2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Tech Leadership CP › AT: Tech Leadership CP
Alonso, Kothari, and Rehman 20 — Cristian Alonso, Economist in the IMF’s Fiscal Affairs Department, Siddharth Kothari, Economist in the IMF’s Asia and Pacific Department, Sidra Rehman, Economist in the IMF’s Middle East and Central Asia Department, 2020 (“How Artificial Intelligence Could Widen the Gap Between Rich and Poor Nations,” International Monetary Fund Blog, December 2nd, Available Online at , Accessed 07-23-2022)
Improvements in the productivity of robots drive divergence between advanced and developing countries if robots substitute easily for workers. In addition, those improvements will tend to increase incomes but also increase income inequality, at least during the transition and possibly in the long run for some groups of workers, in both advanced and developing economies.
There is no silver bullet for averting divergence. Given the fast pace of the robot revolution, developing countries need to invest in raising aggregate productivity and skill levels more urgently than ever before, so that their labor force is complemented rather than substituted by robots. Of course, this is easier said than done. In our model, increases in total factor productivity—which account for the many institutional and other fundamental differences between developing and advanced countries not captured by labor and capital inputs—are especially beneficial as they incentivize more robots and physical capital accumulation. Such improvements are always beneficial, but the gains are stronger in the context of the artificial intelligence revolution.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Space Wars CP › AT: Space Wars CP
NBC News 21 (6/14/2021, )
“We will make it clear at this summit that, of course, any attack on space capabilities like satellites and so on or attacks from space will or could trigger Article 5,” he said, a few hours before chairing a summit with U.S. President Joe Biden and his counterparts. Around 2,000 satellites orbit the earth, over half operated by NATO countries, ensuring everything from mobile phone and banking services to weather forecasts. Military commanders rely on some of them to navigate, communicate, share intelligence and detect missile launches. In December 2019, NATO leaders declared space to be the alliance’s “fifth domain” of operations, after land, sea, air and cyberspace. Many member countries are concerned about what they say is increasingly aggressive behavior in space by China and Russia.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Russia CP › AT: Russia CP---NFU
Rebeccah L. Heinrichs 20, senior fellow at Hudson Institute specializing in US national defense policy, Reject 'No First Use' Nuclear Policy, No Publication, 6-30-2020,
The reality is that every single American president, Democrat and Republican alike, has rejected an NFU declaration because to do so would invite unacceptable risk that could yield catastrophic war—and for no tangible benefit at all.
This is true for four reasons.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Russia CP › AT: Russia CP---Hotlines
Ajeet Kumar 22, US sets up hotline with Russia to prevent any ‘miscalculation’ over Ukraine crisis: Report, Republic World, 03-05-2022,
"What we’ve seen repeatedly is that Russia goes through the pretense of diplomacy to distract and continue on its aggressive path," Blinken had told reporters on Wednesday. "If we determine that there are areas that it’s in our interest to continue to pursue that may involve some engagement for Russia, we’ll continue to pursue that,” he said, adding however that “we’re not going to let Russia dictate in any way what’s in our interests and how to pursue it." Irrespective of the US take on Russia a week earlier, the fresh move has shown some ray of hope during this tough time where both countries seem pledged not to abandon their plan without achieving success.
Biden and Putin have not spoken for more than 24 days now
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Meltdowns CP › AT: Meltdowns CP---No Solvency
David Schlissel, 2-17-2022, IEEFA director of resource planning analysis, "IEEFA U.S.: Small modular reactor “too late, too expensive, too risky and too uncertain”," IEEFA, - Crossings BY
A small modular reactor (SMR) that NuScale has been developing since the turn of the century is “too late, too expensive, too risky and too uncertain,” according to of the project by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
The first-of-its-kind SMR is a serious financial threat to the member communities of the Utah Associated Municipal Power System that have signed up for a share of its power and to any other communities and utilities thinking about doing so. NuScale has optimistically targeted the cost of power from the new plant at $58 per megawatt-hour (MWh), although some estimates predict costs for the power from new SMRs could reach $200/MWh.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Meltdowns CP › AT: Meltdowns CP---No Solvency
Arjun Makhijani, 3-25-2021, president of the Institute for Energy and Environmental Research, "Why Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Won’t Help Counter the Climate Crisis," Environmental Working Group, CROSSINGS BY
Small modular nuclear reactors, or SMRs, are designed to generate less than 300 megawatts of electricity – several times less than typical reactors, which have a range of 1,000 to 1,600 MW. While the individual standardized modules would be small, plans typically call for several modules to be installed at a single power generation site.
