Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › 2AC --- Thumper – AI Regulation

NATO has been developing AI initiatives for years

Soare 21 [Simona R. Soare was a Senior Associate Analyst at EUISS from 2019 to end May 2021, 6-11-2021, Innovation as Adaptation: NATO and Emerging Technologies, GMFUS, https://www.gmfus.org/news/innovation-adaptation-nato-and-emerging-technologies] Eric

Since 2018 NATO has launched several initiatives to support allies in understanding the impact of EDTs on defense. These include:

the Emerging and Disruptive Technologies Roadmap, first developed by NATO Allied Command Transformation (ACT), and officially endorsed by allies in 2019, which identified seven critical technologies, including AI and machine learning, big data, autonomy, hypersonics, space technologies, quantum computing and biotechnologies;6

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO does EDT Now

Emerging tech/AI focus within NATO is happening now – codifying and enhancing it through the Strategic Concept is necessary to combat rising hybrid threats and build multinational capacity for resilience.

Dolan 6-8 -- (Chris Dolan, 6-8-2022, "NATO’s 2022 Strategic Concept Must Enhance Digital Access and Capacities," Just Security, https://www.justsecurity.org/81839/natos-2022-strategic-concept-must-enhance-digital-access-and-capacities/, accessed 6-20-2022) -- nikki

This month in Madrid, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) will update its Strategic Concept, the principal document that guides the alliance’s political-military strategy and collective defense operations. The war in Ukraine has put resilience in the face of Russian aggression front and center, especially in the cyber and information operation domains. Over the years, NATO has digitized and enhanced its security platforms, emphasizing interoperability of systems among its now 30 current member states. If NATO is to become more resilient against advanced persistent threats, hackers, and the maligned states that sponsor them, then the 2022 Strategic Concept must infuse multinational warfighting and deterrence against hybrid threats with methods that facilitate access to data and information sharing on its platforms and across multiple domains, namely in air, cyber, information, land, maritime, and space operations. The 2022 Strategic Concept The Strategic Concept is among NATO’s most important documents as it informs alliance planning, resource allocation, and programming based on changes in the threat environment. But the document has not been updated since 2010. The 2010 Strategic Concept, entitled “Active engagement, Modern Defense,” contained just one brief sentence about cyber attacks and did not even mention China. It also stated that “Today, the Euro-Atlantic area is at peace,” even though Russia had invaded Georgia two years before and the threat of a return to great power competition loomed. To argue that a lot has happened between 2010 and 2022 would be an understatement. Russia’s annexation of Crimea and intervention in the Donbas in 2014 and the invasion of Ukraine in 2022 shattered any illusions of a lasting peace with Russia. China’s territorial ambitions, economic assertiveness, threats against Taiwan, and military modernization threaten the rules-based order. Emerging technologies – in the form of hypersonic weapons, artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and machine learning – have intensified great power competition. The 2022 Strategic Concept should highlight the essential role of technology in collective defense. To build greater digital capacity while also emphasizing resilience, NATO must adopt a new technological orientation on the military strategic level of command, especially within the Allied Command Transformation (ACT) in Norfolk, Virginia and the Allied Command Operations (ACO) in Mons, Belgium. ACT leverages advanced technologies for security and defense in capabilities, procedures, public-private partnerships, civil-military relations, and at NATO’s Centers of Excellence. Led by the Supreme Allied Commander Europe, ACO is responsible for collective defense through direction, requirements, planning, and execution at the strategic level. However, the Strategic Concept 2022 should focus less on the emergence of new technologies and more on how NATO’s military and civilian personnel use them. ACO and ACT must emphasize greater accessibility to information and data for its multinational warfighters, cyber operators, and civilian professionals. NATO must reach out to experts in the private sector, academia, and non-governmental organizations to harness ways to expand access and emphasize flexibility in multi-domain operations. NATO can do this by providing more grants to private sector partners and establish a new center of excellence on data and information sharing. ACO and ACT should also enable personnel and partners to readily access data and information in DIMEL domains: diplomatic, information/cyber, military, economic, and legal. This would expand the range of measures needed by ACT and ACO to connect and correlate deterrence with evolving hybrid threats. To deter hybrid threats across multiple domains, with enhanced access on different digital platforms, NATO members should develop smarter and lethal capabilities to confront threats from state and non-state actors. This would allow ACT and ACO to prepare for any contingency and respond to adversaries in battlefields and battlespaces. Plug and Play The 2022 Strategic Concept encourages collaboration in the implementation of guidelines and procedures through a “plug-and-play” concept, in which platforms and systems are optimized for readiness and response at lightning speed. Plug-and-play is based on approaches used in commercial software that allow for innovation and easy access to networks and systems through secure platforms. The NATO School Oberammergau should offer platform training and education courses programs in mobile access for ACT and ACO personnel with appropriate security clearances. This would allow them to access the appropriate platform and utilize data and information necessary for their tasks and responsibilities. For example, NATO’s Small Arms and Light Weapons (SALW) and Mine Action (MA) Information Sharing Platform contains rich and publicly available datasets on the roles played by the alliance in mitigating the illicit trade in small arms, tanks, aircraft, and naval vessels. It reports and updates NATO-funded projects to prevent adversaries from acquiring these weapons. However, the SALW-MA platform is outdated and not user friendly, impeding its functionality in practice. Put simply, NATO’s ACT and ACO should focus as much on easing access to information as it does on advanced technologies and conventional weaponry. This would provide NATO with useful tools to access data and intelligence on the strategic, operational, and tactical levels and in land, sea, air, space, and cyber domains using devices and platforms that can seamlessly connect in different locations. But NATO Commands cannot simply expect its existing personnel to adapt. They must be trained and educated on a regular basis to use digital infrastructures in ways that make their jobs easier. On the strategic level, the 2022 Strategic Concept must provide NATO’s political and military leaders with flexibility and resources to discern the diversity of hybrid threats in the environment. NATO’s strategic planners, cyber operators, and warfighters should be trained and educated in relevant digital platforms, access, and sharing data and information in ways that improve collaborative decision-making and collective defense. On the operations level, personnel must be given enough space to share data and intelligence as well as to train tactical level personnel on software that enables them to collect, analyze, process, and disseminate information quickly and easily across multiple domains. Addressing these challenges is difficult for just one nation-state, let alone for all 30 NATO members. Therefore, the 2022 Strategic Concept should emphasize connectivity between member states in multi-domain operations and in collaboration with the private sector and academia. Accessibility to information and data sharing among NATO members should be securitized and harmonized. Essential Role of Artificial Intelligence The challenge for NATO is not necessarily adopting and investing in emerging and disrupting technologies for collective defense. Rather, the question is whether ACT and ACO can enhance accessibility to digital platforms and ease communications between platforms. Here, artificial intelligence (AI) can play a role in overcoming critical obstacles. AI is now occupying a greater space in NATO’s collective defense orientation. The challenge in the 2022 Strategic Concept will be delineating the degree to which AI will enhance the ability of the alliance to analyze information and assess data. Moreover, AI is only as good as the data it relies on. To maintain its technological edge, in 2021 NATO released an Artificial Intelligence Strategy, a good step toward maximizing interoperability of weapons systems, improving infrastructure, and building resilient hybrid defenses. While it emphasizes collaboration with the private sector and academia, the strategy needs further refinement as AI would help NATO’s military and civilian personnel interlink devices on different platforms, perform rigorous data analytics, and quicken response time in response to a conventional or hybrid attack. One innovation is the Defence Innovation Accelerator for the North Atlantic (DIANA). DIANA leverages partnerships among academics, technology companies, start-up firms to address the full spectrum of threats in the security environment. Private sector firms utilizing DIANA can access innovation sites and test centers that focus on artificial intelligence, machine learning, quantum computing, autonomous machines, and biotechnology. In the past, alliance members supported the creation and development of a venture capital Innovation Fund for technology companies and start-ups. The Strategic Concept should support the initiative with sustained public funds in ways that allow for strategic-level planning at ACO and ATO to communicate more effectively at the operational and tactical levels. DIANA and the Innovation Fund are models for the alliance. An existing partnership that is proving effective is NATO’s collaboration with Klarrio, a firm that provides the alliance with innovative real-time data analytics and streaming services to combat disinformation and fake news. Klarrio has partnered with NATO’s Strategic Communications Center (StratCom) to assist the alliance in the information domain by streaming data analysis, processing, and applications analytics to identify and eradicate disinformation for NATO’s strategic-level planners. It supports and updates dashboard services to track suspicious activities in social media platforms, maintains an interactive user interface, generates analytical reports, and uses machine learning to analyze data and information.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO does EDT Now

