Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Interoperability

Ethical principles are essential for Legal interoperability within NATO military operations

Trabucco and Stanley-Lockman, 2022 – prof of Political Science, University of Copenhagen and prof of Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University [Lena and Zoe, The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance, March, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs” https://www.oxfordhandbooks.com/view/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780197579329-e-69 Acc 4/16/22 TA]

NATO and Technological Change: Three Pillars of AI Governance This section considers three pillars where NATO has procedures and competency to operationalize AI governance through both mechanisms of policy alignment and standards, and enhance security in the international environment. The pillars reflect foundational issue areas constitutive of governance but are also issue areas where previous scholars have cautioned as particularly challenging in the AI governance space. The three pillars—(1) ethics and values, (2) legal norms, and (3) safety and security—are meant to illustrate three conditions for NATO to facilitate policy and standards harmonization. Importantly, these pillars are not exhaustive areas in which NATO will need to consider governance structures to responsibly implement AI technology, but rather highlight particular issues that researchers and analysts acknowledge as significant hurdles in navigating AI governance (see Table 69.2).54 Table 69.2: Cross-tabulating NATO’s governance mechanisms with pillars of AI governance Ethics and Values Legal Norms Safety and Security NATO Policy and Strategic Planning Core, shared values at foundation of Alliance’s political cohesion that informs civilian oversight of operations and overall institutional effectiveness; included in principles Alignment between differing legal interpretations between Allies, particularly as affects the ability of forces to communicate and interoperate in dynamic contexts; constant calibration of policies based on legal interpretations Strategic planning for maintaining integrity of information in military operations and transparency measures that reinforce democratic accountability; setting priorities on defensive systems and countermeasures to protect from motivated attacks and intentional failure modes of AI-enabled weapon systems

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Interoperability

Collaboration is key to avoid lopsided adoption of AI systems, which would undermine joint operations.

Lawrence and Cordey, 2020 – researchers for The Cyber Project at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs [Christie and Sean, August, The Cyber Project Paper “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence Edited by Lauren Zabierek and Julia Voo https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/2020-08/TransatlanticAI.pdf Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

Joint US-EU defense-related AI efforts appear sparse,349 however there is a growing push particularly from the US and NATO to increase transatlantic defense cooperation on AI. The aforementioned DOD Artificial Intelligence Strategy stressed the importance the US and allied partners to “maintain its strategic position to prevail in future battlefields and safeguard a free and open international order.”350 Growing Chinese and Russia aggression and weaponization of new technologies like AI is a central motivation for the US government’s push to strengthen the international AI alliance.351 Acting Director of JAIC Nand Mulchandani explains that collaboration with European partners on AI is necessary for three main reasons. First, joint AI R&D and adoption efforts are important for developing strong capabilities and bolstering transatlantic hard power. Second, leading AI capabilities--among the US and its allies--acts as a deterrent for conflict. Third, if deterrence fails, AI-related interoperability and capabilities are necessary if the US and its allies must go to war. A military alliance cannot be lopsided and unequal AI adoption may hinder the tactical aspects of conflict.352 During the already mentioned recent visit to NATO headquarters in Brussels, Former Director of the JAIC Lt. Gen. Shanahan had collaborative engagements with European allies and NATO around the importance of AI joint efforts, ensuring military interoperability, and the convergence of Europe’s AI ethical principles with the DOD’s five principles of AI ethics.353 The visit appeared to increase NATO’s focus on devising an AI strategy for the Alliance.354 Despite these positive steps, there are still concerns about potential obstacles to increased defense collaboration, particularly around IP ownership and funding restrictions that may exclude US involvement in EDF and PESCO.355, 356

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Interoperability

Addressing ethical concerns is key to interoperability – differing ethical views cause different technological approaches, which destroys NATO’s ability to coordinate between different militaries.

