Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Topicality
Additional Violations › 1NC---Biotech---Industries

The USfg is the three branches.

White House 18, official website of the White House, carbon dated September 17, 2018, “Our Government”, https://www.whitehouse.gov/about-the-white-house/our-government/ \\SYang

The Federal Government is composed of three distinct branches: legislative, executive, and judicial, whose powers are vested by the U.S. Constitution in the Congress, the President, and the Federal courts, respectively.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Additional Violations › 1NC---Biotech---Industries

Interpretation---Biotechnology has to involve industries.

Lilian Nyanjui ND, researcher specializing in microalgae, heavy metals and related pollution, phytoremediation, and water resources engineering, “What is Biotechnology”, https://www.academia.edu/10359485/What_is_Biotechnology \\SYang

The concept of 'biotech' or 'biotechnology' encompasses a wide range of procedures (and history) for modifying living organisms according to human purposes going back to domestication of animals, cultivation of plants, and "improvements" to these through breeding programs that employ artificial selection and hybridization. Modern usage also includes genetic engineering as well as cell and tissue culture technologies. Biotechnology is defined by the American Chemical Society as the application of biological organisms, systems, or processes by various industries to learning about the science of life and the improvement of the value of materials and organisms such as pharmaceuticals, crops, and livestock. In other words, biotechnology can be defined as the mere application of technical advances in life science to develop commercial products. Biotechnology also writes on the pure biological sciences (genetics, microbiology, animal cell culture, molecular biology, biochemistry, embryology, cell biology). And in many instances it is also dependent on knowledge and methods from outside the sphere of biology including:

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: Cognitive Biotech › T-Interps › 1AR---C/I---Biotech = BCIs

More ev.

Allison Henry 22, member of the Vanderbilt Institute for Global Health at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, March 22, “Brain Computer Interfaces: The Future of Healthcare is Now”, \\SYang

At the intersection between neuroscience, medicine, and technology lies arguably one of the most groundbreaking developments of this century: brain computer interfaces, or BCIs. BCIs are systems that bridge the nervous system and modern-day biotechnology to significantly improve the quality of life for users. From cochlear implants and prosthetic limbs to video game systems that are more accessible to those with neurological disabilities, BCIs have been designed for a variety of purposes, both medical and recreational, and consequently are of great interest in biomedical and technological fields of research.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: Cognitive Biotech › T-Interps › 2AC---C/I---Biotech = BCIs

C/I---Biotechnology includes brain-computer interfaces.

Hannah Gallagher 21, Corporate Associate at Winston & Strawn LLP and JD recipient from Washington University, xx/xx/2021, “Regulating the Sixth Sense: The Growing Need for Forward-Looking Data Privacy and Device Security Policy as Illustrated by Brain-Computer Interfaces”, , published in Washington University Journal of Law and Policy \\SYang

BCI is an emerging biotechnology that could allow elective brain augmentation. This is an extreme but logical extension of the existing trend towards invasive consumer technology products. From stationary desktop computers to portable laptops to smart phones which have essentially become fifth limbs for many of today’s consumers121 to the Internet of Things (IoT) devices that are becoming increasingly prevalent in homes (e.g., Alexa, Nest, smart refrigerators, doorbell cameras, etc.), connected devices—and the data that they collect—are becoming integrated into more and more aspects of consumers’ daily lives.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: Cognitive Biotech › T-Interps › 2NC---Biotech---No BCIs

NRC votes neg.

National Research Council 12, operating arm of the United States National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, “Human Performance Modification”, \\SYang

The National Research Council will form an ad hoc committee to focus on developmental capabilities in the general area of human performance modification. The committee will perform an initial review of the literature, select the most promising areas, and identify the lead players (state or non-state) in those areas. Areas of investigation include biotechnology, brain-computer interfaces, cognitive enhancement, electronics, nanotechnology, and neural implants. This does not preclude additional areas uncovered during the course of the study. The committee will exclude conventional pharmaceuticals and exoskeletons per the sponsor’s direction.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: Cognitive Biotech › T-Interps › 2NC---Biotech---No BCIs

The army votes neg.

