Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Job Guarantee Link Answers › Link Turn – Job Guarantee Manages Inflation

Non unique and turn – the Fed over-focuses on monetary policy to the detriment of jobs mandate – the plan’s job guarantee solves for negative effects on workers

Paul, Duke University Cook Center on Social Equity Postdoctoral associate, et al., 18

[Mark, William Darity Jr. is the Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African-American Studies and Economics and the Director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, Darrick Hamilton is Professor of Economics and Urban Policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics at the New School for Social Research, and Director of the Doctoral Program in Public and Urban Policy at The New School, 3-9-18, Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, “The Federal Jobs Guarantee—A Policy to Achieve Full Employment,” https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/3-9-18fe.pdf, p. 8accessed 6-24-23, ah]

Improving workers livelihoods as the Federal Reserve manages its dual mandate. As noted above, the Federal Reserve has a dual mandate—maximum employment and price stability. Through its use of monetary policy, the Federal Reserve plays a vital role in promoting full employment; however, monetary policy has proven insufficient for eliminating involuntary unemployment. Historically, the Federal Reserve has had a significant role in increasing unemployment as a result of combating any inflationary pressures that may exist in the economy. With a job guarantee policy in place, the Federal Reserve can conduct monetary policy without promoting rising levels of unemployment. In this scenario, the job guarantee program can maintain employment and consumption expenditures while the Federal Reserve employs monetary policy to reduce private investment in order to cool the economy. Thus, U.S. workers would be less vulnerable to the Federal Reserve not adhering to their responsibility of a dual mandate appropriately due to their cultural over-emphasis—a function of their close ties to the financial sector—on price stability.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Job Guarantee Link Answers › Link Turn – Job Guarantee Manages Inflation

Link Turn – Jobs guarantee serves as an inflation management tool.

Mejia, MIT Economics PhD student and Albrecht, International Center for Law & Economics Chief Economist, 22

[Jackson and Brian C., 5-23-22, Contemporary Economic Policy “On Price Stability with a Job Guarantee.” , access date: CC]

Indeed, MMT economists pitch the JG explicitly as an inflation management tool to replace the Phillips-curve-based non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) system employed by central banks today.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Job Guarantee Link Answers › Link Turn – Job Guarantee Dampens Inflation

A job guarantee dampens inflation through provision of public goods

Paul, Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity Postdoctoral Associate, et al., 18

[Mark, William Darity, Jr., Samuel DuBois Cook Professor of Public Policy, African and African-American Studies and Economics and the Director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, & Darrick Hamilton, Professor of Economics and Urban Policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and Department of Economics at the New School for Social Research, and Director of the Doctoral Program in Public and Urban Policy at The New School, 3/9/18, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “The Federal Job Guarantee - A Policy to Achieve Permanent Full Employment,” https://www.cbpp.org/research/full-employment/the-federal-job-guarantee-a-policy-to-achieve-permanent-full-employment#_ftn1, accessed 6/26/23, EP]

The provision of socially useful goods and services. During the Great Depression, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) were public employment programs designed to put Americans back to work. The programs were implemented near the height of the Great Depression, when the national unemployment rate reached 25 percent. These programs, implemented under the Roosevelt administration, provided goods and services that benefited all Americans by facilitating the logistics and technological expansion of our public infrastructure, including 650,000 miles of new or improved roads; 39,000 schools built, improved, or repaired; 4,000 new or improved utility plants; and 225,000 concerts performed. Under a job guarantee, even those who do not receive employment via the NIEC will likely benefit through the increased provision of public goods and socially desirable goods and services. Furthermore, the provision of productive goods and services will dampen inflationary concerns.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › AT – Wage Increases Cause Inflation

Schweitzer, Teamsters Senior Research Analyst & Khattar, Center for American Progress Director, 22

[Justin and Rose, 09-01-2022, Center for American Progress “Wages and Employment Do Not Have to Decline to Bring Down Inflation.” , access date: 6-24-2023, CC]

While economists traditionally worry about a wage-price spiral, there remains no evidence that wages are causing increases in inflation. Workers need pay raises after decades of stagnation, and simply put, wages and employment do not—and should not— have to decline to bring down inflation.

The nature of the U.S. economic system is such that any negative change in the economy is almost always going to hurt low-income people the most. Yet most of the people who say inflation needs to be addressed because it is hurting poor households only propose to address it by enacting policies that would disproportionately hurt those same poor households. The solution instead should be to continue using fiscal policy to focus support to struggling households, improve the economy’s productive capacity, create more resilient supply chains, and limit the profiteering of those at the top at the expense of everyone else. Corporations must invest more in their long-term sustainability through improved supply chain capabilities and conditions for workers rather than short-term profiteering.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › Employment Solves Economic Growth

High unemployment leads to recession.

