Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › NET-BENEFITS › NB – Politics

States solves the affirmative, causes federal follow on, and avoids politics

Economic Security Project, 22. The Economic Security Project (ESP) works to advance economic prosperity by providing research, supporting campaigns to get from pilot to policy, and working to change narratives about economic inequality and poverty. “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income.” “States Lead the Way.” April 13, 2022.

Economic Security Project, Shriver Center on Poverty Law. Report.

In light of the current limits at the local and federal level, there is an opportunity for state governments to explore ambitious, publicly funded cash transfer policies that:

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UI

Employment program should be managed by states- States should increase their currently unsatisfactory UI policies- Help protect people from recessions and aids marginalized communities.

Tucker ‘23

Tucker, Whitney. “States Should Strengthen Unemployment Insurance Systems to Weather Possible Downturn Ahead.” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 16 Feb. 2023, www.cbpp.org/blog/states-should-strengthen-unemployment-insurance-systems-to-weather-possible-downturn-ahead.

A recession may or may not be around the corner, but the chances are significant enough that states should be prudent and take steps to bolster their unemployment insurance (UI) systems and, in some cases, to reverse recent years’ policies that have weakened them. Investments in state UI programs should be prioritized over calls for wasteful tax cuts that will leave states underprepared for economic downturn.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Experimentation

Experimentation tests varied policies and produces the best model

Althouse 04- American law professor and blogger (Ann, “VANGUARD STATES, LAGGARD STATES: FEDERALISM AND CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS,” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Vol. 152, No.6, June 2004, Accessed Online at , Accessed Online on 6-28-20, LASA-DG)

Consider the statement Justice Brandeis made about state experimentation in his dissenting opinion in New State Ice. Referring to the problems of the Great Depression, he wrote: Some people assert that our present plight is due, in part, to the limitations set by courts upon experimentation in the fields of social and economic science; and to the discouragement to which proposals for betterment there have been subjected otherwise. There must be power in the States and the Nation to remould, through experimentation, our economic practices and institutions to meet changing social and economic needs. I cannot believe that the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment, or the States which ratified it, intended to deprive us of the power to correct the evils of technological unemployment and excess productive capacity which have attended progress in the useful arts. To stay experimentation in things social and economic is a grave responsibility. Denial of the right to experiment may be fraught with serious consequences to the Nation. It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country. This Court has the power to prevent an experiment. We may strike down the statute which embodies it on the ground that, in our opinion, the measure is arbitrary, capricious or unreasonable. We have power to do this, because the due process clause has been held by the Court applicable to matters of substantive law as well as to matters of procedure. But in the exercise of this high power, we must be ever on our guard, lest we erect our prejudices into legal principles. If we would guide by the light of reason, we must let our minds be bold.25 Justice Brandeis does not appear to view “experimentation” as a metaphor. His government policymakers operate “in the fields of social and economic science.”26 Justice Brandeis sought to unleash not only the state government scientists, but also the federal ones. He favored experimentation not only in matters of commerce, but also “in things social and economic.”27 He cautioned courts to resist interfering with the process of experimentation: Judges have a “grave responsibility” when they exercise the power they have “to prevent an experiment.”28 That Justice Brandeis urges both restraint and boldness should not be seen as an inconsistency. For Brandeis, boldness comes in the form of trusting government experimenters with their “novel” ideas and refraining from serving mere “prejudices”—as opposed to true “principles”—which the “high power” of review judges have designed for themselves. Substantive due process rights were a powerful tool, capable of “stay[ing] experimentation,” but according to Brandeis, because of the benefits that might come from innovative policymakers, especially in dire times, the courts needed to be careful not to fall into the lazy practice of seeing their own preconceptions as fundamental liberties. He repeats the idea of bravery: Judges should be bold enough to allow the “single courageous State” to design new programs and policies.29 Judicial bravery manifests itself as the restraint that permits activism on the part of the brave policy scientists. There is “risk,” for sure, but at least in a system of federalism, where the bold experiment comes from the state, the risk is confined to one state.30 Of course, Brandeis saw the national government as conducting experiments that ought to inspire judicial restraint as well, but readers are left to make their own inferences about how much restraint Brandeis expected from judges when the experiment is not confined to one state. The Supreme Court Justices have cited the New State Ice dissent many times over the years. It has been mobilized not only to justify interpreting constitutional rights narrowly and permitting a state law to stand, as in the original case, but also to justify avoiding the creation of new rights. The theory is that the state democratic processes might operate upon the same field and produce similar solutions, policies that function as better-crafted versions of the rights the courts might otherwise have designed. For example, in a concurring opinion in Washington v. Glucksberg, 31 Justice O’Connor referred to New State Ice as she rejected the idea of a due process right to physician assisted suicide: that the states were in fact “undertaking extensive and serious evaluation”32 in this area inspired her to refrain from attempting to clutter experimentation with a judicially designed solution.33 The New State Ice dissent has been used by the Supreme Court to justify self-restraint to make room for other courts to play a role in the process of articulating constitutional law. In Johnson v. Louisiana, 34 Justice Powell, concurring in an opinion that accepted nonunanimous jury verdicts in state criminal cases, acknowledged that “the Civil War Amendments altered substantially the balance of federalism,” but rejected the notion that “they were intended to deprive the States of all freedom to experiment with variations in jury-trial procedure.”35 Noting the importance of “empirical study . . . as a foundation for decisionmaking,” he invoked New State Ice: One of the more obvious merits of our federal system is the opportunity it affords each State, if its people so choose, to become a “laboratory” and to experiment with a range of trial and procedural alternatives. Although the need for the innovations that grow out of diversity has always been great, imagination unimpeded by unwarranted demands for national uniformity is of special importance at a time when serious doubt exists as to the adequacy of our criminal justice system. The same diversity of local legislative responsiveness that marked the development of economic and social reforms in this country, if not barred by an unduly restrictive application of the Due Process Clause, might well lead to valuable innovations with respect to determining—fairly and more expeditiously—the guilt or innocence of the accused.36 Doubt about the criminal justice system could have been provided as a reason to expand the requirements of constitutional law, but Justice Powell uses doubt as a reason to keep the experimentation going, in order to generate evidence about what the best answer is. Powell thought the Court should refrain from “drawing [the] difficult lines” needed to define constitutional rights and for now approve of one state’s approach to nonunanimous verdicts. Later, in “a different context” and with the aid of information produced through state experimentation, the Court would be in a better position to “find[] the required balance” needed to perform the difficult task of defining the scope of constitutional due process.37 Similarly, in Globe Newspaper Co. v. Superior Court, 38 