2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › DSCA 2NC – Link UQ
Marcus Weisgerber 22, 6-30-2022, "Pentagon Agency Wants to Send Arms Monitors to Ukraine," Defense One, https://www.defenseone.com/policy/2022/06/pentagon-agency-wants-send-arms-monitors-ukraine/368867/
DSCA, the agency in charge of foreign US arms sales, currently has no on-the-ground access to US-donated weapons to Ukraine and whether they are being used as intended. This was stated by Jed Royal, deputy director of the Defense Security Cooperation Agency [DSCA] to journalists during a round table meeting last Thursday [June 30]. Due to the war in Ukraine, no toolkit works as it did in peacetime, i.e. going to a foreign country, opening military warehouses, tracking serial numbers, the state of weaponry, its availability, etc. Royal confirmed the view that currently in this situation, DSCA officials are “somewhat limited” in their ability to carry out more robust monitoring of weapons supplied to Ukraine. BulgarianMilitary.com recalls that in recent weeks there have been allegations of illegal arms trade during wartime. As we wrote, sources claim that Ukraine sold Russia two self-propelled French Caesar howitzers. Ukraine [France too] rejects this claim. Last month, a Javelin anti-tank guided missile system appeared for sale on the darknet, with the place of purchase being Kyiv, the capital of Ukraine. Jed Royal told reporters that officials will have to be more creative in carrying out their duties, but only if the agency sends more people into the field to conduct inspections. “Once we have more people in the country, we should be in a position to actually go do more physical validation [and] verification, going forward,” he said. “That’s the kind of thing that we’re looking for here. It still won’t be like a peacetime environment for it. So we’re going to have to get creative in how we do this.” It has not yet been decided how and when DSCA officials will begin inspections of weapons delivered to Ukraine. Royal is hoping to get a cooperation office in Ukraine to house examiners, a practice worldwide carried out by the agency. However, Royal does not want to send a “task force”. Ukraine received M30/M31 rockets with 51lb of PBX-109 high explosives Photo credit: Think Defence Jed Royal said that at the moment the only verification being done was on credibility – assurances from the Ukrainians that were given to DSCA agents and described them as “very solid and satisfactory”. Congress wants the same BulgarianMilitary.com recalls that currently, Ukraine has received US$6 billion worth of military equipment as military aid. US President Joe Biden almost once a month announces a new package of weapon systems, ammunition, and consumables that the US is ready to give to Ukraine, thereby increasing the revenge against Ukraine.While Congress has been broadly supportive of security assistance to Ukraine, lawmakers across the political spectrum — including Sens. Rand Paul, R-Ky., and Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass. — have raised concerns about the department’s seeming lack of oversight
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 1NC – AT: Trump ahead now
Cohn 7-16 (Nate Cohn, 7-16-2022, "The Key Insights From Our First Poll of the 2022 Midterms," The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/16/upshot/poll-analysis-2022-midterms.html)
Which side has the most energy heading into November? More polls will come as the midterm elections near, but for now we’ve wrapped up our first New York Times/Siena survey, and here are some notable takeaways: Voters are not happy. Just 13 percent of registered voters said America was heading in the right direction. Only 10 percent said the economy was excellent or good. And a majority of voters said the nation was too politically divided to solve its challenges. As a point of comparison, each of these figures shows a more pessimistic electorate than in October 2020, when the pandemic was still raging and Donald J. Trump was president. Joe Biden is in trouble. His approval rating in our poll was in the low 30s. That’s lower than we ever found for Mr. Trump. Democrats would rather see someone else get the party’s nomination in 2024. Mr. Biden’s age was as much of an issue among voters as his overall job performance. Of course, he probably would have trailed “someone else” ahead of the last presidential primary as well, but he still won the nomination because his opposition was weak or fractured. Still, it’s a sign that Mr. Biden is much weaker than the typical president seeking re-election. It could augur a contested primary. Democrats’ Reasons for a Different Candidate What’s the most important reason you would prefer someone other than Joe Biden to be the Democratic Party’s 2024 presidential nominee? Asked of 191 respondents who said they planned to vote in the 2024 Democratic primary and who preferred a candidate other than Joe Biden in a New York Times/Siena College poll from July 5-7, 2022.By The New York Times Trump isn’t doing great, either. Like Mr. Biden, Mr. Trump has become less popular over the last two years. The number of Republicans who hold an unfavorable view of him has doubled since our final polling in 2020. He’s now under 50 percent in a hypothetical 2024 Republican primary matchup. Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida is already at 25 percent in an early test of the Republican primary. Mr. Trump may still be the front-runner, but the polls increasingly look more like the early surveys from the Democratic primary in 2008 — when Hillary Clinton found herself in an extremely close race and ultimately lost to Barack Obama — than the polls ahead of the Democratic primary in 2016, when she won a protracted battle against Bernie Sanders. Many voters do not want to see a 2020 rematch. Mr. Biden still led Mr. Trump in a hypothetical 2024 matchup, 44 percent to 41 percent. What was surprising: Ten percent of respondents volunteered that they would not vote at all or would vote for someone else if those were the two candidates, even though the interviewer didn’t offer those choices as an option. The midterm race starts out close, with voters nearly evenly divided on the generic congressional ballot (voters are asked whether they prefer Democrats or Republicans to be in control of Congress). That’s a little surprising, given expectations of a Republican landslide this year.
