Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
Aff Answers › Jobs Key

Degrowth is a privilege of the bourgeois, it does not consider those that are less fortunate.

Correira, 12. (David Correira; His work, whether in the archives, on the street, or in the classroom, focuses on the state's police powers, law and its relation to violence, and environmental politics. He is a co-founder of the research and mutual aid collective AbolishAPD (abolishapd.org).; February, 2012; “Degrowth, American Style: No Impact Man and Bourgeois Primitivism”; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10455752.2011.648847?journalCode=rcns20; Taylor and Francis Online; Accessed 7/24/2023; JB)

The point of this essay has been to argue that the enormous popularity of No Impact Man, along with its critique[s] of mainstream environmentalism, means that a critical politics of anti-consumption as part of a transformation in socio-ecological relations must take bourgeois primitivism seriously. Otherwise bourgeois primitivism, like mainstream environmentalism before it, will offer capital the environmental legitimacy it requires to resolve crises and restructure the terms of access to nature and labor. Degrowth, as of yet, has not done this. For the remainder of the essay, I offer a brief summary of six areas where it could.

First, the focus of bourgeois primitivism on material objects has eclipsed a concern for structural processes, the role of political institutions and the politics of scale and space. This, I would argue, is a function of seeing the city, and all the privileges that the capitalist city bestows on its affluent residents, as an ontology of space, a pre-existing politics that makes challenging the socio-ecological foundation of capitalist relations impossible through a bourgeois primitivist lens. Bourgeois primitivist environmental political philosophy considers the social costs and collapse of economic restructuring only in terms of individual happiness and bourgeois socio-ecological security. Left without a critical vision of the uneven distribution of social and environmental costs, Beavan’s environmental politics is an aspatial, asocial politics. Therefore primitivist answers to environmental problems can only be located in certain privileged subjectivities of consumption.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Aff Answers › JG Bad For Economy

Cost, private sector, wages and rent seeking ensure JG fails

Earl 18, (Peter C. Earle; is an economist who joined AIER in 2018. Prior to that he spent over 20 years as a trader and analyst at a number of securities firms and hedge funds in the New York metropolitan area. His research focuses on financial markets, monetary policy, and problems in economic measurement. He has been quoted by the Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, Reuters, CNBC, Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, NPR, and in numerous other media outlets and publications. Pete holds an MA in Applied Economics from American University, an MBA (Finance), and a BS in Engineering from the United States Military Academy at West Point, 11/19/18, investors.com/politics/commentary/federal-jobs-guarantee-democrats/, Investors.com)

With the midterm victories in the House of Representatives, Congressional Democrats are likely to begin a full-court press on their most recent policy initiative: a federal jobs guarantee program. Senators Corey Booker, D-N.J., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., have advanced their own, and with the arrival in Congress of affirmed Democratic Socialists like Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Rashida Tlaib of Michigan additional support seems likely.

Several think tanks — including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), Levy Economics Institute (LEI), PolicyLink, and the Center for American Progress — have proposed job guarantee plans. While there are minor differences between them, each essentially contemplates a massive, government-run program to provide work (at a predetermined wage) and benefits to enrollees on demand.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Degrowth Vs. Green New Deal › EXT – Solvency

Degrowth Solves

Foramatti et al. ’19 [September 19, 2019, Joel*, PhD candidate at ICTA-UAB, Marula Tsagkari**, PhD candidate in Energy Policy & Economics at the University of Barcelona, Christos Zografos***, Senior Research Fellow with the Johns Hopkins University, “Why degrowth is the only responsible way forward,” https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/why-degrowth-only-responsible-way-forward/]

To sustain the natural basis of our life, we must slow down. We have to reduce the amount of extraction, pollution, and waste throughout our economy. This implies less production, less consumption, and probably also less work.

The responsibility to do so must lie mainly on the rich, who currently enjoy a disproportionate share of our resources. But we should also do things differently, as much of today's economic activity is of little benefit to human wellbeing. Imagine what could be if we organized democratically to produce what we actually need, distributed those resources fairly, and shared them in common. This, in a nutshell, is the vision of degrowth: a good life for all within planetary boundaries. And while this might seem utopian, there are already concrete policy ideas to start such a transformation.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: JG Key

Corporate control prevents and disrupts any environmental action.