Lu, Financial Writer of the Visual Capitalist financial writer, 23

[Marcus, 3-27-23, World Economic Forum, "Charted: The link between unemployment and recessions,", https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2023/03/charted-the-link-between-unemployment-and-recessions/ DOA – 6-26-23 DD]

The US labour market is currently strong and low unemployment is a classic sign of a strong economy, according to a financial expert.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › Employment Solves Economic Growth

Investment in employment drives growth – not consumption

Papola, Emergent Order Foundation Chief Executive Officer, 13

[John, 1-30-13, Forbes, "Think Consumption Is The 'Engine' Of Our Economy? Think Again.," https://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2013/01/30/think-consumption-is-the-engine-of-our-economy-think-again/?sh=3468d316497f, DOA 6-25-23, DD]

The historical record on economic growth conflicts with this consumption doctrine. Economic growth (booms) and declines (bust) have always been led by changes in business and durable goods investment, while final consumer goods spending has been relatively stable through the business cycle. Booms and busts in financial markets, heavy industry and housing have always been leading indicators of recession and recovery. The dot-com boom and bust, the Great Depression and our current crisis all exhibit the pattern.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › AT – Phillips Curve Links

Foster, Bankrate Senior U.S. Economy Reporter, 22

[Sarah ,01-07-2022, Bankrate.com “The Phillips curve, explained – and what it says about soaring inflation in the COVID economy” , access date: 6-24-2023, CC]

Economists for the past several years have been questioning the accuracy of the Phillips curve and whether it actually oversimplifies the U.S. economy.

The model has become “weaker and weaker and weaker to the point where it’s a faint heartbeat that you can hear now,” Powell said in his July 2019 congressional testimony.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › AT – Phillips Curve Links

Phillips Curve flawed – modern data doesn’t support

Tetrina, Forbes Contributor, 2022

[Kat, 8-31-22, Forbes, “Inflation and Unemployment,” https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/inflation-and-unemployment/, June 24 2023, ah]

Economists point out that the inverse relationship between inflation and unemployment was very clear in the 1950s and 1960s. However, the relationship between these two variables has been less clear over the past 20 years. Between 2012 and 2019, unemployment rates dropped. Inflation remained low, signaling that the relationship between inflation and unemployment, as reflected in the Phillips Curve, may not be as closely tied as previously thought.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Employment Link Answers › AT – Phillips Curve Links

No internal link – no causal relationship between higher wages and higher prices – Phillips Curve model flawed

Dorn, CATO Senior Fellow emeritus, 20

[James A., Winter 2020, CATO Institute, “The Phillips Curve: A Poor Guide for Monetary Policy,” https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/winter-2020/phillips-curve-poor-guide-monetary-policy, accessed 6-27-23, ah]

The real problem with the Phillips curve is not that it supposes that inflation and unemployment are related, especially in the short run, but that it misconstrues that relation as involving a direct causal influence of unemployment on inflation, and vice versa, when in fact it is changes in aggregate demand that cause changes in both unemployment and inflation. According to Mickey Levy, chief economist at Berenberg:

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › UBI Link Answers › No Link – Interest Rate Rise Would be Nominal

Babilla, University of Yaounde macroeconomist and Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model Specialist, 23

[Thierry U. KAME, Summer 2023, "Tax policy reform and universal basic income effectiveness in a currency union: Implications for long-term growth, inequality, and welfare," , Pages 11-12 DOA: 6-24-23 - DD]

This section examines how universal basic income evolves when the currency union faces the normalization of monetary policy due to the inflation crisis. The central bank aims to curb inflation increases by raising its policy rate. As Fig. 3 denotes, following a 1 percent increase in policy rate the elimination of oil subsidies rather than the increase in taxes on capital gains and corporate income effectively accelerates the central bank’s response to inflation. Intuitively, the nominal interest rate has to rise enough to contain rising inflation. This is not the case in the benchmark, where the nominal interest rate responses look similar to those for inflation, reflecting a huge share of oil subsidies in the consumer basket.

