Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Infrastructure Good

Card

Arnsperger and Varoufakisv 2006 - University of Louvain, Belgium and University of Athens, Greece

Christian Arnsperger and Yanis Varoufakis “What Is Neoclassical Economics?

The three axioms responsible for its theoretical oeuvre, practical irrelevance and, thus, discursive power” Panoeconomicus, 2006, 1, pp. 5-18

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Infrastructure Good

Card

Arnsperger and Varoufakisv 2006 - University of Louvain, Belgium and University of Athens, Greece

Christian Arnsperger and Yanis Varoufakis “What Is Neoclassical Economics?

The three axioms responsible for its theoretical oeuvre, practical irrelevance and, thus, discursive power” Panoeconomicus, 2006, 1, pp. 5-18

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Infrastructure Good

Green Infrastructure has been consistent with neoclassical economics–a new viewpoint on Green Infrastructure that integrates science, economics, and social policy ensures efficient and appropriate transfers of values.

Jones et al. 15 - Roger Jones is a research fellow at the Victoria Institute of Strategic Economic Studies at Victoria University in Melbourne. [Jones, R. N., Symons, J. and Young, C. K. (2015) Assessing the Economic Value of Green Infrastructure: Green Paper. Climate Change Working Paper No. 24. Victoria Institute of Strategic Economic Studies, Victoria University, Melbourne, https://vuir.vu.edu.au/32085/1/assessing-economics-gi-green-paper-visesccwp24.pdf]GP

With neoclassical economics moving into the realm of manufactured capital, the transition to the production and consumption of goods and services and the assumption that this maximized utility for the individual, became the driving force for economic theory. This altered the focus on economics from assessing capital value to marginal value. The working assumptions of neoclassical economics are: 1. People have rational preferences between outcomes that can be identified and associated with monetary values. 2. Individuals maximize utility and firms maximize profits. 3. People act independently on the basis of full and relevant information. The downside of industrialisation was being felt through a loss to human health and welfare via soil, water and air pollution. The depletion of natural resources was also recognised as a key concern. This led to the concept of externalities and social costs (Coase, 1960). These were firstly addressed by government taxes and then by property rights that limited the right to pollute/deplete. The first generation of environmental economics that built onto these developments therefore was consistent with neoclassical economics. The limits explored by the Club of Rome (Meadows and Club of Rome, 1972) are more sophisticated than those of Malthus, and current rates of resource depletion are tracking the scenarios constructed in the early 1970s (Turner, 2008). The maturation of the science of ecology, combined with philosophical and mystical traditions valuing nature, led to the birth of ecological economics. The significant difference between environmental and ecological economics is where nature is placed. For environmental economics, relationships between the economy and nature are mainly economic. Ecological economics places the economy as being nested within the global environment with limited exchange between the economy and nature.

Under ecological economics, economic and ecological benefits are not considered to be readily interchangeable. Ecological valuation will also consider an opportunity cost if ecosystems services are removed by development. In the example above, an ecologically-weighted assessment would value the land at the price it would be sold for with the ecosystem intact, because the land could not be developed due to its conservation status. The basic principle is that if economic, environmental and social benefits are all considered to be of value to society, then these values would be more evenly weighted. A framework for valuing green infrastructure requires the integration of science, economics and social policy to ensure the efficient and appropriate transfer of values between the environment, society and the economy. To be implementable by local government, this needs to consider existing structures and future needs by taking into account current practices and how they are likely to evolve over time. Important information about values and benefits is also being obtained from local government and other key stakeholders on an ongoing basis so also needs to be considered.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Taxes Good – Tax Justice

Capitalism creates ‘tax justice’ which levels income inequality – progressive taxes are good broadly.

Picciotto, Sol, Socialism, Progressive Taxation, and the Fiscal State March 8, 2022. Picciotto, Sol: Socialism, Progressive Taxation and the Fiscal State (March 8, 2022). Pre-print version of the chapter ‘Marxism and Socialism: Progressive Taxation and Socialisation of Property’ in the book entitled The Political Philosophy of Taxation: A History from the Enlightenment to the Presen, Available at SSRN:  or  shl)

For over two centuries, since the emergence of capitalism, its socialist critics and opponents have advocated ‘progressive taxation’, as a means for transforming it to an egalitarian system, by replacing private with social or common ownership of the means of production. The term socialism originated due to its advocates’ support for this socialisation of ownership, while ‘communism’ generally came to refer to the type of society which was its aim; in the classic formulation: ‘socialism … is communism in course of construction’ (Bukharin and Preobrazhensky 1919, 334). This paper focuses on socialism in this sense, especially the strand developed by Marx and Engels and their followers, and while it discusses revisionism it does not deal with social-democratic theories that defend private ownership of the means of production.1 In the Communist Manifesto of 1848, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels included ‘a heavy progressive or graduated income tax’ as the second on their list of measures to be adopted in the ‘radical rupture with traditional property relations’ of the communist revolution (Marx and Engels 1968, 52). This was based on Marx’s post-Hegelian view of the need to transform and transcend the state and end its autonomisation from civil society. However, wide differences emerged within socialism, especially in the first decades of the 20th century, on the aims and means for revolutionary transformation, in which the form and role of progressive taxation continued to be viewed as ancillary. Views coalesced around the two poles of communism and social democracy, which were rooted in divergences underlying the philosophical, economic, and political perspectives of different strands of socialism. The gap between these perspectives grew very wide. Marxists prioritised revolutionary transformation based on the socialisation of property, but this became focused on state ownership and planning. They viewed social-democratic taxation programmes as ameliorative reformism, while social democrats retreated from viewing socialism as an alternative system, especially with the retreat from state ownership under neoliberalism and with the collapse of the Soviet bloc. The recent emergence of new anti-capitalist movements has reopened debates about progressive taxation on the left, challenging both perspectives. A few Marxists have begun to re-examine the arguments for progressive taxation made by the founding fathers (Ireland 2019), and others have begun to attempt analyses of contemporary tax issues, although hampered by the lack of any developed Marxist perspective on the forms of taxation (Prokla 2009). Meanwhile, social democrats have begun to focus more on ‘pre-distribution’, and the ways in which state policies, including taxation, have generated increasingly wide and structural economic inequalities, rooted in private ownership. Indeed. it is now increasingly recognised that taxes not only help to legitimise the acceptance of private property as natural, the tax system also helps to create and define private property, as Murphy and Nagel have pointed out (Murphy and Nagel 2002, 8). These shifts were strengthened by the impact of the great financial crash of 2009 and the ensuing austerity policies in the main capitalist countries, which gave momentum to the nascent campaigns around the world for ‘tax justice’.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Social Security Good

Social security is key to lifting people above the poverty line. Empirics prove.

Romig June 2, 2023 [Kathleen Romig *Director of Social Security and Disability Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. She works on Social Security, Supplemental Security Income, paid leave, and other budget issues. Romig previously worked at the Social Security Administration, Social Security Advisory Board, and Congressional Research Service. She began her career as a Presidential Management Fellow, during which time she completed an assignment at the Office of Management and Budget. Romig has a master’s degree in Social Policy from University College Cork, Ireland, where she was a George J. Mitchell Scholar, and a B.A. from Michigan State University’s James Madison College. “Social Security Lifts More People Above the Poverty Line Than Any Other Program.” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities] AZHS

Social Security benefits play a vital role in reducing poverty in every state, and they lift more people above the poverty line than any other program in the United States. Without Social Security, 21.7 million more adults and children would be below the poverty line, according to our analysis using the March 2022 Current Population Survey. Although most of those whom Social Security keeps out of poverty are aged 65 or older, 6.4 million are under age 65, including 1 million children. (See Table 1.) Social Security is particularly important for older women and people of color, who have fewer retirement resources outside of Social Security. Depending on their design, reductions in Social Security benefits could significantly increase poverty, particularly among older adults. Most people aged 65 and older receive the majority of their income from Social Security.[1] Without Social Security benefits, 37.7 percent of older adults would have incomes below the official poverty line, all else being equal; with Social Security benefits, only 10.3 percent do. (See Figure 1.) The benefits lift 15.4 million older adults above the poverty line, these estimates show. Comprehensive studies that match Census survey data to administrative records suggest that the official estimates overstate older adults’ reliance on Social Security but confirm that Social Security lifts millions of older adults above the poverty line and dramatically reduces the poverty rate among people aged 65 and older. (See Appendix for more information.) Social Security is important for children and their families as well as for older adults. About 6.2 million children under age 18 (9 percent of all children in the U.S.) lived in families that received income from Social Security in 2021, according to Census data. This figure includes children who received their own benefits as dependents of retired, disabled, or deceased workers, as well as those who lived with parents or relatives who received Social Security. In all, Social Security lifts 1 million children above the poverty line.[2] Social Security records show that 2.7 million children under age 18 qualified for Social Security payments in December 2021. (See Appendix Table 2.) Of these, 1.2 million were the survivor of a deceased worker. Another 1.1 million received payments because their parent had a severe disability. And 327,000 children under 18 received payments because their parent was retired.[3] Social Security is especially important for women and people of color. Women tend to earn less than men, take more time out of the paid workforce, live longer, accumulate less savings, and receive smaller pensions. Social Security brings 8.8 million older women above the poverty line, as Table 2 shows. Black and Latino workers benefit substantially from Social Security because they have higher disability rates and lower lifetime earnings than white workers, on average. In addition, Black workers have higher rates of premature death than white workers, and so their spouses and children are more likely to be eligible for Social Security survivor benefits. Latino workers have longer average life expectancies than white workers, which means they have more years to collect retirement benefits. Without Social Security, the poverty rate among older Latino adults would be 44.5 percent, and the poverty rat e among older Black adults would be 50.2 percent.[4] Social Security reduces poverty dramatically among older adults in every state as well as Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico, as Figure 2 and Appendix Table 1 show. Without Social Security, the poverty rate for those aged 65 and over would meet or exceed 40 percent in one-fourth of states; with Social Security, it is less than 10 percent in over two-thirds of states. Social Security lifts more than 1 million older adults above the poverty line in California, Florida, and Texas, and over half a million in Illinois, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. A 2017 study by Adam Bee and Joshua Mitchell of the Census Bureau matched the CPS survey responses used for official poverty statistics to administrative data from the Social Security Administration (SSA), Internal Revenue Service, and other government sources.[8] They found that official estimates overstate older adults’ reliance on Social Security and poverty rates among older adults, but confirmed that Social Security lifts millions of adults aged 65 and older above the poverty line and dramatically reduces the poverty rate among these adults. They did not find significant underreporting of income among people of working age. Further study has confirmed their findings using more recent data.[9] Bee and Mitchell found that survey respondents generally reported accurately whether they received Social Security or earnings, but not whether they received pension income. Roughly half of older adult respondents who received pension income — either income from traditional defined-benefit pensions or withdrawals from defined-contribution pensions like 401(k)s or individual retirement accounts — failed to report this, particularly respondents whose pension income was small or inconsistent. On the other hand, respondents who reported receiving Social Security, earnings, or pension income generally reported accurately the amount they received from those sources.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Good – War