What is your preference for the outcome of the 2022 congressional elections?
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 1NC – Dems Winning
Walker 6-30 (Chris Walker, 6-30-2022, “Dems Close Gap on GOP in Midterm Poll Following Supreme Court’s Upending of Roe”, https://truthout.org/articles/dems-close-gap-on-gop-in-midterm-poll-following-supreme-courts-upending-of-roe/)
New polling continues to show that the 2022 midterm election outcome will be a close one, as both Democratic and Republican parties appear to be in a statistical tie on who voters prefer to run Congress next term.
The Supreme Court’s decision to end abortion rights protections appears to be helping Democrats’ numbers.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 1NC – Dems Winning
Ramos 7-15 (Kristian Ramos, 7-15-2022, "Democrats' time to pounce: Republicans suddenly find themselves vulnerable ahead of midterms ," Salon, )
With the approval of the Republican Party plummeting and gas and commodity prices declining, Democrats suddenly have an opportunity to go on offense this midterm cycle by touting the success of the pandemic recovery — and contrasting that with the draconian proposals offered by the alternative.
To do this, Democrats must center the innovation and grit of the American people and show how we are transitioning from a rapid recovery to sustainable growth. Republicans, by contrast, have devolved into a cult beholden to Donald Trump, doubling down on their support for him despite the shocking revelations of the January 6 commission.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 1NC – Dems Winning
Landen 7-23 (Xander Landen, 7-23-2022, "Democrats narrow Congress poll gap to Republicans, closest for 6 months," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/democrats-narrow-congress-poll-gap-republicans-closest-6-months-1727397)
Democrats are narrowing the gap with Republicans in polling ahead of this year's midterm congressional races, according to analysis from FiveThirtyEight. FiveThirtyEight, which compiles generic congressional ballot polls, shows that as of July 22, Republicans have a 1-point lead over Democrats, with 44.2 percent of voters saying that they'd back GOP candidates while 43.2 percent say they'd support Democrats. The latest numbers mark the closest the polling average has been since January, when surveys showed Republicans had only a slight advantage over Democrats. In early January, Republicans were up by only 0.5 percent in the polls. Republicans' lead grew in February to nearly 3 percent, according to FiveThirtyEight, before remaining at around 2 percent for months.
