Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Topicality › 2NC – TVA

UBI is the first step to helping black people gain material wealth.

Ghenis ’20 [Max Ghenis is the founder and president of the UBI Center. Ghenis, Max. “How Universal Basic Income Would Affect the Black-White Poverty and Wealth Gaps.” UBI Center, 20 June 2020, www.ubicenter.org/how-universal-basic-income-would-affect-the-black-white-poverty-and-wealth-gaps. ]

A number of economic policies have been proposed to reduce these gaps, from  to  to . How would universal basic income fare? To answer this question, I went to the Census Bureau’s 2018  (SPM; see this  on SPM’s improvements over the Official Poverty Measure) and the Federal Reserve’s 2016 . I modeled how the black-white gaps in the SPM poverty rate, median wealth, and mean wealth change when providing each person (children, too) an unconditional payment each month. I don’t assume any funding, so this can be thought of as a lower bound on the gap closure, if the UBI were to be funded through progressive taxes. The results show large effects from even modest UBIs. For example, a $200 per month payment would more than halve the black poverty rate, putting it below the current white poverty rate. This would cost about $800 billion per year. A $1,000 monthly UBI would reduce the poverty rate from its current 13 percent to roughly 1 percent for all racial groups, costing about $4 trillion. UBI wouldn’t only reduce the black poverty rate on an absolute basis, it would also close the black-white poverty gap. Currently, the black poverty rate is 1.82 times the white poverty rate; a $200-per-month UBI would reduce that to 1.65, and a $1,000-per-month UBI would reduce it to 1.38. The scale of racial wealth inequality — hundreds of years in the making — dampens the effect compared to poverty. White families have median wealth of $125,000, 7.7 times the median black wealth of $16,300. The mean wealth delta is relatively smaller but larger on an absolute basis: white families have average wealth of $800,000, 5.7 times the $140,000 mean wealth of black families. Again there are significant effects from even the $200-per-month UBI, which would cut the median wealth gap from 7.7 to 6.0 and cut the mean wealth gap from 5.7 to 5.5.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Topicality › 2NC – TVA

We acknowledge the affs unpayable debt, and so we use a basic income to fiscally redistribute all the money the USFG has to black people.

Fouksman And Klein [Klein, E., and E. Fouksman;Dr Elizaveta Fouksman is a Lecturer (Assistant Professor) in Social Justice at the Centre for Public Policy Research in the School of Education, Communication and Society at King's College London."Reparations as a rightful share: from universalism to redress in distributive justice." Development and Change 53.1 (2022): 31-57.]

Although reparations have been supported by a number of groups and in a variety of forms in the US, this case study will focus on the reparations agenda of the Movement for Black Lives. This is because some of the Movement’s racial justice-based proposals specifically included a universal basic income as part of demandsmadebytheMovementin2015–17(MacFarland, 2016; Warren, 2016), making it a particularly useful lens through which to think about the intersections and tensions between claims for universal and reparatory distributional justice. Dorian T. Warren, one of the authors of the demands, placed UBI not under the economic justice heading, but rather under the heading of reparations. Warren points out that a UBI would bene f it the poor the most, and that it would thus be particularly helpful to the formerly incarcerated and to cashless poor Black people. The implication here is that Warren sees class and race as inseparable, precisely because the US is a society whose economic system is based on a history of slavery and economic exploitation, discrimination and incarceration on the basis of race. The argument in favour of UBI as a form of reparations on the basis of the intersection of class and race in a post-slavery society is built on the acknowledgement that class exploitation and expropriation and race are closely tied. Because White Americans earn more on average (due precisely to this history of slavery and post-slavery discrimination), a universal basic income would be taxed back from the wealthy (and largely White) community. Its beneficiaries would be the poor, but due to this history of disadvantage, it would especially benefit Black communities in the US, which have disproportionately high rates of poverty and economic disadvantage.7 Beyond the intersection of class and race, Warren also points out that the universalism and unconditionality of UBI have essential advantages. Not only would universalism prevent a repetition of previous racially discriminatory social policies (such as the New Deal’s purposeful exclusion of largely Black agricultural workers), but it would avoid the ‘paternalistic restrictions that rest on racist tropes’ (Warren, 2017b; see also Warren, 2017a) within current social policies, such as food stamps. Also crucial is the fact the UBI does not have a work requirement, particularly in light of the structural racism that continues to exclude Black communities from employment in the US. Indeed, other theorists of race-based reparations in the US have also made a similar case for universal social or distributory programmes that would lessen racial inequality by aiding all; for instance, Darity and Hamilton (2012) propose a federal work guarantee and child development accounts.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Topicality › 1NC – Interps

The resolution calls for debate over hypothetical government action

Ericson 3 (Jon M., Dean Emeritus of the College of Liberal Arts – California Polytechnic U., et al., The Debater’s Guide, Third Edition, p. 4)

The Proposition of Policy: Urging Future Action In policy propositions, each topic contains certain key elements, although they have slightly different functions from comparable elements of value-oriented propositions. 1. An agent doing the acting ---“The United States” in “The United States should adopta policy of free trade.” Like the object of evaluation in a proposition of value, the agent is the subject of the sentence. 2. The verb should—the first part of a verb phrase that urges action. 3. An action verb to follow should in the should-verb combination. For example, should adopt here means to put a program or policy into action though governmental means. 4. A specification of directions or a limitation of the action desired. The phrase free trade, for example, gives direction and limits to the topic, which would, for example, eliminate consideration of increasing tariffs, discussing diplomatic recognition, or discussing interstate commerce. Propositions of policy deal with future action. Nothing has yet occurred. The entire debate is about whether something ought to occur. What you agree to do, then, when you accept the affirmative side in such a debate is to offer sufficient and compelling reasons for an audience to perform the future action that you propose. 

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Topicality › 1NC – Interps

USfg is the federal government of the United States based in D.C.

Dictionary of Government and Politics 98 (Ed. P.H. Collin, p. 292)

United States of America (USA) [ju:’naitid ‘steits av e’merike] noun independent country, a federation of states (originally thirteen, now fifty in North America; the United States Code = book containing all the permanent laws of the USA, arranged in sections according to subject and revised from time to time COMMENT: the federal government (based in Washington D.C.) is formed of a legislature (the Congress) with two chambers (the Senate and House of Representatives), an executive (the President) and a judiciary (the Supreme Court). Each of the fifty states making up the USA has its own legislature and executive (the Governor) as well as its own legal system and constitution

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Topicality › 1NC – Interps

“Resolved” is legislative

Army Officer School 2005 (“# 12, Punctuation – The Colon and Semicolon”, 5-12, )  

The colon introduces the following: a. A list, but only after "as follows," "the following," or a noun for which the list is an appositive: Each scout will carry the following: (colon) meals for three days, a survival knife, and his sleeping bag. The company had four new officers: (colon) Bill Smith, Frank Tucker, Peter Fillmore, and Oliver Lewis. b. A long quotation (one or more paragraphs): In The Killer Angels Michael Shaara wrote: (colon) You may find it a different story from the one you learned in school. There have been many versions of that battle [Gettysburg] and that war [the Civil War]. (The quote continues for two more paragraphs.) c. A formal quotation or question: The President declared: (colon) "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself." The question is: (colon) what can we do about it? d. A second independent clause which explains the first: Potter's motive is clear: (colon) he wants the assignment. e. After the introduction of a business letter: Dear Sirs: (colon) Dear Madam: (colon) f. The details following an announcement For sale: (colon) large lakeside cabin with dock g. A formal resolution, after the word "resolved:" Resolved: (colon) That this council petition the mayor.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

Reparations are quantifiable. This bolsters the TVA – if reparations can be paid hypothetically, then the aff’s impacts can be solved.