As the central bank deepens its monetary policy normalization, monetary policy becomes more aggressive and the nominal interest rate moves more than under the benchmark and the previous scenario relative to inflation, reflecting the elimination of oil subsidies in the consumer basket. In the presence of monetary policy normalization, the nominal interest rate jumps more than inflation and successfully secures the purchasing power of lower-income households. Since lower-income people consume more and save less, the normalization will trigger a slight increase in consumption, more so under the third policy than the second and first policy. Because lower-income households represent a large share of the population, an increase in lower income consumption will induce a reduction in inequality within the currency union, more so under universal basic income funded by the third fiscal policy than under UBI funded by the second and first fiscal policies. The important effect of the monetary policy normalization on inflation and consumption comes from the fact that, the universal basic income program is more effective in reducing income inequality, when it is funded by the total phasing-out of oil subsidies, rather than increases in tax on capital gains or tax on corporate income.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › UBI Link Answers › No Inflation Link

Mencinger, former Slovenian economic minister, 17

[Jože, 2017, Basic Income Studies, “Universal Basic Income & Helicopter Money”, 2017, vol. 12, issue 2, 8, ProQuest, accessed 6-24-23, DS]

As demonstrated above, the monetary policy transmission mechanism of ECB, which operates through inter-est rate channels has not been functioning despite the decline in interest rates to zero or even negative values. Realizing that, ECB in March 2015 finally turned to quantitative easing (QE) which is considered relatively successful in the USA and UK, thus in the countries with a rather different financial structure (Di Maggio, Kermani, & Palmer, 2016). The evidence so far indicates that the QE program launched by the ECB had little effect on GDP growth and no effect at all on inflation and inflationary expectations. Money has remained with the central banks despite negative interest rates and in the banks or has been migrating to the capital markets which increases the “value” of shares and inflates a new financial bubble. This seems to be a plausible conse- quence of fiscal policies imposing austerity and simultaneous bureaucratization of banking regulation which has accompanied increases of required capital/assets ratios.

Can the ECB do more to help ending stagnation? The traditional distinction between monetary and fiscal policies is theoretically clear; monetary policy manipulates interest rate and monetary base, fiscal policy controls taxation and government expenditures. Furthermore, monetary policy is considered to be efficient in preventing inflation while fiscal policy should be efficient in promoting economic recovery. However, actions of central banks have always been also “fiscal policy”, because their interventions alter the present value of future government principal and interest payments. Quantitative easing (QE) is actually not as exceptional and not much more “fiscal policy” than standard open market operations (OMO); in the QE case central banks only buy government and other bonds of longer duration than in the standard OMO case.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › UBI Link Answers › No Inflation Link

Education and entrepreneurship would offset UBI inflation

Merrill & Neves, University of Minho politics professors, 21 [Catarina; Roberto, 2021, Basic Income Studies, “Unconditional Basic Income and State as an Employer of Last Resort: A Reply to Alan Thomas,” Vol 16, Issue 2, ProQuest, accessed: 6-24-23, DS]

One of Alan Thomas’ main concerns with UBI is its effect on inflation, and consequently its diminished impact in improving the material conditions for the worst-off. On the one hand, a UBI would transfer spending power to those who are most likely to make use of it, namely the worst-off in society. However, considering UBI’s assumed negative effect on work participation, wages will have to rise to attract those who could otherwise live on a UBI. Employers will increase wages and push that through rising prices. Therefore, this inflationary tendency will largely cancel out the value of a UBI to the worst-off. This effect is shared by many as a potential drawback of implementing a UBI.

There are two critical assumptions that determine a view of UBI as “canceling itself out” through inflation: the first is the assumption of labor withdrawal. If workers when granted a UBI exit the labor market (particularly low skilled ones), employers will be forced to increase wages to attract them, leading to the inflation effect mentioned above. A second assumption, intricately linked to the first, is that this withdrawal from the labor market will also be accompanied by a lack of investment in the productive capacity of citizens. Therefore, it will not be possible to increase the production of goods and services, which alongside labor withdrawal reinforces inflation. These two arguments are the reason why economists tend to believe SELR is superior to UBI on macroeconomic terms. In Thomas’ article we can read: “Minsky’s general argument [is] that tax and transfer schemes, absent an independent commitment to full employment, are of their nature inflationary. Those who produce are taxed and that income is moved to those who do not produce goods or services for consumption” (Thomas, 2020, p. 18). And he adds: “A UBI proposal popularizes demand by shifting resources towards those more likely to consume and away from “excessive” savings. But unlike SELR proposal, it fails to balance this out by investing in the productive capacity of individuals and firms” (Thomas, 2020, p. 19). Despite Thomas’ compelling account of the superior nature of SELR in countering inflationary pressures, it seems that his account of the potential impacts of a UBI is once again too hasty.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › UBI Link Answers › Link Turn – UBI Deflationary

UBI is deflationary – Canada proves

UBI Works, Organization, 22

[UBI Works, 8-24-22, “Basic Income—Will It Cause Inflation?,” https://www.ubiworks.ca/blog/basic-income-inflation, accessed 6-26-23, ah]

