Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC T – UBI*** › T – redistribution

UBI is redistribution

Thomas Straubhaar, University of Hamburg, ’17. “On the Economics of a Universal Basic Income,” INTERECONOMICS, Volume 52, 2017 · Number 2 · pp. 74–80, https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2017/number/2/article/on-the-economics-of-a-universal-basic-income.html

Many scholars, such as Nobel laureate Christopher Pissarides, believe it is important to search for more clever strategies to cope with the challenges of digitisation:

…we need to develop a new system of redistributions, new policies that will redistribute inevitably from those that the market would have rewarded in favour of those that the market would have left behind. Now, having a universal minimum income is one of those ways, in fact, it is one I am very much in favour of, as long as we know how to apply it without taking away incentive to work at the lower end of the market.14

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › A2 econ resilient

No resilience – economy is structurally set to crumble

Geoff Crocker- economist and author with 25 years of industry strategy consulting experience. Springer International Publishing. Basic Income and Sovereign Money: The Alternative to Economic Crisis and Austerity Policy. 2020. . Accessed 6/08/23.

The post-war model of economic management is in crisis and needs urgent adjustment. The free market mixture of private investment, pro- duction and consumption, combined with government expenditure and fiscal and monetary policy, has worked reasonably well. It has delivered a general increased standard of living, and relatively stable economies. This relative success owes much to technology. In earlier agrarian economies, and in initial industrial economies, productivity was low, and output insufficient to provide an adequate standard of living. Need exceeded supply, poverty was widespread, people were ill-clothed and ill- fed, partly because as Keynes showed, need was not translated into effective demand via adequate wages, but also because output was limited by low productivity technology. Major advances in technology throughout the twentieth century mean that productivity rose astronomically, such that potential output in the 'machine age' is adequate, and it is now effective demand which is not fully funded. This in turn feeds back to impose a limit on productive output. This then threatens employment, and since employment is the main means of income, standards of living are compromised. But we now face partial system failure, generating seriously dysfunctional outcomes of economic crisis, actual or likely to repeat, pervasive debt, both household and government, continuous austerity policy, extensive poverty, low pay jobs, increased inequality, ecological damage.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › A2 UBI bankrupts the US

Err AFF – there’s always more money

Heller, The New Yorker Socioeconomic Journalist, 18

[Nathan Heller, July 2 2018, The New Yorker, “Who Really Stand to Win From Universal Basic Income,” , 6/25/2023, EJ]

By Lowrey’s assessment, the existing system “would falter and fail if confronted with vast inequality and tidal waves of joblessness.” But is a U.B.I. fiscally sustainable? It’s unclear. Lowrey runs many numbers but declines to pin most of them down. She thinks a U.B.I. in the United States should be a thousand dollars monthly. This means $3.9 trillion a year, close to the current expenditure of the entire federal government. To pay, Lowrey proposes new taxes on income, carbon, estates, pollution, and the like. But she is also curiously sanguine about costs, on the premise that few major initiatives balance out on the federal books: “The Bush tax cuts were not ‘paid for.’ The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were not ‘paid for.’ ” When the country wants to launch a big project, she insists, the double joints and stretchy tendons of a giant, globalized economy come into play.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › Econ impact

Economic collapse would hurt global order—and wipe out roughly 7.8 million jobs

WISEMAN, Associated Press, 5-22-23’

[Paul, 5-22-23’, Oklahoma News 4, “What it would mean for the global economy if the US defaults on its debt,” https://kfor.com/news/international/ap-what-it-would-mean-for-the-global-economy-if-the-us-defaults-on-its-debt/, 6-26, DG]

WASHINGTON (AP) — If the debt crisis roiling Washington were eventually to send the United States crashing into recession, America’s economy would hardly sink alone. The repercussions of a first-ever default on the federal debt would quickly reverberate around the world. Orders for Chinese factories that sell electronics to the United States could dry up. Swiss investors who own U.S. Treasurys would suffer losses. Sri Lankan companies could no longer deploy dollars as an alternative to their own dodgy currency. “No corner of the global economy will be spared” if the U.S. government defaulted and the crisis weren’t resolved quickly, said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics. Zandi and two colleagues at Moody’s have concluded that even if the debt limit were breached for no more than week, the U.S. economy would weaken so much, so fast, as to wipe out roughly1.5 million jobs. And if a government default were to last much longer — well into the summer — the consequences would be far more dire, Zandi and his colleagues found in their analysis: U.S. economic growth would sink, 7.8 million American jobs would vanish, borrowing rates would jump, the unemployment rate would soar from the current 3.4% to 8% and a stock-market plunge would erase $10 trillion in household wealth.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › Econ impact

Economic collapse will cause war

Liu, Managing Director 18’

[Qian, 11-13-2018, World Economic Forum, “The next economic crisis could cause a global conflict. Here's why,” https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/11/the-next-economic-crisis-could-cause-a-global-conflict-heres-why, 6-26, DG]

