A Broader Context for Soft Power Diplomacy (SPD) One of the more common examples used to describe the demonstrable effectiveness of SPD is its application in global communication via broadcasting media. For example, in the aftermath of World Wars II, when the Cold War had just begun between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, Radio Free Europe and Radio Liberty were created by the United States and the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) as conduits to provide more accurate world news to listeners all over the world, particularly to the audience in Eastern Europe, South East Asia, East Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Cultural centers were created all over the world as another conduit to communicate the merits of democracy and a free market society to the common man. A long-term objective was to use these communicated merits to generate admiration and respect for the West. It is interesting to note that SPD tools related to communication were instituted as public diplomacy to alter the behavior of foreign powers by influencing its citizens. The basic asArticles Downloaded by 67.194.0.233 from www.liebertpub.com at 06/24/22. For personal use only. 112 www.absa.org Applied Biosafety Vol. 17, No. 3, 2012 sumption was that if public opinion in a nation or region is molded towards objectives favorable to the West, this would create internal pressure for the hostile foreign government to alter its behavior towards its rivals and ideologies. Many decades of investment in global broadcasting programs during the Cold War yielded desirable results, measured by the fact that more nations in the world have elected governments and open economies, and espouse free trade than ever before. Modern communication technologies—particularly the interactive forms of social networking and the Worldwide Web—have introduced radically new mechanisms to communicate and share information, which are likely to play a major role as soft powers (Nye, 1990). The participation of non-state actors, such as the non-governmental organizations (NGOs), transnational corporations (TNCs), and transnational media corporations (TMCs), has further empowered SPD tools in global communication through social networking media. Tehranian (1997) reported that there are over 30,000 NGOs compared to 200 state actors, but if the number of TNCs and TMCs is taken into account, a significant level of complexity and role-play for SPD in international relations has been added. The scientific community has embraced the latest technological innovations in communications and information sharing with the utmost enthusiasm. This is evidenced by a growing number of online versions of peer-review journals, web sites, and portals exclusively devoted to new biology and life sciences research; here, a vast global network of scientists and technical experts can share information on their current research interests, findings, and guidelines for others to experiment and validate. The open forum used by the scientific community fosters transparency, promotes information-sharing, and propels innovation in research and development. Simultaneously, this environment poses serious security issues on what are generally known as DURC. No regulatory mandates oversee and monitor the vast online media currently used by the scientific community, and it is safe to assume that mandated regulations are less likely to modulate individual scientists regarding ethical questions related to DURC and its potential impact on the research institutional safety and national security. Within this context is where employment of SPD options might prove more effective in modulating behavior through voluntary means. There are good examples, albeit from other industry sectors, where use of SPD options has yielded desirable outcomes. Public diplomacy related to national and international policy on environmental protection and promotion of equity in labor laws and workman compensations has yielded Figure 1 National security policymakers and the scientific community face overlapping bioethical issues during operational planning and implementation of biosecurity and bioterrorism preparedness programs. positive outcomes of global significance. For instance, in global labor governance—in the absence of a formal legal framework—self-regulation, norm setting, and international labor codes provided a policy premise attractively referred to as “voluntaristic initiatives” (Hassel, 2008). Remarkably, the SPD measures to rectify global labor governance did not stem from national governments or from multilateral forums such as the United Nations or the World Trade Organization. Instead, the public diplomacy channeled through mass media and social networking created broader global awareness on issues related to workplace safety and compensation. As a result of increased global public awareness and response by way of consumer boycotts, the private sector adopted more progressive workman compensation programs and invested in improving the quality of workplace conditions, for they could not afford to ignore the collective voice of their consumers (Hassel, 2008). As a result, we now witness a vast number of large, multinational corporations embracing good labor practices and even publicizing these efforts in the marketing of their products. Companies now tout their safe workplace environment, good wages, and best labor practices as part of a corporate culture because it is popular now to be socially responsible. While one could argue that some sectors within the industry have adopted ethical practices because it is the right thing to do, a compelling argument could be made that it makes a better business case offering or a better economic incentive, or arguably that it is a necessity for companies to meet or exceed the ethical demands of consumers and their special interest groups. SPD in this case could be interpreted