Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT: Medicaid DA

5—Alternative drivers of food shortages exist that Medicaid doesn’t solve for such as natural disasters, increased global exports, and price declines.

Johansson ’20. [ Robert Johansson is the USDA’s Chief Economist and reports on farming, trade, and the Covid-19 pandemic.] “America’s Farmers: Resilient Throughout The COVID Pandemic.” September 24, 2020. https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2020/09/24/americas-farmers-resilient-throughout-covid-pandemic

The disruptive impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on the U.S. agricultural system have been broad and varied. And they follow several years of trying production and market conditions for U.S. farmers. In 2017 and 2018, several hurricanes pummeled U.S. farms; 2019 brought historically poor planting conditions and retaliatory tariffs cut potential for our agricultural exports compared to 2017. This year, farmers and consumers have been planning production and managing household budgets at a time when markets — food, commodity, labor, energy — are being jolted by global, national and regional shutdowns, slowdowns, and overall uncertainty. Those shocks to the U.S. and global economies have affected both the supply and demand for food in the U.S. and the rest of the world, leading to short-term, localized shortages in the U.S., particularly in livestock products like meat, while farmers had to deal with, for example, excess milk supplies in other areas. In general, U.S. food prices have risen since January while prices received by U.S. producers have fallen. But while rising wholesale and retail food prices and some temporarily empty shelves drew a lot of public attention and stoked fears over availability and affordability of our food, the severe impacts of the crisis on U.S. farmers have been much less visible. Here we share some information and data on farming operations and how the crisis has impacted U.S. farmers over the past few months. Tough times have been underway for years The COVID-19 pandemic not only triggered a new type of crisis for the farming sector, it also came at a tough time for U.S. farmers. For the past few years, global commodity production has outpaced demand in most years and prices have been falling. Since the historic 2012 U.S. drought and peak in commodity prices in 2013, global commodity production has generally outpaced demand, fueling continued price declines – in nominal and real terms. Between 2012-2019, producer prices for corn fell 48% from $6.89 per bushel to $3.56, and producer prices for soybeans fell 40% - almost six dollars per bushel Prices for cattle, hogs, broilers and milk have also been on downward trend over the past 5 years. However, cost of production for these commodities in 2019 was higher or only marginally lower than five years earlier (see chart 1). During the same period, many of our global competitors, supported in part by advantageous currency values, have ramped up production for export —wheat in the Black Sea region, and corn, soybeans, and cotton in South America. Meanwhile, U.S. farmers have had to deal with a significant economic (tariffs) and weather-related challenges (drought and hurricanes) that have kept production costs relatively high, squeezing the margins for many crop, livestock, and dairy farmers. Clear signs of financial distress had emerged among U.S. farmers even prior to the onset of the COVID-19 outbreak. Investment in equipment was down, farmer debt was up, and so was borrowing against land. By the end of 2019, the delinquency rate on commercial loans hit a six-year high, and the delinquency rate on farmland loans was at its highest level since 2013. Inflation-adjusted farm income increased in 2019, but only when including federal farm aid payments and indemnities for crop insurance. Some of those payments were specifically introduced to assist farmers in adjusting to market disruptions caused by the retaliatory tariffs imposed by China and other countries on U.S. agricultural exports and the unprecedented levels of weather-induced prevented plantings in 2019. COVID-19 exacerbated the challenges facing farmers The rapid proliferation of COVID-19 at home and abroad and subsequent shutdown of parts of the economy led to unprecedented and simultaneous supply and demand shocks to the food system. Crude oil prices, which began the year at $61.18 per barrel, briefly traded negative for the first time ever in April. Grocery store retail sales rose sharply while sales at food service and drinking places during March and April were $47.5 billion lower than during the same period in 2019. The consequences of the crisis for farmers and their families were immediate