Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Affirmative
1AC › 1AC › Advantage 1: Economy

Inflation is a non-issue. Climate jobs guarantee includes an economic buffer controlling supply and demand, which also solves resource limitations.

Fogarty 15 Will Fogarty, Research Fellow for the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. “Federally Funded, Locally Organized: An Affordable Job Guarantee Program”, Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity (July 2015),

2. Inflation: A Non-Issue The conventional wisdom will claim that this proposal, if adopted, will trigger runaway inflation. This fear is misinformed, and greatly exaggerates the consequences of small annual price increases. Most policymakers accept that unemployment helps prevent inflation, although they would likely not say so in a campaign speech. The first obvious objection to this unspoken approach is ethical: Wray asks: Should a nation attempt to maintain macroeconomic stability by keeping a portion of its population sufficiently poor […]. More generally, is unemployment and poverty an acceptable policy tool to be used to maintain currency stability? (Wray 2012, 225) In other words, is inflation so bad that it justifies keeping tens of millions jobless? Ethics aside, the program will actually stabilize prices in the long-run by operating as a buffer stock mechanism, which will effectively allow the federal government to maintain wages at a target level. During an economic boom, private sector wages will not skyrocket because corporations will always have the option of hiring workers from the JG workers (Wray 2012, 224). Just as the buffer stock program for wool stabilizes its market, job security will stabilize the macro-economy far more effectively than widespread unemployment. Granted, the newly employed workers will have greater purchasing power and this may lead to modest increases to short-run prices in certain industries. However, the private sector will rebound by increasing their supply of those goods and services and consequently slow price increases; once again, when businesses need more employees to meet the new demand, they can hire workers from the JG program. It is ironic how the loudest advocates of an unregulated private sector have so little faith in its capacity to respond to increased demand! This brings us to an MMT analysis of inflation, which, in brief, demonstrates that inflation will only occur where the physical resources necessary for production are limited; otherwise, there is no reason to expect unmanageable inflation17 . There is also an important distinction between mild price increases, which the program should create, and problematic inflation (Mosler 2012, 70). Price increases typically reflect a market that is effectively allocating resources; inflation and hyperinflation occur only when there is a shortage or restriction on the supply of certain goods (Mosler 2012, 70). Wray demonstrates that inflation and hyperinflation are almost always tied to social and political upheaval, a civil war, a collapse of productive capacity, or an otherwise weak government (Wray 2012, 257). He concludes: There is nothing in the current or prospective condition [with the JG program] of the United States {or the United Kingdom or Japan – all high deficit nations at the end of 2011} that would lead one to expect high inflation, let alone hyperinflation (Wray 2012, 248). 17 Resource limitations are ever-growing due to climate change; thankfully, much of JG program will be dedicated to promoting and enforcing more sustainable production processes. 17 This paper does not have the space to fully assuage those who will be horrified by the prospect of price increases; nonetheless, it has intended to at least demonstrate that the program will not trigger problematic inflation.

2023 UTNIF Affirmative
1AC › 1AC › Advantage 1: Economy

Job guarantees are affordable, resolve income inequality, and boost the national and local economy

Fogarty 15 Will Fogarty, Research Fellow for the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. “Federally Funded, Locally Organized: An Affordable Job Guarantee Program”, Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity (July 2015),

4. Low Cost of the Program Most program estimates peg the cost of a JG program between one and three percent of total G.D.P (Wray 2014, 1). As Figure 2 (below) shows, this is less than the 3.4% the United States already spends on generally ineffective anti-poverty programs.

Kaboub’s article about the low cost of full employment considers two possible cost scenarios: one in which the JG program hires all unemployed workers in the first year, and another in which the process is gradual. The latter scenario seems more politically plausible and will therefore be analyzed13. By the third year, the program will have hired all workers who are ready, willing, and able; he estimates a workforce of roughly 23 million (Kaboub 2012, 65)14 . He also proposes a wage structure with a base pay of $15 per hour and sliding scale up to $21 per hour, which exceeds the wages proposed in this paper (Kaboub 2012, 65)15 . Kaboub budgets a material cost of $50 billion for the projects themselves, and also includes an annual benefits package of $10,000 (Kaboub 2012, 65). Given a reasonable federal income tax of 15%, he calculates that the program will raise $121 billion in tax revenue (Kaboub 2012, 66). 16 It will save the federal government at least $234 billion in various cost reductions, including $150 billion in savings from unemployment benefits, $100 billion in food assistance programs, and $75 in incarceration costs (Kaboub 2012, 66). All things considered, the program will cost less than $600 billion—practically pennies in comparison to the $29 trillion that the Fed has spent bailing out Wall Street (Kaboub 2012, 66). Most importantly, by year three, the increased purchasing power of the formerly unemployed will generate over $1 trillion annually to U.S. G.D.P. (Kaboub 2012, 66). Once again, affordability is not an issue, but, regardless, this analysis demonstrates the JG program’s relatively low cost and its contribution to economic growth. 13 This proposal is not strictly committed to either the “shock therapy” or “gradual approach” (Kaboub 2012: 65). The shock therapy approach solves the issue immediately, but may cause some administrative and organizational mishaps. The gradual approach should decrease these miscues, but leaves people employable individuals unemployed that much longer. 14 The following estimates are not closely dependent on this figure of 23 million; a few million more will not wildly alter the analysis. In fact, I suspect that the figure will be below 23 million as the newly employed workers will spend their money and expand the economy. Private corporations will need to hire more workers in response, and will look to the JG program to do so. 15 Therefore, these estimates likely exceed the costs of the JG program proposed in this paper. 16 Let us temporarily leave aside that the federal government does not actually use tax revenue to spend. 14 IV.Economic Benefits of JG Program An increase to G.D.P. is certainly not the only economic benefit of the program nor its most important. The United States is the richest country in the world almost twice over, yet income inequality has been steadily increasing for decades and tens of millions of citizens remained unemployment against their will. Clearly, G.D.P. is not the only measure of a country’s economic wellbeing. First and foremost, The JG program will help struggling families by providing them with the means to afford the most basic necessities and allow them enjoy at least some material comforts. The increased purchasing power of the newly employed workers will trigger a boom in the aggregate demand of many goods and services. Businesses will respond to the increased activity and higher profits by hiring more workers into middle-management positions, which will curb rising income inequality. Local and state governments will also see significant increases in tax revenue. Workers will be able to afford homes and pay property taxes; they will consume more goods and services and pay the corresponding taxes. Unlike the federal government, local governments are not currency issuers and do rely on tax revenue and borrowing to spend. There is little reason to doubt that more money will help local and state governments operate more effectively and encourage the development of previously unaffordable projects.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Misc › 2AC – Perm???

Perm do both solves- federal jobs garuntees are key to transition to a degrowth economy

Jason Hickel 2020. Jason Edward Hickel is an economic anthropologist whose research focuses on ecological economics, global inequality, imperialism and political economy.[2] He is a professor at the Institute for Environmental Science and Technology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, a Visiting Senior Fellow at the International Inequalities Institute at the London School of Economics,[2] and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Art. “LESS IS MORE: How Degrowth Will Save the World”

