Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—AI

AI policy drains PC

George Dvorsky 17, 10-25-2017, "Powerful Lobby Group Wants to Keep AI Unregulated," https://gizmodo.com/powerful-lobby-group-wants-to-keep-ai-unregulated-1819842165

The Information Technology Industry Council (ITI)—a Washington D.C.-based lobby group that boasts Google, Amazon, and Microsoft among its many clients—is telling governments to think twice about establishing laws to regulate AI. But given mounting safety, ethical, and social justice concerns, is that such a good idea? On Tuesday, ITI released its “AI Policy Principles,” in which the lobby group outlined “specific areas where industry, governments, and others can collaborate, as well as specific opportunities for public-private partnership.” In the new document, ITI acknowledged the need for the tech sector to promote the responsible development and use of AI, while calling upon governments to support, incentivize, and fund AI research efforts. But as for letting governments take a peek at an ITI client’s source code, or enact laws to steer the safe and ethical development of AI, that’s something it’s a bit less enthused about. “We also encourage governments to evaluate existing policy tools and use caution before adopting new laws, regulations, or taxes that may inadvertently or unnecessarily impede the responsible development and use of AI,” notes ITI in its new list of AI principles. “This extends to the foundational nature of protecting source code, proprietary algorithms, and other intellectual property. Failure to do so could present a significant cyber risk.” According to its mandate, ITI seeks to “encourage all governments around the world—including the US government—to develop policies, standards, and regulations that promote innovation and growth for the tech industry.” It represents some of the heaviest hitters in the tech sector, including Amazon, Facebook, Google, IBM, and Microsoft, while claiming to be “the global voice of the tech sector” and “a catalyst for preparing an AI world.” ITI’s document is timely given just how important AI is starting to become, both in terms of its burgeoning influence on our lives (whether it be a photo-sorting app or an algorithm that invents new medicines), and in the global economy (ITI estimates that AI will add at least $7 trillion to the global economy by 2025). But it’s also timely given the recent calls for oversight and regulation. As Bloomberg reporters Gerrit De Vynck and Ben Brody write: Hypersonic Plane From Venus Aerospace Will Travel to the Edge of Space Big tech companies, and their software, are coming under more scrutiny in the wake of news that Russian-sponsored accounts used social networks to spread discord and try to influence the outcome of the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Algorithms designed by Facebook, Twitter Inc. and Google have also been criticized for increasing political polarization by giving people the type of news they already agree with, creating so-called “filter bubbles.” And the concerns don’t stop there. Developers are starting to be criticized for allowing their AI systems to adopt human biases and prejudices (a recent Princeton study, for example, showed that some AI systems are sexist and racist). There’s also uncertainty about how AI will contribute to technological unemployment, automated warfare, and computer hacking. And there’s still no consensus on the specific ethical or moral codes that need to be imbued into these systems. There’s also the frightening potential, as thinkers like Elon Musk, Stephen Hawking, and others have pointed out, for something to go horribly wrong with AI. As the recent AI breakthrough by Google-owned DeepMind demonstrated, a fast takeoff event, in which AI evolves into a superintelligent form, may happen relatively quickly and without warning, thus introducing catastrophic—and possibly existential—threats. As all of this is happening, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that some concerned observers are calling for the government to step in. Musk has warned that governments need to implement regulations “before it’s too late,” and that it’s only after things get out of hand that we tend to act. Two years ago, the White House implemented a preliminary AI strategy, saying AI needs to be ethical, that it must augment, and not replace, humans, and that everyone should have a chance to participate in the development of these systems. But as for formal regulations, the White House said it’s still premature. As former US president Obama told Wired last year, “Most people aren’t spending a lot of time right now worrying about the Singularity—they are worrying about ‘Well, is my job going to be replaced by a machine?’” “A middle path between no regulation and state regulation is to let industry regulate itself, which is the ITI approach. But this is far from ideal as well: it’s letting the fox guard the henhouse.” Patrick Lin, director of the Ethics + Emerging Sciences Group at California Polytechnic State University, says that regulating new technologies is always a delicate balancing act. “If you set regulation too early, then you may be betting on the wrong standards, and that would be terrible for commercialization, which is important,” Lin told Gizmodo. “The same problem exists with setting too many or unnecessary regulations; they can create barriers to innovation. But commercialization isn’t the only value at stake here; public safety is another value in the equation. So, if there’s little or no regulation for technologies that can have serious impact on our lives—from self-driving cars to AI systems that make criminal sentencing and bank lending decisions—then that will be bad for society. It’s a mistake to have a knee-jerk reaction either way, reflexively for or against regulation. Each technology is different and needs to be considered carefully on its own merits.” Lin says this conversation is currently happening in regards to autonomous vehicles, with one camp arguing that regulatory standards will put manufacturers on the same page about safety-critical functions (which would protect the industry from some liability), with the other camp saying we don’t know enough to start forging standards. “A middle path between no regulation and state regulation is to let industry regulate itself, which is the ITI approach,” says Lin. “But this is far from ideal as well: it’s letting the fox guard the henhouse. There’s no teeth to enforce self-regulations if a company breaks rank; there may be even less transparency than with government regulators; and many other problems.” Currently, the US has no federal agency dedicated to regulating or monitoring AI, and it’ll probably be a while before we see anything like that (if ever). In the meantime, it’ll be up to various groups, both inside and outside the government, to monitor developments in AI, such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (to oversee development of autonomous vehicles) and the Department of Homeland Security (to monitor cybersecurity threats). Some private individuals and companies have created their own groups, such as Musk’s OpenAI initiative and Google’s DeepMind Ethics & Society group. But as Lin points out, there’s a “having your cake and eat it, too” aspect to self-regulation. “On one hand, industry (correctly) says that AI is going to be this game-changing, super-revolutionary thing, but on the other hand, they often tell us not to worry about it, that they have it handled,” he said. “Worse, because the AI industry is so fragmented and full of start-ups—or even individuals without formal education or professional training, working from their basements—you couldn’t possibly get them all on board with your self-imposed regulations, whereas government regulations can use the full force of law to achieve compliance.” Lin says that self-regulation may be better than no regulation or uninformed regulation, especially when it’s about a technology that could cause major problems for society. As examples, he points to fake news, dieselgate, biased decision systems, and so on. Sara Wachter-Boettcher, author of Technically Wrong: Sexist Apps, Biased Algorithms, and Other Threats of Toxic Tech, says she’s happy to see an acknowledgement of the problem and development of shared principles, but the underlying message to her seems to be, “trust us, we’re working on it.” “I would ask, what evidence do we have that they’ve got a handle on removing bias from AI? Why should we trust tech companies when we see examples of them embedding bias into software, or launching products with unintended consequences, every day?,” Wachter-Boettcher told Gizmodo. “I understand that it’s not as simple as lifting the curtain and letting the public look at the code, but there needs to be agreed-upon and enforced levels of transparency and accountability. While industry says it’s afraid of slowing down innovation, I think the rest of us should be a lot more worried about the real risk of flying headfirst into even more inequality, bias, and unintended harm.” In an email to Gizmodo, Jaan Tallinn, the co-founder of Skype, said “we need regulation eventually, but first we need more research into what a positive and effective regulation should look like.” And indeed, those arguing for regulations are having some difficulty articulating what actually needs regulating, and how it should be implemented and enforced. Thankfully, however, these conversations have started and the frameworks for AI regulation are starting to emerge. As Tallinn noted, we’re going to need regulations eventually. The self-serving principles set out by ITI can be seen as pre-emptive attack to delay the inevitable, and to protect its clients from what it sees as meddlesome and potentially costly intrusions. And self-serving it is; it can hardly be said, for example—and as stated in the new list of principles—that the ITI clientele could use some additional financial support from the government. As Oxford philosopher Nick Bostrom wrote last year, “Great resources are devoted to making [progress in AI] happen, with major (and growing) investments from both industry and academia in many countries.” At the same time, investments “in long-term AI safety...remains orders of magnitude less than investment in increasing AI capabilities.” That ITI did not list the funding of AI safety initiatives by industry, government, and private sources as an “AI principle” is as problematic as it is revealing. Moreover, it’s not immediately obvious that profit-driven companies with cranky shareholders in the background are in any way interested in constraints imposed by outside forces, or in voluntarily contributing to the public good. Regulations and government oversight exists in the absence of pro-social forces within the overarching capitalist framework. “We can hope that corporate self-interest will align with public interests, but that is a giant leap of faith, and many companies in ITIC don’t exactly have a great track record at winning public trust,” Lin told Gizmodo. “It’s important to remember that they’re not in the business of protecting the public or promoting democracy—their business is business. When profit motives and humanitarian motives collide, take a wild guess which one usually wins.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—AI

Military-based AI cooperation fails. Public opposition and major private firms will refuse to cooperation.

Lin-Greenberg 20, postdoctoral fellow at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perry World House (Erik, “Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making,” Texas National Security Review, 3.2)//BB

Tepid public support at home and abroad can stymie alliance military operations in two ways. First, public opposition to the use of AI among allied populations may lead policymakers to restrict the use of AI-enabled technologies for military operations. In the event of future hostilities, for example, the South Korean or German governments might oppose an ally’s use of AI-enabled lethal weapon systems on their territory.60 Indeed, advocacy from the public and activist groups has led a growing number of states — including U.S. allies like Pakistan and Jordan — to call for bans on the use of lethal autonomous weapon systems.61 Second, civilian engineers and researchers that develop AI technology may refuse to work on military AI contracts. Disruptions to AI development can hinder the fielding of new capabilities and generate mistrust between the government and civilian firms. Google employees, for instance, protested their involvement in Project Maven, a Defense Department program that uses AI to analyze video collected by military drones.62 In a letter to their CEO, the employees argued that “Google should not be in the business of war,” explaining that the company should not “outsource the moral responsibility of [its] technologies to third parties,” and that work on Defense Department-backed AI would “irreparably damage Google’s brand.”63 The resistance ultimately led Google to terminate its involvement in the contract and generated public criticism of the Defense Department’s AI efforts.64

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—DOD funding

Any slight increase in DoD budget angers voter and is seen as a bolt from the blue

Mark Pocan 20, 7- 20, 2020, Congressman Mark Pocan (D-WI) is the Co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus "The American People Agree: Cut the Pentagon’s Budget ," Data For Progress, https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2020/7/20/cut-the-pentagons-budget