The next economic crisis is closer than you think. But what you should really worry about is what comes after: in the current social, political, and technological landscape, a prolonged economic crisis, combined with rising income inequality, could well escalate into a major global military conflict. The 2008-09 global financial crisis almost bankrupted governments and caused systemic collapse. Policymakers managed to pull the global economy back from the brink, using massive monetary stimulus, including quantitative easing and near-zero (or even negative) interest rates. But monetary stimulus is like an adrenaline shot to jump-start an arrested heart; it can revive the patient, but it does nothing to cure the disease. Treating a sick economy requires structural reforms, which can cover everything from financial and labor markets to tax systems, fertility patterns, and education policies. Policymakers have utterly failed to pursue such reforms, despite promising to do so. Instead, they have remained preoccupied with politics. From Italy to Germany, forming and sustaining governments now seems to take more time than actual governing. And Greece, for example, has relied on money from international creditors to keep its head (barely) above water, rather than genuinely reforming its pension system or improving its business environment. The lack of structural reform has meant that the unprecedented excess liquidity that central banks injected into their economies was not allocated to its most efficient uses. Instead, it raised global asset prices to levels even higher than those prevailing before 2008. In the United States, housing prices are now 8% higher than they were at the peak of the property bubble in 2006, according to the property website Zillow. The price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio, which measures whether stock-market prices are within a reasonable range, is now higher than it was both in 2008 and at the start of the Great Depression in 1929. As monetary tightening reveals the vulnerabilities in the real economy, the collapse of asset-price bubbles will trigger another economic crisis – one that could be even more severe than the last, because we have built up a tolerance to our strongest macroeconomic medications. A decade of regular adrenaline shots, in the form of ultra-low interest rates and unconventional monetary policies, has severely depleted their power to stabilize and stimulate the economy. If history is any guide, the consequences of this mistake could extend far beyond the economy. According to Harvard’s Benjamin Friedman, prolonged periods of economic distress have been characterized also by public antipathy toward minority groups or foreign countries – attitudes that can help to fuel unrest, terrorism, or even war. For example, during the Great Depression, US President Herbert Hoover signed the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, intended to protect American workers and farmers from foreign competition. In the subsequent five years, global trade shrank by two-thirds. Within a decade, World War II had begun. To be sure, WWII, like World War I, was caused by a multitude of factors; there is no standard path to war. But there is reason to believe that high levels of inequality can play a significant role in stoking conflict. According to research by the economist Thomas Piketty, a spike in income inequality is often followed by a great crisis. Income inequality then declines for a while, before rising again, until a new peak – and a new disaster. Though causality has yet to be proven, given the limited number of data points, this correlation should not be taken lightly, especially with wealth and income inequality at historically high levels.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › US key to global econ

Globe Follows Heavily With US Cyclical Trends

Kose, World Bank Group Deputy Chief Economist, et al., 17

[M. Ayhan Kose, Csilla Lakatos, Prospects Group of the Macroeconomics, Trade & Investment Global Practice Senior Economist, Franziska Ohnsorge, World Bank Manager of the Prospects Group in the Equitable Growth, Finance and Institutions (EFI) Practice Group at the World Bank, Marc Stocker, World Bank Senior Economist, 10 Feb 2017, SSRN, “The Global Role of the U.S. Economy: Linkages, Policies and Spillovers, , 6/26/2023, EJ]

International business cycle synchronization tends to be particularly strong when the U.S. economy is in recession but, over the phases of the U.S. business cycle, GDP growth in the rest of the world correlates with the U.S. cycle substantially. For example, growth was on average higher in other advanced economies and EMDEs during periods of U.S. expansions than it was when the U.S. economy was in recession. More importantly, although the four recessions the global economy experienced since 1960 (1975, 1982, 1991, and 2009) were driven by a host of problems in many corners of the world, they all overlapped with severe recessions in the United States.5

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › UBI solves econ

Higher Incomes Increase Consumer Spending

Pettinger, Oxford Economics Teacher, 19

[Tejvan Pettinger, 25 Feb 2019, Economics Help, “Effect of minimum wage on economic growth, inflation and AD/AS,” , 6/26/2023, EJ]

Higher wages increase incomes and are likely to cause higher consumer spending. A significant increase in minimum wages could lead to higher growth. It could also contribute towards inflation for two reasons Higher costs for firms Higher spending by workers. However, the minimum wage is only one factor that affects growth and inflation. In the real world, the UK has seen above inflation increases in the minimum wage without any negative impact on inflation or unemployment – but only negligible impact on economic growth. Effect of higher minimum wages on economic growth If workers receive a pay increase, then there will be a rise in consumer spending. Low-income workers are likely to have a higher marginal propensity to consume (in other words they spend high % of extra pay). This could also cause a multiplier effect, with higher spending causing knock-on effects to elsewhere in the economy; this should help boost economic growth. However, if we assume labour markets are competitive and if we assume that a minimum wage does cause lower employment, then rising unemployment will have a negative impact on aggregate demand. People who become unemployed would spend less, leading to lower aggregate demand.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › UBI solves econ

UBI is the only solution to solve the debt spiral that leads to an economic crisis and austerity policy

Geoff Crocker- economist and author with 25 years of industry strategy consulting experience. Springer International Publishing. Basic Income and Sovereign Money: The Alternative to Economic Crisis and Austerity Policy. 2020. . Accessed 6/08/23.

