Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Pettersen, University of Olso Department of Philosophy, 2011

[Tove, March 2011, Health Care Analysis, “The Ethics of Care: Normative Structures and Empirical Implications,” Accessed 7.17.17 CT @ GDI]

People’s relationships extend in all directions. Some will engender care, others will stifle its growth and give way to conflict, abuse and violence. Care ethicists should therefore study all kinds of relationships, not only private and professional. As the ethics of care accentuates different features than other theories, e.g., harm caused by lack of care, the agents’ vulnerability and dependency, and how they are situated in particular power- and resource situations, it also identifies certain ethical challenges other theories tend to neglect. For instance, the ethics of care is as a result of its focus on interactions, alert to structural violence, i.e. to injuries caused by the way society is organized.2 Structural violence infects relationships between institutions and individuals, and is characterized precisely by lack of care between unequal parties, such as the global corporation vis-à-vis the individual. Such harm can be inflicted slowly and might not be immediately apparent. It can take place even if rights are not violated, and the overall good is maximized. When the dominant party (which might be a global corporation or a health authority) forces the less empowered party (who might be a child or health worker) to acquiesce to or subject themselves (or others) to harmful schemes, the relationship counts as abusive. Disempowerment can cause conflict—at the level of the individual and family as well as of the state.

The political scientist and care ethicist Fiona Robinson’s discussion on corporate social responsibility is an example of how to understand care and responsibility in such asymmetric “intercategory” relations [26]. Corporate social responsibility is the transnational corporate partnerships’ responsibility to assume accountability for the social and natural environment they operate in, and for their economic and social impact. Robinson demonstrates how the ethics of care, with its contextualized focus, can capture certain types of harm more easily than other theories, and how moral arguments springing from the ethics of care can be used against structural violence. Hence, a different normative approach, could pave the way for a more caring environment.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

We must prioritize everyday acts of violence – it is the largest proximal cause of genocide and interstate war

Scheper-Hughes and Bourgois (Prof of Anthropology @ Cal-Berkely; Prof of Anthropology @ UPenn) 2004 (Nancy and Philippe, Introduction: Making Sense of Violence, in Violence in War and Peace, pg. 19-22)