Bazelon et al ’23 (Coleman, Dr. Bazelon frequently advises regulatory and legislative bodies, including the US Federal Communications Commission and the US Congress. June. 8 “Quantification of Reparations for Transatlantic Chattel Slavery”, https://www.brattle.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Quantification-of-Reparations-for-Transatlantic-Chattel-Slavery.pdf accessed Jul. 10. Brattle)//max

As summarized in Figure 11 and Table 34, our analyses quantified reparations compensation of US$100 trillion to US$131 trillion. While these are almost unimaginably large amounts of money, in the preceding sections we have shown that the magnitudes are reasonable given the depth (the harm per person), breadth (the number of people harmed) and duration of the harm, as well as the delay in making reparations. In this section, we show what these reparations would represent to the enslaving countries, especially in the context of their economic performance from the time when they sponsored slavery to the present. Such amounts are difficult to understand in isolation. To begin to put the results in context, the GDP of the United States was approximately US$25 trillion in 2022, and those of the UK and France were approximately US$3 trillion, each. Having a reparations number that is several multiples of a country’s GDP is not surprising. Recall that GDP is a measure of the annual output of a country, while the damages we—and the authors on whose work we build on—have calculated here occurred over centuries. It makes sense that one year of output of a country’s economy is insufficient to repair the damages inflicted on millions of people over 200, 300 or more years. Moreover, the delay in the payment of these reparations also plays an important role. Given that centuries have passed from the harm to the present, the calculated reparations are very sensitive to the choice of interest rate. As shown in Table 37 reducing the interest rate from our baseline 2.5% to 2.3% reduces the reparation to US$100 trillion, and reducing the rate further, to 2.1% reduces the reparation estimate to US$85 trillion.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

Fiscal redistribution solves economic inequality through taxation

Williamson 20 (Vanessa Williamson, “Closing the Racial Wealth Gap Requires heavy, Progressive Taxation of Wealth,” 12-9-20, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/closing-the-racial-wealth-gap-requires-heavy-progressive-taxation-of-wealth)[MO]

Any plan to eliminate the total racial wealth gap requires, in addition to a transformative national investment in Black households and communities, a program of heavy and highly progressive taxation aimed at the very wealthiest Americans. A comprehensive agenda to close the racial wealth gap would likely include reforms to income and estate taxation, plus new taxes on wealth and inheritance, buttressed by a substantial investment in enforcement.

While these taxes would likely also raise substantial revenue, this is not their primary purpose. High and progressive taxation of extreme wealth is in itself a strategy for racial justice because it would directly reduce the portion of the racial wealth gap that exists at the top of the economic ladder.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

The Resolution still lessens income inequality. Fiscal Redistribution helps more than it hurts.

Bourguignon 18 [Francois Bourguignon, "Spreading The Wealth", March 2018, International Monetary Fund, .]

Income redistribution will lower poverty by reducing inequality, if done properly. But it may not accelerate growth in any major way, except perhaps by reducing social tensions arising from inequality and allowing poor people to devote more resources to human and physical asset accumulation. Directly investing in opportunities for poor people is essential. Transfers to the poor should not consist merely of cash; they should also boost people’s capacity to generate income, today and in the future. Education and training as well as access to health care, micro-credit, water, energy, and transportation are powerful instruments. Social assistance is critical to prevent people from falling into poverty traps when adverse shocks hit. Programs such as India’s Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee, in which the state acts as the employer of last resort, do precisely that. Conditional cash transfers have been shown to motivate families to send their children to school, improve their nutrition, and monitor their health. But facilities to meet this additional demand must be made available and must be financed. The same is true of other programs focusing on improving opportunities for the poor. Financing these programs through progressive taxation while providing cash transfer incentives to poor households thus reduces inequality and poverty in the short term and helps these households generate more income over the medium and long term. Is such a strategy of static and dynamic income equalization immune to the efficiency cost of redistribution? In other words, do these taxes and transfers take away the incentives for people to work, save, and become entrepreneurs? Given the limited scope of redistribution in developing economies, it is unlikely that it would have much effect on economic incentives. Substantial income tax progressivity may indeed be achieved with marginal tax rates much below those in advanced economies, where redistribution is not considered to be an obstacle to growth (Lindert 2004). Also, replacing distortionary indirect taxes or subsidies with income transfers should improve efficiency. Moreover, conditional cash transfers appear to have no significant negative effect on labor supply; they may even encourage entrepreneurship (Bianchi and Boba 2013). Strategies that promote greater equality and stronger growth rely on raising resources in a progressive way and spending them on programs that benefit the poorest segment of the population in this generation or the next one. Other policies that do not rely on redistribution may achieve the same goals. Before contemplating redistribution, however, governments ought to consider enhancing the pro-poor nature or inclusiveness of their growth strategies, in particular through fostering employment for unskilled workers.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

UBI is the first step to helping black people gain material wealth.

Ghenis ’20 [Max Ghenis is the founder and president of the UBI Center. Ghenis, Max. “How Universal Basic Income Would Affect the Black-White Poverty and Wealth Gaps.” UBI Center, 20 June 2020, www.ubicenter.org/how-universal-basic-income-would-affect-the-black-white-poverty-and-wealth-gaps. ]

A number of economic policies have been proposed to reduce these gaps, from  to  to . How would universal basic income fare? To answer this question, I went to the Census Bureau’s 2018  (SPM; see this  on SPM’s improvements over the Official Poverty Measure) and the Federal Reserve’s 2016 . I modeled how the black-white gaps in the SPM poverty rate, median wealth, and mean wealth change when providing each person (children, too) an unconditional payment each month. I don’t assume any funding, so this can be thought of as a lower bound on the gap closure, if the UBI were to be funded through progressive taxes. The results show large effects from even modest UBIs. For example, a $200 per month payment would more than halve the black poverty rate, putting it below the current white poverty rate. This would cost about $800 billion per year. A $1,000 monthly UBI would reduce the poverty rate from its current 13 percent to roughly 1 percent for all racial groups, costing about $4 trillion. UBI wouldn’t only reduce the black poverty rate on an absolute basis, it would also close the black-white poverty gap. Currently, the black poverty rate is 1.82 times the white poverty rate; a $200-per-month UBI would reduce that to 1.65, and a $1,000-per-month UBI would reduce it to 1.38. The scale of racial wealth inequality — hundreds of years in the making — dampens the effect compared to poverty. White families have median wealth of $125,000, 7.7 times the median black wealth of $16,300. The mean wealth delta is relatively smaller but larger on an absolute basis: white families have average wealth of $800,000, 5.7 times the $140,000 mean wealth of black families. Again there are significant effects from even the $200-per-month UBI, which would cut the median wealth gap from 7.7 to 6.0 and cut the mean wealth gap from 5.7 to 5.5.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