This leads to an unavoidable requirement to supplement earned income with unearned income, which, as we show below, has indeed grown substantially in the form of pensions, welfare benefits, dividends, and household borrowing. Within unearned income, the share of dividends has grown, whilst the share of welfare benefits has declined, which immediately suggests mounting inequality. But it is the role of household borrowing which is of great concern, since it led, and is leading again, to unsustainable levels of indebtedness. Meanwhile, the increase in welfare benefits has pushed government budgets into continued deficit, which has led to huge government indebtedness. The economic system is inherently and recurrently generating household and government debt which have led to bank failure, economic crisis, and forced governments into austerity policies, which have reduced economic support for low income groups in society. At the same time, current financial orthodoxy insists that governments balance their budgets, at least in the long term. Given the technology- generated increased need for unearned income to sustain aggregate demand in the form of welfare benefits, government budgets are pushed into deficit. Financial orthodoxy then kicks in, and insists on deficit reduction. Hence austerity policy which reduces benefits to low income groups, and thereby further reduces aggregate demand. Low income groups are pushed into Further borrowing and debt and the perverse economic circle is reinforced The surprising but sustainable claim of this argument is that these negative outcomes are at least in part due to technology as it works through the current economic system. Since the high productivity enabled by technology is a source of huge potential economic benefit, then it requires us to radically re-engineer the economic systems to derive maximum human and environmental benefits from technology, and not to suffer adverse consequences from a perversely designed economic system which translates increased productivity into suppressed aggregate wage, deficient aggregate demand, economic crisis, government deficit constraints, the poverty of austerity, and environmental damage. The only solution to this is a basic income paid to everyone, to avoid household debt, and to fund this by sovereign money issued by government, without requiring the purchase of government bonds or the initial issue of those same government bonds, thus avoiding government debt and the austerity policy imposed by deficit reduction. If we are able to replace some part of household borrowing with basic income, then households would not bear unsustainable debt. This would not then lead to economic crisis like the 2007 crisis, which began with sub-prime US mortgage debt. Equally, if we could replace some part of government deficit with sovereign money, i.e. debt-free money issued directly to Fund basic income, as well as central and local government expenditure, then government expenditure would be constrained by real output GDP and not by artificial deficit spending constraints. This may read like a dreamland proposal, but the rest of this book works through the arguments which support it as the only real viable alternative to the endemic debt, crisis, and austerity policy of the present economic system.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › UBI solves econ

Basic Income is simple, accountable, and cost-efficient – Minimizes bureaucracy, administrative costs, and is easy to track

Dorn, University of South Carolina Honors College International Business and Finance Student, 23

[Chase, May 2023, University of South Carolina, “Free Money: The Feasibility of Implementing a Universal Basic Income in the United States”, https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/senior_theses/587/, accessed 6/27/2023, S.P.]

A universal basic income is the simplest and most equal form of welfare. Casting aside existing circumstance, giving all citizens a payment of the same amount at the same time at the same intervals is the most absolute form of equality. The inclusivity aspect also radically simplifies the process. Instead of applying for individual programs that have a variety of convoluted processes and different requirements for access, a universal basic income is essentially a one-size-fits-all form of welfare. The simplicity of the program would greatly minimize the high degree of bureaucracy present in the current welfare system – there would be no need for individual case workers to means test applicants or keep track of enrollees. This would not only reduce the administrative costs of the welfare system, but the spending that does occur would be significantly easier to track, promoting accountability and transparency from the federal government.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Economy*** › UQ – econ bad now

Unemployment is rising, however rates are still well below COVID levels

U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, 23 [U.S. Department of Labor, June 2, 2023, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, “The Employment Situation – May 23,” , Accessed: 06-26-23, CV]

The unemployment rate increased by 0.3 percentage point to 3.7 percent in May, and the number of unemployed persons rose by 440,000 to 6.1 million. The unemployment rate has ranged from 3.4 percent to 3.7 percent since March 2022. (See table A-1.) Chart 1. Unemployment rate, seasonally adjusted, May 2021 – May 2023 Percent Thousands Chart 2. Nonfarm payroll employment over-the-month change, seasonally adjusted, May 2021 – May 2023 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 May-21 Aug-21 Nov-21 Feb-22 May-22 Aug-22 Nov-22 Feb-23 May-23 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1,000 May-21 Aug-21 Nov-21 Feb-22 May-22 Aug-22 Nov-22 Feb-23 May-23 -2- Among the major worker groups, the unemployment rates for adult women (3.3 percent) and Blacks (5.6 percent) rose in May. The jobless rates for adult men (3.5 percent), teenagers (10.3 percent), Whites (3.3 percent), Asians (2.9 percent), and Hispanics (4.0 percent) showed little change over the month. (See tables A-1, A-2, and A-3.) The number of job losers and persons who completed temporary jobs increased by 318,000 to 3.0 million in May, offsetting a decrease in the previous month. (See table A-11.) In May, the number of persons jobless less than 5 weeks edged up by 217,000 to 2.1 million, partially offsetting a decrease in the prior month. The number of persons jobless 15 to 26 weeks increased by 179,000 to 858,000 in May. The number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was essentially unchanged at 1.2 million and accounted for 19.8 percent of the total unemployed. (See table A-12.) The labor force participation rate held at 62.6 percent in May, and the employment-population ratio, at 60.3 percent, was little changed. (See table A-1.) The number of persons employed part time for economic reasons, at 3.7 million, changed little in May. These individuals, who would have preferred full-time employment, were working part time because their hours had been reduced or they were unable to find full-time jobs. (See table A-8.) The number of persons not in the labor force who currently want a job was 5.5 million in May, little different from the prior month. These individuals were not counted as unemployed because they were not actively looking for work during the 4 weeks preceding the survey or were unavailable to take a job. (See table A-1.) Among those not in the labor force who wanted a job, the number of persons marginally attached to the labor force was little changed at 1.5 million in May. These individuals wanted and were available for work and had looked for a job sometime in the prior 12 months but had not looked for work in the 4 weeks preceding the survey. The number of discouraged workers, a subset of the marginally attached who believed that no jobs were available for them, was little changed over the month at 422,000. (See Summary table A.)