From one perspective, this is fantastic news. It means that fewer lives will be wasted in needless jobs, producing and selling things that society doesn’t actually require. It means liberating people to spend their time and energy on other things. But from the perspective of the individual workers who will be laid off from these jobs, it is a disaster. And governments will find themselves struggling to cope with unemployment. This might seem like an impossible bind; and indeed it’s one reason why politicians consider degrowth to be so unthinkable. But there’s a way out. As we shed unnecessary jobs we can shorten the working week, going from forty-seven hours (the average in the United States) down to thirty or perhaps even twenty hours, distributing necessary labour more evenly among the working population and maintaining full employment. We can facilitate this process by introducing a job guarantee (a policy that happens to be resoundingly popular23 ), and roll out retraining programmes so that people laid off from shrinking industries can transition easily to others (renewable energy, public services, maintenance, etc.). This approach would allow everyone to benefit from the time that’s liberated by reducing material throughput. It’s an essential part of any degrowth strategy. The exciting part is that reducing working hours has a substantial positive impact on people’s well-being. This effect has been demonstrated over and over again, and the results are striking. Studies in the US have found that people who work shorter hours are happier than those who work longer hours, even when controlling for income.24 When France downshifted to the thirty-five-hour week, workers reported that their quality of life improved.25 An experiment in Sweden showed that employees who reduced their working time to thirty hours reported improved life satisfaction and better health outcomes.26 Data also shows that shorter hours leave people feeling more satisfied with their jobs, boosting morale and happiness.27 And – perhaps best of all – shorter hours are associated with greater gender equality, both in the workplace and at home.28 Some critics worry that if you give people more time off they’ll spend it on energy-intensive leisure activities, like taking long-haul flights for holidays. But the evidence shows exactly the opposite. It is those with less leisure time who tend to consume more intensively: they rely on high-speed travel, meal deliveries, impulsive purchases, retail therapy, and so on. A study of French households found that longer working hours are directly associated with higher consumption of environmentally intensive goods, even when correcting for income.29 By contrast, when people are given time off they tend to gravitate towards lower-impact activities: exercise, volunteering, learning, and socialising with friends and family.30 These effects play out across whole countries. For instance, researchers have found that if the United States were to reduce its working hours to the levels of Western Europe, its energy consumption would decline by a staggering 20%. Shortening the working week is one of the most immediately impactful climate policies available to us.31 But when we focus on how to release our system from the growth imperative, we begin to get a sense of what a post-capitalist economy might look like. And it’s not scary at all. This is not the command-and-control fiasco of the Soviet Union, or some back-to-the-caves, hair-shirted disaster of voluntary impoverishment. On the contrary, it’s an economy that feels in key ways familiar, in the sense that it resembles the economy as we normally describe it to ourselves (in other words, perhaps as we wish it to be): an economy where people produce and sell useful goods and services; an economy where people make rational, informed decisions about what to buy; an economy where people get compensated fairly for their labour; an economy that satisfies human needs while minimising waste; an economy that circulates money to those who need it; an economy where innovation makes better, longer-lasting products, reduces ecological pressure, frees up labour time and improves human welfare; an economy that responds to – rather than ignores – the health of the ecology on which it depends. And yet inasmuch as it is familiar in these ways, the new economy is fundamentally different from our existing economy, in that it is not organised around the prime objective of capitalism: accumulation.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Hickel

Hickel bases their assumptions on a misinformed framework of material footprint skewes his research

McAfee 20 Andrew Paul McAfee, a principal research scientist at MIT, is cofounder and codirector of the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy at the MIT Sloan School of Management. He studies how digital technologies are changing the world “Why Degrowth Is the Worst Idea on the Planet” OCT 6, 2020 ANDREW MCAFEE wired (https://www.wired.com/story/opinion-why-degrowth-is-the-worst-idea-on-the-planet/) caddo SV

Degrowth exponent Jason Hickel responds to this broad evidence of dematerialization by making once again the shopworn argument that there are no real environmental gains; there’s only globalization of harms. Hickel has argued repeatedly that once offshoring is properly taken into account, dematerialization vanishes. How can this be, when tallies take into account imports and exports of raw materials like NKP, timber, and paper? Because, he contends, they don't take into account the true “material footprint” of production around the world. At this point the degrowth argument departs from reality. I mean literally. As “The Material Footprint of Nations” (the main paper Hickel cites) states, material footprint measures do “not record the actual physical movement of materials within and among countries.” Instead, they’re derived from a “calculation framework [that] … enumerates the link between the beginning of a production chain (where raw materials are extracted from the natural environment) and its end.” Material footprint models estimate the total weight of all the materials disturbed by humans around the world as they produce the goods they eventually consume. All of the ores mined to make metal, the rock quarried to make gravel, the sand scooped up to make glass and microchips—all of these are estimated by country by year in the material footprint calculation framework. A nation’s material footprint, then, is always higher than its direct material consumption (DMC). This is straightforward enough. What’s puzzling is that according to “The Material Footprint of Nations,” some rich countries are seeing their footprint go up even as their consumption goes down. The paper shows that many countries are now dematerializing. DMC has been trending downward for some time in the US, UK, and Japan and may recently have peaked for the European Union and OECD as a whole. Yet in all these cases, the material footprint continues to rise. How can this be? It’s not because the material footprint models do a better job than the USGS of accounting for the metals and other materials in finished goods imports. The technical annex for the global material flows database notes that, as is the case with the USGS tallies, “complex manufactured items are largely excluded.” Instead, the paper notes, “the main reason in most cases was increased indirect use of (dependency on) construction materials.” This is problematic, because those materials are so poorly tracked. As the appendix states, “Many countries have no data on extraction of non-metallic minerals primarily used for construction … When they are available, they are often unreliable, partial, and underreported.” It’s a poor strategy to use sparse, low-quality data to overturn conclusions based on uniform, high-quality data, yet this is what Hickel is doing when he argues that material footprint calculations show dematerialization is an illusion. There’s one other serious problem with this argument. It’s based largely on the estimated “raw material equivalents” of Chinese exports of construction minerals, yet China is not at all a big exporter of these minerals. Instead, China’s main exports are electrical and mechanical machinery, plastics, furniture, apparel, and vehicles. None of these contain a lot of sand, gravel, stone, or clay. So then how do such huge quantities of these and other construction minerals end up somehow being counted among China’s exports? Because China is building a lot of factories, railroads, highways, and other industrial infrastructure each year. The materials footprint calculation framework estimates how much tonnage of construction minerals all this building requires, then allocates about one third of this tonnage to exports. So by this logic, the smartphones and solar panels the US imported from China in, say, 2018 “contain” some of the stone and gravel used to build up China that year. By that same logic, if my neighbors bring me a cake the same year they renovate their house, then my consumption of lumber, drywall, and copper pipe goes up as soon as I have a slice. Hickel doesn’t stand on any firmer ground when he moves from conclusions to recommendations. He has often claimed that 50 billion tons is the maximum weight of global resource extraction that Earth can sustainably handle and that we’re already well past this limit. In the face of this alleged crisis, he maintains that “the only fail-safe strategy is to impose legally binding caps on resource use and gradually ratchet it back down to safe levels.” However, the paper he cites to support his views contains a frank admission: “There is still no hard scientific evidence of causal relationship between human-induced resource flows and the possible breakdown of life-supporting functions at continental or global scale from which … targets [like a 50 billion ton limit] could directly be derived.” Before taking the unprecedented step of setting up a central resource planning bureaucracy, it doesn’t seem like too much to ask for hard scientific evidence that it’s actually necessary.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Throughput

“Material throughput” is a fake metric that’s impossible to calibrate to.

Tsuda ‘21

[Kenta, University College London. 04/30/2021. “Naïve Questions on Degrowth”, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837997] pfox

Degrowthers do not specify a reliable measure of resource use to anchor ‘material throughput’. To the extent that they confront the measurement problem, they refer to proxies. Some discuss consumption mass as a proxy for material throughput—the aggregated weight of the physical materials consumed over time, already estimated at national level as domestic material consumption. They concede the measure is crude as a proxy for throughput, as the mass involved in an activity does not express its ecological impact. As a proxy, it fails to register the differential ecological harms of materials, for example, between a mercury-infused coal ash pile and an equal mass of food scraps in a compost bin. Furthermore, it is premised upon the capacity of statisticians to capture all sources and sinks touched by anthropogenic activity and render the effects on them legible as mass quantities—a daunting and, as far as I know, incomplete task. The alternative proxy is GDP growth itself, according to Daly ‘the best index we have of total resource throughput’. But this introduces a fatal ambiguity when degrowthers make claims about a ‘coupling’ between GDP growth and throughput: which proxy are they using for the latter? If the proxy is mass, the relationship has an unreliable empirical basis. If the proxy is GDP growth itself, the statement is meaningless.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Jevons/Rebound

Jevons is wrong – rebound effects don’t apply to substitute goods.

