Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › IMPACTS › Tech Leadership

US military tech leadership solves every existential risk.

Ash Jain 19, senior fellow with the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, where he oversees the Atlantic Council’s Democratic Order Initiative and D10 Strategy Forum; and Matthew Kroenig, deputy director for strategy in the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security and associate professor of government and foreign service at Georgetown University, 10/30/19, “Present at the Re-Creation: A Global Strategy for Revitalizing, Adapting, and Defending a Rules-Based International System,” https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Present-at-the-Recreation.pdf

The system must also be adapted to deal with new issues that were not envisioned when the existing order was designed. Foremost among these issues is emerging and disruptive technology, including AI, additive manufacturing (or 3D printing), quantum computing, genetic engineering, robotics, directed energy, the Internet of things (IOT), 5G, space, cyber, and many others. Like other disruptive technologies before them, these innovations promise great benefits, but also carry serious downside risks. For example, AI is already resulting in massive efficiencies and cost savings in the private sector. Routine tasks and other more complicated jobs, such as radiology, are already being automated. In the future, autonomous weapons systems may go to war against each other as human soldiers remain out of harm’s way.

Yet, AI is also transforming economies and societies, and generating new security challenges. Automation will lead to widespread unemployment. The final realization of driverless cars, for example, will put out of work millions of taxi, Uber, and long-haul truck drivers. Populist movements in the West have been driven by those disaffected by globalization and technology, and mass unemployment caused by automation will further grow those ranks and provide new fuel to grievance politics. Moreover, some fear that autonomous weapons systems will become “killer robots” that select and engage targets without human input, and could eventually turn on their creators, resulting in human extinction. The other technologies on this lisgt similarly balance great potential upside with great downside risk. 3D printing, for example, can be used to “make anything anywhere,” reducing costs for a wide range of manufactured goods and encouraging a return of local manufacturing industries.61 At the same time, advanced 3D printers can also be used by revisionist and rogue states to print component parts for advanced weapons systems or even WMD programs, spurring arms races and weapons proliferation.62 Genetic engineering can wipe out entire classes of disease through improved medicine, or wipe out entire classes of people through genetically engineered superbugs. Directed-energy missile defenses may defend against incoming missile attacks, while also undermining global strategic stability.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › AT: Recycling

Recycling can’t meet short term spikes in demand --- mining still required

Gramling, 23 --- Ph.D. in marine geochemistry from MIT and the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Earth & Climate writer at Science News (JANUARY 11, 2023 AT 11:00 AM, Carolyn, “Rare earth mining may be key to our renewable energy future. But at what cost?We take you inside Mountain Pass, the only rare earth mine in the United States,” https://www.sciencenews.org/article/rare-earth-mining-renewable-energy-future, JMP)) ***Note - Saleem Ali is an environmental planner at the University of Delaware

Given the concerns over new mining, environmental think tanks like the World Resources Institute have been calling for more recycling of existing rare earth materials to reduce the need for new mining and processing.

“The path to the future has to do with getting the most out of what we take out of the ground,” says Bustamante, of the NRDC. “Ultimately the biggest lever for change is not in the mining itself, but in the manufacturing, and what we do with those materials at the end of life.”

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › AT: Recycling

Substitutes not as effective and recycling is overstated and long-term at best

Foss & Koelsch, 22 --- *Fellow in Energy, Minerals and Materials at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, AND **Research Associate, J.A. Green & Company and Former Research Intern, Center for Energy Studies (December 19, 2022, Michelle Michot Foss, Jacob Koelsch, “Of Chinese Behemoths: What China’s Rare Earths Dominance Means for the US,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/chinese-behemoths-what-chinas-rare-earths-dominance-means-us, JMP))

While long-term supply resilience is a goal, “industrial planners” must proactively mitigate the risks of immediate rare earth product supply disruptions from China. Manufacturers and designers may opt to use REE substitutes, but substitutes do not perform nearly as well.[77] Designers looking to shift away from China-dominated REE may face the task of engineering their products without these materials as the more viable alternative. Recycling offers possibilities, especially from permanent magnets, but a long path lies ahead for this to become viable. Recycling too often is overstated given the outlook for raw materials requirements. Recyclers face the same delays and conundrums in achieving regulatory reviews and permits to move forward as mining and other industrial projects.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › AT: Substitutes

Substitutes can’t meet short term demand --- no guarantees and could take 5+ years

Woods & Hirsch, 22 (November 3, 2022 7:05 PM ET, Darian Woods & Paddy Hirsch – Hosts on NPR’s The Indicator From Planet Money, “An end to China's rare earth monopoly?” https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1134110697, JMP) ***Note - Jonathan Hykawy is the president of Storm Crow Capital Ltd, investor who tracks technologies that use rare earths, Laura Henderson Lewis is a professor of mechanical engineering and chemical engineering at Northeastern University in Boston, Mass

HIRSCH: Which makes the lab production of tetrataenite look kind of like a gift of magical alien technology from outer space, which it sort of is - just without the aliens. But Laura Lewis at Northeastern says it's no quick fix.

LEWIS: Having this is not the same as having a magnet. I often use the analogy - you may have a material to make a brick, but you have to put the bricks together to make a wall. And then that wall makes the Taj Mahal.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – Renewables

Renewables deck REMs---collapses U.S. tech leadership.

