Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Basic Income Link Answers › Republicans Support UBI

Republicans will support the aff, they see it as a replacement for welfare

Battistoni Yale Political Science PhD candidate, 17

[Alyssa, Spring 2017, Dissent Magazine, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income”, , accessed 7/3/2023, eo]

One version functions as a kind of noblesse oblige—a handout to the unfortunates being made obsolete by robots smarter and more efficient than they are. Another version aspires to egalitarian universalism and challenges the legitimacy of privately accumulated wealth. There’s a version that sees UBI as the spark for a generation of entrepreneurs, and another that simply attempts to stave off a revolt of the precarious masses.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Basic Income Link Answers › Republicans Support UBI

No backlash – prominent Republicans support basic income

Yeung, Emory Political Science PhD candidate, 22

[Eddy, 10/19/22, Political Behavior, “Can Conservatives Be Persuaded? Framing Effects on Support for Universal Basic Income in the US”, , accessed 7/1/2023, eo]

This question is politically relevant. First, the political prospect of UBI hinges on public support for the policy. In democracies, public opinion plays an impor- tant role in shaping policy outcomes, particularly in the realm of welfare (Soroka & Wlezien, 2010). This is especially true in the US, where policy changes often require strong backing of the public (Burstein, 2003). Although elites may exert dis- proportionate influence (Bartels, 2008; Gilens, 2012), policy attitudes among the masses—and across the ideological spectrum (Caughey & Warshaw, 2018; Erikson et al., 1993; Lax & Phillips, 2012)—also matter (Canes-Wrone, 2015; Kelly & Enns, 2010). Thus, the political feasibility of UBI is a function of political support from the masses, including conservatives.1

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Basic Income Link Answers › UBI Support Across Political Spectrum

UBI can mobilize support across the political spectrum

Lenczewska, Stanford philosophy PhD candidate & Basic Income Lab fellow, 21

[Olga, 1/4/2021, Stanford Basic Income Lab, “Can people with vastly different political beliefs support a Universal Basic Income?,” ., accessed 7/1/2023, eo]

I am a fifth-year PhD candidate in philosophy at Stanford University and I have been involved with the Basic Income Lab since its beginning in 2017. My work at the Lab has focused on surveying the academic literature on the impact of basic income on gender justice, racial justice, and wellbeing. By reviewing the interdisciplinary literature on this topic, I sought to put into dialogue the normative and the empirical dimensions of this debate. My biggest takeaway from this work has been the realization that universal basic income (UBI) has a rare potential to gather supporters who hold vastly different beliefs and ideological commitments.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Basic Income Link Answers › UBI Popular

COVID has changed things – UBI support increasing post-pandemic

Nettle, Newcastle University Population Health Sciences Institute, et al., 21

[Daniel, Elliott Johnson politics philosophy and religion at Lancaster UK , Matthew Johnson politics philosophy and religion at Lancaster UK, and Rebecca Saxe Brain and Cognitive science at MIT, 3/17/23, Humanities and Social Sciences Communications volume, “Why has the COVID-19 pandemic increased support for Universal Basic Income?”, , accessed 7/2/23, eo]

UBI support for pandemic versus normal times

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Basic Income Link Answers › Bipartisanship

A UBI would pass with bipartisan support

Stevens, New York Times Art and Culture reporter & Paz, New York Times National Desk assistant, 21

[Matt and Isabella, 1/18/21, New York Times, “Andrew Yang’s $1,000-a-Month Idea May Have Seemed Absurd Before. Not Now.” , accessed 7/3/23, eo]

So only now — with millions of Americans facing the prospect of no work and wondering how they will pay the bills — have proposals similar to Mr. Yang’s signature policy prescription gained wide, bipartisan approval. In the sort of political turnabout that may only be possible when society faces dire need, giving free money to Americans suddenly appears not only rational but critically necessary to many Democrats and key Republicans.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › GOP Inflation Attack Will Hurt Biden

Inflation issues would sink Bidenomics

Sutton, Politico Financial Service Reporter 6-29-23

[Sam 06-29-2023, POLITICO, "Powell and Bidenomics will have to tango," , Accessed 7/10/23, S.A.M]

In other words, inflation won’t improve until the backbone of “Bidenomics” — the labor market — starts to slip a disk.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › GOP Inflation Attack Will Hurt Biden

GOP will try to tag Bidenomics with inflation

McManus, LA Times Washington columnist, 7-9-23.