Capitalism’s promotion of international trade reduces war

Beauchamp 15 (Zack interview with Pinker, Steven. Zack Beauchamp is a senior correspondent at Vox where he covers democracy and conflict in America and abroad. His acclaimed feature includes investigations in Hungary and Israel supported by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis reporting. He attended Brown University and The London School of Economics and Political Science. Prof. Steven Pinker earned his PhD from Harvard in 1979, and taught at Harvard, Stanford, and MIT. He has received numerous prizes for his books including The Better Angels of Our Nature, which was about the dawn of a nonviolent era of humanity. “Steven Pinker explains how capitalism is killing war,” Vox, June 4, 2015. https://www.vox.com/2015/6/4/8725775/pinker-capitalism //ghs-LHM)

The idea that war is on the decline — that is, that there are fewer wars today and fewer people are dying from them than ever before — is hard for a lot of people to believe (including Republican presidential candidates). And yet the data makes a very compelling case that that's true:

Those numbers were put together by Steven Pinker, a Harvard psychologist whose book The Better Angels of Our Nature makes the strongest case yet that the world is getting progressively more peaceful. Pinker's argument has come under fire recently, with some arguing that it's way too soon for anyone to say we've turned the corner from an era of war. I spoke with Pinker this week to discuss some of the reasons why, specifically, he thinks the world has gotten so much safer, especially in the past 70 years. We talked about the idea that war just isn't as profitable as it used to be, why Vladimir Putin and ISIS seem to think differently, and what world leaders should do if they actually want to make sure the unprecedented peace of the past 70 years holds. What follows is a transcript of our conversation, lightly edited for length and clarity. Zack Beauchamp: One story you hear from political scientists for why there's been less war recently that it's just less profitable —countries don't gain very much, economically or politically, from taking over new land anymore. Does that seem right to you? Steven Pinker: Yes, it's one of the causes. It's the theory of the capitalist peace: when it's cheaper to buy things than to steal them, people don't steal them. Also, if other people are more valuable to you alive than dead, you're less likely to kill them. You don't kill your customers or your lenders, so the arrival of the infrastructure of trade and commerce reduces some of the sheer exploitative incentives of conquest. This is an idea that goes back to the Enlightenment. Adam Smith and Montesquieu extolled it; it was on the minds of the founders when they built incentives for free trade into the Constitution. I don't think it's the entire story of the decline in war. But I do think it's part of the story. There was a well-known study from Bruce Russett and John Oneal showing statistically that countries that engage in more trade are less likely to get into militarized disputes, and countries that are more integrated into the world economy are less likely to get into trouble with their neighbors. ZB: Is it just that pairs of countries are trading with each more, or has something fundamentally changed about the global economy? SP: It's both. Countries that trade with each other are less likely to pick fights with each other. Independently, individual countries that get more integrated into the global economy are less likely to make trouble. But one of the reasons I say this is only part of the answer is that in the Oneal and Russett analysis, it counted for some percentage of the variance in militarized dispute, but only a chunk. They found independent contributions from democracy and membership in the international community (namely, the number of international organizations and treaties that a country has signed on to). Quite across from calculations of interest that are tilted by international markets and institutions, there's the idea of norms: what you consider and don't consider as a legitimate possible move. [Some scholars] argue that the main factor is that war has been delegitimated — at least among the great powers and the developed states — as a thinkable option. In the 19th century, there was this cliché from [Carl] von Clausewitz that war was just the continuation of politics by other means: you consider whether to go to war [like any other policy option]. Now that's just not something decent leaders do. Finally, cost-benefit calculations depend on what counts as a "cost." If you lose several tens or hundreds of thousands of your own citizens, is that a cost? And how big a cost is it? Now, increasingly, that counts as a cost: leaders are less likely to see their young men as cannon fodder, which means countries are willing to endure other costs to avoid that one. That's a result of the rise of humanistic sentiments, as opposed to nationalistic or ideological ones.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Tech Good

Green tech through capitalism is sustainable

Samuel Alexander, 8-27-2015,( Research fellow, Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute, University of Melbourne "The 'green-tech' future is a flawed vision of sustainability," Conversation, http://theconversation.com/the-green-tech-future-is-a-flawed-vision-of-sustainability-46681 , shl)

There seem to be three main reasons why the “green-tech” conception of sustainability is dominant. First, it is good for business. Sustainability is presented as something we can either purchase as consumers or sell as green entrepreneurs. There is no conflict here between consumer capitalism and sustainability, so the powers that be need not feel threatened. As the sustainable design website Inhabitat declares: “Design will save the world”. Second, the green-tech future is politically palatable. Politicians can defend their “green” credentials without questioning the affluence that consumerist cultures seem to expect and demand. From this perspective, sustainability is a great opportunity for green growth of the economy, which means that politicians do not have argue that we need to consume less. Third, the green-tech future is less challenging for those of us who enjoy the affluent lifestyles that make such tremendous demands on natural resources. God forbid anyone suggest that sustainability requires that we rethink our lifestyles! As George Bush Snr declared (in a comment also attributed to Dick Cheney): “the American way of life is not negotiable”. Fortunately, for all those cultures that emulate the American way of life, the dominant faith in a green-tech future means that we can enjoy consumer affluence in good conscience, knowing that it is consistent with the transition to a just and sustainable world. We just need to do consumerism better, and given that human beings are so clever, that shouldn’t be a problem. Right?

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Tech Good

Sustainable capitalism promotes affs green infrastructure

Leo E. Strine, Jr. (Contact Author), 10-3-2019, "Toward Fair and Sustainable Capitalism: A Comprehensive Proposal to Help American Workers, Restore Fair Gainsharing between Employees and Shareholders, and Increase American Competitiveness by Reorienting Our Corporate Governance System Toward Sustainable Long-Term Growth and Encouraging Investments in America’s Future," No Publication, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3461924

To redress these problems, workers must be given more voice within the corporate boardroom. Companies should have board-level committees that ensure quality wages and fair worker treatment. A fundamental responsibility of that committee should be to guarantee that employees are again equitably rewarded when they help the company improve its profitability, to ensure that workplaces are safe for employees, and to oversee company policies promoting racial and gender pay equity and inclusive, harassment- and discrimination-free workplaces. Complementary labor law reforms making it easier for employees to join a union and bargain over wages are essential to restoring a fair American economy. That should be coupled with authority for companies to create European-style works councils under the workforce committee, to amplify worker voice at all American companies, improve worker well-being, and support and supplement the vital role unions play in protecting workers. And all bargaining and wage setting must occur against the strong backdrop of a living wage. Likewise, to hold companies accountable for how they treat their workers, how they treat their consumers, and whether they operate in an ethical, sustainable, environmentally responsible manner, the public and investors deserve better information about company performance on these critical dimensions. The bailout of corporate America required by the pandemic reminds us that corporations only thrive with the support of our nation, the communities in which they operate, and the sacrifices of their workers, and that they should be managed with that reality in mind. To begin changing corporate governance to require respect of all stakeholders, large companies (whether publicly listed, or owned by a private equity firm or a rich family) receiving federal bailout money should be required to become a benefit corporation under state law. This form of for-profit corporation imposes a “shall” not “may” duty on the board of directors to treat employees and all company stakeholders fairly and with respect, not just the stockholders. This is a just condition of help, and will create a stimulus for this more sensible model of corporate governance to become standard. This form of governance would go a long way to ensure that corporations are run in a sustainable fashion—producing strong returns for stockholders and workers while maintaining reserves to weather an economic crisis. Nor can we ignore the role of institutional investors in pushing for immediate returns and the poor incentives that pressure puts on companies. Institutional investors wield over 75% of stockholder voting power, all but dictating corporate policy through their voting clout. And most middle-class Americans fortunate enough to be invested in the stock market are forced capitalists, who must save for retirement by turning over a portion of every paycheck to a mutual fund family chosen by their employer. Although reforms to how corporations are governed is crucial to ensuring our capitalist system once again works for everyone, corporations will not give more thoughtful consideration to their employees and social responsibility unless the institutional investors who elect corporate boards support doing so. Our imbalanced corporate governance system can be fixed only by aligning institutional investors’ incentives with the interests of their end investors: human beings saving for retirement and their children’s college education. To do so, the institutional investors who control most human investors’ money must vote with their investors’ needs in mind. Index funds should tailor their voting policies to the fact that they are invested for the long haul. To be fair, some institutional investors have started to consider environmental, social, and governance, or “ESG,” factors. But if we want companies to operate in a sustainable, socially responsible manner, then all institutional investors who manage human investors’ money need to factor EESG considerations into their investing and voting decisions, and emphasize the vital missing “E”—the interests of companies’ employees. If companies are spending too much on stock buybacks, taking environmental shortcuts, or failing to adequately compensate and invest in their workforce, that is likely because their stockholders—i.e., institutional investors—have exerted pressures on companies that encouraged this state of affairs. If the goal is to increase the gainsharing among corporations and their other stakeholders—workers, consumers, and society—that can be achieved only by aligning those doing the voting—institutional investors—with the interests of their flesh and blood worker-investors who need not just sustainable corporate profits, but also good jobs, clean air, and safe products. Other complementary measures would help promote sustainable, long-term economic growth that benefits all. We must reform counterproductive tax and accounting policies creating incentives for speculation and rapid portfolio turnover, rather than sound long-term investing. And our nation has economic challenges that must be addressed by public investment. A huge infrastructure and basic research gap is eroding our competitiveness and diminishing our quality of life. We need to supercharge our efforts to address climate change. With investments in basic research, cleaner, more efficient infrastructure, and worker training, we can create jobs in the United States, tackle climate change, help workers in carbon-intensive industries transition to new jobs, reduce racial inequality, revitalize struggling rural regions and urban cities, and enhance the competitiveness of American companies. By implementing tax policy that puts a price on behavior we want to have less of — and making corporations pay their fair share for infrastructure that supports them — we can finance investments in the future to create good jobs that cannot be sent overseas. These ideas would work well along with a responsible approach to carbon and wealth taxation to create a more progressive and socially productive tax system. Finally, we must address legal changes that have given corporate elites an unfair advantage over working Americans, including Supreme Court and regulatory decisions that have undermined labor unions, deprived Americans of their day in court and fueled a massive growth in unchecked corporate political spending. America’s corporations are not playthings. They create jobs, produce goods and services that consumers depend on, affect the environment we live in, and build wealth for human investors to save for retirement and their kids’ education. Corporations are societally chartered institutions of enormous importance. Those who govern them ought to be accountable for the generation of durable wealth for workers, consumers, and human investors. A new accountability system that supports wealth creation within a system of enlightened capitalism—one that aligns the interests of institutional investors and corporations with those of the human beings whose capital they control— is needed. With some modest sacrifice by every interest that wields economic power, we can make our economy work better for all. This Proposal to promote Fair and Sustainable Capitalism would help make that goal a reality

