Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › AT – McCarthy Won’t Get Blame

Fiat ensures the link – McCarthy will get the blame for letting the plan through the House

Cochrane, New York Times, 23

[Emily, 1-7-2023, New York Times "Why McCarthy’s Slog to Speaker Could Mean Dysfunction Ahead in the House," , Accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]

In fact, some of the concessions Mr. McCarthy agreed to would make the practical business of running the House next to impossible. It could be left unable to do basic things like fund the government or finance the federal debt. For the dissidents, that was the point. For the country, it could lead to some grim consequences.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Bipartisanship Key to Agenda

McCarthy catering to the right means Dems win House

Bade, Politico Senior Washington Correspondent, et al, 23

[Rachael, Eugene Daniels and Ryan Lizza, 06-20-2023, POLITICO, "Playbook: Dems salivate as McCarthy caters to the right," https://www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2023/06/20/dems-salivate-as-mccarthy-caters-to-the-right-00102621]

NEVER MIND THE MIDDLE — As the drama between Speaker KEVIN McCARTHY and hardline conservatives roils the House, Democratic leaders are watching with total fascination — and giddiness.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Bipartisanship Key to Agenda

McCarthy is making progress with the Far Right, just as long as he makes no deals with the Democrats

Karni, New York Times Congressional Correspondent, 6-12-23

[Annie, 6-12-2023, The New York Times, "Hard Right Agrees to Allow House Votes but Threatens Continued Blockade,” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/12/us/politics/house-republicans-mccarthy.html?campaign_id=9&emc=edit_nn_20230613&instance_id=94904&nl=the-morning®i_id=2215521&segment_id=135412&te=1&user_id=1af5e18c64a5b5efd416aeca35fd0cac, Accessed 7/3/23, S.A.M]

Hard-right House Republicans agreed late Monday to give their party leaders a temporary reprieve from a weeklong blockade of the House floor, allowing some legislative business to move forward on Tuesday but insisting they would withhold their support for future votes if their demands were not met.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Bipartisanship Key to Agenda

Republicans in the Senate trust McCarthy’s Leadership to appease the Far Right

Weaver, The Hill, 6-11-23

[Al, 6-11-2023, The Hill "Conservative revolt in House alarms Senate GOP," , Accessed 7/3/23, S.A.M]

Some Republicans indicated they are alarmed by what’s going on but said that they are confident McCarthy will be able to quash the situation to allow the House to resume its work. “The House is emotional,” Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) told reporters, that it generally “reflects the mood of the country.” “This is just the way, once in a while, people act out, and that’s just part of the process,” Rounds continued. “They’ll handle it. It’ll be okay.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Bipartisanship Key to Agenda

Senate Republicans are afraid of the Far Right’s political theater in the House

Weaver, The Hill, 6-11-23

[Al, 6-11-2023, The Hill "Conservative revolt in House alarms Senate GOP," , Accessed 7/3/23, S.A.M]

Senate Republicans are growing increasingly concerned with the antics of House conservatives as they paralyze business in the lower chamber with key legislative battles looming in the coming months.Eleven conservative members blocked a handful of messaging bills from reaching the House floor for votes last week — and vowed to keep doing so — effectively grinding the chamber to a halt over Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s (R-Calif.) handling of debt ceiling talks last month. 

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Bipartisanship Key to Agenda

Pearlstein, George Mason Public Affairs Professor, 23

[Steven, 6-20-23, The Washington Post, “How to take congress away from the crazies,” , accessed 7/15/23, DS]

Speakers control the House through rules — not the impenetrable “Rules of the House” that are adopted at the beginning of each two-year session, but temporary “rules” that allow the House to move immediately to the next piece of legislation, setting how long the debate will be and who can offer which amendments. In recent years, as the House has become increasingly partisan, that debate has been brief and amendments few. The effect has been to shut out members of the minority party — roughly half the House — from participation in the legislative process.

Temporary rules are crafted by the House Rules Committee, most of whose members are beholden to the speaker. And because these rules provide the parliamentary mechanism by which the speaker and the majority party control the legislative agenda, members of the majority party are expected to always vote in favor of rules — whether or not they intend to vote for the underlying bill — while members of the minority are expected to vote no as told by the party brass.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › GOP Coop Key to Agenda

GOP right are watching McCarthy to see whose team he is on – if he sides with Democrats, they will shut everything down

Lillis, The Hill Congressional Reporter, 6-12-23

[Mike, 6-12-23, The Hill, "McCarthy faces power test in conservative revolt,"https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4043351-mccarthy-power-test-conservative-revolt/, Accessed 7/3/23, S.A.M]