Michelson, 2021 - Senior Fellow at the Center for European Policy Analysis’s Transatlantic Defense Tech Initiative [Colonel (Retired) Brian M. February 23 “Why NATO Needs Lethal Autonomous Weapon Standards” https://cepa.org/why-nato-needs-lethal-autonomous-weapon-standards/ Acc. 4/5/22 TA]

NATO standards are designed to ensure compatibility among weapon systems, communication architecture, and a host of other warfighting systems. The 7.62mm small arms round is a good example of this. But what is the 7.62mm equivalent standard for the development and employment of autonomous weapon systems? This opens a host of related questions regarding the employment of these systems: What Identification – Friend – Foe (IFF) capability should ground and air units require to prevent fratricide? What degree of certainty does a lethal autonomous weapon system require before final engagement? What level of collateral damage is acceptable? What degree of compatibility between systems is required? Should all these parameters (and others) be adjustable, and if so, at what command level? The attendant ethics also need to be addressed. NATO’s experience in Afghanistan was a case study in the challenges of coalition warfare. Differing risk tolerances, legal requirements, ethical views, domestic political concerns, and at times simply combat capability, all combined into to complex policy cocktail that impeded the effectiveness of combat operations. While modern militaries have accountability, legal, and ethical systems incorporated into their command structures, they are not uniform and leaders in differing militaries have varying degrees of authority. The key questions hinge on two issues: Who gets to decide to employ an autonomous weapon, and who is responsible should things go wrong? The Kunduz hospital strike in October of 2015 was driven primarily by human error. Responsibility was fixed on the chain of command and 16 leaders were disciplined. Who will be responsible if a member nation conducts a NATO-authorized strike and it goes terribly wrong? If this framework is not thoroughly established ahead of time, not only is it likely that commanders may hesitate to use this capability, the risk-aversion inherent in bureaucracies may limit the development of autonomous weapons that will be needed in future conflicts. In the emerging field of lethal autonomous weapons, establishing a common NATO standard for the development and use of autonomous weapons will help address the gap in capabilities among NATO member nations. By establishing these standards, nations can ensure that their defense expenditures on autonomous weapons will create systems that are interoperable, able to contribute to NATO’s capability, and can be employed within defensible ethical guidelines.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Cohesion

Cooperation is key to standardize NATO’s approach to AI, which is key to avoiding technology gaps.

Michelson, 2021 - Senior Fellow at the Center for European Policy Analysis’s Transatlantic Defense Tech Initiative [Colonel (Retired) Brian M. February 23 “Why NATO Needs Lethal Autonomous Weapon Standards” https://cepa.org/why-nato-needs-lethal-autonomous-weapon-standards/ Acc. 4/5/22 TA]

Lethal autonomous weapon systems will come to dominate warfare in the coming years. NATO needs to harmonize its approach to their development and use, or risk being left behind. The rapid weaponization of artificial intelligence, “big data,” social media, robotics, and a host of other technologies presents a clear competitive challenge to NATO, an alliance with members that exist on a wide spectrum of military-technological capabilities. The future effectiveness of NATO will be driven in large part by how it handles these challenges from hobbling its ability both to act in unison and to prevail in a contest of wills. While there are numerous potential technology gaps, one that will likely only increase is partner nations’ ability and willingness to employ lethal autonomous weapon systems. These systems will inevitably grow more capable, and more necessary, in the coming decade. Technological gaps are inevitable considering the disparities in GDP and military budgets. The United States accounts for over 70 percent of NATO’s overall military spending, while the next three largest contributors (the United Kingdom, France, and Germany) provide approximately half of the remaining 30 percent. And with most NATO nations continuing to fund their militaries at under the 2 percent GDP goal, technological gaps will continue to grow. For perspective, the 2021 United States Department of Defense research and development budget is approximately equal to the entire defense outlay of France and Germany combined. With such a large differential, what can be done to help enable effective investments in autonomous weapons by smaller nations? Even more specifically, how can smaller nations provide capabilities that can integrate into, and contribute to the alliance? To better invest limited funds, now is the time to look at a NATO standard for lethal autonomous weapons and their ethical use. While there is no agreed-upon international definition of lethal autonomous weapons systems, the U.S. Department of Defense defines them as “weapon system[s] that, once activated, can select and engage targets without further intervention by a human operator.“ While these are not Schwarzenegger-style Terminators and still have a degree of human control over them, the technology enabling these systems is maturing rapidly, and military necessity will increasingly demand that these systems gain broader parameters of autonomous action. Yet despite the complexity of these systems and the inevitability of their proliferation, NATO does not currently have a common standard for their use or development. In fact, some NATO countries even have opposing views of how to handle them.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Cohesion

Cooperation is essential for cohesion. Ethical AI principles are key to interoperability and doctrine.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