NATO leading on EDT now --- disproves the link

Wodecki 5/4/22

(Ben, “NATO at risk of losing AI innovation race to Russia, China,” pg online @ //um-ef)

The pair cited AI projects being undertaken by adversaries, including China’s attempts to develop purported mind-controllable drones and AI assistants for fighter pilots. But NATO allies have their own capabilities – including U.S.-developed autonomous tanks and British-made systems that provide ground troops with information on the surrounding terrain. The think tank’s study suggests that at present, NATO is leading the AI race – but risks losing its competitive advantage to peer competitors “competitors if allies fail to leverage the private sector, coordinate implementation and engage with the public.” CEPA suggests that NATO allies should accelerate AI adoption and actively encourage private sector innovation. “Ultimately, we hope that these recommendations enable NATO allies to better innovate, scale, deploy, and integrate AI and autonomy-based technologies to form agile, system-wide solutions. NATO to test quantum and hypersonics NATO has found itself on the ropes of late – it’s had to contend with Russia’s illegal invasion of Ukraine, increasing missile tests from a rambunctious North Korea and the ever-growing technological might of China. Last October, it signaled AI as a potentially game-changing addition to its arsenal, with its members formally adopting an AI strategy to try and maintain a technological edge against its adversaries. That strategy includes plans to spend $1 billion to “futureproof” the security pact. New test centers will open in both Europe and North America that will focus on several technologies, including AI, autonomy, quantum and hypersonics, among others. Separate from its strategy, NATO is also planning on setting up DIANA, or Defense Innovation Accelerator of the North Atlantic, which models itself as a transcontinental version of the U.S.’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA). DIANA will be tasked with managing the NATO Innovation Fund, which will receive $82.6 million a year for 15 years.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- Concept = EDT Now

Strategic Concept will include focus on emerging technology and hybrid/cyber threats regardless of the plan – direct statement from NATO general days ago – proves lack of link uniqueness.

