Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Internal Link › State Policy Good

Federal preemption prevents state by state creative solutions.

Lin 20 Albert C. Lin is a Professor of Law at University of California Davis. “Uncooperative Environmental Federalism: State Suits Against the Federal Governmentin an Age of Political Polarization” https://escholarship.org/content/qt64j5g27g/qt64j5g27g_noSplash_161db18130a88901cb11901156950dd0.pdf, [Accessed: 6-18-2021]//cblasi

Although many federal environmental statutes incorporate a cooperative federalism approach, some environmental statutes preempt state regulation in part or altogether. Federal preemption can facilitate interstate commerce by establishing a uniform national standard in place of multiple, potentially conflicting state standards.142 At the same time, preemption can stifle local innovation and be unresponsive to local concerns.143 The Hazardous Materials Transportation Act,144 Ports and Waterways Safety Act, 145 and Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act146 exemplify statutes that promote interstate commerce through preemption provisions.147 States and the federal government have frequently litigated the preemptive effect of these statutes as well as state efforts to impose more stringent standards.148 Preemption’s constricting effects on state sovereignty make these cases unsurprising, if not predictable. Other federalism-related environmental disputes between states and the federal government have centered on the Tenth Amendment, which reserves for the states the powers not delegated to the federal government.149 The leading case interpreting the Tenth Amendment, New York v. United States,150 involved a challenge to a federal law that directed states either to regulate radioactive waste disposal in a specified manner or to take title to the waste.151 The Supreme Court held the statute invalid under the Tenth Amendment because it “‘commandeer[ed]’ state governments into the service of federal regulatory purposes.”152 The Court noted, however, that the federal government may offer states a choice between regulating according to federal standards and having state law preempted.153 In subsequent cases where states have raised Tenth Amendment claims, lower courts have accordingly upheld federal schemes that offered states such a choice and rejected those that did not.154

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Link › AT Federalism Bad/CP Solves/States Solves CC

Federalism can be used towards progressive ends – States should get to take the lead

Ericson 22 – Sean Ericson is an opinion columnist for the Daily, [“It’s About States’ Rights – For Real This Time”, The Minnesota Daily, 7/11/2022, ]RA

In fact, I believe that liberals may have to use state and local government to accomplish their goals in the near future. Democrats will likely lose control of at least one house of Congress in November, and the nation’s highest court has a solidly conservative majority. Andrew Karch is a political science professor at the University of Minnesota who studies federalism in public policy. He said it’s true there are “general tendencies” in which liberals tend to favor federal power (and local power in large, blue cities) more than conservatives. However, those principles “can sort of be downplayed if it’s in the pursuit of certain goals that these parties also find really important,” Karch said. In other words, the stereotype about federal Democrats and state-based Republicans isn’t always true. After the recent decision in Dobbs v. Jackson overturning Roe v. Wade, liberals need to make sure we can protect abortion rights in states where we have control. This will become especially relevant if a federal abortion ban ever gains traction. Climate change is a global crisis. But that doesn’t mean individual states can’t take action. Examples of this include California’s recent move to restrict its state pension funds’ ability to invest in oil, and a bill introduced in New York that would impose a fee on some fossil fuel companies to help pay for climate mitigation projects. States could also impose a carbon tax. This would run the risk of industry fleeing to neighboring states, but it could also reduce a state’s share of carbon emissions. There’s also the question of local government. At the federal level, Democrats are usually the ones favoring centralized government. However, this trend is sometimes reversed at the state and local levels. This, Karch said, is because of how Americans are clustered ideologically. When there are liberal cities within a more conservative state, then liberals are likely to want to decentralize power to the city level, he said, citing the work of Yale law professor Heather Gerken. On the other hand, “many state governments are increasingly adopting preemptive laws,” which prevent cities from passing certain policies. Karch gave the example of laws which prevent cities from raising their minimum wage — laws that exist in many states. Raising the minimum wage should be a progressive priority. A 2019 review of international evidence on the minimum wage found that raising it has a minimal effect on employment and a significant effect on raising workers’ incomes. Plus, studies have associated minimum wage increases with other benefits as well. These include decreased rates of smoking, child neglect, teen alcohol use, teen pregnancy and low birth weight among babies. So liberal federalism isn’t just about states vs. the federal government – it’s also about expanding upon the power of local municipalities to set their own policies. I’m not arguing for unconditional decentralization. Like I said at the beginning, many of this country’s greatest victories for liberty and justice have been the result of the imposition of federal power over states and localities. But, I do believe that federalism can, at times, be useful for progressives. And I also believe that the coming period — one of gridlock and conservative control at the federal level — will be one in which federalism is particularly useful.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Link › Link – Tax and Spend

Increasing regulatory taxes undermines the delicate balance of competitive federalism between the federal government and the states

Mason ’11 — Ruth Mason (Visiting Associate Professor of Law, Yale Law School; Associate Professor of Law and Nancy and Bill Trachsel Corporate Law Scholar, University of Connecticut Law School); “Federalism and the Taxing Power;” California Law Review, Volume 99, 2011; JSTOR, Accessed via KU Libraries

If Congress uses tax expenditures and penalties to regulate areas traditionally or constitutionally reserved to the states, then such tax regulation raises federalism concerns similar to those raised when Congress makes conditional grants to the states.95 Thus, to the extent that we are concerned about the federalism impact of conditional grants, arguably we also should be concerned about the federalism impact of tax expenditures and penalties. Among the values that federalism promotesis horizontal competition among the statesfor residents who are free to move to any state in the Union. Competition forces state governments to respond to the political preferences of their residents.96 The states’ smaller size compared to that of the nation also may facilitate political participation,97 at least when a single voter’s voice carries more weight in state than federal elections.98 Similarly, the smaller size of states, coupled with uneven distribution of voter preferences across the country, facilitates policy diversity: each state can adopt policies that reflect the preferences of its residents, which may differ from national preferences or from preferences of residents of other states.99 Closely related to this is the idea that states may devise different ways to pursue similar policy goals, thus serving, in Justice Brandeis’ famous words, as “laborator[ies]” for “social and economic experiments.”100 Federalism also promotes vertical competition between the federal and state governments. Although the federal and state governments do not compete for residents, James Madison predicted that they would compete for the affections of the governed.101 For any regulatory area not exclusively assigned to the federal or state governments by the Constitution, Madison envisioned that the people would choose their regulator.102 If they trusted the federal government more, the people would invest more power with the federal government, or vice versa. 103 In this way, Madison believed that the federal and state governments would check each other, so that neither would become oppressive.104 It is not necessary to repeat at length here the well-known claim that conditional federal spending jeopardizes federalism values.105 Instead, it should suffice to draw the analogy between federal grant spending and federal tax spending. When it conditions grants upon states’ implementation of particular policies, the federal government thereby reduces the scope for state policy experimentation and competition. Similarly, when the federal government uses federal tax law to reach past the states to regulate private taxpayer behavior though tax expenditures and penalties, it may leave less room for states to implement different or contrary policies. Where federal tax incentives reward taxpayers for engaging in particular activities, such as education,106 home ownership,107 and the purchase of private health insurance,108 those tax incentives may displace the expression of local values and local political preferences. Similarly, to at least some extent the federal government may override local political decisions when it uses tax penalties to discourage certain activities, such as smoking, gambling, and driving. If, in order to secure federal subsidies or avoid federal penalties, taxpayers strive to meet federal (rather than local) standards, then the taxing power raises concerns similar to those raised by the spending power.109 Specifically, if the federal government uses its taxing power to enlarge the scope of its regulatory influence beyond its constitutionally enumerated powers, it reduces the areas in which the states can compete with the federal government and with each other. Thus, just as commentators have accused Congress of using conditional federal grants to crowd out state regulation,110 so too may Congress use federal taxes to crowd out state regulation. Ultimately, the extent of this problem depends on unanswered empirical questions regarding the extent to which federal taxing and spending displaces state and local regulation in similar substantive areas. The impact of federal taxes on state legislative choices also depends on legal questions, such as whether the federal government may use taxes to achieve ends that lie beyond its other constitutionally enumerated powers, and whether such regulation can preempt state taxes and regulations. Parts II and III consider these legal issues

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Link › Link – Welfare

Expanding welfare ensures government overreach through fraud crackdown, decimating state sovereignty and drastically increasing surveillance.

