Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Russia

NATO is still relevant – multiple examples

Hamilton ’22 (Lee H. Hamilton, Lawyer and Former Democratic U.S House of Representative, “Commentary: NATO still relevant, still facing challenges” ) //sethlee

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization is the largest peacetime alliance in the world and has been arguably the most successful such alliance in history. It has had remarkable success in achieving its basic goals: containing Soviet expansion, checking the rise of nationalism and helping integrate Europe. It provides a model for multinational cooperation, something we desperately need in today’s complex and dangerous world. and it has shown an admirable ability to adapt to changing needs and circumstances. Three decades ago, with the collapse of the Soviet Union, it was possible to think NATO had outlived its basic mandate. But it found new and important responsibilities in combating ethnic violence and civil war, as in the former Yugoslavia, and countering terrorism. It maintains an array of peacekeeping and training activities in Europe, the Mediterranean, the Middle East and Africa. Today, the crisis over a possible Russian invasion of Ukraine presents new challenges to the alliance while reinforcing the fact that NATO is as relevant as ever. It is essential to the security of our allies in Europe; and because their security is closely tied to our own, it is essential to the United States. In a sense, NATO rose from the ashes of World War II. Europe had been devastated. An estimated 36.5 million Europeans had been killed, more than half of them civilians. Millions of people were displaced. America, throwing off its history of isolationism, created the Marshall Plan to rebuild Europe’s economy. But Western leaders worried about the region’s military security. Would the Soviet Union seek to extend its dominance into Western Europe? Would nationalist militarism bubble up and lead Europe back toward war? To address those threats, a dozen nations, including the United States, signed the North Atlantic Treaty in April 1949. In the treaty’s best-known section, Article 5, the members declared that “an armed attack against one of them … shall be considered an armed attack against all of them.” It was a pledge for mutual self-defense. Within months, the Soviet Union exploded an atomic bomb, putting an exclamation point on the need for deterrence. The Korean War and the Soviet invasions of Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968 tested NATO, but the alliance held. It was a measure of the treaty’s success that NATO forces were able to avoid military actions throughout the Cold War. Over the decades, NATO expanded. Today it includes 30 member nations, three of them former Soviet republics: Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. It also claims partner relationships with nearly 20 European countries. NATO calls its partnership with Ukraine one of its “most substantial” and says cooperation has increased since 2014, when Russia invaded Ukraine and seized Crimea. Ukraine has expressed interest in joining NATO. Russian leader Vladimir Putin, who views Ukraine as part of “historical Russia,” portrays that prospect as an existential threat. With an estimated 100,000 troops massed near the Ukrainian border, Russia is demanding a guarantee that NATO won’t let Ukraine join. The threat of a Russian invasion of Ukraine poses a real problem for NATO. President Joe Biden said last week that “there are differences” among alliance members about how forcefully to respond, depending on what Russia does. Putin is likely to try to exploit those differences. The best way to resolve this crisis, of course, is through tough, clear-eyed diplomacy, with a clear message that Russia will face consequences if it invades. But it’s harder to negotiate from a position of strength when all your allies may not be on the same page. NATO has achieved remarkable success in maintaining peace and security throughout its 72-year history. It has demonstrated, probably better than any other organization, the importance of multinational cooperation. But as the Ukraine crisis shows, its challenges are far from over. Lee Hamilton is a senior adviser for the Indiana University Center on Representative Government; a Distinguished Scholar at the IU Hamilton Lugar School of Global and International Studies; and a professor of practice at the IU O’Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives for 34 years.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Russia

NATO imperialism didn’t cause war, Russia’s ambitions did.

Majumdar ’22 (Bhaskar Majumdar, Author and graduated from the AMP from Harvard, “Russian Imperialism, Not NATO Expansion, Caused the Ukraine War” ) //sethlee

As per Mearsheimer’s worldview, NATO in general and the US in particular were at fault for welcoming countries that were in the Soviet-led Warsaw Pact. Admitting the three former Soviet republics in the Baltics was rubbing salt into wounded Russian pride. This view forgets that the Russian Empire and its successor, the Soviet Union, expanded in western Europe as well as in the east all the way to the Pacific. In , the Soviet troops even marched into Afghanistan to protect the communist government.

