Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Uniqueness › 2nc NATO Unity Now

NATO is working together and strongly supporting Ukraine with resources

Blinken, 22 – US Secretary of State [Antony J., Jens; 6/1/22; “Secretary Antony J. Blinken And NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg At a Joint Press Availability”; ; accessed 6/21/22; Lowell-DC]

We’ll strengthen our relationships with the European Union and with partners in the Indo-Pacific. We will bolster NATO’s budget. And we will renew our Alliance’s defense and deterrence capabilities. Of course, the strategic concept will reflect what we are now dealing with, and that is a new security landscape in Europe and President Putin’s decision to launch a senseless war of aggression on Ukraine, now in its fourth month.

The people of Ukraine continue to fight with extraordinary courage and skill and with military, humanitarian, and financial support from the United States and countries around the world, including virtually all of the members of NATO. Just this morning President Biden announced a significant new security assistance package to arm Ukraine with additional capabilities in advanced weaponry, precisely what they need to defend themselves against the ongoing Russian aggression. That includes more advanced rocket systems so that they can strike key targets on the battlefield in Ukraine from longer distances. This is a continuation of a strategy that began even before Russia’s invasion. We moved quickly to send Ukraine significant amounts of weapons and ammunition so that they can repel Russia’s aggression and, in turn, can be in the strongest possible position at any negotiating table that may emerge.

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Uniqueness › 2nc NATO Unity Now

Political unity and interoperability are strong now --- key to deter Russia

Eaton 22 – executive officer and assistant professor of Naval Science for the Navy ROTC Unit serving Rutgers and Princeton Universities [6/22, “NATO, Russia, and Competition for Strategic Influence in the Baltic”, U.S. Naval Institute, https://,www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2022/june/nato-russia-and-competition-strategic-influence-baltic, access date, 6/19/22 //TJ]

Russia continues to seek to rebuild its influence on the peripheral states where it was once a hegemon. Russia’s actions in Ukraine demonstrate the threat, and President Vladimir Putin’s own words show the intent. NATO presently acts as an effective shield for allies, with its tremendous political, economic, and conventional advantages over Russia. Despite these strengths, NATO must be mindful that Russia has its own asymmetric advantages in a potential conflict in its near abroad.

NATO has rightly pursued a path to avoid conflict with Russia by maintaining political unity as well as military interoperability and readiness through combined exercises and operations. NATO must continue to maintain that unity and readiness to prevent Russian aggression. Should deterrence fail, swift and credible action to demonstrate collective commitment to NATO defense will be critical to successful defense of the Baltic, and the health of the Alliance as a whole.

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Expansion

NATO expansion key to European and Asian stability --- limits further invasion in Europe by Russia

Mitchell, 22 – senior advisor for the Russia and Europe Center at USIP [A. Wess, May 26,United States Institute of Peace, , Acc 6/23/22, HO]

How would Finland’s and Sweden’s NATO accession impact the geopolitics of Europe? Would it ultimately boost European security?

The United States should always be judicious about adding new treaty allies — it’s a serious thing indeed to widen the U.S. global defensive perimeter. In the case of Finland and Sweden, I see the impact as positive; their accession will round off NATO geographically and improve Europe’s defensibility in a crisis. We should be clear that both Sweden and Finland will need to step up defense spending, along with the rest of Europe. But both have serious, professional militaries with specialized capabilities and a long track record of partnering with NATO. Finland has a serious defensive capability, including one of the largest artillery forces in Europe, and nationwide participation in the reserves like the Swiss or Israeli model. Their long border with Russia is dotted with thousands of lakes and is very defensible, as we saw in the 1930s Winter War. Sweden brings significant naval and especially anti-submarine capabilities.

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Expansion

U.S.-Turkey relations are transactional --- only prioritizing, and compromising through prior consultation can ensure cooperation

Singh & Ulgen, 20 --- *Lane-Swig Senior Fellow and managing director at The Washington Institute, AND **chairman of the Istanbul-based think tank EDAM and a visiting scholar at Carnegie Europe (Nov 17, 2020, Michael Singh and Sinan Ulgen, “Biden Can’t Avoid Erdogan, But He Can Keep the U.S.-Turkish Relationship on Track,” , JMP

For all the problems bedeviling their ties, the United States’ and Turkey’s interests will still be better served by cooperation than antagonism. While nostalgia for the U.S.-Turkey alliance of the past would be misguided, so too would be assuming that the only alternative is enmity. For all of the serious disputes dividing them, Americans and Turks share an interest in limiting Russian influence in the region, countering Iranian adventurism, and preventing nuclear and missile proliferation

Yet the reality is that for the foreseeable future, even if the U.S.-Turkey relationship can be stabilized, it will be more transactional than in the past. This will require a greater willingness than exists at present to prioritize, to work out compromises quietly, to consult early to prevent disputes from arising, and to prevent every disagreement from turning into an existential threat to the relationship.

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Expansion

Turkey can still be convinced to support NATO expansion but it will need to cajoled and persuaded --- Erdogan needs to demonstrate a strong standing with voters in the lead up to the election

Aydıntaşbaş, 22 --- Senior Policy Fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations (16 May 2022, Asli Aydıntaşbaş, “Turkey, NATO, and the Ukraine war: Why Erdogan’s grievances are about more than Sweden and Finland; The Turkish president is unlikely to veto Nordic membership of NATO – but Turkey’s bigger strategic worry is of a NATO-Russia conflict arising out of the war in Ukraine,” , JMP)

Just when NATO members were about to pop the champagne in celebration of Finland’s and Sweden’s applications to join the alliance, the buzz-kill dropped: Turkey’s president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, declared on Friday that he looks unfavourably on the duo becoming members.

“We are following developments. We currently do not have a positive [favourable] position on the issue of Sweden and Finland [joining NATO],” Erdogan told reporters after Friday prayers in Istanbul. “Scandinavian countries are like terrorist groups’ guesthouses,” he continued, referring to the presence in Sweden of exiled Gulenists and sympathisers of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) – which Ankara views as a terrorist organisation that has tentacles in Turkey, Syria, and Iraq.

