Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – Sanctions Thumper

Greece struck down Russians ships in support of EU sanctions

RFERL 4-19 (Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) is a United States government funded organization that broadcasts and reports news, information, and analysis to countries in Eastern Europe, Central Asia, Caucasus, and the Middle East where it says that "the free flow of information is either banned by government authorities or not fully developed", 4-19-22, “Greece Seizes Russian Tanker As Part Of EU Sanctions Over Ukraine”, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, SC)

Greek authorities say they have seized a Russian oil tanker in the Aegean Sea as part of European Union sanctions imposed against Russia for its unprovoked invasion of Ukraine. The Russian-flagged Pegas, with 19 Russian crew members on board, was seized on April 19 near the coastal city of Karystos on the southern coast of the island of Evia. "It has been seized as part of EU sanctions," a shipping ministry official said. The coast guard said the seizure order concerned the ship itself and not its cargo. The vessel had experienced mechanical issues and was being escorted by a tug to the Peloponnese so that its cargo could be transferred to another ship. However, rough seas forced it to Karystos. The European Union, of which Greece is a member, has adopted a wide range of sanctions against Moscow over its unprovoked invasion of Ukraine, designed to cripple the Russian economy and pressure President Vladimir Putin into ending the war against Ukraine. The sanctions include import and export bans for a wide array of goods and a ban on access to EU ports by Russian-flagged ships.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – UQ

Relations are dead

Tasos Kokkinidis ‘22, author at Greek Reporter, “What Has Russia Ever Done For Greece?”, GreekReporter.com, 4/28/22, https://greekreporter.com/2022/04/28/what-russia-ever-done-greece/

Recently, Russia’s Foreign Ministry warned Greece that relations between the two nations that “share the same faith” have been “reduced to almost nothing.” Maria Zakharova, director of the Information and Press Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation, warned in a statement released on social media that the “historical parallels” between Greece and Russia were in danger of becoming “a solid double line between us.” Greece has joined its EU and NATO allies in condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine and has sent military and humanitarian aid to Kyiv. Relations reached a nadir when Greece expelled 12 Russian diplomats in early April. However, recent opinion polls show that more than one out of two Greeks do not support the government’s policies. While refugees from Ukraine are welcomed with open arms in Greece, many Greeks reject the EU measures against Russia. According to one survey, more than 60 percent are decidedly opposed to arms shipments; they see culpability for the war in both Moscow and Kyiv. Greece is also concerned about the close ties between Turkey and Russia. Moscow has been providing Ankara with weapons, including the controversial S400 missile system and has been financing a nuclear power plant built in Turkey.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – UQ

Hostile statements have been exchanged – relations are low

Keep Greece Talking KGT ’22, Greek News in English, “Russian statements against Greece are “unacceptable”, says Foreign Ministry”, Keep Greece Talking, 3/7/22, https://www.keeptalkinggreece.com/2022/03/07/greece-russia-foreign-ministry-unacceptable-statements/

The statement by the spokeswoman of the Russian Foreign Ministry are “unacceptable” the Foreign Ministry in Athens said late on Sunday. Greece ’s Foreign Ministry responded to the unprecedented statement by Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova who lashed out against the country for its stance on the war in Ukraine. Zakharova went to far to accuse the Greek government of “hypocrisy.” – Statement is here. “Greek foreign policy is a principled policy and has always been based on complete respect for international law,” Zakharova’s counterpart in the Greek Foreign Ministry, Alexandros Papaioannou said late on Sunday. “Greece contributes to, and is bound by, the decisions of international organizations it takes part in, such as, among others, the European Union and NATO,” he added. “A main concern of our country’s is to promote truth, on the basis of confirmed and irrefutable facts. Every effort to promote fake news and disinformation, aiming to mislead public opinion, is to be condemned, wherever it comes from. The recent statements by the spokeswoman for the Russian Federation’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as well as the (social media) posts of the Russian Embassy in Athens are, unfortunately, unacceptable. They do not comport with diplomatic practice, or the historical bonds connecting the Greek and Russian people. Greece would like to see historical relations maintained and Russian behavior reflecting this,” the spokesman’s statement concluded.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – UQ

Greece-Russia relations are at an all-time low–Ukraine proves

Kokkinidis 4-23 (Tasos Kokkinidis is a Greek Reporter journalist, 4-23-22, “Russia Warns Greece of Complete Breakdown in Relations”, Greek Reporter, SC)

On Friday, Russia’s Foreign Ministry warned Greece that relations between the two nations that “share the same faith” have been “reduced to almost nothing.” Maria Zakharova, director of the Information and Press Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation, warned in a statement released on social media that the “historical parallels” between Greece and Russia were in danger of becoming “a solid double line between us.” The Russian official focused on Greece’s decision to declare 12 Russian officials “personae non-gratae,” on April 6 joining other European states that had taken similar steps in response to accusations of atrocities committed by Russian forces against civilians in Ukraine. The Foreign Ministry said the decision was made in line with the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations of 1961 and the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations of 1963. Russia’s embassy in Athens condemned Greece’s decision and warned of consequences. “We have strongly protested against this unjustified and hostile step which aims to further destroy our bilateral relations,” the Russian embassy announced in a statement. “We made clear that this action will not remain without consequences,” it further said. Grecian Delight supports Greece Breakdown of Greece, Russia relations despite historic ties In her social media post, Zakharova lamented the breakdown of relations between Russia and Greece and delved into the historic ties between the two countries. “There was a time when Russia helped Greece achieve independence and restore its statehood, and its first head was previously Russia’s foreign minister, but now this country’s diplomatic relations with Russia have been reduced to almost nothing,” Zakharova warned. She added that “this happened despite the fact that we share the same faith with the Greeks, the same traditions, and were always there to help our Greek friends.” “This is not so much an issue of Euro-Atlantic solidarity erasing the past, since it is a sovereign choice for every nation to decide whom to honor. Even worse, this deprives people and nations of their future, independence and the right to make sovereign choices,” Zakharova concluded. Diplomatic spat between Russia and Greece The Russian official has previously alleged that there is an orchestrated defamation of Russia in Greece following the ongoing war in Ukraine. “Senior officials in Athens find themselves making gross accusations against our country and its leadership,” Zakharova said. She added: “We noticed the unprecedented campaign launched in Greece to defame Russia’s policy. Senior officials in Athens allow themselves to make crude accusations against our country and its leadership [and] they are literally competing with their like-minded people. They hypocritically speak of an ‘unprovoked attack’ against Ukraine, for the first time since World War II, a ‘mass invasion’ and so on.” “Europe, including Greece, is fully integrated into the ranks of the Kiev regime’s advocates, while the anti-Russia hysteria cultivated by the authorities has reached a boiling point,” the Russian foreign ministry official said. Greece responded to the statements saying they are “unacceptable.” The spokesperson for the Foreign Ministry, Alexandros Papaioannou, noted the following: “The recent statements by the spokesperson for the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as well as the posts of the Russian embassy in Athens are, unfortunately, unacceptable.”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – UQ

