Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Complementary Currency

States can institute a local jobs guarantee by creating a tax-driven complementary currency

Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.165-166.) @HA?

7.3 The Local Job Guarantee Complementary currencies (CCs), both historically and currently, come in a variety of forms. Some have a fixed exchange rate with the national currency, while others have a rate that is not. Some are based primarily on commitment of the community members to the locality, while others are “tax-driven.” Some are issued by NGOs or other community organization, while others are issued by the local government. To create jobs, localities run what amounts to a local Buckaroo program, where the CC is a non-convertible, floating rate currency issued by the local government and is tax driven. The local government would impose a tax payable only in the CC, say four per household. We propose the tax be imposed on households rather than individuals so as not to penalize larger families. For the program to operate, the CC needn’t be accepted in payment of any other tax. The locality will then announce that it is offering a community service job to anyone ready and willing to work, paying one CC per hour. For localities suffering under the economic crisis plaguing the Eurozone, four hours per week of community service is not too much to ask households to contribute to rebuild their economies. Some households will work more than four hours per week, some will work less. Those who work, say, 40 hours per week, will pay their tax and have 36 CCs left over. Those who are too busy to work in the program (because they are working full-time, for example) will need to acquire CCs from those who have extra. In this way, the CC will circulate in the local economy. Like the Buckaroo and the US dollar, and unlike the Euro, the CC would be a non-convertible, floating currency. Like UMKC and the USA, the local community will be a monetary sovereign (in terms of CC). Depending on the regional, national, and local laws, the CC may be called something other than “money,” but since there are currently hundreds of alternative currencies operating world-wide, there is nothing preventing localities from pursuing full employment in this way (though the legal status may change in different regions). Interestingly, a similar proposal has been independently put forward in the alternative currency literature. Bernard Lietaer and his co-authors, cited above for their recognition of chartalism, have proposed a local employment program based on a complementary currency they call “Civics” (Lietaer et al. 2012, pp. 174–179). As in the local currency literature generally, the authors discuss other aspects of the proposal that make sense, such as the advantages of electronic accounting over paper currency, and cases where households may be exempt from the obligation (elderly, those with disabilities).

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Marijuana Tax

Cities can use marijuana tax to fund the jobs guarantee

Lalljee 21

Jason Lalljee, 12-27-2021, "Meet the mayor-elect who wants to use a weed tax to pay for a guaranteed income program in New York's 4th-biggest city: 'This is an industry with the potential to make millions of dollars.'," Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/ubi-basic-income-weed-marijuana-tax-rochester-mayor-malik-evans-2021-12

In the meantime, the Rochester City Council approved a pilot program for a guaranteed basic income program, providing $500 per month to 175 families that live at or below the federal poverty level. That program will be funded by money from President Joe Biden's American Rescue Plan, which several cities around the US have used to launch their own guaranteed basic income funds. Many of the programs that launched this year are either using funds from the ARP, grants from former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, or money from the state government to help low income residents. Evans wants Rochester's program to ultimately be less reliant on that money, although he is looking to expand the current guaranteed income program to 1,000 families using private funds. "We want to start getting revenue from marijuana because you can't just have the government," he said. Evans launched the Rochester Cannabis Preparation Commission last week, so that the city can get started the moment it gets the go ahead. This builds on the proposal of Evans' predecessor, Lovely Warren, who wanted to use a tax on legal marijuana sales to fund a reparations-oriented universal basic income program. Buffalo, the second largest city in New York, proposed a similar program in March. Rochester is the fourth largest, according to the US Census. New York municipalities have until December 31 to opt out of hosting dispensaries or consumption spaces. More than 400 towns and villages across the state have blocked dispensaries from opening up as the deadline approaches, Rochester being only one of four municipalities in Monroe County to opt in. Evans also wants those who profit off of the industry to be more diverse. An Insider report found this year that top executives at the 14 largest cannabis companies are overwhelmingly white men — about 70% of them. "We'll have to figure out how we go about setting up our program to make sure we can help entrepreneurs who may not have been involved in the [cannabis industry] in the past," Evans said.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Marijuana Tax

States brought in $15 billion tax revenue from recreational marijuana from 2014-2022

Jaeger 23 – [Kyle Jaeger, senior editor for Marijuana Moment's Sacramento, “States Have Generated Over $15 Billion In Marijuana Tax Revenue Since 2014, Though Earnings Declined Last Year, Report Finds,” Marijuana Moment, 05/01/2023, ] /jsam