Grier 18 [Peter Grier, a Washington, D.C., editor for The Christian Science Monitor, is a longtime contributor to Air Force Magazine. His most recent article, “Misplaced Nukes,” appeared in the August 2017 issue. Citing USAF Lt. Col. Justin C. Davey in a 2011 Air War College report, February; "Rare-Earth Uncertainty;" Air Force Magazine; http://www.airforcemag.com/MagazineArchive/Pages/2018/February%202018/Rare-Earth-Uncertainty.aspx]

Their names sound as if they are part of some science fiction universe: yttrium, dysprosium, samarium, neodymium. They are rare-earth elements (REEs)—little-known but crucial ingredients in much modern US military aerospace technology. Take lasers. Lockheed Martin is working on a small, high-power laser weapon that the Air Force Research Laboratory wants to test in a tactical fighter aircraft by 2021. Its active gain medium is a flexible optical fiber infused with a rare-earth element such as erbium or neodymium. Rare-earth elements are widely used in strong, permanent magnets impervious to temperature extremes. They are used in fin actuators, in missile guidance, and control systems; disk drive motors installed in aircraft and tanks; satellite communications; and radar and sonar systems. As might be expected given their importance to national security, these elements used to come from the United States. From the 1960s to the 1980s, the US was the global leader in rare-earth mining and production. That is no longer the case. In recent decades China has become the source of 90 to 95 percent of world rare-earth oxides and the producer of a majority of the globe’s strongest rare-earth magnets. Many US officials and lawmakers view this situation with apprehension. They are pushing for solutions that range from stockpiling critical minerals to the development of substitutes and the reopening of key domestic mines. “It’s a very real concern, and it obviously depends on the elements. But we use them for important technologies to keep us all safe,” said CIA Director Mike Pompeo, in response to an inquiry at a May 2017 Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on worldwide threats to the US. The rare-earth element group consists of 17 minerals. Fifteen are from a chemical group known as the lanthanides; scandium and yttrium are the other two. All share similar geochemical characteristics, generally resembling the chemical makeup of aluminum. Their slight differences in atomic structure give them different optical, electrical, metallurgic, and magnetic qualities. That makes them useful for a wide array of industrial applications. Despite their name, rare-earth elements are relatively widespread in the earth’s crust. They are about as abundant as some major metals, such as copper and chrome. Even rare REEs are more common than gold. Their “rarity” stems from that fact that they are found in low concentrations, up to a few hundred parts per million by weight, at most. That makes it difficult and thus expensive to separate them from surrounding substances into useful products. Development and construction of large-scale rare-earth element recovery infrastructure can take a decade or longer. While unfamiliar to most Americans, REEs are vital components for a wide array of industries. Their unusual physical and chemical properties produce valuable effects when small amounts are combined with other minerals. According to a US Geological Survey, yttrium, europium, and terbium are used to make phosphors—substances that emit luminescence—for the flat panel display screens that are ubiquitous in modern electronics. The glass industry is a large user of rare earths for polishing and to provide color and special optical qualities to finished products. Digital camera lenses can be up to 50 percent lanthanum. REEs are used as catalysts in the production of petroleum and in automotive catalytic converters. They help make lighter flints and fluorescent light bulbs. But their fastest-growing use, and the one arguably most important for US national security, is in lightweight, strong, durable magnets. “Exceptionally notable is how REE alloys revolutionized the magnet trade and subsequently enhanced the products of all other businesses relying on that industry,” wrote USAF Lt. Col. Justin C. Davey in a 2011 Air War College report. The magnets, and by extension the elements, are now common in consumer electronics and indispensable for many defense applications. Samarium-cobalt magnets are more resistant to demagnetization than those made from any other material. This quality—called high coercivity—means high temperatures do not make them lose magnetic strength. That makes them the best choice for many military applications, according to Davey. In contrast, neodymium-iron-boron magnets are incredibly strong and light. By weight they are almost 10 times more powerful than traditional ferrite magnets. That makes them ideal for use in the tiny electronic components such as disk drives that have helped make possible decades of computer-driven innovation. The world’s push for renewable energy sources may only increase the demand for non-renewable REE magnets. A Toyota Prius, for example, uses about two pounds of neodymium in its hybrid power system. Wind turbines need lots of neodymium—new models use up to two tons of neodymium magnets. The Department of Defense is not a major user of rare-earth elements, relatively speaking. Defense accounts for about five percent of US consumption, according to a Congressional Research Service background report on the subject. But REEs are integral to a vast array of Pentagon weapons and general equipment. Flat screens and hard drives are pervasive in the military, from office computers to combat aircraft, ships, and vehicles. Missile guidance and control motors and actuators depend on small, powerful rare-earth magnets. If it were not for them, precision-guided weapons such as the satellite-guided Joint Direct Attack Munition would require much bulkier and more expensive hydraulic systems. The generators that produce electrical power for aircraft all contain samarium-cobalt magnets. The stealth technology that produces white noise to help conceal the sound of helicopter rotor blades uses such magnets as well. F-22 tail fins and rudders move due to motors with powerful, miniature REE magnets. Electronic warfare jamming devices use rare-earth materials, as do laser targeting systems and nascent laser weapons. Each stealthy F-35 strike fighter requires 920 pounds of rare-earth material, according to DOD. Each Arleigh Burke DDG-51 destroyer requires 5,200 pounds. An SSN-774 Virginia-class submarine needs 9,200 pounds. The ability of US contractors to quickly make use of technological innovations and translate them into high-quality military systems is a pillar of the nation’s defense. Given that, the Pentagon is likely to become even more dependent in the coming years on high-tech magnets, motors, lasers, computers, and electric-drive systems that use rare-earth materials.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › LINKS › L – GND

Green New Deal will require 12 times more mining --- would overwhelm current domestic production and force dependence on China

Siciliano, 18 --- Energy and Environment Reporter (December 15, 2018 12:00 AM, John, “A Green New Deal would necessitate a huge increase in mining,” https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/policy/energy/a-green-new-deal-would-necessitate-a-huge-increase-in-mining, JMP))

Moving the world to 100-percent renewable energy under a Green New Deal, or the Paris climate accord, will require at least a twelvefold increase in the not-so-green practice of hardrock mining, according to a new study backed by prominent environmental consultants.

