic growth and that increased saving reduces it. As a wise graduate school professor of mine once told me, to ignore changes in money supply when trying to explain inflation is the equivalent of ignoring the eruption of Mount Vesuvius when trying to explain the destruction of Pompeii.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › AT Unpopular

The plan is popular

Tcherneva 18 (Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in modern money and public policy, The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation, Levy Economics Instiute, April 2018, https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_902.pdf//lsim

Despite decades-long research on the JG, the program was only recently introduced in the popular press. Today it has entered the mainstream conversation, prompting a number of candidates for Congress to run on a JG platform. Recent polls show that Americans overwhelmingly support it. One polling firm (Civis Analytics) called it “one of the most popular issues we’ve ever polled” (McElwee, McAuliffe, and Green 2018). They also found that the JG is very popular with young and low-income voters, and especially voters of color. The program is also more popular with Republican low-income voters than with wealthy Democratic voters. Furthermore, 58 percent of people who voted for Obama but later voted for Trump supported the idea. Data for Progress modeled state-level support for the JG and found that there is strong support in deep-red states as well: West Virginia (62 percent support), Indiana (61 percent), Kansas (67 percent), Mississippi (72 percent), and Georgia (71 percent). Though these results may seem surprising, these are also states with higher-than- average unemployment and poverty rates where the JG can make a big impact.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › AT: UBI

FJG solves better- it empowers the worker and serves as an economic stabilizer

MARK PAUL et al 2017 (Mark Paul is an assistant professor of economics and environmental studies at New College of Florida; William Darity Jr is the Samuel DuBois Cook professor of public policy, African and African-American Studies, and economics; and the director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University; Darrick Hamilton is associate professor of economics and urban policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and the Department of Economics, New School for Social Research; Jacobin; “Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee”; https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/)//Isir

Why Not Just Adopt a Basic Income Guarantee? The universal basic income proposal has gained followers across the political spectrum as a viable path to fight increasing deprivation; it also is a non-incremental, bold policy that merits comparison with the FJG. The FJG and the UBI are not necessarily mutually exclusive. In the end, it depends on the structure of the specific policies proposed: is UBI posited as a substitute or complement to the FJG? Although we oppose the idea of substituting a UBI for a FJG, we believe some form of a UBI, such as a negative income tax, could be beneficial if coupled with the FJG, to ensure an adequate standard of living for all. We argue in favor of FJG over the UBI on the following grounds: the FJG provides the dignity of nonpoverty employment for all who seek it; the FJG enables the nation to fulfill a host of socially useful tasks that are not currently provided, or are underprovided, by the public sector; the FJG carries a lower inflation risk than the UBI; the FJG contributes directly to macroeconomic stabilization; and, perhaps surprisingly, the FJG will cost considerably less. Advocates of the UBI have been critical of the FJG proposal (Van Parijs 1995; Standing 2002; Standing 2013). To justify a UBI, Standing fundamentally questions the ability of a market society to provide jobs for all, claiming that market societies rely on restricted job openings to discipline the poor; however, with the presence of a FJG, full employment is achieved. Standing’s objection rests on a philosophical opposition to the nature of work in modern society. From his perspective, the requirement to work is fundamentally punitive and unjust. Additionally, Guy Standing claims that the FJG would condemn the poor to have to work. On the contrary, the work that we envision via a FJG provides the dignity of contributing to social welfare in a social setting, which in turn is associated with economic, physical, and mental well-being (Goldsmith, Veum, and Darity 1997; Darity 2003). Workers employed under the FJG would enable the nation to fulfill a host of socially useful tasks either not provided or inadequately provided by the private sector, including those outlined. Today, we still observe the enduring benefits of projects constructed under the WPA and CCC—the FJG will ensure that similar projects are constructed, providing economic, social, and environmental benefits for generations to come. Unlike the UBI, the FJG generates productive activity via the public provision of goods and services, lowering the inflationary pressures associated with the allocation of similar levels of income through a UBI. The FJG may have some inflationary pressure, but Pavlina Tcherneva has expressed concern that the magnitude of a UBI might even lead to hyperinflation. Inflation would dampen the real effects of a UBI program. This problem would be exacerbated if workers receiving the UBI exited the workforce altogether and reduced output via voluntary unemployment (Tcherneva 2013). A substantial benefit of the FJG is that it functions as a strong automatic stabilizer in the economy, expanding during economic downturns, and contracting during economic booms when the private sector’s demand for labor increases and workers migrate from the FJG program into the private sector. This mechanism provides substantial macroeconomic stabilizing effects on the economy—potentially reducing the magnitude and frequency of economic downturns. Regarding the UBI, no countercyclical measures are built into the model—allowing financial markets and businesses cycles to continue causing unnecessary economic hardship and job loss for Americans (Goldsmith, Veum, and Darity 1997; Darity 2003). To compare the costs of the two programs, we need to identify the level and ways a UBI could be funded, because levels of generosity could vary greatly. Reviewing work from various UBI advocates, we see that the following three features hold throughout: the policy is universal, the UBI is distributed to individuals, and the UBI is set at a level to support a basic living standard, with a goal of poverty elimination (see Van Parijs, 1995; Standing 2002; Standing 2013). Estimates for the UBI vary, but Charles Clark estimates the UBI would have cost roughly $1.98 trillion in 1999, equivalent to $2.86 trillion in 2016 dollars (2003, 150). Harvey also calculated the total cost of a UBI, finding at the time of his study that it would cost $2.23 trillion, equivalent to $2.98 trillion in 2016 dollars (2005). Both of these calculations are based on a payout of approximately $12,500 per person per year. These are annual cost estimates—estimates that represent a cost more than double that of the FJG during the most severe recession in almost a century (see table 1), and more than four times our estimates under current economic conditions with a modest uptake assumption.26 These estimates showing that the FJG costs are much less than the UBI do not account for the returns to investments that would take place under the FJG—resulting in substantial GDP, employment, and productivity growth. Finally, the costs associated with UBI will not ebb and flow with the business cycle, hence it lacks economic stabilization properties. For these reasons, we strongly support a FJG when UBI it is posited as a substitute, though we recognize that the two can function as complements.27