Povitkina, 18. (Marina Povitkina; Marina Povitkina is a postdoctoral researcher at the Department of Political Science at the University of Oslo (Norway) and the Centre for Collective Action Research at the University of Gothenburg (Sweden). Marina obtained her PhD in Political Science from the University of Gothenburg in 2018. Her dissertation compared how democratic governments achieve environmental sustainability goals depending on their levels of corruption. Her current research is on how corruption hampers collaboration in social dilemmas.; March, 2018; “The Limits of Democracy in Tackling Climate Change”; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09644016.2018.1444723; Taylor and Francis Online; Accessed 7/23/2023; JB)

Some features of democracies, however, are argued to hamper environmental commitments. Due to constant political challenge through electoral cycles, political leaders in democracies are known to be shortsighted, which can prevent them from allocating budget to implement[ing]ation of such long-term policy projects as environmental protection (Congleton Citation1992). Additionally, despite the pluralistic nature of democracies, strong corporate interest groups can gain high influence over the political decision-making. Politicians become compelled to respond to these groups’ short-term interests, which can go against environmental protection and the long-term benefit of the public (e.g. Bättig and Bernauer Citation2009).

Empirical evidence almost uniformly points to the positive effects of democracy on environmental outcomes (e.g. Gleditsch and Sverdrup Citation2003, Li and Reuveny Citation2006, Bättig and Bernauer Citation2009, Bernauer and Koubi Citation2009, Arvin and Lew Citation2011), apart from few exceptions (Midlarsky Citation1998). Spilker (Citation2013) finds that democracy does not seem to matter for environmental outcomes in the developing world, arguing that citizens in low-income countries are unlikely to demand environmental commitments from politicians, as they have other policy preferences.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: JG Key

A federal jobs guarantee inevitably results in corporate manipulation and influence.

Gulker, 18. (Max Gulker; Max Gulker is a former Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. He is currently a Senior Fellow with the Reason Foundation. At AIER his research focused on two main areas: policy and technology. On the policy side, Gulker looked at how issues like poverty and access to education can be addressed with voluntary, decentralized approaches that don’t interfere with free markets.; October 2018; “The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis”; https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf; American Institute for Economic Research; Accessed 7/23/2023; JB)

A[n] federal job guarantee, no matter how well intentioned, would also serve as a magnet for corruption and corporate influence peddling. Especially when administered on a local level, the opportunities for corruption become vast and difficult to monitor. For example, one need not be particularly imaginative to see opportunities for a local building contractor to get free labor by giving kickbacks to officials in charge of placing enrollees in jobs.

Corporations and other interest groups do not have to resort to corruption per se to gain control of the millions of subsidized laborers in a job guarantee. Rent-seeking, where corporations or other incumbent interests compete for influence over government to further their own objectives, is a well-known phenomenon.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDCP

JG and degrowth are fundamentally exclusive

Vansintjan 19(Aaron Vansintjan; a PhD candidate at Birkbeck, University of London; 2019; “Degrowth vs the Green New Deal”; ; DOA 7/23/2023 [Lowell-DB])