and severe. For example, the reduction in miles driven as the public sheltered in place, meant less demand for biofuels, which in turn led to reduced demand for grains used in biofuels, particularly corn. In addition, the immediate and drastic decline in food demand by restaurants and hotel customers isolated farmers and food processors from some of their biggest buyers, especially for meat, dairy, and specialty crops. As a result, we have seen agricultural commodity prices also decline significantly over the past few months (see chart 2). In recent weeks we have seen a reversal in some prices as global demand is recovering. So as consumers were dealing with localized food shortages and rising retail food prices, producers were grappling with falling farmgate prices and a glut of output that forced them to euthanize livestock, dump milk, and dispose of perishable products that could not be stored. Data on differences in prices at the farm and retail levels show that, as of August, the price paid by consumers for one pound of retail beef, for example, has risen by 5 percent since January, 2020 (a significant fall-off from June, when it was 30 percent higher), while cattle producers are receiving 20 percent less for their cattle. Similarly, milk prices are up by nearly 5 percent for consumers since the beginning of the year, and milk prices received by dairy farmers, although were up 5 percent as well in August, they follow successive decreases in prices received from February through June, including a 31 percent decrease from January to June. The loss of jobs across the country have also hit farm families hard. In mid-June we saw rates of unemployment of 8.8 percent in rural areas, compared with 11.6 percent in urban areas. While farming-dependent counties suffered fewer job losses than most other regions, many farm families rely on off-farm income to help with health coverage and to offset losses on the farm operation . With the unprecedented number of job losses we have seen since January, the impact on farm families and their finances could be extreme particularly for farms for which operating margins are so thin right now. According to a recent analysis by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas, the volume of total non-real estate loans declined for a fourth consecutive quarter, falling by 13 percent in the second quarter of 2020 compared to a year ago. The analysis shows that the largest decline in loan volume was for livestock feeder loans, which fell more than 40 percent from a year ago. Outstanding farm debt during the second quarter of 2020 also declined with the slowdown of lending; yet, farm loan delinquency rates continued to edge higher (chart 3a&b). Although comprising less than 2.5 percent of farm loans, the volume of delinquent farm real estate and non-real estate loans increased about 17 percent and 13 percent, respectively, compared to a year ago. The volume of loans past due more than 90 days continued to account for the smallest share of total delinquencies, but increased at a similar rate, suggesting that previously past due loans remained delinquent. Unprecedented crises called for unprecedented measures The magnitude and speed with which the COVID-19 outbreak affected the economy in general, and the food system in particular, motivated Congressional action in the CARES Act and dictated the scale and nature of USDA’s responses. It became quickly obvious that this crisis was nothing like we have ever experienced and that it could pose a real threat to the viability of many farming operations and, with it, to the sustainability of our domestic food supply. While evidence at a national scale is not yet available, losses by Texas agriculture alone were estimated at $6 - $8 billion, or 28-37 percent of the state’s cash receipts in 2019. USDA’s most recent forecast for farm income for 2020, from September 2 projected that producers would receive $31 billion less this year in cash receipts compared to pre-COVID income forecasts from February. Mitigating the crisis required a wide range of measures targeting all aspects of the food supply and demand system and its different stakeholders. Most critically, USDA initially provided assistance through the Coronavirus Food Assistance Program (CFAP 1) estimated to provide up to $16 billion to U.S. farmers and ranchers to help them deal with the significant income losses they incurred during the pandemic.  Following the enactment of the CARES Act in March, USDA quickly developed a broad program to help producers experiencing revenue losses and facing new costs, with sign-ups starting in late May. Payments were made available to producers experiencing losses from across the broad spectrum of U.S. agriculture