States have collectively generated more than $15 billion in adult-use marijuana tax revenue from 2014 to 2022, a new report published on Monday by the Marijuana Policy Project (MPP) found. But while legal states saw about $3.8 billion in cannabis tax dollars in 2022 alone, it represented the first time that revenue was lower than the prior year, which experts attribute to a “multitude of factors,” including COVID-related policies and trends. Still, the fact that 2022 brought in almost $100 million less in tax revenue compared to 2021 is notable given that more states like New Jersey and New Mexico launched their recreational markets last year, which would presumably lend to higher tax yields. States where cannabis legalization is newer did see higher levels of tax revenue, but six states with the most established markets have seen declines offsetting those gains. Here are the 2022 state-by-state totals: Alaska: $28,649,408 Arizona: $223,863,799 California: $1,074,560,287 Colorado: $305,034,034 Illinois: $562,119,019 Maine: $25,329,534 Massachusetts: $250,710,415 Michigan: $326,049,074 Montana: $41,989,466 Nevada: $196,952,338 New Jersey: $20,139,655 New Mexico: $36,684,235 Rhode Island: $579,439 Oregon: $150,316,424 Washington: $529,443,420 Vermont: $2,363,000 Here are the national year-by-year totals: 2014: $68,503,980 2015: $264,211,871 2016: $530,521,110 2017: $736,534,982 2018: $1,308,693,928 2019: $1,749,459,667 2020: $2,814,837,199 2021: $3,866,974,690 2022: $3,774,783,548 CUMULATIVE TOTAL: $15,114,520,975 Vicente LLP Director of Economics and Research Andrew Livingston said in a press release that the overall decline in 2022 were “due to a multitude of factors.” “While 2022 cannabis taxes are lower in some established markets than they were in 2021, it’s important to know how COVID-19 and pandemic initiated lockdown orders increased cannabis demand,” he said. “People could not spend their money going to concerts, going out to dinner, or vacation travel. So many people increased their consumption of consumer packaged goods. Cannabis was a product that could still be purchased and made the difficulty of staying at home for months on end watching TV shows and movies a bit more enjoyable.” Toi Hutchinson, president and CEO of MPP, said that states that have enacted legalization “are benefiting from hundreds of millions in tax revenue each year.” “These new streams of revenue are helping to fund crucial social services and programs across the country, such as education, alcohol and drug treatment, veterans’ services, job training, and reinvestment in communities that have been disproportionately affected by the war on cannabis,” she said. “The states that lag behind will not only be doing a disservice to their constituents—they will also be leaving money on the table.” The new report only looks at recreational marijuana revenue and doesn’t account for sales conducted via states’ separate medical cannabis programs. With newer markets continuing to mature—and states like Delaware and Maryland positioned to launch their own industries after more recently ending prohibition—the expectation is that more tax dollars will follow in the coming years. States in newer markets have continued to see record-breaking marijuana sales as more businesses are licensed and consumers move to the regulated industry. For example, Michigan cannabis sales reached a record high in March, with nearly $250 million in combined recreational and medical cannabis purchases, according to state regulators. Connecticut also saw a record $22 million in combined recreational and medical marijuana sales in March. Missouri cannabis sales reached a record $126 million that month, the second month since adult-use shops opened in the state after voters approved legalization at the ballot last November. The governor of New Mexico recently marked the one-year anniversary of the state’s adult-use marijuana market, touting its more than $300 million in sales since last April as well as the thousands of jobs the cannabis industry has created. In Arizona, the year-end total for 2022 adult-use cannabis purchases reached $1.4 billion. In Massachusetts, the state’s recreational market officially exceeded $4 billion in sales in January after launching in 2018. Conversely, a top Wisconsin senator recently released a legislative analysis that showed just how much money her state lost out to Illinois last year, with Wisconsin residents who lack a regulated market going across the border and spending more than $121 million on marijuana.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Marijuana Tax

There is plenty of state funding in cannabis taxes.

Braun, ’21 (https://fortune.com/2021/12/03/cannabis-taxes-generate-12-billion-by-2030-barclays-estimate/)

When U.S. states and municipalities burn through their federal coronavirus relief money, taxes on legal weed will help blunt the budget pain. Cannabis tax revenue generated more than $2 billion in the U.S. last year and that could grow to $10 billion to $12 billion for states by 2030, exceeding tax revenue from alcohol, according to municipal-bond strategists at Barclays Plc. This year, five states—New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Virginia and New Mexico legalized recreational pot, bringing to 18 the number of states enacting law to regulate and tax cannabis for adult use. “We’ll have some long lasting consequences of the pandemic and you’ll need to make money up somewhere,” said Mikhail Foux, Barclays head of municipal strategy. For now, U.S. municipalities are swimming in cash. States and cities collected $350 billion from the COVID-19 stimulus package to spend on everything from subsides for low income renters to pay increases for teachers. They also plan to fund hundreds of millions of dollars on projects like broadband and water and sewer upgrades—and that’s before they get another massive infusion of cash from the $550 billion infrastructure package approved last month. Municipalities must commit the stimulus money by 2024, and spend it by 2026. And when the federal money’s gone, municipalities will need to find new revenue to pay for ongoing programs they funded with one-time aid. Legal sales of cannabis totaled $17 billion in 2020 and should grow to as much as $27 billion this year, according to Barclays. By 2030 sales should reach about $80 billion, the London-based bank estimates. California took in almost $1 billion in cannabis tax revenue in the first three quarters of 2021, a 21% increase over the same period the prior year. California may bring in $1.7 billion in cannabis revenue by 2026, while New York, New Jersey and Connecticut could generate as much as $2 billion, Barclays estimated. There’s more growth potential in populous states like Florida and Pennsylvania that haven’t yet legalized recreational weed.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › Marijuana Tax