The nuclear industry and the U. S. Department of Energy are promoting the development of SMRs, supposedly to head off the most severe impacts of climate change. But are SMRs a practical and realistic technology for this purpose?
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Grid CP › AT: Grid CP
Carder 22[James, Chief Security Officer at LogRhythm, Open Source Code: The Next Major Wave of Cyberattacks, 2/21/2022, ]
Open source software is ubiquitous. It has become an unequaled driver of technological innovation because organizations that use it don't have to reinvent the wheel for common software components.
However, the ubiquity of software also presents a significant security risk, as it opens the door for vulnerabilities to be introduced (intentionally or inadvertently) to the consumers of open source software products. The recent race to address major vulnerabilities in the widely used Log4j code library is the biggest sign yet that risks within the open source software environment must be addressed.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Econ CP › AT: Econ CP
Rosenbaum 22, Eric, 2-14-2022, Senior Editor and Reporter for CNBC, “A new inflation reading shows the small business tipping point has been reached,” CNBC, //BigSasher
Inflation has taken hold of Main Street, with an increasing number of small business owners saying it will not relent over the next six months and raising prices to offset increases in the costs of supplies, according to the latest CNBC|SurveyMonkey Small Business Survey. President Biden’s approval rating is underwater, and though the small business community skews conservative and the vast majority of liberals surveyed continue to support Biden, support among Democrats ticked down this quarter, and confidence in the Federal Reserve’s ability to control inflation is low. The overall CNBC|SurveyMonkey Small Business Confidence Index score continues to hover around all-time lows, though it remained unchanged from Q4 2021. The latest Consumer Price Index reading, the highest in four decades, isn’t the only sign that rather than giving up its hold over the U.S. economy in 2022. An increasing number of American small businesses say they are now passing on higher costs to customers, or soon will be forced to make that decision. While the 74% of small business owners who say they are experiencing rising costs of supplies is virtually unchanged from Q4 2021, according to a new CNBC/SurveyMonkey Small Business Survey, the number of businesses passing on costs to customers has risen to 47% in the first quarter, up from 39% in Q4 2021. And another 32% indicate they will have to raise prices soon if inflation persists. Sticky inflation is their expectation. Over eighty percent of small business owners expect inflation to still be a problem six months from now (55% say that is “very likely”), according to the . The Main Street concerns about inflation are connected to the small business outlook on the supply chain, with 75% saying these issues are likely to be a problem six months from now. And there is a lack of faith in policymakers, with 71% of small business owners not confident in the Federal Reserve’s ability to control inflation. The CNBC/SurveyMonkey online poll was conducted January 24-30, 2022 among a national sample of 2,227 self-identified small business owners. “The underlying problem with inflation is that there’s no end in sight,” said Laura Wronski, senior manager of research science at , which conducts the survey for CNBC. “We’ve become accustomed to rising and falling Covid waves, and businesses have had the time to rewrite their playbooks to accommodate. But no one knows how quickly or to what degree inflation will continue to rise, so that unpredictability is inducing some unease,” she said, with the lack of faith in the Fed adding to the uncertainty. “I don’t think it is getting better. It has gotten worse,” said Michelle Pusateri, owner of San Francisco-based Nana Joes Granola. Nana Joes Granola witnessed a boom in business during Covid as demand for packaged goods skyrocketed, but the business situation has flipped, with the hyper-growth from earlier in the pandemic now overwhelmed by supply chain and pricing issues and its profit margins being squeezed. Nana Joes Granola stocked up on ingredients and bought them at higher volumes to get lower pricing as demand outstripped supply and logistics issues worsened. The loading up on inventory is “more of a stopgap right now,” Pusateri said, but she expects it will probably become a long-term business issue. Her firm held $94,000 of inventory at the end of 2019, but by the end of last year, that had risen to $327,000. “I think more and more businesses will have to sit on more inventory,” Pusateri said. In multiple ways, small business owners have lost leverage with suppliers. Large buyers are favored in transactions, and smaller buyers are no longer able to order in smaller batches (e.g. half-pallets) or rely on contract pricing. “Lots of ingredients are in high demand, meaning farmers and vendors and brokers can name their price. They can wait until the last highest bidder,” said Pusateri, who is a member of the Goldman Sachs 10,000 Small Businesses Voices community. Among that Main Street sample, 84% indicated in that inflation has gotten worse for them since