Black People Want Reparations

Kox and Edwards ‘22 [Kiana Cox is a research associate at Pew Research Center, where she predominantly contributes to the Center’s work on race and ethnicity, as well as religion, with particular attention to Black communities. Cox earned her doctorate in sociology from the University of Illinois at Chicago. Prior to joining the Center, Kiana was an Assistant Professor of Sociology at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville where she taught courses on race, gender, social movements, statistics, and research methodology. Khadijah Edwards is a research associate focusing on race and ethnicity research at Pew Research Center. Cox, Kiana, and Khadijah Edwards. “Reparations for Slavery.” Pew Research Center Race & Ethnicity, 30 Aug. 2022, www.pewresearch.org/race-ethnicity/2022/08/30/black-americans-views-on-reparations-for-slavery/. ]

Black liberals (84%) and moderates (79%) are more likely than conservatives (71%) to say that descendants of the enslaved should be repaid. And Black adults who say they are registered to vote (80%) are more likely than those who report they are unregistered (72%) to support reparations for slavery. Notably, large majorities of almost all these groups support reparations for the descendants of those enslaved in the U.S. Black adults’ support for reparations also differs based on their views of identity and society. In the survey, Black adults were asked how important being Black was to how they think about themselves and also whether racist laws or racist individuals are a bigger problem for Black people in the U.S. today. Black adults who say that being Black is extremely or very important to their  (84%) are more likely to support reparations for slavery than those who say that being Black is somewhat, a little or not at all important to them (58%). And Black adults who say racist laws are a bigger problem for Black people (87%) are more likely than those who say racist individuals are the bigger problem (72%) to support reparations, though large majorities of both groups still agree. While nearly three-quarters or more of Black adults across education and income levels support reparations, about one-in-five Black adults with a bachelor’s degree (21%) as well as Black adults with middle (21%) or upper incomes (20%) do not think descendants of enslaved people should be repaid.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

African Americans have been historically excluded from any form of reparation by the United States Federal Government, we must prioritize fiscal reparations first.

Ray and Perry 20 (Rashawn, Dr. Ray serves as a professor of Sociology and executive director of the Lab for Applied Social Science Research (LASSR) at the University of Maryland. Andre, Perry has been published by numerous national media outlets, including The New York Times, The Nation, The Washington Post, TheRoot.com and CNN.com. April 15. “Why we need reparations for Black Americans”  accessed Jul. 11. Brookings.edu) [AH]

Black Americans are the only group that has not received reparations for state-sanctioned racial discrimination, while slavery afforded some white families the ability to accrue tremendous wealth. And, we must note that American slavery was particularly brutal. About 15 percent of the enslaved shipped from Western Africa died during transport. The enslaved were regularly beaten and lynched for frivolous infractions. Slavery also disrupted families as one in three marriages were split up and one in five children were separated from their parents. The case for reparations can be made on economic, social, and moral grounds. The United States had multiple opportunities to atone for slavery—each a missed chance to make the American Dream a reality—but has yet to undertake significant action. Missed policy opportunities to atone for slavery with reparations 40 Acres and a Mule The first major opportunity that the United States had and where it should have atoned for slavery was right after the Civil War. Union leaders including General William Sherman concluded that each Black family should receive 40 acres. Sherman signed Field Order 15 and allocated 400,000 acres of confiscated Confederate land to Black families. Additionally, some families were to receive mules left over from the war, hence . Yet, after President Abraham Lincoln’s assassination, President Andrew Johnson reversed Field Order 15 and returned land back to former slave owners. Instead of giving Blacks the means to support themselves, the federal government empowered former enslavers. For example, in Washington D.C., slave owners were actually paid reparations for —the formally enslaved. This practice was also common in nearby states. Many Black Americans with limited work options returned as sharecroppers to till the same land for the very slave owners to whom they were once enslaved. Slave owners not only made money off the chattel enslavement of Black Americans, but they then made money multiple times over off the land that the formerly enslaved had no choice but to work. The New Deal There’s never a bad time to do what’s morally right, but the United States has had prime opportunities to atone for slavery. In the 1930s, the United States was reeling from the 1929 stock market crash and was firmly engulfed in the Great Depression. The Franklin Roosevelt administration implemented a series of policies as part of his New Deal legislation, then, to catapult the country out of depression. Current estimates price the New Deal at about $50 trillion. Two particular policies of the New Deal fell short in redressing American’s racial wrongs—the G.I. Bill and Social Security. Though white and Black Americans fought in WWII, Black veterans could not redeem their post-war benefits like their white peers. While the G.I. Bill was mandated federally, it was implemented locally. The presence of racial housing covenants and redlining among local municipalities prohibited Blacks from utilizing federal benefits. White soldiers were afforded the opportunity to build wealth by sending themselves and their children to college and by obtaining housing and small business grants. Regarding Social Security, two key professions that would have improved equity in America were excluded from the legislation—domestic and farm workers. These omissions effectively excluded 60 percent of Blacks across the U.S. and 75 percent in southern states who worked in these occupations. Roosevelt bargained these exclusionary provisions in the legislation on the backs of Black veterans and workers in order to propel mostly white America out of the Great Depression. There are other policies and practices that contributed to racial wealth gap. Government-sanctioned discrimination related to the 1862 Homestead Act, redlining, restrictive covenants, and convict leasing blocked Blacks from the ability to gain wealth at similar rates as whites. Separate from slavery, damages should be awarded to Black people who were harmed by these policies and practices.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Unpayable Debt NEG 23 › Case › 1NC - Frontline

Responsibility turn: The idea of “Unpayable Debt” is inherently problematic- it allows white people to evade giving reparations and stops black people from attaining much deserved wealth. We have a collective responsibility to give reparations to black people.

Mc Carthy’ 04 [McCarthy, Thomas. "Coming to terms with our past, part II: On the morality and politics of reparations for slavery." Political Theory 32.6 (2004): 750-772.]