Chief Justice Burger, joined by then-Justice Rehnquist, wrote about the importance of empowering state courts to experiment with ways to protect young victim-witnesses in rape trials. The Chief Justice criticized the majority for requiring empirical proof that the state’s mandatory closure rule would lead to increased reporting of sex crimes. Citing the New State Ice dissent, he wrote: “It makes no sense to criticize the Commonwealth for its failure to offer empirical data in support of its rule; only by allowing state experimentation may such empirical evidence be produced.”39 Justice Marshall has raised an important criticism of this kind of deference.40 He criticized his fellow Justices who, even at the behest of a rights claimant facing a death sentence, embraced the notion that the “Court should postpone consideration of the issue until more state supreme courts and federal circuits have experimented with substantive and procedural solutions to the problem.”41 He commented on the expansion of Brandeis’s concept: When Justice Brandeis originally analogized the States to laboratories in need of freedom to experiment, he was dissenting from a decision by the Court applying a now-discredited interpretation of the Due Process Clause to strike down an Oklahoma statute regulating the sale and distribution of ice. As Justice Brandeis recognized, an overly protective view of substantive due process unnecessarily stifles public welfare legislation at the state level. Since then, however, the power of the States-as laboratories metaphor has propelled Justice Brandeis’ concept far beyond the sphere of social and economic regulation. Now we find the metaphor employed to justify this Court’s abstention from reaching an important issue involving the rights of individual defendants under the Federal Constitution.42 New State Ice has also been offered as a justification for striking down federal statutes to preserve room for the free play of state policies. The oldest invocation of Brandeis’s laboratories concept to argue against federal legislative power instead of the scope of individual constitutional rights appears in Justice Jackson’s dissent in Federal Power Commission v. East Ohio Gas Co., 43 a case in which the majority determined that Congress had authorized the Federal Power Commission to regulate the accounting method used by an intrastate gas company.44 Adopting a narrower reading of the statute, Justice Jackson dissented. He attributed Brandeisian notions about experimentation to Congress: Congress may well have believed that diversity of experimentation in the field of regulation has values which centralization and uniformity destroy. As Mr. Justice Brandeis said, “It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.” Long before the Federal Government could be stirred to regulate utilities, courageous states took the initiative and almost the whole body of utility practice has resulted from their experiences. . . . . . . . If now and then some state does not regulate its utilities according to the federal standard, it may be a small price to pay for preserving the state initiative which gave us utilities regulation far in advance of federal initiative.45 Justice Jackson’s deference to the states paid respect to their role in the vanguard of utilities regulation. Contributing to that deference is a sense that there may be no right answers, at least in some areas, such as the accounting methods at issue in that case: “We must not forget that regulatory measures are temporary expedients, not eternal verities—if indeed they are verities at all.”46 Preserving state autonomy in such areas, according to Jackson, could help the vanguard continue to advance: Certainly one of the matters on which the states might well be indulged—the right to an opinion of their own—is as to the accounting methods of a utility whose whole property and business being accounted for is within the state. Out of their diversity of practice and experience emerge pragmatic tests. What the Federal Power Commission seeks to require of this Ohio gas company, for example, is to revert by accounting methods to emphasis on original cost, a basis which William Jennings Bryan for an earlier generation of progressives eloquently urged this Court to reject in the field of railroad rate-making. . . . It must be remembered that closer than any federal agency to those they regulate and to their customers are the state authorities, whose mechanisms are less cumbersome and whose principles can much more quickly be adjusted to the changing times.47 Note that Jackson’s “indulge[nce]” toward the states is supported by the fact that the Federal Power Commission had not endorsed what he considered to be the progressive position and by his faith, inspired by the states’ history of past progressivism, in their potential to arrive at good solutions to real problems. Yet, while projecting this prudence and faith onto Congress, Jackson simultaneously forswore judicial activism: “We should not utilize the centralizing powers of the federal judiciary to destroy diversities between states which Congress has been scrupulous to protect.”48 An important recent invocation of New State Ice to support the invalidation of a federal statute appears in Justice Kennedy’s concurring opinion striking down the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 199049 in United States v. Lopez. 50 Justice Kennedy, joined by Justice O’Connor took note of various state and local approaches to eradicating violence in schools and the uncertainty about how best to solve the problem. Justice Kennedy wrote: While it is doubtful that any State, or indeed any reasonable person, would argue that it is wise policy to allow students to carry guns on school premises, considerable disagreement exists about how best to accomplish that goal. In this circumstance, the theory and utility of our federalism are revealed, for the States may perform their role as laboratories for experimentation to devise various solutions where the best solution is far from clear.51 It has been argued that the existence of a federal law imposing strict prison terms for the gun possession in schools does not detract from the states’ ability to experiment with other solutions to the same problem.52 This is not so: a state or locality that would like to experiment with parental responsibility or with gun-exchange programs53 is looking for an alternative to harsh imprisonment. Sweeping youths into lengthy prison sentences undercuts these experiments despite the fact that the federal government handles the prosecution and runs the prisons.54 New State Ice has also been used to withdraw protection of state autonomy and to empower Congress to impose on the state, as was seen in the majority opinion in Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan Transit Authority. 55 Garcia is the high water mark in the recognition of federal legislative power over the states, so the opinion’s use of Brandeis’s New State Ice dissent might seem puzzling at first, but here Justice Blackmun wielded elegant—if not entirely convincing—rhetoric: The essence of our federal system is that within the realm of authority left open to them under the Constitution, the States must be equally free to engage in any activity that their citizens choose for the common weal, no matter how unorthodox or unnecessary anyone else—including the judiciary—deems state involvement to be. Any rule of state immunity that looks to the “traditional,” “integral,” or “necessary” nature of governmental functions inevitably invites an unelected federal judiciary to make decisions about which state policies it favors and which ones it dislikes. “The science of government . . . is the science of experiment,” and the States cannot serve as laboratories for social and economic experiment, if they must pay an added price when they meet the changing needs of their citizenry by taking up functions that an earlier day and a different society left in private hands.56 That is to say, the good thing about state autonomy is freedom to innovate. It is the vanguard state that Justice Brandeis wanted to promote, so he would see National League of Cities v. Usery’s protection of “traditional [state] governmental functions” as exactly backward.57 Why it would protect the laggards, the states working the traditional field—Justice Blackmun seems to say58—while leaving the vanguard states open to regulation! He therefore perceives nothing worth protecting at the state level and opts to give a free hand to Congress, which seems to be the institution undertaking innovation. It is innovation, after all, that inspires judicial boldness, in the Brandeisian model, so, according to Justice Blackmun, the Court should unleash Congress rather than make a protected sphere for the states.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Half-Time

