Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Social Security

Previous social security pilot programs show the usefulness of pilot programs on insight into the process

Neeraj Sood et al 11[9-1-2011. Neeraj Sood (nsood@healthpolicy.usc.edu) is director of international programs at the Leonard D. Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics and an associate professor in the Titus Family Department of Clinical Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Economics, and Policy, both at the University of Southern California, in Los Angeles. Peter J. Huckfeldt is an associate economist at RAND, in Santa Monica, California. José J. Escarce is a professor of medicine in the David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles. David C. Grabowski is an associate professor in the Department of Health Care Policy at Harvard Medical School, in Boston, Massachusetts. Joseph P. Newhouse is the John D. MacArthur Professor of Health Policy and Management at Harvard University, in Cambridge, Massachusetts., . "Medicare’s Bundled Payment Pilot For Acute And Postacute Care: Analysis And Recommendations On Where To Begin". https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2010.0394. 7-13-2023, Dhilan-GDS]

Bundled payments are increasingly seen as a way to reduce Medicare costs, increase coordination of care, and improve quality of care. Bundling could mitigate some of the negative incentives of the current system—which result in a lack of care coordination, movement of patients among care sites for the purposes of maximizing reimbursement, and other effects that raise costs and probably produce worse outcomes for patients. However, bundling may also have unintended adverse consequences, such as restricting patients’ choice of postacute care providers and stinting on care.

Fortunately, it may be possible to design mechanisms that reduce the impact of these consequences. As the national pilot program for payment bundling moves forward, Medicare should consider including in it pay-for-performance—a quality monitoring and regulation system—to alleviate incentives to skimp. 1 Applying an outlier system of payments to a substantial number of patients, or even to all patients, could also reduce skimping, as well as providers’ financial risk and limitations on patients’ choice of postacute care providers. The general idea would be to have some additional payment—however small—over and above the payment bundle, to be paid in the event of a particularly high-cost case. Finally, contracts that allow for gain and loss sharing could balance the need to achieve savings with the amount of risk placed on providers.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG---AT: UBI Empirics

Empirics from failed UBI experiments don’t apply to the job guarantee---making people work offsets the political weakness of the overall program

Neil Wayland 21, New Wayland, “The Basic Income Illusion,” New Wayland, 7/20/21, https://new-wayland.com/blog/the-basic-income-illusion/

Once a scheme is reduced below the amount of the living wage, it becomes a form of tax credits and those are systemically a subsidy to private businesses. Tax credits induce ‘bullshit’ activities in the private sector — using labour when automation or elimination would be the better options. Only when the public sector provides enough activity for all at the living wage is the private sector required to compete for labour at all levels. Only then is the race to the bottom in wages ended. And all that requires a Job Guarantee — the active process of creating enough to do.

Tying the income to the work prevents the private sector ursuping the scheme and changing it into a subsidy structure for their own benefit.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG---GND

DOE empirics prove – demonstrations spur upscaling and private sector follow on

Department of Energy 21, Energy, Department of. “Doe Establishes New Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.” Energy.Gov, 21 Dec. 2021, www.energy.gov/articles/doe-establishes-new-office-clean-energy-demonstrations-under-bipartisan-infrastructure-law.

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) today announced the establishment of the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations, a new DOE office that will help deliver on President Biden’s bold climate agenda, create new, good-paying jobs for American families and workers, and reduce pollution while benefitting disadvantaged communities.

President Biden’s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law provides more than $20 billion to establish the Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations and support clean energy technology demonstration projects in areas including clean hydrogen, carbon capture, grid-scale energy storage, small modular reactors, and more. Demonstration projects prove the effectiveness of innovative technologies in real-world conditions at scale in order to pave the way towards widespread adoption and deployment. The founding of this office represents a new chapter that builds on DOE’s long-standing position as the premier international driver for clean energy research and development, expanding DOE’s scope to fill a critical innovation gap on the path to net-zero emissions by 2050.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG

The Cory Booker program would be key to solving unemployment

Senate 19 - ("Sen. Booker, Reps. Watson Coleman and Omar Introduce Bicameral Bill to Create Federal Jobs Guarantee Program," No Publication, published 9-12-2019, accessed 7-12-2023, https://www.booker.senate.gov/news/press/sen-booker-reps-watson-coleman-and-omar-introduce-bicameral-bill-to-create-federal-jobs-guarantee-program)//olivia