Geiger 23 – Gabriel Geiger is an investigative reporter at Lighthouse Reports, covering technology and surveillance, [“How Denmark’s Welfare State Became a Surveillance Nightmare”, Wired, 3/7/2023, ]RA

Denmark’s Public Benefits Administration employs hundreds of people who oversee one of the world's most well-funded welfare states. The country spends 26 percent of its GDP on benefits—more than Sweden, the United States, and the United Kingdom. It’s been hailed as a leading example of how governments can support their most vulnerable citizens. Bernie Sanders, the US senator, called the Nordic nation of 6 million people a model for how countries should approach welfare. But over the past decade, the scale of Denmark’s benefits spending has come under intense scrutiny, and the perceived scourge of welfare fraud is now at the top of the country’s political agenda. Armed with questionable data on the amount of benefits fraud taking place, conservative politicians have turned Denmark’s famed safety net into a polarizing political battleground. It has become an article of faith among the country’s right-wing politicians that Denmark is losing hundreds of millions of euros to benefits fraud each year. In 2011, KMD, one of Denmark’s largest IT companies, estimated that up to 5 percent of all welfare payments in the country were fraudulent. KMD’s estimates would make the Nordic nation an outlier, and its findings have been criticized by some academics. In France, it’s estimated that fraud amounts to 0.39 percent of all benefits paid. A similar estimate made in the Netherlands in 2016 by broadcaster RTL found the average amount of fraud per benefit payment was €‎17 ($18), or just 0.2 percent of total benefits payments. The perception of widespread welfare fraud has empowered Jacobsen to establish one of the most sophisticated and far-reaching fraud detection systems in the world. She has tripled the number of state databases her agency can access from three to nine, compiling information on people’s taxes, homes, cars, relationships, employers, travel, and citizenship. Her agency has developed an array of machine learning models to analyze this data and predict who may be cheating the system. Documents obtained by Lighthouse Reports and WIRED through freedom-of-information requests show how Denmark is building algorithms to profile benefits recipients based on everything from their nationality to whom they may be sleeping next to at night. They reveal a system where technology and political agendas have become entwined, with potentially dangerous consequences. Danish human rights groups such as Justitia describe the agency’s expansion as “systematic surveillance” and disproportionate to the scale of welfare fraud. Denmark's system has yet to be challenged under EU law. Whether the country’s experiments with machine learning cross a legal line is a question that could be answered by the European Union’s landmark Artificial Intelligence Act, proposed legislation that aims to safeguard human rights against emerging technologies. THE DEBATE ABOUT welfare in Denmark changed in October 2012, when officials asked residents to send in photos of suspected welfare cheats in their local area. The call led some left-leaning commentators to warn of a “war on welfare,” and arrived as the far-right Danish People’s Party—which criticized the government for “luring” immigrants with welfare benefits—rose up in opinion polls. Within a year, consulting firm Deloitte released an audit of welfare fraud controls in Denmark, finding them inadequate to detect fraud in an increasingly digitized welfare system. The auditors, commissioned by the Danish finance ministry, estimated the “short-term savings” of a new “risk-scoring infrastructure” to be €126 million. Deloitte’s vision was realized in February 2015 with a bill that overhauled the Danish welfare state. It proposed a massive expansion of the Public Benefit Administration’s powers, including the ability to store and collect data on millions of people, access other authorities’ databases, and even request data from foreign governments. Largely unnoticed at the time, it also called for the creation of a “data mining unit” to “control for social benefits fraud.” “You are not guilty just because we point you out. There will always be a person that looks into your data.” The bill was backed by all of the major political parties in Denmark and became law in April 2015. That month, Jacobsen left an IT job in the financial sector to become Denmark’s first head of data mining and fraud detection. As Jacobsen got to work, conservative politician Troels Lund Poulsen took office in June 2015 as Denmark’s new employment minister. He implemented random airport checks to catch welfare recipients taking undeclared vacations, and proposed giving the new data mining unit access to welfare recipients’ electricity and water bills in order to detect where they were living. He was joined by a growing chorus of supporters, with one municipality reportedly asking for data from cell towers to track where welfare recipients were staying. “It’s about politics,” Poulsen said in March 2018. “It is important for me to send a clear signal that we will not accept social cheating and fraud.” Jacobsen’s critics have accused her unit of conducting mass surveillance, but she argues that there are clear safeguards that prevent overreach. Jacobsen says her algorithms don’t actually cancel benefits—they only flag people as suspicious. Ultimately, it is up to a human fraud investigator to make the final call, and citizens have the right to appeal their decisions. “You are not guilty just because we point you out. There will always be a person that looks into your data,” she says. The majority of Danish residents flagged for investigation are found innocent. Of the nearly 50,000 cases selected by the data mining unit in 2022, 4,000, or 8 percent, resulted in some form of punishment. In the cases where wrongdoing was found, the data mining unit has managed to recover €‎23.1 million—a significant return on its annual budget of €‎3.1 million. But the scale and reach of Denmark's data collection has been criticized by the Danish Institute of Human Rights, an independent human rights watchdog, and the Danish Data Protection Authority, a public body that enforces privacy regulations. Justitia has compared the Public Benefits Administration to the National Security Agency in the US, and claimed that its digital monitoring of millions of Danish residents violates their privacy rights. Jacobsen says the agency’s use of data is proportional under European data protection laws, and that preventing error and fraud is important to maintain trust in the welfare state. The Public Benefits Administration is also looking to have its algorithms check citizens earlier in the process, when they first apply for benefits, to avoid situations where they have to repay large sums of money. “Most citizens are honest; however, there will always be some citizens who try to get welfare benefits that they are not entitled to,” Jacobsen says. Jacobsen also argues that machine learning is fairer than analog methods. Anonymous tips about potential welfare cheats are unreliable, she claims. In 2017, they made up 14 percent of the cases selected for investigation by local fraud officials, whereas cases from her data unit amounted to 26 percent. That means her unit is more effective than anonymous tips, but nearly half of the cases local investigators decide to take on come from their own leads. Random selection is also unfair, she claims, because it means burdening people when there are no grounds for suspicion. “[Critics] say that when the machine is looking at data, it is violating the citizen, [whereas] I might think it’s very violating looking at random citizens,” Jacobsen says. “What is a violation of the citizen, really? Is it a violation that you are in the stomach of the machine, running around in there?” Denmark isn’t alone in turning to algorithms amid political pressure to crack down on welfare fraud. France adopted the technology in 2010, the Netherlands in 2013, Ireland in 2016, Spain in 2018, Poland in 2021, and Italy in 2022. But it’s the Netherlands that has provided the clearest warning against technological overreach. In 2021, a childcare benefits scandal, in which 20,000 families were wrongly accused of fraud, led to the resignation of the entire Dutch government. It came after officials interpreted small errors, such as a missing signature, as evidence of fraud, and forced welfare recipients to pay back thousands of euros they’d received as benefits payments. As details of the Dutch scandal emerged, it was found that an algorithm had selected thousands of parents—nearly 70 percent of whom were first or second generation migrants—for investigation. The system was abandoned after the Dutch Data Protection Authority found that it had illegally used nationality as a variable, which Amnesty International later compared to “digital ethnic profiling.” The EU’s AI Act would ban any system covered by the legislation that “exploits the vulnerabilities of a specific group,” including those who are vulnerable because of their financial situation. Systems like Jacobsen’s, which affect citizens’ access to essential public services, would also likely be labeled as “high risk” and subject to stringent requirements, including transparency obligations and a requirement for “high levels of accuracy.” The documents obtained by Lighthouse Reports and WIRED appear to show that Denmark’s system goes beyond the one that brought down the Dutch government. They reveal how Denmark’s algorithms use variables like nationality, whose use has been equated with ethnic profiling. One of Denmark's fraud detection algorithms attempts to work out how someone might be connected to a non-EU country. Heavily redacted documents show that, in order to do this, the system tracks whether a welfare recipient or their “family relations” have ever emigrated from Denmark. Two other variables record their nationality and whether they have ever been a citizen of any country other than Denmark. Jacobsen says that nationality is only one of many variables used by the algorithm, and that a welfare recipient will not be flagged unless they live at a “suspicious address” and the system isn’t able to find a connection to Denmark. The documents also show that Denmark’s data mining unit tracks welfare recipients’ marital status, the length of their marriage, who they live with, the size of their house, their income, whether they’ve ever lived outside Denmark, their call history with the Public Benefits Administration, and whether their children are Danish residents. Another variable, “presumed partner,” is used to determine whether someone has a concealed relationship, since single people receive more benefits. This involves searching data for connections between welfare recipients and other Danish residents, such as whether they have lived at the same address or raised children together. “The ideology that underlies these algorithmic systems, and [the] very intrusive surveillance and monitoring of people who receive welfare, is a deep suspicion of the poor,” says Victoria Adelmant, director of the Digital Welfare and Human Rights Project. FOR ALL THE complexity of machine learning models, and all the data amassed and processed, there is still a person with a decision to make at the hard end of fraud controls. This is the fail-safe, Jacobsen argues, but it’s also the first place where these systems collide with reality. Morten Bruun Jonassen is one of these fail-safes. A former police officer, he leads Copenhagen's control team, a group of officials tasked with ensuring that the city’s residents are registered at the correct address and receive the correct benefits payments. He's been working for the city’s social services department for 14 years, long enough to remember a time before algorithms assumed such importance—and long enough to have observed the change of tone in the national conversation on welfare. “What is a violation of the citizen, really? Is it a violation that you are in the stomach of the machine, running around in there?” While the war on welfare fraud remains politically popular in Denmark, Jonassen says only a “very small” number of the cases he encounters involve actual fraud. For all the investment in it, the data mining unit is not his best source of leads, and cases flagged by Jacobsen’s system make up just 13 percent of the cases his team investigates—half the national average. Since 2018, Jonassen and his unit have softened their approach compared to other units in Denmark, which tend to be tougher on fraud, he says. In a case documented in 2019 by DR, Denmark’s public broadcaster, a welfare recipient said that investigators had trawled her social media to see whether she was in a relationship before wrongfully accusing her of welfare fraud. While he gives credit to Jacobsen’s data mining unit for trying to improve its algorithms, Jonassen has yet to see significant improvement for the cases he handles. “Basically, it’s not been better,” he says. In a 2022 survey of Denmark’s towns and cities conducted by the unit, officials scored their satisfaction with it, on average, between 4 and 5 out of 7. Jonassen says people claiming benefits should get what they’re due—no more, no less. And despite the scale of Jacobsen’s automated bureaucracy, he starts more investigations based on tips from schools and social workers than machine-flagged cases. And, crucially, he says, he works hard to understand the people claiming benefits and the difficult situations they find themselves in. “If you look at statistics and just look at the screen,” he says, “you don’t see that there are people behind it.”