Lisbeth Perez 21, MeriTalk and MeriTalk State and Local Government Staff Reporter covering the intersection of government and technology, September 9, 2021, “Emerging Tech is Critical to Supporting the Future Soldier, ARL Officials Say”, \\SYang

Tomorrow’s troops will draw on biotechnology and brain-computer interfaces, augmented reality headsets and adaptive camouflage, and other tools barely dreamt of by today’s soldiers. The U.S. Army Research Laboratory (ARL) continues to look broadly across the swath of technologies critical to supporting the Army today and in the future, according to ARL officials on September 8 at a Defense One webinar. 

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: Cognitive Biotech › T-Interps › 1NC---Biotech---No BCIs

Interpretation---BCIs aren’t biotechnology.

Isabella Grandic 19, feminist activist and organizer, January 16, 2019, “Human Intelligence is Worth Imitating”, https://tinyurl.com/383axkj5 \\SYang

But we’ve entered a remarkable time in history. We have technologies like VR AR, brain-computer interfaces, biotechnology and quantum computing set to solve some of the world’s biggest issues. Perhaps the craziest, most innovative technology, modelled based on the neural networks of the human brain, is artificial intelligence. AI is going (notice I didn’t say “might” or “has the potential to”) disrupt every single industry.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2AC › W/M – PGM specific

Prefer it as it is within the context of the topic

Abhijit Singh, 09-21-2016, "Is China Really Building Missiles With Artificial Intelligence?," No Publication,

With rising security challenges in the global commons, there is growing interest in the subject of “intelligent” weapons systems. This is especially so in the maritime realm, where recent studies have shown that precision-guided weaponry and networked systems are likely to play an increasingly important role. Even while accepting autonomous systems as the future of maritime warfare, however, many find the subject of “intelligent weapon systems” to be deeply contentious. A good point of departure for the discussion on autonomous combat systems is a recent report in the Chinese media about the development of a family of cruise missiles with artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities. In August this year, a Chinese daily reported that China’s aerospace industry was developing tactical missiles with inbuilt intelligence that would help seek out targets in combat. The “plug and play” approach, a Chinese aerospace executive pointed out, could potentially enable China’s military commanders to launch missiles tailor made for specific combat conditions. Oddly enough, no clarifications were offered for what “tailor made cruise missiles with high levels of artificial intelligence and automation” really meant. Apart from reiterating China’s global leadership status in the field of artificial intelligence, the Chinese source did not provide any insight into the specific nature of autonomous capability being developed. The issue for many naval commanders is the dichotomy between the theoretical definition of Artificial Intelligence and its popular interpretation. Technically, AI is any onboard intelligence that allows machines in combat to execute regular tasks, allowing humans more time to focus on demanding and complex missions. Modern-day combat requires war-fighters to operate with the active assistance from sensors and systems. In theory, AI provides the technology to augment human analysis and decision-making by capturing knowledge that can be re-applied in critical situations. It purports to change the human role from “in-the-loop” controller to “on-the-loop” thinker who can focus on a more reflective assessment of problems and strategies, guiding rather than being buried in execution detail. [AD OMITTED] In practice, however, Artificial Intelligence is a term used for a combat system that has the ability to take targeting decisions. This is more in the nature of “who to target,” as opposed to “how to target,” which is anyway a task that guided missiles have been performing with some precision. It’s worth emphasizing that maritime forces remain skeptical of autonomous weapon systems with independent targeting capability. In the nautical realm, the launch of a missile on an enemy platform is an act of war. The decision to execute a missile launch is the exclusive preserve of the command team (led by the ship’s captain), which must independently assess the threat and act in pursuit of war objectives. [AD OMITTED] Despite several advancements allowing for a more precise targeting of platforms, the logic of maritime operations hasn’t fundamentally changed. As a result, naval missiles haven’t been invested with any serious intelligence to make command decisions to target enemy units. While their ability to strike targets has been radically enhanced — through the use of superior onboard gyros, computing systems, and track radars — the basic mode of operation of cruise missiles remains the same. To be sure, Artificial Intelligence is considered indispensable in the development of new-age naval weapons, in particular hypersonic missiles. After China’s recent high-speed (over Mach 10), “extreme maneuvers” hypersonic tests, it is amply clear that future combat missions will require a human-machine interface on an unprecedented scale; which is why four other Asian states — Japan, India, South Korea, and Taiwan — have been developing supersonic and hypersonic systems. Each one of them has expressed an aspiration for a sophisticated maritime force, with long range sensors, armor protection, precision weapons, and networking technologies. Yet none has been developing naval missile systems with artificial intelligence.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2AC › W/M – PGM specific