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Unity

Disagreements spillover and tube cooperation on an entire NATO program

Nicholas Burns 19, Goodman Family Professor of the Practice of Diplomacy and International Relations at Harvard Kennedy School, MA in International Relations from the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, and Douglas Lute, Senior Fellow at the Project on Europe and the Transatlantic Relationship, Former United States Permanent Representative to the North Atlantic Council, Holds Degrees from the United States Military Academy at West Point and from the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, “NATO at Seventy: An Alliance in Crisis”, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School Report, February 2019, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/nato-seventy-alliance-crisis

NATO needs to take a hard look at itself. Across twenty-five indicators of democracy rated by Freedom House, the downward trend among NATO allies over the past decade is stark.35 Especially in Central Europe but not exclusively, there are setbacks in the media, the judiciary and the functioning of national democratic institutions. The rate at which democracy is declining in Poland, Hungary and Turkey is particularly alarming. In 2017 and 2018, these three states’ scores represented some of the largest one-year declines in political rights and civil liberties of all 195 countries ranked by Freedom House.36 Poland—with the largest category declines in the forty-year history of the survey—is close to leaving the “consolidated democracy” category.37 Hungary is no longer rated a consolidated democracy. Turkey, whose decline in freedom over the last ten years represents the largest of any country in the world, crossed the threshold from “free” to “not free.”38

While less severe today, nationalist populism movements in other allies represent a broader, more diffuse threat to NATO and can amplify other challenges facing the Alliance. The United States is not immune, with its Freedom House rating declining in 2018 due to “Russian interference in the 2016 election, violations of basic ethical standards by the new administration and a reduction in government transparency.”39 While this slippage in the U.S. is relatively recent and still minor in scale, it nonetheless diminishes America’s standing as a standard-bearer for democracy and further erodes its leadership position within the Alliance. Further, anti-democratic policies among allies open vulnerabilities for interference by competitors outside the Alliance, especially Russia that seeks to divide NATO and the EU politically using hybrid tactics.40

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Unity

This unity is not guaranteed and takes a lot of work and active diplomacy to sustain

Wormuth, 22 --- Secretary of the Army, US Department of Defense (June 2, 2022, Christine Wormuth, moderated by Vivian Salama who serves as a national security reporter at The Wall Street Journal “NATO allies must not take their unity on Ukraine for granted, says Secretary of the Army Christine Wormuth,” , JMP)

VIVIAN SALAMA: President Biden has repeatedly made it clear that there are not going to be boots on the ground in this conflict so long as it’s isolated within Ukraine’s borders. Something I heard repeatedly while I was there is that military leaders and the president’s office even are concerned that as this conflict increasingly becomes prolonged, momentum to assist, to keep on fueling them with weapons, with assistance, with other kinds of training, could start to wane and especially when we have our own domestic priorities to worry about.

And so how do you see the US sustaining this level of support for Ukraine in a way that could actually make a difference in embattled regions like the Donbas, which is suffering significantly right now?

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › 1nc DA NATO Unity

Ensuring Russian strategic failure in Ukraine is the U.S. goal BUT it’s not a guarantee and requires full cooperation and unity of allies to make adjustments to strategy and posture

McPartland, 22 --- assistant director with the Atlantic Council’s Transatlantic Security Initiative (May 11, 2022, Connor, “How can the US and NATO help bring about Russia’s ‘strategic failure’ in Ukraine?” , JMP)

With Ukraine having repelled Russian forces near Kyiv, the Kremlin’s war of aggression has entered a new phase: a more limited offensive in eastern Ukraine. As the United States and its transatlantic allies and partners formulate fresh strategies for what will likely be a protracted conflict, there are several factors they must consider, senior officials and experts said at a recent Atlantic Council event.

The US objective is Russian “strategic failure”—militarily, politically and economically— US Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs Celeste Wallander said at the May 2 conference, titled “Priorities for the NATO Summit and Security in Europe.” That would involve in the long term “holding the Russian leadership to account in front of its own population and in front of the global stage,” she said. Wallander’s comments expanded on US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin’s recent statement that the United States “want[s] to see Russia weakened to the degree that it can’t do the kinds of things that it has done in invading Ukraine.”

2022 MNDI Disadvantage
DA – Turkey / NATO Unity – MNDI AHP › Notes

Time did not permit us to develop this file as fully as we wanted. Here are some suggestions for supplementing it in the future:

Expand the link section – this is very important because many affirmatives will utilize their solvency or “say yes” evidence to demonstrate that the plan is popular and possibly improves unity with NATO. Even if all NATO states eventually support the plan, you could develop a link around the diplomatic capital, concessions or horse-trading that the U.S. or other member states would have to do in order to reach consensus

Find more reasons why it is good to include Finland and Sweden in NATO outside of deterring Russia. This would give the disad an impact external to many affirmatives.

Both arguments could become net benefits to consultation counterplans.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › Emerging tech

Americans don’t support emerging tech legislation

Zhang 19 [Baobao Zhang . "Public opinion lessons for AI regulation". 12-10-2019. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/research/public-opinion-lessons-for-ai-regulation. 6-23-2022.] -AL