House Republicans return to Washington on Monday after a humiliating week when conservative rebels brought floor action to a halt, foiled votes on GOP priorities and rekindled questions about the ability of Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) to guide his party through the tough policy fights in the months ahead. Republican leaders have a series of suspension votes scheduled for Monday evening, featuring uncontroversial bills expected to pass easily with Democratic support. But the real test will come Tuesday, when they’ve slated floor action on a second series of proposals — including the four bills that never reached the floor last week — that will require cooperation from the same conservative firebrands who blocked them the first time around.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Spending Will Trigger GOP Backlash v McCarthy

Lillis, The Hill Senior Staff Writer, et al. ,6-23-2023

[Mike, and Mychael Schnell, The Hill Staff Writer, and Emily Brooks, The Hill Staff Writer, 6-23-2023, The Hill, “McCarthy seeks to mollify conservatives ahead of federal spending fight,” https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4065223-mccarthy-seeks-to-mollify-conservatives-ahead-of-federal-spending-fight/, accessed 7-3-23, DG]

To mollify those gripes, the Speaker summoned a group of at least eight conservatives to his office in the Capitol on Friday afternoon, seeking to convince the skeptics that Republican leaders share their goals when it comes to spending cuts. Afterward, McCarthy characterized the discussion as a sort of primer on the goals GOP leaders aim to achieve in their appropriations bills.

“You have to think differently. We got to start at the beginning,” McCarthy said. “It’s walking people through what’s in the approps bills now, and what could be as the other ones get marked up. Greater input, greater conversations. And the more knowledge, the better off we are in the better chance we have at passing.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Spending Will Trigger GOP Backlash v McCarthy

Lillis, The Hill Senior Staff Writer, et al., 6-13-23

[Mike, and Mychael Schnell, The Hill Staff Writer, and Emily Brooks, The Hill Staff Writer, 6-13-23, The Hill, “GOP moderates strike back after conservative revolt paralyzes House,” , accessed 7-3-23, DG]

Tuesday morning’s conference meeting came hours after House conservatives said they would retreat from their days-long revolt — at least temporarily — and allow legislative business to move forward on the floor as they continue discussions with Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) about reining in deficit spending.

The chamber advanced four pieces of legislation on the floor Tuesday, including one that conservatives blocked last week when they kicked off the blockade.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – McCarthy Link Args › Links › Spending Will Trigger GOP Backlash v McCarthy

GOP issuing ultimatums about spending – The aff’s spending is guaranteed to make Republicans go against McCarthy

Kapur, NBC Senior national reporter, 7/10/23

[Sahil, 7/10/23, NBC News, “House GOP conservatives send McCarthy an ultimatum on funding the government,” , accessed 7/10/23, eo]

WASHINGTON — A group of 21 House conservatives sent Speaker Kevin McCarthy a letter Monday threatening to vote against government funding legislation unless it meets a series of demands.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Jobs Guarantee CP Link Answers › CP Net Benefit – Job Guarantee CP Avoids the Politics Link

Jobs guarantee avoids the basic income politics link – job creation and tax revenue make it politically palatable

Loomis, University of Rhode Island history professor, 18

[Erik, 4-25-18, The New York Times, “The Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee,” , accessed on 7-2-23, JC]

Job creation fits American cultural norms around work more effectively than the idea of universal basic income. It avoids politically unpopular forms of welfare while significantly bolstering the welfare state for those who need it. Encouraging private sector job creation would limit the impact on the deficit while adding tax money to the nation’s coffers.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › EITC Link Answers › CP Net Benefit – EITC CP Avoids the Link to Politics

No link – EITC expansion has bipartisan support

Slater, Sacramento Bee and Lightman, Congressional Reporter 7-11-23

[Sonora, David, 7-11-2023, Sacramento Bee "Biden, Democrats want to increase tax breaks for parents. It could help 15 million Californians," , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M]

Brea Turner struggles to keep up with rising prices. She struggles to pass her college classes, raise her young daughter and work at her part-time job. The California State University-Sacramento student said she still needs the COVID-era child tax credit, which was expanded to ease financial hardships for families during the pandemic. That enhanced benefit ended last year. But Washington lawmakers are seriously considering returning it to its 2021 level, when qualifying parents could receive monthly payments of up to $300 and annual tax breaks of up to $3,600 per child.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › EITC Link Answers › CP Net Benefit – EITC CP Avoids the Link to Politics

EITC has bipartisan support, both parties want to expand the program.