[Doyle, 7-9-23, Los Angeles Times, "How 'Bidenomics' looks now isn't what matters. It’s how voters view it in a year that counts," https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-07-09/bidenomics-voters-presidential-race]

For another, the facts are slowly rallying to Biden’s side. The economy is growing by about 2% a year, job creation remains strong and — most important from a political standpoint — inflation has eased to 4% from last year’s peak of 9%. After two years in which prices were rising faster than wages, real incomes are slowly growing again.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bipartisan Economic Agenda Boosts Biden

Biden’s bipartisan economic policies tide Republican pushback on bills

Weisman, The New York Times Political Correspondent &Epstein, The New York Times journalist, 6-29-23

[Jonathan, Reid, 6/29/23, The New York Times, “Republicans’ Problem in Attacking Biden: They Helped Pass His Economic Bills,” , Accessed 7/8/23, J.D.]

No doubt they will take swings at him anyway. But it may be more difficult to land punches given that plenty of them voted for the bipartisan infrastructure and semiconductor manufacturing bills.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Key to Win Progressive Support

Campaigning on the economy is effective for progressives

Jacobin, 6/13/23

[6/13/2023, Jacobin, “Trump’s Kryptonite: How Progressives Can Win Back the Working Class”, , accessed 7/9/23, eo]

Overall, we find that progressives can make inroads with working-class voters if they run campaigns that convey a credible commitment to the interests of working people. This means running more working-class candidates, running jobs-focused campaigns, and picking a fight with political and economic elites on behalf of working Americans.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › AT – Bidenomics Won’t Help Biden

Bidenomics perceived well now – helps his campaign

Sutton, Politico Financial Services Reporter, 7/5/2023

[Sam, July 5th 2023, Politico, “Voters don’t love Bidenomics. Markets are coming around.”, , Accessed 7/8/2023, S.P.]

President Joe Biden is telling the American people that the economy is in better shape than they think. As inflation starts to fade, some on Wall Street are starting to believe it.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden has been good for the economy–he just needs to get the public to realize that

Balz, Washington Post Chief Correspondent, 7-8-23

[Dan, 7-8-23, Washington Post, “Can Biden make ‘Bidenomics’ a winning message in 2024?,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/07/08/biden-economy-voters/, accessed 7-15, DG]

This president is dealing with an economy that keeps producing jobs month after month, but also an economy with inflationary pressures mixed with fears of a recession that have kept people worried. It is those concerns that the current campaign is designed to address.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden’s campaign focus centers around a strong economy

Werschkul, Yahoo Finance Washington correspondent, 6-18-23

[Ben, 6/18/23, Yahoo Finance, “Why Biden polls so low on the economy — and what he is trying to do about it”, https://finance.yahoo.com/news/why-biden-polls-so-low-on-the-economy--and-what-he-is-trying-to-do-about-it-142504457.html, accessed 7/8/23, eo]

It’s a feature of Biden’s 2024 re-election effort so far that is surely causing heartburn in his inner circle: not only are the president’s overall approval ratings low but voters usually rate his performance on the crucial issue of the economy even lower.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

The Biden campaign’s future will be focused on Bidenomics

Bade, Politico senior Washington correspondent, et al. 6/26/23

[Racheal, Eugene Daniels, Politico White House correspondent, Ryan Lizza, Politico Chief White House correspondent, 6/23/23, Politico, “Playbook: The White House goes macro on ‘Bidenomics’”, . , accessed 7/8/23,eo]

BIDEN’S NEW BUZZWORD — With Congress out for an extended July Fourth holiday recess and 2024 hopefuls hitting the donor circuit ahead of Friday’s Q2 fundraising deadline, the week is shaping up to be quieter than the chaos we’ve seen recently — at least in theory ...

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Outlook on increased support for Bidenomics good.

