2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › PC Key---2NC
Meredith Lee Hill 5-10. "Biden invites lawmakers to White House to discuss farm bill amid looming debt limit crisis ". POLITICO. 5-10-2023. https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/10/biden-farm-bill-debt-limits-00096190
President Joe Biden is wading into the high-stakes negotiations over the farm bill, amid growing concerns the debt limit stand-off could knock that must-pass piece of legislation off track.
Biden has invited a small, bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House Thursday to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization, according to four people familiar with the plans who were granted anonymity to discuss internal conversations. Congress is aiming to write and pass what is expected to be a $1 trillion-plus bill, which will authorize U.S. food and agriculture spending for the next decade, by this fall. But even senior Senate Republicans are increasingly wary that the mounting debt crisis could derail the traditionally bipartisan farm bill.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: Delay---2NC
Kaaltv 6-5. "Farmers voice their opinions on Farm Bill". ABC 6 News - kaaltv. 6-5-2023. https://www.kaaltv.com/news/top-news/farmers-voice-their-opinions-on-farm-bill/
Monday, U.S. Congressman Brad Finstad’s team held the first of 21 listening sessions in district one, in Dodge Center. Their goal is to learn what farmers like in the Farm Bill and ways Congress can improve it.
Even before the listening session started, district outreach representative, Keith Allen, was shooting the brave with farmers in attendance. He says that early findings show that farmers are generally happy with the bill.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: Delay---2NC
Ximena Bustillo 2-2. "Congress gears up for another farm bill. Here's what's on the menu". NPR. 2-2-2023. https://www.npr.org/2023/02/02/1151727273/congress-gears-up-for-another-farm-bill-heres-whats-on-the-menu
Lawmakers drank thick milkshakes brought to them by the Pennsylvania Dairymen's Association as they listened to farmers, ranchers and community leaders from around the state talk about their needs and wants for the 2023 farm bill.
The Pennsylvania Farm Show in Harrisburg served as the perfect curtain opener for House Agriculture Committee Chair GT Thompson to begin discussions on the measure that funds many parts of the American food supply chain and rural development.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: UQ Overwhelms---2NC
Jonathan Ahl 22. Reporter. "A new, divided Congress will have to take on a new Farm Bill with far-reaching effects ". Iowa Public Radio. 11-28-2022. https://www.iowapublicradio.org/ipr-news/2022-11-28/a-new-divided-congress-will-have-to-take-on-a-new-farm-bill-with-far-reaching-effects
The Congress that takes office next year will feature a Senate with a narrow Democratic majority and a House that, so far, has a slim Republican majority. What’s not clear is how that split in control will affect one of the biggest pieces of legislation on the agenda next year: the Farm Bill.
The massive piece of legislation (the 2018 version cost $428 billion dollars) includes everything from how farmers are protected in case of crop losses, SNAP benefits for the food insecure, and policy on environmental and land use issues.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: SNAP fights---2NC
Chris Clayton 23. DTN Ag Policy Editor, . "How the House Debt Ceiling Battle Spills into Plans for the Next Farm Bill". DTN Progressive Farmer. 4-25-2023. https://www.dtnpf.com/agriculture/web/ag/news/article/2023/04/25/house-debt-ceiling-battle-spills
Asked if Democrats would agree to some deal to tighten work requirements for SNAP, Costa said, "Well, the Speaker is attempting with his Republican colleagues to attach their Christmas list to the lifting of the debt ceiling."
Costa noted the arguments over finding ways to tighten eligibility for SNAP don't go away. "For those of you who have been in the reauthorization of the farm bill, this is always an issue and a debate we have every five years," he said.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: SNAP fights---2NC
Paul Yeager 6-2. With David Miller. "Market To Market - June 2, 2023". Iowa Pbs. 6-2-2023. https://www.iowapbs.org/shows/mtom/episode/9795/market-market-june-2-2023
Tom Sell is co-founder of Combest, Sell and Associates, a Washington D.C. - based lobbying firm specializing in agricultural issues. Sell believes the bipartisan history of the Farm Bill appears to be alive and well.
Tom Sell/Co-Founder Combast, Sell and Associates: “So now with that taken care of in this debt ceiling deal, I'm hopeful that it just creates this wake or a little pathway for the Farm Bill to go through where we're really going to focus on the farm safety net. That's, that's kind of where the leaders on both sides have said they want to, they want to build consensus.”