$740 billion. That’s how much Congress is on track to approve for the defense budget in 2021. In the middle of a pandemic, as millions of Americans face unemployment, evictions, and a broken healthcare system. In 2020, the defense budget was 90 times the size of the budget of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Now, we face a pandemic with a lack of resources, no nationwide testing plan, 3.6 million cases and over 138,000 deaths. Maybe, just maybe, we could have been better prepared for this disaster if the budget for our public health agency wasn’t about 1 percent of the defense budget. On Tuesday, Congress will vote on the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), but before that, they will vote on my amendment with Congresswoman Barbara Lee and Senator Bernie Sanders to cut the bloated defense budget by 10 percent. We have a choice. We can ignore the systemic problems that this pandemic has brought to the surface, continue with businesses as usual and rubber stamp a $740 billion giveaway to defense contractors. Or we can listen to the American people and save $74 billion towards their urgent needs—housing, healthcare, education and more. In Data for Progress’ latest poll, the majority of American voters want us to put their needs over the profits of Lockheed Martin, Raytheon and Boeing. Fifty-six percent of voters support cutting the defense budget by 10 percent to pay for priorities like fighting the coronavirus, education, healthcare & housing—including 50 percent of Republicans. image1.png Fifty-seven percent of voters supported cutting the defense budget by 10 percent if funding was reallocated to the CDC and other more pressing domestic needs. Only 25 percent of people opposed the cut, that means more than twice as many people support an over $70 billion cut to our defense budget than don’t, a 2:1 ratio. The polling is abundantly clear: the American people know that new nukes, cruise missiles, or F-35s won’t help them get their next unemployment check, or pay next month’s rent, or put food on their family’s table, or pay for the costs of healthcare in a global pandemic. Over the past four years, during a time of relative peace, America has increased its defense spending by 20 percent, over $100 billion. There is no other part of the Congressionally-appropriated federal budget that has increased by this much—not education, not housing, and not public health. We have seen the effects of supporting this endless cycle of exponential defense spending. In January, President Trump’s unilateral assassination of Iranian General Hassan Soleimani almost led us down the path of another endless war. In the last month, we have seen the President order military responses to civilian protestors in Lafayette Park so he could hold a photo-op and we have seen Department of Homeland Security agents swarm the city of Portland assaulting and arresting protesters. The Pentagon’s bloated budget incentivizes people like President Trump to threaten wars abroad and unleash militarized troops on our own people. The American public has seen this firsthand and this new poll clearly shows that they are fed up. Our nation is facing a pandemic that has killed more American people than the Iraq War, the Afghanistan War, 9/11, the Persian Gulf War, the Vietnam War and the Korean War combined. Yet, despite the coronavirus clearly being the greatest threat to our nation currently, Congress is instead about to authorize and appropriate more money for defense spending than anything else. Tomorrow, you will likely hear some Republicans say that our amendment to cut 10 percent from this budget is another attack from the “leftist mob” in Congress, that we want to undermine this country’s safety. We think America is only as safe as its people at home feel, and right now with rampant unemployment, millions losing healthcare, underfunded education, and families facing eviction—the American people need our help. So often, as progressive members of Congress, we try to explain to our Democratic and Republican colleagues that the American people are more progressive than they think. We point to polls showing overwhelming support for Medicare for All, for a Green New Deal or a $15 minimum wage. Progressive values are mainstream values, because progressive values put people first. That’s why a majority of Americans support cutting our excessively large defense budget—because they no longer see their values or needs reflected in the actions of the Pentagon. Now it’s up to us, the people they elected to represent their interests, to hear them and take action. Tomorrow, Congress can choose—the American people or not.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—DOD funding

Plan perceived as driven by the military industrial complex as a scheme to increase’s DOD funding which angers dems who see it as trading off with domestic issues like Roe

Robert Weissman 22, 6-7-2022, "Americans Widely Reject Proposals for More Pentagon Spending — So Should Congress," Data For Progress, https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2022/6/7/americans-widely-reject-proposals-for-more-pentagon-spending

The United States spends, by far, more on its military than other nations. U.S. military spending is more than the next nine countries combined; it is 12 times the amount Russia spends. Yet demands persist from the military-industrial complex to spend ever more. For the upcoming year (fiscal year 2023), the Biden Administration has requested a $31 billion increase in Pentagon spending, to $813 billion. Congress is poised to add even more to that total — with some saying the United States should spend a trillion dollars on the military budget. The House and Senate Armed Services committees are expected to vote in June on spending levels in the National Defense Authorization Act. Polling from Data for Progress and Public Citizen in May 2022 indicates that spending more on the military than requested by President Biden would be out of step with the public. The polling shows: A strong majority of voters oppose an increase in military spending above Biden’s request. Sixty-three percent of those polled say the military's budget should remain at the level that Biden and the Department of Defense requested. Military spending concerns a majority of Americans, with 55 percent of voters reporting they are “somewhat concerned” or “very concerned” about current proposals for $813 billion in defense spending next year. Democrats overwhelmingly say Pentagon spending should not exceed current levels when thinking about proposals to increase funding (83 percent say spending levels are too high or should remain the same, while 8 percent say military spending should be higher). When informed about how much the military is poised to receive, as compared to other agencies, a majority of Republican voters say the military budget should not be raised further (51 percent, versus 37 percent who think too little is spent). There are very strong policy arguments to cut military spending significantly. Not only does the United States vastly outspend other nations, it doesn’t effectively manage what it does spend. The Pentagon is unable to pass an audit, and Pentagon spending is replete with waste and fraud both small (a spare parts maker with a 3,800 percent profit level) and large (the defective and dysfunctional F-35 program that will cost more than $1.7 trillion over its projected 50-year lifespan, according to the Project on Government Oversight). And money allocated to the Pentagon is money that could instead be spent on priority domestic and human needs, and to ensure true national security. For example, last year Congress increased Pentagon spending by $28 billion over the Biden Administration’s request. That same amount could instead have been spent to scale up global vaccine production and end or at least diminish dramatically the pandemic. Did the extra $28 billion for the Pentagon do anything to make us safer? By contrast, is there any doubt that our national security would have been massively improved if we had helped vaccinate the world? Pentagon cuts also are popular. Fifty-six percent of Americans supported reinvesting 10 percent of the Pentagon budget into coronavirus relief, housing, and education in the first year of the pandemic, according to Data for Progress polling. In this immediate moment, however, the congressional debate is not about Pentagon cuts, but about further increases. Those arguing for more Pentagon spending say it is necessitated by inflation. This argument ignores the fact that the Biden request already accounted for inflation and the fact that the Pentagon does not experience inflation in the same way as the general economy, in part because many of its costs are set by long-term contracts. Others say the Ukraine war necessitates more spending. But the U.S. already spends far more than Russia, and Ukraine-specific expenses are being funded by supplemental spending bills and should not be incorporated into the Pentagon’s base budget. The arguments for still more Pentagon spending are, in short, red herrings. But that’s no surprise. In truth, no matter what Pentagon spending level Biden proposed, the military-industrial complex would respond with the same one-word answer: more. It’s not an argument the American people are buying, however. Congress shouldn’t either.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—Emerging tech

Big tech lobbyist’s means the plan costs PC

Emily Birnbaum 22, 1-24-2022, "Tech spent big on lobbying last year," POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/morning-tech/2022/01/24/tech-spent-big-on-lobbying-last-year-00001144

TECH LOBBYING SURGE — Apple, Amazon, Google and Facebook spent a total of more than $55 million on lobbying the federal government in 2021, according to newly filed lobbying disclosures, breaking their own records and outstripping other top-spending industries in Washington, such as defense and pharmaceuticals, for another year in a row. In comparison, the “Big Four” tech companies spent about $34 million on lobbying in 2020. — Behind the increase: Google’s spending jumped roughly 27 percent, from $7.5 million in 2020 to $9.5 million in 2021, as the company has sought to fend off antitrust legislation and has dealt with concerns about YouTube’s contribution to right-wing radicalization. Facebook and Amazon broke their own spending records, with Amazon shelling out $19.3 million and Facebook spending more than $20 million. Facebook’s spending spree came as the company dealt with fallout from whistleblower Frances Haugen’s revelations; Amazon has faced antitrust heat as well as significant labor complaints. Apple, which has had a more muted presence in Washington, spent $6.5 million in 2021 — a small number compared to its “Big Four” peers but still vastly more than smaller tech companies such as Spotify, which spent $820,000 in 2021. — Speaking of those smaller rivals … 2021 was a huge year for the small- to medium-sized tech companies, which say they have been harmed by gatekeeping by giants like Google, Facebook, Amazon and Apple. Complaints from companies like Oracle, Yelp, Tile and Spotify have taken center stage and informed antitrust legislation now moving through the House and Senate Judiciary Committees. As a result, ‘Big Tech’’s rivals are spending more than ever, too: Oracle, the software company known for taking on Google, spent $9.1 million on lobbying in 2021, up from about $8 million the year before. Microsoft, though hardly a small company, has gained a reputation for lobbying against its tech-sector rivals. It spent about $10.2 million on lobbying in 2021 compared to $9.4 million in 2020, an increase of roughly 8 percent. Fox Corp., the media company owned by Big Tech antagonist Rupert Murdoch, increased its spending by about 22 percent between 2020 and 2021, as the company lobbied in favor of the antitrust bills in both chambers. Fox spent $3.6 million in 2021, compared with $3 million in 2020. Epic Games, which is locked in a legal battle with Apple over Apple’s App Store, registered its first in-house lobbyists during the last month of 2021, reporting $40,000 in in-house lobbying spending. Epic also tapped a pair of high-powered outside lobbying firms last year, the Gibson Group and Subject Matter. — Overall, this spending pales in comparison to the tens of millions spent by Facebook, Amazon and Google. But it’s still notable that these companies are dialing up their presences in Washington, readying themselves for all the fights ahead. NATSEC HAWKS ARE CIRCLING — As the tech antitrust bills pick up steam in the Senate, Google has been the tech company most forcefully pushing the idea that reforms could threaten national security. “Handicapping America’s technology leaders would threaten our leading sources of research and development spending,” Google’s president of global affairs and chief legal officer, Kent Walker, wrote in a blog post last week. He argued that the bill that received a markup, S. 2992 (117), would “give a free pass” to foreign companies and cited a letter from last year from twelve former U.S. national security officials who argued the antitrust bill could hurt U.S. competitiveness. (All 12 former officials have ties to major tech companies, as POLITICO previously reported.) The legislation would prohibit Apple, Facebook, Amazon and Google from favoring their own products and discriminating against rivals on their platforms. Google spokesperson Julie Tarallo told MT that the company believes S.2992 “risks threatening our global competitiveness and security, which is why we will continue urging Congress to take more time to consider these and other unintended consequences.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—Emerging tech

NATO driven innovation alienates millennial and young voters which depresses dem turn out