"The current global supply of several critical metals is insufficient to transition to a renewable energy system," a new study released Thursday by Leiden University in the Netherlands and environmental consulting firms Metabolic and Copper8 concludes.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Renewables Stable

Inflation Reduction Act incentivizes U.S.-sourced minerals for clean energy

Barbanell, 23 --- Director of U.S.-International Engagement at World Resources Institute where she leads high-level climate and energy dialogues between non-governmental U.S. participants and counterparts in China, India, and the European Union (May 3, 2023, Melissa, “Overcoming Critical Minerals Shortages Is Key to Achieving US Climate Goals,” https://www.wri.org/insights/critical-minerals-us-climate-goals, JMP))

Does the Inflation Reduction Act Require Critical Minerals to Be Sourced Domestically?

Yes, to some extent. The Inflation Reduction Act explicitly requires domestic sourcing of critical minerals only for its electric vehicle tax credits. Other clean energy technologies (such as wind and solar) do not need to use domestically sourced minerals to qualify for the Investment Tax Credit (ITC) or Production Tax Credit (PTC). However, the act offers an additional 10% bonus credit to incentivize companies to incorporate U.S.-sourced critical minerals in all types of clean energy components.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Domestic Production Stable

Incentives increasing to boost domestic REE production

Khan, 23 (April 25, 2023 1:00 am ET, Yusuf, “The U.S. Wants a Rare-Earths Supply Chain. Here’s Why It Won’t Come Easily; New tax credit bill seeks to challenge China’s dominance in the processing of critical minerals,” https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-u-s-wants-a-rare-earths-supply-chain-heres-why-it-wont-come-easily-dfc3b632, JMP))

A bipartisan bill set to be introduced in Congress this week would offer a tax credit for establishing rare-earth magnet production in the U.S., a crucial component for the clean-energy transition. MP Materials efforts to build a local supply chain demonstrate the challenge for American producers. The bill, to be introduced by Rep. Guy Reschenthaler (R., Pa.) and Rep. Eric Swalwell (D., Calif.), includes a $20-a-kilogram credit for U.S.-made magnets, while manufacturers sourcing 90% of their component parts from U.S. producers could be entitled to a $30-a-kilogram credit, according to a draft seen by The Wall Street Journal. The credit is planned to be phased out by Dec. 31, 2035. The bill, known as the Rare Earth Magnet Manufacturing Production Tax Credit Act of 2023, is the latest in a list of incentives to encourage rare-earth production as more attention is being focused on the metals and where they come from. Rare earths such as neodymium, dysprosium and terbium are used in permanent magnets that are needed to help drive motors in electric vehicles, offshore wind turbines and increasingly within robotics. According to experts, they are going to become more crucial as the drive to adopt clean-energy technology grows. Wood Mackenzie’s Rare Earths Market Service estimates demand for rare-earth oxides stood at 171,300 metric tons in 2022 and projects it to grow to 238,700 tons by 2030. The bill comes amid efforts to revive the Mountain Pass mine, that sits on the border between California and Nevada. It was once the world’s No. 1 source of rare earths—elements valued for their magnetic and conductive properties. Now it is looking to get back in the game and deliver a domestic supply of them for the energy transition, all the way from mine to magnet. The Mountain Pass mine started life soon after the gold rush in the 1870s, producing mainly gold, copper, lead and zinc. Production changed over the years, and from the 1960s to the 1990s, it was the primary global source of rare earths. After financial and environmental struggles at the turn of this century, mining at the site was suspended in 2002 before being bought and restarted in 2017 by MP Materials Corp. , a Las-Vegas-based rare-earth producer. “Mountain Pass is arguably the best rare-earth asset in the world. If it were oil, it would be Saudi Arabia,” says James Litinsky, chief executive of MP Materials, which continues to own and operate the mine. Yet, during the time when mining was suspended at the site, the rare-earth industry shifted from niche products to reaching critical status in the U.S., Europe and Japan. Now, roughly 60% of all mined rare-earth minerals are sourced from China. Three other major sources exist in Myanmar, Australia and Mountain Pass.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Domestic Production Stable

U.S. ramping up domestic REE production to reduce reliance on China

- More funding could be available to scale up

DOE, 23 (APRIL 4, 2023, “Biden-Harris Administration Invests $16 Million to Build America's First-of-a-Kind Critical Minerals Production Facility,” https://www.energy.gov/articles/biden-harris-administration-invests-16-million-build-americas-first-kind-critical-minerals, JMP))

WASHINGTON, D.C.— As part of President Biden’s Investing in America agenda, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) today announced $16 million from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to bring critical mineral supply chains to America and reduce reliance on competitors like China. The funding will support projects in West Virginia and North Dakota for the development of a first-of-a-kind rare earth element and critical minerals extraction and separation refinery. Rare earth elements and other critical minerals and materials are key to manufacturing clean energy technologies right here in America that will help the nation reach the Biden-Harris Administration’s goal of a net-zero emissions economy by 2050. 