Tucker 6-17 -- (Patrick Tucker, 6-17-2022, "New NATO Strategic Concept Will Broaden Vision of Deterrence," Defense One, https://www.defenseone.com/threats/2022/06/new-nato-strategic-concept-will-broaden-vision-deterrence/368366/, accessed 6-20-2022) -- nikki

The new NATO Strategic Concept set to be unveiled later this month will press alliance members to envision deterrence as a matter not just of tanks and bombs but of supply chain security, cyberattacks, climate change, innovation, and more. “The strategic concept needs to be able to live for the next decade, so it looks far beyond the current crisis in Ukraine. It looks at the implications for our security of…climate change, innovation, the use of…hybrid warfare, cyber war and the role of cyber in our societies. But also resilience. How resilient are our Western societies to these kind of attacks and what do we need to do in order to tackle that?” David van Weel, NATO’s assistant secretary general for emerging security challenges, said on Friday during the Defense One Tech Summit. Much has changed since NATO’s most recent strategic concept document came out in 2010, Van Weel said. Even before Russia launched a brutal war on the alliance’s doorstep, its members had growing concern about China’s rise, its influence over emerging technology, and its outsized share of the world’s electronics supply. The new concept will reflect the fact that future threats to alliance members won’t be purely military. “Supply chain was not an issue 10 years ago. We were still globalizing. We were working on the basis of just-in-time, just-enough logistic routes. And now we've seen with the pandemic, with the economic vision that China tends to use against countries or the fact that a simple container vessel can get stuck in the Suez Canal for two weeks, how fragile we are,” he said. “Safety and security is much more than building a border and having soldiers behind it. It's also about being able to…look after yourself and be independent.” While the strategic concept will bring new emphasis to non-military threats, it won’t short-change military deterrence, a need dramatically demonstrated by the ongoing Russian war on Ukraine. “I don't think it's either/or. We see now in Ukraine that what they need, mostly, now in order to stop the advancements of Russia in the Donbas is heavy artillery. And I think many people would have said two years ago that heavy artillery is probably not something we'll see in a conflict in the near future in Europe,” Van Weel said. “So we shouldn't be quickly drawing conclusions on what means are obsolete, or needed. But I think it is safe to say that in addition to that classical military deterrence and defense, there is an aspect to deterrence and defense that needs to take into account all these other [things] whether they are in energy supplies, supply chains, cyber, or in innovation and technology that can be used against us. “I'm pretty confident that all these aspects will feature prominently in the new strategic concept.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- Concept = EDT Now

Strategic Concept will already include a focus on emerging tech – link is non-unique

Harper 6-1 -- (Jon Harper, 6-1-2022, "Emerging tech to have prominent role in NATO's new strategic concept," FedScoop, https://www.fedscoop.com/emerging-tech-to-have-prominent-role-in-natos-new-strategic-concept%ef%bf%bc/, accessed 6-20-2022) -- nikki

Emerging and disruptive technologies will be a key focus area of NATO’s new Strategic Concept which will be unveiled later this month, the U.S. ambassador to the alliance told reporters Wednesday. The document is expected to be adopted at the upcoming NATO summit in Madrid, marking the first time in more than a decade that the transatlantic military pact has released a new Strategic Concept. The guidance sets the alliance’s strategy and security tasks, outlines the challenges and opportunities it faces in a changing security environment, and provides direction for its political and military implementation. There will be “a lot on new threats and challenges, a heavier emphasis on things like emerging and disruptive technologies, heavier emphasis on new domains like cyber and space, more on climate change,” U.S. Ambassador to NATO Julianne Smith told the Defense Writers Group in Washington. Smith did not elaborate on what the emerging technologies are, and FedScoop did not have the opportunity to ask her about them before the meeting with reporters ended. However, individual members of NATO have already their signaled interest and concerns about unmanned systems, AI, autonomy and hypersonics, among other emerging capabilities. For example, last week senior Pentagon officials and their U.K. counterparts signed an Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Statement of Intent, setting shared strategic objectives related to AI readiness. The agreement “will deepen AI cooperation between the two Allies, maintaining and increasing interoperability and promoting values-based global leadership for the responsible development, procurement, and use of AI in defense,” according to a DOD news release. Non-NATO members from the Asia-Pacific region will also be attending the summit for the first time, including Australia, New Zealand, Japan and South Korea. The threat posed by Russia and China will be addressed during discussions and in the new Strategic Concept. At the meeting leaders will have an opportunity “to have a conversation about what we’re both seeing. It’s been interesting for me to watch, say, countries in the Asia-Pacific talk about hybrid threats on their side of the Pacific, how are they grappling with disinformation, cyberattacks, the aggressive tactics that they’re seeing, acts of intimidation from China. And then you pair that with an Estonian or a Lithuanian and they talk about some of the challenges that they’re seeing from Russia,” Smith said. “It’s about sharing lessons learned, sharing new policies that we’re developing. We’ve had a number of conversations about emerging and disruptive technologies [and] how are we grappling with that,” she added. Other topics expected to be discussed at the confab include NATO’s force posture in Eastern Europe, and Sweden and Finland’s plans to join the alliance.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non UQ --- Emerging Tech

The strategic concept will expand NATO’s emerging tech cooperation inevitably.