The Green New Deal has gone mainstream. The idea is to combine a massive federal job creation program with bold action to rapidly shift away from and protect Indigenous rights. Long a buzzword in the U.S. Green Party, a Green New Deal resolution was introduced in February by insurgent Democrats like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who've solidified its scope and demands. Now, Canadian leftist organizations like Courage are presenting their own proposals for a "Green New Deal of the North." And in March, federal NDP leader Jagmeet Singh began voicing support for the Green New Deal idea. But some are wary of proposals like the Green New Deal--they say that it only "greens" the capitalist imperative of perpetual economic growth, which is the true cause of environmental destruction. These critics--degrowthers--believe that to reduce our environmental impacts, we need to scale down and material use throughout the economy. This will likely lead to a downturn in gross domestic product (GDP) growth, so we need to restructure the economy so it doesn't rely on economic growth as an indicator for well-being. Unlike the Green New Deal, however, degrowth isn't a policy platform--it's more of a movement, or what participants call an "umbrella concept," bringing together a wide diversity of ideas and social and environmental justice struggles. There are other differences between the two, but each brings something unique to the just transition table. What would a conversation between degrowth and the Green New Deal look like? SIMILARITIES * THINKING BIG. Both degrowth and Green New Deal proposals aren't afraid to put forward visionary ideas. * DIVERSE SOLUTIONS. Instead of proposing a few one-size-fits-all policies, both argue for a diverse platform, touching on all sectors of the economy. * GROUNDED IN MOVEMENT STRUGGLES. While the degrowth movement has strong links to environmental justice, justice, and alter-globalization movements around the world, Canadian proponents of the Green New Deal have links to labour, Indigenous, and climate justice movements. * NEW ECONOMICS. Both proposals draw from heterodox, post-Keynesian economic disciplines to advocate for a debt-free, co-operative economy. * CARING ECONOMY. They also share an appreciation for what they call a "caring economy"--encouraging work that has low environmental impact and helps to address inequa lity, like health care, teaching, art, child care, and building community. * POST- AND POST-CAPITALIST. By proposing to cut and benefits to fossil fuel companies, both projects have a post-carbon vision of the future. And, while there are capitalist boosters of both the Green New Deal and degrowth, many proponents on both teams see the proposals as fundamentally anti-capitalist--advocating for a society where everything is held in common. INTERNATIONALIST. Degrowthers say that "the West must degrow so that the South can choose its own path of development," and they include international solidarity in their core principles. The Green New Deal, though largely focused on Western countries, hopes to build an international solidarity economy, changing the uneven relationship between rich and poor countries. DIFFERENCES THEORY AND POLICY Degrowth is mostly an academic movement, focused on challenging mainstream economics. There have been some degrowth policy proposals, but there is not always agreement in the movement about those policies. GROWTH Most evidence points to economic growth being strongly coupled with environmental destruction. We should focus on reducing impact and restructuring the economy, even if that might mean less growth. Degrowthers argue that for the Green New Deal to lead to a post-capitalist future, it must not be tied to economic growth. But, they also acknowledge that a degrowth platform might be a hard sell politically, especially in North America. CONSUMERISM Degrowth has long been focused on the problem of consumerism, or, how we have created a high-waste economy where we are forced to buy crap that we don't need. It is possible to increase well-being while dismantling the imperial mode of living, tied to an unsustainable capitalist system. The Green New Deal, in contrast, is mostly a policy platform. Those who back it and worked on it may be academics and activists, but the focus is on putting together a visionary set of policies. Most Green New Deal platforms are either agnostic about, or supportive of, economic growth. Some Green New Deal advocates argue that it is possible to decouple environmental impact from economic growth. Courage's platform does not mention the word "growth" once. The Green New Deal backed by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez barely mentions it. Green New Deal advocates often avoid talking about the need to reduce consumption, which is not seen as a popular selling point in North America--it's met with bacldash like Republican outcry that Ocasio-Cortez wanted to "take away their hamburgers." Courage does mention the need to shift away from "individual and wasteful consumerism." UNIQUE POLICIES * Degrowth would reduce the working week and support companies to facilitate job sharing between employees. * Ecological tax reform, taxing expenditure and polluting activity instead of income. High taxes on income from capital and inheritance. * Rehabilitate existing housing stock, with high taxes on empty homes and speculation. * Reduce advertising, with strict criteria for advertising in public spaces, like in Grenoble, France. * Basic and maximum income. * Fundamental to the Green New Deal is a job guarantee and funded retraining for fossil fuel industry workers. * All new green jobs should be public, or community owned * Raise minimum wages and guarantee workplace protection * Grant migrants their democratic rights and access to services. * Universal child care. * Public transport in cities and public electric vans in rural areas; co-operative ride sharing. * Recognize Indigenous and offer equal services and locally owned energy in Indigenous communities. * Large-scale construction of co-operative housing units. * Ban planned obsolescence in design and . * Invest in co-operative and community banking, so that people's money isn't used to invest in harmful industry. * Repurpose Canada's arms industry for zero-carbon transportation. * Strong human rights and environmental regulations for Canadian mining companies.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDB › UBI Key to Degrowth

Basic income key to degrowth

Julio Linares & Gabriela Cabaña 1 Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN), 286 Ivydale Road, London SE15 3DF, London, UK. ORCID: 0000-0003-0330-0001 Email: jrlinares16@gmail.com 2 London School of Economics and Political Science, Houghton Street, WC2A 2AE, London, UK. ORCID: 0000-0002-1661-6892, Email: g.r.cabana-alvear@lse.ac.uk

