Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › AT – Green New Deal Popular

Green New Deal details are extremely divisive – polls prove

[YouGov Blue, 3-19-19, Data for Progress “Memo: U.S Voters Strongly Support Bold Climate Solutions,” https://www.dataforprogress.org/the-green-new-deal-is-popular, accessed 7-2-23, DG]

Next, respondents were asked to more or less explicitly evaluate the Green New Deal. Specifically, we asked respondents:

◂ Would you support or oppose a Green New Deal, a policy in which the Federal government creates jobs and invests in low-income communities building energy efficient infrastructure, replacing lead water pipes, and updating America's energy grid?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › Green New Deal Unpopular

Big government climate policy not popular - the public doesn’t want to pay for it

Polumbo, Foundation for Economic Education Policy correspondent, 21

[Brad, 5-26-2021, Foundation for Economic Education Stories, “New Poll: Americans Aren’t Willing to Pay for the ‘Green New Deal’—And It’s Not Even Close,” https://fee.org/articles/new-poll-americans-aren-t-willing-to-pay-for-the-green-new-deal-and-it-s-not-even-close/, accessed 6-30-23, DG]

Americans largely agree that climate change and pollution are real problems. But a new poll reveals that they aren’t interested in shelling out massive amounts from their wallets in pursuit of progressive, big-government “solutions” like the so-called “Green New Deal.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › AT – Dems Support Green New Deal

House Dems not campaigning on Green New Deal

Isaac Dovere, CNN, 23

[Edward 6-28-23, CNN, "Hakeem Jeffries is staging a takeover of the New York Democrats. His hope to become Speaker may depend on it.," , Accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]

Whether Jeffries can wrangle New York’s infamously infighting parochial party players will be the biggest test of his own political and fundraising abilities. He only recently took over for former Speaker Nancy Pelosi as the leader of House Democrats.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › AT – Dems Support Green New Deal

King opposes Green New Deal as overbroad and unrealistic

Sen. King (I-ME) Press Release, 19

[3-26-19, The Office of Angus King (I-ME), “King Statement on Green New Deal Resolution,” https://www.king.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/king-statement-on-green-new-deal-resolution, accessed 6/30/23, S.A.M]

King Statement on Green New Deal Resolution

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › AT – Dems Support Green New Deal

Manchin, Senate Energy Committee Chair, opposes the Green New Deal – multiple concerns about cost, reliable energy, and phasing out fossil fuels

Sen. Manchin (D-WV) Press Release, 19

[3-26-2019, The Office of Joe Manchin, “MANCHIN VOTES AGAINST THE GREEN NEW DEAL,” https://www.manchin.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/manchin-votes-against-the-green-new-deal, accessed 6/30/23, S.A.M]

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV) released the following statement on his decision to vote against the Green New Deal.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › GOP Backlash

Moderate Lisa Murkowski is taking a third way on the Green New Deal.

Sen. Murkowski (R-AK) Press Release 19

[3-26-19, Murkowski Newsroom, “Alaska Public Media: Green New Deal? Murkowski says no, opts for middle way on climate,” https://www.murkowski.senate.gov/press/article/alaska-public-media-green-new-deal-murkowski-says-no-opts-for-middle-way-on-climate, accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]

Sen. Lisa Murkowski is talking about global warming more than ever these days. While the Green New Deal is a lightning rod in Congress, Murkowski says she’s reaching for what’s politically possible.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › GOP Backlash

The Senate Republican Whip opposes any Green New Deal-esque Plan.