The Federal Jobs Guarantee Development Act would:∂ · Select up to 15 communities across the country facing high unemployment based on local need and assets, ensuring that work would advance critical local and national priorities like child and elder care, infrastructure, and community revitalization.∂ · Guarantee that every interested adult with residence in a pilot community may participate in the program to obtain a guaranteed job.∂ o Jobs will include a prevailing wage, paid family and sick leave, and comprehensive health coverage like that enjoyed by Members of Congress.∂ · Require that each pilot community creates a “Community Job Bank” website, which will feature high-impact jobs sourced primarily by local communities, as well as Federal agencies, based on their needs and priorities.∂ · Expand the Work Opportunity Tax Credit to incentivize private employers to recruit and hire participants out of the pilot program.∂ · Authorize a rigorous evaluation of the program’s implementation and impact across a number of metrics, including unemployment rates, private sector wages, safety net spending, and incarceration rates.∂ o Workers participating in the program will maintain their job for the full three years of the pilot program.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG

NYCEI is key to solving the effects of unemployment but is important for a federal scale up

Hailie Kim 21 [New York City Council Candidate for District 26] – (NYCEI Proposal), published 4-21-2021, accessed 7-11-2023 (https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5f961e7eefe78d7d6f588070/60cddc57f5aacd7a05ff9d30_nycei.pdf)//olivia

The New York City Employment Initiative (NYCEI) will employ 25,000 New Yorkers on a wide variety of projects, providing public service benefits to all New Yorkers. It will be a standing program, complementary to economic stimulus programs such as green public infrastructure investments, which also create jobs. As a local employment program delivering quality public services at scale, it will serve as a de facto pilot program for a federal Job Guarantee. It will significantly and permanently reduce the many harmful effects of unemployment for individuals, families, neighborhoods and our city as a whole. Background and Overview Everyone deserves a job. Involuntary unemployment is, in Rep. Ayanna Pressley’s words, a “moral and economic scourge” that the government has a duty to eliminate. It spreads through and across communities, like a contagious disease, leading to physical and mental illness, alcoholism, suicide, crime, and poorer educational outcomes for children. (See Tcherneva, The Case for a Job Guarantee, pp. 32-39) It is a racial justice issue, with Black Americans consistently suffering an unemployment rate roughly double that of white Americans. In April, just here in Queens, 122,000 people were unemployed. That is still three times the March 2020 level. Investments in green infrastructure and social housing, which I and others have proposed, will boost our economy and help get us back to pre-Covid employment levels. This is necessary but not enough. Even in December 2019, when unemployment was the lowest it had been in decades, there were still 146,000 unemployed New Yorkers, including nearly 30,000 in Queens, and those numbers roughly double if the underemployed are included. The persistent shortage of jobs, even in good times, is the problem that this proposal addresses. The number of jobs in an economy such as New York’s is driven by the level of demand for the goods and services that the economy is capable of producing. Such demand can come from governments as well as individual consumers. This proposal, the New York City Employment Initiative (NYCEI), creates new jobs by creating new demand for a wide variety of important public services including environmental care, public arts and performances, after school services and much more. While reducing unemployment is the driving motivation, the newly provided public services are equally important, and will be enjoyed by every New Yorker. A small preview of NYCEI is happening this year with the Mayor’s New York City Cleanup Corps (CCC). Using federal stimulus money from the latest Covid relief bill, the City will hire 10,000 people to restore, maintain and improve public spaces in a variety of ways, not just cleanup. Vegetation planting and playground maintenance are just two of the many services that will be provided by CCC workers. CCC is necessarily temporary, because its funding is temporary. NYCEI is a permanent, standing program, funded with general revenues, and it has a broader mandate. Thus, all CCC services and jobs could continue indefinitely under NYCEI, and many more would be added. Art and arts education, and care economy services like after school programs and elder care are just some examples of services that are chronically under provisioned by our society and appropriate for expansion under NYCEI. At the funding level that I am proposing, NYCEI would employ about 25,000 people, and additional jobs will be created in the private sector as workers spend their income into the local economy. Furthermore, by demonstrating how local employment programs can be implemented at scale, and the benefits they can provide, NYCEI will serve as a de facto pilot program for a federal Job Guarantee, such as those proposed by Sen. Cory Booker and Rep. Ayanna Pressley. Under these proposals, projects are conceived and administered locally. Thus, NYCEI puts us in a position to rapidly scale up to a full guarantee under federal funding, much as CCC can scale up to NYCEI. NYCEI will be described in detail in the next section; its goals are summarized here. 1.Create quality public service jobs for thousands of New Yorkers. 2.Provide a wide variety of important public services to all New Yorkers. 3.Maintain and enhance workers’ skills, so they will be ready to move to higher paying private or public sector employment when opportunities arise. 4.Serve as a de facto pilot program for a federal Job Guarantee, and make our city “Job Guarantee-ready”, so we can rapidly scale up to a full guarantee under a federal program.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG

A basic job pilot program is more amendable with long lasting benefits

Simon Sarris 18, web developer focusing primarily on the HTML5 Canvas, contributes to the website StackOverflow, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, “Why Basic Jobs Are Better Than Basic Incomes,” 1/15/18, 

Studying a UBI pilot with an end date is not studying UBI at all; it is studying a misnamed, temporary cash payment. By the very nature of pilot programs, a cohort’s behavior cannot reliably change over the long term. No study has ever guaranteed money to a cohort forever, which impacts the validity of the study’s outcomes. Even if a program were able to offer funds forever, it would be difficult for a pilot to show the long-term effects, some of which may not be seen for generations. What pilot, for example, can tell us what it’s like for kids to grow up with parents who’ve never worked? Universal Basic Income pilots also tend to fail at the Universal part. It’s hard to study how society would change if you are not piloting something that affects all of society. For example, this study in Finland, is far from universal: “During the experiment, a total of 2,000 unemployed persons between 25 and 58 years of age will receive a monthly payment of €560, unconditionally and without means testing. The experiment will run for two years.” Basic Job programs, by contrast, are more amenable to piloting and gradual roll-out. New clusters of jobs appear (and end) all the time. Piloting Basic Jobs can be done in different communities with varying magnitudes, and the legislation to do so is already in place: In the United States, the Humphrey-Hawkins Full Employment Act of 1978 allows the government to create a ‘reservoir of public employment’ in case private enterprise does not provide sufficient jobs. These jobs are required to be in the lower ranges of skill and pay so as to not draw the workforce away from the private sector. However, the act did not establish such a reservoir (it only authorized it), and no such program has been implemented in the United States, even though the unemployment rate has generally been above the rate (three percent) targeted by the act. — via . And even a pilot may have lasting benefits. What we learn from a Basic Jobs pilot will be more applicable than studying temporary cash transfers in a community and expecting that knowledge to translate into society-wide UBI. If a pilot is successful, one can imagine a kind of National Civil Service, organized like existing federal programs such as the National Park Service, which can hire professionals to train and supervise projects.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---JG

CP key to feasibility— Pilot Programs allow the Government to changes necessary increases effectiveness

Ryan Nunn et al. 18, (Ryan Nunn, The Hamilton Project and the Brookings Institution; Jimmy O’Donnell, The Hamilton Project; Jay Shambaugh, The Hamilton Project, the Brookings Institution, and The George Washington University, “Labor Market Considerations for a National Job Guarantee,” December 2018, https://www.hamiltonproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/JobGuarantee_FP_web_20190206.pdf)

Senator Cory Booker’s Federal Jobs Guarantee Development Act of 2018 would establish a pilot program to learn more about how a job guarantee would work in practice. Local governments and nonprofits would provide jobs under plans approved by the Secretary of Labor, with the federal government providing reimbursement for the costs of these jobs.