Half-time solves – social services and other part-time jobs cover basic needs, but it activates better training, innovation, and labor flexibility.

Newman ’21 (Nathan Newman, a writer and professor of criminal justice and sociology at CUNY, “Reset Labor Markets With a Local Half-Time Job Guarantee”, The Nation, September 21st 2021 https://www.thenation.com/article/economy/half-time-job-gaurantee/tnamp/)

But can workers and their families thrive on a half-time job guarantee?

Obviously, income from half-time work even at $15 per hour is not going to be a comfortable life, but because government supports have become more generous—particularly with policy changes made during the pandemic—a half-time job guarantee offers a reasonable safety net for working families.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

State UBI solves and other states will follow on

Miles Howard, 20. Contributor & freelance writer who covers culture, travel and transformational politics. “The Federal Check Won't Be Enough. Now's The Time For Mass. To Introduce A Universal Basic Income.” March 25, 2020. https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2020/03/25/universal-basic-income-congress-coronavirus-covid-19-miles-howard

Localized UBI would go much further than the state-centric economic relief ideas that we’ve come up with thus far. The interest-free small business loans that Baker announced last week would still leave many of us indebted. The Boston Resiliency Fund, announced by Boston Mayor Marty Walsh, is a step in the correct direction (it would provide food and additional forms of material aid to kids, older adults and health care workers). But to address the full scale of the coronavirus economic fallout, we need the federal and state governments to come up with a livable and fair substitute for the economy that we’d otherwise be paying into as consumers, workers and business owners. Mailing out checks to everyone each month would move us a lot closer to that goal. Universal cash aid would not only prevent bankruptcies but also save lives. Instead of thinking of cash aid as "free money," think of it as paying people to stay home, social distance and do their duty to prevent hospitals from being swarmed with COVID-19 patients. Trump is already talking about sending people back to work by Easter (ignoring the recommendations of epidemiologists). Cash payments would help governors push back against Trump and urge their residents to stay home as long as public health officials recommend. Massachusetts could find a way to do this. We reaped a billion-dollar surplus last year, and while we’ve agreed on how to spend $541 million of it, that still leaves a hefty balance. We could even make Gouveia’s aid package universal, sending out checks to everyone now and finding a way to tax wealthier households retroactively. That would solve the means-testing, red-tape problem. But on a broader level, doing this would be an act of leadership and innovation in line with the history of Massachusetts. We love to rest on laurels when it comes to reliving the days of giving people health care and legalizing same-sex marriage. Now, as millions of Americans struggle to survive the pandemic without going bankrupt, Massachusetts could show other states how to compensate for the federal government’s inadequate response to the economic calamity.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

Other states would say yes – multiple states already experimenting with basic income projects now

Josephine Fuller, 22. Fuller is a reporter for The US Sun covering all things regarding money and consumers. Prior to moving to finance, she was part of the news desk covering events. “HELPING HAND 29 cities and states sending payments between $200 and $1,200 monthly – full list of universal basic income in 2023.” Nov 26, 2022. https://www.the-sun.com/money/6761547/cities-states-universal-basic-income-2023/

AMERICANS all over the country are getting help making ends meet through universal basic income (UBI) programs. These guaranteed income programs provide monthly payments to eligible participants. These programs offer money to low-income residents with no strings attached. Usually, the programs are government-sponsored or run by not-for-profits. In most cases, there are no strings attached to how the cash can be used and it doesn't have to be paid back. While there is growing support or these programs, those who oppose them say they discourage people from finding work.

Here are some of the UBI programs across the country.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

UBI has already been successful at the state level

Lalljee, ’21 (Jason Lalljee is a junior economic policy reporter on the economy team. Before working at Insider, he was an intern at USA Today, spending two summers at the Washington desk and one summer with the opinion team. Jason graduated from the University of Chicago, with degrees in political science and English.)

More than interest — when former US presidential candidate Andrew Yang announced that a UBI program of $1,000 direct payments to citizens every month would be the keystone policy of his platform, he drew an unexpected amount of grassroots support in a crowded primary year. Guaranteed income programs have been gaining even more traction during the pandemic, which took a particular toll on low-wage workers and threw many Americans into poverty. At least 11 direct-cash experiments went into effect this year, Bloomberg estimated in January. Former Stockton, California mayor Michael Tubbs, took the idea to the next level by launching the Mayors for a Guaranteed Income network. As of this year, there are 60 mayors in the program, advocating — and launching pilot programs for — guaranteed income for their residents. California recently launched the first statewide guaranteed income program in the US, providing up to $1000 per month to qualifying pregnant people and young adults leaving the foster care system. The basic income program that Tubbs launched in Stockton in 2019, the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration, has been considered the model for other cities that have followed in its footsteps, offering low-income residents hundreds of dollars a month and measuring their job prospects, financial stability, and overall well-being afterward. According to SEED, participants improved in all those metrics. Sustainability is increasingly top of mind for many consumers. Here's how it's translating to investment strategies. Group Sustainability is increasingly top of mind for many consumers. Here's how it's translating to investment strategies. Nika Soon-Shiong, a co-director of the Compton, California, guaranteed income program Compton Pledge, told Insider in November that basic income programs help people who are typically shut out of welfare programs. "Guaranteed income makes a case for investing in our undocumented neighbors and formerly incarcerated residents," Soon-Shiong she said. "In doing so, it addresses the reality of the nation's fragmented, punitive welfare structure."

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

States are best suited to implement basic income.

Michael Tanner, 15. Tanner is a senior fellow with the Cato Institute and the author of numerous books, including The Poverty of Welfare: Helping Others in Civil Society. “The Pros and Cons of a Guaranteed National Income.” CATO Institute Policy Analysis, May 12, 2015. Number 773. https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa773.pdf

Any guaranteed income proposal would, of course, involve both coercion and redistribution. It would also represent a federally imposed one-size-fits-all approach. As such, it should be approached with caution and skepticism. In an ideal world, private charity would be the primary mechanism for assisting the poor. Certainly private charity has a much stronger track record of providing the type of assistance that offers a route out of poverty. And, because charity is voluntary, it comes without the moral questions inherent in any redistribution scheme. At the very least, welfare should be a function of state and/or local governments, not the federal government. States can, in Justice Brandeis’ words, “serve as a laboratory; and try novel and social experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”12 Putting states and localities in charge of welfare, as was the case for much of this country’s history, would allow greater experimentation and competition.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

States solve better – avoids gridlock, litany of funding mechanism and strong chance of follow on.

Howard ’18 (Michael W Howard, a professor of philosophy at the University of Maine coedited two books on Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend, national coordinator for the US Basic Income Guarantee Network and coeditor of the journal Basic Income Studies, “Universal Basic Income: Policy Options at National, State, and Local Levels “, Maine Policy Review, December 1st 2018, ) OC

Are basic-income policy proposals relevant at the state or local level? Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend illustrates how states can create dividends from sovereign wealth funds, or more directly from taxation of the use of common assets. But what about resource-poor states like Maine? Gary Flomenhaft (2012) calculated that even Vermont, also a resource-poor state, has enough resources that, if all the rents were taxed, and the revenue distributed as dividends, every citizen could receive between $1,900 and over $10,000 annually. Of course, clawing back these resources after having turned them over to private companies would face major political challenges. A more modest, partial basic income could be created at the state level in several ways. A state-level carbon tax, desirable as a way to reduce fossil-fuel emissions, could yield a significant universal dividend, and the dividend would rectify an otherwise regressive and unpopular consumption tax. A carbon tax with progressive tax reductions has been implemented successfully in British Columbia (Durning and Bauman 2014). The earned income tax credit, which exists at the state as well as the federal level, could be made refundable. That is, those without earned income would receive a credit, increasing their income when it falls below a minimum. It is unlikely that refundable tax credits or carbon taxes at the state level could be large enough to adequately address either the environmental requirements or the income needs, but policies at the state level can pave the way for more adequate policies at the federal level, when the political environment there becomes more favorable. Other policies that could be introduced at the state level are a universal child allowance or a refundable child tax credit. Universal child allowances are minimum incomes that go to all children regardless of means or behavioral conditions. Lastly, at the municipal or state level, pilot projects such as those discussed earlier can generate public discussion of minimum-income policies and empirical evidence to inform policy making. Any Maine city, particularly with grant support, could launch similar experiments.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – UBI

States solve fiscal redistribution, leads to federal follow on

Economic Security Project, 22. The Economic Security Project (ESP) works to advance economic prosperity by providing research, supporting campaigns to get from pilot to policy, and working to change narratives about economic inequality and poverty. “States Lead the Way,” “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income.”

Economic Security Project, Shriver Center on Poverty Law. Report. April 13, 2022. https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/

Why Should States Engage With Guaranteed Income?