Tsuda ‘21

[Kenta, University College London. 04/30/2021. “Naïve Questions on Degrowth”, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837997] pfox

The macro-economic rebound effect is an axiom of degrowth theory, not a finding, and there is reason to doubt it. Whether the rebound effect applies to a given efficiency gain is an empirical question: apparently it applied to 19th-century improvements in coal combustion, at least for a time. There is no reason to believe that it necessarily transfers to all situations, however. Efficiency gains will not yield a rebound effect, for example, where they generate an entirely distinct substitute good. Increased use of petroleum-fueled engines that were more efficient than coal-fired engines brought no rebound effect in coal consumption, at least not by the mechanism Jevons described; rather it expanded use of a distinct resource, petroleum. Degrowthers side-step this by emphasizing the commensurability of all terrestrial resources—with the above example, of coal and petroleum. ‘Material throughput’, encompassing all resources and sinks, is capacious enough to make substitution impossible: one cannot substitute away from physical reality. But is it a helpful category or merely a placeholder term?

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 REMs

REM shortages are being solved through innovation and continued growth now

Bubar 22

Don Bubar is a geologist with over 35 years of experience in mineral exploration in Canada. Mr. Bubar is a graduate of McGill University (B.Sc., 1977) and Queen’s University (M.Sc., 1981). From 1984 to 1994, he worked for Aur Resources Inc. as Exploration Manager and later VP, Exploration. Since 1995, Mr. Bubar has been President and CEO of Avalon “Innovation is key to maintain rare earth supply chains” april 15th 2022 Donald S. Bubar innovationsnewsnetwork https://www.innovationnewsnetwork.com/innovation-is-key-to-maintain-rare-earth-supply-chains/17428/ caddo SV

Rare earth supply chains are a commodity group that is getting a lot of attention in the media these days but is still poorly understood by anyone who has not studied chemistry and earth science. Many people consider rare earths to be a term used to describe any relatively rare element needed in new technology. In fact, they are a specific group of 15 elements in Group 3 of the Periodic Table beginning with #57 lanthanum (La) and often referred to as the lanthanides. Two other similar rare elements occurring in Group 3 are scandium and yttrium. They are often included as rare earths as they are usually found in similar geological host rocks as the Lanthanides while remaining chemically distinct. Two-sub-groups within the rare earth supply chain have been defined based on their atomic number: the light rare earths (#57-61, lanthanum to Promethium) and heavy rare earths (#62-71, samarium to lutetium). The light rare earths, especially lanthanum and cerium, are always more abundant in any rare earth resource but the relative abundance of lights versus heavies can vary depending on geological context. Ironically, the rare earth elements are not that rare and occur in a variety of geological environments and minerals, but are rarely concentrated to levels that may justify developing the resource from which to extract them as the main commodity. This is why producing them as a by-product from a resource where they occur with other valuable traditional commodities is increasingly being recognised as a new opportunity. This is how production began in China, where they occur in a resource called Bayan Obo that was developed originally as a large iron ore mining operation in which they subsequently discovered rare earth and niobium enrichment. It continues to be the largest rare earth producer in the world. Separating lanthanides Because the 15 lanthanides are very similar chemically, they have always been difficult to separate using traditional solvent extraction technologies. While this can be done, it is a very expensive process involving multiple circuits in a very large facility. But it is very important to achieve full separation because each of the separated rare earths have different properties that allow for their application in a variety of technologies. The most important application these days are in high strength permanent magnets which are vital for electric motor efficiency especially for electric vehicles. The two most important “magnet rare earths” are the lights neodymium and praseodymium used in the original neodymium-iron-boron magnets. There are now variants on these high strength magnet compositions to include heavy rare earths notably, dysprosium, which creates heat resistance as well as samarium and terbium. Other applications include lasers, x-ray technologies, colour phosphors, fluorescent lamps, glass, ceramics and polishing powders to name a few, plus potential for many more through more research and innovation. Rare earths supply chains optimal separation process technology Where innovation is needed most urgently in order to facilitate establishing new rare earth supply chains outside of China, is in the separation process to simplify it and reduce costs. Some progress is being made both in Canada and in Europe and it is just a matter of time now before an optimal separation process technology is defined. Avalon Advanced Materials Inc has a lot of experience in what the challenges are in starting a new rare earth supply production from an in-ground bedrock resource. But one of the emerging opportunities that we are excited about is the potential for recovering rare earths from the wastes on closed mine sites without having to do any mining. It is a good example of how the circular economy can be established in the mining industry while also innovating new more efficient extraction processes to apply to the wastes. Closed phosphate mine site The opportunity Avalon is looking at is a closed phosphate mine site located in North Eastern Ontario where phosphate minerals were originally recovered for fertiliser applications from a carbonatite intrusion. It is a classic example of a mine developed in the past to produce one traditional commodity where the resource contained many other elements that had little economic interest then, but do today and the mine wastes now represent an attractive opportunity to recover them. These include rare earth elements, scandium, zirconium and potentially others as carbonatite intrusions can host a variety of metals and minerals of economic interest. Once again, the key will be applying an innovative extraction process to recover the rare earths and scandium from the phosphate mineral apatite while also recovering the phosphate for other applications including crop specific fertiliser products. There are undoubtedly other similar opportunities where alkaline intrusive-hosted mineral deposits including nepheline syenites were developed for one traditional commodity, or even used as aggregate, where rare earths and other rare elements may now be looked at as opportunities to extract critical minerals from the wastes. The time has come to establish the circular economy for rare earth supply chains, while also facilitating the development of the clean technologies needed to achieve a future low carbon economy.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Defo

Afforestation happens now --- proves growth can create opportunity for environmental goals

Amaechi 23 Lead content writer at EnvironmentGo Providence Amaechi “Top 25 Examples of Afforestation Projects Globally” January 20, 2023 environmentgo (https://environmentgo.com/afforestation-projects/#Conclusion)

