2023
DDI
Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---JG---1NC
Annie Lowery 18, staff writer at the Atlantic, “A Promise So Big, Democrats Aren’t Sure How to Keep It,” The Atlantic, 5/11/18, https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/05/the-democratic-party-wants-to-end-unemployment/560153/
This radical idea is called a jobs guarantee, and Senators Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Cory Booker of New Jersey have in the past few weeks come out in support of it. Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, another 2020 presidential aspirant, stands behind the idea too. Representative Ro Khanna, who represents much of Silicon Valley, has legislation providing a government jobs guarantee forthcoming in the House, he told The Atlantic. The most powerful think tanks on the left—including the wonkish Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, the politically attuned Center for American Progress, and the progressive Levy Economics Institute of Bard College—have published jobs-guarantee policies or are planning to do so. A blue-sky policy idea has become an animating policy mandate in a matter of months.
The impulse is a radical one, with policymakers spurred to action by the incremental progress of the Obama years, the polarization and obstinacy of the right, the shock election of Donald Trump, the leftward ideological march of younger voters, and the decades of economic stagnation afflicting lower-income voters. “We have been a society, for generations, that has had this fundamental belief that if you’re willing to work hard, if you’re willing to put in the grit and the struggle, you should be able to thrive and make it in America,” Booker told me. “When you have the kind of societal abundance that we have, if you’re willing to work, you should have a shot at economic stability and the American dream. We do not believe we should leave people behind to the ravages of unemployment and poverty.”
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Competition---Substantial
Sonya Sotomayor 17, Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, J.D. from Yale University, A.B. in History from Princeton University, “Life Technologies Corp. v. Promega Corp., 580 U.S. ___ (2017),” Justia, 2/22/17,
The threshold determination to be made is whether §271(f)(2)’s requirement of “a substantial portion” of the components of a patented invention refers to a quantitative or qualitative measurement. Life Technologies and the United States argue that the text of §271(f)(1) establishes a quantitative threshold, and that the threshold must be greater than one. Promega defends the Federal Circuit’s reading of the statute, arguing that a “substantial portion” of the components includes a single component if that component is sufficiently important to the invention.
We look first to the text of the statute. Sebelius v. Cloer, 569 U. S. ___, ___ (2013) (slip op., at 6). The Patent Act itself does not define the term “substantial,” and so we turn to its ordinary meaning. Ibid. Here we find little help. All agree the term is ambiguous and, taken in isolation, might refer to an important portion or to a large portion. Brief for Petitioners 16; Brief for Respondent 18; Brief for United States as Amicus Curiae 12. “Substantial,” as it is commonly understood, may refer either to qualitative importance or to quantitatively large size. See, e.g., Webster’s Third New International Dictionary 2280 (defs. 1c, 2c) (1981) (Webster’s Third) (“important, essential,” or “considerable in amount, value, or worth”); 17 Oxford English Dictionary 67 (defs. 5a, 9) (2d ed. 1989) (OED) (“That is, constitutes, or involves an essential part, point, or feature; essential, material,” or “Of ample or considerable amount, quantity, or dimensions”).