This essay is about care. It proposes a political vision to move towards a care-centred society that will allow the flourishing of everyone while keeping the planet inhabitable and thriving. For this utopian horizon that we name an ecology of care, we propose the creation of a Basic Income system that is constituted outside of and beyond the realm of the nation-state, as a means of changing humanity’s relationship to itself and transitioning from capitalism to a commons-based society. It argues for a dis-embedding of work—and the time allocated to it—from money, through a refor1 This essay was prepared for a keynote lecture given by the authors in August 2019 at the 19th World Basic Income Congress held in Hyderabad, India. 30 SOCIETY REGISTER 2022 / VOL. 6, NO. 3. mulation of the production of money in the form of an income distributed as an equal share to all those who are part of the planetary commons. Finally, it connects this Basic Income proposal with degrowth as a radical and necessary reformulation of society that considers its ecological roots and replaces the obsession with endless economic growth with the principle of taking care of people. This paper argues that if we are to fundamentally revert the crisis of today and create this ecology, there are three simultaneous transformations to start: (1). Money Commons: which means the re-appropriation of the money system outside the realm of the state and banks and into the commons, where value is created and wealth is defined, reproduced, shared and maintained by all those who participate in the reproduction of the commons, beyond the borders of nation-states. (2). Degrowth: in order to encourage self-reliance for all within planetary boundaries, a money system which is alive and hence decays when it is not used is proposed as the basis for the creation of a different type of money, made itself with a different set of values. Creating ecologies of money means bringing diversity to the monetary ecosystem as a way of healing the harm done by today’s money monoculture, where money is created as a form of a debt with an interest on people’s time by private banks and states. Making money alive aims at creating money within and for the commons to have the life needed for them to achieve a viable economic alternative. (3). Pluriversal Basic Income: recentering our awareness on care as the source of the value in work—which decouples labor from income or wage slavery from people’s time—can be achieved through the distribution of a Basic Income given to people unconditionally, just because they exist. This formulation of a Basic Income offers a different epistemic base from nation-state proposals, and it can be a tool for the emergence of new political projects and social forms. Politically, the pluriverse is a weaving together of different forms of knowing, imaginations and practices of freedom organized democratically as a confederation in order to transcend the nation-state

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDB › UBI Key to Degrowth

Basic income key to degrowth

Baptiste Mylondo -6-13-2012, "," BIEN, https://basicincome.org/bien/pdf/munich2012/mylondo_en.pdf

However, saying that, I must add that the economic degrowth I plead for, should not be an economic recession. What I mean is that an economic degrowth should not, in anyway, make the poors worse of. In a degrowth economy, everyone should be : – Able to satisfy his basic needs. – Able to access to the goods and services we think essential to live a good life. Thus, if we want to make sure that the poors won’t be worse of, we have to arrange things so that everyone could satisfy his basic needs by accessing to the essentials. In short, we have to insure a basic income (basic income being here understood in its widest sense, including a package of free access to certain goods and services).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDB › UBI Key to Degrowth

A UBI shrinks the economy – that’s essential to degrowth

Luduvice, André Victor Doherty. 2021. “The Macroeconomic Effects of Universal Basic Income Programs.” Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, Working Paper No. 21-21. .

What are the consequences of a nationwide reform of a transfer system based on means-testing toward one of unconditional transfers? I answer this question with a quantitative model to assess the general equilibrium, inequality, and welfare effects of substituting the current US income security system with a universal basic income (UBI) policy. To do so, I develop an overlapping generations model with idiosyncratic income risk that incorporates intensive and extensive margins of the labor supply, on-the-job learning, and child-bearing costs. The tax-transfer system closely mimics the US design. I calibrate the model to the US economy and conduct counterfactual analyses that implement reforms toward a UBI. I find that an expenditure-neutral reform has moderate impacts on agents’ labor supply response but induces aggregate capital and output to grow due to larger precautionary savings. A UBI of $1,000 monthly requires a substantial increase in the tax rate of consumption used to clear the government budget and leads to an overall decrease in the macroeconomic aggregates, stemming from a drop in the labor supply. In both cases, the economy has more equally distributed disposable income and consumption. The UBI economy constitutes a welfare loss at the transition if it is expenditure-neutral and results in a gain in the second scenario.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDB › UBI Solves Environment

UBI provides the path to move away from environmental harm

Cabaña ’22 [Gabriela, July 6, 2022, PhD student in anthropology at the London School of Economics, “Could Basic Income Be an Unexpected Ally of Ecological Transformation?”, https://aps.aucegypt.edu/en/articles/798/could-basic-income-be-an-unexpected-ally-of-ecological-transformation]

