What role for the United Nations? In his address to the General Assembly in September 2018, UN Secretary-General António Guterres warned that ‘multilateralism is under fire precisely when we need it most’. But among the many pressing problems that call for a multilateral approach to be properly addressed, he highlighted two ‘epochal challenges’ in particular: climate change, which is of course of great concern but not covered in this article, and risks associated with advances in technology. Indeed, ‘rapidly developing fields such as artificial intelligence, blockchain and biotechnology have the potential to turbocharge progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals’, Guterres said. On the other hand, new technologies also present serious perils along the way, from mass economic unemployment to cybercrime and malicious use of digital tools.35 Guterres cautioned against the weaponization of AI and the possibility of a dangerous arms race in this domain, including the development of lethal autonomous weapons systems, going so far as to contend that ‘the prospect of machines with the discretion and power to take human life is morally repugnant’. Less oversight over these weapons could severely compromise efforts to contain threats, prevent escalation, and ensure compliance with international humanitarian and human rights law. He urged Member States ‘to use the United Nations as a platform to draw global attention to these crucial matters and to nurture a digital future that is safe and beneficial for all’. To lead by example and engage the UN Secretariat in this enterprise, the SecretaryGeneral launched his own Strategy on New Technologies, with the objective of defining how the UN system will support the use of these technologies to accelerate the achievement of the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda and to facilitate their alignment with the values enshrined in the UN Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the norms and standards of international law. Among the pledges and commitments to pursue this strategy were deepening the UN’s internal capacities and exposure to emerging technologies; increasing understanding, advocacy, and dialogue; supporting dialogue on normative and cooperation frameworks; and enhancing UN system support to government capacity development. 37 In the same vein, the High-Level Panel on Digital Cooperation was established by the Secretary-General in 2017 to promote dialogue and look into proposals to build trust and cooperation between countries and other stakeholders, the private sector, research centers, civil society, and academia. In its report, released in June 2019, the Panel envisaged several potential roles for the UN to add value in the digital transformation: as a convener; providing a space for debating values and norms; generating standard setting; holding multi-stakeholder or bilateral initiatives on specific issues; developing the capacity of Member States; ranking, mapping, and measuring cybersecurity; and making available arbitration and dispute-resolution mechanisms. The report put forward various recommendations, such as adopting by 2020 a ‘Global Commitment for Digital Cooperation’ to consolidate in a single political document shared values, principles, understandings, and objectives regarding the governance of cyberspace. Also, it did not shy away from making principled statements of ethical significance, the stipulation that ‘life and death decisions should not be delegated to machines’ being a case in point.38 Most of the UN initiatives on new technologies are focused upon the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals, such as the annual ECOSOC’s Science, Technology, and Innovation Forum, which had its fourth edition in May 2019. On the AI front, the flagship UN platform for global dialogue with the wider public is the AI for Good Global Summit, hosted every year in Geneva by the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) in partnership with other UN agencies, the XPrize Foundation (organization offering incentivize prize competitions) and the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM).39 This interdisciplinary event brings together speakers from governments, industry, academia, media, and the research community to discuss how AI can be utilized to achieve inter alia results in ending poverty, alleviating hunger, promoting health, and identifying development solutions. The UN Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICRI) established in 2017 a Center for Artificial Intelligence and Robotics in The Hague, with the aim of disseminating information, undertaking training activities, and promoting public awareness. The Center has notably been active in cybercrime, law enforcement, criminal justice, counter-terrorism, and malicious use of AI.40 Also important is UNESCO’s humanistic approach on ethics, policy, and capacity building in response to new emerging challenges related to AI technologies, including philosophical reflections on what it means to be human in the face of disruptive technologies from the ethical perspective. 41 The New York-based Centre for Policy Research of the United Nations University (UNU) has been conducting foresight analyses, developing collaborative research projects with external partners, and convening policy seminars and events. In 2018, the Centre launched an on-line platform on AI and Global Governance to foster cross-disciplinary insights and ‘inform existing debates from the lens of multilateralism’, as a tool for Member States, multilateral agencies, funds, programs, and other stakeholders.42 The UN Institute for Disarmament Research (UNIDIR) has a research project on the weaponization of increasingly autonomous technologies since 2013, anchored in the idea that mitigating or reducing potential harms caused by AI will be crucial to harness ‘AI for Good’. 