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › AT: Thumper---Budget---2NC
Jerry Hagstrom 23. "Thompson: Finish farm bill this year". The Hagstrom Report. 5-18-2023. https://www.thefencepost.com/news/thompson-finish-farm-bill-this-year/
Thompson said the fact that 42 million individuals are on the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program shows that families are struggling amid the high cost of gasoline and food.
Thompson said he believes the debt ceiling issue will be resolved. He added that he finds the June 1 deadline helpful, and after that Congress will have four months to write the farm bill against the deadline of the expiration of the current law. He said he has “complete confidence” in House Budget Committee Chairman Jodey Arrington, R-Texas, to come up with a budget.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › Will Pass---2NC
Noah Wicks & Philip Brasher 5-31. "House passes bill to increase debt limit, modify SNAP rules". AgriPulse. 5-31-2023. https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/19497-house-passes-bill-to-increase-debt-limit-modify-snap-rules
Leaders of the Senate and House Agriculture committees say the bill effectively removes a key barrier to passing a new farm bill by taking the issue of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program work requirements off the table.
The bill would increase the maximum age for SNAP work requirements from 49 to 54, but also add exemptions for the homeless, veterans and young people under 24 who have left the foster care system. The Congressional Budget Office estimates 78,000 people will gain benefits in an average month due to the new SNAP exemptions, which more than offset the impact of the increased age limit.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › Will Pass---2NC
USMEF 5-30. U.S. Meat Export Federation."Trade needs to be a higher priority in next farm bill". Beef Magazine. 5-30-2023. https://www.beefmagazine.com/news/trade-needs-be-higher-priority-next-farm-bill
With the current farm bill set to expire Sept. 30, Peterson said a one-year extension is likely. But he noted that if work requirements for those receiving nutrition assistance are included in negotiations on raising the debt ceiling, this could help accelerate the farm bill debate.
"And I think if that gets handled in the debt ceiling, however they handle it, and people get a chance to vote on it, that's probably the most important thing that could happen to help get the farm bill passed," he explained.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › Will Pass---2NC
Allura Leggard 5-24. "Sen. Schumer pushes for passing of Farm Bill to help farmers and consumers save money". WSTM. 5-24-2023. https://cnycentral.com/news/local/sen-schumer-pushes-for-passing-of-farm-bill-to-help-farmers-and-consumers-save-money
AUBURN, N.Y. — The 2018 Farm Bill will expire in September 2023, and dairy farmers and consumers have started to worry about how this can negatively impact them if the bill doesn’t pass.
Sen. Chuck Schumer (NY-D) was in Auburn Wednesday morning and said the passing of this bill is major.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › Will Pass---2NC
Kellan Heavican 6-5. "NCGA expects on-time farm bill with debt ceiling raised". Brownfield Ag News. 6-5-2023. https://brownfieldagnews.com/news/ncga-expects-on-time-farm-bill-with-debt-ceiling-raised/
With Congress raising the debt ceiling, the National Corn Growers Association says that could clear the way for lawmakers to pass the 2023 Farm Bill on time.
President Tom Haag tells Brownfield leaders of the Senate and House Ag Committee know the clock is ticking. “They understand where they have to be and I think with this debt limit, they have the reinforcements to go a little bit faster with it and hopefully we can get it taken care of.”
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › Uniqueness---2NC/1NR › Will Pass---2NC
Eric Bohl 6-2. Staff writer for National Hog Farmer, your leading source of all hog- and slop-related news. "Debt ceiling deal may clear way for farm bill". National Hog Farmer. 6-2-2023. https://www.nationalhogfarmer.com/news/debt-ceiling-deal-may-clear-way-farm-bill
This week's bipartisan agreement to suspend the debt ceiling until 2025 in exchange for various spending reforms may directly impact the farm bill's chances this year. The bill, called the Fiscal Responsibility Act, made several eligibility changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP. Disagreement over these changes had been a major point of contention standing in the way of a farm bill reauthorization.