Greece-Russia relations are low – tit-for-tat diplomat expulsions

Agence France-Presse AFP 6/28/22, is a French private international news agency headquartered in Paris, France, “Russia expels eight Greek diplomats”, Inquirer.net, 6/28/22, https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1617997/russia-expels-eight-greek-diplomats

MOSCOW — Russia said Monday it was expelling eight Greek diplomats over a decision by Athens to deliver military equipment to Ukraine, where Moscow’s troops are fighting. Greece’s ambassador was summoned to the Russian foreign ministry and told the diplomats had eight days to leave the country, said a ministry statement. The decision was “the direct consequence of unfriendly actions taken by the Greek authorities”, said the ministry. The statement referred specifically to the delivery of weapons and military material to Ukraine and the expulsion of Russian diplomats from Greece. The Greek foreign ministry expressed “profound regret” over the move, which it claimed was “baseless”. Athens said the diplomats in question were “distinguished by their professionalism and high sense of responsibility (and) performed their duties in accordance with the provisions of the Vienna conventions on diplomatic and consular relations.” Athens expelled 12 Russian diplomats in April, following Moscow’s military operation in Ukraine, launched in late February. Despite the two countries historical ties, because of their shared Orthodox Christian religious heritage, Athens has joined other Western nations in condemning the Russian military operation. Western countries around the world have expelled several hundred Russian diplomats over the issue, and Russia has replied in kind.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – AT: Shutoff Now

Europe wont completely shut off Russia

Smith 22 (Elliot Smith is a Markets Reporter for CNBC in London. He joined the team in April 2019 after two and a half years with Citywire, where his reporting garnered the 2018 PressGazette British Journalism Award for Specialist Media (Finance), March 11, 2022, “Goldman Sachs predicts what will happen to Europe’s economy if Putin shuts off the gas taps”, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/03/11/goldman-predicts-what-will-happen-to-europes-economy-if-putin-shuts-off-gas.html)

Given Russia’s reliance on exports to Europe and its ever-shrinking sources of revenue elsewhere in light of the suite of international sanctions, BCA Research strategists suggested in a note Wednesday that a complete stoppage was unlikely. “Although Moscow forged a new deal with Beijing last month to supply China’s CNPC with an additional 10 billion cubic meters of gas a year, the new planned pipeline to carry these supplies will take two to three years to complete,” said Mathieu Savary, chief European strategist at BCA Research. “In the meantime, Russia will have to rely on its sales to Europe to fund its military incursion in Ukraine and ensure domestic stability.” Savary suggested, however, that Novak’s threat still highlights the risk of disruption to European energy supplies, which will continue to exert upward pressure on natural gas prices in the near term. “Until the risk premium in oil and natgas prices dissipates, high energy costs will lead to a period of stagflation in the Eurozone,” Savary added. “Investors should maintain a cautious stance towards European risk assets over the near-term.”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – AT: Shutoff Now

Greece is effectively supplying Russian oil despite pressure for European shutoff – they are increasing STS transfers to avoid future sanctions

Tsvetana Paraskova 6/19/22, author for Oilprice.com, “Tanker Companies Race To Ship Russian Oil Ahead Of New Sanctions”, Baystreet.ca, 6/19/22, https://www.baystreet.ca/commodities/5673/Tanker-Companies-Race-To-Ship-Russian-Oil-Ahead-Of-New-Sanctions

Western sanctions have so far failed to crush Russia’s oil exports as Moscow is redirecting crude to its more than willing Asian buyers, China and India. European vessel owners, especially private Greek operators, are moving a lot of the Russian oil in the months before the EU ban on seaborne Russian oil imports kicks in at the end of this year. Greek tanker owners have increased their exposure to Russian oil shipping in the past two months as they race to profit from the higher demand for heavily discounted Russian oil in China and India. Once EU sanctions on seaborne imports of Russian oil take effect this December, Greek tanker operators will have to stop shipping Russian oil. A much bigger blow to Russian oil exports that will have dramatic consequences on the global oil tanker market and oil prices comes from provision number two in the sixth sanctions package - EU operators will be prohibited from insuring and financing the marine transportation of Russian oil to third countries. Until the sanctions enter into force, European, especially Greek, tanker owners are moving a lot of Russian oil to Asia, making a lot of money in the process. Shippers from Greece, China, and Turkey are eagerly taking advantage of the situation, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. By shipping Russian ESPO crude from Kozmino to the Chinese coast, a ship owner can make $1.6 million—three times what they would have made before the war in Ukraine. Earlier this month, Ukraine called out Greece for shipping Russian oil. “We see Greek companies providing almost the largest tanker fleet for the transportation of Russian oil,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said in a speech to a conference in Athens via video link. “Once again: this is happening precisely when another Russian energy resource is being used as a weapon against Europe and against the family budget of every European. I am sure that this does not meet the interests of Europe, Greece, or Ukraine,” Zelensky added. Greek vessel owners made 151 port calls from Baltic and Black Sea Russian ports between May 1 and June 27, up by 41% compared to the same period last year, according to data compiled by Lloyd’s List using Lloyd’s List Intelligence. Almost half of all crude and refined products exported from key Baltic or Black Sea ports were shipped on vessels Greek tanker owners beneficially own, the data showed. TMS Tankers of billionaire George Economou is the biggest Greek player in the Russian market and second overall, second only to Russia-owned Sovcomflot, which is under Western sanctions, according to the data. Greek tankers are also participating in ship-to-ship (STS) transfers offshore Greece, Malta, and south of Gibraltar, Lloyd’s List data showed. It’s difficult to predict what will happen to the global tanker market when the EU sanctions enter into force, but demand for oil remains high, so tankers will be used on other routes, a CEO at a Greek shipping firm told The Wall Street Journal. “They will travel longer distances which means they will make more money,” the executive added. “Dark” STS transfers of Russian crude, alongside shutting off vessel transponders and attempts to disguise the origin of the oil, are set to only increase as the EU sanctions approach, analysts say.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – AT: Sanctions

Greece has become the hotspot for STS transfers because they can evade sanctions – crucial to supply over 1/4 of all European energy

Ryan Hogg ’22, joined Business Insider in March 2022 as a Weekend Business News Fellow on the UK team based in London. He holds a Gold Standard NCTJ qualification, and previously interned with the Financial Times, “Greek shipping companies are profiting by masking the transport of Russian oil, report says”, Business Insider, 6/5/22, https://www.businessinsider.com/greek-shipping-companies-profit-from-transporting-russian-oil-report-2022-6