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Link › Link – UBI

UBI is a veil for special interest, guts social security, and embodies government overreach.

Harris 22 – Aaron Harris is the host of Decentralized Revolution podcast, freelance writer, and contributor to the Mises Caucus, [“Universal Basic Income & State Overreach”, Mises Caucus, 2/7/2022, https://lpmisescaucus.com/universal-basic-income/universal-basic-income-state-overreach-christopher-e-baecker/]RA

The enactment of a Universal Basic Income (UBI) is dependent upon a couple variables. The first is theory. In a perfect world, a UBI would replace all other federal welfare spending programs. Adults would be given a monthly stipend from the government. Rather than depend on various programs, such as for food aid, health insurance, etc. they would be free to take care of their needs as they see fit, on an individual basis. The bureaucracy that runs and maintains these programs would be folded in favor of a check-cutting operation akin to that of social security. The potential savings could amount to more than half of current federal government spending. There’s also the intangible benefit of a market working more efficiently, plus more personal autonomy over government welfare. In the real world however, the aforementioned savings translate into special interests, starting with 535 federal legislators in the U.S. Congress. In the traditional sense, their job is simply to represent their districts’/states’ interests in the federal government, giving voice to a diverse set of American voices from coast to coast, from the Rio Grande to the Arctic Circle. In reality, with almost $7T in annual spending and 70K+ pages in the federal register, they’ve morphed into “getting things done” puppets. They need to be seen as dispensing favors to this group or that. If there is less to “do,” or less taxpayer revenue to dole out, they would likely feel useless, unneeded. The prospect is no doubt untenable to some. Then there’s the bureaucracy, staffed with 1000s of civilian employees who have jobs on the line. Also, the inherent nature of government expects less of them given the fact that it will never “go out of business” due to lack of competition, or profit-seeking. That makes it a cushy gig to give up without a fight. Finally there are the nominal beneficiaries of these programs, represented most vocally through various lobbying groups. Though those that are actually dependent on federal welfare programs might reasonably be expected to protest their demise, so would their advocates. The reason for these activists’ 9-5 existence is lobbying not only for these programs’ continuation, but many times their expansion. This is not to exclude all the state and local level agitators reluctant to see the federal gravy train shut or slowed down. One ostensible principle put forth by these factions is that “we’re all Americans, and should therefore take care of each other collectively, from rich states to poor states.” There are other, countervailing principles at work. While it’s true that a UBI has garnered support from some conservative corners of the debate, it is predicated on the notion that the responsibilities of the federal government are accepted as-is. Moreover, to one degree or another, it should take care of its citizens. Not everyone accepts this precept. There are one or two segments of the American political spectrum that rejects outright that government should financially support its citizens, for multiple reasons: they do not have to work for it, it comes courtesy of faceless bureaucrats, it robs them of the incentive to invest in themselves, work, save, etc. Plus, in many instances, there are multiple non-profit, private charities in that arena, who arguably do as good, if not a better job. These charities are funded by voluntary donations, fact that could lead to a compromise in the public sphere. The operations of the federal government are largely funded by taxes on income and investment gains. By definition, these levies discourage these optimal, beneficial behaviors. Society progresses, and people flourish, when they work, when they find a match for their passions and/or skills. They are productive. When they save a portion of their disposable income, some of that finds its way into the hands of those of us who have ideas for new or improved products. These flow back into the hands of consumers who then utilize them to make their lives easier, frequently saving them time, which in turn can find its way back into (more) productive ventures. It’s a virtuous cycle …… when unimpeded by obstacles such as taxation. To compound matters, progressive taxation tends to fall disproportionately on those who are most productive (as measured by the marketable value of certain skillsets), more able to save and keep this cycle going. Of the various types of taxation, the ones we’d ideally frown most on are those that disincentivize the behaviors/habits society most benefits from. That leaves consumption. There is the mistaken notion that consumer expenditures “drive economic growth.” This is likely due to how Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is reported. More than two-thirds of it is chalked up to us buying stuff. Consumption is literally the destruction of all that came before it. It’s the end of the production process. Destroying something being labeled as growth is the equivalent to the popular misconception that WWII brought us out of the Great Depression. Alas, we do it. After all, we’re Americans. Part of our trade deficit is due to our preference to buy more than we save (hence the foreign direct investment which fills the gap). We’re going to buy stuff. Only an exorbitant level of sales tax will stop us from doing so. If we want to move forward with a UBI, repealing the 16th amendment is a crucial step.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Link › Link – Job Guarantee

Jobs regulations are handled by the states now. A federal job guarantee uniquely undermines state sovereignty.