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Competition---Increase
Judge Tucker 9, Supreme Court of Virginia, Reno's Ex'rs v. Davis, 14 Va. 283, 289, 1809 Va. LEXIS 53, 11/8/1809
Thursday, November 23. On the merits, Wickham argued that, by the word "increase," children born after the death of the testator only passed; for at the time of the death and not until then, the will speaks. This is a question of intention. If the children living when the will was made had names, it would have been more natural to describe them by name, than by the word increase. But according to the general usage of the country, the word "increase" means the same as "future increase." Parol testimony on this subject is improper, as it goes to prove what the testator meant by particular words.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Competition---Increase
Louis M. Phillips 2, Bankruptcy Judge, US Bankruptcy Court, “In re Lawrence D. Goldberg, Debtor. Dwayne M. Murray, Trustee, Plaintiff, v. Mae M. Stacy Trust and F. Eugene Richardson, Defendants,” 277 B.R. 251, 2002, WestLaw
In determining the plain meaning of the phrase “increases the obligor's insolvency,” the Court initially notes that this phrase makes no reference whatsoever to a “reasonably equivalent value” test26 or even to the “fair consideration” test of the Section 3 of the UFCA.27 Instead, Article 2036 of the Civil Code merely uses the word “increases,” and the absence of “reasonably equivalent value” language or “fair consideration” language rings loudly in the Court's judicial ear. Accordingly, the Court will focus on the plain meaning of the term “increases.” Taking note from one of the dictionaries of choice of the United States Supreme Court,28 the Court finds that the definition of the word “increase” in Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary reads as follows:
*270 [T]o become progressively greater (as in size, amount, number, or intensity) .... to make greater: AUGMENT .... INCREASE, ENLARGE, AUGMENT, MULTIPLY mean to make or become greater. INCREASE used intransitively implies progressive growth in size, amount, intensity; used transitively it may imply simple not necessarily progressive addition ... the act or process of increasing: as ... addition or enlargement in size, extent, quantity.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › AT: Governance NB---Defense
Caitlin Talmadge 19, Associate Professor of Security Studies in the School of Foreign at Georgetown University, as well as Senior Non-Resident Fellow in Foreign Policy at the Brookings Institution. 8/22/19, "Emerging Technology and Intra-War Escalation Risks: Evidence from the Cold War, Implications for Today." https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01402390.2019.1631811
Yet the future relationship between emerging technologies and escalation may not be as straightforward as these statements imply. The debate about emerging technologies tends to portray them as a powerful independent variable – an exogenous factor that is both necessary and sufficient to cause conflict escalation. This paper argues instead that emerging technologies are more likely to function as intervening variables; they may be necessary for escalation to happen in some cases, but they alone are not sufficient, and sometimes they will not even be necessary. The strongest drivers of escalation will actually lie elsewhere, in the realms of politics and strategy. As a result, concern about new technologies is warranted, but determinism is not. An overemphasis on the dangers of technology alone ignores the critical role of political and strategic choices in shaping the impact of technology, and also could lead to a misplaced faith in arms control or other means of trying to stuff the technological genie back in the bottle.5
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › AT: Governance NB---Defense
Todd S. Sechser 19, the Pamela Feinour Edmonds and Franklin S. Edmonds, Jr. Discovery Professor of Politics and Public Policy at the University of Virginia and Senior Fellow at the Miller Center of Public Affairs, Neil Narang is an Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of California, Santa Barbara, Caitlin Talmadge is Associate Professor of Security Studies in the School of Foreign at Georgetown University, 8/22/19, “Emerging technologies and strategic stability in peacetime, crisis, and war”, Journal of Strategic Studies, 42:6; pg. 728-729
Yet the history of technological revolutions counsels against alarmism. Extrapolating from current technological trends is problematic, both because technologies often do not live up to their promise, and because technologies often have countervailing or conditional effects that can temper their negative consequences. Thus, the fear that emerging technologies will necessarily cause sudden and spectacular changes to international politics should be treated with caution. There are at least two reasons to be circumspect.
First, very few technologies fundamentally reshape the dynamics of international conflict. Historically, most technological innovations have amounted to incremental advancements, and some have disappeared into irrelevance despite widespread hype about their promise. For example, the introduction of chemical weapons was widely expected to immediately change the nature of warfare and deterrence after the British army first used poison gas on the battlefield during World War I. Yet chemical weapons quickly turned out to be less practical, easier to counter, and less effective than conventional high-explosives in inflicting damage and disrupting enemy operations.6 Other technologies have become important only after advancements in other areas allowed them to reach their full potential: until armies developed tactics for effectively employing firearms, for instance, these weapons had little effect on the balance of power. And even when technologies do have significant strategic consequences, they often take decades to emerge, as the invention of airplanes and tanks illustrates. In short, it is easy to exaggerate the strategic effects of nascent technologies.7
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › AT: Governance NB---Fails
Binoy Kampmark 21, was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge, lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne, "War Mongering for Artificial Intelligence", International Policy Digest, 2-26-2021, https://intpolicydigest.org/warmongering-for-artificial-intelligence/
Internal changes are also suggested to ruffle a few feathers. The US State Department comes in for special mention as needing reforms. “There is currently no clear lead for emerging technology policy or diplomacy within the State Department, which hinders the Department’s ability to make strategic technology decisions.” Allies and partners were confused when approaching the State Department as to “which senior official would be their primary point of contact” for a range of topics, be they AI, quantum computing, 5G, biotechnology, or new emerging technologies.