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › AT Take Too Long

Empirics prove quick access to employment

Tcherneva 18 (Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in modern money and public policy, The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation, Levy Economics Instiute, April 2018, https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_902.pdf//lsim

The job guarantee will maintain a repository of jobs and places of work—via the Community Jobs Banks—that can quickly accommodate new entrants into the program and let them go without disruption should they find alternative employment. The ability to absorb or shed employees is not a unique challenge for the JG. Indeed every labor market segment within the private, nonprofit, or public sectors deals with new entrants and job leavers on an ongoing basis. Furthermore, the creation of jobs relatively quickly need not be a tall task either. Experience has shown that large-scale employment programs can be up and running in a matter of a few months (e.g., the New Deal programs in the United States and Argentina’s Plan Jefes). Such programs, however, have often been implemented as emergency measures. If the JG is designed as a preparedness response, a lengthier period of assessment, design, and planning is needed for its long-run success. Once such a program is in place, finding work for any additional entrants is a much easier task by comparison. A fair amount of experimentation may be needed initially, as well as continual evaluation to improve program performance over the long run.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › AT: expensive

FJG benefits reduce costs – its not as expensive as it looks

MARK PAUL et al 2017 (Mark Paul is an assistant professor of economics and environmental studies at New College of Florida; William Darity Jr is the Samuel DuBois Cook professor of public policy, African and African-American Studies, and economics; and the director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University; Darrick Hamilton is associate professor of economics and urban policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and the Department of Economics, New School for Social Research; Jacobin; “Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee”; https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/)//Isir

Would Such a Program Be Prohibitively Expensive? Although the initial financial cost estimated in table 1 may at first glance appear high, the initial costs will be offset by extensive cost savings through reduction of current social insurance programs, many of which would be substantively less necessary, return on investment within the program itself, moderation of economic downturns, expansion of economic capacity, and increases in tax revenues, particularly at the local and state levels. The latter entities frequently are bound by fiscal year constraints to balance their budgets that lead to tremendous cutbacks in the services they provide during economic downturns. The FJG substantially will reduce the need for the current levels of social insurance programs as individuals become ineligible for benefits such as SNAP after their earnings surpass the designated thresholds. In addition, progressive taxation, as outlined, could be enacted if politicians sought to offset the remainder of the FJG. Because the funding of the FJG will have Keynesian stimulus effects even as it directly provides full employment, we expect that increases in economic production will help reduce net costs further. Part of the initial cost of the FJG is due to the failure of the U.S. government to provide universal health care for its citizens. If the government were to provide all Americans with health-care coverage, program costs would be reduced considerably.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

FJG is a necessary step to solving systemic inequality and poverty

Treuhaft and Blackwell 20 (Sarah Treuhaft is Senior Director of Policy and Partnerships at the Institute on Race, Power, and Political Economy at The New School. She holds master’s degrees in city planning and international and area studies from the University of California, Berkeley and was a Peace Corps volunteer in Togo, West Africa. Angela Glover Blackwell is Founder in Residence at PolicyLink. She is a Professor of Practice at the Goldman School of Public Policy, University of California.

“A Federal Job Guarantee Is a Crucial Tool to Fight Inequality.” Inequality.org. 1/2/20. )

Skyrocketing inequality and persistent racial inequities are erasing the American dream for all but the lucky few and hobbling true economic prosperity. Tackling this toxic inequality must be the fight of this decade, and doing so requires breaking up the stranglehold of wealth at the top, growing the largest and most diverse middle class in history, and ensuring that no person or family falls below a standard of living that affords them economic security and dignity. One crucial tool that would go a long way toward establishing a new baseline of economic security for all is a Federal Job Guarantee: a public option for a good job that pays a living-wage and offers full benefits on projects that address long-neglected community needs and produce public benefits. Environmental restoration and energy efficiency retrofits to address our climate crisis; sidewalk and street repair, public art, and greening projects to reinvigorate disinvested neighborhoods; and new teachers’ aides, child care workers, and elder care workers to create a care infrastructure are just a few examples of the community-building work that would become possible with a job guarantee. RACIAL INEQUALITY Guaranteed jobs would address a key failure of our economy: the inability to provide jobs for all even in the best of times. Today, amidst record-low unemployment, millions of Americans — 11.2 million as of the most recent jobs report — want full-time work but cannot find it. Some 5.8 million workers are actively job-seeking. Another 4.2 million are working part-time but want more hours. And 1.2 million want a job but have given up looking for one. This is a chronic crisis that disproportionately harms Black, brown, and rural communities. A job guarantee would also target our epidemic of low-wage, unstable jobs. A recent Brookings Institution analysis revealed that 44 percent of American workers earn less than $18,000 per year. And the latest Fed study found that 17 percent of workers contend with unpredictable, varying schedules. Guaranteed jobs would provide them with a far better option. A Federal Job Guarantee would set a new, higher standard — not only for wages but also for hours, schedules, and benefits — that private employers would need to compete against to find workers. Ensuring that all who want to work can have a good job would transform our economy. No one would need to go through the devastating experience of not finding employment. Workers facing discrimination because of their race, their gender identity, or for having a criminal record would gain economic opportunity. People stuck in jobs where they are harassed or unsafe would have a viable alternative. Poverty, racial inequity, and working poverty would decline. And, when the next recession hits, workers could take up guaranteed jobs — maintaining consumer demand and moderating the effects of the downturn for workers and businesses alike. This vast potential to deliver on economic security, dignity, and stability is why hundreds of individuals, leaders, and organizations working for racial, economic, and environmental justice have signed on to a Jobs for All manifesto calling on policymakers to enact a job guarantee. We hope that the readers of this blog will also sign on. In putting forth this manifesto, we seek to bolster growing political momentum for a job guarantee. Last fall, Senator Cory Booker and Representatives Bonnie Watson Coleman and Ilhan Omar introduced legislation for a pilot job guarantee program in 15 communities across the country. A job guarantee is also a key feature of the Green New Deal Resolution introduced by Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez with 98 cosponsors. And Senator Bernie Sanders has made a job guarantee a key plank in his economic policy agenda in his bid for the presidency A job guarantee is also one of the most popular economic policies around. Multiple polls show that a majority of eligible voters support guaranteed jobs—including a good share of Republicans (48 percent according to one poll). At this time of unprecedented economic and ecological upheaval, it is time for bold policies that move us toward an inclusive and sustainable economy. It is time for a Federal Job Guarantee.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