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Green Tech Good

Capitalism is sustainable, solves through the use of green innovation

Mhlanga 22 – David Mhlanga is a Postdoctoral Researcher at the University of Johannesburg, SA. His research includes financial inclusion, poverty studies, and industry 4.0. His wider subject areas include development economics, economics of A.I, health, and education economics. [“Stakeholder Capitalism, the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR), and Sustainable Development: Issues to be Resolved”, Cooperative Challenges for Sustainable Development of Enterprises in the Era of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, no. 7, https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/14/7/3902] AT GH  

In terms of stakeholder capitalism, it “Can either be an ideology adopted by leaders at individual companies or a model enforced by governments through laws and regulations []. Some of the ways companies can independently demonstrate a commitment to stakeholder capitalism, paying fair wages, reducing the CEO-worker pay ratio, ensuring safety in the workplace, lobbying for higher tax rates, avoiding tax loopholes, providing good customer service, engaging in honest marketing practices, investing in local communities, preventing environmental damage among others” []. The WEF’s 50th annual meeting in Davos has “focused on stakeholder capitalism with the central theme, “Stakeholders for a Cohesive and Sustainable World”. This theme shows that if organizations are encouraged to instill this doctrine of stakeholder capitalism in their businesses, the world will be a better place to live, the sustainable development goals will be achievable, and some of the imminent challenges that are associated with the Fourth Industrial Revolution will be addressed. A study by Mhlanga and Moloi [] assesses the usefulness of the stakeholder theory in addressing the challenges that affect the world in the 4IR. Mhlanga and Moloi [] discovered that the challenges of cybersecurity and warfare, climate change, inequality, digital exclusion, and even job losses, among a variety of challenges, can be addressed if stakeholder capitalism is taken as the philosophy that guides the operation of corporations. These challenges can be addressed because good capitalism emerges as companies incorporate stakeholder capitalism as the central philosophy. Mhlanga and Moloi [] indicate that stakeholder capitalism, when embraced, encourages collaboration among stakeholders. The United Nations, in Goal 17, indicate that the only way of meeting the SDGs is by working together. It was highlighted that collaboration through international investments and support is required to allow for innovation and technical development, fair trade practices, and equal access to markets. The United Nations went further to indicate that, for us to build a better world, there is a need to create supportive institutions, and to be empathetic, inventive, passionate, and collaborative. The other argument that is given by Mhlanga and Moloi [] is that the only way for companies to better save society is for them to embrace stakeholder capitalism. Embracing stakeholder capitalism will result in companies coming up with various social responsibility activities, and in companies that pay their fair share of taxes, which can be used to address the problems that are related to inequality and various economic and social challenges. In addition, the challenges that are related to climate change also require a massive investment in clean energy, which can prove to be impossible in some developing countries, but, when companies pay fair taxes, the money can be used to come up with projects that promote the use of clean energy, even in developing nations, which will help to address the challenge of climate change. The other outstanding contribution of stakeholder capitalism is its principles, which encourage a better kind of capitalism, where companies strive to offer their customers a better value proposition that meets their needs, and to accept and promote fair competition and a level playing field. These principles, if adopted in firms, will help us to deal with the problems that are related to job losses, cyber warfare, and technological exclusion, among others. What this points to is that the only way to attain sustainable development and to, subsequently, meet the SDGs, is through the encouragement of good capitalism, which allows corporations and the various stakeholders to work together. The only way for this to happen is when corporations embrace stakeholder capitalism. Nevertheless, some gaps still exist, which raises a lot of questions, especially in terms of the quest to achieve a sustainable world.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Good – Innovation

Cap key to innovation – placing value on human capital is the necessary force behind education

Keita 16 (Lansana, Associate Professor of Economics and Philosophy at the University of the Gambia. His publications include Science, Rationality and Neoclassical Economics and Philosophy and Development. “Models of Economic Growth and Development in the Context of Human Capital Investment – The Way Forward for Africa,” Africa Development / Afrique et Développement, Vol. 41, No. 1 (2016), Published by: CODESRIA, pgs 38-46, https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/90001833 //ghs-LHM)