Sen. Thune (R-SD), Republican Whip, 23

[John, 6-9-2023, U.S. Senator John Thune, "Green New Deal is a Bad Deal for America," Accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]

From the earliest days of his administration, President Biden has moved to accelerate his vision of a Green New Deal future. His early decisions to cancel the Keystone XL pipeline and pause energy development on federal lands sent a clear message that discouraged domestic production of conventional energy, which led to higher prices for American families. With the help of Democrats in Congress, the president has also increased taxes and fees on conventional energy producers, which will only drive prices higher.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › GOP Backlash

The Ranking Member of the Committee of Energy hates the Green New Deal

Sen. Barrasso (R-WY), Energy and Natural Resources Ranking Member, 21

[4-19-2021, US Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources Republican News, "Barrasso: The Green New Disaster is Back," , Accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Today, U.S. Senator John Barrasso (R-WY), ranking member of the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources (ENR), issued the following statement in response to reports that the Green New Deal resolution will be reintroduced in the House of Representatives and the Senate.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › GOP Backlash

Rep. Boebert (R-CO) Press Release 22

[Lauren, 6-30-2022, Congresswoman Lauren Boebert, “Supreme Court Effectively Kills the Green New Deal and Upholds the Rule of Law,” https://boebert.house.gov/media/press-releases/supreme-court-effectively-kills-green-new-deal-and-upholds-rule-law#:~:text=Issues-,Supreme%20Court%20Effectively%20Kills%20the%20Green%20New,Upholds%20the%20Rule%20of%20Law&text=In%20response%20to%20the%20Supreme%20Court's%20landmark%20decision%20in%20West%20Virginia%20v., accessed 7-3-23, DG]

(Lauren Boebert is a congress woman who serves for the 3rd district of Colorado)

In response to the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in West Virginia v. EPA, Congresswoman Lauren Boebert issued the following statement:

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › Green New Deal Politically Divisive

Gustafson, University of Cincinnati Public Policy Professor, et al., 19

[Abel, Seth Rosenthal, Yale Program on Climate Change Communication research methodologist, Matthew Ballew, Yale Program on Climate Change Communication research Specialist, Parrish Bergquist, Georgetown University McCourt School of Public Policy professor, John Kotcher, Ph.D. at George Mason University Science Communication program PhD, Edward Maibach, Professor at George Mason University, Anthony Leiserowitz, Ph.D. is the founder and Director of the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication and a Senior Research Scientist at the Yale School of the Environment, 11-18-19, Yale Program On Climate Change Communication, “How Political Polarization Increased on the Green New Deal,” https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/publications/how-political-polarization-increased-on-the-green-new-deal/, accessed 7-3-23, DG

The Green New Deal, a proposed set of U.S. policies that seeks to address climate change, entered the political stage in early 2019 and continues to occupy the spotlight of the climate policy conversation. Our new article documents the dramatic changes in Americans’ awareness of and support for the Green New Deal in just four months. For example, we found that Republicans who regularly watch Fox News became much less supportive of the Green New Deal.

Data for this study were provided by the Climate Change in the American Mind survey, conducted in December 2018 and April 2019. By measuring familiarity with – and support for – the Green New Deal over time, we were able to observe the development of political polarization in attitudes about the Green New Deal while the issue was rising from obscurity to national prominence.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Green New Deal Links › Green New Deal Politically Divisive

Dems and Republicans are on record opposing a Green New Deal, any backtracking gives the other side the advantage.

Koss, E&E News, 21

[Geof, 8-10-21, E&E News by POLITICO "Senate rejects Green New Deal as marathon voting begins," Accessed 7/3/23, S.A.M]

The Green New Deal took center stage this afternoon as the Senate launched a marathon of amendment votes to the $3.5 trillion budget resolution that Democrats are vowing to pass before the August recess.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Jobs Guarantee Links

Federal job guarantee would ensure a political fight, requiring compromise

Loomis, University of Rhode Island history professor, 18

[Erik, 4-25-18, The New York Times, “The Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee,” , accessed on 7-2-23, JC]

A federally guaranteed job is not the full answer to economic inequality or an automated world. It needs to be paired with a higher minimum wage and labor law reforms that allow workers to unionize and win collective bargaining agreements. Work under the federal job guarantee starting at $15 an hour would help produce those outcomes.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › AT – UBI Draws Support Across Groups