Responsible and ethical military AI between allies is important because policy alignment can improve interoperability in doctrine, procedures, legal frameworks, and technical implementation measures. Agreeing not only on human centricity for militaries adopting technology, but also on the ways that accountability and ethical principles enter into the design, development, deployment, and diffusion of AI helps reinforce strategic democratic advantages. Conversely, ethical gaps between allied militaries could have dangerous consequences that imperil both political cohesion and coalition success. More specifically, if allies do not agree on their responsibilities and risk analyses around military AI, then gaps could emerge in political willingness to share risk in coalition operations and authorization to operate alongside one another. Even though the United States is the only country to have adopted ethical principles for defense, key allies are formulating their own frameworks to account for ethical risks along the AI lifecycle. This report explores these various documents, which have thus far been understudied, at least in tandem. Overall, the analysis highlights both convergences in ethical approaches to military AI and burgeoning differences that could turn into political or operational liabilities.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Human Control

Human control is key – it is the most pressing issue to resolve in military AI

Vestner, 2021 - Head of Security and Law Programme at Geneva Centre for Security Policy [Tobias, July 8 “Warfare and Artificial Intelligence” in Robin Geiß and Henning Lahmann (eds), Research Handbook on Warfare and Artificial Intelligence -forthcoming https://www.gcsp.ch/publications/military-operations-and-artificial-intelligenceGCSP Acc 5/27/22 TA]

At this stage, AI technologies and their military applications, as well as respective policies, are only emerging. Yet the integration of AI into armed forces will most likely transform the preparation and execution of military operations. This paper has analysed how AI systems will most likely affect and be affected by principal instruments for preparing and conducting military operations. Overall, the introduction of AI for military operations leads to a tension between AI influencing these instruments and these instruments serving to properly manage military AI. With regard to strategy, it can be expected that AI will be used for developing strategies, similar to planning activities. The introduction of AI applications throughout armed forces will likely also need to be considered by military strategists, as the speed and complexities of military operations may increase. Doctrine is an appropriate tool to define armed forces’ perception of AI as well as humans’ role regarding the use and control of AI, thereby serving as a hook for institutional ethics, values, and identity. Given doctrine’s purpose, AI will likely not have a major role in determining doctrine. Yet the planning process will likely be heavily supported by AI systems, which may lead to higher quality and speed of planning processes, eventually improving military decision-making. While AI can well support the management of ROE, these are instruments that can serve to guide the concrete authority attributed to AI systems and define human-machine teaming for specific missions in line with superior guidelines such as doctrine, (other) directives, and plans. Orders, however, are likely to become irrelevant for the interaction between AI systems and human-system interaction. Overall, a recurring theme is the interaction between AI systems and commanders, operators, and soldiers. Indeed, human control is a requisite for the purposeful use of AI in a human world. Yet, human-machine teaming remains subject to challenges. Many processes related to military operations will still require human input. Moreover, it seems crucial that military staff will be enabled to follow, understand, and keep appropriate control of AI systems. This is not only an ethical and legal challenge but a requisite to achieve effective enhancement of military operations through the introduction of AI. Further reflections and research on AI and military operations in general as well as on AI and strategy, doctrine, plans, ROE, and orders, in particular, should therefore focus on the human-machine interaction, as this remains the most pressing challenge of AI-enabled warfare. This may serve to find and define an adequate balance between AI influencing instruments for preparing and conducting military operations and these instruments serving to properly manage military AI.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Human Control

Human control is key to for responsible AI use

Sauer, 2021 - Senior Research Fellow at Bundeswehr University [Frank serves on the International Panel on the Regulation of Autonomous Weapons IRRC No. 913 March “Stepping back from the brink: Why multilateral regulation of autonomy in weapons systems is difficult, yet imperative and feasible” https://international-review.icrc.org/articles/stepping-back-from-brink-regulation-of-autonomous-weapons-systems-913 Acc 4/5/22 TA]