The implications of the above discussion are that the Romer model could be more economically expressed by just three variables: Capital (K), Labour (L), and A (level of technology). This produces the usual formulation of the orthodox Cobb-Douglas production function as Y = A(K)αL β. We unpack this formulation as follows: K in this instance represents physical capital and L represents labour with varying degrees of embodied human capital. A represents the level of technology already embodied in capital, K. But there is a feedback loop here: it is active labour (L) as human capital (H) that produces technology which in turn requires increased and novel amounts of human capital over time. This hypothesis is supported by Romer’s observation that ‘what is important for growth is integration not into an economy with a large number of people but rather into one with a large amount of human capital (Romer 1990:98). The reformulation above of the orthodox Cobb-Douglas production function guarantees that Solow’s growth impasse is easily avoidable. The point is that existing cultures necessarily impart human capital skills from the earliest human growth years onwards. The street sweeper is subjected to human capital inputs in the same way as the engineer, albeit to a much lesser degree. The moral here is that a necessary condition for economic growth and development for the countries of Africa are large investments in human capital at all levels. The problem with the Solow and Romer models is that they fail to recognise that labour is the driving force in economic growth and development, and that labour is necessarily embodied with human capital in all its activities. Furthermore, it is labour as embodied human capital that produces technology. In fact, human capital is knowledge imparted by learning and operant conditioning in to the thinking powers of humans. Human capital in turn is the source of technology which represents what is essential about humans. It is for this reason that human capital standing alone is enough to explain the fact that countries that are not mass producers of technological goods but are home to populations which benefit from substantial investments in human capital are economically successful. Cases in point are countries such as New Zealand, Denmark, Finland, Holland, and Norway whose investments in human capital guarantee that their citizens experience approximately twelve years of secular modern education. The investment in human capital for such nations is geared not only to inculcate technical skills but also to imbue their citizens with the dispositions and skills necessary for critical thinking in all intellectual areas. The same applies to larger population nations such as Australia and Canada, which though not noted for their technological prowess, are home to populations that are guaranteed substantial investments in human capital. Investment in human capital would seem to be the necessary requirement for economic growth and development. It is not only the basis for autonomous development in terms of new technological adaptations but also the basis for developing societies whose citizens are compatible with social requirements of modern technological society. By contrast, countries that have not invested adequately in human capital remain mired for the most part in technologies and thinking modes of the pre-modern era. The UNDP’s Human Development Index document provides a fairly comprehensive picture of the correlations and causalities between investments in human capital and the existing agreed-on metrics of human economic development and welfare. Evident proof of this is to compare the first ten countries on the UNDP’s Human Development Index list and the last ten. But the same correlations that point to causal connections could be obtained by simply using four countries that are in the ‘very highly developed’ sector and the last four of the ‘low human development’ sector. The central point being made here is that development does not necessarily entail autonomous industrial and technological development but necessarily means having a populace whose behaviours demonstrate maximal investments in human capital not only in terms of both modern, technical and secular knowledge, but also in terms of social dispositions. For example, the very small country Iceland is not noted for its industrial prowess yet with 10.4 years of investment in human capital, its per capita GDP is $35, 116 and its average life expectancy is 82.1 years. Iceland is 13th on the UNDP’s HDI table andis among the ‘very highly developed’ countries. But consider the following table including eight nations out of one-hundred-and-eighty-seven (187) and the causal links between investment in human capital and development in terms of its most important metrics are obvious. Table 2: Years of Schooling and Per Capita GDP for the Years 2012-2013 for Selected ‘Very High Development’ Countries According to the UNDP’s Human Development Metrics Country (Very High Human Development) Mean Years of Schooling Per Capita GDP (2011 PPP $) H.D.I. Rank Norway 12.6 $63.909 1 Australia 12.8 $41, 524 2 New Zealand 12.5 $32, 569 7 Denmark 12.1 $42,880 10 Table 3: Years of Schooling and Per Capita GDP for the Years 2012-2013 for Selected ‘Low Development’ Countries according to the UNDP’s Human Development Metrics Country (Low Human Development) Mean Years of Schooling Per Capita GDP (2011 PPP $) H.D.I. Rank Chad 1.5 $1,622 184 Central African Republic 3.5 $588 185 Congo (DRC) 3.1 $444 186 Niger 1.4 $873 187 Source for Tables 2 and 3: http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/table-1-humandevelopment-index-and-its-components. To reinforce this, consider the fact that even two years of schooling makes a very noticeable difference. Greece – now undergoing serious economic problems – ranks 29th on the HDI table with 10.2 years of schooling and a per-capita GDP of $24, 658. It would seem that at least 12 years of schooling is the minimum to break into the upper ranks of development. The sum of the above is reinforced by Thomas Piketty’s observation that ‘Knowledge and skill diffusion is the key to overall productivity growth as well as the reduction of inequality both within and between countries. We see this at present in the advances made by a number of previously poor countries, led by China’ (Piketty 2014:23). Piketty himself is chary about using the phrase ‘investment in human capital’ to describe investment in education and skills training given its loaded historical significance (Piketty 2014:46). Matters can be improved with greater expenditure on education to produce more years of schooling. But the task is daunting given that the countries that show ‘very high human development’ on the UNDP’s Human Development (2012) Index spend 5.3 per cent of GDP on public education, while those of ‘medium human development’ and ‘low human development’ spend only 3.7 per cent and 3.8 per cent respectively. Furthermore, it should be noted that the GDPs of the countries of ‘very high human development’ are multiples of those of ‘low human development’. The following table demonstrates this point, assuming that 5 per cent of GDP is spent on education. Table 4: Five Per cent of GDP Per Capita Expenditures on Education for Four Selected Countries Country Population (2016) in millions GDP($ B) 5% of GDP Spent on Education ($B) Senegal 15 $16 $0.8 Netherlands 17 $853 $43 New Zealand 5 $187 $9.3 Ghana 28 $38 $1.9 Source: Author’s data-gathering. Obviously, 5 per cent of GDP spent on education would yield vastly different results from country to country based on the scope of real GDP output. The challenge is enormous but results can be had with efficient budgeting, spending and the creative usage of refurbished technologies. A goal-directed drive to development is what seems lacking for the most part. In the modern era, there have been sets of strongly contested models that have sought to establish the optimal models for human economic transactions within and between communities. It is on this basis that real world economics becomes intermingled with politics, thereby explaining the operative nomenclature of ‘political economy’. In fact, economics in practice is political economy. But the objectivisation of any form of political economy required that the corresponding background theories be reified as being representative of human nature and behaviour. Thus, the ongoing ideological conflict between ‘free market economics’ on the one hand and ‘more controlled forms of economic activity’ on the other. In this regard, three names stand out in the modern era: Smith, Marx, and Keynes. These names are important because their holders developed important models as to how the social economies of the modern world should be structured. Smith is seen by his followers to have developed the optimal social economic model according to which individuals within an economic space produce and exchange goods and services mainly on the basis of selfinterest under conditions of minimal government interference. The economic model developed by Smith has been reduced to phrases such as ‘free market economics’ and ‘free market economics produce optimal results’, and so on. The Marxian model argued that left to its own devices thefree market segmented into capital owners and workers would tend to be periodically disruptive of the economy principally on account of the differentials between the returns on capital and labour income. The solution, according to Marx, would be for the workers to expropriate the capital owners so as to correct the dividend imbalance. The capitalist market system did not collapse on account of its ‘internal contradictions’ as Marx presaged, for a number of reasons, one of which was the expansion of capitalism into areas newly colonised by the economically dominant countries of Europe. Thus, the gains made by the workers in the metropolitan areas derived partially from the gains of capital invested in the colonial territories where raw materials and the costs of labour were obtainable at minimal costs (Lenin 1917). But that did not solve the issue concerning structural capitalism given the ‘Great Crash’ of 1929. The solution to that issue was provided by Keynes in his magnum opus, ‘The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money’ (1936). Keynes’s solution, in contradistinction to Say’s Law of Markets, was to create a crucial role for a nation’s government in managing the endemic issues of periodic overproduction and under-consumption that plague the generic capitalist economy. The key element in Keynes’s thesis seems to have been adopted by the majority of industrialised countries in that by intervening permanently in the market economy according to worker demands by way of trade unions and the like, Marx’s predictions seem to have been allayed. In fact, the important ex-state communist nations such as The Soviet Union and China, erstwhile practitioners of a totalitarian capitalism by the state, have now adopted versions of Keynes’s ‘mixed-economy’ model. By way of political party representation the various countries have been able through taxation to extract from capital and their populations enough surpluses to ensure adequate production of public goods and compensation during times of economic downturns. But such theorising in terms of how the modern market economy should be run is rarely countenanced in African universities or governmental circles. Academic discussions just assume that economics should be pursued according to the standard neoclassicalmodel now current in Western universities. In terms of practice, the standard approach is to follow the ministrations of the IMF, World Bank and the lending agencies of the Euro-American world. The names of Kwame Nkrumah, Julius Nyrere, Claude Ake, etc. rarely ever come up in discussions about the optimal models for African economic development. This can happen only when academic economics in Africa views economics not as some species of accounting or engineering but as an evolutionary social science strongly embedded in politics and sociology. What is to be Done With the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, the West was left triumphal on the economic scene. The path to economic growth and development was strictly determined thenceforth by Western institutions such as the IMF and the World Bank. Neoliberalism with its mantra of privatisation and minimal government intervention in the economy was the only model that the nations of Africa and the South were recommended to follow. The NEPAD (New Economic Policy for African Development) was the new programme that African nations were being encouraged to embrace. Before that, of course, one recalls the ECA (Economic Commission for Africa) and its blueprint for African economic growth and development. This was the Lagos Plan of Action (draft 1980) that urged models of balanced growth in the context of mixed economies along the lines as practiced by the nations of European Union. The LPA also stressed self-sufficiency and intra-continental trade and cooperation. It should be noted that the LPA was developed as a Pan African initiative drawn up to map out a path for African economic growth and development. A vigorously critical response from the World Bank followed – prepared by Elliot Berg, an economist at the Bank. The Berg Report (1991) stressed that private markets rather than the state should be the prime mover toward economic growth and development, and that regional integration was not recommended and that – in so many words – Africa’s path to growt and development should be by way of the Bretton Woods institutions and what are now called ‘neoliberal’ economic policies. The Berg report also argued that the developmental role of the state as the main agent of development should be reduced on account of the neoclassical economic principle that free markets tend to be better at promoting growth and development. It also pointed out that the LPA neglected to point to the issue of governmental corruption as a major impediment, and to suggest ways to curb such. In retrospect, the LPA was a much better theoretical starting point to tackle Africa’s economic problems rather than the neoliberal and dependency ministrations offered by the IMF and World Bank. So what is to be done? The answer I propose should include efficient and people-oriented government policies as a necessary step for development. That can be achieved only when the various populaces are boldly involved through direct action. With efficient and development-oriented governance the following measures should be implemented: 1) regional integration in terms of currencies and movement of goods, services, and labour. The EU model is worthy of emulation on this basis. Regional groupings such as ECOWAS, SADEC, etc. should be made to work. 2) Pan African institutions such as transcontinental cooperative banks, research institutes and well-funded universities should be encouraged and promoted. 3) There should be concerted and combined efforts of the populaces of West Africa to confront France’s neocolonial policies regarding the CFA currency. Currently, the French Central Bank requires that member CFA countries deposit 65 per cent of their reserves into the French Treasury. 4) There should be more efforts to found a convertible African currency managed by a strongly capitalised African Central Bank in strong coordination with African governments in terms of their individual fiscal policies. Should such a currency be used for the capitalisation of indigenous projects such as regional and trans-continental railways, highways and roads, manufacturing, heavy industry manufacture, solar energy enterprises, it would necessarily increase in unit value over time. Heterodox economist Ha-Joon Chang (2008:12) argues that the path to development is not the one recommended by neoliberal economics which includes free market transactions, minimal government, private enterprise, and invitation to foreign investors. Ha-Joon Chang has this to say about Korea’s economic advancement. ‘Whatever its recent problems have been, Korea’s economic growth and the resulting social transformation over the last four and a half decades have been truly spectacular’ (Chang 2008:12). This rapid economic development and technological transformation are often described as a ‘miracle’, and this is Chang’s explanation: The Korean economic miracle was the result of a clever and pragmatic mixture of market incentives and state direction. The Korean government did not vanquish the market as the communist states did. However, it did not have blind faith in the free market either. While it took markets seriously, the Korean strategy recognized that they often need to be corrected through policy intervention (Chang 2008:15). More specifically: The government owned all the banks, so it could direct the life blood of business – credit. Some big projects were undertaken directly by state-owned enterprises – the steel maker POSCO, being the best example – although the country had a pragmatic, rather than ideological, attitude to the issue of state ownership (Chang 2008:14). To ensure the growth of infant industries, targeted industries were protected by tariffs (Chang 2008:14). But above all, according to Chang, economic development for developing nations would depend heavily on manufacturing. He makes this point emphatically when he writes: ‘Contrary to the advice of the Bad Samaritans, poor countries should deliberately promote manufacturing industries’ (Chang 2008:214).But behind all this is South Korea’s continuing investment in human capital. Despite rough beginnings, South Korea ranks (2013) 15th on the UNDP’s Human Development Index and shows an average of 11.8 (cf Sweden 11.7 years of schooling) years of schooling. This is what explains its noted prowess in high technology and industrial production. The following OECD economics observation supports this thesis: “Education played a key role in Korea’s transformation from one of the poorest countries in the world to a leading industrial nation by promoting the development of human resources and technological change… The exceptionally rapid development of education in Korea is illustrated by differences in the levels of educational attainment for different age cohorts. The share of the population with at least a secondary education ranges from 98 per cent, the highest in the OECD area, for young adults (25-34), to only 43 per cent for older adults (55-64) (Figure 1). Similarly, 65 per cent of young adults have completed tertiary education, the highest share in the OECD, compared to only 13 per cent of older adults (Panel B). In addition to these quantitative measures, Korea has consistently ranked near the top in the OECD in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). As Korea has few natural resources, it must rely on the development of its human resources (Jones 2013:5).” In sum, ‘universal access to primary and secondary schools promoted social mobility and income equality… [thereby] laying the foundations for Korea’s success in IT and the growth of a knowledge-based economy’ (Jones 2013:5). Chang’s analysis above could serve as a possible path for African development. But this would not in any way minimise the need for an expansion of the manufacturing sectors in African nations. On account of the abundant labour power that Africa possesses, there are areas in manufacturing such as sports equipment manufacturing that could be exploited. As an example, football as a sport is very popular in a continent of one billion persons, yet the manufacture of footballs, which is highly labour intensive, is dominated by Pakistan and China. Africa could easily enter that market and those of other sports too. One major incentive here would be the fact that the cost of labour in this instance would be approximately on a par with Pakistan and China, or even less. Similarly, other manufacturing areas that require labour inputs mainly could be exploited. Yet again, investments in human capital at the managerial levels would also be required if Africa’s manufacturing sectors were to expand. But perhaps the most important pay-off for African countries in terms of optimal investments in human capital would be in its capacity to encourage cultural changes within societies whose existing cultures, developed within sociological structures and knowledge bases, are just not appropriate for modern post-industrial and modern-technology reliant societies. Investments in education and human capital geared towards the knowledge banks of the modern world would do much to improve the political structures and atmospheres of the nations of the South including those of Africa. The nation state and the large economic communities are the socio-economic structures on which the modern world operates, not the smaller communities of ethnic groups and their local particularities and premodern modes of thinking. Modern education and investment in human capital would recognise the logical content of this argument.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Good – Poverty

Growth is the single most important metric for solving poverty

Pritchett 2020 - RISE Research Director at the Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford. Previously, he was a Senior Fellow at the Center for Global Development and Professor of the Practice of International Development at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University

By Lant Pritchett February 2, 2020 “Poverty Reduction and Economic Growth” https://econofact.org/poverty-reduction-and-economic-growth

