Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato collapse good – top level

NATO is outdated, imperialistic, and interferes with the United Nations now – it should be abolished to allow the UN to take its place

Verma 3/8. Sudesh, former journalist, he is a member of BJP’s media relations department and represents the party as spokesperson while participating in television debates. “NATO has failed: UN must be strengthened” https://thedailyguardian.com/nato-has-failed-un-must-be-strengthened/

The Russian military intervention in Ukraine has exposed the world’s inability to control the situation if a powerful State decides to use its military power to set things right with its immediate neighbouring countries. The prime reason for this massive failure is the absence of a moral and righteous world body that has the mechanism to implement dharma-based order. NATO clearly does not fit the bill.The only organisation that could do this is the United Nations but it has got weakened due to shadow boxing by major world powers—the Big Five that includes the US, the UK, France, China and Russia. They trust their own military strength and have no reason to strengthen the UN. The veto enjoyed by them ensures that this body remains defunct to prevent any major crisis involving any of these players. All these five have developed sophisticated weaponry and are major suppliers of arms across the world. NATO cannot replace the UN since it is a group of countries having a vested interest to empower itself and maintain superiority vis-a-vis other countries. The world does not matter to NATO countries if they are not involved in acts of war with non-NATO countries. And if push comes to shove NATO can fight any country or grouping in the world based on its combined military strength and economic might. At least NATO would like to believe this.The fact that three permanent members of the UN Security with veto are members of the NATO—France, the UK and the US—makes it evident that the organisation seeks to be happy with its own enclave where they would enjoy liberty, freedom and democracy and will also have the wherewithal to fight others if these are hurt. Even in the vastly interdependent and integrated world, NATO believes that it can live peacefully even if other countries suffer. The UN has 193 members which means that 163 countries are outside the NATO framework.

Becoming a member of NATO brings in security plus economic empowerment. Actually, the strategy of the British Empire where the military back-up by the Crown was used to further business interests has been emulated by NATO. NATO would intervene if its economic interest is hurt or if it concludes that certain actions of any country are hurting its core held principles. The massive airpower would ensure that NATO troops would not even need to be on the ground if it desires to punish a country. The control over English media by NATO countries both in terms of finance, governmental control and ideology would ensure that a larger legitimacy is provided to its actions. The US intervention in Afghanistan was justified as much as its withdrawal that happened after two decades. The US intervened in Iraq to destroy weapons of mass destruction but when it did not find any, it blamed intelligence failure. The UN has been relegated to providing legitimacy to the course of action decided by NATO. These NATO countries have enough clout because of their influence and are able to lobby successfully at the UN and get the support of smaller countries to add to their legitimacy.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato collapse good – top level

NATO obsolete – causes more harm than good

Jacobs 2022 (Seth Jacobs is a history professor who studies the political and cultural history of the U.S. in the 20th century. His research focuses on the connection between U.S. domestic culture and foreign policy, “On NATO”, )//MargaretE

Three decades on, we are still stuck with the alliance, and as recent events demonstrate, it is no laughing matter. NATO has become obsolete. Indeed, Washington’s whole Europe-first orientation is anachronistic, a wasteful, expensive holdover from the cold war that ought to have been abandoned years ago and that distracts us from the true dangers we face abroad.

Mearsheimer, to his credit, deplored this development more vehemently than anyone. A self-described “unrepentant realist,” he had no patience for the aggressive internationalism that defined Western statecraft in the Clinton, Bush, and Obama presidencies. NATO as an anti-Soviet bloc made sense to him; NATO as an ever-expanding club of vaguely like-minded nations was foolish—and dangerous. According to the tenets of realism, when one great power trespasses upon another’s sphere of influence, the result is nearly always conflict, and Mearsheimer insisted that that was the case with NATO’s eastward march. It did not matter that officials from the United States and its European allies insisted that they had no designs on Russia. Russian President Vladimir Putin was not convinced. He perceived their encroachment as an existential threat and responded violently, first by annexing Crimea in 2014, then by invading Ukraine in 2022. While most pundits in the West denounced Putin’s barefaced breach of international law, Mearsheimer proclaimed that NATO was to blame, that its leaders ought to have recognized that their apparent intent to incorporate Russia’s bordering countries into their alliance would trigger war, and that Putin was only doing what an American president would do if, say, Iran built a military association and invited Mexico and Canada to join. In a gauntlet-flinging guest essay for the Economist in March and a follow-up interview in the New Yorker, Mearsheimer condemned NATO for naiveté and called for a pragmatic solution to the crisis that would keep Ukraine as a neutral country and leave Putin in power, with Crimea and the Donbas in his grasp.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato collapse good – top level