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › A2 China hegemony inevitable

Prefer trends over snapshots---China is on the verge of catching up.

Anwer ’22 [Ruqayyaa; January 18; Academic at Riphah International University, Pakistan, Ph.D.; Daily Sabah, “China is winning the power battle in AI race with US,” ]

Significantly, there will always be economic ups and downs, but the underlying drive that's occurring in Chinese culture right now will continue to create new prospects and growth. China has announced a five-year plan worth $1.8 trillion to dominate AI, robotics, 6G and all other technologies by 2035, releasing a five-year plan worth $1.8 trillion.

In comparison to the European Union and the U.S., China's AI capabilities have advanced in several areas. China has surpassed the bloc as the world's largest AI publisher. Moreover, the quality of its AI research has consistently improved over time. Its software and computer services companies have increased their R&D expenditures. China's determination to master AI goes far beyond the recognition that this group of technologies will be the most crucial driver of economic advancement over the next quarter-century. China's data collection and national determination have helped it to close the gap with American leaders in this area over the last decade.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Impact – tech race bad

US China tech war escalates to draw in allies and goes nuclear

Ignatius, Diploma of economics at University of Cambridge , 22

[David, 9/13/22, Washington Post, “Opinion|What if the United States loses the AI race against China?,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/09/13/artificial-intelligence-ai-high-tech-race-with-china/, 6/29/23, PE]

These days, every pundit and prognosticator is trumpeting the revolution that’s ahead in artificial intelligence. But a new bipartisan report conveys a grim message: The United States is losing the race to develop this technology that will transform every workplace and battlefield. “Absent targeted action, the United States is unlikely to close the growing technology gaps with China” and will fall behind in the critical AI sector, argues the report. It was issued Monday by a group chaired by Eric Schmidt, the former CEO of Google and head of the congressionally mandated National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence, which put out its findings last year. The new report follows the commission’s work; it was privately funded by Schmidt. The new report uses unusually stark language in describing the danger posed by China’s rapid advances in critical technologies such as AI, quantum computing, 5G communications and synthetic biology. In a section titled, “What Does Losing Look Like?” it describes a series of significant consequences for the United States should it fail to meet the Chinese challenge. Among the catalog of horrors: “China dominates the economy of the future and captures trillions of dollars’ worth of value generated by the next wave of technologies.” “China uses its techno-economic advantage for political leverage. Nations — including U.S. allies — reliant on China’s tech swing into the PRC’s political orbit.” “Authoritarian regimes sell the case that they are masters of the modern world.” “An open internet is compromised.” “The U.S. military’s technological edge erodes. The PRC annexes Taiwan.” “The PRC cuts off the supply of microelectronics and other critical technology inputs.” Follow David Ignatius's opinions Follow The report’s authors summarize the catastrophic outcome: “In total, this picture amounts to the unraveling of the order the United States and the democratic world built after World War II and a serious challenge to U.S. prosperity. The United States and other democracies would become economically dependent, losing their engines of prosperity and freedom of action in the world. ... Even if only some of this came to pass, the world would be a darker place for the United States and democracy.” Frightening technology scenarios like this have become increasingly common over the past decade, and they might overstate the extent of China’s advantage. Chinese economic growth is slowing; its tech sector has been shaken by poorly planned government intervention, and its deteriorating demographic position might not support the “China Dream” of dominance that President Xi Jinping has often advanced. But even so, Schmidt told me in a recent interview, China remains “focused on the deeper technologies,” such as AI, that will command the future. The bleak report doesn’t just summarize the costs of losing. It argues the United States will, in fact, lose this race without changes in government policy to focus attention better on the technology challenge. “The United States still has no process or person responsible for achieving technology advantage,” the report says. “The U.S public-private ecosystem has vast competitive strengths, but they are un-gathered. America needs a plan for mastering the new geometry of innovation to compete.” William M. “Mac” Thornberry, a former Republican congressman from Texas who was one of four advisers assisting Schmidt, stated the challenge bluntly in an interview: “If we continue on the current path, we lose.” The report, he says, is intended to explain to Americans, “Here’s what losing looks like to you, individually.” Essentially, the report argues for national “industrial policy” focused on technology, much like the recently passed legislation to support the semiconductor industry in the United Studies. Schmidt argued that the Chips and Science Act, on its own, won’t be sufficient to reclaim the United States’ lead in technology. “China has a Chips Act every year,” Schmidt contended, through continuous government funding for critical projects. The Schmidt report is the latest wave of a campaign for greater public and private funding in key technologies. Critics have argued that such directed funding for technology would subsidize already profitable companies such as Google and other tech giants. In that sense, critics contend, Schmidt and the other representatives of the tech sector are advancing their industry’s interests, at a time when there are other powerful claims for government support. The report counters that there’s need for investments that will benefit all Americans by sharpening the nation’s competitive edge and protecting its values. In the technology competition with China, the report argues, “at stake is the future of free societies, open markets, democratic government, and a world order rooted in freedom not coercion.” In a foreword to the report, former secretary of state Henry Kissinger sounds a “Back to the Future” note. He writes that the report is modeled on a similar bipartisan project he directed in the 1950s, when the U.S. faced a Soviet Union competitive threat. The aim, back then, was to “explain the issues facing our country that may have been hard for the government to tell the American people.” Whether America is actually losing the technology race against China is hard to say. The value of this report is that it reminds us how severe a price the United States would pay if optimism about its AI future proved to be wrong.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Impact – ILO good