We know that Basic Income works. There’s decades of evidence showing that it benefits our health, our economy, and our communities. But among some newcomers to Basic Income, there’s a false concern that it could cause inflation – a mistaken belief that building a guaranteed income floor for those who need it could somehow reduce the purchasing power of our dollars.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Generic Link Answers › No Link – Housing Key

Alt causes to inflation – housing key

Siegel, Washington Post Federal Reserve and economics reporter, 6-13-23

[Rachel 6/13/23, The Washington Post, “Inflation eased further in May but remains above normal levels” https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/06/13/cpi-inflation-fed-interest-rate/, 6/25/23, MR]

Housing costs continue to be a big driver of overall inflation. Rent rose 0.5 percent in May over the month before, only a minor improvement from a 0.6 percent increase in April. Rental costs were still up 8.7 percent from a year earlier.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Consumer Confidence Raising Spending

Optimism might be up via the Consumer Confidence Index, but actual spending isn’t

Adams, McKinsey Dallas partner, 6-22-23

[Christina, Kari Alldredge, and Andrew Pitakos, Christina Adams is a partner in McKinsey’s Dallas office, Kari Alldredge is a partner in the Minneapolis office, and Andrew Pitakos is the product manager for ConsumerWise and is based in the Chicago office, 6-22-23, McKinsey, “A monthly update on the state of the US consumer: June 2023,” https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/consumer-packaged-goods/our-insights/a-monthly-update-on-the-state-of-the-us-consumer#, 6-29-23, DS]

Optimism is trending upward—but spending isn’t. As noted in last month’s update, optimism ticked up among US consumers as the spring season began. (ConsumerWise data on consumer confidence are updated on a quarterly basis.) Yet despite this modest increase in optimism, consumers’ overall real year-over-year spending declined for the second month in a row, as the next chart shows.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › Investor Confidence Low

Inflation high now, business investment going down

Vanguard, 5-18-23

[Vanguard, 5-18-23, Vanguard, “Our investment and economic outlook, May 2023,” , accessed 6-29-23, DS]

With inflation still too high and the labor market still tight, we expect Federal Reserve policymakers to raise their target for short-term interest rates once more next month. In a change to our forecast, we expect that hike to be the last in a series that so far spans 10 meetings and 5 percentage points. We now see the Fed’s terminal rate in a range of 5.25%–5.5%, just a quarter of a percentage point higher than the current rate target. We also have raised our year-end inflation forecast and modified our labor market forecast.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › Economic Decline Coming

The US economy is declining and showing signs of a recession

Boskin, Stanford University Economics Professor, 6-29-23

[Michael, 6/29/23, Project Syndicate, “America’s Economy on the Edge,” , accessed 6/29/23, EP]

STANFORD – Most major economies are flirting with, or tipping into, recession. While Canada and Sweden appear to have just pulled themselves back from the brink, Germany, Europe’s largest economy, is already in a technical recession, following two consecutive quarters of negative growth.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Federal Reserve Won’t Raise Rates

Degen, Pensions & Investments Reporter, 6-28-23

[Paul, 6-28-23, Pensions & Investments “Powell says more rate hikes probably ahead, but recession unlikely” , access date: 6-29-23, CC]

"If you look at the data over the last quarter, what you see is stronger-than-expected growth, a tighter-than-expected labor market and higher-than-expected inflation," Mr. Powell added. "So that tells us that although policy is restrictive, it may not be restrictive enough, and it has not been restrictive for long enough."

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Federal Reserve Won’t Raise Rates

Wiseman, Associated Press Economics Reporter, 23

[Paul, 6-22-23, Associated Press “Fed’s Powell reinforces likelihood of more rate hikes because of persistently high inflation” , access date: 6-29-23, CC]

Chair Jerome Powell reiterated Thursday that the Federal Reserve will likely raise interest rates at least once more this year because of persistently high inflation in the economy’s service sector and the surprisingly tight job market.

Speaking to a Senate committee, Powell noted that “inflation has moderated somewhat since the middle of last year.” Still, the Fed chair stressed, “inflation pressures continue to run high.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Federal Reserve Won’t Raise Rates

Smialek, New York Times Federal Reserve and Economics Reporter, 6-22-23

[Jenna, 6-22-23, New York Times “Fed Chair Sees ‘Long Way to Go’ on Inflation Fight” , access date: 6-29-23, CC]

Jerome H. Powell, the chair of the Federal Reserve, told House lawmakers that the United States remains a “long way” away from low and stable inflation even 15 months into the central bank’s campaign to cool the economy and wrestle down rapid price increases.

Mr. Powell testified before the House Financial Services Committee on Wednesday. He told lawmakers that the labor market remained very tight and that inflation — while it has come down notably from its peak last summer — was still too fast. In light of that, the Fed could raise interest rates even higher than their current level of just above 5 percent.