Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

Applying a separate set of laws to the territories exemplifies racist, colonialist mindsets – reject territorial exceptionalism that reproduces the violence of imperialism.

Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

This self-conception is directly at odds with the notion of the United States as a twenty-first century colonial empire that openly discriminates against millions of its own citizens. That may explain the lack of public consciousness on the U.S. mainland that the territories are twenty-first century colonies. As Roberto Ariel Fernandez notes, there is "the need for realism in studies of law and society, particularly in the context of United States domination over Puerto Rico."190 So why is there a stark disconnect between the United States's self-conception and its treatment of the territories?

[*1753] A. Invisible Empire: U.S. Colonialism and Inequality Thrive amid U.S. Narratives of Sovereignty, Self-Determination, and Racial Progress

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

That precedent enshrines separate and unequal treatment on the basis of locality.

Santana 23 [Willie Santana is a Visiting Assistant Professor of Law at Lincoln Memorial University’s Duncan School of Law where he teaches legal writing, criminal practice skills and constitutional law.; “The New Insular Cases”; William & Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice; Volume 29, Issue 2; January 2023; https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1599&context=wmjowl]//eleanor

The damage that the Insular Cases inflict upon American notions of equal treatment and protection of the laws is pervasive.245 Disparate treatment of Americans in the territories continues in various fronts.246 For instance, Congress treats each territory in different ways when it comes to federal safety-net programs.247 Such classifications, ostensibly based on locality, are only required to satisfy rational basis review.248

In United States v. Vaello Madero, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether Puerto Rico’s exclusion from the Supplemental Security Income program violated the equal protection guarantees of the Fifth Amendment.249 The First Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously ruled that the program discriminated against people in the island without an adequate rational basis.250 The facts of the case

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

The plan affirms the first circuit’s decision which eliminates second-class citizenship for territorial residents. Racist precedents are NOT immutable.

Torres-Rios 22 [Nelson Torres-Ríos, J.D. 2011, Rutgers Law School, is an Attorney admitted in New York, New Jersey, and the United States Supreme Court. He is also an Assistant Professor at Hostos Community College in the Bronx.; “ARTICLE: RACIAL BARRIERS TO EQUAL PROTECTION: UNITED STATES V. VAELLO MADERO”; Rutgers Law Record, 49, 102.; 2022; Lexis]//eleanor

The federal government's argument is premised on misleading information that island residents do not make contributions to the federal treasury. Specifically, the government claims the following to exclude Puerto Rico from SSI benefits: Puerto Rico's unique tax status and the cost of extending the program to residents of Puerto Rico. The government also relied on Califano and Harris as binding precedent. Note however, that Califano did not rule on the validity of Puerto Rico's exclusion under the equal protection clause but instead ruled on the issue of the right to travel. Harris was a class action suit regarding the Aid to Families with Dependent Children, a different federal program. 73

Puerto Rico, despite its economic challenges and colonial status, makes significant contributions to the federal treasury. Judge Torruella of the First Circuit explained that Puerto Ricans have consistently made higher contributions than taxpayers in at least six states, averaging about $ 3.5 billion despite a recession and catastrophic natural events. 74These payments include federal income tax on income from sources outside of Puerto Rico, federal income taxes by all federal employees on the island, and full Social Security, Medicare, and Unemployment Compensation taxes that are paid throughout the United States. 75Despite making these payments, Puerto Rico is severely underfunded in many federal programs, including Medicare, despite having a population that exceeds many states. 76These findings are significant, and contradict the court's economic analysis in Califano and Harris. More importantly, the First Circuit took aim at the fiscal argument by the government explaining that "cost alone" could not provide a rational basis. 77

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

The Insular Cases are widely regarded as bad and racist precedent, but courts continue to rely on them – that denies equal protection for millions of Americas.

Ciolli 23 [Anthony M. Ciolli, Practicing Faculty, St. Mary's University School of Law; past President, Virgin Islands Bar Association; Special Assistant to the Hon. Rhys S. Hodge, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands.; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: JUDICIAL ANTIFEDERALISM”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

The United States has a colonies problem. The more than 3.5 million Americans who live in the U.S. territories of American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands lack some of the most fundamental rights and protections, such as the right to vote.1 This deprivation is due to a series of decisions decided more than a century ago, collectively known as the Insular Cases.2 In these cases, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the "half-civilized,"3 "savage,"4 "alien races"5 that inhabited America's overseas territories were not entitled to the same constitutional rights and protections afforded to Americans residing in the mainland United States, based on the idea of the white man's burden and similar, then prevalent theories of white supremacy.

For decades, the Insular Cases have had "nary a friend in the world,"6 with even the Supreme Court repeatedly imploring that they "should not be further extended."7 Justice Gorsuch recently acknowledged:

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

Courts rely on the Insular cases to maintain racial discrimination that puts territorial residents in a perpetual state of limbo through a double move that denies territories BOTH sovereignty AND equal rights. Vaello doubled down by rendering the rational basis test functionally meaningless as applied to territories.

Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

Justice Sotomayor's dissent also shows the bankruptcy of the majority's "rational basis" rationale. The majority decision not only reinforced second-class citizenship for residents of Puerto Rico, but also weakened equal protection under the Fifth Amendment by rendering the rational basis standard almost meaningless in this context.

Justice Sotomayor's dissent concluded by getting to the heart of the matter when it comes to territorial status: "The Constitution permits Congress to 'make all needful Rules and Regulations' respecting the Territories. That constitutional command does not permit Congress to ignore the equally [*1740] weighty constitutional command that it treat United States citizens equally."90

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

In Vaello, the court applied the rational basis test rather than strict scrutiny, a higher standard of review used for discrimination against “suspect classes” – that ruling willfully ignores the history of racial discrimination against territorial residents.

Fergus-Callahan, 23 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://irp.cdn-website.com/8c66f319/files/uploaded/Fergus_United%20States%20v.%20Vaello-Madero-d4cfc6a8.pdf)//EG

