Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › No Solvency – Healthcare

Single-payer healthcare system would eliminate the health insurance industry, leading to massive job lost, decline in quality of care, and crowding out of experienced doctors for cheaper medical graduates

Nelson 22 (Jaeger Nelson, Unit Chief at the Congressional Budget Office, “Economic Effects of Five Illustrative Single-Payer Health Care Systems”, Congressional Budget Office, February 2022, https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2022-02/57637-Single-Payer-Systems.pdf) VQ

The implementation of a single-payer health care system would significantly alter the structure of the health care sector in the United States. How the sector adapts to that new structure is highly uncertain and could alter the economic effects of the program. For example, the implementation of a single-payer health care system would nearly eliminate the health insurance industry, which employed approximately 400,000 people in 2020. Additionally, health care providers’ response to increased demand for care and changes in their payments rates could affect the supply of care and the types of care provided. Under the options with lower payment rates, some physicians and nurses who were already in the workforce might respond by retiring or working fewer hours. However, under the scenario with higher payment rates, not all physicians and nurses would receive lower payment rates than they do under current law. (For example, general practitioners might see rates similar to or higher than those under current law.) CBO also anticipates that providers would respond to increases in the demand for care by increasing their capacity and adapting practice patterns to accommodate more patients. There is also significant uncertainty about how providers would respond to the changes under the illustrative options. CBO expects that many of the services that would have been provided by physicians who retire would instead be provided by new medical graduates or by other less costly health care professionals, such as nurse practitioners and physician assistants, which would decrease spending. In addition, because the average reduction in payment rates would vary among specialties under both payment scenarios, the differential changes in rates might encourage more medical graduates to go into primary care rather than into medical specialties. The supply effects ultimately depend on the design of the overall health care system, as well as its implementation and regulation.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › No Solvency – Healthcare

Single-payer healthcare inflates healthcare bills while providing worse service – wouldn’t boost U.S. public health system

Pipes 22 (Sally C. Pipes, President and chief executive officer of the Pacific Research Institute, “Opinion: Single-Payer ‘Medicare for All’ Would Inflate Americans’ Healthcare Bills”, Time of San Diego, June 7, 2022, https://timesofsandiego.com/opinion/2022/06/07/single-payer-medicare-for-all-would-inflate-americans-healthcare-bills/)

Inflation is ripping through every sector of the U.S. economy. But there’s one curious exception: healthcare. The cost of medical care is up 3.5% in the last year. The overall inflation rate, by contrast, is nearly two-and-a-half times higher — 8.3%. So why are Sen. Bernie Sanders and 14 of his Democratic colleagues proposing to essentially nationalize the U.S. health insurance system? The Vermont socialist introduced his latest bid for Medicare for All in May at a hearing of the Senate Budget Committee, which he chairs. Thanks but no thanks, senator. As other countries with government-run healthcare systems prove, Medicare for All is no bargain. In fact, patients trapped in socialized medicine often pay huge sums out of pocket — and for low-quality care. It’s true that the United States spends more per head on health care than other advanced economies. But that’s largely a function of wealth. Americans, on average, are much richer than our peers in other developed nations. For example, per-capita health spending is $6,600 higher in the United States than in the United Kingdom. But Americans make $22,000 more per year, on a per-capita basis. Similarly, Germany spends about $5,500 less per head on health care. But its per capita GDP is about $17,000 less than the United States. Our higher spending levels correlate with better health outcomes. Cancer prevalence has been rising globally, but survival rates in the United States have been increasing. Meanwhile, Americans typically do not have to endure the long waits common in the United Kingdom and Canada. In April, more than 24,000 people in England waited more than 12 hours in emergency departments before a decision was made about whether to admit them. In a newly released book, former UK Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt said that he was “shocked to his core” by failures in care, including hundreds of avoidable deaths. In Canada in 2019, 4.6 million people over the age of 12 lacked a family doctor, according to the country’s national statistics agency. Last year, the median wait to receive treatment from a specialist in Canada following referral by a general practitioner was 25.6 weeks — roughly six months. Patients pay dearly for their low-quality government-sponsored health care. There are the high taxes, of course. A typical family of four in Canada pays more than $15,000 in taxes just for health care. In the United Kingdom, the National Health Service costs each English household around 5,785 pounds — a little over $7,100 — each year. That per-household cost has increased more than 75% since 2000. Increasingly, people abroad are paying for a lot of their own care out of pocket — despite having government-sponsored health insurance. In the United Kingdom, out-of-pocket healthcare expenses rose about 5.3% between 2020 and 2021. By 2019, 17% of the costs of medical care in the United Kingdom were coming directly out of people’s wallets. The Canadian healthcare system doesn’t cover prescription drugs or dental, vision, or rehab services. Out-of-pocket payments accounted for roughly 15% of Canadian healthcare costs in 2019. In the United States, by comparison, just 11% of healthcare expenses come out of patients’ pockets. A recent event promoting single payer that Sen. Sanders put on with Norway’s ambassador to the United States, Anniken R. Krutnes, was rife with irony. She claimed, “I will never pay more than $350 a year for health care or medicines,” referring to her annual deductible. If so, she’ll likely be skipping dental care and the many prescription drugs the government has decided not to cover. In fact, Norway ranks right behind the United States and Switzerland in per-capita healthcare expenses. Total out-of-pocket costs accounted for nearly 14% of Norwegian health expenses in 2019. Almost 15% of Norway’s workforce elects to pay for private supplemental health coverage to avoid government rationing and wait times. Most private supplemental insurance plans are covered via employment. Sen. Sanders would ban even that kind of modest private coverage under Medicare for All. Government-provided health care abroad is not free. People pay for it one way or another — whether out of pocket, through taxes, or even with their lives.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › No Diversionary War !

There’s better ways to distract and institutions check.

Liu 19 [Christopher Liu, Political Science PhD, “Information And International Conflict,” 2019, Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations, 3496, https://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=5282&context=edissertations, EA]

In chapter four, I advance the literature on diversionary war in two ways. First, I argue that diversion is fundamentally the manipulation of foreign policy salience, and that this objective can be achieved by actions short of war. Given the high costs of waging war, diversion is unlikely to be the primary motive for any high-intensity interstate conflict—this is particularly true if diversion can be bought for the cheap. Second, I argue that domestic political institutions constrain the ability of leaders to reap the rewards of diversion in critical ways. In particular, leaders under a free media system face structural barriers in their ability to generate salient, positive news coverage of low-intensity foreign policy actions due to the autonomy of journalists in such systems. On the other hand, leaders who exercise political control over media institutions can mandate high levels of positive coverage for foreign policy when they desire, thus enhancing their ability to benefit from diversionary policy.

I test predictions from this theory using a data set of international conflict, domestic unrest, and media freedom. The results provide tentative support, insofar as media freedom conditions the relationship between unrest and conflict. However, while theory predicts that this conditionality should take the form of not free states exhibiting a stronger diversionary relationship, I find stronger evidence supporting the inverse: that free states are less likely to initiate conflict when unrest increases.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › No Diversionary War !

Empirics confirm this – talk is cheap

Carter 19 [Erin Baggott Carter, Assistant Professor at the School of International Relations at the University of Southern California, “Diversionary cheap talk: economic conditions and US foreign policy rhetoric, 1945-2010,” 2019, International Interactions, Vol. 46, Issue 2, pp. 163-198, https://doi.org/10.1080/03050629.2020.1688319, EA]

This study argues that when economic conditions deteriorate, Democratic presidents use hostile foreign policy rhetoric to build domestic support. By cueing national identity, they elicit an ingroup rally that boosts their popularity. The quantitative evidence is consistent with the theory. Poll data show that citizens evaluate leaders more highly after they engage in hostile foreign policy rhetoric. The effect is strongest for Democratic presidents among Independent and Republican voters. Economic data suggest that leaders are more likely to engage in hostile foreign policy rhetoric when unemployment and inflation are higher. Further strengthening the notion that this behavior is strategic, rallies only materialize when leaders target traditional rivals, since threatening outgroups render intergroup distinctions most stark. I find no evidence for diversion in the form of material conflict initiation. For leaders choosing between hostile rhetoric, economic reform, and international conflict to increase domestic popularity, hostile rhetoric is the least costly and risky option, even though it is a short term solution because sustained rhetorical belligerence may invite criticism from party elites. For Democratic presidents, cheap talk pays.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › No Diversionary War !

US won’t start a diversionary war due to inequality.

Boehmer 7 – associate prof of poly sci @ UT-El Paso

Charles Boehmer, Associate Professor, Dept. of Political Science @ University of Texas at El Paso. “The Effects of Economic Crisis, Domestic Discord, and State Efficacy on the Decision to Initiate Interstate Conflict”. Politics and Policy. Volume 35, Issue 4, Pages 774-809. Wiley InterScience. December 7, 2007.

Scholars such as MacFie (1938) and Blainey (1988) have nevertheless questioned the validity of the diversionary thesis. As noted by Levy (1989), this perspective is rarely formulated as a cohesive and comprehensive theory, and there has been little or no knowledge cumulation. Later analyses do not necessarily build on past studies and the discrepancies between inquiries are often difficult to unravel. "Studies have used a variety of research designs, different dependent variables (uses of force, major uses of force, militarized disputes), different estimation techniques, and different data sets covering different time periods and different states" (Bennett and Nordstrom 2000, 39). To these problems, we should add a lack of theoretical precision and incomplete model specification. By a lack of theoretical precision, I am referring to the linkages between economic conditions and domestic strife that remain unclear in some studies (Miller 1995; Russett 1990). Consequently, extant studies are to a degree incommensurate; they offer a step in the right direction but do not provide robust cross-national explanations and tests of economic growth and interstate conflict.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › No Nationalism !