An overwhelming majority of the American public believes that artificial intelligence (AI) should be carefully managed. Nevertheless, as the three case studies in this brief show, the public does not agree on the proper regulation of AI applications. Indeed, population-level support of an AI application may belie opposition by some subpopulations. Many AI applications, such as facial recognition technology, could cause disparate harm to already vulnerable subgroups, particularly ethnic minorities and low-income individuals. In addition, partisan divisions are likely to prevent government regulation of AI applications that could be used to influence electoral politics. In particular, the regulation of content recommendation algorithms used by social media platforms has been highly contestable. Finally, mobilizing an influential group of political actors, such as machine learning researchers in the campaign against lethal autonomous weapons, may be more effective in shifting policy debates than mobilizing the public at large. Algorithms used to recommend content on social media have increasingly come under scrutiny. Platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube use machine learning to suggest media content and advertisements that optimize for user engagement. Civil society groups and researchers have expressed concerns that these algorithms help spread misinformation, proliferate digital propaganda, create partisan echo chambers, and promote violent extremism. Unlike facial recognition technology that could more readily be managed at the local or state level, social media platforms have users across the U.S. and around the world. California has sought to regulate online bots and protect consumer privacy, setting the terms of the debate for federal regulations. However, it remains to be seen if the federal government will follow the way of California or oppose the state’s policies. In the U.S., legislation to regulate social media platforms has stalled because of the divergent policy priorities of the two parties. In light of Russian intervention in the 2016 U.S. presidential election and the Cambridge Analytica scandal, Congress has held several hearings to investigate and castigate tech companies. The techlash from the left and the right are different: Democrats prioritize the prevention of digital manipulation and consumer privacy while Republicans focus on alleged bias against conservatives. Democratic senators have introduced legislation that would increase transparency for online campaign advertisements and require tech companies to safeguard users’ sensitive data. Republican lawmakers have accused social media platforms of censoring conservative viewpoints, despite evidence to the contrary. The Trump White House is reportedly drafting an executive order to combat this alleged bias. The American public is concerned about the lack of accountability by tech companies that operate social media platforms, but does not agree on policy solutions. According to a report from the Pew Research Center, 51% of the U.S. public thinks that tech companies should be regulated more than they are now. At the same time, Americans indicate that they have greater trust in tech companies than the U.S. federal government to manage the development and use of AI in the best interests of the public, per data from the Center for the Governance of AI. The public is evenly split on whether there should be regulation of content recommendation algorithms based on political affiliations or political viewpoints, according to a 2017 Harvard/Harris Poll survey. The partisan division among lawmakers in Congress is also reflected in public opinion. There exists a stark asymmetry in how Republicans and Democrats perceive bias in social media platforms and tech companies. While 54% of Republicans think it is very likely that social media platforms censor political viewpoints, only 20% of Democrats do, according to a survey from the Pew Research Center. Conversely, while 53% of Democrats think major tech companies support the views of liberals and conservatives equally, only 28% of Republicans feel the same way. With political gridlock hindering governmental regulation of algorithms used by social media platforms, tech companies have tried to answer their critics through industry self-regulation. Nevertheless, industry self-regulation is not immune to underlying conflicts in American politics. For instance, Google’s AI ethics board dissolved after the company’s employees and outside civil society groups protested the inclusion of Heritage Foundation president Kay Coles James and drone company CEO Dyan Gibbens on the board.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › Election interference

Foreign interference won’t affect outcomes—no external internet accessibility and too many built in redundancies.

Shaban 16 [Hamza Shaban, Hamza Shaban is a technology policy reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, D.C. State Election Officials Confront Fears Of Election Day Hacking, BuzzFeed, 9-9-2016, Accessible Online at https://www.buzzfeed.com/hamzashaban/state-election-officials-confront-fears-of-election-day-hack?utm_term=.tkb76qeB8#.ju2VRwDeK] SW 9-14-2016

A month after 20,000 private emails from the Democratic National Committee were published online, election officials across the country received a series of warnings from the FBI: Hackers were targeting states’ election websites and, in at least one case, were able to steal voter registration data. The Department of Homeland Security has since created an election cybersecurity action campaign, and US intelligence officials have begun investigating the possibility of a covert Russian intelligence operation that seeks to undermine the integrity of the American election.

But despite the growing concerns over foreign meddling coming from Congress, intelligence experts, and the Clinton campaign, state election officials say American voters have little to fear.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › A2 NATO

GOP supports NATO unification, Ukraine a reason.

Livingston 4-6 [Abby Livingston, Washington Bureau Chief, The Texas Tribune 4-6-2022 Texas Republicans who opposed resolution supporting NATO criticize and question its language Texas Tribune https://www.texastribune.org/2022/04/06/congress-nato-support-texas-representatives/] 6-27-2022

Republican U.S. Rep. Michael McCaul of Austin is the top House Republican on foreign affairs and voted to support NATO. On Wednesday, he sported a blue-and-gold Ukrainian ribbon on his suit jacket at the Capitol. He told The Texas Tribune that NATO countries are “stepping up” in ways some countries had lagged before. A frequent conservative critique of NATO is that many European countries fall short of the expected standard that all member countries spend at least 2% of their GDP on defense. “NATO is more unified than it’s ever been. Germany now is putting in 2% of their GDP. And they are sending weapons and they are training,” he said. NATO bonds further frayed in recent years, as Trump regularly railed against the alliance. But his criticism did lead to several NATO countries deciding to increase their defense spending. Everything changed six weeks ago when Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, a country on the Eastern European frontier that long aspired to join the organization. Several NATO countries located near Ukraine, like Poland, are most impacted by the refugee exodus from Ukraine. At the heart of NATO is an agreement among all 30 countries known as Article 5, which states an attack on one NATO member country is an attack on all NATO allies. The 9/11 attacks on the United States are the single time in the alliance’s existence that Article 5 has been invoked. Former NATO Ambassador Kay Bailey Hutchison addressed the vote in an interview with the Tribune on Wednesday. Hutchison carefully noted she had not read the language in the House resolution but insisted the political establishment is behind NATO. “I know we have bipartisan support for NATO — I know that,” she told Tribune CEO Evan Smith, pointing to her former colleagues in the U.S. Senate. “We have that bipartisan support,” she later added. “I’ve seen it.” U.S. Rep. Colin Allred, a Dallas Democrat who serves on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, seemed mystified that so many Texans voted against a resolution supporting NATO, noting that the last two Republican presidents prior to Trump — George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush — were NATO boosters. “I really don’t know what to make of it,” he said. “We’ve seen how important it is, and I find it really hard to understand.”

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › A2 NATO

Republicans support NATO expansion, Finland and Sweden will help share the load with military.

