Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Affirmative
Emerging Tech Innovation Aff › 1AC (Overhighlighted) › 1AC — RMA Advantage

The NATO Innovation Fund (NIF) and defense innovation accelerator (DIANA) are good first steps, but additional U.S. support is key to actualize their benefits.

Nelson 21 — Nicholas Nelson, Non-Resident Senior Fellow for Emerging Tech and Policy with the Transatlantic Defense and Security Program at the Center for European Policy Analysis, Senior Technology Advisor at the Georgia Tech Research Institute, 2021 (“Getting NATO Innovation Right,” Center for European Policy Analysis, June 18th, Available Online at https://cepa.org/getting-nato-innovation-right/, Accessed 07-03-2022)

The Defense Innovation Accelerator and NATO Innovation Fund announced at the NATO Summit are welcome developments, but they require new authorities and differentiated talent.

Swift technological change has meant governments and the military created new organizations and approaches to innovation and rapid acquisition. Unfortunately, many do not have the necessary authority, budget, or workforce to succeed, meaning that meaningful change and impact have been sacrificed for theater. For the newly announced Defense Innovation Accelerator North Atlantic (DIANA) – with planned locations in Toronto and Cambridge, UK – and the NATO Innovation Fund (NIF) to succeed, they must address authority and budget concerns, and then bring in the right personnel to lead and staff them.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Emerging Tech Innovation Aff › 1AC (Overhighlighted) › 1AC — RMA Advantage

NATO deterrence prevents global hotspot escalation and great power war.

Dowd 22 — Alan W. Dowd, Senior Fellow in the Center for America's Purpose at the Sagamore Institute—a think tank, Senior Fellow at the Fraser Institute and the American Security Council Foundation, Contributing Editor and Columnist at the American Legion Magazine, former Adjunct Professor of American Foreign Policy at Butler University and Anderson University, 2022 (“Putin’s war, NATO’s unity, Ukraine’s valor,” American Legion Magazine, March 15th, Available Online at https://www.legion.org/landingzone/255256/putin%E2%80%99s-war-nato%E2%80%99s-unity-ukraine%E2%80%99s-valor, Accessed 04-04-2022)

[*** Note: 9/11 refers to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks against the United States; 11/9 refers to the November 9, 1989 fall of the Berlin Wall.]

Vladimir Putin’s “unprovoked, unjustified, unconscionable war” has taken thousands of lives, destroyed much of Ukraine’s modern infrastructure and ancient landmarks, and created the largest tidal wave of refugees in Europe since World War II. Yet amidst all these horrors, there’s a flicker of hope: The NATO alliance is more united than at any time since 9/11 – and more important than at any time since 11/9. This is the very opposite of what Putin expected.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Emerging Tech Innovation Aff › 1AC (Overhighlighted) › 1AC — RMA Advantage

NATO EDT superiority will cement effective deterrence — quickly getting innovative tech to the battlefield is key.

Hodges 21 — Ben Hodges, Pershing Chair in Strategic Studies at the Center for European Policy Analysis, Retired Lieutenant General in the U.S. Army where he served as Commanding General of the United States Army Europe, Senior Associate Fellow at the Royal United Services Institute for Defense and Security Studies (UK), 2021 (“Defense Technologies… for What? Speed, Speed, Speed!,” Center for European Policy Analysis, February 17th, Available Online at https://cepa.org/defense-technologies-for-what-speed-speed-speed/, Accessed 07-10-2022)

Giving our armed forces the proper technologies to perform their mission will ultimately ensure that deterrence never fails.

The key to effective deterrence for the transatlantic alliance is speed: speed of recognition of the Kremlin’s malign activities; speed of decision to start necessary deployments, movements and related activities; and speed of assembly to move faster than the Kremlin to pre-empt attacks and signal our preparedness to act. Fortunately, a wide range of new technologies are emerging and evolving that can improve speed, if they are properly integrated into our armed forces and into our plans.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Emerging Tech Innovation Aff › 1AC (Overhighlighted) › 1AC — RMA Advantage

Failing to maintain NATO’s technological superiority will cause great power nuclear war — out-competing Russia and China in the EDT RMA is key.