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT: Medicaid DA

4—Link turn. Medicaid expansion not only fails to prevent rural hospital closure but contributes to them by increasing financial pressure on hospitals.

Dublois ’23. [ Hayden Dublois is the data and analytics director for the Foundation for Government Accountability. He holds a Bachelor of Arts in Economics from Middlebury College and a Master of Business Administration (MBA) from Fitchburg State University.] “Medicaid Expansion Won’t Stop Rural Hospital Closures.” April 28, 2023. https://www.wsj.com/articles/medicaid-expansion-wont-save-rural-hospitals-obama-care-fraud-dependency-e9ad20c7

Democrats think they’ve found the key to convincing Republican states to expand Medicaid and cover millions more able-bodied adults in the government-run health-insurance program. Over the past few years, Democrats have claimed that refusing to accept ObamaCare’s central policy will force the closure of rural hospitals, hurting GOP states and voters the most. This tug-at-the-heartstrings message has swayed Republican-dominated states such as South Dakota, Missouri and, as of late March, North Carolina to expand Medicaid. But it’s a lie. I have analyzed every hospital closure since 2014 when ObamaCare went into effect. Medicaid expansion has failed to halt rural hospital closures, and in some cases it contributes to them. The reason is simple: Medicaid is so poorly run that it often adds financial burdens to hospitals. The 10 Republican-led states that haven’t adopted this policy would be wise to hold their ground, given that Medicaid expansion also has disastrous consequences for state budgets and fosters historic levels of government dependency. Here are the facts. Since 2014, dozens of hospitals have closed in states that haven’t expanded Medicaid. Yet their stated reasons almost always have nothing to do with Medicaid expansion. Damage from natural disasters, declining business and fraud, among many other factors, have caused hospitals to close. Only four hospitals in nonexpansion states directly attributed their closures to a lack of Medicaid expansion. Two of them later were alleged to have engaged in wide-scale fraud and financial mismanagement, casting doubt on their earlier statements. Even more telling is what happened in the nearly 40 states that did expand Medicaid before the start of this year. Despite the assurances of liberal activists, nearly 50 hospitals have closed in these states since expansion passed, including more than a dozen in rural areas. Missouri voted to expand Medicaid by ballot initiative in August 2020, with implementation beginning a little more than a year later. Yet two rural hospitals closed in September 2022, well after expansion took effect. The situation will surely worsen. According to data from the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, 1 in 4 rural hospitals in expansion states are still at risk of closure. A 2019 Navigant study found that the top five states at risk of losing community-essential rural hospitals are all expansion states. This is exactly what Medicaid expansion was supposed to prevent, yet expansion itself is driving this crisis in rural and urban hospitals alike. The program’s reimbursement rates are about 60% of what private health insurance pays, often leaving hospitals with large losses on Medicaid patients. Nationwide, more than 18 million able-bodied adults and counting have enrolled in the program due to expansion, and each new recipient potentially adds red ink to a hospital’s balance sheet. Rural hospitals typically struggle financially as it is, and Medicaid expansion can push them into insolvency. But the problem isn’t limited to rural hospitals. Pennsylvania expanded Medicaid in 2015 and Philadelphia’s Hahnemann Hospital closed in 2019 because of what the Philadelphia Inquirer called a “heavy reliance on Medicaid.” Despite these closures, hospital advocacy groups have joined Democrats in vigorously demanding expansion. The promise of federal money in the short term—and the resulting bonuses and pay bumps for hospital executives—is apparently more important than future stability. Democrats won’t stop until they convince all 50 states to expand Medicaid. As one activist told the New York Times in March, “this argument about rural hospital closures has been an incredibly compelling argument to voters.” That same story, which focused on Mississippi, was titled “A State’s Choice to Forgo Medicaid Funds Is Killing Hospitals.” Mississippi and Alabama are likely the next two states in Democrats’ sights. The remaining Republican-led states shouldn’t fall for it. By not expanding Medicaid, they are likely saving rural hospitals from even worse financial pressure, while protecting taxpayers from enormous losses and saving able-bodied adults from government dependence. In these states, at least, the truth about Medicaid expansion still prevails.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT: Medicaid DA

No link. Medicaid expansion fails—doesn’t help hospitals financial health or job security, which is what is was intended to do.

Harris ’23. [ Jessica Harris is a Policy Analyst at the Cardinal Institute for West Virginia Policy where she works to enact meaningful solutions and motivate her community. She holds a bachelor’s degree in criminology from West Virginia University and a Master of Public Administration and policy from American University.] “Medicaid Expansion Fails to Deliver on Promises.” March 10, 2023. https://www.realclearpolicy.com/articles/2023/03/10/medicaid_expansion_fails_to_deliver_on_promises_886506.html

Medicaid expansion is failing states across the nation according to a recent Foundation for Government Accountability (FGA) report. The report found states that have expanded Medicaid have faced more hospital closures than states that haven’t expanded the program. Of course, for years, advocates have claimed that expansion would be a necessary provision for financial health and job security for hospitals. Though, as suspected, data reveals the opposite. More accurately, non-expansion states have seen improved profitability, a larger bed capacity, and increased job growth.  For quite some time, expansion advocates have made the promise that Medicaid expansion would lead to economic booms for states, creating jobs and improving hospital finances, but the program’s launch clearly tells a different story. By expanding Medicaid through the Affordable Care Act (ACA), colloquially known as “Obamacare,” the federal government hoped to provide care for a larger share of low-income Americans. Under the ACA, states now have the option to expand their Medicaid programs to cover adults 65 and under with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level and an enhanced federal matching rate (FMAP) for their expansion populations. FMAP varies by state but allows the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to reimburse each state for a percentage of its total Medicaid expenditures. As of now, 38 states have adopted Medicaid expansion. States that have enacted the expansion are consequently awaiting success but face unrealized promises. Moreover, in the first year of the program, nearly 40% of expansion states lost hospital jobs. Here are the grim statistics from FGA’s report: 1 in 5 expansion states saw hospital job losses. From 2013 to 2016, Medicaid shortfalls at hospitals in expansion states grew by nearly 50%. Nearly 50 hospitals, many of which were rural facilities, shut their doors after expansion was implemented. Only 5% of hospitals directly cited a lack of Medicaid expansion in their list of reasons for closure; however, half of these hospitals were involved in alleged fraud or severe financial malpractice. 1 in 4 rural hospitals in expansion states are at risk for closure. The report also highlights the flaws in the health systems of Appalachian states, many of which have expanded Medicaid. The report states that the Ohio Valley Medical Center in Wheeling, West Virginia and East Ohio Regional Hospital in Martins Ferry, Ohio closed in 2019 resulting in the release of roughly 1,200 hospital workers. According to the report, hospitals partly accredited the closures, creating $37 million in losses, due to the “lower-reimbursing Medicaid program.”