Harper 6/1/22 [Jon Harper is the Managing Editor of DefenseScoop. He covers the Pentagon and military technology. ; “Emerging tech to have prominent role in NATO’s new strategic concept”; Fed Scoop; June 1, 2022; https://www.fedscoop.com/emerging-tech-to-have-prominent-role-in-natos-new-strategic-concept%ef%bf%bc/]//eleanor

Emerging and disruptive technologies will be a key focus area of NATO’s new Strategic Concept which will be unveiled later this month, the U.S. ambassador to the alliance told reporters Wednesday. The document is expected to be adopted at the upcoming NATO summit in Madrid, marking the first time in more than a decade that the transatlantic military pact has released a new Strategic Concept. The guidance sets the alliance’s strategy and security tasks, outlines the challenges and opportunities it faces in a changing security environment, and provides direction for its political and military implementation. There will be “a lot on new threats and challenges, a heavier emphasis on things like emerging and disruptive technologies, heavier emphasis on new domains like cyber and space, more on climate change,” U.S. Ambassador to NATO Julianne Smith told the Defense Writers Group in Washington. Smith did not elaborate on what the emerging technologies are, and FedScoop did not have the opportunity to ask her about them before the meeting with reporters ended. However, individual members of NATO have already their signaled interest and concerns about unmanned systems, AI, autonomy and hypersonics, among other emerging capabilities. For example, last week senior Pentagon officials and their U.K. counterparts signed an Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Statement of Intent, setting shared strategic objectives related to AI readiness. The agreement “will deepen AI cooperation between the two Allies, maintaining and increasing interoperability and promoting values-based global leadership for the responsible development, procurement, and use of AI in defense,” according to a DOD news release. Non-NATO members from the Asia-Pacific region will also be attending the summit for the first time, including Australia, New Zealand, Japan and South Korea. The threat posed by Russia and China will be addressed during discussions and in the new Strategic Concept. At the meeting leaders will have an opportunity “to have a conversation about what we’re both seeing. It’s been interesting for me to watch, say, countries in the Asia-Pacific talk about hybrid threats on their side of the Pacific, how are they grappling with disinformation, cyberattacks, the aggressive tactics that they’re seeing, acts of intimidation from China. And then you pair that with an Estonian or a Lithuanian and they talk about some of the challenges that they’re seeing from Russia,” Smith said. “It’s about sharing lessons learned, sharing new policies that we’re developing. We’ve had a number of conversations about emerging and disruptive technologies [and] how are we grappling with that,” she added.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- Cyber

The strategic concept will already discuss cyber.

Garamone 22 [Jim Garamone is a Reporter at U.S. Department of Defense; “Russia Forcing Changes to NATO Strategic Concepts”; US Department of Defense; June 1, 2022; https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3049900/russia-forcing-changes-to-nato-strategic-concepts/]//eleanor

Even before the Russian invasion, the Madrid Summit was poised to be a game-changer for the alliance. The summit crown jewel was to be the agreement on a new strategic concept for the alliance. Much has changed since the last time NATO leaders approved a strategic concept in 2010. "Even before February 24, there was a deep appreciation across the alliance that the language on Russia from 2010 was sorely outdated and needed a significant upgrade and needed to reflect the current environment," Smith said. "There was also an appreciation that China, for the first time, needed to be part of the strategic concept." In addition, the concept must address new threats and challenges, including "a heavier emphasis on things like emerging and disruptive technologies, heavier emphasis on new domains like cyber and space, [and] more on climate change," she said. And then, Russia again invaded its neighbor, which added new demands and complexities to the summit. Now, there is a force-posture piece to discussions in Madrid. The allies — including the United States — have sent thousands of service members to the alliance's frontline states to deter Putin. The number of NATO battlegroups in those states increased from four to eight. Biden has pledged to defend every inch of NATO territory. The allies will discuss how the long-range footprint of NATO forces in Europe should look. "What over the medium- and long-term should the alliance be looking to do in that neighborhood to reinforce NATO's eastern flank?" Smith asked. Another response to the Russian invasion is applications by Sweden and Finland to join the alliance. The two nations, long NATO partners, have military capabilities that would fit seamlessly into the alliance, Smith said. "The hope is that those two countries will join us in Madrid as invitees," she said. China, too, is a concern. The foreign ministers of Australia, New Zealand, Japan and South Korea will join NATO leaders in Madrid. Smith believes this will broaden "the conversation about our shared security, … talking to them about things like emerging and disruptive technologies and cyber," she said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Coord Now

No coordination now --- U.S. too unpredictable

Speranza 12/1/21

(Lauren Speranza, Director of the Transatlantic Defense and Security Program at the Center for European Policy Analysis, “American Leadership in NATO: A Rocky Return but a Firm Future,” pg online @ // um-ef)