Will Moreland 19, 4-3-2019, associate fellow with Foreign Policy at Brookings. His research focused on the future of U.S. alliances and multilateralism in a more geopolitically competitive world "Love me today, love me tomorrow? Millennials and NATO," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2019/04/03/love-me-today-love-me-tomorrow-millennials-and-nato/

As NATO leaders commemorate the 70th anniversary of the Washington Treaty, talk of crisis again swirls around the alliance. Yet, against President Trump’s continued skepticism and reports lamenting the lapse in American leadership, signs for optimism surface. Surveys reveal relatively high public support for NATO. The 2019 Munich Security Conference saw the largest, and bipartisan, congressional delegation. Yet, today’s groundswell of public support is likely to instill false confidence in the future of Americans’ sentiments. Backing the alliance is easy today, particularly among the rising millennial generation, as opposition to unpopular policies of Donald Trump. However, when examined in the context of millennial foreign policy priorities, questions emerge as to NATO’s role vis-à-vis the issues that motivate them—and, therefore, the long-term support for the alliance. Despite Trump’s longstanding inclinations, NATO today is in a relatively good place with the American body politic. As the most recent Chicago Council survey finds, not only do “a majority of Americans continue to favor maintaining (57 percent) or increasing (18 percent) the U.S. commitment to NATO…the 18 percent of Americans who want to increase the U.S. commitment to NATO is the highest level ever recorded in Chicago Council surveys.” If talk of a “commitment” seems too vague, respondents broadly feel comfortable, at least in theory, backing up words with action. Fifty-four percent favor using American forces to respond to a Russian invasion of a Baltic state—a new record since the question was first asked in 2014. Such figures help explain the continued, bipartisan willingness to flout the president on this issue. This support is not limitless. For a nation weary from nearly two decades of war, the matter of burden-sharing is a real issue. A Europe perceived to be shirking a growing responsibility for its own defense—such as recent troubling reports from Berlin—could squander that support. Nonetheless, for an alliance turning 70, NATO looks decently well-armed to weather another storm. People carry European Union flags during a protest ahead of a visit by Russian President Vladimir Putin, in Budapest February 16, 2015. Putin will discuss Russian gas supplies to Hungary when he visits Budapest on Tuesday, an adviser to the Russian president said on Monday. The trip will be Putin's first bilateral visit to a European Union country since June 2014, reflecting a warming in ties that has irked some of Hungary's allies in the EU and NATO. REUTERS/Laszlo Balogh (HUNGARY - Tags: POLITICS CIVIL UNREST) - LR2EB2G1H542J no immediate action and is largely synonymous with endorsing partnership with Europe. When the Trump administration—particularly the president—has driven trans-Atlantic rifts over issues from trade to the Iran Deal (Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA), NATO stands out as a symbol of continued cooperation in a turbulent relationship. But as time passes, it is an open question how NATO’s mission tracks with the foreign policy priorities of millennials, fast becoming the largest voter demographic in the United States. While representing a cooperative partnership, which millennials do value, NATO has less direct bearing on the generation’s top five foreign policy goals, as found by research from the Chicago Council and Charles Koch Institute in 2018. Asked for their priorities, respondents cited the importance of: Protecting American jobs: 70 percent Preventing the spread of nuclear weapons: 64 percent Securing adequate supplies of energy: 59 percent Improving America’s standing in the world: 52 percent Combating world hunger: 47 percent Though important issues in their own right, these objectives are not traditional ones with which NATO was created to contend directly: territorial defense and the maintenance of stability in Europe. Such an absence speaks, in part, to the millennial generation’s distance from NATO’s founding moment. For a cohort without any memory of great power conflict, NATO’s key role in deterring war is baked into assumptions about how the world is naturally. Yet if, as my colleague Robert Kagan argues, “we have lived so long inside the bubble of the liberal world order that we can imagine no other kind of world,” then my millennial generation risks great stakes on this assumption. A lack of historical memory that conflict can spark and spread even in Europe is tragic, but not unreasonable. After all, even a scholar as thoughtful on these issues as Barry Posen can question the U.S. commitment to NATO in the popular press without considering the U.S. role in warding against the return of “the German question.” In this broader historical context, the absence of “maintaining U.S. military superiority”—another option on the survey—from millennials’ top five priorities not only contrasts with preceding generations, but raises concerns as to whether the alliance will be resourced to perform its mission or become more of a hollow symbol. THE NEED FOR INFORMED SKEPTICISM Millennial skepticism of a militarized American foreign policy is not baseless. From lived experience, armed force appears ineffective at best, an expensive boondoggle at worst—especially in the Middle East. Particularly since 9/11, as Robert Malley and Jon Finer have argued, “Washington has become addicted to quick military fixes” when “sometimes what’s needed is a far broader approach.” Nonetheless, a U.S. strategy containing a military component oriented toward the forward defense of democracy in an increasingly contested world—as NATO does in Europe—reflects a different dynamic. While millennials are more familiar with scenes of American soldiers patrolling desert streets or civilians mourning casualties from drone strikes as exemplifying military power, the forward deployment of U.S. forces, as a deterrent, has helped maintain peace in Europe and Asia. As a recent RAND Corporation report notes, “U.S. troop presence was associated with…a lower likelihood of interstate war.” That deterrence factor, however, is increasingly called into question. As the congressionally-charted National Defense Strategy Commission report details in Europe: “Russia is seeking to create situations of military strength vis-à-vis America and its allies, and despite its limited resource base, it is having considerable success.” To repair this growing disparity, the commission asserts, “the United States needs more than just new capabilities; it urgently requires new operational concepts that expand U.S. options and constrain those of China, Russia, and other actors.” As NATO allies confront critical questions about the allocation of resources, a more nuanced understanding of the U.S. military role in NATO and Europe is vital to an informed debate on U.S. strategy. Such a conversation should be a debate, not merely acceptance of a limitless military budget. Already millennial skepticism of pursuing military primacy is increasingly represented in an ongoing and vibrant policy debate—particularly among progressives. Considering a spectrum of views, including deviating from military primacy to military sufficiency, is necessary in a climate of heightened geopolitical competition and limited resources. To draw on President John F. Kennedy, the United States may be willing to “pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship,” but it is not wise to pay every price, bear every burden, meet every hardship. Washington must deploy its assets strategically in a competition with authoritarian powers that encompasses a host of domains. The military sphere cannot, and will not, be the end all of the growing competition. But nor can it be wished away as a factor that requires a serious and informed conversation among millennials as to how defense issues, including NATO, should be included in American foreign policy.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—NATO

NATO security cooperation worries voter and is perceived as trading off with domestic issues that appeal more to swing voters

Bruce Stokes 20, 9-4-2020, "US Electorate Shows Distrust of the Realities of Foreign Policy," Chatham House – International Affairs Think Tank, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2020/09/us-electorate-shows-distrust-realities-foreign-policy

Whoever occupies the White House after the election, it is evident the emphasis will be on ‘America First’, and that only characteristics and approaches will differ. If Donald Trump is re-elected, his electoral base will support a continuation of isolationist, protectionist policies. If Joe Biden becomes president, he will enjoy some limited popular backing for international re-engagement, but his voters still clearly want him to prioritize domestic issues. Implications for the foreign policy of the next US administration are evident. America may have a long history of isolationism, but that should not be confused with ignorance of the growing interconnectedness of today’s world. However, Americans are struggling to find a new equilibrium for their country’s role in the world. Around seven-in-ten hold the view that the United States should take a leading or major role in international affairs, and the same number acknowledge that international events affect their daily life. But Americans remain reticent about global engagement, and half of registered voters believe other countries take unfair advantage of the United States. This clear contradiction is mirrored in what can be expected from the election victor, with a Joe Biden administration likely to speak for those who want America to lead, while a second Donald Trump administration is expected to continue complaining about US victimization by an ungrateful world. A majority (57%) of Americans say foreign policy is ‘very important’ to them as they decide who to vote for in the 2020 election. This may seem like a high priority, but American polls often show many issues are ‘very important’ to voters. What matters is relative importance and foreign policy pales in comparison with the significance the public accords to the economy (79%) or healthcare (68%). Immigration (52%) and climate change (42%) are of even less relative importance to voters. Notably, despite the deep partisanship in American politics today, there is no difference between Republican and Democrat voters on the low priority they accord foreign policy. And barely one-third (35%) of the public give top priority to working with allies and international institutions to confront global challenges such as climate change, poverty and disease — in fact only 31% say improving relations with allies should be a top foreign policy priority over the next five years. However, despite this apparent lack of support for international relations, a rising majority of Americans believe international trade is good for the economy — running contrary to many international assumptions that Americans are inherently protectionist. But this increased interest may not amount to much in reality. Americans also believe trade destroys jobs and lowers wages. Trump is clearly wedded to a protectionist worldview and may continue to try dismantling the World Trade Organization (WTO). Biden is unlikely to initiate any new trade liberalizing negotiations given what would be, at best, a slim Democratic majority in the Senate and anti-trade views held by many unions and blue-collar voters among his constituency. Any political capital he commits to trade is likely to focus on reforming the WTO, but privately his advisers admit they are not optimistic. In addition, both Biden and Trump face strong public support for ratcheting up pressure on China, although their lines of attack may differ, with Trump likely to double down on tariffs while Biden would work closely with Europe on both trade and human rights issues. More broadly, almost three-quarters (73%) of Americans now express an unfavourable view of China, up 18 points since the last presidential election. One-quarter of Americans classify Beijing as an ‘enemy’ with almost half saying the US should get tougher with China on economic issues, although attitudes do divide along partisan lines, with Republicans generally more critical of Beijing, but Democrats are tougher on human rights. On immigration, Trump’s policies are out of step with the public. Six-in-ten Americans oppose expanding the border wall with Mexico, 74% support legal status for immigrants illegally brought to the United States as children — including a majority of Republicans (54%) — and as many Americans favour increasing immigration as support decreasing it. But Trump has already promised to double down on limiting immigration if he wins because it is what his Republican electoral base wants and, as with trade, this is one of his long-expressed personal beliefs. If he wins, expect more mass roundups of undocumented people, completion of his border wall and stricter limitations on legal immigration. In contrast, Biden is likely to loosen constraints on immigration because he believes immigration has been good for the economy and the Democratic party is increasingly dependent on Hispanic and Asian voters, the two fastest growing portions of the population. However, open borders are not a Biden option. The US foreign-born population is at near-record levels and, every time in American history the portion of foreign born has come close to being 14% of the total population — in the 1880s, the 1920s and now — there has been a populist backlash. Democrats cannot risk that again. On climate change, there is strong evidence the American public is increasingly worried, and likely to support rejoining the Paris Agreement if Biden is elected and increases US commitments to cut carbon emissions. But the public also appears unlikely to punish Trump if, as promised, he leaves that accord, and he is almost certain to continue denying climate science in the interest of the coal, oil, and gas industries. The public’s concern about global warming does not necessarily translate into support for taking substantive action. There is a huge partisan divide between the number of Democrats (68%) and Republicans (11%) who say climate change is a very important issue in the 2020 election. When pressed on what action they want on climate change, and who they trust to do it, Americans are less likely than Europeans to accept paying higher prices. A carbon tax stands no chance of passing the Senate, thanks to moderate Democrats from fossil-fuel states, and America’s love affair with large, CO²-emitting vehicles shows no signs of ebbing. The outcome of the 2020 US election will almost certainly not be determined by foreign concerns, although an international crisis — a terrorist incident, a military confrontation with China or North Korea — could impact voting in an unforeseen way. But given the mood of the American electorate, if Trump is re-elected, there will be scant public pressure for a more activist, collaborative US foreign policy, beyond support for a tough line on China, while a win for Biden will give more room for some international initiatives. But public opinion data is clear. Voters want the next US president to focus first on domestic issues — overcoming the pandemic, digging the country out of a deep economic hole, calming racial tensions, and reversing inequality. The outcome of the election may end America’s recently antagonistic foreign policy and halt the deterioration of its international role. But dramatic American re-engagement appears unlikely as the public’s priorities lie elsewhere.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Links › L—Generic—NATO