Even if inequality spurs national identification, it doesn’t cause antagonism toward outgroups or diversionary war

Gal Ariely 15, senior lecturer in the Department of Politics & Government, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, PhD from the University of Haifa’s School of Political Sciences, “Does National Identification Always Lead to Chauvinism? A Cross-national Analysis of Contextual Explanations,” Globalizations, 2015, https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/43980028/Ariely_Globalizations_2015.pdf?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1515397197&Signature=78lnbbHNRVjhLgOKyRPKm%2BK8M1o%3D&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DDoes_National_Identification_Always_Lead.pdf

With respect to internal explanations, the effects of income inequality and ethnic diversity are presented in Table 3. Models 3.1 and 3.2 indicate that neither directly affects chauvinism. H4 is therefore not supported. The results suggest, however, that both have a negative effect on the national-identification slopes. Contrary to our expectations, countries with higher levels of economic and ethnic division appear to exhibit a weaker relation between national identification and chauvinism. While these findings might seem to contradict H5, the pattern was caused by outliers. After excluding South Africa—the most unequal and ethnic diverse country in our sample—the effect of ethnic diversity is not even of borderline significance. After excluding Chile—the most unequal country in our sample—the interaction effects for economic inequality were also far from significant. The results, therefore, do not support H5.21¶ Conclusions¶ During the historic phone call between President Obama and Iranian President Sheikh Hasan Rouhani in September 2013, the latter stated that his country’s nuclear program ‘represents Iran’s national dignity’.22 This declaration reflects the common perception that Iran’s nuclear program mobilizes Iranians in support of resisting further national humiliation at the hands of foreigners (Moshirzadeh, 2007). This reflects the important role national feelings play in the contemporary international arena. Evidence from other examples—such as the Israeli-Palestine conflict—indicates that national identity serves as a key factor in conflict resolution. The prominence of national feelings is not limited to the Middle East, their effect on public attitudes towards international issues, and conflicts also being manifest in the West (Billig, 1995; Kinder & Kam, 2010).¶ It is thus hardly surprising that scholars seeking to develop a better understanding of conflicts adopt a social-psychology perspective, replacing the deterministic view that identification with one’s in-group necessarily leads to antagonism towards out-groups with an examination of the broader social context. In line with this approach, the present paper focuses on the way in which political and social contexts encourage chauvinistic views towards the international arena and how they affect the relation between national identification and chauvinism.¶ Integrating various social and psychological theories, we investigated two external contextual explanations (globalization and conflict) and an internal explanation (social division). Employing cross-national survey data, we examined the relation between national identification and chauvinism across 33 countries. The findings indicate that a positive relationship exists between national identification and chauvinism across most of the countries, although the level differs from country to country. Using a multilevel regression analysis, we tested to see whether globalization, conflict, and social division correlate with this variation. The results indicate that social and political contexts are related to chauvinism and the ways national identifi- cation and chauvinism are linked. Although a closer relation exists between national identification and chauvinism in more globalized countries, globalization failed to explain the variation in chauvinism itself. These findings support the notion that globalization highlights the importance of national identity (Calhoun, 2007; Castells, 2011). While those sections of globalized societies that are attached to their country also tend to resist international cooperation and endorse hostile views, the complexity of the phenomenon—as evinced by the divergent findings of previous studies (e.g. Jung, 2008; Norris & Inglehart, 2009)—calls for further research of this interpretation. The fact that the current study is cross-sectional must also be taken into account, the findings adducing the relation but not the causal relations between the variables. In contrast to experimental studies, the present design is similarly limited in its ability to offer a robust control for alternative explanations.¶ Another external factor found to be relevant—to a certain degree—was conflict. Countries that suffered large numbers of deaths in conflicts and mobilized resources and personnel exhibited higher levels of chauvinism. When other indices for conflict were used, however, these results were not replicated. A possible explanation for this finding lies in the inherent limitation in the way in which conflicts are measured across various countries. Measuring international conflicts is a challenging task (Anderton & Carter, 2011). While the ways of measuring conflict were chosen because they reflect different dimensions of conflict in order to be representative of a wide range of countries, the problem of comparability cannot be ignored. An alternative explanation may derive from the fact that only deaths from conflict and resources/personnel mobilization are sufficiently significant to contribute to chauvinism. The limitations of our measurements of conflict and research design mean that this idea must remain speculative, however. In addition, it is important to emphasize that the sample of countries is also limited as many countries are not involved in conflict and there is also limited variation in the types of conflicts.¶ Contrary to what the divisionary theory of national mobilization would lead us to expect, neither economic inequality nor ethnic diversity were related to chauvinism or affected the relation between national identification and chauvinism. This finding might also be explained by the limitation of the current research design. The number of countries included in the ISSP 2003 National Identity Module being relatively small and the sample only covering countries with available survey data, the results relate solely to this specific sample of countries. Across another set of countries, social division might play a far more significant role. Another explanation might be the meaning given to national identification and chauvinism across the countries. While evidence exists for the comparability of the scales across most of the countries, the divergent meaning probably attributed to them in Germany, the United States, and Israel might form an additional limitation.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending – Middle Class

Middle-class is key to U.S. economic stability. Turns case.

Tankersley 12 [Jim Tankersley, economics reporter for The New York Times, “The 100% Economy: Why the U.S. Needs a Strong Middle Class To Thrive”, The Atlantic, 05-18-2012, ] AW

This is how Nick Hanauer has come to be standing in the owner's box at a Seattle Sounders FC professional soccer game, snacking on chicken fingers, and listing the very expensive things he owns. "I told you about Mexico," he says, meaning the villa in Cabo San Lucas. "Did I tell you about the fly-fishing ranch?" Meaning the 170 acres in Montana. Yes, he did. He also mentioned the ski chalet in Whistler, British Columbia, the hideaway in the San Juan Islands north of Seattle, and the private jet. "And," he added helpfully at one point, "we have a really big boat." Last year, his wife and some of her friends decided they would like to renew their wedding vows. So Hanauer and a few buddies invited nearly 80 couples to Las Vegas for a vow-renewal ceremony featuring three officiants, followed by a private after-party in the rooftop lounge of the Palms Casino Resort. All captured by a professional filmmaker. Hanauer is 52 and worth several hundred million dollars. His brown hair is thick and mossy, with just a fleck or two of gray, and he is fond of wearing dark denim pants and shirts with open collars. An ace venture capitalist, he is the founder of several companies, including one called aQuantive that he sold to Microsoft for $6.4 billion. On the day of the sale he personally banked $270 million. In 2011, Hanauer says he paid an effective federal tax rate of 11 percent. He occupies the upper echelon of an elite group of Americans, the top 1 percent of all earners, who have amassed the lion's share of the nation's wealth gains over the past several decades. Many economists expect he and his class of entrepreneurs to fuel the country's next great engine of growth. Like a lot of self-made rich guys, Hanauer has developed a theory on how to fix the ailing economy. He preaches it in op-ed columns, television interviews, political gatherings, and casual conversations with Seattle's innovation royalty. He was invited to give a speech this spring by the organizers of TED, the nonprofit that has grown famous for commissioning "TED talks" on such diverse topics as the nature of innovation, the science of global warming, and the need to spread contraceptives throughout the developing world. Hanauer's pitch took five minutes at the TED University conference on March 1. Afterward, organizers seemed keen to post it on their website. Then in May, they abruptly told him his remarks were too controversial, too political for TED, and wouldn't be published online. The disqualifying notion at the center of Hanauer's talk was that the innovators and businessmen are not, in fact, "job creators"--that the fate of the economy rests instead in the hands of the middle class. So Hanauer wants to tax rich guys like himself more, to pay for investments to nurture middle-class families. "We've had it backward for the last 30 years," Hanauer said at the TED conference. "Rich businesspeople like me don't create jobs. Rather, they are a consequence of an ecosystemic feedback loop animated by middle-class consumers." When the middle class thrives, he said, "businesses grow and hire, and owners profit." Emerging research from high-powered experts across the ideological spectrum backs that economic inversion. Their work shows how America's long-term prosperity is in jeopardy because the middle class is struggling and the super-rich are pulling away. Widening income inequality helped drive us into the Great Recession and is holding back our recovery. It is tempting to view the stagnation of the middle class and the disappearance of middle-skill jobs as a problem for only some of us. That's simply untrue. Mounting economic evidence suggests strongly that Hanauer's argument is correct and is, in fact, fundamental to America's future. It's not a do-good argument. It is a selfish one, both for innovators and for every other American counting on the innovator class to power growth for decades to come. The evidence suggests that the United States needs a vibrant middle class. Not for any of sentimental reasons, but because it's a very dangerous thing not to have. As Hanauer is discovering, that's not something many American elites want to hear. DOING LESS WITH MORE Economists don't even broadly agree on who is in the middle class. Some say it's anyone within a 50-percentile ring around the U.S. median income. As good a general definition as you'll find comes in a new paper summarizing the economic case for how the middle class spurs economic growth from economists Heather Boushey and Adam Hersh of the liberal Center for American Progress. "A middle-class family has some economic security," they write, "be that a good job with health insurance and a retirement plan, or some savings in the bank to tide them over in an emergency or to send a child to college or even float a family member who wants to start up a business." By any definition, the middle class is eroding. Real median household incomes basically flatlined over the past 30 years. Each of the last three recessions has vaporized huge numbers of the middle-skilled jobs that used to pay a good family wage, on factory assembly lines or in customer-service centers or, most recently, in classrooms and city halls. This has led to what the MIT economist David Autor calls the "hollowing out" of American jobs, with a few middle-skill workers finding training for high-skilled, higher-paying careers, and the rest shoved downward into low-wage, low-skilled jobs or onto the unemployment rolls. If the decline continues, this is what research suggests the U.S. will look like in the years ahead: Roads and bridges will fall into disrepair. Public schools will struggle to graduate students prepared for the job market. Consumer spending will tumble. Small businesses will close, and fewer and fewer new ones will spring up to take their place. Corporations like Amazon and Apple will scrounge the country to cope with chronic engineering shortages. Rich guys like Hanauer will find themselves with fewer customers, fewer potential employees, and many more worries about the swelling ranks of the have-nots breaking out their pitchforks. The timing couldn't be worse. The United States was first a resource economy, then a production economy, then a full-fledged industrial economy. In the past two decades, globalization turned the nation into a consumption economy--we bought things from other countries and from one another, increasingly with borrowed money. That model collapsed in the financial crisis. What comes next, economists often tell us, is the innovation economy. Our international trading partners will boast cheaper labor, laxer business regulation, lower taxes, more abundant resources, and, in the case of China and India, faster-growing flocks of new consumers. We'll still have the best ideas. We'll keep coming up with the best new products before anyone else does, and everyone else will be forced to buy them from us. That's our comparative advantage. Research suggests that this advantage flows directly from the strength of the American middle class, starting with its spending power. The super-rich don't pay enough people to do enough things for them, or at least not enough to drive the economy. Middle-class families do. That's the core of Hanauer's argument, and research from the Census Bureau and the Brookings Institution, among others, support it. Middle-class families have more disposable income than low-income families, who largely buy only necessities, and they're more likely to spend their disposable income than wealthy families are. As Hanauer puts it, he and his rich friends, for all their lavish parties and jet-away vacations, don't buy enough shirts, cars, and restaurant meals to match the spending that would occur if, say, their wealth was divided up among thousands of poor families. Studies on what economists call "marginal propensity to consume" bear out this idea. Hence Hanauer's claim that middle-class consumers, not innovators, create jobs. Amazon didn't create a new group of book buyers; it just peddled a more convenient way to buy books. Its success created lots of jobs in Seattle, Amazon's hometown, but it also killed lots of jobs in strip malls across the country. Increasing the number of book buyers would boost sales and jobs in the industry, with no downside. Middle-class families buy more than books. They invest heavily in two of the most important drivers of economic growth: infrastructure and human capital. The middle class demands the highways and the schools that boost the overall functioning of the economy. Unlike the Hanauers, those families can't afford to bypass the nation's air-transit system with a private jet, or to send their children to elite private schools. (Hanauer raises this point with his 12-year-old son, Cole, after picking him up from just such a school in the family's Audi. Cole objects. "Cindy's kids go to public school," he says. Nick nods. Cindy Crawford, he explains. The model. Their neighbor in Cabo.) Statistics suggest that Cole Hanauer won't grow up to be an entrepreneur. The risk-takers of tomorrow are growing up in today's middle-class families. Data from the nonprofit Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation suggest that seven of 10 American entrepreneurs have come from the middle class. Only one in 100 was born very wealthy or very poor. The middle class incubates entrepreneurs because it offers a good combination of time, resources, and motivation to invest in skills and climb the innovation ladder. Put it this way: The comforts that flowed from the Pacific Coast Feather Co., his then-modest family business, provided Nick Hanauer with a house full of books and days full of time to explore big ideas. Think of those comforts as an investment. The eventual return was Hanauer's venture-capital portfolio. Poor families just scraping by at the margins can't make those investments, so their children struggle to achieve in school and pursue higher education. Children from rich families may, thanks to their extreme childhood comforts, lack the desire to build wealth and climb the economic ladder, which the Kauffman study found to be a key motivation for would-be entrepreneurs. The economy sags when kids who could have grown up to be physicists end up spending their lives brewing lattes at Starbucks. Or when a young woman born to be a teacher finds herself babysitting, for peanuts, while she waits for a classroom to open up. LOSING GROUND Courtney Carbone, wrapped in a scarf and a nervous smile on a cool spring morning, is a transplant to the Northwest. She grew up in northwestern Connecticut, daughter of a carpentry teacher and a waitress who went on to teach preschool. Her parents were not so different from Nick Hanauer's, actually. From the age of 9, Carbone knew what she wanted to do with her life. She was bright and rebellious. At the prep school she attended on loans that her parents took out, she routinely skipped classes when she didn't respect the teacher's effort. "That just made me want to be a teacher even more," Carbone says. "I wanted to be the one who made students want to show up." She got her wish after graduate school, landing a job teaching English at a Connecticut prep school. That was 2006. In 2009, the recession brought budget cuts crashing down on her school, and she lost her job. She drifted West in her teal 1997 Nissan Altima to live with a friend and look for a teaching job in Seattle. She is still looking. Last year, she attended a regional job fair in Northern California, which she compared to speed dating. She got several interviews. No callbacks. Carbone has nannied and babysat. She has applied for teaching jobs up and down the West Coast. She taught two composition classes at a community college for 11 weeks. She suffered from depression, lost her sense of identity, saw her relationship with her boyfriend dissolve. She moved briefly to Utah last winter to work in a child-care center at a ski resort, earning a season lift pass and less than $10 an hour. Now, back in Seattle, she is caring for a friend's two special-needs children, for $15 an hour, in cash. Carbone happens to be looking for a teaching job at the worst possible time. Washington state has shed 6,500 local education positions since 2009, due to budget cuts. "I know that every time I apply for a job, I'm one of hundreds of people," she says. "But at the same time, knowing something and feeling something are different things. After a while [not getting a job] starts to eat away at your soul." Carbone isn't spending money, isn't feeding that great middle-class consumption engine of growth. She's paying a very small amount in sales taxes, which largely fund the state's road-building and school budgets. She's not doing her part to support the institutions that help stabilize growth. "I keep selling things and getting rid of stuff," Carbone says. "It's freeing, in a way. But I do keep dreaming of the apartment I had when I was a teacher, full of plants and beautiful things that were mine." Carbone's struggles aren't rare, even in one of America's most innovative cities. Seattle hides its erosion better than a lot of other places, away from the rain-soaked microbrew pubs and the towering new Amazon buildings near downtown. "This feels idyllic," says Jake Rosenfeld, a sociologist at the University of Washington. "Seattle doesn't seem like a place I'd worry about." Except, he does. State forecasters expect no net middle-class job growth in the next decade, The Seattle Times recently reported. The state Supreme Court has declared that Washington's schools are failing their constitutional mandate to educate all children adequately. Tuition at Rosenfeld's university now runs 20 percent of a median family income, up from 6 percent two decades ago. The Seattle-based real-estate data firm Zillow reports that middle- and lower-tier homes in the metro area lost an average of 38 percent of their value in the housing collapse, compared with 29 percent for top-tier homes. ELEVATOR DOWN Here, and across the country, the economy is suffering because people cannot fulfill their potential. Researchers at the University of Chicago and Stanford University published a paper this spring arguing that up to one-fifth of America's wage growth over the past 50 years can be attributed to the knocking down of social barriers that prevented women and minorities from doing their best--clearing the way for waitresses to become lawyers, or African-American orderlies to become doctors. Now, the reverse appears to be happening. Workers who once produced $100,000 a year of manufactured goods have been forced downward into jobs flipping $20,000 worth of burgers. Carbone, who once produced $40,000 in education services, now tends toddlers for half that value. That's an economy-wide output loss. If the slide continues, "growth would go down, no question," says Chang-Tai Hsieh, an economist at Chicago's Booth School of Business who was the study's lead author. True, a branch of economists and conservative politicians say that rising inequality isn't bad for growth and might even be good. Edward Conard, a former managing partner of private-equity firm Bain Capital, argues in a book out this month that the income gulf should be even wider because it's a sign that the economy is rewarding risk-takers. Conard contends that too many Americans today avoid risk-taking, settling into comfortable fields such as law. The only way to jar more smart people into the innovation game, he says, is to increase the rewards of success. History contradicts that argument. For nearly all of the recorded economic past, rising national wealth went hand in hand with rising equality. A seminal 2000 study by World Bank economist William Easterly, "The Middle Class Consensus and Economic Development," found that countries with larger middle classes enjoy higher levels of growth and income, along with a variety of health benefits such as lower infant mortality rates and greater life expectancy. In a 2011 paper, economists Andrew Berg and Jonathan Ostry of the International Monetary Fund studied nations' economic growth through history and concluded that "longer growth spells are robustly associated with more equality in the income distribution." The correlation was greater than for any other factor, including liberalizing trade and cracking down on corruption. Widening inequality can throw the economy into crisis. Chicago Booth economists Marianne Bertrand and Adair Morse argue in a draft paper this spring that the rising income gap in the United States fueled a surge in recent years of what they dubbed "trickle-down consumption"--middle-class families drained their savings and maxed out their credit cards to keep up with the jet-set lifestyles of the Hanauers of the world. Hanauer worries about the prospect of inequality expanding not contracting, in the years to come. If you extrapolate the trends over the past 30 years, he warns, in another 30 years, the richest 1 percent will take home 37 percent of U.S. income. The bottom 50 percent will earn a paltry 6 percent. "If you let that happen," he says, "very bad things happen." Wide income inequality correlates to political unrest--the Arab Spring is a classic example--and just the threat of turmoil distorts the economy. Wealthy people who fear massive attempts to redistribute their wealth--we're talking huge tax increases here, not a few extra points tacked on the top marginal rate--do inefficient things with their money. They wall off their houses and install high-tech security systems. They park money in offshore bank accounts. They don't buy new equipment, or hire more workers, even if they see a chance to profit from those investments, because they worry that someone could come along at any moment, a mob or a cash-strapped government, or both, to take it all away. We aren't there yet. Seattle was jostled by protests on May Day, when anarchists broke off from an Occupy march downtown and smashed store windows; by the next day, most people in town had shrugged off the damage as a small-group aberration. But Hanauer worries that the climate could change. Soon. "Ultimately, taxes are a bribe rich people pay to poor people so they won't kill them," he says. "People understand that. We're an armed nation, you know. Things could get very fucking ugly."