An increasing catastrophe caused by humans is deforestation. An area nearly twice the size of Wales, or over 47,000 km2, of the forest is destroyed every year. In actuality, the Amazon rainforest has lost 17% of its area just in the last 50 years. A description of deforestation. Afforestation, as opposed to reforestation, is the planting of trees in areas where there have never been any woods. In essence, it involves creating new forests where none previously existed or may have done so for many millennia. This has numerous advantages, including boosting biodiversity, generating jobs, and removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. The three main methods for doing this are agroforestry, silviculture, and natural regeneration. Some countries, such as China, and global initiatives, such as the Great Green Wall, are using afforestation to improve the lives of their citizens and prevent their land from becoming desert. The Vikings cut down trees in Iceland many years ago. To strengthen the health of its ecosystems, Iceland is now looking into how to include afforestation programs in land management. Table of Contents Top 25 Examples of Afforestation Projects Globally 1. The World Economic Forum’s Trillion Trees Initiative 2. The Bonn Challenge – Global Effort To Restore 350 Hectares of Forest by 2030 3. Ethiopia’s Green Legacy Initiative – 350 million Trees in Just One Day 4. Ecosia – Planting Trees One Web Search at a Time 5. The Nature Conservancy – Planting One Billion Trees 6. The World Land Trust – Helping Reforest Our Planet 7. One Tree Planted – Restoration Partner of the United States Forestry Service 8. Sustainable Tree-Based Food Production Systems – World Agroforestry 9. Ecosystem Restoration Camps – the Movement To Restore the Earth 10. International Tree Foundation – Tree Planting and Capacity Building 11. Plant to Stop Poverty, Tanzania 12. Sacred Seeds Garden, Colombia 13. La Pedregoza, Colombia 14. Daintree Life Revegetation, Australia 15. Sowing Water, Brazil 16. One Tree Matters, Australia 17. Amazon Windshields, Bolivia 18. Recover the Mediterranean Diversity, Spain 19. Usambara Biodiversity Conservation, Tanzania 20. Alvelal, Spain 21. Reforest the Mata Atlântica, Brazil 22. Agroforesterie et Boisement, France 23. Bore, Kenya 24. Reforest the Amazon Basin, Brazil 25. Community Tree Planting, United Kingdom Conclusion Recommendations Providence Amaechi Top 25 Examples of Afforestation Projects Globally 1. The World Economic Forum’s Trillion Trees Initiative One of the biggest reforestation programs currently in action is the Trillion Trees Initiative. Governments, corporations, members of civic society, and ecopreneurs have joined forces to build a common platform for the forestry community. It unites and supports a wide range of organizations doing their part to restore our planet by planting trees. Through this platform, everyone in the area who is interested in planting trees can collaborate with others working toward the same or related objectives, including the Global Partnership on Forest and Landscape Restoration, the UN Decade of Ecosystem Restoration, and the Bonn Challenge (see below). 2. The Bonn Challenge – Global Effort To Restore 350 Hectares of Forest by 2030 Another significant tree-planting program is the Bonn Challenge, which aims to restore 350 million hectares of forest by 2030. This project was started by the IUCN and the German government. The 2014 UN Climate Summit, it was later supported and expanded by the New York Declaration on Forests. There have been 172.35 million hectares pledged thus far. Under the Bonn Challenge, numerous nations made lofty commitments, and many of them have already made notable strides toward fulfilling those promises. To find out more about the promises made and the inspiring success stories of tree planting that resulted from them, click the link below. 3. Ethiopia’s Green Legacy Initiative – 350 million Trees in Just One Day The Bonn Challenge and other similar efforts have helped many nations achieve great things, and Ethiopia’s Green Legacy Initiative appears to be a significant addition. Launched last May, this program is an attempt to tackle climate change and environmental deterioration. Although we are unable to confirm the precise quantity of trees planted (by an estimated 23 million participants), it is evident that numerous trees were planted. The previous world record for the most trees planted in a single day was likely surpassed by this campaign in Uttar Pradesh, India, in 2016, when more than 800,000 people planted 50 million trees. Even though it is unclear exactly how many trees were planted, it is obvious that Ethiopia is making remarkable progress in forestry. The government of Ethiopia set a goal to plant 4 billion trees by the end of last year. 4. Ecosia – Planting Trees One Web Search at a Time Since its 2009 founding, the web search engine Ecosia has planted approximately 86 million trees. Ecosia uses the money generated by the 15 million active users of its search engine to plant trees. They have a number of effective restoration initiatives underway all around the world and hope to plant a billion native trees. Working with local partners who keep an eye on trees planted in the ground, Ecosia supports over 20 tree-planting programs in 15 different countries. They concentrate on planting in places with high biodiversity and where people want them. 5. The Nature Conservancy – Planting One Billion Trees The Nature Conservancy’s “Plant a Billion Trees” initiative is another large-scale effort to combat deforestation and slow climate change. For more amazing tree-planting initiatives supported by donations from this campaign in Africa, China, and the Americas, see this site. 6. The World Land Trust – Helping Reforest Our Planet More than 2 million trees have been planted thanks to funding from the World Land Trust. Many people are contributing to the restoration of forests that have been lost to deforestation by planting trees with the World Land Trust. The World Land Trust collaborates with a network of local conservation partners to safeguard important habitats and reforest lands that have been cleared for development. Take a look at, for instance, their efforts in the Atlantic Forest of Brazil. 7. One Tree Planted – Restoration Partner of the United States Forestry Service Over 4 million trees have been planted by One Tree Planted in 18 nations and four worldwide areas. In North America, 1.2 million in Africa, 465,000 in Asia, and 423,000 in South America, they have planted more than 1.8 million trees. They intend to plant more than 6 million additional trees in 2020. They now collaborate with other organizations and are a recognized United States Forest Service (USFS) partner in reforestation. 8. Sustainable Tree-Based Food Production Systems – World Agroforestry Agroforestry and related techniques are promoted by World Agroforestry, a research and development hub. Governments, development organizations, local communities, and farmers can use the knowledge shared by ICRAF to harness the power of trees to make farming and livelihoods more environmentally, economically, and socially sustainable at all scales. They run six regional programs throughout Sub-Saharan Africa, Asia, and Latin America from their headquarters in Nairobi, Kenya. Additionally, World Agroforestry carries out research in over 30 other developing nations. Agroforestry knowledge educates and supports a wide range of agroforestry programs around the world, helping to increase tree cover and regreen degraded land. 9. Ecosystem Restoration Camps – the Movement To Restore the Earth There are hundreds of members in this Dutch non-profit organization, Ecosystem Restoration Camps, representing more than 30 different nations. One million individuals coming together to rehabilitate degraded areas in 100 ecosystem restoration camps throughout the world by 2030 is their main objective. Visit their website to observe the incredible tree planting taking place at the current camps. Additionally, you can discover more about the worldwide emergence of seedling camps. 10. International Tree Foundation – Tree Planting and Capacity Building A philanthropic organization called the International Tree Foundation manages tree-planting initiatives in the UK and Africa. For the sake of the future of our world and human life, they support a variety of community-led programs that establish and encourage forests and trees. In 2019, they planted close to 500,000 trees. Undoubtedly, there are a lot more amazing tree-planting initiatives. Many of them concentrate on a specific area. They have extremely defined goals, such as reforesting a country, recovering the Amazon, providing food, and increasing community resilience. Whether we’re talking about a single, modest plantation or millions of trees, millions of people around the world are having a significant impact. 11. Plant to Stop Poverty, Tanzania The Plant to Stop Poverty project employs an integrated strategy to advise and assist poor communities in rural areas in using agroforestry to combat persistent poverty and the effects of climate change. While forests are restored and conserved through tree planting, this way of generating food and revenue ensures security. In past programs in several districts, we have planted more than 140.000 trees. 12. Sacred Seeds Garden, Colombia This project entails establishing a botanical garden in the Orinoco River basin to preserve its traditional medicinal trees and plants. It is located on a 16-hectare block of land inside a natural reserve. The Missouri Botanical Gardens in the United States are working on the project.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Pollution

China proves growth Is key and carbon tax is the next step for emission and air pollution reduction

MCAFEE 20 Andrew Paul McAfee, a principal research scientist at MIT, is cofounder and codirector of the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy at the MIT Sloan School of Management. He studies how digital technologies are changing the world “Why Degrowth Is the Worst Idea on the Planet” OCT 6, 2020 ANDREW MCAFEE wired () caddo SV

China's progress with air pollution is heartening, but it's not surprising to most economists. It's a clear example of the environmental Kuznets curve (EKC) in action. Named for the economist Simon Kuznets, EKC posits a relationship between a country's affluence and the condition of its environment. As GDP per capita rises from an initial low level, so too does environmental damage; but as affluence continues to increase, the harms level off and then start to decline. The EKC is clearly visible in the pollution histories of today's rich countries, and it's now taking shape in China and elsewhere. Also consider air pollution death rates around the world. As the invaluable website Our World in Data puts it, “Rates have typically fallen across high-income countries: almost everywhere in Europe, but also in Canada, the United States, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, Israel and South Korea and other countries. But rates have also fallen across upper-middle income countries too, including China and Brazil. In low and lower-middle income countries, rates have increased over this period.” The EKC is a direct refutation of a core idea of degrowth: that environmental harms must always rise as populations and economies do. It's not surprising that today's degrowth advocates rarely discuss the large reductions in air and water pollution that have accompanied higher prosperity in so many places around the world. Instead, degrowthers now focus heavily on one kind of pollution: greenhouse gas emissions. The claims made are familiar ones: that any apparent reductions in greenhouse gas emissions in rich countries are due to offshoring rather than actual decarbonization. Thanks to the Global Carbon Project, we can see if this is the case. GCP has calculated “consumption-based emissions” for many countries going back to 1990, taking into account imports and exports, yielding the greenhouse gas emissions embodied in all the goods and services consumed in each country each year. For several of the world's richest countries, including Germany, Italy, France, the UK, and the US, graphs of consumption-based carbon emissions follow the familiar EKC. The US, for example, has reduced its total (not per capita) consumption-based CO2 emissions by more than 13 percent since 2007. These reductions are not mainly due to enhanced regulation. Instead, they've come about because of a combination of tech progress and market forces. Solar and wind power have become much cheaper in recent years and have displaced coal for electricity generation. Natural gas, which when burned emits fewer greenhouse gases per unit of energy than does coal (even after taking methane leakage into account), has also become much cheaper and more abundant in the US as a result of the fracking revolution. To ensure that these greenhouse gas declines continue to spread and accelerate, we should apply the lessons we've learned from previous pollution reduction success. In particular, we should make it expensive to emit carbon, then watch the emitters work hard to reduce this expense. The best way to do this is with a carbon dividend, which is a tax on carbon emissions where the revenues are not kept by the government but instead are rebated to people as a dividend. William Nordhaus won the 2018 Nobel Prize in economics in part for his work on the carbon dividend, and an open letter advocating its implementation in the US has been signed by more than 3,500 economists. It's an idea whose time has come.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – A2s › 2AC/1AR – A2 Pollution