Democrats Narrow Congress Poll Gap to Republicans
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 2AC – House GOP Winning
Gonzales 7-14 (Nathan L. Gonzales, 7-14-2022, "Ratings show GOP taking House control, but no red wave — yet," Roll Call, https://rollcall.com/2022/07/14/ratings-show-gop-taking-house-control-but-no-red-wave-yet/)
ANALYSIS — If the election were held today, it looks as if Republicans would gain seven House seats, according to Inside Elections’ individual race ratings. While that would be enough for the majority, it certainly wouldn’t qualify as a red wave. Still, that doesn’t mean Democrats can rest easy, and GOP gains are likely to be higher. If you tally all the races rated as Solid Republican, Likely Republican, Lean Republican and Tilt Republican, and split the 18 Toss-up races evenly, Republicans would have 221 seats. That would be a net gain of seven seats. They need a net gain of only four for the majority. Of course, Republicans wouldn’t turn that down, but it would be a minuscule gain and a massive disappointment for the GOP because the expectations and current projections are high. Over the past century, the president’s party has lost an average of 30 House seats in midterm elections. Midterm elections are typically performance reviews on the sitting president, and Joe Biden’s job rating is in rough shape. He’s at 39 percent approve and 56 percent disapprove, according to the latest FiveThirtyEight average, with no sign of a rebound. Seventy-five percent of Americans believe the country is on the wrong track, compared with just 18 percent who believe the country is headed in the right direction, according to the RealClearPolitics average. That’s usually not good for the party in power, and Democrats control the executive and legislative branches of government. When people are asked which party they want in control of Congress, Republicans have a 1.9-point lead, according to the averages on FiveThirtyEight and on RealClearPolitics. At least one model, from Emory University professor Alan Abramowitz, suggests that a generic ballot lead of that size should power Republicans to a 19-seat gain in the House.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 2AC – Dems Losing Now
Marriner and Reklaitis 7-22 (Katie Marriner, Victor Reklaitis, 7-22-2022, "Republicans still favored in midterm elections, but their chances for taking back Senate are dropping," MarketWatch, https://www.marketwatch.com/story/republicans-still-favored-in-midterm-elections-but-their-chances-for-taking-back-senate-are-dropping-11657887755)
Republicans are widely expected to score wins in this November’s midterm elections, thanks in large part to Americans’ frustrations with raging inflation. High prices for gasoline RB00, -0.05% and other essentials are helping to keep President Joe Biden’s approval ratings low — and giving a talking point for Republicans to use against Biden and his fellow Democrats. But the GOP’s odds for taking back control of the Senate have fallen significantly this month, as shown in the chart below that’s based on data from betting market PredictIt. They’re down to just above 60%, off from nearly 80% in mid-June. Republicans’ odds for regaining the House haven’t seen that type of drop and remain strong, staying well above 80%.
Odds
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 2AC – Dems Losing Now
Roche 7-7 (Darragh Roche, 7-7-2022, "Democrats' worst case scenario for the midterms," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/democrats-worst-case-scenario-midterms-joe-biden-republicans-1722543)
Democrats are widely expected to suffer defeats in the upcoming 2022 midterm elections, with Republicans aiming to retake the House of Representatives and the Senate. The serving president's party usually performs poorly during midterms and while it seems likely President Joe Biden will see major losses this November, it's not clear just how bad things will be for the Democrats. Polls suggest the Democrats are on course for disappointment and that the party could potentially lose control of both chambers of Congress and see newly empowered Republican majorities stymying Biden's agenda in the run up to the next presidential election. A GOP gain in either chamber would hamstring the Biden administration, but the worst case scenario would see comfortable Republican majorities in both chambers, potentially leading to a slew of investigations and possibly even impeachment of the president.
Losing the Senate
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
*Disad Updates** › Midterms 2AC – Dems Losing Now
Lindsay 7-19 (James M. Lindsay, 7-19-2022, "A Midterm Election Update," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/blog/midterm-election-update)
Back in March, I reviewed what we know about U.S. congressional midterm elections. The big takeaway was that the president’s party generally loses House seats, but not necessarily Senate seats. That is especially true when the president is struggling in the polls. With President Joe Biden’s approval rating at 42 percent eight months out from Election Day, that historical pattern was bad news for Democrats and good news for Republicans. The one bright spot for Democrats was that the decennial redistricting of House seats looked to be going in their favor. So where do things stand three and a half months from Election Day? The picture appears to have gotten darker for the Democrats—at least when it comes to holding onto the House. Biden’s average public approval rating now stands at 38 percent, and his average disapproval rating at 57 percent. To put those numbers in perspective, no elected president since World War II has been lower in the polls at this point in his presidency. (Scientific polling didn’t begin until the 1940s, so we can’t compare Biden’s