2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 2NC---AI---Fully Autonomous---Violation
, , and 20, Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Manchester; Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Manchester; Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Manchester, October 30, 2020, “Localisation of Unmanned Underwater Vehicles (UUVs) in Complex and Confined Environments: A Review”, \\SYang
UUV operation is not a binary choice between fully manual or fully autonomous, rather there are different levels of autonomy (LoA) []. For this work, we will adopt and adapt the six levels of autonomy proposed for surgical robots in [].
0. No Autonomy—the UUV is entirely tele-operated by a human.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 2NC---AI---Fully Autonomous---Violation
British Aerosystem Services 21, British multinational arms, security, and aerospace company based in London, England and the largest defence contractor in Europe, Carbon dated April 15, 2021, “What are Autnomous UUVs?”, https://www.baesystems.com/en-us/definition/what-are-autonomous-uuvs \\SYang
Designed to operate below the water’s surface in both littoral (coastal) areas and the open sea, Autonomous UUVs have no crew aboard and are capable of carrying out missions using a mix of reconfigurable pre-programmed instructions, sensor-responsive directives, and, when near the surface, GPS navigation. They are similar to Remotely-Operated Underwater Vehicles (ROVs), but ROVs are piloted by a human on another nearby water craft via a tether, while Autonomous UUVs operate independent of a human pilot, so there is no tether. These unmanned submersibles simply perform their assigned mission, then return to pre-programmed coordinates with no human intervention.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---AI---Fully Autonomous
Dr. Alix Valenti 22, defense and security freelance journalist for Armada International, January 17, 2022, "Dead Reckoning – Pathways to USV/UUV Autonomy", https://www.armadainternational.com/2022/01/dead-reckoning-pathways-to-usv-uuv-autonomy/, Armada International, accessed 7-11-2022 \\SYang
‘Autonomous’, ‘unmanned’, ‘uncrewed’, ‘lean manning’… over the past few years, the defence world has seen a proliferation of terms emerge to refer to the progressive removal of humans from naval vessels. And, as is usually the case with most buzzwords entering a new domain, most of these terms have been used interchangeably to underpin the evolution of Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) and Unmanned Underwater Vehicles (UUV).
The reality, of course, is far more complex. Behind the concepts of USVs and UUVs lie different levels of autonomy, with different degrees of human involvement for different missions and with each degree of autonomy/human involvement comes a range of operational opportunities and technological challenges.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---AI---Fully Autonomous
Ware ’19 [Jacob; September 24; holds a master’s in security studies from Georgetown University and an MA (Hons) in international relations and modern history from the University of St Andrews; War on the Rocks, “Terrorist Groups, Artificial Intelligence, and Killer Drones,” https://warontherocks.com/2019/09/terrorist-groups-artificial-intelligence-and-killer-drones/]
In 2016, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) carried out its first successful drone attack in combat, killing two Peshmerga warriors in northern Iraq. The attack continued the group’s record of employing increasingly sophisticated technologies against its enemies, a trend mimicked by other nonstate armed groups around the world. The following year, the group announced the formation of the “Unmanned Aircraft of the Mujahedeen,” a division dedicated to the development and use of drones, and a more formal step toward the long-term weaponization of drone technology.
Terrorist groups are increasingly using 21st-century technologies, including drones and elementary artificial intelligence (AI), in attacks. As it continues to be weaponized, AI could prove a formidable threat, allowing adversaries — including nonstate actors — to automate killing on a massive scale. The combination of drone expertise and more sophisticated AI could allow terrorist groups to acquire or develop lethal autonomous weapons, or “killer robots,” which would dramatically increase their capacity to create incidents of mass destruction in Western cities. As it expands its artificial intelligence capabilities, the U.S. government should also strengthen its anti-AI capacity, paying particular attention to nonstate actors and the enduring threats they pose. For the purposes of this article, I define artificial intelligence as technology capable of “mimicking human brain patterns,” including by learning and making decisions.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---SC---Must be DSCA
Jonathan B. Holloway 22, Commander, Naval Meteorology and Oceanography Command (CNMOC), “Naval Oceanography is DOD’s Leading UUV Authority”, \\SYang
STENNIS SPACE CENTER, Miss. —— Underwater warfare, as a physical-battlespace, has grown in parallel to current technological innovation, expanding use of unmanned underwater vehicles (UUV), and the U.S. Naval Meteorology and Oceanography Command (Naval Oceanography) has prepared—over the last 150 years—to be the nation’s leading authority for all things UUV.