Kroenig 21 — Matthew Kroenig, Professor in the Department of Government and the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, Director of the Global Strategy Initiative and Deputy Director of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council, former Special Government Employee and Senior Policy Adviser to the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, Plans, and Capability/Nuclear and Missile Defense Policy at the U.S. Department of Defense, former Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, holds a Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of California-Berkeley, 2021 (“Will Emerging Technology Cause Nuclear War?: Bringing Geopolitics Back In,” Strategic Studies Quarterly, Volume 15, Issue 4, Winter, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via EBSCO Open Access Journals, p. 64-70)

[*** Note: 4IR = “The world is experiencing a fourth industrial revolution (4IR) in which a wave of new and transformative technologies is being developed, including artificial intelligence (AI), additive manufacturing, quantum information technology, hypersonic missiles, biotechnology, and directed energy.4 While these technologies are expected to have profound implications for societies and economies, most are dual use and will also affect national security, including nuclear strategic stability.” (p. 59) ***]

New Tech Arms Race

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Politics Disadvantage › Politics DA Link – 1NC

There are political hurdles to effective interoperability of AI in NATO.

Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)

On that note NATO, or any other international organization, is not exempt from these political hurdles. As EDTs increasingly become a focal point in the geopolitical space, any approach of AI governance in the international security environment will have global political undertones. This will undoubtedly be a significant hurdle for NATO as it balances responsible AI development and Allied coordination and cooperation in a changing geopolitical landscape. And certainly, the political realities may well represent the greatest challenge and disincentivize NATO to emerge as a leader in responsible military AI. Nevertheless, the three pillars indicate that NATO is an institution with considerable opportunity to shape responsible AI governance. More specifically, this entails urging and facilitating Allied standards and policies to establish foundations for emerging military technology built on informed and ethical principles and enhance the international security environment.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Cooperation on Ethical AI Will Fail

Transatlantic cooperation on the ethical use of AI will fail.

Ulrike Franke, 2021 (Senior Policy Fellow, European Council on Foreign Relations), ARTIFICIAL DIVIDE: HOW EUROPE AND AMERICA COULD CLASH OVER AI. Jan. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from https://ecfr.eu/publication/artificial-divide-how-europe-and-america-could-clash-over-ai/

Like-minded democratic states share an interest in guaranteeing that AI is developed and used in accordance with liberal democratic values. Both the US and Europe say they want to ensure that everyone can benefit equally from AI, and that competition does not create incentives that lead to an undercutting of standards. However, despite these shared interests, transatlantic cooperation on ethical AI may not be as easy as it first appears.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Don’t Build It In the First Place

An AI arms race leads to World War III.

Lyle J. Goldstein, 2/1/2019 (Research Professor in the China Maritime Studies Institute (CMSI) at the United States Naval War College, “China's Olive Branch to Save the World from AI Weapons,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)

Unlike most defense analysts, who are content to passively observe this process, these authors contend that the intensifying arms race in lethal AI systems constitutes a “Pandora’s box [魔盒]” that could lead the world to “the apocalypse [终结时代].” Great Western thinkers and innovators from Stephen Hawking [霍金] to Elon Musk [马斯克] are cited. It is indeed noted that Musk warned in fall 2017 that an AI arms race could even be the spark for World War III. Western experts may smirk at a Chinese argument that involves discussion of human rights, but Xu and Ge articulate concern that targeted killings by drones violate a “person’s right to a fair trial.” Moreover, they view the characteristics of such robotic systems as lacking in emotion or ethical reasoning and having “psychological distance [心里的距离]” that will lead invariably to “massacres and such humanitarian disasters [滥杀等人道主义灾难].” Illustrating the important point that Chinese defense scientists are also increasingly perturbed by the possibility escalation in an AI strategic environment, Xu and Ge evince the concern that AI weaponry “significantly lowers the threshold of war [这极大降低了战争的门槛].”

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Don’t Build It In the First Place

The development of AI leads to an AI arms race around the globe—the best hope is to stop it in its tracks.

Mike Thomas, 2021 (staff reporter), BUILTIN. July 6, 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Not everyone agrees with Musk that AI is more dangerous than nukes, including Ford. But what if AI decides to launch nukes — or, say, biological weapons — sans human intervention? Or, what if an enemy manipulates data to return AI-guided missiles whence they came? Both are possibilities. And both would be disastrous. The more than 30,000 AI/robotics researchers and others who signed an open letter on the subject in 2015 certainly think so. “The key question for humanity today is whether to start a global AI arms race or to prevent it from starting,” they wrote. “If any major military power pushes ahead with AI weapon development, a global arms race is virtually inevitable, and the endpoint of this technological trajectory is obvious: autonomous weapons will become the Kalashnikovs of tomorrow. Unlike nuclear weapons, they require no costly or hard-to-obtain raw materials, so they will become ubiquitous and cheap for all significant military powers to mass-produce. It will only be a matter of time until they appear on the black market and in the hands of terrorists, dictators wishing to better control their populace, warlords wishing to perpetrate ethnic cleansing, etc. Autonomous weapons are ideal for tasks such as assassinations, destabilizing nations, subduing populations and selectively killing a particular ethnic group. We therefore believe that a military AI arms race would not be beneficial for humanity. There are many ways in which AI can make battlefields safer for humans, especially civilians, without creating new tools for killing people.”