Developed countries have reduced air pollution without offshoring or degrowth proves growth solves

MCAFEE 20 Andrew Paul McAfee, a principal research scientist at MIT, is cofounder and codirector of the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy at the MIT Sloan School of Management. He studies how digital technologies are changing the world “Why Degrowth Is the Worst Idea on the Planet” OCT 6, 2020 ANDREW MCAFEE wired () caddo SV

In some important areas, however, a very different pattern emerged after 1970: Growth continued, but environmental harm decreased. This decoupling occurred first with pollution, and first in the rich world. In the US, for example, aggregate levels of six common air pollutants have declined by 77 percent, even as gross domestic product increased by 285 percent and population by 60 percent. In the UK, annual tonnage of particulate emissions dropped by more than 75 percent between 1970 and 2016, and of the main polluting chemicals by about 85 percent. Similar gains are common across the highest-income countries. How were these reductions achieved? The two possibilities are cleanup and offshoring. Either rich countries figured out how to reduce their “air pollution per dollar” so much that overall pollution went down even as their economies grew, or they sent so much of their dirty production overseas that the air at home got cleaner. The first of these paths reduces the total burden of human-caused pollution; the second just rearranges it. The evidence is overwhelming that rich countries cleaned up their air pollution much more than they outsourced it. For one, a great deal of air pollution comes from highway vehicles and power plants, and rich countries haven’t outsourced driving and generating electricity to low-income ones. In fact, high-income countries haven't even offshored most of their industry. The US and UK both manufacture more than they did 50 years ago (at least until the Covid-19 pandemic sharply reduced output), and Germany has been a net exporter since 2000 while continuing to drive down air pollution. The rest of the world has been exporting its manufacturing pollution to Germany (to use degrowthers’ phrasing), yet Germans are breathing cleaner air than they were 20 years ago. Rich countries have reduced their air pollution not by embracing degrowth or offshoring, but instead by enacting and enforcing smart regulation. As economists Joseph Shapiro and Reed Walker concluded in a 2018 study about the US, “changes in environmental regulation, rather than changes in productivity and trade, account for most of the emissions reductions.” Research about the cleanup of US waters also concludes that well-designed and enforced regulations have successfully reduced pollution.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Misc Extra

Economic growth benefits the poor by raising incomes and boosting mobility

Geloso 23 [Vincent Geloso is an Assistant Professor of Economics at George Mason University, earned a Ph.D. in economic history from the London School of economics; “Why Economic Growth is good for the Poor”; Montreal Economic Institute; 7/1/23; https://www.iedm.org/why-economic-growth-is-good-for-the-poor/]

It is popular in certain circles to attack the very idea of economic growth. This series of brief studies examines some common misconceptions behind these attacks. One criticism sometimes made is that economic growth often leaves the poor behind. The assumption is that the fruits of economic growth are disproportionately enjoyed by the rich. However, the evidence for such a claim is weak. Economic growth does tend to benefit the poor, especially in open economies. The belief that the poor do not benefit from growth was more prevalent before the rise of big data, which made it easy to assemble large data- sets (needed to estimate income distribution) for a large number of countries over long periods of time. It has also become easier and easier to access the data produced by multiple sources. As a result, several efforts have been made to assess the validity of the claim that the gains from growth are not well-distributed. The first such large study was carried out by two economists from the World Bank in 2002. Using data for 93 countries from 1950 to 1999, they found that a 1% increase in average incomes was associated with roughly a 1% increase in the income of the average person in the poorest 20% of the population.2 A 2016 study replicated and up- dated their results, this time for 121 countries. Their findings again suggest that the poor benefit from economic growth as much as the average person does Figure 1 uses the available distributional data regarding the growth of income per capita and growth of income per person in the poorest 10% of the population for 113 countries between 2000 and 2015.4 The horizontal axis indicates the growth rate of average incomes during the period, while the vertical axis indicates the growth rate of average incomes for the poorest 10% of the population. The diagonal line depicts a one-for-one relation- ship, whereby the poor would benefit exactly as much as the average person. A point below that line represents a country where average incomes grew faster than incomes for the poorest 10%, while a point above the line means incomes for the poor grew faster than average incomes in that country. As can be observed, most points are clustered around the line. This suggests that most countries enjoyed comparable growth Income growth, average vs. poorest 10%, 113 countries, 2000-2015 Income growth for poorest 10% Viewpoint – Why Economic Growth Is Good for the Poor across the income distribution, and growth was essentially inclusive. Some researchers, though, have found that the relationship is not one-for-one.5 However, even here, the claim is not that the poor do not benefit from economic growth, merely that they do not benefit as much as the average person (or the very rich). Other studies show that increases in economic freedom are associated with increases in income at all decile levels.6 But they find that the gains are larger in the higher income deciles, so that the share of income that goes to the poorer slices of the population falls.7 Every decile thus enjoys higher incomes, but not proportionally so. At first glance, this seems to suggest that the growth generated by economically free societies tends to favour richer individuals more (albeit without hurting the poor). First glances, however, can be deceiving, and this result is contested in the literature.8 Moreover, individuals do not necessarily stay in the same deciles over time. In fact, there is substantial movement between deciles. Statistics Canada has been tracking workers over five-year win- dows since 1982. In the latest window, from 2015 to 2020, we see for example that Quebecers who were in the poorest decile in 2015 ended up on average in the third decile in 2020.9 Moreover, workers enter (youths taking a first job, immigrants) and leave (older individuals retiring or dying) the income datasets. For an accurate picture, we must take into account movements be- tween deciles over time, as well as entries and exits from the data. How can we make sure that the poor benefit from economic growth? The answer boils down to the role of economic policy and the importance of promoting economic freedom (which is to say: limited government regulation, small government, strong property rights, open trade, and sound money). There are studies that test the extent to which in- come mobility—movements along the income ladder, from one decile to another—increases both directly and indirectly with greater economic freedom. Mobility increases directly because of the absence of government hurdles.10 It increases indirectly because freedom promotes economic growth, which matters more to expanding the choices available to the poorest families—choices such as acquiring new skills, accessing capital to start businesses, etc.11 Both channels matter, but when compared, the indirect effect matters far more.12 By stimulating income growth for all, economic freedom allows the poor to rise far above the socio-economic conditions into which they were born. As such, the poor benefit more from economic freedom and growth because it gives them more chances to lift themselves up. Simply put, one cannot disentangle the institutions that generate economic growth from those that generate improved opportunities for the poor to rise up above their conditions at birth.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Misc Extra

Growth means greater environmental protection through green jobs and infrastructure

Mountford and Jaeger 17 [Helen Mountford is the President and CEO of ClimateWorks foundation and was VP for Climate and Economics at the World Resources Institute (WRI). Joel Jaeger is a Senior Research Associate for WRI’s Systems Change Lab and Climate Program; “America Doesn’t have to Choose Between the Economy and the Climate”; 7/1/23; https://www.wri.org/insights/america-doesnt-have-choose-between-economy-and-climate]