Boak, AP Economics Writer, et al., 6/28/23

[Josh Boak, Emily Swanson, Associated Press Polling Editor, Chris Megerian, Associated Press White House Reporter, 6/28/23, AP, “President touts ‘Bidenomics’ though new poll shows just 34% approve his handling of the economy,” , 7/8/2023, EJ]

White House aides believe that Biden’s speech on Wednesday can generate greater awareness of his policies and increase Democratic voters’ appreciation of the economy. While the president’s allies acknowledge that many Americans still hold dim views of the economy, they note that the actual economic data was far worse last November, when Democrats mounted a stronger-than-expected showing in the midterm elections.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden is finally starting to change the narrative—now is not the time for a polarizing massive plan

Krugman, University of New York Economics Ph.D. program professor, 7-3-23

[Paul, 7-3-2023, The New York Times, “Can Biden Change the Economic Narrative?,” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/03/opinion/biden-economy-inflation-unemployment.html?campaign_id=39&emc=edit_ty_20230704&instance_id=96688&nl=opinion-today&regi_id=2215521&segment_id=138334&te=1&user_id=1af5e18c64a5b5efd416aeca35fd0cac, accessed 7-8-23, DG]

Back in the 1970s, Arthur Okun, an economist who had been a policy adviser to Lyndon Johnson, suggested a quick-and-dirty way to assess the nation’s economic condition: the “misery index,” the sum of inflation and unemployment. It was and is a crude, easily criticized measure. The measurable economic harm from unemployment, for instance, is much higher than that from inflation. Yet the index has historically done a quite good job of predicting overall economic sentiment.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden is reorienting the narrative to boost economic successes

Dionne Jr., Georgetown University Government Professor, 6-28-23

[E.J, 6-28-23, The Washington Post, “If ‘Bidenomics’ works, it will be a very big deal,” , accessed 7-8-23, DG]

President Biden might not seem like a revolutionary, but he is presiding over a fundamental change in the nation’s approach to economics. Not only is he proposing a major break from the “trickle-down” policies of Ronald Reagan, as Biden highlighted in a speech in Chicago on Wednesday. He is also departing from many orthodoxies that shaped the presidencies of Democrats Bill Clinton and Barack Obama.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Bidenomics is embraced by Biden as core piece of 2024 campaign- emphasis on American investment and empowerment

Blumenthal, Huffpost reporter, 6-28-23

[Paul, 6/28/2023, Huffpost, “In Speech On Bidenomics, Biden Tries To Turn The Page On Reagan (And Every President Since),” , Accessed 7/8/2023, J.D.]

In a major speech on Wednesday outlining his economic policy, Joe Biden took a page from his old pal Barack Obama. When Obama ran for reelection in 2012, he embraced the pejorative name given to his signature policy achievement — Obamacare. In Chicago today, Biden embraced the insult the Wall Street Journal Opinion page gave to his economic plans — Bidenomics.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden is trying to change the narrative now–but he has to be very careful

Balz, Washington post Chief Correspondent, 7-8-23

[Dan, 7-8-23, Washington Post, “Can Biden make ‘Bidenomics’ a winning message in 2024?,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/07/08/biden-economy-voters/, accessed 7-15, DG]

Few political objectives are more important for President Biden than winning the economic debate in 2024. Democrats know that their chances of prevailing in the presidential election are severely diminished if the Republican nominee and the GOP are seen as more capable and trusted on this issue.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Narrative Key

Biden is currently rallying behind Bidenomics – perceptions will be key

Basu, Axios politics editor & Nichols, Axios political reporter, 6/28/23

[Zachary and Basu, 6/28/23, Axios, “Axios Sneak Peek,” , accessed 7/15/23, eo]

President Biden has finally stopped worrying and learned to love "Bidenomics," less than two weeks after joking to an audience of union workers: "I don't know what the hell that is."

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Bidenomics Link Args › Links & Internal Links › Bidenomics Key to Biden Support

Continued focus on positive economy message key

Popli, TIME, 7-7-23

[Nik, 7-7-2023, "Why Joe Biden is Running on the Economy," Time, , Accessed 7/15/23, S.A.M]

With the presidential election just over one year away, the Biden Administration faces a challenge: how to convince skeptical voters that the economy is in much better shape than they think.