Zengerle ’22 (Patricia Zengerle is a Correspondent for Congress and National Security in the Thomson Reuters, “U.S. Republicans Join Democrats in Backing NATO Expansion Despite Rising Nationalism,” U.S.News, 5/23/2022, https://www.usnews.com/news/top-news/articles/2022-05-23/u-s-republicans-join-democrats-in-backing-nato-expansion-despite-rising-nationalism)

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Democratic and Republican U.S. Senate leaders introduced a resolution on Monday backing Sweden and Finland's bids to join NATO, underscoring support for expanding the alliance despite growing nationalism in the Republican party. It will take a two-thirds majority in the 100-member Senate to approve the expansion of the alliance, requiring "yes" votes from at least 17 Republicans along with every Democrat. Many U.S. Republicans have been following the lead of former President Donald Trump - the party's leader - toward more nationalist foreign policy. Trump accused NATO allies of not spending enough on their own defense and excessively burdening the United States. Russia's invasion of Ukraine has prompted Finland and Sweden to apply to join NATO. In the Senate, 11 Republicans voted "no" last week against legislation providing $40 billion to help Ukraine, with some saying they wanted the funds director to Americans. Last month, 63 Republican members of the House of Representatives, nearly one-third of the full caucus, opposed a bill reaffirming U.S. support for NATO. The top Senate Republican, Mitch McConnell, and Jim Risch, the top Republican on the foreign relations panel, joined Democratic Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and committee chairman Bob Menendez and other senators in introducing the resolution. "We fully support their application to become NATO members and are looking forward to their swift ascension in the coming months," Menendez said in a statement. McConnell referred to Finland and Sweden as "strong countries with formidable military capabilities" and said in his statement, "both nations' robust defense funding means their accession would meaningfully bolster our pursuit of greater burden-sharing across the alliance. I fully support the Senate providing its advice and consent as quickly as possible." (Reporting by Patricia Zengerle; editing by Grant McCool)

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › A2 Win for Biden

The plan distracts Democrats – they need to focus on the economy to win midterms

Rosenberg 1/27/22 President, NDN and the New Policy Institute, a think tank based in Washington, DC Prominent American political strategist, thought-leader and commentator An experienced television news producer and highly regarded political strategist and thought-leader, Simon has spent three decades in national media and politics. He is a veteran of two Presidential campaigns, including a senior role in the famous 1992 Clinton War Room. In his current capacity as President of NDN/New Policy Institute, Simon advises leading politicians, Administration officials and policy makers on a wide range of issues here in the United States and abroad. He is a frequent commentator in the national media, appearing regularly in major newspapers and websites, political journals and on cable and network television. A few years ago GQ magazine named him one of the 50 most powerful people in Washington. In this past election cycle, he was a senior advisor to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, helping craft the stategy which netted the Democrats 40 seats and earned the highest vote share by either party since 1986. Simon is a graduate of Tufts University and currently serves on the board of the Tisch College of Civic Life at Tufts, where he recently taught a semester-long seminar to undergraduates on American politics. He is a Henry Crown Fellow at the Aspen Institute, a member of the U.S. State Department’s Advisory Committee on International Information and Communications Policy and an advisory board member of the Open Source Elections Technology Institute. Outside of his work with NDN, Simon has advised private corporate and political clients, including Univision, Nanomix, Discourse Intelligence, and the DCCC. He and his wife, Caitlin Durkovich, and their three teenage children live in Washington, DC. “Memo: Dems Need To Focus On Winning The Economic Argument,” January 27, 22, https://www.ndn.org/memo-dems-need-focus-winning-economic-argument

Winning The Economic Argument – This week we hosted noted economist Rob Shapiro for a terrific discussion of his two recent essays in the Washington Monthly, It’s A Biden Boom – And No One Has Noticed Yet and The Biden Boom Is Bigger Than We Thought. You can watch it here. The two essays make clear that 2021 was a banner year for the American economy, one of the best in the post WWII era – 6m jobs, 5+% GDP growth, record new business formations, real wage gains for the bottom 50% of workers, 5m people gaining health insurance, booming housing and stock markets. There can be no doubt that the vast majority of Americans are better off today than they were a year ago, and given the daily adversity we all faced due to COVID, we need to tip our hats to the resilience, ingenuity and can do spirit of the American people. The question of why the electorate doesn’t understand that the economy is better, and why Americans give Republicans a big advantage on the economy right now when their recent track while in office is among the worst in American history (3 consecutive recessions) are among the most important questions in American politics today. It is very hard to see how Democrats are competitive in the elections this fall without doing something significant to change voter’s basic understanding of how just much better the economy is today, and how much better the economy has been with Democrats in power over the past 30 plus years (40m of the 42m jobs created since 1989 have been created under Democratic Presidents). As a matter of politics, changing this understanding should be the singular mission of the Democratic Party in 2022. There are many forms a big campaign like this could take, but there are two pieces which Democrats should consider right away: The DNC Leads A Big Conversation About How With Democrats Things Get Better – The DNC should take on this mission, and organize a yearlong education effort involving every element of the party across the country. Power points, videos, fact sheets, web sites should be developed, and every state and local party have to make it be their goal to be loud and proud about the achievements of Joe Biden and the Democrats more broadly this year. Language and arguments should be tested, workshopped. A large multimedia ad campaign should be developed to support the free media effort, and it should run in the second quarter of this year, from mid-April to July 4th. Every Democrat should be asked to contribute to this vital effort, and a target goal of $50m should be established. Voters need to know this information now, not in the fall – that is when candidates have to do their job. Other elements of the center-left family with resources can amplify the effort. At a strategy level the goal should be to get the Democrats even or ahead with Republicans on the economy by Labor Day, making it far more likely the election will be competitive this fall. A campaign like this also has the benefit of bringing the party back together around a singular mission, something we think the party can use right now. Elected Officials Do Months of Events Showing How Much Better Things Are – In research NDN did in late 2010 and early 2011, we asked voters who did they need to hear from to know a recovery was taking place. The clear answer was local business people. Voters told us that if they heard it from a brewery which had hired a few more people, or a factory that was going to two shifts, then they would believe a recovery was taking place. That work informed the work of the Obama White House, and Senate and House Democrats over the next few years as we struggled to help people understand a recovery was indeed taking place. Today’s elected Democrats should tear some pages from this playbook, and spend most of their public events in state or district in the coming months with local business people who can validate that things are better. These local leaders could also become stars in campaign ads and videos. The efforts to play up the Infrastructure Bill should be seen as part of this effort, and not stand alone; for there are limits to how much political benefit Democrats will get from things people will not see or feel before November. As the incumbent party, Democrats will be judged this fall largely on whether voters think we’ve done a good job, that things are better. Things are better, and we should spend the next 10 months relentlessly making the case that they are. Every moment we spend talking about things which will not be felt by the election should be understood now as a distraction. We have a vital argument to win this year; one we can win; and one we must win to make the elections competitive this fall. And we need to keep repeating – if we can’t get credit for what we’ve done, it’s unlikely we are going to get credit for things which haven’t happened yet. Things are better. With Democrats things are better. Things are better today than they were a year ago. Let’s get to work people. Final note – we are not as convinced as others that inflation is the central reason Democrats have struggled to break through on the economy this year. For more on that see here. We believe the central reason we haven’t broken through is that we haven’t tried hard enough. That’s a fixable thing, and what this plan tries to address. Does this plan assume the economy stays strong in 2022, and we can keep making the argument? Yep. It is the likely scenario and we should go for it.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › A2 Win for Biden