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Don’t Build It In the First Place

The best way to stop AI is to not build it in the first place.

Kai Kupferschmidt, 2018 (contributing correspondent for Science magazine), SCIENCE. Jan. 11, 2018. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Pinker thinks the scenarios reveal more about human obsessions than real risks. We are drawn to prospects "that are highly improbable while having big impacts on our fitness, such as illicit sex, violent death, and Walter-Mittyish feats of glory," he writes. "Apocalyptic storylines are undoubtedly gripping—they are a supernormal stimulus for our morbid obsessions." Sure, he says, one can imagine a malevolent, powerful AI that people can no longer control. "The way to deal with this threat is straightforward: Don't build one." Tallinn argues it's better to be safe than sorry. A 2017 survey showed that 34% of AI experts believed the risks associated with their work are an important problem; 5% said they are "one of the most important problems." "Imagine you're on a plane, and 40% of experts think that there is a bomb on this plane," Tallinn says. "You're not going to wait for the remaining experts to be convinced."

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

AI decision-making is more difficult to challenge.

Ulrike Franke, 2021 (Senior Policy Fellow, European Council on Foreign Relations), ARTIFICIAL DIVIDE: HOW EUROPE AND AMERICA COULD CLASH OVER AI. Jan. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from https://ecfr.eu/publication/artificial-divide-how-europe-and-america-could-clash-over-ai/

Related to concerns about bias are those about the transparency of how AI works. Employing machine-learning methods means that systems are no longer programmed - namely, told what to do by human beings - but instead learn how to behave either by themselves or under human supervision. It is difficult for a human to understand and track how an AI-enabled system has reached a conclusion. This makes it hard to challenge AI-enabled decisions, and to tell whether malicious actors have exploited the vulnerabilities of AI systems.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

AI will evolve beyond our control.

Mark Stockley, 2015 (writer for Sophos), ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE COULD MAKE US EXTINCT, WARN OXFORD UNIVERSITY RESEARCHERS. Feb. 17, 2015. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

AI is included, along with nanotechnology and synthetic biology, in a category of emerging risks. The emerging risks are poorly understood but also have the potential to solve many of the other problems on the list. The threat of AI comes from its potential to run away from us – it’s just possible that AI will end up working on itself and evolve beyond our understanding and control.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

Superintelligence is not controllable.

Manuel Alfonseca, et al, 2021 (Escuela Politécnica Superior, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain), JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

A superintelligence poses a fundamentally different problem than those typically studied under the banner of “robot ethics”. This is because a superintelligence is multi-faceted, and therefore potentially capable of mobilizing a diversity of resources in order to achieve objectives that are potentially incomprehensible to humans, let alone controllable.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

A super-intelligent AI is uncontrollable.

Robby Berman, 2021 (political analyst), THE FUTURE. Jan. 20, 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

There have been a fair number of voices—Stephen Hawking among them—raised in warning that a super-intelligent artificial intelligence could one day turn on us and that we shouldn’t be in such a hot, unquestioning hurry to develop true AI. Others say, naw, don’t worry. Now a new white paper from scientists at the Center for Humans and Machines at the Max Planck Institute for Human Development presents a series of theoretical tests that confirm the threat: Due to the basic concepts underlying computing, we would be utterly unable to control a super-intelligent AI. “We argue that total containment is, in principle, impossible, due to fundamental limits inherent to computing itself,” write the paper’s authors.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

Artificial Intelligence can’t be controlled.

Robby Berman, 2021 (political analyst), THE FUTURE. Jan. 20, 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Artificial intelligence that's smarter than us could potentially solve problems beyond our grasp. AI that are self-learning can absorb whatever information they need from the internet, a Pandora's Box if ever there was one. The nature of computing itself prevents us from limiting the actions of a super-intelligent AI if it gets out of control.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

It is impossible to contain a rogue AI.

Manuel Alfonseca, et al, 2021 (Escuela Politécnica Superior, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain), JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Superintelligence is a hypothetical agent that possesses intelligence far surpassing that of the brightest and most gifted human minds. In light of recent advances in machine intelligence, a num-ber of scientists, philosophers and technologists have revived the discussion about the potentially catastrophic risks entailed by such an entity. In this article, we trace the origins and development of the neo-fear of superintelligence, and some of the major proposals for its containment. We argue that total containment is, in principle, impossible, due to fundamental limits inherent to comput¬ing itself. Assuming that a superintelligence will contain a program that includes all the programs that can be executed by a universal Turing machine on input potentially as complex as the state of the world, strict containment requires simulations of such a program, something theoretically (and practically) impossible.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

Humans can’t compete with artificial superintelligence.