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – Great Power Conflict

Independently, resource accumulation for green energy will spark great power conflict --- transition will be slow and messy

Domestic production, REE alternatives, working with allies are all hopeful at best

Brands, 22 --- Henry A. Kissinger Distinguished Professor of Global Affairs at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (November 01, 2022, Hal, “The Green-Energy Revolution Will Make the World More Dangerous,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-green-energy-revolution-will-make-the-world-more-dangerous/, recut by JMP))

Think a green transition will free America from high-stakes competition over energy supplies? Think again. Since the Industrial Revolution, changing patterns of energy consumption have propelled international conflict. Today, the world is entering a very messy period, in which rivalry over sources of renewable energy will steadily intensify, even as older clashes over oil and other hydrocarbons continue to play out.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – Uniqueness + Link

Clean energy increases reliance on China’s rare earth supplies at a time when the West is accelerating efforts to reduce dependence – supply diversification is a process that takes time

Springfield ‘4/17/23 [Cary Springfield, 4-17-2023, “Global Competition over China-Dominated Market for Rare-Earth Elements Heats Up,” International Banker, https://internationalbanker.com/finance/global-competition-over-china-dominated-market-for-rare-earth-elements-heats-up/, St. Mark's School of Texas, Ashrit Manduva '24]

Such fears are prompting Western governments led by the US, the EU, Australia and Japan to look at investing more in their respective domestic rare-earth production facilities. “The adoption of EVs alone will require an additional 200,000 tonnes of rare earths in the next ten years,” Luisa Moreno, president of Canadian rare-earth mining firm Defense Metals, told the mining industry publication Mining Technology in April 2022. “There is need for more mine production, and we need to build rare earths supply chains outside China, starting with refinery capacity. The West also needs the capacity to make rare earths metals, rare earths magnets, and other products and technologies.”

But could times be changing? A series of key events of late could see Western consumers’ reliance on China’s rare-earth supplies gradually diminish. Most recently, for instance, Tesla confirmed in early March that the forthcoming iteration of its permanent magnet EV motor would not contain a single rare-earth element. Colin Campbell, vice president of powertrain engineering at the EV company, noted that “as the world transitions to clean energy, demand for rare earths is really increasing dramatically, and not only is it going to be a little hard to meet that demand but mining that rare earth, it has environmental and health risks”.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 1NCs › 1nc – DA

Taiwan conflict goes nuclear

- first strike based on conventional losses or inadvertent escalation make it likely

Goldstein ’23 [Lyle Goldstein, director of Asia Engagement at the Washington DC think tank, Defense Priorities. He is also a visiting professor at the Watson Institute for Public and International Affairs at Brown University. Goldstein previously served 20 years as research professor at the US Naval War College, where he received the Superior Civilian Service Medal for his pioneering research on Chinese military development. 3-13-2023, "The trouble with Taiwan," Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, https://thebulletin.org/premium/2023-03/the-trouble-with-taiwan/, St. Mark's School of Texas, Ashrit Manduva '24]

The nuclear problem

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 1NCs › 1nc – DA

That ruins the domestic supply chain and wrecks combat readiness – increased dependence on China triggers military aggression in Taiwan.

Foss & Koelsch, 22 --- *Fellow in Energy, Minerals and Materials at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, AND **Research Associate, J.A. Green & Company and Former Research Intern, Center for Energy Studies (December 19, 2022, Michelle Michot Foss, Jacob Koelsch, “Of Chinese Behemoths: What China’s Rare Earths Dominance Means for the US,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/chinese-behemoths-what-chinas-rare-earths-dominance-means-us, SRB+JMP))

The U.S. government, of course, has its own part to play. First, strategic planners must honestly distinguish rare earth demand for defense and other strategic purposes from non-strategic demand. While both strategic and non-strategic demand must be balanced in order to stabilize supply, delivery delays for defense purposes carry significant implications for combat readiness, especially in an era of heightened major-power tension. It is also crucial that the U.S. government ensure its strategic stockpiles of REE are filled to aid in these efforts.

Conclusion

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 1NCs › 1nc – DA

The US is diversifying supply chains now but needs time to break overdependence – the plan pushes us back to China to meet renewable demands.

Lu, 23 (APRIL 14, 2023, Christina Lu is a reporter at Foreign Policy. Prior to joining FP, she worked at Foreign Affairs and the Southern African Institute for Policy and Research in Lusaka, Zambia. She is a graduate of Cornell University, The Critical Minerals Club, https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/04/14/us-china-critical-mineral-security-europe-rare-earth-energy-transition / SRB)

U.S. lawmakers are scrambling to weaken China’s grip on the critical mineral supply chains that are key to the global energy transition, as escalating tensions stoke fears of strategic vulnerabilities and potential geopolitical disruptions.

While decades of investments have allowed Beijing to dominate the processing and refining of key critical minerals, worsening U.S.-China relations have sparked a new push to redraw the map. Desperate to disentangle from China, Washington has been joining forces with allies to secure new supplies, part of a broader realignment as countries increasingly forge new trade ties alongside geopolitical lines, rather than the bottom line.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
REMs DA – CNDI 23 › 1NCs › 1nc – Case Turn

Turn: The plan would force greater dependence on China AND trigger tradeoffs with military weapons development that rely on rare earth elements

Ernst, 22 --- U.S. Senator from Iowa (5-4-2022, Joni, “DEMOCRATS' GREEN AGENDA RISKS NATIONAL SECURITY,” https://www.rpc.senate.gov/policy-papers/democrats-green-agenda-risks-national-security, SRB)