FJG solves- altering the power dynamic between labor and capital is critical to solving poverty and unemployment

Paul et al 18 (Mark Paul, William Darity, Jr., and Darrick Hamilton. Mark Paul is a Postdoctoral Associate at the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University. William Darity Jr. is the Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African-American Studies and Economics and the Director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University. Darrick Hamilton is Professor of Economics and Urban Policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics at the New School for Social Research, and Director of the Doctoral Program in Public and Urban Policy at The New School. “The Federal Job Guarantee—A Policy to Achieve Permanent Full Employment.” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. 3/9/18)

A job guarantee would fundamentally transform the current labor market in the United States. Our current conception of full employment is inadequate; we discuss a bold policy in this paper to bring the United States to a permanent, more accurate indicator of full employment—by which we mean that everyone who seeks a job can find one at non-poverty wages. Beyond providing full employment, the job guarantee could be a turning point for American workers. Workers are faced with stagnating real wages and a continued erosion of labor’s share of income. The job guarantee could significantly alter the current power dynamics between labor and capital—particularly for low- wage workers and traditionally marginalized groups. Benefits of the program reach beyond those directly employed under the NIEC. If a job guarantee were to be implemented, it also would function as a de facto employment floor in the labor market. Private employers would have to offer wages and benefits that are at least competitive with the NIEC in order to attract workers. The universal nature of the program would ensure jobs for all— including those with some forms of disability who may not be employed through the private sector. The universal design is critical to ending working poverty and involuntary unemployment; this is in contrast to other forms of intervention in the labor market, such as minimum wage laws, which do not ensure access to employment in the first place. Nevertheless, complementary changes to the existing social insurance system would be necessary to eliminate poverty entirely, as some individuals may be unable to work for various reasons.54 Despite the discussion of full employment as a national priority for nearly a century now, policymakers have failed to deliver an economy that prioritized employment for all. Full employment is a goal that the private market in unable to achieve, therefore requiring government intervention in the labor market. Above, we discuss a transformative policy proposal—a federal job guarantee—whereby the government engages in the direct hiring of workers at non-poverty wages to achieve, and maintain, a full employment economy. Whether or not policymakers agree with the specifics we suggest in our proposal, we encourage them to think about bold solutions to achieve and maintain full employment. Restructuring our public policies to eradicate involuntary unemployment and poverty is within our reach.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

Jobs guarantee structurally stabilizes the economy by addressing inequality in the labor market from the bottom-up

Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023

Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy., The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative

Just like the shortest distance between two points is a straight line, the fastest way to eliminate unemployment is to hire the unemployed directly. The Job Guarantee does not eradicate unemployment through stimulus checks, tax cuts, subsidies or incentives, training, education, or other aggregate supply or aggregate demand management policies. Neither does it rely on progrowth policies that run the economy ‘hot’, worsen income inequality, and stimulate extractive and environmentally destructive investments. It is a net new job creation program, that hires those seeking employment directly, in areas of social and environmental need. It creates employment on demand or what Minsky (1986) called an infinitely elastic demand for labor. The Job Guarantee is not a ‘depression solution’ or ‘workfare’ either; it is permanent and voluntary and there are no requirements for participation in exchange for some other benefit. It is an additional program in the landscape of income and training support programs for the unemployed. Since millions of people look for living wage jobs unsuccessfully even during economic expansions, the program aims to ensure that enough employment opportunities are available. The Job Guarantee is not a replacement for any other social assistance or unemployment insurance and there is no requirement for participation. By design, the Job Guarantee is a bottom-up policy. While it provides an employment safety-net to all, it will benefit those at the bottom of the income distribution in particular. By contrast, top-down, progrowth, pro-investment policies tend to increase demand for the highly-educated, highly-paid and, often, already-employed workers. Top-down policies focus on closing the output gap and tolerate jobless recoveries, while bottom-up policies aim to close the labor demand gap and produce job-led growth (Tcherneva 2011a). As noted, a critical macroeconomic feature of the Job Guarantee is that it replaces the NAIRU, or the unemployed buffer stock, with an employed buffer stock. In recessions, workers who are laid off from the private sector would find employment opportunities in the Job Guarantee and, should they choose to take them, government spending on hiring would expand in a countercyclical fashion, generating a job-led recovery by design. When private sector demand for workers is restored, private firms would attract them away from the Job Guarantee with better pay and additional benefits. Government spending would automatically shrink, offsetting any inflationary pressures that may emerge from the increased private sector labor demand and spending. The key here is that government spending on the Job Guarantee program is not the source of inflation. Instead, it is a damper on deflationary and inflationary pressures that occur in the private economy. Such a countercyclical employment mechanism is necessary for a market economy, whose perennial feature is the business cycle, and where jobs are dependably the first casualties of those changes. In the U.S., 80 percent of total employment is created in the private for-profit sector, whereas non-profits, states and localities, and the federal government employ the remaining 20 percent, but it is the private sector that experiences the greatest employment volatility. Yet, experience has shown that countries which have achieved tight full employment over the business cycle, either via industrial and lifetime employment policies (as in postwar Japan) or employer-of-last-resort policies (as in postwar Sweden), do not have the same large fluctuation in overall unemployment. With a Job Guarantee in place, labor markets would be more stable and the program would not have to expand and contract as dramatically as unemployment currently does. Put differently, an economy that has an employment buffer stock is far more stable than one with an unemployment buffer stock. Forstater (1998) has argued that the Job Guarantee would operate with loose labor markets. This does not mean that employment in the Job Guarantee program would fluctuate dramatically; instead, it means that labor flows across sectors would be driven by abundant employment opportunities and not under duress due to job scarcity and economic insecurity. Another macroeconomic feature of the Job Guarantee is that it establishes a price anchor and a benchmark for all wages in the economy (Mitchell 1998). As workers would be hired by private employers at a premium above the Job Guarantee wage, the latter becomes the effective minimum wage. While many countries have minimum wage laws, they are not fully effective wage floors, because the wage of the person who seeks but fails to find employment at that wage would still be zero. In other words, working people need both a wage standard (a minimum wage - benefit package) and the guarantee of an available employment opportunity. It is worth noting that the Job Guarantee would secure that labor floor, even if Congress fails to amend the minimum wage law (which is long overdue)7, but the disruptive effects on the private sector would be minimized if the two policies were passed in tandem. In the present proposal, the Job Guarantee wage is fixed but not indexed to inflation, to avoid creating an automatic wage-price inflation mechanism. This proposal favors one fixed based wage (as opposed to tiered wages) to enhance price stability and prevent competition for workers between the public and private sectors across the wage spectrum. The structural innovation of the policy is to provide an opt-out for workers in poverty paying private sector jobs. To maintain the wage floor at a living level and ensure that workers capture productivity gains, Job Guarantee legislation should require statutory review of the wage-benefit package and mandate increases lockstep with productivity. At the time of this writing (2021), the proposed Job Guarantee wage is consistent with legislative efforts across the U.S. to raise the minimum wage to $15/hr. This level, however, may soon be inadequate to keep a family of four with two working adults above poverty, and the proposal would need to be revised. To sum up, the price stabilization features of the program include, 1) a base wage which is anchored at the living wage level, increased periodically lockstep with productivity gains, but not indexed to inflation; 2) a countercyclical spending mechanism that expands in recessions and shrinks in expansions, 3) spending on hiring that is always at the ‘right level’, and not more or less than what is necessary to employ the unemployed, 4) full employment without relying on general ‘stimulative’ aggregate demand policies, which tend to bid up the prices of already employed resources, including high wage workers, 5) an increase in both demand (from the purchasing power of the newly employed) and supply (public goods production), 6) an increase in supply associated with creating the highest primary, secondary, and tertiary effects, compared to other job creation policies, 7) a reduction in existing social and financial costs of unemployment and various anti-poverty measures, and 8) a method for building capacity that alleviates any inflationary pressures across sectors (e.g., providing school bus drivers during a pandemic shortage or deckhands at busy ports).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