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

No uniqueness – Chevron gets struck down now

Dempsey et. Al. 5-24, Financial Services lawyer and advocate

[Leah Dempsey, Elisabeth Esposito, Eric Waeckerlin, William McGrath, Bella Wolitz, Rosa Baum, Leah Dempsey was vice president and senior counsel for federal advocacy at ACA International, "Chevron Deference on the Chopping Block? Supreme Court to Hear Case That Could Change Landmark Precedent," Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, 5-24-2023, ] /RS

Several sitting Supreme Court justices have indicated a willingness to narrow or even strike down the Chevron doctrine. For example, Justice Clarence Thomas has written that Chevron rests on the “fiction that ambiguity in a statutory term is best construed as an implicit delegation of power to an administrative agency to determine the bounds of the law.” Cuozzo Speed Techs., LLC v. Lee, 579 U.S. 261, 286 (2016) (Thomas, J., concurring). Justice Brett Kavanaugh has criticized Chevron for encouraging administrative agencies to aggressively pursue policy goals unless “clearly forbidden” by statute. Brett Kavanaugh, Fixing Statutory Interpretation, 129 Harv. L. Rev. 2118, 2150 (2016). And in dissent to the court’s denial of certiorari in Buffington v. McDonough, 143 S. Ct. 14, 18–19 (2022) (Gorsuch, J., dissenting), Justice Neil Gorsuch opined that pursuant to the framework imposed by Chevron, “[r]ather than provide individuals with the best understanding of their rights and duties under law a neutral magistrate can muster, we outsource our interpretive responsibilities. Rather than say what the law is, we tell those who come before us to go ask a bureaucrat.” Other Supreme Court justices have also criticized the Chevron doctrine or taken the position that clear statements from Congress are required for major regulatory programs. Brownstein wrote about one example, regarding West Virginia v. EPA, 142 S. Ct. 2587 (2022) here. Another example includes Dep’t of Transp. v. Assoc. of American R.Rs., 575 U.S. 43, 61 (2015) (Alito, J., concurring).

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

PC is fake

Hirsch 13, former foreign editor, chief diplomatic correspondent, and national economic correspondent for Newsweek,

[Michael Hirsh, lecturer and commentator on Fox News, CNN, MSNBC, National Public Radio, "There’s No Such Thing as Political Capital," Yahoo News, 2-8-2013, ] /RS

Some political scientists who study the elusive calculus of how to pass legislation and run successful presidencies say that political capital is, at best, an empty concept, and that almost nothing in the academic literature successfully quantifies or even defines it. “It can refer to a very abstract thing, like a president’s popularity, but there’s no mechanism there. That makes it kind of useless,” says Richard Bensel, a government professor at Cornell University. Even Ornstein concedes that the calculus is far more complex than the term suggests. Winning on one issue often changes the calculation for the next issue; there is never any known amount of capital. “The idea here is, if an issue comes up where the conventional wisdom is that president is not going to get what he wants, and he gets it, then each time that happens, it changes the calculus of the other actors” Ornstein says. “If they think he’s going to win, they may change positions to get on the winning side. It’s a bandwagon effect.”

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

The court just ruled on equal protection – proves no change in PC

Harris 6-29, staff writer at The Atlantic.

[Adam Harris, author of The State Must Provide: Why America's Colleges Have Always Been Unequal—and How to Set Them Right, "The Decision That Upends the Equal-Protection Clause," Atlantic, 6-29-2023, ] /RS

In a 40-page opinion, Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the majority, argued that the institutions violated the equal-protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution by failing to use race “within the confines of narrow restrictions outlined by the court.” The programs, Roberts wrote, effectively require stereotyping of underrepresented minorities. “When a university admits students ‘on the basis of race, it engages in the offensive and demeaning assumption that [students] of a particular race, because of their race, think alike,’” Roberts wrote. He also pointed out that the Court has, in the past, suggested that such programs need a sunset date and lack a “logical endpoint.”