Overall, the US government comes in for a battering, reproached for operating “at human speed not machine speed.” It was lagging relative to commercial development of AI. It suffered from “technical deficits that range from digital workforce shortages to inadequate acquisition policies, insufficient network architecture, and weak data practices.”
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › AT: Governance NB---2AC
Steven Pinker et al. 20, PhD, Professor of Psychology at Harvard; Stuart Russell, Professor of Computer Science at UC Berkeley; Lucas Perry; “Steven Pinker and Stuart Russell on the Foundations, Benefits, and Possible Existential Threat of AI”; 6/29/20; https://futureoflife.org/2020/06/15/steven-pinker-and-stuart-russell-on-the-foundations-benefits-and-possible-existential-risk-of-ai/
Lucas Perry: Now that’s quite a beautiful picture of the future. There’s a lot of existential hope there. The other side to existential hope is existential risk. Now this is an interesting subject, which Steve and you, Stuart, I believe have disagreements about. So pivoting into this area, and Steve, you can go first here, do you believe that human beings, should we not go extinct in the meantime, will we build artificial superintelligence? And does that pose an existential risk to humanity?
Steven Pinker: Yeah, I’m on record as being skeptical of that scenario and dubious about the value of putting a lot of effort into worrying about it now. The concept of superintelligence is itself obscure. In a lot of the discussions you could replace the word “superintelligence” with “magic” or “miracle” and the sentence would read the same. You read about an AI system that could duplicate brains in silicon, or solve problems like war in the Middle East, or cure cancer. It’s just imagining the possibility of a solution and assuming that the ability to bring it about will exist, without laying out what that intelligence would consist of, or what would count as a solution to the problem.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---Fails
Megan McArdle 12, Staff writer at the Atlantic, "CBO Report: Medicare Pilot Programs Don't Control Health-Care Costs,” The Atlantic, 1/18/2012, https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/cbo-report-medicare-pilot-programs-dont-control-health-care-costs/251613/
I'm considerably less enthusiastic about pilot projects than your average wonk. Today, re-reading Hannah Rosin's terrific article about housing-project demolition in Memphis, I was reminded why:
Starting in 1977, in what became known as the Gautreaux program, hundreds of families relocated to suburban neighborhoods--most of them about 25miles from the ghetto, with very low poverty rates and good public schools. The authorities had screened the families carefully, inspecting their apartments and checking for good credit histories. They didn't offer the vouchers to families with more than five children, or to those that were indifferent to leaving the projects. They were looking for families "seeking a healthy environment, good schools and an opportunity to live in a safe and decent home."
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---Fails
Michael Kirsch 10, consultant specializing in health care policy issue, “Will pilot programs really lead to innovation and save money?,” Kevin MD, 8/16/2010, https://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2010/08/pilot-programs-lead-innovation-save-money.html
Reasonably enough, most of the potential changes—at least in Medicare—are to be preceded by pilot or demonstration projects designed to test their feasibility. In fact, according to one health care blogger with time on his hands, PPACA includes no less than 312 mentions of demonstrations and 80 mentions of pilots.
Just how important are all these pilots and demos? Harvard’s David Cutler, who served as a key advisor to the Obama administration in developing the reform strategy, clearly believes they are vital. Writing in the June Health Affairs, he stresses the need for rapid implementation of the pilots and demonstrations in order to help achieve eventual savings of “enormous amounts of money while simultaneously improving the quality of care.”
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---Full Scale Perm
Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis
While pilots can be used to evaluate already-implemented policies, prospectively proposing a policy pilot involves identifying an intervention for evaluation grounded in a theory of change. Evidence is likely to be most valuable and valued when it addresses deficits left by traditional information gathering processes. Tests can address competing stakeholder narratives and theories of change for example, or can be used to try out new ideas. Within the USPTO, participants in the Office’s “Edison Scholar” program have helped to develop pilot programs including the “Glossary pilot,” other pilots have come from or been supported by the Public Patent Advisory Committee (“PPAC”), a Federal Advisory Committee of the agency.
