2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion Unnecessary – Sweden & Finland Already Capable
Maitra 22 – National Security Fellow, at the Center for the National Interest [SUMANTRA, MAY 23, 2022, Center for Renewing America, “NATO EXPANSION FOR FINLAND AND SWEDEN: A DANGEROUS AND UNNECESSARY DISTRACTION FROM US INTERESTS” https://americarenewing.com/issues/nato-expansion-for-finland-and-sweden-a-dangerous-and-unnecessary-distraction-from-us-interests/ Acc 6/19/22 ER]
Within ten weeks, Finland’s eight decades-long equidistance, and Sweden’s two centuries long neutrality were jettisoned, in favor of unprecedented levels of military bloc formations and foreign military power support pledges, most notably from fellow Scandinavian nations: Denmark, Iceland, Norway, and a post-Brexit Britain.5 Having rejected their historic neutrality, Finland and Sweden have now made formal applications to NATO membership. However, the new desire for NATO membership should not be construed as revealing a lack of current defenses or alertness towards the danger posed by Russia.
The existing force postures of Finland and Sweden are uniquely designed to deter Russia unilaterally. The Finnish force of 280,000 is augmented by around 900,000 reservists who are trained for wartime.6 Finland never abolished conscription, so the Finnish population is functionally ready for wartime service at a moment’s notice. Finnish “Comprehensive Security” stresses training to balance Russian hybrid warfare, with intelligence exchange, interoperability, and training with Western forces.7 Finnish strategy of insurgency as a deterrence tactic to blunt massive occupation forces is designed with Russia in mind. Finnish defence spending is roughly 2% of GDP and certain to increase.8 Finland is thus well positioned to blunt and deter any Russian invasion on its own and is almost certain to have major western support in arms and resources in case of a war, even without NATO membership, as Ukraine has enjoyed.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion Undermines European Cooperative Defense
Maitra 22 – National Security Fellow, at the Center for the National Interest [SUMANTRA, MAY 23, 2022, Center for Renewing America, “NATO EXPANSION FOR FINLAND AND SWEDEN: A DANGEROUS AND UNNECESSARY DISTRACTION FROM US INTERESTS” https://americarenewing.com/issues/nato-expansion-for-finland-and-sweden-a-dangerous-and-unnecessary-distraction-from-us-interests/ Acc 6/19/22 ER]
America’s strategic interest in the European balance is not under any significant threat from a potential hegemonic challenge that seeks to dominate the entirety of European landmass under one army and one flag.26 During the early years of the Republic, American grand strategy in Europe was one of cautious detachment and non-interference in the imperial affairs of the European great powers. After the fall of the traditional historic balancer of Europe, the British empire, and facing two world wars and hegemonic threats to security from Imperial, and subsequently Nazi Germany, American strategy evolved to one that mirrored the historic British grand-strategy of “offshore balancing,” that ensured that America would intervene whenever there was a hegemonic threat in the European horizon. To that end, the interests of the United States, much like the British empire before her, is to ensure a militarily disunited Europe, and maintain open trade and sea routes.
The difference in this instance was that the British aspired to attain this objective through a delicate “balance of power” within the continent with minimal interference to tilt the balance as and when required, while cautiously avoiding continuous engagement in the domestic affairs of European countries, or commitments about spreading rights and values. While the American interest in ensuring no hegemonic threat in the European continent remained intact, the American grand-strategy, especially after the collapse of the Soviet Union, deviated from an earlier realist one. It in turn sought to institutionalise peace across the continent, while ensuring fundamental human rights in every corner – or in the words of John Mearsheimer and Barry Posen, ensure primacy and spread “liberal hegemony.”
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion Undermines Asian Pivot
Ashford, 22 – senior fellow in the New American Engagement Initiative at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security [5-30-2022, washington post, "NATO Should Think Twice Before Accepting Finland and Sweden," https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/nato-should-think-twice-before-accepting-finland-and-sweden/2022/05/30/b412ee2a-dff7-11ec-ae64-6b23e5155b62_story.html accessed on 6-18-2022, LKK]
One of the ironies of Russia’s war against Ukraine — ostensibly fought to prevent that nation from joining the North Atlantic Treaty Organization — has been its impact on two of Europe’s traditionally neutral states, Finland and Sweden. On May 18, just 84 days after the invasion, Swedish and Finnish ambassadors handed over applications to join NATO in a public ceremony at the alliance’s headquarters in Brussels.