Naval Oceanography uses an assortment of UUVs to collect environmental-battlespace data which create real-time, predictive models for operational purposes to the U.S. Navy’s Fleet—where each UUV is utilized based on its unique capability.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---SC---Must be DSCA
Hooper ’19 [Lt. General Charles and Michael O’Hanlon; June 4; Director of the Defense Security Cooperation Agency; Senior Fellow and Director of Research, Foreign Policy, Brookings; “How Security Cooperation Advances U.S. Interests,” Brookings Institute Foreign Policy Studies Program event]
The Defense Security Cooperation Agency is mandated by Congress to execute all security cooperation, some on behalf of the State Department, much on behalf of the Department of Defense, writ large and worldwide. It is most known for being the executive agent for foreign military sales, and that's what most people know about us. But we're also responsible for excess defense articles. We are the executive agent for all five Department of Defense regional centers, so the Marshall Center in Germany; the Inouye Center, Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies, in Hawaii.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › T-Interps › 1NC---SC---Must be DOD
Quinn ’19 [Major Jason A. Quinn; 2019; Judge Advocate in the United States Army; the Military Law Review, “Other Security Forces Too: Traditional Combatant Commander Activities Between U.S. Special Operations Forces and Foreign Non-Military Forces,” vol. 227]
Under this definition, “security sector assistance” includes the relevant policies, programs, or activities of any executive agency. Complicating matters, though, Congress has considered a proposed definition for “security sector assistance” that, in contrast to the presidential policy definition,130 encompasses DoS programs, but not DoD or other executive agency programs.131 In addition, Congress has defined “security cooperation” as DoD specific,132 but it has not defined “security assistance.”
The DoD adheres to the presidential policy definition and further defines “security cooperation” as all its relationship building and foreign partner development activities, including “security assistance,” which the DoD defines as a subset of security cooperation that is funded and authorized by the DoS and administered by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency.133 The DoS, on the other hand, uses the term “security assistance” in a manner that contradicts the DoD's definition, employing it to describe any DoS or DoD assistance to foreign military or other security forces.134
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › Indicts › AT: Pfau
2AC Pfau ‘21
(Lieutenant Andrew Pfau, USN, is a submariner serving as an instructor at the U.S. Naval Academy. He is a graduate of the Naval Postgraduate School and a recipient of the Rear Admiral Grace Murray Hopper Computer Science Award, “A ROADMAP TO SUCCESSFUL SONAR AI,” pg online @ https://cimsec.org/tag/asw/ //um-ef)
Dataset Curation
2022
Michigan
Topicality
T: AI Submarines › Indicts › AT: Groen
2AC Groen ‘20
(Michael S. Groen, Director, Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, “Joint Artificial Intelligence Center Director Briefs Reporters on Efforts to Scale AI,” pg online @ https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/2427955/joint-artificial-intelligence-center-director-briefs-reporters-on-efforts-to-sc/ //um-ef)
<<<GRAY HIGHLIGHTING FOR REFERENCE>>>>
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 2AC---C/I › 2AC---C/I: “part of”
Cambridge Dictionary, No Date, "area," Cambridge Dictionary, https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/area//jc
a subject or activity, or a part of it: Principal growth in the past year has been in the area of new technology in manufacturing and medical settings. He looked continually for ways to expand his startup firm's area of expertise
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › We Meet › W/M: Cybersecurity K2 Biotech
Frank Van, 3-23-2021, "How cybersecurity helps biotech companies prepare for successful IPO," No Publication, https://www.ey.com/en_nl/life-sciences/how-cybersecurity-helps-biotech-companies-prepare-for-successful-ipo
Biotech companies should incorporate a solid cybersecurity posture as they progress from entrepreneurial start-up towards public listing. In brief The ‘bad guys’ are always looking for their next target. Companies preparing to list create a lot of buzz, and draw the attention of these bad guys. Cybersecurity has become a business imperative. As every biotech company is unique, a cybersecurity program needs to be customized to their specific risks. By understanding their cybersecurity posture, biotech companies can make better decisions towards a more secure future. Publicly listed biotechs: attractive targets for cyber criminals One thing cyber criminals, hacktivists, nation states and other malicious actors have in common is that they generally do their homework, looking for the next opportunity and target. Biotech entrepreneurs that are leading their companies towards successful initial public offerings (IPOs), draw attention to themselves through media announcements and investment community buzz. Consequently, as also shown in the visual below, these companies are commonly targeted for their intellectual property, financial information and other sensitive assets, their “crown jewels.” Today, cybersecurity is no longer just a technology or risk issue. It has become a strategic business imperative. A cyber breach or data leak would be detrimental right before an IPO – a critical time when the integrity of your company and your brand needs to be perceived as positively as possible. [AD OMITTED] Defining the right cybersecurity approach The right cybersecurity program helps defend a company by defining and developing controls that enable stable growth, safeguard critical assets, reduce the likelihood of a breach, or to help recover quickly should there be an incident. It’s best to develop a cybersecurity strategy and program that suits a specific company’s needs and environment, with best practices and recommendations that are essential for pre-IPO companies. By taking a proactive approach to managing cybersecurity risk, you’ll send a positive message to existing and future investors, board members and other key stakeholders: not only do you care about innovation and generating value but you care enough to protect it.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › We Meet › W/M: AI K2 Cybersecurity