September, and only 13% see supply chain issues subsiding over the first half of 2022. Nana Joes Granola’s main ingredient, oats, has seen a huge spike in price, and Pusateri does not expect any downward pricing pressure given the current level of supply and demand. It’s not just an increase in input costs, but the magnitude of the increase which is walloping smaller companies. Eric Groves, co-founder and CEO at online small business platform Alignable, which has been , pointed to the percentage of businesses that indicate they are seeing the highest level of cost increases. Overall, 78% of small businesses say their costs are above pre-pandemic levels, but the largest block of small businesses (29%) say they are seeing price hikes of 25% or more for their business inputs. All of the headlines about inflation will make it easier for small business owners to increase costs and not have customers react as negatively as they might expect, but while over 50% of businesses are passing along the cost increases to customers, only 9% tell Alignable they can do this at a level where it is above breakeven for them. “Costs have gone up more than their ability to pass it on down, and that’s what is critical to recovery,” Groves said. “That’s where the feeling of stress is coming from. It’s the squeezing of margins, not just revenue ... what’s going in their pocket,” he added. It is a fraught situation for small businesses trying to figure out how much they can afford to charge without risking a decline in customer numbers and loss of recurring revenue, with many small businesses still not all the way back from Covid’s shock. Alignable’s data finds roughly 35%-37% of businesses saying that 90% or more of their customers from the pre-Covid period have returned. Small business owners tend to be optimistic by nature, but Alignable’s data shows them more pessimistic now about their own recovery timelines. Last June, small business owners expected revenue to be back at pre-Covid levels midway through 2022. Now that has been pushed back by a full year to mid-2023. Pusateri says inflation is beginning to eat into demand for her company’s granola, which is priced at the premium end of the product category. “People are starting to look at what they are spending on. For us, it’s more of people starting to really look at pocketbooks,” she said. NFIB’s found the percentage of small business owners having to increase prices rising to over 60%, the highest reading in the NFIB data since Q4 1974. “They are getting squeezed by supply chain disruptions and inflation and workforce shortages and already had to reinvent themselves a few times over in the past few years, and are running out of options,” said Kevin Kuhlmann, who leads the NFIB’s government relations team. “They are continuing to adapt ... but you can only increase prices so much before you might see a loss,” he said. Nana Joes Granola accessed a Covid economic injury disaster loan from the Small Business Administration to fund its higher level of inventory buying, but that financing program ended in 2021, and there is no indication the federal government will reinstate it. Pusateri said she is now being forced to contemplate business loans or taking on investors, a move she has not had to make previously. “There aren’t many policy options for issues like inflation and the supply chain,” Kuhlmann said. And even if inflation is tamed, that does not mean prices will go down. “It’s sort of a new normal,” he said. “You want to slow down price increases. It’s frustrating business owners.” Small business does tend to be a lagging rather than a leading indicator for the economy, but the growing worries on Main Street are “a worrisome indication that inflation will be more persistent,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Analytics. “Their pricing decisions tend to lag their bigger competitors, so if small businesses are raising prices more aggressively it could signal inflation becoming more endemic,” Zandi said. And since small businesses do not tend to think of themselves as having pricing power over the long-term, if they are “becoming more emboldened” it is an indication that inflationary pressures are broader-based, he added. The CNBC/SurveyMonkey Small Business Confidence Index score continues to hover around all-time lows, holding at 44 out of 100, which was unchanged from Q4 2021 and nearly identical to the all-time low score of 43 from a year ago. Overall, the business outlook is mixed, with 46% of Main Street businesses saying they expect revenue to increase in the next 12 months, according to the CNBC|SurveyMonkey data. Politics is a factor, with only 33% of business owners saying conditions are “good,” equal to the 33% of business owners who say they support President Biden. The percentage of Democrats who expressed support for Biden remains very high, at 83%, but did decline this quarter by six percentage points. Just under half (49%) of Democratic small business owners described conditions as good. A majority of Democrats expect inflation to still be a problem six months from now (67%) but that is considerably less than the 92% of Republicans who see inflation sticking around. And Democrats are much more likely to believe the Fed can control inflation, at 61%, versus 11% of Republicans surveyed. Certain sectors within