2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
AT: Case › AT: Economy Advantage---Offense › 1NC---Economy Link Turns
Robert Doar 18, Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, 2018, “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net,” https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income
As for those not among the high earners, UBI would surely illustrate a basic law of economics and negatively affect the incentive to work and produce. One thing I saw clearly in my 19 years of working in safety net programs in New York was that when benefits rose, work and earnings declined. And in the major study of UBI-like programs provided in Seattle and Denver, substantial, unconditional payments were found to cause a near 14 percent decline in labor force participation, and a 27 percent reduction in hours worked by women. That’s a labor force drop-off greater than the difference between the highest participation rate we’ve ever seen in this country and the lowest.
That doesn’t only mean people will be less driven than ever to earn their way out of poverty. Less work also means fewer “feelings of citizenship and social inclusion,” worse mental health and feelings of wellbeing, less happiness, worse self-esteem, even worse health among children, more crime, and way more drug abuse. The benefits of working are vast and well-documented, and anti-poverty programs should encourage work – not discourage it.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › 2NC---AT: Inflation Turn---AT: Empirics
Ellen Brown 20, attorney, founder of the Public Banking Institute, and author of twelve books including the best-selling Web of Deb, 4/21/20, https://basicincometoday.com/how-and-why-a-fed-financed-ubi-would-not-lead-to-inflation/
Critics of central bank money injections point to the notorious hyperinflations of history – in Weimar Germany, Zimbabwe, Venezuela, etc. These disasters, however, were not caused by government money-printing to stimulate the economy. According to Prof. Michael Hudson, who has studied the question extensively, “Every hyperinflation in history has been caused by foreign debt service collapsing the exchange rate. The problem almost always has resulted from wartime foreign currency strains, not domestic spending.”
For contemporary examples of governments injecting new money to fund domestic growth, we can look to China and Japan. In the last two decades, China’s M2 money supply grew from 11 trillion yuan to 194 trillion yuan, a nearly 1,800% increase. Yet the average inflation rate of its Consumer Price Index hovered between 2% and 3% during that period. The flood of money injected into the economy did not trigger an inflationary crisis because China’s GDP grew at the same fast clip, allowing supply and demand to rise together. Another factor was the Chinese propensity to save. As incomes went up, the percent of income spent on goods and services went down.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › 2NC---AT: Inflation Turn
Mohammad Rasoolinejad 21, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, 2021, “Universal Basic Income: The Last Bullet in the Darkness,” https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.05658.pdf
UBI has failed in many cases solely due to an uncontrolled money supply to the middle class, which produced hyperinflation. The catch here is that UBI should not be controlled by the executive branch of government. In the case of democracy, it is quite logical to assume each candidate will promise higher UBI rates to gain more votes. This will produce a vicious cycle ending with hyperinflation. UBI should be under the control of an independent entity, such as the Federal Reserve in the United States. That entity will control the money supply and amount of UBI based on projections of inflation. UBI will be an extra tool of the Federal Reserve which can directly target inflation and wealth disparity.
As an example assume the target inflation to be two percent and country’s inflation rate sustainably runs below the target. Eq. 2 gives an estimation for the UBI rate to be paid to achieve the target inflation. After running the program for certain amount of time (for example three months), the inflation rate shall be reassessed. If running below or above the target range, the rate can be readjusted accordingly. UBI rate eventually goes to zero if the inflation rate sustainably runs above the target range.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › 2NC---AT: Inflation Turn
Richard Vague 16, serves on the University of Pennsylvania Board of Trustees and the Penn Medicine Board of Trustees, and on a number of business boards. He is chair of the University of Pennsylvania Press, and chair of the Innovation Advisory Board of the Abramson Cancer Center. He also serves on the Governing Board of the Institute for New Economic Thinking and the board of the Fund for the School District of Philadelphia. 12-2-2016, "Rapid Money Supply Growth Does Not Cause Inflation," Institute for New Economic Thinking,
Monetarist theory, which came to dominate economic thinking in the 1980s and the decades that followed, holds that rapid money supply growth is the cause of inflation. The theory, however, fails an actual test of the available evidence. In our review of 47 countries, generally from 1960 forward, we found that more often than not high inflation does not follow rapid money supply growth, and in contrast to this, high inflation has occurred frequently when it has not been preceded by rapid money supply growth.