MacDonald 23 – Alexander MacDonald is an in-house counsel at Instacart. Before coming to Instacart, he worked in the Washington, DC offices of Littler Mendelson, PC, where he advised management on all aspects of labor-management relations, [“The Department of Labor’s Independent Contractor Rule: A Quiet Threat to Federalism?”, The Federalist Society, 3/30/2023, https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/the-department-of-labor-s-independent-contractor-rule-a-quiet-threat-to-federalism]RA

The U.S. Department of Labor is considering a new rule that would narrow the definition of “independent contractor” under federal wage-and-hour law. The Department published a preliminary version of the rule last fall, and it is expected to post a final version this spring. But even though the proposal has been public for months, there is still widespread confusion about how far it would go. For example, in recent comments to the media, former National Labor Relations Board Chairman William Gould IV suggested that the proposal would “preempt” certain state laws, including California’s laws for app-based drivers. Though he may not know it, Gould is both right and wrong. While the proposed rule would not “preempt” state laws per se, it would interfere with states’ ability to experiment with new work rules. And in that way, it would undermine democratic decision making and bedrock principles of federalism. To understand the nuance, some background is necessary. When Gould mentioned preemption, he was talking about Proposition 22. Prop 22 was approved by California voters in 2020 by a nearly 6-to-4 margin. The law created a new, comprehensive system for the state’s app-based workers. It guaranteed the workers a minimum hourly rate, offered them new benefits, and required certain safety precautions. It also guaranteed that the workers could continue to operate as independent contractors. That last guarantee was necessary because California has some of the strictest worker-classification laws in the country. Without Prop 22, there was a risk that app-based workers would have had to become employees—a result most of them said they didn’t want. Prop 22 was vehemently opposed by the state’s biggest labor unions, including the SEIU, which immediately sued to block the law. A trial judge initially declared the law unconstitutional. But last month, an appellate panel reversed the trial judge’s order. The panel held that Prop 22 was constitutional except for two provisions dealing with amendments. It carved those provisions out and upheld the law’s core features. It was this decision that prompted Gould’s statement. Gould said that he expected the California Supreme Court to weigh in and reverse the appellate court. But even if it didn’t, he said that the Department of Labor’s new rule would “preempt” Prop 22. That statement was both right and wrong. It was wrong because, formally speaking, the rule won’t preempt anything. The FLSA explicitly allows states to adopt their own wage-and-hour standards. Nothing about the FLSA preempts those standards or forces states to follow federal rules. So technically speaking, the rule would not “preempt” Prop 22. Prop 22 will set a standard for California law, and the Department’s rule will set one for federal law. But practically speaking, the rule will complicate things in California. When the Department proposed the rule, it said that it would consider certain kinds of control as evidence of an employment relationship for federal purposes. Those kinds of control could include, for example, mandatory training. So mandatory training could be evidence of employment even if companies are required to provide the training under state law. That result implicates Prop 22. Among other things, Prop 22 requires drivers to take certain safety and harassment training. So according to the rule, mere compliance with Prop 22 could be evidence of employment under federal law. And if workers are employees under federal law, they might not be able to work as independent contractors under state law. Companies and workers have to arrange their relationships to meet minimum legal requirements. And those arrangements could get quite complicated if the workers have different statuses under different laws. The result, then, is that the Department’s rule could make it more difficult to adopt creative programs like Prop 22. Prop 22 represents a voter-initiated experiment in worker classification and benefits. It’s an effort to preserve flexibility while also offering workers new benefits and guarantees. Reasonable people can disagree about whether it’s the best way to handle new kinds of work, such as work in the “gig economy.” But most people would say that states should at least be able to try new approaches. After all, that kind of experimentation undergirds our federal system. The founders wanted most policy to get made at the state level. They knew different states would try different solutions. And by studying those solutions, other states could make informed decisions about their own policies. Every state could run its own experiments, and those experiments would power the laboratory of democracy. The Department’s proposal would subvert the federal system without saying so. Without any notice or public debate, it would lock workers nationwide into a single kind of work arrangement. State governments would have less room to experiment and design creative programs. Likewise, voters would have less freedom to express their own preferences. They would be left with one top-down model—a model workers, businesses, and voters have already rejected.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › States Lead CC Now

States are leading because of federal inaction – Trump proves drive overcomes polarization – multiple initiatives prove

Farber et al. 21 (Daniel A. Farber,1 Yuichiro Tsuji,2 and Shiyuan Jing,3 1: Sho Sato Professor of Law @ UC Berkeley; 2: Associate Professor @ Meiji University Law School in Tokyo; 3: Postdoc and Assistant Research Fellow @ Koguan School of Law, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, “Thinking Globally, Acting Locally: Lessons from the U.S., Japan, and China,” SSRN, 3/27/21, , ccm)

American state governments have actively engaged with the issue of climate change on many fronts.235 States have also been active in promoting renewable energy, sometimes under the climate umbrella and sometimes independently. California began to pursue its own climate policies as early as presidency of George W. Bush, when the federal government steadfastly refused to take any action at all to reduce emissions, and seemed dedicated to increasing them through expanded production of fossil fuels.236 In this way, the Trump Era is similar to this earlier period.237 For instance, as soon as Trump announced his intent to withdraw from the Paris Agreement, the governors of New York and California announced the formation of the U.S. Climate Alliance along with their intentions to comply with the U.S.’s emissions reduction commitment.238 Many states have adopted renewable portfolio standards (RPSs), which require that a certain percentage of electricity sold by each utility come from renewable sources. By forcing utilities to buy renewable energy, an RPS promotes the development of more solar and wind energy.239 California’s RPS has a 50 percent target for 2030.240 There are significant variations in these standards from state to state in terms of the targets, deadlines, and types of generation classified as renewable. 241 Currently twenty-nine states have an RPS, and another eight have voluntary standards or non-binding targets.242 In addition, as of 2019, twenty states had adopted climaterelated targets of some kind, twenty-six had some type of energy efficiency program, and over half were engaged in some form of adaptation planning.243

There is a clear political division in terms of renewable energy mandates, with Democratleaning states the most likely to have strong requirements.244 There are two regions of the United States that have refused to enact RPS mandates. One, in the West, consists of Idaho, Wyoming, and Nebraska. The other is in the Southeast, where states have lagged in adopting renewable energy.245 These states are dominated by conservative Republicans. Among the states that are addressing climate change in meaningful ways, California has played a leading role. California legislation focusing specifically on climate change dates back to a 1988 law mandating an inventory of California greenhouse gas emissions.246 In 2002, the state took advantage of an exception to federal preemption of emissions standards for new cars by enacting legislation requiring reduction of CO2 emissions. 247 In 2006, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed the California Global Warming Solutions Act, usually referred to as AB 32,248 which requires California to reduce emissions to the 1990 level by 2020. California’s cap-and-trade program set a declining, statewide cap on greenhouse gas emissions. An emissions trading program sets a ceiling on the amount of total amount of emissions (the “cap”) and establishes a market in which firms can trade the right to emit specified amounts (the “trade”).249

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › AT Covid

Covid proves Biden will respect federalism

Alex Seitz-Wald, 2-23-2021, Alex Seitz-Wald is senior digital politics reporter for NBC News.Why President Biden can't make states vaccinate teachers — or anyone else," NBC News, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/joe-biden/why-president-biden-can-t-make-states-vaccinate-teachers-or-n1258565, Accessed: 6-28-2021, /MB

WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden wants to vaccinate teachers to speed school reopenings, but more than half the states aren't listening and haven't made educators a priority — highlighting the limited powers of the federal government, even during a devastating pandemic.

"I can't set nationally who gets in line, when and first — that's a decision the states make," Biden said while touring a Pfizer plant in Michigan on Friday. "I can recommend."