The concept is a guiding document, now under development, intended to revitalise NATO’s purpose and core tasks for the future. After former US President Donald Trump’s and French President Emmanuel Macron’s respective accusations of NATO being “obsolete” and “brain dead”, the alliance is in grave need of a new concept that brings the US and Europe together to tackle the security challenges of today and tomorrow. The problem, however, is that the two sides are not entirely coordinated on how to do that. Compared to the Trump era, divisions among the allies are not nearly as evident. But given Washington’s growing focus on the Indo-Pacific over Europe and flawed coordination efforts thus far, its allies have some doubts about how America’s intentions regarding NATO will mesh with their own. Europe, for its part, is in some ways stronger than ever—thanks to four years of consolidating its own interests and capabilities in response to growing US unpredictability. Now, it finds itself sometimes at odds with Washington over key issues such as China, strategic autonomy and even technology. Simultaneously, it is more capable of defending its positions. Given the domestic political volatility in the US, its allies are skeptical about what US decisions will last through the next presidential elections. This means their own decisions matter even more. All of these dynamics complicate the crafting of NATO’s future common agenda.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- Concept broad now

Non unique – its already expanding to cyberattacks, China, and adding new members.

Feldscher 22 [Jacqueline Feldscher is senior national security correspondent at Defense One.; “NATO’s Next Strategic Concept Will Add China’s Threats, US Ambassador Says”; Defense One; June 1, 2022; https://www.defenseone.com/policy/2022/06/natos-next-strategic-concept-will-add-chinas-threats-us-ambassador-says/367613/]//eleanor

Even as a war rages in its own backyard, NATO will use its highly anticipated summit later this month to look beyond the concerns of the moment and address the threat posed by China for the first time in a major document, a top American official told reporters on Wednesday. Much of the conversation at the upcoming summit in Madrid is still expected to focus on deterring Russia amid its invasion of Ukraine and considering the applications from Finland and Sweden to join the alliance. But the strategic concept to be unveiled at the summit must encompass the next decade, which will see threats from China and emerging technology such as cyber attacks, said Julianne Smith, the United States’ permanent representative to NATO. “We are largely in agreement that Russia is the preeminent challenge, the primary threat that the NATO alliance is facing in this moment, and because of that, you’ll see a heavy emphasis on Russia right out of the gates at the top,” Smith said at an event hosted by the Defense Writers Group. “There is also an appreciation across NATO that this document is not intended to last for a week. This document…is supposed to last for 10 years.” NATO’s current strategic concept was released in 2010, four years before Russia annexed Crimea and years before major cyber attacks were commonplace. The 36-page document does not mention China; it also says the alliance seeks “a true strategic partnership” and more cooperation with Russia. The new, not-yet-finalized document set to be released in Spain will include the first mention of China in a NATO strategic concept, Smith said—though a statement released in June 2021 after an alliance summit in Brussels said that China’s “growing influence and international policies can present challenges that we need to address together as an alliance.” NATO leaders are also expected to address cooperation between Russia and China and how it affects the alliance, Smith said. NATO members have been united in their condemnation of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The alliance itself has provided no military support to Ukraine, a non-member, but many member countries, including the United States, have shipped billions of dollars worth of arms to Kyiv in addition to money for humanitarian aid and economic recovery. Besides the long view of the strategic concept, Smith said, NATO leaders might also release a communique or political declaration about the current threat posed by Russia and the war in Ukraine. NATO, which includes countries in Europe plus the United States and Canada, is seeking to expand its relationships with governments outside the region, and has invited leaders from Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and South Korea to attend the summit in Madrid, Smith said. Smith said there is no talk of an Indo-Pacific-focused council within NATO, but added that bringing in partners from the region can help share lessons about Chinese and Russian cyber attacks and disinformation campaigns. “It’s been interesting for me to watch countries in the Asia-Pacific talk about hybrid threats on their side of the Pacific…from China. Then you pair that with an Estonian or a Lithuanian, and they talk about some of the challenges that they’re seeing from Russia,” she said. One of the biggest questions to be addressed at the summit is how many troops or weapons NATO will position on its border with Russia in the medium and long term, Smith said. NATO ramped up its presence on its eastern front when the war in Ukraine began, but it’s not clear how long those troops will stay, or what the force posture will look like if the fighting ends. There’s also the question of whether Finland and Sweden, which applied to join NATO last month, will be welcomed into the alliance by the summit in late June amid Turkish opposition because of the Nordic countries’ views on terrorism. NATO leader Jens Stoltenberg said Wednesday that he will meet in “in the coming days” in Brussels with senior officials from Turkey, Finland, and Sweden to discuss Turkish concerns. “I’m confident that we will find a united way forward,” Stoltenberg said during a press conference at the State Department.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- Concept broad now

The strategic concept will cover a wide range of issues inevitably.