Labor and unemployment are unique drivers of inequality – aff is key.

Nik Popli, 2-8-2022, "Why Income Inequality in America Hasn’t Risen in a Decade," Time, https://time.com/6220111/income-inequality-us-2/

While the research suggests individual income inequality is shrinking, figures from the Census Bureau present a less optimistic picture for American households, which are facing current inflation levels of 8.3%, putting pressure on living costs. The Census Bureau’s 2021 American Community Survey, released Oct. 4, found that household income inequality was “significantly” higher than its 2019 estimate (based on a calculation of the Gini index, a summary measure of income inequality used across the world). Contrary to the two scholars’ findings about individual income, the Census Bureau found that household income inequality increased over the last year for the first time since 2011 due to declines in real income—which takes inflation into account—at the bottom of the income distribution. The scholars attribute this difference to changes in the Bureau’s data collection and processing methods. “That report is looking at household income inequality rather than inequality in individual earnings,” Aeppli says. “It’s a different unit of analysis and different quantity. And even when we correct for that difference, we still observed that household income inequality seems to be stabilizing in the last decade—it just isn’t as pronounced.” Research in related fields seems to support the scholars’ findings. As earnings grow for low-wage workers, the number of Americans living below the poverty line has also decreased, says Chris Wimer, director of the Center on Poverty and Social Policy at Columbia University. A number of policies designed to offset the impact of rising prices have contributed, including employment expansions, stimulus payments and the child tax credit of 2021. “But some of those policies are going away,” Wimer says, “so families coping with inflation no longer have the same policy support.” However, the Harvard and MIT study suggests that policy measures have had less of an impact than market dynamics. It argues that a tight labor market is what’s driving these changes in inequality rather than other factors like minimum wage legislation, labor action or a shortage of workers. The early months of the pandemic put frontline workers dealing with the public face-to-face at the most risk, and saw workers resigning in droves, particularly in the food services and retail industries. Their analysis found that raising minimum wages to $15 an hour would, perhaps unsurprisingly, increase earnings at the bottom, though most cities did not increase minimum wages in 2021. However, labor shortages meant that some employers were offering higher wages in order to get staff in these roles. Despite the research paper’s hopeful indicators, experts say we’re still nowhere near making a dent in overall inequality. “We’re not even in the ballpark, let alone within spitting distance, to the kinds of changes we need to make,” the Brookings Institution’s Edelberg says. Overall income inequality, she argues, is not just driven by hourly wages—as the report tracks—but also by who’s working and how many hours they are working. In fact, it may take years—or decades—for low-wage workers to start feeling the effects of declining income inequality, even if the downward trend continues. As the nation deals with the worst inflation in 40 years, prices on just about everything have skyrocketed, from living expenses to gasoline to food. “We’ve seen positive movement with the lowest wage sectors having the biggest gains,” Edelberg says, “but there’s no way I think we want to declare mission accomplished.”

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

Jobs guarantee structurally changes the economy to address inequality through automatic stabilization

Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023

Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy., The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative

Orthodox economic theory presents the policy maker with an impossible choice: eradicate unemployment at the cost of undesirable inflation or keep prices stable by maintaining some level of involuntary unemployment. This is the canon, as embodied in the natural rate of unemployment theory and the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment (NAIRU). In the mainstream, there is no alternative. Heterodoxy has long criticized the NAIRU and the natural rate, but has not mounted a robust challenge for lack of a clearly articulated policy alternative that can target both goals: full employment and price stability. Modern Money Theory (MMT) has such a proposal – the federal Job Guarantee. The Job Guarantee (JG) is a permanent, federally-funded and locally administered program, which would provide a voluntary employment opportunity with a living wage and benefits, on demand, to anyone who is seeking such work. It has three key aspects. First, as a permanent feature of the policy landscape, it is a structural macroeconomic policy response to unemployment, whatever its causes. As an anti-cyclical economic stabilizer, it creates employment in times of greatest need, such as recessions. As an employment safety-net, it addresses pandemic, technological, or climate-related job losses. The program is also self-limiting, shrinking when other parts of the economy furnish their share of well-paying jobs. As such, it is a policy alternative to the current practice of fine-tuning monetary or fiscal policy around some alleged ‘natural’ or ‘necessary’ level of unemployment (i.e., the NAIRU).1 Second, the program is a robust labor policy that establishes an economy-wide labor standard. By supplying living-wage jobs on demand, it secures the benchmark for wages, benefits, and working conditions for all employment in the economy. This benchmark strengthens the anti-inflationary features of the Job Guarantee, by stabilizing one of the most essential prices in the economy – that of paid work. Third, the Job Guarantee is the answer to a recurring demand to secure the right and entitlement to dignified and well-remunerated employment to any person of legal working age, irrespective of their labor market status, race, gender, color, or creed.2 It secures the internationally recognized “right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favorable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment,” as articulated in the Universal Declaration of Human Right (1948) and many a national constitution.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves Econ Inequality

Jobs guarantee structurally solves inequality- addresses wages and labor power

Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023

Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy., The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative

To sum up, while the Federal Reserve has no reliable theory of inflation or the NAIRU, it nevertheless insists on forfeiting jobs for price stability. By contrast, MMT argues that public policy has both the responsibility and the ability to achieve and maintain both. Only the currency issuer can institute and implement automatic anticyclical economic stabilizers, including an employment stabilizer. This is the macroeconomic function of the Job Guarantee. It is worth pointing out that, while this specific Job Guarantee framework emerges from an understanding of the unique currency-issuing powers of the state, as a real-world policy solution, the Job Guarantee is also available to nations that do not issue or control their currencies. This is because they too will continue to face the outsized costs of unemployment. Whatever the monetary system, the public sector is responsible for the unemployed; it bears the unavoidable real and financial costs of unemployment and related social problems. In a certain sense, paying for poverty and unemployment is already baked into government budgets and the Job Guarantee, as will be discussed below, is a superior policy method for eliminating them compared to conventional methods. A non-sovereign monetary system, however, may face obstacles to achieving and maintaining tight long-run full employment, because the policy space available to do so is smaller than that of monetarily sovereign nations. The above discussion highlights a core MMT claim: unemployment is a public sector failure that only the state can remedy. While unemployment is reproduced in multiple ways, in all cases, it is a situation when someone is willing to work for currency, a demand that only the issuer can ultimately 6 choke off. From here, it follows that the private sector cannot provide employment to all, not only because it runs against the logic of the profit motive, but also because the private sector does not have (and is unwilling to part with) the very means to employ the unemployed (currency), precisely at a time when the problem of unemployed is most acute (in downturns). Furthermore, the logic of the private sector is to minimize its cost of production, including labor costs. Therefore, providing jobs for all who need them is inherently outside the purview of private sector activity. To put it directly, firms are not in the business of hiring every job seeker who comes a knocking. A STRUCTURAL POLICY, NOT JUST A JOBS PROGRAM The Job Guarantee is a structural macroeconomic policy that secures full employment and price stability, while addressing the inequities already embedded in the labor market, including the large social and economic costs of unemployment. It is important to make the case for the Job Guarantee, even if the NAIRU were abandoned as a policy guide, because the convention (even among laborfriendly economists) is to define ‘full employment’ as some positive level of involuntary unemployment. This is because conventional policy approaches simply cannot deliver jobs for all.6 And, even when they aim for low levels of unemployment, they continue to work through the highly-unequal existing labor market mechanisms. The Job Guarantee is a game-changer for the economy and the most vulnerable workers. It is well understood that official statistics do not capture the true levels of unemployment – especially those experienced by people of color, with disabilities, caregivers, veterans, or in regions of ongoing economic distress. Indeed, the labor market is not a fair game and structural inequities in hiring are exacerbated by the fact that there are not enough employment opportunities for all. As the COIVID experience showed (Cajner et al. 2020), job losses are not experienced equally either: the lower the wage – the higher the job losses and the slower the recovery in lost payrolls. This is true for garden-variety recessions too. Job losses among low wage workers, who have the least capacity (savings or other assets) to weather a recession, occur earlier, longer and are proportionately greater than those for people at the high end of the income distribution (Tcherneva 2012). The perennial threat of unemployment is a powerful force of reproducing inequities in the labor market, denying certain workers employment opportunities, eroding wages and benefits for those who work, and growing the precariat. The Job Guarantee helps secure decent employment for all, and especially for the most disenfranchised groups and people facing systemic barriers to employment.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves- Unemployment

Jobs guarantee solves structural unemployment, addresses inequality, and increases growth

Heires 04 June 2021 [Gregory "A Federal Jobs Guarantee: Ending Unemployment," NJFAN, https://njfac.org/index.php/2021/06/04/a-federal-jobs-guarantee-ending-unemployment]