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending – Middle Class

$30TN won’t pay for itself - single-payer would have to increase tax burden on the middle class

CRFB 19 [Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, “Would Medicare for All Require a Middle-Class Tax Hike?”, CRFB, 10-22-2019, https://www.crfb.org/blogs/would-medicare-all-require-middle-class-tax-hike]@RN

With several 2020 presidential candidates endorsing a move to single-payer health care (Medicare for All), there is an ongoing debate over whether such a plan would include higher taxes on the middle class. While no candidate has fully specified how he or she would pay for the cost of Medicare for All, our analysis finds fully offsetting the cost would require higher taxes on the middle class. Even with extremely aggressive revenue-raising policy changes, we only identify enough revenue increases from high earners and businesses to cover about 40 percent of the cost of Medicare for All. However, higher taxes don't necessarily mean higher costs, and depending on the details many households could end up paying less in taxes under Medicare for All than they currently pay in premiums and cost sharing. For purpose of this Fact Check, we define Medicare for All as comprehensive single-payer health care that covers virtually all services with no (or only negligible) premiums, copayments, or other cost sharing, and we define middle class as individuals earning above $25,000 but less than $200,000 ($250,000 for families), based on a common political definition. The combination of a less generous version of Medicare for All and a broader definition of middle class might lead to a different result. Medicare for All is a relatively amorphous term that has historically been used to describe universal or universally-available, government-provided health insurance, and it is currently being used to describe a generous single-payer plan that covers virtually all medical interventions with no networks, premiums, or cost sharing. Based on a variety of estimates from credible sources, such a plan is likely to cost the federal government $28 trillion to $32 trillion more than it would spend under current law over the next decade (a new Urban Institute study suggests costs of $27 trillion to $35 trillion under several scenarios). These costs come from expanding coverage, increasing benefit generosity, and – most significantly – eliminating current premiums, deductibles, and copayments, which are partially offset by reductions in provider, drug, and administrative costs. Advocates of Medicare for All have generally called for financing the costs through tax increases. However, there is disagreement over whether the tax hikes would apply to the middle class. For example, former Vice President Joe Biden has argued Medicare for All "will require middle-class taxes to go up, not down," and Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) has said "I do think it is appropriate to acknowledge that taxes will go up" (though premiums and other costs will fall). On the other hand, Senator Kamala Harris (D-CA) has said her "vision for Medicare For All does not include a middle-class tax hike," and Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) has largely evaded the question by simply saying "costs are going to go up for the wealthiest Americans, for big corporations…and hard-working middle-class families are going to see their costs going down.” Others outside of the presidential field have made even bolder claims. For example, Chris Talgo of The Federalist has argued that "tax burdens would double, and for tens of millions of families, the increased taxes would far outweigh not needing to pay for health insurance," while economist Gabriel Zucman says that "Medicare for All would cut taxes for the vast majority of workers" (emphasis added). appear to be any plausible path to finance it with tax increases on just wealthy individuals and businesses. To get a sense of how difficult it would be to raise $3 trillion per year from high-income earners alone, it may be helpful to understand how much income is available for taxation. Based on estimates from the Joint Committee of Taxation (with adjustments based on data from the Institute for Taxation and Economic Policy), tax units making over $200,000 per year will make about $4 trillion in after-tax income this year, while tax units with income above $500,000 will make about $2 trillion. These figures suggest that paying for Medicare for All from high earners alone would require an average tax rate close to or above 100 percent for higher earners. It would be impossible to achieve this revenue with an income tax alone. To give a sense of how much could be raised from high earners, we compiled an extremely aggressive list of tax increases on the wealthy and corporations with very rough (and generally optimistic) estimates of how much revenue each option would raise. The table below assumes policymakers raise the top two tax rates from 35 and 37 percent up to 70 percent, phase out most deductions and exclusions for higher incomes, double the corporate income tax rate from 21 to 42 percent, impose a tax on wealth or tax capital gains mark-to-market for high net worth individuals, establish a tax on financial transactions and large financial institutions, and pass a variety of other tax increases. Using our very rough estimates and excluding many interactions and economic feedback, we estimate these policies would raise a total of $11 trillion over a decade, enough to cover roughly 40 percent of the cost of Medicare for All. While the list above does not technically include all possible taxes that could be imposed on the wealthy, the policies it does include are extremely aggressive, more aggressive than may be politically or even technically possible. A top individual rate of 70 percent would almost certainly bring top marginal tax rates above their revenue-maximizing levels (including state and local rates). A 42 percent corporate income tax rate would put the total corporate tax rate at close to twice the international average and a third higher than the next highest developed nation. A wealth tax would likely lead to constitutional challenges. Moreover, these policies are likely to reduce incentives to work and invest, slowing economic growth and reducing their combined revenue stream. It is unlikely that policymakers could agree to enact anywhere close to $11 trillion in tax increases only on the wealthy and corporations, let alone the $30 trillion needed to fund Medicare for All. As a result, funding Medicare for All will almost certainly require broad-based taxes that apply to the middle class, either directly or indirectly (for example through an employer payroll tax or consumption tax). While taxes would need to go up on the middle class in order to pay for Medicare for All, total costs for middle-class families may go up or down – and median costs are likely to fall, as most taxes are more progressive than current premiums. Currently, a large share of health care is financed from individual premiums, employer-paid premiums (which ultimately result in lower wages), and out-of-pocket costs paid by individuals and families. Under Medicare for All, the government would finance these costs, resulting in lower direct health care costs for individuals and families. Essentially, premiums and cost sharing would be replaced with taxes. Whether a family pays more or less on net under Medicare for All will depend on how the program is financed and will also differ from person to person. For example, imagine Medicare for All were financed with a broad tax equal to 25 percent of income. In that case, a single 40-year-old making $100,000 and currently paying $10,000 in premiums and cost-sharing would end up paying $15,000 more; meanwhile, a family of four making $60,000 and paying $25,000 in premiums and cost sharing would end up paying $10,000 less (these figures exclude tax and wage interactions). The more progressive the revenue stream, the fewer people who will end up paying more but the larger net increase those people will face. Importantly, whether net costs go up or down is not the only important metric. For some, costs may go up, but so too will the health services they receive. For others, average net costs may go down, but so will the flexibility to adjust spending based on preference, need, and ability to pay. Taxes may also distort behavior and slow income growth in ways that premiums and cost-sharing do not. It is impossible to assess whether the middle class is better off or worse off under Medicare for All until all the plan's details – especially how to pay for Medicare for All – are specified. Even then, data and analysis will need to be supplemented with judgement calls, as many of the costs and benefits associated with Medicare for All are intangible or not directly comparable. **** Regardless of the overall impact of Medicare for All, it is clear that taxes on the middle class would have to rise in order to pay for it. Those taxes could be imposed directly on workers, indirectly through taxes on employers or consumption, or through a combination of direct or indirect taxes. There is simply not enough available revenue from high earners and businesses to cover the full cost of eliminating premiums, ending all cost-sharing, and expanding coverage to all Americans and for (virtually) all health services. But in exchange, the absence of premiums and cost-sharing could represent a net gain or loss to individuals' finances depending on how much they currently pay, how much they currently make, and how the ultimate financing is structured.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending – !

Single Payer would devastate the economy, prices are unprecedented and current proposals don’t account for estimates of cost

Stark 17 (Roger Stark is a health care policy analyst at Washington Policy Center, “Single-Payer Would Devastate The Economy,” Forbes, Dec 7, 2017, https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2017/12/07/single-payer-would-devastate-the-economy/?sh=7a2eec996442) LAB

We already have two examples of a single-payer system in the U.S. The Veterans Administration (VA) health care system is a socialized, single-payer program. Taxpayers fund the system, hospitals are owned by the government, and providers are all government employees. Although the VA system has offered good health care to many veterans, we have learned that on balance the system is plagued with cost overruns, inefficiencies, and prolonged wait times for care. The second example is Medicare, which began in 1965 and is a single-payer system for seniors, 65 years of age and older. Funding is through payroll taxes, premiums, and an ever-increasing percentage of money from federal general taxes. By 1990, spending in Medicare was seven times over the original budget. Medicare is not financially sustainable in its present form. Like the VA system, Medicare has helped many people, but the cost of “Medicare for All” would devastate the overall economy. The non-partisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) analyzed Senator Sanders’ proposal from a financial standpoint. He calls for six new or expanded taxes. Everyone would pay 6.2% more in payroll tax and 2.2% more in income tax. Higher-income workers would experience four additional taxes. Income taxes would increase, capital gains would be taxed as ordinary income, certain current deductions would be eliminated, and estate taxes would increase. Forbes Daily: Get our best stories, exclusive reporting and essential analysis of the day’s news in your inbox every weekday. Email address Sign Up By signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Service (including the class action waiver and arbitration provisions), and Privacy Statement. Even with these expanded taxes, the CRFB reports that multiple analysts, including the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, find Senator Sanders’ calculations to be short by up to $14 trillion over 10 years. Canada has had a single-payer system for over 30 years and its experience is revealing. Canadians are proud that every citizen has health insurance. From a cultural standpoint, the principle of universal coverage is a priority for the country. It also makes it easier for the citizens to overlook the problems within the system. The demand for health care far outweighs the supply of care in Canada. Health care spending is now one of the greatest expenses for every province in the country. The long wait times in Canada are not in the patient’s best interest and would not be acceptable for the vast majority of Americans. Health care rationing through waiting-lists is effective when supply is overwhelmed by demand. The question is whether government bureaucrats should have the authority to pick and chose what procedures patients receive and who should actually receive those treatments, while others are forced to wait for care. Canada actually has a two-tiered health care system. Wealthy Canadians who do not want to wait for care and can pay cash, can and do receive treatment in the U.S. Under a single-payer system, health care spending must compete with all other government activity for funding. This makes health care very political and subject to change with every new budget. It also forces each health care sector to compete with the other for limited money. A single-payer system sounds like a simple solution to the U.S. health care problem. The reality is far different. Fundamentally, a single-payer system centralizes all health care with the government, is far too expensive, and limits access to health care by rationing. Instead of patients and doctors making key decisions, bureaucrats get to make those life and death choices about the kind and amount of health care people receive.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending – !

Medicare for all would decimate the economy and contribute to rising inequality – higher taxes, unaffordable new costs, and spending cuts.

PAHCF 20 (Partnership for America's healthcare future - The nation’s leading doctors, nurses, clinicians, community hospitals, health insurance providers, and biopharmaceutical companies.) “Medicare for all could decimate the economy” Partnership for America's healthcare future 02-04-2020

https://americashealthcarefuture.org/medicare-for-all-could-decimate-the-economy/

WASHINGTON – The unaffordable costs, tax increases and negative economic consequences of proposed one-size-fits-all new government health insurance systems – such as Medicare for All, Medicare buy-in and the public option – continue to make headlines. A new analysis from Penn Wharton reveals that Medicare for All “could shrink U.S. GDP by as much as 24% by the year 2060,” Yahoo Finance . … [T]he model warns, if the plan is deficit-financed – paid for by government borrowing – “the negative effects of larger deficits on labor supply, capital accumulation and GDP would significantly outweigh the positive effects on the economy that come from a larger and healthier workforce.” … According to studies, the cost of Medicare for all sits at roughly $32 trillion over the next decade. But, as the analysis notes, [Senator Bernie] Sanders’ universal health care plan doesn’t have a built-in financing mechanism … Sanders’ wealth tax would generate $1 trillion less in revenue than he stated … The real trouble comes when Medicare for all is financed by deficits. With government borrowing, universal health care could shrink the economy by as much as 24% by 2060, as investments in private capital are reduced. The one-size-fits-all government health insurance system “could decimate the economy,” the Washington Examiner . This contributes to the mounting evidence that Medicare for All would burden American families with unaffordable new costs, as the Urban Institute finds “that federal spending on health care would increase by roughly $34 trillion under a single-payer plan similar to Medicare for All,” CNN . The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) that “fully offsetting the cost would require higher taxes on the middle class” and “require the equivalent of tripling payroll taxes or more than doubling all other taxes.” Senator Sanders previously that Americans making more than $29,000 per year would “pay more in taxes” for Medicare for All. “No matter how you cut the numbers, there is absolutely no way to pay for Medicare for all without tax increases – or spending cuts – on the middle class,” Marc Goldwein of CRFB POLITICO. “There’s no question it hits the middle class,” Kenneth Thorpe, Chairman of the Health Policy and Management Department, Emory University The Washington Post.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending

The plan blows up tax obligations and delivers subpar care – it’s more costly than private health insurance for most Americans

Moffit 18 [Robert E. Moffit, Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy, “Why Single-Payer Would Make Health Care Worse for Americans,” The Heritage Foundation, 9-26-18, ] [ST]

How Much Would It Cost? The cost of a single-payer system would depend upon its design, benefit levels, and scope of coverage. In the case of Sanders’ proposal, estimates consistently show that the plan would impose dramatic obligations on the federal taxpayer, and that the proposal would incur substantial annual deficits. For example: The Urban Institute estimates 10-year spending of $32 trillion, only about half of which would be covered under Sanders’ funding options Mercatus Center’s Charles Blahous estimates a 10-year $32.6 trillion increase in federal spending. Even “doubling all currently projected federal individual and corporate income tax collections would be insufficient to finance the added federal costs of the plan.” Economist Kenneth Thorpe of Emory University estimates $24.7 trillion in additional federal spending, and also estimates an average deficit of $1.1 trillion per year. The Center for Health and Economy estimates a 10-year net cost of up to $44 trillion, and an annual deficit of $2.1 trillion. Would Single-Payer Reduce Administrative Costs? Advocates argue that single-payer would save the nation money by reducing administrative costs, eliminating the administrative expenses of marketing and advertising private health insurance, managing private benefits and utilization, and securing profits. Advocates claim that administrative costs would be much lower in a Medicare-like system than under a system dominated by private insurance. Payment would be based on the Medicare model, where annual administrative costs are about 2 percent of total costs. But pointing to Medicare’s low percentage of administrative costs is over-simplistic and misleading. Per capita administrative costs may be higher in Medicare. For instance, in 2009 they were $509 in Medicare and $453 in private insurance. Medicare costs are lower as a percentage of the total only because total claims costs tend to be much higher in Medicare than in private insurance. This is because Medicare’s older and less healthy population file the claims costs. Medicare shifts administrative costs to doctors, hospitals, nursing homes, home health agencies, and other medical professionals who must comply with Medicare’s huge and complex regulatory requirements. Compliance with tens of thousands of pages of Medicare rules, regulations, guidelines, billing, and other paperwork requirements consumes vast amounts of time, energy, and effort on the part of the private-sector professionals who participate in the Medicare program. Medicare fails to effectively control waste, fraud, and abuse in the program. This failure of administration results in the staggering loss of tens of billions of taxpayer dollars each and every year. Private-sector health plans, policing their billing, have no comparable record in accumulating such enormous losses. How Would Single-Payer Control Health Costs? Single-payer would control costs by capping the amount spent on health care through a global budget, imposing a system or price controls or payment reductions on doctors and other medical professionals, or some combination of both. In a normal market, cost control is a function of supply and demand. Where there is no market, there are no such market forces, and the control of costs must be ultimately an administrative or legislative function. Government officials cannot control demand—they can only control supply. So, in effect, cost control in the single-payer system is inevitably supply control. Control over the supply of medical services is secured through a global budget, price controls, or regulations on payment and price. Under the Sanders proposal, for example, cost control is secured by a global budget and by imposing Medicare payment rates. Blahous, a former Medicare trustee, estimates that under the Sanders proposal, provider payments would be cut by an estimated 40 percent by usingMedicare payment rates. Using Medicare payment rates throughout the entire American health care economy would hurt patients. Already, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services projects that “nearly half of hospitals, approximately two-thirds of skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), and over 8 percent of home health agencies (HHAs) would have negative total facility margins.” Would Taxes Go Up Under Single-Payer? The tax burden would be enormous, roughly doubling the current tax obligations for today’s taxpayers. One funding option Sanders proposes is a 7.5 percent payroll tax, plus a 4 percent income tax on all Americans, as well as a wide variety of specialized taxes on investments and taxes targeted to higher-income Americans. (He outlines these tax proposals as options, but they are not included in the latest version of his bill.) The problem is that even the proposed set of new federal taxes are insufficient to fully fund the Sanders program. One estimate suggests the proposal would require combined payroll and income taxes of 20 percent. In a fully-funded Sanders program, a vast majority of working Americans would pay more for health care than they do today: 71 percent of all working families. 85 percent of taxpaying Medicaid recipients. 66 percent of taxpaying Medicare recipients. 65 percent of young adult workers. 57 percent of workers in firms under 50 employees. The bottom line: Compared to what most Americans pay for health care today, a fully funded program—as envisioned by Sanders—would cost more for 71 percent of the nation’s working families, including low-income families, according to Thorpe. Would Everyone Get Equal Access to Health Care Under Single-Payer? No. The British and Canadian experiences with single-payer demonstrate that universal government coverage is not the same thing as universal access to quality care. Moreover, social inequalities in accessing care, based on wealth or political influence, are often exacerbated. In 2017, Canadians were on waiting lists for an estimated 1,040,791 total procedures. Often, wait times are lengthy. For example, the median wait time for arthroplastic surgery (hip, knee, ankle, shoulder) ranges from 20 weeks to 52 weeks. In the British National Health Service, cancelations are common. Last year, the National Health Service canceled 84,827 elective operations in England for nonclinical reasons on the day the patient was due to arrive. The same year, it canceled 4,076 urgent operations in England, including 154 urgent operations canceled two or more times. Times of high illness are a key driver in this problem. For instance, in flu season, the National Health Service canceled 50,000 “non-urgent” surgeries. In Canada, private insurance is outlawed (as it would be under Sanders’ proposal). In 2017, “an estimated 63,459 Canadians received non-emergency medical treatment outside Canada.” In Britain, private insurance is permitted—but it is an additional cost to the taxes that British citizens pay for the National Health Service. Escaping the system is an option for the wealthy, or for those who are willing to forego other expenditures to get the care they want or need. Government-run health care cannot deliver on its promises. It would impose unprecedented taxes on Americans, deliver subpar care to patients, and put government in charge of personal health care decisions. Americans deserve better.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn – Spending