“This is a historic moment which we must seize,” said Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg. “You are our closest partners, and your membership in NATO will increase our shared security.” It seems likely that their applications will be swiftly approved, and NATO will soon grow to a 32 member states.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion => Nuclear War with Russia
Ashford, 22 – senior fellow in the New American Engagement Initiative at the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security [5-30-2022, washington post, "NATO Should Think Twice Before Accepting Finland and Sweden," https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/nato-should-think-twice-before-accepting-finland-and-sweden/2022/05/30/b412ee2a-dff7-11ec-ae64-6b23e5155b62_story.html accessed on 6-18-2022, LKK]
Consider also the question of the defensibility of new NATO territory. Admitting Sweden could be strategically beneficial, allowing NATO forces to better control the Baltic Sea and to use Gotland Island, at an important chokepoint off the Baltic States, as a staging ground for any future conflict.
Finnish territory, in contrast, is a strategic nightmare. It would dramatically increase the alliance’s exposure to any future attacks by Moscow: the country shares an 800-mile border with Russia that, as a recent study from the Center for Strategic and International Studies put it, is “highly exposed to Russian military threats.”
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion => Nuclear War with Russia
Caldwell and Vought, 22 – President of the Center for Renewing America and VP of Foreign Policy at Stand Together [Dan and Russ; 6/13/22; Fox News; “Finland and Sweden joining NATO won’t make U.S. safer”; ; accessed 6/18/22; DWC]
It is not in the national interest of the United States, through NATO, to commit to defend two wealthy European welfare states whose neutrality has kept them safe and prosperous for more than 70 years. While some insist Russia’s invasion of Ukraine changes everything, the fact remains that new security guarantees will force trade-offs, consume more resources, and increase the likelihood of a confrontation with a nuclear-armed adversary.
Despite rhetoric from NATO evangelists that can often give the contrary impression, adding Finland and Sweden to NATO will lead to increased costs for the U.S.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › NATO Expansion => Nuclear War with Russia
Caldwell and Vought, 22 – President of the Center for Renewing America and VP of Foreign Policy at Stand Together [Dan and Russ; 6/13/22; Fox News; “Finland and Sweden joining NATO won’t make U.S. safer”; ; accessed 6/18/22; DWC]
Additionally, neither country currently meets the 2 percent of GDP defense spending goal that was agreed to by NATO members. Just as in other parts of Europe, a security guarantee provided by the United States could encourage free-riding and disincentivize increased investment in defense capabilities in favor of more spending on politically popular social programs.
But most dangerously, adding Finland and Sweden to NATO will increase the risk of a nuclear confrontation with Russia. As a result of its failures in Ukraine, the threat posed by Russia’s conventional forces has been reduced. But Russia still possesses a large nuclear arsenal that, according to the head of the Defense Intelligence Agency, they will likely rely on more to secure their borders — including the nearly 850-mile one they share with Finland. NATO membership for Finland and Sweden includes extending the umbrella of America’s nuclear deterrent to both nations, thus elevating the risk that any border dispute could escalate into a nuclear exchange.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › AT: Turkey Autonomous Weapons Link
Gurcan, 21 --- served in Afghanistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Iraq as a Turkish military adviser from 2002 to 2008 (June 8, 2021, Metin Gurcan, “Turkish drone sets off international buzz over 'killer robots'; The appearance of Turkish artificial intelligence-controlled drones in Libyan skies has rekindled questions on how lethal autonomous weapons will affect regional geopolitics and whether they should be banned,” , JMP)
Turkish military sources familiar with the matter confirmed that Kargu-2s had been used in Libya on multiple occasions, but denied that the drones — which have both autonomous and manual operation modes — were allowed to use artificial intelligence to select and hit targets. The drones operated autonomously only to reach target areas, after which operators on the ground made the decisions to strike, the sources told Al-Monitor on condition of anonymity.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Congress Will Delay NATO Expansion
Auerswald 22 – Professor of Security Studies at the U.S. National War College [David Auerswald, May 17, 2022, “How the US Senate could slow down Sweden and Finland’s NATO future” https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/how-the-us-senate-could-slow-down-sweden-and-finlands-nato-future/ Acc 6/21/22 ER]
If history is any guide, the Senate will overwhelmingly support adding Finland and Sweden to NATO (certainly by more than the two-thirds required by the Constitution). That was the case in 1998, when senators supported membership for the Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland by an 80-19 vote; in 2003, when senators unanimously welcomed Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia, and Slovenia by a 96-0 vote; in 2008, when senators admitted Albania and Croatia by voice vote; and in 2017 and 2019, when it approved Montenegro and Northern Macedonia, respectively, to join the Alliance with only two dissenting votes each time.