This large and at first sight “messy” Part VII is central to this anthology’s thesis. It encompasses everything from the routinized, bureaucratized, and utterly banal violence of children dying of hunger and maternal despair in Northeast Brazil (Scheper-Hughes, Chapter 33) to elderly African Americans dying of heat stroke in Mayor Daly’s version of US apartheid in Chicago’s South Side (Klinenberg, Chapter 38) to the racialized class hatred expressed by British Victorians in their olfactory disgust of the “smelly” working classes (Orwell, Chapter 36). In these readings violence is located in the symbolic and social structures that overdetermine and allow the criminalized drug addictions, interpersonal bloodshed, and racially patterned incarcerations that characterize the US “inner city” to be normalized (Bourgois, Chapter 37 and Wacquant, Chapter 39). Violence also takes the form of class, racial, political self-hatred and adolescent self-destruction (Quesada, Chapter 35), as well as of useless (i.e. preventable), rawly embodied physical suffering, and death (Farmer, Chapter 34). Absolutely central to our approach is a blurring of categories and distinctions between wartime and peacetime violence. Close attention to the “little” violences produced in the structures, habituses, and mentalites of everyday life shifts our attention to pathologies of class, race, and gender inequalities. More important, it interrupts the voyeuristic tendencies of “violence studies” that risk publicly humiliating the powerless who are often forced into complicity with social and individual pathologies of power because suffering is often a solvent of human integrity and dignity. Thus, in this anthology we are positing a violence continuum comprised of a multitude of “small wars and invisible genocides” (see also Scheper- Hughes 1996; 1997; 2000b) conducted in the normative social spaces of public schools, clinics, emergency rooms, hospital wards, nursing homes, courtrooms, public registry offices, prisons, detention centers, and public morgues. The violence continuum also refers to the ease with which humans are capable of reducing the socially vulnerable into expendable nonpersons and assuming the license - even the duty - to kill, maim, or soul-murder. We realize that in referring to a violence and a genocide continuum we are flying in the face of a tradition of genocide studies that argues for the absolute uniqueness of the Jewish Holocaust and for vigilance with respect to restricted purist use of the term genocide itself (see Kuper 1985; Chaulk 1999; Fein 1990; Chorbajian 1999). But we hold an opposing and alternative view that, to the contrary, it is absolutely necessary to make just such existential leaps in purposefully linking violent acts in normal times to those of abnormal times. Hence the title of our volume: Violence in War and in Peace. If (as we concede) there is a moral risk in overextending the concept of “genocide” into spaces and corners of everyday life where we might not ordinarily think to find it (and there is), an even greater risk lies in failing to sensitize ourselves, in misrecognizing protogenocidal practices and sentiments daily enacted as normative behavior by “ordinary” good-enough citizens. Peacetime crimes, such as prison construction sold as economic development to impoverished communities in the mountains and deserts of California, or the evolution of the criminal industrial complex into the latest peculiar institution for managing race relations in the United States (Waquant, Chapter 39), constitute the “small wars and invisible genocides” to which we refer. This applies to African American and Latino youth mortality statistics in Oakland, California, Baltimore, Washington DC, and New York City. These are “invisible” genocides not because they are secreted away or hidden from view, but quite the opposite. As Wittgenstein observed, the things that are hardest to perceive are those which are right before our eyes and therefore taken for granted. In this regard, Bourdieu’s partial and unfinished theory of violence (see Chapters 32 and 42) as well as his concept of misrecognition is crucial to our task. By including the normative everyday forms of violence hidden in the minutiae of “normal” social practices - in the architecture of homes, in gender relations, in communal work, in the exchange of gifts, and so forth - Bourdieu forces us to reconsider the broader meanings and status of violence, especially the links between the violence of everyday life and explicit political terror and state repression, Similarly, Basaglia’s notion of “peacetime crimes” - crimini di pace - imagines a direct relationship between wartime and peacetime violence. Peacetime crimes suggests the possibility that war crimes are merely ordinary, everyday crimes of public consent applied systematically and dramatically in the extreme context of war. Consider the parallel uses of rape during peacetime and wartime, or the family resemblances between the legalized violence of US immigration and naturalization border raids on “illegal aliens” versus the US government- engineered genocide in 1938, known as the Cherokee “Trail of Tears.” Peacetime crimes suggests that everyday forms of state violence make a certain kind of domestic peace possible. Internal “stability” is purchased with the currency of peacetime crimes, many of which take the form of professionally applied “strangle-holds.” Everyday forms of state violence during peacetime make a certain kind of domestic “peace” possible. It is an easy-to-identify peacetime crime that is usually maintained as a public secret by the government and by a scared or apathetic populace. Most subtly, but no less politically or structurally, the phenomenal growth in the United States of a new military, postindustrial prison industrial complex has taken place in the absence of broad-based opposition, let alone collective acts of civil disobedience. The public consensus is based primarily on a new mobilization of an old fear of the mob, the mugger, the rapist, the Black man, the undeserving poor. How many public executions of mentally deficient prisoners in the United States are needed to make life feel more secure for the affluent? What can it possibly mean when incarceration becomes the “normative” socializing experience for ethnic minority youth in a society, i.e., over 33 percent of young African American men (Prison Watch 2002). In the end it is essential that we recognize the existence of a genocidal capacity among otherwise good-enough humans and that we need to exercise a defensive hypervigilance to the less dramatic, permitted, and even rewarded everyday acts of violence that render participation in genocidal acts and policies possible (under adverse political or economic conditions), perhaps more easily than we would like to recognize. Under the violence continuum we include, therefore, all expressions of radical social exclusion, dehumanization, depersonal- ization, pseudospeciation, and reification which normalize atrocious behavior and violence toward others. A constant self-mobilization for alarm, a state of constant hyperarousal is, perhaps, a reasonable response to Benjamin’s view of late modern history as a chronic “state of emergency” (Taussig, Chapter 31).

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Racism is an inherent part of income inequality – UBI helps mitigate the effects of distorted wealth accumulation and concurrent prejudice

Iannuzzi & Oishi, Assistant and Professor of Phycology, 21

(Jazmin Brown Iannuzzi, assistant professor at the University of Virginia, Shigehiro Oishi, professor of psychology at the University of Virginia, Racial Inequality at the Brink: How Economic Inequality Exacerbates Racial Prejudice and the Potential Alleviating Role of a Universal Basic Income”, https://www.russellsage.org/sites/default/files/racialprej_LOI_example.pdf-grh)

In the U.S., both economic inequality and racial economic inequality – or the unequal distribution of financial resources across racial groups – is large and growing. From 1983 to 2016, the median White family went from approximately 8 times to 13 times more wealth than the median Black family (Pew, 2016). More recently, the pandemic has left Black families more vulnerable to death by COVID-19 and its economic shocks (Hardy & Logan, 2020; Wrigley-Field, 2020). Making matters worse, data suggest that income inequality precedes rises in White-on-Black racial prejudice (Connor et al., 2019; see also Hovland & Sears, 1940). Unfortunately, little empirical data investigates how inequality impacts individuals’ psychological processing and, in turn, increases prejudice. And, almost no work investigates the impact of inequality on racial minorities (Bianchi, 2020). Critically, inequality could also exacerbate prejudice between low-social power groups, stifling coalition building across these groups. The global pandemic’s widening of economic inequality makes now a crucial moment for understanding how inequality may exacerbate prejudice and for developing effective strategies to mitigate this process’s dire outcomes. The current application (1) puts forth a new hypothesis: inequality group-competition hypothesis, and (2) examines whether a policy, such as universal basic income, could mitigate the impact of inequality on prejudice (see Figure 1). We hypothesize that higher inequality triggers beliefs that people are in competition for limited resources because people tend to think the economy is zero-sum, meaning that one person’s higher earnings implies others’ lower earnings (Friedman & Friedman, 1990; related work see Buttrick & Oishi, 2017; Sommet et al., 2017). Perceiving others as competitors for scarce resources increases individuals’ concerns about their individual position and their groups’ position within society (Elliot, 2006; Esses et al., 2001). Status concerns activate both the desire to gain more resources for the self and group, as well as fear of losing relative position in the socioeconomic hierarchy (e.g., Davidai & Ongis, 2019; Sommet et al., 2017). Further, because inequality fosters the mindset of living in an intensely competitive environment, residents may be particularly attuned to group membership cues, such as race, as a way to determine whether someone has the potential to be economically beneficial (because they are ingroup member) or harmful (because they are an outgroup member). Providing for basic needs via a universal basic income may mitigate the impact of higher inequality on increasing prejudice by assuaging people’s zero-sum biases and their fears that others are competing for limited resources. However, to whom basic income is provided must be carefully considered to mitigate resentment toward a specific income and racial group.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