Luckily, the process of conceptualizing the issue and translating it into diplomatic language has begun, and has already made some progress. After almost six years, the codification of a positive obligation of human control over weapons systems is establishing itself more and more at the heart of the debate. This general notion, gaining prominence in the wake of the call for “meaningful human control” originally introduced by the NGO Article 36,15 is being embraced by civil society as well as a consistently growing number of CCW States Parties. Accordingly, the conceptualization is now finding broad acceptance in both academic literature and the diplomatic debate – not least because the United States and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) have adopted it. This is not some sort of categorical definition of LAWS (versus non-LAWS) via a list of criteria. Instead, it is a functional understanding of the phenomenon.16 From a functionalist point of view, the LAWS issue is best understood as one of autonomy in a weapons system – that is, of the machine rather than a human performing a certain function (or certain functions) during the system's operation.17 Every military operation concluding with an attack on a target can be systematized along discrete steps of a kill chain or targeting cycle.18 This includes finding, fixing, tracking, selecting and engaging the target (as well as assessing the effects afterwards). Many weapons systems are already capable of performing some of the targeting cycle functions without human input or supervision – for example, a drone navigating from one waypoint to the next via satellite navigation and thus performing a part of the “finding” function without having to be remotely controlled. An autonomous weapon, however, completes the entire targeting cycle – including the final stages of selecting and engaging the target with force – without human intervention. In the debate about LAWS, the focus rests mainly on those last two functions (which the ICRC calls “critical”19) because most of the effects of weapon autonomy currently under discussion derive from giving up human control over them and handing the decision to use force over to a machine.20

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Human Control

Human control is the essential common goal that allows allies to develop AI standards and norms.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

In this light, this issue brief seeks to provide policymakers and analysts with one view on how similarities between allied perspectives on ethical AI for defense create opportunity for increased collaboration, and how the differences that are beginning to take shape can undermine said collaboration. Alignment and collaboration start with an understanding of variations in definitions of terms like trustworthy AI, ethical AI, and responsible AI in the defense context. These definitions are often fluid, depending on the legal, ethical, and cultural traditions of different countries. But different conceptions of responsible military AI nevertheless share foundations that help frame the analysis here. Broadly speaking, this issue brief focuses on how defense stakeholders steward AI innovation and integration in ways that: (1) respect the moral and ethical reasoning that underpins the responsible use of force; (2) meet and enhance compliance with law, which is based on ethics and translates reasoning into concrete obligations; and (3) minimize risks and unintended consequences for a safer and more secure international security environment. To uphold ethical, legal, and safe foundations of AI development and deployment in defense, allies coalesce around two shared themes in their approaches to responsible military AI. First is that decisions around the design, development, deployment, and diffusion of AI do not enter into a vacuum, but rather into an existing, multi-layered legal framework. It is not controversial for democratic countries to declare their shared obligation to respect law in order to remain accountable.8 This accountability is owed to domestic citizenries, to the armed forces themselves, and to allies and partners in coalition settings, as well as to adversaries and the international community at large. As such, for some allies, emerging conceptions of responsible AI are closely interlinked with responsible state behavior, with continued legal compliance as the minimum requirement.9 The second commonality in all of the frameworks examined here is a shared focus on human centricity. There are several definitions of human-centric AI, but for the purpose of this analysis, it can be understood as the idea that AI is designed to meet human needs and improve upon the role of the human.10 Not all frameworks use the term itself, but all stress the central role of humans in that machines should not replace humans and that humans remain responsible and accountable for decisions. By extension, this means a common approach to designing AI systems in such a way that the human user is not expected to adjust her or his own decision-making capacities to conform to the technology.11 The inverse would place the machine at the center of decision-making systems. Meanwhile, countries consider humans to be central to defense planning and operations, and stress in their positions that they do not think it moral or lawful to delegate human responsibility to machines.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Ethics

The US must coordinate with Allies on ethical principles to ensure the responsible use of AI

Schmidt and Work, 2021 – Chairs of The National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence [Eric and Robert, “National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence Final Report Executive Summary” Acc 6/7/22 TA]

Manage risks associated with AI-enabled and autonomous weapons. AI will enable new levels of performance and autonomy for weapon systems. But it also raises important legal, ethical, and strategic questions surrounding the use of lethal force. Provided their use is authorized by a human commander or operator, properly designed and tested AI enabled and autonomous weapon systems can be used in ways that are consistent with international humanitarian law. DoD’s rigorous, existing weapons review and targeting procedures, including its dedicated protocols for autonomous weapon systems and commitment to strong AI ethical principles, are capable of ensuring that the United States will field safe and reliable AI-enabled and autonomous weapon systems and use them in a lawful manner. While it is neither feasible nor currently in the interests of the United States to pursue a global prohibition of AI-enabled and autonomous weapon systems, the global, unchecked use of such systems could increase risks of unintended conflict escalation and crisis instability. To reduce the risks, the United States should (1) clearly and publicly affirm existing U.S. policy that only human beings can authorize employment of nuclear weapons and seek similar commitments from Russia and China; (2) establish venues to discuss AI’s impact on crisis stability with competitors; and (3) develop international standards of practice for the development, testing, and use of AI-enabled and autonomous weapon systems.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Ethics