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – JG

California proves – states can adopt job guarantees

-including specific to climate and infrastructure

Park ’21 (Jeong, “Guaranteed work: California commission calls for government jobs program after pandemic,” MARCH 03, 2021, https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article249640183.html)

The Sacramento Bee is exploring the future of work in California as the state recovers from the coronavirus pandemic. The series is supported by the Solutions Journalism Network, a nonprofit organization dedicated to rigorous and compelling reporting about responses to social problems. California labor and economic leaders in a new report are calling for a “social compact” for workers, including ideas such as generating a million new jobs in clean energy and providing a federal and state jobs guarantee by 2030. Those were few of the ideas outlined in a report published Tuesday by the state’s Future of Work Commission, a group of leaders appointed by Gov. Gavin Newsom in 2019 to look at how California can prepare its economy for the next decade and beyond. Its research began before the coronavirus pandemic sent the state’s economy spiraling last year, a crisis that members said underscored the urgency of the commission’s recommendations. “Events of the past year have amplified and accelerated existing trends, including the inequality of wages, income and wealth,” Newsom said in a statement. “By working together, California can model a new Social Compact for work and workers that can set a trajectory for the nation.” Commission members said the report provides concrete ways the state can address the rise of income inequality and help its workforce retrain for an uncertain job market. While the private sector should drive the majority of job creation, government can nurture high-quality careers and serve as a “backstop” to guarantee employment, the commission said in its report. But questions remain as to how those proposals will be translated into policies, as well as to how the state will address the rise of new types of employment such as gig work — which went largely unmentioned in the report. “Really, the goal of the commission was to tackle big questions with bold thinking, to do it in a way that would require multiple actors to participate,” said California Labor Secretary Julie Su, a member of the commission. “Questions that have arisen because of the report are heartening to those who worked on it because the point is to spur action, spur thinking and to get lots of people in different sectors of the civil society interested.” JOBS GUARANTEE In its report, the commission laid out five “moonshot” goals to achieve by 2030, such as having enough jobs guaranteed for all Californians who want to work. The commission also called for eliminating working poverty among hospitality, retail and care workers, as well as doubling the share of workers who have access to benefits such as paid time off. The state should also create at least 1.5 new “high-quality” jobs for every one new “low-quality” job and grow the number of workers prepared for future jobs by two to three times, the commission said. The commission laid out a variety of policy proposals to achieve those goals. For instance, California could partner with the federal government to guarantee all Californians a job, through incentives for private sector job creation or public employment opportunities akin to the Works Progress Administration during the Great Depression, the commission said. The commission also cited the New Hope Project in Milwaukee as an example, where low-income workers in the 1990s were offered community service-based full-time job opportunities as well as an income subsidy to lift them out of poverty. However, a jobs guarantee shouldn’t involve work requirements for those receiving unemployment insurance, the commission said. Those jobs should be at the quality workers “desire to build a quality life” and should be accessible “regardless of gender, race, status, background, and location,” the commission said. Such idea of a job guarantee has been gaining traction among progressives, with Bernie Sanders’ presidential campaign last year specifically calling for the idea. The commission also calls for at least 1 million new jobs in line with the state’s climate goals, by providing incentives for infrastructure projects that deploy clean energy such as wind and solar. Government agencies can also partner with educational and training institutions to better train workers for clean energy jobs, the commission said.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Fiscal Redistribution

States have the power to create their own welfare programs.

Weaver and Gais, ’02 – (Weaver is a Senior Fellow, Governance Studies at The Brookings Institution, and Professor of Public Policy and Government at Georgetown University, and Gais is a director at the Rockefeller Institute of Government) https://www.brookings.edu/articles/state-policy-choices-under-welfare-reform/

However, the law also created a block grant giving states flexibility in fashioning their own policy and administrative strategies to achieve the goals of the law. State innovation and experimentation are seen as critical ingredients of policy change. Federal time limits and work requirements apply only to cash assistance funded by the federal block grant, Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF). States can, however, devise programs without time limits or work requirements when they use their own money, spending state funds under TANF’s “maintenance of effort” provision, which requires states to spend 75 percent of the state dollars they spent in 1994. States can even use federal TANF funds to provide benefits to low-income families without time limits if those benefits help pay the costs of working, such as child care or transportation. States can impose stricter work requirements or shorter time limits. They can change many other eligibility requirements for cash assistance, including asset and earnings disregards. They determine the services to be offered to low-income families and define who is eligible for such services. And they have wide discretion over which providers—public or private, secular or religious—carry out their programs.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Fiscal Redistribution

States are able to more efficiently enact a GI program.

Economic Security Project, ’22 – (Economic Security Project, “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income, 2022) https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/

We need a permanent federal guaranteed income, but political gridlock and polarization threaten to frustrate attempts at a federal program in the immediate term. States have an opportunity to push closer to that ideal with large scale, publicly funded, permanent programs of their own that will provide essential data and experience toward the realization of a federal program. This guide seeks to arm state-level advocates and policymakers with information regarding the choice points in program design, the positive impacts shown by existing research, and special considerations for states including options for guaranteed income implementation, interactions with existing public benefits programs, opportunities for public funding, and promoting racial equity.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Fiscal Redistribution

That overcomes the inequality-depoliticization cycle. Increasing state-level fiscal redistribution is key.

Steven Deller et al 20, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, Center for Community and Economic Development, University of Wisconsin—Madison. Craigh Maher, 2 School of Public Administration, University of Nebraska-Omaha. and Judith Stallmann, 3 Departments of Agricultural and Applied Economics, Rural Sociology and Public Affairs, Community Development Extension, University of Missouri. "Do tax and expenditure limitations exacerbate rising income inequality?" Economics and Politics. //pipk

Political scientists concur with international trade economists who argue that institutional structures, rules, and policies matter. While multicountry studies may explain how national policies affect crosscountry differences in income inequality, they do not help us understand how national policies affect within-country income inequality. Hatch and Rigby (2015) note there is significant heterogeneity in U.S. states’ fiscal policies—taxation and expenditures—and other. laws, including labor laws such as right to work Kelly and Witko (2012) find that state policy, such as state minimum wage laws, plays an important role in reducing income inequality, and Franko and Witco (2017) find that state laws that weaken unions also increase income inequality. Langer (2001) finds states that adopt more demandside economic development policies, such as investment in education and research and development, as opposed to more traditional supply-side policies, such as tax incentives, show reductions in income inequality. Solt (2008) finds that as inequality rises those in the lower-income categories become disengaged from the political process leading to a cycle where greater income inequality results in greater political inequality thus reinforcing policies that may favor the wealthy at the expense of the poorer. This latter result is largely reaffirmed by Kelly and Enns (2010: p855) who find “economic inequality is, in fact, self-reinforcing” through policy actions. As Hayes and Medina Vidal (2015) discuss, there is political response bias in favor of the wealthier, which also reinforces inequality.

Newman et al. (2015) talk in terms of how income inequality can influence public policies in terms of redistributive and inequality democracy perspectives. Here, the former argues that democratic processes create the potential for addressing inequality that is generated by economic forces. The bulk of the electorate will vote in their own economic self-interested and pursue policies that promote redistribution. Unequal democracies take a grimmer perspective in that higher-income voters have a disproportionate influence on economic policies to the detriment of lower- and middle-income voters. Gilens (2005, p778) in a study of voting behavior across different income levels finds “…that when Americans with different income levels differ in their policy preferences, actual policy outcomes strongly reflect the preferences of the most affluent but bear virtually no relationship to the preferences of the poor or middle-income Americans.”

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › SOLVENCY › S – Fiscal Redistribution

The counterplan results in overturning Tax and Expenditure Limitations, which independently solves inequality.