The bill calls for three-year grants that would be provided to local governments that partner with philanthropic organizations to provide jobs. The pilot would be conducted with 15 local governments, of which at least four would be rural, six would be urban, and one would be tribal. Eligible government participants would have an unemployment rate that is at least 150 percent of the national unemployment rate. Priorities for the job plans would include child care, elder care, disabled care, and infrastructure activities.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Ext

Programs like AVANCE were successful in solving employment, child care, and education --

Pavetti, LaDonna, et al 96. “Designing Welfare-to-Work Programs for Families Facing Personal Or ...” Designing Welfare-to-Work Programs for Families Facing Personal or Family Challenges, www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/67236/407338-Designing-Welfare-to-Work-Programs-for-Families-Facing-Personal-or-Family-Challenges.pdf. Accessed 13 July 2023.

Only two of these programs, Avance and FaDSS have been formally evaluated. Thus, it is not possible to say definitively whether these programs are successful or not. However, the program statistics available from some of these programs are encouraging.

A formal evaluation of the Avance program was conducted from 1987 to 1992 with support from the Carnegie Corporation of New York. The evaluation found that mothers had developed more positive attitudes about their role as effective teachers of their children and that they interacted in a more positive and stimulating

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Ext

Pilot programs empirically do better – the child welfare proves

Carey 11, Carey. “Effective Investments - Casey Family Programs.” Effective Investments, www.casey.org/media/waiver-projects.pdf. Accessed 13 July 2023.

The federal Child Welfare Demonstration Projects, signed into law in 2011, allow states and tribes to apply for a waiver so that they may better target their share of Title IV-E foster care dollars. Demonstration projects can focus on improving child safety, providing prevention and permanency services designed to safely reduce the need for foster care, and making quality-of-care improvements for those in the child welfare system. The bulk of those dollars currently is spent to maintain children in foster care.

Today, communities in 25 states, the District

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---Ext

Maine paramedicine project proves – pilot projects identify weaknesses and allow a scale up

Karen Pearson & George Shaler 17 [Journal of Health and Human Services Administration , FALL 2017, Vol. 40, No. 2 (FALL 2017), pp. 141-185//olivia

Hospital readmissions emergency department visits cost of healthcare, and involves innovative healthcare solutions across the healthcare delivery system. Community paramedicine (CP) is one model of community-based healthcare innovation, having as one of its primary goals the reduction in non- urgent 911 calls, which will, in turn, help in reducing the cost of emergency department care. In rural areas, CP programs also help fill gaps in the local healthcare delivery system due to shortages of primary care physicians. Additionally, CP programs provide trained EMS personnel working within the healthcare system to monitor patients at high risk for hospital readmission, help these high-risk patients manage their chronic diseases, comply with medication regimens, and access social services to help keep them in their home. These efforts seek to align with the "triple aim" of reducing healthcare costs, improving the health of the population, and enhancing patient quality and experience (Institute for Healthcare Improvement, 2016). CP programs are beginning to flourish across the nation, and the need to provide demonstration or pilot programs is essential to providing a consistent and high- level standard for this model of care. While the overarching goals are to align with the Triple Aim, piloting a community paramedicine program also allows each community to develop and implement a program tailored to the healthcare needs of their specific community. A successful program builds the evidence base that can then be used to create legislative change necessary to financially sustain this model of care across the healthcare delivery system.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---2NC

Government agencies need pilot programs for better rates of success

Matthew Milone 21 Matthew Milone is a licensed attorney and is currently the head of CDS’s Federal Services division. Matt holds a B.A. from The Catholic University of America, a J.D. from Quinnipiac University School of Law, and is licensed to practice law in New York. https://cdslegal.com/insights/insights-federal/the-benefit-of-pilot-programs-to-the-federal-government/