In my view, the case for slavery reparations should makes systematic use of the facts that the United States is a nation-state with an unbroken constitutional history and that African Americans were denied equal protection under the law for most of that history. Without this emphasis, arguments for slavery reparations may founder on the further fact that the nonblack population of the United States derives largely from waves of post–Civil War immigration—including the most recent, post–civil rights wave, which now com prises some thirty to forty million foreign-born citizens and fifty to sixty million first- or second-generation Americans. In regard to a population of this sort, it makes little sense, I think, to construct arguments for reparations turning on the claim that all nonblacks have contributed to the continuance of black inequality or at least have benefited from it. Even supposing that were true in some sense, how could we begin to conceptualize the infinitely com plex attributions of differential responsibility involved? And arguments that eschew individual attributions of responsibility for conceptions of national responsibility centered around cultural continuity, and on the sense of identi fication with the past it brings, lose much of their force when applied to a community shaped by successive waves of multicultural immigration.This is not true, however, of arguments that turn, rather, on the constitutional continuity of a legal-political community. The approach defend holds that there is a collective responsibility of U.S. citizens as such for the enduring harms to African Americans that have resulted from legally sanctioned injuries of race under earlier regimes. Each generation of citizens, whether native- or foreign-born, inherits the burdens of membership—the national debts ,as it were—together with the benefits of membership. Any conceptually coherent case for bestowing upon incoming citizens full rights to the national territory, public institutions, and the like, which are the accumulated results of the actions of earlier generations of citizens—including the actions of civil rights activists, who have bequeathed to all minorities fairer structures of opportunity—is at the same time a case for their inheriting the liabilities incurred by those earlier generations.16 Thus, the responsibility to rectify the continuing harms of pastracial injustice accrues to the political community as a whole ,not only because those wrongs were generally state sanctioned and frequently state implemented but also because present members who share inherited benefits must by the same logic share inherited liabilities. Our national inheritance was in considerable part unjustly acquired at the expense of African Americans,and as a result,it is now unfairly distributed in respect to them. The issue here is not whether individual citizens’ ancestors owned slaves, or whether they have personally benefited from discrimination against blacks, but that they now share in and benefit from an unjustly acquired and unfairly distributed national inheritance. This is not a matter of collective guilt but of collective responsibility; and reparation is not a matter of collective punishment but of collective liability.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › MMT = very bad

MMT cannot just ignore the issue of inflation

Drumetz and Pfister Francoise Drumetz is the Director and Microeconomic and Structural Research at Le Banque de France. Christian Pfister is the Deputy Director General, DG Statistics for the Banque de France (French Central Bank) and lecturer at Sciences Po and Paris I University. “Modern Monetary Theory: A Wrong Compass for Decision-Making.” Intereconomics.

A major criticism that can be addressed to MMT is that its proponents are unable to prove their claims given the lack of formal modelling. In line with this criticism, the following appraisal reviews MMT’s key assumptions on inflation, monetary policy, fiscal policy and their (lack of) feedback. According to Palley (2019b), MMT is especially dismissive of the problem of inflation and lacks a doctrine. For instance, Wray (2019) writes: “Fortunately – or unfortunately depending on one’s view – modern economies usually operate with sufficient slack that even large boosts to aggregate demand are not likely to put much pressure on wages and prices. Our critics continue to fight an inflation battle that was won almost two generations ago” (7). As regards monetary policy’s role in managing aggregate demand, MMT’s discarding of interest rates as a tool of stabilisation policy is problematic. First, Tymoigne and Wray (2013) posit that the “sensitivity” of aggregate demand to interest rates is low. As interest rates are seen as affecting the cost of borrowing, which influences costs of production and prices, low interest rates may lead to lower inflation; however, such a cost-push argument is purely short term in nature. Second, discarding interest rates as a stabilisation tool would create political economy and instrument shortage problems (Palley, 2019b). From a political economy point of view, monetary policy is the preferred instrument to manage aggregate demand because fiscal policy is difficult to use to stabilise the business cycle. In addition, the loss of an instrument would compound the difficulty for a policymaker to achieve her policy targets. Third, MMT’s prescription to keep nominal interest rates at a very low, near-zero level would also foster macroeconomic instability, with, during the upward phase of the cycle, real rates falling and potentially causing higher inflation, which would in turn lower real interest rates.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › MMT = very bad

Empirical examples of MMT theory being applied have failed, and models for its implementation in the US have negative results

Drumetz and Pfister Francoise Drumetz is the Director and Microeconomic and Structural Research at Le Banque de France. Christian Pfister is the Deputy Director General, DG Statistics for the Banque de France (French Central Bank) and lecturer at Sciences Po and Paris I University. “Modern Monetary Theory: A Wrong Compass for Decision-Making.” Intereconomics.

Both historical precedents and an attempt to measure the impact of the MMT programme in the USA through public debt monetisation provide strong cautionary tales against such an approach. According to Edwards (2019), Almost every one of the Latin American experiments with major central bank-financed fiscal expansions took place under populist regimes and all of them ended badly…. In most of these episodes…, policy makers used arguments similar to those made by MMTers to justify extensive use of money creation to finance very large increases in public expenditures (3). Ocampo (2020) also mentions the case of Argentina under Peron (1946-1955) or Peronist regimes, particularly the years 1946-1948, 1973-1974, 2007, 2012 and 2020, and the one of Nazi Germany between 1937 and 1945. Palley (2019a) evaluates that the full monetisation by the central bank of the increase in the public deficit caused by the implementation of the MMT programme in the USA would imply a fiftyfold increase in the monetary base-to-GDP ratio relative to the 2018. He highlights that those money supply dynamics “would almost certainly trigger high inflation in both asset markets and goods markets, as well as causing significant inflationary and destabilizing exchange rate depreciation” (Palley, 2019a, 153). Indeed, already in 1982, Sargent had studied the end of four big inflations (Austria, Hungary, Poland and Germany in the 1920s) showing that it was not simply the increasing quantity of central bank notes [in modern economies, reserves] that caused the hyperinflation…, it was the growth of fiat currency that was unbacked, or backed only by government bills, which there never was a prospect to retire through taxation (89).

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › MMT = very bad

MMT is a flawed way of handling government spending and causes inflation. (I hatethis tag)

Roche 22 [Cullen Roche, Founded Pragcap website in 2008, Feburary 7 2022, MMT Failed Its First Big Inflation Test, PragCap, https://www.pragcap.com/mmt-failed-its-first-big-inflation-test/]