1. Territorial Residents Have Been Subjected to a History of Purposeful Unequal Treatment. The Court applies strict scrutiny to laws that discriminate against a group that it considers a suspect class, for example a group that has experienced "a history of purposeful unequal treatment. *lo Notably, classifications made on the basis of race or national origin are always regarded as suspect and are always subjected to strict scrutiny by the Court. 18 Because even a cursory examination of the treatment of the territories by the federal government reveals persistent discrimination empowered by a series of racist Supreme Court decisions, territorial residency should necessitate strict scrutiny application. Prior to the Spanish-American War, territory acquired by the United States followed a pattern established by the Northwest Ordinance wherein the new possession was subjected to federal plenary control before it was ultimately granted statehood. 169 The assumption, importantly, was always that the first stage-under which the annexed territory was subject to federal plenary control-was temporary. 17 Accordingly, territories were "to be regarded as inchoate States. "71 Given America's revolutionary history and its constitutional commitment to representative democracy, and given Supreme Court precedent condemning the idea that possessions not destined for statehood could be established by the federal government, many believed that any other arrangement would be "contrary to the spirit of the Constitution. " 172 However, when the United States acquired Puerto Rico, this belief became inconvenient. The American appetite for empire was growing, 7 but so was a concern that annexing island territories into the national polity would «darken" the American frontier. 17 White Americans influenced by the concept of manifest destiny had been instilled with the belief both that they were inherently superior to other races and ethnic groups and that those other peoples were "destined" to be ruled by them.** Therefore, Puerto Rico's population, "composed of a mixture of Negro, Indian, and Spanish ancestryL.1' not only "rendered the island incapable of independent self-government," but also rendered it unfit for integration into the Union. 176 The majority opinion in Downes, authored by Justice Brown, was very cognizant of this perceived threat to American citizenship.17 It expressed concern over "extremely serious" consequences if "savages" were "entitled to all the rights privileges and immunities of citizens" immediately upon annexation.* It alluded to «grave questions" it considered unique to the acquisition of Puerto Rico due to "differences of race, habits, laws and customs of the people.™* In its conclusion, it reiterated the fear that governance "according to Anglo-Saxon principles" in possessions «inhabited by alien races, differing from us in religion, customs, laws, methods of taxation and modes of thought" might be "impossible. "180 Justice White's concurrence likewise expressed concern that the "evil of immediate incorporation" lay in the possibility of extending rights to "millions of inhabitants of alien territory" who could overthrow "the whole structure of the government. " Is That tension between the desire to expand the American empire and the reluctance to admit non-Anglo-Saxon peoples as American citizens was the driving force behind the Court's invention and adaptation of the doctrine of incorporation. 182 Faced with a choice between " incorporating into the United States people racially and ethnically different from Anglo-Saxon Americans" and relinquishing the "spoils" of the war, the Court manifested a third option. 183 It "simply invented, out of whole cloth," the doctrine of territorial incorporation, and, in so doing, made possible the indefinite possession of territories with no guarantee that they would ever become states. 184 This "racially motivated imperialist legal doctrine gave sanction to indefinite colonial rule over majority-nonwhite populations at the margins of the American empire. * The Insular Cases, byproducts of this overtly racist line of thought, resulted in what would be two centuries of purposeful, unequal treatment of the territories by Congress. As prominent legal scholars argue, the placement of residents of Puerto Rico "outside the polity" in Downes create a "second-class, 'subordinated' citizenship" for territorial Americans. 18 As a result, the Supreme Court has permitted the United States to foster economic dependence in the territories unaccompanied by the full spectrum of federal welfare benefits afforded to United States citizens living in the states. 187 Residents of the territories are often excluded from federal benefits programs altogether; when they are included, the programs are often funded at lower rates than identical programs available in the states. 18 For example, Medicaid programs in the territories are reimbursed there at lower rates than identical programs in the states; food assistance, which is not capped in the states, is capped in some of the territories; and SSI benefits, which extend to all U.S. citizens in the states, do not extend to all U.S. citizens in the territories, as illustrated by Vaello-Madero. 189 Additionally, the possession of the territories, largely consisting of strategically located insular areas, has enabled the United States to project "global hegemonic power" in a way that is unique to these areas. 9° To fully reap this benefit, it has established an enduring military presence in the territories 91 which has often resulted in "economic changes, environmental degradation, and local, everyday violences^ against residents. #19 For example, the United States Navy has used the Puerto Rican island of Vieques for six decades to conduct training exercises which included live-fire bombing tests. 19 As a result, it is now one of the most "complicated (and expensive" Superfund sites in the United States, and the contamination left by the bombings is accompanied by heightened cancer rates among the island's residents. 191 In Vaello-Madero, the Government argued that the discrimination at issue, the exclusion of Puerto Rico from SSI benefits, is purely location-based; the Court, by ruling for the Government, adopted that position as well."* That distinction, however, is a legal fiction. It willfully ignores the fact that the Insular Cases, a series of decisions that has been "repeatedly excoriated as suspect and racist, made the indefinite discriminatory treatment of Puerto Rico residents possible in the first place.1% In his concurrence in Vaello-Madero, Justice Gorsuch echoed that opinion, decrying the Insular Cases as "shameful? and tacitly acknowledging that they authorize the government to discriminate based on ethnicity, race, and religion. IT It is also important to note that 99% of the residents of Puerto Rico identify as Hispanic or Latino. * Thus, not only is the reasoning behind the discriminatory treatment of residents of Puerto Rico ethnically motivated, but the practical effect of the "location-based" discrimination at issue burdens a historically disadvantaged minority. 199 Because the federal government has historically discriminated against the territories by burdening the area for military purposes and excluding or partially excluding them from federal benefits programs, and because the Insular Cases have authorized this disparate treatment on racially and ethnically discriminatory grounds, territorial residence should be considered a "suspect classification" entitled to strict scrutiny review.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

Poverty causes disparities in education, health, and standards of living.

Roballo 17

(Lorial Roballo. An Aftercare Case Manager at a social services non-profit in their Safe Harbor division. “10 FACTS ABOUT POVERTY IN PUERTO RICO.” The Borgen Project. November 13 2017.https://borgenproject.org/10-facts-poverty-puerto-rico/#:~:text=43.5%20percent%20of%20Puerto%20Ricans,for%20a%20family%20of%20four.)//PWD

Puerto Rico, also known as the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, is a self-governing organized territory of the United States of America. This means that Puerto Ricans are citizens of the U.S. Approximately 3.3 million people live on the island but, due to rising problems, a larger mass exodus is occurring than in the 1950s. Here are 10 facts about poverty in Puerto Rico.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

Extending federal benefits solves – SSI, SNAP, and Medicare benefits would alleviate poverty and improve disaster reslience.

Ocasio, 21 – Evette Ocasio is a graduate of DePaul University College of Law and is currently litigation counsel for ARDC (Evette Ocasio, "Puerto Rico's Second-Class Statehood: The Impact of Puerto Rico's Restricted Access to Federal Public Benefits Programs on Puerto Rico's Economic Recovery," DePaul Journal for Social Justice 15, no. 1 (Winter 2021 - Spring 2022): [192]-[219] )//EG