numbers with, say, James Buchanan’s.) Barring a turn in events, Biden is more likely to hurt than help the chances of Democratic congressional candidates. The bad news doesn’t end there for Democrats. The once-promising results of decennial redistricting have dimmed. New York State’s Court of Appeals tossed out a redistricting plan drafted by the state’s Democratic-controlled legislature that would have added as many as three Democratic seats to New York’s congressional delegation. New York instead adopted a redistricting plan drawn up by a court-appointed special master that created more competitive districts and opened up the possibility that Republicans might gain seats. In Maryland, a court struck down the Democratic-controlled state legislature’s initial redistricting proposal as “extreme partisan gerrymandering.” The revised plan passed by the Maryland legislature likely will preserve the state’s one Republican congressional seat. Republicans, meanwhile, got good news on the redistricting front. The most significant development was in Florida, where Governor Ron DeSantis used his veto to force the Republican-controlled state legislature to abandon a redistricting plan that had only a slight Republican bias. After much back-and-forth, the legislature approved the plan that DeSantis drew up. It’s projected to give Florida Republicans four more House seats than they had under the old map.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › 2AC – Funding Fails
De Rugy 3/10 (Veronique de Rugy, senior research fellow at George Mason University, 3-10-2022, “More Defense Spending Does Not Equal More Safety”, Reason, accessed 6-28-2022, )//kp
The brutal invasion of Ukraine by Russia has renewed conservatives' calls for large increases of our defense budget. The extra money, we are told, would fund more weapons to better prepare us to respond to aggression in a world that looks increasingly dangerous. As compelling as these arguments can be in a stressful time, it's not quite so simple.
Providing military defense is a valid function of the federal government. However, that doesn't give license to Congress to simply pile on more spending, even when there are dangers out there. Nor does it mean that more spending will result in a completely safe world for us Americans. That's in part because that world doesn't exist. There's only so much safety money can buy.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › 2AC – Funding Fails
Manjoo 1/13 (Farhad Manjoo, New York Times columnist, 1-13-2022, “We Must Stop Showering the Military With Money”, The New York Times, accessed 6-22-2022, )//kp
Last month, Senator Joe Manchin, the West Virginia Democrat who has frustrated much of President Biden’s policy agenda, released confirming what he’d been hinting for weeks. He for the Build Back Better Act, the Democrats’ $2.2 trillion 10-year plan to address climate change and invest in child care, health care and education. Manchin argued it would increase inflation, harm the electricity grid and hamper national security and was simply just too “mammoth” and “sweeping” to support.
“I have always said, ‘If I can’t go back home and explain it, I can’t vote for it,’” he .
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Impact---AT: Dystopia
Dupont 08 [Benoit Dupont, August 2008, “Hacking the Panopticon: Distributed Online Surveillance and Resistance,” <<Benoit is the holder of the Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity and the Research Chair for the Prevention of Cybercrime>>, D_Sociology of Crime Law and Deviance]
I offer an additional interpretation inspired by Gary Marx’s (2007) techno-fallacies article and the heuristics’ theory of Tversky and Kahneman (1982). Just like technophiles often succumb to the false belief that there is a technological fix for every security problem, surveillance scholars (as an epistemic community, not as individuals) are not immune to biases that lead them to assume that the monitoring technologies embedded in virtually every aspect of our lives are a clear indicator of our inexorable fall into a 1984 reality. Three biases are particularly salient in this belief system. The first bias is the initiative bias, which leads people to attribute less initiative and less imagination to others than to themselves (Kahneman & Tversky, 1993, p. 3), especially if they belong to a lower socio-economic group. While surveillance scholars are able to offer elaborate narratives of the hidden power of the electronic panopticon and its significance, they frequently discount the interpretive capacities and agency of surveillance subjects and the resistance strategies that ensue. The loss aversion bias refers to the asymmetrical evaluation of positive and negative outcomes, where losses are systematically overestimated and gains are underestimated. This bias seems particularly pronounced ‘‘when the reference point is the status quo, and when retention of the status quo is an option’’ (Kahneman & Tversky, 1993, p. 14). This bias corresponds in surveillance studies to the reticence manifested toward the study of positive developments (Haggerty, 2006, p. 35) such as the accountability produced by meta-surveillance applications or the independence afforded to elderly patients by monitoring systems that let them stay at home. The tendency to predict widespread erosions of freedom has also been a prominent feature of surveillance studies, despite the lack of empirical and historical data to support this claim. Democracies have not crumbled since advanced monitoring technologies have invaded our lives, and the lack of sophisticated surveillance tools has never prevented authoritarian states to enroll thousands of informers to control internal dissent (Pfaff, 2001). Finally, the third heuristic is the probability bias whereby a confusion is made between what is possible and what is probable (Ohm, 2007). This bias is very closely connected with the previous one, because on contentious subjects such as surveillance and privacy, people tend to focus on disastrous outcomes and neglect the role played by randomness (Taleb, 2004), complexity, and contested rationalities (Espeland, 1998) among supervisors. Surveillance scholars frequently present what may happen as what will happen, obscuring the mechanisms that so often derail the best plans. Perhaps, the fact that Bentham’s panopticon was actually never built and that the British government preferred instead to deport its prisoners to Australia, an open-air prison where convict supervision was deliberately kept at a minimum (Kerr, 1989; Jackson, 1998), should serve as a reminder that dystopias are about as likely to materialize as utopias.