Reducing poverty in developing countries has been a longstanding and central concern of development economics. Over the past two decades, there has been a noticeable shift in the approach taken by development economists to address this question. Researchers have increasingly focused their efforts on randomized controlled trials — an experimental approach commonly used in medical research — to determine the effectiveness of anti-poverty programs and interventions. This shift was highlighted by the 2019 Nobel Prize in Economics awarded to Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo and Michael Kremer, which recognized their work for breaking down the issue of fighting global poverty into "smaller, more manageable, questions – for example, the most effective interventions for improving educational outcomes or child health." One question that remains, though, is how much overall reduction in the poverty rate one can expect from projects, programs or policy interventions that raise the well-being of those in absolute poverty at a given level of income, versus how much poverty reduction comes from broad-based economic growth. The Facts: In the last quarter century 1.1 billion people, about one-seventh of the world’s population, have been lifted out of extreme poverty. Yet progress has been uneven across different regions and significant challenges remain. A dramatic reduction of extreme poverty in East Asia, particularly in China, accounts for an important share of the advances in combating global poverty, with poverty reductions in South Asia also contributing their share. In contrast, progress has been much slower in Sub-Saharan Africa (see here). The World Bank counts all persons in a household as “poor” if the household per capita daily consumption or income is below a “poverty line.” It uses three different thresholds, $1.90, $3.20, and $5.50 per person per day, where local currency values are translated into 2011 dollar values, and taking into account the fact that goods and services are cheaper in poorer countries (so-called “purchasing power parity” currency conversion rates). The World Bank notes a marked reduction in extreme poverty (less than $1.90 per day) over the past quarter century, with a decrease from 36 percent in 1990 to 10 percent in 2015. Still, over 700 million people around the world continued to live in extreme poverty in 2015. One way to consider the relationship between economic growth and poverty is to look across countries and compare median incomes and the share of the population living in poverty. The median income is the income level at which half the population has an income higher than this amount and half the population has an income below this amount. Statisticians focus on median income rather than average income because a small number of people with very high levels of income alter the average much more than the median and can give rise to a distorted picture of the income profile of a country. In theory, two countries could have the same median income and yet have very different poverty rates. Differences in how income is distributed within countries could make it so that two countries with the same median income could have very different poverty rates. For an extreme example, consider a country with a median income of $5,000 per capita (the equivalent of about $13.70 per person per day); This country could have no one living with an income of less than $5.50 per day, effectively having a rate of zero poverty under a $5.50 dollar-a-day threshold; Alternatively, half of the population could be living with an income less than $5.50 a day (in which case no one would have an income in the range between $5.50 and $13.70) — and, in this case, there would be a 50 percent poverty rate. Thus, there is not necessarily a tight relationship between the median income in a country and its poverty rate. However, in actuality, there is an extremely tight relationship between median income and poverty rates across countries. Using data for 633 observations on 141 countries and the poverty threshold of $5.50 per person per day, the correlation between poverty rates and poverty predicted on the basis of median income alone is 99 percent (the richest 28 countries that have very low poverty rates are excluded from this analysis). This means that pretty much all of the variation in poverty rates across countries can be accounted for by their differences in median income. This implies that one might expect significant reductions in the share of the population living in poverty when countries move to higher levels of median income. To illustrate, I estimate on the basis of this relationship that if a country at the average income of the lowest quartile of countries were to grow by two percent a year for 20 years (which is roughly the average growth in the post WWII era) its rate of poverty would fall by about half to 35.9 percent at the $1.90 a day poverty level (see here). The chart illustrates the relationship between median income and the share of a country's population living in poverty. It shows the lowest poverty rate observed for 141 countries for a variety of years between 1980 and 2015 at different levels of median income or median consumption per capita. (Consumption and income data are all in terms of 2011 U.S. dollar values adjusted for differences in purchasing power across countries.) No country with median income per capita below $2558 per year ($7.00 per day) had less than a third of the population living in poverty (see chart). Only one country with median income or consumption below $3535 had a poverty rate less than 10 percent. No country with median income or consumption below $1045 had less than 75 percent of the population living in poverty (e.g. Angola, with 2008 median consumption of $1035, had a poverty rate of 80 percent). Changes in countries’ median incomes or median consumption and changes in their respective poverty rates are also very highly correlated. An analysis of the change in a country’s income or consumption over a decade or more and its associated change in the poverty rate over that same period for the 114 countries with reliable data on these longer spells illustrates this, with a correlation of about 93 percent. Of course, some countries had more poverty reduction than what would be predicted given their income or consumption growth (e.g. Indonesia, Nepal) while others had less (e.g. Mali, Swaziland) but, by and large, poverty reduction was very accurately predicted by the change in median income. None of this analysis turns on the magnitude or efficacy of countries’ anti-poverty programs. But that is precisely the point. One can predict extremely accurately the level and change in absolute poverty (at a variety of threshold poverty levels) without any references to changes in the distribution of income below the median level, which would be the type of change that one might imagine anti-poverty programs target. There is no evidence that these programs have, of yet, been an important source of differences in the rates of poverty or in the pace of overall poverty reduction. Determining what promotes sustained growth for poor countries and how to implement policies that increase or sustain growth, however, remain deep research and policy challenges. The Nobelists (and many others) have rightly pointed out that one does not get reliable guidance on appropriate policies to promote growth from the earlier generation of simple analyses that associate certain preconditions with subsequent growth, especially those analyses that do not take into account more complex differences across countries’ experiences and circumstances. More recently, economists have attempted to come up with more practical advice by studying the episodic nature of developing country growth spurts (as here) as well as what is associated with more sustained growth accelerations and decelerations (here, here and here among many others). Moreover, “growth diagnostic” approaches (an example of one such approach here) attempt to map the specific facts and conditions of a country to policy recommendations. While this represents progress in providing useful guidance for policy makers, all agree there is more research to be done to improve these approaches. The hope is to provide empirics and tools that produce a better chance of good decisions on the range of important choices developing country politicians and policy makers have to make. Broad-based growth, defined as the process that raises median income, is far and away the most important source of poverty reduction. There is no instance of a country achieving a headcount poverty rate below 1/3 of its population (at moderate poverty line of $5.50) without achieving the median consumption of that of Mexico. This is not to say that there do not exist anti-poverty programs that are cost-effective and hence should be expanded, or, conversely, that there are anti-poverty programs that are not cost-effective (or even have zero impact on poverty) and should be cut back or eliminated. Analyses of these types of programs would enable a more efficient use of resources devoted to poverty reduction. But large and sustained improvements in global poverty will almost certainly have to focus on how to raise the productivity of the typical person in a poor country, which is a key source of national income growth.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Good – Democracy

Cap leads to democracy and social, political advancement through increased quality of living

Friedman 7 (Benjamin M, a political economist the William Joseph Maier Professor of Political Economy, and formerly Chairman of the Department of Economics, at Harvard University. He joined the Harvard faculty in 1972, after receiving his PhD in economics there. He has written/edited fourteen books. “Capitalism, economic growth & democracy,” Daedalus, Summer, 2007, Vol. 136, No. 3, On Capitalism & Democracy, Published by: The MIT Press on behalf of American Academy of Arts & Sciences, pgs 47-50, https://www.jstor.org/stable/20028128 //ghs-LHM)

Half a century ago, the open question was whether central planning or a de centralized private market could better deliver efficient production of goods and services, investment in new capital resources, and gains over time in productivity and therefore, ultimately, in a population's standard of living. Richard Nixon's famous 'kitchen debate' with Nikita Khrushchev, in 1959, attracted so much interest at the time not just on account of the surrounding theatrics but because the question about which they were arguing was genuinely under dispute. Americans' memories of the 1930s were still strong; Soviet living standards were reportedly improving rapidly; and the Soviets had only recently demonstrated their scientific prowess by launching the Sputnik satellite into orbit around the Earth. Later, when Khrushchev said that the Soviet Union would 'bury' the United States, he was not threatening nuclear war (as many at the time misinterpreted him to imply) but predicting that the Soviets, with their superior economic system, would eventually overwhelm the West economically and therefore politically. Khrushchev was wrong. And as more and more people living under Communism came to realize the error of that prediction, change ensued in fairly short order. Mao's China gave way to Deng's not as a matter of ideological preference - quite the contrary - but because Chinese citizens did not want to live in poverty forever and China's rulers feared the consequences of forcing them to do so. Similarly, a key trigger of the demise of the Soviet Union and its empire was that enough people there and in Eastern Europe - importantly including practically all of the nomenklatura - eventually understood that, notwithstanding the official propaganda, they were falling ever farther behind Western living standards. In 1990 the average Soviet living standard was only one-third that of the United States, even after allowing for differences in the cost of living. The comparable ratio for Poland versus (West) Germany was one-eighth. Perhaps ironically, an even more dramatic demonstration of the superior effectiveness of market-oriented economic systems is Korea. At the time of its partition, at the end of World War II, what became South Korea was the poorer, more agricultural part of the Korean peninsula; most of the industry was in the north. Incomes and living standards were meager to negligible by Western standards. Today the South Korean standard of living is more than half that of the United States, modestly ahead of Portugal's, and more than twice Russia's. South Koreans enjoy levels of life expectancy, nutrition, and literacy comparable to Americans' (and the South Korean child mortality rate is lower). North Korea, by contrast, remains a desperately poor country where people regularly starve in significant numbers, malnutrition is widespread, and those who can manage to do so sneak across the border into China in search of either handouts or surreptitious work at subsistence wages. Whether these contrasts will eventually arrest the attention of the North Korean public, and the country's political leadership, in a way comparable to what happened in China, the Soviet Union, and Eastern Europe is an interesting subject for speculation. But the important fact remains that, ever since the Industrial Revolution, de centralized market economies have had a proven record of delivering rising living standards over sustained periods of time. Asking whether a market economy and democracy go together is therefore tantamount to asking whether economic growth and democracy go together. And thinking of the matter in that way suggests a mechanism by which the connection between the two might indeed be causal. The experience of many countries suggests that when a society experiences rising standards of living, broadly distributed across the population at large, it is also likely to make progress along a variety of dimensions that are either part of the very definition of democracy or closely associated with democracy. These include not just open, contested elections to determine who controls the levers of political power but also political rights and civil liberties more generally ; openness of opportunity for economic and social advancement; tolerance toward recognizably distinct racial, religious, or ethnic groups within the society, including immigrants if the country regularly receives in-migration ; and a sense of fairness in the provision made for those in the society who, whether on account of limited opportunities, lesser human endowments, or even just poor luck in the labor market, fall too far below the prevailing public standard of material well-being. Conversely, experience also suggests that when a society is either stagnating economically or, worse yet, suffering a pervasive decline in living standards, it is not only likely to make little if any progress in these social, political, and (in the eighteenth-century sense) moral dimensions, but all too often it will undergo a period of rigidification and retrenchment, sometimes with catastrophic consequences. The key to why so many societies behave in this way is that most people evaluate their living standards not in absolute but relative terms. Further, substantial evidence points to two distinct benchmarks by which people judge how well off they are: Most people are pleased when they are able to live better than they, or their families, have lived in the past. And they are pleased when they are able to live better than their friends, neighbors, coworkers, and others with whom they compare themselves. The pervasive tendency for people to evaluate their economic situation by these relative, rather than absolute, benchmarks explains a variety of economic and psychological behaviors that otherwise would be puzzling. For example, within any one country, at any given time, people with higher incomes are systematically happier than those with lower incomes, but there is no corresponding increase over time in how happy people are on average even though average incomes may be steadily increasing. As Adam Smith observed long ago, "All men, sooner or later, accommodate themselves to whatever becomes their permanent situation," so that "between one permanent situation and another there [is], with regard to real happiness, no essential difference." Smith went on, "In every permanent situation, where there is no expectation of change, the mind of every man... returns to its natural state of tranquillity. In prosperity, after a certain time, it falls back to that state ; in adversity, after a certain time, it rises up to it."2 But this propensity toward a relative rather than an absolute perspective can also explain why market economies, as long as they deliver rising living standards to most of a society's population, lead more often than not to democracy and many of the other features of a democratic society. If people derive satisfaction both from living better than they have in the past and from living better than people around them - and, importantly, if these two sources of satisfaction are at least partially substitutes for one another - then when people are in fact living better than they have in the past (and have confidence that their living standard will continue to improve in the future) they will attach less urgency to the desire also to live better than others around them. Hence the economically self-protective instinct that underlies so much of what emerges as intolerant, antidemocratic, and ungenerous behavior - racial and religious discrimination, antipathy toward immigrants, lack of generosity toward the poor - naturally takes a back seat to other priorities when the economy is delivering sustained growth with broadly distributed increases in living standards. A salient implication of this key role played by rising living standards (as opposed to merely a country's average income level) is that many countries throughout the developing world probably will not have to wait until they reach Western levels of per-capita income before they begin to liberalize socially and democratize politically. Here again, South Korea is an instructive example. Over roughly a quarter century, beginning within a decade of the conclusion of the Korean War, South Korea achieved a remarkable record of economic growth that took the country's per-capita income from an extremely low level to better than what one-fourth of Americans then enjoyed and better than what one-third of the richer countries in Western Europe had. And, over a similar period, but following somewhat behind, South Korea evolved from a one-party military dictatorship under Syngman Rhee and his successors into a reasonably well-functioning electoral democracy, with most of the usual democratic freedoms.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 1AR – Cap Good – Env – Innovation