Increasing defense spending on NATO is unpopular across the board—causes the dem’s to lose swing votes

Steven Kull 19, April 2019, Dr. Steven Kull is a political psychologist who studies the impact of public opinion on public policy. He has conducted polls and focus groups in over 30 countries around the, Program for Public Consultation, No Publication, https://publicconsultation.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/NATO_Report_0419.pdf

Defense Spending Levels by NATO Allies Respondents were told about the dispute between the US and other NATO members regarding their lower levels of defense spending towards NATO. Presented three options for dealing with this situation, the least popular option was to press European countries to spend more by threatening to disengage from Europe and possibly withdraw from NATO. The most popular option for both parties, supported by half, was to remain part of NATO, but reduce U.S. military investments to bring them more in line with the level that the Europeans spend. The second most popular option was to press European countries to spend more, but not to threaten to disengage or withdraw from NATO. Respondents were introduced to the dispute between the US and European NATO members over defense spending levels as follows: For some years now there has been a dispute between the U.S. and other members of NATO about their level of defense spending. The U.S. has complained that it spends about 4-5% of the U.S. economy on its military, while European nations generally spend about 2% or less, some as low as 1%. Europeans point out that the amount that the U.S. spends is not only in Europe but also in Asia and in the U.S. homeland, and that Europe already spends twice as much as Russia, which is NATO’s primary focus. Nonetheless, in 2014, the European NATO partners agreed to set a goal to increase their defense spending to at least 2% of their budget. There have been some increases, but only 4 of the 26 European countries have met this goal, though several more are expected to reach this level within the year. One of the largest countries, Germany, is unlikely to reach it at any point in the near future. They were then told that there is some debate about what the U.S. should do about this situation and were asked to evaluate three options with an argument in favor of each one. Three possible approaches were presented. The first argument stressed that the Europeans should stop taking advantage of the US after it freed them from Hitler and defended them during the Cold War, that the Europeans can afford to do their share, and that the Russians pose a smaller threat, so if Europeans do not do more, the US should be ready to disengage from Europe. This argument did only moderately well with an overall majority of 56% finding it convincing. However, there was a sharp partisan divide: 76% of Republicans, but only 39% of Democrats found it convincing. Likewise in very red districts 61% found this argument convincing, but only 43% in very blue districts. The second proposal considered was to press European countries to spend more, but to refrain from threatening to disengage from Europe or withdraw from NATO. The argument for this stressed that it is not really feasible to withdraw from Europe or NATO, that the US should not make such a threat, that doing so could backfire by emboldening Russia and causing Eastern European countries to draw closer to Russia, and that overall, it is better for the US to stand close to Europe and that doing so is affordable. This argument did far better than the first argument. Overall 80% found it convincing as did 87% of Democrats. Among Republicans , 72% found it convincing — roughly the same as the 76% who found the argument for the first proposal convincing — suggesting substantial ambivalence. In very red districts , 72% found the argument convincing — more than the 61% that found the argument for the first proposal convincing. The third proposal was that the US should remain in NATO but adjust its military investment there to be more in line with the European investment. This argument stressed that the European members of NATO spend a substantial amount on the military and many troops under arms, that their reluctance to spend more is understandable given the low level of threat from Russia, that adjusting US commitments might cause Europeans to do more, but even if they do not, NATO will still be far stronger than Russia. This argument also did quite well with 74% finding it convincing. Among Republicans (77%) and in very red districts (75%) it did the best of all arguments, with 72% of Democrats concurring. Asked for their final recommendation, the clear favorite, endorsed by about half overall and by both parties, was the third option. The least attractive option was to threaten withdrawal from Europe and NATO , which was endorsed by just 12% overall —one in five Republicans and a miniscule 4% of Democrats. The option of pressing the Europeans but not threatening withdrawal was endorse d by 35% overall — Republicans 29%, Democrats 41%. Those who voted for Donald Trump in 2016 did not differ much from Republicans. One in five said the US should threaten to withdraw, while 48% favored adjusting the US military commitment.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › ATL abortion right XO

XO didn’t do enough

Michael Collins 22, 7-8-2022, "Biden announces steps to protect abortion access, but advocates urge him to do more," USA TODAY, https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2022/07/08/roe-v-wade-biden-executive-order-protecting-abortion-access/10010822002/

WASHINGTON – Facing pressure from his party to act more aggressively to safeguard abortion access, President Joe Biden on Friday announced steps his administration is taking, including protecting access to medication and making legal representation available to women who choose to travel out of state for the procedure. Advocacy groups have pressed for strong action, such as a declaration of a public health emergency and leasing federal property to abortion providers, since the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade. Biden has resisted such moves. “This is a moment – the moment – the moment to restore the rights that have been taken away from us and the moment to protect our nation from an extremist agenda,” Biden said in the White House Roosevelt Room before signing an executive order that outlines the steps his administration will take. Biden's order instructs the Department of Health and Human Services to protect and expand access to abortion care, including access to medication approved by the Food and Drug Administration as safe and effective for over 20 years. The order tasks the department with expanding access to reproductive health services, including family planning and providers, emergency contraception and long-acting reversible contraception such as intrauterine devices, according to a fact sheet distributed by the White House. The administration promised to increase outreach and public education on abortion and to ensure the safety of patients and providers, including mobile clinics sent to borders to provide care for out-of-state patients. An advocacy group pushing to restore and sustain public insurance said Biden's actions don't go far enough. "We are glad to see the White House start to implement a whole of government approach to abortion access, but this plan, which the White House committed to months ago, is both late and not enough," said Morgan Hopkins, interim executive director of campaigns and strategies at All* Above All. Mini Timmaraju, president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, praised Biden’s order as a “really strong next step" but said she wants to see what specific actions the administration is going to take. 'THIS IS NOT OVER':Harris warns Supreme Court may target gay marriage, contraception next Biden called for the creation of a task force on access to reproductive health care and sought to provide protection to women who travel across state lines to access clinical abortion services. The attorney general's office was instructed to give assistance to states that offer legal protection to out-of-state patients and health care providers. The attorney general and the White House counsel's office will convene private attorneys that offer free legal services, as well as bar associations and public interest groups, to encourage legal representation to patients, providers and other groups that provide reproductive services. Two weeks ago, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the decision in 1973 that established a constitutional right to abortion. Friday, Biden cast last month's ruling as a throwback to the 1800s when women didn't even have the right to vote. His voice rising, Biden said a 10-year-old girl in Ohio got pregnant as the result of a rape and was forced to travel to Indiana to get an abortion. “A 10-year-old girl should be forced to give birth to a rapist's child?" he asked. "I can't think of anything that is much more extreme." Biden called again for Congress to overturn the decision by writing Roe v. Wade into federal law. He said he supports changing filibuster rules in the Senate to make it easier to codify the right to abortion and privacy into federal law. Sixty votes are needed in the Senate to pass most legislation because of the filibuster. Changing the rules would allow senators to write Roe v. Wade into law with a simple majority. Getting rid of the filibuster is up to the Senate, and there aren’t enough votes to make that happen. The fastest way to overturn the ruling, Biden said, is to pass a law to protect abortion rights. “For God’s sake, there’s an election in November,” he said. “Vote! Vote! Vote! Vote!” BEYOND ABORTION:Ruling overturning Roe v. Wade sparks debate about Supreme Court's legitimacy amid partisan passions Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra said federal officials are working to increase access to medication abortion in limited circumstances, ensure providers have appropriate training and resources and direct the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid to take legal steps to protect family planning care. Biden's order instructs Becerra to submit a report in 30 days on protecting access to abortion medication and contraception and ensuring that women have access to emergency medical care. Fatima Goss Graves, president and chief executive officer of the National Women's Law Center, lauded Biden for taking steps to protect access to reproductive services but warned that “speed and intensity” are demanded to get people the care they need. “Undoing these injustices will take efforts by all of us, including using the full force of the federal government,” she said. Hopkins, of All* Above All, said more women are denied reproductive care every day as a result of the Supreme Court ruling. "The ripple effects of the Supreme Court decision will spare no one – and the harm will fall hardest on people of color working to make ends meet," she said. "President Biden must do more." March for Life, which opposes abortion, criticized Biden for issuing the order. "It is tragic that this administration is using its power to push for more and more painful abortions which harm women and take innocent lives," said the group's president, Jeanne Mancini. "Our nation today faces significant challenges, not enough abortion is not one of them."