Democrats have spent the past year pursuing their radical Green New Deal energy agenda. Now the left is using Russia’s war in Ukraine to try to justify a massive transition to electric vehicles and renewable energy. If enacted, this would significantly increase our dependence on China for certain “critical minerals” and other materials needed for these energy sources. If the left successfully implements its flawed agenda without strengthening supply chains, the United States could become significantly dependent on China for its energy needs. China could use its commanding influence over green energy technology to get its way in the future, just as Russia used its energy to influence Europe not to act prior to the invasion of Ukraine. GROWING DEMAND FOR CRITICAL MINERALS Critical minerals are specific substances identified as being vital to a range of industries including energy, electronics, and the military. Electric vehicles and renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, require significant amounts of critical minerals. One analysis by several professors from the United Kingdom found that to swap the UK’s 32 million cars with EVs would demand about double the world’s annual output of cobalt, almost all the neodymium, and 75% of the lithium. Comparatively, about eight times as much would be required to convert the entire U.S. fleet of 260 million cars. A 2021 report by the International Energy Agency found that by 2040, anticipated global green energy commitments could increase demand for “rare earth elements,” a subset of critical minerals, by as much as 700%. Demand for nickel could grow by 1,900%, cobalt by 2,100%, and lithium by a staggering 4,200%. These minerals are needed for the development of wind turbines and solar panels, as well as for electric vehicles. These substances also play a key part in our national defense. Construction of each F-35 combat aircraft requires more than 900 pounds of critical minerals. Copper, lead, cobalt, uranium, and a significant amount of other minerals are needed for munitions, armor, and communications gear. Ships, vehicles, and aircraft will continue to require these materials to keep up with advanced technological needs. The problem is acute; the DoD is facing a critical shortage of munitions and the defense industry is having trouble meeting the demand for more advanced weapons. The U.S. military’s stockpile of critical minerals is already shrinking and increased demand will continue to stress those reserves. If we add to the demand for these minerals to make more electric vehicles and solar panels, while not increasing domestic production, we would only make it tougher to meet the need for military applications. In a recent Energy and Natural Resources Committee hearing, one defense industry executive discussed how competition from other products has affected his ability to get parts needed to make advanced weapon systems. DEPENDENCE ON FOREIGN MINERAL SUPPLIES The problem is not just that Democrats’ plans will increase the demand for these elements. It is also a question of where the materials come from. The pandemic made us all aware of how dependent we are on the global supply chain and what happens in one link of that chain breaks. The supply of critical minerals is no different. The batteries for a typical electric car require 19.6 pounds of lithium, and 58% of the world’s lithium is processed in China. Batteries also require high-quality nickel; almost 20% of global supply is produced by Russia. Russia’s actions in Ukraine demonstrate what can happen when one country controls a large share of the global energy market. European countries have grown dependent on the Russians for much of their oil, natural gas, coal, and other energy supplies. Now they are scrambling to find alternative sources of fuel to heat their homes and fuel their economies. For many of these countries, their dependence was fueled by radical climate policies such as phasing out nuclear power and limiting fracking. Democrats, through their anti-fossil-fuel agenda, have been trying to eliminate America’s ability to produce domestic oil and gas that could help us respond to this kind of shock to the energy markets. Furthermore, the Biden administration’s sanctions provide loopholes to allow for energy transactions until June 24. Democrats have a way to relieve the pressure Russia places on energy markets, mainly by increasing domestic production, but so far they have seemed more interested in pursuing a progressive campaign against energy. Instead of learning a lesson about the danger of depending on other, often antagonistic, countries for critical materials, the Biden administration and Democrats in Congress are pushing an agenda to make things worse. Democrats are actually trying to use Russia’s war in Ukraine to justify their climate goals, while disregarding the fact that we do not have enough of the raw materials necessary to support their pipe dreams and will therefore be forced to rely more on China. Just as the Russians have used energy to influence Europe, the Chinese have already used their command over the critical minerals market to advance their political agenda. In 2010, the Chinese government temporarily stopped all exports of critical minerals to Japan over a diplomatic dispute around a collision at sea, foreshadowing what is to come if the world depends on China for the majority of its energy-related mineral needs.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA › UBI › AT Velocity

Their Theories about the velocity of money and inflation are wrong – inflation is artificially created to drive up spending from the poor while the richest aren’t impacted by it at all

Brown 20 Ellen Hodgson Brown is an American author, attorney, public speaker, and advocate of alternative medicine and financial reform, most prominently public banking. Brown is the founder and president of the Public Banking Institute, a nonpartisan think tank devoted to the creation of publicly run banks. “How and Why a Fed-Financed UBI Would Not Lead to Inflation” Basic Income Today, April 21, 2020 ///Mgal