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

No link uniqueness - The court just ruled on equal protection

Hamid and Shah 6-30, Crimson Staff writers

[Rahem D. Hamid and Neil H. Shah, Crimson Staff Writers, "Inside the Decision: Here’s What the Supreme Court Said About Affirmative,” The Harvard Crimson, 6-30-2023, ] /RS

The Supreme Court ruled against Harvard and the University of North Carolina in a landmark decision Thursday morning, radically restricting the consideration of race in college admissions.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

Roberts has no support/PC now

Chait 7-3, writer for New York magazine

[Jonathan Chait, previously a senior editor at The New Republic and an assistant editor of The American Prospect. He writes a periodic column in the Los Angeles Times, “The Last Republican Politician," Intelligencer 7-3-2023, ] /RS

If you were to ask Roberts to explain this pattern, he would no doubt insist he is merely interpreting the law as written. As a nominee in 2005, he famously likened his role to an umpire calling balls and strikes, a conceit he has clung to even as the Court’s reputation for above-the-fray independence has dwindled. “We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges,” he said in 2018 after Trump lashed out at a federal judge over an immigration ruling.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Court Capital DA

Nonuq: SCOTUS alr mega conservative - they are eager to use their power and Roberts vote is irrelevant after Barrett’s arrival

Liptak '22 [Adam;7-1-2022; Adam Liptak covers the United States Supreme Court and writes Sidebar, a column on legal developments. A graduate of Yale Law School, he practiced law for 14 years before joining the news staff of The New York Times in 2002. ; "A Transformative Term at the Most Conservative Supreme Court in Nearly a Century," ]

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court moved relentlessly to the right in its first full term with a six-justice conservative majority, issuing far-reaching decisions that will transform American life. It eliminated the constitutional right to abortion, recognized a Second Amendment right to carry guns outside the home, made it harder to address climate change and expanded the role of religion in public life.

But those blockbusters, significant though they were, only began to tell the story of the conservative juggernaut the court has become. By one standard measurement used by political scientists, the term that ended on Thursday was the most conservative since 1931.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Chevron DA

Rural hospitals are already at a breaking point

Ron Southwick 23. Editor of Chief Healthcare Executive, part of MJH Life Sciences, Formerly at PennLive and Reading Eagle, 5-23-23. “Rural hospitals struggle with staffing shortage, and not just doctors.” https://www.chiefhealthcareexecutive.com/view/rural-hospitals-struggle-to-find-workers-and-not-just-doctors

While hardly any hospitals are having an easy time these days, rural health systems are facing profound difficulties.

“In rural America, the challenges are a little more difficult to navigate,” says Joanne Conroy, CEO and president of Dartmouth Health.

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Chevron DA

no impact - Rural hospitals already in dire straits---many financial challenges

Zachary Levinson 23. Project Director, Program on Medicare Policy, Kaiser Family Foundation, 2-23-2023. "Rural Hospitals Face Renewed Financial Challenges, Especially in States That Have Not Expanded Medicaid," https://www.kff.org/health-costs/issue-brief/rural-hospitals-face-renewed-financial-challenges-especially-in-states-that-have-not-expanded-medicaid/.

Rural hospitals now face renewed financial challenges. After increasing substantially earlier in pandemic, median operating margins among the rural hospitals in our analysis fell from 7.7% in July 2019-June 2022 to 3.3% in the July 2021-June 2022 period. When subtracting out relief funds documented in hospital cost reports, median operating margins were slightly lower than pre-pandemic levels during the July 2021-June 2022 period and would likely have been even lower if accounting for relief funds that were not specifically documented by hospitals. Industry reports suggest that the outlook for hospitals and health systems deteriorated in 2022, which is only partially reflected in our analysis of July 2021-June 2022 data. In this context, it is not clear whether hospital closures may reemerge as an issue facing rural communities. There were seven hospital closures in 2022, which was greater than the number in 2021 (2 closures), but still less than the average number from 2005-2022 (10.3).

Median operating margins among rural hospitals were lower in non-expansion states than in expansion states in each period of our analysis, leaving these facilities in weaker financial standing to confront the challenges that have faced the hospital sector in recent months. For example, during the July 2021-June 2022 period, median operating margins among rural hospitals in our analysis fell to 2.1% in non-expansion states (compared to 3.9% in expansion states) and -0.7% when subtracting out documented relief funds (compared to 1.2% in expansion states).