Advocates describe a Federal Jobs Guarantee as an affordable solution to the challenges of short-term and structural unemployment. If enacted, the jobs guarantee would ensure that nearly all job seekers are able to find work, and it would significantly diminish government spending on unemployment relief and the many individual, family, and societal problems caused by unemployment. “A Federal Jobs Guarantee would virtually end unemployment,” said Trudy Goldberg, chair of the Nation Jobs for All Network. “I am absolutely convinced that a jobs guarantee would ultimately save tax dollars through reducing the cost of unemployment while bringing in more revenue thanks to the new employment opportunities it would create,” said NJFAN board member Phillip Harvey, a professor of law and economics at Rutgers University. The pandemic-induced economic downturn has created a growing interest in a federal jobs guarantee. Earlier this year, Rep. Ayana Pressley (D-Mass.) unveiled a proposal for a jobs guarantee with the support dozens of groups, including the NJFAN and PolicyLink. The Right to a Job In our modern political era, the roots of the proposal go back to the New Deal. As early as 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt, in a major campaign speech, stated that “Every man has a … a right to make a comfortable living.” It was the achievement of full employment in World War II that convinced him that it was possible for the federal government to guarantee living-wage work. The first tenet of President Roosevelt’s 1944 Economic Bill of Rights called for the “right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms of the nation.” The second tenet supported the right to “earn enough” to lead a life of dignity. Goldberg points out that FDR regarded the job guarantee as “the most fundamental, and one on which the fulfillment of the others in large degree depends.” By this he meant that the right to employment would make it easier to achieve guarantees of decent housing, health care, and education. In short, Goldberg emphasizes, the Job Guarantee is central to the achievement of essential economic rights. The adopted in 1948—and inspired by Roosevelt’s Economic Bill of Rights–states that everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favorable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment. For decades, NJFAN has been a leading voice in the country for a federal jobs guarantee. In 1994, Goldberg and NJFAN board members Sheila D. Collins and Helen Lachs Ginsburg wrote “,” which launched the National Jobs for All Network (formerly Coalition). In the book, the authors outlined a plan for full employment that would guarantee a living-wage work “based on the philosophy that work and production, exchange and distribution should be redesigned in ways that are conducive to the full development of the innate potential of all people and to the sustainability of the ecosystem.” A Federal Job Guarantee would set a new, higher standard — not only for wages but also for hours, schedules, and benefits — that private employers would need to compete against to find workers, according to a . A proposal developed by NJFAN board member Darrick Hamilton and economists William Darity and Mark Paul envisions creating a National Investment Employment Corps. The U.S. Labor Department would run the new agency, which would allocate funds for state, county, and local governments, as well as Native American nations. It would work with other federal agencies to provide funds for training and jobs in infrastructure and care giving. The price tag for a federal jobs program would be hefty, requiring the spending of billions of dollars on new jobs and training. One estimate places the tab at $612 billion a year, which assumes that official unemployed workers and others who are seeking work but not covered by the official government unemployment statistics would be paid $20 an hour and work 40 hours a week, according to a 2020 Insider article by George Pearkes. But put that in perspective: The Bureau of Economic Analysis reports that the government spends substantially more on military consumption and investment every year: 3.94 percent as of the third quarter of 2019, versus 2.7 percent of GDP on all discretionary non-defense spending consumption and investment by the federal government, which does not include transfer programs like Medicare and Social Security. While the spending on a federal jobs guarantee would be high, its expenditures would be partially offer by spending related to job loss. With a federal jobs program in place, the need for unemployment insurance ($33 billion in fiscal year 2016) would plummet, as a study by the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities points out. Demand for Temporary Assistance to Needy Families ($16 billion) would largely disappear. Thanks to boosted wages, millions of families would not have to rely on Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program ($368 billion) and the Children’s Health Insurance Program ($14 billion). Affected workers would not need to be covered by health care coverage, so they would no longer need to rely on Medicaid ($368 billion) as they would health coverage in their new jobs. Apart from addressing the persistent problems of poverty, inequality, structural unemployment and low-wages, a federal jobs guarantee would benefit the economy overall. A federal jobs guarantee would help address the business cycle and be “smoother” than one-time traditional stimulus packages, according to Harvey. Historically, governments have responded to major economic downturns and employment crises with Keynesian-inspired policies of injecting huge sums into the economy. These expenditures, however, generally do not target specific jobs and specific areas where unemployment is high, and there is a lag of about 18 months before the stimulus works. With a permanent program in place, the government would be able to act more quickly to provide jobs to unemployed workers to help jump-start the economy. “The program would be faster, better targeted and cheaper,” Harvey said.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves- Unemployment

FJG spills over to promote stability and increased revenues for resources

Paul et al 18, Mark Paul is a Postdoctoral Associate at the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, William Darity Jr. is the Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African-American Studies and Economics and the Director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, Darrick Hamilton is Professor of Economics and Urban Policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics at the New School for Social Research, and Director of the Doctoral Program in Public and Urban Policy at The New School, “The Federal Job Guarantee - A Policy to Achieve Permanent Full Employment,” Center on Budget and Policy Politics, March 9, 2018, https://www.cbpp.org/research/full-employment/the-federal-job-guarantee-a-policy-to-achieve-permanent-full-employment#_ftn1//Isim

The benefits of permanent full employment in the U.S. economy through the creation of the NIEC would be substantial. They include, but are not limited to: The elimination of involuntary unemployment. A public option for employment means workers will no longer be forced into unemployment. The policy would eliminate cyclical and structural unemployment and provide workers with the dignity and sense of purpose that comes with employment. Furthermore, the elimination of involuntary unemployment would bypass the social and personal ills associated with unemployment, such as the erosion of skills, increased rates of physical and mental illness, suicide and attempted suicide, and failed relationships, among others.[31] A true floor in the labor market. While minimum- and living-wage laws have historically been implemented to place a floor in the labor market, they fail to provide viable pathways to employment or out of poverty for those looking for work but unable to obtain employment in the first place. The job guarantee would function as a de facto floor in the labor market, greatly increasing the bargaining position of workers throughout the economy. For private employers to attract employees, they would have to offer a job that is at least as good as the one offered by the government. The elimination of working poverty. Unemployment is one of the strongest predictors of poverty in the United States. Households whose usual breadwinners are out of work are three times more likely to be poor than working households.[32] The job guarantee would substantially reduce poverty by eliminating involuntary unemployment and setting a non-poverty wage and compensation floor in the labor market. Improving workers livelihoods as the Federal Reserve manages its dual mandate. As noted above, the Federal Reserve has a dual mandate—maximum employment and price stability. Through its use of monetary policy, the Federal Reserve plays a vital role in promoting full employment; however, monetary policy has proven insufficient for eliminating involuntary unemployment. Historically, the Federal Reserve has had a significant role in increasing unemployment as a result of combating any inflationary pressures that may exist in the economy. With a job guarantee policy in place, the Federal Reserve can conduct monetary policy without promoting rising levels of unemployment. In this scenario, the job guarantee program can maintain employment and consumption expenditures while the Federal Reserve employs monetary policy to reduce private investment in order to cool the economy. Thus, U.S. workers would be less vulnerable to the Federal Reserve not adhering to their responsibility of a dual mandate appropriately due to their cultural over-emphasis—a function of their close ties to the financial sector—on price stability. The restoration of local and state tax bases. By providing for full employment, the job guarantee will increase employment, and therefore expenditures and tax revenues for local and state governments. Although the job guarantee is designed as a universal program, more resources will flow to communities that currently have the highest rates of unemployment and underemployment (presumably because of higher uptake of NIEC employment opportunities). This will result in increased government resources to better serve their constituents. Macroeconomic stabilization. The job guarantee would function as a robust automatic stabilizer in the economy, maintaining levels of employment during economic downturns through direct hiring, and freely allowing workers to flow from the jobs program to the private sector during economic boom times. While workers may see some decrease in their purchasing power during an economic contraction, the job guarantee will automatically expand as demand for employment in the private sector contracts, providing a buffer to incomes and guarding against major pitfalls in effective demand. The provision of socially useful goods and services. During the Great Depression, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) were public employment programs designed to put Americans back to work. The programs were implemented near the height of the Great Depression, when the national unemployment rate reached 25 percent. These programs, implemented under the Roosevelt administration, provided goods and services that benefited all Americans by facilitating the logistics and technological expansion of our public infrastructure, including 650,000 miles of new or improved roads; 39,000 schools built, improved, or repaired; 4,000 new or improved utility plants; and 225,000 concerts performed. Under a job guarantee, even those who do not receive employment via the NIEC will likely benefit through the increased provision of public goods and socially desirable goods and services. Furthermore, the provision of productive goods and services will dampen inflationary concerns.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves- Unemployment