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › ATL abortion right XO

XO wasn’t sufficient – only the promise of congressional action mobilizes voters

Grace Panetta 22, 7-9-2022, "Democrats' priorities have crumbled under Biden and time is running out for the party to deliver before the midterms," Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/why-democrats-cant-pass-bidens-agenda-2022-7

Enshrining abortion rights nationally: On June 24, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, a move that made abortion illegal in some states. Most congressional Democrats are in favor of a national abortion rights law, and have voted in favor of the Women's Health Protection Act. The bill would make abortion legal in every state and undo most restrictions. It is similar to the abortion rights set out under the now-defunct Roe, though it also allows abortions after viability for undefined "health reasons." For that reason, Republicans have called it "extreme" and refused to support the legislation. It passed the House but has already failed twice in the Senate this year. Eleven more senators would be needed to pass the legislation under the 60-vote threshold. Manchin opposes the legislation, saying it goes beyond Roe. That's why Biden calling for a filibuster carve-out on June 30 is unlikely to be effective. Manchin and Sinema remain staunchly opposed to abolishing the filibuster for any reason. Even without the filibuster, Democrats lack the 50 votes they would need to pass their bill. GOP Sens. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Collins both support abortion rights but say Democrats' bill has gone too far because it doesn't create moral or religious exemptions. Collins is working on a bipartisan abortion rights bill with Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia, but one senior Democratic Senate aide told Insider that Democratic women senators and abortion rights groups say privately that they don't see the legislation going anywhere because nine Republicans would need to get onboard, "which everyone knows will never happen right now." Democrats have stressed that they want to put Republicans on the spot over the issue to draw a contrast between the parties ahead of the November midterms. Only remote possibilities exist for enshrining abortion rights nationally. One would be for some Republicans to cross over on the filibuster and on the abortion rights bill. Another would be for Democrats and Republicans to compromise on which measures they're willing to support. One former leader in the reproductive rights movement told Insider that even a limited bill, such as guaranteeing access to abortion in the first trimester, would help 90% of patients seeking to terminate pregnancies. In such a scenario, states would be allowed to raise the gestation floor if they choose. But both sides remain staunchly divided on the issue, meaning that without a supermajority in the Senate or the abolishment of the filibuster, it could remain in limbo with a patchwork of rules from state to state for years to come.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq—dems win—AT empirics

Empirics flow neg—president’s party has been able to gain seat’s in midterm elections

Dean Obeidallah, 22, 3-8-2022, "Opinion," MSNBC, https://www.msnbc.com/opinion/msnbc-opinion/democrats-chances-2022-midterm-elections-are-better-doomsayers-predict-n1290695

Anyone else sick and tired of hearing so-called political experts predict that Democrats are going to lose badly in this year's midterms? Apparently it doesn’t matter that in President Joe Biden’s first year, 6.6 million new jobs were reported, the strongest first year of job gains of any president since our government began collecting such data in 1939. Nor does it appear to matter that unemployment is down from 6.7 percent in former President Donald Trump’s last full month in office to 3.8 percent and that wages are up 5 percent over the past year. There are multiple signs that tell us Democrats could not only hold on to the House but even pick up a few Senate seats. Pundits tell us it’s an “ironclad” rule — as Fivethirtyeight.com put it — that the president’s party loses congressional seats in midterm elections. Hence, headlines that predict Democrats will lose this November in a “wipeout” and a “bloodbath.” If you listen to these people, you might be tempted to cancel the 2022 election and simply crown the GOP the winners of the House and the Senate. Democrats should be concerned going into November. They hold only a nine-seat margin in the House, and the Senate is divided 50-50, with Vice President Kamala Harris serving as a tie-breaking vote. However, there are multiple signs that tell us Democrats could not only hold on to the House but even pick up a few Senate seats given that there is an open Senate seat in Pennsylvania and a vulnerable GOP incumbent in Wisconsin, both states Biden won in 2020. For starters, while Biden won the White House in 2020, Democrats lost 13 seats in the House. That wasn’t good for the party, obviously, but for 2022 purposes, it means the most vulnerable Democrats are already gone. On the flip side, not a single Republican incumbent in the House lost in 2018. Good luck with GOP pulling that trick twice and not losing even one of the 213 House seats they currently hold in 2022. For example, in New York, the recently finalized congressional map that reflects the 2020 census data is expected to result in Democrats picking up three current Republican seats in November. Plus, history tells us that there have been two times in the modern era that a president’s party gained seats during midterm elections —and the circumstances that led to those victories apply to 2022 in varying degrees. In 1998, with Bill Clinton in the White House, Democrats gained five House seats. How did Democrats buck history? GOP arrogance and overreach. The House GOP, led by then-Speaker Newt Gingrich, impeached Clinton for lying about his affair with an intern, Monica Lewinsky. But as midterm exit polls found, two thirds of voters didn’t think Clinton — who was leading a strong economy — should have been impeached, and they cast their votes accordingly. Today’s GOP is even more arrogant and heavy-handed than Gingrich’s GOP was. Consider the Texas law that bans abortion after six weeks and forces a woman who is raped to carry her rapist’s fetus to term. That abomination of a law is being copied by numerous Republican-controlled states despite the fact that 65 percent of Americans believe the Supreme Court should uphold its landmark Roe v. Wade decision and only 29 percent support the Supreme Court striking down the constitutional right to abortion access. The Republicans don’t care what a majority of Americans think; they only care about imposing their extreme religious beliefs upon the rest of us. In 1998 with Bill Clinton in the White House, Democrats gained five House seats. How did Democrats buck history? GOP arrogance and overreach. Ditto for the party’s overreach by banning books and what they wrongly call critical race theory (CRT). Americans are becoming increasingly aware that so-called CRT bans are racist laws designed to prevent teachers from sharing the history of Black achievement and Black suffering at the hands of white bigots. Look at Virginia where Republican Glenn Youngkin won the governor’s race in 2021 based in part on his attacks on CRT. A recent poll found that 57 percent of Virginians oppose banning CRT and only 37 percent support it. That finding helps explain why Youngkin, who won in November with 51 percent of the vote, is already underwater with a 41 percent approval rating. With only a few exceptions, these extreme abortion bans, bans on books and CRT, and voter suppression efforts in 19 states are embraced by Republicans nationwide. To animate their own voters, Democrats can and should use the GOP’s tyranny against them in 2022. The second time in recent history that a president’s party picked up seats during a midterm election was 2002, the year after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, when President George W. Bush was in the White House with a sky-high approval rating and Republicans gained eight House seats and two in the Senate. While Jan. 6, 2021, and 9/11 are not nearly the same, the 2022 election will be the first after the “domestic terrorism” waged on the U.S. Capitol by Trump supporters trying to prevent the peaceful transfer of power. The big difference, of course, is that after 9/11, Americans united against those who attacked us. In contrast, the GOP overwhelmingly supports and celebrates former President Donald Trump, who radicalized his supporters with lies about the election and called them to Washington to “stop the steal.” Since then, Trump has defended the attackers and suggested he would pardon them if he were elected president again. Republicans want 2022 to be a referendum on Biden’s performance given that his approval ratings are in the low 40s, but Democrats should turn the tables and frame the election as a referendum on Republican extremism: from the oppressive laws mentioned above to their embrace of the man who gave us Jan. 6. That could spike Democratic turnout. Zeeshan Aleem Midterm elections are won and lost on turnout. In the 2018 midterm, when voter turnout was the highest in 100 years, Democrats won 40 House seats. Contrast that with 2014 when voters came out in the lowest number in over 70 years: Democrats lost 13 House seats and nine Senate seats. Ignore the pundits and the noise. When Democrats come out big, Democrats win big. This year is no exception; in fact, history tell us that victory in this November’s election is completely in the hands of Democrats.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq –– AT innovation bill thumper

McConnell kills the bill—no thumper

Joseph Zeballos-Roig 22, 6-30-2022, "Mitch McConnell says he'll kill the bipartisan China bill if Democrats revive their agenda with Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema," No Publication, https://news.yahoo.com/mitch-mcconnell-says-hell-kill-214014174.html

Mitch McConnell vowed to effectively kill major bipartisan legislation if Democrats pursue their own plan. McConnell's statement is a major and perhaps fatal setback for a lengthy effort to pass a China bill. Lawmakers on both sides have moved to bulk up the US semiconductor industry, which is a major part of the plan. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell declared on Thursday that he would block the progress of President Joe Biden's major bipartisan semiconductor bill aimed at thwarting China if Democrats continue to pursue a separate economic plan crafted from the ashes of Build Back Better. "Let me be perfectly clear: there will be no bipartisan USICA as long as Democrats are pursuing a partisan reconciliation bill," McConnell tweeted. In response, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's office blasted McConnell as a tool of the "Chinese Communist Party." Related video: The moment Ketanji Brown Jackson was confirmed to SCOTUS Scroll back up to restore default view. "Make no mistake: Senator McConnell is now siding with the Chinese Communist Party against American workers and American industry," Pelosi spokesperson Henry Connelly wrote on Twitter. "And why? So that the GOP's pals in Big Pharma can keep ripping off Americans struggling to afford their prescriptions." McConnell's statement all but spells the death knell for bipartisan talks that have dragged on throughout the year as both chambers crafted their own sweeping plans aimed at reinvigorating America's supply chain amid China's rise. It comes as Democrats inch closer to striking a deal at reviving their stalled party-line climate and healthcare bill. Democratic and Republican leaders continuously feuded over the China bill's scope in negotiations this year. Republicans pressed Democrats to ditch provisions dealing with trade, labor, and immigration to keep it smaller. A chunk of the bill set aside $52 billion to shore up the US semiconductor industry during a chip shortage, a key Democratic priority. Centrist Democratic Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema are key votes on Biden's stalled economic agenda. All 50 Senate Democrats must band together to advance the smaller spending bill with a tie-breaking vote from Vice President Kamala Harris. Spokespeople for Manchin and Sinema didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. Biden and the White House have repeatedly made clear that passing the China bill is a major priority. The legislation, the USICA or United States Innovation and Competition Act, is at times just called the China bill. It is so massive that it has sparked a reputation for all of the various special-interest driven provisions that have found their way into the text. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo has repeatedly warned that failing to pass the legislation could have devastating consequences. Raimondo said on CNBC on Monday that GlobalWafers might not follow through on its plans to build a $5 billion factory in Texas if the bill fails. "It has to be done before they go to August recess," said Raimondo, who has been closely involved in the talks. "I don't know how to say it any more plainly. This deal … will go away, I think, if Congress doesn't act." Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer authored the Senate's version of the bill, a sign of just how serious leadership is in passing it. Biden also pushed it during his State of the Union address in March. The Senate passed its $250 billion package last June. The House advanced its own plan in February. Both sides have been trying to sort out the details for months. "To compete for the best jobs of the future, we also need to level the playing field with China and other competitors," Biden said during his address. "That's why it is so important to pass the Bipartisan Innovation Act sitting in Congress that will make record investments in emerging technologies and American manufacturing."