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Diplomacy
Unker 17 [Akin Unker, 06-11-2017, “Computational Diplomacy: Foreign Policy Communication in the Age of Algorithms and Automation,” Cyber Governance & Digital Democracy,”
Automation doesn’t change the fact that diplomats and embassies still matter. Foreign policy, like all politics, is a factor of human condition, including sense, gut feeling and cultural cues, along with its imperfections. However, there is a clear trajectory whereby states that can best adapt to automation – in war, foreign policy and economy – will develop more efficient ways of dealing with the challenges of an interconnected, data-centric world. Diplomacy too, can retain its relevance and influence over politics between nations, so long as it can properly designate areas where automation can help and where it can’t. Although all states will come up with their own answers to these questions, based on their own individual interests and needs, the common direction in which automation and foreign policy is headed is more or less similar for all countries. In the future, diplomacy has to build data processing and management capabilities, with dedicated departments and scientists supporting diplomats and negotiators on the ground. The structure of this new framework will also heavily depend on regime type, scope of foreign interests and alliance behavior.
The structural shadow of uncertainty over diplomacy is stronger than ever. Some communicative rituals and practices of diplomacy are growing more obsolete, as modern political communication slides increasingly to short and sharp rhetoric, coupled with automation tools that bombard audiences at unprecedented levels. Diplomacy itself is hardly obsolete however, as the task of mediating and negotiating power relations is perhaps as important as it was during the Cold War. New power centers – in the form of technology companies and big data brokers – are changing the state-centric parameters of classical realism perhaps, but the inherent dynamics of power realignment still render diplomacy a crucial endeavor. To rise to the challenge however, modern diplomacy has to develop a strong computational capacity, able to adapt to the changing nature of digital communication and advances in automation.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Pursley 10 [Mike, “From Alienation to Autonomy by Franco "Bifo" Berardi”//ASherm]
Here’s a taste of some of the most abstract: “The infinite capacity of replication of the recombining simulator device erases the originality of the event.” Or how about: “The productive finalization of technology ends up subjugating the thinking process from the standpoint of its own epistemological structures.” Indeed. Capitalism, and his absolute distaste for it, is where Bifo makes himself absolutely clear. It’s the catch-all cause for all modern strife, a “pathogenic mechanism” that is the ruin of everything. Preaching “liberation from capitalism” is where the author will most likely loose all but the most radical of readers. The capitalist system is clearly not without faults, but presenting it as scapegoat for every ill we face may be too simple. At times Bifo seems a cranky old curmudgeon madly shaking his fist at the present. This is the Bifo that bemoans “collective mental pollution” and says of the world: “too many signs, too fast, too chaotic.” His qualms with hyperreal society are at times a good diagnosis of our problems, but the prescribed anti-capitalist panacea remains questionable. For all the theory involved to make his case, Bifo’s solution is strangely and kind of awesomely underwhelming. We are urged to reconsider how wealth is defined, to focus more on friendships and an easygoing life rather than profits. Who but Henry Ford himself could argue with that? The volume ends with a few thoughts on the current Great Recession, where the collapse of the economy “can be read as the return of the soul.” For that, we will have to see.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Campbell 98 [David, “Performing Politics and the Limits of Language, Theory & Event”]