NATO is a tool of imperialism and US heg – disbandment key to peace

Wight 2022 (John Wight is an author and political commentator based in Scotland, “NATO’s disbandment is long overdue”, )//MargaretE

The decisive role of NATO in achieving the West’s objectives in the former Yugoslavia need not detain us. The point is that today – bearing in mind NATO’s role in the dismemberment of Yugoslavia, its role in helping turn Afghanistan into a failed state, its critical role in toppling Gadaffi in Libya and turning that country into a failed state, and its stance in threatening Russia’s security in Eastern Europe – it is no longer feasible or possible to harbor any lingering belief that NATO is anything other than a tool of US hard power, deployed not to protect and defend, but to destroy and dominate.

Whenever you hear Joe Biden and other leaders and officials of NATO-member states advocating diplomacy to resolve the current crisis, it is notable that none advocate the one thing that would not only end the current crisis and avert war in Ukraine, but do much to restore stability and security to a world that has long been desperate for both.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato collapse good – top level

NATO collapse good – prevents structural violence, China and Russia war, and increased militarism

Benjamin 2019 (Medea Benjamin co-founder of CODEPINK for Peace, is the author of "Inside Iran: The Real History and Politics of the Islamic Republic of Iran" and "Kingdom of the Unjust: Behind the U.S.-Saudi Connection.", “Why NATO should be obsolete”, )//MargaretE

While claiming to “preserve peace,” NATO has a history of bombing civilians and committing war crimes. In 1999, NATO engaged in military operations without UN approval in Yugoslavia. Its illegal airstrikes during the Kosovo War left hundreds of civilians dead. And far from the “North Atlantic,” NATO joined the United States in invading Afghanistan in 2001, where it is still bogged down two decades later. In 2011, NATO forces illegally invaded Libya, creating a failed state that caused masses of people to flee. Rather than take responsibility for these refugees, NATO countries have turned back desperate migrants on the Mediterranean Sea, letting thousands die.

In London, NATO wants to show it is ready to fight new wars. It will showcase its readiness initiative—the ability to deploy 30 battalions by land, 30 air squadrons and 30 naval vessels in just 30 days, and to confront future threats from China and Russia, including with hypersonic missiles and cyberwarfare. But far from being a lean, mean war machine, NATO is actually riddled with divisions and contradictions. Here are some of them:

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---Perm Russia in NATO

It's a more sustainable solution to tensions with Russia than stopping NATO expansion.

Charles A. Kupchan 10, Professor of International Affairs at Georgetown University and a Senior Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, “NATO's Final Frontier: Why Russia Should Join the Atlantic Alliance,” Foreign Affairs, May/June 2010,

Third, Russia's integration into NATO would enable Georgia and Ukraine to join the alliance without provoking a crisis with Moscow. According to the Russian political scientists Sergei Karaganov and Timofei Bordachev, the admission of these countries into NATO would increase "the risk of a conflict with unforeseeable consequences." Stopping the enlargement of NATO could avert this problem but would leave another one unsolved: How can Russia and its neighbors be integrated into a unitary Euro-Atlantic order? As Andrew Monaghan of the NATO Defense College notes, "Even if enlargement stops, Russia remains excluded from Euro-Atlantic mechanisms."