To be clear, MMT’s theory of inflation claims that the government need only worry about “real resource” constraints since they can print money to cover any solvency problem. This is obvious in one sense (the government has a printing press) and also vague to the point of being useless (since “real resource constraint” isn’t a measurable concept).¹ In any case they claim that we should implement policy that would pre-emptively account for high inflation. The problem with this claim is: NONE OF THE MMT ADVOCATES PREDICTED THE CURRENT HIGH INFLATION. So, right off the bat they’re claiming they can build a proactive inflation fighting model even though their existing models clearly didn’t predict the current inflation. Strike One. But let’s cut them some slack. Predicting inflation is hard. I say that all the time. So, maybe when the government spends too much you just wait until it’s a problem and then you try to get in front of it. Given that, we would expect MMT advocates to be out in force calling for tax hikes and smaller deficits, right? Except no. THEY’VE ACTUALLY [have] BEEN CALLING FOR MORE GOVERNMENT SPENDING IN THE LAST YEAR. Strike Two. Okay, but maybe that’s not what they really meant. Maybe they want to spend more in certain areas, but also increase taxes and run countercyclical policies that would counteract inflation. Except no. In Turkey, for instance, MMT’s founder actually said that the government should cut rates, but when the Turkish Central Bank cut rates the Lira collapsed 50%. So, countercyclical monetary policy isn’t an option there. We’ll call this ball one because I am being generous even though this is a called strike three right down the pipe. What about fiscal policy? Surely MMT advocates are calling for broadly higher taxes despite calling for targeted spending increases. But no. Stephanie Kelton says higher taxes are not part of MMT’s inflation fighting policies. Except Kelton’s book explicitly says that taxes are an inflation fighting tool: “We agree that we should rely on adjustments in taxes and spending (fiscal policy) rather than interest rates (monetary policy) to balance our economy. We also agree that fiscal deficits, in and of themselves, are neither good nor bad. What matters is not whether the government’s budget is in surplus or deficit but whether the government is using its budget to achieve good outcomes for the rest of the economy. We agree that taxes are an important way to reduce spending power and that taxes should never be increased simply to appear fiscally responsible.” In fact, the NY Times article citing the “victory lap” says the same thing: “In an M.M.T. world, the Congressional Budget Office would have carefully analyzed possible inflation ahead of time, and lawmakers would have tried to offset any strain on available workers and widgets with stabilizing measures and tax increases.” But as soon as there was a voracious backlash to this article calling out this contradiction Kelton went to Twitter to declare: “MMT has obviously proven correct….MMTers never said to fight inflation with tax hikes.”² Her own book explicitly said taxes are an inflation fighting tool. But now that high inflation is here they’re saying we shouldn’t rely on tax increases and government cutbacks to fight inflation because this is mostly a supply chain issue.³ This is all very confusing to be honest. And I hate to say it, but this is strike 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9. The inning is over. In summary, MMT hasn’t been proven correct by any measure. If anything they’ve handled the current inflation in a worrisome manner. They didn’t predict the current high inflation, consistently said it would be transitory and have had no countercyclical response to combat it now that it’s here (despite claiming tax hikes are the right way to beat down inflation). Which begs the question – what if they’re wrong again? What if inflation lingers longer than they think? I personally think inflation will decline slowly in the coming years, but I also think the Fed and Congress are right to hedge that bet by slowing spending and raising rates. Meanwhile, MMT advocates have no countercyclical response at all. In fact, their response has been more procyclical spending. Not only is it a poor predictive model, but the model appears to contain little to no sensible risk management in case of a worst case scenario. It’s a worrisome response at best and a sign that MMT has failed its first real test with inflation.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › MMT = very bad

Modern Monetary Theory leads to inflation and wrecks the economy.

Roberts 22 [Lance Roberts, Chief Investment Strategist for RIA Advisors and Lead Editor of the Real Investment Report, July 23 2022, MMT Policy Was Tried, And It Failed, Seeking Alpha, ]

MMT Policy (Modern Monetary Theory), the grand experiment, was tried following the pandemic-driven shutdown of the economy. It failed miserably. However, before we get to its failure, we need to review the policy to understand why it failed to work as anticipated. According to Investopedia: The central idea of MMT is that governments with a fiat currency system under their control can and should print (or create with a few keystrokes in today's digital age) as much money as they need to spend because they cannot go broke or be insolvent unless a political decision to do so is taken. Some say such spending would be fiscally irresponsible, as the debt would balloon and inflation would skyrocket. But according to MMT: Large government debt isn't the precursor to a collapse that we believe it is; Countries like the U.S. can sustain much more significant deficits without cause for concern; and A small deficit or surplus can be extremely harmful and cause a recession since deficit spending is what builds people's savings. Here is the critical paragraph: According to MMT, the only limit that the government has when it comes to spending is the availability of real resources, like workers, construction supplies, etc. When government spending is too great with respect to the resources available, inflation can surge if decision-makers are not careful. Taxes create an ongoing demand for currency and are a tool to take money out of an economy that is getting overheated, says MMT. This goes against the conventional idea that taxes are primarily meant to provide the government with money to spend to build infrastructure, fund social welfare programs, etc. With this base understanding, we can "review the tape" to judge whether MMT was successful in its implementation as an economic policy tool. At the end of 2019, Federal Debt outstanding was $23.2 trillion. Of course, three months later, the government would decide to shut down the economy to battle the COVID-19 outbreak. That decision was the defining moment that implemented MMT policy with successive rounds of monetary stimulus from direct checks to households to expanded government subsidies. By the year-end of 2021, Federal Debt swelled to nearly $30 trillion. Such is the most significant increase in government spending in U.S. history. While the spending of a massive flood of stimulus temporarily boosted economic growth by “pulling forward” future demand, it also created several problems. The most obvious problem was the impact of dramatically increasing demand on a supply-stricken economy. With the economy “shut down” due to government-mandated restrictions, the flood of stimulus payments led to a demand boost. Given the basic economics of supply versus demand, prices rose. As expected, would be the case, the implementation led to a massive surge of inflation. (Given most Americans’ have fixed healthcare and housing payments for a contractual period, the third measure shows what cost-of-living is for most every month.) Such is always the problem of injecting money into the economic system. The repeated argument that more stimulus helps the “poor working class” is erroneous. As we argued in “Bidens Stimulus Will Cut Poverty For One Year,” when you provide “free” money, those that provide the products and services lift prices accordingly. A recent study shows this impact. “An analysis by the Penn Wharton Budget Model found that low- and middle-income households spent about 7% more in 2021 for the same products they bought in 2020 or 2019, an average of about $3,500,” according to the report. In other words, when you provide “free capital,” a market-based economy will adjust prices to compensate for the additional demand for products and services. Those primarily living paycheck-to-paycheck see their “disposable incomes” getting “taxed” away. Such leaves their standard of living unchanged. The following graph shows the average American now has a record deficit requiring more than $4,500 of new debt annually. Such is why socialism in any form does not elevate the middle class but shrinks it.While MMT proponents suggest that giving free money will boost economic equality, the opposite is the case, as shown by the net worth of the top 10 percent versus the bottom 50 percent of the population.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › Green Tech Doesn’t Solve

The private sector is crucial to poverty reduction

Pfeffermann ’01 [Guy Pfeffermann is the International Finance Corporation's Chief Economist and an Adjunct Professor at the School of Advanced International Studies, Johns Hopkins University (Washington). Pfeffermann, Guy. “Poverty Reduction in Developing Countries: The Role of Private Enterprise.” Finance and Development | F&D, June 2001, www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2001/06/pfefferm.htm#author]