States bringing in billions in tax revenue

Braun 21 [Martin Z. Braun, Bloomburg reporter, “Cannabis taxes may generate $12 billion for U.S. states by 2030, according to Barclays strategists,” Fortune, 12/03/2021, ] /jsam

Cannabis tax revenue generated more than $2 billion in the U.S. last year and that could grow to $10 billion to $12 billion for states by 2030, exceeding tax revenue from alcohol, according to municipal-bond strategists at Barclays Plc. This year, five states—New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Virginia and New Mexico legalized recreational pot, bringing to 18 the number of states enacting law to regulate and tax cannabis for adult use. “We’ll have some long lasting consequences of the pandemic and you’ll need to make money up somewhere,” said Mikhail Foux, Barclays head of municipal strategy. For now, U.S. municipalities are swimming in cash. States and cities collected $350 billion from the COVID-19 stimulus package to spend on everything from subsides for low income renters to pay increases for teachers. They also plan to fund hundreds of millions of dollars on projects like broadband and water and sewer upgrades—and that’s before they get another massive infusion of cash from the $550 billion infrastructure package approved last month. Municipalities must commit the stimulus money by 2024, and spend it by 2026. And when the federal money’s gone, municipalities will need to find new revenue to pay for ongoing programs they funded with one-time aid. Legal sales of cannabis totaled $17 billion in 2020 and should grow to as much as $27 billion this year, according to Barclays. By 2030 sales should reach about $80 billion, the London-based bank estimates. California took in almost $1 billion in cannabis tax revenue in the first three quarters of 2021, a 21% increase over the same period the prior year. California may bring in $1.7 billion in cannabis revenue by 2026, while New York, New Jersey and Connecticut could generate as much as $2 billion, Barclays estimated. There’s more growth potential in populous states like Florida and Pennsylvania that haven’t yet legalized recreational weed.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › States Have Money

States have the money to do basic income

Noah Smith, 21. Smith is an American blogger, journalist, and commentator on economics and current events. Smith obtained his doctorate in Economics from the University of Michigan in 2012 and was an assistant professor of Behavioral Finance at Stony Brook University “Will New Mexico prove a universal basic income can work?” August 14, 2021. https://www.tbsnews.net/analysis/will-new-mexico-prove-universal-basic-income-can-work-288169

Basic income experiments like the one in Stockton, California (on which Santa Fe's experiment is modeled) have achieved promising results with modest monthly sums. Most encouragingly, recipients worked more rather than less, consistent with the idea that a modest stipend represents a hand up instead of just a handout; extra monthly cash gave them the time and mental space to focus on long-term self-betterment. A few hundred extra dollars a month is also unlikely to hurt labor supply; something that's borne out by economic evidence. And while still somewhat expensive, it's at least within the realm of fiscal possibility. States are the perfect place to try out this new, scaled-down basic income. Unlike cities, they have the money to carry out these experiments at a truly universal level; Stockton or Santa Fe can hand out money to a few people, with the help of private foundations, but states have far deeper pockets.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › FUNDING › States Have Money

States have sufficient money to implement fiscal redistribution

Johannes Fleck et al, 21. *Fleck is an economist at the Federal Reserve Board of Governors. *Jonathan Heathcote is a monetary advisor in the Research Department of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. *Kjetil Storesletten is the Richard and Beverly Fink Professor of Economics at University of Minnesota and a Fellow of Econometric Society. *Giovanni L. Violante is a Professor of Economics at Princeton University. “Tax and Transfer Progressivity at the US State Level,” September 2021. . This is a working paper. The date we accessed it was 5/22/23.

Income inequality has risen sharply in the United States and other countries during recent decades. This trend has rekindled interest in using government redistribution through taxes and transfers as a policy tool to potentially address adverse aspects of inequality. A natural first step is to measure the redistribution already taking place through the current government tax- and transfer system. Most of the US debate has focused on redistribution at the federal level. But tax revenue at the state and local level is also large, amounting to around 7% of GDP compared to 8% for federal income taxes and 6% for payroll taxes during the last decades. Moreover, there is large variation across US states in terms of the level of per capita tax revenue, in terms of the choice of tax base, and in terms of the level and composition of spending.1 Thus, one might expect substantial differences across states in terms of how much redistribution the tax and transfer system delivers.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › 1NCs › 1nc – JG (Half-Time)

Half time solves – more feasible and can be implemented by states to model for the federal level

Newman ’21 (Nathan Newman, a writer and professor of criminal justice and sociology at CUNY, “Reset Labor Markets With a Local Half-Time Job Guarantee”, The Nation, September 21st 2021 https://www.thenation.com/article/economy/half-time-job-gaurantee/tnamp/)

In the wake of the Covid recession, state and local governments have the chance to remake local labor markets—and public assistance—by adopting a policy guaranteeing half-time employment at $15 an hour for every resident.