Steven Deller et al 20, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, Center for Community and Economic Development, University of Wisconsin—Madison. Craigh Maher, 2 School of Public Administration, University of Nebraska-Omaha. and Judith Stallmann, 3 Departments of Agricultural and Applied Economics, Rural Sociology and Public Affairs, Community Development Extension, University of Missouri. "Do tax and expenditure limitations exacerbate rising income inequality?" Economics and Politics. //pipk

At the same time as Harrison and Bluestone's “great U-turn,” in the mid-1970s there was also a surge in antitax activity. On June 6, 1978, California voters approved Proposition 13, the “People's Initiative to Limit Property Taxation,” which placed a constitutional limit on increases in property tax assessments to two percent per year. Also, in 1978, voters approved the "Headlee" tax limitation amendments to the Michigan Constitution, limiting increases in property taxes to the rate of inflation. Two years later, Massachusetts approved Proposition 2½, which limited increases in the property tax (as well as automobile excise taxes) to only 2.5% per year (hence the name). The current era is one where almost every state has some form of Tax and Expenditure Limitations (TELs) legislation for local governments, and most states have self-imposed limits on state governments (Amiel, Deller, & Stallmann, 2009).

The timing of the reversal of income convergence (the Great U-turn) and the tax revolt movement that occurred in the mid to late 1970s could be a coincidence, but it raises important questions. First, was the tax revolt, and specifically the movement in support of TELs, an attempt by those with higher incomes to protect their income or wealth by lowering their taxes? Alternatively, did the desire for lower taxes by the public result in unintended consequences that exacerbate trends in widening income inequality? Taxes are unequally distributed across income groups and the instruments chosen to limit tax/spending growth—restricting property taxes versus sales taxes or limiting the overall ability to raise taxes or increase expenditures—may have the unintended result of increasing income inequality. Additionally, unintended consequences may be the result of lower revenues and increasing budget inflexibility that result in cuts to programs that address income inequality.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Gambling Plank

Gambling contributed billions to state and local governments

Hillyer 22, (Ben Hillyer, Journalist for US and Middlesboro News, 10-9-2022, "How Much Does the US Economy Benefit from Legalized Gambling?," Middlesboro News, https://www.middlesboronews.com/2022/10/09/how-much-does-the-us-economy-benefit-from-legalized-gambling/

The United States economy is the world’s largest economy and benefits greatly from legalized gambling. Gambling is a billion-dollar industry in the United States, generating more than $70 billion in tax revenue for state and local governments. Legalized gambling also creates jobs. More than 1 million people are employed in the gambling industry in the United States. There has been a rise in the number of casinos and sportsbooks that offer gambling sites for different games. Whether you want to find some Nfl odds or play online poker, you will always find a site that suits you. Gambling also provides a boost to tourism. Casino resorts generate billions of dollars in economic activity each year, and they attract visitors from all over the world. Las Vegas is the most popular tourist destination in the United States, and much of its success is due to its legal casinos.  How does gambling affect the US economy? Casinos are perhaps the most well-known type of gambling in the US. They are found in many states and generate a lot of revenue. Casinos create jobs for people in the hospitality industry and bring in tourists from other states who spend money at local businesses. Lotteries are another popular form of gambling in the US. Many states have their own lottery systems, and there is also a national lottery. Lotteries generate revenue for state governments, but they also result in people spending money on tickets that they may not be able to afford. Horse racing is another popular form of gambling in the US. Horse racing tracks are found in many states, and people bet on races both in person and online. Horse racing generates revenue for the horse owners, trainers, and jockeys, as well as for the state governments that regulate it. How does gambling contribute to the US GDP? Gambling is a big industry in the United States, with casinos, lotteries, and other forms of gambling contributing to the country’s gross domestic product (GDP). In 2016, gambling contributed to about 1.7 percent of the GDP, or about $240 billion. The gambling industry has been growing steadily over the past few years. The gaming industry supports a total economic impact with: $261.4 billion of output (business sales) 1.8 million jobs with $74.0 billion of labor income (wages, salaries, tips, benefits and other labor income) $40.8 billion of federal, state and local taxes, including $10.7 billion of gaming taxes. What is the tax revenue generated by gambling in the US? Tax revenue of commercial casinos (in the state of Nevada) amounted to approximately 1.02 billion U.S. dollars in 2021. This number is only estimated to grow in the coming years. Legalized gambling has been proven to be of benefit to the US economy

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Gambling Plank

Benefits of legalizing casinos spills over- creates jobs and gives states funds

Citywatch 23, (Citywatch Desk, 5-16-2023, "Legalization of Gambling Creating Job Opportunities for the Locals," City Watch, ) @HA?

LEGALIZED GAMBLING - Over the past few decades, gambling has become one of the fastest-growing industries in the US. The same trends are seen in different other countries where different forms of gambling are legal. Before 1980, gambling was only legal in Atlantic City and Nevada. The gambling industry added a lot to the tax revenues of these two cities. Local authorities generated massive funds to support local infrastructure and other development projects. The benefits of poker legalization forced other cities to think about the benefits of these rules and regulations. Most of the states in the US have regulated online gambling in the last two decades. Governments are using the legalization of gambling as an effective tool for the growth of the local economy. Benefits of Gambling Legalization Players get to enjoy easily available entertainment options. Casino operators earn huge profits by attracting new players. Governments collect huge revenue in the form of taxes. Here are some major benefits explained that governments and locals get to enjoy due to regulated gambling activities. Job Opportunities for the Locals Casino operators need skilled workers and experts to carry out business operations. The single casino can offer jobs to a few hundred people in different parts of the business. From bartenders to machine attendants, casinos need skilled workers. If the unemployment rate is higher in your area, you must find out about US online poker regulations and legal US poker sites. If there are no regulated casinos in the area, the local government can invite investors and casino operators for the new business startups. Once businesses find secure and safe investment opportunities, they are more likely to make decisions that will support the government and locals. Once a business has started its operations in the area, it will expand, and that might create even more opportunities for the right workforce. More Tax Collection Local authorities and government bodies need to collect taxes from businesses and the public for different projects and tasks. Casinos generate millions of dollars in revenue, and they also pay heavy taxes as per state laws. More revenue will result in higher tax collection for the government, and this whole situation will help to offer better services and facilities to the locals. Rogue casinos not only avoid tax laws, but they also scam players. Legalizing these casinos will offer better protection to the players. Casino operators will also think twice before making any move that might be against the laws and regulations of the state. Improved Local Retail Businesses Las Vegas is a popular destination for the gamblers. They like to spend their nights in the streets and evenings in the busy casinos of the city. Tourists are not only going to spend money in casinos, but they will also interact with the other attractions of the city. People need hotels to stay in, restaurants to eat, and malls to shop in. So, the establishment of one business will support a lot of local businesses indirectly. These opportunities will uplift the living conditions in the area. The fear of lost revenue from the casino tax collection will force neighboring states to think about legalizing gambling businesses. In simple words, the decision of one country or state will create favorable business conditions for the entire region. Many countries have already improved their infrastructure and other departments by legalizing these businesses. The new LA budget is up for approval, and most of the projects in the budget depend upon the revenue generated by casinos and other similar startups. Consumer Protection Online casino scams are common in the states where gambling is not regulated. Players join rogue casinos, and they end up losing their hard-earned money to these illegal casinos and apps. When players have regulated options available, they won’t have to join these illegal casinos. Playing at rogue casinos is not only risky, but it can also get you in legal trouble. It is always a good move to check the legality of the casino. The home page usually has all the information available about the legal status of the casino. The registration and license numbers can be verified online. If the casino is not regulated by valid authorities, it is best for you to stay away from such options. Conclusion Legalizing popular games like online poker will benefit the state, businesses, and locals. At large, the legalization of online poker is a win-win situation for all. Sooner or later, more states are going to make rules and regulations for online poker. Delaying these decisions will only result in the lost tax revenue. Online poker is one of the most popular games in the gambling industry. With millions of active players from different countries, this one game can make a great difference when we talk about the benefits of legal gambling.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Corporate Tax Plank

Higher corporate taxes fund infrastructure, increasing labor power, reduce unemployment and poverty, and fund state budgets.