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–roe k2 dems win

Dobbs decision could turn the race towards Democrats

Narea and Zhou 7/10 – Nicole Narea covers the personalities, conversations, and political battles shaping state-level races and polices and why they matter to the entire country and Li Zhou is a politics and policy reporter for Vox, 7-10-2022, "The battleground House and Senate races where the end of Roe could have the biggest impact," Vox, https://www.vox.com/2022/7/10/23200973/abortion-house-senate-midterms-roe-dobbs

In the wake of the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, Democrats have repeatedly proposed the same solution: voting in the midterms. “If you want to change the circumstances for women and ... girls in this country, please go out and vote,” President Joe Biden emphasized in a speech on Friday. “For God’s sake, there’s an election in November.” As Democrats stare down the typical backlash the president’s party experiences in the midterms, they hope abortion rights will energize voters in key battleground states and districts and combat this dynamic, helping them keep their majorities in the House and Senate. Whether it does remains to be seen: There are still several months before the midterm elections, and voters are focused on a number of issues, including the economy. According to multiple polls conducted in June and July, inflation remains a top issue for many voters, though abortion rights is highly ranked as well. Giving Democratic lawmakers hope, too, are other surveys that have found Democrats are more likely to say they’ll vote in the midterms because of abortion rights compared to Republicans. It’s worth noting that most of these surveys were national, and that abortion rights could have a bigger impact at the regional level, particularly in states where abortion rights are actively being threatened or restricted. When it comes to congressional races, the issue is likely to have the largest effect in swing Senate and House seats where candidates are in extremely tight contests — races in which even small shifts in turnout and enthusiasm could make the difference.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–roe k2 dems win

Roe v. Wade has inflamed voters and urged reevaluation of parties – will cause a dem win

Cox 7/8 [Ana Marie Cox, Ana Marie Cox is an American author, blogger, political columnist, and critic. The founding editor of the political blog Wonkette, she was also the Senior Political Correspondent for MTV News, and conducted the "Talk" interviews featured in The New York Times Magazine from 2015 to 2017, “Democrats Can Win if They Embrace the Politics of Fear”, New York Times, July 8 2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/08/opinion/democrats-abortion-midterms.html]//RA

When it comes to abortion rights, the Democrats need to lean into the politics of fear.

They face a base that feels betrayed and a set of wealthy, moderate voters in purple states who  Democrats need both of these groups to stave off defeat in the fall, and fear can drive them to the polls. What should the Democrats tell them to be afraid of? A national abortion ban.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–roe k2 dems win

Roe overturning increases voter turn out

Hulse and Lerer 21 [Carl Hulse is chief Washington correspondent and a veteran of more than three decades of reporting in the capital Lisa Lerer is a national political correspondent, covering campaigns, elections and political power https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/20/us/politics/abortion-2022-midterm-elections.html]//LP

With the Supreme Court ruling likely to come next year — less than six months before midterm elections that will determine control of Congress and the future of President Biden’s agenda — the court’s expanded conservative majority has injected new volatility into an already turbulent political atmosphere, leaving both parties to game out the potential consequences. Republicans had already shown that they intended to take aim at Democrats over social issues, and abortion will only amplify the culture wars. Nearly all agree that the latest fight over Roe, which has been building for years, is certain to have significant political repercussions. Conservative voters are traditionally more energized than liberals about the abortion debate, and for many of them it has been the single issue spurring voter turnout. But Democrats, likely to be on the defensive given their current hold on the White House and Congress, say a ruling broadly restricting abortion rights by a court whose ideological makeup has been altered by three Trump-era appointees could backfire on Republicans and galvanize women. “Outlawing Roe would create a backlash that would have critical unintended consequences for those who would like to repeal it,” said Senator Jeanne Shaheen, Democrat of New Hampshire and a leading voice in Congress for abortion rights. “The women of the country would be very upset, particularly young women, that there would be such a deliberate effort to limit women’s access to reproductive choices.” Those on the right, already anticipating a favorable ruling given the conservative tilt of the 6-3 court, say they expect liberals to seize on the issue to try to “scare” voters. But they believe they can make a case for “reasonable” abortion limits. “This is clearly going to invigorate people on both sides of the debate, but this is a winning issue for pro-life candidates,” said Mallory Quigley, a spokeswoman for the Susan B. Anthony List, a conservative nonprofit. She said she did not expect conservative voting enthusiasm to ebb if the right triumphed at the Supreme Court, an outcome that would bring to fruition years of emphasis on electing anti-abortion lawmakers at the federal and state levels and working aggressively to confirm conservative judges. “What happened on Monday is evidence that elections have consequences,” Ms. Quigley said, referring to the Supreme Court’s decision to take a case about a Mississippi law that seeks to ban most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy — about two months earlier than Roe and subsequent decisions allow. The Supreme Court action may have political ramifications before next year. The case is likely to be argued weeks before Virginia voters head to the polls in November to elect a new governor in a race often seen as a midterm bellwether. Terry McAuliffe, a former governor and most likely the Democratic nominee, is eager for another political battle over abortion rights, rattling off his record protecting clinics in the state and vetoing legislation that would impose restrictions.. “This is going to be a huge motivator,” he said in an interview. “In 2013, I promised women I would be a brick wall to protect their rights. And I will be a brick wall again.” Senator Rick Scott of Florida, the chairman of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, downplayed the potential effect of the court ruling, though he said that as an abortion opponent he welcomed the court taking up the case. But Mr. Scott said he believed voters would be more persuaded by what he described as the Biden administration’s failings on issues such as immigration, the economy, taxes, inflation and more. While the lines have always been starkly drawn on abortion into the pro and anti camps, public opinion has proved more nuanced, with a clear majority backing Roe but majorities also favoring some limits. How the Supreme Court comes down on the fine points of abortion law could determine how the issue plays in the elections. “Considering the decision will likely be made five months ahead of the election, and depending on the decision itself, it’s too early to measure its ultimate impact on the midterms,” said Nathan Gonzales, the editor of the nonpartisan Inside Elections. Mr. Gonzales said it could conceivably energize Republicans but also pay benefits for Democrats — a view shared by others. President Donald J. Trump helped inspire record turnout last year from Democratic voters, who were eager to reject his administration. With Mr. Trump no longer on the ballot, many Democrats say the Supreme Court case could provide crucial midterm motivation, particularly for suburban women in swing districts who were instrumental in Democratic wins last year. Katie Paris, the founder of Red, Wine and Blue, a group focused on organizing suburban female voters for Democrats across the country, said the Supreme Court news immediately touched off alarm on the Facebook groups and other social media channels run by her organization. “When the news came out that this was going to be taken up, it was like, ‘Everybody get ready. This is real,’” she said. “We know what this court could do, and if they do it, the backlash will be severe.” Tresa Undem, a pollster who specializes in surveys on gender issues, said that abortion rights would continue to be an effective cause for Democrats because voters link it to larger concerns about power and control that motivated female voters during the Trump administration. “Democrats and independents have felt a loss of control and power from people at the top,” said Ms. Undem, who has conducted polling for several abortion rights organizations. “Now you have six individuals who are going to make these decisions about your body in this personal area that will affect the rest of your life.” Mr. Bennet said he could not predict the political implications of the court taking on abortion, but he wanted to alert his supporters that something of consequence was at hand. “There are a lot of people who have worked for a long time to overturn Roe v. Wade, and that is what is at stake,” he said. “I think people needed to hear that in the wake of the Supreme Court taking this case from Mississippi.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–roe k2 dems win

Abortion right’s mobilizes voters now but the plan weakens the signal

Josh Marshall 22, 6-6-2022, Joshua Marshall is an American journalist and blogger writing about elections for 25 years "Opinion," No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/06/opinion/democrats-midterms-abortion-roe.html

Democrats hope to make November’s midterm elections a referendum on Roe v. Wade, the linchpin decision upholding abortion rights, which the Supreme Court is almost certain to strike down this summer. That strategy makes sense. Polls show that roughly two in three Americans oppose overturning Roe and almost 60 percent support passing a bill to set Roe’s protections in a federal law. What’s more, polls showed a rising number of voters listing abortion as their top midterm issue after news of Roe’s imminent demise leaked in the form of a draft court opinion published by Politico. Unfortunately, their current plan is almost sure to fail. After the Democrats came up with just 49 votes to bring a Roe-protecting bill before the Senate on May 11, they promised to keep fighting and, in the words of Senator Amy Klobuchar, “take that fight right to the ballot box” in November. But you can’t make an election into a referendum on an issue if you can’t point to anything winning the election would accomplish. To make the 2022 elections a referendum on Roe, Democrats have to put protecting Roe and abortion rights on the table. Here’s one way to do that: get clear public commitments from every Senate Democrat (and candidate for Senate) not only to vote for the Roe bill in January 2023 but also to change the filibuster rules to ensure that a majority vote would actually pass the bill and send it to the White House for the president’s signature. At present, there are likely 48 Senate Democrats who can make that pledge. Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema are dead set against any changes to the filibuster — a fact you likely know because most of President Biden’s agenda has been bottled up behind their refusal for the past year. Some claim that Senators Manchin and Sinema are just taking the public heat for a number of other Senate Democrats who are also unwilling to change the filibuster rules. That’s highly unlikely. But if any do have misgivings, that’s why the public commitments are so important. Getting a list of holdouts down to a publicly named handful is the first step to persuading them to fall in line. If my math is right and there are 48 Senate Democrats ready to make that pledge, they need two additional Democratic senators in the next Congress. And that is the party’s message that makes the 2022 midterms a referendum on Roe: “Give us the House and two more senators, and we will make Roe law in January 2023.” The End of Roe v. Wade Commentary by Times Opinion writers and columnists on the Supreme Court’s decision to end ​​the constitutional right to abortion. Michelle Goldberg: “The end of Roe v. Wade was foreseen, but in wide swaths of the country, it has still created wrenching and potentially tragic uncertainties.” Spencer Bokat-Lindell: “What exactly does it mean for the Supreme Court to experience a crisis of legitimacy, and is it really in one?” Bonnie Kristian, journalist: “For many backers of former President Donald Trump, Friday’s Supreme Court decision was a long-awaited vindication.” It might also mark the end of his political career. Erika Bachiochi, legal scholar: “It is precisely the unborn child’s state of existential dependence upon its mother, not its autonomy, that makes it especially entitled to care, nurture and legal protection.” No ambiguity, no haggling, no living in Senator Manchin’s head for a year. You give us this, and we’ll give you that. That tells voters exactly what will be delivered with a Democratic win. It also defines what constitutes a win: control of the House and two more Senate seats. Dig deeper into the moment. Special offer: Subscribe for $1 a week. The campaign message is clear: If you want to protect Roe, give us those majorities. If this is your passion, here’s where to channel that passion. These are the Senate seats we need to hold (in New Hampshire, Arizona, Georgia and Nevada) and here are the ones we need to win (in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin and possibly in Ohio, Florida and North Carolina). With those commitments in hand, one question should be on the lips of every Democratic candidate. Will you make a firm commitment to never vote for a federal law banning abortion nationwide? Few, if any, Republicans would be able to make that pledge. And their evasions wouldn’t just make them look ridiculous; that would put squarely on the table the very real threat that Republicans would enact a nationwide abortion ban as soon as January 2025. That could prove enough to win Senate races in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Ohio. In a way, though, this strategy isn’t so much about winning the 2022 midterms or even making Roe into a federal law, although it’s the best way to accomplish both. It’s just an example of how you win elections. Effective campaigns are built on connecting the intense beliefs of the electorate — their hopes and fears — directly to the hard mechanics of political power. You’ve got to connect those wires. If you were testing some new electrical contraption, that’s the first thing you’d do: make sure the energy supply is wired to the engine that makes it run. This is no different. Without tying a specific electoral result to a clear commitment to a specific legislative action after the elections, you’re not connecting those wires. What Democrats would be proposing is a classic small-c conservative solution in the best sense of the word. Codifying Roe would preserve the set of rights and protections that the vast majority of Americans have lived their entire adult lives with and that the overwhelming majority of Americans do not want to change. The threat that the court will strike down such a law is real but overstated. And in any case, refusing to act because of what opponents might do is the definition of political paralysis. So how do Democrats get from here to there? They likely can’t rely on the party’s leaders, at least not at first. But they’re not essential. It’s really up to voters and activists and particularly committed members of Congress. Probably half the Democrats in the Senate would be happy to sign on this dotted line by the end of the day. Those who are up for re-election, even in safe races, will come around quickly. Some senators may resist at first. And that wouldn’t be surprising. Politicians seldom see any advantage to committing themselves in advance or reducing their room for maneuver. It’s always safer to keep your options open and be as general as possible until the final moment. That’s why assembling a clear public list of commitments is critical. Once the list gets down to a handful of hesitaters, the pressure from Democrats nationwide, focused on those members, will be overwhelming. If there are real holdouts, they’ll fold in short order. You don’t need to wait on Nancy Pelosi or Chuck Schumer or President Biden. You can get the ball rolling by calling up your Democratic senator today.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–roe k2 dems win