as the collective voice of consumers that now has a huge influence on the global marketplace and the international economy. A broader global acceptance of an environmentally friendly “green policy” is yet another example where SPD measures have made a significant impact on environmental diplomacy when environmental treaty-making systems were deemed less effective (Susskind, 1994). SPD in environmental diplomacy offered self-enforcing options to nationstates without compromising their sovereignty and promoted better coordination among the various institutions involved. NGOs working on environment and global ecosystem protection promoted SPD tools and measures as part of global agreements aimed at environmental sustainability, greater awareness of pollution, and the need for environmental protection. Progress was made possible in this arena by carefully crafted SPD tools and methodologies that were deployed to influence government policymakers and regulators, private and public sectors, academia, and the international media. Soft Power Diplomacy to Counter Biological Threats It is evident from the preceding section that SPD tools and methodologies have remarkable success in the formulation and implementation of national and international policies related to public health, trade and commerce, and protection of the environment and ecosystem. Human pursuits to understand natural processes through research and discovery are essential aspects of our society, and therefore, SPD tools imparting education and training for aspiring scientists to increase awareness on the dual-use threats and instill code of conduct for responsible behavior may succeed as well. Existing biological threat-related mandates are mostly hard regulations promulgated either at the national level or a binding requirement under the existing international biological arms control regime. However, during the past 2 decades, policymakers, life sciences researchers, and the biotechnology industrial community have evidenced interest in exploring SPD tools and methodologies in what could be the architecture for future biological engagements covering research and development, global health security, and protection against new and emerging diseases and threats of bioterrorism. Unfortunately, progress in bioengagement architecture remains fragmented due to a divergent stakeholder community and an overall lack of understanding of the potentials of misuse of new frontiers in modern biological research and development. Bioethics-based SPD provides the enduring quality of higher-order thinking and enhancement of quality of life through self-imposed behavior modification, which is inherently appealing to the research and policy communities. Understanding the moral dimensions of the emerging health and biological systems, and analyzing them according to the bioethical principles and core value system of the community, will drive decision making at the bottom levels, where the practice of science and medicine occurs. SPD will provide the conceptual framework to evaluate a series of competing options and illuminate the inherent recognition that there is no single moral course of action. Practical application of a bioethics-inspired SPD framework faces fundamental challenges.
First, policy analysts and researchers working on SPD in the international arena often cite the sheer complexity of the legal and technical issues involved in domains such as global nonproliferation treaties, international labor laws, and environmental protections that render hard regulations less effective in the long run (Sisson & Marginson, 2001). This would apply to any treaty-based efforts towards nonproliferation of biological weapons given the sheer size, scope, and complexity of modern biological research and the vast and varied applications in the biotechnology domain. For instance, the 1972 BWC has no provision for enforcement because of the fundamental difficulties with verifiability of treaty compliance. A key problem with the implementation of verification is that the BWC applies not only to sovereign entities but also to private parties as well. Unlike nuclear nonproliferation treaties (and the AntiBallistic Missile Treaty [ABM] which involves sovereign nations’ commitment to reduction and eventual elimination through mutually verifiable and implementable protocols), biological treaty verification covers an extremely vast array of stakeholders involving the private sector, university research laboratories, and contract research facilities in biotechnology R&D and commercial development. A formal inspection regime is bound to be ineffective, and compliance verification is nearly impossible. Second, bioethics-based SPD approaches are likely to be more effective in the globalized biotechnology research and commercial environment, where business-to-business contacts and networked strategic communication have assumed a prominent role in engaging the stakeholder communities. SPD tools and methodologies are better suited to exploit the evolving social networking and other platforms for communication and information-sharing such as professional societies, disease surveillance and reporting networks, data sharing and reporting systems, and collaborative research programs. SPD tools will greatly benefit the global biotechnology research community and the industry that depends on new biologics-based product development and commercialization. Likewise, global informationsharing on disease prevention and health promotion through the 2005 World Health Organization’s International Health Regulations (IHR) (WHO, 2005) brings the global comity of 194 nations as state parties to voluntarily share diseasespecific information through a standard reporting format. The goal to harmonize global rules to categories of infectious disease identification and reporting has inherent appeal as a SPD, where the broader aims are to enhance