Often forgotten on the mainland, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is the largest United States territory and home to over 3.1 million residents.1 Although residents of Puerto Rico have enjoyed naturalized U.S. citizenship for over 100 years,2 the federal government has yet to grant them equal treatment. Puerto Rico's residents cannot vote in federal elections, nor do they have representation in Congress.3 The federal government also limits, and in some cases entirely precludes, funding allotments to Puerto Rico for many federal public benefits programs that make up the U.S. "social safety net." 4 These programs, such as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), are essential to those with low incomes, the elderly, individuals with disabilities, and families with dependent children.5 Puerto Rico has faced over a decade of economic downturn. It has high poverty and unemployment rates and low labor participation rates. Puerto Rico has been marred by public debt, political corruption, mismanagement, national disasters, and inadequate federal assistance. The U.S. entered the Great Recession in December 2007 and recovered by June 2009.6 In contrast, Puerto Rico's recession began in 2006 but never fully ended.7 By 2016, the island's $72 billion debt crisis led the federal government to establish The Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico (Oversight Board), to manage the restructuring of Puerto Rico's debt and fiscal planning.' In September 2017, the island was devastated by Hurricanes Irma and Maria, which wiped out the island's electric grid, washed out roadways and bridges, and damaged buildings and residences. 9 The damage to the power grid from Hurricane Maria led to the largest blackout in U.S. history and the second largest in the world.10 Specifically, Puerto Ricans were left without electricity in the midst of the Caribbean heat, causing already limited food to spoil, water pumps to fail, and medical equipment, such as dialysis machines, to be unusable." Power was finally restored to the whole island after 328 days, but the infrastructure remains vulnerable to this day.12 Hurricane Maria wiped out 80% of the crop value in Puerto Rico, leading to an estimated $780 million loss in agriculture yields.13 The Hurricane's devastation also triggered increased outmigration from Puerto Rico to the mainland U.S., creating lasting effects on the island's ability to recover that are felt today.14 In 2018 alone, approximately 133,500 Puerto Rican residents left the island, up 36.9% from 2017.15 In short, the economic downturn in Puerto Rico has been exacerbated by natural disasters. Many of the island's residents need government assistance. Even as Americans, Puerto Rican residents are excluded from federal programs created for Americans in need: Supplemental Security Income (SSI), SNAP, and Medicare Part D Low-Income Subsidy (LIS). 16 On April 10, 2020, the First Circuit held that the categorical exclusion of otherwise eligible Puerto Rican residents from SSI violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fifth Amendment, finding eligibility based on the differentiation in status not to be rationally related to a legitimate government interest. 17 The ruling in Vaello-Madero guided much of the District Court of Puerto Rico's analysis in Martinez, which looked not only at Puerto Rico's access to SSI, but also its access to SNAP and Medicare Part DLIS benefits.18 In Pena-Martinez,the Court held it was unconstitutional discrimination to deny eligible residents of Puerto Rico access to SSI, SNAP, and LIS benefits solely due to their residency in Puerto Rico. 19 The District Court declared, "[T]o be blunt, the federal government discriminates against Americans who live in Puerto Rico."20 While both decisions are major victories for Puerto Rican residents, the U.S. government's appeals in Vaello-Madero and Pena-Martinezare pending before the U.S. Supreme Court and the First Circuit, respectively. Although restricted access to federal benefits is not the root cause of economic disparity on the island, it has exacerbated the conditions of poverty and hindered its economic recovery. If Puerto Rico is granted the same access to federal funding and federal public benefit programs as states in the mainland are, there would be improved disaster planning, a quicker response for disaster relief, and an increase in economic assistance and work training resources that could bring Puerto Rican residents out of poverty. This paper examines the limited access Puerto Rico's residents have to federal benefits such as SNAP, SSI, and Federal Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) to determine how these limitations have exacerbated the high poverty rate in Puerto Rico and impacted post- Hurricane Maria relief efforts on the island. Part II briefly discusses the poverty statistics in Puerto Rico pre- and post- Hurricane Maria. Next, Part III identifies the differences between federal public benefits programs implemented in Puerto Rico and the contiguous U.S. Finally, Part IV analyzes how implementing SNAP, Federal EITC, or statehood would improve the economic recovery of the island.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

Political subordination and lack of any federal representation curtails relief efforts.

Fergus-Callahan, 23 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://www.denverlawreview.org/united-states-v-vaello-madero-a-shameful-failure-to-protect-needy-american-citizens-living-in-the-u-s-territories)//EG

2. Territorial Residents Are Powerless to Protect Themselves from the Majoritarian Political Process. The principle that legislation burdening disenfranchised groups is entitled to strict scrutiny arises from Justice Harlan Fiske Stone's footnote in United States v. Carolene Products. 200 "Footnote four's" focus on "political processes which can ordinarily be expected to bring about repeal of undesirable legislation" which can "ordinarily be relied upon to protect minorities" laid the foundation for the Court in subsequent cases to "trigger" strict scrutiny when the challenged classification burdens a group without political protection. 21 Although the Court ordinarily accords a "heavy presumption of constitutionality" to legislative enactments made by "a coequal and representative branch of. . Government, " that presumption must be questioned if the enactment burdens a group that is not adequately represented 202 Residents of Puerto Rico, despite heir statutory U.S. citizenship, cannot vote in Presidential elections. 203 Their representation in Congress is limited to one non-voting Resident Commissioner, who "is constrained to a role akin to that of a lobbyist. "2 Puerto Rico is "self-governed" in that its people can choose a governor and establish a constitution, but Congress retains plenary authority to revoke this power at any time. 205 Congress could likewise revoke Puerto Ricans' United States citizenship. 206 The "indefinite political subordination" of residents of Puerto Rico, sanctioned by the Supreme Court in the Insular Cases, leaves them defenseless against discriminatory legislation, a status that is not only problematic, but also constitutionally suspect. *27 It should therefore obligate the Court to employ strict scrutiny when evaluating classifications that burden territorial residents. Nowhere is the effect of Puerto Rico's political powerlessness more dramatically illustrated than in the disaster relief context. As an island territory, Puerto Rico is on the front line of the climate crisis.208 Residents of Puerto Rico *disproportionately experience sea level rise, extreme temperatures, intense tropical storms, and the resulting damage to ecosystems, health, culture, and infrastructure," despite contributing very little to greenhouse gas emissions. 209 In 2017 alone, the island was devastated by two Category 4 hurricanes, Hurricane Irma and Hurricane Maria. I Hurricane Maria, a "near-Category 5" storm that struck within weeks of Hurricane Irma, left almost 3,000 dead and decimated the island's agriculture and aging power infrastructure.? In the aftermath of the storm, the island lost power for almost two months, and intermittent outages continued for six months after that.21? Residents lacked potable water, fuel, and food supplies.? In September 2022, six years after Hurricane Maria's landfall, the flooding and rainfall from Hurricane Fiona again left the island's residents powerless and without potable water.?" The federal government's actions in the aftermath of the 2017 storms laid bare the enduring effects of Puerto Rico's political powerlessness. For example, the federal government triggers the disaster response component of welfare assistance, designed to offer local governments additional flexibility and funds to cope with disasters like tropical storms, only after the President declares a "major disaster" or "emergency" exists in the area requesting aid.?$ As a result, only a President that Puerto Rico residents did not and could not vote for can authorize Puerto Rico's disaster relief funds.216 Once a "major disaster" is declared, the President instructs federal agencies, including the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), to "support . .. local efforts in whatever was authorized by federal law. »217 When, however, FEMA is responding to multiple disasters at once, "extra political pressure and impetus can make a difference" in how the agency prioritizes aid recipients.? Puerto Rico's one non-voting member of Congress lacks the political ammo necessary to ensure aid is delivered in an equitable and timely manner, and it likewise lacks the bargaining power necessary to lobby for an aid package from Congress.29 In this way, Puerto Rico's indefinite disenfranchisement leaves it "shut out from agenda-setting, determining funding and policy priorities, and opportunities to sit at the decision-making table. *22 Disaster relief access is just one example of the way Puerto Rico's political powerlessness plays out in the legislative setting and accordingly why the Court should treat classifications burdening this disenfranchised group with strict scrutiny. As one commenter points out, an additional argument in support of this contention is "the role the judiciary has played in the entrenchment of Puerto Rico's 'political vacuum.'*# He points out that "the indefinite reaffirmation of Congress's plenary power over the island" stated by the Court in Harris and Califano "raises concerns when combined with Supreme Court statements regarding the "temporary' character of the arrangement made possible by the Insular Cases and the territorial incorporation doctrine. " If the Court "created an intermediate step on the divergent roads to statehood or independence . under the presumption that Congress would revisit the matter at a later date," Congress's failure to do so while continuing to pass discriminatory legislation should be viewed with suspicion.? This suspicion should necessitate the application of strict scrutiny.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

That creates health and standard of living disparities.