The more interesting question is how long it will take the Senate to provide its advice and consent—and here the record does not bode well. The amended treaty is likely to be signed in the next few weeks, perhaps even before the NATO Summit at the end of June. That means the Senate, which is typically in recess during August, would need to hold hearings and vote in June and July, September and October, or wait until a lame duck session after the midterm elections. The fastest enlargement process, in 2003, took a month and a half from the NATO signing ceremony to final Senate passage. Other rounds took much longer: The 1998 round took more than four months, while the 2017 and 2019 enlargements took more than ten and eight months, respectively. The war in Ukraine could certainly speed up the process, but do not be surprised if the Senate process drags into the fall.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › U.S.-Turkey Relations Low
Restoring the balance
But serious thorns remain in Turkey’s relations with certain allies, and the estrangement risks undermining NATO’s resilience at a critical juncture.
For one, Turkey is deeply irritated that the United States and others are partnering with the People’s Protection Units (YPG), the Syrian branch of the PKK, in the fight against the Islamic State. It is also frustrated at the imposition of arms embargoes—or covert restrictions on arms sales—by its allies over issues like Ankara’s purchase of Russian-made S-400 air-defense systems, its Syria policy, and its support for Azerbaijan in the 2020 war against Armenia. These differences have led to a mutual erosion of trust between Turkey and its allies, sometimes making consensus-building on critical matters difficult.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Alaaldin, 22 – Nonresident Fellow for Foreign Policy at the Center for Middle East Policy at Brookings (Ranj, 2022"Turkey’s threat to derail Swedish and Finnish NATO accession reraises the Kurdish question," Brookings; https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2022/06/03/turkeys-threat-to-derail-swedish-and-finnish-nato-accession-reraises-the-kurdish-question/;DOA: 6-21-2022) SMTX//BSA
Turkey’s opposition to Sweden and Finland joining the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) in the wake of Russia’s war on Ukraine has elevated the Kurdish question on the international stage. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is attempting to capitalize on the urgency of fortifying Western deterrence by increasing the pressure on the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK). The insurgent group has fought the Turkish state for five decades to secure greater rights for Turkey’s Kurds but enjoyed a rapid ascension with the onset of the Syrian civil war and Washington’s 2014 decision to partner with its sister organization to defeat the Islamic State group (IS).
The PKK has constituted a major component of Turkey’s relationship with Europe and the United States for decades, and Erdoğan has initiated several military campaigns into Syria’s northeast to suppress the autonomous enclave the PKK’s sister organization, the Peoples’ Protection Units (YPG), formed in the midst of the civil war. While Turkey may be using the Nordic NATO accession talks to receive Western backing for another campaign, it has a long record of carrying out cross-border incursions against the PKK and Erdoğan may also be trying to secure other concessions, including the lifting of embargoes on Turkey’s defense industry.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Coşkun, 22 – senior fellow at CEIP and former director general for int-security affairs at the Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs (June 24, 22; Alper Coşkun; “Turkey and NATO are stronger with each other. They must de-thorne their relationship”; https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/turkeysource/turkey-and-nato-are-stronger-with-each-other-they-must-de-thorn-their-relationship/AI)
As NATO prepares for its summit in Madrid next week, Turkey is in the headlines for holding up Finland and Sweden’s bids to join the Alliance—irking not only the two candidate countries, but also their would-be NATO allies.
Ankara wants Helsinki and Stockholm to stop harboring and supporting individuals affiliated with the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), which it considers to be a terrorist organization (and is recognized as such by both the United States and the European Union). It also demands an end to the arms embargoes imposed by these countries after Turkey’s military operation in northern Syria in 2019. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has made it clear that nothing short of concrete steps will be enough to reverse Turkey’s stance.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Ünlühisarcıklı, 22 -- manager of the Resource Development Department of the Educational Volunteers Foundation of Turkey [5-19-2022, Özgür, “Erdoğan Will Not Walk Away Empty-Handed,” , accessed on 6-18-2022, LKK]
Sweden and Finland’s decision to apply for NATO membership is welcome with enthusiasm across the Atlantic, but Turkey may spoil the party.