No one cares about foreign policy during midterms.

Cook 22 (Charlie Cook. Cook is an American political analyst for the Cook Political Report. “Foreign Policy Unlikely to Save Democrats in the Fall”. National journal. February 2022. https://www.cookpolitical.com/analysis/national/national-politics/foreign-policy-unlikely-save-democrats-fall)

Biden’s 41 percent overall approval rating in Gallup was bracketed by a , 36 percent on handling “the situation with Russia,” 37 percent on the economy, and 40 percent for foreign policy. Given how monolithic partisans are in their approval ratings and actual voting, it is always useful to look only at independents, the ‘jump ball’ Americans. Biden’s overall rating among them was 35 percent (5 points below his approval among all adults). His best marks were on dealing with the coronavirus (45 percent approval), followed by foreign policy (37 percent), Russia (35 percent), and the economy (30 percent). It is pretty clear the president and his administration’s denial of the threat of inflation and slow reaction to it was exceedingly damaging to him. (While we are on the subject, it is fascinating to see Senate Democrats, after so passionately advocating for more infrastructure spending this past year, propose suspending the gasoline tax for the rest of the year, no matter that the gas tax is the primary regular funding source for transportation infrastructure. Panic is never pretty.) While we don’t know the trajectory that the Russia/Ukraine crisis will take, and there are , we do know that in the absence of a large number of U.S. military deaths, Americans rarely vote on foreign-policy issues, particularly in midterms. The state and direction of the economy, particularly , is far more determinative. Turnout and the relative levels of enthusiasm between the two parties’ bases is key. There was a big gap heading into the 2018 midterm elections with, as usual, the party out of power much more motivated going into the fall of that year—though the Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court nomination did a lot to close the gap in predominantly rural areas, which helped Republicans actually score a net gain in the Senate while getting hosed (a political science term) in the House. Right now, Democrats are the party suffering from a lack of motivation among their base. If someone wanting a read on a midterm is only going to watch two things, it should be a president’s approval rating and the , both pretty good barometers of which way the wind is blowing and whether it’s light, moderate, or heavy.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Link › A2 Win for Biden

Russia actually not a win for Biden in the mind of voters

Vakil 02/25/22 Caroline Vakil is currently a breaking news reporter at The Hill where I cover a range of political and national interest stories. I am especially passionate about covering housing/infrastructure and transportation. Throughout my various work experiences, I've enjoyed exploring how to apply my reporting and research across different platforms including newspapers, magazines, TV, and a podcast. “62 percent of voters say Putin wouldn’t have invaded Ukraine if Trump were president: poll” The Hill, February 25, 22, https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/595919-62-percent-of-voters-say-putin-wouldnt-have-invaded-ukraine-if-trump/

A majority of American voters say that Russian President Vladimir Putin would not have invaded Ukraine had former President Trump still been in office, according to a new survey released on Friday. A new Harvard Center for American Political Studies (CAPS)-Harris Poll survey released Friday found that 62 percent of those polled believed Putin would not be moving against Ukraine if Trump had been president. When looking strictly at the answers of Democrats and Republicans, 85 percent of Republicans and 38 percent of Democrats answered this way. However, 38 percent of all Americans polled believed that Putin would have invaded Ukraine even if Trump had been president. Trump’s critics contend that the former president’s relationship with Putin was extremely cozy. For example, Trump publicly called for Russia to be admitted to the G-7 and has repeatedly criticized Ukraine. Meanwhile, the Biden administration has staunchly defended the independence of Ukraine. The House twice impeached Trump, the first time related to his opposition to providing Ukraine with military aid. A majority of Americans polled — 59 percent — also said they believed that the Russian president moved on Ukraine because Putin saw weakness in President Biden, while 41 percent said that it was not a factor in Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine. Soon after Russia invaded Ukraine late Wednesday, President Biden condemned what he described as an “unprovoked and unjustified attack” and expressed solidarity with Ukraine. The U.S. has imposed sanctions on Russian financial institutions, Russian elites and their family members, the Nord Stream 2 AG — the parent company of the Nord Stream 2 pipeline — and, the White House confirmed Friday, Putin himself, among other entities. However, the U.S. has resisted calls to kick Russia out of the SWIFT international banking system, despite appeals from Ukrainian officials and some U.S. lawmakers. The polling comes after Biden has suffered low approval ratings in recent months. Since taking office, the president has had to navigate a multitude of issues, including a lingering COVID-19 pandemic, a chaotic evacuation from Afghanistan, infighting among Democrats over the administration’s legislative agenda and now the invasion of Ukraine. The Harvard CAPS-Harris Poll survey was conducted between Feb. 23 and Feb. 24 with 2,026 registered voters. The survey is an online sample drawn from the Harris Panel and weighted to reflect known demographics. As a representative online sample, it does not report a probability confidence interval.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Uniqueness overwhelms