Despite the hype of supposed proliferating job openings, long experience shows that even if we approach rates of nominal “full employment” again, such statistics will inevitably ignore higher unemployment rates for Black, Latino, formerly incarcerated, and many other workers. In a Covid-based recession where women in particular have struggled to return to previous levels of employment, a job guarantee may be critical to restore real employment alternatives for everyone who wants a job.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › 1NCs › 1nc – JG (Local Currency)

Counterplan alone develops the localism necessary to prevent extinction

Ben G. Price 22, National Organizer, Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF), “Don’t Fight City Hall; Make It Work for People and Nature,” Foreward, Empowering Municipal Sustainability: A Guide for Towns, Cities, and Citizens, ed. Alexandra Reed Lajoux, de Gruyter, 2022, ISBN 978-3-11-068986-0, pp.xi-xvi

In Empowering Municipal Sustainability: A Guide for Towns, Cities, and Citizens, Alexandra Lajoux presents an extensive review of tools available to citizens and to locally elected officials in their quest to respond to constituent demands for community sustainability.

The book has global reach but is made in America, where citizen empowerment is sorely lacking. Most Americans seem to believe that all the governing that matters happens in state capitols and in Washington D.C.—and those centers of power are far beyond our reach and influence. The reason for this outward-looking stance toward government, and perhaps for Lajoux’s presentation of options for the governments located in our own hometowns, is that community residents have generally given up hope that local authority exists to set policy and respond to quality of life and existential challenges, such as the relationship between local industrial and extractive projects and cancer rates, habitat loss, and climate change.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › 1NCs › 1nc – JG (Local Currency)

A local jobs guarantee solves better and a complementary currency system can pay for it.

Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.159-162.) @HA?

According to neo-chartalism, a non-convertible floating currency is a monopoly of the issuer. The issuer has not only the power to impose debt obligations, but to designate what is acceptable to settle those obligations, what it will accept at its pay offices. In this way, the issuer can create a demand for otherwise worthless bits of paper, leading to general acceptability. The monopoly issuer can use its own monopoly money to purchase goods and services, including labor-power. These and related powers constitute a menu of instruments that may be used to conduct policy based on the principles of functional finance (Forstater 1999). Under such a system, the issuer’s budget may be freely used to promote job creation and other socio-economic goals. Such a system crucially depends on a one-to-one correspondence between money and the issuer, and only with such a strict correspondence does the issuer’s debt become truly riskless, enabling the issuer to buy anything for sale—and settle any obligation—denominated in the unit of account (Goodhart 1998). When communities forfeit their monetary sovereignty and the strict correspondence is severed, as in the current structure of the European EMU, they do face financial constraints, and currency risk is replaced by default risk. In 2012, I visited Italy to speak about the European crisis. The options for real change considered by the panelists included: (1) exit from the EMU by Italy or other individual member nations; (2) radical reform of the structure of the monetary union (or the use of “emergency” measures hidden in the fine print), for example, seriously increasing the deficit-GDP and debt-GDP ratios, zero-interest or low interest (or negative nominal interest!) loans to individual nations; (3) an end to the monetary union and a return to national currencies; and (4) the creation of a fiscal authority at the Euro level to work in concert with the ECB, that is, a “United States of Europe” (Kregel 1999). During the discussion period, a young audience member asked, “So, short of waiting for the politicians in our countries or the bureaucrats in the EU to implement changes they lack the will and/or the power to undertake, is there nothing we can do to help the unemployed and their families in our cities and localities?” While a second-best solution, because they will still be operating within the constraints of the monetary union, we proposed communities consider issuing a form of complementary currency (CC) quite consistent with neo-chartalist principles, and that a local job guarantee (JG) program be implemented to employ the unemployed in community service jobs. In fact, the general idea of alternative currencies is not one that is new in Europe. In addition, the proposal is one that could be applied in other contexts where a full-blown national JG is not possible, either due to the constraints of some type of fixed exchange rate (whether a peg to another country’s currency or a monetary union) or because of political obstacles. In the USA, for example, proposals for a job guarantee have been put forward as national policies due to the flexibility the federal government has in paying for the program. This flexibility stems from the ability of the Treasury and the Central Bank to work in cooperation to implement fiscal and monetary policies. There are many obstacles, however, to government policies at the federal level, including political, administrative, legislative, and ideological. An alternative route to job creation at the local level would be to use a complementary currency to pay for community service employment. In this way, cities, counties, or states that are currency users in terms of dollars can become currency issuers in terms of the complementary currency. In addition, this form of local financing dovetails nicely with the focus of most job guarantee proposals on local administration and management of JG activities by local governments, non-profits, and NGOs. There are numerous other potential benefits of the local solution for individuals, families, neighborhoods, communities, and regions (Forstater 2013). It is possible that the benefits of a well-managed local currency may mean its implementation is desirable even in communities within a nation operating a neo-chartalist monetary system and managing its budgets according to the principles of functional finance (including a job guarantee), and during prosperous times and not only in the event of a crisis. 7.1 Money, Employment, and Complementary Currencies When there is unemployment, jobs and money, not resources and goods, are scarce. In a full-employment economy, there is a sense in which resources are scarce. Economizing is important, as resources can only be allocated to some use if they are removed from another productive activity. In an economic system with unemployment, however, resources are not scarce, as production may be increased by employing the unemployed resources. But there are other kinds of scarcity in the economy suffering from unemployment: “What is scarce is money. The lack of money to spend on the goods is what keeps the unemployed resources from producing more goods” (Lerner 1951, p. 147). Historically, many complementary currencies appeared during times of economic crisis, when money was not adequately available. If the amount of national currency was not sufficient to meet the community’s needs, they would simply create their own. During the Great Depression, there were dozens, if not hundreds, of cases of local currency, just in the USA (Gatch 2011). In Europe as well, numerous complementary currencies appeared during the Great Depression, and many exist there today. The contemporary literature on complementary currencies acknowledges and accepts the central insights of chartalism and functional finance. Bernard Lietaer and Jacqui Dunne, in Rethinking Money (2013), write: [A] sovereign government does not really “need” to raise taxes to pay for its expenses. Once this is understood, it becomes clear that neither taxes nor government bonds “finance” government spending. Instead, taxes are required to give value to money. (Lietaer and Dunne 2013, p. 27) In People Money: The Promise of Regional Currencies (2012), the authors state that “[i]f the authorities want to encourage regional currencies, so that their full potential can be realised, the most effective way of doing this would be to accept them in payment of specific taxes” (Kennedy et al. 2012, p. 68). Lietaer and his co-authors, in Money and Sustainability: The Missing Link (2012, pp. 133–138), cite authors such as Wray (1998), Mosler (1994), and others in support of what they call the “Fiat Currency Paradigm,” which they contrast with the “Official Paradigm” (i.e., the orthodox view). The core characteristic of the fiat currency paradigm, they argue, is that, “the systemic role of taxes is to give value to a currency, which, in the case of a fiat currency, would otherwise have no intrinsic value whatsoever” (Lietaer et al. 2012, p. 136). Historical analyses of what has been called “tax anticipation scrip” (essentially what neo-chartalists have termed “tax-driven money”) in the USA in the 1930s now include references to chartalism (Gatch 2011). Articles analyzing local currencies in journals such as the International Journal of Community Currencies and the Journal of Cleaner Production likewise reference the modern money literature (see, e.g., Dittmer 2013). Modern money theory has until recently not reciprocated this engagement of the complementary currency literature with neo-chartalism, functional finance, and the JG. This does seem to be changing a bit, however, and there have also been some notable exceptions, such as Peacock (2006, 2013). One of the most important links between chartalism and complementary currencies has been the Buckaroo program at the University of Missouri—Kansas City (UMKC).