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › AT Biden

Biden’s using “new federalism” and local approaches now

Marshall, 5/4 (Will Marshall, President at the Progressive Policy Institute) 5/4/21 "Biden should empower local governments, not D.C. bureaucracies." Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/biden-should-empower-local-governments-not-dc-bureaucracies-opinion-1588265. 5-4-2021. accessed 5-28-2021. ALS

President Joe Biden has surprised his critics across the political spectrum with an audacious $6 trillion blueprint for national reconstruction. His resolve to "go big" reflects a palpable public desire for bold action after the enormous losses in lives, jobs and small businesses that America has suffered during the COVID-19 pandemic. But whether the country at large is eager to welcome "big government" back from political exile—as some progressive politicians and reporters hopefully claim—is far from clear. In fact, surveys show most Americans remain deeply skeptical about Washington's capabilities. Fortunately, Biden has other problem-solving tools at his disposal. Specifically, he should look to local governments, which have emerged as American federalism's star performers. Instead of concentrating more power in Washington, the White House should work to decentralize decisions and resources to creative city and county leaders. This strategy—call it "metro federalism"—relies on three facts. First, economic innovation and job creation are concentrated in metropolitan regions. Second, citizens have more confidence in their local governments than they do in Washington. Third, the progressive outlook of most metro areas makes them natural allies for the Biden administration. The speed and strength of America's recovery from the coronavirus calamity is inextricably linked to what happens in urban centers. The nation's 10 highest-producing metro economies generated $7.2 trillion in economic value in 2018, surpassing the output of 38 U.S. states. Biden's push for huge public investments in modern infrastructure, and for leveraging federal procurement to "buy American," are essential to ensuring America's ability to compete with China for mastery of the technologies that will define our future. Our cities will be the front line of this campaign. Metro regions are our most dynamic innovation clusters, especially for digital technology, pharmaceuticals, electric vehicles, biotechnology and robotics. The pandemic has taken an especially devastating toll on minority-owned small businesses in urban areas. The White House should huddle with metro leaders on strategies to use federal dollars to nurture and scale up such enterprises. Their success is essential to creating new jobs and economic vibrancy in distressed neighborhoods hit hardest by the pandemic, as well as narrowing racial, gender and class inequities the COVID crisis has aggravated. While the federal government has been stagnate [paralyzed] by polarization and negative partisanship, the nation's metro regions have become our leading hubs of public innovation and creative, on-the-ground problem solving. This is no secret to everyday Americans. When U.S. voters are asked which level of government they trust most to be responsive and to help them solve their problems, it's no contest. Only 20 percent say they trust the federal government to do the right thing most of the time. By contrast, 72 percent say they have a "great deal" or fair amount" of trust in their local government. Metros also are replacing states as America's laboratories of democracy. Many states are controlled today by right-wing populists who seem more interested in waging cultural wars than governing. Many red-state legislatures have tried to upend federalism in their own states. Essentially hostile to blue urban islands, they have passed waves of "preemption" laws aimed at limiting cities' ability to raise revenues, adopt minimum wages, gun regulations, zoning ordinances, prohibit discrimination and require facemasks during the pandemic. A generation ago, notes The Atlantic's Ronald Brownstein, cities-versus-suburbs was the key political fault line. Today that line has moved outward—cities and inner suburbs are Democratic bastions, while Republicans dominate less densely populated exurbs, small towns and rural communities. "The political convergence between cities and inner suburbs would multiply the impact of any Biden partnership with local leaders," says Brownstein. "He has the chance to build alliances—and thus extend policies—across entire metropolitan regions, achieving greater scale than he could by working with central cities alone." What's more, Biden needs metro leaders' help in translating massive public investments into concrete and effective action on the ground. Those leaders possess local knowledge and civic resources that can help the White House set priorities and target spending in ways most likely to spark an inclusive economic recovery, tackle racial and class disparities and make our society more resilient for the next national emergency. As metro analyst Bruce Katz observes, the federal government is organized vertically. Siloed programs send money and mandates down to state and local governments. Metros operate horizontally, through cross-sector "networked governance" that includes business, banks, nonprofits and "anchor" institutions like universities and medical complexes. That flexibility and broad civic buy-in will be crucial to the success of Biden's agenda. The urge to centralize political power is imprinted deep into the progressive consciousness. But the centralizing strategies of the 20th century are ill-suited to solving public problems in 21st-century America. Biden is right to go big, but he should also go local—by empowering more supple local governments, not Washington bureaucracies, to get the job done.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › AT Biden

Biden is taking collaborative approaches with states now

D’Angelo and Kaufman, 21 (Chris D’Angelo and Alexander C. Kaufman, Jan 1 2021, “Biden Nominees Signal A New Era Of Climate Federalism”, HuffPost, , accessed 6/27/2021) TK

President-elect Joe Biden has assembled what environmentalists are calling an “all-star” team to lead his government’s efforts to curb climate change and reverse the Trump administration’s astoundingly pro-polluter legacy. Rep. Deb Haaland (D-N.M.), one of the first two Native American women elected to Congress and a strong supporter of the Green New Deal movement, would replace a former oil lobbyist if the Senate confirms her as head of the Interior Department. In place of the ex-coal lobbyist running the Environmental Protection Agency would be Michael Regan, who brokered the biggest coal-ash cleanup settlement in U.S. history as North Carolina’s top environmental regulator. The Energy Department would swap a fossil fuel die-hard for Jennifer Granholm, Michigan’s former governor and attorney general and now a clean energy advocate. With the Senate likely to remain in Republican hands this year, Biden seems to be preparing to resurrect the Obama administration’s approach after Democrats lost the House in the 2010 midterms: a combination of aggressive regulation, executive orders and close collaboration with states. To oversee the effort, Biden picked Gina McCarthy, Barack Obama’s former EPA chief and architect of the administration’s regulatory suite, as his domestic climate czar, a position Obama initially created in his first term to coordinate the federal government’s energy and environmental strategy and work to get climate legislation passed in Congress. Beyond their stark ideological contrasts to President Donald Trump’s agency heads, Biden’s top-level nominees also appear to signal the new administration’s plans to embed climate policies at the state level, cementing the clean-energy transition and making it harder for the next GOP president to undo whatever progress his administration makes. “There’s this very calculated, hard-nosed recognition among the choices that executive action is going to be the key to progress, and action at the state level is going to be the key to progress,” said Cara Horowitz, a climate policy expert at UCLA School of Law. As the Obama and Trump presidencies prove, it could likely be a rocky road. Absent new legislation, the White House must creatively interpret its legal mandate to enact rules under existing statutes, leaving them open to challenge. Republican state attorneys general sued the Obama administration so routinely that the top cop in Texas joked: “I go into the office in the morning. I sue Barack Obama, and then I go home.” GOP-led states persuaded the Supreme Court to block Obama’s signature power plant regulation in 2016, and that was before Trump added three right-wing justices to the bench and stacked lower federal courts with conservatives. Red states are already vowing to pursue that same strategy. But Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris have options. And they’ve made it clear they’re all on the table. “The Biden-Harris Administration intends to pull every lever available, not only through executive and legislative action, but partnering together with cities, states, and businesses to reverse course on the climate threat, advance environmental justice and a clean energy future, and create millions of good-paying union jobs,” Jamal Brown, a Biden transition spokesman, told HuffPost in an email.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › AT Non-unique / Overreach Now

No overreach now – statutes are focused on preserving state leadership and avoiding federal pre-emption

Ryan 15 (Erin Ryan, Elizabeth C. & Clyde W. Atkinson Professor and Associate Dean for Environmental Programs @ Florida State University and Lewis & Clark Law School; J.D., Harvard Law School, M.A., Wesleyan University, “Response to Heather Gerken's Federalism and Nationalism: Time for a Détente?” Saint Louis University Law Journal, Volume 59, Summer 2015, pp. 1147-1166, , ccm)

Examples of this inverted principal-agent relationship may be fewer in number given the role of federal supremacy, but even within some programs of cooperative federalism, federal supremacy has been purposefully waived to approximate an inverted principal-agent relationship between state and federal actors.83 In environmental law, for example, both the Coastal Zone Management Act and the Clean Water Act create circumstances in which the federal government must win state approval of federal plans in an area of law clearly governed by federal commerce authority.84 Countless other statutes also carve out space for state leadership on issues that could have been subject to federal preemption, including those Abbe Gluck explained earlier today.85

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
2NC Cards › Uniqueness › AT Non-unique / Overreach Now

Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. More government interference is the brink – we should want to INCREASE state sovereignty.