Single-payer is more expensive than private health insurance – it would require massive broad-based taxation and trillions in additional health care spending

Moffit 20 [Robert E. Moffit, Ph.D., Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy, “Single-Payer is Not the Solution to America’s Health Care Problems”, Heritage Foundation, 11-17-2020, https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/single-payer-not-the-solution-americas-health-care-problems] AW

Costs Congressional sponsors, as noted, claim that the substitution of broad-based federal taxation for private health insurance costs would result in most American families paying less for health care than they do today. Sen. Sanders concedes that his proposed program would require broad-based taxation on the general population, not just high taxes on the economically advantaged few. Examining his initial (2016) proposal, however, Professor Kenneth Thorpe of Emory University, a former advisor to President Clinton, estimated that the Sanders proposal—if it were fully funded—would require a 14.3 percent payroll tax, as well as a 5.7 percent income-related premium; in other words, a level of taxation equal to 20 percent of payroll. Thorpe concluded that 71 percent of all working families would pay more for health care than they do under the current system. A 2020 Heritage Foundation econometric analysis broadly confirmed Thorpe’s findings, estimating that the program would require a tax of 21.2 percent on earnings, and 73.5 percent of Americans would have less money in their pockets. Over 156 million Americans today have employer-sponsored coverage—roughly half of the American population—and those households losing job-based coverage would experience an average income reduction of $10,554, which means about 87 percent of those households would be worse off. Spending Some academic specialists estimate that a single-payer system can indeed achieve lower levels of household and national health care spending. It is theoretically possible, of course, to achieve such fiscal objectives if, and only if, federal officials would enforce either serious caps on national health care spending (global budgets), regardless of the demand for services, or impose severe reductions in medical reimbursements unlike anything Americans have previously experienced. The prevailing view among prominent health care economists, liberal and conservative alike, is that such an outcome is highly unlikely. For example, scholars at the Urban Institute, a prominent liberal-leaning think tank, estimated that a single-payer program would require a federal spending increase of $34 trillion over ten years, and total American health care spending would increase by $7 trillion. Dr. Charles Blahous, a former trustee of the Medicare program, initially projected a $32.6 trillion increase in additional federal spending, and later emphasized that this federal and overall national spending would likely be higher. The Center for Health and the Economy, a conservative-leaning policy group, focused on the Sanders plan and estimated that federal spending could range between an additional $35-$45 trillion over ten years, while generating a deficit of up to $2.1 trillion annually. A Rand Corporation study estimated the combination of additional federal spending and comprehensive benefits plus the absence of cost-sharing could result in an overall annual increase in national health care spending ranging, depending on utilization, anywhere from 1.8-9.8%.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Inequality Rising

Inequality is stabilizing

Popli 22 (Nik Popli – Reporter at TIME. “Income Inequality in America Hasn’t Risen in a Decade. It May Not Feel Like It.” TIME. 10/5/22. https://time.com/6220111/income-inequality-us-2/)

The U.S. may have the highest level of income inequality of the G7 nations, but new research suggests that disparity has actually stabilized over the last decade, thanks to rapid growth in wages for the lowest-paying jobs. It just may take a while for the average American to feel it. A pair of researchers from Harvard and MIT examined data from the period between 1980 and 2020, and found that income inequality peaked in 2012 and then began to stabilize even though many of the drivers of rising inequality—such as a decline in union membership—have persisted. “After decades of rising inequality, overall earnings inequality stopped growing, and possibly declined, since 2012,” according to the research paper, titled Rapid wage growth at the bottom has offset rising U.S. inequality. That could be good news for the fight against inequality, but the gains are hardly permanent and could be wiped away if the economy spirals. “It’s got me feeling very cautiously optimistic,” says Clem Aeppli, a Harvard PhD student and co-author of the research article, which was published on Monday in the competitive PNAS journal. “Optimism in the sense that maybe the increase in inequality we’ve observed since the 1980s is not inevitable.” But Aeppli says he is also “incredibly cautious…because the stabilization in inequality seems so reliant on these very fragile market conditions.” Tracing income inequality can be especially messy, but the researchers say they pulled together multiple measures of earnings—from household and business surveys to Bureau of Labor Statistics data—which they say all told a similar story: Income inequality is declining as growth for low-wage workers outpaces middle- and high-wage workers. “It’s unexpected good news for those of us who have been studying inequality trends for a while,” says Nathan Wilmers, an associate professor at MIT Sloan and co-author of the research paper. Separate data from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta shows that as of August, the bottom quartile of U.S. earners saw a 7% increase in wages over the last year, while those in the top quartile saw wages increase 4%. According to Wendy Edelberg, a senior fellow in economic studies at the Brookings Institution and director of The Hamilton Project, wage gains have been greatest for the leisure and hospitality sector and the retail trade sector, while workers in other industries have not seen the same benefits. “We’ve seen big declines in real wages for every sector except those two,” she says, partly because of pandemic and inflationary pressures. “And they happen to be pretty low wage sectors.” While the research suggests individual income inequality is shrinking, figures from the Census Bureau present a less optimistic picture for American households, which are facing current inflation levels of 8.3%, putting pressure on living costs. The Census Bureau’s 2021 American Community Survey, released Oct. 4, found that household income inequality was “significantly” higher than its 2019 estimate (based on a calculation of the Gini index, a summary measure of income inequality used across the world). Contrary to the two scholars’ findings about individual income, the Census Bureau found that household income inequality increased over the last year for the first time since 2011 due to declines in real income—which takes inflation into account—at the bottom of the income distribution. The scholars attribute this difference to changes in the Bureau’s data collection and processing methods. “That report is looking at household income inequality rather than inequality in individual earnings,” Aeppli says. “It’s a different unit of analysis and different quantity. And even when we correct for that difference, we still observed that household income inequality seems to be stabilizing in the last decade—it just isn’t as pronounced.” Research in related fields seems to support the scholars’ findings. As earnings grow for low-wage workers, the number of Americans living below the poverty line has also decreased, says Chris Wimer, director of the Center on Poverty and Social Policy at Columbia University. A number of policies designed to offset the impact of rising prices have contributed, including employment expansions, stimulus payments and the child tax credit of 2021. “But some of those policies are going away,” Wimer says, “so families coping with inflation no longer have the same policy support.” However, the Harvard and MIT study suggests that policy measures have had less of an impact than market dynamics. It argues that a tight labor market is what’s driving these changes in inequality rather than other factors like minimum wage legislation, labor action or a shortage of workers. The early months of the pandemic put frontline workers dealing with the public face-to-face at the most risk, and saw workers resigning in droves, particularly in the food services and retail industries. Their analysis found that raising minimum wages to $15 an hour would, perhaps unsurprisingly, increase earnings at the bottom, though most cities did not increase minimum wages in 2021. However, labor shortages meant that some employers were offering higher wages in order to get staff in these roles.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Inequality Rising

Inequality is decreasing – wages are no longer stagnating and unemployment rates are declining

Semuels 23 (ALANA SEMUELS - Economic correspondent at TIME. She is a four-time nominee for the Gerald Loeb Award for Distinguished Business and Financial Journalism, and has won awards from the Society of Business Editors and Writers and the Los Angeles Press Club. “American Inequality is (Finally) Lessening.” TIME. 3/31/23. )

If 2022 was the year the U.S. economy came roaring back like a lion, 2023 is more of a lamb. Modest job growth, consistent inflation, falling home prices, slowing GDP growth—meh. February was another month of meh, the government reported Friday, with personal incomes increasing 0.3% in February after growing 0.6% in January. In addition, consumer spending grew 0.2% in February. But there’s some pretty good news that doesn’t readily appear in the steady stream of government data released each week. After decades in which the gap between the richest and poorest Americans grew by leaps and bounds, the strange rebound from the pandemic has led to something different: a slow reduction in inequality across the economy. Incomes of people in the bottom half of income distribution grew by 4.5% in the last calendar year, much faster than the 1.2% average income growth of all Americans, according to Realtime Inequality, a tool launched by economists at the University of California, Berkeley to show a more holistic picture of how the U.S. economy is faring, as compared to GDP. While lower-income households struggled following the Great Recession, taking more than eight years to reach pre-crisis income levels, they have done much better in the pandemic’s aftermath. Between February 2020 and September 2022, average income for the lowest-earning 50% of Americans increased by more than 10%, faster than all groups of population except for the top 1%, according to a paper by the Realtime Inequality economists, Thomas Blanchet, Emmanuel Saez, and Gabriel Zucman. This reduction in inequality breaks from a long-running trend in which the rich were getting richer and the poor were stagnating. Since 1980, the top 10% of earners have seen income grow 144%, while the bottom half of earners saw just 20% growth in income. “What we’re witnessing since the late 2010s—significant growth rates for low-wage workers—is a notable break from the trend that has prevailed since the 1980s,” Zucman says, in an email. The biggest factor driving this reduction in inequality is a tight labor market that has pushed up wages for workers whose pay had previously been stagnating. The monthly unemployment rate hovered around 4% in both 2018 and 2019 as well as in 2022 (the massive layoffs at the beginning of the pandemic spiked unemployment in 2020 leading into 2021); this year it hit a decades-long low at 3.4% in January. Economists expect the government to report an unemployment rate of 3.6% when it releases March data on April 7.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › No Bioterror !