The solution, then, is for Georgia and Ukraine to join a NATO in which Russia is already, or is soon to be, a member, ensuring that their entry would cause little, if any, geopolitical tension. More generally, if membership in the CIS remains separate from membership in NATO, Europe's East and West will be subject to indefinite geopolitical division and jockeying over zones of influence. In contrast, if NATO opens its doors to members of the CIS, such dividing lines and the competition that accompanies them will likely fade away. There is a precedent for this evolution: all of the CIS members already cooperate with NATO through the Partnership for Peace program and the Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---Perm Russia in NATO

Only offering Russia integration---even if it refuses---communicates NATO’s benign intent---integration solves broad security coop

Charles A. Kupchan 10, Professor of International Affairs at Georgetown University and a Senior Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, “NATO's Final Frontier: Why Russia Should Join the Atlantic Alliance,” Foreign Affairs, May/June 2010,

Nonetheless, the West is making a historic mistake in treating Russia as a strategic pariah. As made clear by the settlements after the Napoleonic Wars and World War II -- in contrast to the one that followed World War I -- including former adversaries in a postwar order is critical to the consolidation of great-power peace. Anchoring Russia in an enlarged Euro-Atlantic order, therefore, should be an urgent priority for NATO today.

Russia has been disgruntled with the expansion of NATO ever since the alliance began courting new members from the former Soviet bloc in the early 1990s. However, Russia's economic and military decline and the West's primacy encouraged NATO members to discount the potential consequences of Russian discontent. "As American capabilities surged and Russian capabilities waned," the political scientists Daniel Deudney and G. John Ikenberry have observed, "Washington policymakers increasingly acted as though Russia no longer mattered and the United States could do whatever it wanted."

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---Perm Do Both---Cyber

Combining for a best takes advantage of their relative strengths---they’re mutually reinforcing, NOT an op cost

Adina Ponta 21, advisor to the Committee on Information Technology and Communications in the Romanian Parliament, teaching lecturer at the Babeș-Bolyai University in Romania and a postdoctoral researcher at the Law School’s Center for Business Law & Information Technology, “Legal Instability in Cyberspace and OSCE’s Mitigation Role,” Juridical Tribune, vol. 11, no. 3, 12/28/2021, DOI.org (Crossref), doi:10.24818/TBJ/2021/11/3.01

Fourth, strengthening the regional structures for conflict prevention requires a great amount of political will. However, for broader inclusion, coherence, and complementarity of efforts, and to avoid risks of duplication, international partners should enhance their cooperation at all working levels. More synergy among regional organizations will enhance common understanding of threats, exchange of lessons learned, and promote cooperation over competition. These efforts can provide advanced legal policy training for diplomats and local capacity building, which is crucial to follow-up on the implementation of CBMs. The OSCE should avail itself of the dialogue channels in place and establish new partnerships for a comprehensive picture of regional views and conflict prevention mechanisms.

Cyberpolicy cooperation and understanding of States’ views and concerns should build on the significant overlap in membership of the EU, the OSCE, and NATO, organizations with highly complementary mandates. While the EU focuses on strengthening resilience through finance and diplomacy, the OSCE’s model of regional security, and NATO’s crisis management capacities could merge into meaningful synergies with the purpose of conflict prevention and early warning, common features of these organizations’ mandates.51

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---Perm Do Both

The perm is best---NATO and the OSCE are complimentary---combining dialogue best propagates new security norms

Anton Sergeevich Gavrilov 18, Антон Сергеевич Гаврилов, researcher at Mariisk State University, “Международные организации как механизмы регулирования международных отношений (ООН, ОБСЕ, НАТО),” or “International Organizations as Mechanisms for Regulating International Relations (UN, OSCE, NATO),” Марийский государственный университет, 2018, pp. 490–492, translated by Yandex

На сегодняшний день систему международных отношений невозможно представить без таких организаций, как ООН и ОБСЕ. Современный мир все больше сталкивается с проблемами вооруженных столкновений, с самого разного типа кризисными ситуациями. И лучший ключ к разрешению подобных проблем — деятельность данных организаций. Нельзя недооценивать всю значимость миротворческих операций, проводимых ООН, невозможно выразить всю благодарность деятельности ОБСЕ за проводимые ей планы по урегулированию кризисных ситуаций, возникших в том или ином регионе. Это лишь немногие плюсы данных международных организаций. Подводя итог в данном вопросе, стоит сказать, что значимость ООН и ОБСЕ огромна. Военнополитический блок НАТО, несмотря на свои сомнительные и далекие от доверия средства решения возникших проблем, также представляет собой важного игрока на международной арене и оказывает существенное влияние на нее. НАТО так же, как ООН и ОБСЕ, способствует эффективному предотвращению конфликтов и активно участвует в кризисном регулировании.