For government agencies, pilot programs are a great way to experiment with new technology. Frequently, there are questions around implementation, access and overall functionality. Implementing a pilot program allows an agency to identify these challenges early, develop synergy with their provider and define the service model that will be necessary for larger scale adoption. Our two-year contract with a major government agency (the “Agency”) is a useful example of how agencies can benefit from a pilot program as well as the best way to ensure its effectiveness. CDS was privileged to be awarded a contract to develop and implement a Relativity project to assist the Agency in responding to public requests for information, including requests under the FOIA and Privacy Act, as well as to assist in streamlining its workflow to reduce the backlog of overdue FOIA requests. To accomplish our mission statement, CDS leveraged Relativity as a SaaS in our FedRAMP authorized Cloud with great success. A pilot program enables agencies and providers to test the effectiveness of a planned solution on a smaller scale. In our agency engagement, we were able to work with a small team of stakeholders to develop effective workflows, identify inefficiencies early and smooth out any issues, technical or otherwise. This saved time and money as technology was deployed on a limited scale and user feedback was incorporated on a real-time basis. In addition, in working with the Agency, employees who participated in the pilot had the chance to see first-hand the value of the software. These individuals became our internal advocates, helping spread the word on the pilot’s success, potentially train other end-users, answer questions and more. We felt that working so closely with the Agency made our team better and helped dial in our processes and workflows. In the process, we were able to provide them with the knowledge, training and wherewithal to accomplish their mission statement and expand on those objectives.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---2NC

Policymakers use pilot projects to anticipate and gain the political and public support necessary

Radhika Gore 22. “Policy by Pilot? Learning From Demonstration Projects for Integrated Care Comment on "Integration or Fragmentation of Health Care? Examining Policies and Politics in a Belgian Case Study".” International journal of health policy and management, vol. 12 7152. 8 Jun. 2022, doi:10.34172/ijhpm.2022.7152

Governments are known to use pilot projects as a policy instrument precisely when fragmented state institutions and partisan divisions make it difficult to introduce large-scale reform. 4 Policymakers have turned to analytic pilot projects to anticipate the potential effects of reform proposals before legislating policy. Pilot projects can allow governments to try new strategies, innovate, and gain public and political support for a policy idea. They can also be used as policy implementation tools: they can be structured as experiments to allow stakeholders to interact, exchange perspectives and knowledge, and develop new solutions for policy implementation in a staged manner, with room for trial and error.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---2NC

Success in the pilot breaks the political deadlock and builds consensus for universal implementation

Henry J. Aaron 8, Bruce and Virginia MacLaury Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, Economic Studies, in Washington, D.C., Stuart Butler, Vice President, Domestic and Economic Policy Studies, at the Heritage Foundation, also in Washington, “A Federalist Approach To Health Reform: The Worst Way, Except For All The Others,” May 2008, http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/27/3/725.full

These differences should not be ignored as the nation strives to reform its health care system. Some people argue that national legislation is imperative to achieve consistent, comprehensive coverage throughout the country. Others hold that separate action by individual states is the wiser course, given the U.S. political system and disagreements on the best way forward, even among experts of the same philosophical persuasion. This disagreement is important, but adherents of both positions should recognize that encouraging state action to expand coverage at this time will advance both agendas. We argued some time ago in Health Affairs that measures to energize state experimentation within a federal-state framework based on clear national goals will achieve two objectives: it will extend coverage in the near term, and it will advance the date at which coordinated national action is possible.2 Our view has not changed, and it is unlikely to do so, no matter who wins the next presidential election.

State Reform: The Best Way To Trigger National Action

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › Solvency › Solvency---2NC

Pilot projects solve---converts skeptics and develops champions who’ll push universal rollout but experimentation is key

Sara Bennett 4, PhD, Member of the Health Economics and Financing Programme at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and Senior Research Advisor for the Partners for Health Reform plus Project, Abt Associates Inc, “The Role of Pilot Programs: Approaches to Health Systems Strengthening,” Partners for Health Reform Monograph, August, p. 4-5

The process of building support for, designing, and implementing “big bang” health system reform can present a number of challenges: It is often politically contentious. There is likely to be much uncertainty about the effectiveness of alternative reform packages given the relatively limited research base that exists on health system strengthening as well as the difficulties of applying conclusions from one context to very different contexts. Many health system reforms require government and other stakeholders to acquire new skills and capacities that typically take time to develop. For reform to succeed, ways to work deal with these issues must be worked out.