Producing a pathogen isn’t the same as producing a bioweapon – tons of logistical barriers - zero historical evidence for this impact

Jefferson et al. 8/21/14 (Catherine, senior policy advisor for international security at the Royal Society, where she led a project on Neuroscience, Conflict and Security. Prior to this she was a research fellow with the Harvard Sussex Program on Chemical and Biological Weapons at the University of Sussex, where she also obtained her DPhil, Filippa Lentzos, Senior Research Fellow in the Department of Social Science, King’s College, Claire Marris, Department of Social Science, Health and Medicine, King’s College, “Synthetic biology and biosecurity: challenging the “myths”’, http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fpubh.2014.00115/full)

Myth 5 Terrorists want to pursue biological weapons for high consequence, mass casualty attacks Underlying the first four myths are certain assumptions about who the terrorists might actually be, what their intentions are, what capabilities they might pursue, and the level of skills and resources available to them. Despite a lack of analysis of the potential adversaries involved in the misuse of life science research, the bioterrorism threat has generally been portrayed in policy circles as an imminent concern, and emphasis is placed on high consequence, mass casualty attacks, performed with “weapons of mass destruction” (WMD). For example, in one of the President George W. Bush’s earliest statements following 9/11 and the “anthrax letter” attacks that drew the American people’s attention to the biological weapons threat, he said: Since September 11, America and others have been confronted by the evils these [biological] weapons can inflict. This threat is real and extremely dangerous. Rogue states and terrorists possess these weapons and are willing to use them (58). Later, he set up a WMD Commission and tasked it with examining the threat posed by the nexus of international terrorism and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. In its report, this Commission asserted: Unless the world community acts decisively and with great urgency, it is more likely than not that a weapon of mass destruction will be used in a terrorist attack somewhere in the world by the end of 2013. The Commission further believes that terrorists are more likely to be able to obtain and use a biological weapon than a nuclear weapon. The Commission believes that the U.S. government needs to move more aggressively to limit the proliferation of biological weapons and reduce the prospect of a bioterror attack [(59), p. xv]. Bioterrorism became one of the Bush Administration’s key security concerns over its two terms in office. One estimate of civilian biodefense expenditure across the federal government since 2001 is that more than $70 billion have been spent (60). Despite this, on the 10-year anniversary of 9/11 and the “anthrax letter” attacks, the former US senators who chaired the WMD Commission, Bob Graham and Jim Talent, released a “report card” on America’s bio-response capabilities that concluded the US was still unprepared to respond to large-scale biological attacks. It also warned: Naturally occurring disease remains a serious biological threat; however, a thinking enemy armed with these same pathogens — or with multi-drug-resistant or synthetically engineered pathogens — could produce catastrophic consequences. A small team of individuals with graduate training in several key disciplines, using equipment readily available for purchase on the Internet could produce the type of bioweapons created by nation-states in the 1960s. Even more troubling, the rapid advances in biotechnology, such as synthetic biology, will allow non-state actors to produce increasingly powerful bioweapons in the future [(61), p. 11]. We see here how the myths we previously discussed, about de-skilling and increased access, and about the ease of designing new dangerous pathogens, underlie concerns about terrorists’ potential ability to launch a mass attack, and how these are connected, by actors, with the advent of synthetic biology. The senators were not alone in their assessments. For instance, the US Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist made a similar warning in an earlier speech outlining the global threat of infectious disease and bioterrorism, and the need to better prepare the US and the world to respond to epidemics and outbreaks: No intelligence agency, no matter how astute, and no military, no matter how powerful and dedicated, can assure that a few technicians of middling skill using a few thousand dollars worth of readily available equipment in a small and apparently innocuous setting cannot mount a first-order biological attack … Never have we had to fight such a battle, to protect so many people against so many threats that are so silent and so lethal (62). Similar messages were reinforced at the highest level. Addressing BWC members at their five-yearly meeting in 2011, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said: The advances in science and technology make it […] easier for states and non-state actors to develop biological weapons. A crude, but effective, terrorist weapon can be made by using a small sample of any number of widely available pathogens, inexpensive equipment, and college-level chemistry and biology (63). She also acknowledged, however, that not everyone in the international community shared the US assessment: I know there are some in the international community who have their doubts about the odds of a mass biological attack or major outbreak. They point out that we have not seen either so far, and conclude the risk must be low. But that is not the conclusion of the United States, because there are warning signs, and they are too serious to ignore (63). The belief that the focus should be on mass attacks was bluntly stated by an FBI agent at a symposium on synthetic biology this year (1st May), when she warned: “These technologies do not just pose a risk to individual buildings or cities, but if cleverly deployed, can reduce our population by significant percentages” (64). Challenges to Myth 5 There are two dimensions to Myth 5. The first is about the intention of would-be terrorists, and the assumption is that terrorists would seek to produce mass casualty weapons and pursue capabilities on the scale of twentieth century state-level bioweapons programs. While most leading biological disarmament and non-proliferation experts believe that the risk of a small-scale bioterrorism attack is very real and very present, they consider the risk of sophisticated large-scale bioterrorism attacks to be very small (65). This is backed up by historical evidence. The three confirmed attempts to use biological agents against humans in terrorist attacks in the past were small-scale, low casualty events aimed at causing panic, and disruption rather than excessive death tolls: (i) the Rajneesh cult’s use of Salmonella on salad bars in local restaurants to sicken potential voters and make them stay away from the polls during Oregon elections in 1984; (ii) the 1990–95 attempted use of botulinum toxin and anthrax by the Japanese Aum Shinrikyo cult; (iii) and the “anthrax letters” sent to media outlets and members of US Congress in 2001 resulting in at least 22 cases of anthrax, five of which were fatal (66, 67). The second dimension to Myth 5 is the implicit assumption that producing a pathogenic organism equates producing a weapon of mass destruction. It does not. Considerable knowledge and resources are necessary for the processes of scaling up, storage, and developing a suitable dissemination method. These processes present significant technical and logistical barriers. Drawing from her in-depth study of the Iraqi, Soviet, and US bioweapons programs (3, 4), Ben Ouagrham-Gormley explains: Scaling up fragile microorganisms that are sensitive to environmental conditions and susceptible to change — and viruses are more sensitive than bacteria — has been one of the stiffest challenges for past bioweapons programs to overcome, even with appropriate expertise at hand. Scaling-up requires a gradual approach, moving from laboratory sample, to a larger laboratory quantity, to pilot-scale production, and then to even larger-scale production. During each stage, the production parameters need to be tested and often modified to maintain the lethal qualities of the agent; the entire scaling-up process can take several years (68). The dissemination of biological agents also poses difficult technical challenges. Whereas persistent chemical agents such as sulfur mustard and VX nerve gas are readily absorbed through the intact skin, no bacteria and viruses can enter the body via that route unless the skin has already been broken. Biological agents must either be ingested or inhaled to cause infection. To expose large numbers of people through the gastrointestinal tract, possible means of delivery are contamination of food and drinking water, yet neither of these scenarios would be easy to accomplish. Large urban reservoirs are usually unguarded, but unless terrorists added massive quantities of biological agent, the dilution effect would be so great that no healthy person drinking the water would receive an infectious dose (66). Moreover, modern sanitary techniques such as chlorination and filtration are designed to kill pathogens from natural sources and would probably be equally effective against a deliberately released agent. Bacterial contamination of the food supply is also unlikely to inflict mass casualties. Cooking, boiling, pasteurization, and other routine safety precautions are generally sufficient to kill pathogenic bacteria. The most likely way to inflict mass casualties with a biological agent is by disseminating it as a respirable aerosol: an invisible cloud of infectious droplets or particles so tiny that they remain suspended in the air for long periods and can be inhaled by large numbers of people. A high-concentration aerosol of B. anthracis or some other pathogen, released into the air in a densely populated urban area, could potentially infect thousands of victims simultaneously. After an incubation period of a few days, depending on the type of agent and the inhaled dose, the exposed population would experience an outbreak of an incapacitating or fatal illness. Although aerosol delivery is potentially the most lethal way of delivering a biological attack, it involves major technical hurdles that most terrorists would be unlikely to overcome. To infect through the lungs, infectious particles must be microscopic in size – between 1 and 5 μm in diameter. Terrorists would therefore have to develop or acquire a sophisticated delivery system capable of generating an aerosol cloud with the necessary particle size range and a high enough agent concentration to cover a broad area. Overall, an important trade-off exists between ease of production and effectiveness of dissemination. The easiest way to produce microbial agents is in a liquid form, yet when such a “slurry” is sprayed into the air, it forms heavy droplets that fall to the ground so that only a small percentage of the agent is aerosolized. In contrast, if the bacteria are first dried to a solid cake and then milled into a fine powder, they become far easier to aerosolize, yet the drying and milling process is technically difficult. The Aum Shinrikyo cult struggled with dissemination (67, 69, 70). In one of its anthrax dissemination attempts, it sprayed unknown, but probably very large, quantities of a liquid aerosol (most likely crude culture, unprocessed in any way) of B. anthracis from the roof of the Aum’s headquarters building in Tokyo. For the dissemination, the Aum set up two sprayers on the roof of the eight-story building, each within a large round cooling tower. Pipes were extended from the cooling towers to tanks below, which were filled with a liquid suspension of B. anthracis. The device worked poorly, producing large droplets rather than the very fine aerosol needed for effective transmission of anthrax. It also appears the spore concentration was very low (at least five orders of magnitude below that necessary for a highly infectious wet aerosol). In another dissemination attempt, targeting the area around the Kanagawa prefectural office and the Imperial Palace, the Aum equipped vehicles with spraying devices, but according to prosecutors’ statements, the nozzle of the sprayer clogged and the operation failed. Despite its 200 m2 laboratory containing, amongst other equipment, a glove box, incubator, centrifuge, drier, DNA/RNA synthesizer, electron microscope, two fermenters each having about a 2,000 litre capacity, and an extensive scientific library, and despite its repeated attempts at dissemination, the Aum was unsuccessful in causing any disease, and in retrospect it is clear that the cult did not even make the first substantive step toward an effective bioweapon. If, despite the odds, aerosolization was achieved, the effective delivery of biological agents in the open air is highly dependent on atmospheric and wind conditions, creating additional uncertainties. Only under highly stable atmospheric conditions would the aerosol cloud remain close to the ground where it can be inhaled, rather than being rapidly dispersed. Moreover, most microorganisms are sensitive to ultraviolet radiation and cannot survive more than 30 min in bright sunlight, limiting their use to night-time attacks. One major exception is anthrax, which can be induced to form spores with tough outer coats that enable them to survive for several hours in sunlight. Terrorists could, of course, stage a biological attack inside an enclosed space such as a building, a subway station, a shopping mall, or a sports arena. Such an attack, if it involved a respiratory aerosol, might infect thousands of people, but even here the technical hurdles would by no means be trivial.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › No Bioterror !

