2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Job Shortages—A2 “Decentralized Administration”
Lowrey, Atlantic journalist, ‘18
[Annie Lowrey, journalist, “A Promise So Big, Democrats Aren’t Sure How to Keep It,” THE ATLANTIC, 5—11—18, , accessed 6-9-23]
Then there is the question of how the government would go about creating all those jobs. State and local governments tend to keep a long backlog of shovel-ready infrastructure projects. But few have lists of hundreds of thousands of menial temp jobs, permanent care positions, teaching positions, and ecological restoration projects on hand—along with an infrastructure for job training and job matching, as a jobs guarantee would require. Granted, there is some existing infrastructure. “Local unemployment offices have basically been rebranded today as a local job centers or one-stop career centers,” Kelton said. “There are like more than 2,500 of these things spread all over the country.” Still, a jobs guarantee would mean the government hiring tens of thousands of bureaucrats to locate make-work and manage training and employment programs across the country—in every part of the country.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Job Shortages—A2 “Decentralized Administration”
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘18
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research, “Proposed Federal Jobs Guarantee Is Too Big to Exist,” American Institute for Economic Research, 5—4—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
My concerns that follow are less about the standard partisan debate on big government programs, and more about the profound implications of dropping an organization of this size on the U.S. labor market. No matter one’s political leanings, these concerns should not be dismissed.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Job Shortages—2NC
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘18
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research,“The Dangerous Fantasy of a ‘Jobs Guarantee’,” WALL STREET JOURNAL, 11—14—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
Beyond its cost, the job guarantee would turn the fundamental logic of work on its head. Generally, people work for employers, whether private organizations or government agencies, because employees add enough value to sustain their wages and still benefit the employer. Under a job guarantee, creating value is an afterthought. The program's potential is limited further by additional rules the authors propose, such as barring competition with existing private or public jobs and requiring that the positions be low-skilled.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Job Shortages—1NC
Earle, AIER research fellow, ‘19
[Peter C. Earle, Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, “'Federal Jobs Guarantee' Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats,” INVESTOR’S BUSINESS DAILY, 11—19—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
Currently, individuals in the job market "sell" their labor to firms as much as firms "purchase" labor. Mutually, this transaction — employment — arises because both the employee and employer benefit; value is recognized reciprocally. With a federal jobs guarantee program, the government is inserted between the employee and the employer; the value proposition is limited at best. Centralized plans such as these forgo the most fundamental elements of markets — information, competition, and incentives — in favor of rote bureaucratic reckoning.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Administrative Problems—2NC
Chait, New York journalist, ‘18
[Jonathan Chait, journalist, “Democrats Are Rushing Into a Job Guarantee. It Could Be a Huge Mistake,” NEW YORK MAGAZINE, 4—25—18, , accessed 6-4-23]
That’s just the small problem. The big problem is that designing a federal jobs program large enough to usefully employ all applicants is a devilishly complex challenge that none of the proposals currently circulating have worked through.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Administrative Problems—2NC
Taylor, Journal of Economic Perspectives Managing Editor, ‘18
[Timothy T. Taylor, Managing Editor, Journal of Economic Perspectives, “The Job Guarantee Controversy,” Conversable Economist, 4—30—18, , accessed 5-1-23]
The government managerial problem
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Administrative Problems—1NC
Gulker, AIER Senior Research Fellow, ‘18
[Max Gulker, PhD, Economics, Stanford University, Senior Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, THE JOB GUARANTEE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS, American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, p. 4-5]
Rather than cooperative, work arrangements in a job guarantee are a series of three interlocking mandates, as shown in figure 2. An individual mandates that the federal government provide a wage and benefits, the federal government mandates that some government agency (local, state, or federal) identify or create work for this and other individuals, and that agency mandates that the individual perform certain work.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Democracy Ans: 2NC
Ghatak et al 17 [Sam Ghatak, Lecturer, Political Science, University of Tennessee Knoxville, Aaron Gold, PhD Student, Political Science, UT Knoxville, Brandon C. Prins, Professor and Director of Graduate Studies, UT Knoxville, “External threat and the limits of democratic pacifism,” Conflict Management and Peace Science 34(2): 141-59, Emory Libraries]