UBI solves poverty – empirics

Rutger Bergman, journalist, March 6, 2017, “Utopian thinking: the easy way to eradicate poverty,” The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/06/utopian-thinking-poverty-universalbasic-income.

It’s an incredibly simple idea: universal basic income – a monthly allowance of enough to pay for your basic needs: food, shelter, education. And it’s completely unconditional: not a favour, but a right. But could it really be that simple? In the three years that followed, I read all I could find about basic income. I researched dozens of experiments that have been conducted across the globe. And it didn’t take long before I stumbled upon the story of a town that had done it, had eradicated poverty – after which nearly everyone forgot about it. This story starts in Winnipeg, Canada. Imagine a warehouse attic where nearly 2,000 boxes lie gathering dust. They are filled with data – graphs, tables, interviews – about one of the most fascinating social experiments ever conducted. Evelyn Forget, an economics professor at the University of Manitoba, first heard about the records in 2009. Stepping into the attic, she could hardly believe her eyes. It was a treasure trove of information on basic income. The experiment had started in Dauphin, a town north-west of Winnipeg, in 1974. Everybody was guaranteed a basic income ensuring that no one fell below the poverty line. And for four years, all went well. But then a conservative government was voted into power. The new Canadian cabinet saw little point in the expensive experiment. So when it became clear there was no money left for an analysis of the results, the researchers decided to pack their files away. In 2,000 boxes. When Forget found them, 30 years later, no one knew what, if anything, the experiment had demonstrated. For three years she subjected the data to all manner of statistical analysis. And no matter what she tried, the results were the same every time. The experiment – the longest and best of its kind – had been a resounding success.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Poverty’s continued structural violence makes extinction and war inevitable

Szentes, Professor Emeritus at the Corvinus University of Budapest, 2008 (Tamás Szentes 08,. “Globalisation and prospects of the world society” 4/22/08 http://www.eadi.org/fileadmin/Documents/Events/exco/Glob.___prospects_-_jav..pdf)