Biological weapon attacks are too complex – even with large-scale funding, access to information, and gene-editing tools – terrorists will choose not to pursue or will likely fail.

Revill ’17 [Dr. James Revill, Research Fellow with the Harvard Sussex Program at SPRU, Past as Prologue? The Risk of Adoption of Chemical and Biological Weapons by Non-State Actors in the EU, European Journal of Risk Regulation, 8 (2017), pp. 626–642, https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/6B824CDE0E25FD86AC3D0BD07822A743/S1867299X17000356a.pdf/div-class-title-past-as-prologue-the-risk-of-adoption-of-chemical-and-biological-weapons-by-non-state-actors-in-the-eu-div.pdf]

The second factor is “the perceived complexity of the innovation in terms of adoption and use”.40 This is important in the innovation literature, as Rogers remarked, “[t]he complexity of an innovation, as perceived by members of a social system, is negatively related to its rate of adoption”.41 Several scholars of terrorist innovation have also highlighted the issue of complexity;42 or, as Cragin et al have stated, “[h]ow simple or complex a technology appears affects perceptions of how risky it will be to adopt.”43 In most cases terrorist groups appear to have largely opted for the simplest pathway towards the achievement of their goals and the weapons used tend to be vernacular, functional devices drawing on local and readily-available materials, rather than sophisticated, “baroque” technologies. This is certainly the case with IEDs, the history of which is characterised largely by incremental innovations – although nevertheless frequently effective ones – with many means of delivery recycled from the past.44 Complexity can therefore be seen as important in the adoption of technology by terrorists generally, but is perhaps particularly acute in the case of CBW technology. Some CBW can be relatively simple: “chlorine-augmented, vehicle-borne IEDs,” as employed by Al-Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) from 2006 to 2007 are not sophisticated weapons.45 Attacks on chemical production facilities, an apparent tactic of Serbian forces in the early to mid-1990s,46 employed relatively simple technologies – specifically explosives – with toxicity a secondary by-product. Direct contamination of food,47 drink48 or healthcare products49 does not require particularly sophisticated technology for the purposes of delivery – although may require some considerable skill to culture and scale-up a biological agent – and has been a common approach in European CBW incidents.50 Similarly, the contamination of water systems, something familiar to Europe,51 can also be relatively easily attempted. However, in most cases such methods of dissemination have generated results that are far short of the “mass destruction” that CBW are associated with, although this does not mean such a possibility can be ignored by those working on public health preparedness. Although some relatively simple approaches could cause significant harm, mass casualty attacks still require considerable expertise, something particularly acute in the context of biological weapons.52 The most effective route to weaponising biology is arguably through the process of aerosolising agents, something recognised mid-way through the last century as opening up the theoretical possibility of using biological weapons on a gigantic scale.53 However, realising such theoretical potential is difficult and it took states decades to develop more predictable biological weapons,54 and even then such weapons were acutely vulnerable to environmental factors.55 For non-state groups such complexity has proven a significant barrier to CBW development. By means of an example, one of the best-resourced biological weapons programs, that of Aum Shinrikyo, failed variously because the group acquired the wrong strain, contaminated fermenters and were faced with insurmountable production and dissemination difficulties.56 There are of course exceptions, such as the 2001 anthrax Letter Attacks in the US. However, if one accepts the conclusions of the FBI that this sophisticated attack with aerosolised anthrax in the US postal system was perpetrated by a US biodefence researcher, Dr Bruce Ivins,57 it is an exception that proves the rule. To circumvent the difficulties with aerosolisation, arguably one could use human-to-human transmissible biological agents as part of a suicide bioterror operation. There are good reasons for concern over how crude suicide bioterrorists could employ such a tactic. However, the use of highly contagious agents is also poorly predictable and would have to deal with social factors, such as the “spatial contact process among individuals”, which can spell “out the difference between large-scale epidemics and abortive ones”.58 The counter to this argument is the growing access to data and the changing human geography of the life sciences. Some 83% of European households reportedly are online, effectively allowing access to what is a growing body of available data on CBW, including so-called bioterrorist “recipes” and “blueprints” that are available in both mainstream scientific as well as more subversive literatures online. It is also clear that there is a changing human geography in European life sciences (for peaceful purposes), with the emergence of 30 DIY-bio groups located in Europe59 and some 80 European teams in the international Genetically Engineered Machines (IGEM) competition in 2016.60 This is compounded by reports that groups such as Daesh have deliberately sought to recruit foreign fighters “including some with degrees in physics, chemistry, and computer science, who experts believe have the ability to manufacture lethal weapons from raw substances”.61 Whilst it would be unwise to ignore such developments, there is a need for caution in looking at the extent to which new technologies and geographies will facilitate the adoption of chemical and biological weapons by groups seeking to target European countries. First, data is not information, and information is not knowledge, let alone the tacit knowledge required for CBW.62 In many cases a degree of determination and dedication will be required merely to separate online fantasy from fact and identify operationally useful information (of relevance to the European context) from nonsense (or information pertinent to contexts other than Europe). Second, with new technologies there is the potential for such tools to enable some, but certainly not all, actors, and even then new technologies bring new challenges. CRISPR, gene editing technology is currently seen as a particular source of promise and peril, which purportedly enables “even largely untrained people to manipulate the very essence of life”.63 As much may be technically true, yet “untrained people” would nonetheless require some guidance in identifying suitable areas of genetic structures to manipulate. Moreover, CRISPR would only get aspiring weaponeers so far, with the process of culturing, scaling-up and weaponisation still requiring considerable attention and interdisciplinary skills, typically generated through “large interdisciplinary teams of scientists, engineers, and technicians”,64 in order to be effective. Indeed, for all the progress in science and technology, biological weapons are still not used, in part, because of the complexity of such weapons; and the chemical weapons that are used today are largely the same as the chemical weapons of 100 years ago. As Robinson noted “It remains the case today that, in the design of CBW, increasingly severe technological constraint sets in as the mass-destruction end of the spectrum is approached: the greater and more assured the area-effectiveness sought for the weapon, the greater the practical difficulties of achieving it”.65

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › Turn – Private Equity - !

PE exits continue to decline. Any disruption to the market risks a collapse.

Sraders 23 (Anne Sraders, Senior writer for Fortune covering the finance industry, venture capital, startups, fintech, and cryptocurrency, “Private equity had a pretty resilient Q1, but the ‘risk is this is the best quarter of the year’”, Yahoo! Finance, 4/20/2023, https://finance.yahoo.com/news/private-equity-had-pretty-resilient-104141359.html?guccounter=1) VQ

However, exits—when private equity investors cash in on their investment and return those funds to their limited partners—continue to fall as the IPO window remains shut and many private equity firms are hesitant to sell companies at low valuations. Per the PitchBook report, U.S. PE exit count and value both declined for the third consecutive quarter in Q1. “The biggest worry is…you're way down on exits,” says Clarke, and every quarter “is another quarter of very little cash flow coming back [to LPs].” He believes the industry “has to find a third avenue for creating liquidity—I mean, you either bring a company public, or you sell it to a larger player.” Clarke points out that public PE firms are talking about other strategies on their earnings calls, including the secondary market. But Clarke says that the gap between net buying versus selling in PE has widened. “Eventually that feeds into fundraising and that feeds into performance if you don't solve this. The risk is that this is the best quarter of the year, and fundraising starts stepping down from this point,” Clarke warns. In other words, if PE firms can’t exit more of their investments and return cash back to their investors, who can then feed it back into the system, “they don't have a lot of time before...that fundraising starts to shut down like it did on the venture capital side.”

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › Turn – Private Equity - !

Private equity is key for growth

Barber and Goold 07 [Felix Barber and Michael Goold, Felix Barber is a director of the Ashridge Strategic Management Centre at Hult International Business School and a coauthor and Michael Goold is a founding director of the Ashridge Strategic Management Centre and a coauthor, “The Strategic Secret of Private Equity,” Harvard Business Review, 09-2007, ] [ST]

Private equity. The very term continues to evoke admiration, envy, and—in the hearts of many public company CEOs—fear. In recent years, private equity firms have pocketed huge—and controversial—sums, while stalking ever larger acquisition targets. Indeed, the global value of private equity buyouts bigger than $1 billion grew from $28 billion in 2000 to $502 billion in 2006, according to Dealogic, a firm that tracks acquisitions. Despite the private equity environment’s becoming more challenging amid rising interest rates and greater government scrutiny, that figure reached $501 billion in just the first half of 2007. Private equity firms’ reputation for dramatically increasing the value of their investments has helped fuel this growth. Their ability to achieve high returns is typically attributed to a number of factors: high-powered incentives both for private equity portfolio managers and for the operating managers of businesses in the portfolio; the aggressive use of debt, which provides financing and tax advantages; a determined focus on cash flow and margin improvement; and freedom from restrictive public company regulations. But the fundamental reason behind private equity’s growth and high rates of return is something that has received little attention, perhaps because it’s so obvious: the firms’ standard practice of buying businesses and then, after steering them through a transition of rapid performance improvement, selling them. That strategy, which embodies a combination of business and investment-portfolio management, is at the core of private equity’s success. Public companies—which invariably acquire businesses with the intention of holding on to them and integrating them into their operations—can profitably learn or borrow from this buy-to-sell approach. To do so, they first need to understand just how private equity firms employ it so effectively. The Private Equity Sweet Spot Clearly, buying to sell can’t be an all-purpose strategy for public companies to adopt. It doesn’t make sense when an acquired business will benefit from important synergies with the buyer’s existing portfolio of businesses. It certainly isn’t the way for a company to profit from an acquisition whose main appeal is its prospects for long-term organic growth. However, as private equity firms have shown, the strategy is ideally suited when, in order to realize a onetime, short- to medium-term value-creation opportunity, buyers must take outright ownership and control. Such an opportunity most often arises when a business hasn’t been aggressively managed and so is underperforming. It can also be found with businesses that are undervalued because their potential isn’t readily apparent. In those cases, once the changes necessary to achieve the uplift in value have been made—usually over a period of two to six years—it makes sense for the owner to sell the business and move on to new opportunities. (In fact, private equity firms are obligated to eventually dispose of the businesses; see the sidebar “How Private Equity Works: A Primer.”). The benefits of buying to sell in such situations are plain—though, again, often overlooked. Consider an acquisition that quickly increases in value—generating an annual investor return of, say, 25% a year for the first three years—but subsequently earns a more modest if still healthy return of, say, 12% a year. A private equity firm that, following a buy-to-sell strategy, sells it after three years will garner a 25% annual return. A diversified public company that achieves identical operational performance with the acquired business—but, as is typical, has bought it as a long-term investment—will earn a return that gets closer to 12% the longer it owns the business. For the public company, holding on to the business once the value-creating changes have been made dilutes the final return. In the early years of the current buyout boom, private equity firms prospered mainly by acquiring the noncore business units of large public companies. Under their previous owners, those businesses had often suffered from neglect, unsuitable performance targets, or other constraints. Even if well managed, such businesses may have lacked an independent track record because the parent company had integrated their operations with those of other units, making the businesses hard to value. Sales by public companies of unwanted business units were the most important category of large private equity buyouts until 2004, according to Dealogic, and the leading firms’ widely admired history of high investment returns comes largely from acquisitions of this type. More recently, private equity firms—aiming for greater growth—have shifted their attention to the acquisition of entire public companies.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › Turn – Private Equity - !