The agreement requires able-bodied SNAP beneficiaries without dependents up to age 54 to work or be in a work training program, an increase from the current maximum age of 49. It also added new exemptions to the work requirements for the homeless, veterans and people younger than 24 who were formerly in foster care. The changes are estimated to result in a net addition of about 78,000 new recipients.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › 1NC › Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC
Julian Cribb 22. Fellow of the Royal Society for the Arts, the Australian Academy of Technological Science (ATSE) and the Australian National University Emeritus Faculty, “How food can end wars, repair climate and restore the Earth”, https://juliancribb.blog/2022/05/25/how-food-can-end-wars-repair-climate-and-restore-the-earth/
Humans have fought over food and the means of producing it for 20,000 years, as rock art in Australia shows. Food, water and land scarcity are primary drivers in two thirds of modern conflicts today. Indeed, many people seem to have forgotten that the primary German war aim in World War II was to take farmland from the Soviets and put German farmers on it. It is very likely that controlling the Ukraine’s bountiful and reliable food bowl is among Putin’s main aims also. In the short run this is imposing hunger and even starvation on hundreds of millions of people far beyond Europe.
Spreading hunger in turn snowballs into government failures, civil wars and refugee tsunamis around the world – as it did in 2008 when a shortfall in Ukrainian grain exports led to revolutions in three Arab countries. Already, a third of a billion people – equal to the entire population of Europe – leave their homes each year, either as refugees or economic migrants, to seek better lives in countries which seem more stable and food secure. War will add to the flood.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › 1NC › Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC
Grace Yarrow 23. Editorial intern at The Hill. "How the farm bill could alleviate food insecurity fueled by Ukraine war". Hill. 5-25-2023. https://thehill.com/policy/international/4021371-how-the-farm-bill-could-alleviate-food-insecurity-fueled-by-ukraine-war/
The war raging in Ukraine has exacerbated food insecurity across the world — and food aid experts are looking to the 2023 farm bill for solutions.
Ukraine’s massive grain supplies typically feed 400 million people per year, but the war has “drastically cut supplies” and driven up food costs for consumers in rich and poor countries alike, according to the World Food Program (WFP).
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › 1NC › Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC
Richard Morrison 21. Senior fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, expert in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) theory, former managing editor at OpenMarket, B.A. in Government from Claremont McKenna College. "The Case Against a Universal Basic Income". Competitive Enterprise Institute. 7-3-2021. https://cei.org/opeds_articles/the-case-against-a-universal-basic-income/
That common sense approach to work and responsibility poses a big obstacle for any UBI proposal. Despite the UBI’s approval ratings when Americans are asked about it, actual legislation to implement it would be highly controversial. In the 1970s, presidents Richard Nixon and Jimmy Carter — who had famously divergent political views — both endorsed UBI proposals that went down to defeat when the public was confronted with the details.
Many recent UBI proposals have called for a new benefit to replace much, if not all, existing social welfare spending. This radical simplification, often called a “grand bargain,” would theoretically ally conservatives, who want to reform the system’s cost and complexity, with progressives, who want to avoid anyone “falling through the cracks” of the many different current programs. But anyone who thinks that such a bargain is likely has spent too much time in political theory seminars and not enough time on Capitol Hill.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › 1NC › Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC
Jim Wiesemeyer 5-11. Washington analyst for Pro Farmer, previously a Washington editor with Doane’s Agricultural Report and Washington editor and managing editor of the Washington Farmletter. "Lawmakers Meet with Biden to Discuss Farm Bill 2023". Drovers. 5-11-2023. https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/lawmakers-meet-biden-discuss-farm-bill-2023
President Biden invited a bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House this afternoon to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization. Invitees include Rep. G.T. Thompson (R-Pa.), Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.), Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.), Rep. David Scott (D-Ga.), and USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack.
Stabenow labeled the session as a chance to “have a broader discussion about the farm bill and all the implications for it,” and that it will show “we are working together in a bipartisan way.” She also noted it was a chance for both sides to share their priorities for the bill.
2023
ENDI
Disadvantage
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 › 1NC › Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC
Ian Kast 5-24. Writer for the Michigan Farm Bureau. "'We will get one' — Stabenow confident on farm bill, concerned about debt ceiling". Farm News Media. 5-24-2023. https://www.michiganfarmnews.com/stabenow-confident-on-farm-bill-concerned-about-debt-ceiling
Debate over the 2023 Farm Bill is in full swing as Congress considers raising the nation’s debt ceiling to avoid a default on the federal debt.