Support for the concept of basic income does not translate into support for specific mechanisms – the devil is in the details

Lenczewska, Stanford philosophy PhD candidate & Basic Income Lab fellow, 21

[Olga, 1/4/2021, Stanford Basic Income Lab, “Can people with vastly different political beliefs support a Universal Basic Income?,” , accessed 7/1/2023, eo]

Of course, having reasons to support this particular policy does not mean that this is the preferred policy for addressing some of the complex social and economic challenges of today. Different ideological groups might see UBI only as a second or third best solution to the problems they want to tackle. As such, while UBI may not be the first option policy for all to address issues of economic security, it may be one of the rare policies that individuals with differing political beliefs may be able to agree on in the end.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › UBI Unpopular with Republicans

Universal Basic Income is very unpopular among Republicans

Ghenis, UBI Center president, et al., 21

[Max, Katarina van Alebeek, UBI Center research assistant, Will Fedder, UBI Center research assistant, 10/18/21, UBI Center, “Introducing the UBI Poll Tracker”, , accessed 7/2/23, eo]

The UBI Poll Tracker reveals remarkable variation in public opinion around basic income, across countries, demographic groups, time, and question framing.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › GOP Backlash

Texas Republicans attempted to ban a Universal basic income

DuPree KXAN news reporter, 22

[Will, 11/22/22, Basic Income Today, “New Republican Bill in Texas Aims to Forbid UBI Pilots”, , accessed 7/2/2023, eo]

AUSTIN (KXAN) — Austin could become the last Texas city to enact a guaranteed income program if a bill filed Monday becomes law.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › UBI Unpopular

Plan will trigger a backlash – overwhelming GOP opposition to UBI

Gilberstadt, Pew Research Assistant, 20

[Hannah, 8-18-20, Pew Research Center, “More Americans Oppose Than Favor The Government Providing A Universal Basic Income For All Adult Citizens”, , accessed 6-30-22, EH]

A narrow majority of U.S. adults (54%) say they would oppose the federal government providing a guaranteed income – sometimes called a universal basic income (UBI) – of about $1,000 per month for all adult citizens, whether or not they work; 45% favor the proposal.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › UBI Unpopular

UBI politically divisive – polls prove public split on support and details

Sharpe, University of Massachusetts News Content Associate, 23

[Jared, 6-16-23, University of Massachusetts, “Majority Of Americans Support Supreme Court Reforms, Including Term Limits And Ethics Requirements, According To New UMass Amherst Poll”, , accessed 6-30-23, EH]

The latest UMass Amherst Poll also asked respondents about a pair of hypothetically transformative policies – the implementation of universal basic income for all Americans and greater federal oversight of election laws.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › UBI Triggers Welfare Debate

The aff is not politically feasible – the plan would trigger massive controversy

Morrison, Competitive Enterprise Institute senior fellow, 21

[Richard, 7/3/2021, Competitive Enterprise Institute, “The Case Against a Universal Basic Income”, , accessed 7/3/2023, eo]

The vast majority of programs target specific groups — children, the disabled and the elderly — that have the greatest need. Under the current system, shame felt by an able-bodied adult capable of working is a feature, not a bug.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › UBI Triggers Welfare Debate

The GOP will use the plan to spark a debate about cutting welfare

Wax, New York Young Republican Club president and political activist and commentator, 20

[Gavin, 4-27-20, Foundation For Economic Education Stories, “Universal Basic Income Makes Welfare More Efficient, Which Is Bad, Dummy, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

A plan so crazy it just might work. That’s the essence of the pitch for a universal basic income. And it’s starting to sound reasonable to conservatives. They hope it will make welfare more efficient, but that’s its biggest problem.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Basic Income Links › Politically Divisive

Plan not popular – UBI funding faces massive political hurdles – will force either cuts or taxes

Greenstein, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities Founder & President Emeritus, 19

[Robert. 6-13-19, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, "Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It," https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it - DOA 6-27-23 DD]

Will the politics change radically?