Basic income – an unconditional, universal and periodic cash transfer that all people belonging to a political community receive – has been a long-advocated measure and emergent human right (Van Parijs, 2004; Raventós, 2015; Standing, 2017). For at least a couple of decades, dedicated literature has presented this policy as a break from the usual failures and traps of conditional schemes, providing not only less poverty and more economic security, but a different sense of political equality and freedom (Widerquist, 2013). It has also been pushed as a feminist policy, in particular in its potential to transform and re-signify the unpaid care work women are mostly burdened with (Cox, 2019; Zelleke, 2009; Weeks, 2011; Zúñiga-Fajuri et al., 2022).

While still controversial and certainly unconventional, basic income has gathered political traction in the last decade. With some pilots and trials in different contexts, there is now growing evidence that supports that much of the prejudices against this policy are unfounded including fears of ‘laziness’ among the recipients (Davala et al., 2015; Silva & Lima, 2019). Still, most of the reluctance to commit to a full-on implementation of basic income comes back to the wider transformation it would entail to our understanding of social integration (Cabaña, 2019), and the role of work, in particular.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › A2: PDB

FJG converges with capitalism by defining identity in relationship to work – only the CP which institutes a UBI avoids risk of cooption.

Will Stern, 2-17-2020, "The Misguided Altruism of the Federal Job Guarantee," Medium, https://medium.com/basic-income/the-misguided-altruism-of-the-federal-job-guarantee-6ff81b4ffa78

The idea of a Federal Job Guarantee comes from a place of compassion for the beleaguered working class. Champions of the policy like Bernie Sanders, a frontrunner for the Democratic Nomination for President, push the idea in the hopes of providing the millions of unemployed Americans with a renewed sense of purpose, dignity, and cash flow that has been stripped from them since the recession of 2008, as swaths of the working class have found themselves left behind by soaring GDP and corporate profits.

However, this well-meaning policy holds multiple assumptions stemming from the outdated culture of protestant work ethic and capitalism’s translation and confluence of human value and economic value. These institutional beliefs are so pervasive in our politics and discourse surrounding our economy, that even the most progressive among us are susceptible to their gravitational pull.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI Decreases Growth › Spending

A UBI would increase spending massively, resulting in increased taxation

Greenstein, 2019 - President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities [Robert, June 13, “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It” https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it]

The Cost There are over 300 million Americans today. Suppose UBI provided everyone with $10,000 a year. That would cost more than $3 trillion a year — and $30 trillion to $40 trillion over ten years. This single-year figure equals more than three-fourths of the entire yearly federal budget — and double the entire budget outside Social Security, Medicare, defense, and interest payments. It’s also equal to close to 100 percent of all tax revenue the federal government collects. Or, consider UBI that gives everyone $5,000 a year. That would provide income equal to about two-fifths of the poverty line for an individual (which is a projected $12,700 in 2016) and less than the poverty line for a family of four ($24,800). But it would cost as much as the entire federal budget outside Social Security, Medicare, defense, and interest payments. Some UBI proponents respond that policymakers could make the UBI payments taxable. But the savings from doing so would be relatively modest, because the vast bulk of Americans either owe no federal income tax or are in the 10% or 15% tax brackets. For example, if you gave all 328 million Americans a $10,000 UBI and the cost was $3.28 trillion a year (about $33 trillion over ten years) before taxes, then making the UBI payments taxable would reduce that cost only to something like $2.5 trillion or $2.75 trillion (or $25 trillion to $27.5 trillion over ten years). Paying For It Where would the money to finance such a large expenditure come from? That it would come mainly or entirely from new taxes isn’t plausible. We’ll already need substantial new revenues in the coming decades to help keep Social Security and Medicare solvent and avoid large benefit cuts in them. We’ll need further tax increases to help repair a crumbling infrastructure that will otherwise impede economic growth. And if we want to create more opportunity and reduce racial and other barriers and inequities, we’ll also need to raise new revenues to invest more in areas like pre-school education, child care, college affordability, and revitalizing segregated inner-city communities. A UBI that’s financed primarily by tax increases would require the American people to accept a level of taxation that vastly exceeds anything in U.S. history. It’s hard to imagine that such a UBI would advance very far, especially given the tax increases we’ll already need for Social Security, Medicare, infrastructure, and other needs.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI Decreases Growth › Spending