Clean sweep for GOP – history, Biden, coalition, generic ballot, candidate strength, enthusiasm, fundraising, primary turnout

Greenblatt 5-27 [Alan Greenblatt -- Senior Staff Writer. Alan covers politics as well as policy issues for Governing. He is the coauthor of a standard textbook on state and local governments. He previously worked as a reporter for NPR and CQ and has written about politics and culture for many other outlets, print and online., 5-27-2022 You Don't Need to Be a Fortune Teller: Signs Point to GOP Sweep This Year Governing https://www.governing.com/now/you-dont-need-to-be-a-fortune-teller-signs-point-to-gop-sweep-this-year] 6-26-2022

For Democrats this year, the only real question is whether the elections will be only moderately bad or completely terrible. If you think like a weather forecaster, all kinds of data point to a major storm. By basically every metric you can think of — fundraising, candidate recruitment, voter enthusiasm, demographic shifts — a big wave is forming that will sweep hundreds of Democrats out of office, up and down the ticket. The main reason isn’t hard to suss out. Every president can count on his party losing seats in midterms, but President Biden’s approval ratings are particularly bad. On average, 41 percent of Americans approve of the job he’s doing, compared with 54 percent who disapprove. “That is one of the lowest marks of any president since World War II,” says Henry Olsen, a conservative analyst at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. “Unless that changes, I would expect a solid Democratic defeat.” Granted, President Donald Trump’s approval ratings were similarly bargain basement in 2018 — but then, Republicans lost control of the House that year, along with seven governorships. The more important comparison, at any rate, is not with Trump but with Biden himself. Biden won the presidency in 2020 by 4.5 points. If he’s down 13, that represents a huge drop in support, which seriously imperils his party. Swing voters have swung hard against Biden. His net approval rating among independents is roughly minus 20. That’s a group he carried in 2020 by 13 points, according to exit polls. We’ve already witnessed a demonstration of how the president’s numbers can drag down other Democrats. Last November, Biden’s net disapproval numbers were 12.5 percent points lower than his victory margin in 2020. Guess what? The swing from Biden’s share of the vote to that won in 2020 by the Democratic candidates for governor was 12 points. Gov. Phil Murphy managed barely to hold on in New Jersey, but Democrat Terry McAuliffe lost the governorship to Republican Glenn Youngkin in Virginia — a state Biden had carried a year earlier by 10 points. Now, Biden’s numbers are even lower than they were back in November. This means any Democrat who won their last election by less than double-digit margins should be nervous. That certainly includes vulnerable governors such as Tony Evers of Wisconsin and Laura Kelly of Kansas. “The president’s dismal ratings are what people care about the most,” says GOP consultant David Carney. “It could be a bloodbath up and down the ballot, from the school board to Congress." There are several known unknowns that could shift the landscape between now and Nov. 8. Inflation might tick lower and the war in Ukraine may have played out in a way that helps Biden politically. Perhaps Tuesday’s school shooting in Texas will activate voters in a way that other mass shootings have failed to do. An NPR/Marist poll released last week found that the expected Supreme Court action to overturn Roe v. Wade should help energize Democrats. Sixty-six percent of Democrats said it would make them more likely to vote this fall, versus 40 percent of Republicans. “There are two big things that we don’t know yet how they will play: The first one is the Jan. 6 committee and its hearings, and the second one is this abortion decision,” says Lara Brown, a political scientist at George Washington University. “Depending on how those capture the attention of the country and different demographics, I do think that can impact the magnitude of what ever wave the Republicans are looking at.” But in the weeks since Justice Samuel Alito’s majority opinion on abortion law was leaked, there’s been no evidence of a surge in Democratic participation in primaries or early voting. Not even any real uptick. “I’d be surprised if Roe v. Wade did not energize the marginal Democratic voter, the sort that would usually vote in the presidential race but not necessarily in the midterm, but that only gets you so far,” Olsen says. “The real game is the swing voter.” Undoing Obama’s Coalition Biden’s old boss, Barack Obama, put together a winning coalition during his presidency, combining college-educated whites with young, Black and Latino voters. The danger for Democrats is that Biden appears to be unraveling that coalition. About the only groups still solidly in his camp are dedicated members of the Democratic base, such as Black voters and college-educated women. Biden carried close to two-thirds of Hispanic voters in 2020, but their shift toward Trump, compared to 2016, was notable, especially in states such as Florida and Texas. In the Texas primaries in March this year, participation in GOP primaries was up dramatically in heavily Hispanic portions of South Texas that traditionally have been overwhelmingly Democratic. An NPR/Marist poll released last month found that 52 percent of Latinos say they’re more likely to support Republican candidates for Congress; just 39 percent favor Democrats. Young voters have been a particular problem for Biden. Voters under 30 favored Biden over Trump, 60 percent to 39 percent, in 2020, but they’ve soured on him since. Biden’s approval rating among young voters has dropped by 18 points over the past year, according to a Harvard Institute of Politics poll – which is in line with what other pollsters are finding. Even as Democrats shed support among Latinos, young voters and parents, the party’s longstanding problem with working-class white voters continues to worsen. The April NPR/Marist poll found Democrats are only favored by a third of white voters without college degrees, compared to 55 percent who say they are likely to support Republicans. “The people who are left backing Biden are the people who would back any Democrat under anything except extreme circumstances,” Olsen says. “That’s a terrible place to be in for an election. You’ve lost America’s middle.” Generically Bad The NPR/Marist poll asked what is known as a generic ballot question — are you more likely to favor a Republican or a Democrat — rather than asking about any individual candidates who might be on the ballot. Candidates do matter. Republicans were notably unhappy that Pennsylvania voters decided to nominate conspiracy-minded state Sen. Doug Mastriano for governor last week, viewing him as more likely to lose in November than other potential picks. Similarly, Republican