national, regional, and global public health security. Finally, bioethics-inspired SPD tools offer more flexible approaches to addressing thorny issues, such as conflicts of interest among stakeholders involved in various aspects of public- and private-funded biotechnology ventures, compared to mandated compliance with national regulations or treaty obligatory requirements. This is basically due to the fundamental differences in the enforcement between SPD and mandatory regulations. Whereas, successful implementation of a mandate is primarily via some form of legal sanction or a form of punishment, SPD methodologies carry no such punishments due to noncompliance. Instead, SPD approaches are primarily driven by ethical and moral implications of advances in biomedical sciences and on value judgments pertaining to code of conduct and responsible behavior in the areas of biological research and biotechnology. SPD tools such as peer-review audits, institutional review boards, best business practices, and institution collaboration are premised on professional responsibility and practitioners’ voluntary commitment to adhere to institutional-level oversight and the broader ethical and moral questions related to science, medicine, health, life, and the environment. Education and Training as SPD Training and educational programs in bioethics and biosecurity as part of university curricula towards advanced degrees in modern biology and biomedical sciences would considerably promote aspiring scientists’ awareness of dualuse threats and recognition of biorisks in their own work and in that of others. Unfortunately, in current university curricula for students, few educational modules exist regarding ethics training on biological and biomedical tracks, and even those few programs treat biosecurity and dual-use issues only superficially. A case-study of bioethics training in the United Kingdom reported that biosecurity-related education received scarce attention from educators, and bioethics course modules reviewed during the study did not adequately address biosecurity and dual-use issues (Revill, 2009). To a large measure, training in bioethics would serve as the lynchpin in educational programs, bringing up the moral obligations and expectations of responsible behavior on the part of the scientific community regarding the potential security implications of dual-use research (Kuhlau et al., 2008; Selfelid, 2009). Institutions such as Bradford University (Bradford, England) with leading-edge educational programs in bioethics and biosecurity have focused on educational criteria to identify biorisks and obligatory measures on the part of life scientists to take preventive measures. The SPD-based moral obligations offer training modules to: a) prevent bioterrorism; b) engage in responsible activities; c) recognize negative implications of dualuse research; d) avoid submitting for publication study results posing biosecurity risks; e) participate in educational and training programs promoting biorisk awareness and dual-use risks; f) maintain oversight of dangerous pathogens and toxic substances in the laboratory; and g) develop a protocol to deal with suspicious activities of students and laboratory staff. Training modules addressing these core criteria should be available more broadly, both as part of formal educational programs and on-the-job training programs for staff and laboratory operators. Recognizing the value of dual-use education for scientists, the BTWC Review Conferences have repeatedly identified education, awareness-raising, and ethics training on code of conduct and responsible behavior to prevent potential misuse of biological research (BTWC, 2008). However, no clear guidelines are available to state parties on the nature of educational and training programs, implementation metrics, and performance measures. Given the vast scope and scale of the modern global biological research enterprise, educational programs for national implementation ought to address a much broader range of activities if the goal is to prevent misuse of research and prevent acquisition and use of biological weapons. This is yet another justification to more actively consider SPD-based tools to impart broader awareness through bioethics and biosecurity education and training programs. Moving Toward a Global Bioethics Network The conceptual architecture guiding bioethics-inspired SPD will resonate with a) the medical ethics first written in the 18th century by Thomas Percival, which forms the code of ethics in the practice of clinical medicine and the ethical framework in the 1846 creation of the American Medical Association, and b) the Nuremberg Code for research ethics, established in the aftermath of World War II, on the use of human subjects in experimental research (Mitscherlich & Mielke, 1947). In 1979, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services issued the first historical document on ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects. This was known as “The Belmont Report” and provided a set of bioethics-inspired principles of respect, beneficence, and justice as the foundation for use of human subjects in medical research (DHHS, 1979). Most recently, the 2009 Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues for the first time addressed more broadly the bioethical issues related to advances in biomedical sciences research and biotechnology and explored SPD options to ensure the freedom to pursue scientific research and innovative technology development in a socially and ethically responsible manner (DHHS, 2012). These guidelines offer a conceptually cohesive framework to the more challenging task of crafting SPD approaches taking into account the difficult bioethical issues surrounding the spectacular progress in biomedical and genomic research. It is relevant to note that the conceptual elements of SPD and regulatory mandates and treaty obligations