Regardless of source, it is critical to connect the identified treatment to the eventual intended outcome. By answering the question, “how is treatment X supposed to achieve outcome Y,” a law- or policy-maker describes a “theory of change.” A widely-accepted method of specifically testing the underlying theory of change is through “mechanism experiments,” a technique for determining whether the underlying theory of change is actually sound. Mechanism experiments support testing of the core underlying assumptions without requiring an extensive randomized controlled experiment; as described in Part II, to the extent they simulate rather than actually effect policy changes, they impose fewer administrative burdens.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---2AC
Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis
As discussed in Part II, the legal requirements for carrying out pilots related to an agency’s objectives need not be particularly strenuous. But marshalling the necessary agency approvals can present major hurdles. Implementing pilots can require employees to vary their behavior or depart from the normal course of operations, introducing both time and disruption costs.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---2AC
Neil Wayland 21, New Wayland, “The Basic Income Illusion,” New Wayland, 7/20/21, https://new-wayland.com/blog/the-basic-income-illusion/
The essential weakness of the Basic Income system is known, but hidden in platitudes. Many an article on basic income will highlight the ‘experiments’ that allegedly show wondrous benefits to the participating area.
But they avoid mentioning the hidden issues with these ‘experiments’.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---2AC
Timothy Rudd et al. 13, Researchers at MRDC, “Financing Promising Evidence-Based Programs: Early Lessons from the New York City Social Impact Bond,” MDRC, MDRC, 12/2013, ERIC
Ideally, the program should be pilot-tested at full scale. SIBs attract money that allows innovative programs to expand rapidly, but this expansion is likely to come with challenges. It may therefore be desirable to pilot-test a program at full scale, and only evaluate it after it achieves a steady state of operation. On the other hand, pilot programs require time and money, both of which are likely to be constrained in SIB arrangements. In this case, the trade-offs of money and time allowed for a pilot test at half scale. The experience was valuable, but certain issues came to light only after the program was expanded to full scale. Future SIBs will also probably need to weigh the benefits of full-scale pilot tests against the limitations of time and money.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Aff Answers › Pilot Program CP---2AC
Beryl A. Radin 2k, American public administration author, researcher, and academic, elected member of the National Academy of Public Administration, Managing Editor of the Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, “The Government Performance and Results Act and the Tradition of Federal Management Reform: Square Pegs in Round Holes?,” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, vol. 10, no. 1, 01/01/2000, pp. 111–135
At the same time, there are differences between GPRA and earlier efforts. Its enactment as legislation (rather than as executive orders) has built in a role for Congress that is relatively unusual in government reform efforts. David Rosenbloom (1998) has noted that GPRA's "[d]eep legislative involvement in agency strategic planning ... fits the institutional role Congress designed for itself in 1946." Rosenbloom has noted that public administration reformers in the United States have a tradition of looking past the separation of powers when they design reforms. GPRA, however, was different. In addition, GPRA's inclusion of pilot projects and provision of a number of years for start-up are not the usual way to conceptualize reform efforts. Although GPRA was enacted in 1993, its real requirements did not take effect until 1997.
To some degree, the passage of GPRA and the interest in its implementation reflect the public attention to management that has been a characteristic of the 1990s. Embraced by the Clinton administration and viewed as complementary to the Gore reinvention effort, GPRA's focus on performance of government agencies is an example of the interest in this topic throughout various levels of government. The multiple aspects of legislation— particularly its emphasis on the relationship between budgeting and performance—can be viewed as an attempt to respond to public concerns about the ways that public monies have been expended. The report from the Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs attached to the legislation noted that u[p]ublic confidence in the institutions of American government is suffering from a perception that those institutions are not working well. ... the public believes that it is not getting the level and quality of government service for which it is paying."6
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › AT: Defense
Kira Matus 14, PhD, Havard University. Associate Head and Associate Professor, Division of Public Policy, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, “Existential risk: challenges for risk regulation,” Risk and Regulation, 11/25/14, http://www.lse.ac.uk/researchAndExpertise/units/CARR/pdf/Risk‐and‐Regulation‐28‐existential‐risk.pdf
There is a trend in many areas towards attention to ‘big’ risks. Financial regulation has become increasingly concerned with so‐called systemic risks. Others, and not just Hollywood blockbusters, have been attracted to the study of civilization‐destroying catastrophic risks. Indeed, the OECD has become increasingly interested in ‘high level’ risks and ways in which different national governments seek to prepare for and manage actual events, such as the aftermath of major earthquakes, or the response to a terrorist attack. The notion of ‘existential’ risk might be adding to the cacophony of emerging ‘big’ risk concerns. However, existential risk deserves special attention as it fundamentally adds to our understanding of particular types of risks, and it also challenges common wisdom regarding actions designed to support continued survival.