The role of private enterprise in development has been neglected by scholars, governments, and aid organizations. This is regrettable: a vibrant private sector generates jobs, raises incomes, and makes better, cheaper goods and services available. The positive contribution that private enterprises can make to development and poverty reduction is likely to be obvious to most readers. They would agree that, in the long term, economic development cannot occur without dynamic private companies. They would also agree that good government and efficient public administration are equally necessary. The success of Singapore shows what such a combination can achieve. Then why write an article on the subject? Many of the Seattle, Washington, D.C., Prague, and Davos protesters blame multinational corporations for retarding development, despoiling nature, and keeping wages down. Not only is the development impact of private firms an emotional and contentious subject but research has tended to be compartmentalized, concentrating on only one of the many aspects of this subject—multinational corporations, small and medium-sized enterprises, microenterprises, the performance of privatized firms, foreign direct investment, private infrastructure, or corporate governance, to name a few—without looking at the bigger picture. Except in Marxist literature, little has been published about the development impact of private enterprise per se. One possible reason for academic compartmentalization may be the way in which basic economic statistics—the raw materials of nationwide empirical research—are organized. The United Nations System of National Accounts, which governs the way the most essential economic statistics are collected and assembled in the United Nations' member states, does not draw a distinction between private and public firms; instead, the two are lumped together into "productive sectors" such as manufacturing, mining, and services. It is therefore impossible, in most countries, to trace over time the contribution of private firms to value added, investment, and incomes. Investment data for private firms are available in about 50 of the world's 200-plus countries, but, in the vast majority of countries, the value added and incomes they generate are unknown. (The World Bank Group publishes private investment data annually under the heading "Trends in Private Investment in Developing Countries" in the International Finance Corporation's Discussion Papers series as well as on the web at www.ifc.org/economics/pubs/discuss.htm.) There can be no doubt that, in today's affluent countries, poverty is far less widespread than it was in earlier times. In 1820, the average income per head in Finland, Norway, and Sweden was less than $1,000 at 1990 prices; hundreds of thousands of people emigrated from those countries to the United States, where income per head was $1,300. Today, these three countries are among the richest in the world. It is also important to consider intergenerational changes, because income mobility can be high from generation to generation. In Brazil, for example, more than half of the persons surveyed recently who had grown up in poor families moved out of poverty. The majority of those who started their working lives in agriculture as unpaid family workers, or at age 10 or younger, are now living above the poverty line. What has happened in Brazil has happened in the developing world as a whole. Income mobility is high, but this fact has not received much public attention. According to household income and expenditure surveys, the total number of persons whose incomes are less than $365 a year worldwide—those the World Bank calls the "absolute poor"—has not changed much since 1987. Considering the efforts made by governments and aid organizations, the stagnation of the very lowest incomes is disappointing and seems to indicate that no progress has been made in reducing poverty. However, since 1987 the population of the developing countries has increased by about one billion people. It follows that the number of persons living above the absolute poverty line has increased very substantially during the last 15 years; these persons either had never been among the "absolute poor" or had somehow succeeded in escaping absolute poverty. Examining how one billion people in the developing world stayed out of poverty or escaped it should teach us a lot about what is necessary to achieve large-scale poverty reduction. How do people manage to escape absolute poverty? Household surveys show that the answer, in large part, is found in each country's rate of overall economic growth. Recent research confirms beyond doubt that economic growth is a necessary condition for poverty reduction (Dollar and Kraay, 2001). The impact of national growth on the incomes of the poorest 20 percent of the population is about the same as it is on society as a whole. That is, a doubling of GDP over 25 years—annual growth of 2.9 percent—was found to be associated with a doubling of the poor's incomes. This robust finding is drawn from 80 countries over a period of 40 years. A sobering corollary of the analysis is that the distribution of income within these 80 countries, which is mostly highly skewed, has hardly changed in 40 years. The data also indicate that poor people do not suffer the biggest falls in income during economic crises and that openness to foreign trade benefits poor people as much as it does other economic groups, as do respect for the rule of law and fiscal discipline. Interestingly, the data suggest that curbing high inflation benefits the poor more than the rest of society. Furthermore, contrary to the view that the poor may have benefited from growth in the past but no longer do so in today's "globalized" world economy, the analysis shows that the positive relationship between growth and poverty reduction has not changed. Some of the events most closely related to economic improvement are finding a job, or a relative's finding a job, or moving to a better job. Indeed, job creation is a major—probably the major—path out of poverty. The most sustainable job creation is by firms, whether they are new, very small firms or larger enterprises expanding in a growing economy. In almost all developing countries, including China, private enterprises are the main source of new jobs. These include firms in all sectors of activity, large and small firms, domestic and foreign firms. Although government jobs also contribute to income mobility, attempts at deliberate job creation, whether by central governments or by state-owned enterprises, have nearly always been unsustainable. Public enterprises tend to lose money; eventually, many either collapse or become a drain on public resources.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › Green Tech Doesn’t Solve

Plan Doesn’t Solve: FJG cuts out private sector entirely

Malley and Moutos ’96 [Jim Malley is a Professor in Economics at the University of Glasgow. Thomas Moutos is Professor of Economics at the Athens University of Economics and Business and a CESifo Research Fellow. Malley, James R., and Thomas Moutos. “Introduction.” Does Government Employment “Crowd-out” Private Employment?: Evidence from Sweden, vol. 98, University of Glasgow, Department of Political Economy, Glasgow, 1996, pp. 289–291. ]

A common feature of most macroeconomic models is their treatment of government expenditure. It is usually assumed that changes in government expenditure have no direct effect on the labour market. But, in fact, a considerable proportion of government expenditure (for some OECD countries more than 50 per cent) goes for wages and salaries to govern- ment employees. Changes in government spending which take the form of increases in government employment will have a direct influence on the labour market. With an upward-sloping aggregate labour supply curve, aggregate employment and the real wage will increase but private employ- ment will fall as a result of an increase in government employment. The degree of crowding-out of private employment by government employ- ment will obviously depend on the slopes of both the aggregate labour demand and supply schedules. If labour supply is perfectly elastic with respect to the real wage, there will be no crowding-out. However, if labour supply is perfectly inelastic with respect to the real wage, then there will complete crowding-out of private employment by government employment.1 The crowding-out of private employment by government employment described in the above paragraph is similar to the crowding-out of private spending by government spending found in traditional macroeconomic models. Both depend on the effects of government actions on prices (i.e., the real wage and the real interest rate) which in turn affect private sector decisions. We term this type of crowding-out "indirect crowding-out". But obviously, increases in government employment can directly displace private employment (e.g., public utilities, railways, etc.). We term this "direct crowding-out". In this paper we contend that once both types of crowding-out are taken into consideration, increases in government employment can result in decreases in aggregate employment. In other words, the crowding-out can be more than complete. We illustrate this case by examining quarterly Swedish data for the period 1964-90. Our focus on Sweden is motivated by the fact that the growth of the public sector was an explicit objective of Swedish economic policy for four decades until the early 1980s; see Lundberg (1985). The growth of govern- ment employment during these years reflected the decision of successive socialist governments to enlarge the role of the public sector in the economy. Figure 1 reflects these developments by contrasting the evolu- tion of the share of government to total employment (less self-employed) since 1960 for Sweden, the United States and Japan. In 1960 the share of government employment to total employment was the same in Sweden and the U.S., and equal to about 15 per cent, whereas in Japan the share was approximately equal to 13 per cent in 1965.2 Although for the U.S. and Japan this share virtually remained constant for the next two decades, in Sweden it rose steadily to about 33 per cent at the end of 1990. On the basis of this we interpret the evolution of government employment in Sweden not as a result of irreversible "leaning-against-the-wind" policies, but as the popular desire of the electorate for "bigger government". In other words, we treat government employment as an exogenous variable. In Section IV, we present econometric evidence which supports this assertion.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › Green Tech Doesn’t Solve

Green technology leads to massive waste and pollution.