ILO good – better than the alternative

Remarks of Alan Wm. Wolff ’22, October 5, “The Crisis of the Liberal International Order Thoughts on the Future of the Multilateral Trading System,” Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE) Mt. Pelerin Society, https://www.piie.com/sites/default/files/2022-10/2022-10-05wolff.pdf

A large part of the reason for international cooperation is that the alternatives are even less acceptable. There are enormous stresses in the world. Technological change has caused disruptions and will continue to do so, probably with greater frequency and deeper effect. No country can successfully resist technological developments. Geopolitical tensions will always be present, even if there are periods of respite, such as were the years during which the WTO was conceived and born. Fragmentation of the global trading system would involve severe costs for all economies. Assurance of supply requires more trade not less. Differences in interests need to be worked with, with divisions reduced to the extent possible.

It is the responsibility of leaders, in governments, in business, and in non-governmental organizations, to seek to shape the external environment in which they exist. The rules of the trading system need to evolve to adapt to new circumstances. It is the job of trade negotiators to manage to find solutions that can be agreed to.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – UBI solves

UBI enables creativity

Phil Teer. The Coming Age of Imagination: How Universal Basic Income Will Lead to an Explosion of Creativity. November 14, 2019. Pg. 12-13.

Universal basic income is one answer. The idea of paying every adult a sum of money, just enough to live on, not subject to means- testing, for the rest of their life as a right is becoming an increasingly popular idea. Paying people enough money to get by will help us get through the initial turmoil in the jobs market. It will protect people as they deal with periods between jobs or adapt to the gig economy. Setting the amount of basic income at a level that is just enough to survive but no more will mean there is still an incentive to take up what work is available, to do small paid tasks or hold down a few part-time or temporary roles. Eventually, as the wealth generated by automation increases, we will be able to pay each other more. By that point we will look at work as something we do for pleasure, not because we need to eat. The type of work we will be doing by that point will be different. Automation will take the most formulaic jobs first. There will be fewer drivers and divorce lawyers as these tasks are mostly predictable and routine, although humans will still do the trickier driving and contested divorces. The jobs that are left will be more creative or caring roles. They will be jobs with unpredictable outcomes or ones where huge amounts of empathy are required. They will be the challenging, human, rewarding and even fun jobs. With time on our hands and a degree of financial security something amazing will happen. We will stop using our leisure time to recover from work and start using it to develop a new type of work where we do the things that we have a talent for. We will have more ideas and we will make more of our ideas happen. We will do more creative things and our creativity will be generative. It will generate new breakthroughs in science. new directions in art, new political movements and new sources of economic growth. It is not the money of investors that creates new markets. It is the creativity of the inventor, the imagination of the designer and the vision of the founder. Imagination is the most powerful force on the planet. Ideas create markets. It is our creative imagination that drives politics, society and business forward. It is practical, this idea of basic income. It has been tested in small ways in many places. These tests always show that when you give people money they do constructive things with it. Rather than blowing it on booze, they invest it in themselves.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – UBI solves

UBI sparks social entrepreneurship and creates new jobs

Jennifer Light. The JR Executive. Universal Basic Income’s Impact on Entrepreneurship. . Jan 22, 2021. AR.