the small business community that are more exposed to the global supply chain are facing greater pressures, and there are positive indicators across the business landscape. As a whole, companies are doing a good job of passing through costs to customers with corporate profit margins as wide as they’ve ever been back to World War II, but the benefits of pricing power are accruing more to the largest corporations. Small businesses do not typically have high cash reserve levels — according to Alignable it is on average 34 days of cash on hand — leading to a situation in which any kind of financial hit is very difficult to recover from. “So as they are trying to build back to recovery from Covid, every little bit of extra margin they can eke out is critical, and with cost increases and the inability to pass along, we will see more and more businesses struggling with that,” Groves said. A key measure of business health, business-to-business payment transactions, isn’t showing any signs of stress, with even companies of 500 employees or less paying bills on time. “At least so far, they are managing,” Zandi said. Small businesses sentiment, similar to consumer sentiment, tends to be reactive and based on the most recent information or anecdote rather than longer-term forecasting, which means that current gas and fuel prices, which can be major inputs for small businesses, can lead to a sharper shift in sentiment in the short-term. On Monday, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York released an inflation survey that showed in over a year, though still near a record level. But Zandi said if nothing else, the latest data from Main Street is “proof positive we have a problem.” Pusateri described herself as “a lot less confident now” after having made it through Covid, and even having seen hyper-growth during the earlier part of the pandemic. “I thought getting through 2020, ‘oh my god, we did it.’ We were still profitable. And then, all of a sudden, I couldn’t find ingredients.” Nana Joes Granola went from 135% profit growth during the packaged foods boom to currently operating at less than breakeven in a pricing environment hitting it from all sides. In addition to the supply issues, wage inflation and lack of leverage as a buyer, freight charges across the country have risen and the company has had to change its free shipping policy for its direct consumer business. “We’re getting steamrolled over. Everywhere I look getting price increases,” Pusateri said. The financial market and economists including Zandi expect inflation will moderate later in 2022, but if it doesn’t happen soon, he said, “the small business owners will be right.” “I don’t think inflation is going away any time soon,” Pusateri said. “We will be stuck in this.”
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Econ CP › AT: Econ CP
Berkshire and Schneider 22, Jennifer C. and Jack, 3-21-2022, Ms. Berkshire, a journalist, and Mr. Schneider, a professor at the University of Massachusetts Lowell, have written extensively about public education. "If You Think Republicans Are Overplaying Schools, You Aren’t Paying Attention," NY Times, //BigSasher
Today, as the middle class falls further behind the wealthy, the belief in education as the sole remedy for economic inequality appears more and more misguided. And yet, because Democrats have spent the past 30 years framing schooling as the surest route to the good life, any attempt to make our education system fairer is met with fierce resistance from affluent liberals worried that Democratic reforms might threaten their carefully laid plans to help their children get ahead.
In California, plans to place less emphasis on calculus in an effort to address persistent racial and socioeconomic disparities in math achievement have spawned furious backlash. So, too, did the announcement last fall that New York City schools would be winding down their gifted and talented program, which has been widely criticized for exacerbating segregation — an announcement that Mayor Eric Adams has begun to walk back.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: China CP › AT: China CP
Ben Wolfgang 20, covers the Pentagon, military and foreign affairs for The Washington Times, 'Hotline' between U.S., China feared as strategic attack tool, AP NEWS, 8-5-2020, https://apnews.com/article/foreign-policy-china-archive-mark-esper-cold-war-7a6aac96de971f69f1e41099ab132b88/shppp
In 21st century conflict, even the crisis hotline could become a weapon of war.
There are growing fears among foreign policy specialists and military and intelligence officials that any new crisis communication systems with China updated, tactical-level versions of the cliched “red phone” between Washington and Moscow at the height of the Cold War could themselves become strategic tools of attack or deception.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Bioterrorism CP › AT: Bioterrorism CP
McNeil 18 — Donald G. McNeil Jr., science and health reporter specializing in plagues and pestilences, 2018 (“Why Don’t We Have Vaccines Against Everything?,” New York Times, November 19th, Available Online at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/19/health/vaccines-poverty.html, Accessed 07-23-2022)
Vaccines are among the most ingenious of inventions, and among the most maddening.