Katz 21 - Diane Katz is Senior Research Fellow in Regulatory Policy in the Thomas A. Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies, of the Institute for Economic Freedom and Opportunity, at The Heritage Foundation, [“Biden Administration’s Overreach Affecting States’ Rights, Too”, The Heritage Foundation, 12/10/2021, https://www.heritage.org/government-regulation/commentary/biden-administrations-overreach-affecting-states-rights-too]RA

Since 2000, Congress and various presidents have approved more than 190 statutes with intergovernmental mandates, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Collectively, the laws have imposed more than 1,000 separate directives. The volume of red tape is massive. States are also much more dependent on federal grants-in-aid, which comprised nearly a third (32.4%) of total state spending in fiscal year 2020. The number of federally funded grant programs grew from 132 in 1960, to 387 in 1968, and 664 in 1998. That number is now 1,274—and growing. Washington is about to unleash the second injection of COVID-19 cash—some $1.9 trillion under the American Rescue Plan Act—along with $1.2 trillion from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. Moreover, if passed by the Senate, the inaptly named “Build Back Better” bill will dispense several trillion dollars more. The various conditions attached to the grants drive policy at the state level and inject federal involvement in virtually every aspect of local governance. Such excessive federal interference inhibits policy competition among states, as well as the relative transparency and accountability of state-level and local-level regulation. It also impedes the ability of both citizens and businesses to escape flawed policies by crossing state borders. Previous efforts to curb intergovernmental meddling, such as enactment of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act, have largely failed. New actions are sorely needed. Congress should start by requiring legislative sponsors to identify the constitutional basis of their bills. Floor time should be allotted to debate the sufficiency of the justification. Congress should also codify President Reagan’s Executive Order 12612, which directed departments and agencies to grant states the “maximum administrative discretion possible” and to limit state discretion “only where constitutional authority for the action is clear and certain and the national activity is necessitated by the presence of a problem of national scope.” Agencies should also be required to conduct federalism assessments (for review by the Office of Management and Budget) for all proposed rules with federalism implications. Each assessment should analyze the state costs that the rule would impose, and agencies should be required to report the results of the assessments to Congress and the public. The challenge before the nation is to divest power from the administrative state, restore the constitutional constraints that best safeguard liberty, and make America exceptional once again.

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Federalism DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › 1NC – Jobs Guarantee

That separation of power is critical to successful environmental policy.

Stan Meiburg, 4-26-2021, Ph.D. is the Director of the Graduate Studies in Sustainability at Wake Forest University and a Fellow at the National Academy of Public Administration, [“American Federalism and the Environment”, Federalism.US, https://federalism.us/2021/04/american-federalism-and-the-environment/]

To a degree unprecedented in recent American history, the environment, especially but not limited to climate change, has moved to the front rank of our public policy concerns. Even more remarkable is the degree to which this concern is interwoven with other threads: economic recovery, racial and social justice, energy supply and demand, trade policy, financial investments, agricultural policy, and national security. This attention reminds us of the rise of the environmental movement over fifty years ago, symbolized by the prominence of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and the first Earth Day, April 22, 1970. Among the most significant consequences of that rise was the creation by then-President Nixon of a new federal organization, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, a combination of parts from fifteen agencies around the government. The new agency, known universally by its acronym, EPA, opened its doors on December 2, 1970, headed by a 38-year-old former state senator from Indiana, William Ruckelshaus. The following twenty years witnessed a tremendous expansion in federal environmental law. Congress passed and Presidents signed into law twenty major pieces of environmental legislation, including such landmarks as the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, and Safe Drinking Water Act, the Toxic Substances Control Act, the Ocean Dumping Act, and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (better known as “Superfund”). Though many challenges remain, today we are the beneficiaries of these initiatives in the form of cleaner air, water and land. To cite one set of statistics: since 1970, real GDP has increased by 285%, we drive almost three times as many miles, we have added more than 125 million people to our population, and we use 48% more energy; yet our emissions of the so-called “criteria pollutants” –hydrocarbons, particles, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, lead and carbon monoxide–have decreased by 77%. Though federal leadership has been essential, this success is not the result of unilateral federal action. Federalism has been at the heart of much of this progress and of many of its most intense controversies. The private sector and non-governmental organizations have both played vital roles, but the interplay of federal and state action has been and remains a hallmark of U.S. environmental policy. Like most federalism discussions, this one starts with the Constitution. EPA has broad authorities derived from the enumerated powers given to Congress in the commerce clause. This clause has been broadly interpreted through the years, but debates persist over its scope, as evidenced by current arguments about the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act over the “navigable waters” of the United States. Apart from constitutional issues, the expansion of federal environmental law between 1970 and 1990 rested upon a parallel framework which President Nixon referred to as “the new federalism”. This new federalism contrasted with previous expansions of federal authority in the Progressive Era, the New Deal, and the Great Society by explicitly giving significant discretion to states in the administration of federal statutes. With the notable exceptions of Superfund and TSCA, the major environmental statutes provide for states to implement their permitting and enforcement authorities. The organization of EPA reflects this difference. EPA is decentralized, in that almost half of its staff reside in ten regional offices, located in standard federal region cities. However, unlike the Park Service, the Forest Service, the USDA extension service, the Natural Resources Conservation Service, the Federal Housing Administration, the Federal Highway Administration, or the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, EPA with few exceptions does not have staff stationed in state capitals or in field locations. EPA delegates authorities that such staff might exercise to state environmental agencies. States acquire these authorities by seeking delegation or approval from EPA, according to the provisions of the various environmental statutes. By and large this process was completed over thirty years ago, and it is fair to speak now of a U.S. environmental enterprise where governance is shared between states and EPA (and, to an increasing degree, tribal authorities).

2023 UTNIF Disadvantage
Federalism DA – UTNIF – Starter Packet › 1NC › 1NC – Jobs Guarantee

Jobs regulations are handled by the states now. A federal job guarantee uniquely undermines state sovereignty.

MacDonald 23 – Alexander MacDonald is an in-house counsel at Instacart. Before coming to Instacart, he worked in the Washington, DC offices of Littler Mendelson, PC, where he advised management on all aspects of labor-management relations, [“The Department of Labor’s Independent Contractor Rule: A Quiet Threat to Federalism?”, The Federalist Society, 3/30/2023, https://fedsoc.org/commentary/fedsoc-blog/the-department-of-labor-s-independent-contractor-rule-a-quiet-threat-to-federalism]RA