A UBI would cause skyrocketing spending, increasing taxes and devastating the economy

Hughes, 2023 - Founder of Bull Oak Capital, an investment advisory firm [Ryan, Jan 27, “Universal Basic Income is a Bad Idea” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

COST OF UBI UBI is expensive. Very expensive. As an add on, without simultaneously trimming government programs, it would require a significant tax increase. Following the Finnish study results, Kari Hamalainen, chief researcher at the VATT Institute for Economic Research, said implementing a universal basic income for all citizens “would be expensive. If we had a universal basic income, we’d have to incorporate taxation”, and based on these results, “it would be unsustainable.” Bridgewater Associates conducted a study in 2018, which found the cost of a $1,000/mo stipend to every adult in the U.S. would run approximately $3.81 trillion per year. This amount represented 21% of US GDP or 78% of tax revenue in 2018. (Source: CNBC) Yes, the stipend would help to make people feel more financially secure, but as the Finnish study proved, it would not meaningfully increase employment or production. It would merely be an enormous expense, one that would likely cripple the U.S. economy.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI Decreases Growth › Comparative General

Only a UBI leads to degrowth, an FJG stimulates the economy and increases spending.

Tsai, 22. (Daniel Tsai; Daniel is a lawyer, management consultant, educator, columnist, and the author of two books: Law, Technology and Culture and the Business of Social Media and Entertainment (Toronto: Top Hat, 2022). Daniel has worked with a number of TSXV listed companies, national and multinational companies, private businesses and entrepreneurs. Daniel is an award winning teacher and has a teaching certificate from the University of Cambridge.; July 2022; “Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream”; https://theconversation.com/why-a-universal-job-guarantee-beats-the-basic-income-pipe-dream-186793; The Conversation; Accessed 7/24/2023; JB)

There are a few unique barriers that undermine universal basic income and its ability to be implemented. As we have seen with government support programs related to COVID-19, government stimulus in the form of direct cash can cause inflation. These programs reduce the supply of lower skilled employees in the job market, as some people invariably decide to stay at home, rather than work.

Like the Canada Emergency Response Benefit, universal basic income might take away the incentive to work for some, resulting in a labour market bereft of workers. This would result in a vicious cycle: employers would raise wages to attract those willing to work, which would increase inflation and cost of living, causing businesses, in turn, to raise costs to be able to afford higher salaries for their workers.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI Decreases Growth › Comparative General

While JG enhancing productive, BI stagnates economies and proliferates alternative unproductive forms of work.

Tsai, Daniel, Lecturer in Business and Law, Toronto Metropolitan University, 7-28-2022, "Why a universal job guarantee beats the basic income pipe dream," No Publication, https://www.proquest.com/docview/2696508849?parentSessionId=f%2FG97nWEn%2BUyvtBe%2BXiGtKSdWS%2F%2BUtr6vt5DwhDnFcY%3D&pq-origsite=primo&accountid=14667

With the current cost-of-living crisis resulting in dramatic inflation, higher interest rates and a looming recession, people have been searching for solutions to the economic crisis. A universal job guarantee may just be the answer we’re looking for, especially since Canada lost 43,000 jobs in June.

While most people are familiar with the idea of a universal basic income — the notion of giving every citizen a basic income, irrespective of their income level or need — few are familiar with the idea of a universal job guarantee.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › JG not Key

Degrowth is the concept of shrinking the economy – JG not key.

World Economic Forum, 6-15-2022, "Degrowth: what's behind this economic theory and why it matters today," https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/06/what-is-degrowth-economics-climate-change/

Degrowth broadly means shrinking rather than growing economies, so we use and put.

The idea is that by pursuing degrowth policies, economies can help themselves, their citizens and the planet by becoming more sustainable.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › JG = Corrpution

That undermines any climate policy.

Norman Eisen r, 6-5-2020, "Corruption is a threat to planet Earth," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/corruption-is-a-threat-to-planet-earth/

While resource extraction has slowed around the world, environmental challenges—and the corruption that exacerbates them—remain as potent as ever. To confront these challenges, it is necessary to clearly understand these environmental corruption risks and the devastating impacts they wreak across the world—throughout the pandemic and beyond.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › JG = Corrpution

A job guarantee will cause corruption.