According to an April 6 article on CNBC.com, Spain is slated to become the first country in Europe to introduce a universal basic income (UBI) on a long-term basis. Spain’s Minister for Economic Affairs has announced plans to roll out a UBI “as soon as possible,” with the goal of providing a nationwide basic wage that supports citizens “forever.” Guy Standing, a research professor at the University of London, told CNBC that there was no prospect of a global economic revival without a universal basic income. “It’s almost a no-brainer,” he said. “We are going to have some sort of basic income system sooner or later ….” “Where will the government find the money?” is no longer a valid objection to providing an economic safety net for the people. The government can find the money in the same place it just found more than $5 trillion for Wall Street and Corporate America: the central bank can print it. In an April 9 post commenting on the $1.77 trillion handed to Wall Street under the CARES Act, Wolf Richter observed, “If the Fed had sent that $1.77 Trillion to the 130 million households in the US, each household would have received $13,600. But no, this was helicopter money exclusively for Wall Street and for asset holders.” “Helicopter money” – money simply issued by the central bank and injected into the economy – could be used in many ways, including building infrastructure, capitalizing a national infrastructure and development bank, providing free state university tuition, or funding Medicare, social security, or a universal basic income. In the current crisis, in which a government-mandated shutdown has left households more vulnerable than at any time since the Great Depression, a UBI seems the most direct and efficient way to get money to everyone who needs it. But critics argue that it will just trigger inflation and collapse the dollar. As gold proponent Mike Maloney complained on an April 16 podcast: Typing extra digits into computers does not make us wealthy. If this insane theory of printing money for almost everyone on a permanent basis takes hold, the value of the dollars in your purse or pocketbook will … just continue to erode …. I just want someone to explain to me how this is going to work. Having done quite a bit of study on that, I thought I would take on the challenge. Here is how and why a central bank-financed UBI can work without eroding the dollar. In a Debt-Based System, the Consumer Economy Is Chronically Short of Money. First, some basics of modern money. We do not have a fixed and stable money system. We have a credit system, in which money is created and destroyed by banks every day. Money is created as a deposit when the bank makes a loan and is extinguished when the loan is repaid, as explained in detail by the Bank of England here. When fewer loans are being created than are being repaid, the money supply shrinks, a phenomenon called “debt deflation.” Deflation then triggers recession and depression. The term “helicopter money” was coined to describe the cure for that much-feared syndrome. Economist Milton Friedman said it was easy to cure a deflation: just print money and rain it down from helicopters on the people. Our money supply is in a chronic state of deflation, due to the way money comes into existence. Banks create the principal but not the interest needed to repay their loans, so more money is always owed back than was created in the original loans. Thus debt always grows faster than the money supply, as can be seen in this chart from WorkableEconomics.com: When the debt burden grow so large that borrowers cannot take on more, they pay down old loans without taking out new ones and the money supply shrinks or deflates. Critics of this “debt virus” theory say the gap between debt and the money available to repay can be filled through the “velocity of money.” Debts are repaid over time, and if the payments received collectively by the lenders are spent back into the economy, they are collectively available to the debtors to pay their next monthly balances. (See a fuller explanation here.) The flaw in this argument is that money created as a loan is extinguished on repayment and is not available to be spent back into the economy. Repayment zeros out the debit by which it was created, and the money just disappears. Another problem with the “velocity of money” argument is that lenders don’t typically spend their profits back into the consumer economy. In fact, we have two economies – the consumer/producer economy where goods and services are produced and traded, and the financialized economy where money chases “yields” without producing new goods and services. The financialized economy is essentially a parasite on the real economy, and it now contains most of the money in the system. In an unwritten policy called the “Fed put”, the central bank routinely manipulates the money supply to prop up financial markets. That means corporate owners and investors can make more and faster money in the financialized economy than by investing in workers and equipment. Bankers, investors and other “savers” put their money in stocks and bonds, hide it in offshore tax havens, send it abroad, or just keep it in cash. At the end of 2018, US corporations were sitting on $1.7 trillion in cash, and 70% of $100 bills were held overseas. Meanwhile the producer/consumer economy is left with insufficient investment and insufficient demand. According to a July 2017 paper from the Roosevelt Institute called “What Recovery? The Case for Continued Expansionary Policy at the Fed”: GDP remains well below both the long-run trend and the level predicted by forecasters a decade ago. In 2016, real per capita GDP was 10% below the Congressional Budget Office’s (CBO) 2006 forecast, and shows no signs of returning to the predicted level. The report showed that the most likely explanation for this lackluster growth was inadequate demand. Wages were stagnant; and before producers would produce, they needed customers knocking on their doors. In ancient Mesopotamia, the gap between debt and the money available to repay it was corrected with periodic debt “jubilees” – forgiveness of loans that wiped the slate clean. But today the lenders are not kings and temples. They are private bankers who don’t engage in debt forgiveness because their mandate is to maximize shareholder profits, and because by doing so they would risk insolvency themselves. But there is another way to avoid the debt gap, and that is by filling it with regular injections of new debt-free money.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Inflation DA › UBI › LT - Econ Growth

A UBI doesn’t cause inflation and instead results in economic growth– its empirically proven that government transfers only cause inflation of the economy can’t match it,

Brown 20 Ellen Hodgson Brown is an American author, attorney, public speaker, and advocate of alternative medicine and financial reform, most prominently public banking. Brown is the founder and president of the Public Banking Institute, a nonpartisan think tank devoted to the creation of publicly run banks. “How and Why a Fed-Financed UBI Would Not Lead to Inflation” Basic Income Today, April 21, 2020 ///Mgal

How Much Money Needs to Be Injected to Stabilize the Money Supply? The mandated shutdown from the coronavirus has exacerbated the debt crisis, but the economy was suffering from an unprecedented buildup of debt well before that. A UBI would address the gap between consumer debt and the money available to repay it; but there are equivalent gaps for business debt, federal debt, and state and municipal debt, leaving room for quite a bit of helicopter money before debt deflation would turn into inflation. Looking just at the consumer debt gap, in 2019 80% of US households had to borrow to meet expenses. See this chart provided by Lance Roberts in an April 2019 article on Seeking Alpha: After the 2008 financial crisis, income and debt combined were not sufficient to fill the gap. By April 2019, about one-third of student loans and car loans were defaulting or had already defaulted. The predictable result was a growing wave of personal bankruptcies, bank bankruptcies, and debt deflation. Roberts showed in a second chart that by 2019, the gap between annual real disposable income and the cost of living was over $15,000 per person, and the annual deficit that could not be filled even by borrowing was over $3,200: Assume, then, a national dividend dropped directly into people’s bank accounts of $1,200 per month or $14,200 per year. This would come close to the average $15,000 needed to fill the gap between real disposable income and the cost of living. If the 80% of recipients needing to borrow to meet expenses used the money to repay their consumer debts (credit cards, student debt, medical bills, etc.), that money would void out debt and disappear. These loan repayments (or some of them) could be made mandatory and automatic. The other 20% of recipients, who don’t need to borrow to meet expenses, would not need their national dividends for that purpose either. Most would save it or invest it in non-consumer markets. And the money that was actually spent on consumer goods and services would help fill the 10% gap between real and potential GDP, allowing supply to rise with demand, keeping prices stable. The end result would be no net increase in the consumer price index. The current economic shutdown will necessarily result in shortages, and the prices of those commodities can be expected to inflate; but it won’t be the result of “demand/pull” inflation triggered by helicopter money. It will be “cost/push” inflation from factory closures, supply disruptions, and increased business costs. International Precedents Critics of central bank money injections point to the notorious hyperinflations of history – in Weimar Germany, Zimbabwe, Venezuela, etc. These disasters, however, were not caused by government money-printing to stimulate the economy. According to Prof. Michael Hudson, who has studied the question extensively, “Every hyperinflation in history has been caused by foreign debt service collapsing the exchange rate. The problem almost always has resulted from wartime foreign currency strains, not domestic spending.” For contemporary examples of governments injecting new money to fund domestic growth, we can look to China and Japan. In the last two decades, China’s M2 money supply grew from 11 trillion yuan to 194 trillion yuan, a nearly 1,800% increase. Yet the average inflation rate of its Consumer Price Index hovered between 2% and 3% during that period. The flood of money injected into the economy did not trigger an inflationary crisis because China’s GDP grew at the same fast clip, allowing supply and demand to rise together. Another factor was the Chinese propensity to save. As incomes went up, the percent of income spent on goods and services went down. In Japan, the massive stimulus programs called “Abenomics” have been funded through bond purchases by the Japanese central bank. The Bank of Japan has now “monetized” nearly half the government’s debt, injecting new money into the economy by purchasing government bonds with yen created on the bank’s books. If the US Fed did that, it would own $12 trillion in US government bonds, over three times the $3.6 trillion in Treasury debt it holds now. Yet Japan’s inflation rate remains stubbornly below the BOJ’s 2% target. Deflation continues to be a greater concern in Japan than inflation, despite unprecedented debt monetization by its central bank. UBI and Fears of the “Nanny State” Wary critics warn that a UBI is the road to totalitarianism, the “cashless society,” dependence on the “nanny state,” and mandatory digital IDs. But none of those outcomes need accompany a UBI. It does not make people dependent on the government, so long as they can work. It is just supplementary income, similar to the dividends investors get from their stocks. A UBI does not make people lazy, as numerous studies have shown. To the contrary, they become more productive than without it. And a UBI does not mean cash would be eliminated. Over 90% of the money supply is already digital. UBI payments can be distributed digitally without changing the system we have. A UBI can serve the goals both of fiscal policy, providing a vital safety net for citizens in desperate times, and of monetary policy, by stabilizing the money supply. The consumer/producer economy actually needs regular injections of helicopter money to remain sustainable, stimulate economic productivity, and avoid deflationary recessions.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Military Readiness DA › FJG › Heg Bad and FJG Solves