None of the countries that suffered under Moscow’s yoke wants to go back to those. That is what so many of them lined up to join NATO when the Soviet Union fell. Eastern European nations also turned to the EU because of economic opportunities on offer. Poles, Lithuanians and even Hungarians prefer to work in France, Germany and the UK instead of in Russia. In a nutshell, NATO guaranteed security against an imperial Moscow while the EU boosted the economy for Eastern Europe. 

2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Russia

Russian adventurism in the 21st century.

Ginta T. Palubinskas 22, a Professor of Political Science at West Virginia State University. She earned her Ph.D. in Public Policy from George Mason University, where she subsequently served as the Director of Undergraduate Programs for the Department of Public and International Affairs. 2022, “NATO at 70: Peace in a Changing Security Environment,” ÆTHER: A JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC AIRPOWER & SPACEPOWER, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/AEtherJournal/Journals/Volume-1_Issue-2/Palubinskas.pdf

Why NATO? Russia’s attack on Ukraine and illegal annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the events that followed clarified the state of the transatlantic security environment and provided a concise answer to the question of why NATO is needed today. The Alliance is needed now for the same reason it was needed when it was created. Now, as then, the UN cannot guarantee collective security against aggression. Transatlantic countries continue to face the same threat, albeit in a different form, that existed when NATO was established. The Alliance has proven effective in its mission for more than seven decades and continues to be necessary for the preservation of transatlantic security and, by extension, the liberal international order. In short, we need NATO in order to maintain world peace. Can NATO Endure? The NATO alliance and the context within which it operates have changed significantly over time. At its inception, NATO focused on the security of Western Europe, the United States, and Canada. Today, it protects the majority of European countries, as well as the United States and Canada. It is comprised of 30 Allies, protects almost one billion people on both sides of the Atlantic, and represents half of the world’s military and economic might. The challenges NATO faces and the environment in which it operates are also notably different than those that existed when the Alliance was created. In 1949, NATO guarded against the threat of military attack that could be countered through traditional military strengths. At that time, the Soviet Union was the primary threat to the Alliance. Today, NATO is deterring Russian expansion rather than Soviet expansion, facing an adversary that readily deploys the means of hybrid warfare against its targets in order to achieve its political goals. It is an aggressor that has successfully melded hybrid warfare with information, cyber, diplomatic, political, economic, and social means of warfare.51 Russia is a continually evolving apex predator. Consequently, NATO operates in a rapidly changing and unpredictable environment fueled in large part by a state that operates outside the bounds of international law and works to foil the international system while simultaneously insisting no international question may be resolved without it. Permanently on guard, NATO has successfully adapted to political, economic, and social changes that have altered the international security environment over the course of more than seven decades. The Alliance is the transatlantic community’s perpetual guardian, its constantly evolving primary line of defense. As such, it remains an essential component of transatlantic security and the liberal international order. But, can it endure? Currently, every indication is that NATO is a durable compact: all of its 16 longtime members have remained in the Alliance, 14 new members have joined since the end of the Cold War, and additional countries have joined NATO’s Partnership for Peace with the hope of becoming members of the pact. Despite some assertions that NATO and the ideas that underpin the liberal world order are obsolete, NATO’s image has improved on both sides of the Atlantic amid growing security concerns. And it is generally “seen in a positive light across publics within the alliance.”52 The benefits of membership far outweigh the costs. The price of peace costs less than the price of war and rebuilding. Maintaining Peace in the Twenty-First Century The twenty-first century transatlantic security environment has largely been shaped by a revanchist Russia, which has emerged as the single greatest threat to transatlantic peace and security in the post-Cold War era. Over the course of the past 30 years, Russia’s foreign policies and actions have fallen into well-defined historical patterns. Russia’s resurgent expansionism, use of force to change borders, abuse of its UN Security Council veto, and its hostility toward its neighbors and the liberal international order have created comparable conditions to those that led to NATO’s creation in 1949. The Alliance’s success in maintaining transatlantic peace and security through deterrence, along with Litvinov’s, Henderson’s, and Kennan’s post–World War II observations, provides policymakers with important insights into how to approach today’s transatlantic security situation and how to value NATO. In short, Litvinov pointed out that Russia’s desire to expand is insatiable; Henderson observed that its goals never change; and Kennan advised that Russia understands and respects the logic of force above all else.53 NATO has been an effective and durable alliance, one that continues to be a timely and elegant response to the dangers facing transatlantic peace in the twenty-first century. NATO remains the most effective means of ensuring peace for years to come. Æ