Those who argue that hate speech demands juridical responses assert that not only does the speech communicate, but that it constitutes an injurious act. This presumes that not only does speech act, but that "it acts upon the addressee in an injurious way" (16). This argumentation is, in Butler's eyes, based upon a "sovereign conceit" whereby speech wields a sovereign power, acts as an imperative, and embodies a causative understanding of representation. In this manner, hate speech constitutes its subjects as injured victims unable to respond themselves and in need of the law's intervention to restrict if not censor the offending words, and punish the speaker: This idealization of the speech act as a sovereign action (whether positive or negative) appears linked with the idealization of sovereign state power or, rather, with the imagined and forceful voice of that power. It is as if the proper power of the state has been expropriated, delegated to its citizens, and the state then rememerges as a neutral instrument to which we seek recourse to protects as from other citizens, who have become revived emblems of a (lost) sovereign power (82). Two elements of this are paradoxical. First, the sovereign conceit embedded in conventional renderings of hate speech comes at a time when understanding power in sovereign terms is becoming (if at all ever possible) even more difficult. Thus the juridical response to hate speech helps deal with an onto-political problem: "The constraints of legal language emerge to put an end to this particular historical anxiety [the problematisation of sovereignty], for the law requires that we resituate power in the language of injury, that we accord injury the status of an act and trace that act to the specific conduct of a subject" (78). The second, which stems from this, is that (to use Butler's own admittedly hyperbolic formulation) "the state produces hate speech." By this she means not that the state is the sovereign subject from which the various slurs emanate, but that within the frame of the juridical account of hate speech "the category cannot exist without the state's ratification, and this power of the state's judicial language to establish and maintain the domain of what will be publicly speakable suggests that the state plays much more than a limiting function in such decisions; in fact, the state actively produces the domain of publicly acceptable speech, demarcating the line between the domains of the speakable and the unspeakable, and retaining the power to make and sustain the line of consequential demarcation" (77). The sovereign conceit of the juridical argument thus linguistically resurrects the sovereign subject at the very moment it seems most vulnerable, and reaffirms the sovereign state and its power in relation to that subject at the very moment its phantasmatic condition is most apparent. The danger is that the resultant extension of state power will be turned against the social movements that sought legal redress in the first place (24)
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Keefer 11 [Lucas Keefer is currently a graduate student studying philosophy and psychology at Georgia State University. “Review - The Soul at Work” //ASherm]
Of course, some Marxist theorists have already been aware of this need for a critique of contemporary consciousness and have suggested important alternatives. Berardi follows Deleuze and Guattari in adopting a therapeutic approach, though we might also follow Lefebvre (1943/2009) and suggest that a critique of semiocapitalism might also depend on returning to an analysis of the reality of alienation in the everyday lives of those oppressed. If the “soul” oppresses itself under semiocapitalism, it does so only by investing all meaning in the symbolic reality of simulations. Marxist-scientific critique remains, therefore, one way of returning this oppressed symbolic consciousness to the reality of its oppression (see also e.g. Martín-Baró, 1994). Berardi also notes the ways in which semiocapitalism pathologizes (and medicates) reactions against alienation (207). The increased rates of depression and availability of anti-depressants, Berardi suggests, are an indication of humanity’s resistance to a system of symbolic production that exploits subjectivity. As a result, no medicalization of depression can ever hope to successfully treat the root cause of depression, which lies in the alienated existence of postmodernity. The problem here is striking: treatments for depression cost money and only further demand that people labor under semiocapitalism to afford their medications and therapy. It is a race to the bottom in which exploitation and treatment perpetuate each other indefinitely. Berardi suggests a therapeutic shift towards schizoanalysis, following Deleuze (214-219), which suggests that therapeutics must be an ongoing project of restoring autonomy in the face of capitalism’s control over desire. One noteworthy omission from this text is the absence of any consideration of semiocapitalism’s relationship to other capitalisms. While Berardi illustrates the process of alienation in semiocapitalism, these analyses must be tempered by a recognition that cognitive labor is not the norm. While globalization may change this over time, we should recognize that semiocapitalism itself depends upon the more concrete alienation of the physical laborers who provide food (e.g. de Botton, 2009), etc. For semiocapitalism to be parasitic upon the “souls” of human laborers, it must also be parasitic upon the bodies of others to perpetuate the physical existence that underlies the alienation of the soul.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Lear 12 [Ben Lear is an underemployed researcher living in Manchester, UK. He recently co-authored an article in Occupy Everything! Reflections on Why it's Kicking off Everywhere, and is a member of Plan C. “Lifeboat Communism – A Review of Franco “Bifo” Berardi’s After the Future”//ASherm]