It has become a stylized fact that dyadic democracy lowers the hazard of armed conflict. While the Democratic Peace has faced many challenges, we believe the most significant challenge has come from the argument that the pacifying effect of democracy is epiphenomenal to territorial issues, specifically the external threats that they pose. This argument sees the lower hazards of armed conflict among democracies not as a product of shared norms or institutional structures, but as a result of settled borders. Territory, though, remains only one geo-political context generating threat, insecurity, and a higher likelihood of armed conflict. Strategic rivalry also serves as an environment associated with fear, a lack of trust, and an expectation of future conflict. Efforts to assess democratic pacifism have largely ignored rivalry as a context conditioning the behavior of democratic leaders. To be sure, research demonstrates rivals to have higher probabilities of armed conflict and democracies rarely to be rivals. But fundamental to the Democratic Peace is the notion that even in the face of difficult security challenges and salient issues, dyadic democracy will associate with a lower likelihood of militarized aggression. But the presence of an external threat, be that threat disputed territory or strategic rivalry, may be the key mechanism by which democratic leaders, owing to audience costs, resolve and electoral pressures, fail to resolve problems nonviolently. This study has sought a ‘‘hard test’’ of the Democratic Peace by testing the conditional effects of joint democracy on armed conflict when external threat is present. We test three measures of threat: territorial contention, strategic rivalry, and a threat index that sums the first two measures. For robustness checks, we use two additional measures of our dependent variable: fatal MID onset, and event data from the Armed Conflict Database, which can be found in our Online Appendix. As most studies report, democratic dyads are associated with less armed conflict than mixed-regime and autocratic dyads. In every one of our models, when we control for each measure of external threat, joint democracy is strongly negative and significant and each measure of threat is strongly positive and significant. Here, liberal institutions maintain their pacific ability and external threats clearly increase conflict propensities. However, when we test the interactive relationship between democracy and our measures of external threat, the pacifying effect of democracy is less visible. Park and James (2015) find some evidence that when faced with an external threat in the form of territorial contention, the pacifying effect of joint democracy holds up. This study does not fully support the claims of Park and James (2015). Using a longer timeframe, we find more consistent evidence that when faced with an external threat, be it territorial contention, strategic rivalry, or a combination, democratic pacifism does not survive. What are the implications of our study? First, while it is clear that we do not observe a large amount of armed conflict among democratic states, if we organize interstate relationships along a continuum from highly hostile to highly friendly, we are probably observing what Goertz et al. (2016) and Owsiak et al. (2016) refer to as ‘‘lesser rivalries’’ in which ‘‘both the frequency and severity of violent interaction decline. Yet, the sentiments of threat, enmity, and competition that remain—along with the persistence of unresolved issues—mean that lesser rivalries still experience isolated violent episodes (e.g., militarized interstate disputes), diplomatic hostility, and non-violent crises’’ (Owsiak et al., 2016). Second, our findings show that the pacific benefits of liberal institutions or externalized norms are not always able to lower the likelihood of armed conflict when faced with external threats, whether those hazards are disputed territory, strategic rivalry, or a combination of the two. The structural environment clearly influences democratic leaders in their foreign policy actions more than has heretofore been appreciated. Audience costs, resolve, and electoral pressures, produced from external threats, are powerful forces that are present even in jointly democratic relationships. These forces make it difficult for leaders to trust one another, which inhibits conflict resolution and
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Inequality Defense: 2NC
Cowen, George Mason University, ‘16
[Tyler Cowen, George Mason University, “Is the Concept of Inequality the Best Way of Thinking About Our Economic Problems?” THE US LABOR MARKET, ed. M.R.Strain, American Enterprise Institute, 2016, www.aei.org/spotlight/econ-labor-should-we-be-concerned-about-income-inequality]
Another claim is that high income or wealth inequality is bound to lead to political revolution, instability, riots in the streets, or some other set of negative consequences. Yet the data don't show this. The most violent period in recent American history was something like 1963–73, which came right after and during America's most significant period of robust middle-class income growth. Overall, the research does not suggest definitive conclusions, but there is at least as much evidence suggesting that rising expectations are a more important cause of instability than is income inequality. In sum, America has serious problems of inadequate education, lack of retraining, and some quite bad policies in particular areas. In most cases that disaggregation is a better way of understanding what is going on rather than emphasizing inequality at the macroeconomic level. The gap between rich and poor is neither the major driver of the actual problems nor the most important symptom of the most significant problems. Lack of opportunity in absolute terms is the main symptomatic problem.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Inequality Defense: 1NC
Elise Must 16, PhD student at LSE, this was her PhD thesis, 8/1/16, “When and how does inequality cause conflict? Group dynamics, perceptions and natural resources”,
Does economic inequality lead to conflict? This question has attracted the attention of prominent scholars at least since the time of Aristotle (Nagel 1974). The frequent assumption that unequal distribution somehow fuels rebellion has resulted in a vast amount of theoretical as well as empirical work. For long, results remained mixed. Despite countless qualitative studies asserting that inequality is a major reason for conflict outbreak, quantitative studies struggled to establish a firm relationship between the two (Blattman and Miguel 2010, Cramer 2005, Lichbach 1989).