What is existential risk? We can approach this question by looking at several attributes. The first attribute is what, in fact, is at risk. One set of existential risks are those that threaten survival. These are the acute catastrophes, i.e. the idea that particular events’ impacts are likely to extinguish civilization. Such risks have been identified when it comes to asteroids, nuclear war, and other largescale events that undermine the possibility for survival in general, or, at least, in large regions. A second set is based on the idea that existential risks are not just about physical survival, but about the survival of ways of life. In other words, certain risks are seen as threatening established ways of doing things, cultures, social relationships, and understandings of the ‘good life’. There is, of course, much disagreement about what the good life constitutes, and therefore there will always be disagreement as to what exactly an existential risk constitutes.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › AT: Defense
Dr. Tom Pegram & Julia Kreienkamp 19, Pegram is Associate Professor in Global Governance and the Deputy Director of the Global Governance Institute; Kreienkamp is a researcher at the UCL Global Governance Institute, where she also works on the Horizon 2020 project Global Governance and the European Union: Future Trends and Scenarios (GLOBE), “Governing Complexity: Design Principles for Improving the Governance of Global Catastrophic Risks,” Global Governance Institute, November 2019, https://www.ucl.ac.uk/global-governance/sites/global-governance/files/governing_complex_global_catastrophic_risks_ggi_policy_brief_nov2019.pdf
Articles in the New York Magazine might ask, ‘why we don’t seem able to imagine climate catastrophe?’ (Wallace-Wells 2017). But increasingly the prospect of possible catastrophe and, in the extreme, human extinction, is informing policymaking at the highest levels, as well as society at large (Castelloe 2018). And, many would argue, with good reason. From climate change and ecosystem collapse, to parasitic artificial general intelligence (AGI), the misuse of advanced biotechnologies and nuclear weapons, we confront daunting challenges within an increasingly interconnected globalised civilization, where catastrophic failure anywhere could mean failure everywhere. As Martin Wolf of the Financial Times suggests, humanity’s efforts to overcome the tragedy of the global commons ‘could prove to be the defining story of the century’ (Wolf 2012). Martin Rees agrees, suggesting that existential risks make it unlikely that humanity will reach the end of this century without major changes (Rees 2014). Governance scholars predict a rocky road ahead, observing a move from conventional distributional politics (who gets what, when and how) to existential politics which ‘is like distributional politics on steroids: the stakes are whose way of life gets to survive’ (Green, Hale and Colgan 2019).
Of course, global catastrophic risks (GCRs) are nothing new to scholars and practitioners working in the well-established areas of climatology, risk management, resilience, and cognate fields.3 The scholarship is replete with typologies of ‘wicked’ (and less wicked) problems and classifications of GCRs (Alford and Head 2017; Avin et al 2018). Although rarely addressed explicitly (Harrington 2016; Levin et al 2012), a focus on GCRs in global politics scholarship is also apparent in the subdomains of environmental and resilience governance (e.g. Galaz 2014). There is also a substantial policy and practitioner literature which provides sophisticated mapping, taxonomies, rolling assessments of global risks (WEF 2019), slow-developing risks (IRGC 2013), and, increasingly, what policymakers might do about them (CSER 2019).