What does the end of the future mean for radical politics? It is at this point that Bifo’s argument becomes problematic. In an argument that intersects with groups such as Tiqqun, Bifo argues that we must see “Communism as a necessity in the collapse of capital.” Distant from the voluntarism of previous forms of Communist politics, this “post-growth Communism” will be best understood as a necessary response to capital’s refusal of labour. Cut adrift from the “opportunity” to work, with welfare systems dismantled, Bifo argues that we will witness the proliferation of zones of autonomy responding to the needs of an increasingly precarious and superfluous social body. Communist politics will emerge from an exodus, both voluntary and compulsory, from a stagnating and increasingly predatory state-capital nexus. This exodus is both social, in the development of an alternative infrastructure, and personal, in the withdrawal from the hyper-stimulation of the semiotic economy. Bifo abandons hope in collective contestation at the level of the political. Bifo’s politics could be described as a kind of “lifeboat communism.” As the crisis ripples, mutates, and deepens, Bifo sees the role of communism as the creation of spaces of solidarity to blunt the worst effects of the crisis of social reproduction. Gone is the demand for a better world for all, the liberation of our collective social wealth, or the unlocking of the social potentials of technology. Rather, Bifo’s politics are based around insulating a necessarily small portion of society from the dictates of capital. By withdrawing from the political sphere, we accept the likelihood of losing the final scraps of the welfare state and concede the terrain of the political to zombie politics and predatory capital. Rather than seeking new forms of organization to re-enter the political stage, Bifo seems to suggest that we seek shelter beneath it as best we can. This shying away from the political stage is the weakness at the heart of the book. Recent eruptions of political struggle have captured the collectiveimagination because they demonstrate that political contestation is still possible today, in spite of the obstacles Bifo has described. The Occupy movement and the uprisings in the Middle East and North Africa have resonated with all those who still have hope in collective struggle. Although these movements have encountered varying problems, to which we must develop solutions, they dispel the idea of an unchangeable present. The current blockages to successful organising have been shown to be strategic and tactical, not terminal. Misdiagnosing the current inertia of post-political public life as a terminal condition leads the left towards an evacuation of the political, while we should instead reassert its primacy. If we abandon any hope of fighting in, against, and beyond the existing architecture of the state and capital, and instead seek refuge in small communes, and go-slow practices, we abandon all real hope of a generalized, or generalizable, emancipatory politics. Although Bifo’s analysis of the difficulties of collective action resonates with all of us who have attempted to organize struggles in the past few decades, the proposal for a simple withdrawal from capitalism is a bleak politics indeed – which, at its most optimistic, calls for an orderly default by portions of the proletariat. The horizons of communist politics appear much narrower when capitalism is no longer seen as the repository of a vast store of social wealth awaiting collective redistribution, but rather redefined as an unassailable site of universal and permanent austerity combined with widening social redundancy. It is hard to imagine a network of self-organized projects and systems supporting the majority of the population in the context of an increasingly predatory capitalism. Emerging from the and isolated leftist scenes, this lifeboat communism will by its very nature have a limited carrying capacity, as the anarchist experience in post-Katrina New Orleans attests. The lifeboats that Bifo calls for will undoubtedly be too small and makeshift to harbor us all. The crisis is twofold. It is a crisis of capitalist profitability, and of an increasingly precarious and surplus global proletariat whose reproduction (as both labour and body) is under threat. It is unlikely that the proliferation of communes, squats, food co-ops, file sharers, urban gardeners, and voluntary health services will bring forth a new, better world. But while the current seemingly post-political situation throws up massive obstacles to organizing, there is still a potential for collective contestation. The capitalist state, racked by its own legitimacy crisis and weekly political scandals, is more vulnerable than it appears. We need only recall the period of unexpected hope built by students in Britain, occupiers in Oakland, and vast swathes of North Africa and the Middle East during the past two years. These movements were mobilised through the betrayal of a vision of the future – but alongside their rage, they put forth a hope which can guide our politics. The task at hand is to unlearn old behaviour and to forge new tactical and organisational weapons for struggle. Bifo’s contribution is a timely and challenging one, but it ultimately leads us back towards a DIY culture and “outreach” politics. As our movements come to terms with these limits, we must also hold onto the belief that luxury for all is possible. The social potential of unfilled blocks of flats, emerging technologies like 3D-printing, and the desires of the millions of underemployed, should remind us of this. This will not be possible without a collective struggle against the state and the demands of capital, one which simultaneously defends what we have and attempts to move beyond it. A retreat to lifeboat politics is both premature and a self-fulfilling prophecy. While Bifo correctly analyses the current conjuncture – clearly identifying the post-political state, the weakness of the Left, the crisis of profitability and new forms of labour, and their impact on the subject – his political prescriptions lead us in the wrong direction. Just as Bifo does, we place the struggle against work at the center; but we can also seek to liberate social wealth, rather than insulate a lucky few from the ravages of capital. Rather than “No Future,” we must raise a different banner: “The future’s here, it just needs reorganizing.”