Private Equity Firms are the driving force behind innovation and job creation, and help the government develop critical infrastructure assets and climate solutions

Capolaghi & Labye 3-15 (Laurent Capolaghi is a member of the Board of Directors and Treasurer of the Inclusive Finance Network Luxembourg, Renaud Labye has a master’s degree in applied economics from the Louvain-La-Neuve School of Business, “Why is private equity the driving force behind innovation and job creation in Europe, and Luxembourg?,” Ernst & Young, March 15, 2023, ) LAB

Innovation: Start-ups and SMEs, especially those active in the technology and digital industries, are the innovation and growth engine of the European – and even worldwide – economy. By offering the financing and assistance needed to enable companies to realize their full potential – by focusing on skill development, training and mentorship in order to boost creativity – PE investments directly contribute to the innovation capacity of our economy. Today, it is estimated that 25,000 companies in Europe are backed by private equity, with 17,800 of these being SMEs3. Talent: The primary influence of PE is likely to be seen in the realm of employment. The employment rate is a key indicator of the health of an economy, and creating jobs is crucial for the wellbeing of society. PE firms invest in companies to promote growth, which in turn leads to job creation. In fact, a recent study from Invest Europe4 showed that PE-owned companies in Europe created 103 566 jobs in 2020, corresponding to a net increase of 2%, while the European job market, as a whole, contracted by 1,6%. Furthermore, today, PE-owned companies employ 10 million people in Europe, representing more than 4,3% of the total workforce. Increased capital access: Private equity firms typically have access to large amounts of capital (also known as “dry powder”) that might otherwise be unavailable from conventional sources, such as banks, that they can use to finance businesses. This is particularly critical for smaller businesses or those in fields which are considered risky by conventional investors. Additionally, PE firms are less strict than banks in terms of repayment terms or covenants, and provide companies more flexibility to cash back their investments, which is extremely welcomed by companies in launching phase. Infrastructure development: All over the world, keeping pace with demographic changes and the expectations and behaviours of citizens has become increasingly challenging. Linked to this, governments face growing difficulties to finance the construction or maintenance of infrastructure projects aligned with demographic/citizen trends. More and more, we see private equity companies partner with governments to build and develop critical infrastructure assets, such as roads, airports, utilities, as well as infrastructure which encourages sustainability – the latter a reflection of how PE can direct capital to positively impact societies. Social impact: PE firms are playing a growing role as a facilitator for sustainable investments, responding to ESG (environmental, social and governance) criteria. They push the companies they invest in to adopt socially responsible behaviors, and also provide resources and expertise to businesses seeking climate change solutions and firms focusing on increasing access to healthcare and education in marginalized regions. To illustrate this ESG trend and success, as at the end of 2020, sustainable investment products accounted for 11% of total net assets domiciled in Europe, more than doubling in net assets since 2018. In 2020, sustainable funds also attracted over half of the net new money invested in the investment fund market5. Financial performance: While not all PE funds are profitable (a recurring figure suggests that between 83 and 90% are profitable), data analysis and studies have shown that the investment performance of PE funds outperforms investment yields of listed companies over short, medium and long-term horizons. Indeed, the average internal rate of return for PE investments is, when looking at historical data – 30 years of PE existence – for Europe, around 15% when the overall economy was around 6-7%6. This outperformance is even bigger when looking at more recent years, probably driven by the growing experience and expertise of PE managers.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Health Care Adv › Turn – Private Equity - !

Private Equity investments in healthcare increase innovations and accessibility while greatly benefiting doctors.

Kroin and Simons 23 (Micheal Kroin, CEO & Managing Partner at Physician Growth Partners, Ezra Simons, Managing Partner at Physician Growth Partners, “Industry Voices—Private equity investment in healthcare is making a positive impact … especially for doctors”, Fierce Healthcare, April 28, 23, https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/finance/industry-voices-private-equity-investment-healthcare-making-positive-impact-especially) VQ

The last 10 years have been a time of tremendous change in U.S. healthcare. One of the key drivers of this change has been growing investment from private equity into both larger healthcare companies and, more recently, into specialty medical practices. Although this activity is reported on and sometimes scrutinized, less often is any focus given to the positive impact that this inflow of capital has had, both for doctors and patients. According to public reports, private equity acquisitions of healthcare-related businesses have risen from an estimated annual deal value of $41.5 billion in 2010 to more than $200 billion in 2021. PE firms have pumped more than $750 billion into U.S. healthcare during the past 10 years and this money has had an impact. These funds have helped unlock lifesaving treatments, such as mRNA vaccinations, helped to level the playing field between doctors and payers and created thousands of new jobs by funding research and development in the life sciences and expanded care in medical practices. Copious data on private equity’s healthcare investments has been compiled by the Washington, DC-based American Investment Council, and the venture capital/private equity research site, PitchBook. The numbers tell a compelling story. Since 2012 private equity funds both large and small have invested $280 billion in more than 1,800 life sciences and medical devices businesses. More than 250 deals in 2020 plowed private equity money into outpatient clinics, ambulatory surgery centers and urgent care centers. All this has expanded access to care, funded new technologies, and made healthcare businesses more efficient by eliminating duplicative administration costs. Even America’s Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), the lobbying group for insurance payers, acknowledges in a recent report, that private equity firms consolidate smaller healthcare entities to increase their market power and leverage in setting reimbursement rates with payers. AHIP regards this as a bad thing, pushing for federal scrutiny of even the smallest transactions, and portraying physician practice mergers as a threat to care. In fact, the main threat these practice mergers represent is to the massive profits of healthcare payers like the ones AHIP represents. Dr. Matthew Zimm, a Pennsylvania ophthalmologist who concluded a private equity partnership in 2022, said the benefits for a practice like his were clear. “In the end, this is an individual decision. It is not for everyone, but trends in the healthcare market suggest that private independent practices are not the future. Doctors faced with the increasing complexity of practice have the choice to join a health system or work with a Managed Services Organization (MSO). My peers have had way better experiences working this way (with an MSO) and so far I am also.” Even payers recognize the benefit of consolidating healthcare delivery businesses for greater efficiency. In 2011, UnitedHealth Group, one of America’s largest health insurance companies, created Optum. It is a subsidiary that provides pharmacy services and healthcare delivery. In the past 10 years, this UHC-Optum model of vertically integrated payer and care has sparked a pattern of healthcare acquisitions resulting in transactions fusing Aetna and CVS, Cigna and Express Scripts, and Humana with Kindred. Surely these megamergers would not occur if there was no value to be gained in this kind of consolidation. And research suggests that the benefit is not limited to strengthening the financial leverage of the practice. A September 2022 JAMA Health Forum investigation compared 578 private equity-acquired dermatology, gastroenterology and ophthalmology physician practices with more than 2,800 similar independent practices. The study found from 2016 to 2020 that internal spending (such as on new equipment), reimbursement, new and unique patient volume and total patient encounters all increased substantially at the private equity-acquired practices. This suggests that PE-owned practices were more profitable but also more accessible, providing increased care and choice for patients. Clearly, private equity investment in healthcare practices is having an impact on patients and payers, but what about the physicians? During the pandemic, the media has been filled with stories of healthcare workers that are stressed and struggling. Research bears this out. According to a Medscape annual survey of more than 12,000 U.S. physicians, before COVID-19 in 2020 a total of 69% of doctors reported being “largely happy at work.” However, in the 2021 report, only 49% expressed happiness with their work environment. There are three key benefits to medical practices attracting private equity investment: better technology, expanded facilities and economies of scale offering more leverage when dealing with vendors and payers. The doctors that Physician Growth Partners represent are partnering with an organization for the rest of their careers—not in search of a quick buck. All are focused on maintaining excellent patient care—delivered in a way that preserves doctors’ voices, decision making and patient scheduling. Take Dr. Zimm as an example. He had spent nearly 15 years building a strong eye care and cataract surgery practice in Northwest Pennsylvania. A third-generation doctor, he had a better understanding than most of how to successfully run a practice. Still, Dr. Zimm recognized that he had done as much as he could on his own. “The administrative burdens of being a doctor get bigger every year. Insurance companies put roadblocks in our way when we are trying to focus on the patient. Hiring, firing, contracts, negotiating with suppliers. The level of bureaucracy we deal with now is ridiculous. My grandfather started practicing in the 1950s and what he had to do compared to now . . . well, it’s a whole new ballgame.” Working with a transaction advisory firm, Dr. Zimm negotiated a partnership with Sunvera Group, a Michigan-based eye care platform that is a unit of Ridgemont Equity Partners. “I think the wave of the future is to have doctors dealing with the patient while leaving the back-office work to professionals that specialize in that. Just a short time into our partnership we are already seeing the structures that Sunvera has in place that are making the transition easier. Wheels are turning to help us learn about how to build and grow the practice with input from me.” Getting access to new technology so they can offer new capabilities and services is very important to most doctors, and especially those who work in demanding specialties like cardiology or urology. New technologies and techniques can lead to better patient care, improved outcomes and professional growth for physicians. However, doctors often aren’t willing or able to invest $500,000 or more in the latest equipment. Private equity capital makes these advances possible. Another benefit of private equity investment is the opportunity to expand care into new and underserved areas. Orthopaedic Specialists of Austin (OSA), a Texas-based clinic with seven physician shareholders and three locations, sought out an arrangement with Growth Ortho, a PE-backed platform that was building out in several different regions. OSA specifically wanted a partner that could expand its ability to care for the greater Austin community while offering clinical autonomy and the opportunity to move into other markets in Central Texas. Now, nearly six months after the transaction closed, they are pursuing a strategy of provider recruitment, de novo geographic expansion and seeking opportunities for additional practice acquisitions throughout the state. Gaining economies of scale is another key benefit when private equity investment is considered. This happens with the kinds of administrative and operational support that many private equity firms excel at implementing. For example, a consolidated back-office group can help a practice bill more efficiently and completely for the services provided, secure lower costs on supplies, and eliminate duplicative paperwork. Dr. Zimm cited the drive for efficiency as a major motivation for his decision to link up with a private equity-backed platform. “There is a massive shortage of ophthalmologists in the U.S. It’s estimated that the country will be 5,000 or 6,000 short by 2030. We must work smarter with what we have. Over the years my team and I have built our clinic to focus on great results, but it means we also must focus on new technology and fight for surgical time. There are massive administrative demands on us and that’s where I saw we really needed to get help if we are going to stay at the forefront with our practice.” Private equity investment can provide medical practices and specialty groups with more leverage to negotiate with hospitals and insurance payers, both of which have historically held much greater bargaining power. With more business strength and operational efficiency backing them up, doctors can maintain their focus on patient care and perhaps be more satisfied in their work as a result. All of these factors show that private equity investment in healthcare practices can drive better working conditions for doctors while helping them improve patient care and offer more advanced services.