Klinger et al 14 (Scott Klinger, Director of Revenue and Spending Policies, Center for Effective Government, Liz Ryan Murray, Policy Director, National People's Action, Katherine McFate, President and CEO, Center for Effective Government, George Goehl, Executive Director, National People's Action, Center for Effective Government, 3-27-2014, "The Disappearing Corporate Tax Base: How to Reclaim Lost Tax Revenue to Rebuild State Budgets,” Center for Effective Government, ) @HA?

With record profits, corporations could pay a larger share of their profits to invest in our aging physical infrastructure and to protect against new health and environmental risks. With more corporate taxes, we could rehire laid-off teachers and first responders, help shore up municipal finances, and undertake repairs and new projects to keep our communities strong, healthy, and vibrant. We could close tax loopholes that reward corporations for shifting jobs and profits offshore and for exorbitantly compensating their executives. In fact, if corporations today paid taxes at the same rates they paid under the Eisenhower or Nixon administrations, significant new revenues would be available to the nation. If Corporations Paid the Same Proportion of Taxes as In Times Past... Corp Income . Tax Paid (in Corp Tax as Corp Tax as % Corp Profits as Yea' Pres'dent Billions of % of GDP of Fed Budget % of GDP 2013 dollars) 1953 Eisenhower (R) $185.3 5.9% 30.5% 5.9% 1973 Nixon (R) $189.7 2.7% 15.7% 6.7% 1993 Clinton (D) $117.5 1.7% 10.2% 4.7% 2013 Obama (D) $273.5 1.6% 9.9% 12.5% At present, the debate around corporate tax reform is almost exclusively focused on how much corporations can "afford" to pay while remaining competitive. This must change. Last year, corporate profits reached record levels — more than 12 percent of GDP. At the same time, corporate taxes were less than two percent of GDP. Corporations can, and should, pay far more. At one time, they did. Even today, they pay higher taxes in other developed countries than they do in the U.S. If corporate tax payments had grown at the same rate as the overall economy since 1953 (were the same percentage of the economy they were when Eisenhower was president), corporations would have paid $957 billion last year, $683 billion more than they actually paid. If corporate tax payments were the same share of the economy as in 1973, when Richard Nixon sat in the Oval Office, corporations would have paid $461 billion in 2013, $188 billion more than they actually paid. With an additional $188 billion in corporate taxes (which would raise corporate taxes to about 3.5 percent of GDP) we could spend $36 billion and refill the 667,000 state and local public jobs lost to budget cuts. We can put unemployed Americans back to work educating our kids, responding to emergencies, repairing our roads, collecting our trash, and tending our parks and public spaces. We could also make a long-term investment in repairing our roads, bridges, schools, levees and dams, and public water systems. The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) estimates that a sustained investment of $125 billion a year would bring our infrastructure up to 21st century standards. This sort of investment would help businesses operate more efficiently (ASCE estimates that deficient infrastructure costs businesses nearly $1 trillion a year in traffic delays, vehicle repairs, and delivery problems, among other things) and would make our economy more attractive to investors. It would also create 2.5 million new jobs. We could use the remaining funds to restore cuts to Head Start, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, Meals on Wheels, Housing Choice vouchers, and restore funding for environmental protection and for student financial aid. Demanding that the corporations that have grown and prospered from the social, political, and economic structures in America contribute to the support of the nation is simple equity. We can achieve a new prosperity this way in four simple steps: Step 1: Adopt corporate tax reform that ensures companies help pay for the public systems that benefit their business and the national economy Given our continuing high rates of unemployment and stagnant wages, many Americans want to see U.S. corporations contributing more to help the nation -— especially since many of these same corporations relied on the government for assistance when the financial crisis occurred. We can raise significant revenue from profitable corporations by closing the following loopholes and adopting one new tax. End Deferral of Taxes on Offshore Profits (would raise $59 billion per year) In the 19605, the Kennedy administration, eager to support U.S. businesses expanding into foreign markets, adopted a rule that allowed U.S. taxes on foreign income to be put off, or deferred, until those funds were brought back to the U.S. While this rule made sense at the time, modern corporations use it as the major tool to avoid paying U.S. taxes. U.S. multinational corporations have amassed more than $2 trillion of offshore profits, much of it in tax havens and all of it untaxed in the U.S. While there are many proposals for stemming this outflow of profits and jobs, none is more effective than simply ending deferral. If this were done, corporations would report their offshore income on their U.S. tax returns and then get a full credit for all taxes paid to a foreign government. If they are operating in a country with a corporate tax system similar to ours, they would owe little to no additional tax at home. If. however. they are sheltering their income in a tax haven, they would be responsible for the full American tax rate. Sen. Bernie Sanders (l-VT) and Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) have introduced the Corporate Tax Fairness Act, which would end the deferral provision. Close CEO Pay Loopholes (could raise $5 billion a year) In 1993. Congress tried to control soaring executive pay by instituting a cap on how much pay corporations could deduct from their taxes. They settled on a figure of $1 million per executive per year. Companies could continue to pay their top management as much as they wanted, but they would only receive tax breaks on the first million dollars per employee. As the bill moved toward final passage a giant loophole was inserted, allowing unlimited deductions so long as the pay was deemed to be "performance based." That loophole had the perverse impact of accelerating executive compensation to levels never before seen as companies replaced cash compensation (which faced limited tax deductibility) with stock-based bonus compensation that would be fully deductible. Closing this loophole will increase the funding the federal government has available for aid to states by $50 billion over the next decade. Sens. Jack Reed (D-RI) and Richard Blumental (D-CT) have introduced the Stop Subsidizing Multimillion Dollar Corporate Bonuses Act, which would close this loophole. Adopt a Wall Street Sales Tax (could raise 8174-354 billion a year) Excessive speculation and lax oversight resulted in Wall Street excesses crashing the economy in 2008. While communities across America are still struggling to fully recover, Wall Street is once again thriving - paying its employees more than $1 billion in bonuses last year. Hundreds of billions of dollars could be generated by establishing a small sales tax on trades of stocks. bonds, and other financial assets like futures contracts and credit default swaps (the latter played a powerful role in the 2008 financial collapse). The European Union will begin to impose a financial transaction tax later this year. In contrast. Congress has failed to act, although several bills have been introduced in Congress that would impose different levels of tax. We believe that at least a portion of this revenue should be dedicated to increased federal aid to states and cities. States and cities were particularly hard hit by the 2008 economic crash. and it would be fitting for Wall Street's excessive trading profits to be channeled to rebuilding local economies. Step 2: Demand That the Super Wealthy Contribute to the Nation Tax Wealth Like Work (could raise $161 Billion a year) If you invest for a living in America, you are taxed at half the rate you would be if you worked for a living. Discounted tax rates on capital gains (the money one makes buying and selling stocks and other assets) cost the US Treasury $161 billion last year. Each year. the IRS publishes detailed data on the taxes paid by the 400 richest Americans. In 2009 (the most recent year studied —the data is delayed because taxpayers have three years to file amended tax returns). the average income of a top 400 taxpayer was $202 million; it took 577 million to just qualify for this exclusive club. The collective income of these 400 people exceeded 57 trillion. Among the top 400, $49 billion of their income came from dividends and capital gains taxed at reduced rates. and just $7 billion came from wages or salaries. Because of this heavy reliance on tax breaks on income from investments, the richest 400 taxpayers paid an effective tax rate of just 19.9 percent. The Buffett Rule (could raise $5 billion a year) Billionaire investor Warren Buffett, the second wealthiest man in America, surveyed his office and found that his 17 percent federal tax rate was lower than all of his staff, including his secretary. Struck by this blatant inequity, Buffett called for a change in the law. In response, Congress and the president have each proposed a "Buffett Rule," in which wealthy Americans earning more than $1 million a year would pay at least 30 percent of their income in taxes to help pay for the cost of public services and investments. Step 3: Repeal the Budget Control Act of 2011 Slashing government spending takes money out of the economy and reduces the opportunity for growth and recovery. When teachers. infrastructure construction workers, and first responders lose their jobs. they no longer spend money