FJG prevents pursuit of heg and the embedding of militarism in American lives

Day 18 (Meagan Day, staff writer at Jacobin, 10-19-2018, "Ending Economic Conscription," Jacobin, ) @HA?

The United States has eight hundred foreign military bases. The rest of the world combined has only seventy. Our nation’s leaders are the makers and breakers of combat, our presidents and generals the gods of war. American militarism intensifies conflict and produces needless misery and bloodshed abroad. It also starves our own populace of resources that should be going to good public education, health care, housing, and jobs. For the wellbeing of people at home and elsewhere, the American left has a responsibility to oppose our nation’s military hegemony. No doubt strong moral and ideological opposition to war and militarism are at the heart of any effective strategy. But we should also consider the tactical importance of ambitious social-democratic reforms like a federal jobs guarantee, strong unions, and the universal social provision of higher education and health care. These reforms may not put an end to American empire, but they do have an important effect: they make it harder for the military to recruit from the domestic working class. To combat the reign of the American military abroad, we need to end economic conscription at home. When domestic economic prospects are grim, the military has no problem recruiting soldiers. When those prospects improve, recruitment falls. How do we know? We can see a micro-version of this process happening right now. This year, for the first time in thirteen years, the Army reported it was short thousands of recruits. This year’s unemployment rate is also the lowest we’ve seen in that same time period. These facts are related, and the military agrees. “It’s a tough market out there,” said the Army’s deputy chief of staff. He meant it literally: in tight labor markets, when there are more jobs than workers, employers have to compete to attract labor. Meanwhile, workers have more options (which isn’t to say abundant, fantastic options), and they naturally choose the better jobs on offer — leaving employers who are offering comparatively bad bargains scrambling to fill positions. Hence the shortage of military recruits. Part of the problem is that, by the standards of the US labor market, the military isn’t a totally bad economic bargain for working-class Americans. In fact, it’s a comparatively attractive option for many people, in particular because it offers a steady income, free college and job training, and a lifetime of public health care. In other words, it offers recruits some of the things a decent welfare state would give all its citizens. Indeed, more soldiers report “benefits” as a major motivation for enlisting than any “call to serve.” It follows that if we give people better economic options in civilian society, they are less likely to join the military in droves. This observation is important for the purposes of building an antiwar movement. A working-class background is the greatest demographic predictor of military service. People who serve in the military may not always enter with pro-war ideas in their heads, but they certainly encounter all kinds of justifications for America’s worldwide military presence and its endless overseas conflicts during their service. Additionally, every working-class person who enlists has a whole network of friends and family members who become more likely to identify with the military and are therefore more vulnerable to right-wing “patriotic” pageantry and military chauvinism, including the mainstream GOP’s maudlin reverence for the American flag and Donald Trump’s promises to “bomb the hell” out of our enemies and make the military “so strong that no one will mess with us.” Working-class support for the military is often overstated, but it is high enough to hamstring any antiwar movement angling for mass support — which is the only kind of antiwar movement that can win. The more recruits the military has, the more deeply it embeds itself in working-class American life. This obviously presents an enormous obstacle to building opposition to war. And it is precisely the working class that must oppose war, because not only are workers the majority of society and the group with the actual leverage to force change, but they’re also the ones who fight and die in the wars themselves. As Eugene V. Debs said, “The master class has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles. The master class has had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject class has had nothing to gain and all to lose — especially their lives.” In order for our society to achieve peace, working people must realize they’re being conned into war. So how do we go about removing the economic incentive for joining the military? Ensuring full employment is a great start. Full employment means that everyone who’s actively looking for a job can easily find one, which forces employers to compete with each other for hires, and gives workers more options and more power in the economy. Although unemployment is pretty low right now, there will inevitably be another economic crisis, and the gains made will evaporate. A better way to achieve full employment for the long haul is a federal job guarantee of some kind. But wages aren’t only a natural effect of a tight or loose labor market — they also rise and fall based on the degree of organized class struggle. Strong unions, which can be built through a combination of rank-and-file union activism and pro-labor legislative reforms, are key to driving and keeping wages up, and therefore competitive with the military’s offerings. And finally, wages by themselves aren’t enough to lure working people away from the military, which also pays for college and job training, and provides free medical care for the rest of a person’s life. How can the civilian job market compete with that? The answer is to provide things like college tuition, job training, and health care through universal federal-level social programs. We already have templates for these, as Medicare for All and free tuition at public universities are rapidly becoming some of the most wildly popular new policy ideas in the United States. A combination of a jobs guarantee, strong unions, and universal social programs would put an enormous dent in the army’s program of economic conscription. There would still be an ideological battle to fight over American nationalism and militarism. But it would be easier to win if the military were less embedded in American working-class life — and it won’t be less embedded until working people stop gravitating toward the military out of economic self-interest. Social-democratic reforms therefore must be considered part of any serious antiwar or anti-imperialist strategy.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Military Readiness DA › Universal healthcare › LT - Eligibility