These quantitative studies, including the most influential ones by Collier and Hoeffler (2004) and Fearon and Laitin (2003), rely on analysis of individual measures of inequality. However, as most prominently set forth by Frances Stewart, it is minority groups or collectives of individuals who rebel, not the whole population, nor individuals (Stewart 2002). Stewart’s theoretical development has given rise to several quantitative studies which uniformly support the role of economic group inequality in inducing conflict (Buhaug, Cederman, and Gleditsch 2014, Cederman, Weidmann, and Bormann 2015, Cederman, Weidmann, and Gleditsch 2011, Deiwiks, Cederman, and Gleditsch 2012, Østby 2008a, b, Østby, Nordås, and Rød 2009). Hence, there is an emerging consensus in the literature that inequality causes civil conflict when it overlaps with relevant group identities.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Inequality Alt Cause: 2NC
Baranoff 15
Olga Baranoff- staff, Washington Center for Equitable Growth. World Economic Forum. What’s caused the rise in income inequality in the US?. . May 5, 2015. DOA: 06/17/23. AR
Income inequality has increased in the United States over the past 30 years, as income has flowed unequally to those at the very top of the income spectrum. Current economic literature largely points to three explanatory causes of falling wages and rising income inequality: technology, trade, and institutions. The existence of different explanations points to the difficulty of pinning down causes of inequality. Part of this difficulty is rooted in the complexity inherent in larger labor market inequalities. Falling labor force participation, stagnating median wages, and declining share of labor income, for example, are all part of current U.S. labor market trends. These trends are certainly connected, but they also have been studied through various research frameworks, which can inexorably lead to different policy implications. Acknowledging the complex and intertwined nature of these explanations is crucial to developing policy solutions that address the joint causes of inequality. Of the three explanations for rising inequality, the so-called technology-and -education argument is the most prominent. This hypothesis focuses on the large wage premiums for workers with high levels of education and skills. According to Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor David Autor, demand for skills has consistently increased across developed countries. The skill premium, then, is a result of skills not being supplied at a rate to keep up with demand. The proposed solution to inequality driven by these trends is increasing education and job training opportunities for workers so they can get better paying jobs. A second explanation is trade and globalization. Scholars, including Autor, point to increases in trade and offshoring as a cause of income inequality. According to this hypothesis, growing trade between the United States and the rest of the world, especially China, has increased the number of imports in the U.S. economy, which has led to job loss in industries that originally produced these goods in the United States. Offshoring has also affected jobs and wages. Both these trade phenomena lead to declining employment, falling labor force participation, and weak inflation-adjusted wage growth. Possible policy solutions for this trend include those that would make U.S. exports more competitive, among them the depreciation of the U.S. dollar. The last explanation suggests that U.S. government policies created an institutional framework that led to increasing inequality. Since the late 1970s, deregulation, de-unionization, tax changes, federal monetary policies, “the shareholder revolution,” and other policies reduced wages and employment. This explanation would seem to call for policy changes such as increasing unionization, better supervision of Wall Street, raising the minimum wage, and maintaining a full-employment focus in monetary policy, to address inequality and declining wages. These three main explanations for income inequality show the difficulty in pointing to one cause of inequality over others. Researchers’ emphasis on disentangling causes of income inequality is relevant to understanding the issue, but it also highlights the complexity of factors that contribute to labor market inequality. Income inequality has no one cause. As such, any policy solutions that address inequality must match this nuance and acknowledge the various factors that contribute to inequality.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Inequality Alt Cause: 1NC
Soken-Huberty 22
Emmaline Soken-Huberty- writer. Human Rights Careers. Income Inequality 101: Causes, Facts, Examples, Ways to Take Action. . 2022. DOA: 06/17/23. AR.