But it’s not just about preventing risks. Climate action can actively benefit the economy, according to new work from the New Climate Economy. The key drivers of economic growth – resource efficiency, infrastructure investment and innovation – can be harnessed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It’s a logical connection: a more efficient economy is a more productive economy, and a more efficient economy also emits less carbon. The economic case for climate action is only becoming stronger as time goes on and the costs of clean energy and other technologies continue to drop. Since 2008, the cost of utility-scale solar energy in the United States has fallen 64 percent and the cost of wind energy has fallen 41 percent, making them increasingly cost-competitive with traditional fossil fuel power, even without subsidies. Even without considering the air pollution and climate benefits, clean energy makes economic sense. Many U.S. states are already proving that it is possible to have a strong economy and a strong environment. Thirty-three states and the District of Columbia expanded their economies while reducing energy-related carbon emissions from 2000 to 2014, according to Brookings. This includes red states like Kentucky, Alaska and Georgia, as well as blue states like California, New York and Massachusetts. This is an economic issue, not a political one. As a whole, from 2000 to 2015, the United States grew its GDP by 30 percent while reducing its energy-related emissions by 10 percent. Beyond economic growth, climate action can also have positive impacts on employment. Solar and wind are among the most dynamic industries in the nation. In 2016, the solar industry created one out of every 50 new jobs in the United States. Wind turbine technicians are expected to be the fastest-growing occupation over the next 10 years. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, there are already 374,000 American jobs in solar energy, 102,000 in wind energy and more than 2.2 million related to energy efficiency. For comparison, 160,000 Americans work in coal. The solar and wind jobs are spread out from coast to coast, including concentrations in the Midwest and Southwest. Boosting investment in sustainable infrastructure would create even more jobs, as well as close the massive infrastructure deficit in the United States. Risky Business has found that investing in a clean energy transition would create roughly 460,000 additional construction jobs by 2030. The number of coal mining and oil- and gas-related jobs would decline by more than 130,000 by 2030, but the net effect on U.S. employment would be positive. Of course, for those Americans who do lose their jobs through the energy transition, the net job gains are little consolation, especially if they take place in other communities or states. The critical role of government is not to hold back the transition when it brings jobs and growth, but instead to manage it carefully. A just transition will be essential as economic activity shifts, with strong support for displaced workers, affected communities and low-income households through retraining and economic diversification. While it may be tempting to try to prop up the ailing coal industry, in the end it is only a very expensive way to delay the inevitable transition. Market forces have made it clear that coal just isn’t coming back. It’s better to diversify local economies away from coal while providing assistance to local communities during the transition, ensuring they remain vibrant for decades to come, not just for a few more years.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Misc Extra

Degrowth stunts green innovation and lowers agricultural yields

Chambers 21 [Collin L. Chambers is a Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Syracuse University; “Degrowth: An Environmental Ideology with Good Intentions, Bad Politics”; Liberation School; 7/1/23; https://www.liberationschool.org/degrowth-a-politics-for-which-class/]

Proponents of degrowth argue that there are absolute “planetary limits” and a fixed “carrying capacity” that cannot be surpassed by humans if we want to avoid ecological collapse. This is not only pessimistic in that it dismisses the idea that, under socialism, we could figure out new sustainable ways to grow, but it’s also completely devoid of class analysis. There’s no distinction between socially-produced limits and natural limits. Degrowth is anti-modern, anti-technological, and anti-large scale production and infrastructure. Kallis argues that “only social systems of limited size and complexity can be governed directly rather than by technocratic elites acting on behalf of the populace… Many degrowth advocates, therefore, oppose even ‘green’ megastructures like high-speed trains or industrial-scale wind farms[!]” [13]. The same can be said about degrowth solutions to the problems the capitalist agricultural system creates. Proponents of degrowth propose small scale (both urban and rural) methods of agriculture production to replace industrial-scale agriculture. They, in fact, glorify and romanticize “peasant economies.” Despite the problems of capitalist industrial agriculture, there are two main benefits of industrial-scale agriculture. First, it has drastically increased yields. At the present moment, there is enough food produced to feed 11 billion people. Second, industrial farming has thoroughly decreased the backbreaking labor needed for agricultural and food production. In 1790, 90 percent of the U.S. workforce labored on farms. In 1900, it was 35 percent At the present moment, only one percent of the U.S. workforce works on farms [14]. Certainly, in any just society we would want to spread out food production more evenly amongst the population. But getting rid of industrial-scale agriculture and reverting to small-scale peasant and small landowner agriculture would require massive numbers of workers to go back to the land and perform backbreaking agricultural work. Such a transformation would inevitably reduce agricultural yield substantially, increasing the possibility of food insecurity and hunger among vast swathes of the population. And what would we do with the commodities and infrastructure we’d have to destroy to create such plots of land? Moreover, such a vision necessitates the redistribution of land from private ownership of large landholders. Is this achieved through revolution or through governmental reforms? In either case, if we’re struggling to reclaim land then why not broaden our horizons and redistribute land in the interests of the environment and the people, including Indigenous and other oppressed nations in the U.S.? Degrowth is, furthermore, idealist and divorced from the material reality within which U.S. workers currently live. Matt Huber, a Marxist environmental geographer, argues that a “truly humane society must commit to relieving the masses from agricultural labor,” and that we cannot act as if “small-scale agricultural systems are much of a ‘material basis’ for a society beyond industrial capitalism” [15]. This is not to say that small-scale and urban farming are undesirable, but that they’re insufficient in a country like the U.S. The Cuban model of urban farming and agriculture–which is a heroic achievement of the Cuban Revolution–can’t simply be mapped onto this country or the rest of the world. Additionally, we shouldn’t forgo modern technologies that already exist just because they are “large scale” or because they currently contribute to environmental degradation within capitalist society. Doing so would in effect produce more ecological waste! In an important piece on capitalism and ecology, Ernest Mandel writes: “it is simply not true that modern industrial technology is inevitably geared towards destroying the environmental balance. The progress of the exact sciences opens up a very wide range of technical possibilities” [16]. Increased rates of pollution and environmental degradation occur because capitalists pursue profits at the expense of the environment, not because of the technologies themselves. Socialists have to distinguish between instruments of production and their use under capitalism.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Misc Extra

Degrowth fails to mitigate climate change and leaves economy vulnerable

Naudé 3-23 [Wim Naudé is a quantitative development economist, Distinguished Visting Professor at the University of Johannesberg, South Africa, and a Visiting Professor in Technology, Innovation, Marketing, and Entrepeneurship at RWTH Aachen University, Germany; “Seven Reasons Why Degrowth is no Solution to the ecological crisis; Illuminem; 7/1/23; https://illuminem.com/illuminemvoices/seven-reasons-why-degrowth-is-no-solution-to-the-ecological-crisis]

Degrowthers diagnose a real problem. Unfortunately, the downsizing of western economies is not a solution. At least seven reasons can be highlighted why degrowth is insufficient. Most (63%) of current carbon emissions come from developing countries - where it will only continue to increase in the foreseeable future. The 2022 Emissions Gap Report notes (p. 67) that “virtually the entire future increase in global primary energy demand is expected to occur in these [developing] economies.” Even if western economies are shrunk, they would still be extensive and emit significant carbon. Degrowth may be dirty. Global redistribution, as degrowthers envisage, will increase aggregate consumption through a well-known "growth through redistribution" effect. Inequality reduces economic growth, hence the opposite will raise growth. Businesses may substitute more expensive cleaner production techniques for cheaper but more polluting technologies. Governments would also not be able to borrow further to spend on social and basic needs or environmental protection. Because of the endowment effect, who propose people would be unlikely to vote for politicians lowering their levels of GDP per capita, especially in certain countries, at least if it is to fight climate change. A 2022 poll found that only 1% of USA voters listed climate change as the most crucial challenge. And politicians, being generally subject to a status quo bias, would be reluctant to propose such a radical policy. As proponents acknowledge “political parties that have put forward degrowth ideas have received limited support in elections.” Degrowth is not only politically infeasible because voters would not give up their incomes but also because it is a costly way to tackle the ecological crisis. It has been calculated that if the world shrinks GDP per capita by 10% (around US$7,000 billion), it will reduce carbon emissions by about 3.3 gigatons, meaning a cost of US$2,100 per ton of emissions. A recent study published in Nature put the social cost of carbon dioxide (SC-CO2) at US$185 per ton of emissions. Degrowthers want us to pay more than ten times the price. A recent inventory of degrowth policies identified 530 proposals associated with the movement. This proliferation is because the degrowth movement is “multi-faceted". It has become a rally-cry for anyone with a societal and environmental grievance, whether against capitalism, colonialism, patriarchy, or utilitarianism. Because of the confusion this proliferation creates, a recent paper prioritized these into an “Iceberg model of degrowth policy proposals." At the top of the iceberg, prominent policies are universal basic income, work-time reductions, job guarantees, maximum income caps, non-for-profit cooperation, eco-villages, and housing cooperatives. None of these are novel and most are, or have already been, implemented - most extensively in market economies. Furthermore, there is no attempt to link these policy proposals to decoupling - how many carbon emissions would they eliminate? How fast? No evidence is provided. The lack of evidence on the carbon reduction that the iceberg model of policies will achieve - and achieve soon, as the matter is pressing - is a concern. We would not imagine subjecting human populations to potentially dangerous experimental drugs without rigorously testing their efficacy. Why embrace the "medicine" prescribed by the degrowth movement? Olivier Simar-Casanova described this ethical and moral problem with degrowth clearly: “Global warming is a serious issue, and claiming to respond to it with solutions of uncertain carbon efficiency, which we do not know how to implement in practice, is irresponsible.” The dangers of shackling economies without any evidence as to the likely outcome are that it would leave the world much more exposed and vulnerable to shocks, make the adjustment to a zero-carbon-emitting economy , and raise the risk of conflict by turning the economy into a zero-sum game.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Misc Extra