Agreeing to ethical principles is essential to responsible use of AI, which includes standardization and interoperability

Christie, 2020 - Deputy Head of the Innovation Unit, NATO Emerging Security Challenges Division [Edward Hunter, 24 November NATO Review, “Artificial Intelligence at NATO: dynamic adoption, responsible use” https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2020/11/24/artificial-intelligence-at-nato-dynamic-adoption-responsible-use/index.html Acc. 4/16/22 TA]

Committing to responsible use The Alliance’s success with AI will also depend on new and well-designed principles and practices relating to good governance and responsible use. Certain Allied governments have already made certain public commitments in the area of responsible use, addressing concepts such as lawfulness, responsibility, reliability, and governability, among others. In parallel, Allies have taken part in the Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems under the auspices of the United Nations, leading to the formulation of 11 guiding principles. Importantly, there is a good case for viewing work on adopting AI and work on principles of responsible use as complementary and synergistic. In effect, there are certain essential principles or goals that will underpin and facilitate both engineering good practice, as well as responsible state behaviour. Certain national principles imply a need for specific design requirements. For example, a principle of governability may be linked to technical abilities to detect and avoid unintended consequences, and to disengage or deactivate in case of unintended behaviour. The technical characteristics required to ensure that these and other objectives are met will necessarily be part of the design and testing phases of relevant systems. In turn, the relevant engineering work will be an opportunity to refine understanding, leading to more granular and more mature principles. Further work in the area of Testing, Evaluating, Verifying and Validating (TEVV) will be essential, as will support from relevant Modelling and Simulation efforts. NATO’s well-established strengths in the area of standardization will help frame these lines of effort, while also ensuring interoperability between Allied forces.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Ethics

NATO principles for Responsible AI use allow allies to align with the broader agenda.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

As part of the implementation of the EDT agenda, the NATO AI Strategy is expected to pick up on this theme in “guidance on both principles for responsible use of AI-enabled platforms and export control mechanisms.”150 Accountability and transparency—for weapon systems with varying levels of autonomy, as well as AI enabled systems—and rules for industry may feature in this approach.151 Already, the NATO Science & Technology Organization has identified a “strong emphasis on explainability, trust and human-AI collaboration” as well as “processes and standards for verification, validation and accreditation” as areas of interest for NATO, though they are not yet formalized in publicly pronounced principles.152 Overall, the issuance of principles at the NATO level will be helpful to reflect priorities of multiple Allies, permit more Allies to align nascent or ad hoc initiatives to the broader agenda with one another, and potentially help bridge responsible AI with best practices or standardization that industry can follow.153

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework - Human Dignity

Dignity is the most important value because it is key to our international human rights obligations

Docherty, 2014 - senior researcher in the Arms Division of Human Rights Watch [Bonnie “Shaking the Foundations The Human Rights Implications of Killer Robots” Human Rights Watch http://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/reports/ arms0514_ForUpload_0.pdf Acc 12/27/20 TA]

IV. Human Dignity The concept of human dignity lies at the heart of international human rights law. The opening words of the UDHR assert that “recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world.”78 In ascribing inherent dignity to all human beings, the UDHR implies that everyone has worth that deserves respect.79 The ICCPR establishes the inextricable link between dignity and human rights, stating in its preamble that the rights it enumerates “derive from the inherent dignity of the human person.”80 Regional treaties echo this position, and the Vienna Declaration of the 1993 World Human Rights Conference affirms that “all human rights derive from the dignity and worth inherent in the human person.”81

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework - Human Dignity

Focusing on dignity is essential to make the ban successful – it resonates with the public.