Unemployment disproportionately effects minorities, the FJG program helps and spills over to improve all communities from its efforts

 20, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY.  She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy, “The Case for a Job Guarantee”, Polity Press, June 5, 2022// Isim

It took eleven long years after the Great Financial Crisis to bring the US unemployment rate to a postwar low of 3.5 percent. Still there were millions of people who could not find paid work. The official figure in February 2020 was 5.8 million, but with a proper count that number would be more than doubled.1 Job loss is not an affliction that touches everyone equally. It disproportionately affects the young, the poor, individuals with disabilities, people of color, veterans, and former inmates. Growth, we are told, will raise all boats, but drawn-out jobless recoveries have been the norm for half a century now, and jobs have increasingly failed to deliver good pay. When we consider the question “When the economy grows, who gains?” we find a disturbing answer. In the immediate postwar era, as economies expanded after each recession, the vast majority of the gains went to the bottom 90 percent of families. The exact opposite has been true of the last four expansions (Figure 1).2 Since the 1980s, a growing economy primarily grew the incomes of the wealthiest 10 percent of families. Worse, during the recovery from the Great Recession, average real incomes for the bottom 90 percent of families fell in the first three years of the expansion. Figure 1 Distribution of Average Income Growth During Expansions Source: Pavlina R. Tcherneva, “Reorienting Fiscal Policy: A Bottom-up Approach,” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 37(1), 2014: 43–66. Today, millions of people cannot find paid work, and millions more need above-poverty pay. Wages have stagnated for decades. Real average income for the bottom 90 percent of families was $34,580 in 2017, 2.2 percent lower than it was twenty years earlier. Meanwhile, real average income of the richest 0.01 percent of families grew by 60.5 percent during the same period (Table 1), and was nearly 556 times higher than that of the bottom 90 percent (or 1,000 times higher if we include capital gains).3 Table 1 Runaway Inequality Source: Author’s tabulations of T. Piketty and E. Saez, “Income Inequality in the United States, 1913–1998,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(1), 2019 [2003]: 1–39. Behind the unemployment and inequality numbers hide the millions of different faces, experiences, circumstances, and personal challenges of those dealing with joblessness and inadequate pay. Maybe you are one of them or you know someone who is. Maybe you lost your job in the Great Recession and are now working two part-time jobs, struggling to pay the bills. Maybe you graduated high school, cannot afford college, and are looking to save some money first. Maybe the children have fled the nest and you, the stay-at-home parent, would like to find paid work, but it has been decades since your last job and you don’t know where to begin. Maybe you’ve sent out 215 résumés already,4 but even in this “strong economy” you still cannot find stable well-paid work. Maybe it’s because of your age, gender, the color of your skin, or your criminal record. Maybe you are someone with a disability who wishes to work, but getting the kind of jobs you could do seems impossible and, if you do get one, the current law allows your employer to pay you as little as $1/hour.5 Maybe the firm found a “better” candidate. You keep knocking on the next door, emailing the next employer, but the call never comes. The unemployment office is here to help – you take additional classes, spruce up your résumé, and practice your interview skills. You put your best foot forward but strike out again. Or maybe you are hired, but it’s only another low-paying job with no benefits. You barely make ends meet and the long commute and unpredictable shifts make coming home for dinner or doing homework with the kids a challenge. You are willing to work hard for that job, but the job just isn’t working for you. And this time you are lucky. Remember 2009, the overcrowded unemployment offices, and the many online ads that said: “the unemployed need not apply”?6 But maybe you are none of the above people. Maybe you have an OK job, at least compared to your friends. The pay is not great but the firm promises opportunities for advancement. You can provide for the family and, after a few more months, you will finally earn that two-week paid vacation. The only problem is that your boss harasses you mercilessly. But you stick around. Could you really give up this “stable” job? And you are so close. You can almost smell the ocean. Maybe you live in Puerto Rico, and your shop was swept away by Hurricane Maria. Many people died, many more fled, and a year and a half later one in twelve people on the island were still looking for work. Or maybe you escaped the California fires, but you lost your job and the FEMA money for your incinerated home is running out. You and many others in flood- and tornado-ravaged areas still need to pay the bills, and local communities still need rebuilding. How many of these stories can we tell? In the US – millions; globally – hundreds of millions. The loss of one’s job and livelihood is not just a consequence of unusual circumstances or “acts of God.” It is a regular occurrence. The drumbeat of the economy, expanding in good times and shrinking in bad, along with outsourcing and technological change, creates ongoing job losses. And while new employment opportunities are also created, they are never enough for all jobseekers even at the peak of expansions. Meanwhile many workers are in unstable, poorly paid jobs. In 2018, there were 6.9 million working people earning below the official poverty level.7 For millions of Americans, one job is just not enough. What if we changed all that and made it a social and economic objective that no jobseeker would be left without (at a minimum) decent living-wage work? What would be the impact on the lives of people, communities, and the economy? Imagine that you go back to the unemployment office but this time, in addition to every other resource it offers, it also produces a list of local public service jobs, each offering a basic wage (say $15/hour), healthcare, and affordable quality childcare. You can choose from full- and part-time options. As it does now, the office continues to offer additional wraparound services including training, credentialing, GED completion, family-focused case management, transportation subsidies, counseling, referrals, and others. These are local job opportunities in the municipality or local non-profits (finally, a shorter commute), but they are federally funded (not that you care, a paycheck is a paycheck). The urban fishery is starting a new STEM program with local schools. The historical society is digitizing its maps and records. The Green New Deal has launched a comprehensive weatherization program and green infrastructure projects abound. A project is hiring for that waterpipe replacement that dragged on for years, and the cleanup of the vacant lot behind the municipal park needs workers. Local community groups are running outreach programs for veterans, the homeless, at-risk youths, and former inmates, and community health clinics are offering apprenticeships and training opportunities. A community theater is running afterschool programs for children and evening classes for adults. All of these jobs were either nonexistent or the projects were sorely understaffed before the Job Guarantee was launched. If your community has been battered by extreme weather disasters or environmental hazards, the program will help staff the cleanup and rebuilding efforts and the region’s revitalized fire and flood prevention programs. And this entire menu of options is organized and supplied courtesy of the Job Guarantee. It is a program in cooperation with local and municipal governments and local non-profit providers to ensure that no jobseeker is ever turned away. The Job Guarantee office is there to help you transition to better-paid employment opportunities in the private or public sectors. The economy is growing and new job ads promise opportunities for advancement, flexible hours, and telecommuting. With your additional experience and training, you line up some job offers. You say goodbye to the Job Guarantee and are off to the next opportunity. Or maybe you do not need the Job Guarantee at all. After all, you are a highly educated and skilled indivisual with an entirely different professional experience- your career ladder is clear, your contacts are many, and you are able to jump from one opportunity to the next with ease. You earn a good income, provide for your family, and would never consider or likely need to apply for the Job Guarantee. But the program has helped rehabilitate your neighborhood, built community gardens in your kids' schools, organized new programs and community events in the local library, and restored the nearby hiking trails and public beaches. Can this become a realistic scenario? Can we put in place a program that provides a basic employment safety net for those who need it, while creating some much needed community work that benefits everyone in every state and every county, no matter how small or how remote? Subsequent chapters will argue that the answer is yes, and that we already know a lot about how to make it happen. Such a program would deliver overwhelming benefits economic, social, and environmental. Maybe these stories resonate and you can see the impact a public job option could have. With the Job Guarantee, you could find local work in a community project that mattered to you. You could say "no" to an abusive employer if you had a living-wage alternative. You could get a starter job before moving on to other opportunities, and save yourself the frustration of being rejected time and again by employers who may not like your sparse résumé. You would be able to avoid the stress of applying for food stamps and other government programs, because you have a living-wage job and can make ends meet. We are here just scratching the surface of the difference a Job Guarantee could make to the lives of the millions of people behind the unemployment and underemployment numbers. But maybe these stories don't resonate. It just sounds too good to be true. Isn't there something called the "natural unemployment rate"? What can the government really do about it? Can it even create jobs and, if it tried, wouldn't it distort market incentives? Maybe you worry that people wouldn't work as hard if they weren't afraid of being unemployed. Or that the program would ruin productivity. And how much would it cost? Isn't it very expensive to hire millions of people? All of these concerns and more are addressed in the following pages. The economics of unemployment is bad economics. One need not share the personal distress unemployed people and their families face to understand that hiring those willing to work is a much better economic approach than the one we have at present. Reaching that understanding is the task of the next chapter.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › Economy/Inequality Advantage › FJG Solves- Unemployment