Ben Ashman, 2019 (multimedia journalist), WHEN AI GOES WRONG: WHAT HAPPENS WHEN MACHINES GO ROGUE? July 24, 2019. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Artificial superintelligence (ASI) has the potential to be incredibly powerful and poses many questions as to how we appropriately manage it. In an interview with the BBC, Stephen Hawking said that ASI would “take off on its own, and re-design itself at an ever-increasing rate. Humans, who are limited by slow biological evolution, couldn’t compete and would be superseded.”

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

Efforts to contain rogue AI are impossible.

Robby Berman, 2021 (political analyst), THE FUTURE. Jan. 20, 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

The most obvious way to keep a super intelligent AI from getting ahead of us is to limit its access to information by preventing it from connecting to the internet. The problem with limiting access to information, though, is that it would make any problem we assign the AI more difficult for it to solve. We would be weakening its problem-solving promise possibly to a point of uselessness. The second approach that might be taken is to limit what a super-intelligent AI is capable of doing by programming into it certain boundaries. This might be akin to writer Isaac Asimov’s Laws of Robotics, the first of which goes: “A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.” Unfortunately, says the study, a series of logical tests reveal that it’s impossible to create such limits. Any such a containment algorithm, it turns out, would be self-defeating. “If you break the problem down to basic rules from theoretical computer science, it turns out that an algorithm that would command an AI not to destroy the world could inadvertently halt its own operations. If this happened, you would not know whether the containment algorithm is still analyzing the threat, or whether it has stopped to contain the harmful AI. In effect, this makes the containment algorithm unusable.” The team investigated stacking containment algorithms, with each monitoring the behavior of the previous one, but eventually the same problem arises: The final check halts itself, rendering it unreliable.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

AI designed to solve the world’s problems cannot be contained.

Manuel Alfonseca, et al, 2021 (Escuela Politécnica Superior, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain), JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Interestingly, reduced versions of the decidability problem have produced a fruitful area of re-search: formal verification, whose objective is to produce techniques to verify the correctness of computer programs and ensure they satisfy desirable properties (Vardi & Wolper, 1986). However, these techniques are only available to highly restricted classes of programs and inputs, and have been used in safety-critical applications such as train scheduling. But the approach of considering restricted classes of programs and inputs cannot be useful to the containment of superintelligence. Superintelligent machines, those Bostrom is interested in, are written in Turing-complete program¬ming languages, are equipped with powerful sensors, and have the state of the world as their input. This seems unavoidable if we are to program machines to help us with the hardest problems facing society, such as epidemics, poverty, and climate change. These problems forbid the limitations im¬posed by available formal verification techniques, rendering those techniques unusable at this grand scale.

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

AI risks human extinction and it can’t be controlled.

Mark Stockley, 2015 (writer for Sophos), ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE COULD MAKE US EXTINCT, WARN OXFORD UNIVERSITY RESEARCHERS. Feb. 17, 2015. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Researchers at Oxford University have produced the first list of global risks ‘that pose a threat to human civilisation, or even possibly to all human life.’ The report focuses on risks with ‘impacts that for all practical purposes can be called infinite’. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is on it. And while human extinction might be a horrific, accidental side effect of climate change, a metorite impact or a super volcano, the report warns that AI might decide to cause our extinction deliberately (my emphasis): ...extreme intelligences could not easily be controlled (either by the groups creating them, or by some international regulatory regime), and would probably act to boost their own intelligence and acquire maximal resources for almost all initial AI motivations. And if these motivations do not detail the survival and value of humanity, the intelligence will be driven to construct a world without humans. This makes extremely intelligent AIs a unique risk, in that extinction is more likely than lesser impacts. [ellipses in original].

2022 SDI Negative
Disadvantages › Rogue AI Disadvantage › Impact – Can’t Be Controlled

Attempts to control AI will backfire and risk extinction of the human race.

Manuel Alfonseca, et al, 2021 (Escuela Politécnica Superior, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain), JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH. 2021. Retrieved May 18, 2022 from

Bostrom extensively discusses the weaknesses of the various mechanisms. He relies on sce-narios in which, short of rendering the AI useless, well-intentioned control mechanisms can easily backfire. As an illustrative example, a superintelligence given the task of “maximizing happiness in the world,” without deviating from its goal, might find it more efficient to destroy all life on earth and create faster-computerized simulations of happy thoughts. Likewise, a superintelligence con-trolled via an incentive method may not trust humans to deliver the promised reward, or may worry that the human operator could fail to recognize the achievement of the set goals.