Rosert, 2019 - Professor for International Relations at Universität Hamburg [Elvira, with Frank Sauer Researcher at Bundeswehr, Global Policy, July 5 “Prohibiting Autonomous Weapons: Put Human Dignity First” https://doi.org/10.1111/1758-5899.12691 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

The discourse about LAWS is not and does not have to be confined to the CCW discussions. While human dignity is admittedly not a crucial point of reference within this particular forum, it is a universal and ubiquitous concept that does resonate with States Parties in other UN fora (such as the General Assembly, for instance). In addition, as of 2019, it is in fact quite likely that the CCW will yet again end up being merely an incubator for regulative action. Should the process surrounding LAWS leave the CCW, proponents of a ban on LAWS must be ready to refocus on human dignity. After all, in the US, 55 per cent of the public is opposed to LAWS (Carpenter, 2013); in Germany, 71 per cent of the population is against handing weapons control in warfare over to AI (YouGov 2018). And international opinion polls conducted online by the Open Roboethics Initiative (2015) as well as by IPSOS (CSKR 2019b; Roff, 2017) indicate not only a similar picture but even growing resistance against LAWS at the global level. Since the public's reaction to LAWS is mostly visceral, rather than based on legal considerations, putting human dignity first will gain traction. This point is granted even by skeptics of our line of argument: ‘There could be some campaigning advantages. Saying that something is against human dignity evokes a strong visceral response’ (Sharkey, 2018, p. 9).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework - Human Dignity

Dignity is the most important value because it is a precondition for all other human values

Heyns, 2016 - Professor of Human Rights Law, University of Pretoria [Christof, Human Rights Quarterly 38 (2016) 350–378 “ Human Rights and the use of Autonomous Weapons Systems (AWS) During Domestic Law Enforcement” Acc 12/27/20 TA]

However, there is also the further question of whether machines should be given this power. This raises the question of whether the rights to bodily integrity do not require whatever force is used against a human being to be authored by a human being as opposed to a robot. For example, is it not inherently arbitrary for a machine to take decisions about life and death over human beings? The question whether machines should have such power also raises questions about the right to human dignity. B. The Right to Human Dignity The preamble of the Charter of the United Nations reaffirms “faith in fundamental human rights [and] in the dignity and worth of the human person.”74 Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights provides that “[a]ll human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.”75 The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights refers to dignity in its preamble but does not list it as a substantive right in the rest of the text, though it is intertwined with other rights.76 The protection of human dignity is the common aim of international human rights law as well as IHL, and this commonality underlies their complementarity.77 Dignity has been called the “mother”78 of all human rights and is recognized to underlie much of IHL.79 Is it inherently a violation of the right to dignity if the decision to use force against a human being is made by a computer as opposed to another human?

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework – Ethics First

The Moral questions about AI are the most important ones – prefer my contextual evidence

Johnson and Axinn, 2013 - Prof of Philosophy at the Univ of South Florida and PhD Candidate in Engineering at Penn [Aaron and Sidney, Journal of Military Ethics, Volume 12, Issue 2, August “The Morality of Autonomous Robots” www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/15027570.2013.818399 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

The Major Question All of these questions ignore the bigger, more important moral question: should we relinquish the decision to kill a human to a non-human machine? In this paper we argue primarily that the discussion needs to focus on this most important question, and not on the details of the technology or its efficacy. We now further argue that the decision to take a human life must be an inherently human decision and that it would be unethical to allow a machine to make such a critical choice. The concept of what a rational human is, a being that can give itself the moral law, is essential to considering this matter.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework – Ethics First

Morality must come first because the weapons don’t exist yet, and the ethical framework will Decide how they are treated.

Johnson and Axinn, 2013 - Prof of Philosophy at the Univ of South Florida and PhD Candidate in Engineering at Penn [Aaron and Sidney, Journal of Military Ethics, Volume 12, Issue 2, August “The Morality of Autonomous Robots” www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/15027570.2013.818399 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

Conclusion For the reasons presented above, reasons both military and humanitarian, we propose that autonomous robots, carrying lethal weapons and operated by computer programs alone, be treated on the same basis as the United States now treats chemical weapons (gas warfare among them). As noted earlier, the U.S. and all other nations should agree not use such weapons. A second Ottawa-style conference would be an appropriate mechanism to accomplish this moral goal internationally. Nuclear weapons are an example of technology that was brought into use before civilization and the laws of war could react to them. We need to act now to establish the moral and legal standing of automatic robots before they enter into common usage. The Ottawa conference prohibiting anti-personnel mines (August 2007), as mentioned, would be an excellent model for what should be done about automatic robots. A nation that relies on such weapons ignores the humanitarian basis for the laws of war, and when there is an international convention banning them, such a nation will be acting dishonorably. As technology continues to progress there will certainly be borderline questions11, but the central notion cannot be abandoned, that a lethality decision is to be made only by a human and not a machine. That should remain the key focus of debate and be the guiding moral principle.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Harms - Framework – Ethics First