Webber 6/24/22 [Mark Webber, Professor of International Politics, University of Birmingham; “Ukraine war: Nato summit to meet in a world reordered by Russian aggression and Chinese ambition”; The Conversation; June 24, 2022; https://theconversation.com/ukraine-war-nato-summit-to-meet-in-a-world-reordered-by-russian-aggression-and-chinese-ambition-184882]//eleanor

The most substantive item on the agenda is an updating of Nato’s key Strategic Concept – which sets the alliance’s values and strategic objectives for the next decade. The current version, adopted in 2010, has served Nato well – but it was based on premises that no longer apply. Then, the global war on terror and Nato’s role in expeditionary operations as far afield as Afghanistan were what determined its purpose. Now, according to deputy secretary general Mircea Geoană, speaking at a conference in Copenhagen on June 10, Nato is more preoccupied with a new era of what he referred to as great power competition – focusing on Russia and China. It seems certain that a new document will be adopted. Russian belligerence has helped forge agreement, as has a growing appreciation of the “systemic challenges” posed by China. The multiple challenges of Nato’s security environment mean the document will pay attention to many other issues. Some will be quite separate from Russia and China – climate change, global health and terrorism among them. But others – hybrid and asymmetric threats, the militarisation of space, cyber security and the geostrategic importance of the Arctic and the Asia-Pacific – will be intimately connected to calculations concerning Moscow and Beijing.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Cohesion (Turkey)

Turkey will never say yes to Sweden/Finland.

Natasha Turak 22, Senior International Correspondent for CNBC, “'The stakes here are now massive': Turkey is threatening to block NATO membership for Sweden and Finland,” https://www.cnbc.com/2022/05/17/will-turkey-block-nato-membership-for-sweden-and-finland.html/micahw

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has doubled down on his opposition to Sweden and Finland joining the NATO alliance, a move that would be historic for the two Nordic countries in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

"We will not say 'yes' to those [countries] who apply sanctions to Turkey to join security organization NATO," Erdogan said at a news conference late Monday. He was referring to Sweden's suspension of weapons sales to Turkey in 2019 over its military activities in Syria.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Cohesion (Turkey)

They are throwing a hissy-fit over American F-16s---that’s straining their relationship.

W. Robert Pearson 22, Former Ambassador of the United States to Turkey and Director of Human Resources in the Foreign Service, “Turkey back at the barricades,” https://www.mei.edu/publications/turkey-back-barricades/micahw

Turkey is walking a narrow line. For now, NATO states are acting as if these difficulties will be settled. Turkey has a right to raise its concerns. Finland and Sweden have a right to explain their views. Delaying the membership process too long could escalate the level of NATO’s frustration with Turkey. Moreover, Turkey enjoys freedom from NATO sanctions on Russia. Turkey is benefiting from those exceptions financially and diplomatically by remaining officially neutral to Russia even as it supplies arms to Ukraine. Additionally, Turkey is no longer playing an active role as mediator. The real arrangement to settle the war will be up to Russia and Ukraine. Congress likely will hold up any approval of the F-16 deal until the obstacles to Swedish and Finnish memberships are removed.

Mr. Erdoğan has now added the United States to his list of countries to once again attack. The more the Turkish president feels empowered to criticize the United States and the administration that was willing to reach out to him, the less likely it is he will ever see the F-16s and the modernization kits. The longer he holds up approval of Finland’s and Sweden’s applications for membership, the more questions will arise about Turkey’s current role in the Russian war on Ukraine. Vladimir Putin has even said he is not opposed to these new memberships per se. If Turkey asks for too much, Ankara might lose much more than it bargained for.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Cohesion (Turkey)

Greece hates Turkey’s guts.

Anthee Carassava 22, Senior International Journalist at The Times, “Greek Forces on High Alert over Crisis with Turkey,” https://www.voanews.com/a/greek-forces-on-high-alert-over-crisis-with-turkey/6598746.html/micahw

Greece’s armed forces are on high alert in the Eastern Aegean Sea as tensions escalate with Turkey. Officials have been responding to what they say are mounting provocations by Turkey’s leadership.

Senior Greek Defense Ministry sources say the military intelligence they have gathered point to the prospect of so-called hybrid threats that Greece may face from its neighbor Turkey as the two NATO allies compete for oil and gas drilling rights in contested parts of the Aegean and Mediterranean seas.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Cohesion (Turkey)

Turkey does a little trolling.

Michael L. Crowley & Steven J. Erlanger 22, Crowley is a senior diplomatic correspondent in the Washington bureau, Erlanger is the chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe for The New York Times, “For NATO, Turkey Is a Disruptive Ally,” https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/30/us/politics/turkey-nato-russia.html/micahw

WASHINGTON — When President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey threatened this month to block NATO membership for Finland and Sweden, Western officials were exasperated — but not shocked.

Within an alliance that operates by consensus, the Turkish strongman has come to be seen as something of a stickup artist. In 2009, he blocked the appointment of a new NATO chief from Denmark, complaining that the country was too tolerant of cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad and too sympathetic to “Kurdish terrorists” based in Turkey. It took hours of cajoling by Western leaders, and a face-to-face promise from President Barack Obama that NATO would appoint a Turk to a leadership position, to satisfy Mr. Erdogan.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- No Cohesion

NATOs strategic concept is failing now – cohesion is dead and its super overstretched.