The U.S. Department of Labor is considering a new rule that would narrow the definition of “independent contractor” under federal wage-and-hour law. The Department published a preliminary version of the rule last fall, and it is expected to post a final version this spring. But even though the proposal has been public for months, there is still widespread confusion about how far it would go. For example, in recent comments to the media, former National Labor Relations Board Chairman William Gould IV suggested that the proposal would “preempt” certain state laws, including California’s laws for app-based drivers. Though he may not know it, Gould is both right and wrong. While the proposed rule would not “preempt” state laws per se, it would interfere with states’ ability to experiment with new work rules. And in that way, it would undermine democratic decision making and bedrock principles of federalism. To understand the nuance, some background is necessary. When Gould mentioned preemption, he was talking about Proposition 22. Prop 22 was approved by California voters in 2020 by a nearly 6-to-4 margin. The law created a new, comprehensive system for the state’s app-based workers. It guaranteed the workers a minimum hourly rate, offered them new benefits, and required certain safety precautions. It also guaranteed that the workers could continue to operate as independent contractors. That last guarantee was necessary because California has some of the strictest worker-classification laws in the country. Without Prop 22, there was a risk that app-based workers would have had to become employees—a result most of them said they didn’t want. Prop 22 was vehemently opposed by the state’s biggest labor unions, including the SEIU, which immediately sued to block the law. A trial judge initially declared the law unconstitutional. But last month, an appellate panel reversed the trial judge’s order. The panel held that Prop 22 was constitutional except for two provisions dealing with amendments. It carved those provisions out and upheld the law’s core features. It was this decision that prompted Gould’s statement. Gould said that he expected the California Supreme Court to weigh in and reverse the appellate court. But even if it didn’t, he said that the Department of Labor’s new rule would “preempt” Prop 22. That statement was both right and wrong. It was wrong because, formally speaking, the rule won’t preempt anything. The FLSA explicitly allows states to adopt their own wage-and-hour standards. Nothing about the FLSA preempts those standards or forces states to follow federal rules. So technically speaking, the rule would not “preempt” Prop 22. Prop 22 will set a standard for California law, and the Department’s rule will set one for federal law. But practically speaking, the rule will complicate things in California. When the Department proposed the rule, it said that it would consider certain kinds of control as evidence of an employment relationship for federal purposes. Those kinds of control could include, for example, mandatory training. So mandatory training could be evidence of employment even if companies are required to provide the training under state law. That result implicates Prop 22. Among other things, Prop 22 requires drivers to take certain safety and harassment training. So according to the rule, mere compliance with Prop 22 could be evidence of employment under federal law. And if workers are employees under federal law, they might not be able to work as independent contractors under state law. Companies and workers have to arrange their relationships to meet minimum legal requirements. And those arrangements could get quite complicated if the workers have different statuses under different laws. The result, then, is that the Department’s rule could make it more difficult to adopt creative programs like Prop 22. Prop 22 represents a voter-initiated experiment in worker classification and benefits. It’s an effort to preserve flexibility while also offering workers new benefits and guarantees. Reasonable people can disagree about whether it’s the best way to handle new kinds of work, such as work in the “gig economy.” But most people would say that states should at least be able to try new approaches. After all, that kind of experimentation undergirds our federal system. The founders wanted most policy to get made at the state level. They knew different states would try different solutions. And by studying those solutions, other states could make informed decisions about their own policies. Every state could run its own experiments, and those experiments would power the laboratory of democracy. The Department’s proposal would subvert the federal system without saying so. Without any notice or public debate, it would lock workers nationwide into a single kind of work arrangement. State governments would have less room to experiment and design creative programs. Likewise, voters would have less freedom to express their own preferences. They would be left with one top-down model—a model workers, businesses, and voters have already rejected.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Turtle Island › AFF › 2AC

The counter plan fails to result in indigenous sovereignty.

Hunt & Stevenson 06/17/16 (Dallas Hunt & Shaun A. Stevenson at Routledge Taylor & Francis Group “Decolonizing geographies of power: indigenous digital counter-mapping practices on turtle Island” Settler Colonial Studies accessed- 07/01/23 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2201473X.2016.1186311?scroll=top&needAccess=true&role=tab) //srgoli

There are, of course, significant examples of Indigenous mapping techniques emerging in more recent years that de-emphasize the hegemonic effects of colonial cartographies, while utilizing the very same cartographic tools. With the help of the Aboriginal Mapping Network, the Fort Albany First Nation in Northern Ontario, for example, uses GIS technologies to foster intergenerational knowledge transfer, using mapping techniques and tools to reconnect youth with the surrounding land.38 Additionally, ‘The Living Atlas’ project is an interactive thematic atlas focused on the changing geographies of a number of First Nation territories, from the Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations and Okanagan Nation Alliance in British Columbia, to the Northeast Superior Forest Community in Ontario. These maps allow First Nation communities to map integral characteristics of their territories, previously unaccounted for on traditional Euro-Canadian maps, from climate change and health, to Indigenous food sheds and culturally significant locations. Similarly, Jane Jacobs shows how urban Indigenous peoples re-mapping of city space destabilizes colonial cartography in relation to tourist maps. Jacobs, however, is careful to note that the decolonizing political potential of this re-mapping of the tourist landscape is limited; she writes: ‘[it] probably will not result in [Indigenous peoples] gaining significant or meaningful land rights’.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Turtle Island › NEG › 2NC

Land is slowly being given back on a small scale but handing it over on a large scale mitigates the effects of climate change.

Jim Robbins 6/03/21 (Jim Robbins is a veteran journalist based in Helena, Montana. A regular contributor to Yale Environment 360, he has written for the New York Times, Conde Nast Traveler and numerous other publications. His latest book is the . “How Returning Lands to Native Tribes Is Helping Protect Nature” Yale Environment 360- accessed-7/01/23 https://e360.yale.edu/features/how-returning-lands-to-native-tribes-is-helping-protect-nature)//srgoli

There is a burgeoning movement these days to repatriate some culturally and ecologically important lands back to their former owners, the Indigenous people and local communities who once lived there, and to otherwise accommodate their perspective and participation in the management of the land and its wildlife and plants. Throughout the United States, land has been or is being transferred to tribes or is being co-managed with their help. In California, a land trust recently transferred 1,199 acres of redwood forest and prairie to the Esselen tribe, and in Maine, the Five Tribes of the Wabanaki Confederacy recently reacquired a 150-acre island with the help of land trusts. Other recent land transfers to tribes with the goal of conservation have taken place in Oregon, New York, and other states. The use of Indigenous management styles that evolved over many centuries of cultures immersed in nature — formally called  (TEK) — is increasingly seen by conservationists as synergistic with the global campaign to protect biodiversity and to manage nature in a way that hedges against climate change. The Nature Conservancy, for example, one of the world’s largest conservation organizations, has institutionalized the transfer of ecologically important land with its Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities Program in both the U.S. and globally.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Turtle Island › NEG › 2NC

Animism and Indigenous culture solve for climate disaster and we must learn from them to avoid extinction

Graham Harvey 7/01/19 (Graham Harvey is Professor of Religious Studies at the Open University, UK. “Animism and ecology: Participating in the world community” Ecological citizen accessed- 07/01/23 https://www.ecologicalcitizen.net/pdfs/v03n1-13.pdf)//srgoli

Relationships and relations are not necessarily nice (as Terry Pratchett [1993: 169–70] once said of elves). This, after all, is why many animists employ shamans and other diplomatic ritualists to negotiate with members of other species. The issues are particularly acute because (to paraphrase what the Iglulik shaman Aua told Knud Rasmussen [1929: 55–6]) in order to eat it is necessary to consume relations (as there are no other kinds of being). The inescapable context for efforts to act respectfully is that all beings are both predators and prey in relation to others. If consumption and consumerism are at the heart (or guts) of the Anthropocene and of the anthropogenic climate disaster, what we eat – or rather who we eat – is of critical importance. Understanding consumption as a relationship with an ethical dimension (as well as ontological and cosmological ones) is one significant implication of animism. Whilst familiar polemics against ‘consumerism and ‘over-consumption’ seem tired and without force, perhaps the more stark terms ‘predator’ and ‘prey’ might aid efforts to shift thinking – and therefore acts – in which we relate to the larger-than-human world. One of the ways in which animist relationships with our animate relations (especially those we eat) are making significant contributions to efforts to confront contemporary challenges is in insisting on the de-centring of humans and on the (re-)making of a respectful community. As climate disaster and mass extinctions increase, lessons might be learnt from the Indigenous communities, scholars and writers who are producing scientific and creative narratives in which “Indigenous peoples work to empower their own protagonists to address contemporary challenges” (Whyte, 2019: 224). The animist relationships of many Indigenous traditions not only offer vital exemplars of ways to make, maintain and/or restore inter-species respect, but also embody powerful critiques of the ideologies and practices that have got us into this mess.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Turtle Island › NEG › 2NC

Indigenous communities are known to have a more respect from the environment; Therefor they can take care better care of the land. Solve better than climate policies

Jamail & Rushworth 5/31/22 (Dahr Jamail is the author of Beyond the Green Zone and more. He has won the Martha Gellhorn Prize for Journalism and the Izzy Award. is a teacher of Native American literature and the author of Sam Woods: American Healing, Going to Water: The Journal of Beginning Rain, Diaspora’s Children, etc. The New Press Accessed- 7/01/23

“It all connects for her, as President Sharp is watching Quinault children understand what Indian country is about. She remembers the television commercial of the Native American seeing a garbage dump, and the camera pans in to show a tear running down his cheek. Native children are realizing the value of our shared waters, contrasted with the idea of isolationism or superiority that is so prevalent in the dominant culture. “We fight against this because we are embattled, and we struggle, because we are in opposition to all of this, and we have so much adversity, but we really just want to live in peace with people, and be at peace with our world,” she said softly, as tears welled in her eyes. “So we advocate for better climate policy because we are aware of the global crisis, and how this will require everyone, because no one is immune from the climate crisis, and everybody has a responsibility.” She paused, then went on to state that everyone has their place, that we just need to remember the North Star of our values, and specifically for Native Americans, the precontact lessons that are timeless and have been proven through centuries and millennia, and more recently, as science has proven what the Indigenous have always known—that they already had the best practices with Earth.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Turtle Island › NEG › 1NC

Returning Turtle Island solves economy crises and climate change.