Degrowth is economically and politically inviable and misunderstands capitalism

Bonilla 22 [Jesus Zomora Bonilla is Professor of Logic and Philosophy at Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia and a dean of the Faculty of Philosophy at UNED; “The Limits of Degrowth”; Mapping Ignorance; accessed 7/2/23; ; kate]

The second premise, that capitalism requires exponential economic growth, also hides several fallacies. The most important one is that the concept of capitalism that is used in it is nothing more than a conceptual wimp, one that, rather than help us understand how the economic system really works, is limited to accumulating without rhyme nor reason any of the aspects that many people dislike about the current economy (inequality, the existence of poor countries, globalization, the destruction of the environment, or the inauthenticity of consumerism). The truth is that our economic system has many features that it is appropriate to designate as “capitalist” (for example, that production is carried out mostly by private companies, that consumption and investment decisions are usually done in more or less free markets, that the search for profits is the main engine of companies, and that earning a lot of money, in general, is considered by almost everyone as one of their main objectives in life), but we must not forget that this same economic system also has many fundamental characteristics that make it absurd to consider it as a purely capitalist system (above all, the fact that in most advanced countries the state collects practically half of all private income in the form of taxes, provides numerous public services, employs directly or indirectly about a quarter or a fifth of the active population, and regulates almost all economic activities to a greater or lesser degree). When the preachers of degrowth tell us to end capitalism, it is often unclear exactly which of those things they think it necessary to end, although it seems reasonable to suspect that a project such as theirs, whose goal is to drastically impoverish almost everyone in the developed countries, it will be impossible to carry it out except with something very similar to an absolutely centralized management of almost all economic activities, and not only at the level of one state, but at the same time throughout all the world, that is, through a kind of world economic dictatorship. And, since it is also quite difficult to imagine that the vast majority of the population is willing to voluntarily advance along that path, it is also logical to suspect that a project such as degrowth would have no choice but to do without, not only “capitalism” but, what is much more important, without democracy itself. Convinced (like so many other visionaries throughout history) of the absolute sanctity of their ends, degrowthers stubbornly refuse to think seriously about the profound large-scale political infeasibility of their proposals and take refuge behind a wall of further fallacious arguments. For example, the argument that degrowth “is not an option”, but that we will have to go towards it “by hook or by crook”, that is, either by accepting it now and putting ourselves in its benevolent and wise hands or waiting for environmental collapse to come and suffer much worse consequences. But the truth is that , and, in any case, the current political-economic system is much more likely to allow us to circumvent the worst environmental problems and the possible lack of resources, than a kind of fanciful global degrowth dictatorship, one that deep down nobody knows how we could manage to make it work for more than a few weeks, nor do we have the slightest certainty that the attempt to institute it would not lead humanity to a global conflict infinitely more terrible than those of the past century. Lastly, another of the fallacies of degrowthers (like that of almost every totalitarian ideology) is to pretend that, in fact, true democracy is the one they intend to establish, since it would eliminate any accumulation of political and economic power by current oligopolies and would let the true voice of the people be heard for the first time, or anything like that. In addition, they often resort to the strategy of showing that, when an assembly is organized with ordinary citizens who can freely deliberate on these issues, the result tends to be that everyone ends up agreeing that on reducing energy consumption, restricting the use of private transport, limiting air travel, eliminating plastics, eating much less meat, stopping deforestation, and a long list of similar beautiful wishes. However, the fact that most people do not voluntarily follow these recommendations in their private lives, and that they prefer not to vote for parties that propose to make such measures mandatory, this fact does not seem to be able to convince degrowthers that what people supposedly “freely and reflectively agree” in those “Playmobil assemblies” (as I have called them elsewhere) is not what people really want and think, but only the result of subjecting a small group to the pressure of trying to show off as “good fellows” before officiants who present those dreams as the only possible moral truth.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Tsuda

c. Global follow-on is DOA.

Tsuda ‘21

[Kenta, University College London. 04/30/2021. “Naïve Questions on Degrowth”, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837997] pfox

Domestic policy is only the start. Degrowthers do not directly address the issue of international coordination, but presumably all large economies would need to contract in order to achieve the required material-throughput reductions. Degrowth in one country is a non-starter. International coordination of degrowth, however, threatens to reproduce the domestic coordination problem within the anarchic dynamics of inter-state politics, where economic magnitude comes armed with military power. It seems likely that every state will aim to maximize its relative position in a degrowth world—that is, to degrow the least relative to other nations. Recognizing this problem, powerful states will then aim to establish an international agreement—a Global Degrowth Pact, say—to constrain each other. The Pact would include mechanisms to monitor and punish defection. Pact members would settle on metrics against which national contraction could be measured. Where national statistics failed to conform to the degrowth schedule, punishment would kick in—escalating economic sanctions, for example.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Tsuda

b. “Fulfilling needs” is void-for-vagueness.

Tsuda ‘21

[Kenta, University College London. 04/30/2021. “Naïve Questions on Degrowth”, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837997] pfox

Degrowthers claim that desirable economic activity can be defined as fulfilling human needs. Since needs are finite, they argue, the economic activity required to meet them is finite too. The task of government is to foster need-satisfying activities and eliminate superfluous ones. But degrowthers provide no conclusive list of human needs—likely because such an account is not possible. Need is not a freestanding category; it is dependent upon other conditions of ethical or social flourishing. Some needs, under that label or another, are uncontroversial: everyone can agree a human being should have food, shelter, healthcare, a baseline education, association with amiable fellow humans. One can broaden out from this—freedom of conscience, capacity for self- expression, privacy, a qualified freedom of expression. But a needs-based theory is not doing much work in defining these entitlements, and effectively every universalist political theory is agreed on them.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Offense › 2AC – Tsuda

a. Sectoral discrimination is impossible to manage.

Tsuda ‘21

[Kenta, University College London. 04/30/2021. “Naïve Questions on Degrowth”, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837997] pfox

To mitigate the suffering, degrowthers universally insist on a policy of ‘controlled’ or ‘managed’ contraction. With economic reduction carefully engineered, the degrowther regime would coordinate public remediation of unemployment, homelessness, hunger and other privations, as society shifted down to the optimal level of material throughput. Central to the plan would be an industrial policy of sectoral—or perhaps, inter-firm—discrimination. Socially beneficial (and thus environmentally tolerable) enterprises would be allowed to expand, while detrimental ones might be targeted for direct shutdown. The result would be localized pockets of growth—providing jobs, tax revenue, innovation—within a contracting aggregate economy. Without any clear administrative proposals from degrowthers to go on, let us imagine that the regime might use the tax code: start with a rebuttable presumption of harm and impose tax penalties if a firm reports net growth. Firms that can prove their contribution to the public interest would qualify for a license to grow, or exemption from the tax penalties. Alternatively, the regime could authorize a government agency to identify socially undesirable firms and place them into something like a receivership for orderly wind-down.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Sustainability › 2AC – Growth Sus + Good

Degrowth slows innovation and holds us back from solving climate change

Katz 22 Richard Katz is editor-in-chief of The Oriental Economist Report (TOE) and a former Carnegie Council Senior Fellow for the Asia Dialogues program. “’Degrowth’ shrinks the fight against climate change“ 1 November 2022 east asia forum Richard Katz(https://www.eastasiaforum.org/2022/11/01/degrowth-shrinks-the-fight-against-climate-change/)