It’ s a common place that human society can survive and develop only in a lasting real peace. Without peace countries cannot develop. Although since 1945 there has been no world war, but --numerous local wars took place, --terrorism has spread all over the world, undermining security even in the most developed and powerful countries, --arms race and militarisation have not ended with the collapse of the Soviet bloc, but escalated and continued, extending also to weapons of mass destruction and misusing enormous resources badly needed for development, --many “invisible wars” are suffered by the poor and oppressed people, manifested in mass misery, poverty, unemployment, homelessness, starvation and malnutrition, epidemics and poor health conditions, exploitation and oppression, racial and other discrimination, physical terror, organised injustice, disguised forms of violence, the denial or regular infringement of the democratic rights of citizens, women, youth, ethnic or religious minorities, etc., and last but not least, in the degradation of human environment, which means that --the “war against Nature”, i.e. the disturbance of ecological balance, wasteful management of natural resources, and large-scale pollution of our environment, is still going on, causing also losses and fatal dangers for human life. Behind global terrorism and “invisible wars” we find striking international and intrasociety inequities and distorted development patterns , which tend to generate social as well as international tensions, thus paving the way for unrest and “visible” wars. It is a commonplace now that peace is not merely the absence of war. The prerequisites of a lasting peace between and within societies involve not only - though, of course, necessarily - demilitarisation, but also a systematic and gradual elimination of the roots of violence, of the causes of “invisible wars”, of the structural and institutional bases of large-scale international and intra-society inequalities, exploitation and oppression. Peace requires a process of social and national emancipation, a progressive, democratic transformation of societies and the world bringing about equal rights and opportunities for all people, sovereign participation and mutually advantageous co-operation among nations. It further requires a pluralistic democracy on global level with an appropriate system of proportional representation of the world society, articulation of diverse interests and their peaceful reconciliation, by non-violent conflict management, and thus also a global governance with a really global institutional system. Under the contemporary conditions of accelerating globalisation and deepening global interdependencies in our world, peace is indivisible in both time and space. It cannot exist if reduced to a period only after or before war, and cannot be safeguarded in one part of the world when some others suffer visible or invisible wars. Thus, peace requires, indeed, a new, demilitarised and democratic world order, which can provide equal opportunities for sustainable development. “Sustainability of development” (both on national and world level) is often interpreted as an issue of environmental protection only and reduced to the need for preserving the ecological balance and delivering the next generations not a destroyed Nature with overexhausted resources and polluted environment. However, no ecological balance can be ensured, unless the deep international development gap and intra-society inequalities are substantially reduced. Owing to global interdependencies there may exist hardly any “zero-sum-games”, in which one can gain at the expense of others, but, instead, the “negative-sum-games” tend to predominate, in which everybody must suffer, later or sooner, directly or indirectly, losses. Therefore, the actual question is not about “sustainability of development” but rather about the “sustainability of human life”, i.e. survival of mankind – because of ecological imbalance and globalised terrorism. When Professor Louk de la Rive Box was the president of EADI, one day we had an exchange of views on the state and future of development studies. We agreed that development studies are not any more restricted to the case of underdeveloped countries, as the developed ones (as well as the former “socialist” countries) are also facing development problems, such as those of structural and institutional (and even system-) transformation, requirements of changes in development patterns, and concerns about natural environment. While all these are true, today I would dare say that besides (or even instead of) “development studies” we must speak about and make “survival studies”. While the monetary, financial, and debt crises are cyclical, we live in an almost permanent crisis of the world society, which is multidimensional in nature, involving not only economic but also socio-psychological, behavioural, cultural and political aspects. The narrow-minded, election-oriented, selfish behaviour motivated by thirst for power and wealth, which still characterise the political leadership almost all over the world, paves the way for the final, last catastrophe. One cannot doubt, of course, that great many positive historical changes have also taken place in the world in the last century. Such as decolonisation, transformation of socio-economic systems, democratisation of political life in some former fascist or authoritarian states, institutionalisation of welfare policies in several countries, rise of international organisations and new forums for negotiations, conflict management and cooperation, institutionalisation of international assistance programmes by multilateral agencies, codification of human rights, and rights of sovereignty and democracy also on international level, collapse of the militarised Soviet bloc and system-change3 in the countries concerned, the end of cold war, etc., to mention only a few. Nevertheless, the crisis of the world society has extended and deepened, approaching to a point of bifurcation that necessarily puts an end to the present tendencies, either by the final catastrophe or a common solution. Under the circumstances provided by rapidly progressing science and technological revolutions, human society cannot survive unless such profound intra-society and international inequalities prevailing today are soon eliminated. Like a single spacecraft, the Earth can no longer afford to have a 'crew' divided into two parts: the rich, privileged, wellfed, well-educated, on the one hand, and the poor, deprived, starving, sick and uneducated, on the other. Dangerous 'zero-sum-games' (which mostly prove to be “negative-sum-games”) can hardly be played any more by visible or invisible wars in the world society. Because of global interdependencies, the apparent winner becomes also a loser. The real choice for the world society is between negative- and positive-sum-games: i.e. between, on the one hand, continuation of visible and “invisible wars”, as long as this is possible at all, and, on the other, transformation of the world order by demilitarisation and democratization. No ideological or terminological camouflage can conceal this real dilemma any more, which is to be faced not in the distant future, by the next generations, but in the coming years, because of global terrorism soon having nuclear and other mass destructive weapons, and also due to irreversible changes in natural environment.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

UBI solves homelessness – promotes choice in housing and improves health and well-being.

Kerman, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health 21’

[Nick, 9-28-2021, International Journal on Homelessness, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness,” The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness | International Journal on Homelessness (uwo.ca), 6/26, DG]

Using a homelessness prevention framework (Dej et al., 2020; Oudshoorn et al., 2020), UBI would constitute structural prevention through its alteration of legislation and policy that promotes primordial stabilization and tertiary intervention. The former focuses on policy-level preconditions of social issues, such as financial security, whereas the latter involves mitigation of the harmful effects of existing problems, or homelessness in this case (Oudshoorn et al., 2020). Operating on the assumption that UBI would provide a level of income that is sufficient for meeting all physiological needs, there are four mechanisms for how UBI could help to structurally prevent and end homelessness: (a) reducing values-based exclusion in the provision of income supports, (b) promoting choice in housing, (c) facilitating workforce returns and buffering against automation job losses, and (d) improving health and well-being in another form of means testing. By providing cash payments that do not fluctuate as a result of housing status, UBI would enable people experiencing homelessness to save the money that would have been allocated to paying rent or living costs. Like the New Leaf projectthat provided a large, lump sum cash payment to people experiencing homelessness (Foundations for Social Change, 2020), accumulated UBI income during homelessness could help people to afford a rent deposit (e.g., first and last month’s rent) and expedite exits out of homelessness.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Unaddressed homelessness splinters society and creates a population who are alienated and diminished – the homeless are deemed “disposable”