Tisdall 6/12/22 [Simon Tisdall is a foreign affairs commentator. He has been a foreign leader writer, foreign editor and US editor for the Guardian; “Behind Nato’s defensive ‘shield’ lies weakness and division. Ukraine will pay the price”; June 12, 2022; https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/12/behind-natos-defensive-shield-lies-weakness-and-division-ukraine-will-pay-the-price]//eleanor

While many allies have stepped up, important European Nato members cower behind an alliance they previously disparaged and neglected. They use it to avoid making costly national commitments to Kyiv that might anger Moscow. Daydreaming of EU strategic autonomy, France’s Emmanuel Macron prefers talk to action. Germany’s Olaf Scholz epitomises dither and delay. Viktor Orbán, Hungary’s sanctions-busting prime minister, often seems to bat for the other side. Cynically self-serving attempts by Turkey’s troublemaker president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, to sabotage Finland and Sweden’s membership applications also undermine a united front. Jens Stoltenberg, Nato’s inoffensive secretary general, will struggle to repair these fissures. Poland and other “frontline” states want a tougher approach, including permanent positioning of additional troops, heavy weapons and planes on Russia’s borders. In response, Nato officials promise “robust and historic” decisions. As for Ukraine, its leadership has all but abandoned hopes of membership, solemnly promised at Nato’s 2008 Bucharest summit, and has ceased calling for direct military intervention. “Of course, we will hear words of support… we are very grateful for that,” said its foreign minister, Dmytro Kuleba. Having previously accused Nato of “doing nothing”, he does not expect concrete action in Madrid on accession or, for example, “Black Sea security”. That last remark referred to the unforgivable, ongoing US-European failure to challenge Moscow’s illegal blockade of Ukraine’s ports, which is creating global food shortages. Nato could and should be exerting greater pressure on Russian forces, so helping persuade Putin to end his genocidal war It’s one of many areas where Nato could and should be exerting greater pressure on Russian forces, so helping persuade Putin to end his genocidal war. Why is Nato not doing more? Taken together, all the rationales and excuses for passivity and inaction produce a picture of an alliance significantly less united, powerful and organised than its admirers pretend. Initially backing Ukraine, albeit at arm’s length, gave Nato a boost. Its stock rose from the low-point of last year’s Afghan withdrawal debacle. But if, as expected, the war grinds on, if both sides grow desperate, if the diplomatic impasse deepens, and if the threat of wider conflict rises, Nato’s long unaddressed weaknesses and vulnerabilities will become both more obvious and more hazardous for those crouching behind its battlements. Its post-Soviet bluff may finally be called. It would be unrealistic to expect seamless political unanimity in so large an organisation. But the fact that each member has an equal say when, in terms of military capacity, they are absurdly unequal, hinders swift, bold decision-making. A Russian nuclear or chemical provocation, for example, would be likely to produce a paralysing cacophony of conflicting voices within Nato – and Putin surely knows it. At the same time, there is huge over-reliance on the US, a military superpower without whose agreement nothing happens and behind whose might the laggards lurk, refusing to pay their way. Organisationally and militarily, too, Nato is all over the place. It has three joint command headquarters – in Italy, the Netherlands and the US. But its top general is based in Belgium. Inter-operability of different countries’ weapons systems is lacking, as are joint training exercises, arms procurement and intelligence-sharing. Nato is also increasingly overstretched, caught between a Russian threat in the Euro-Atlantic area and challenges in the Indo-Pacific from an aggressively expansionist China. Leaders from Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand are expected in Madrid. Their shared nightmare: a “no limits” totalitarian Sino-Russian global axis with echoes of the 1939 Nazi-Soviet pact. Nato is due to publish its 10-yearly “strategic concept” on how to deal with all this, plus trans-national terrorism, destabilising climate change, cyber warfare and the rise of anti-democratic states. It’s a tall order.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO Cohesion

Disunity is at an all-time high---Greece, Turkey, France, and the US are all pissed at eachother.

Paul Antonopoulos 21, PhD Candidate at Vila Velha University, “2021: A year of NATO disunity like no other,”

2021 is arguably the year when intra-NATO tensions and rivalry widened more so then ever since the alliance's inception in 1949. Although NATO most recently expanded its membership to include Montenegro in 2017 and North Macedonia in 2020, the rift caused by competing interests and the emboldening of revisionist ideologies (neo-Ottomanism and Anglo Chauvinism) among bloc members has only widened in recent years, but no other like 2021.

Intense NATO disunity first became prevalent during the Syrian War. Turkey continues to be enraged that the US, France and other member states train, fund and arm the People’s Protection Units (YPG), the Syrian branch of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) that Ankara recognizes as a terrorist organization. Meanwhile, Washington is furious that Turkey defied warnings to not purchase the Russian-made S-400 missile defense system, and thus in December 2020 imposed sanctions on its fellow NATO member, an unprecedented action. With former US President Donald Trump unwilling to confront Turkey in a serious way in order to not jeopardize his personal business interests in the country, his successor Joe Biden has more willingly confronted his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO Cohesion

NATO political infighting is the norm.