Greek shipping companies are engaging in "ship-to-ship" switches to disguise the transport of Russian oil, according to data reviewed by London's Sunday Times newspaper. The data suggested "ship-to-ship" transfers in the Russian port of Kavkaz, where a Russian ship will unload oil from its vessel onto another vessel coming from a neutral company, has been on the increase since Russia invaded Ukraine in February. Findings by the newspaper also showed Greek ports had become a hotspot, with transfers in the port of Kalamata rising by 20% in a month. The Sunday Times cited one example of a Russian-flagged ship, the Vladimir Monomakh, entering the port of Kavkaz on March 1, before transferring its oil to the 25,000 tonne Greek-owned, Maltese-flagged Minerva Emily, thereby masking the oil's origins. The report said Andreas Martinos, the owner of Minerva Marine, was making large profits by transferring Russian oil in this way. There was no evidence of sanctions being breached and Minerva was not attempting to conceal its actions, the Sunday Times said. It also cited data from Lloyd's List showing that ships owned by Greek billionaire George Economou transported 1.9 million tonnes of oil directly from four Russian ports in April. Oil prices following Russia's invasion have hit 14-year highs, fueling Russia's war efforts. Moscow is thought to be making $800 million a day from oil exports as Western countries try to reduce their reliance on Russian energy. This week the European Union reached an agreement to ban Russian oil arriving by sea by the end of this year, but supplies sent through pipelines will be exempt. Russia supplies just over a quarter of the EU's oil.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – AT: Sanctions

Greece has recently started helping Russia with oil exports

Wetzel 5-8 (Daniel Wetzel. Principal Agilist / Agile Coach at Discover Financial Services | CSM, ICP-ACC, ICP-ATF · Daniel Wetzel. Head of Tracking Sustainable Transitions, 5-8-22, “Greece helps Russia circumvent sanctions - Die Welt”, SC)

Russian oil tankers continue to call at European ports unhindered amid EU attempts to limit Russia's ability to export energy. Greece is now helping Russia to circumvent this ban. That’s according to Die Welt, Ukrinform reports. It is noted that Greek shipowners are expanding their business with Russia. In April, Greece’s share in the transportation of Russian oil has tripled against 2021. According to Lloyd's insurance company, a total of 190 tankers departed from Russian ports in April, of which 76 flew the Greek flag. In late April, the Greek-flagged supertanker Nissos Rhenia loaded Russian oil at a port in the Netherlands and headed for Singapore. The number of shipments to India, China, and South Korea has also increased. According to the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), Russia exports 7 million barrels of oil and petroleum products daily. It should be recalled that earlier Dutch dockers refused to unload the Sunny Liger tanker carrying Russian diesel fuel, as European nations are close to approving an embargo on Russian petroleum products.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Brink

European sanctions are already tanking EU economies–it will only get worse

Noack 3-2 (Rick Noack is a Paris-based correspondent covering France for The Washington Post. Previously, he was a foreign affairs reporter for The Post based in Berlin, where he covered international news. He also worked for The Post from Washington as an Arthur F. Burns Fellow and from Britain, Australia and New Zealand. Originally from Germany, he studied at Sciences Po Paris, Johns Hopkins University and King's College London, 3-2-22, “European sanctions on Russia will cost Europe, too, early signs show”, The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/03/02/europe-russia-sanctions-backlash/)

PARIS — One factor has long underpinned pushback by European governments and business over sanctions on Russia: concern for their own pocketbooks. But in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the continent has seen a rapid about-face and has already begun to feel the effects. When Russia annexed the Crimean Peninsula in 2014 and backed separatists in Ukraine’s east, European business groups were among the most vocal skeptics of the E.U. sanctions that followed. Just weeks ago, a major German business association was celebrating a “gratifying” surge in trade with Russia, while Italian CEOs met virtually with Russian President Vladimir Putin to discuss stronger ties even as the crisis was heating up. In a matter of days, the tone has changed. Since the invasion began last week, Russia, facing a flurry of sanctions, has become an economic pariah. Even Putin’s defenders among European businesses, especially in Italy and Germany, have rallied behind what France’s finance minister this week called an “all-out economic and financial war” against Russia, the European Union’s fifth-biggest trading partner. (He later apologized for saying “war.”) “It is beyond any discussion that the German business world supports the imposed sanctions,” read a statement by the chairman of the German Eastern Business Association, a trade group in long-standing favor of robust ties to Russia. The widespread support for sanctions has already begun to come at an economic cost, on top of those borne from the turmoil of war, affecting energy prices, inflation and the cost of raw materials. Experts warn that backlash could follow. Many of the effects, including higher gas, electricity and food prices, have either set in or could hit in the next six weeks, said Andrew Kenningham, chief Europe economist at Capital Economics, a research consultancy. That spans the final stretch of the French presidential election campaign, potentially playing into the hands of the crowded field of populist candidates running against President Emmanuel Macron. In a written address to parliament last Friday, Macron prepared voters for volatile weeks and months ahead. “This major crisis will have consequences on our lives, our economy,” he said. Prime Minister Jean Castex has said the government would intervene to shield companies and citizens “as well as possible.” Sanctions “will have dramatic long-term implications and, relatively soon, very strong price implications, starting first with energy but then trickling down through the entire economy,” said Georg Zachmann, a senior fellow at Bruegel, a Brussels-based think tank. While much of the continent seems willing to bear the price for now, such effects could drive division, especially if Europe targets Russian gas and oil exports, or if Russia decides to withhold supplies. Even in the absence of such moves, the international oil benchmark surged beyond $110 a barrel on Wednesday, as buyers refrained from purchasing Russian crude amid financial uncertainty and the prospect of supply chain disruptions. European natural gas — of which some 40 percent comes from Russia — hit an all-time high this week. “We will need gas, we will need oil. And if that doesn’t keep coming, then political unity in Europe will be difficult to maintain,” Zachmann said. Germany, which imports more than 50 percent of its natural gas from Russia, will be hard-pressed to find alternatives. The country has already suspended the newly built Nord Stream 2 pipeline project, which was built to convey gas from Russia, last month. Some see nuclear energy as a possible lifeboat. The crisis has reawakened one of the country’s most divisive debates — and one that appeared to have been settled, with all remaining nuclear power plants set to be taken off the grid this year. But speaking on Sunday, Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck, whose Green Party is rooted in the country’s anti-nuclear movement, was no longer willing to rule out an extension. “Nothing is a taboo,” he said, also raising the possibility of more reliance on coal. In the aftermath of the invasion, European leaders seemed to set economic concerns aside, agreeing to disconnect seven Russian banks from SWIFT, the world’s most important payment mechanism. European companies and banks with subsidiaries or strong links to Russia, including British multinational oil and gas company BP and French bank Societe Generale, are expected to bear the initial brunt. Countries including Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia, which have significantly reduced their dependency on Russia but remain more exposed than many other European nations, could also be among the first to feel the hit. The E.U. has yet to impose import bans on some of the most lucrative Russian exports — including oil, gas and raw materials. But experts say it will be impossible for the E.U. to fully disentangle desired sanctions targets from broader economic effects that will rebound on Europe. Trade with Russia and Ukraine has already been disrupted enormously. Key Russian banks will be cut off from SWIFT within days, major shipping companies have said they would stop most cargo deliveries to and from Russia, and flight bans are preventing some goods from reaching their destinations. German carmaker Volkswagen said this week that it would suspend production in two electric car plants because of supply chain disruptions linked to the conflict. Meanwhile, a major Russian steel exporter, Severstal, said it was redirecting exports “to alternative world markets” after its main shareholder was sanctioned by the E.U. For European consumers, the most noticeable impact could be surging inflation, which was already up. A potential “2 percent reduction in purchasing power doesn’t sound much, but those households who have lower incomes and high heating and fuel costs will be much worse affected,” Kenningham said. As inflation rises, inequality could deepen — and consumers in countries including Spain and Germany, where governments have largely refrained from freezing gas and electricity prices, could be hit more severely than consumers in France, for example, where policymakers intervened early. A senior French official, speaking on the condition of anonymity to be candid, said the European Commission is already in contact with countries that could “if necessary, divert part of their production to the European Union.” The official cited Qatar and the United States, along with Algeria, Nigeria and other exporters, as possible options. The prospect of energy shortages — and a full halt in Russian deliveries — could overshadow European politics through the rest of the year. In the long-run, the disruptions could be a boost for supporters of renewable energy. But in the short run, the urgent need to find alternatives to Russian oil and gas is likely to have the opposite effect.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Oil Internal Link