The purpose of this paper is to present these findings and solicit feedback on our data, methods, and conclusions.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › AT: Perm Do Both
Mohammad Rasoolinejad 21, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, 2021, “Universal Basic Income: The Last Bullet in the Darkness,” https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.05658.pdf
Current society in developed countries suffers from inequality and a huge wealth disparity. Such an environment leads to the dissatisfaction of the poor and middle class, which can lead to crisis and chaos. Examples of this also happened prior to World War II. The wealth disparity can be decreased by social programs which are usually funded by taxes. Taxation, and especially progressive taxation, seems unfair to the wealthy and also acts as decelerator for the economy. Corporate tax tends to decrease the profit margin of corporations and decreases their comparative advantage on the global scale.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › 2NC---Solvency
Ellen Brown 20, attorney, founder of the Public Banking Institute, and author of twelve books including the best-selling Web of Deb, 4/21/20, https://basicincometoday.com/how-and-why-a-fed-financed-ubi-would-not-lead-to-inflation/
According to an April 6 article on CNBC.com, Spain is slated to become the first country in Europe to introduce a universal basic income (UBI) on a long-term basis. Spain’s Minister for Economic Affairs has announced plans to roll out a UBI “as soon as possible,” with the goal of providing a nationwide basic wage that supports citizens “forever.” Guy Standing, a research professor at the University of London, told CNBC that there was no prospect of a global economic revival without a universal basic income. “It’s almost a no-brainer,” he said. “We are going to have some sort of basic income system sooner or later ….”
“Where will the government find the money?” is no longer a valid objection to providing an economic safety net for the people. The government can find the money in the same place it just found more than $5 trillion for Wall Street and Corporate America: the central bank can print it. In an April 9 post commenting on the $1.77 trillion handed to Wall Street under the CARES Act, Wolf Richter observed, “If the Fed had sent that $1.77 Trillion to the 130 million households in the US, each household would have received $13,600. But no, this was helicopter money exclusively for Wall Street and for asset holders.”
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Money Printing CP › 1NC---Money Printing CP
Mohammad Rasoolinejad 21, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, 2021, “Universal Basic Income: The Last Bullet in the Darkness,” https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.05658.pdf
UBI can be funded through money printing, deficit spending or by revenue from taxes. In the first case, the base money supply will increase. The risk with this case is raising inflation. As long as inflation is under control, money printing can help in many other issues (such as alleviating national debt or increasing comparative advantage of country in the trade) in a manner that is fair to everyone. The following sections will elaborate more on the benefits that money printing can provide.
The government will issue the notes to fund the UBI program in deficit spending. This case resembles transferring money from the wealthy (local or foreign) to the middle class and poor. However, the lower and middle class become endebted to the wealthy and their debt must be paid at a later time. Deficit spending may also cause inflation, as lower-income households tend to spend a higher percentage of household income. This method is not preferable, as raising money through debt issuing is not sustainable in the long run.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---AT: Budget Deficit
Michael W. Howard 18, professor of philosophy at the University of Maine. 2018, "Universal Basic Income: Policy Options at National, State, and Local Levels," Maine Policy Review 27.2 (2018) : 38 -42, https://core.ac.uk/reader/217150830
Are basic-income policy proposals relevant at the state or local level? Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend illustrates how states can create dividends from sovereign wealth funds, or more directly from taxation of the use of common assets. But what about resource-poor states like Maine? Gary Flomenhaft (2012) calculated that even Vermont, also a resource-poor state, has enough resources that, if all the rents were taxed, and the revenue distributed as dividends, every citizen could receive between $1,900 and over $10,000 annually. Of course, clawing back these resources after having turned them over to private companies would face major political challenges.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---AT: Budget Deficit
NASBO 22 – National Association of State Budget Officers, 2022, “Fiscal Survey of States,” https://www.nasbo.org/reports-data/fiscal-survey-of-states
With data gathered from all 50 state budget offices, this semi-annual report provides a narrative analysis of the fiscal condition of the states and data summaries of state general fund revenues, expenditures, and balances. The spring edition details governors’ proposed budgets; the fall edition details enacted budgets.
Overview - Fall 2022
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---Follow On
Nolan Downey 22, Staff Attorney for the Legal Impact Network at the Shriver Center. 4-13-2022, "States Lead the Way," Economic Security Project,
The legacy of so-called “welfare reform” and decades of disinvestment have resulted in a social safety net that perpetuates racism and is fundamentally incapable of allowing people to meet their basic needs and live with dignity. It is time to boldly reimagine the social safety net, eliminate deep poverty and provide stability to middle income households by implementing a guaranteed income. Ultimately, a federal program should be vigorously pursued, but a mass movement needs to be built to overcome gridlock at the federal level. States have a vital role to play as leaders in building public policy. Through creation of state-level guaranteed income programs funded through equitably raised revenue, states can progress toward economic justice for their lowest-income residents regardless of employment status, supplement the existing safety net, and build necessary momentum toward a federal program needed to meet current and coming economic challenges.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---Follow On
Michael W. Howard 18, professor of philosophy at the University of Maine. 2018, "Universal Basic Income: Policy Options at National, State, and Local Levels," Maine Policy Review 27.2 (2018) : 38 -42, https://core.ac.uk/reader/217150830
A more modest, partial basic income could be created at the state level in several ways. A state-level carbon tax, desirable as a way to reduce fossil-fuel emissions, could yield a significant universal dividend, and the dividend would rectify an otherwise regressive and unpopular consumption tax. A carbon tax with progressive tax reductions has been implemented successfully in British Columbia (Durning and Bauman 2014).