PGMs are now considered AI

Jon Harper, 10-7-2019, “JUST IN: Pentagon Contemplating Role of AI in Missile Defensse,” National Defense, https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2019/10/7/pentagon-contemplating-role-of-ai-in-missile-defense//jc

Artificial intelligence is expected to play a critical role in helping the United States counter emerging missile threats, according to experts. Traditional types of ballistic missiles are being superseded by more advanced systems. They include more maneuverable and precision-guided ballistic missiles, low-flying cruise missiles and hypersonic weapons that can travel at speeds of Mach 5 or faster, Missile Defense Agency Director Vice Adm. Jon Hill noted Oct. 7 during remarks at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C. “The unpredictability … is very challenging,” he said. “It challenges your sensor architecture, it challenges your fire control and it challenges the methods by which you engage. So I do believe that we are at an inflection point in how we're going to defend not only the homeland, but our forward-deployed forces and our friends and allies. And we have to think differently.” AI can help the Defense Department as it tries to tackle the problem, he said.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2AC › C/I – Semi-Autonomous systems

C/I: All AI is semiautonomous

Travis N Rieder et al, 06-xx-2020, "Artificial Intelligence in Service of Human Needs: Pragmatic First Steps Toward an Ethics for Semi-Autonomous Agents," PubMed, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32228385///jc

The ethics of robots and artificial intelligence (AI) typically centers on "giving ethics" to as-yet imaginary AI with human-levels of autonomy in order to protect us from their potentially destructive power. It is often assumed that to do that, we should program AI with the true moral theory (whatever that might be), much as we teach morality to our children. This paper argues that the focus on AI with human-level autonomy is misguided. The robots and AI that we have now and in the near future are "semi-autonomous" in that their ability to make choices and to act is limited across a number of dimensions. Further, it may be morally problematic to create AI with human-level autonomy, even if it becomes possible. As such, any useful approach to AI ethics should begin with a theory of giving ethics to semi-autonomous agents (SAAs). In this paper, we work toward such a theory by evaluating our obligations to and for "natural" SAAs, including nonhuman animals and humans with developing and diminished capacities. Drawing on research in neuroscience, bioethics, and philosophy, we identify the ways in which AI semi-autonomy differs from semi-autonomy in humans and nonhuman animals. We conclude on the basis of these comparisons that when giving ethics to SAAs, we should focus on principles and restrictions that protect human interests, but that we can only permissibly maintain this approach so long as we do not aim at developing technology with human-level autonomy.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2AC › W/M

W/M: Semi-Autonomous systems were discussed in the Twenty-Ninth AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence

Shlomo Zilberstein, 03-04-2019, "Twenty-Ninth AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence," AAAI Publications, https://www.aaai.org/ocs/index.php/AAAI/AAAI15/paper/viewPaper/9920//jc

The vision of populating the world with autonomous systems that reduce human labor and improve safety is gradually becoming a reality. Autonomous systems have changed the way space exploration is conducted and are beginning to transform everyday life with a range of household products. In many areas, however, there are considerable barriers to the deployment of fully autonomous systems. We refer to systems that require some degree of human intervention in order to complete a task as semi-autonomous systems. We examine the broad rationale for semi-autonomy and define basic properties of such systems. Accounting for the human in the loop presents a considerable challenge for current planning techniques. We examine various design choices in the development of semi-autonomous systems and their implications on planning and execution. Finally, we discuss fruitful research directions for advancing the science of semi-autonomy.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2NC---Definitions › 2NC---PGMs