Помимо собственных целей, которые ставят перед собой данные международные организации, они также следуют и целям коллективного характера. Ярким примером взаимодействия двух игроков международной арены в рамках коллективного целеполагания является взаимодействие НАТО и ООН.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---NATO Key---OSCE Fails

The OSCE’s non-binding---that wrecks conflict resolution

A. M. Skryabina 18, А. М. Скрябина, researcher at at Mariiskii State University, “ОБСЕ как субъект контроля за соблюдением прав человека в Европе, или почему неэффективна ее деятельность,” or, “The OSCE as a subject of monitoring the observance of human rights in Europe, or why its activities are ineffective,” Марийский государственный университет, 2018, pp. 392–394, translated by Yandex

ОБСЕ или Организация по безопасности и сотрудничеству в Европе – довольно молодая организация по поддержке безопасности и стабильности относительно своих коллег, таких как ООН, ЕС или НАТО, создана лишь в 1975 году. Создание Организации по безопасности и сотрудничеству в Европе было направлено на закрепление 10 принципов хельсинкского Заключительного акта Совещания по безопасности и сотрудничеству в Европе: суверенного равенства, неприменения силы и ее угроз, нерушимости границ, территориальной целостности государств, мирного урегулирования споров, невмешательства во внутренние дела, уважение прав человека и основных свобод, включая свободу мысли, совести, религии и убеждений, равноправие и право народов располагать своей судьбой, сотрудничество между государствами и добросовестное выполнение обязательств по международному праву. И по сей день, со времен образования первых организаций по обеспечению мирного порядка, таких, как Лига Наций, главной целью мирового сообщества остается поддержание безопасности и контроль за соблюдением прав человека.

В 1995 году ОБСЕ стала первой организацией, отвечающей за общеевропейский порядок. Ее спектр действий направлен на предупреждение кризисов и конфликтных ситуаций, их урегулирование и постконфликтная реабилитация. Помимо решения вопросов экономики и экологии, укрепления мира и безопасности в Европе, немаловажным аспектом деятельности ОБСЕ является защита прав людей. Уважение прав человека и основных свобод является ключевым элементом всеобъемлющей концепции безопасности ОБСЕ. Во-первых, идет борьба с торговлей людьми. Действия ОБСЕ против торговли людьми координируются Управлением Специального представителя и координатора по борьбе с торговлей людьми. Во-вторых, идет обеспечение гендерного равенства, свободы религии, слова, передвижения, СМИ. В-третьих, ОБСЕ выявляет, ищет пути разрешения напряженности между этническими представителями и устанавливает стандарты прав для групп меньшинств. Создано Бюро по демократическим институтам и правам человека (БДИПЧ), которое представляет собой институт по содействию обеспечению прав человека, развитию демократии и утверждению верховенства закона.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---NATO Key---OSCE Fails

The OSCE fails---it can’t mediate conflicts if the parties aren’t open to mediation.

Philip Remler 21, nonresident scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, “The OSCE as Sisyphus: Mediation, Peace Operations, Human Rights,” Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI), 2021, JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep30942

Over the past decade, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) has unwillingly been returning to its origins as a Cold War–era Conference – a forum where states and blocs, often antagonistic to one another and espousing opposing ideals, can air their frictions and hostilities and look for ways to overcome them.

A brief historical review is necessary. The Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe (CSCE) established by the 1975 Helsinki Final Act was one manifestation of Europe’s aspiration to establish an international order to keep the peace and, as Andrei Sakharov wrote in his Nobel speech that year, to stress “the link between defense of peace and defense of human rights”.1

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---NATO Key---Interop

NATO is key---they have unique institutions for facilitating legal interoperability

Zoe Stanley-Lockman & Lena Trabucco 22, Stanley-Lockman is an Associate Research Fellow in the Military Transformations Programme at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore; Lena Trabucco is a dual degree candidate pursuing a PhD in political science at Northwestern University and a PhD in Law at iCourts Center of Excellence in International Courts at the University of Copenhagen, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance, edited by Justin Bullock et al., Oxford University Press, 03/18/2022, DOI.org (Crossref), doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.013.69