In an unexpected move, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has announced that he does not favor the two countries’ membership to NATO on the grounds that they are havens for terrorist organizations targeting Turkey, specifically the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and its offshoots. Both Sweden and Finland reject this claim but remain open to discussions with Turkey on the subject.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Tosu, 22 – Director of International Programs at the University of Nevada (6/23/2022, Mehmet, 2022"Unity, solidarity against common threats key for NATO, Türkiye tells US," No Publication; , DOA: 6-23-2022) SMTX//BSA
There must be unity, harmony and solidarity among NATO allies against common security and terrorist threats, Türkiye’s Presidential spokesperson Ibrahim Kalin said in a phone call with US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan on Thursday.
Along with bilateral political and economic ties, the officials held discussions on Türkiye’s role in NATO and contributions to the alliance, the upcoming NATO Madrid summit, Sweden and Finland’s NATO bids, grain shipments through the Black Sea and other regional issues, according to a statement from the Turkish presidential spokesperson.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Wintour, 22 – Diplomatic Editor of The Guardian [Patrick; 6/14/22; The Guardian; “Turkey threatens year’s delay to Swedish and Finnish entry to Nato”; ; accessed 6/18/22; DWC]
Turkey has said it is willing to delay Swedish and Finnish membership of Nato for more than a year unless it receives satisfactory assurances that the two Nordic countries are willing to address support for Kurdish groups it regards as terrorist organisations.
Finland’s prime minister said on Tuesday that the two nations’ Nato applications could stall if the issue is not resolved before a vital Nato summit due to start in Madrid on 29 June.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA NATO Expansion Answers › Turkey Will Block NATO Expansion to Sweden / Finland
Turak, 22 -- CNBC correspondent (5/17/22, Natasha ‘The stakes here are now massive’: Turkey is threatening to block NATO membership for Sweden and Finland. ) //AB
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has doubled down on his opposition to Sweden and Finland joining the NATO alliance, a move that would be historic for the two Nordic countries in the wake of .
“We will not say ‘yes’ to those [countries] who apply sanctions to Turkey to join security organization NATO,” Erdogan said at a news conference late Monday. He was referring to Sweden’s suspension of weapons sales to Turkey in 2019 over its military activities in Syria.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA Unity Answers › Russia Won’t Use Nuclear Weapons
Wormuth, 22 --- Secretary of the Army, US Department of Defense (June 2, 2022, Christine Wormuth, moderated by Vivian Salama who serves as a national security reporter at The Wall Street Journal “NATO allies must not take their unity on Ukraine for granted, says Secretary of the Army Christine Wormuth,” , JMP)
VIVIAN SALAMA: Before we move on to another subject, just a really blunt question, being that there is concern that President Putin could resort to nuclear weapons at some stage, especially if he gets desperate in this conflict. What is the Army’s role in preventing that kind of a scenario, especially absent direct military involvement in Ukraine?
CHRISTINE WORMUTH: You know, I think what we can do—I mean, first of all, I think it’s important to say that, you know, we are undoubtedly looking at that type of contingency and trying to think through what our options—you know, what options would be available to policymakers if that were to happen? The Army, I think what we can most, you know, helpfully do is to try to provide training for how to operate under those kinds of conditions. You know, we have personal protective equipment and things like that. But I think, you know, if Putin were to decide to use some sort of tactical nuclear demonstration, I think, you know, that would erase, in my mind, any possibility that he could be anything other than a pariah leader and a—leader of a pariah state, you know, for decades going forward. So I think that Putin would have to think extremely long and hard about that, since he clearly wants to try to bring Russia back into the international community at some point. I don’t see how he does that if he goes nuclear.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA Unity Answers › Unity Not Key
Skaluba & Rodhian, 22 --- *served as principal director for European and NATO policy in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, AND **associate director in the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security’s Transatlantic Security Initiative (January 18, 2022, Christopher Skaluba – also director of the Transatlantic Security Initiative in the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, and Conor Rodihan, “No consensus? No problem. Why NATO is still effective,” , JMP)
As the crisis over Ukraine intensifies, key stakeholders are looking to Brussels for signs of Western resolve. At the NATO-Russia Council meeting on January 12, the Alliance delivered: In a vivid expression of solidarity, it categorically (and unanimously) rejected Russian demands to forgo future expansion or withdraw forces from member countries.