IER 21 [IER, non-profit organizations that research governmental regulations of global energy markets, July 22, 2021, Green Technologies Cause Massive Waste and Pollution, IER, https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/green-technologies-cause-massive-waste-and-pollution/]

Electric vehicle batteries, solar panels, and wind turbines result in a massive amount of waste and pollution. China is responsible for half of the total electric vehicles in the world—a number that is growing rapidly. About half of its retired batteries are not disposed in an environmentally sound way, causing significant waste and pollution problems detailed below. Batteries can be recycled but the cost is high, as it is with solar panels, which can contain hazardous materials. Most solar panels end up in landfills as do wind turbines, whose large blades are a major factor in their disposal. The United States does not have a policy for recycling these green technologies, which means that U.S. landfills can expect to see a massive increase in disposed materials from them as President Biden seeks to implement his net-zero carbon plan for all U.S. energy by 2050. China is a major market for electric vehicles. According to the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers, by the end of May 2021, the number of electric vehicles in China is estimated to be 5.8 million, accounting for about half of the total number in the world. Due to favorable incentives compared to petroleum vehicles, the number of electric vehicles in China increased 17 percent between 2014 and 2020, reaching 1.37 million. Accompanying the production and sale of new electric vehicles is the rapid development of the battery industry and the massive increase in retired batteries. The service life of new electric vehicle batteries is about 5 to 8 years, meaning batteries need to be recycled or disposed of in that time frame. In 2020, the cumulative retired batteries in China reached 200,000 tons (about 25-gigawatt hours) and is expected to increase to 780,000 tons (about 116-gigawatt hours) by 2025—a multiple of almost 4 in just 5 years. Over half of those retired batteries are not recycled properly and instead are sold to small factories at high prices, who are not expected to dispose of them in an environmentally sound fashion. According to Professor Wu Feng at Beijing Institute of Technology, “A 20-gram cell phone battery can pollute three standard swimming pools of water, and if abandoned on the land, can pollute 1 square kilometer of land for about 50 years.” Compared to cell phone batteries, the pollution caused by the batteries of electric vehicles is far greater. Electric vehicle batteries contain cobalt, manganese, and nickel, which do not degrade on their own. Manganese, for example, pollutes the air, water, and soil, and more than 500 micrograms per cubic meter in the air can cause manganese poisoning. Another major source of pollution in lithium-ion batteries is the electrolyte. The lithium hexafluorophosphate in the electrolyte is hydrolyzed in the air to produce phosphorus pentafluoride, hydrogen fluoride, and other harmful substances, which is a major threat to soil and water resources. Phosphorus pentafluoride is a strong irritant to human skin, eyes, and mucous membranes, and is also a very reactive compound that hydrolyzes in humid air to produce toxic and corrosive white fumes of hydrogen fluoride. Li Yongwang, general manager of Synfuels China, indicated that the batteries of electric vehicles are likely to cause far more pollution than the exhaust pollution of petroleum vehicles because exhaust pollution can be controlled, while the cost of recycling electric vehicles is high and difficult. Once the total volume of electric vehicles reaches 10 percent of the total number of vehicles, major pollution problems are expected to be encountered. If the batteries are not properly handled during the recycling, dismantling, and processing stages, fires, explosions, heavy metal pollution, and organic emissions can result. In 2020, the cumulative installed capacity of batteries in China reached 63.6-gigawatt hours, up 2.3 percent. According to Everbright Securities, from 2020 to 2060, the cumulative demand for lithium batteries will reach 25 terawatt-hours. Since 1-gigawatt hour of battery corresponds to 600 tons of lithium carbonate, the demand for lithium carbonate is expected to reach 15 million tons. Disposal of electric vehicle batteries is a major problem and not all countries have adequately dealt with the problem, including the United States. Similar to electric vehicle batteries, the cost of solar panel recycling is high, resulting in solar panels ending up in landfills. It costs an estimated $20 to $30 to recycle one solar panel, which compares to a cost of $1 to $2 for sending that same panel to a landfill. Solar panels are mostly made of glass, which has low value as a recycled material, but they also have small amounts of silicon, silver, and copper as well as heavy metals (cadmium, lead, etc.) that some governments classify as hazardous waste. Hazardous waste can only be transported at designated times and via select routes. Because solar panels are delicate and bulky, specialized labor is required to detach and remove them to avoid their shattering and polluting local areas. The International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA)’s official projections claim that “large amounts of annual waste are anticipated by the early 2030s” and could total 78 million metric tons by 2050 based mostly on a 30-year life cycle for the solar panels. According to the Harvard Business Review, the volume of solar waste is expected to surpass that of new installations by 2031. By 2035, discarded solar panels could outweigh new units sold by 2.56 times, increasing the levelized cost of solar energy, a measure of the overall cost of an energy-producing asset over its lifetime. According to the Harvard Business Review, the levelized cost of solar could be four times the current projection when solar waste is factored into the calculation. The U.S. government does not have a PV recycling policy and as such most solar waste ends up in landfills after cables and aluminum frames are removed. States have not been addressing the problem adequately, either. First Solar is the only U.S. solar panel manufacturer that has a recycling program, which applies only to its own products. The company has a global capacity of two million panels per year. Decommissioning wind turbines includes the removal of all physical material and equipment related to the project to a depth of about 48 inches. Most of the concrete foundations used to anchor the wind turbines, however, are as deep as 15 feet. The concrete bases are hard to fully remove, and the rotor blades contain glass and carbon fibers that give off dust and toxic gases. While most (90 percent) of a turbine can be recycled or be sold to a wind farm in Asia or Africa, researchers estimate the United States will have more than 720,000 tons of blade material to dispose of over the next 20 years, a figure that does not include newer, taller higher-capacity wind turbines. Wind turbine blades are made of a tough but pliable mix of resin and fiberglass—similar to what spaceship parts are made from. Decommissioned blades are difficult and expensive to transport. They can be anywhere from 100 to 300 feet long and must be cut up on-site before getting trucked away on specialized equipment to a landfill that may not have the capacity for the blades. Landfills that do have the capacity may not have equipment large enough to crush them. One such landfill cuts the blades into three pieces and stuffs the two smaller sections into the third, which is cheaper than renting stronger crushing machines. In Minnesota, Xcel Energy estimates conservatively that it will cost $532,000 (in 2019 dollars) to decommission each of its wind turbines—a total cost of $71 million to decommission the 134 turbines in operation at its Noble facility. Decommissioning the Palmer’s Creek Wind facility in Chippewa County, Minnesota, is estimated to cost $7,385,822 for decommissioning the 18 wind turbines operating at that site, for a cost of $410,000 per turbine. Few countries have dealt with policies for decommissioning green technologies.Including the cost of recycling can increase the lifetime cost of a green technology substantially as the Harvard Business Review concluded for solar panels. If the cost of electricity is four times its current estimate as the Harvard Business Review suggests, Americans should know that before the nation plunges head-long into deploying it as a principal source of energy. If President Biden is serious about his net-zero carbon plans first for the generating sector and then for the entire U.S. energy system, he needs to address the waste and pollution problems resulting from these technologies or the United States will be faced with overflowing landfills and taxpayers will be paying billions and maybe trillions to fix the problem. In order for these technologies to live up to their proponents’ claims of their environmental cleanliness, policymakers should not continue to ignore this looming and real environmental problem. It appears, however, that in his quest to move towards “green energy,” it may be easier for Biden to spend the federal government’s money resulting in hidden future costs that the American taxpayer will have to foot rather than confront the problem.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Green New Deal Neg 23 › Case › Dirigisme Approach Fails

A dirigisme approach to the economy fails.

