2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Trump Wins - Polls
OSHIN, The Hill Breaking News Reporter, 6-27-23
(OLAFIMIHAN, 6-27-23, The Hill, Trump tops Biden for first time in Morning Consult poll. https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4070063-trump-tops-biden-for-first-time-in-new-poll/)
Former President Trump took a 3-point lead over President Biden among registered voters in a new survey in a hypothetical head-to-head match-up ahead of the 2024 presidential election.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Trump Wins - Polls
Ewan Palmer, Newsweek 7-4-23
(Ewan, 7-4-23, Newsweek, “Donald Trump Holds Big Lead Over Joe Biden in Swing States, Polls Show.” )
Trump has a significant lead over President Joe Biden in key swing states heading into the 2024 presidential election, according to a poll.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Trump Wins - Polls
PRNewswire 2-16-23
(JUNE HARVARD CAPS / HARRIS POLL: MAJORITY THINK CASE AGAINST TRUMP IS STRONG BUT INDICTMENT HAS NOT AFFECTED HIS SUPPORT. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/june-harvard-caps-harris-poll-194200424.html)
President Joe Biden's approval rating remains at 43% and Donald Trump continues to lead their 2024 matchup, by 6 points this month. The poll covers public opinion on the Trump federal indictment, electric vehicles and policy issues like parental rights. Download key results here.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Trump Wins - Polls
Greg Valliere 6-28-23
(Chief U.S. Policy Strategist. AGF Investments. Could Donald Trump Win Re-election? Plus, Fresh Kremlin Intrigue. https://perspectives.agf.com/could-donald-trump-win-re-election-plus-fresh-kremlin-intrigue/)
DONALD TRUMP IS IMMUNE TO BAD NEWS: Yesterday a tape was released with him seemingly showing top secret documents to guests at Mar-a-Lago; House Speaker Kevin McCarthy expressed reservations about supporting him; and now there’s a report that Rudy Giuliani may be seeking a plea deal.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Student Loans
Gans, The Hill Breaking News reporter, 7-14-23
(Jared, 7-14-23, Th Hill. “Biden administration announces $39 billion in student debt relief for 804,000 borrowers”. https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/4097236-biden-administration-announces-39-billion-in-student-debt-relief-for-804000-borrowers/)
The Biden administration has announced that it will provide $39 billion in total student debt relief for 804,000 borrowers, its latest step since President Biden’s student loan forgiveness plan was struck down by the Supreme Court. The Education Department said on Friday that the relief is being provided on income-driven repayment plans, in which the federal government cancels remaining balances for the borrower after they have made their payments for 20 or 25 years.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Climate Funding
Luna, LA Times, 6-19-23
(Taryn , Staff Writer. Covers Gov. Gavin Newsom and California politics in Sacramento. LA Times. Biden announces funding to combat climate change, raises campaign money, during swing through California. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-06-19/biden-funding-to-combat-climate-change-during-california-visit)
PALO ALTO — On his first trip to California since announcing his reelection campaign, President Biden on Monday announced $600 million in federal funding to fight the effects of climate change after touring a Northern California nature reserve with Gov. Gavin Newsom.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Elections Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-Unique – Immigration
Schoen, former President Clinton advisor & Stein, former Senator Clinton advisor, 7-13-23
(David & Andrew, 7-13-23, Senior adviser to Bill Clinton’s 1996 campaign, a White House adviser (1994-2000) and an adviser to Hillary Clinton’s 2000 US Senate campaign. How Biden risks losing in 2024 over failure to stop the migrant surge. https://nypost.com/2023/07/13/how-biden-risks-losing-in-2024-over-failure-to-stop-the-migrant-surge/)
Immigration is shaping up to be a major issue in the 2024 presidential campaign — and that’s bad news for President Biden’s re-election prospects.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Farm Bill Bad – Pesticides
Beyond Pesticides, 6-26-23
[Beyond Pesticides, 6-26-23, Beyond pesticides, “Congress Asked to Help Stop Ecosystem Collapse in the Farm Bill by Preserving Local Authority to Restrict Pesticides,” , accessed 7-12, DG]
The Farm Bill covers many areas—ranging from the supplemental nutritional assistance program (SNAP) to trade—and one provision that the pesticide industry would like to include is preemption of local authority to restrict pesticide use. This attack on local governance would undercut the local democratic process to protect public health and safety, especially important in the absence of adequate federal protection of the ecosystems that sustain life.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Farm Bill Bad – Worsens Climate Change
Williams, Sentient Media Reporter, 6-20-23
[Marlena, 6-20-23, Sentient Media, “What the 2023 Farm Bill Could Change for Animals and Farmers”, , Accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]
According to the Environmental Protection Agency, agriculture accounts for about 10 percent of all U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. While current EPA data shows that emissions in most other sectors have declined in recent years, agriculture-related emissions have increased by 7.2 percent since 1990. What’s more, animal agriculture is the single largest source of methane emissions in the United States. Though the Farm Bill’s Conservation Title aims to incentivize farmers to implement climate-friendly practices like crop diversification and hedgerows, the Bill is surprisingly flawed when it comes to addressing the impact of factory farming.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › AT – Farm Bill Solves Climate
Haiar, Nebraska Examiner reporter, 6-26-23
[Joshua, 6-26-23, Nebraska Examiner, “Farming Carbon: Farm Bill Presents Opportunity To Unite Farmers, Climate Activists”, , accessed 7-12-23, EH]
Bonnie said the Biden administration is using $300 million from the Inflation Reduction Act for research and initiatives to incentivize farmers to adopt soil health practices – like testing what soil health practices work best in different regions.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › AT – Farm Bill Solves Climate
Williams, Sentient Media Reporter, 6-20-23
[Marlena, 6-20-23, Sentient Media, “What the 2023 Farm Bill Could Change for Animals and Farmers”, , Accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]
In addition, the Farm Bill has traditionally been more or less silent on one of the simplest known ways to improve animal welfare and curb climate change: reducing meat consumption. Despite the fact that cutting the consumption of meat and other animal products could lead to serious reductions in annual greenhouse gas emissions, the Farm Bill has tended to favor overly-broad advice about “healthy eating” over the concrete diet solutions that could have a real impact on animals and the environment.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › AT – Farm Bill Solves Equity Impacts
Ayasi, UC Berkeley Global Justice Program Policy Analyst Ph.D. & Elsheikh, Othering and Belonging Institute Global Justice Program Director, 15
[Hossein, Elsadig, 10/28/15, Othering and Belonging Institute, “The US Farm Bill: Corporate Power and Structural Racialization in the US Food System,” , Accessed 7/12/2023, J.D.]