One vital and unique contribution for NATO is facilitating legal interoperability among the Allies to resolve some of the most pressing legal barriers for AI implementation in future Allied operations. Legal interoperability, a subset of larger coalition interoperability, refers to the operational coordination around partner legal obligations and interpretations.75 It ensures “that within a military alliance, military operations can be conducted effectively consistent with the legal obligations of each nation.”76 Legal interoperability is a critical component of multilateral operations that has thus far been under-examined, despite its centrality to successful military operations. This is largely because “legal factors have a bearing on everything in alliances and coalition operations—from determining basic ‘troop-to-task’ considerations to decisions regarding the targets to be engaged—and the types of ordinances that may be used.”77

To enhance legal interoperability, NATO can exert its influence on how Allies can develop and deploy AI consistent with their legal obligations through its unique standardization capacities. Historically, NATO has taken significant steps to bridge the legal gap between Allies on critical procedures that bridge responsible state behavior with such “troop-to-task” considerations. One instructive example from past operations is detention policies in non-international armed conflicts.78 The promulgation of detention standards illustrates the operational significance of NATO’s common legal procedures, even for coalitions of the willing that formally operate outside NATO structures. By way of background, the U.S.-led coalition in Afghanistan had internal debates regarding the 96-hour security detention time period.79 The United States advocated extending the 96-hour rule, where coalition partners insisted adhering to the NATO standard, even though it was not a NATO operation.80 Generally the detention example illustrates NATO legal standards providing clarity to non-NATO operations; in some cases, Allies adopt NATO standards as accepted thresholds that continue to inform coalition policies beyond NATO structures and operations.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
AFF › OSCE CP---2AC

Perm do both---regulatory fora are complimentary, NOT competitive

Daniel Mügge 21, Professor of Political Arithmetic at the University of Amsterdam, “Cooperation á la carte is the way forward for EU AI regulation,” London School of Economics, 11/26/2021, https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2021/11/26/cooperation-a-la-carte-is-the-way-forward-for-eu-ai-regulation/

Earlier this year, the EU became the first major jurisdiction to publish a set of draft rules for artificial intelligence (AI). There are good reasons to keep close legislative tabs on AI technology. Concerns range from algorithmic discrimination and distorted democracy to ubiquitous surveillance and outright oppression.

Beyond these questions loom deeper concerns. A world saturated with machines able to predict and exploit our fears and desires fundamentally challenges human autonomy. At the same time, AI-led automation has the potential to deprive many people of their jobs once the government debt-fuelled post-pandemic boom peters out. Already, automation has driven a wedge between the upper and lower echelons of labour markets. Aided by smart machines, many highly educated workers have seen their productivity rise, while jobs with more routine tasks, in contrast, have slowly disappeared.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do the CP---AT: Member States---Ext

NATO member states are fundamentally different from NATO the core organization.

Nick Amies 21, staff writer at DW, “Looking to the future,” DW, 2021, https://learngerman.dw.com/en/amid-birthday-celebrations-nato-faces-challenges-of-a-changing-world/a-4147405

NATO's 28 members are desperately grappling with the question of what, exactly, their military club is meant to do in this new world of asymmetrical warfare, cyber attacks, energy security and the socially destabilizing effects of climate change and financial collapse.

Old challenges with dangerous new dimensions

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do the CP---AT: Member States

The difference is vital and fundamental

Brian Collins 2, Lt. Col. In the US Air Force and a faculty member of the National War College in Washington, D.C., “Operation Enduring Freedom and the Future of NATO,” Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, vol. 3, no. 2, Georgetown University Press, 2002, pp. 51–56

The U.S. -led military action in Afghanistan in response to the attacks of September II raised a number of important issues regarding the future of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the relationship between the United States and its transatlantic allies. On September 12, , NATO invoked Arti- cle 5 - the mutual defense clause of the Washington Treaty - thereby committing NATO to help defend the United States from the perpetrators of the attacks. Shortly thereafter, NATO sent seven of its Airborne Early Warning and Control (AWACS) aircraft, crews, and ground support personnel to assist in the air defense of the United States. In addition to demonstrating NATO's military resolve and buttressing the political declaration of Article 5» the deployment of NATO AWACS aircraft also freed up U.S. aircraft for Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan.