Paluch, Center for Public Integrity, 19

[Gabrielle, 4/17/19, The Center for Public Integrity, “Why wasn’t a tax cut with rare bipartisan support part of tax overhaul talks?,” https://publicintegrity.org/inequality-poverty-opportunity/taxes/trumps-tax-cuts/even-republicans-like-this-tax-cut-for-the-working-poor-why-wasnt-it-expanded-by-trumps-tax-law/, ACCESSED 7/13/23, PE]

When the Republican-controlled Congress crafted its massive tax-cut bill in 2017, President Donald Trump routinely claimed it would cut levies for the middle class. But one tax relief proposal that many economists felt could bring bigger benefits to these Americans was conspicuously absent — an expansion of the Earned Income Tax Credit. The EITC, which dates to 1975, is a tax credit claimed by low- and moderate-income families and individuals that in many cases wipes out any federal taxes owed, with any leftover credit refundable for cash. When it was expanded in the last big tax reform law in 1986, President Ronald Reagan described the law in general as “the best anti-poverty bill, the best pro-family measure, and the best job-creation program ever to come out of the Congress.” Democrats like it because it reduces income inequality; Republicans like it because it promotes work rather than a reliance on welfare. Republicans and Democrats have frequently proposed increasing EITC benefits and expanding the program to workers who aren’t currently eligible, mostly childless working poor.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › Partisanship

Plan will spark a partisan fight over the details of Social Security reform

Gleckman, Forbes senior contributor, 22

[Howard, 10-22-22, Forbes, “Politicians are Arguing Again about Social Security. That’s a Good Thing,” , Accessed 7/1/23, J.D.]

Suddenly, Social Security reform is back in the news. For all the wrong reasons, perhaps. But at least politicians are talking about it. And that’s a good thing.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › GOP Backlash

Republicans want to cut Social Security – April vote proves

Lawson, Social Security Works Executive Director, 23

[Alex, 4-26-23, Social Security Works, “217 Republicans Just Voted to Cut Social Security”, , accessed 7/3/2023, S.P.]

(Washington, DC) — The following is a statement from Alex Lawson, Executive Director of Social Security Works, in response to 217 House Republicans voting for a bill that reduces funding for the Social Security Administration:

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › GOP Backlash

Republicans want to slash Social Security

Johnson, Common Dreams, 23

[Jake, 5-23-23, Common Dreams, “House Dems Announce Bill to Expand Social Security as GOP Default Threat Imperils Payments”, , accessed 7/2/23, S.P.]

Rep. John Larson (D-Conn.), the lead author of the latest version of the Social Security 2100 Act, said during Tuesday's press conference that Social Security recipients are not "bargaining chips" and blasted Republican proposals to slash benefits.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › GOP Backlash

Republicans will oppose the plan – they want to cut Social Security, not expand it

Eberwein, Heartland Signal Reporter, 23

[Richard, 1-6-23, Heartland Signal, “The Republican plan to cut Social Security is very real”, , accessed 6/30/23, S.P.]

In recent months, Republican leadership in Congress has expressed their desire to make cuts to popular safety net programs like Social Security and Medicare. Most notably, probable Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy and Senate Minority Whip John Thune both openly laid out their plans to make cuts to Social Security benefits.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › GOP Backlash

Expansion will trigger a massive debate about the plan – GOP wants to rollback Social Security benefits

Johnson, Common Dreams, 22

[Jake, 8-15-22, Common Dreams, “On Social Security’s 87th Birthday, Progressives Warn GOP Wants to ‘Take a Chainsaw to It,’ , Accessed 7/1/23, J.D.]

Advocates and progressive lawmakers on Sunday celebrated the 87th birthday of Social Security--one of the most popular and successful federal programs in U.S. history--and warned that its modest benefits remain under serious threat as Republicans openly signal their desire to gut the New Deal mainstay, a move that would hurl millions into poverty.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › Political Capital

Social Security reform requires massive political lift

Akabas, Bipartisan Policy Center economic policy director, 23

[Shai, 4-13-23, The Hill, “Finally, we have a true shot at bipartisan Social Security Reform,” , Accessed 7/3/23, J.D.]

Pronouncements from both sides of the aisle that we must “protect” Social Security from any fiscal reforms obscure a hard truth: A vote for the status quo is a vote to cut benefits by nearly a quarter for every single beneficiary starting in just over 10 years.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Social Security Links › Triggers Debate

Social Security reform will trigger a tough debate about raising taxes or reducing benefits

Biggs, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Senior Fellow, 23

[Andrew, 6/22/23, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, “Bill Cassidy’s Well Intentioned But Misguided Social Security Reform,” Accessed 7/3/2023, J.D.]

Senator Bill Cassidy (R., Louis.) has been making the media rounds promoting his idea for a bipartisan Social Security reform plan, including a recent article in National Review Online. I admire Cassidy’s efforts, even more so when the leaders of both political parties have failed to show the initiative that Social Security reform warrants. If every Senator were like Cassidy, Social Security’s multi-trillion dollar shortfall would have been addressed rather than left to fester for decades. And yet, Cassidy’s core idea — the federal government borrowing $1.5 trillion to invest in the stock market, with the proceeds directed to Social Security — isn’t a very good one. It’s effectively a tax increase in disguise, and one that comes with considerable risk and instability to federal government finances.