The problem with capitalism, Saito contends, is that it worships economic growth. The problem with growth, he claims, is that it inevitably brings on ecological disasters. While Karl Marx claimed that, under socialism, growth would create abundance galore while still protecting nature, Saito is part of a group of academics calling themselves Marxist, but who have rewritten Marx as if he were a Malthusian. Marx’s real complaint about capitalism was his belief that capitalism would inevitably put a fetter on growth while harming workers and nature. In reality, global per capita GDP has increased fourfold over the last 70 years. The solution to the problems created by growth is even more growth and further technological progress. Consider the nearly three billion people who rely on animal dung and wood to cook and heat their homes. A firewood stove generates 100 times more emissions than one fuelled by natural gas. The biggest growth in emissions comes from countries that are neither poor nor rich but are in transition. Once countries get rich, carbon emissions tend to slow and eventually decline. In Japan, the United States and Europe, carbon dioxide emissions rose in tandem with GDP during their transition to affluence. But in the 1970s, carbon dioxide emissions in Japan slowed, then flattened out and finally started falling in the past decade, even as GDP kept rising. Japan’s 2019 emissions were 15 per cent below 2007 levels. A similar trend of falling emissions can be seen in the United States, Europe and China. In the United States, emissions in 2019 were 16 per cent below those of 2007. In Europe, carbon dioxide emissions peaked in 1980 and fell 30 per cent by 2019. The decline in China began a decade ago, but it’s too early to be sure this trend will last. While the arc of development bends toward greener energy, these natural processes do not move speedily enough to avoid catastrophe. They need to be accelerated by government policies. Fortunately, support for green policies rises with per capita GDP. Once a population’s basic survival needs are satisfied, voters have the economic means and the political desire to reduce pollution and conquer climate change. For example, Japan’s famous ‘Pollution Diet’ in 1970 — a session of parliament dominated by concerns over pollution — passed a series of strong pollution laws under pressure from the public. In China, citizen outrage has compelled the government in Beijing to halve the city’s air pollution from its level in 2013, raising life expectancy. Today, half the world’s population lives in countries where it now costs less to build and operate new wind or solar plants than to operate existing coal or gas-fired power plants, let alone build anew. With each passing year, the cost advantage of renewables is growing. The poorest countries can shift from dung and firewood directly to renewables, bypassing the carbon-intensive phases of coal, oil and gas required by past generations. More developed countries can afford to phase out fossil fuels. That is already beginning to happen. In 2020, renewables supplied more than 80 per cent of global growth in electric capacity. But the pace of the energy transition sometimes depends as much on a country’s politics as on its level of development. The European Union is halfway toward the elimination of coal by 2030. While China is still increasing its use of coal, it has also increased solar and wind from 5 per cent of its electricity output in 2011 to 24 per cent in 2020. During the same period, renewables’ share of the energy supply in India rose from 7 per cent to 18 per cent. In contrast, Japan has tripled its reliance on coal for electricity generation since 1985. Although renewable energy prices are falling in Japan, they are still among the highest in the world for political reasons. For example, the price of land for solar and wind farms is high because Japan’s regulations restrict the use of even abandoned farmland. Saito and other ‘degrowthers’ retort that this partnership between growth and greener energy is temporary. Even without climate change, they contend there is still an absolute limit to resources. But what counts as a resource is technologically-determined. In the 19th century, people feared running out of firewood and predicted that city streets would be covered in disease-spreading horse manure. The firewood shortage was solved by coal and eventually by oil. The horse manure malady ended with the rise of automobiles. The real danger is not that any country will adopt degrowth policies but rather that by discrediting environmentalism, the degrowth movement could undermine efforts to defeat climate change.

2023 UTNIF Evidence
Aff › 2AC/1AR – Sustainability › 2AC – Growth Sus + Good

Growth is key to fighting poverty – economic degrowth fails

Zimet 22 [Saul Zimet is a graduate student at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice at the City University of New York. He was a Hazlitt Fellow at the Foundation for Economic Education; “Why Economic Degrowth is Terrible for Everyone – Especially the Poor”; Foundation for Economic Education; 7/1/23; https://fee.org/articles/why-economic-degrowth-is-terrible-for-everyone-especially-the-poor/]

University of Oxford economist Max Roser has that the number of people in extreme poverty has fallen by roughly 137,000 individuals every single day for the past 25 years. That’s over a billion people—more people than there were on Earth just. This miraculous occurrence has been called “the most important fact about wellbeing in the world since World War II” by the Nobel Prize winning Princeton University economist Angus Deaton in his book. And as CNN host and Washington Post columnist Fareed Zakaria has, these data indicate that more people have escaped extreme poverty in the last fifty years than had done so in the preceding five hundred. Harvard University cognitive scientist Steven Pinker notes in his 2018 book that if this trend were to continue, the extreme poverty rate would reach zero by the year 2026. The COVID-19 pandemic and lockdowns set the global economy back a few years, but the virtual end of extreme poverty remains broadly within reach, which is an unprecedented circumstance to be in as a species. As Deaton and Pinker delineate in their aforementioned books, and as Harvard University Department of Economics chairman Benjamin M. Friedman explains in his book, improving the material fortunes of the poor causes their physical health, educational opportunities, life expectancies, safety from violence, trust in their neighbors, and countless other standards of living to improve. As Pinker writes, “Though it’s easy to sneer at national income as a shallow and materialistic measure, it correlates with every indicator of human flourishing.” Notably, those brought out of extreme , which have mostly been in places like China and India, were largely not helped by massive social programs but by a growing global market for their labor. If redistribution of pre-existing wealth were the cause of this phenomenon, then the reduction in extreme poverty would have been accompanied by a reduction in extreme wealth in some other subset of the population. To the contrary, there is no significant demographic with massive losses to match those massive gains. Rather, as Americans and other denizens of wealthy countries have become, their increased demand for overseas labor has brought people from farms to factories, from factories to office parks, and so on. That has been made possible by gross world product since 1990. This widespread growth has been unfolding ever since it began around the time of the industrial revolution, which is why of the human population lived in extreme poverty throughout all of human history before 1800, and why less than 10 percent live in extreme poverty today. It was economic growth, not redistribution programs, that has brought the masses out of extreme poverty like never before in human history. George Mason University economist Tyler Cowen explains in a Foreign Affairs that, “In the medium to long term, even small changes in growth rates have significant consequences for living standards. An economy that grows at one percent doubles its average income approximately every 70 years, whereas an economy that grows at three percent doubles its average income about every 23 years—which, over time, makes a big difference in people’s lives.” To concretize this point, Cowen proposes a thought experiment in his book: “Redo U.S. history, but assume the country’s economy had grown one percentage point less each year between 1870 and 1990. In that scenario, the United States of 1990 would be no richer than the Mexico of 1990.” It is not just wealthy Americans that would be worse off in such a scenario—the lower and middle classes of Mexico are much worse off than the lower and middle classes of the United States, and this is largely a function of the general success of each country’s economy. In political and economic discourse today, there are two major strategies being proposed to alleviate poverty. One strategy is to redistribute wealth from those who have a lot, the most economically powerful members of society, to those who don’t, the most economically weak members of society. This zero-sum strategy is virtually destined to fail because it requires making enemies of the most economically powerful members of society, who are definitionally both incentivized and empowered to prevent the redistribution. This is largely why every major socialist experiment in history has resulted in some elite class taking control and enriching themselves to the enormous detriment of the lower classes. The other strategy is to increase the abundance of wealth so much that an ever-expanding portion of the population can afford to meet their needs. This positive-sum strategy is built on economic growth. Just like increasing the supply of apples causes their price to come down, increasing the supply of wealth reduces the barriers to earning enough resources to get your needs met in a market economy. As others become wealthier, they will be willing and able to pay more for your labor. And as the economy grows, more technological and scientific progress can be funded, which eventually increases the capabilities of the. Instead of making enemies out of the economic elite, this strategy makes allies out of them, which means it is far more likely to succeed in practice. And as we have seen, unlike any other strategy ever attempted, this has already proven effective at a global scale for reducing poverty and improving the human condition in other ways through technological and scientific progress. In the fullness of time, even a small change in the economic growth rate means the difference between starvation and survival for millions or billions of people, not to mention humanity’s extinction and its ability to fund enough technological progress to eventually become sustainably multiplanetary. The critics of growth are wrong about, but they’re also wrong to downplay its role in the fight against poverty. If winning that fight is indeed their goal, policymakers should put reversing America’s dismal growth trend near the top of their priority list.