Profit-based innovation can solve but only if it is directed by policies like the aff

Hsu 2021 - D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law

Shi-Ling Hsu 16 December 2021 “How Capitalism Saves the Environment” Capitalism and the Environment: A Proposal to Save the Planet, Cambridge University Press pp. 28 – 55 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108681599.003

2.9 Choose Capitalism Clearly, the job in front of humankind is enormous, complex, and many-faceted. The best hope is to be able to identify certain human impacts that are clearly harmful to the global environment, and to disincentivize them. Getting back to notions of institutions in capitalism, what is crucial is aligning the right incentives with profit-making activity. What capitalism does so well – beyond human comprehension – is coordinate activity and send broad signals about scarcity. Information about a wide variety of environmental phenomena is extremely difficult to collect and process. If a set of environmental taxes can help establish a network of environmental prices, then an unfathomably large and complex machinery will have been set in motion in the right direction. Also, because of the need for new scientific solutions to this daunting list of problems, new science and technology is desperately needed. Capitalism is tried and true in terms of producing innovation. Again drawing upon the study of institutions, it is not so much that individuals need a profit-motive in order to tinker, but the prospect of profit-making has to be present in order for institutions, including corporations, to devote resources, attention, and energy towards the development of solutions to environmental problems. Corporations can and should demonstrate social responsibility by attempting to mitigate their impacts on the global environment, but a much more conscious push for new knowledge, new techniques, and new solutions are needed.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Good – Environment – Innovation Key

Only capitalism can motivate the type of innovations necessary to solve climate change

Hsu 2021 - D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law

Shi-Ling Hsu 16 December 2021 “How Capitalism Saves the Environment” Capitalism and the Environment: A Proposal to Save the Planet, Cambridge University Press pp. 28 – 55 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108681599.003

Frankly, humankind needs some technological breakthroughs akin to miracles to rescue the planet on which it depends. A second reason that capitalism is suited to the job of environmental restoration and protection is its propensity to spur innovation. Humankind does not currently have the technological capability to adequately repair harm already done to the environment, or to even monitor ongoing and future harms. It certainly does not have sufficient technological capability to deal with climate change. Humankind is ill-equipped to reduce its carbon footprint, adapt to unavoidable climatic changes, or reverse some of the emissions already extant in the biosphere. Innovation is an existential matter to humankind and, for that matter, most of the species currently in existence on the planet. There are no magic bullets for innovation. By their nature, innovation is uncertain, and often unexpected. Many solutions are still unknown, perhaps not even dreamed of yet. Hawken et al. describe the experience of a plant operations manager at a Dow Chemical plant in Louisiana, who experimented with a contest among its line workers to suggest operational efficiencies. No tinkerers need apply: project proposals were required to provide a minimum return on investment of 50 percent. In the first year, he received twenty-seven suggestions that averaged a return of 173 percent. In the second year, he received thirty-two suggestions that averaged a return of 340 percent. Somehow, these not-so-little improvements had escaped the attention of management.53 Like the Swedish line workers that found ways to reduce NOx emissions, Dow workers most intimate with plant operations were able to find an astounding number of operational improvements. Perhaps the most that could be said about the role of government in innovation is that the best that it can do is provide the incentives for innovation, but avoid interfering with development. One example of unexpected innovation started in the automotive industry, and has now unexpectedly branched out into residential electricity generation and storage. More than a few financial analysts expressed surprise when the electric carmaker Tesla surpassed the combined value of Ford and General Motors in January 2020. That was such a shocking event because at the time Ford and GM were selling twenty-six times as many cars as Tesla. What gives? Financial analysts writing about the astronomical value of Tesla stock see electric vehicles as a growth industry – itself a good sign – and that Tesla had a unique head start on all of the other carmakers in the world. Tesla CEO Elon Musk is nothing if not an opportunistic capitalist, and despite his mercurial management of the company, he seems to have assured investors that his company is poised to make and sell many, many more electric vehicles. Parenthetically, and potentially very relevant, Tesla acquired a rooftop solar company, Solar City, in 2016. What is the connection? Tesla and Solar City were two of the entities out there entertaining the idea that electric vehicles could serve a residential household as a battery, collecting and storing excess solar energy during the sunny day, for drawing down at night. If this idea remains nascent, the idea of storing excess solar energy has pulled Tesla into the energy storage business, as a supplement to its rooftop solar business. Combining electric vehicle technology and rooftop solar technology has the potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and save money in two realms, transportation and home electricity. Perhaps even more importantly, Tesla’s foray into residential electricity has actually enabled an even broader push, into the large-scale energy storage business. Energy stored in large batteries – another area where capitalist energies might colonize – is extremely useful in its ability to deliver electricity when demand unexpectedly surges. Energy storage is such an important technology because it can fix a chronic problem with renewable energy sources such as wind and solar: their intermittency. Storing excess electricity generated by renewable sources adds value to the renewable source, and represents a potentially low-cost, zero-carbon replacement for fossil fuel-fired power plants built to handle sporadic and unexpected peak demands. State regulators and electric utilities are scrambling to find alternative ways of delivering power during these peak demand times, without having to start up a fossil fuel-fired power plant. Suffice it to say, electric vehicle dominance is far from assured for Tesla. In recent years, the behemoth automaker General Motors has jettisoned some of its costly capital assets to raise money to try and challenge Tesla for electric vehicle leadership. Whether the stodgy, century-old company, which had required federal subsidies in 2010 to survive, can reinvent itself, is an open question. But it is likely to play a role in ensuring that Tesla continues to innovate, and perhaps not just in the electric vehicle industry. Finally, a third reason that capitalism is suited to the job of environmental restoration and protection is its ability to undertake and complete projects at very large scales. In keeping with a major thesis of this book, construction at very large scales should give us a little pause, because of the propensity of capital to metastasize into a source of political resistance to change. But some global problems, especially climate change, may require very large-scale enterprises. For example, because greenhouse gas emissions may already have passed a threshold for catastrophic climate change, technology is almost certainly needed to chemically capture carbon dioxide from ambient air. But carbon dioxide is only about 0.15% of ambient air by molecular weight, and a tremendous amount of ambient air must be processed just to capture a small amount of carbon dioxide. This technology has often been referred to as “direct air capture,” or “carbon removal.” Given that inherent limitation, direct air capture technology must be deployed at vast scales in order to make any appreciable difference in greenhouse gas concentrations. There is certainly no guarantee that direct air capture will be a silver bullet. But if it is to be an effectual item on a menu of survival techniques, it will more assuredly be accomplished under the incentives of a capitalist economy. Capitalism might also help with the looming crisis of climate change by helping to ensure the supply of vital life staples such as food, water, and other basic needs in future shortages caused by climate-change. In a climate-changed future, there is the distinct possibility that supplies of vital life staples may run short, possibly for long periods of time. Droughts are projected to last longer, with water supplies and growing conditions increasingly precarious. Capitalist enterprise could, first of all, provide the impetus to finally reform a dizzying multitude of price distortions that plague water supply and agriculture worldwide. Second, capitalist enterprise can undertake scale production of some emergent technologies that might alleviate shortages. Desalination technology can convert salty seawater into drinkable freshwater.54 A number of environmental and economic issues need to be solved to deploy these technologies at large scales, but in a crisis, solutions will be more likely to present themselves. A technology that is already being adopted to produce food is the modernized version of old-fashioned greenhouses. The tiny country of the Netherlands, with its 17 million people crowded onto 13,000 square miles, is the second largest food exporter in the world,55 exporting fully three-quarters that of the United States in 2017.56 The secret to Dutch agriculture is its climate-controlled, low-energy greenhouses that project solar panel-powered artificial sunlight around the clock. Dutch greenhouses produce lettuce at ten times the yield57 and tomatoes at fifteen times the yield outdoors in the United States58 while using less than one-thirteenth the amount of water,59 very little in the way of synthetic pesticides and, of course, very little fertilizer given its advanced composting techniques. Sustained shortages in a climate-changed future might require that a capitalist take hold of greenhouse growing and expand production to feed the masses that might otherwise revolt.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Sustainable – Ethics

Cap is Sustainable – stakeholder capitalism promotes ethical consumption.