It is important to distinguish pilots that address complex health system reforms from those that focus on a single intervention or a vertical program within the health sector. Complex health system reform pilots typically aim to advance the reform implementation cycle and have explicit or implicit links to the broader policy process. This usually means that they involve a wide range of stakeholders with varying perspectives and values, and, therefore, as noted above, they tend to be politically sensitive and contentious. In addition, they are more programmatically complex. In contrast, reforms that address a single intervention or a vertical program tend to have a smaller set of relevant stakeholders, and these stakeholders are likely to share a common programmatic understanding. Because of these factors – the large groups of stakeholders generally involved contention around reform design, and the complexity of the nature of system reforms – pilot projects offer particular advantages for health system reforms:

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › 1NC › Pilot Program CP---1NC

Spillover cements a decentralized model for policy innovation necessary to solve extinction.

Charles Weiss 22, the first Science and Technology Adviser to the World Bank, serving in that position from 1971-86, became Distinguished Professor of Science, Technology and International Affairs (STIA) at the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in 1997, was the director of the STIA program from 1997-2006, now Distinguished Professor Emeritus, and a Visiting Scholar at the American Association for the Advancement of Science, “13 Playing with Fire,” Survival Nexus: Science, Technology, and World Affairs, Oxford University Press, 2022, pp. 251-266

We are needlessly allowing technology to take the world to the brink of disasters from accidental climate disruption, nuclear war, and pandemics— at the same time that we are allowing the means for controlling these technologies to erode. In effect, we are edging closer and closer to cliffs from which we have removed the guardrails. Fortunately, people are beginning to develop— or at least to think about— protections against some of these dangers.

A technology-based model of authoritarian government is being promoted and exported as a technological, economic, and political challenge to Western liberal democracies. The Internet and social media, conceived as vehicles for free exchange of information and platforms for untrammeled innovation, in some countries have become instruments of repression. At the same time, a systematic, worldwide campaign of misinformation and disinformation, spread via social and mass media, has deliberately sown distrust in the democratic process, in government, in international institutions, in science, in expertise of all kinds, and in the very idea that there is such a thing as truth. In the United States, the scientific consensus concerning climate change has been overwhelmed by misinformation and disinformation spread by political and business interests that it threatens, while public messaging regarding the CO VID-19 pandemic has been at best mixed. All this has made it difficult for people to understand the complex and dangerous new threats to the environment, to their health, to their security, and to democratic government.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Pilot Program CP › 1NC › Pilot Program CP---1NC

It spills up, avoids backlash, AND emboldens rigorous experimentation necessary for effective regulations.

Colleen V. Chien 19, Justin D'Atri Visiting Professor of Business Law, Columbia Law School; Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law; 2013-2015 White House Senior Advisor, Innovation and Intellectual Property, “Rigorous Policy Pilots: Experimentation in the Administration of the Law,” 104 Iowa L. Rev. 2313, July 2019, Lexis

The range of open questions in law and policy that can be addressed by pilots are wide-ranging. They include, for example, the question of how giving a universal basic income ("UBI") to individuals impacts their well-being and employment. In 2017, the Finnish government began tracking the outcomes of 7,000 unemployed citizens, about a third to which it gave $ 600 a month, [*2317] to address this question; 14several U.S. jurisdictions are planning their own tests. 15Also unknown is how the administration of patent law and issuance of quality patents best advance the Constitutional goal of "promoting the progress of science and useful arts." 16Over the last decade, the United States Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO") has run numerous pilots to address this question. 17As the D.C. Circuit has said, "there are some situations in which, "a month of experience will be worth a year of hearings.'" 18While experiments or pilots can address a variety of questions pertaining, e.g., to a policy's feasibility or stakeholder reactions, when the question concerns whether the policy has caused an observed outcome, a controlled trial that provides the treatment to one part of population, withholds it from another, and then compares the difference in outcomes provides the best insight. Such rigorous experiments can be designed, in turn, with or without randomization, and to vary the rules or laws that apply or to approximate such changes. A pilot that limits to whom a rule or policy applies constrains the risk but not the learning. As Justice Brandeis famously dissented, "a single courageous state may ... serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." 19