Social entrepreneurship is the most crucial type of entrepreneurship, as it is startup companies that develop ideas and solutions to current social, cultural, and environmental issues, such as climate change. Unfortunately, entrepreneurship has been on the decline. According to the INC, “entrepreneurs have been in decline for 40 years due to fear of financial failure.” Furthermore, the Office of Advocacy explains that around one in twelve small businesses is doomed to close a year, most commonly due to low sales and restricted cash flow. To resolve the fear of failure and stimulate small businesses, a Universal Basic Income (UBI) of $1,000 a month should be implemented. Luckily, a UBI has the potential to stimulate entrepreneurship further and give businesses the push they need to start, and provide a safety net for companies. The largest concern of most small business startups is the lack of funding and spending ability. According to an NSBA study, more than 25% of small business owners say they aren’t able to obtain the funds they need to operate their business. Not only are legal fees expensive, but branding and web hosting sites are as well. According to Sammi Carmella, a writer for Business News Daily, average costs for a micro-business average around $3,000. The Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship quantifies that many small businesses were forced to finance through personal savings and credit cards. They explain, “over 80% of US entrepreneurs utilized personal sources of funding, accounting for 57% of all startup financing acquired during this period.” Additionally, a UBI would provide a sense of security for entrepreneurs. Blakeman explains that one of the major reasons for the decline in startups is the fear of failure. Fortunately, the Smith School of Business elaborates that a UBI eliminates one of a small businesses’ largest fears, a fear of failure. With a safety net to fall back on in times of need, it would provide entrepreneurs with the confidence necessary to continue social innovation and new product development. This is crucial for those who have less financial spending power to create a startup business, as it would alleviate the fear of failure. What does this mean in the long run for entrepreneurs and small business owners? The NSDMC explains that around 50% of businesses in the US are owned by minorities. Furthermore, these minority-owned businesses pay close to $50 billion in tax revenue to the government. If these businesses don’t have the spending power to take risks and continue their startup, it could have devastating effects on the economy. Problematically, the USSC stated, “minority-owned firms are two to three times more likely to be denied credit, more likely to avoid applying for loans based on the belief that they will be turned down, and more likely to receive smaller loans and pay higher interest rates on the loans that they do receive.” This means that minority-owned businesses are less likely to have enough money to continue to grow their businesses without a UBI. The impact this has on the economy is enormous, because approximately 50% of the US GDP growth is because of increases in innovation. With no money for startups, to create businesses, and innovate, the US GDP is in trouble. However, a UBI is proven to work. Per QuantumRun, in some places where UBI was implemented, there was a 301 percent rise in entrepreneurship. There is data to show that for every 1 percentage point increase in the rate of entrepreneurship in a state, there is a 2 percent decline in the poverty rate. Therefore, with an increase in innovation, business, and an economic boost, a Universal Basic Income would result in an increase in the labor force. The Big Experience estimates over 4.6 million new estimated jobs would be created, through new business ventures.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – UBI solves

UBI fosters entrepreneurial spirits

Jason Francis D’Mello, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Entrepreneurship at Loyola Marymount University. Universal Basic Income and Entrepreneurial Pursuit in an Autonomous Society. Journal of Management Inquiry 2019, Vol. 28(3) 306–310. . AR.