2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Russia

It’s especially necessary because of Ukraine. Backing down would be a catastrophe.

The Times 22, Britain’s oldest national daily newspaper, 2-15-2022. “The Times view on the Ukraine crisis: Preserving Peace,” The Times, https://archive.ph/lfew2#selection-743.0-743.54

For more than 70 years, NATO has acted as the guarantor of western security. Russian aggression and threats against Ukraine have nothing to do with any supposed provocation by the transatlantic alliance. Demands by the Kremlin that Kyiv forswear forever any ambition to join NATO are a smokescreen for its real objectives and, even if acted upon, would not defuse this crisis. Western governments would merely be inviting further revanchism by President Putin if it entertained them for even a moment, let alone acceded to them.

The notion of a bar on accession to NATO momentarily excited hopes of a solution to the crisis whereby 100,000 Russian troops have massed across Ukraine’s eastern border. Vadym Prystaiko, Ukraine’s ambassador to Britain, appeared to suggest in a BBC interview on Sunday that Kyiv might abandon the aim of joining NATO as the price of avoiding war. A spokesman for Mr Putin said that, while this did not mark a change in Ukrainian policy, it would be a step in the right direction.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Russia

Putin’s actions centered NATO’s focus away from imperialist operations onto Russia. The existence of NATO is necessary to preserve peace.

James Stavridis 19, (Ret.), a TIME Contributing Editor, was the 16th Supreme Allied Commander at NATO and is Vice Chair, Global Affairs at The Carlyle Group and Chair of the Board of the Rockefeller Foundation. April 4th, 2019, “Why NATO Is Essential For World Peace, According to Its Former Commander.” Time, https://time.com/5564171/why-nato-is-essential-world-peace/

Very few Americans could find tiny Montenegro on a map. Fewer still could offer a cogent description of the differences between Slovenia and Slovakia.

Most can’t name the three Baltic countries. Yet thanks to Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s charter, which was signed 70 years ago in Washington, every American is bound by law to defend with blood and treasure each of those nations, and 22 others to boot.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NATO Good › 2AC – Laundry List

Collapse causes allied prolif, infighting, and forges stronger US and European military opposition to Russia – simulations prove.

Dr Bastian Giegerich and Liana Fix 19, Director of Defence and Military Analysis for The Military Balance; Professor of International Affairs at the Koerber Foundation in Berlin, “European Security in Crisis: What to Expect if the United States Withdraws from NATO,” , cy

Trump’s musings about a NATO withdrawal have served as a wake-up call for some in Europe that Europeans urgently need to assume greater responsibility for their own security. This realization is one of the reasons why closer defense cooperation and a greater degree of strategic autonomy are high on the European Union’s agenda. But are Europeans able to defend themselves? How would they think about their defense without the United States?

A policy game prepared by Körber-Stiftung and the International Institute for Strategic Studies sought to answer these questions this summer in Berlin. Five country teams with experts from France, Germany, Poland, the United Kingdom, and the United States addressed a fictional scenario that involved a U.S. withdrawal from NATO, followed by crises in a NATO member state in the western Balkans and across Eastern Europe. How would Europeans react to such a scenario? What are the red lines, interests, and priorities of the respective actors? How might Europeans organize their defense if the United States withdraws from NATO, and what role could the United States play in European security after the withdrawal?