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Lack 19 [Tony Lack, 2019, “Franco “Bifo” Berardi: The Second Coming,” Marx & Philosophy Review of Books,”
According to Berardi, the system is immune to transformative criticism because it entertains all positions and allows every voice to be heard. Serious criticisms mix and mingle with absurd conspiracy theories, apocalyptic scenarios, and fake news.
How do we begin to bring about the solution, the second coming of communism? Berardi reinterprets Marx’s Eleventh Thesis on Feuerbach, stressing the importance of interpretation as a form of political praxis. He claims, ‘It may be that Marx’s famous eleventh thesis on Feuerbach – the central pillar of the revolutionary methodology of the last century and a half – simply needs to be overturned. Marx wrote there that ‘Philosophers have hitherto only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it’ – and the philosophers of the last century tried to do so. The results are catastrophic’ (3).
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Sayarer 15 [Julian Sayarer, 06-15-2015, “Cheer up ‘Bifo’—history hasn’t ended yet,” openDemocracy,
Verso’s new Futures series was put together, so states the inside page, to assess the “outer limits of social and political possibility.” So it’s disappointing to find in Franco ‘Bifo’ Berardi’s contribution Heroes: Mass Murder and Suicide, such a lack of the possible. Indeed, the book often seems little more than a lament for the impossible scale of the task facing advocates of progressive politics in an age of neo-liberalism.
From Virginia Tech to Norway’s Anders Breivik, mass shootings are mashed together with collateralised debt obligations and credit default swaps to create an antediluvian collage of the variety used to caricature leftists as disgruntled losers with a dislike of progress.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?
Johnson 03 [David Johnson, 2003, “Why View All Time from the Perspective of Time’s End? A Bergonsonian attack on Bataillean transcience,” Time & Society]
Existential Aspects Life is a serious business of highly charged temporal stakes, involving a being’s struggle to secure for itself the experience of pleasure time/free time rather than pain time/slave time. Since lived time is a living stake, death is not the profound phenomenon that Bataille thinks it is. For one who is racked by drawn-out pain, the pain of death situated at the end of time is an irrelevance. And for one who is caught up in the throes of extended pleasure, the dubious pleasure of death is likewise irrelevant. Death, far from being profound, may simply provide a pragmatic escape from a life of pain and toil, or a simple halt to a life of pleasure and freedom. We can see death as important to time in that it is the end of the great game of time, the great flow. But death is relative in importance to time for the same reason; it is simply the end of the great game of time, a game without which it would be pure abstraction. However, we are not suggesting that death has absolutely no importance for living beings. On the contrary. By countering Bataille’s view of death, which tries to domesticate death through attempting to engage it in ‘intimate’ dialogue, and which tries to make political gain out of death, we can see death as a real, non-negotiable phenomenon. Death can no longer be thought of as an ambiguous but essentially accessible deity, but must instead be seen as that which wipes out real substantial time with no hope of appeal. Death can now be viewed as a certain element in the game of time, as something to be dreaded or desire as the end of time, but which has no fixed moral or political meaning in itself. By affirming the reality of time we are in fact affirming the reality of death, and so we are proposing a more tragic philosophy than the one Bataille proposes – which is ironic, given that Bataille is considered by most postmodernist/post-structuralist philosophers to be perhaps the cruellest thinker.