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Chevron DA

Supreme Court not swayed by public opinion.

Jessee et. Al ‘22 – Professor of Political Methodology at UT at Austin

[Stephen Jessee: associate professor of political methodology at the University of Texas at Austin, Niel Malhorta: associate professor of political economy at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, Maya Sen: professor of public policy at Harvard Kennedy School; “The Supreme Court is Now Operating Outside of American Public Opinion,” Politico, 07/19/2022, https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/07/19/supreme-court-republican-views-analysis-public-opinion-00046445//IC]

Of course, the Constitution in no way requires justices to follow public opinion. The justices are not popularly elected, and the Supreme Court was designed in large part so that the justices, with their lifetime appointments, would be insulated from political pressures, including the ups and downs of public opinion. The majority’s opinion in Dobbs warns that the Court “cannot allow our decisions to be affected by any extraneous influences such as concern about the public’s reaction to our work.”

2023 DDI Affirmative
Disads › AT Chevron DA

Nonuq: SCOTUS alr mega conservative - they are eager to use their power and Roberts vote is irrelevant after Barrett’s arrival

Liptak '22 [Adam;7-1-2022; Adam Liptak covers the United States Supreme Court and writes Sidebar, a column on legal developments. A graduate of Yale Law School, he practiced law for 14 years before joining the news staff of The New York Times in 2002. ; "A Transformative Term at the Most Conservative Supreme Court in Nearly a Century," ]

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court moved relentlessly to the right in its first full term with a six-justice conservative majority, issuing far-reaching decisions that will transform American life. It eliminated the constitutional right to abortion, recognized a Second Amendment right to carry guns outside the home, made it harder to address climate change and expanded the role of religion in public life.

But those blockbusters, significant though they were, only began to tell the story of the conservative juggernaut the court has become. By one standard measurement used by political scientists, the term that ended on Thursday was the most conservative since 1931.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

AFF is a pre req to statehood since it helps Puerto Rico escape “extra-constitutional realm”

Martinez, '21[Luna;10-20-2021; ; "A Colony Is a Colony Is a Colony: Puerto Rico and the Courts," A Colony Is a Colony Is a Colony: Puerto Rico and the Courts" ]

With the proliferation of months dedicated to celebrating different identities that have for too long been pushed to the periphery, we must not forget that representation does not equal liberation. Latinx Heritage Month calls us to look beyond statements from everyone from elected officials to corporations and from academic institutions to nonprofits that pay lip service to diversity without taking meaningful steps to address the historical harms that these communities have endured. As a territory perpetually relegated to an extra-constitutional realm, Puerto Rico remains without a path to either statehood or independence. Just as a rose by any other name would not change its scent, calling Puerto Rico a sovereign but unincorporated state does not change the nature of its legal status: a colony in everything but name. The Center for Constitutional Rights remains committed to supporting our comrades in Puerto Rico in their struggle for self-determination.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

A majority of Puerto Rican’s strongly oppose statehood

Mark-Viverito 18 - American Democratic politician and former speaker of the New York City Council from 2014 to 2017, as well as councilmember for the 8th district from 2006 to 2017

[Melissa Mark-Viverito, “Gov. Scott misses the mark on Puerto Rican statehood,” 5/10/18, https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/politics/387100-gov-scott-misses-the-mark-on-puerto-rican-statehood//MDC]