have interdependencies, and the overall effectiveness of the former is linked to the policy-guiding development and implementation of the latter. Figure 2 illustrates the interdependency of SPD with the policy-making and regulatory establishment and implementation process. Mandatory regulations by design require compulsory compliance and stipulate penalties for noncompliance. Hence, success in a large measure depends on faithful compliance by the regulated community, which is where SPD tools and methods come into play. Defined more broadly as a process that effects a change in attitude upon a willing subject without invoking the regulatory mandates, SPD aims to enhance voluntary stakeholder participation towards the broader regulatory objectives set forth under the mandates. Simultaneously, SPD tools and methodologies offer the regulatory community feedback on the mandates to allow further modifications in the regulatory process to improve implementation effectiveness and to better coordinate with the regulated community. Therefore, maintaining internal consistency with mandatory regulation is a crucial aspect in the formulation of SPD strategies. We propose bioethically-inspired SPD tools and methodologies be closely linked to the existing regulatory process to ensure consistency in communication and to assess overall compliance. Key criteria would involve identification and delineation of the essential conceptual elements of SPD architecture. The decision-making process in a clinical or laboratory setting among two or more seemingly conflicting choices often revolves around anticipated positive or negative outcomes at different levels: Articles Figure 2 Bioethical principles guide formulation and interpretation of soft power diplomacy initiatives and its interdependency with hard regulatory mechanisms. Downloaded by 67.194.0.233 from www.liebertpub.com at 06/24/22. For personal use only. 116 www.absa.org Applied Biosafety Vol. 17, No. 3, 2012 a) The first set of decision points revolves around individual needs and interests weighted against those of the community, where choices may present options beneficial to one while placing a serious burden on the other. b) The second set of decision points revolves around short- and long-term benefits, where options offering immediate short-term benefits require careful consideration of long-term impact on human society and the general environment. c) The third and final set of decision points revolves around the balanced consideration of administering justice as opposed to the relevance of mercy to the affected community. For example, the decision to provide licensure for a new category of medical countermeasures may address a serious public health problem but at the same time pose an unquantified measure of risk to population subgroups likely to be exposed to the new medical countermeasures. Bioethics-inspired SPD should recognize the basic dilemma presented in each of these decision points where competing values are at play. Therefore, the need for a SPDguided decision-making process would extend beyond the professional communities and their governing institutions. The bioethics-inspired SPD roadmap would have to engage a broader participation of society-at-large since the overall impact is on the human society as a whole. A global bioethical network of broader stakeholder communities will be actively involved in the formulation of SPD tools and methodologies that go beyond the narrow confines of regulatory mandates. Figure 3 illustrates the functional components of bioethics-inspired SPD tools and methodologies, where considerable emphasis is placed at the individual and institutional level and provides transparency to a wide array of stakeholder communities throughout the network. Nodal elements participating in the network would participate in dialogue and discussions ranging from: a) initiatives to modify behavior at the individual level that results in self-governance; b) balanced consideration on threats to populations versus individuals as in the case of bioterrorism; c) methods to safeguard DURC and intellectual properties produced through research; and d) approaches to improve biosecurity without hindering the advancement of biomedical science research and technology innovations. As illustrated in Figure 3, the proposed SRM tools and methodologies of a global bioethical network are directed primarily at individual scientists and the institutional-level decision makers with a guiding rationale that better outcomes are realizable when implemented proactively as a voluntary initiative to broadly promote education, awareness and active participation: • Peer-review (for both ethics and safety) of research proposals to ensure that proposed research is fully vetted prior to initiation of the project. Articles are already being reviewed by most of the popular publications to ensure that gained knowledge is not publicly available if it should be determined a threat to biosecurity (Johnson, 2012). Articles Figure 3 Soft power diplomacy tools and methodologies constituting the conceptual architecture for a Global Bioethical Network guide national security policymakers and the stakeholders in the scientific community. • Research checklists to aid scientists in determining if their research takes into account all the concerns of biosecurity and also to help ingrain the standards through repetitious use of the tool. • Dual-use plan for publicly funded projects in the future (e.g., animal use plan). Currently, biosafety plans are required when submitting grant proposals, but it should become a standard practice for government-funded research to also require a plan to ensure the protection of dual-use information through a “dual-use plan.” • Clearinghouse for scientists to direct questions and to determine if a piece of information or specific research area is a biosecurity concern. • Advisory boards at the state