NATO also provided blanket air rights for U.S. aircraft, access to bases and ports, and other non-combat support. However, NATO did not lead Operation Enduring Freedom, nor did it develop the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) deployed to Afghanistan in the wake of the American rout of the Taliban. The Europeans expected more of a say in the planning and execution of operations since the alliance had stood firm with the United States after the attacks. Since the understanding for fifty years had been that the United States would come to the aid of Europe and lead its defense, it was only natural to assume that Europe would play a large role if the United States was attacked. However, this was not the case; the United States preferred a coalition involving NATO members but not NATO itself.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do the CP

The OSCE is distinct

Alan W. Dowd 22, Senior Fellow at the Center for America's Purpose at Sagamore Institute, “Looking ahead to Fortress Ukraine,” American Legion, 2-24-2022, https://www.legion.org/landingzone/255571/looking-ahead-fortress-ukraine

Given Russia’s actions, it’s difficult (though not impossible) to see how such a force could be administered by the U.N. Security Council. And given sensitivities on both sides of the NATO-Russia divide, it’s unlikely that NATO could replicate in Ukraine its role leading the Implementation Force (IFOR), the Multinational Stabilization Force (SFOR) and the Kosovo Force (KFOR) in the former Yugoslavia. An alternative model is the Multinational Force and Observers (MFO) peacekeeping mission, which has been deployed in the Sinai since 1981. The MFO is funded by a group of donor nations and manned and supplied by a group of troop-contributing nations. In a similar way, Ukraine could invite trusted partners to contribute personnel, material and funding to this effort. The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) – with a track record of border-management and a membership enfolding the entire Euro-Atlantic region – could play a coordinative role. Owing to their unique capabilities, certain NATO members (though not NATO itself) would be needed to provide enabling support.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do the CP

NATO is the military alliance---to be considered a NATO activity, NATO itself must be the initiating or joint initiating authority.

NATO 22, “ABOUT NATO,” US Mission to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization,

Formed in 1949 with the signing of the Washington Treaty, NATO is a security alliance of 30 countries from North America and Europe. NATO’s fundamental goal is to safeguard the Allies’ freedom and security by political and military means. NATO remains the principal security instrument of the transatlantic community and expression of its common democratic values. It is the practical means through which the security of North America and Europe are permanently tied together. NATO enlargement has furthered the U.S. goal of a Europe whole, free, and at peace.

Article 5 of the Washington Treaty — that an attack against one Ally is an attack against all — is at the core of the Alliance, a promise of collective defense. Article 4 of the treaty ensures consultations among Allies on security matters of common interest, which have expanded from a narrowly defined Soviet threat to the critical mission in Afghanistan, as well as peacekeeping in Kosovo and new threats to security such as cyber attacks, and global threats such as terrorism and piracy that affect the Alliance and its global network of partners.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do Both---Fails

The perm fails---it reaffirms the primacy of NATO in norm-setting which is incompatible with visions of security architecture that Russia can accept.

Mark Neymark 22, Марк Афроимович Неймарк, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor of the Department of Political Science and Political Philosophy of the Diplomatic Academy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, “Красные линии стратегической безопасности России: от метафоры к критической альтернативе,” or, “The Red Lines of Russia's Strategic Security: from metaphor to critical alternative,” Научно-Аналитический Журнал Обозреватель, no. 1 (384), 2022, translated by Yandex, doi:10.48137/2074-2975_2022_01_5

Для нормализации отношений с альянсом российское руководство настаивает на возвращении к ситуации, документально зафиксированной в «Основополагающем Акте Россия – НАТО», подписанном в 1997 г. обеими сторонами «на основе твёрдого обязательства, принятого на высшем политическом уровне».

В документе говорилось, что Россия и НАТО будут содействовать укреплению ОБСЕ, включая дальнейшее развитие её роли в качестве основного инструмента превентивной дипломатии, предотвращения конфликтов, урегулирования кризисов, постконфликтного восстановления и регионального сотрудничества в области безопасности, а также укрепления её оперативных возможностей по осуществлению этих задач. «ОБСЕ в качестве единственной общеевропейской организации безопасности играет ключевую роль в поддержании европейского мира и стабильности».