Despite the more-than-challenging circumstances, Senate Ag Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow is confident the farm bill will pass.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 2AC Case Cards---Growth Advantage › Entrepreneurship Key to Growth---XT
Jungsuk Kim et al., 22. Professor in the Department of Economics of Sejong University in the Republic of Korea, with Cynthia Castillejos-Petalcorin, Donghyun Park, Yothin Jinjarak, Pilipinas Quising, Shu Tian, August 2022. “Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth: A Cross-Section Empirical Analysis.” Asian Development Bank Background Paper. https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/institutional-document/826606/adou2022bp-entrepreneurship-economic-growth.pdf
Entrepreneurship, or the activity of starting and running a business, is a vital ingredient of economic growth and development. Entrepreneurs contribute greatly to innovation, and they are central to dynamic Schumpeterian competition and economic dynamism. Innovative entrepreneurs are the principal agents of the never-ending Schumpeterian process of new products, services, technologies, firms, and industries replacing existing products, services, technologies, firms, and industries. Fortune 100 is replete with new companies that are using new technologies to produce and sell new products. Just as Fortune 100 of 1970 is unrecognizable today, today’s Fortune 100 will be unrecognizable in 2070. Behind the constant emergence of new companies with new technologies and new products are visionary, game-changing, risk-taking entrepreneurs such as Steve Jobs who started Apple with his friends in the garage of a suburban California home. Competition forces even mundane, ordinary entrepreneurs such as street food vendors to innovate. Therefore, the contribution of entrepreneurship to the economy is not confined to transformational entrepreneurs.
Despite their significant contribution to innovation and economic growth, entrepreneurship was a relatively under-researched and under-appreciated. This is partly because of lack of data until recent years when the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) and other entrepreneurship databases were developed. At a broader level, the lack of research and appreciation reflects the innate difficulty of quantifying entrepreneurship and the factors which motivate entrepreneurs to become entrepreneurs. Further, entrepreneurship is difficult to explain as a rational endeavor because most new businesses fail. Becoming an entrepreneur thus requires irrational exuberance or optimism. Yet another possible reason for why economists tended to neglect entrepreneurship is its tremendous diversity. Entrepreneurs range from street food vendors to transformational innovators such as Elon Musk, making it difficult to clearly conceptualize entrepreneurship. While mundane entrepreneurs contribute a lot to the economy, game-changing entrepreneurs contribute disproportionately to innovation, productivity growth, and economic dynamism.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 2AC Case Cards---Growth Advantage › UBI Solves Innovation---XT
Jinhyo Joseph Yun et al. 19. Principal researcher at DGIST and a Professor at Open Innovation Academy of SOItmC, with KyungBae Park, Sung Duck Hahm, and Dongwook Kim. “Basic Income with High Open Innovation Dynamics: The Way to the Entrepreneurial State.” J. Open Innov. Technol. Mark. Complex. 2019, 5(3), 41; . https://www.mdpi.com/2199-8531/5/3/41
So, our meta-analysis suggests that basic income with three additional policy leverages would motivate open innovation dynamics.
5. Conclusions
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 2AC Case Cards---Growth Advantage › UBI Solves Entrepreneurship---XT
María-Teresa Aceytuno-Pérez et al. 23. Universidad de Huelva, Huelva, Spain, with Manuela A. de Paz-Báñez and Celia Sanchez-López, 4-27-23. “Assessing the Impact of the Implementation of Universal Basic Income on Entrepreneurship.” https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/bis-2022-0022/html
We argue that the implementation of UBI can be viewed as an external enabler that would dramatically change the environment of entrepreneurial activity and this would shape the process of venture creation, affecting both the individual perception of the opportunity and the capacity and decision to act upon it. Consequently, the effect of an UBI would not be limited to de-risking entrepreneurial activity, as has been posited before in the literature, but would be much broader. We consider that UBI shapes entrepreneurial action, arguably facilitating the decision to become an entrepreneur. Namely, we consider that the implementation of a UBI would affect the decision to become an entrepreneur at three different levels, increasing (i) its perceived desirability, (ii) its perceived feasibility, and (iii) the propensity to act and create a business venture. UBI would improve perceived desirability and feasibility of becoming entrepreneur, potentially increasing individuals’ propensity to develop entrepreneurial actions and facilitating it by the provision of seed capital.
The positive relationship between UBI and entrepreneurship found in the case of Alaska (Feinberg and Kuehn 2019) provides empirical support to the proposition that the implementation of UBI increases both firm entry and self-employment. The cases of India (Davala et al. 2015), Namibia (Haarman et al. 2019) and Ontario, Canada (McDowell and Ferdosi 2020, 2021) also support this finding. Other experiments, like that of Kenya, show no conclusive results on firm entry (Egger et al. 2019; Haushofer and Shapiro, 2016), whilst entrepreneurship remains unstudied in the remainder of the cases.