Florida Gov. Rick Scott, who is running for the U.S. Senate, recently came out in support of making Puerto Rico the 51st state of the Union. In his remarks, Scott claimed that “the U.S. should ‘respect the will of the people of Puerto Rico.’” I could not agree more. The problem is that the clear majority of Puerto Rican voters have consistently rejected the idea of statehood in five referenda held on the matter. In 1967, 1993, 1998, 2012 and 2017, Puerto Rican voters have reiterated time and again that they do not want Puerto Rico to become a state. Unfortunately, when it comes to this highly divisive issue, many stateside politicians ignore – either willfully or unwittingly – the complicated history of U.S. colonialism in Puerto Rico and our people’s repeated attempts to change that reality. The history of referendum results and how they were set up is key to understanding this issue. Let us recap. After losing the first two votes held on the matter in 1967 and 1993, the statehood movement attempted to rig the process and held a referendum in 1998 which excluded the Commonwealth option. Puerto Ricans did not fall for this trap and 51 percent voted for the “None of the Above” option. In 2012, after packing the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico and overturning the legal precedent for that option to appear on the ballot, the statehood party once again tried to rig the ballot by excluding “None of the Above.” This time, voters cast blank ballots to protest and statehood received only 45 percent of the vote, which is lower than the 46 percent it received in 1998. Given that the referendum results were inconclusive, the Obama administration proposed, and Congress approved, a process whereby the Puerto Rico State Election Commission (CEE in Spanish) would receive $2.5 million in federal funds for an educational campaign and referendum with options to resolve the status of Puerto Rico. Release of the funding was contingent upon the U.S. Department of Justice approving the language of the ballot and the educational materials to ensure they complied with the Constitution, laws, and public policies of the U.S. government. Having won the governor’s mansion, the Legislature, and the non-voting delegate Resident Commissioner position in Congress in the 2016 election, the pro-statehood New Progressive Party (NPP) had a once in a lifetime opportunity to hold a first-of-its-kind “federally sanctioned” referendum. Then, something unexpected happened. The Department of Justice reviewed the referendum materials sent by the Commonwealth government and it decided that changes needed to be made because the language was misleading. This was another attempt by the statehood faction to artificially manufacture a statehood “win” by excluding other options or wording them in such a way their supporters would find unacceptable. This was the same strategy statehooders employed in 1998 and 2012; which explains the need for DOJ to have a role in the first place. Yet, instead of fixing the language to ensure it complied with DOJ requirements – and so Congress would take the referendum seriously – the governor decided to go ahead with a statehood referendum that excluded the current Commonwealth status, or any autonomic alternative, and presented voters with the faulty ballot rejected by the Attorney General. This was clearly an attempt to fulfill a campaign promise and avoid risking defeat. Again, voters saw right through it and every non-statehood political party in Puerto Rico called for a boycott of the vote. The day of the referendum, only 23 percent of voters showed up at the polls. This is significant in an island with average voter turnout of more than 70 percent. Policymakers on Capitol Hill should keep this history in mind the next time statehood supporters come knocking on their door alleging that statehood has the support of 97 percent of Puerto Ricans. That is simply misleading and inaccurate. With eight out of 10 voters choosing not to vote in that referendum, the results do not express the true desire of the people of Puerto Rico to achieve self-determination. In addition, why would Congress pay attention to the results of a referendum that purposefully ignored the conditions it set for such a vote? Why was the current pro-statehood government so afraid of holding a vote according to DOJ guidelines? For the longest time statehooders have been clamoring for federal buy-in to resolve this dilemma. Unfortunately, what they got was an expensive political check the box exercise that was rightly ignored in Washington. After a severe financial crisis that has resulted in more than 600,000 Puerto Ricans leaving the Island, $72 billion in debt, and a botched federal response to Hurricane Maria, Puerto Rico needs to rebuild. Tens of thousands of homes remain without power, 8 months after the storm, and hundreds of thousands of Puerto Ricans – all U.S. citizens – continue to be displaced in states all over the mainland. Now is not the time to play politics with the aspirations of the people of Puerto Rico. What Puerto Rico deserves is a fair and inclusive self-determination process to end more than 100 years of U.S. colonialism in the island. What it does not need is stateside politicians fishing for campaign contributions by twisting the truth about this critical matter. Puerto Rico has always rejected statehood. After President Trump’s insults to Puerto Ricans and his failed hurricane disaster relief efforts, that rejection is likely to continue.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

A pivotal component of the intellectual and ideological project underpinning the maintenance of this colonialist legal regime is the notion that Congress's plenary power over the territories is unbounded by meaningful judicially-enforced Constitutional constraints.

Torruella 7, Former chief judge of that court United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

[Juan R. Torruella, Puerto Rican jurist. He served as a United States circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit from 1984 until his death, and as chief judge of that court from 1994 to 2001, “The Insular Cases: The Establishment Of A Regime of Political Apartheid,” Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2007, ] /RS

In the fourth academic sally, Professor James Bradley Thayer, in an article singularly lacking in any reference to supporting authorities, minced no words in asserting that "America [should not] forget her precedence of teaching nations how to live." 45 Reflecting a belief that was dear to the hearts of manifest destiny exponents of the time,46 Thayer argued that "there is no lack of power in our nation, - of legal, constitutional power, to govern these islands as colonies, substantially as England might govern them." 47 Cavalierly disposing of Marshall's and Taney's opinions as mere dicta, he concluded that not only did the Constitution not cover the territories, but also that, "except as to one or two particulars, [the power of Congress to govern the territories was] to be measured only by the terms of the cessions which it has accepted, or of the treaty under which a territory may have come in." 48 Beyond these restraints the territories were "subject to the absolute power of Congress." 49 As we shall see, this was a viewpoint that was to gain adherents in high judicial circles.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