Cutting off oil leads to economic decline

Associated Press 22 (May 4, 2022, “EXPLAINER: What's the Impact if Europe Cuts off Russian Oil?”, )

The European Union's executive commission has proposed phasing out imports of Russian oil within six months. It is part of Europe's struggle to stop paying Russia $850 million a day for energy and hit the Kremlin's finances over its invasion of Ukraine. But reversing decades of dependence on Russian oil and natural gas is not a simple matter for the 27-nation bloc. For one thing, Hungary says it won't go along with a boycott, while Slovakia and Czech Republic are seeking a multiyear transition period. All are landlocked and big users of Russian oil. Here is what the oil sanctions could mean for people in Europe and the rest of the world: HOW MUCH DOES EUROPE PAY RUSSIA FOR ENERGY? Gas and oil have kept flowing even as governments denounce the war. The EU sends $450 million a day to Russia for oil and $400 million per day for natural gas, according to calculations by analysts at the Bruegel think tank in Brussels. That means energy revenue is bolstering the Kremlin's budget, adding to foreign currency reserves that could help Russia support the ruble and partly make up for Western sanctions that froze much of Russia's foreign currency reserves held outside Russia. HOW MUCH RUSSIAN OIL GOES TO EUROPE? Europe is the biggest purchaser of Russian crude, receiving 138 million tons in 2020 out of Russia's total exports of 260 million tons — or 53%, according to the BP Statistical Review of World Energy. Europe, which imports almost all of its crude, gets a quarter of its needs from Russia. Oil is refined into fuel for heating and driving as well as being a raw material for industry. WHY IS THE FOCUS ON OIL INSTEAD OF NATURAL GAS? It’s harder to find alternative sources of natural gas because it comes mainly by pipeline. It would be easier to find other sources for oil, which mostly moves by tanker and is traded globally. So a natural gas boycott is off the table for now. Heavy gas users like Germany say an immediate cutoff could cost jobs, with industrial associations warning of shutdowns in glass and metals businesses. Cutting off both natural gas and oil would likely cause a recession in Europe, economists say. WHAT COULD HAPPEN WHEN RUSSIAN OIL SUPPLIES STOP? Europe imported 3.8 million barrels a day from Russia before the war. In theory, European customers could replace those barrels from suppliers in the Middle East, whose exports now mostly go to Asia, as well as from the United States, Latin America and Africa. Meanwhile, cheaper Russian oil could take the place of the Middle East shipments to Asia. But it would take time to make that adjustment. New supplies would have to be found elsewhere. Several large refineries in central and Eastern Europe rely on oil from a Soviet-era pipeline and would have to find another way of getting oil to make gasoline and other products. Bruegel analysts say that means European countries should be ready to impose measures to reduce fuel use, such as making public transport free and incentivizing car-sharing. If those measures don't work, tougher ones such as odd-even driving bans based on license plate numbers would be needed. Similar measures were taken during the 1973 OPEC oil embargo, when Germany imposed car-free Sundays. Russia is a major supplier of Europe’s diesel fuel for trucks and farm equipment, meaning its price affects those for a wide range of food and goods. EU governments also are gambling that Russia will not respond by turning off natural gas supplies to Europe. Russia has already cut off Bulgaria and Poland, ostensibly for refusing to pay in rubles. WHAT COULD HAPPEN TO THE GLOBAL OIL MARKET? Chances are that oil prices would go up for everyone because oil is a global commodity. That would mean higher prices at the pump and for home heating, less disposable income for consumers and be a drag on the economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic. Russia would probably produce and export less oil after losing its biggest customer, Europe. That's because all of Russia's exports can't simply be redirected from nearby Europe to far-off Asia due to shipping and logistical constraints. It would mean a major reshuffling of the world's crude oil flows. Buyers in India and China might avoid Russian oil if it means possible sanctions trouble with the West. And Western customers are already shunning Russian oil because they don’t want to be associated with the country or can't find insurers or banks willing to handle dealings with Moscow. On the other hand, some Asian customers might jump at the chance to snap up discounted Russian oil. Especially if the sales are off the books, as appears to be happening in some cases. The OPEC oil cartel led by Saudi Arabia — which sets production levels along with allied non-members like Russia — has made it clear it won’t increase output to make up for any supply loss from Russia due to a boycott. They meet again Thursday. Rystad Energy expects a loss of 1.5 million to 2 million barrels per day and oil reaching $120 to $130 per barrel by year's end. A milder scenario, in which most Russian oil shunned by Europe is snapped up in other energy-hungry countries not taking part in the sanctions, would see a loss of 1 million barrels per day. Oil prices would drop below $100 by June and keep falling to $60 by year's end.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – AT: Link Thumper

Thumpers only put the DA on the brink – relations may have soured in many areas post-Ukraine, BUT they are being maintained now for the purposes of oil exports – the new and unexpected action of the aff throws the whole situation into disarray