level similar to the U.S. National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity (DHHS, 2012) with the aim to better utilize local and regional capabilities for oversight and to promote educational awareness. • Research assessment template for individual assessment of potential research. • Global forums and NGOs can serve as venues for best practices and experiences to be shared. We should focus on creating communities at this level and down to the individual. • A list of proposed obligations for life scientists as a set of standard, widely accepted, best practices from peers across the field. • Training on best practices. As illustrated in Figure 3, performance outcome depends on proactive initiatives at the individual level and voluntary participation of institutions in the overall process. Unlike the established regulatory framework that depends solely on enforcement by authorities at the national and international levels, the SPD framework for the bioethical network is proactive, participatory, and fundamentally based on the awareness of the community. National science policymakers have considered policy options and research standards, and best business practices to oversee DURC without compromise on the essential core tenants of the freedom to pursue biological research (Shea, 2007). These efforts are in concert with concurrent initiatives from the scientific community (NRC, 2004). However, the framework outlined in this study formally integrates a systems approach to the evolving consensus in the scientific community towards simultaneous measures that promote self-regulation at the individual level and better biosecurity measures at the institutional level, both supported by increased biodefense-related awareness and educational programs (Dolgister, 2007). The global bioethical network would serve as the SPD architecture to develop in a proactive manner in tandem with major international forums, such as the Intersessional Working Groups of the BWC and the World Health Organization, aimed at broadening the network of communities and providing a forum to develop and test novel SPD tools. These tools are aimed at improved awareness of biological risks and a better understanding of the threats posed by new and emerging infectious diseases. The network would provide a forum for sustained interactions among various participants and a cross-cultural dialogue on the development of national systems for research ethics, education, and outreach. Recommendations National security policymakers examining alternate options to meet the goals of biological threat reduction through treaties and hard regulations ought to place more emphasis on the potential role of SPD tools and methodologies for developing universal norms towards open-source bioethics. Policymakers should note the effective precedence in the contemporary international arena to articulating SPD approaches as alternative options to meet the goals and objectives of the treaty- and legislation-based hard regulations. • Leverage growing awareness: National security policymakers should consider SPD-based policy alternatives to more effectively leverage the growing awareness among scientific researchers towards self-regulation and the promotion of responsible conduct in research. Institutionlevel guidelines on research misconduct, safe handling of sensitive data and materials, and a peer-review process in research publications that takes biosecurity into account are also required. Clearly, regulatory mandates and international treaties are partial solutions to addressing the sensitive and contentious bioethcial challenges associated with biological threat reduction and biosecurity. • Alternative options to empower regulatory mandates: A bioethics-inspired SPD framework has the power to dramatically alter the nature of discussions related to biosecurity in the life sciences research enterprise. In particular, the dynamic of the SPD framework should address the shortcomings in existing regulatory mandates in the biotechnology-driven Bioeconomy, where not much is known of its inherent hazards and potential long-term impact on human society, the general environment, and national/international security. • Engage the global community on the merits of SPD initiatives: Bioethics-inspired SPD is attractive for its enduring quality of high-order thinking that shapes quality-oflife goals. A deliberate process aimed at embracing the moral dimensions of human endeavors, such as in conducting research with troubling ethical dimensions, with the potential to adversely impact health and the general environment, will guide decision making at the operational level. • Integrate bioethics-based SPD as part of education curricula: Given the broad interdisciplinary nature of the SPD tools and methodologies, universities and institutions should develop educational and specialized training programs catering to students pursuing careers in science and technology, law, public policy, and business. These training programs should focus on the nonbinding rules or instruments in the SPD and approaches to integrate these tools within the existing regulatory framework. Biosafety professionals have stressed the value of well structured educational programs on codes of conduct, biosafety, and biosecurity as a prerequisite for graduation in advanced university education and training programs (Johnson, 2006). Bioethics-inspired SPD tools and methodologies could also play a meaningful role in biological arms control and biological threat reduction goals. They could aid in carefully evaluating and deciding among a series of competing options, but with the inherent recognition that there is no single moral course of action. Active participation from the scientific and policy communities is essential to further articulate the influential role of SPD in countering biothreat proliferation and to gain participation of other stakeholders