NATO has a moral obligation to adopt ethical principles for AI weapons before they are used

Gilli, 2020 - Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College [Andrea, NDC Research Paper No.15 – December ““NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence” https://www.ndc.nato.int/news/news.php?icode=1514 Acc 4/21/22 TA]

Ethical purpose: ethics and values (with Zoe Stanley-Lockman) NATO has an interest, and a moral obligation, to promote the adoption of its values in the realm of AI. Democratic values inform the Alliance’s goals, thus giving meaning to its material capabilities – including its military power. At the same time, the integration of AI into the fields of security and defence poses unique moral, ethical, legal, and safety-related questions.85 It is thus imperative that the Alliance actively considers and operationalizes AI ethics, regardless of the degree and scope of AI integration within NATO and its Allies. The common principles and values pronounced in the Atlantic Treaty represent the foundations on which NATO was built. Such principles and values – democracy, freedom, rule of law, individual rights, free markets – are the bond underlying the transatlantic community, which in fact predates the Atlantic Alliance.86 Norms and values can strongly shape the international system.87 Given the intense international competition in the technological, military, economic, and normative domains, embedding democratic values into AI is as much a strategic imperative for the Alliance as it is a functional one.88 In addition to signalling to domestic populations that NATO and its Allies follow through on their commitments to uphold values as the basis of the political and military Alliance, incorporating AI ethics into the “NATO-mation” agenda also serves as a bulwark against the incursion of unwelcome illiberal values in the course of future technological development.89

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Extend – Harms - Human Dignity

5. Inherent Worth – AI denies dignity because it cannot respect the Inherent Worth of individuals – it can only mimic morality.

Johnson and Axinn, 2013 - Prof of Philosophy at the Univ of South Florida and PhD Candidate in Engineering at Penn [Aaron and Sidney, Journal of Military Ethics, Volume 12, Issue 2, August “The Morality of Autonomous Robots” www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/15027570.2013.818399 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

Morality Humans give themselves moral commands, programs are given the commands they are to follow. A machine can replicate an action that has been called moral, but morality does not come from following someone else. In this way a machine can act morally, by mimicking its programmer, but it cannot be moral. Similarly when playing back a video of a moral act one would not say that the video was moral, it is simply replaying the moral act of its subject. An autonomous robot is clearly more complicated than a video, and can more directly interact with the world and respond to feedback, however it is still just playing back moral actions, and is not truly making the decisions for itself. Moral commands are based on values, and values are produced and indicated by sacrifices (Axinn 2010, also see section on Military Honor, below). While robots are aware of following orders, they are not aware of making sacrifices. Artificial Intelligence still has no real notion of sacrifice (and Artificial Morality is still just a phrase and not a developed subject). Therefore robots have no values of their own, although they are following the values of their programmers. A distinctive human characteristic therefore is the ability to think morally based on one’s values, and to give oneself the moral commands. Morality requires, according to Kant, that the principle of one’s action must be one that is capable of being followed universally. Again, not the specific act, but the principle of the act must be one that everyone can follow. The ability to judge and extract the principles of an action cannot be codified or programmed. As Kant put it, ‘judgment…cannot be taught.’ (1965: p. A133). Furthermore, Kant insists, ‘general logic can supply no rules for judgment…’ (1965: p. A135). Without this ability we find once again that a robot can only mimic morality by replicating actions as commanded.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Extend – Harms - Human Dignity

4. Compassion – AI systems cannot uphold dignity because they cannot feel compassion for others.

Docherty, 2018 - senior researcher in the Arms Division of Human Rights Watch [Bonnie August 21, “Heed the Call A Moral and Legal Imperative to Ban Killer Robots” Acc 12/27/20 TA]