Some global killers, like smallpox and polio, have been totally or nearly eradicated by products made with methods dating back to Louis Pasteur. Others, like malaria and H.I.V., utterly frustrate scientists to this day, despite astonishing new weapons like gene-editing.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Baltic War CP › AT: BALTBAT CP
Vaiksnoras 2, Vitalijus, 2000-2002, Major General of the Lithuanian Armed Forces and Lithuanian Military Representative to NATO and EU, “The Role of Baltic Defence Co-operation for the Security of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania,” No Publication, //BigSasher
The difficulties in the implementation of the BALTBAT project could hardly be overestimated. The Baltic countries have set themselves a task to create a military unit meeting the highest international standards, while having at the same time to create their military structures from scratch. There was a lack of practically everything except for the political will among the leadership of the three Baltic countries and enthusiasm on the part of the three fledgling defence establishments.
Of course, such problems as the scarcity of resources and of the lack of adequately trained military personnel in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were well known before the launch of the project. It was only in the light of firm determination of the defence leadership in the Baltic states and prospects for substantial support from a number of Western countries that the task looked feasible. The problem, which was clearly underestimated, was the fact that the implementation of the BALTBAT project was affecting a number of institutions in the Baltic states beyond their military structures. Those often were unready and sometimes unwilling to co-operate in such a complex multinational project, especially as appropriate legal framework was lacking. So many things the Baltic states had to do for the first time in their history. In particular, the project implementation was often obstructed by lengthy procedures for border crossings between the three Baltic countries, paper work related to military transit, taxation of various training materials designated for BALTBAT, cost-sharing arrangements, and others. This was often causing frustration among the supporting countries as well as the BALTBAT soldiers. And as the project was of such a high political visibility, information on all the practical difficulties was immediately reaching the policy level and was forcing the BALTBAT Steering Group and other senior political bodies to get involved into micro management of the project.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Baltic War CP › AT: Suwalki CP
Carpenter 22, Ted Galen, senior fellow in defense and foreign policy studies at the Cato Institute, is the author of 12 books on international affairs, 2-28-2022, "Many predicted Nato expansion would lead to war. Those warnings were ignored," //BigSasher
The following year, the Kremlin demonstrated that its discontent with Nato’s continuing incursions into Russia’s security zone had moved beyond verbal objections. Moscow exploited a foolish provocation by Georgia’s pro‐western government to launch a military offensive that brought Russian troops to the outskirts of the capital. Thereafter, Russia permanently detached two secessionist‐minded Georgian regions and put them under effective Russian control.
Western (especially US) leaders continued to blow through red warning light after a red warning light, however. The Obama administration’s shockingly arrogant meddling in Ukraine’s internal political affairs in 2013 and 2014 to help demonstrators overthrow Ukraine’s elected, pro‐Russia president was the single most brazen provocation, and it caused tensions to spike. Moscow immediately responded by seizing and annexing Crimea, and a new cold war was underway with a vengeance.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: Animal Biotech CP › AT: Animal Biotech CP
Lowe 16 — Derek Lowe, worked for several major pharmaceutical companies, holds a PhD from Duke in organic chemistry, 2016 (“Trouble at Santa Cruz Biotechnology,” Science . Org, May 23rd, Available Online at https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/trouble-santa-cruz-biotechnology, Accessed 07-23-2022)
The commercial antibody market is already a mess, although that's not a new development, but it's gotten messier. Santa Cruz Biotech, one of the big suppliers, is getting out of a big part of the business. Actually, "being forced out of the business through their own actions" is probably a better description. The company has been hit with a $3.5 million dollar fine over its treatment of its goats and rabbits, and has to give up its license under the Animal Welfare Act. That means they can continue with mice, rats, and chickens, but the rabbit and goat antibody production is now shut down.
The USDA had found evidence of mistreatment at the company's facilities in California, and (in a bizarre development) also found an entire goat facility that the company had not been reporting. The current settlement includes the "neither admits nor denies" language about the company's culpability, but you don't give up a big piece of your business and agree to the largest animal-welfare fine in USDA history if you think you have a good case. You also don't suddenly cause 4,000 animals to vanish right before an inspection, which is what apparently happened a few months ago
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: AI CP › AT: AI CP---R&D Spending
Heney 20 — Paul Heney, writer for R&D world, 2020 (“Current R&D challenges,” R&D World, May 1st, Available Online at , Accessed 07-23-2022)
Technology growth in the R&D environment appears to be continuous and without much letup or increase in the rate of change. According to the respondents to R&D World magazine’s 2020 Global R&D Funding Forecast reader survey, performed in September 2019, most researchers have seen significant technology changes over the past year (September 2018 to September 2019). 89% of the survey respondents experienced technology growth in their industry, while only 6% saw a slowdown in their industry’s technology growth. The rate of technology change is likely accelerating, but the acceleration rate is remaining close to the same each year we collect data for our R&D Funding Forecasts.