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Aff Answers › 2AC – AT: HR Impact

Human rights frameworks are extremely complex and difficult to execute

Vandenhole and Gready 14 (Wouter Vandenhole, Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Antwerp, Belgium; Paul Gready, Professor, Centre for Applied Human Rights, University of New York, USA; “Failures and Successes of Human Rights-Based Approaches to Development: Towards a Change Perspective,” Nordic Journal of Human Rights, , October 2014)//sposten

III. HRBADs and Organisational Change Logically preceding a solid understanding of the complexity of social change is the need to better understand what it takes for an organisation to introduce an HRBAD with a view to bring about social change successfully in the first place. Both in change theory and organisations theory, it has been emphasised that views on change and on how organisations change are very often based on implicit assumptions. Both sets of theories also point out the complexity of (organisational) change, and the existence of many different and often competing approaches or “schools”, with some emphasising structural constraints (i.e. constraints based on durable social structures) and others individual agency. Both dimensions are important and often operate in tandem.33 Moreover, a distinction is to be made between formal structure and actual day-to-day activities, for the assumption that organisations function according to formal blueprints is not supported by empirical research,34 hence the emphasis again on the need for much more empirical work. In the case example of UNICEF that follows, we look in particular into internal reflection and planning, and leadership and true believers as explanatory entry points for the (lack of) organisational change accompanying the introduction of an HRBAD. In addition to these drivers of change, we shall pay attention to the spoilers of change, such as lack of capacity or staff turnover, and to the tension between HRBAD and RBM. Attempts at introducing HRBAD by the UN at the country level by states and by non-governmental organisations seem to show similar trends at first sight, though much more research is needed before firm conclusions can be reached.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Aff Answers › 2AC – AT: Europe Free Speech Bad

Europe’s free speech measures are good, and the US has to change its policies---prefer evidence from social media insiders

Haugen 22 (Frances Haugen, former Facebook product manager who focused on combating misinformation and espionage; "Europe Is Making Social Media Better Without Curtailing Free Speech. The U.S. Should, Too", 4-28-2022, New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/28/opinion/social-media-facebook-transparency.html, DOA: 7-16-2022)//sposten

Elon Musk’s deal to take Twitter private, which has spurred questions about power, censorship and safety for the future of the platform, happened just days after the European Union reached a landmark agreement to make social media less toxic for users. The new E.U. standards, and the ethic of transparency on which they are based, will for the first time pull back the curtain on the algorithms that choose what we see and when we see it in our feeds.

In Europe’s case, the dryly named Digital Services Act is the most significant piece of social media legislation in history. It goes to the heart of what I’ve tried to do as a whistle-blower who worked inside Facebook: make social media far better without impinging on free speech. Today, Facebook’s poorly implemented content moderation strategies leave those most at risk of real-world violence unprotected and consistently succeed at only one thing: angering everyone.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Aff Answers › 2AC – Aff Solves

Open-source intel solves---only a risk of decreasing misinformation since the truth is already there

Glover 22 (Claudia Glover; "Open-source intelligence key to fighting Russian disinformation during Ukraine war", 6-7-2022, Tech Monitor, https://techmonitor.ai/technology/emerging-technology/open-source-intelligence-ukraine-war, DOA: 7-16-2022)//sposten

Open source intelligence can be vital in the fight against disinformation, according to a study released today which assesses the impact of novel and emerging technologies on the spread of false information during the Ukraine war. While open data can be harnessed positively to fight disinformation, those deploying it must also be aware of the risks, security experts say.

The report, entitled ‘The Information Battlefield: Disinformation, declassification and deepfakes‘ was released today to mark the launch of the Centre for Emerging Technology and Security (CfETS), a new research centre at the Alan Turing Institute for artificial intelligence which aims to boost the UK’s security by giving policy makers better information about emerging technologies.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Aff Answers › 2AC – Aff Solves

Any information from Russia still leads to inaction---triggers our impacts and means they cannot solve

Grimes 22 (David Robert Grimes, scientist and author of Good Thinking: Why Flawed Logic Puts Us All at Risk and How Critical Thinking Can Save the World (The Experiment). His work focuses on health disinformation and conspiracy theory, and he is an international advocate for the public understanding of science. He is a recipient of the Nature/Sense about Science Maddox Prize, and a fellow of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry; "Russian Misinformation Seeks to Confound, Not Convince: Rather than take a side, these campaigns create decision paralysis that leads to inaction", 3-28-2022, Scientific American, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/russian-misinformation-seeks-to-confound-not-convince/, DOA: 7-16-2022)//sposten