43 More broadly, UNIDIR’s objectives in studying the relationship between AI and international security aim at further clarifying functional concerns in the development and future deployment of autonomous weapons systems, including the risk of accidents; manipulation and other vulnerabilities in weaponization; changes in the nature of conflict and their impact upon strategic stability; commercial development of AI-related technologies and its links with the defense industry; access to sensitive technologies and their use to conduct asymmetric warfare; and the structural effects of the AI revolution on geopolitics and power dynamics in the international system.44 In turn, the UN Office for Disarmament Affairs (UNODA), both in New York and in Geneva, has been working to implement the Secretary-General’s Agenda for Disarmament (Securing Our Common Future), which includes the consideration of possible challenges posed by new weapon technologies. One of the action points of the Agenda seeks to support efforts by Member States ‘to elaborate new measures, including through political or legally binding arrangements, to ensure that humans remain at all times in control over the use of force’.45 Other initiatives include the UN Innovation Network, connecting a collaborative community of innovators within the UN System, as well as a myriad of projects developed by UN agencies to apply AI tools in their daily practice in the field Despite the relative lack of clarity on the way forward, the future role of the UN will be inextricably linked to the global governance of AI. Research and policy proposals on this topic are beginning to shed light upon the likelihood of international cooperation on transformative AI-related issues, incentives needed for the parties to reach meaningful agreements, proper conditions for compliance, and costs of defection or unilateral, non-cooperative measures. 46 Proposals range from informal mechanisms in narrowly-focused domains to much more ambitious, institutionalized forums, such as the establishment of an international regulatory agency, to be named, for example, the ‘International Artificial Intelligence Organization’ (IAIO), aimed at setting standards and benchmarks across numerous areas to be regulated. However, even the proponents of such broad-spectrum organization concede that reaching a workable international consensus on this idea seems rather a remote possibility in the short term. 47 Another proposition to consider is creating a new body modeled on the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) to provide policymakers with technical, neutral assessments, subject to review by states, underlining the opportunities, implications, and potential risks of AI, always through evidence-based research by the tech and scientific communities.48 A case can be made for an ‘Intergovernmental Panel on Artificial Intelligence’ (IPAI), as Miailhe did, to gather a large interdisciplinary group of experts with a mandate to collect, organize, and analyze credible and up-to-date information on AI challenges. 49 As technologies become more and more sophisticated and indecipherable to the layman, sound technical advice will be in high demand if intergovernmental negotiations are to be launched to tackle these thorny issues, separating myth, hype, and misinformation from what is in tune with the body of evidence and human knowledge available so far. Politicians obviously have no need to know technicalities about reinforcement learning, multilayer perceptrons, convolutional neural networks, or Boltzmann machines. But as AI puzzles and their impact upon society become increasingly relevant in the real world, AI researchers cannot deny that suitable communication with the political leadership will be of paramount importance to guide decisionmaking in the right direction. One key challenge is to keep the major players engaged, so that AI governance can be instrumental in providing stability to safeguard the system in everyone’s interest. Even though some proposals may require more time for maturation, others could be implemented in a more straightforward manner, without the need for a fully-fledged, previous commitment from governments on the parameters and preconditions deemed appropriate for establishing new criteria at the international level. Advisory and non-binding settings involving states, the private sector, and civil society could be a first step if focused upon information gathering, independent analyses, and recommendations geared at prevention rather than regulation per se. Traditional, institutionally-based intergovernmental diplomacy seems too slow if compared with the staggering pace of technological innovation. Informal, ad-hoc, plurilateral initiatives spurred by some like-minded countries (‘coalitions of the willing’) may at times promote added value in governance, but they usually lack universal appeal and raise suspicious of their agendas in the eyes of states left outside these groups. A better solution to escape shortterm paralysis [immobilization] is for the UN, with the authority and legitimacy conferred to it by Member States, to take the lead and offer a collective space, open to all, strictly voluntary, to encourage cooperation and work on prevention, capacity-building, and normative recommendations. A good example along these lines would be the creation of a ‘Global Foresight Observatory’ on the convergence of AI with other emerging technologies, under the auspices of the UN, as envisaged in the report of UNU’s Centre for Policy Research, i.e. a multi-stakeholder, inclusive platform to foster cooperation in technological and political preparedness for responsive innovation.50 This sort of initiative fits well with what the UN can do even in hardknock situations. Trying to be too ambitious from the very beginning may backlash and lead nowhere. It is essential not to allow resistance from becoming lethargic and continue exploring alternatives to take concrete steps in AI governance in a robust and comprehensive manner.