FJG ensures a full employment economy and solves poverty

Paul et al. 18 Mark Paul is a Postdoctoral Associate at the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University. William Darity Jr. is the Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African-American Studies and Economics and the Director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University. Darrick Hamilton is Professor of Economics and Urban Policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics at the New School for Social Research, and Director of the Doctoral Program in Public and Urban Policy at The New School.; MARCH 9, 2018; The Federal Job Guarantee - A Policy to Achieve Permanent Full Employment; Isim

A job guarantee would fundamentally transform the current labor market in the United States. Our current conception of full employment is inadequate; we discuss a bold policy in this paper to bring the United States to a permanent, more accurate indicator of full employment­—by which we mean that everyone who seeks a job can find one at non-poverty wages. Beyond providing full employment, the job guarantee could be a turning point for American workers. Workers are faced with stagnating real wages and a continued erosion of labor’s share of income. The job guarantee could significantly alter the current power dynamics between labor and capital—particularly for low-wage workers and traditionally marginalized groups.

Benefits of the program reach beyond those directly employed under the NIEC. If a job guarantee were to be implemented, it also would function as a de facto employment floor in the labor market. Private employers would have to offer wages and benefits that are at least competitive with the NIEC in order to attract workers. The universal nature of the program would ensure jobs for all—including those with some forms of disability who may not be employed through the private sector. The universal design is critical to ending working poverty and involuntary unemployment; this is in contrast to other forms of intervention in the labor market, such as minimum wage laws, which do not ensure access to employment in the first place. Nevertheless, complementary changes to the existing social insurance system would be necessary to eliminate poverty entirely, as some individuals may be unable to work for various reasons.[54] Despite the discussion of full employment as a national priority for nearly a century now, policymakers have failed to deliver an economy that prioritized employment for all. Full employment is a goal that the private market is unable to achieve, therefore requiring government intervention in the labor market. Above, we discuss a transformative policy proposal—a federal job guarantee—whereby the government engages in the direct hiring of workers at non-poverty wages to achieve, and maintain, a full employment economy. Whether or not policymakers agree with the specifics we suggest in our proposal, we encourage them to think about bold solutions to achieve and maintain full employment. Restructuring our public policies to eradicate involuntary unemployment and poverty is within our reach.