The United States isn’t among the top most unequal countries in the world, but it has a much higher Gini coefficient when compared to similar economies. According to Statista, the top 10% of earners in the United States (in the third quarter of 2022) held 68% of the country’s total wealth. The lowest 50% held just 3.3.%. Like South Africa, the United States’ history of racial segregation plays a big role. Slavery made it impossible for Black people to build wealth, but even after emancipation, Jim Crow laws severely restricted economic opportunities. The effects resonate to this day. A 2018 analysis of incomes and wealth found that over the past 70 years, there’s been no progress in reducing income and wealth inequalities between Black and white households. Inequality is also driven by the fact that wages haven’t kept pace with inflation. In June 2022, consumer prices hit 9.1% higher than the year before. This made it the largest annual increase since 1981. Wages have been going up, but they’ve been consistently at 4.5%. The federal minimum wage hasn’t increased since 2009: it’s just $7.25. A study found that in 91% of U.S. counties, a full-time minimum wage worker doesn’t make enough to afford a one-bedroom apartment rental.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Labor Market Strong Now: 2NC
Raimondo - 40th U.S. Secretary of Commerce- 23
Gina M. Raimondo- 40th U.S. Secretary of Commerce. U.S. Department of Commerce. News: Unemployment is at its Lowest Level in 54 years. . February 3, 2023. DOA: 06/17/23. AR
Today, the U.S. Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics released the monthly Jobs Report which shows the unemployment rate has dropped to 3.4% with more than a half million jobs created in January and 800,000 manufacturing jobs created in the last two years. “President Biden’s economic plan is working,” said Commerce Secretary Raimondo. “When President Biden took office, the unemployment rate was 6.3%. Today, it is just 3.4%. That’s the lowest in 54 years.” Also last month, the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis reported Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew at 2.9% for the last quarter of 2022 and that real wages were higher last month than they were seven months ago. “Last quarter, we experienced strong growth in GDP, consumer spending, and disposable income,” said Raimondo. “We have more work to do, but we’re building a strong economy that works for all Americans.” In addition, there was near record low unemployment among the Black population (5.4%) and Hispanic population (4.5%). Job growth was widespread, led by gains in leisure and hospitality, professional and business services, and health care. Employment also increased in government, partially reflecting the return of workers from a strike. “Let’s not forget where we were when the President took office – the economy was in crisis,” said Raimondo. “Now, we’ve achieved record job creation, record low unemployment, and a record number of small business applications. America is on the move once again.”
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Labor Market Strong Now: 1NC
Ember, NYT journalist, ‘23
[Sydney Ember, journalist, “U.S. Job Growth Remains Strong Despite Economic Clouds,” NEW YORK TIMES, 6---2—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
American employers added an unanticipated barrage of workers in May, reaffirming the labor market’s vigor.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Labor Power Turn: 1NC
Hiscox, trade unionist, ’20 (Michael Hiscox is a trade unionist and a member of the ACT Labor Left, 8-22-2020, "The Job Guarantee," Challenge Magazine, https://www.challengemag.org/post/the-job-guarantee-weakening-worker-power)
Modern Monetary Theory and the Job Guarantee have gained significant traction on the left and within public policy circles, particularly since the health and economic crisis hit.