The earned income tax credit, which exists at the state as well as the federal level, could be made refundable. That is, those without earned income would receive a credit, increasing their income when it falls below a minimum. It is unlikely that refundable tax credits or carbon taxes at the state level could be large enough to adequately address either the environmental requirements or the income needs, but policies at the state level can pave the way for more adequate policies at the federal level, when the political environment there becomes more favorable.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---Solvency---Ext
Jason Lalljee 21, junior economic policy reporter on the economy team, political science and English @ UChicago. 12-16-2021, "33 basic and guaranteed income programs where cities and states give direct payments to residents, no strings attached," Business Insider,
Here's a look at all the active or recently active guaranteed income programs in the US, in no particular order.
Compton, California
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---Solvency---Ext
Nolan Downey 22, Staff Attorney for the Legal Impact Network at the Shriver Center. 4-13-2022, "States Lead the Way," Economic Security Project,
Advocates for guaranteed income have an array of choice points in program design. While guaranteed income programs have chosen eligible low-income participants based on the characteristics of a target population (e.g. Black mothers in living in public housing or unhoused youth) or residence in a particular geographic area, the breadth of permanent state programs will largely depend on program cost and mechanisms for raising revenue to meet that cost. States also have an opportunity to think creatively about different implementation strategies that utilize existing state infrastructure to deliver cash to eligible individuals – such as enacting or expanding a state Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Child Tax Credit (CTC). Whether a state chooses to build a new program or implement a large-scale guaranteed income through an expanded EITC, either method could have implications for how payments interact with existing social safety net programs. There are also a host of choices around payment level and payment frequency that may have implications on existing benefits. Below is a table showing a high-level depiction of program design from a relevant cross-section of cash transfer programs that have produced meaningful data on how a guaranteed income could impact recipients.26
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 2NC---Solvency
Rachel Treisman 21, writer and editor for the Morning Edition live blog, which she helped launch in early 2021. 3-4-2021, "California Program Giving $500 No-Strings-Attached Stipends Pays Off, Study Finds," NPR,
A high-profile universal basic income experiment in Stockton, Calif., which gave randomly selected residents $500 per month for two years with no strings attached, measurably improved participants' job prospects, financial stability and overall well-being, according to a newly released study of the program's first year.
The Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration, or SEED, was founded in February 2019 by then-Mayor Michael Tubbs and funded by donors, including the Economic Security Project.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › States CP › 1NC---Fifty States do the plan CP
Jason Lallijee 21, Journalist at Insider, 12/16/21, “33 basic and guaranteed income programs where cities and states give direct payments to residents, no strings attached,” https://www.businessinsider.com/how-many-ubi-guaranteed-basic-income-programs-us-cities-states-2021-12
The concept of a "universal basic income" has inspired widespread interest in recent years.