2023 CNDI Counterplan
States CP › 1NCs › 1nc – JG (Marijuana)

The CP combines two policies that solve inequality and jobs.

Perez 19 [Maritza Perez, Senior Policy Analyst for CJR at Center for American Progress, "Using Marijuana Revenue to Create Jobs," Center for American Progress, 5-20-2019, ]/jsam

Correcting these injustices by using marijuana-related tax revenue to create specific opportunities for affected communities must come first—not at some later, undefined time. Below are several proposals offered by or implemented in jurisdictions across the country that provide communities most harmed by the war on marijuana with access to the benefits of creating a regulated marijuana market. These proposals include automatically clearing the records of people arrested or convicted of marijuana offenses; supporting businesses owned and operated by people of color entering the regulated marijuana market; and encouraging equitable licensing practices in the market.

Jurisdictions, however, should also offer broader solutions that are not necessarily connected directly to the regulated marijuana market. This issue brief, therefore, proposes using tax revenue from marijuana sales to create public sector jobs specifically for communities affected by the war on marijuana. The proposal uses the model laid out in CAP’s 2018 report, “Blueprint for the 21st Century: A Plan for Better Jobs and Stronger Communities,” that makes major investments in employment for long-term residents of targeted distressed areas who want to work.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › AT: Mining Environment Impact

Electrokinetic mining significantly reduces pollution

Normile, 22 --- writes about research and science policy developments in Asia, particularly China and Japan (1 NOV 2022, Dennis, “It’s electric! Technique could clean up mining of valuable rare earth elements; Current methods to extract key ingredients for green technologies require polluting chemicals,” https://www.science.org/content/article/it-s-electric-technique-could-clean-mining-valuable-rare-earth-elements, JMP))

Electric cars, wind turbines, and LED lighting all help keep the environment clean, but making them can be a dirty business. The high-performance magnets in motors and generators and the glowing phosphors in LEDs and flat screens all depend on substances called rare earth elements (REEs). And capturing REEs from the clay deposits in which many are found requires leaching agents that pollute soil and groundwater.