Zhang 23 - Ruirui Zhang, Ph.D., is an associate professor at the Department of fashion design and Retailing at Framingham State University. Her research interests include sustainable consumption, environmental philosophy, fashion SMEs sustainability practices and GHG accounting, and life cycle assessment. Dr. Zhang's research has been published in Sustainable Production and Consumption, the International Journal of Fashion Design, Technology, and Education, and Bloomsbury Publishing, etc. [“Gifts and Commodities: A Dialectical Thought Experiment for Sublation”, Sustainability 15, no. 9: 7562, https://doi.org/10.3390/su15097562] AT GH

Within business models that consider stakeholder capitalism as a model, shareholder capitalism has received criticism for its lack of ethical grounding, as it prioritizes the interests of shareholders and their freedom to operate businesses, often at the expense of long-term sustainability and ethical considerations. This short-term focus on profit maximization has contributed to suboptimal outcomes, including global issues such as wealth inequality, environmental degradation, unsafe working conditions, and climate change. However, stakeholder capitalism is gaining popularity among institutions such as companies and organizations [,]. This model prioritizes balancing the interests of all stakeholders, including shareholders, employees, vendors, customers, local communities, and the environment. Its aim is to shift focus away from short-term profit-seeking and towards fulfilling business obligations to serve the interests of all stakeholders [], with a particular emphasis on the well-being of people and the planet. For stakeholder capitalism to serve as a more equitable and sustainable model that benefits everyone instead of just a few, decision-makers at all levels, including governments and companies, must move away from fetishizing profits and adopt a broader definition of economic progress and activities []. One approach we propose to achieve this is by replacing the single-minded measurement matrix, which is commodities produced, exchanged, and consumed in the neo-liberal free market system, with a “giftized commodity” that captures a broader scope beyond just monetary value. Integrating this new construct into the stakeholder capitalism agenda requires boards of directors and executives to have explicit knowledge and understanding of the importance of fulfilling obligations of giving, receiving, and reciprocity in the value chain of giftized commodity production and consumption. Within the discussion of the scope of marketplace obligations, understanding that human behavior concerning consumption, production, and disposal of goods involves a giftized commodity and not a mere commodity brings to light the fact that the obligations of marketplace participants extend beyond the autonomous buyer-seller transaction given so much attention by neo-liberal economists. When the marketplace commodity is recognized as inherently having dimensions of gift, deliberations by consumers, policymakers, and academicians take into account far-away people, future generations, and nature as an essential part of a market-place transaction and not as a superfluous duty (a duty that, with equal ethical import, may or may not be acknowledged by a buyer/seller). Becoming “green” is not a marketing or lifestyle decision; it is a responsibility for participating in a market. Goals for sustainability, determined by the United Nations or any other body, require a change in human behavior. Obligations bend behavior, and obligations in giftized commodities are not superadded niceties. They must affect the behavior of people, corporations, and governments.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Sustainable

Capitalism keeps the working world in balance

Walter Libby, 3-6-2016, "The End Game”, , shl)

So, was Marx right? Economically, that remains to be seen. But Marx, the revolutionist, he's dead. Today, even if revolution was in the air, if workers were to overthrow the system, they'd have to contend with modern armies: tanks, machines guns and Apache helicopters. But that aside, the fact is, we live in a MAD world where anarchy is in the air. In such an environment, if the global economy were to collapse, there would be no revolution; only chaos and martial law. Here, the nuclear powers go into their respective versions of DEFCON I: don't mess with us while we try to clean up this mess. So hunkered down in their nuclear fortresses, what's likely to rise from the wreckage is a quasi-Orwellian world where power for the sake power rules: the eternal rule of Big Brother. So, even if Marx is right economically, what is there to cheer about; a darkening cloud of uncertainty and angst hangs over the global economy in a MAD world. So, let's cut to the source of that uncertainty and angst. Capitalism and Marxism are ideologies that rose out of the industrial revolution (the most significant event in human history), and as they emerged, they brought forth an age of idiocy. These are matter over mind theories. For them, it is the material base, the marketplace that determines history. And here, both have put their faith and our fate in the hands of that marketplace god; different prophets to be sure, but with the same belief: history is preordained. For Marxists, it's simply this: the Industrial Revolution, as it winds its way through history, constantly advances technology and so constantly replaces workers with machines. Inevitability this process reaches a crisis stage wherein unemployment reaches a critical mass, and pissed-off workers rise up and overthrow the existing order, put in place a dictatorship of the proletariat who take hold of the productive reins and once the process is complete, they turn to communism: from each according to ability, to each according to need — the end of history. With capitalism it's all too simple: the marketplace in and of itself self-corrects; keeps everything in balance — end of story, end of history.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Sustainable

Capitalism is sustainable, we’re entering a golden age

Hausfather 21 – Hausfather, Zeke, 6/21, Zeke is a climate scientist and energy systems analyst with a PhD in climate science from the University of California, Berkeley. ("Absolute Decoupling of Economic Growth and Emissions in 32 Countries," Breakthrough Institute,https://thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/absolute-decoupling-of-economic-growth-and- emissions-in-32-countries) BHO

The past 30 years have seen immense progress in improving the quality of life for much of humanity. Extreme poverty — the number of people living on less than $1.90 per day — has fallen by nearly two-thirds, from 1.9 billion to around 650 million. Life expectancy has risen in most of the world, along with literacy and access to education, while infant mortality has fallen. Despite perceptions to the contrary, the average person born today is likely to have access to more opportunities and have a better quality of life than at any other point in human history. Much of this increase in human wellbeing has been propelled by rapid economic growth driven largely by state-led industrial policy, particularly in poor-to-middle income countries. However, this growth has come at a cost: between 1990 and 2019, global emissions of CO2 increased by 56%. Historically, economic growth has been closely linked to increased energy consumption — and increased CO2 emissions in particular — leading some to argue that a more prosperous world is one that necessarily has more impacts on our natural environment and climate. There is a lively academic debate about our ability to “absolutely decouple” emissions and growth — that is, the extent to which the adoption of clean energy technology can allow emissions to decline while economic growth continues. Over the past 15 years, however, something has begun to change. Rather than a 21st century dominated by coal that energy modelers foresaw, global coal use peaked in 2013 and is now in structural decline. We have succeeded in making clean energy cheap, with solar power and battery storage costs falling 10-fold since 2009. The world produced more electricity from clean energy — solar, wind, hydro, and nuclear — than from coal over the past two years. And, according to some major oil companies, peak oil is upon us — not because we have run out of cheap oil to produce, but because demand is falling and companies expect further decline as consumers increasingly shift to electric vehicles. The world has long been experiencing a relative decoupling between economic growth and CO2 emissions, with the emissions per unit of GDP falling for the past 60 years. This is the case even in countries like India and China that have been undergoing rapid economic growth. But relative decoupling alone is inadequate in a world where global CO2 emissions need to peak and decline in the next decade to give us any chance at limiting warming to well below 2℃, in line with Paris Agreement targets. Thankfully, there is increasing evidence that the world is on track to absolutely decouple CO2 emissions and economic growth — with global CO2 emissions potentially having peaked in 2019 and unlikely to increase substantially in the coming decade. While an emissions peak is just the first and easiest step towards eventually reaching the net-zero emissions required to stop the world from continuing to warm, it demonstrates that linkages between emissions and economic activity are not an immutable law, but rather simply a result of our current means of energy production. In recent years we have seen more and more examples of absolute decoupling — economic growth accompanied by falling CO2 emissions. Since 2005, 32 countries with a population of at least one million people have absolutely decoupled emissions from economic growth, both for terrestrial emissions (those within national borders) and consumption emissions (emissions embodied in the goods consumed in a country). This includes the United States, Japan, Mexico, Germany, United Kingdom, France, Spain, Poland, Romania, Netherlands, Belgium, Portugal, Sweden, Hungary, Belarus, Austria, Bulgaria, El Salvador, Singapore, Denmark, Finland, Slovakia, Norway, Ireland, New Zealand, Croatia, Jamaica, Lithuania, Slovenia, Latvia, Estonia, and Cyprus. Figure 1, below, shows the declines in territorial emissions (blue) and increases in GDP (red). To qualify as having experienced absolute decoupling, we require countries included in this analysis to pass four separate filters: a population of at least one million (to focus the analysis on more representative cases), declining territorial emissions over the 2005-2019 period (based on a linear regression), declining consumption emissions, and increasing real GDP (on a purchasing power parity basis, using constant 2017 international $USD). We chose not to include 2020 in this analysis because it is not particularly representative of longer-term trends, and consumption and territorial emissions estimates are not yet available for many countries. There is a wide range of rates of economic growth between 2005-2019 among countries experiencing absolute decoupling. Somewhat counterintuitively, there is no significant relationship between the rate of economic growth and the magnitude of emissions reductions within the group. While it is unlikely that there is not at least some linkage between the two factors, there are plenty of examples of countries (e.g., Singapore, Romania, and Ireland) experiencing both extremely rapid economic growth and large reductions in CO2 emissions. One of the primary criticisms of some prior analyses of absolute decoupling is that they ignore leakage. Specifically, the offshoring of manufacturing from high-income countries over the past three decades to countries like China has led to “illusory” drops in emissions, where the emissions associated with high-income country consumption are simply shipped overseas and no longer show up in territorial emissions accounting. There is some truth in this critique, as there was a large increase in emissions embodied in imports from developing countries between 1990 and 2005. After 2005, however, structural changes in China and a growing domestic market led to a reversal of these trends; the amount of emissions “exported” from developed countries to developing countries has actually declined over the past 15 years. This means that, for many countries, both territorial emissions and consumption emissions (which include any emissions “exported” to other countries)

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Cap Sustainable – Scarcity

Cap solves scarcity by promoting investment in a circular economy

Richards 20(Anne, Chief Executive Officer at Fidelity International. She has worked in research analysis, and promotes ESG/sustainable investing. She received her Master of Business Administration from INSEAD. “Scarcity and growth: our world's contradictory terrors,” The World Economic Forum, January 6, 2020, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/01/scarcity-growth-worlds-contradictory-terrors/ //ghs-LHM)