More than interest — when former US presidential candidate Andrew Yang announced that a UBI program of $1,000 direct payments to citizens every month would be the keystone policy of his platform, he drew an unexpected amount of grassroots support in a crowded primary year. Guaranteed income programs have been gaining even more traction during the pandemic, which took a particular toll on low-wage workers and threw many Americans into poverty. At least 11 direct-cash experiments went into effect this year, Bloomberg estimated in January.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Topicality › 2NC---AT: We Meet
Melissa Kearney 19, Neil Moskowitz Professor of Economics at the University of Maryland, with; Magne Mogstad; 11/21/19, “Universal Basic Income (UBI) as a Policy Response to Current Challenges: Summary,” https://www.economicstrategygroup.org/publication/universal-basic-income-ubi-as-a-policy-response-to-current-challenges/
Kearney and Mogstad argue that, in practice, a UBI would be an extremely expensive, inefficiently targeted, and potentially harmful policy that would solve none of the economic challenges it purports to address. First, a UBI that provided $10,000 a year to every American adult would cost more than half of the current annual federal budget. To fund such a program would require the crowd out of existing programs and potential investments. Second, since a UBI is not inherently designed to redistribute resources to the most needy individuals, moving from our current system to a UBI would redistribute resources away from those who are most likely to benefit from income support programs. And third, since a UBI lacks a direct mechanism to help workers learn new skills or broadly support the development of human capital in the U.S., it does not offer a long-term solution to the challenge of weakened employment prospects.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Topicality › 1NC---T – No UBI
Melissa Kearney 19, Neil Moskowitz Professor of Economics at the University of Maryland, with; Magne Mogstad; 11/21/19, “Universal Basic Income (UBI) as a Policy Response to Current Challenges: Summary,” https://www.economicstrategygroup.org/publication/universal-basic-income-ubi-as-a-policy-response-to-current-challenges/
First, on inequality and redistribution, a UBI is by design not ideal for redistributive purposes. For example, a UBI that paid $10,000 to every U.S. adult would cost about $2.5 trillion per year, well more than half the current federal annual budget. Furthermore, by giving money to everyone, there would be far fewer resources available to redistribute money and/or invest in the human capital of those with the most need. In calculations presented below, we show the practical trade-off between giving more money to a more targeted group of low-income individuals and less money to a more diffuse group including less needy individuals. We cite work by Hoynes and Rothstein (2019) documenting the loss of progressivity that would come from replacing our current system of transfer programs with a UBI. We further argue that programs that are universal do not accomplish as much in terms of generating social benefits as those that are targeted, citing evidence from examples such as childcare and early childhood education programs.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Off-Case › Topicality › 1NC---T – No UBI
David Coady 20, social spending expert in the IMF's Fiscal Affairs Department, with; Nghia-Piotr Le; June 2020, “Designing Fiscal Redistribution: The Role of Universal and Targeted Transfers,” IMF Working Paper
Although increasing income inequality has been observed in many countries, the varying experiences across countries, with inequality even decreasing in a sizeable share of countries, suggests that public policy and institutions play and important role in determining such outcomes.2 In this respect, fiscal redistribution (i.e., the transfer of income from higher to lower income households via tax and transfer schemes) has a key role to play in addressing income inequality. For instance, evidence from studies of fiscal redistribution shows that over threequarters of the difference in average disposable income inequality between advanced and Latin American countries (with the lowest and highest average disposable income inequality, respectively) is accounted for by differences in the extent of fiscal redistribution rather than by differences in market incomes (Bastagli, Coady and Gupta, 2015).
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Aff – UBI › AT: Money Printing CP › AT: Competition
Michalis Nikiforos 17, PhD in Economics, Levy Institute research scholar working in the State of the US and World Economies Program, with; Marshall Steinbaum and Gennaro Zezza; August 2017, “Modeling the Macroeconomic Effects of a Universal Basic Income,” https://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/RI-Macroeconomic-Effects-of-UBI-201708.pdf
The Levy model is a purely macro model: it contains aggregate economic actors and treats them as individuals. For example, the “household sector” is one large household, the “corporate sector” is one large firm, and the “government” is one unitary organization that conducts both fiscal and monetary policy. This is standard in the macroeconomics literature but is not necessarily well suited to study the effect of a UBI on the macroeconomy, because a UBI inherently affects the distribution of income among households. If the distribution of income matters for macroeconomic outcomes—and there is reason to think that it does—then a policy like UBI that alters the distribution of income among households needs to be interpreted in light of a distributional model in order to forecast its macroeconomic effect. We thus modify the basic model with adjustments for heterogeneity in income taxes paid and in propensity to consume across households, both of which (we show) are relevant to forecasting the macroeconomic impact of UBI.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Aff – UBI › AT: Money Printing CP › 1AR---Progressive Taxes Good
Sita N. Slavov 20, with Alan D. Vicard, American Enterprise Institute. 9-16-2020, "A VAT-Financed Universal Basic Income Can Still Be Progressive," TAX NOTES FEDERAL, SEPTEMBER 28, 2020,
In reality, a UBI is a highly progressive policy, even if funded by a regressive tax such as a VAT. A VAT-financed UBI would still impose net burdens on the wealthy (and would still provide net benefits to low-income households), although not to the same extent as an income-tax-financed UBI. Carter’s error reflects common misperceptions about the progressivity of taxes and spending.
Although the wealthy would receive UBI benefits, their benefits would be far outweighed by the taxes they would pay to finance the UBI. Carter recognizes that point for the income-tax-financed UBI, noting that “Jeff Bezos would be paying millions of dollars more each year in exchange for his UBI.” However, it is easy to see that Bezos’s VAT payments would also far exceed his UBI benefits, although by a lesser amount.