officials in Missouri are hoping another candidate can coalesce enough support to stop Eric Greitens, who resigned as governor in disgrace in 2018 amid multiple scandals, from winning nomination to the Senate. Republicans left winnable seats on the table in 2010 and 2012 by nominating “unacceptable” candidates unable to win in the general election, as Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky himself said last month. “From an atmospheric point of view, it’s a perfect storm of problems for the Democrats,” McConnell said. “How could you screw this up? It’s actually possible. And we’ve had some experience with that in the past.” McConnell was referring to the 100-seat Senate, which is currently tied. There are relatively few Democratic seats in play this year, meaning each race will count enormously. Still, Republicans have enough opportunities not only to win the majority but come away with a total of perhaps 53 or 54 seats. The GOP needs only five seats to take control of the 435-member House. Redistricting has turned out to be more or less a wash, but on net Republicans gained a slight advantage. A lot of GOP-tilted seats have been fortified against all but the worst-case scenarios, while Democrats hold more seats that are marginal. They’ll have little protection in a wave year. There’s hardly any ticket-splitting, with voters favoring candidates of one party or the other up and down the ballot. There are only 16 seats in the House where the district voted one way for president in 2020 and the other for Congress. The players matter, but sometimes the playing field matters more. In the most competitive House districts, generic Republicans are leading generic Democrats by 47 percent to 39 percent. That’s according to internal polling by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee. Even bad candidates can win in the right environment, which this is shaping up to be for Republicans. “We’re going to have a lot of people winning that no one ever heard of,” Carney says. Messaging and Money The abortion issue may help Democrats politically in a couple of ways. It could help inspire young voters who don’t like the GOP but aren’t Biden stans. It also gives the party something to talk about. Since the Alito leak, Democrats have been much more full-throated in support of abortion rights than Republicans have been about its demise. Democrats would like to think they can easily convince voters that Republicans can’t be trusted since they support the election lies of a twice-impeached coup leader. But if tying Republicans to Trump were a winning strategy, it would have paid off for McAuliffe in Virginia, who certainly tried it. Republicans aren’t made of Teflon. The very term “culture war” suggests there are two sides battling, so efforts to ban books or restrict the teaching of racial history and gender identity won’t play well with everyone. “The more the party focused on these culture war issues, I actually believe the less it will help them in the suburbs,” says Brown, the George Washington University professor. But culture war issues motivate the party’s base. And, to appeal to swing voters, Republicans have plenty of other clubs with which to beat Biden and the Democrats. Maybe you’ve already heard this, but inflation has jumped the most in four decades. Gas prices, already at a retail average of $4.60 per gallon, may well go higher with summer travel demand — perhaps as high as $6. Homicides have increased dramatically since 2019, fueling a return to “tough on crime” rhetoric among Republicans. It's all easy fodder for an opposition party to run on. Polls indicate that voters trust the GOP more, by significant margins, when it comes to inflation and the economy in general. Republicans are enjoying their biggest advantage regarding the crime issue in decades. All of this is reflected in how partisans are responding. The gap between the numbers of Democrats and Republicans retiring from Congress is the highest it’s been in decades. At the legislative level, Republicans are leaving fewer seats open than Democrats. Republicans raised $170 million from January to March through WinRed, an online fundraising platform. That still lags the Democrats’ ActBlue, which has traditionally been much more robust, but represents nearly a one-quarter jump for WinRed over the same period in 2020. The Republican Governors Association raised $33 million in the first quarter of the year, which was nearly $10 million more than the Democratic Governors Association. The Republican State Leadership Committee brought in just over $10 million, compared with $6.5 million for the Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee. Who Will Turn Out? In the end, voter behavior matters most of all. Again, the GOP has a big advantage. A slew of polls have showed large and indeed growing gaps in terms of levels of enthusiasm about voting this year between Republicans and Democrats. But we don’t have to rely strictly on polls any more. We’re still relatively early in the primary season, but Republicans are showing up in ways that Democrats are not. In the first 10 states to hold primaries this year, Republicans received 61 percent of the total vote, according to an analysis by GOP pollster John Couvillon. The party generating more enthusiasm in primaries has fared quite well in the last few midterms. Democrats received 54 percent of the primary vote in 2018 — a solid midterm year for them — while Republicans got 55 percent in both 2010 and 2014, landslide years for the party. It’s true that primary turnout isn’t a perfect measure, since not all races are equally competitive. On Tuesday, for example, Stacey Abrams was unopposed for the Democratic nomination for governor of Georgia, while GOP Gov. Brian Kemp faced a contentious, if ultimately easy, contest against former Sen. David Perdue. Turnout on the GOP side increased by a half-million votes, compared to the 2018 primary. But looking at the total picture, it’s clear more Republicans are turning out. A lot more Republicans. Overall Republican primary turnout is up 32 percent, while Democratic turnout has actually declined 3 percent. All this paints a pretty grim picture for Democrats. They’re running behind on the issues that concern voters most. Their leader is losing support among key constituencies. Their potential candidates are less likely to run, while their voters are less likely to turn out. It’s clear that Republicans will be stronger at the end of the year than they are now. It’s not yet possible to say how much stronger, but if anyone offers to bet you Democrats will retain power in Congress, take their money. At the state level, GOP victories may not be as momentous, but that’s only because they already hold majorities among governors, legislators and legislative chambers. For Republicans, it’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas will fall early this year, on Nov. 8.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Uniqueness overwhelms