As war envelops Ukraine, Russian sources have strived to create a miasma of disinformation about the invasion. Among ample efforts to distort reality, the Russian Ministry of Defense asserted recently that U.S.-backed labs in Ukraine have been developing bioweapons. Outlandish as this falsehood may be, Fox’s Tucker Carlson gave it credence by arguing that the U.S. government’s response was a “cover-up.”

As the Russia-Ukraine war intensifies, so too will the flow of disinformation. This is an age-old strategy Russia has long history of employing, and a playbook that others, most notably anti-vaccine activists, have borrowed from liberally. Yet, rather than focusing effort on convincing people of a falsehood, the Russian strategy takes a tack reminiscent of a strategy long employed by the tobacco industry: to sow so much doubt about what is true that it sends people into decision paralysis. Faced with a cacophony of wild and conflicting claims, people do nothing, unsure of what is right.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 2NC – Democracy Impact

Democracy solves extinction

Carla Zoe Cremer & Luke Kemp 21, The Future of Humanity Institute, Oxford. Centre for the Study of Existential Risk, Cambridge. "Democratising Risk: In Search of a Methodology to Study Existential Risk" //pipk

There is an intimate and neglected relationship between existential risk and democracy. Democracy must be central to efforts to prevent and mitigate catastrophic risks. It is also an antidote to many of the problems manifest in the TUA. Do those who study the future of humanity have good grounds to ignore the visions, desires, and values of the very people whose future they are trying to protect? Choosing which risks to take must be a democratic endeavour.

We understand democracy here in accordance with Landemore as the rule of the cognitively diverse many who are entitled to equal decision-making power and partake in a democratic procedure that includes both a deliberative element and one of preference aggregation (such as majority voting)45,115. Decision-making procedures are not either democratic or non- democratic, but instead lie on a spectrum. They can be more or less democratic, inclusive, and diverse.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 2NC – Link

Europe’s “anti-disinformation” campaigns spill over into destroying free speech worldwide

Tuccille 22 (J.D. Tuccille; "Europe Escalates the Threat to Online Free Speech", 4-29-2022, Reason, https://reason.com/2022/04/29/europe-escalates-the-threat-to-online-free-speech/, DOA: 7-16-2022)//sposten

It's easy to overstate, but attitudes towards freedom of action differ in the United States and the European Union. Americans tend to believe that people have a right to make their own decisions and are better trusted to do so than coercive governments; Europeans place more faith in the state, allowing room for personal choice only after officialdom installs guardrails and files away sharp edges. Yes, that exaggerates the case and there are plenty of dissenters under both systems, but it captures the treatment of speech and online conduct in the EU's new Digital Services Act.

"Today's agreement on the Digital Services Act is historic, both in terms of speed and of substance," European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen commented on April 23. "The DSA will upgrade the ground-rules for all online services in the EU. It will ensure that the online environment remains a safe space, safeguarding freedom of expression and opportunities for digital businesses. It gives practical effect to the principle that what is illegal offline, should be illegal online. The greater the size, the greater the responsibilities of online platforms."

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 2NC – Link

US and European anti-disinformation campaigns are racist and inadvertently censor unaffiliated Russians---makes it even more difficult to challenge Russia’s regime---the AFF is a Cold War remnant

NCAC 3/8 (Ncac Editor; "Free Speech and the War in Ukraine", 3/8/2022, National Coalition Against Censorship, https://ncac.org/news/free-speech-and-the-war-in-ukraine, DOA: 7-9-2022)//sposten

Cultural institutions in the US and Europe have the right, of course, to express their symbolic opposition to the war by blacklisting Russian artists. However, they must consider the full implications. Today’s cultural institutions are full of artists and performers from countries across the globe. Should all these artists be held responsible for the misdeeds of their political leaders? Should they be asked to publicly condemn these leaders when doing so puts them and members of their family at risk of retaliation by their governments? Banning Russian artists based on their political views or, worse, solely because of their nationality, while welcoming artists from China and other repressive regimes undermines any moral high ground an institution can claim.

