2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Democracy › 2NC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Robert Richie, 3-1-1998, "The Case for Proportional Representation," Boston Review, js]
1. PR increases voter turnout. Voter turnout is generally estimated to be 10-12 percent higher in nations with PR than in similar nations using winner-take-all elections. This difference is understandable. In the United States, as we indicated, relatively few legislative elections are competitive, and our analysis of recent House elections demonstrates a strong correlation between the degree of competition and the level of participation. People in non-competitive districts–whether supportive of the majority or minority–might better invest their time and resources by supporting candidates in competitive races elsewhere than by voting in their own. In PR systems, winning fair representation is dependent on voter turnout. Because nearly every vote will help a party win more seats, voters have more incentive to participate, and parties have incentives to mobilize their supporters. Moreover, parties and other electoral organizations have strong incentives to keep their supporters informed, and informed citizens are more likely to vote. 2. PR provides better representation for racial minorities. The 1982 amendments to the Voting Rights Act resulted in more districts drawn with majorities of racial and ethnic minorities. This increase in "majority-minority districts" produced a remarkable leap in representation of people of color in the US House in 1992. Between 1990 and 1992, the number of black and Latino House members jumped from 35 to 55.In a series of recent rulings against so-called "racial gerrymandering," the Supreme Court has made it much harder to establish majority-minority districts; the result is almost certain to be a decrease in the number of elected black legislators. Lani Guinier, Jesse Jackson, and other civil rights leaders have argued for PR as an alternative, and already more than 75 localities have adopted semi-proportional systems to settle voting rights cases. By building from a fundamental principle of political fairness, PR could secure voting rights of racial minorities, without specifically targeting minority voters (just as Social Security protects low-income seniors by providing benefits for all).In addition to winning a fair share of seats, minorities would have greater opportunities to negotiate for influence because they could "swing" among parties. South Africa used PR in its first all-race elections in 1994, and the two leading parties–the African National Congress and the National Party–ran multiracial slates with messages of inclusion. When New Zealand had its first PR election in 1996, the first Asian citizen was elected, and Pacific Islanders and indigenous Maoris tripled their representation. A Maori-backed party formed a coalition government with the governing party–a party whose relationship with Maoris had been analogous to Republicans' post-1960 relationship with American blacks.By improving representation, PR in turn encourages minority communities to mobilize and win access to power. From 1925 to 1955, Cincinnati used the "choice voting" form of PR to elect a nine-seat city council. (See sidebar for an explanation of choice voting.) In 1929, when blacks were barely 10 percent of the population, a black independent candidate ran a strong campaign. In the next election, he was added to the Republican party's slate and was elected. In 1947, when blacks were 15 percent of the population, a former president of the Cincinnati NAACP ran in large part to defend the choice voting system that was under attack from Republicans seeking to restore their old domination of the council. In an indication that any substantial group of voters cannot be ignored with PR, the other major party slate supported him in 1949. He was elected, resulting in black representatives holding two of nine seats.3. PR increases the number of women in office. The percentage of women elected to office in the United States–only 11 percent of the US Congress–is scandalously low, particularly in light of the relative strength of the American women's movement compared to other nations with far higher percentages of women legislators. Studies show that women representatives make a qualitative and quantitative difference in the type of legislation introduced and passed, yet the growth of women in state legislatures and Congress has stalled since 1992 despite relatively high turnover and the historic high in women's candidacies in 1996.In state legislative elections, women win seats in significantly higher percentages in multiseat districts than in one-seat districts. The major reasons for this difference are that women are more likely to run and voters are more likely to seek gender balance when there is more than one seat to fill. Because PR expands options, PR systems give women additional leverage to force the major parties to support more women candidates. In 1994, a threat by women supporters of the major parties in Sweden to form a new women's party led to women winning 41 percent of seats in 1994 because the major parties recruited more women candidates. New Zealand, Italy, and Germany are among a growing number of democracies that use systems with a mix of winner-take-all districts and PR seats. It is instructive that women in all three countries are three times more likely to win seats elected by PR than to win in one-seat districts.4. PR ends gerrymandering. Drawing district lines for political purposes has occurred from the first redistricting–the term "gerrymander" refers to a Massachusetts district plan drawn in 1812. But gerrymandering has become far more potent in an era of powerful computers, more detailed census information, and better techniques for measuring voter preferences.As one example, Democrats in control of the redistricting process in Texas in 1991 placed the eight Republican incumbents in districts that were packed to be among the most conservative in the nation. These incumbents were easily reelected in 1992, but Democrats won 21 of the remaining 22 seats with only 50 percent of the statewide vote. Only one race was won by less than 10 percent, and the three open seats went to state legislators serving on redistricting committees. Congresswoman Eddie Bernice Johnson, the primary architect of the plan, admitted in 1997 that the redistricting process "is not one of kindness. It is not one of sharing. It is a power grab."PR makes gerrymandering of any sort far more difficult. The smaller the percentage of votes that can be "wasted" on losing candidates–49 percent in a winner-take-all race, but less than 20 percent in a five-seat PR election and less than 10 percent in a 10-seat PR election–the harder it is for legislators to manipulate electoral outcomes.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Democracy › 2NC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Russell Berman, 7-6-2023, Russell has written extensively about Congress, political reform, and policy experiments in states and cities. He previously covered the House of Representatives for The Hill newspaper and served as a Washington correspondent for the New York Sun. "A Radical Idea for Fixing Polarization," Atlantic, js]