Lucas 22 [Edward Lucas is a nonresident fellow at the Center for European Policy Analysis, a Liberal Democratic candidate for the British Parliament, a former senior editor at The Economist, and the author, most recently, of Cyberphobia: Identity, Trust, Security and the Internet, 6-7-2022, NATO Is Out of Shape and Out of Date, Foreign Policy, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/06/07/nato-ukraine-russia-war-alliance-reform-geopolitics-military/] Eric

Nothing in recent weeks suggests that these questions will get clear answers. For starters, the 30-strong alliance is unwieldy. In military terms, only a handful of members matter—above all, the United States—but in political terms, even little Luxembourg and Iceland get a voice. Worse, the political divides are huge. Turkey under President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is a semi-authoritarian state that flirts with Russia and fumes at what it considers European meddling over human rights. Hungary under Prime Minister Viktor Orban is taking a different but downward path, fusing wealth and power into a new system of control at home and undermining U.S. and European attempts to put pressure on Russia and China. Macron’s relentless posturing and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s foot-dragging create constant obstacles and distractions. The two leader’s weaknesses, on glorious display since the start of the war, have already enriched the language:  is a German neologism for “dither,” while  in Polish (and its equivalent in Ukrainian) can be roughly translated as “vacuous grandstanding while doing nothing.”

Macron and Scholz corrode decision-making with their foibles and thus place a big question mark over the alliance’s credibility and cohesion. Any threat or provocation from Russia is unlikely to be clear or conveniently timed. More likely it will be something deliberately ambiguous, such as a Russian drone that “accidentally” strays onto the territory of a front-line state and hits a target. Some countries would favor a tough response. Others would fear escalation and want dialogue. Still others would take the ambiguity as a convenient excuse to do nothing. Would the 30—soon to be 32—national representatives in the North Atlantic Council, the alliance’s deliberative body, really make a speedy and tough decision on how to react? More likely, some of them would plead for delay, diplomacy, and compromise. Those actually facing the possibility of attack would be far more hawkish, preferring a sharp military confrontation to even the smallest Russian victory. “Not one inch, not one soul,” a senior military figure from one of the Baltic states, speaking anonymously, told me. “We have seen what they did in Ukraine.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO Cohesion

Increasingly NATO cohesion is decreasing – there is less economic and political will

Ellehuus 21 [Rachel Ellehuus is the Secretary of Defense Representative in Europe (SECDEFREPEUR) and the Defense Advisor (DEFAD) for the U.S. Mission to NATO, 7-21-2021, NATO Futures: Three Trajectories, No Publication, https://www.csis.org/analysis/nato-futures-three-trajectories] Eric

By 2024, only half of the allies have reached the NATO benchmarks of spending 2 percent of their Gross Domestic Product (GDP) on defense and 20 percent that on major equipment. The gap between the most and least capable allies affects both interoperability and political will. NATO increasingly relies on the same handful of countries to generate forces for missions at home and abroad. After failed efforts to increase its common funding, the persistence of NATO’s “costs lie where they fall” system causes force-contributing allies to become frustrated with “free riders” in the alliance. While some countries invest in new and emerging technologies, only a few can muster the resources to field or procure these capabilities, and adversaries slowly gain a technological edge. The United States begins to rely on ad hoc coalitions of the most willing and capable allies, further eroding NATO’s role as the security partner of choice. NATO’s nuclear deterrence posture comes into question following the U.S. Congress’s decision to fund modernization of the U.S. nuclear triad only partially. Other allies begin to waver on their roles in the extended deterrence mission (including procurement of new dual-capable aircraft), forcing a rethink and reorganization of NATO’s nuclear posture.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO Cohesion

NATO already has multiple structural problems – overstretch is the squo.

West 22 [West, 6-12-2022, Behind Nato’s defensive ‘shield’ lies weakness and division. Ukraine will pay the price, Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/12/behind-natos-defensive-shield-lies-weakness-and-division-ukraine-will-pay-the-price] Eric

Why is Nato not doing more? Taken together, all the rationales and excuses for passivity and inaction produce a picture of an alliance  than its admirers pretend.

Initially backing Ukraine, albeit at arm’s length, gave Nato a boost. Its stock rose from the low-point of .

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Non-UQ --- NATO Cohesion

NATO cohesion is non-unique.

Simon and Arteaga 22 [Luis Simón is Senior Analyst and Director of the Elcano Royal Institute’s Brussels Office, in addition of being Research Professor of International Relations at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel. He holds a PhD in International Relations from the University of London, and a MA in European Studies from the Institute d’Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po). Félix Arteaga is a Senior Analyst at the Elcano Royal Institute and a Lecturer at the Instituto Universitario General Gutiérrez Mellado (Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia, UNED). He has a doctorate in International Relations and a BSc in Political Science from Madrid’s Universidad Complutense.; “NATO gets an update: the Madrid Strategic Concept”; Real Instituto Elcano; January 17, 2022; https://www.realinstitutoelcano.org/en/analyses/nato-gets-an-update-the-madrid-strategic-concept/]//eleanor

The restating of the bond is essential after a period of turbulence. The advent of Donald Trump as US President in January 2017, his unusually explicit criticisms of NATO and the European countries raised major doubts among the European allies regarding the US commitment to the defence of Europe and led them to push the ‘strategic autonomy’ agenda within the framework of the EU. The pivot to Asia and the importance placed on China by US Administrations completed a context of uncertainty in which the French President Emmanuel Macron went so far as to assert that NATO had become ‘brain dead’. Added to this was the questioning in some countries of the democratic values and the rule of law that have maintained internal cohesion and require an unequivocal reaffirmation.