The people of a nation are not identical with its leadership and should not be equated with it. On the contrary, they can be allies in opposing a repressive regime from within. Among the Russian artists blacklisted today are people who have been critical of the war.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 2NC – UQ

Europe’s a double-turn on free speech---language vagueness, exceptions, and President Macron

Hilu 22 (Charles Hilu; "Don’t Listen to Europe on Free Speech", 6-23-2022, National Review, https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/dont-listen-to-europe-on-free-speech/, DOA: 7-9-2022)//sposten

Yesterday, vice president of the European Commission for Values and Transparency Věra Jourová addressed the E.U.–U.S. Defense and Future Forum in Washington, D.C. “Do not throw away your shot, and help us protect democracy from the risk coming from both the online and offline world,” she urged attendees. She implored Americans to take actions similar to those of the E.U. against “information manipulation.”

Anyone who heard what Jourová had to say should be dubious. Most countries in the European Union do not share the same commitment to free speech, whether online or offline, and we in the United States should not be taking advice from people who do not hold the right as highly as we do.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 1NC – Disinformation DA

Human rights are key to address a continuum of existential threats

Robinson 21 (Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland and former UN high commissioner for human rights, is Chair of The Elders and Chair of the Business & Human Rights Resource Centre’s Advisory Board; "A Human-Rights Approach to Global Challenges", 7-13-2021, Project Syndicate, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/human-rights-approach-to-tackling-covid19-and-climate-change-by-mary-robinson-2021-07, DOA: 7-8-2022)//sposten

The world will neither rebuild from the pandemic, nor have any chance of tackling wider existential threats such as climate change, until leaders once more instill a sense of hope in political and civic life. Fortunately, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights offers a roadmap to help humanity chart a path forward.

DUBLIN – The COVID-19 pandemic has recast the world for millions of people. Or, more correctly, the pandemic has exposed and aggravated deep inequalities of race, gender, and class across societies, and highlighted the inability of many political systems to respond in ways that protect individual human rights and dignity. The world will neither rebuild from this crisis, nor have any chance of tackling wider existential threats such as climate change, until we can once more instill a sense of hope in political and civic life.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 1NC – Disinformation DA

Free speech is key to broader human rights, democracy, and development---censorship only increases the risk of disinformation

OHCHR 7/8 (*article references Irene Khan, Bangladeshi lawyer appointed as of August 2020 to be the United Nations Special Rapporteur for freedom of expression and opinion, the first woman appointed to this mandate. She previously served as the seventh Secretary General of Amnesty International*; "UN expert warns of dangerous decline in media freedom", United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, 7-8-2022, https://www.ohchr.org/en/stories/2022/07/un-expert-warns-dangerous-decline-media-freedom, DOA: 7-8-2022)//sposten

Reporters getting killed while chasing a story. Online attacks against women journalists, including death and rape threats. Targeted electronic surveillance to intimidate and silence investigative journalism.

This is the dangerous reality for many journalists around the world as media freedom and safety have diminished in the digital age with a grave impact on human rights, democracy and development, a UN expert warned.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
DA – Info Warfare – CPWW – Michigan Summer Debate Institutes 2022 › Neg › 1NC – Disinformation DA

Anti-information campaigns post-Ukraine against Russia and China are devastating for free speech---also turns the AFF because it makes it impossible to gain clear insights on the situation in Russia