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › Solves Emerging Tech
Cary Coglianese 18, Edward B. Shils Professor of Law and Political Science; Director, Penn Program on Regulation, University of Pennsylvania Law School, “Optimizing Regulation for an Optimizing Economy,” University of Pennsylvania Journal of Law & Public Affairs, Vol. 4, November 2018, No. 1,
Much economic activity in the United States today emanates from technological advances that optimize through contextualization. Innovations as varied as Airbnb and Uber, fintech firms, and precision medicine are transforming major sectors in the economy by customizing goods and services as well as refining matches between available resources and interested buyers. The technological advances that make up the optimizing economy create new challenges for government oversight of the economy. Traditionally, government has overseen economic activity through general regulations that aim to treat all individuals equally; however, in the optimizing economy, business is moving in the direction of greater individualization, not generalization. An ever more optimizing economy therefore demands an increasingly smart, optimizing system of regulatory oversight. To ensure that government can properly balance policy goals in the new economy, steps need to be taken now to enhance the technological and analytical sophistication of the regulatory workforce, improve government’s information technology infrastructure, build stronger and more complete collections of data, and draw on policy lessons from other periods of technological innovations. In the optimizing economy, government regulators will continue to play a crucial role in protecting the public from market failures, but, to fulfill that role, government will need to follow the private sector’s lead and build up its own capacity for optimization.
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › Solves Emerging Tech
Cary Coglianese 18, Edward B. Shils Professor of Law and Political Science; Director, Penn Program on Regulation, University of Pennsylvania Law School, “Optimizing Regulation for an Optimizing Economy,” University of Pennsylvania Journal of Law & Public Affairs, Vol. 4, November 2018, No. 1,
Across a range of sectors, economic activity in the United States today increasingly derives from technological advances that facilitate the use of resources in ever more marginally effective and efficient ways. Rather than exploiting new resources altogether, many of the most captivating innovations in today’s economy instead deploy technology to optimize the production or allocation of existing resources, goods, and services.
Consider several seemingly disparate examples. So-called sharing economy firms like Uber and Airbnb find transformational ways to allocate to willing buyers otherwise under-used resources, such as private cars and extra bedrooms. Marketing firms rely more than ever on data mining to make highly targeted pitches to consumers, while supply-chain and delivery system optimization has streamlined manufacturing and retail markets. Major advances in health care now travel under the banner of “precision medicine,” with health care professionals using sophisticated genetic screening and other data analysis to target treatments even more effectively to individual patients. Fintech firms promise to deliver financial products more accurately designed and priced to reflect underlying borrower risks and thus expand access to capital. These and other changes across the economy signal an important trend toward using technology to contextualize in ways that make possible more efficient uses of available resources.1
2023
DDI
Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Internal NB › I/L---Pilots Solve---2NC
Cary Coglianese 12, Professor of Law and professor of political science at the University of Pennsylvania Law School, where he is also director of the Penn Program on Regulation, “Measuring Regulatory Performance: Evaluating the Impact of Regulation and Regulatory Policy,” OECD Expert Paper No. 1, August 2012, https://www.oecd.org/gov/regulatory-policy/1_coglianese%20web.pdf
Evaluation research has a vital role to play in a regulatory environment that values learning. Now that I have presented, in Section 2 of this report, a framework for selecting indicators of regulatory performance and, in Section 3, a framework for selecting research designs to determine whether changes in those indicators can be causally attributed to regulation or regulatory policy, I turn to recommendations for bringing indicators together with research designs to provide evaluations that inform future regulatory decision making. The first recommendation discussed below is to apply in each OECD country an integrated framework that combines the analysis presented in Section s 2 and 3 of this report in order to generate substantially more decision-relevant evaluation research. The second recommendation is for each OECD country to develop institutional arrangements that will promote and support high-quality execution of research that uses the integrated framework presented in the first recommendation.
4.1 Integrated framework for evaluating regulatory performance This report’s elaboration of the essential considerations that go into selecting regulatory performance indicators and evaluation research designs has not been motivated by an academic quest for knowledge for its own sake, but rather by the desire to guide research that can inform future regulatory decision making. Evaluation research can inform decision making about a broad range of policy relevant questions, such as: Should a regulation or set of regulations (or regulatory policy) continue to remain on the books? Should a regulation or regulatory policy addressing one problem be emulated to address the same problem in another jurisdiction or similar problems in the same jurisdiction? Should effort be given to modify or seek to improve a regulation or regulatory policy? Are there particular types of regulatory instruments or tools that work better than others? If so, under what conditions?