Thorington 16 [C.B. Thorington, retired physicist that is interested with economics and politics, December 19 2016, Dirigisme No Longer Works. What Replaces It?, Adividedworld, https://www.adividedworld.com/economic-ideas/dirigisme-no-longer-works-what-replaces-it/.]

Actually, dirigisme as a way of ruling a country has never really worked. Dirigisme, the philosophy that a country’s elites should rule a country though technocratic expertise, was just never applied with sufficient force to screw up the works. Not at least in Western countries until relatively recently. The Soviet Union was the first really huge example of how badly state control of the economy wrecked its functioning. For a very long time — at least since the Great Depression in the 1930s — Americans have persuaded themselves that government interventions in the economy could actually solve economic problems they believed inherent to capitalism. At the time of the depression’s onset, a common view of its cause was “cut-throat competition” between companies believed to be built-in to free-markets. This view motivated President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s administration to institute the National Recovery Administration (NRA) to mitigate this ferocious capitalist competition by bringing together industry, labor, and government. They were then expected to set codes for “fair practices”, as well as to set prices. There seemed to be no appreciation for how the disabling of Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand could actually prolong the depression. Dirigisme’s siren song was especially sweet to academic and political elites. It sang about the special power and status (not to mention the increased riches that would accompany them!) they would enjoy as the only ones with the requisite knowledge and understanding to rule society. From their point of view, the masses of common people had neither the education nor the wisdom to rule themselves. This is a fundamental attitude that almost defines progressivism, which depends on technocratic elites to ensure the general welfare. Progressives’ view of reality during the Great Depression soon caused them to seize a second explanation to add to the first. The economist John Maynard Keynes taught his academic peers that free-market institutions together with fear of the economic future were motivating many people to save too much money, depressing demand for the economy’s output. His solution to this problem was to substitute government demand for the lost market demand, requiring government to direct and allocate capital flows. How could any politician with a thirst for power not respond positively to such a siren song? It took a very long time after the Great Depression for neoclassical doubts to begin a substantive challenge to the Keynesian and dirigiste consensus. In 1963 the economist Milton Friedman and his colleague Anna Schwartz published an extremely seminal work that offered yet another explanation for the Great Depression that would eventually displace previous explanations as the primary cause. Entitled A Monetary History of the United States, 1867-1960, the book placed primary blame not on the free-market, but on the failures of an agency of the federal government, the Federal Reserve. Beginning in 1928 the Federal Reserve switched from a quantity of money theory of price stability to a real bills doctrine (see here and here) that required material goods to back all money creation. Concerning the real bills doctrine, Friedman and Schwartz wrote The foregoing fallacy survives today in the notion that the Federal Reserve should use easy monetary policy to lower interest rates to target levels consistent with full employment. For just as the real bills doctrine calls for expanding the money stock with rises in the needs of trade, so does the interest targeting proposal call for increasing the money supply when the market rate of interest rises above its target level-this monetary expansion continuing until the rate disparity is eliminated. The problem with the real bills doctrine as Friedman and Schwartz see it is that under it there are no limits to the quantity of money. Whatever amount of money a banker is willing to lend to produce new goods is justified under the doctrine. Also, the doctrine can be construed to mean that as the overall demand for goods falls, then so should the money supply. This is exactly what happened after 1928. According to Friedman and Schwartz, the money supply dropped by about one-third between 1929 and 1933. The lack of liquidity caused many businesses to default on their debts, making them and the banks to whom they owed the debt bankrupt, thereby causing the banking system to collapse in 1932. Another sign that something was going very, very wrong with neo-Keynesian thought, the brand of Keynesianism current at the time, was the stagflation of the 1970s, a simultaneous occurrence of economic stagnation with general price inflation. Neo-Keynesians declared that stagflation could not possibly happen because of what their Phillips Curve predicted. In their view economic growth strong enough to cause price inflation would inevitably lower unemployment. The Phillips curve then showed an inverse relationship between inflation and the unemployment rate: when one rose, the other fell. The famed monetarist Milton Friedman and independently Edmund Phelps together explained stagflation in terms of monetarist ideas about inflationary expectations. The neo-Keynesians soon incorporated their criticisms into their own theories, along with responses to other New Classical criticisms, and in the process became the New Keynesians. However the contradictions between the predictions of New Keynesians and actual reality began to accumulate as governments’ share of the GDP inexorably increased. Back in 1960 the expenditures of American governments at all levels — local, state, and federal — absorbed 26.5% of GDP, rose to a plateau of around 34% during the administrations of Reagan and Bush the Elder, then peaked at 35.4% during Clinton’s administration in 1992. Total expenditures then fell under the influence of welfare reform and cutbacks in defense spending to 30% in 2000. Following that, total government spending grew to around 32.5% of GDP during the regime of Bush the Younger. As a Keynesian response to the Great Recession during the Obama administration, the expenditures reached a peak of 39.3% in 2009-2010. Since then expenditures have fallen due to fiscal sequestration and Republican resistance back to 33.7%. Despite these heroic Keynesian efforts to stimulate the economy from 2009 to the present, they achieved very little as can be seen in the graph below. Throughout the Obama era, the real GDP growth has fluctuated around a two percent growth rate; over the past four quarters (Q4 2015 through Q3 2016), it has averaged 1.57%. The economy did technically recover from recession, but our growth rate right now is approximately half of what is considered to be our long term average. From 1948 to 2007, U.S. GDP growth averaged 3.41% per year. On the other hand, if you were to calculate a 10-year moving average of GDP growth, as the Gallup organization recently did, you would average over the short-term of recessions and booms to isolate the truly long-term trends. In performing this calculation from 1966 to 2016, Gallup found the really long-term trend of economic growth to be decreasing approximately 0.4% per decade. Gallup attributed this very long-term decline primarily to the destructive effects of the dirigiste state’s economic regulations. In Europe and Japan, the results of Keynesian stimulus programs, both monetary and fiscal, have been similarly dismal. The annualized EU growth in the third quarter of 2016 over the the same quarter in 2015 was 1.9% and has been the same for the past three quarters. The similar statistic for Japan was 0.3% for the third quarter of 2016 and has been declining for the past three quarters. These extremely bad results of the dirigiste state throughout the West and Japan have not totally escaped the notice of at least some of the academic economic elite, mostly Keynesian economists. Inspired by Larry Summers, they are attempting to explain our current economic stagnation in terms of a very old Keynesian doctrine called secular stagnation. There is absolutely no doubt we are in a period of economic stagnation, and that it is secular (i.e. long-term and not tied to the business cycle). The only problem in what they are doing is that they are looking for the causes of the stagnation in all the wrong places. They assume the causes lie in market failures of free-markets, rather than the government failures Gallup discovered in explaining the plot above. Nevertheless, Summer’s group of Keynesian economists at least acknowledge there is something very wrong with the advice given by Keynesian economists to governments around the world. If this stagnation continues under dirigiste policies, can there be any doubt that other dirigiste academics will begin to question their ideological faith?