Ryan Bourne, APRIL 24, 2018 , "A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster," Cato Institute, https://www.cato.org/blog/jobs-guaranteed-economic-disaster

As if all these consequences were not bad enough, such a program will be ripe for corruption and political interference at the government, provider and individual level. Senator Sanders’ plan would be administered by the Department for Labor, with local and state governments submitting projects to regional offices for consideration. There’s a huge question mark on whether projects will be considered on economic grounds, when there might be an incentive for make‐​work schemes to aid particular politicians or indeed to put resources towards “public good” causes or NGOs more in line with the ethos of the governing party. For Democrats this might be for environmental issues. For Republicans it might be, say, for a wall on the southern border. NGOs and local public bodies themselves will have incentives to apply for federal funds for projects that would otherwise have occurred anyway, and to maximize the number of applications. Pork barrel projects would proliferate. What is more, at the individual level, the guarantee coupled with the purported unwillingness to judge worker performance on a commercial basis will incentivize low levels of work effort on the margin. Conclusion The Jobs Guarantee then is an extremely large and costly endeavor, which would have major economic consequences and risk a large federal politicization of the labor market and public project delivery. The US does have serious labor market issues to contend with — not least depressed labor participation and a weak productivity outlook — but are things really so bad that they require such a risky and extensive policy response? Well‐​paid jobs and low levels of real unemployment are outcomes desired by all. But attempting to achieve that through this program amounts to cracking a nut with a sledgehammer, undermining what matters far more for living standards: efficiency and productivity.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › General

A jobs guarantee causes growth

David Broder, 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," No Publication, https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/

This is good for the economy as a whole. Rather than expanding the  rolls during economic busts, the FJG would put folks to work and moderate the business cycle. Federal workers’ paychecks will increase demand, which will increase economic growth.  agree that today’s secular stagnation — insufficient demand — is contributing to continued “” growth after the Great Recession. Only modest upticks in growth for the foreseeable future will come if we continue the status quo.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › General

The plan enables economic flexibility, preventing economic shocks from becoming major crises

Zumaeta ’22 [Jorge N. and William Darity; August 4; Regional Economist for the Florida Department of Labor, Fulbright Research Scholar in Economics and holds a BA and MS in Economics from Florida Atlantic University and a Ph.D. in Social Sciences – Economics from Tilburg University; “Federal Job Guarantee as a Path for Ending Income Inequality and Promoting Business Sustainability,” DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1906593/v1]