THE UNITED STATES FOOD SYSTEM AND THE OUTCOMES generated by the US Farm Bill are characterized by widespread social, economic, political, and environmental inequity. These outcomes are characteristic of a society that produces inequity in every domain—social, economic, political, and environmental.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › AT – Farm Bill Solves Migrant Workers
[Caitlyn, 6/21/23, Colorado Public Radio, “With shortage of local labor, farmers and advocates want Congress to create incentives for migrant farmworkers,” , Accessed 7/12/23, J.D.]
Coloradans are about to enjoy the bounty of the summer: Rocky Ford melons, Palisade peaches, and Olathe sweet corn.
But the farmers who grow that produce have a big problem. There just aren’t enough workers.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › SNAP Restrictions Good
Rachidi, Senior Fellow and Rowe Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, 06-23-23
[Angela, 6-23-2023, American Enterprise Institute - AEI, "SNAP Can Improve Nutrition, Help Farmers, and Support the Environment," https://www.aei.org/op-eds/snap-can-improve-nutrition-help-farmers-and-support-the-environment/?mkt_tok=NDc1LVBCUS05NzEAAAGMlh6KxtGn-Mh8fLw4IAcH5rgI61_0yo5XJ8d2CTwNwPh6vNHahYIt14RvPWWvjsCfbIcfAMHfioDgkaWXfihwiRCkilDJ4iVC3nccMB9Yjaw8, Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]
In contrast, SNAP provides more than $100 billion in food benefits to low-income families each year and covers 40 million people, approximately 12% of the US population. Yet, the program has no nutritional standards and participants spend a sizeable share of benefits (at least 25%) on unhealthy foods such as sugary beverages, frozen prepared foods, prepared desserts and candy.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › SNAP Restrictions Good
Rachidi, Senior Fellow and Rowe Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, 06-15-23
[Angela, 6-15-2023, American Enterprise Institute - AEI, "The Conservative Case for SNAP Restrictions," , Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]
Conservatives believe in individual freedom, free enterprise, and limited government. This is why conservatives often bridle against the government restricting individual choice—even when it comes to the use of public benefits. After all, being free to make decisions for yourself and your family is fundamental to conservative thought.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › AT – SNAP Cuts Bad
Ford, American Enterprise Institute’s Center For Opportunity And Social Mobility adjunct fellow, 6-7-23
[Leslie, 6-7-23, Wall Street Journal, “Don’t Give Away The Farm Bill”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]
Republicans have one more chance to roll back out-of-control welfare spending this year. The farm bill—must-pass legislation that authorizes food stamps and other agriculture programs—will be voted on by December. GOP lawmakers should focus on reining in President Biden’s unprecedented and expensive food-stamp hike.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Extension Solves
RFD TV, 6/22/23
[6/22/23, RFD TV, “There is optimism for an on-time Farm Bill now that these hurdles are done, according to Rep Lucas,” , accessed 7/12/2023, EJ]
However, despite a push to get the bill passed on time, Lucas also emphasizes a one-year extension is better than a weak legislation.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Extension Likely
Smith, IowaAgriBusinessNetwork, 7-3-23
[Riley, 7-3-2023, IowaAgriBusinessRadioNetwork, "Creative budgeting needed to fund a “no-new-money” farm bill," , Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]
An American Farm Bureau Federation (AFBF) official says it may take some creative budgeting to meet producer needs in a ‘no-new-money’ farm bill. Andrew Walmsley, AFBF senior director of government affairs, said the issue is how to meet producer needs for the next five years with those needs much different than during the 2018 farm bill and with few, if any, new dollars.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Extension Likely
Wiesemeyer, AgFax, 6-20-23
[Jim, 6-20-23, AgFax, “Farm Bill Debate Set to Heat Up at Senate Appropriations Committee Meeting,” , accessed 7/12/23, eo]
While the funding deadline is the end of September, most lawmakers expect Congress to extend the deadline through a continuing resolution (CR) to the end of December to avert a government shutdown.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Extension Likely
Douglas, Reuters agriculture journalist, 6-22-23
[Leah, 6-22-23, Reuters, “US Lawmakers Float Possible Farm Bill Extension Amid Delays”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]
The U.S. Congress may need to pass a short-term extension of the country's current farm bill, the largest food and nutrition spending package, amid delays drafting the next one, the top lawmakers on the Senate and House farm committees said on Thursday.