To collect data on the trends in R&D performance for this report, the editors of R&D World magazine create and deploy annual electronic reader surveys. Responses for last year’s 2019 R&D Funding Forecast resembled survey results collected for this report — within 1% of each other. To create these reports, three surveys are deployed annually, generally with about two to three weeks separating them. Each survey has about twenty distinctive questions. For the 2020 Funding Forecast, the editors received more than 2,100 responses, which is definitely statistically significant, and the results are considered reliable.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff › AT: AI CP › AT: AI CP---American AI Initiative
Schwab 19 — Katharine Schwab, Deputy editor of fast company’s technology section, 2019 (“7 problems with Trump’s ‘American AI’ Initiative,” Fast Company, February 12th, Available Online at , Accessed 07-23-2022)
MORE RESOURCES FOR AI PROJECTS COULD BE GOOD–BUT ONLY IF IT’S DONE IN A RESPONSIBLE WAY
One element of Trump’s initiative calls for federal agencies to open up federal data, algorithms, and computing power to AI experts in industry and academia.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Warming CP › 1NC---Warming CP
Lauren Sommer 22, Vacuuming carbon from the air could help stop climate change. Not everyone agrees, NPR.org, 5-2-2022, https://www.npr.org/2022/05/02/1095097566/carbon-dioxide-removal-climate-emissions/shppp
The world has moved so slowly over the last 40 years to rein in greenhouse gases that scientists are now finding that cutting the use of fossil fuels alone may not be enough to stave off the worst effects of climate change. The world is on track for increasingly destructive heat waves, floods and storms. That means heat-trapping gases may also need to be pulled out of the atmosphere.
It's known as "carbon dioxide removal." In the latest international climate assessment, scientists found that using it will be "unavoidable" if countries are going to meet their pledges to keep average global temperatures from rising to ever-harmful levels.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Ukraine CP › 2NC---Solvency---Ukraine
Falk 22 [Thomas, Thomas O. Falk is a journalist and political commentator. He has covered politics for The Spectator, The Diplomat, GB News, Haaretz, South China Morning Post and others, “Ukraine: What does neutrality mean, and could it lead to peace?”, 3/15/22, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/3/15/ukraine-what-does-neutrality-mean-and-could-it-lead-to-peace]
“Russia does not have the desire or capacity to fully occupy the country. Neutrality is a panacea to solving the current crisis, and Finland is the model that provides a reasonable path ahead,” Moustakis said.
However, questions remain about what neutrality would mean to Ukraine, Katharine AM Wright, senior lecturer in international politics at Newcastle University, told Al Jazeera.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Ukraine CP › 1NC---Ukraine
Beauchamp 22 [Zack, senior correspondent at Vox, where he covers global politics and ideology, and a host of Worldly, Vox's podcast on foreign policy and international relations., “How the US and its allies can help Ukraine without starting World War III”, 3/3/2022, ]
While the current Western approach has been good at raising the costs of Putin’s invasion, it’s less obvious exactly how it’s supposed to end it.
One common misconception about sanctions, in particular, is that they work by brute force: that the target country suffers so much economic pain that they unilaterally give up on the policy the sanctioner dislikes. In actuality, sanctions more typically work when used as a negotiating tool — serving as a stick, accompanied by diplomatic carrots.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Ukraine CP › 1NC---Ukraine
Freeman 22[Robert, Freeman is Founder and Executive Director of The Global Uplift Project which builds small-scale infrastructure projects in the developing world to improve humanity’s capacity for self-development. Robert taught economics and history at Los Altos High School where he also coached the Speech and Debate team, including producing a national champion in 2006., “How the US Could Solve the Ukraine Crisis Tomorrow”, 3/7/22, ]
If the U.S. is sincerely interested in a peaceful resolution of the crisis—and for argument's sake, let's assume that it is—it can attain that end with two simple moves: declare that Ukraine will not be admitted into NATO; and remove its offensive nuclear missiles from Russia's borders.
Since Ukraine is not a matter of strategic interest to the U.S., this would come at little cost to the U.S. but will yield vastly disproportional gains to the situation by facilitating immediate de-escalation. Both the U.S. and NATO have stated informally that Ukraine will not be admitted anyway, so nothing, save, perhaps a little face, is lost. It would allow Russia to withdraw with something to be said for its efforts.