Not only are PGMs not considered AI, BUT AI is also an active problem to PGM resource allocation – prefer our sources from actual Congressional Research

CRS Report, 06-11-2021, "Precision-Guided Munitions: Background and Issues for Congress," Congressional Research Service, https://sgp.fas.org/crs/weapons/R45996.pdf//jc

Emerging factors that may affect PGM programs. Another potential issue for Congress is how DOD’s programs for developing and procuring PGMs might be affected by emerging factors such as

the U.S. withdrawal from the Intermediate Nuclear Force (INF) treaty;96

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 2NC---Definitions › 2NC---Generic

Semi-autonomous weapons are excluded from international community debates about AI

Ingvild Bode, 2-16-2021, "Artificial Intelligence, Weapons Systems and Human Control," E-International Relations, https://www.e-ir.info/2021/02/16/artificial-intelligence-weapons-systems-and-human-control///jc

However, questions about the nature and quality of human control raised by these existing systems are not part of the ongoing discussion on AWS among states at the UN-CCW. In fact, states using automated weapons continue to actively exclude them from the debate by referring to them as ‘semi-autonomous’ or so-called ‘legacy systems.’ This omission prevents the international community from taking a closer look at whether practices of using these systems are fundamentally appropriate.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 1NC---Autonomous

Interpretation: Artificial Intelligence is different from autonomous robotics

Mike Ball, 11-12-2020, “Artificial Intelligence vs Autonomy for Mobile Robotics,” Unmanned Systems Technology,

Autonomy and artificial intelligence (AI) are often used interchangeably in conversation and in the media. These two concepts, however, are quite different in practice. Understanding the difference between AI and autonomy will help your company to make the most practical choices for greater productivity now and in the future. At Inertial Sense, we specialize in integrating AI, machine learning and autonomous systems to create the right solutions for our clients’ autonomous robotic systems needs. Artificial Intelligence vs. Autonomy Artificial intelligence applications and autonomy are both valuable tools in the industrial environment. These technologies can be used independently or can work together to achieve the desired results. Here’s an easy way to breakdown the differences between the two: autonomous robotics = task completion and AI = problem-solving. Autonomous robotics systems are designed for use in predictable environments to complete tasks within a specific, usually pre-planned, environment. Sensors are of critical importance in providing robots with detailed and accurate information about their location within the domain. Autonomous robotics systems rely on these sensors to navigate their environments and to perform their tasks quickly and effectively. Autonomous devices and systems can be powered by conventional software or by AI systems that allow them to learn and adapt as they operate. Artificial intelligence is defined by Yale University as “building systems that can solve complex tasks in ways that would traditionally need human intelligence.” This typically involves machine learning technologies and the use of highly advanced sensors to collect information about the environment and to allow the system to react appropriately to external stimuli.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 1NC---Semi-Autonomous

Violation: PGMs are semi-autonomous

Heather Roff, 1-16-2015, "Autonomous or 'Semi' Autonomous Weapons? A Distinction Without Difference," HuffPost, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/autonomous-or-semi-autono_b_6487268//jc

We have roughly four functions on a weapons system: trigger, targeting, navigation, and mobility. We might think of these functions like a menu that we can order from. Semi-autonomous weapons have at least one, if not three, of these functions. For instance, we might say that the Samsung SGR-1 has an "autonomous" targeting function (through heat and motion detectors), but is incapable of navigation, mobility or triggering, as it is a sentry-bot mounted on a defensive perimeter. Likewise, we would say that precision guided munitions are also semi-autonomous, for they have autonomous mobility, triggering, and in some cases navigation, while the targeting is done through a preselected set of coordinates or through "painting" a target through laser guidance.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › 1NC---Semi-Autonomous

Interpretation: “Artificial Intelligence” is distinct from semiautonomous weapons