Alexi Friedman ’22, author for the Greek Reporter, “Greece Not Safe For Russian Citizens, Putin’s Minister Claims”, Greek Reporter, 6/23/22, https://greekreporter.com/2022/06/23/greece-not-safe-russian-citizens/

Sympathies among many Greeks still lean toward Russia. In a survey released last month, Greeks and Cypriots were the least likely among Europeans to blame Russia exclusively for the war. The Europe-wide poll showed that while 54 percent of EU Nations overall strongly agreed that Russia was primarily responsible for the war, just 27 percent of Greeks polled shared the same feeling. It showed that 24 percent of Greeks mostly agreed while 23 percent mostly disagreed and 22 percent totally disagreed. In Cyprus, 21 percent totally agreed, and 24 percent mostly agreed. Those who mostly disagreed are at 28 percent while those who totally disagreed with the statement comprise 23 percent of the Cypriot votes, according to the tally. The poll was conducted by Eurostat—the statistical body of the EU. In late April, Russia’s Foreign Ministry warned Greece that relations between the two nations that “share the same faith” have been “reduced to almost nothing” after Greece’s decision earlier that month to declare twelve Russian officials “persona non-gratae.” Governments around the world, including Greece, have imposed sweeping sanctions against Russia and its citizens for the invasion. In mid-March, Greece began freezing assets of Russian citizens identified on an international list for sanctions sent to all European Union countries in the wake of the invasion. Late last month, Athens also said it would send its older weapons to Ukraine after Germany said it would send a fleet of cutting edge infantry fighting vehicles to Greece. Greece has not totally cut its ties to Russia. For the month of April, the number of tankers carrying Russian fuel that arrived in Greece reached record-breaking highs, indicating that the country’s waters have become a top destination for transporting Russian fuel. Arrivals of ships carrying fuel from Russia to Greece doubled in April compared to March, according to a Reuters report at the time.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link

Greek-Russian relations are driven by perception of Greece being an active member of NATO – only the action of the plan results in a decrease in Russia’s willingness to pursue the relationship – empirics prove that only security cooperation, not harsh words impact the relationship

Constantinos Filis ’18, is Research Director of the Institute of international Relations in Athens, Greece. He is a specialist in Russian and former-Soviet affairs and a strategic planning expert on Greek foreign policy., “Orthodox myths: Greece’s pragmatic approach towards Russia”, European Council on Foreign Relations, 10/29/18, https://ecfr.eu/article/commentary_orthodox_myths_greeces_pragmatic_approach_towards_russia/

The Greek government has dialled down its rhetoric since the expulsions, releasing official statements in favour of rapprochement. But the Russian leadership now appears to see Athens as a long arm of Washington: at the height of the dispute in July, Russia blamed the United States for the deterioration in Greek-Russian relations. Still, it does not want to break ties completely. With its relations with Turkey becoming more strategic in nature (energy, trade, and revisionism are common denominators), Russia needs to maintain a balance – with both Greece and Cyprus – in securing its enhanced position in the eastern Mediterranean. The mood in Greek-Russian relations has therefore shifted from neutral-positive to neutral-negative, but prime minister, Alexis Tsipras’s visit to Moscow in December is already creating a more positive atmosphere. The recent resignation of the foreign minister, Nikos Kotzias, should also alter things; the July crisis had begun to take on the nature of a campaign between Kotzias and Russia. After the expulsions, Kotzias publicly accused Russia of being Turkey’s ‘comrade-in-arms’ and of betraying the level of Greek-Russian friendship attained over the past 190 years, insinuating that Moscow and Ankara were joining forces against Athens. Despite the obvious limitations in Greek-Russia relations, a further deterioration would serve no purpose, particularly at a time of general fluidity and in the midst of Greece’s attempt to return to normality and attract investment. Athens needs to be careful to avoid finding itself part of opportunistic joint ventures that Russian might perceive as aggressive in nature, be it against Russia itself, or Iran. That said, even in Kotzias’s harshest words he alluded to a supposed closeness between Greece and Russia. Under certain circumstances Athens may still find it difficult to take a firm stance against Moscow, given the latter’s assertiveness and the confrontational trend in Western-Russian relations.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link

Security cooperation with NATO reverses the trend of Greek-Russo relations – empirics prove that Greece will abandon the relationship in favor of liberalizing their economy

Nikolay Gennadievich Kuznetsov ’17, *is a Ph.D., Professor, first Vice-Rector, Rostov State University of Economics, Rostov-on-Don, Russian Federation, **Ivan Ignatievich Savvidy is an expert in strategic and innovative development of a society with limited liability "GROUP AGROKOM", the President of Public organization of the Federal national-cultural autonomy of Greeks of Russia, ***Natalia Dmitrievna Rodionova is an Associate Professor, Department of Economic Theory, Rostov State University of Economics, Rostov-on-Don, Russian Federation, ****Elena Sergeevna Tsepilova is an Associate Professor, Department of Regional Management, IIPAM RANEPA, Moscow, Russian Federation, “Economic Cooperation of Russia and Greece during the Sanction Restrictions period and the Policies to Strengthen the Integration Process”, European Research Studies Volume XX, Issue 1, 2017, https://www.ersj.eu/repec/ers/papers/17_1_p2.pdf