Yet as the crisis evolves, decisions about how to support Ukraine will become more difficult, and there’s a limit to how unified NATO can be. While the West might agree on introducing tough new economic sanctions and reinforcing the Alliance’s eastern flank, boosting Kyiv’s military capacity—by supporting an insurgency, for instance, or sending anti-tank weapons—will be impossible to achieve by consensus and is much more likely to come from individual members than under NATO auspices.
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA Unity Answers › AT: Consultation Link
Lorenz, 20 --- international security expert at the Polish Institute of International Affairs [Wojciech, November, 2020, “Strengthening NATO’s cohesion through consultation”, , accessed 6/23/22, NB]
In recent years, NATO’s mechanisms of consultation have proved lacking in defusing tensions and discouraging unilateral actions, both in the Euro-Atlantic area and beyond it.
During Donald Trump’s presidency, for example, the US withdrew troops from Syria, despite the possible impact on the security of the Allies. This unilateral decision encouraged Turkey to send troops to Syria, which could further complicate the fight with Islamic terrorist groups and increase the risk of confrontation between Turkey and Russia, which has a military presence in Syria. Also, despite NATO’s presence in Afghanistan, the US pursued negotiations with the Taliban without providing NATO with an insight into its plans. And it only resorted to consultations in NATO on its decision to withdraw from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces treaty after the criticism from the Allies. Similarly, it first announced the decision to withdraw troops from Germany and only later consulted with Allies about how to limit the impact on NATO. Some of these decisions were publicly criticised by NATO members, most vocally by French president Emmanuel Macron who, before the 2019 NATO leaders meeting, accused the Alliance of being “brain dead” and took the opportunity to promote the idea of European ‘strategic autonomy’.9
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA Unity Answers › AT: Consultation Link
Lorenz, 20 --- international security expert at the Polish Institute of International Affairs [Wojciech, November, 2020, “Strengthening NATO’s cohesion through consultation”, , accessed 6/23/22, NB]
The strongest norms and most elaborate mechanisms have been developed regarding consultations on collective defence policy. Since this is a primary task of NATO, derived directly from the Washington Treaty, some experts claim that there might be a legal obligation to consult before a NATO member takes a definite action, which could undermine the common defence.4 There is no mechanism to enforce compliance and there are numerous examples of Allies bypassing consultation to take unilateral actions. Nevertheless, most Allies try to respect such a norm as it creates a similar obligation for the US, limiting the risk, for example, of the unexpected or uncoordinated withdrawal of US troops from Europe.
There is another important dimension of consultations concerning actions outside the Euro-Atlantic area—since this is not a ‘treaty area’ there is no apparent legal obligation to consult. Nevertheless, the European Allies expected the US to use consultations to inform them about plans that could affect NATO’s security. The US was also interested in such consultations, expecting that they would facilitate coordination of NATO policies in support of American foreign policy goals, but this rarely turned out to be the case. The 1967 Harmel report was an attempt to strengthen this dimension of consultation and thus NATO’s political cohesion, stating that “the North Atlantic
2022
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Affirmative DA Unity Answers › No NATO Unity / Cohesion
Carpenter 22 – senior fellow for defense and foreign policy studies at the Cato Institute [Ted Galen, MARCH 23, 2022, CATO institute, “Just How United Is NATO (and the World) against Russia?” ER]
Beyond NATO (and longstanding U.S. allies in East Asia), the absence of support for Washington’s strategy of imposing harsh penalties on Russia is glaringly evident. That problem surfaced almost immediately. On March 2, the United Nations General Assembly approved a resolution condemning Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and calling for the immediate withdrawal of Russian military forces. 141 countries voted for the resolution, and U.S. officials gloated that only 5 voted against it.
However, a stunning 35 countries decided to abstain, even though a favorable vote to placate the United States and its allies should have been an easy option, since the resolution was purely symbolic, not obligating UN members to take any substantive action. Yet a significant number of countries in Asia, the Greater Middle East, and Sub‐Saharan Africa, opted to snub Washington. When more than 20 percent of the General Assembly’s membership refuses to embrace a purely feel‐good measure Washington wants passed, the U.S.-sponsored global coalition looks fragile indeed.