Now, a Chinese group has developed—and tested on tons of soil—an approach called electrokinetic mining that relies on electric currents to free the REEs, sharply reducing the need for polluting chemicals. The strategy, described this week in Nature Sustainability, could be “a game changer, providing that it is feasible at a large scale,” says Anouk Borst, a geologist at KU Leuven.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › AT: Mining Environment Impact

Fossil fuel harms outweigh

mining for REE much smaller than that for fossil fuels

Osaka, 23 (February 2, 2023 at 6:30 a.m. EST, Shannon Osaka, “Minerals are crucial for electric cars and wind turbines. Some worry whether we have enough; Minerals are crucial for electric cars, wind turbines, and solar panels. Some worry whether the future supply can meet the rising demand,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/02/02/critical-minerals-run-out-shortage/, JMP)) ***Note --- Seaver Wang is the co-director of climate and energy at the energy think tank the Breakthrough Institute

Wang said that there will probably be enough minerals — and that the environmental impacts of mining them should pale in comparison to the damages of fossil fuels. (Humanity “mines” billions of tons of fossil fuels from the ground every year; even a huge increase in mineral mining will only be millions of tons.)

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › AT: China Impact

China won’t restrict supply

Foss & Koelsch, 22 --- *Fellow in Energy, Minerals and Materials at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, AND **Research Associate, J.A. Green & Company and Former Research Intern, Center for Energy Studies (December 19, 2022, Michelle Michot Foss, Jacob Koelsch, “Of Chinese Behemoths: What China’s Rare Earths Dominance Means for the US,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/chinese-behemoths-what-chinas-rare-earths-dominance-means-us, SRB)

Chinese officials are highly conscious of the geopolitical advantage they derive from their REE dominance. The 2010 incident over REE shipments to Japan was a wake-up call to import-dependent customers. Almost a decade later in 2019, threats of restricted supply returned.[65] Xi’s visit to a REE magnet production facility in Ganzhou in 2019 was widely regarded as a sign that restricting REE supply is on the table.[66] A week later, the People’s Daily posted an article explicitly threatening that if “the U.S. side wants to use the products made by China’s exported rare earths to counter and suppress China’s development,” the U.S. should not “underestimate the Chinese side’s ability to safeguard its development rights and interests.”[67] The more recent MIIT draft controls list proposed in January 2021 also suggests that international policy responses significantly influence Chinese domestic policies toward rare earths.[68] Officials in Beijing are particularly focused on how quickly the U.S. would secure alternatives if REE were included on the control list.

Therein lies a paradox: China’s state-supported rare earth enterprises remain at the behest of international market dynamics. Overburdening policy changes and perceived supply insecurity would push buyers away from Chinese suppliers. Any restrictive moves would likely spur proactive value chain restructuring away from Chinese REE. Therefore, Chinese officials would be unlikely to directly restrict trade for political reasons and calls for such are primarily just sword rattling to disguise domestic policies and production controls that bear a more long-term effect on supply coming out of China.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Recycling Solves

Recycling and reducing waste can help fuel energy transition

Klinger, 23 --- Assistant Professor of Geography at the University of Delaware, where she teaches in the Minerals, Materials, and Society Program (January 23, 2023, Julie Michelle Klinger, “Does Our Sustainable Future Start in the Mine? Rare earth mining will disrupt local climate resilience. Who should pay the price?” https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/our-sustainable-future-starts-in-the-mine/, JMP))

Finally, the intense debate around where to open new mines can create the impression that mining is the only option. This is another major blind spot. Yes, the data for the renewable energy transition and building a circular economy indicates that mining must be part of any pathway forward, but it should be second to recycling and reduced wastefulness. Mining in a climate-smart way requires care and democratic deliberation, not haste and authoritarianism. This requires more time than the climate emergency would seem to allow, but we can buy ourselves greater resource security as well as some more time and space to think carefully about mining in socially and environmentally responsible ways if we instead focus on dramatically and immediately scaling up recycling rare earths from electronic waste and current mine tailings. Yes, these are complex and costly propositions, but so too is mining. The difference is that rare earth rich “waste” is abundant; places that can be mined without major climate compromise are not.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Domestic Reserves Solve

REE mining won’t undercut climate goals and there are enough reserves to power clean energy transition

Osaka, 23 (February 2, 2023 at 6:30 a.m. EST, Shannon Osaka, “Minerals are crucial for electric cars and wind turbines. Some worry whether we have enough; Minerals are crucial for electric cars, wind turbines, and solar panels. Some worry whether the future supply can meet the rising demand,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/02/02/critical-minerals-run-out-shortage/, JMP))

Recent research has also shown that the amount of minerals required for the shift to renewable energy is significant — but falls well within the amount of reserves available. A study released recently by scientists at the University of California at Irvine and MIT found that current reserves of minerals like aluminum, copper, manganese, silver and more should support building enough wind and solar power to meet climate targets. What’s more, the mining from those operations would not have an outsize impact on global warming. (One repeated critique of renewable energy is that the intensity of mining might counteract the emissions benefits of wind and solar.) According to the study, the materials required for the transition to low-carbon electricity would take up somewhere between 1 and 9 percent of the remaining carbon budget: a significant amount but one that wouldn’t undercut overall climate goals. “The emissions to produce a refined ton of steel or aluminum to meet all of this demand would not really threaten global carbon budgets,” said Seaver Wang, the co-director of climate and energy at the energy think tank the Breakthrough Institute and the lead author on the paper. (The study focused on electricity generation. The researchers did not look at the mineral requirements for transportation or electric vehicles.)