Mary Meade 6/01/22 (Editor and Digital Content Manager at Green America. Writer and Editor. Digital Marketer. Environmental & Social Justice. “Native Land in Native Hands: Why the Land Back Movement Makes Economic Sense” Green America- accessed 7/1/23 )//srgoli

Returning land means Native people can heal from the trauma of the last 600 years. It’s the right thing to do—and the economically smart one. In the beginning, a woman fell from the sky, clutching seeds and fruits. The animals helped her find safety on the back of a turtle and brought her mud, from which she grew the seeds and fruits into a wilderness. In these moments together, the animals and Skywoman created Turtle Island, later named North America by European colonists. This creation story, shared among many tribes in the Great Lakes region, as told by Robin Wall Kimmerer in her book, Braiding Sweetgrass, reflects the relationship Native tribes have shared with the land for countless generations—and one that was stolen from millions of people when colonists crossed the ocean and forcibly removed Native tribes from their lands. And while returning land back to Native peoples is a moral imperative, there are economic and environmental benefits that would come with doing the right thing. Today, that movement is called Land Back, and is about putting Indigenous lands in Indigenous hands. Krystal Two Bulls (Oglala Lakota, Northern Cheyenne), the director of NDN Collective’s Landback campaign, says that reclaiming land is part of a bigger movement. “It’s the reclamation of our kinship systems, our governance systems, our ceremony and spirituality, our language, our culture, our food systems, our housing, our health care…those are all based on our relationship to the land,” says Two Bulls. “The land provides for us and is a life source for us.” Beyond the legal obligation to honor the treaty, there are economic benefits to honoring treaties. Helen Ding, a senior economist at World Resources Institute, published a report demonstrating just that. The 2016 report titled Climate Benefits, Tenure Costs: The Economic Case for Securing Indigenous Land Rights, focuses on securing Indigenous land in Bolivia, Brazil, and Columbia, which collectively contain most of the Amazon Basin and is home to millions of Indigenous peoples. If these peoples could have secured land titles, the estimated benefits in ecosystem services—such as reduced pollution, erosion control, and carbon storage—could result in an estimated economic benefit of up to $119 billion for Bolivia, $1.2 billion for Brazil, and $277 billion for Colombia over a 20-year period, according to that report. As a climate mitigation strategy, the cost of securing Indigenous land titles in the Amazon Basin is five to 42 times lower than the average cost of carbon capture and storage for coal- and gas-fired power plants. When it gets down to the dollar, protecting Indigenous land rights makes economic sense. “Moving away from land rights as a legal issue and helping people to understand that increasing land tenure security is essentially an economic matter and helps to reduce carbon emissions and protect forests,” Ding says. Settler colonialism has resulted in genocide, poverty, addiction, and much more harm to Native nations, which have the highest poverty rate among minorities according to Census data. Two Bulls states that the root of their ills comes from land theft; therefore, the solution is giving land back. Across Turtle Island, Indigenous tribes are finding ways to return home. In 2020, the Esselen Tribe was returned nearly 1,200 acres of their ancestral lands near Big Sur, California, after 250 years. In late 2021, the Squaxin Island Tribe was gifted over a thousand acres of land near the southern Puget Sound in Washington. In April 2022, 465 acres in the Chesapeake Bay was donated to the Rappahannock Tribe. hese stories are examples of land back. While there are many ways in which land can return to Native hands, such as a land purchase or a trust, the 465 acres given to the Rappahannock was the result of collaboration between the tribe and the Chesapeake Conservancy. The Conservancy managed a massive fundraising effort to purchase the land to donate to the tribe. While 465 acres is a small fraction of the Rappahannock’s original territory, it is a step in the right direction. “There’s more work to do,” says Joel Dunn, CEO of the Chesapeake Conservancy. “There’s more land to protect along this beautiful river. There’s more land that we can buy for the tribe.” With that land, the Rappahannock Tribe will be able to reclaim their cultural ties and practices. Chief Richardson describes the land as the tribe’s “grocery store,” with more than 250 plant and animal species the tribe gathers for food, crafts, and medicinal purposes. The environmental stewardship the tribe promises to practice—including developing an Indigenous conservation education center to teach future generations—will help restore the wetlands and help declining species make a return. “When we reclaim lands, it opens up economic opportunities for us to be able to have revenue streams that are able to address the issues in our communities,” says Two Bulls. Tourism is one such revenue stream, says Two Bulls, noting that NDN Collective’s Land Back campaign currently has a focus on public lands like national parks and monuments. “The root of [the word] ‘economy’ means taking care of your home,” says Two Bulls. “We’re not trying to reclaim land ownership in a Western colonial way of thinking about it. We are trying to reclaim our ways of being, which was never based on money.” And while giving land back creates economic and environmental incentives, it also means giving Indigenous peoples the means to care for themselves and their communities again through their relationship with the land.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › AFF › 2AC

Super chimneys are not proven and may have disastrous effects

Ming et al ’14 (Tingzhen Ming and Wei Liu School of Energy and Power Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China, Renaud de Richter and Sylvain Caillol Institut Charles Gerhardt Montpellier − UMR5253 CNRS-UM2 − ENSCM-UM1 – Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Chimie de Montpellier, 8 rue de l’Ecole Normale, 34296 Montpellier Cedex 5, France “Fighting global warming by climate engineering: Is the Earth radiation management and the solar radiation management any option for fighting climate change?” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews vol. 31 p. 792-834 sec. 6.4. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032113008460)//ahigh

Indeed, on some Pesochinsky's designs, the tower is alongside a mountain slope or drilled inside a mountain (which seems too expensive) and numerous air pipes are connected on the sides. Di Bella [155] suggested a similar concept by using giant open pit-mines and also recycling waste-heat from power plants. This heat input could be useful to prevent cold inflow entering these large diameter chimneys. To illustrate the potential of these devices, according to Pesochinsky's calculations [156] only 10 super chimneys 5 km high can offset the heat surplus in the Earth atmosphere, which causes current global warming. This would mean that all the atmospheric circulation would be completely reorganized from only 10 points on the Earth’s surface: the climate induced perturbations could be much worse than what we want to avoid. Hopefully with smaller, cheaper and more numerous super chimneys, better distributed on the surface of the planet, this deleterious effect can be avoided. The calculations done are rather simple, and were confirmed by Mudde [157] from Delft University of Technology. They are based on a difference of temperature of 50 °C and as the super-chimney will facilitate air convection by bringing masses of warm air up to 5 km, then when the heat from the air radiates out, as it will be already at high altitude, less energy will be reabsorbed by the atmosphere, due to a thinner layer of atmosphere to go through. Therefore, more heat will be leaving the atmosphere, thus reducing the global atmospheric temperature. The authors believe that more scientific studies are needed to prove the concept, and that the technology still fairly mature to build 5 km high chimneys.

Constructional generalities are given by Pesochinsky with no real details: tall skyscrapers already exist; unlike chimneys, buildings entail much heavier construction because there are floors, ceilings, several fluids and lifts going up and down, and all other elements within buildings which are necessary to make it useful for humans. A chimney is just a cylinder, thus is a much lighter structure and can be build a lot taller than any building with new “super-strong” materials, not even described by Pesochinsky.