Maccarthy 22 (Mark Maccarthy, Nonresident Senior Fellow in Governance Studies at the Center for Technology Innovation at Brookings. He is also adjunct professor at Georgetown University in the Graduate School’s Communication, Culture, & Technology Program and in the Philosophy Department. He teaches courses in the governance of emerging technology, AI ethics, privacy, competition policy for tech and the ethics of speech. He is also a Nonresident Senior Fellow in the Institute for Technology Law and Policy at Georgetown Law, B.A. from Fordham University, an M.A. in economics from Notre Dame and a Ph.D. in philosophy from Indiana University, professional staff member of the U.S. House of Representatives’ Committee on Energy and Commerce, where he handled telecommunications, broadcasting and cable issues, and as a regulatory analyst at the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. He was in charge of the Washington office for Capital Cities/ABC, served as senior vice president for Visa, Inc. and ran the public policy division of the Software & Information Industry Association; "Why a push to exclude Russian state media would be problematic for free speech and democracy", 4-14-2022, Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2022/04/14/why-a-push-to-exclude-russian-state-media-would-be-problematic-for-free-speech-and-democracy/, DOA: 7-8-2022)//sposten

In the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Russia has excluded media outlets based in the U.S. and allied countries. Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Radio Free Europe, Deutsche Welle, BBC, and other news sources are no longer legally available there. A self-imposed digital iron curtain has descended across Europe, enforced in part by the new draconian Russian law criminalizing the distribution of “false information” about the Ukraine conflict.

But the closing of the information space has not been one-sided. The European Union has banned Russian state media in Europe and U.S. companies have made it more difficult to access these media outlets in the U.S., thereby reducing the range of information sources available to the public here in the West.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
**AT: Kritiks** › **2AC – AT: Baudrillard** › Boooooooo

WHO ON HELL IS BAUDRILLARD?

BALSAS 06

(BALSAS is an interdisciplinary journal on media culture.  Interview with Art Group BBM, “on first cyborgs, aliens and other sides of new technologies,” translated from lithiuanian )

Valentinas: We all know that Jean Baudrillard did not believe that the Gulf War did take place, as it was over-mediated and over-simulated. In fact, the Gulf War II is still not over, and Iraq became much more than just a Frankenstein laboratory for the new media, technology and “democracy” games. What can we learn from wars that do not take place, even though they cannot be finished? Are they becoming a symptom of our times as a confrontation between multiple time-lines, ideologies and technologies in a single place? Lars: Actually, it has always been the same: new wars have been better test-beds for the state of art technologies and the latest computer-controlled firearms. The World War I already was a fully mechanized war where pre-robots were fighting each other and gassing the troops. And afterwards, the winners shape the new world order. Olaf: Who on hell is Baudrillard? The one who earns money by publishing his prognoses after the things happen? What a fuck, French philosophy deals too much with luxury problems and elegantly ignores the problem itself. It’s no wonder, this is the colonizer’s mentality, you can hear it roaring in their words: they use phrases made to camouflage genocide. I went to see that Virilio’s exhibition "Ce qui arrive" at Foundation Cartier in 2003. I was smashed by that banal presentation of the evil of all kinds: again, natural catastrophes and evil done by man were exposed on the same wall, glued together with a piece of "theory". There you find it all, filed up in one row: the pure luxury of the Cartier-funded Jean Nouvel building, an artwork without any blood in its veins, and that late Christian philosophy about the techno-cataclysm being the revenge of God. Pure shit, turned into gold in the holy cellars of the modern alchemists’ museums. The artist-made video "documents" of the Manhattan towers opposed to Iraqian war pictures: that’s not Armageddon, that’s man-invented war technology to be used to subdue others. And there is always somebody who pushes the buttons, even when the button is a computer mouse some ten thousand kilometers away from the place where people die, or even if it is a civil airplanes redirected by Islamists. Everybody knows that. War technology has always been made to make killing easier. And to produce martyrs as well. Janneke: Compare Baudrillard with Henry Dunant, the founder of the International Committee of the Red Cross. Dunant was no philosopher, he was just an intelligent rich man in the late 19th century. But his ideas went far more in the direction where you should hope to find philosophers as well. He experienced war as a "randonneur": he passed by, he saw the suffering and the inhumanity of war. And he felt obliged to act. Apart from the maybe 10 days he spent on the battlefield, on the beautiful meadows in the Europeans Alps, helping wounded people to survive, as a complete medical layman he decided to do something more sustainable against these odds. He knew that his efforts couldn’t prevent war in general, but he felt that he could alter the cruelty of reality. And he succeeded in doing it. No wonder that in our days we find the most engaged people to support the TROIA projects intention in Geneva, where they are still based. And they are not only doing their necessary surgeon’s work in the field: they are as well fighting with the same energy on the diplomatic battlefield.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
**AT: Kritiks** › **2AC – AT: Baudrillard** › Boooooooo

And they create epistemic disregard to material violence.