Previdi & Velez Vega, 20 [Irene Lafarga Previdi, community engagement coordinator at the center for collaborative research in health disparities, Carmen Velez Vega, PhD from the University of Puerto Rico, chair of the social sciences department at University of Puerto Rico, 11-18-20 ‘Health Disparities research Framework Adaption to Reflect Puerto Rico’s Socio-Cultural Context’, file:///C:/Users/lundi/Downloads/ijerph-17-08544.pdf //alundy]

Another legal aspect that impacts the quality of life of Puerto Ricans is federal transfer payments. These are divided into two categories, earned benefits such as Medicaid, Social Security and veterans’ pensions and direct aid such as nutritional assistance and grants [36]. In 2019, most of the transfer payments to individuals were earned benefits and not welfare related [40]. However, federal transfers to individuals in Puerto Rico are arbitrarily capped at levels below those of the states in U.S. [36]. This does not take into account the population levels or the need for these kinds of services but instead is a form of selective discrimination based on the fact that the archipelago is an unincorporated territory and not a state. If Puerto Rico were treated as a state, federal transfer programs for health, i.e., Medicaid and nutrition, i.e., Women, Infants and Children (WIC) Nutrition Program would be substantially greater. However, the fact is that Puerto Rico receives fewer U.S. federal dollars to Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, 8544 7 of 11 assist with social programs than states with comparable populations [10]. This has, as a consequence, meant that people living in Puerto Rico have limited access to social support measures that could help to improve living conditions and thus their overall health. Puerto Ricans are being treated as second-class citizens due to the unequal treatment of the U.S. government through federal regulations, which are implemented arbitrarily without any consultation or participation from Puerto Ricans. These federal regulations influence the living conditions of Puerto Ricans at individual, interpersonal, community and societal levels (see Table 1). This has an impact on health outcomes and the quality of life, for example, higher costs for basic needs including healthcare and food due to cabotage regulations. This also can be understood through the concept of embodiment, which refers to “how we, like any living organism, literally incorporate, biologically, the world in which we live, including our societal and ecological circumstances” [41] (p. 351). This construct takes into consideration the fact that humans are social beings as well as biological beings, which means that in order to understand health disparities we must understand the living conditions of individuals and communities. For example, factors such as food insecurity and food deserts, deficient infrastructure (i.e., electricity, potable water, public transportation, internet access), economic and social deprivation, toxic environmental exposures, lack of access to adequate healthcare and poor job conditions all leave a physical mark on the body of individuals, communities and societies. This tells us that “it is no accident that from population patterns of health, disease, and wellbeing it is possible to discern the contours and distribution of power, property, and technology within and across nations, over time” [41] (p. 350).

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

Lack of social safety nets exacerbate poverty in the territories.

Racine and Camacho 21 [Karl A. Racine is the attorney general for Washington, D.C. Leevin T. Camacho is the attorney general for Guam; “Dear Supreme Court: 3.5 million Americans in territories deserve same federal benefits”; USA Today; November 9, 2021; https://oag.dc.gov/release/op-ed-dear-scotus-35-million-americans-territories]//eleanor

What do American citizens living in Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa all have in common? They lack equal access to federal social safety net programs, like Supplemental Security Income and food stamps that lift families and children out of poverty.

By now, you’re thinking that there must be a good explanation for why 3.5 million American citizens – 98% of whom are ethnic minorities – are excluded from these benefits.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

Denial of social security services to US territories creates poverty and low living standards – climate disasters magnify deprivation.

Hammond 21 [Andrew Hammond, Assistant Professor of Law, University of Florida Fredric G. Levin College of Law; “Territorial Exceptionalism and the American Welfare State”; Michigan Law Review; 2021; https://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/mlr119&div=59&g_sent=1&casa_token=&collection=journals]//eleanor

Vaello-Madero's exclusion from public benefits epitomizes the extent to which federal law places millions of Americans outside the welfare state. Federal law excludes these American citizens from crucial public benefits simply because they live in the U.S. territories. For instance, Puerto Rico, the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), and American Samoa are excluded from SNAP (food stamps). Instead, these three territories receive block grants for food assistance, which do not respond to a surge in increased need.9 That's why, after Hurricane Maria decimated the island, Puerto Rico languished as it waited to receive additional temporary aid from Congress. 10 When it comes to healthcare, federal law reimburses territories for their Medicaid programs at significantly lower rates than it does for states." And as with food assistance, the federal government caps medical assistance for each of these territories, a limit that does not exist for the fifty states or the District of Columbia.12 As Vaello-Madero's case illustrates, no American living in Puerto Rico can receive SSI benefits, regardless of age or disability.

These discrepancies surrounding public benefits mirror the exclusion of territorial Americans in other areas of federal law. An American who lives in, say, Florida who then moves to the British Virgin Islands can vote in presidential elections via an absentee ballot." But if that same person moves to the U.S. Virgin Islands, she cannot. 14 To draw attention to its residents' disenfranchisement, Guam held a presidential straw poll on Election Day. 15 American Samoans possess an even stranger status. While those born in the other four territories are recognized by the federal government as citizens by birth, the State Department stamps American Samoans' passports with the following disclaimer: "The bearer [of this passport] is a United States national and not a United States citizen." 16 Last year, a federal judge disagreed, ruling that a person born in American Samoa is a U.S. citizen within the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Tenth Circuit heard argument on the case last fall. 18 Any inquiry into the public law that governs the U.S. territories necessarily runs up against a persistent democratic deficit.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Social Security ADV

In U.S. v Vaello Madero the court ruled that the federal government can deny territorial residents Social Security benefits, using the “rational basis test,” a lower standard of review for denying equal protections.

Millhiser 22 [Ian Millhiser is a senior correspondent at Vox, where he focuses on the Supreme Court, the Constitution, and the decline of liberal democracy in the United States. He received a JD from Duke University and is the author of two books on the Supreme Court.; “The Supreme Court rules that cruel laws must still be enforced”; Vox; April 21, 2022; https://www.vox.com/2022/4/21/23035592/supreme-court-puerto-rico-vaello-madero-ssi-rational-basis-brett-kavanaugh-sonia-sotomayor]//eleanor

United States v. Vaello Madero, which the Supreme Court decided on Thursday, is a heartbreaking case. It asks whether many of the poorest and most vulnerable Americans can be cut off by their own government simply because they live in the wrong part of the United States.

But Vaello Madero is also a case about democracy, and whether democratic governments can enact policies that are needlessly cruel. In an 8-1 decision joined by every justice but Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the Court effectively answered that question in the affirmative.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- Climate Change

Climate effects can be mitigated and there are solutions now- extinction is severely exaggerated

Sandberg 19 Anders Sandberg, 5-29-2019, "Will climate change cause humans to go extinct?," Conversation, Excerpts: Intro, Under Pressure, Building Resilience

The claim that humanity only has just over a decade left due to climate change is based on a misunderstanding. In 2018, a fairly difficult-to-read report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) warned that humanity needs to cut its carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions in half by 2030, to avoid global warming of 1.5°C above the levels seen before the industrial revolution. What this actually means is roughly, “We have about 12 years before fixing climate change becomes really expensive and tough.” Humanity can still live in a world with climate change – it’s just going to be more work, and many lives and livelihoods are likely to be threatened. But it’s complicated, because this century we are facing many problems at the same time, and we are more dependent on each other than ever. Under pressure To get our food, most of us humans depend on global transport, payment and logistics systems. These, in turn, require fuel, electricity, communications and a lot of other things to work properly. All these systems are connected to each other, so if one starts crashing, the chaos may cause other systems to crash, and before we know it we’ll have massive shortages and conflicts. It’s hard to calculate the exact risk of this happening, since it has never happened before. Until recently, the world was split into separate regions that were largely independent of each other. But we do know that climate change puts the whole world under pressure – everywhere, at the same time – making the risk of these systems collapsing more serious. For example, it’s easier for businesses to handle cybersecurity and energy supply when they don’t also have to cope with natural hazards. Likewise, it’s difficult for governments to maintain infrastructure when politicians are busy dealing with the public’s reactions to food prices, refugees and ecological crises. Building resilience Geoengineering to reduce the impact of climate change – for example, by reducing CO₂ levels or pumping reflective particles into the Earth’s atmosphere to deflect the sun’s rays – might work. But if disaster strikes and those operations stop, the effects of climate change can return quickly. The reasonable thing to do is to work on making our systems more resilient – and there are plenty of opportunities to do this. In practice, this means more local energy production, better backup systems, work on reducing climate change, and being more willing to pay extra for safety.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- Climate Change