At issue is how this research on motivations relates to our hypothetical scenario with UBI and entrepreneurial behavior? Productivity, performance, and perseverance are outcomes of motivations that come from within the individual, not from external rewards (Deci, 1976; Steers, Mowday, & Shapiro, 2004). A study on the motivations of individual innovators found that intrinsic motivations were indicated by joy of work, confidence, autonomy, and duty and were critical during the early stage of a venture (Bhaduri & Kumar, 2011). In other words, the motivation was driven by the purpose found in the work itself. In a world of automation and its impending disruption of employment for the masses, it is 308 Journal of Management Inquiry 28(3) highly likely that people will have to depend on alternative means of support for their subsistence. Could UBI be the answer? And for those bitten by the entrepreneurial bug, could UBI actually be the saving grace, helping them to get by and freeing them up to pursue their entrepreneurial creativity? One analogy to such a system is that of a base salary plus commission compensation plan that has proven to be very successful in the sales world. Can UBI provide the safety net for the entrepreneurial community to have the freedom to pursue their dreams? This is an empirical question worthy of further research and discourse. Entrepreneurial Intentions There are many examples of entrepreneurs who find incredible successes to the tune of billions of dollars of wealth, only to pledge to give the majority of their earnings away. The wealth appears to possibly serve as a mechanism for “keeping score” more than the motivation to build the business. Also, within the entrepreneurship literature, there are several examples of the importance of nonmonetary rewards as motivators for entrepreneurial action (Andersson, 2008; Baron, Franklin, & Hmieleski, 2016; Parker, 2009; Uy, Foo, & Song, 2013). These nonpecuniary benefits of entrepreneurship are found through the autonomy and satisfaction with the work and range of possibilities to apply an individual’s skills and abilities, leading to richer experiences in his or her work. In fact, one study found that founders of innovative, high-growth firms financed by venture-capital funds were willing to work for lower incomes than other, nonfounding executives employed at the same firms, even after controlling for level of stock and stock option ownership (Wasserman, 2004). A quick glance at research on creativity and modern innovation communities shows similar patterns. At an organizational level, teamwork, autonomy, domain-relevant competencies, inclusiveness, fair processes, and practices all positively support satisfaction with creativity in the workplace. Individually, similar to previous research cited, the strength of intrinsic motivations enhances satisfaction with creativity (Sacchetti & Tortia, 2013). Other research on creativity finds that the types of value priorities (self-direction) and intrinsic motivational orientation (Kasof, Chen, Himsel, & Greenberger, 2007) influence creative behavior. Consider the musician in our modern society. This creative pursuit requires deeper motivation than reward incentives. The odds of finding success are quite rare with nearly one million composers, songwriters, and music publishers registered on either American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) or Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI). According to these two leading performance rights organizations, over one million songs are written, recorded, and released each year, yet very few artists are able to earn a sustainable living off their work. The motivation for artists to be creative is an intrinsic one, and these artists continue their pursuits regardless of being able to earn a living from their art. Perhaps UBI could be the solution to enable entrepreneurs to remain gainfully engaged and in pursuit of their dreams in a world where jobs would be hard to come by! Peer-Production and Open-Source Communities Our modern society is also ripe with examples of innovation without profit, found through peer production or a form of open creation and sharing performed by groups online in a decentralized manner (Benkler, Shaw, & Hill, 2015). These open-source communities include participants with diverse, nonmonetary motivations, separate governance comprised of participatory, meritocratic, and charismatic models instead of traditional contractual or proprietary systems (Benkler et al., 2015). The platforms are also typically free, such as Wikipedia, GNU/Linux, Apache web server, and the cyberpunk movement credited for developing the recently popularized blockchain technology. These peer-production platforms directly challenge conventional economic theories of motivation and cooperation because they offer no clear extrinsic incentives (Benkler et al., 2015). Highly skilled individuals continue to contribute without monetary rewards. Research suggests that the motivations to participate in these communities include the value of the software to the developer, hedonic pleasure of building software, increased human capital, reputation, employment prospects, and social status within a community of peers, reciprocity, sense of efficacy, and collective identity (Benkler et al., 2015; Ghosh, 1998; Kollock, 1999; Lerner & Tirole, 2002; von Hippel & von Krogh, 2003; von Krogh, 2003). These intrinsic and sociopsychological motivators may be similar to the motivators of our future entrepreneur existing within a UBI society in which traditional monetary rewards may cease to exist. Privileges in Entrepreneurship Despite the wide range of research topics found in entrepreneurship, few scholars have adequately discussed privilege as being an antecedent to the choice to engage in entrepreneurial activity. Yet, the data indicate that wealth, race, and family background are often significant drivers of entrepreneurial activity (Blanchflower & Oswald, 1998). Levine and Rubinstein (2017) point out that that entrepreneurs tend to be male, White, better educated and more likely to come from high-earning, two-parent families (Levine & Rubinstein, 2017). Moreover, with over US$1.4 trillion of student loan debt, economic privileges may continue to factor into selfemployment decisions (Morelix, 2015). Privilege in entrepreneurship has also been researched among those who transition late in their careers. For individuals aged 50 years or above, a transition into entrepreneurship significantly increases the quality of life measured by needs of control autonomy, self-realization, and pleasure, while at the same time offering a significant reduction in income (Kautonen, Kibler, & Minniti, 2017). Clearly, not everyone at this age is afforded such an opportunity due to limitations of health, family obligations, and other economic constraints. This study gives supporting evidence to a popular perspective that those who can take entrepreneurial risks today enjoy a certain level of privilege. Other work related to reentry into entrepreneurship after previous failures supports this notion that there are certain individuals who may have a safety net, or access to capital to allow for certain risks to be taken during their pursuit of opportunities. There are certainly also entrepreneurs who emerge out of necessity, being forced into self-employment due to adverse conditions. However, this discussion focuses on opportunity entrepreneurs, who choose self-employment voluntarily. UBI may offer more individuals with entrepreneurial intentions new privileges to take on action on their ideas by increasing their ranges of affordable loss. By acknowledging entrepreneurial privilege, I am not necessarily dismissing the grit, perseverance, resilience, tenacity, innovativeness, resourcefulness, leadership, vision, and other crucial qualities that these entrepreneurs may have. However, I suggest that there is a strong possibility that other individuals, less privileged in our current society, may also possess and discover similar qualities that could allow them, too, to thrive during the process of pursuing opportunities (even if some ventures resulted in failures). These individuals lack the privileges found among those who are self-employed in our labor economic research, such as an inheritance, family wealth, access to capital, and other advantages that reduce the risk of not being able to meet basic survival needs. The “rags to riches” narrative that claims that anyone can become an entrepreneur in our society does not quite align with the research on who actually chooses to become self-employed. Entrepreneurial privilege seems to currently determine who gets to play (and stay) in the game. As automation permeates our world and job losses become widespread, alternative public policy solutions such as UBI will become a distinct possibility. Critics of UBI argue that having such a safety net could demotivate people from becoming productive and lead to inertia. However, it can also be argued that the intrinsic motivation and creative spirit, that is prevalent in our entrepreneurial community, would prevail. With the comfort and freedom from job stress, provided by UBI, one would not need to be privileged to pursue one’s entrepreneurial dream! UBI may offer a wider safety net for more entrepreneurs to be productive within our society regardless of the monetary rewards of their pursuits. Social psychology literature on motivations offers strong evidence that human motivation can persist in a world where income is universal as long as there is meaning found in being actively engaged. As the labor market shrinks, new markets may emerge. Peerproduction and open-source communities may serve as the motivators for these types of markets. Reputational capital, status, identity, and other intrinsic motivators may bring a similar sense of purpose to individual lives as our current monetary wealth does. It is difficult to predict what types of consumer demand, customer pain points, or social problems our future world may face. However, looking at the history of human behavior, motivations, innovations, and social relations, there may certainly be a positive outcome from entrepreneurs collaborating and creating in new ways that meet a higher order of needs than what we may understand today. These advances will create more opportunities and give purpose to the ambitious individual. While it remains to be seen what specific activities will occupy the future entrepreneur’s time, I have confidence that he or she will share the same empathy, imagination, and ingenuity as the entrepreneurs we know today to recognize unmet needs and creatively solve the problems they discover to be entrepreneurial opportunities. In conclusion, I argue that as long as humans have the freedom to dream and imagine a more hopeful future while believing that their behavior can impact the world around them in a positive way, entrepreneurship will live on and may thrive even in an unexpected environment.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – UBI solves