Saumya Kalia is an Associate Editor at The Swaddle ’22. “ Her journalism and writing explore issues of social justice, digital sub-cultures, media ecosystem, literature, and memory as they cut across socio-cultural periods, “People Who Are Homeless Are Unfairly Criminalized, Suggests New Study,” THE SWADDLE, https://theswaddle.com/people-who-are-homeless-are-unfairly-criminalized-suggests-new-study/

In 2009, researcher Sylvia Walby wrote of crises, and the ways they deceive us. “Crises are both ‘real,’ in the sense of actual changes in social processes, and socially constructed, in the sense that different interpretations of the crisis have implications for its outcome.”

The home, and the absence of it, are sites of crisis too. Homelessness is growing to be a feature of the modern urban landscape; as cities grow, the rights of people to claim space in these development utopias dwindles. Much of this is justified through myth-making about criminality and deviance: if people are destitute, they must have led themselves there, goes the popular belief. But in this picture of scarcity, what is real, and how much of it is constructed?

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Homelessness is increasing – creates cycles of individual and community suffering which multiply

Homeless Link ’22, 07 April, “What is the impact of homelessness?” https://homeless.org.uk/knowledge-hub/what-is-the-impact-of-homelessness/

Not having a home as a stable and secure base can make it harder for people to find a job, stay healthy and maintain relationships. People often experience feelings of isolation, increasing their chances of taking drugs or experiencing mental health problems. Did you know: Sometimes, issues that people believe cause homelessness are actually a result of homelessness, such as substance abuse and poor mental health. Evidence suggests that the longer someone is homeless, the more complex their problems become and the more difficult it can be to get back on their feet. Physical Health Issues People with no home often have complex health needs. The mean age at death of homeless people was 46 years for men, 43 years for women. This compares to 76 years for men and 81 years for women in the general population.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

UBI creates an environment of dignity inside and outside the workforce

Juliana Bidadanure – Faculty Director, Stanford Basic Income Lab and Assistant Professor in Philosophy, Stanford University, et al. ’18, Sean Kline – Director, San Francisco Office of Financial Empowerment; Camille Moore – Former Carnegie Mellon Heinz Fellow, Center for City Solutions, National League of Cities; Brooks Rainwater – Senior Executive and Director, Center for City Solutions, National League of Cities; Catherine Thomas – Graduate Fellow, Stanford Basic Income Lab and PhD candidate in Psychology, Stanford University, “Basic Income In Cities A guide to city experiments and pilot projects,” NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES, https://www.nlc.org/resource/universal-basic-income-whos-piloting-it/

UBI raises the floor so people can live with dignity. It also empowers individuals to make choices with greater liberty. With a sufficiently high guaranteed income, recipients would have more freedom to say no to abusive, demeaning or dull jobs; and they would have the freedom to say yes to a multi-sided existence with more time for care, education and training.

In fact, many have taken an interest in UBI on grounds of gender justice. Women are more likely to take on roles caring for the elderly and children — both career paths that typically pay poorly. If we believe that care for our aging population and for the next generation are central to a healthy society, then we should also promote and enable care work. UBI, it is hoped, would give workers the ability to dedicate more time to this important work. Moreover, under most welfare systems, the dependent of a rich-enough spouse is not eligible for cash benefits of their own. This has proved disastrous for those in abusive households with financial dependency. Once again, women have been historically more likely to find themselves excluded from existing safety nets. UBI would help remedy this problem.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Dignity is a prerequisite to utilitarianism

Heyns, Professor of Human Rights Law, University of Pretoria, ‘16 [Christof, Human Rights Quarterly 38 (2016) 350–378 “ Human Rights and the use of Autonomous Weapons Systems (AWS) During Domestic Law Enforcement” Acc 12/27/20 TA]