Extinction highly improbable and catastrophic framing of climate change only worsens the issue- alientating climate supporters

Shellenberger 19 Michael Shellenberger, 11-25-2019, "Why Apocalyptic Claims About Climate Change Are Wrong," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/11/25/why-everything-they-say-about-climate-change-is-wrong/?sh=132ce78812d6

Environmental journalists and advocates have in recent weeks made a number of apocalyptic predictions about the impact of climate change. Bill McKibben suggested climate-driven fires in Australia had made koalas “functionally extinct.” Extinction Rebellion said “Billions will die” and “Life on Earth is dying.” Vice claimed the “collapse of civilization may have already begun.” Few have underscored the threat more than student climate activist Greta Thunberg and Green New Deal sponsor Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. The latter said, “The world is going to end in 12 years if we don't address climate change.” Says Thunberg in her new book, “Around 2030 we will be in a position to set off an irreversible chain reaction beyond human control that will lead to the end of our civilization as we know it.” Sometimes, scientists themselves make apocalyptic claims. “It’s difficult to see how we could accommodate a billion people or even half of that,” if Earth warms four degrees, said one earlier this year. “The potential for multi-breadbasket failure is increasing,” said another. If sea levels rise as much as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change predicts, another scientist said, “It will be an unmanageable problem.” Apocalyptic statements like these have real-world impacts. In September, a group of British psychologists said children are increasingly suffering from anxiety from the frightening discourse around climate change. In October, an activist with Extinction Rebellion (”XR”) — an environmental group founded in 2018 to commit civil disobedience to draw awareness to the threat its founders and supporters say climate change poses to human existence — and a videographer, were kicked and beaten in a London Tube station by angry commuters. And last week, an XR co-founder said a genocide like the Holocaust was “happening again, on a far greater scale, and in plain sight” from climate change. Climate change is an issue I care passionately about and have dedicated a significant portion of my life to addressing. I have been politically active on the issue for over 20 years and have researched and written about it for 17 years. Over the last four years, my organization, Environmental Progress, has worked with some of the world’s leading climate scientists to prevent carbon emissions from rising. So far, we’ve helped prevent emissions increasing the equivalent of adding 24 million cars to the road. I also care about getting the facts and science right and have in recent months corrected inaccurate and apocalyptic news media coverage of fires in the Amazon and fires in California, both of which have been improperly presented as resulting primarily from climate change. Journalists and activists alike have an obligation to describe environmental problems honestly and accurately, even if they fear doing so will reduce their news value or salience with the public. There is good evidence that the catastrophist framing of climate change is self-defeating because it alienates and polarizes many people. And exaggerating climate change risks distracting us from other important issues including ones we might have more near-term control over. I feel the need to say this up-front because I want the issues I’m about to raise to be taken seriously and not dismissed by those who label as “climate deniers” or “climate delayers” anyone who pushes back against exaggeration. With that out of the way, let’s look whether the science supports what’s being said. First, no credible scientific body has ever said climate change threatens the collapse of civilization much less the extinction of the human species. “‘Our children are going to die in the next 10 to 20 years.’ What’s the scientific basis for these claims?” BBC’s Andrew Neil asked a visibly uncomfortable XR spokesperson last month. “These claims have been disputed, admittedly,” she said. “There are some scientists who are agreeing and some who are saying it’s not true. But the overall issue is that these deaths are going to happen.” “But most scientists don’t agree with this,” said Neil. “I looked through IPCC reports and see no reference to billions of people going to die, or children in 20 years. How would they die?” “Mass migration around the world already taking place due to prolonged drought in countries, particularly in South Asia. There are wildfires in Indonesia, the Amazon rainforest, Siberia, the Arctic,” she said. But in saying so, the XR spokesperson had grossly misrepresented the science. “There is robust evidence of disasters displacing people worldwide,” notes IPCC, “but limited evidence that climate change or sea-level rise is the direct cause” What about “mass migration”? “The majority of resultant population movements tend to occur within the borders of affected countries," says IPCC. It’s not like climate doesn’t matter. It’s that climate change is outweighed by other factors. Earlier this year, researchers found that climate “has affected organized armed conflict within countries. However, other drivers, such as low socioeconomic development and low capabilities of the state, are judged to be substantially more influential.” Last January, after climate scientists criticized Rep. Ocasio-Cortez for saying the world would end in 12 years, her spokesperson said "We can quibble about the phraseology, whether it's existential or cataclysmic.” He added, “We're seeing lots of [climate change-related] problems that are already impacting lives." That last part may be true, but it’s also true that economic development has made us less vulnerable, which is why there was a 99.7% decline in the death toll from natural disasters since its peak in 1931. In 1931, 3.7 million people died from natural disasters. In 2018, just 11,000 did. And that decline occurred over a period when the global population quadrupled. What about sea level rise? IPCC estimates sea level could rise two feet (0.6 meters) by 2100. Does that sound apocalyptic or even “unmanageable”? Consider that one-third of the Netherlands is below sea level, and some areas are seven meters below sea level. You might object that Netherlands is rich while Bangladesh is poor. But the Netherlands adapted to living below sea level 400 years ago. Technology has improved a bit since then. What about claims of crop failure, famine, and mass death? That’s science fiction, not science. Humans today produce enough food for 10 billion people, or 25% more than we need, and scientific bodies predict increases in that share, not declines. The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) forecasts crop yields increasing 30% by 2050. And the poorest parts of the world, like sub-Saharan Africa, are expected to see increases of 80 to 90%. Nobody is suggesting climate change won’t negatively impact crop yields. It could. But such declines should be put in perspective. Wheat yields increased 100 to 300% around the world since the 1960s, while a study of 30 models found that yields would decline by 6% for every one degree Celsius increase in temperature. Rates of future yield growth depend far more on whether poor nations get access to tractors, irrigation, and fertilizer than on climate change, says FAO. All of this helps explain why IPCC anticipates climate change will have a modest impact on economic growth. By 2100, IPCC projects the global economy will be 300 to 500% larger than it is today. Both IPCC and the Nobel-winning Yale economist, William Nordhaus, predict that warming of 2.5°C and 4°C would reduce gross domestic product (GDP) by 2% and 5% over that same period. Does this mean we shouldn’t worry about climate change? Not at all. One of the reasons I work on climate change is because I worry about the impact it could have on endangered species. Climate change may threaten one million species globally and half of all mammals, reptiles, and amphibians in diverse places like the Albertine Rift in central Africa, home to the endangered mountain gorilla. But it’s not the case that “we’re putting our own survival in danger” through extinctions, as Elizabeth Kolbert claimed in her book, Sixth Extinction. As tragic as animal extinctions are, they do not threaten human civilization. If we want to save endangered species, we need to do so because we care about wildlife for spiritual, ethical, or aesthetic reasons, not survival ones. And exaggerating the risk, and suggesting climate change is more important than things like habitat destruction, are counterproductive. For example, Australia’s fires are not driving koalas extinct, as Bill McKibben suggested. The main scientific body that tracks the species, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature, or IUCN, labels the koala “vulnerable,” which is one level less threatened than “endangered,” two levels less than “critically endangered,” and three less than “extinct” in the wild. Should we worry about koalas? Absolutely! They are amazing animals and their numbers have declined to around 300,000. But they face far bigger threats such as the destruction of habitat, disease, bushfires, and invasive species. Think of it this way. The climate could change dramatically — and we could still save koalas. Conversely, the climate could change only modestly — and koalas could still go extinct. The monomaniacal focus on climate distracts our attention from other threats to koalas and opportunities for protecting them, like protecting and expanding their habitat. As for fire, one of Australia’s leading scientists on the issue says, “Bushfire losses can be explained by the increasing exposure of dwellings to fire-prone bushlands. No other influences need be invoked. So even if climate change had played some small role in modulating recent bushfires, and we cannot rule this out, any such effects on risk to property are clearly swamped by the changes in exposure.” Nor are the fires solely due to drought, which is common in Australia, and exceptional this year. “Climate change is playing its role here,” said Richard Thornton of the Bushfire and Natural Hazards Cooperative Research Centre in Australia, “but it's not the cause of these fires." The same is true for fires in the United States. In 2017, scientists modeled 37 different regions and found “humans may not only influence fire regimes but their presence can actually override, or swamp out, the effects of climate.” Of the 10 variables that influence fire, “none were as significant… as the anthropogenic variables,” such as building homes near, and managing fires and wood fuel growth within, forests. Climate scientists are starting to push back against exaggerations by activists, journalists, and other scientists. “While many species are threatened with extinction,” said Stanford’s Ken Caldeira, “climate change does not threaten human extinction... I would not like to see us motivating people to do the right thing by making them believe something that is false.” I asked the Australian climate scientist Tom Wigley what he thought of the claim that climate change threatens civilization. “It really does bother me because it’s wrong,” he said. “All these young people have been misinformed. And partly it’s Greta Thunberg’s fault. Not deliberately. But she’s wrong.” But don’t scientists and activists need to exaggerate in order to get the public’s attention? “I’m reminded of what [late Stanford University climate scientist] Steve Schneider used to say,” Wigley replied. “He used to say that as a scientist, we shouldn’t really be concerned about the way we slant things in communicating with people out on the street who might need a little push in a certain direction to realize that this is a serious problem. Steve didn’t have any qualms about speaking in that biased way. I don’t quite agree with that.” Wigley started working on climate science full-time in 1975 and created one of the first climate models (MAGICC) in 1987. It remains one of the main climate models in use today. “When I talk to the general public,” he said, “I point out some of the things that might make projections of warming less and the things that might make them more. I always try to present both sides.” Part of what bothers me about the apocalyptic rhetoric by climate activists is that it is often accompanied by demands that poor nations be denied the cheap sources of energy they need to develop. I have found that many scientists share my concerns. “If you want to minimize carbon dioxide in the atmosphere in 2070 you might want to accelerate the burning of coal in India today,” MIT climate scientist Kerry Emanuel said. “It doesn’t sound like it makes sense. Coal is terrible for carbon. But it’s by burning a lot of coal that they make themselves wealthier, and by making themselves wealthier they have fewer children, and you don’t have as many people burning carbon, you might be better off in 2070.” Emanuel and Wigley say the extreme rhetoric is making political agreement on climate change harder. “You’ve got to come up with some kind of middle ground where you do reasonable things to mitigate the risk and try at the same time to lift people out of poverty and make them more resilient,” said Emanuel. “We shouldn’t be forced to choose between lifting people out of poverty and doing something for the climate.” Happily, there is a plenty of middle ground between climate apocalypse and climate denial.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- Climate Change