In order to treat other human beings humanely, one must exercise compassion and make legal and ethical judgments.[52] Compassion, according to the ICRC’s fundamental principles, is the “stirring of the soul which makes one responsive to the distress of others.”[53] To show compassion, an actor must be able to experience empathy—that is, to understand and share the feelings of another—and be compelled to act in response.[54] This emotional capacity is vital in situations when determinations about the use of force are made.[55] It drives actors to make conscious efforts to minimize the physical or psychological harm they inflict on human beings. Acting with compassion builds on the premise that “capture is preferable to wounding an enemy, and wounding him better than killing him; that non-combatants shall be spared as far as possible; that wounds inflicted be light as possible, so that the injured can be treated and cured; and that the wounds cause the least possible pain.”[56] While compassion provides a motivation to act humanely, legal and ethical judgment provides a means to do so. To act humanely, an actor must make considered decisions as to how to minimize harm.[57] Such decisions are based on the ability to perceive and understand one’s environment and to apply “common sense and world knowledge” to a specific circumstance.[58] Philosophy professor James Moor notes that actors must possess the capacity to “identify and process ethical information about a variety of situations and make sensitive determinations about what should be done in those situations.”[59] In this way, legal and ethical judgment helps an actor weigh relevant factors to ensure treatment meets the standards demanded by compassion. Judgment is vital to minimizing suffering: one can only refrain from harming humans if one both recognizes the possible harms and knows how to respond.[60] Application to Fully Autonomous Weapons Fully autonomous weapons would face significant challenges in complying with the principle of humane treatment because compassion and legal and ethical judgment are human characteristics. Empathy, and the compassion for others that it engenders, come naturally to human beings. Most humans have experienced physical or psychological pain, which drives them to avoid inflicting unnecessary suffering on others. Their feelings transcend national and other divides. As the ICRC notes, “feelings and gestures of solidarity, compassion, and selflessness are to be found in all cultures.”[61] People’s shared understanding of pain and suffering leads them to show compassion towards fellow human beings and inspires reciprocity that is, in the words of the ICRC, “perfectly natural.”[62]

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Extend – Harms - Human Dignity

3. Objectification – Autonomous weapons systems violate human dignity because they reduce humans to objects – to data points.

Sauer, 2021 - Senior Research Fellow at Bundeswehr University [Frank serves on the International Panel on the Regulation of Autonomous Weapons IRRC No. 913 March “Stepping back from the brink: Why multilateral regulation of autonomy in weapons systems is difficult, yet imperative and feasible” https://international-review.icrc.org/articles/stepping-back-from-brink-regulation-of-autonomous-weapons-systems-913 Acc 4/5/22 TA]

The key ethical implication of weapon autonomy in a weapons system's critical functions is thus that allowing algorithms to make kill decisions violates human dignity because the victim is reduced to an object, a mere data point fed to an automated, indifferent killing machine. It is worth spelling out that this objection is valid even if civilians (or other non-combatants) remain unharmed. After all, narrowing the focus solely to the possibility that LAWS might not be able to make proper – or even better – distinctions between combatants and civilians, a cornerstone of the legal case against LAWS discussed in the CCW, loses sight of the fact that combatants, too, are imbued with human dignity. In other words, weapon autonomy raises a more fundamental concern than the legal strand of the LAWS debate suggests, because “successfully discerning combatants from noncombatants is far from the only issue”.89 As a general rule, the use of LAWS against humans can be deemed an unacceptable infringement on human dignity because delegating the decision to kill to an algorithm devalues human life.90 Exceptions from this rule would only be conceivable if they were explicitly not made on the basis of weighing bare lives against each other and then deliberately opting for algorithmic killing. An example for such a boundary case could be a sailor's reliance on weapon autonomy in a narrowly bound scenario of desperate self-defence. If the aforementioned navy frigate91 were to be under a saturation attack by anti-ship missiles and, potentially, also manned aircraft, then inadvertently endangering human life by relying on autonomous defensive fire for the survival of the ship and its crew could be considered acceptable ex post. Generally speaking again, being killed as the result of algorithmic decision-making matters for the person dying because a machine taking a human life has no conception of what its action means: “In the absence of an intentional and meaningful decision to use violence, the resulting deaths are meaningless and arbitrary.”92 In other words, the least we can do when killing another human being in war is to recognize this death of a fellow member of our species and put the weight accompanying this decision onto our conscience. The mindlessness of machines killing humans based on software outputs strips the latter of their right to be recognized as humans in the moment of death. This also matters for society at large. Modern warfare, especially in democracies, already decouples societies from warfighting in terms of political and financial costs.93 A society outsourcing moral costs by no longer even concerning itself with the act of killing, with no individual combatants’ psyches burdened by the accompanying responsibility, crosses a moral line. It risks losing touch with fundamental humanitarian values such as the right to a dignified life and respect towards fellow human beings.94 To sum up this section, while the legal verdict on weapon autonomy increasing IHL compliance is still out and will be for some time, a more fundamental objection against LAWS based on deontological limits is valid today.