The internal link is built in cognitive psychology—a UBI will only generate an increase in AI

Santens 04-27-2023 (Scott, Senior Advisor for Humanity Forward and also serve on the board of directors of the Gerald Huff Fund for Humanity and as the editor of Basic Income Today — a daily UBI news hub., A.I. Will Not Displace Everyone, Everywhere, All at Once. It Will Rapidly Transform the Labor Market, Exacerbating Inequality, Insecurity, and Poverty., https://www.scottsantens.com/ai-will-rapidly-transform-the-labor-market-exacerbating-inequality-insecurity-and-poverty/)-TL

People really don't enjoy doing nothing, and people will always enjoy paying others to do something they can't do as well, or don't want to do themselves, and that will remain true to some degree even when technology can do so much more for us. Even right now, there are already new examples, of paying someone else to use AI to accomplish something, because some people are already better at using AI than others, and because time will always be limited. Because time is limited, there will always be a reason to just pay someone to do something for us, even if the tools exist for us to do it ourselves using AI, as long as people have money to spend. That's the one neat trick. We have to make sure everyone always has money to spend if we want to make sure that people can always earn additional money doing some kind of work, or afford to do some kind of work they enjoy for free. Besides volunteering, it's also a lot easier to start a business to create new jobs if you have an income underneath you to support you, and the people around you also have an income to be your customers. Our collective economic future is up to us. We can choose the path where we all equally share in the massive wealth generation that AI makes possible (that we all made possible together with our collective data) by greatly increasing our collective productivity, and where we all always have the money to spend to pursue new interests, paid or unpaid. Or we can choose the path we're currently still on, where AI makes life harder for a large percentage of the population while massively enriching a relative few, and where jobs really do become harder to come by because spending power has been concentrated in too few hands to provide sufficient overall demand to fuel our economy. Which path do you prefer?

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – China UQ

Secrecy means the gap is closer than it seems

Ian Clay and Robert D. Atkinson ‘23, January 23, “Wake Up, America: China Is Overtaking the United States in Innovation Capacity,” INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION FOUNDATION,

However, as mentioned previously, China has recently become much more secretive about its major breakthroughs in high-performance computing. A report by The Next Platform’s Nicole Hemsoth from October of last year suggests that China had already achieved exascale performance on two separate systems.105 Therefore, China’s progress is likely understated by the available data, and the plateauing of its progress relative to the United States in both number of systems and cumulative performance in the latter half of the decade may simply be a result of China’s keeping its cards close to its chest.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – China UQ

China must be out-competed before they catch up

Ian Clay and Robert D. Atkinson ‘23, January 23, “Wake Up, America: China Is Overtaking the United States in Innovation Capacity,” INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION FOUNDATION,

Beyond just these specific examples, China’s progress is demonstrating itself through broader measures of innovation, such as the aforementioned GII. While Kennedy dubbed China the “fat tech dragon” because of the alleged imbalance in growth between its innovation input score and its innovation output score, this analysis neglects the fact that in the 2016 edition of the GII, China’s output score was higher than at any other point between 2009 and 2016 (the years Kennedy considers). Furthermore, China’s “efficiency” score, defined as the ratio of a nation’s output score to its input score (or, put another way, a nation’s innovation metabolism), ranked seventh among all nations.36 For reference, Switzerland, which ranked first overall, had the 5th highest efficiency score, Germany had the 9th highest, the United States had the 25th highest, and Japan had the 65th highest.

In the recently released 2022 edition of the GII, China ranks 11th overall (and Hong Kong ranks 14th overall), ahead of countries such as Japan (13th) and Canada (15th).37 Moreover, China ranks just 21st in input score and 8th in output score, and its output score was well above the 2016 level. China’s GII-defined strengths are “Trade, diversification, & market share” (an innovation input for which China ranks third) and “Intangible assets” (an innovation output for which China ranks second).

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Innovation*** › Innovation – China UQ

China catching up fast

Ian Clay and Robert D. Atkinson ‘23, January 23, “Wake Up, America: China Is Overtaking the United States in Innovation Capacity,” INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION FOUNDATION,

Overall, China made notable progress relative to the United States. This progress was strongest and most widespread in innovation outputs and—unsurprisingly—in indicators not accounting for size, where it surpassed the United States. However, China made progress relative to the United States in all three innovation types, both when accounting for size and when not. In summary, China is beginning to make use of its massive economic and demographic endowments to eclipse the United States in gross output of innovation indicators (e.g., number of science and engineering articles published, number of doctoral degrees awarded, advanced-industry output, etc.). This has translated into slower but still significant progress in indicators accounting for the size of each country’s economy or population, where China still lags behind the United States.