Gaurav Belani, No Date, "Artificial Intelligence in Cybersecurity," No Publication, https://www.computer.org/publications/tech-news/trends/the-use-of-artificial-intelligence-in-cybersecurity
The cyberattack surface in modern enterprise artificial intelligence graphics Source environments is massive, and it’s continuing to grow rapidly. This means that analyzing and improving an organization’s cybersecurity posture needs more than mere human intervention. AI and machine learning are now becoming essential to information security, as these technologies are capable of swiftly analyzing millions of data sets and tracking down a wide variety of cyber threats — from malware menaces to shady behavior that might result in a phishing attack. These technologies continually learn and improve, drawing data from past experiences and present to pinpoint new varieties of attacks that can occur today or tomorrow. In this post, we’ll review the use of AI in cybersecurity (both good and bad), along with what the experts and executives have to say about this matter.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › We Meet › W/M: AI K2 Biotech
Catherine Shaffer, 4-1-2020, "Artificial Intelligence Is Helping Biotech Get Real," GEN - Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology News, https://www.genengnews.com/insights/trends-for-2020/artificial-intelligence-is-helping-biotech-get-real/
Artificial intelligence (AI) may sound futuristic, but it already exists in many everyday technologies. For example, it gives our handheld devices voice and facial recognition capabilities. AI is also making its presence felt in biotechnology, where it has become integral to many aspects of drug discovery and development. AI applications in biotech include drug target identification, drug screening, image screening, and predictive modeling. AI is also being used to comb through the scientific literature and manage clinical trial data. By leveraging machine learning, AI can manage disparate clinical trial datasets, enable virtual screening, and analyze vast amounts of data. Besides reducing clinical trial costs, AI can gain otherwise unobtainable insights and feed them back into the drug development process. AI technologies to serve the biotech industry are being developed by several companies. Their services are rapidly becoming indispensable as older methods like classical statistical analysis or manual image scanning reach their practical limits.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 2NC › Other Cards
Oxoden 1866 (Ashton, Reverend and Honorary Canon of Canterbury, “Our Church and Her Services”, p. 67, Google Books) //jc
Thirdly, that His will may be done by us here on earth, as it is done by saints and angels in the world above. We say "in earth," and not on earth; for the word in means throughout—that is to say, in every part of the earth.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 2NC › 2NC---AT: “One or More”
English Language & Usage Stack Exchange, 12-1-2016, "Which is correct: "one or more is" or "one or more are"?," https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/13284/which-is-correct-one-or-more-is-or-one-or-more-are//jc
The Cambridge Guide to English Usage says: For most writers the choice depends on whether you’re thinking of a single case or general principle. Usage commentators in the UK and the US have been inclined to say it should be plural; and the Harper–Heritage usage panel voted heavily in its favor (78%). Yet Webster’s English Usage (1989) found ample American evidence for the singular construction, and it’s just as common as the plural in British data from the BNC. Writers using the singular take their cue from one, whereas the plural-users are responding to those [people] or the [things]. (BNC stands for British National Corpus. It is a computer database of 100 million words.)
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 2NC › 2NC---AT: “One or More”
Allen 93 (Robert, Editor and Director – The Chambers Dictionary, Does Grammar Matter?)
Grammar matters, then, because it is the accepted way of using language, whatever one’s exact interpretation of the term. Incorrect grammar hampers communication, which is the whole purpose of language. The grammar of standard English matters because it is a codification of the way using English that most people will find acceptable.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 2NC › 2NC---AT: “One or More”
Martin Lassen, No Date, ""One Or More Is" or "One Or More Are": Which Is Correct?," Grammarhow, https://grammarhow.com/one-or-more-is-or-one-or-more-are///jc
“One or more” is used to talk about something that is either equal to one or any number greater than that. It’s always used in a context that means more than one but without any real indication of whether one might be the correct number. Generally, if you say “one or more,” it means you’re unsure what the number you’re talking about is exactly. It can refer to “one,” but you’re usually confident that it should refer to a few more as well.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
In the Area › 1NC
Law Insider, No Date, "In the area Definition," Law Insider, https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/in-the-area//jc
In the area means all of the activities. Examples of In the area in a sentence In the area of sustainability, Raiffeisen KAG also attends so-called “stakeholder forums” which provide an excellent platform for a dialogue with stakeholders such as suppliers, clients, employees, representatives of authorities and other investors. In the area of business dialogues, Raiffeisen KAG distinguishes between pro-active and reactive engagement. In the area between roadways of a divided highway, including crossovers.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---C/I---“is”
Not sure why I put this card in here at all.
Writing Explained 22, some website that teaches grammar, "Is vs. Are – What’s the Difference?", https://writingexplained.org/is-vs-are-difference, accessed 7-7-2022 \\SYang
What does is mean? Is is a form of the verb to be, which indicates a state of existence or functions as an auxiliary verb. Is is the third-person singular present tense of to be.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---AT: Member States Only---NATO Card
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization 22, a military collective defense alliance including 30 European and North American countries that might come up in the 2022-2023 high school policy debate topic, accessed July 7, 2022, “What is NATO?”, https://www.NATO.int/NATO-welcome/, official NATO website \\SYang
The most important players in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization are the member countries themselves.