No human extinction from climate change

Pestser 21 Patrick Pester, 8-30-2021, "Could climate change make humans go extinct?," livescience, Excerpts: Intro, Too hot to handle?

The impacts of climate change are here with soaring temperatures, stronger hurricanes, intensified floods and a longer and more severe wildfire season. Scientists warn that ignoring climate change will yield "untold suffering" for humanity. But if things are going to get that much worse, could climate change make humans go extinct? Scientists predict a range of devastating scenarios if climate change is not kept under control, but if we just consider the direct impacts, then there's some good news; it's unlikely to cause our mass extinction. "There is no evidence of climate change scenarios that would render human beings extinct," Michael Mann, a distinguished professor of atmospheric science at Penn State and author of "The New Climate War: The Fight to Take Back Our Planet" (PublicAffairs, 2021), told Live Science in an email. However, it's possible that climate change will still threaten the lives of hundreds of millions of people, such as by leading to food and water scarcity, which has the potential to trigger a societal collapse and set the stage for global conflict, research finds. Too hot to handle? Humans are increasing the amount of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide and methane, in the atmosphere through the burning of fossil fuels and other activities. These gases trap and hold heat from the sun, causing global temperatures to rise and the climate to change much faster than it otherwise would, putting humanity on a dangerous path. A runaway greenhouse effect is probably the only way climate change impacts could directly cause human extinction, according to Luke Kemp, a research associate at the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. This effect happens when a planet is caught in an unstoppable, positive feedback loop of warming and absorbs more heat than it loses, until the planet's oceans evaporate and it can no longer sustain life. Fortunately, the runaway greenhouse effect is not a plausible climate change scenario on Earth. For the effect to occur, a planet needs carbon dioxide levels of a couple of thousand parts per million (Earth has a little over 400 parts per million) or a huge release of methane, and there isn't evidence for that at this time, Brian Kahn, a research scientist at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, told NASA in 2018. Venus has the runaway greenhouse effect, but it is much closer to the sun and has a much thicker, carbon dioxide-rich atmosphere that traps more heat than Earth's, Live Science previously reported. The science doesn’t support the notion of runaway warming scenarios, although climate doomists often make such claims, Mann said. "There’s no reason to exaggerate the climate threat. The truth is bad enough, and reason enough to take dramatic action." fish-eye lens photo of planet Earth from above with field of stars in the background A fish-eye lens photo of Earth from space. (Image credit: Getty / Nuttawut Uttamaharad / EyeEm) According to Mann, a global temperature increase of 5.4 degrees Fahrenheit (3 degrees Celsius) or more could lead to a collapse of our societal infrastructure and massive unrest and conflict, which, in turn, could lead to a future that resembles some Hollywood dystopian films. One way climate change could trigger a societal collapse is by creating food insecurity. Warming the planet has a range of negative impacts on food production, including increasing the water deficit and thereby reducing food harvests, Live Science previously reported. Food production losses can increase human deaths and drive economic loss and socio-political instability, among other factors, that may trigger a breakdown of our institutions and increase the risk of a societal collapse, according to a study published Feb. 21 in the journal Climatic Change.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- Climate Change

Jobs Guarantee solves climate change

Finn 17 Daniel Finn, 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," No Publication, Excerpt: Section 4, Omitted: Sections 1-3,5