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do Both

Linking OSCE cooperation to NATO poisons the well for reviving the organization.

Matthew Levinger 18, George Washington University, “Forging Consensus for Atrocity Prevention: Assessing the Record of the OSCE,” Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal: Vol. 11: Iss. 3: 60-74, http://doi.org/10.5038/1911-9933.11.3.1505

A greater challenge to the OSCE collaborative problem-solving efforts has been the rising tension between Russia and the West. During the early 1990s, Yeltsin and other Russian leaders embraced the organization as the potential centerpiece for a future collaborative European security architecture. In subsequent years, however, the Western participating States placed increasing emphasis on expanding NATO and the EU, to the detriment of the OSCE. The expansion of NATO to include Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic in 1999, and an additional seven states including the Baltic republics in 2004, drove home the view among Russian leaders that the OSCE was “erecting a wall within itself, artificially dividing its members into the NATO and EU members, and the rest.” Under these new conditions, declared Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, “NATO deals with security issues, the EU with economic issues, while the OSCE will only monitor the adoption of these organizations’ values by countries that have remained outside the EU and NATO.”35

In the late 1990s, Western criticisms of Russia’s military campaign in Chechnya, along with Russian unhappiness over NATO’s bombing of Kosovo and Serbia, created further frictions, which intensified after the election of Vladimir Putin as President of the Russian Federation in 2000. Russia’s leaders increasingly expressed suspicions that the OSCE agenda was “destabilizing its neighborhood and in the long run potentially also Russia itself.”36 They were particularly unhappy with the work of the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), which they saw as “regionally biased against the East.”37 Beginning in 2002, Russia sent its own observers to monitor elections in the post-Soviet states, alongside monitors from the OSCE and EU, in order to counter the “Western bias” in ODIHR’s conclusions. On Russia’s insistence, the OSCE also sent observers to monitor elections in Western participating States, including Canada and the United States.38 Russian leaders accused the OSCE of being a tool of Western interests in Ukraine both during the Orange Revolution of 2004 and during the political crisis of 2014, and bridled at ODIHR’s repeated criticisms of election irregularities in Belarus. Unnamed Western states, claimed Putin in 2007, were “trying to transform the OSCE into a vulgar instrument designed to promote the foreign policy interests of one or a group of countries.”39

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › Competition › AT: Perm do Both

The perm relegates OSCE to an ancillary role---that politicizes norms and guts capacity to build independent confidence-building measures.

Lev Voronkov 18, Лев Сергеевич Воронков, professor at the Moscow State Institute of International Relations, “ОБСЕ и европейская безопасность. Что дальше?,” or, “OSCE in the ‘New Architecture of European Security’,” Современная Европа, no. 1 (80), 2018, translated by Yandex, doi:10.15211/soveurope120186979

С момента созыва Совещания по безопасности и сотрудничеству в Европе (СБСЕ) и в течение более 20 лет концепция общеевропейской системы безопасности и сотрудничества создавалась совместными усилиями всех государствучастников в ходе одобрения консенсусом итоговых документов проводимых в рамках СБСЕ конференций, форумов или совещаний экспертов.

Представители каждого государства имели возможность оказывать реальное влияние на содержание одобряемых документов и тем самым – на формировавшуюся эволюционным путём концепцию европейской безопасности, учитывающую их суверенные права.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
OSCE CP › NATO Bad NB › Avoids NATO Bad---2NC

The OSCE can fully replace NATO’s security role in Europe but avoids exacerbating security dilemmas.

Ejaz Hussain 22, London-based analyst on South-Asian and Middle-Eastern security, “Russia-Ukraine conflict: Can OSCE replace NATO?,” Global Village Space, 3-2-2022,

As predicted, Russia being one of UN’s original P-5 members, used its right of Veto against any probable UNSC Resolution aimed at punishing Kremlin for launching a military operation against Ukraine.

China, another Veto power in UN, customarily stayed away from the US-led club in the Security Council.