There are different conceptions of dignity. For example, it has a religious connotation for some and is tied up with the belief that humans are created in the image of God (imago Dei);87 others rely on the Kantian notion that each person should be treated as an end and not as a means.88 Dignity can also be seen as related to the capacity of someone to be a moral person and as moral responsibility.89 Violations of dignity often take the form of physical infringements of the person, but it is not confined to that—not being able to act out one’s moral choices could be another form of indignity. Underlying the concept of dignity is a strong emphasis on the idea of the infinite or incommensurable value of each person.90 The Kantian concept of dignity assigns this value to each person as a separate and unique, or irreplaceable, individual. Acts of indignity involve an unwarranted reduction of this worth. Each person has an inner core that may not be infringed upon, even if such infringement would be beneficial to the common good because that would mean they are used as a tool. Individual dignity cannot be accounted for properly within schemes of instrumental rationality, where competing claims are measured against each other based on their assigned weights, because each human being is considered to be of infinite value.91 Exactly whose dignity is potentially at stake? In the first place, I would submit, the concern should be about the dignity of those at the receiving end of the force used: those targeted as well as those caught in the crossfire.92 Secondly, the dignity of those in whose name force is used may also be at stake. The effect of AWS on the dignity of these two different categories will now be considered in turn. How does the use of AWS impact the dignity of those subjected to the use of force? It has been argued that to have the decision whether one lives or dies being made by machines is the ultimate indignity and similar arguments can be made about other forms of force, especially if they are potentially lethal or can seriously maim. 93 A machine, bloodless and without morality or mortality, cannot fathom the significance of using force against a human being and cannot do justice to the gravity of the decision.94 Each instance where force is used against a human being requires that another human being should decide afresh whether to cross that threshold. The heuristic argumentation used by computers fails to capture and do justice the complexity and fullness of human life and decisions about life. Robots cannot be preprogrammed to respond in an appropriate way to the infinite number of scenarios that real life—and real people—offer.95 Death by algorithm means that people are treated simply as targets and not as complete and unique human beings, who may, by virtue of that status, meet a different fate. They are placed in a position where an appeal to the humanity of the person on the other side is not possible. Some have argued that people in such situations are treated like pests or objects, as a nuisance that must be gotten rid of, rather than as someone with inherent dignity.96 When someone comes into the sights of a computer, that person is literally reduced to numbers: the zeros and the ones of bits.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Dignity is key to universalizing human worth

Applbaum, Professor of Ethics and Public Policy at the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, ‘98 [Arthur "Are Violations of Rights Ever Right?*." Ethics 108.2 (1998): 340-366 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

Since we think of ourselves as beings that matter, consistency demands that we extend that status to others. Says Nagel, ‘‘I believe, as did Kant, that what drives us in the direction of universal- izability is the difficulty each person has in regarding himself as having value only for himself, but not in himself. If people are not ends in themselves—i.e. impersonally valuable—then they have a much lower order of worth.’’ If one wishes to view and value oneself as a being that is an end in itself, and not as a means to be used for the ends of others, then the status of an end must be extended to others. The violation of other persons—using them as means—therefore is an impersonal bad, something we all have reason to avoid and prevent. But if such violation is bad, why should we not seek to minimize violations, even if that sometimes requires a lesser violation? Because a violation-minimizing violation uses one as a means for the ends of others and so fails to treat persons as ends in themselves. If persons are to matter in the highest possible way, then morality must value not only the absence of violations of persons, but the treatment of persons as beings who have the status of being inviolable—whose violation is not permissible. ‘‘What actually happens to us is not the only thing we care about: What may be done to us is also important, quite apart from whether or not it is done to us—and the same is true of what we may do as opposed to what we actually do.’’ Since having the status of inviolability is of great value, if morality permits violations so as to maximize the good of not being violated, all persons cease to have a high degree of inviolability, which is a great bad. We all may be better off in a world in which morality always treated us as ends, and so where it is always morally impermissible to violate us, even though we are thereby more likely to suffer violation at the hands of immoral actors

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Welfare and means-testing are a cruel price to pay for basic needs – first they lose their job, then bureaucracy strips recipients of dignity

Bregman, historian, ‘16

[Rutger Bregman, M.A., UCLA, journalist, and Dutch historian, UTOPIA FOR REALISTS: THE CASE FOR A UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME, OPEN BORDERS, AND A 15-HOUR WORKWEEK, translated by Elizabeth Manton, The Correspondent, 2016, epub]

Futile? For the first time in history, we are actually rich enough to finance a sizable basic income. We can get rid of the whole bureaucratic rigamarole designed to force assistance recipients into low-productivity jobs at any cost, and we can help finance the new simplified system by chucking the maze of tax credits and deductions, too. Any further necessary funds can be raised by taxing assets, waste, raw materials, and consumption.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Must adjust for automation or inequality will continue to rise

Peter Dizikes- writer at the MIT News Office, ‘23 MIT Technology Review. Automation drives income inequality. . February 21, 2023. Accessed: 06/15/23. AR.

When you use self-checkout machines in supermarkets and drugstores, you are probably not—with all due respect—doing a better job of bagging your purchases than checkout clerks once did. But such automation lets employers cut spending on labor in a way that has contributed significantly to income inequality in the US. A new study coauthored by MIT economist Daron Acemoglu estimates just how much: replacing workers with technology “explains 50 to 70%” of the increase in inequality from 1980 to about 2016. Acemoglu and coauthor Pascual Restrepo, PhD ’16, looked at US Bureau of Economic Analysis statistics on the extent to which human labor was used in 49 industries from 1987 to 2016—as well as data on machinery and software adopted in that time—alongside Census Bureau metrics on worker outcomes for roughly 500 demographic subgroups, broken out by gender, education, age, race and ethnicity, and immigration status. They concluded that since 1980, automation has reduced the wages of men without a high school degree by 8.8% and women without a high school degree by 2.3%, adjusted for inflation. Incomes for people with college and postgraduate degrees have risen substantially during that period. Moreover, they say that although these specific innovations have been good for the corporate bottom line, they have not yielded much in the way of productivity gains that would improve overall quality of life. “These are controversial findings in the sense that they imply a much bigger effect for automation than anyone else has thought,” Acemoglu says.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence

Rapid widespread labor automation is inevitable – basic income is a safety net for people becoming more vulnerable as tech advances

Kelly, RMIT University in Melbourne, ‘22

Kelly, Lauren. School of Media and Communication, RMIT University, Melbourne Australia, “Re-politicising the future of work: Automation anxieties, universal basic income, and the end of techno-optimism.” Journal of Sociology, 0(0). . October 9, 2022. Accessed: 06/15/23. AR.

Predicting the technological future of work is back on the academic agenda, exemplified by the swathe of influential literature published on the subject since the mid-2010s (Brynjolfsson & McAfee, 2014; Ford, 2015; Frey & Osborne, 2013; Kaplan, 2015; Schwab, 2016; Susskind & Susskind, 2015). While history has often been punctuated by concerns of technological job loss (Gorz, 1999; Keynes, 1930; Leontief & Duchin, 1986; Rifkin, 1995), it is now argued that this time it’s different due to advances in particular technologies – namely robotics, big data, and artificial intelligence. The rise of smart machines and automated decision-making technologies now threatens non-routine, professional, and even creative occupations that were, until recently, considered immune to automation. Assumptions of inevitable job loss are widespread and reproduced through the policy recommendations of international organisations, influential consultancy firms, and government white papers.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › 1AC Plan & Solvency – Progressive Income Tax

Any trade-offs with other social services are good – welfare has failed

Thomas Straubhaar, University of Hamburg, ’17. “On the Economics of a Universal Basic Income,” INTERECONOMICS, Volume 52, 2017 · Number 2 · pp. 74–80, accessed June 29, 2023, https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2017/number/2/article/on-the-economics-of-a-universal-basic-income.html

While the extent of redistribution requires a (normative) political discussion, the (positive) economic analysis can convincingly demonstrate that a “blind” social policy is the most effective, most efficient and thus the most equitable social policy.21 An efficient social policy should support people, and not specific factors of production or regional or sectoral industries. Furthermore, it should refrain from paternalistic behaviour and simply flow unconditionally. The fundamental aim should be to redistribute some degree of purchasing power from people with higher incomes to those with lower incomes. Direct individual payments to economically weaker people are more targeted, less expensive and more effective than indirect measures which require the fulfilment of specific criteria, particular preconditions or certain behaviours, for example, the requirement of being employed or at least searching for employment, or the attainment of a specified age.

It is part of the tragedy of a misunderstood social policy that it attempts to reach a political goal with unsuitable means. Social-politically motivated interventions in the markets’ mechanisms are inappropriate. In many cases, they provoke outcomes that are the opposite of what should be achieved. They lead to unnecessary duplicate structures and an expensive bureaucracy. Many people receive financial support through the current procedure via the social insurance system, only to have that support contradicted through the tax system.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › 1AC Plan & Solvency – Progressive Income Tax

Studies prove UBI solves

Lu, Science Writer at Guardian Australia, 2020

[Donna, 5/6/20, NewScientist, “Universal basic income seems to improve employment and well-being,” https://www.newscientist.com/article/2242937-universal-basic-income-seems-to-improve-employment-and-well-being/, 6/27/23, PE, accessed June 29, 2023]

The world’s most robust study of universal basic income has concluded that it boosts recipients’ mental and financial well-being, as well as modestly improving employment. Finland ran a two-year universal basic income study in 2017 and 2018, during which the government gave 2000 unemployed people aged between 25 and 58 monthly payments with no strings attached. The payments of €560 per month weren’t means tested and were unconditional, so they weren’t reduced if an individual got a job or later had a pay rise. The study was nationwide and selected recipients weren’t able to opt out, because the test was written into legislation. Minna Ylikännö at the Social Insurance Institution of Finland announced the findings in Helsinki today via livestream. The study compared the employment and well-being of basic income recipients against a control group of 173,000 people who were on unemployment benefits. Between November 2017 and October 2018, people on basic income worked an average of 78 days, which was six days more than those on unemployment benefits. There was a greater increase in employment for people in families with children, as well as those whose first language wasn’t Finnish or Swedish – but the researchers aren’t yet sure why. When surveyed, people who received universal basic income instead of regular unemployment benefits reported better financial well-being, mental health and cognitive functioning, as well as higher levels of confidence in the future. When asked whether basic income could help people dealing with situations such as the economic fallout of the covid-19 pandemic, Ylikännö said that it could help alleviate stress at an uncertain time. “I think it would bring people security in very insecure situations when they don’t know whether they’re going to have an income,” she said. The findings suggest that basic income doesn’t seem to provide a disincentive for people to work. However, the effect of basic income was complicated by legislation known as the “activation model”, which the Finnish government introduced at the beginning of 2018. It made the conditions for accessing unemployment benefits stricter. The timing made it difficult to separate the effects of the basic income experiment from the policy change, said Ylikännö. “We can only say that the employment effect that we observed was as a joint result of the experiment and activation model,” she said. Preliminary findings, released in February last year, had previously found no difference between the two groups for the number of days worked in 2017. “Money matters, but alone it’s not sufficient to significantly promote either labour supply or demand,” said Ylikännö.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › 1AC Plan & Solvency – Progressive Income Tax