4. Federal jobs could provide socially useful goods and services. During the Great Depression, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) were public employment programs designed to put Americans back to work after the national unemployment rate reached 25 percent. These programs, implemented under the Roosevelt administration, provided socially beneficial goods and services that benefited all Americans. Some of our national parks — Zion, Glacier, and Shenandoah — received substantial work contributions from employees of the federal jobs programs. The Blue Ridge Parkway was a federally funded and staffed infrastructure program. A new federal job guarantee could undertake similarly bold and much-needed public-works projects. The American Society of Civil Engineers gave the United States a D+ in infrastructure and prices necessary repairs at $3.6 trillion. This lack of investment has lowered employment rates, cost businesses sales, and reduced incomes for American families. Make no mistake, these are government choices. They could choose instead to hire unemployed workers to repair bridges, maintain roadways, and update power grids. Likewise, Bill McKibben just called for us to “declare war” against climate change. With climate change being perhaps the largest threat to our well-being, bold action is needed. The job guarantee program would create the capacity to do just that. Professor Robert Pollin of the Political Economy Research Institute calls for scaling up the transition to a green economy, which would create millions of new jobs along the way. He and his colleagues estimate what a Green New Deal would look like, and find that a transition to a green economy would amount to an estimated $200 billion in investment annually, resulting in a drop in “US emission by 40 percent within 20 years, while creating a net increase of 2.7 million jobs.” In part, this is due to the labor-intensive nature of energy efficiency and other “green” investments. Additional services, when combined with a FJG, would save average American households thousands, if not tens of thousands, a year. According to the Economic Policy Institute, for example, tuition-free and universal child care and education — staffed by FJG workers — would trim an average of $22,631 annually from families’ budgets in expensive places such as DC while saving households in places like Arkansas a more modest $5,995 on average. To be sure, a UBI would free up time to volunteer, to care for sick relatives, or to start small businesses. Additionally, the UBI would finally provide greater financial freedom to those that choose to stay at home and engage in care work — disproportionately provided by women. However, the FJG has the ability to provide high quality services, such as child care and elder care, that would greatly reduce the care burden, providing more choice while building on the current social safety net.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- War

Increased globalization and resiliency stops any chance of war

Woods 16 Ngaire Woods, 3-3-2016, "The Global Economy’s Stealth Resilience," Project Syndicate,

OXFORD – Last week, Christine Lagarde, the International Monetary Fund’s managing director, warned that if countries do not act together, the global economy could be derailed. Likewise, the OECD has warned that countries must move “urgently” and “collectively” to boost global growth prospects. Yet the G-20 finance ministers and central-bank governors to whom these entreaties were directed failed to agree any such action at their recent meeting in Shanghai. To be sure, the communiqué released after the meeting includes a pledge to use “all policy tools – monetary, fiscal, and structural – individually and collectively” to “foster confidence and preserve and strengthen the recovery.” But the communiqué also reflects distinct divisions – particularly with regard to the role of monetary and fiscal policy in stimulating growth – among the finance ministers and central bankers who agreed on its text. On monetary policy, the communiqué offers the empty statement that the G-20 would “continue to support economic activity and ensure price stability, consistent with central banks’ mandates.” That avoided the central question: Should central banks be attempting to stimulate growth through “unconventional” monetary policies? The Bank for International Settlements thinks not, arguing in its 2015 annual report that “monetary policy has been overburdened” in an attempt to reinvigorate growth, a reality that is reflected in “the persistence of ultra-low interest rates.” The result is a vicious cycle of too much debt, too little growth, and too-low interest rates that, to quote the BIS’s Claudio Borio, “beget lower rates.” This sobering analysis has not stopped the Bank of Japan or the European Central Bank from further monetary easing. Nor did it deter People’s Bank of China Governor Zhou Xiaochuan from expressing a willingness to shoulder more of the growth-stimulating burden in Shanghai. But not everyone is ignoring the writing on the wall. Reserve Bank of India Governor Raghuram Rajan has called on the IMF to examine the effects of unconventional monetary policy not just on the countries that implement them, but also on the rest of the world. Likewise, Bank of England Governor Mark Carney has pointed out that countries using negative interest rates (including, most recently, Japan) are, by forcing currency devaluation, exporting weak demand – ultimately a zero-sum game. When it comes to fiscal policy, agreement is similarly lacking. The IMF is urging surplus countries like Germany to pursue more stimulus. The OECD, too, has called upon its wealthier members to take advantage of their current ability to borrow for long periods at very low interest rates to increase growth-enhancing investment in infrastructure. These calls provoked a sharp rebuttal from German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble, who condemned the “debt-financed growth model.” The result of this conflict was a vague declaration by the G-20 that it would use “fiscal-policy flexibly to strengthen growth, job creation, and confidence, while enhancing resilience and ensuring debt as a share of GDP is on a sustainable path.” In light of the statements by the IMF and the OECD, this distinct failure to agree on monetary and fiscal policy seems highly dangerous. But both institutions may be overstating the problem. In fact, despite widespread uncertainty – volatile capital flows, plummeting commodity prices, escalating geopolitical tensions, the shock of a potential British exit from the European Union, and a massive refugee crisis – the stalling of global cooperation may be less risky today than it was even a decade ago. The key factor in this context has been widespread recognition of the risks inherent in economic globalization, and concerted efforts to build up the needed resilience on a national, bilateral, or regional basis. Consider finance. Twenty years ago, a catastrophic financial crisis began in Thailand and quickly spread across East Asia. Since then, those economies, and others in the emerging world, have self-insured against crisis by building up huge stockpiles of foreign-exchange reserves. Partly as a result of this, the volume of reserves has risen from some 5% of world GDP in 1995 to around 15% today. Emerging economies are also holding less sovereign debt, and they have created bilateral and regional currency-swap arrangements. In addition, more than 40 countries have deployed macro-prudential measures since the 2008 global financial crisis. Countries also benefit from greater access to more diversified sources of finance. Some emerging and developing countries now access global bond markets individually. And the role of regional development banks – including the African, Asian, and Inter-American Development Banks, as well as the newly created Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank and the New Development Bank – has grown. The final manifestation of this new pattern of cooperation – which might be called “distributed governance” – appears in trade. While the Doha Round of negotiations has staggered and fallen, liberalization is proceeding apace, owing to the proliferation of bilateral, regional, and super-regional deals. These new governance arrangements have important resilience-enhancing effects; but they may not offer a more efficient alternative to multilateralism, and they do not eliminate the need for traditional multilateral institutions. On the contrary, bodies like the IMF, the World Bank, and the World Trade Organization should be responsible for analyzing and transmitting vital information to the array of institutions that are filling their traditional role.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- War

COVID and 2008 recession prove no war- prefer most recent data

Siegel 21 Rachel Siegel, Andrew, 1-28-2021, "2020 was the worst year for economic growth since World War II," Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/01/28/gdp-2020-economy-recession/