Improving Business and Economic Efficiencies The FJG has tremendous potential for influencing positively business and economic efficiencies by creating productive working environments that align with innovation, higher federal labor standards, and training opportunities. We start from the premise that an efficient labor market will transfer efficiencies and competitiveness to the firms and businesses. For example, it is said that economic efficiency takes place when all goods and factors of production in an economy are distributed or allocated to maximize value and minimize waste and negative externalities. This could be accomplished only with a well-prepared labor force that has the hard and soft skills needed to determine better resource allocations all through the production process and delivery of services. Business and economic efficiency pivots on making cost-effective production decisions within company and industry sectors, making sensitive decisions to capture segments of the market, and efficient distribution of goods and services. According to the World Economic Forum, efficient workers with the most suitable job skills will be the ones delivering a higher level of efficiencies and productivity in the firms. The FJG will offer labor market stability which will provide the base for efficient labor markets that will incentivize employees and employers to promote productivity. Our FJG proposal recommends balancing the creation of direct government jobs and indirect private sector jobs which would vary depending on the phase of the business cycle of the economy. A well-trained workforce will add flexibility to labor markets allow workers to shift from declining firms and enable companies and the economy as a whole to respond to external shocks. Unfortunately, the dynamic upswings and downswings of the economy do not provide enough market stability for businesses to invest in the long-term educational development of their workers. On the contrary, most businesses, particularly small businesses, have the tendency to focus on the short-term benefits and financial bottom line. Indirect private-sector employees could be FJG employees leased to private sector companies, similarly to the State University System of Florida are Florida State employees but are leased to the university system. There are a few examples at the county level as well. Industries Recession-Resistant Over the last six recessions, some industries are more prone to stronger declines in employment levels than others. This depends on several factors and the nature of the decline of economic activity. Figure 6 shows that Education and Health Services major industries division has experienced a positive percent change in employment. It is imperative to pay attention that these very same industries experiencing qualified labor shortages. The FJG program should invest in services that align with these industries as key industries to smooth out the business cycles. Multiplier Effect on Strategic Industries Visual analysis of the industry-by-industry multipliers[3] from the Total Requirement (Appendix VI) rapidly reveals strong effects from the Manufacturing; Finance, Insurance, Real Estate, Rental and Leasing; and the Professional and Business Services industries. All these industries amount to 66 percent of the total employment effect in the entire economy. Just manufacturing alone contributes to 34 percent of the entire effect. If there is a need to make the FJG more impactful, in terms of the return on investment, then these three industries are the ones we should be aiming at investing in. All other industries amount to the remaining 34 percent. Alternatives to the Federal Job Guarantee Many believe that the Universal Basic Income (UBI) (Anderson, 2000) (Bharat, 2014) is an alternative to the FJG. Nothing could be further from the truth. Both programs, the FJG and the UBI provide either salary/wages or cash payment by the government to all residents. The FJG provides a better platform since it engages the person in a working activity as an employee rather than just a cash recipient, from this perspective, exposing persons to a culture of work and training opportunities. Our research shows that Pilot UBI programs have taken place or are ongoing in the United States, Brazil, Canada, Finland, and other parts of the world. We have not seen a pilot of the FJG anywhere around the globe. Advocates of UBI affirm that it helps with fighting poverty, reducing income inequality, improving the health of recipients, and empowering women by recognizing the value of unpaid homemakers and caregivers. UBI proponents believe that it encourages employment and skills training. Opponents of UBI say that it provides a disincentive to work and weakens the economy. They also say it is unaffordable and less effective than targeted aid and welfare. Additionally, Robert Greenstein, President of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, states that "if you take the dollars targeted on people in the bottom fifth or two-fifths of the population and convert them to universal payments to people all the way up the income scale, you're redistributing income upward. That would increase poverty and inequality rather than reduce them." Furthermore, UBI does not cure addiction, poor health, lack of skills, or other factors that contribute to poverty. The FJG is not just a better proposition than UBI. FJG adds money to the economy by increasing productivity and output. This is how you avoid or greatly reduce the severity of, inflation. It forces private industry and the military to up their game, to be competitive with the FJG: better than a bare-minimum living wage, benefits, and working conditions. During times like the current crises, the FJG would expand to accommodate the dislocated workers providing not only a safety net but a motivation to keep active in the labor force despite all challenges. This context provides a more productive, engaging, and mentally healthy environment. This study presented on page 24 a section that introduces the nontangible benefits of the FJG, primarily listing all the benefits derived from engaging in work activities. Since the beginning of humanity, man has developed skills that develop satisfaction and independence by generating his or her own means of survival, in this case, earning a wage for work. The FJG as an Economic Safety Net During The COVID 19 Global Pandemic The FJG and the UBI have been getting a lot of attention from policymakers during the COVID 19 Global Pandemic (Lee, 2020). If we would have had one of these programs, the blow to economic activity would have been minimized by having persons receiving some kind of cash assistance, wages, or salaries to assist them during these difficult times. Nevertheless, it is important to highlight that most government employees have kept working during the COVID-19 crisis, acting as economic stabilizers. In other words, most government employees have been equipped to exercise a greater level of flexibility and adaptability to the huge challenges created by COVID 19 Global Pandemic. In many regards, this flexibility and adaptability come from continued training opportunities, including upskilling and re-skilling of soft skills and hard skills. With the continuation of employment and training opportunities come the health benefits that are crucially important during a pandemic. Unfortunately, Americans that become dislocated workers or unemployed during this global health crisis, have lost their health insurance adding to the stress and uncertainty. As many as 44 million Americans lost their jobs during the peak of COVID-19, primarily impacting the most vulnerable communities (Hardy, et Al., 2020). The FJG offers a tangible, sensitive, and sustainable proposition to dramatically tackling poverty reduction and smoothing out open market economic swings. The ability to employ all not only benefits the individual and their respective families but the business in general since the demand for goods and services would not decline as in a crisis without a safety net. The FJG program should be designed to absorb all employees negatively affected and keep working and earning wages during difficult times (Aspromourgos, 2000). Once the economy bounces back, then the private section could rehire these employees. Dr. Daniel P. Carpenter from Harvard University and Dr. Darrick Hamilton from Ohio State University published a paper that calls for the federal government to provide an FJG for everyone that has become unemployed due to COVID-19 by directly hiring millions of workers in the coming two years. They argued such a measure would rejuvenate the workforce and "inj