Progressive taxation funds the plan – best balance of welfare and growth

JEFF SPROSS ’19, SEPTEMBER 24, “Andrew Yang's UBI problem,” THE WEEK, https://theweek.com/articles/858097/andrew-yangs-ubi-problem

Having people choose between the UBI check and their existing welfare benefits is meant to save the government money. But simply adding the annual cost of Yang's $1,000-a-month Freedom Dividend to all existing spending — state, local and federal — would still leave America with less government spending than France as a share of GDP. Granted, that's no small political task, but it's entirely doable from a budgeting and basic economic perspective. Meanwhile, Yang could get the additional financing he needs by increasing the progressive income tax the U.S. already has, starting from the top down. That would avoid the regressive hit to struggling Americans that comes with a VAT. If you're going to do something as wildly ambitious as call for a national UBI, you might as well call for a return to Franklin Roosevelt's income tax rates while you're at it.

Finally, it's worth dwelling on the larger narrative Yang tells for why he thinks the country needs his Freedom Dividend. Basically, he argues that automation and robotics are going to wipe out large segments of the workforce, and a UBI is needed to catch the people who fall through the cracks. This prediction has clearly fired up a lot of Yang's supporters, but it's far from obvious that future disruptions brought by automation will be any worse than what our economy's already endured for the last two centuries.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › 1AC Plan & Solvency – Progressive Income Tax

Raising taxes on the rich to fund UBI is topical and optimal in terms of feasible solvency

Stephen Nuñez ’20, January 17, “UBI & the City,” PHENOMENAL WORLD, https://www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/universal-basic-income-the-city/

The progressive income tax, which at baseline mirrors the actual marginal tax rates in New York City, is altered to finance this new expenditure. Income taxes can be adjusted by shifting the tax level without altering its progressivity (the relative difference in marginal tax rates across income categories remains constant) or by directly altering the progressivity. In the latter case, for example, one could alter marginal tax rates for the very wealthy without changing them for lower and middle income households. The paper explores financing the UBI through separate changes to the income tax’s level and progressivity, and builds a foundation to test optimal combinations of the two.

Like all such models, the paper’s DSSE has some important limitations. Because interest rates are exogenously given and do not change in response to taxes or savings behavior, the model effectively excludes bond markets from general equilibrium calculations. This is a reasonable assumption when looking at city-level policy; what happens in NYC alone does not have a large effect on national bond markets or interest rates. It is also a reasonable assumption when analyzing small open economies in an international setting, as the central banks of economically smaller countries have little control over the price of borrowing in international bond markets. Second, because the policy analyzed is city-level, the revenue to fund it is raised entirely within the city and only city residents receive it. At the US federal level, safety net policy is not subject to that constraint: states may raise more revenue for a program than their residents receive or vice versa. Taken together, these features mean we should exercise caution in extrapolating from city-level analysis to a national level guaranteed income policy.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › Advantage [ ] – Competitiveness

UBI supercharges American AI advancement – key to collaboration and investment in projects the government is already forwarding

MaMo TechnoLabs ’23, April 14, 2023, “Tech and AI: How Progress and Peril Have Shaped Our Changing World,” https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/tech-ai-how-progress-peril-have-shaped-our-changing-world/

To sum up, there is an urgent need for increased collaboration between government, industry, and civil society to ensure the fair and equitable sharing of the benefits brought about by technology developments and artificial intelligence. Programmes like the universal basic income, which would ensure that everybody get a basic income regardless of whether or not they are working, might help achieve this goal. Activities like this may help make sure that the benefits of technology progress and AI are shared more widely and that no one is left behind.

Conclusion

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Big stick v.2*** › Advantage [ ] – Economy

Prefer our long-term projections – their ev is a mere “snapshot” – even if growth will ‘tick up’ at times, the overall trend is downward without the plan

** Can save for 2AC **

Gee Lefevre et al, Jessica Egan & Adam Hobbs, ’23, March 8, “U.S. Economic Outlook 2023: A ‘Soft Landing’ or ‘Deep Recession’” TENEO – a global CEO advisory firm,

The U.S. government is currently trying to navigate its economy through a challenging inflationary period and orchestrate an outcome that has never been achieved. In other words, manage the dual challenges that rising inflation and rising interest rates have on economic growth while avoiding a recession and achieving its fabled soft landing.