Best & Kellner 91

(Steven – Associate Professor of Philosophy @ the University of Texas-El Paso and Douglas – George Kneller Chair in the Philosophy of Education in the Graduate School of Education and Information Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, Postmodern Theory, p. 138-139)

Furthermore, Baudrillard's analysis operates on an excessively high level of abstraction. He fails to make key distinctions and engages in misplaced abstraction. For instance, Ron Silliman pointed out in his response to Baudrillard at the Montana conference that Baudrillard failed to distinguish between tranvestism and transexuality. Transvestites play at dressing as members of the opposite sex and enjoy the 'gender fucking' and subversion of dress codes; transsexuals, by contrast, are often tortured and suffering individuals who can appear uncomfortable in either sex ~ as evidenced by the high rate of suicides of those who undergo sex change operations. But human suffering is erased from Baudrillard's semiological universe which abstractly describes certain sign spectacles abstracted from material underpinnings. The same bad abstraction appears in his travelogue America (l988d). Baudrillard speeds through the desert of America and merely sees signs floating by. He looks at Reagan on TV and sees only his smile. He hangs out in southern California and concludes that the United States is a 'realized utopia'. He fails to see, however, the homeless, the poor, racism and sexism, people dying of AIDS, oppressed immigrants, and fails to relate any of the phenomena observed to the vicissitudes of capitalism (he denies that capital ever existed in America!), or to the conservative political hegemony of the 1980s. Baudrillard's imaginary is thus a highly abstract sign fetishism which abstracts from social relations and political economy in order to perceive the play of signs in the transvestite spectacles of the transaesthetic, transsexual, and transpolitical. Baudrillard's 'trans' manoeuvres, however, are those of an idealist skimming the surface of appearances while speeding across an environment which he never contextualizes, understands, or really comes to terms with.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
**AT: Kritiks** › **2AC – AT: Baudrillard** › Boooooooo

Their vague theoretical account can’t produce material change.

Best & Kellner 91

(Steven – Associate Professor of Philosophy @ the University of Texas-El Paso and Douglas – George Kneller Chair in the Philosophy of Education in the Graduate School of Education and Information Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, Postmodern Theory, p. 117)

Moreover, while Baudrillard was calling for a cultural revolution and total revolution (1975: pp.130ff.), he never explicitly formulated any concrete vision or practice of revolution, other than some reflections on urban grafitti as a form of political resistance (Baudrillard 1976: pp. 118ff.). Thus his micropolitics are rather vague and empty. His ultra-left politics of the time are really no more than slogans which position his theory as 'ultrarevolutionary'. But, it is not clear what this revolution could accomplish in view of the hegemony of the dominant codes that he described. In fact, there is extreme tension between his advocacy of cultural revolution and his descriptions of the system's ability to absorb all oppositional practices. For a cultural revolution would produce new practices, institutions, signs, codes, values, and so on, but in Baudrillard's theory all practices and signs are controlled by and absorbed into the almighty code - a typically vague and undertheorized term. Thus, the only practice that he can really recommend is total refusal, total negativity, and the utopia of radical otherness (Baudrillard 1975: pp. 130ff., passim). Like Foucault and Deleuze and Guattari, Baudrillard's politics at this time circulate in the trajectory of ultra-leftist 'gauchiste' discourses which purport to be more radical and revolutionary than traditional Marxism. Such gauchistes took ultra-left positions and operated outside of the major left parties, either forming splinter parties or groups, or acting as an extra-parliamentary opposition. Baudrillard and other French thinkers of the period, deeply influenced by the heterogeneous uprisings of May 1968, decisively broke with Marxian working-class politics and sought alternative perspectives for revolutionary politics. Yet he never succeeded in articulating any concrete and specific political perspectives and in his later works turned away from political reflection and critique altogether.