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › No Link

Clean energy doesn’t require REE and scarcity spurs adaptions and alternatives including substitution and recycling

Lovins, 21 --- Adjunct Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Stanford University, chairman emeritus of RMI (December 8, 2021, Amory Lovins, “Reality Check: Greener, Friendlier Alternatives Exist for Rare Minerals in Batteries,” https://rmi.org/rmi-reality-check-greener-friendlier-alternatives-exist-for-rare-minerals-in-batteries/, JMP))

The Myth For years, commentators have been handwringing about the extraction practices, environmental and social harms, and corporate ownership of mining operations that contribute to clean energy technology, with a focus on cobalt, rare earths, and other rare ingredients of the clean energy transition. Much like governmental, intergovernmental, and private assessments of “critical materials,” these critiques pay far too little attention to how scarcity, usually signaled by price, elicits not only mineral exploration and mine development but also a powerful set of other and faster adaptations and alternatives like efficient use, substitution, and recycling. A major contribution to this genre comes from a New York Times investigative series around cobalt in in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The Times’s informative reportage sheds important light on the geopolitical as much as the human-rights ramifications of clean energy. But the Times series, like nearly all prior “critical materials” coverage, rests on a flawed premise: that cobalt is one of the “essential raw materials needed for the production of electric car batteries—and is now critical to retiring the combustion engine and weaning the world off climate-changing fossil fuels.” The Reality That cobalt is an essential raw material needed to produce electric car batteries is true for one class of car-battery chemistries, but others use little cobalt or none at all. Standard-range Tesla cars’ batteries use no cobalt. Battery leaders Samsung and Panasonic are designing out cobalt. The portfolio of these alternatives continues to improve and expand. Several years ago, I wrote about “rare earths” (17 unusual chemical elements that are not geologically rare) in The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists and why they are not a substantial cause for concern in the transition to clean energy. For the past decade, commentators have warned (and stock speculators hyped) that China’s near-monopoly on supermagnet rare-earth elements could make the growing global shift to electric cars and wind turbines impossible—because their motors and generators, respectively, supposedly required supermagnets and hence rare earths. But that’s nonsense. In the four years since that Bulletin article, one of the key substitutions it mentions—iron-nitride supermagnets using no rare earths but with comparable or potentially greater performance—entered the market. But even without that magnet innovation, everything that permanent-magnet motors and generators do can also be done as well or better using two other innovations that require no rare earth minerals: control software and power electronics made of silicon, the most abundant solid element on Earth. Both kinds of magnet-free machines can do everything required not only in electric cars but also in wind turbines—functions often claimed to be impossible without tons of neodymium. That some wind turbines use rare-earth permanent-magnet generators does not mean others must. It’s better not to, and the word is spreading. Tesla’s car business was built on magnet-free induction motors. Its latest autos use the second magnet-free kind, synchronous reluctance motors, albeit spiced with small magnets. But most commentators on “blood minerals” are not experts on motors, solar cells, electricity, electronics, or even mining. They should talk to more people who are. The Bottom Line Accessible alternatives to “critical materials” can make excellent EV batteries, solar cells, and wind turbines. The US Department of Energy aims to eliminate cobalt in electric-car batteries by 2030; industry is doing it far faster. And a billion batteries in old consumer-electronics devices, many 30-fold richer in cobalt than the remaining cobalt-using car batteries, await recycling in clean and profitable American factories already being scaled up. Brains outpace mines. Let’s not let myths outpace truth.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Inevitable

REE mining is inevitable even without green energy --- the disad is fossil fuel industry propaganda and efforts to improve process are underway

Klinger, 23 --- Assistant Professor of Geography at the University of Delaware, where she teaches in the Minerals, Materials, and Society Program (January 23, 2023, Julie Michelle Klinger, “Does Our Sustainable Future Start in the Mine? Rare earth mining will disrupt local climate resilience. Who should pay the price?” https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/our-sustainable-future-starts-in-the-mine/, JMP))

Rare earth elements have reemerged in the news as U.S. anxieties over economic interdependence with China grow. New revelations about social and environmental violence in supply chains, most recently in Myanmar, surface under headlines that have circulated since 2009. They often suggest that rare earth elements are only used for green energy and, thus, that green energy is solely responsible for the devastation wrought by rare earth mining.

Over the past decade, this narrative has profoundly shaped the debate around renewable energy infrastructure and our prospects for mitigating the climate emergency in line with Paris climate goals or Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) guidelines. At the same time, massive efforts are underway globally to diversify rare earth supply chains and movements against green colonialism accelerate apace with movements to remove regulatory checks on industry and fast-track mining operations. The debate over where and how the rare earth mining and refining industry is built outside of China is contentious and polarizing, but the intensity of the debate is a sign of progress. We are now confronting the tough questions around mineral acquisition, no longer content to merely decry the injustice of offshoring environmental harm. To reach a brighter, greener future, communities in the Global North are exploring what it means to be more responsible for their mineral needs.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Turns Environment

Expanded mining and construction to meet Green New Deal goals will cause significant environment devastation