CRS Report, 12-01-2020, "Defense Primer: U.S. Policy on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems," Congressional Research Service, https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/IF11150.pdf//jc

Definitions. There is no agreed definition of lethal autonomous weapon systems that is used in international fora. However, Department of Defense Directive (DODD) 3000.09 (the directive), which establishes U.S. policy on autonomy in weapons systems, provides definitions for different categories of autonomous weapon systems for the purposes of the U.S. military. These definitions are principally grounded in the role of the human operator with regard to target selection and engagement decisions, rather than in the technological sophistication of the weapon system. DODD 3000.09 defines LAWS as “weapon system[s] that, once activated, can select and engage targets without further intervention by a human operator.” This concept of autonomy is also known as “human out of the loop” or “full autonomy.” The directive contrasts LAWS with humansupervised, or “human on the loop,” autonomous weapon systems, in which operators have the ability to monitor and halt a weapon’s target engagement. Another category is semi-autonomous, or “human in the loop,” weapon systems that “only engage individual targets or specific target groups that have been selected by a human operator.” Semiautonomous weapons include so-called “fire and forget” weapons, such as certain types of guided missiles, that deliver effects to human-identified targets using autonomous functions. The directive does not cover “autonomous or semiautonomous cyberspace systems for cyberspace operations; unarmed, unmanned platforms; unguided munitions; munitions manually guided by the operator (e.g., laser- or wire-guided munitions); mines; [and] unexploded explosive ordnance,” nor subject them to its guidelines.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 2NC---AI---All of it.---Violation

Their authors are straight-up wrong and paid off---at worst, if they’re right, then search, reasoning, planning, language processing, and more count as AI---that’s a huge limits DA.

Alfonso Reyes 20, CTO at Oil Gains Analytics LLC, December 17, 2020 “Why Machine Learning is not Artificial Intelligence?” https://oilgains.medium.com/why-machine-learning-is-not-artificial-intelligence-61b174a3c9a2 \\SYang

It is simple: because ML is only a contributing branch of AI. If we follow Norvig and Russell book -and other authors-, saying that machine learning is equivalent to artificial intelligence is grossly misleading. ML is a contributing discipline of AI, just like search, reasoning, planning, decision making, natural language processing, vision, and robotics.

For instance, ML by itself cannot be intelligent because lacks reasoning, planning, logic, and doesn’t interact with the environment. ML detects patterns and performs predictions based on statistical analysis of data using math based algorithms. These algorithms are not intelligent per se.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---AI---All of it.

Violation---Machine learning is a tool used by AI---at worst it’s not AI at all, and at best it’s effects T because AI uses ML---effects T is a voter because it allows arbitrary, contrived aff advantages, makes neg prep impossible by spiking out of core links, and mixes burdens.

Wayne Thompson, Hui Li and Alison Bolen 22, Chief Data Scientist at SAS and a globally renowned presenter, teacher, practitioner and innovator in the fields of data mining and machine learning; Senior Staff Scientist at SAS; editor at SAS; xx/xx/2022, “Artificial intelligence, machine learning, deep learning and beyond”, https://www.sas.com/en_us/insights/articles/big-data/artificial-intelligence-machine-learning-deep-learning-and-beyond.html \\SYang

Machine learning automates analytical model building. It uses methods from neural networks, statistics, operations research and physics to find hidden insights in data without being explicitly programmed where to look or what to conclude.

A neural network is a kind of machine learning inspired by the workings of the human brain. It’s a computing system made up of interconnected units (like neurons) that processes information by responding to external inputs, relaying information between each unit. The process requires multiple passes at the data to find connections and derive meaning from undefined data.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---AI---All of it.