Lack of universal healthcare directly hurts military readiness and eligibility

Bieniek-Tobasco 20 (Ashley Bieniek-Tobasco, DrPH, assistant professor of environmental and occupational health sciences at the University of Illinois Chicago (UIC), 6-13-2020, "A National Security Case for Public Health Infrastructure and Universal Healthcare," No Publication, https://publichealth.uic.edu/news-stories/a-national-security-case-for-public-health-infrastructure-and-universal-healthcare/)@HA?

Military Readiness and National Security Threats There are direct national security implications of poorly funded public health infrastructure and universal healthcare. While the overall health of U.S. citizens and our capacity to adequately and expeditiously respond to health threats is a critical national security issue, it puts our military at risk, even potentially limiting eligible recruits. Inadequate preparation and delayed responses, as reflected in the current response to COVID-19, puts additional strains on our public health systems, our military, and the frontline workforce. Inadequate response to this pandemic has necessitated the use of military personnel and equipment, due to significant nationwide public health infrastructure and resource deficits, resulting in severe illness and tens and thousands of preventable deaths. Additionally, a lack of sustained public health financing in the early phases of this pandemic placed U.S. civilians as well as military personnel at risk and may have adversely impacted military readiness. Although the military personnel are generally younger and healthier than the general population, the virus does not discriminate by service status or age. Moreover, healthy people are not immune to COVID-19, and can still become severely ill, require hospitalization, or die.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Military Readiness DA › UBI › LT- Vetrans

UBI halves Veteran poverty

Ghenis 20 (Max Ghenis, president of the UBI center, Nate Golden, researcher with the UBI center, 11-11-2020, "A $300-per-month UBI would cut Veteran poverty in half," UBI Center, ) @HA?

A $300-per-month UBI would cut Veteran poverty in half Today we honor over 19 million Americans who have served in the military, of whom one in 13 is in poverty. This is a third lower than the poverty rate among non-Veterans, thanks to higher incomes and Veteran benefits, but still amounts to over 1.4 million people who lack resources to cover basic needs. Universal basic income would help. Existing assistance programs cut Veteran poverty substantially. Two million Veterans receive refundable tax credits—the Earned Income Tax Credit and the refundable portion of the Child Tax Credit—and 1.3 million receive SNAP (formerly food stamps). Certain veteran households are also eligible to receive up to $36,387 per year through the Veterans Pension program, depending on their household size, income, net worth, age, service period, and disability status. Veterans with disabilities related to their active-duty service can also receive up to $44,208 per year, depending on their household size and severity of their disability through the Veterans Disability Compensation program. The Veterans Benefit Administration provides a number of other benefits around health, education, and other areas, especially for elderly Veterans. Yet these programs fail to reach all Veterans in need. As the Department of Veterans Affairs found in 2012, veterans with disabilities have a higher official poverty rate than non-veterans with disabilities for all age groups except over age 65, and half of Veterans don’t use VA programs. 20 percent of Veterans have a service-connected disability, and as we wrote in July, one in five people with disabilities is in poverty—nearly double the rate of people without disabilities. In that analysis, we also showed that a $300-per-month universal basic income (UBI) would halve poverty among people with disabilities. What would UBI do for all Veterans? In this analysis, we modeled a UBI funded by a flat tax on adjusted gross income (AGI). In this model, every $100 monthly UBI requires a 3.3 percent tax on AGI. To fund a $300-per-month UBI, the federal government would have to levy a 9.8 percent tax. But like we found in the disability analysis, this would also reduce Veteran poverty by half. Poverty among children in Veteran households would be cut by 60 percent. Studies suggest that reducing Veteran poverty could address issues disproportionately experienced by Veterans. Over 37,000 Veterans experience homelessness on a given night, and a recent experiment in Canada found that cash transfers accelerated transitions out of homelessness. Veterans have a higher rate of mental illness, especially depression, PTSD, and substance abuse disorder, while Finland’s UBI experiment improved mental health. Controlling for age and sex, the Veteran suicide rate exceeds the non-Veteran suicide rate by 50 percent, and a review of cash transfer programs in low- and middle-income countries found significant suicide reductions. The unique Veteran experience warrants investment in tailored solutions, such as the health and education programs offered by the VA. Cash transfers like universal basic income can also reduce their incidence of poverty and empower them to meet their individual needs. Even modest basic incomes such as a tax-funded $300 per month would halve Veteran poverty and more than halve poverty among children of Veterans, improving poverty-linked outcomes for those who have served.