Benson, 20 --- policy analyst in the Government Relations Department at The Heartland Institute (April 14, 2020, Tim Benson, “Mining Expansion Necessary for Green New Deal Would Devastate the Global Environment,” https://heartland.org/opinion/mining-expansion-necessary-for-green-new-deal-would-devastate-the-global-environment/, JMP))

A new Heartland Institute Policy Brief details how the expansion of mining operations for the rare earth minerals needed to scale up “renewable” energy sources to meet the goals of the “Green New Deal” (GND) would cause significant global environmental devastation. In “How the Green New Deal’s Renewable Energy Mining Would Harm Humans and the Environment,” author Paul Driessen explains how if the GND were enacted, an attempt would be made to replace all electricity generation in the United States from fossil fuel and nuclear sources with that generated from wind or solar sources. To replace all these sources, Driessen makes a “conservative” estimate that almost 19 billion solar panels would need to be constructed and installed, covering an area roughly the size of New York and Vermont combined. He also cites a study from researchers at Harvard University that estimates the amount of land needed to power the country by wind energy would be equal to roughly a third of the continental United States. To dramatically ramp up wind and solar electricity generation to this extent would “necessitate an unprecedented worldwide expansion in mining,” says Driessen. “And those mining operations would rely primarily on fossil-fuel-powered heavy equipment, since battery-powered equipment for enormous industrial operations does not exist.” These mining operations would also involve “removing and crushing hundreds of billions of tons of rock and ore, causing major habitat losses and widespread pollution,” according to Driessen. “It would also create serious human health impacts, especially in countries that do not have modern equipment and health and safety protections.” Among these mining operation would be those for rare earth elements (REE) such as dysprosium, indium, neodymium, and tellurium, which are necessary to produce wind turbines or photovoltaic solar panels. However, mining a single ton of these REEs, according to Driessen, produces up to 420,000 cubic feet of toxic gases, 2,600 cubic feet of acidic wastewater, and a ton of radioactive waste. More than 70 percent of the world’s REEs are either mined in China, a totalitarian communist dictatorship with a dismal environmental and human rights record, or by companies under the control of the Chinese Communist Party. Other materials needed to be mined to produce solar panels and wind turbines, as well as to produce the anticipated battery backups systems for these “renewable” sources, include lithium, cobalt, and copper. To store a week’s worth of electricity for the entire country when wind and solar aren’t generating it, Driessen estimates would require “two billion half-ton battery packs similar to those used in Tesla automobiles.” Each of these batteries would require at least 26 pounds of lithium. The cobalt needed for these batteries is mostly mined in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where more than 40,000 children currently labor in mining operations for pittance wages in unsafe and unhealthy conditions. Copper mining would also have to be dramatically expanded to meet this new GND demand, even though it takes roughly 125,000 pounds of mined, crushed, and refined ore to produce 1,000 pounds of finished copper. Although the United States has proven reserves of these commodities, environmental policy at both the state and federal level have closed off most of these deposits from mining. Therefore, Driessen argues, enacting the GND would increase our dependence for these minerals on China and “other countries that regularly disregard workplace safety, child labor concerns, land reclamation, and pollution controls.” “Wind and sunshine are certainly clean and renewable energy sources but,” Driessen concludes, “the technologies required to harness these intermittent, weather-dependent energies to benefit humanity require raw materials and mining operations that are anything but clean, ‘green,’ renewable, sustainable, or ethical. This fundamental reality can no longer be ignored. GND technologies rely heavily on mineral extraction in someone else’s backyard, often in less-developed countries, where other people and their children do the dirty, dangerous work of providing essential raw materials while suffering from environmental and human degradation.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › China

Chinese control over rare earths jeopardizes US hegemony – all military equipment relies on these minerals

Ahmed ’22 [Sayeed; 09/09/2022; Ph.D. in Environmental Management and Internet-based Collaborative Modelling from University of Strathclyde, MEng in Civil Engineering from Asian Institute of Technology, CEO of Bayside Analytix; "US controls advanced chips, but China has another card," Daily Star, https://www.thedailystar.net/opinion/views/news/us-controls-advanced-chips-china-has-another-card-3115316 //The St. Mark’s School of Texas, Anish Guddati–Class of 2024]

US defence giant Lockheed Martin's highly successful fighter jet F-35 made its maiden flight in 2006. This sleek flying machine is still in operation with variations such as the F-35A (2015), B (2016) and C (2019). Each such jet contains 417kg of "rare earths," an essential material without which its intricate electronics and weaponry would not exist. But it is the US' foremost strategic rival, China, who controls the rare earths' supply. Beijing realised the importance of rare earths as early as in 1992, when Deng Xiaoping said, "The Middle East has oil; China has rare earths."

What are rare earths, exactly? These are 17 nearly indistinguishable lustrous silvery-white soft heavy metals in the Periodic Table, a scientific tabulation of Earth's chemical elements) such as dysprosium, praseodymium and ytterbium. From jets or weaponry, smartphones, hard drives, electric vehicles and LED lights, to wind turbines and petroleum processing – everything depends on these "touchstones." Rare earths provide the magical touch to all these products that power today's advanced economies and cutting-edge technology.