Relations between Russia and Greece have always been friendly and mutually beneficial; this is primarily due to the lack of fundamental differences between the two countries. They were united and are still united by common historical memory and cultural heritage, which stimulates initiatives both from Russian and from Greece. Special role in the Russian-Greek relations have played the development of direct links with the Black Sea regions of Russia –these are the places of residence of representatives of the Greek Diaspora. Greece occupies a special position in Russian foreign policy and according to Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in the world, as he says, "there are few other countries, that are so closely related as Russia and Greece, with such a long history of sincere friendship"6 . In addition Greece is the only NATO country to actively develop military-technical cooperation with Russia. Year 2016 is a cross-year for Russian-Hellenic culture and heritage and as the Prime Minister of Greece A. Tsipras characterized his visit to Russia as "the beginning of a new spring" in relations between Athens and Moscow. In May 2016 a joint declaration for an effective Government Partnership between the two countries was signed. It declares modernization, according to which willingness to contribute to the creation and promotion on the market of modern competitive products and encouraging mutual investments in innovative technologies, the elimination of barriers and constraints to the free and cost-effective sharing of the results with activities, improving the business environment in a fair, prompt and constructive dialogue between the business communities and public authorities of the two countries. Also a memorandum of understanding on inter-regional cooperation between the Russian Ministry of Economic Development and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Greece was adopted. The parties signed a "road map" of RussianGreek relations in the field of agriculture, adopting a tourism program of mutual actions for the next three years, including contributing to the speedy changes from the agreement signed in May 25, 2006 between the Russian Federation and the European Community on the facilitation of visas issuance to the citizens of these countries, promoting the dialogue on establishing visa-free travel for them. In addition, Russia and Greece signed a Memorandum of Understanding and Cooperation in the field of standardization between the Federal Agency for Technical Regulation and Metrology of the Russian Federation and the national infrastructure system in Greece, a memorandum of understanding between the autonomous non-commercial organization "Russian Investment Agency: Invest in Russia" and the Greek organization of investment and foreign trade, as well as a memorandum of understanding between the Ural Federal University and the University of Piraeus. The paper notes readiness to expand trade in goods and services, the importance of development of small and medium-sized businesses for the economies of both countries, cooperation in energy, agriculture and the transport sector including the transit potential of the Greek transport system. The institutional framework for the partnership between the two countries is: Mixed Russian-Greek Commission on Economic, Industrial and Scientific Cooperation (within the framework of working groups on energy, agriculture, scientific and technical cooperation, tourism, and inter-regional cooperation), Mixed RussianGreek intergovernmental commission on military-technical cooperation, the GreekRussian Chamber of Commerce, Russian-Greek Council for cooperation and investment (created with the participation of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Russian businessmen), Russian-Greek Business Council for trade and economic cooperation, the Russian-Greek forums of civil society and more. Russian-Greek cooperation is developing in the framework of the Chambers of Commerce and Industry (CCI): the Union of Greek Chambers of Commerce and Industry, the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Athens, the Piraeus Chamber of Commerce and Industry, the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Thessaloniki and Kozani and the Federation of Greek producers, the Greek Organization of Small and Medium Enterprises, the Center of Inter-Balkan cooperation "HELEKSPO" organization. Cooperation with Greek partners is also carried out within the Euro Chambers and the Business Council of the Black Sea Economic Cooperation (BSEC). In September 2016 the Russian delegation, which includes more than fifty companies from different regions of the country, participated in the largest exhibition in the Mediterranean area, the 81st Thessaloniki International Fair (TIF) in the city of Thessaloniki. At the same time the International Forum "The RussianGreek Business Dialogue" was held. It consisted of Russian-Greek business in a forum in which the development of cooperation in the field of agriculture, the prospects for regional cooperation, cooperation in the sphere of science and education, for the exchange of technology capabilities and more were discussed; in addition the Russian-Greek Forum on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency took place. 2. Theoretical, Informational and Empirical Grounds of the Research The downgrading of the Russian-Greek relations observed since 2009 fits into the general trend of world development: in the context of globalization the mutual trade and investment is highlighted, whereas stability and positive dynamics of bilateral cooperation depends on the availability of sufficient economic basis. In the case of trade relations between Russia and Greece in the period before 2009 the economic potential has not been implemented adequately, even in 2008, which was the peak point of trade cooperation, while trade turnover between Russia and Greece gave way to trade turnover between Russia, Bulgaria and Romania, not to mention investments7 . The causes for the decline of economic relations development will be divided into three groups: In the first group, the national-ethnic causes, which are expressed in the actual disappearance of the Russian lobby in Greece and the Greek lobby in Russia, are included. Currently, you can only talk about individual initiators of the development of Russian-Greek relations among businessmen. Despite the fact that among the major Russian businessmen there are a lot of people of Greek origin, their role in the economic relations between the two countries is insignificant. In addition, they have to withstand the tough competition with pro-Turkish and pro-Serbian lobby in Russia, because of its economic content of Russian-Greek, Russian-Turkish and Russian-Serbian relations which are very close. We have to admit a landslide reduction of contingent media ideas and supporters of maintaining the dialogue between the two countries, its practical implementation in the trade and mutual investment. In the second group, the historical-ideological causes, which consists of a slowdown in the Russian approach to the possibilities of relations with Greece, due to the fact that their current state and prospects are assessed mainly through historical and ideological stereotypes, are included. The current angle approach to Russian-Greek relations should be recognized as outdated, inconsistent with the global trend, the growth and the strengthening of economic integration in international relations. In the third group, the domestic economic and social causes, which are the sharp deterioration of the situation in the Greek economy, the change in its foreign policy priorities, its strengthening policy and its dependence on creditors, are included. The crisis has not forced the Greek leadership to pursue a more diversified foreign policy so far. On the contrary, it has led to greater coherence in economic (including foreign trade) Greece's policies with those of the European Union, and in the field of international security policy - with a common vector of NATO. And these factors are negative from the standpoint of the development of Russian-Greek economic relations, a fact that is necessary to take it into account as long as Greece does not come out the crisis.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – UQ – AT: Diplomat Expulsion

No impact on the relationship – relations have stabilized

Iefimerida 6/29/22, Greek news site, “Greece and Russia expected to normalize diplomatic relations over time, Russian FM spox”, iefimerida, 6/29/22, https://www.iefimerida.gr/english/greece-russia-expected-normalize-diplomatic-relations

Common sense should prevail over time and diplomatic activity between Russia and Greece in Moscow and Athens become normalized, Russian Foreign Affairs Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova noted at a press briefing of Russian and international journalists on Wednesday. Responding to questions, the Russian spokeswoman said the expulsion of 8 Greek diplomats from Moscow "was a necessary response to the unfriendly actions of the Greek side," while she called the deportation of 12 Russian diplomats from Greece "unprecedented." She claimed that the deportation by Greece was based on "the desire, the aim to weaken Russian diplomatic representatives and obstruct their natural operations to greatest degree possible, based on a made-up excuse." Zakharova also complained that "Greece's present government moved to a greater escalation, by developing a loud mass media campaign, publishing private data of these people," an "unethical tactic which we are naturally not going to copy." She stressed that "mutual deportations were not Moscow's choice," and added that despite staff reductions the Russian embassy in Athens and the Russian consulate general in Thessaloniki would continue to operate as per usual.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – UQ

Polls show that Greece sides with Russia even post-Ukraine

ANADOLU AGENCY AA ‘22, is a state-run news agency headquartered in Ankara, Turkey, “Almost half of all Greeks are against EU sanctions on Russia: Poll”, Daily Sabah, 7/7/22, https://www.dailysabah.com/world/europe/almost-half-of-all-greeks-are-against-eu-sanctions-on-russia-poll

A poll has revealed that more than 40% of Greeks disagree with European Union sanctions against Russia, according to a Eurobarometer survey. Results of the online poll published on Thursday showed just over half of respondents – 51% – hold Russia responsible for the crisis, while 45% do not agree with this view. Some 66% of Greeks believe a distinction should be made between the Russian leadership and the Russian people, as opposed to 27% who clubbed the two together. However, the poll found 53% of Greek respondents agreed with the economic sanctions imposed on Russia and wealthy Russian oligarchs. Only 31% of Greeks are satisfied with their government's response to the war in Ukraine, with the figure dropping further down to 29% for the EU's reaction. Some 40% agreed on financing the purchase and supply of military equipment to Ukraine. Almost all Greeks – 95% – were in favor of providing humanitarian support, while 74% backed the idea of financial support for Ukraine. Rising energy bills As Greeks grapple with massive energy bills, 94% agreed that measures should be taken at the European level to limit the impact of rising energy prices on consumers and companies. Another 94% said rising energy costs have significantly impacted their purchasing power. However, regarding Greece's dependency on Russian energy, 70% of respondents said the country should reduce its reliance on Moscow. The poll also found Greeks to be particularly skeptical about sources for information about the war – only 39% trust European authorities, state authorities (39%), journalists (23%), nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) (21%) and social media (35%).