“the”

Kentucky Supreme Court 3 (Opinion in Kotila v. Com., 114 SW 3d 226 - Ky: Supreme Court 2003. Google scholar caselaw, date accessed 9/26/21)

Whether a conviction under this statute requires possession of all (as opposed to any) of the chemicals or equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine under some manufacturing process is a matter of statutory construction. First, we examine the language of the statute, itself. United States v. Health Possibilities, P.S.C., 207 F.3d 335, 338-39 (6th Cir.2000) ("The starting point in a statutory interpretation case is the language of the statute itself."). Obviously, the multiple manufacturing methods and the availability of a broad range of readily available chemicals and equipment necessary for each manufacturing process militates against itemizing within the statute all of the possible chemical and equipment combinations by which methamphetamine could be manufactured. Nevertheless, KRS 218A.1432(1)(b) does not read "[p]ossesses chemicals or equipment," or "[p]ossesses some of the chemicals or equipment," or "[p]ossesses any of the chemicals or equipment." It reads "[p]ossesses the chemicals or equipment for the manufacture of methamphetamine." The presence of the article "the" is significant because, grammatically speaking, possession of some but not all of the chemicals or equipment does not satisfy the statutory language. "The" is "[u]sed as a function word before a plural noun denoting a group to indicate reference to the group as a whole." Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2369 (1993).

In decisions spanning three different centuries, the appellate courts of this Commonwealth have found use of the word "the" to have a significant effect upon meaning. See Revenue Cabinet v. Hubbard, Ky., 37 S.W.3d 717, 719-20 (2000) ("[U]se of the definite article `the' indicates that the statute refers to the entire body and not to discrete parts or components ...."); Cardwell v. Haycraft, Ky., 268 S.W.2d 916, 918 (1954) (the trial court's contributory negligence instruction was erroneous in that it contained the definite article "the" before the words "proximate cause" and "such language indicates that `the sole' rather than `a contributing' cause was meant."); Schardein v. Harrison, 230 Ky. 1, 18 S.W.2d 316, 319 (1929) ("[I]f the makers of the Constitution had intended to qualify the word `office' [in Ky. Const. § 161] they would have inserted the definite article `the' before `office.'") (quotation omitted); Sheriff of Fayette v. Buckner, 11 Ky. (1 Litt.) 126, 128 (1822) (holding that legislative act referencing "the clerk of the court" intended a particular clerk of court referenced elsewhere in the legislation). For similar interpretations by other jurisdictions, see, e.g., State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Old Republic Ins. Co., 466 Mich. 142, 644 N.W.2d 715, 718 (2002); Patricca v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment, 527 Pa. 267, 590 A.2d 744, 751 (1991); McClanahan v. Woodward Constr. Co., 77 Wyo. 362, 316 P.2d 337, 341-42 (1957); Williams v. McComb, 38 N.C. (3 Ired. Eq.) 450 (1844) ("[G]rammatically speaking, `The,' is a definite article before nouns, which are specific or understood, and is used to limit or determine their extent."). We are directed by the General Assembly to construe our statutes "according to the common and approved usage of language." KRS 446.080(4). Following that directive, we construe "the chemicals or equipment" to mean all of the chemicals or all of the equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine.

2022 Michigan Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 2NC---AI---Fully Autonomous---Violation

The technology doesn’t even exist yet---no takebacks. [WE READ GREEN]

1AC Wilson 19 – J.R. Wilson has been a full-time freelance writer, focusing primarily on aerospace, defense and high technology, since 1992, when he finished a four-year assignment as North American Group Editor for the UK-based Jane’s Information Group. A 1971 graduate of the University of Missouri School of Journalism, he spent eight years with United Press International before joining McDonnell Douglas Astronautics Co. as head of public relations for the space sector. ("Unmanned submarines seen as key to dominating the world’s oceans," Military Aerospace, 10-15-2019, https://www.militaryaerospace.com/unmanned/article/14068665/unmanned-underwater-vehicles-uuv-artificial-intelligence, Accessed 7-1-2022, LASA-SC)

The Spanish and British empires dominated the world in large part by dominating the oceans. Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan were major sea powers during World War II by adding submarines to their surface fleets.

That combination remains the key to sea power today, dominated by the U.S. Navy, with 68 nuclear-powered submarines, 11 aircraft carriers, and more than 450 other ships like destroyers, cruisers, and support ships.