Reversal of Roe v Wade could flip midterms towards the democrats

Scher 7/5 – Bill Scher is a political writer at the Washington Monthly. He is the host of the history podcast When America Worked and the cohost of the bipartisan online show and podcast The DMZ., 7-5-2022, "The End of Roe v. Wade Could Help Democrats in These Midterm Races," Washington Monthly, https://washingtonmonthly.com/2022/07/05/the-end-of-roe-v-wade-could-help-democrats-in-these-midterm-races/

Here are some vulnerable Republicans. GOVERNORS: Brian Kemp (Georgia), Ron DeSantis (Florida), and Greg Abbott (Texas) These Republican governors signed abortion bans that are unpopular in their states. Just this week, a Quinnipiac poll showed the Georgia gubernatorial race between incumbent Republican Brian Kemp and former House Minority Leader Stacey Abrams in a dead heat, with Abrams closing a two-point gap since January. However, a smattering of prior polls from other outfits suggests that Kemp may still hold a slight lead. Kemp signed a 2019 law effectively banning abortion after six weeks of pregnancy, with exceptions for risking the mother’s death, “medically futile” pregnancies, and—if a police report is filed—rape and incest. The law has not been enacted because of a federal court injunction, but now that Roe is gone, the injunction should be soon lifted. Most Georgians won’t celebrate. A January Atlanta Journal-Constitution poll found that 54 percent of Georgia voters opposed the law, and 68 percent did not want Roe overturned. The Democratic gubernatorial nominee in Texas, former Representative Beto O’Rourke, might face a tougher battle as he trails Governor Gregg Abbott by five points in the most recent Quinnipiac poll and eight points in the most recent CBS/YouGov poll. But regarding abortion policy, Quinnipiac found that Texas voters preferred O’Rourke over Abbott by two points. And 59 percent of Texans in the CBS/YouGov poll disapprove of Abbott’s handling of abortion. (The Quinnipiac poll was taken before, and the CBS/YouGov poll was partially taken before, the Dobbs ruling.) Perhaps O’Rourke can widen that margin. Abbott has already enacted a six-week abortion ban and a ban on most distribution of abortion pills. He also signed a trigger law, which will soon detonate, banning all abortions except to save the mother’s life, with a maximum sentence of 99 years for abortion providers. Yet, according to the June Quinnipiac poll, 59 percent of Texas voters support legal abortion in all or most cases. A December Spectrum News/Ipsos poll found that 55 percent opposed the six-week ban. As I wrote last month, Abbott’s unpopular abortion position hadn’t weakened his overall standing, because the impact of his policies hadn’t been widely felt. Most Texans seeking abortions were still getting them, either by illegally obtaining pills or by crossing state lines. But with an even more draconian law about to go into effect and disappearing abortion access in three of its four neighboring states, the loss of reproductive freedom may soon be more painfully noticeable. In Florida, DeSantis signed a law in April banning abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy, a rare example of the right-wing firebrand not going to the farthest possible extreme. He is being pressured by the right to go further in the wake of Dobbs, even though most Florida voters didn’t want him to go as far as he did. In a February poll from the University of North Florida, 57 percent opposed the 15-week ban, which went up to 62 percent when informed that the legislation had no exceptions for rape and incest. Florida’s support for abortion rights is long-standing, and the state constitution includes a right to privacy that has been interpreted by state courts to cover reproductive freedom. A 2012 attempt to supersede court rulings with an anti-abortion ballot initiative failed, with 55 percent of the electorate voting against it. In fact, on June 30, a county circuit judge placed a temporary injunction on the 15-week ban because it runs afoul of the state constitution. But the Florida Supreme Court is stocked with Republican appointees—who serve six-year terms—and may follow the U.S. Supreme Court’s example, disregard precedent, and overrule the lower court. If it upholds the ban, that will give the Democratic nominee—to be chosen in an August primary—an even stronger argument for replacing DeSantis. Other 2022 governor’s races to keep an eye on: Arizona, Iowa, Ohio, South Carolina, and South Dakota: According to the data from Grumbach and Warshaw, these states have pro-choice majorities. (South Dakota just barely, though its voters in 2006 and 2008 defeated proposed abortion bans in referenda.) Yet Ohio’s Mike DeWine, Iowa’s Kim Reynolds, and South Carolina’s Henry McMaster all signed effective six-week bans (injunctions have been lifted in Ohio and South Carolina). South Dakota’s 2005 trigger law lacks rape and incest exceptions—and defies the voters’ will in subsequent referenda. Nevertheless, it’s kicking in with Governor Kristi Noem’s enthusiastic support. Also, in Arizona, where the incumbent Republican is not running for reelection, a 1901 law banning abortions enacted when Arizona was a territory might be resurrected. The four incumbents are viewed as having easy paths to reelection in November; The Cook Report with Amy Walter rates McMaster, Noem, and Reynolds as “Solid,” with DeWine as “Likely.” But it’s worth watching to see if their unpopular abortion stances give their Democratic challengers a fresh foothold.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq–– tipping point now

Right now key – if the dem’s can shift public perception now they can get ahead

David Siders 22, 6-29-2022, "Roe jolts the midterms: 5 takeaways from the 2022 election midpoint," POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/news/2022/06/29/roe-jolts-the-midterms-5-takeaways-from-the-2022-election-midpoint-00043082