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – UQ

Relations are high now – all the aff’s args are just blips in the road

Florian Schmitz ’22, author for DW.com, “Ukraine-Russia war: Greek government and public don't see eye to eye”, DW.com, 4/26/22, https://www.dw.com/en/ukraine-russia-war-greek-government-and-public-dont-see-eye-to-eye/a-61585099

Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis adheres to the EU's course of supporting Kyiv in the fight against Moscow. Greece has already supplied weapons to Ukraine. But recent opinion polls show that more than one out of two Greeks do not support the government's policies. While refugees from Ukraine are welcomed with open arms in Greece, many Greeks reject the EU measures against Russia. According to one survey, more than 60%t are decidedly opposed to arms shipments — they see culpability for the war in both Moscow and Kyiv. One of the reasons for the ambivalent attitude is that Greek conservatives traditionally see Russia as an ally. In 2019, five years after the annexation of Crimea, Mitsotakis, who was opposition leader at the time, traveled to Moscow. Underlining a "relationship of trust" between his Nea Demokratia party and Putin's United Russia party, he promised Russia would always find Greece to be a "trustworthy dialogue partner." Significance of a shared faith Many Greeks' sympathize with Russia first and foremost because of their shared Orthodox faith, says Athanasios Grammenos. "The Russians for centuries presented themselves as the protectors of Orthodox Christians during the Ottoman Empire." Moscow never actively helped, but the myth of the great savior in the east is strongly anchored in Greek culture, the political scientist at the University of Thessaloniki told DW. Many people with right-wing convictions, also members of the conservative party, still believe that for some magical reason the Russians are going to take Istanbul, formerly the Orthodox stronghold of Constantinople, liberate it and give it to Greece, fulfilling the dream of a new Byzantine Empire, he says. The political scientist argues that Russia is trying to gain influence through the Orthodox faith in other Balkan countries, too, particularly in North Macedonia and Serbia, where people are divided concerning the European Union. That's where Russia is using "the old strategy of the Orthodox Commonwealth." That hasn't been as easy in Greece, Grammenos notes. The Greek Orthodox Church recognized the autocephalous church of Ukraine in 2019, clearly acting against the wishes of Russian Orthodox Church leaders. "In Greece, church is a reflection of society," he says, adding some priests are into strange conspiracy theories, which "has an impact on many believers."

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – UQ

The majority of the Greek government officials are Russophiles – only the action of the plan forces the country’s hand

Riya Baibhawi ’22, author for RepublicWorld.com, “Explainer | Tied To Russia For Centuries, Modern Greece Struggles To Pick 'right Side' In Ukraine War”, RepublicWorld.com, 3/12/22, https://www.republicworld.com/world-news/russia-ukraine-crisis/tied-to-russia-for-centuries-modern-greece-struggles-to-pick-right-side-in-ukraine-war-articleshow.html

While Mitosotakis announced that he was on the right side of history, the choice was not that clear for a majority of his compatriots who still hold Russophile views. Both Greece and Russia have been tied together for decades with the ex-Soviet State protecting the Hellenic Republic from regional rival Turkey. Their history dates back to the 19th century when Russia joined forces with UK and France to aid Greece in the naval battle of Navarino. While the war was far from over, the victory proved to be a cornerstone in Greece’s independence movement. Apart from history, both the countries have an overwhelmingly Orthodox Christian population and unbreakable cultural ties. Another factor is shared mistrust towards the west which multiplied manifold as the Mediterranean country continued sinking in financial debt. Notably, there are Greeks, a small number of them, who believe that Putin is a ‘great leader.’ “Speaking to VOA news Nikos Marantzidis, professor of Balkan, Slavic and Oriental Studies at the University of Macedonia said, “Greek public opinion has a Russophile dimension, friendly feelings linked to history, a common culture based on Orthodoxy and for some, mistrust towards the West."”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – UQ

Greece reveres Putin – pushes the nation’s politics to maintain relations

Diet Simon ’22, is a freelance journalist having spent 50 years contributing to Germany’s Deutsche Welle, “Why Putin has so many fans in Greece”, Neos Kosmos, 4/3/22, https://neoskosmos.com/en/2022/04/03/sport/sport-opinion/why-putin-has-so-many-fans-in-greece/