While recent attention has focused on the potential of MMT and the Guarantee to compromise progressive taxation and the welfare state, this article will instead focus on the risk it poses to the bargaining power of workers and their unions.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Equity Turn: 2NC
King, post-doctoral visitor at York, 2020 (Adam D.K. King, Post-Doctoral Visitor in the Department of Politics at York University in Toronto, 2020, Critical reflections on the job guarantee proposal, Studies in Political Economy, 101:3, , GDI-MAM)
The idea of guaranteed employment through a public sector jobs program has gained considerable popularity among social movement and labour union activists in the United States over the past several years. Although the notion of guaranteed employment through a federal jobs program has been part of certain strands of the North American Left throughout the twentieth century,57 important policy specificities characterize the most recent and popular iteration of the JG. Current demands for a JG draw upon the proposals of economists and policy researchers associated with the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College and a particular variant of Post-Keynesian economics.
In this article, I critically evaluate this version of the JG proposal from two angles. First, by looking at the intellectual origins of the JG in the work of economist Hyman Minsky, as well as in the writings of contemporary JG proponents, I contextualize the JG’s origins as part of the search for a progressive full employment solution to the inflationary crises of the 1970s. Through this approach, I highlight what I take to be a central issue with contemporary JG proposals: the seeming incompatibility between the characterization of the JG as a price stabilization program—that is, as an inflation-containing approach to full employment—and current JG advocates’ claims about the programs’ potential to raise wages and labour standards for workers throughout the labour market. My contention is that it cannot do both simultaneously, and that it is likely that any politically feasible variation would simply pool the unemployed into a low-wage, workfare-like program.
2023
GDI
Negative
Labor Advantage Answers › Equity Turn: 1NC
Palley, independent economist, ’18
[Thomas Palley, 9-14-2018, "Job Guarantee Programs: Careful What You Wish For," Social Europe, , GDI-MAM]
*JGP – Job Guarantee Program
2023
GDI
Negative
Green Jobs Advantage Answers › Too Late to Solve Climate: 2NC
Atkins, journalist, ’21
[C.J. Atkins, journalist, “Already too Late: IPCC Report Says Global Warming Consequences Now Unavoidable,” PEOPLE’S WORLD, 8—9—21, , accessed 3-30-23]
It’s too late to reverse the massive damage humanity has done to the Earth’s climate, and deadly weather is already baked into our future. That’s the conclusion from a depressing new report issued Monday morning by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a United Nations body that forecasts the effects of human activity on the climate.
2023
GDI
Negative
Green Jobs Advantage Answers › Too Late to Solve Climate: 1NC
Plumer, NYT journalist, ‘23
[Brad Plumer, journalist, “Climate Change Is Speeding Toward Catastrophe. The Next Decade Is Crucial, U.N. Panel Says,” NEW YORK TIMES, 3—20—23, , accessed 3-30-23]
There is still one last chance to shift course, the new report says. But it would require industrialized nations to join together immediately to slash greenhouse gases roughly in half by 2030 and then stop adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere altogether by the early 2050s. If those two steps were taken, the world would have about a 50 percent chance of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius.
2023
GDI
Negative
Green Jobs Advantage Answers › Climate Not Existential: 2NC
Farquhar et al., Oxford University PhD Candidate, ’17
[Sebastian Farquhar, PhD Candidate, Oxford University, with 5 co-authors from Oxford University, EXISTENTIAL RISK: DIPLOMACY AND GOVERNANCE, Global Priorities Project, 2017, p. 8]
The most likely levels of global warming are very unlikely to cause human extinction.15 The existential risks of climate change instead stem from tail risk climate change – the low probability of extreme levels of warming – and interaction with other sources of risk. It is impossible to say with confidence at what point global warming would become severe enough to pose an existential threat. Research has suggested that warming of 11-12°C would render most of the planet uninhabitable,16 and would completely devastate agriculture.17 This would pose an extreme threat to human civilisation as we know it.18 Warming of around 7°C or more could potentially produce conflict and instability on such a scale that the indirect effects could be an existential risk, although it is extremely uncertain how likely such scenarios are.19 Moreover, the timescales over which such changes might happen could mean that humanity is able to adapt enough to avoid extinction in even very extreme scenarios