at neighborhood stores. gas stations, and restaurants. Mandatory spending cuts such as those imposed by the Budget Control Act reduce public services, penalize public sector workers, and harm the communities where they live. January's Murray-Ryan budget compromise was widely reported as bringing some relief from the automatic mindless across-the-board cuts known as the "sequester." Some media sources even proclaimed that the "age of austerity" had ended. But the BCA was a ten-year commitment and it is still in effect. It limits our nation's ability to invest in new needs - like expanding Social Security to address the looming retirement security crisis or to address emerging threats like climate change and new infectious diseases. Step 4: Insist Corporations Pay State Taxes De-Couple State Taxes from Wasteful Federal Tax Giveaways (amount raised depends on the particular federal tax benefits eliminated from state tax returns) The federal tax code is loaded with corporate tax breaks, thanks to expensive lobbyists and large campaign contributions. Unfortunately. many states use the taxable income portion of federal tax forms as a basis for calculating state taxable income. When they (10. states are reinforcing federal tax breaks. State legislators can prevent this by critically examining the worst of these tax breaks and requiring companies to add them back into their state taxable income. More than half the states require corporations to add back in benefits from bonus depreciation rules in the federal tax code. Bonus depreciation allows corporations to deduct 50 percent of the cost of new property or equipment in the year it was purchased, rather than spreading out the deduction over the useful life of the equipment. President Obama extended bonus depreciation three times since. The provision expired at the end of last year, one of 55 tax breaks that ended. Congress is expected to renew these largely corporate tax breaks soon. Even while stopping federal assistance to the states or extended unemployment benefits to millions of Americans, Congress appears willing to allow the continuation of corporate tax breaks. Close Water's Edge Loophole (could raise more than $1 billion) Twenty-three states and the District of Columbia have in place combined reporting provisions that calculate corporate state income based on a formula that considers where sales transactions occur. In these states, legislators can require corporations to add back any income earned "beyond the water's edge" of U.S. territorial boundaries in offshore tax havens. Montana and Oregon have already made this change, and Maine is currently actively debating legislation that would end this loophole. Improve Corporate Tax Disclosure At present, corporations provide very little information on the taxes they pay. Federal disclosure rules require them to make estimates of taxes they expect to pay but do not require them to reveal exactly how much they pay to the federal government. Companies are supposed to disclose how much they pay in taxes to the 50 states collectively, but some corporations ignore even this modest requirement. In Citizens for Tax Justice's recent report on state taxes, they found that 19 of the 288 companies studied provided not even the minimal state tax disclosure required by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The SEC should enforce current tax disclosure regulations. and they should extend tax disclosure rules and require all firms to disclose the taxes they pay in each state where they operate. A corporation should also be forced to disclose the amount and purpose of public subsidies it receives, including the impact of these subsidies on their businesses and whether the subsidies resulted in additional jobs. Enact Federal Legislation Outlawing Interstate Tax Subsidy Competition (could save states 580 billion a year) Corporations are currently playing states off against one another in a competition to keep existing jobs or attract new ones. These corporate tax subsidies — whether paid in cash or in tax credits - cost state and local governments about $80 billion a year. according to a 2012 study by The New York Times. These subsidies deplete state economic development resources and often fail to deliver the jobs promised by the corporation. Stopping this race to the bottom has proven difficult. Congress should consider enacting legislation that ties continuing federal revenue sharing to ending these wasteful subsidies. This would help level the playing field for states that refuse to engage in this kind of jobs blackmail, and it would ensure that the federal revenue assistance to states is not siphoned off to support for profitable corporations instead of helping to provide much needed public services like education and infrastructure to citizens. Enact the Marketplace Fairness Act (could raise an additional $23 billion in sales tax revenue for states) For the last two decades, a court decision has blocked states from applying state sales taxes to Internet transactions undertaken by residents in their states. Allowing tax-free Internet sales has allowed e-commerce to thrive and has created an unfair disadvantage for Main Street merchants; many failing small businesses site the competition from Internet distributors as the source of their demise. Enacting this legislation would allow states to tax Internet sales and recapture 523 billion a year in lost sales tax revenue. Several recent studies have exposed that in addition to starving state and federal budgets of revenue, many large corporations are, in effect, double-dipping by relying on government programs to supplement their poorly paid workers' wages. The fast-food industry alone is costing tax-payers nearly $7 billion per year in public assistance to their underpaid workers. Corporations must pay a living wage with benefits to their workers or pay a substantial penalty to supplement workers' pay, allow workers a venue to collectively negotiate with their employees, and pay for the provision of government services. Our Choice: Higher Corporate Profits or Public Structures that Work for Everyone America's leading corporations are experiencing record profits. Some of the largest corporations rely on public spending for a majority of their business. Others dominate the market in their respective industry and use their size and market share to increase their profits (rather than competing on innovation and service). All of these corporations have been able to grow and prosper because of the legal protections and social and economic benefits that America provides. We have a huge national consumer market, an effective system of interstate commerce. a functional national transportation and communications system, an affordable and secure energy grid, a large business services industry, and an educated workforce. But American families are struggling. More than 10 million Americans are out of work. and nearly half of them have been jobless for more than six months. The salary and wages of most Americans have been stagnant for decades, and millions have faced foreclosure and retirement insecurity. This divide is pulling the country apart. And yet in the midst of these national difficulties, some of America's largest corporations are calling for lower taxes. With corporate profits at record levels. stock markets reaching new highs each month. and CEO pay once again soaring. the idea that current tax rates on corporate profits hurt the competitiveness of American businesses is blatantly false. In fact, most U.S. multinational corporations pay a higher rate of tax on their income earned in foreign countries than they pay on their U.S. profits. Of the 12S multinational corporations studied by Citizens for Tax Justice in their recently released Sorry State of Corporate Taxes report, two-thirds paid an average 27.3 percent tax rate in foreign nations and just 15.8 percent in U.S. taxes. Across the entire 125-company universe, the companies studied paid an average foreign tax rate nearly three percent higher than their average tax rate on U.S. income. Unfortunately, corporate tax reform has bipartisan support in Congress. Both President Obama and House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Dave Camp (R-MI) have proposed sweeping corporate tax reform that would eliminate many loopholes and lower corporate tax rates. While the two plans differ in significant ways, both propose lowering the official tax rate on corporate profits instead of asking extremely profitable corporations to contribute more to the national infrastructure that makes their success possible. We've seen how that story ends. Even if a disastrous 'revenue neutral' proposal carries the day, it won't hold once corporate lobbyists dive back in to re-open their favorite loopholes. The multinational corporations that have parked profits in offshore tax haven accounts to avoid paying U.S. taxes are demanding another corporate "tax holiday," which would allow them to bring a large portion the more than $2 trillion of untaxed assets they have offshore back into the U.S. by paying pennies on the dollar of what they would otherwise owe. Bipartisan bills have been introduced in the House and Senate to capitalize an infrastructure bank using money generated from a corporate tax holiday. President Obama has proposed a similar one time tax on untaxed offshore profit that would provide hundreds of billions of dollars of tax forgiveness to the very corporations that have gamed the tax system the most. There's a better way to raise money for infrastructure - end the deferral provision that allows corporations to play this game. Doing so will generate $59 billion every year, rather than the $150 billion one-time amount that would be raised by the Obama plan.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Complementary Currency

State job guarantee has more benefits than FJG- community, unemployment, and innovation

Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.166-167.) @HA?