As far as Putin’s war against Ukraine is concerned, Greece is deeply split. The Russian president has many fans in the country. Part of the reason are historical roots. There’s probably no other EU country where as many people as in Greece revere Vladimir Putin. The war against Ukraine has not damaged the friendship with Russia that many Greeks feel. The affection has religious, historical and ideological roots. “Murderer Putin” was written on placards held up by demonstrators recently in Thessaloniki in northern Greece. But where Putin and his war are concerned Greeks are deeply split. Opinion polls have found 65% of men and women thinking that Greece should stay neutral about the conflict. 39 per cent said Greece should not join the EU’s sanctions against Russia. 67% oppose Greece supporting Ukraine by supplying weapons. More than a third even expressed “understanding” for the Russian invasion. The government of the conservative prime minister, Kyriakos Mitsotakis, supports Ukraine with weapons and humanitarian aid. Mitsotakis declared: “There can be no neutrality. Either one favours peace and international law or one is against.” But when on Thursday President Volodymyr Zelensky addresses the Greek parliament by live video link from Kiev a number of seats will probably remain empty. The Greek communist party KKE has already announced it won’t take part in the session. All but one member of the left wing Mera25 party of the former finance minister Yanis Varoufakis will also stay away. It will be interesting to see whether deputies of the left alliance Syriza of former premier Alexis Tsipras will also boycott. Like the majority of the leading Syriza politicians Tsipras hails from the Stalinist KKE. A few weeks after the Russian annexation of the Crimean the then opposition leader Tsipras went to Moscow in May 2014 where he flagellated the “neo-fascism” in Kiev. A year later as premier Tsipras continued his snuggle-up course with Vladimir Putin. Just hours after being sworn in as premier he received the Russian ambassador Andrey Maslov as the first foreign diplomat. One of the first congratulatory telegrams came from Putin. A little later Panos Kammenos, Tsipras’ coalition partner of the right wing-nationalist Independent Greeks, the new defense minister and also a Putin fan, brought into play the option that Greece should ask Moscow for loans to cut the umbilical cord to the financial support from the EU. When the Greek financial crisis peaked in summer 2015 and Tsipras flirted with withdrawal from the Euro zone. He is said to have asked Putin to help him print new drachma notes. The then French president François Hollande reports in a book Putin had told him this in a telephone conversation. Tsipras denies this episode. Less than three months after being elected the new Greek Prime Minister Tsipras went to Moscow. Putin returned the visit the following year. As part of his official state visit agenda the Kremlin chief made a side trip to the sacred Mount Athos, the monks’ republic in northern Greece. The reason for the pilgrimage was a celebration of the 1,000th year of Russian monks joining the others on the mount. In the perception of many Greeks the common religion is a strong bond between the two countries. The Orthodox Christianisation of Russia started from Byzantium in the 10th century. In both Greece and Russia the Orthodox faith remains a major driver of nationalism. That explains the affinity to Russia of large sections of the Greek right and clergy. But the attraction also has historical roots. Early in the 19th century the Russian czarist empire supported the Greeks in their war of liberation from Ottoman occupation. In 1827, in the sixth year of the Greek uprising, Russian warships, jointly with French and British units, demolished the Turkish fleet in the Battle of Navarino (Navarino Bay (modern Pylos), is on the west coast of the Peloponnese). That was the turning point that secured independence for the Greeks. For that reason Russia already then had many fans among them. From 1827 to 1865 there was even an influential “Russia Party” in Greece, a collection point for conservative-absolutist forces. In 2021 both countries celebrated the “​Year of History of Greece and Russia”, commemorating the 200th year of the Greek revolution. Hence many Greeks still regard Russia as a natural ally of their country, including because of the historical Russian rivalry with Turkey for control of the maritime straits of the Bosphorus and the Dardanelles as well as the spheres of influence in central Asia. Among leftist politicians like the former communist Tsipras an ideological, antifascist elective affinity resonates that links back as far as the era of the Greek civil war from 1946–49. Then the mainly KKE-comprised left popular front fought with support from Albania, Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union for Greece to join the Eastern Bloc. But now the war on Ukraine puts the love for Russia of many Greeks to a severe test, because in the Ukraine there are about 150,000 ethnic Greeks. Most live in Mariupol and Odessa. Many have already been killed in the Russian attacks. Yet a poll found only 26 percent of Greeks willing to actively help Ukraine. 68 percent are dissatisfied with the government’s stance regarding the conflict. That is likely to include many followers of the governing party, Nea Dimokratia (ND). Since 2011 the ND has been in a partnership with Putin’s party United Russia.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Greece-Russia Relations › 1NC – Greece Relations › 1NC – Oil Scenario

Economic decline causes great power war and extinction

Liu 18 (Qian Liu is an economist based in China, November 13, 2018, “From Economic Crisis to World War III”, https://www.neweurope.eu/article/from-economic-crisis-to-world-war-iii/)

The next economic crisis is closer than you think. But what you should really worry about is what comes after: in the current social, political, and technological landscape, a prolonged economic crisis, combined with rising income inequality, could well escalate into a major global military conflict. The 2008-09 global financial crisis almost bankrupted governments and caused systemic collapse. Policymakers managed to pull the global economy back from the brink, using massive monetary stimulus, including quantitative easing and near-zero (or even negative) interest rates. But monetary stimulus is like an adrenaline shot to jump-start an arrested heart; it can revive the patient, but it does nothing to cure the disease. Treating a sick economy requires structural reforms, which can cover everything from financial and labour markets to tax systems, fertility patterns, and education policies. Policymakers have utterly failed to pursue such reforms, despite promising to do so. Instead, they have remained preoccupied with politics. From Italy to Germany, forming and sustaining governments now seems to take more time than actual governing. Greece, for example, has relied on money from international creditors to keep its head (barely) above water, rather than genuinely reforming its pension system or improving its business environment. The lack of structural reform has meant that the unprecedented excess liquidity that central banks injected into their economies was not allocated to its most efficient uses. Instead, it raised global asset prices to levels even higher than those prevailing before 2008. In the United States, housing prices are now 8% higher than they were at the peak of the property bubble in 2006, according to the property website Zillow. The price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio, which measures whether stock-market prices are within a reasonable range, is now higher than it was both in 2008 and at the start of the Great Depression in 1929. As monetary tightening reveals the vulnerabilities in the real economy, the collapse of asset-price bubbles will trigger another economic crisis – one that could be even more severe than the last, because we have built up a tolerance to our strongest macroeconomic medications. A decade of regular adrenaline shots, in the form of ultra-low interest rates and unconventional monetary policies, has severely depleted their power to stabilise and stimulate the economy. If history is any guide, the consequences of this mistake could extend far beyond the economy. According to Harvard’s Benjamin Friedman, prolonged periods of economic distress have been characterised also by public antipathy toward minority groups or foreign countries – attitudes that can help to fuel unrest, terrorism, or even war. For example, during the Great Depression, US President Herbert Hoover signed the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, intended to protect American workers and farmers from foreign competition. In the subsequent five years, global trade shrank by two-thirds. Within a decade, World War II had begun. To be sure, WWII, like World War I, was caused by a multitude of factors; there is no standard path to war. But there is reason to believe that high levels of inequality can play a significant role in stoking conflict. According to research by the economist Thomas Piketty, a spike in income inequality is often followed by a great crisis. Income inequality then declines for a while, before rising again, until a new peak – and a new disaster. Though causality has yet to be proven, given the limited number of data points, this correlation should not be taken lightly, especially with wealth and income inequality at historically high levels. This is all the more worrying in view of the numerous other factors stoking social unrest and diplomatic tension, including technological disruption, a record-breaking migration crisis, anxiety over globalisation, political polarisation, and rising nationalism. All are symptoms of failed policies that could turn out to be trigger points for a future crisis. Voters have good reason to be frustrated, but the emotionally appealing populists to whom they are increasingly giving their support are offering ill-advised solutions that will only make matters worse. For example, despite the world’s unprecedented interconnectedness, multilateralism is increasingly being eschewed, as countries – most notably, Donald J. Trump’s US – pursue unilateral, isolationist policies. Meanwhile, proxy wars are raging in Syria and Yemen. Against this background, we must take seriously the possibility that the next economic crisis could lead to a large-scale military confrontation. By the logic of the political scientist Samuel Huntington, considering such a scenario could help us avoid it because it would force us to take action. In this case, the key will be for policymakers to pursue the structural reforms that they have long promised while replacing finger-pointing and antagonism with a sensible and respectful global dialogue.