Economics is the science of scarcity. And Friedman’s ideas solved the scarcity problems of his day – the lack of price stability and the difficulty of accessing financial capital. By bringing inflation under control and freeing up the flow of capital, he made them less scarce. The world has made undeniable strides in the past half century. We have fed and clothed most of a world population that has doubled since 1970. Malnutrition has plummeted and living standards have risen. But the cost has been high. We have choked the ocean with plastic, burned our forests and altered climate patterns. In fact, we have changed the world so much that scientists have declared we are living in the Anthropocene epoch – a geological age defined by the impact of humans on a planet we have permanently changed. As a consequence, we have changed the nature of scarcity. Now positive yield, societal stability, and what might be called environmental capital, are scarce. These are things that Friedman might have considered inexhaustible. But, as we are learning, they too have their limits. R H Tawney, the economic historian, said: “The certainties of one age are the problems of the next.” The certainties of the previous age have certainly given us a conundrum today: the prices of financial assets have risen steadily, the world is running out of stuff that we need, and yet we are struggling to dispose of the things that we don’t. Paradoxically, this has led to both the economic fear that growth will soon come to an end, and the ecological fear that it will not. Circularity - While we wait for another Friedman to come along, we, as investors must adapt to the realities of today. We have to reimagine what defines economic success. That is where the concept of the circular economy comes in. Circularity means moving from a linear world in which we make, consume and then dispose of products, to one where waste can be fed back into the system as a raw material. Success isn’t just measured by growth. It’s measured by effective reuse. Eventually, this shift won’t be a matter of choice. History is littered with species and civilizations that stayed linear and ran out of road. The Easter Islanders, who managed to denude their island of 16 million trees within a few hundred years, spring to mind. At the moment, only around 9% of the world’s economy can be considered as “circular,” or as being recycled and reused. But from Greta Thunberg’s school strikes to the proposals for a Green New Deal in the US, this new economic philosophy of circularity is beginning to take hold in the minds of policymakers and the general public. Today’s young are already weighed down with concern about whether there will be a planet left to inherit from their parents. Forget shiny new cars. They will ask why, when 92% of cars in Europe are empty and parked at any one time, according to an HSBC research note, people don’t just share. The Corporate Future - Just as consumers are asking questions about the sustainability of their own habits, so investors must ask themselves questions about which business models are best placed to weather this change. Since Friedman developed his ideas in the early 1970s, the role of corporations has transformed. As a result, even the CEOs of the biggest corporates have said that running them solely for the benefit of equity owners is no longer an option. That includes CEOs of the US Business Roundtable, who last year embraced “stakeholders” over “shareholders”. Businesses don’t exist in isolation – they have multiple stakeholders, from employees, to the communities they work in and the planet as a whole. Our job will become less about finding the best short-term returns and rather more about discovering sustainable businesses and industries to invest in. Shareholder value is still a vitally important driver of corporate behaviour. But it’s not the only one that matters when you look at the longer-term horizon. The economic models of the past solved the problems of scarcity of the past. The circular economy may not answer all the questions of the “extremely perplexed” but it does present a starting point to help solve today’s problems of scarcity. Our capital markets will increasingly reward the companies and investors that are positioned to rise to the challenge.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Industrial Ecology

The plan is an example of ‘industrial ecology’ – an absolute free market may be bad for the environment, but establishing policies that constrain and direct the energies of capitalism can redirect its destructive impulse towards positive projects

Hsu 2021 - D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law

Shi-Ling Hsu 16 December 2021 “How Capitalism Saves the Environment” Capitalism and the Environment: A Proposal to Save the Planet, Cambridge University Press pp. 28 – 55 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108681599.003

“Industrial ecology” is a field of research which emerged in the 1990s that seeks to find technical and economic opportunities within industry to reduce environmental harm. Rather than grudgingly accept capitalism as an unfortunate reality, industrial ecology purposefully works within capitalism, seeking the cooperation of industry in formulating not only different environmental solutions, but potentially different industrial processes. If Speth, Lewis, and other writers of that ilk see capitalists – corporations, in particular – as inherently capricious, industrial ecologists hope to harness the expertise of polluting corporations to help solve the technological problems of pollution: [I]ndustrial ecology also positions corporate entities from service companies to manufacturing companies to mining corporations to giant agricultural operations as key players in the protection of the environment. The first generation view, which sees corporations as reprobates causes us to miss out on their potential for environmental leadership especially on the technological aspects of environmental problems by looking to industry for environmental benefit.33 This represented a clear conceptual break from what had been at the time a dominant paradigm of pollution control, which was adversarial in nature. Industrial ecology also sounded a call to reform pollution laws that addressed pollution piecemeal, one pollutant at a time, one media at a time, one industrial process at a time, by urging focus on industries and their environments as holistic systems, so that all of the linkages (including pollution) can be addressed at once. A broader systems view would hopefully produce environmental policy that is less myopic, more focused on preservation of ecological systems, and preventing separate regulations from working at cross-purposes. For example, one area of industrial ecology would concern solid wastes, and would call for a more careful search of opportunities to recycle and reuse industrial wastes, as opposed to stringent and inflexible regulations governing the waste that might preclude productive and cost-saving reuse. In their book, Natural Capitalism, Paul Hawken, Amory Lovins, and Hunter Lovins make many of these same points, and seek many of the same opportunities. Their focus is more explicitly on the contribution of natural systems to human wealth creation and well-being, a concept that has been dubbed “ecosystem services.” Viewed that way, natural systems like wetlands that provide a variety of benefits to humans, such as flood control, water purification, wildlife habitat, and recreation, are capital, or “natural capital.”34 Like industrial ecologists, natural capitalists such as Hawken, Lovins, and Lovins would install an accounting system so that firms take account of harm to natural systems caused by their production processes. The hope is that not only that polluting firms internalize environmental externalities, but that there exist some incentive for firms to restore, or repair, or, invest in natural capital. Like industrial ecologists, natural capitalists see a number of production processes that are both inefficient and environmentally harmful, and look for policies to reform those processes. Like industrial ecologists, they contemplate extensive tax reform, taxing some polluting harms (like carbon dioxide) and eliminating harmful expenditures, such as most agricultural subsidies. Like industrial ecologists, and unlike Speth, Lewis, Marx, Schumpeter, and Polanyi, they are hopeful about preserving both capitalism and the global environment. And importantly, like industrial ecologists, they find inspiration in the ways that natural systems produce ecosystem services and process waste, seeking to install production systems that mimic natural processes. Those natural restorative processes provide potentially important lessons for private, capitalist firms in the business of environmental restoration. This would require, as this book argues in Chapter 7, a much, much broader scientific knowledge base of how human activity affects the global environment. My call in this book goes further than industrial ecologists and natural capitalists do. Not only do I believe that capitalism, and its profit-making corporate machines, are compatible with a more enlightened approach to environmental protection, I believe that it will be the central means by which the global environment is restored and protected. Capitalism is a powerful social force that will drive society in whatever direction it is pointed. But it has to be consciously pointed in the right direction.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Affirmative › 2AC – Perm – Combo Deal

Capitalism can be reformed through the incorporation of extern social systems like the alternative – ‘all or nothing’ approaches are too fatalistic and ignore how forcing companies to internalize pollution costs

Hsu 2021 - D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law

Shi-Ling Hsu 16 December 2021 “How Capitalism Saves the Environment” Capitalism and the Environment: A Proposal to Save the Planet, Cambridge University Press pp. 28 – 55 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108681599.003

Polanyi seems to have been proven correct that capitalist firms, compelled to make profits in competitive markets, have supplanted many social structures, and profoundly influenced the development of people within them. But it is proving too much to say that capitalist firms are driven only by profits. It is true that the environment seems to be the most convenient dumping ground for external costs, causing Speth to pronounce corporations “externalizing machines.” The built-in incentive to find ways to cut costs by fobbing them off on others is undeniable. But while corporations routinely greenwash and whitewash their behavior, it seems too simplistic to caricature all corporations in the era of capitalism driven solely, inexorably, by greed, and utterly indifferent to the disintegration of society and the global environment. If there is an undeniable logic to the externalizing compulsion within capitalism, there is also much reason to expect responses pushing back. First, there is Polanyi’s “double movement,” efforts to protect societal structures from displacement by capitalism. Social structures are critical to most people, rivaling or surpassing economic opportunity in importance. Politically, at least in democracies, there apparently is at least as much purchase to be had by politicians promising to restore social structures, even by demagoguery or deceit, as there is in promising economic riches. The history of labor laws, environmental laws, and once upon a time antitrust laws, has vindicated Polanyi. Polanyi thought these responses would ultimately fall short, and capitalism would wind up cannibalizing both society and itself. But while all of these areas of regulation have regressed at some point, it is premature to declare defeat. Second, it seems oversimplistic to assume that all capitalist titans are capriciously indifferent to a dark future of broken capitalism and a ruined environment. Corporate behavior may often seem to point in that direction, but a closer look is warranted. It is implausible that even the wealthiest capitalists imagine they can insulate themselves from massive crises that roil the masses. Some imagine that capitalist titans think they could build a moat around a castle of economic opulence and lock out the masses. This seems implausible in the environmental context. Nor does it seem likely that, even if capitalist titans think they can somehow construct a lifeboat for themselves, their family, and something like a community of their friends, this would seem a worthy endeavor, even to capitalists. The cognitive dissonance is just too great. The former Volvo and IKEA executive, and now a sustainability expert, Göran Carstedt, once said “People say that corporations must first and foremost make profits … Of course they do! But that is like saying people must first and foremost breathe.”35 As Donald Trump began the formal withdrawal of the United States from the Paris agreement, the 2015 United Nations Conference of Parties agreement that created an international framework for the reduction of greenhouse gases, the Chief Executive Officers of seventy-five large global corporations announced their support for the agreement, and their company’s commitment to voluntarily contribute their share of emissions reductions. These firms included Apple, Google, Microsoft, Bank of America, Citigroup, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Unilever, Nestlé, Disney, and Goldman Sachs, heading a up a who’s-who list of rapaciously greedy capitalists. It is more plausible that capitalist firms, and the officers and directors therein, would prefer to pursue more sustainable paths of profit-making, but feel constrained by corporation laws and some hard-to-define business norms. To embark upon something less than a profit-maximization path would require the solution of two difficult problems: (i) inculcating a cultural change within the firm, and (ii) coordination with competitors and rivals. In addition to economic barriers, strongly held norms and emotions usually obstruct changes in operation. In that sense, Polanyi and the capitalism skeptics are right in that there is something inexorable about capitalism and about competitive global markets that compels a firm to make profits first and foremost.