The U.S. economy shrank by 3.5 percent in 2020 as the coronavirus pandemic ravaged factories, businesses and households, pushing U.S. economic growth to a low not seen since the United States wound down wartime spending in 1946. Overall, the economy was surprisingly resilient in the second half of the year, given the falloff at the start of the public health crisis, according to data released Thursday from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Yet, the 1 percent growth in the fourth quarter signaled a faltering recovery and a long road ahead, with 9.8 million jobs still missing and 23.8 million adults struggling to feed their families. “2020 has no precedent in modern economic history,” said David Wilcox, senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics and a former director of the domestic economics division at the Federal Reserve. “The influenza of 1918 and 1919 predates our modern system of economic statistics, and since World War II, there’s never been a contraction that even remotely approached the severity and the breadth of the initial collapse in 2020.” It’s the first time the economy has contracted for the year since 2009, when gross domestic product shrank by 2.5 percent during the depths of the Great Recession. The next-worst plunge was 1946, when the economy shrank by 11.6 percent as the nation demobilized from its wartime footing. Consumer spending in the final three months of the year slowed down in all 15 categories tracked by the BEA, as the sectors that powered third-quarter growth faltered. Americans spent less on restaurants and hotels, a sector that had been a surprising third-quarter bright spot, and the growth of spending on motor vehicles and health care slowed after a steep third-quarter acceleration. The recession may be over — technically “There has been a broad recovery but, economically speaking, we’re not out of the woods yet,” said Ben Herzon, executive director at IHS Markit. Senate Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) seized on the new GDP figures in a speech on the Senate floor, arguing that they make the case for passing a big new relief bill. “Given these economic numbers, the need to act big and bold is urgent,” Schumer said. “Given the fact that the GDP sunk by 3.5 percent last year, we need recovery and rescue quickly.” President Biden has proposed a $1.9 trillion economic relief package with money for individual Americans and cities and states, as well as coronavirus testing and vaccines, among other provisions. Schumer reiterated Thursday that he intends to take steps to move the package forward next week, with or without GOP support. Many Republicans say the proposal is too costly and unnecessary on top of about $4 trillion in relief that Congress already passed, including $900 billion in December. The economy is getting even worse for Americans with a high school diploma or less education Even as the economy shed jobs like never before in 2020, personal income grew significantly, BEA data shows, largely because of $1,200 stimulus checks and enhanced unemployment benefits provided by the Cares Act. Disposable personal income grew faster for lower-income households than it did for the average household, according to an analysis published Thursday by Jason Furman, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute and a former top economist in the Obama administration, and Wilson Powell III of the Harvard Kennedy School. However, those gains were front-loaded and have begun to erode. Federal stimulus drove personal income to record highs in the late spring, but the levels fell off significantly in the second half of the year as relief programs under the Cares Act wound down or expired. Congress also approved a $900 billion stimulus package last month, which sent Americans new $600 stimulus checks and extended unemployment benefits by as much as $300 a week through mid-March. “The package enacted at the end of December was completely welcome, but we’re clearly seeing that it took some time to roll out and get that aid to folks,” said Wendy Edelberg, director of the Hamilton Project at the Brookings Institution and former chief economist at the Congressional Budget Office. This is the last GDP report from President Donald Trump’s tenure. Until the pandemic, Trump was on track for an economic record that put him near the middle of the pack among recent presidents. But the coronavirus crisis ensured that Trump oversaw the slowest economic growth of any president in the period since World War II. Economic chaos reigned in 2020. In the second quarter, gross domestic product contracted at the fastest quarterly rate ever for the United States, as the pandemic walloped workers and businesses and kept millions from leaving their homes. Then, in the third quarter, GDP soared at a record pace as parts of the economy reopened and businesses brought workers back onto their payrolls. Governors’ shutdowns did not cause the pandemic jobs crisis The nascent economic recovery was propelled by a rebound of sales of automobiles and household goods such as furniture, and in renovations and supplies for home offices. Consumer spending — which accounts for more than two-thirds of U.S. economic activity — used to be driven by an ever-growing demand for services, including leisure and hospitality, and restaurants and bars. But as the pandemic warped tried-and-true shopping habits, economists watched consumers move their spending from services to goods. Purchases of computers, home office equipment and fire pits quickly overtook those of hotel rooms and movie tickets. In fact, 2020 was the best year ever for Bedford Fields Home & Garden Center in the forested hills of Bedford, a suburb of Manchester, N.H. When the pandemic hit, “literally everybody became gardeners,” office manager Tracey Auger said. The GDP category that includes nurseries and garden-supply stores was one of the fastest-growing in 2020. Federal Reserve Chair Powell says ‘nothing more important’ to economy than vaccinating Americans “So many people were home, and we were deemed essential and one of the few places people could go to shop,” Auger said. “They needed somewhere to go, a project to do.” Auger, who has worked at Bedford Fields for nine years, said the shop has based its 2021 orders on the assumption that this year will be somewhere between a normal year, like 2019, and the housebound plant madness of 2020. Bedford Fields has doubled its seed order for 2021 and has secured a full order of plants; after months of shortages, growers have finally caught up to surging demand. For every business that has thrived in the era of social distancing, though, dozens of others have continued to suffer as customers stay home and governments restrict activity at high-contact businesses such as bars, restaurants and event centers. At a news conference Wednesday, Powell said the pace of the recovery in economic activity and employment has moderated in recent months, with service-sector workers — mainly women and people of color — struggling to regain a foothold in the workforce. “That is really the main thing about the economy, is getting the pandemic under control, getting everyone vaccinated, getting people wearing masks and all that,” Powell said. “That’s the single most important economic growth policy that we can have.” The businesses that have been hit hardest disproportionately employ women, people of color and workers without college educations. Americans in those groups are suffering. Economists call it a K-shaped recovery: The top end of the economy continues to improve, even as lower earners fall further behind. The covid-19 recession is the most unequal in modern U.S. history Constance Hunter, chief economist at KPMG, pointed to different slices of the economy that have their own versions of the K-shaped recovery. Among corporations, tech companies such as Zoom and Netflix are soaring. Airlines, less so. For workers, Hunter said that among Americans who can work from home, the unemployment rate is 3.9 percent. The rate is 8.5 percent for people who have to report to a job site. “In general, the GDP number is informative about the economy,” Hunter said. But “because of this corporate K, a household K, a geographic K, we have to dig under the hood in a different way.” In the fourth quarter of 2020, spending from state and local governments fell 2.5 percent from the same quarter the previous year, adjusted for inflation. That’s the sharpest decrease since mid-2012, and mirrored the toll from the 2008-2009 financial crisis. In the years after the Great Recession, economists pointed to the slow return of public-sector jobs as a drag on the broader recovery. The coronavirus crisis has once again spurred many left-leaning economists and policymakers to push for continued aid to state and local governments. “I just want us to learn the lessons from the 2008-2009 Great Recession,” said Lisa Cook, an economist at Michigan State University. “With greater funding for state and local governments, [a relief package] will stem the adverse affects of what we’re seeing with respect to the virus.” Cristal Farrington, 48, was laid off in May after more than two decades of climbing the corporate ladder at New York City firms that buy and distribute specialty foods and restaurant equipment. Farrington is looking for whatever work she can get but said she was not optimistic that business would pick up in 2021, because the timelines for vaccine rollout and reopening remain fuzzy. And even if things turn around, it will be years before Black women like her are welcomed back into the workforce, she said. “People of color, we’ve always been on the edge, teetering,” Farrington said. “Because we always know we’re going to be the first ones let go and the last ones hired.” Economists surveyed by the Wall Street Journal predict a strong rebound in 2021, with the economy growing by 4.3 percent. That would be the best year since the late 1990s, as high earners unleash the billions they have saved during the pandemic. One bright spot in 2020 is that the personal saving rate hit the highest on record, and some businesses are betting that — combined with a vaccine rollout, the December stimulus and any future Biden administration stimulus — all that saving will power a swift rebound. The online review site Yelp this week reported that more businesses reopened in December than in any month since June. It also augurs well for this year that, in December, interest in wedding planning soared 22 percent above its 2019 level — a sign of hope for the battered live-events industry

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Aff Answers › Impact › !- War

Recession won’t create war

Clary 15 Christopher Clary 4-22-2015, "Economic Stress and International Cooperation: Evidence from International Rivalries," No Publication, Excerpt: Abstract

Do economic downturns generate pressure for diversionary conflict? Or might downturns encourage austerity and economizing behavior in foreign policy? This paper provides new evidence that economic stress is associated with conciliatory policies between strategic rivals. For states that view each other as military threats, the biggest step possible toward bilateral cooperation is to terminate the rivalry by taking political steps to manage the competition. Drawing on data from 109 distinct rival dyads since 1950, 67 of which terminated, the evidence suggests rivalries were approximately twice as likely to terminate during economic downturns than they were during periods of economic normalcy. This is true controlling for all of the main alternative explanations for peaceful relations between foes (democratic status, nuclear weapons possession, capability imbalance, common enemies, and international systemic changes), as well as many other possible confounding variables. This research questions existing theories claiming that economic downturns are associated with diversionary war, and instead argues that in certain circumstances peace may result from economic troubles.