Within today's highly partisan political landscape, the need for quality evidence about the performance of law and policy presents a rare opportunity for agreement, on the methods if not the values or agendas advanced by evidence. Calls for "smarter use of data and evidence ... to orient decisions and accountability around service and results" 20and "an aggressive management agenda ... that delivers smarter, more innovative, and more accountable government for citizens ... . by applying ... evidence about what [*2318] works" 21 have appeared in President Trump's and President Obama's management agendas, respectively. The passage of the Foundations for Evidence-Based Policy Making Act of 2018 ("2018 Evidence Act"), besides showing that Democrats and Republicans actually can agree on something, will consolidate and coordinate statistical expertise for assessment among rank and file bureaucrats across the federal government. 22

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › China DA › 2NC – UQ

The US and China’s relationship is tense now

CFR n.d.(Council on Foreign Relations is a non-partisan organization to help the public understand foreign policy, “US-China Relations,” n.d.,) [MO]

President Biden orders the U.S. Air Force to shoot down a Chinese-operated balloon off the southeastern U.S. coast after security officials say it was spying on sensitive military sites. China calls the balloon a civilian weather-monitoring craft that accidentally veered into U.S. air space. China’s foreign ministry as “a serious violation of international practice” and vows retaliation. The incident causes the Biden administration to cancel a trip by U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken to Beijing, raising fresh concerns over a worsening of U.S.-China relations already strained by U.S. support for Taiwan and trade frictions.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › China DA › 1NC – Shell

Taiwan escalates to nuclear war

Klare 22 (Michael Klare is the Nation’s defense correspondent, “Could the Fight Over Taiwan Trigger Nuclear War?,” 10-13-22, ) [MO]

But hold on! As it happens, Ukraine isn’t the only place on the planet where a nuclear conflagration could erupt in the near future. Sad to say, around the island of Taiwan—where US and Chinese forces are engaging in ever more provocative military maneuvers—there is also an increasing risk that such moves by both sides could lead to nuclear escalation.

While neither American nor Chinese officials have explicitly threatened to use such weaponry, both sides have highlighted possible extreme outcomes there. When Joe Biden last spoke with Xi Jinping by telephone on July 29, the Chinese president warned him against allowing House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to visit the island (which she nonetheless did, four days later) or offering any further encouragement to “Taiwan independence forces” there. “Those who play with fire will perish by it,” he the American president, an ambiguous warning to be sure, but one that nevertheless left open the possible use of nuclear weapons.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › China DA › 1NC – Shell

China will use its rapport with Russia to prepare to invade Taiwan

Singleton 3/6 (Craig Singleton is a senior Chinese fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, “China’s Ukraine Peace Plan is Actually About Taiwan,” 3-6-22, ) [MO]

After twelve grinding months, China appears no more capable of influencing the outcome of Russia’s war in Ukraine than it was at the conflict’s inception. Largely reduced to spectator status, Beijing’s primary role has been to provide Moscow with a financial lifeline by ramping up of heavily discounted Russian crude oil and coal, while reaping an unexpected windfall from surging exports to Russia. But these and other Chinese half-measures appear aimed, for now, at ensuring Russia has what it needs to sustain its wartime economy—not actually win the war.

In a similar twist, China’s 12-point peace for Ukraine is not geared toward restoring peace in Europe. Indeed, China’s dead-on-arrival missive has little to do with ending the war in Ukraine and everything to do with setting the conditions to win a future war over Taiwan. Put differently, China recognizes the causes of Russia’s failure in Ukraine are the same that threaten its eventual reunification plans.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › China DA › 1NC – Shell

This plan weakens the US, China will be led to strengthen its relationship with Russia

Krastev and Leonard 21 (Ivan Krastev is the Chairman for the Center of Liberal Stratgies, Mark Leonard is the Director of the European Council on Foreign Relations, “The crisis of American power: How Europeans see Biden’s America,” 1-19-21, https://ecfr.eu/publication/the-crisis-of-american-power-how-europeans-see-bidens-america) [MO]

Our survey showed that Europeans’ attitudes towards the United States have undergone a massive change. Majorities in key member states now think the US political system is broken, that China will be more powerful than the US within a decade, and that Europeans cannot rely on the US to defend them. They are drawing radical consequences from these lessons. Large numbers think Europeans should invest in their own defence and look to Berlin rather than Washington as their most important partner. They want to be tougher with the US on economic issues. And, rather than aligning with Washington, they want their countries to stay neutral in a conflict between the US and Russia or China.