Donald Trump’s legacy was on trial in Washington on Tuesday. But it was his future as the leader of the Republican Party that was being tested elsewhere in the country in the first primaries of the post-Roe v. Wade world. More than half the states have now held primaries, and we’re beginning to see just how important Trump may be to the GOP — and how important Roe may be to the Democrats. They are desperate to stave off disaster in November, and from the Democrats’ messaging on Roe to their interventions in Republican primaries in Colorado and Illinois on Tuesday, the latest big round of multi-state primaries offered the first test of Democrats’ new outlook on the midterms. As Trump labors to hold onto the GOP and Democrats labor to limit their losses in the midterms, here are five takeaways from a big primary night — and a midterm report card on the state of the race: Trump is worse off than ever Donald Trump’s preferred candidate in a contested House race, Rep. Mary Miller, won her member-on-member primary in Illinois on Tuesday. But that’s not likely to be the talk of the town, not after the testimony heard Tuesday about his culpability in the riot at the Capitol on Jan. 6. Even on good nights for the former president these days, he keeps taking hits. Halfway through the midterms, Trump’s candidates have won competitive primaries in Ohio and Pennsylvania, among other states. And there have been scores of Republicans who faced minimal or no opposition who Trump endorsed to pad his resume. By the end of the primaries, he’ll be crowing about his designed-to-be-favorable scorecard in the midterms. But there’s a reason that every time one of his endorsed candidates wins, Republicans point back to Trump’s collapse in Georgia, or to polls like the one in New Hampshire last week that had Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis statistically tied with Trump among Republican primary voters in the first-in-the-nation primary state. The primaries have been mixed for Trump. He may not be beaten, but he’s beatable — and that wasn’t so clear when the primary season began. What’s more, while primaries drag on around the country, Trump is getting mauled in Washington, where the Jan. 6 committee hearings appear to be having at least some effect. Fifty-eight percent of Americans now think Trump should be prosecuted for his role in the riot at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, according to a recent ABC News/Ipsos poll, up slightly from previous measures. And that was before Tuesday’s jaw-dropping testimony about Trump’s behavior on Jan. 6. Between Trump’s mixed midterm record, DeSantis’s rise and the testimony on Tuesday, said John Thomas, a Republican strategist, the party is “starting to see a crack here” in Trump’s grip on the party. Dick Wadhams, a former Colorado Republican Party chair and longtime party strategist, said, “There are a lot of signs the party is starting to move ever so slightly away from Trump.” SCOTUS is the new Trump The testimony on Tuesday — that Trump was told supporters in Washington on Jan. 6 were armed — gave Democrats yet another Trump-related outrage to pin on the GOP. But electorally, the effectiveness of yoking Republican candidates to Trump has always been in question. It didn’t work for Terry McAuliffe in last year’s gubernatorial race in Virginia. It hasn’t moved polling at all this year. And by November, Trump will have been out of office for nearly two years. The better foil for Democrats is almost certain to be the Supreme Court’s overturning on Friday of Roe v. Wade. And Democrats know it. Judging by Tuesday’s primaries, the party in power in Washington will be running against the court in the fall. The messaging began even before the decision came down. Dems prepare for showdown in state legislatures post-Roe | The Midterm View The Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee has now become one of the most important arms of the Democratic party post-Roe. Eugene Daniels talks to Jessica Post, of the DLCC on how abortion rights will be used in the 2022 midterm elections. Democratic Rep. Sean Casten, who beat Rep. Marie Newman in a member-on-member primary in a Chicago-based district, ran ads pledging to defend abortion rights from “extreme Republicans and right-wing judges.” (Newman had put the matter to voters in personal terms, describing her own decision, at 19, to have an abortion.) In the race to fill the seat now held by retiring Rep. Bobby Rush, an outside group promoting Karin Norington-Reaves aired TV spots with black-and-white images of conservative justices, saying Norington-Reaves would “fight against the tyranny of the good old boys.” Norington-Reaves was running behind in that primary late Tuesday. But the ad will likely endure. It’s the kind of framing an incumbent party uses when it needs to run against something – and Democrats aren’t pleasing voters enough in Washington to be running on what they’ve done. “You can run against the Supreme Court,” said Craig Hughes, a Democratic strategist in Colorado. “I do think Roe will absolutely matter.” Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez speaks to abortion-rights activists in front of the U.S. Supreme Court after the Court announced a ruling in the Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organization case on June 24, 2022, in Washington, DC. ROE V. WADE OVERTURNED There are reasons to think Hughes may be right — not enough to keep Democrats from losing the House, probably, but at least enough to limit their losses. The ruling was unpopular, and in three polls released since the Roe decision, the generic ballot has shifted in Democrats’ favor — with voters favoring Democratic candidates over Republicans in November by as much as 7 percentage points. “Hoping it’s the start of a trend,” said Kelly Dietrich, a former Democratic fundraiser who is based in Illinois and founded the National Democratic Training Committee, which trains candidates across the country. “We’ll see.” Democratic voters aren’t turning out — yet Primary turnout has historically been a poor indicator of general election turnout, but in a year in which Democrats are desperate for younger, lower-propensity voters to find their way to the polls, the early turnout numbers in Illinois and New York on Tuesday were another bad sign. In Illinois, early vote totals were lagging 2018 totals both statewide and in Chicago, the kind of big, Democratic city where an outpouring of voters due to Roe, if one were to come, would have been expected. It was the same story in New York, where turnout was expected to be lackluster. Democrats may be furious about Trump’s behavior on Jan. 6 or about the Supreme Court’s behavior last week. But it’s not translating into voting — at least not yet. “Nobody’s turning out,” said one Democratic strategist in Illinois who requested anonymity to speak freely. “I mean nobody. Nobody is voting … The early vote numbers are abysmally bad.” The strategist said voters are “pissed off” but that between Roe and voting, “I don’t think people are connecting the dots.” Democrats came into the midterm election cycle facing historic headwinds, widely expected to lose the House in November. And things haven’t been going their way since. President Joe Biden’s public approval rating has dropped below 40 percent. Inflation does not appear to be going anywhere, and a recession may be near. There is still a path for Democrats to blunt Republicans’ gains. If Democrats can prosecute the case on Roe effectively, their voters could have reason to turn out in November. And the Jan. 6 committee may get what James Carville, the former Bill Clinton strategist, called a “head of steam.” It certainly looked like it might on Tuesday. “The path is not impossible,” Carville said. Still, early voting in the general election isn’t far off. “If this needle doesn’t move by the end of July,” Carville said, “it’s probably not going to move.” Democrats’ savvy, sad ‘choose your own adventure’ It tells you everything you need to know about how bad things are for Democrats this year that they spent heavily in Illinois and Colorado on Republicans, meddling in the opposition’s primaries in a bid to guarantee win-able elections in the fall. Joe Biden carried those states by about 17 percentage points and 14 percentage points, respectively, in 2020. They aren’t exactly states a confident party would expect to swing to the GOP. Yet in a difficult midterm year, even Democrats acknowledge the map for Republicans could expand. Call the spending ahead of Tuesday’s primaries an insurance policy. In Illinois, where Democrats sought to tear down Richard Irvin in the gubernatorial primary, the intervention worked, elevating a Republican state senator, Darren Bailey, who is widely viewed as less electable than Irvin in the fall. Republican gubernatorial candidate Darren Bailey, right, laughs with his wife Cindy Stortzum. Republican gubernatorial candidate Darren Bailey, right, laughs with his wife Cindy Stortzum while responding to reporters questions after winning the Republican primary Tuesday, June 28, 2022, in Effingham, Ill. | Charles Rex Arbogast/AP Photo But in Colorado, the strategy was a bust. Outside groups poured millions of dollars down the drain in an effort to keep businessman Joe O’Dea from winning the Republican U.S. Senate nomination, and he won, anyway. So did Republicans running in two other Colorado races Democrats tried unsuccessfully to sway. It’s hard to argue with the politics of Democrats trying to set up the best race they can. Still, as one Colorado-based Democratic strategist put it, “This choose-your-own-adventure thing is a little bit of risk-reward.” Money is always scarce in general elections, and Democrats may be groaning about the Colorado investment in November. The ‘Big Lie’ takes a hit It was a big night for pro-democracy Republicans in Colorado, where a threesome of election deniers appeared headed to defeat. Ron Hanks, a Colorado state representative who was in Washington on Jan. 6, 2021 and maintains, falsely, that Trump won, lost to O’Dea, a more moderate Republican, in the U.S. Senate primary. Tina Peters, a county clerk who was indicted on charges she was part of voting system technology breach scheme, went down in her primary for secretary of state, as did Greg Lopez, who also believes Trump won, in the gubernatorial race. Pair those with the big night election defenders had in Georgia’s gubernatorial and secretary of state races last month, and the Big Lie is taking some hits. But it’s nowhere near close to fading out of the GOP. In Illinois, Miller, who campaigned with Trump recently, won despite voting against certifying the 2020 election, and hitting her opponent, Rep. Rodney Davis, for his votes to certify Biden’s election. That’s on top of the dozens of election deniers who have already won primaries in states across the country, many of them relatively young-for-politics Republicans who, win or lose, will maintain a presence in the party for years. There’s Doug Mastriano, the far-right election conspiracy pusher who won the Republican primary for governor of Pennsylvania. In Nevada, Republican Jim Marchant, a leader of a circle of MAGA-aligned election deniers running to become secretaries of state, easily won his primary earlier this month. The Michigan Republican Party’s nominee for state attorney general, Matthew DePerno, is a Kalamazoo lawyer who was a major figure in Trump’s failed bid to overturn the election in Michigan. More are likely to be nominated in the second half of the year. Right after a break in the multi-state primaries, in August, comes Arizona, where Kari Lake, the former TV anchor who insists Trump carried the state, is among leading candidates for governor. Also on the ballot in that state: state Rep. Mark Finchem, one of the chief proponents of his state’s farcical ballot review, is running for secretary of state. Regardless of Trump’s fortunes, large majorities of Republicans still believe his lie that the election was rigged. If the primaries have taught us anything, it’s that that lie may outlast him. “I think a lot of Americans have just lost faith in American institutions,” said Sean Walsh, a Republican strategist who worked in the Reagan and George H.W. Bush White Houses. For many Republicans, he said, “I think the lack of faith in the electoral system does outlast Trump. Sadly, I think it does.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq—Dems win

Democrats achieve a slim victory now

Budowsky 5/25 [Brent Budowsky, Budowsky is an American political opinion writer and columnist for The Hill, “Budowsky: How Dems can win an epic midterm election,” The Hill, June 25 2022, https://thehill.com/opinion/3500318-budowsky-how-dems-can-win-an-epic-midterm-election/]//RA

On Nov. 8, 2022, the American people will make a decision that will change the course of history, send shock waves across the globe, and be written about by historians a century from now. It may literally be the most important midterm election in a century. Here’s why:

Today democracy is fighting back fiercely against attacks by foreign dictators abroad and Republican partisans at home who still try to reverse the 2020 election, elect state Republicans who would corrupt the 2024 election, and practice aggressive voter suppression reminiscent of the dark days of segregation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA › Uq › Uq—Dems win

The Dems are ahead in the Senate, but it’s close

Silver 6/30 – Nate Silver is the founder and editor in chief of FiveThirtyEight and the author of “The Signal and the Noise: Why So Many Predictions Fail — But Some Don’t.”, 6-30-2022, "Why Republicans Are Favored To Win The House, But Not The Senate," FiveThirtyEight, https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/why-republicans-are-favored-to-win-the-house-but-not-the-senate/

Democratic hopes of keeping the Senate are much more viable, however. Part of this, as I mentioned, is because they appear to have stronger candidates in a handful of key races. Pennsylvania, for instance — which is an open seat after the retirement of Republican Sen. Pat Toomey — is ordinarily the sort of seat that you’d expect Republicans to win since Pennsylvania is a purple state in a Republican year. However, the Democratic candidate, Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, is ahead of Republican Mehmet Oz, the doctor and TV personality, in every poll conducted so far. The model, though, is trained to be a bit skeptical given the fundamentals of the race, so it hedges against those polls and, at this point, has determined that Pennsylvania is best thought of as a toss-up. Still, that means Democrats have roughly a 50-50 chance of gaining a GOP-held Senate seat, offsetting potential losses elsewhere. Indeed, our forecast sees the overall Senate landscape to be about as competitive as it gets. The Deluxe forecast literally has Senate control as a 50-50 tossup. The Classic and Lite forecasts show Democrats as very slight favorites to keep the Senate, meanwhile, with a 59 and a 62 percent chance, respectively. Ball-swarm (or bee-swarm) chart showing which party wins control of the House in 100 sample outcomes from our Deluxe model’s 40,000 simulations, where Democrats have a 47 percent chance of winning the chamber and Republicans have a 53 percent chance. Part of this is because Senate terms last for six years, and so most of these seats were last contested in 2016,3 a mediocre year for Democrats in which they lost the popular vote for the House and also lost Senate races in swing states such as Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Arizona. Of the 35 Senate seats up for grabs in November, 21 are currently held by Republicans. True, most of these are not competitive, but in addition to their chances to gain a GOP-held seat in Pennsylvania, Democrats also have credible chances in Wisconsin and North Carolina (and outside chances in Ohio and Florida, although those are a stretch given how GOP-leaning both states have become). Republicans don’t have any surefire pickups, meanwhile. Our model regards their best chances as being in Georgia, but that race is rated as a toss-up. And the races in Arizona and New Hampshire merely lean toward the Democratic incumbent, meaning they are still highly plausible GOP pickup opportunities. Still, the picture isn’t as bad as you might expect for Democrats. If the political environment really deteriorates for them, they’ll be in trouble, lose most of the competitive races and even blue states like Colorado could come into play. But if things are merely pretty bad for Democrats instead of catastrophic, the outcome of the Senate will remain uncertain enough that stronger candidates could make the difference for them.