7.4 Enhancing Community: Other Benefits of Localism The local job guarantee would have all the regular potential benefits of employment and the national job guarantee, such as increased production of community services, developing skills, utilizing creativity, and countering the social costs of unemployment. The local aspect of the program has additional potential benefits, however, such as those often noted in the local currency literature and other considerations of localism. The program promotes increased interaction with one’s neighbors, and in this and other ways can strengthen community ties. The program therefore promotes mutual aid and reciprocity. Family and neighborhood empowerment follows from a program based on cooperation and local development. Numerous environmental benefits are also possible. Previously, in addition to arguing that the JG may serve as a vehicle for humanistic social policies, such as a living wage, health care or child care benefits, and a shorter work week, I have suggested that the program might be used to help redefine what constitutes valuable work and also provide spaces for experimenting with alternative, non-capitalist social organization (Forstater 2013). It is possible the JG, and especially the local JG, may be an area for positive collaboration between the public sector and the solidarity economy (sometimes called the “social and solidarity economy,” or SSE) (Utting 2015). Several concepts related to the solidarity economy and that have been little examined in economics are temporary autonomous zones (TAZ), prefigurative behaviors, and heterotopias. A heterotopia also refers to alternative or counter-hegemonic spaces in the present, not some future dream world that will only arrive after capitalism is completely ended (Watson and Gibson 1995). Similarly, many use temporary autonomous zones (TAZ) as creative community alternatives (Graeber 2007). Prefigurative politics (or behaviors or institutions) refer to the principle of behaving now in ways consistent with the future society we want to create, not waiting until that time arrives, and behaving in anti-social ways now (Milstein 2010). In all these cases, the point is that we should not and cannot wait for the arrival of the imagined future to begin, in fact the alternative already exists, and we must nurture, learn from, and improve upon these. There is much work to be done; some of it might begin in a local job guarantee program that results from a partnership of local or regional governments and the solidarity economy.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Complementary Currency

Empirics Prove complementary currency is achievable and effective

Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.162-164.) @HA?

7.2 The UMKC Buckaroo Program: A Neo-Chartalist Complementary Currency When the Center for Full Employment and Price Stability (C-FEPS) moved to the Economics Department at UMKC in the fall of 1999, the department commenced a service-learning program that would encourage students to do community service while learning about modern monetary systems and government budgets. Rather than directly requiring students to do community service, the department created its own currency, called the “Buckaroo.” The name of the currency is a play on the words “kangaroo” (the UMKC university mascot), “buck” (a common slang term for a dollar), and—being located in Kansas City—the word for cowboy derived from the Spanish, vaquero (“Buckaroo”). On the face of the Buckaroo is the inscription: “this note represents one hour of community service by a UMKC student,” and the note is denominated as “One ROO Hour.” The note also has a picture of Thorstein Veblen, the Institutionalist economist who held a position for a time at the University of Missouri, and whose work is closely studied by students at UMKC. Instead of just requiring students to do service, professors include as part of the course requirements that students pay a tax of, for example, four Buckaroos per week for the semester. Approved community service providers (state and local government offices, public schools, NGOs, and not-for-profit agencies) submit requests to the UMKC Economics Department “Treasury” for student hours and are awarded “special drawing rights” (SDRs) as long as basic health and safety and liability standards are met. Service providers pay students one Buckaroo per hour, which is equivalent to spending by the Treasury. Students pay their tax with the Buckaroo notes they earn performing community service, and the requirement is met when their tax liability is met. There is no limit to how many Buckaroos a student can earn. Some students will perform more hours of service than that needed to satisfy their tax liability. Buckaroos are freely transferable, so they may exchange for goods and services or other currencies. Buckaroos are a floating exchange rate currency, in other words UMKC does not peg the exchange rate between buckaroos and dollars, for example. Buckaroos are also non-convertible, meaning UMKC doesn’t promise to convert it to anything, such as gold. The Buckaroo is a case of public monopoly, since UMKC is the sole supplier and it is against the rules to counterfeit Buckaroos. The Buckaroo is a sovereign currency, issued by a monopoly supplier who imposes a tax liability in its otherwise worthless currency. UMKC only promises it will accept Buckaroos in payment of taxes. The dollar is also a sovereign, non-convertible, floating currency without intrinsic value and operated as a public monopoly. The only promise the US Treasury makes is that it will accept dollars in payment of taxes. UMKC always runs a Buckaroo deficit, because students always earn more than their tax liability (they lose some, keep some as souvenirs, etc.). UMKC’s Buckaroo fiscal deficit is exactly equal to the Buckaroos saved by the students. The value of the Buckaroo is a function of what the students have to do to earn a Buckaroo from UMKC, and is unaffected by the size of the deficit or the amount of Buckaroo spending by the department. UMKC Buckaroo spending, however, does not depend on collecting taxes. Certainly, UMKC does not need to borrow Buckaroos in order to spend. A UMKC graduate, Fadhel Kaboub, earned his PhD and left to become a professor at Denison University, where he started a similar program there called “Denison Volunteer Dollars.” If UMKC decided it would give up its currency, and join a monetary union with Denison, then UMKC could not pay students unless it collected taxes first, or borrowed DVDs in private markets. UMKC would no longer be a monetary sovereign. It would no longer be a money monopolist. It could no longer continue to run fiscal deficits to create full employment and satisfy the desire of students to save. Denison would tell UMKC it better get its fiscal house in order, and so force UMKC to accept an austerity program. When Greece, Spain, Italy, and other member nations joined the Euro, it put itself in exactly the same position as UMKC, if UMKC gave up the Buckaroo and joined Denison in a monetary union (or pegged the Buckaroo to the DVD). Before adopting the Euro, the member nations were also monetary sovereigns, and their currencies were also a non-convertible floating currencies backed by the tax system. But when they adopted the Euro, they voluntarily gave up their monetary sovereignty. They are no longer money monopolists. They are no longer a currency issuers, but now, like households, they are currency users. Short of UMKC voluntarily giving up its monetary sovereignty, however, the similarities between the Buckaroo and other non-convertible, floating currencies such as the dollar: Governments issue money to buy what they need; they tax to generate a demand for that money; and then they accept the money in payment of the tax. If a deficit results, that simply indicates that the population wishes to hoard some of the money. The deficit is of no consequence to the government; it merely allows the population to save in the form of government money. If the government wants to, it can let the population trade the money for interest-earning government bonds, but the government never needs to borrow its own money from the public. Taxes and bonds, therefore, have nothing to do with financing a government’s spending. (Wray 2000, pp. 61–62)