Specifically repudiating the Insular Cases’ conclusion is necessary – reverses the solidification of new colonialism

Santana 23 [Willie Santana, 1-2023, Visiting Assistant Professor of Law at Lincoln Memorial University’s Duncan School of Law where he teaches legal writing, criminal practice skills and constitutional law, “The New Insular Cases,” William & Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice, https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1599&context=wmjowl] /RS

The Insular Cases and their progeny continue to be a stain on American constitutional jurisprudence. Their domestic in an international sense but foreign in a domestic sense rationale is materially indistinguishable from the separate but equal jurisprudence that originated with the same court.298 Both decisions generated similar results. People in the territories have poverty rates substantially higher than that of even the most impoverished states.299 They are effectively disenfranchised in the national polity.300 They are, in fact, separate and unequal. The Supreme Court has written eloquently at times about the temporary or limited scope of the Insular Cases but has failed to overrule them at every turn.301 In another terrible about-face, it is in the process of creating New Insular Cases that solidify a colonialism that is anathema to the country’s founding principles. It should reverse course.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

Express overrule is key. Keeping cases of this kind results in continuing harms--socially, legally, and ethically--even when they are allegedly "overruled in the court of history." DON’T READ THIS IF YOU READ IT IN THE 1AC

Rice 22 – Assistant Professor of Law U of A (also duke but)

Daniel B. Rice, Expert on Constitutional Law and impact of shifting cultural paradigms on US legal precedent, "Repugnant precedents and the court of history," Mich. L. Rev. 121 (2022): 577, 7/17/23, pp. 618-25 //MS

In many respects, the moral makeup of long-dead generations is virtually unrecognizable today. Yet through the medium of precedent, lapsed cultural values continue to enjoy legal authority in the present. This Part explores the complex relationship between doctrinal stasis and ethical change. In doing so, it first highlights the continuing harms that repugnant precedents can cause. It then proposes specific methods of implementing well-grounded conceptions of aversive ethos.310 These recommendations may not satisfy proponents of strict judicial modesty. But they respect the Court’s conventions of repudiation—unlike the court-of-history approach—and would facilitate far more satisfying “ethical” overrulings than would rigid adherence to the canonical stare decisis factors.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

Perm do Both – not doing the plan exacerbate colonialism since we don’t interact with legal doctrines we can never shift to decolonization Puerto Ricans don’t want the CP aff is key

Bordner ‘20 – Lawyer and Author about empire and climate justice in the Insular Areas

Autumn Bordner, Research Fellow at The Berkeley Center for Law, Energy, & the Environment, JD from Stanford Law, analysis of how climate migration impacts territorial sovereignty in the Republic of the Marshall Islands, “D.C. and Puerto Rico are not the same,” Legal Planet - Environmental Law and Climate Policy Insights, //JJB

I’ll say it again. Puerto Rico is not like D.C. Puerto Rico is a colony.

2023 DDI Affirmative
CPs › AT: Statehood CP

Doesn’t solve SSI benefits since we don’t know if the US will give equal treatment

Bayonet 22[Gabriel Prats; 2021-2022; The author is a third year law school student from the Inter American School of Law. ; "Vaello-Madero: Putting on Hold Equal Rights for Territorial Citizens," Revista Juridica de la Universidad Interamericana de Puerto Rico 56, no. 1 (2021-2022): 39-71//JJB]

The rationale of these recent Supreme Court rulings suppresses the traditional political proclivities of framing every constitutional principle of territorial law into a straitjacket of political status. Viewing them as political advancements, or backward constitutional thinking for that matter, will only thwart the constitutional analysis of what is occurring in the U.S. Supreme Court and in the territories. The hypersensitive Supreme Court docket indeed transcends those boundaries that have plagued our ability to crack the mold on status. We are at the doorstep of a potential expansion on encroachment of the boundaries of federalism, constitutionally sanctioned by the Highest Court of the Land. The open question remains: Whether a vertical alliance between the federal government and a territory, a horizontal relationship strongly entrenched through citizenship, or some other arrangement, can bestow upon all residents of the territories the same civil liberties and equal treatment it gives to other kindred citizens of the fifty States. This is the matter at stake which the Supreme Court is destined to confront in the near future.