The Democrats will be wiped out – history, Biden approval, inflation, secondary issues

Hulsman 5-14 [John C. Hulsman is the president and managing partner of John C. Hulsman Enterprises, a prominent global political risk consulting firm. 5-14-2022 The Case For A Republican Clean Sweep In The 2022 Midterms – OpEd Eurasia Review https://www.eurasiareview.com/14052022-the-case-for-a-republican-clean-sweep-in-the-2022-midterms-oped/] 6-26-2022

In 2020, my firm reached one of its peaks, correctly calling close but clear wins for the Democrats in the House of Representatives and the presidency, as well as precisely predicting the 50-50 split in the Senate. For all our pride in this, the 2022 midterms are just around the corner, with a new set of political imperatives that need to be mastered. So, without further ado, here we go: The 2022 midterms will result in a Republican wipeout of the Democrats, with the GOP gaining upwards of 30 seats in the House and one or two in the Senate, giving them full control of the Congress. Here is the case for our bold prediction.

First, the historical record is squarely against President Joe Biden and the Democrats. Since 1870, only four elections out of 38 resulted in the party holding the White House losing fewer than five seats, which is the size of the party’s present paper-thin majority in the House. Traditionally, the country tends to have so-called buyer’s remorse after the first two years of a presidency, either faulting the new team for failing to live up to its campaign promises or conversely fearing the new White House is trying to do too much. In either case, the opposition party has been supported 34 out of 38 times as an institutional check on the new president’s power.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Non-unique – Roe

Democrats are going to win because of Roe

Khaled ’22 ( Fatma Khaled is a staff writer at Newsweek, “Republicans Fear Abortion Ruling Will 'Bail the Dems Out' in 2024, Midterms,”, Newsweek, , 6/25/2022)

Still, some Republicans believe that the Supreme Court's decision will backfire against their party, including former President Donald Trump, who privately told his advisers that overturning Roe is "bad for Republicans" as it could potentially impact some key voters such as suburban women, The New York Times reported Friday. Jason Roe, the former executive director of the state Republican Party in Michigan, said he is "nervous" about the political implications of the Court's decision, according to Politico, because "the opportunities we should have with suburban women become more complicated when that issue is on the table, and I think it puts us on defense." One Trump adviser said that the former president is "convinced it won't help him in the future," referring to abortion, according to The Washington Post on Friday, and that it is better if other issues became the primary focus in the wake of the midterms and the 2024 election. However, the Court's ruling might work in the Democrats' favor, according to a former GOP congressman, who preferred to be anonymous. "The only thing [Democrats] have got going for them is the Roe thing, which is what, 40 years of settled law that will be changed that will cause some societal consternation," the congressman told Politico. "And can they turn that into some turnout? I think the answer is probably 'Yes.'" "Maybe instead of losing 45 seats, they lose 30," he added. "There will be a few seats that Republicans would have won without [the abortion rights decision], and they may not win them now." Meanwhile, a Republican operative familiar with polling in state and federal races, who also spoke with Politico on the condition of anonymity, noted that overturning Roe impacts swing voters who lean Republican. "It takes a sizeable bloc of voters who were leaning [Republican], and it gives them reason to vote Democrat," he said. "And they haven't had any reason to vote Democrat in quite a while." Political commentator S.E. Cupp told CNN on Friday that politically she "can't imagine a better voter turnout engine than this ruling for Democrats" in the midterms. "And you can make the argument that the Republicans' legislative victories and the Supreme Court victory by a conservative court are regressive, they're taking us backwards. Whether you like them or not, you can't deny the fact that they're going backwards...They're taking us back to a different time when these weren't rights," she said, and added: "It really does feel anachronistic with where the country is, and so I think that's a good message for Democrats." Newsweek reached out to political scientist at Georgetown University Hans Noel, the spokesperson for Republican political strategist Sarah Longwell, and Republican political strategist Danny Diaz for comment.

2022 CNDI Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Non-unique – Roe

Outrage over Roe vs Wade overturn flips the script on midterms - democrats will win now

Morgan 06/24 [Morgan, David, reuters.com, “With Roe overturned, U.S. Democrats turn abortion battle to November midterms”, Date accessed: June 24th 2022]

WASHINGTON, June 24 (Reuters) - Leading Democrats sought to turn Friday's Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade into a rallying cry for the November elections, warning of grim consequences for women, contraception and gay marriage if Republicans regain control of Congress. In a 5-4 ruling powered by its conservative majority, the high court overturned the 1973 landmark decision that had recognized a woman's right to an abortion, and had legalized it nationwide, for nearly half a century. The decision was greeted as a stunning victory by anti-abortion Republicans and other conservatives, while Democrats and abortion-right activists protested what they described as a step backwards for the rights of American women. But with control of the House of Representatives and the Senate at stake in the Nov. 8 midterm elections, Democrats also warned that the rights of women and others would face further dangers if Republicans regain control of Congress. "The Republicans are plotting a nationwide abortion ban. They cannot be allowed to have a majority in the Congress to do that," said House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi, the chamber's top Democrat, told reporters. "It is clear that we just have to win a majority in November. Everything is at stake," added Pelosi, a Catholic who was barred from taking communion last month by the archbishop of San Francisco because of her support for abortion rights. About 71% of Americans - including majorities of Democrats and Republicans - say decisions about terminating a pregnancy should be left to a woman and her doctor, rather than regulated by the government, according to Reuters/Ipsos polling. Democrats hope voter anger about the Supreme Court's decision will help them retain their razor-thin margins of control in the House and Senate. With President Joe Biden's approval rating slumping, most forecasters have so far favored Republicans' chances of winning a majority in at least the House. "This fall, Roe is on the ballot. Personal freedoms are on the ballot. The right to privacy, liberty, equality are all about it," Biden said on Friday. It was not clear how easily Democrats could use the abortion rights message to mobilize support. Despite having control of the White House and both chambers of Congress for nearly 18 months, Biden and his Democratic allies have disappointed their core supporters with repeated failures on hot-button issues including abortion, voting rights and social spending. Efforts to reform the Senate filibuster and overcome Republican opposition to the Biden agenda have been hamstrung by opposition from within their own party, specifically Democratic Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema. Even their success at enacting moderate gun-safety legislation proved uninspiring to strong gun-control advocates and was overshadowed twice by the Supreme Court, which broadly expanded gun rights a day before overturning Roe v. Wade. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said voters would now have a clear choice between Democrats and "MAGA Republicans," using an acronym for allies of former President Donald Trump. "Elect more MAGA Republicans if you want nationwide abortion bans, the jailing of women and doctors and no exemptions for rape or incest. Or, elect more pro-choice Democrats to save Roe," Schumer said in a statement. House Republicans welcomed the ruling and talked openly about a path forward to "end abortion in this country." "The Supreme Court's decision overturning Roe v. Wade, overturning that flawed decision finally allows states and Congress to protect life in ways that we never were able to for the last 50 years," Representative Steve Scalise, the No. 2 House Republican, told reporters.