For most americans, voting for a member of Congress is one of their simplest civic duties. Every two years, they pick the candidate they like best—usually the same one they chose last time—and whoever gets the most votes will represent them and a few hundred thousand of their neighbors in the House of Representatives. In nearly every case, the winner is a Republican or Democrat, and whichever party captures the most seats secures a governing majority.That basic process has defined congressional elections for much of the past century. But according to a growing number of political-reform advocates, it has outlasted its effectiveness and could prove ruinous for American democracy if left in place. They blame the current winner-take-all system for driving U.S. politics toward dangerous levels of polarization. Without radical change, they say, the damage could be irreversible. “Our democracy is on a pretty troubling trajectory right now over the next decade or two,” says Lee Drutman, a political scientist and senior fellow at the left-leaning New America Foundation, “and all of the problems that we’re experiencing are only going to get more intense.”Drutman is a co-founder of Fix Our House, a group that envisions a new configuration for the lower chamber of Congress in which districts would elect several representatives, not just one. Most states would have fewer but larger districts, and unlike America’s current system, a district wouldn’t simply be won by the party with the most votes; instead, its multiple seats would be parceled out according to the percentage of the vote that each party gets. This means that previously niche parties would suddenly have a shot at winning seats. The system is known as proportional representation. If implemented, its backers believe it could help transform America into a multiparty democracy.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Democracy › 2NC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Amy J. Douglas, Douglas is a leading expert on electoral voting systems, including proportional representation, redistricting issues in the United States FairVote, No Date, "PR Library: What is "proportional representation" and why do we need this reform? ," , js]
Here in the U.S., proportional representation would be easiest to acquire on the local level, where modifying a city charter is usually all that is necessary. For that reason, much of the grassroots political activity promoting PR has taken place on the local level. For example, in the 1990s, two large cities — Cincinnati and San Francisco — voted on referendums to adopt PR. Both efforts were narrowly defeated, with PR garnering the support of almost 45% of the voters in both cases. Proportional representation also is feasible for Congressional elections. The Center for Voting and Democracy in Washington, D.C. has developed plans for Georgia and North Carolina that demonstrate how easy it would be to create multi- member PR districts for U.S. House elections. Importantly, such plans would not require a constitutional amendment. All that would be needed is to repeal a 1967 federal law requiring single-member district elections for the House, and several bills have been introduced in Congress that would do just that. In fact, with the approval of the Department of Justice under the Voting Rights Act, some states already are using PR in local elections, and minorities are using this system to elect their fair share of representatives. The debate over proportional representation is just beginning in this country; but it is an idea whose time has come. If we want our elections to be fairer and more democratic, and if we want voting to become a more powerful and meaningful political act, then we should take a long and careful look at this reform.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Democracy › 2NC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Christopher Ingraham, 3-1-2021, "Analysis," Washington Post, js]
Dissatisfaction with two-party politics is at an all-time high, new Gallup polling shows, with 62 percent of Americans saying Democrats and Republicans are doing such a poor job of representing their constituents that a third party is needed.But the zero-sum, winner-take-all dynamics of U.S. elections make it nearly impossible for third parties to gain electoral traction, despite survey data that shows fully half of Americans do not identify with any party and label themselves independents. This was underscored this past weekend at the Conservative Political Action Conference, when former president Donald Trump ruled out creating a third political party to promote his brand of nationalist conservatism.To hear those calling for change — including many scholars and some lawmakers — the inherent problem with our current system is that it shoehorns the entire spectrum of political opinion into just two parties. Warnings that the nation has backslid toward autocracy — driven in large part by the Republican Party’s shift away from democratic norms — bring added urgency, they say, and reversing that Trump-era trend will require something radical: breaking up the Democratic and Republican parties.The two-party trap The current system is something of a historical accident, as Lee Drutman, a political scientist at the New America Foundation, explains in his book “Breaking the Two-Party Doom Loop.” It is an unintended consequence of the simple-majority election method, in which votes for third parties are effectively “wasted.”“Given only two viable choices, all voters must align themselves with one vision, which makes it hard to register their ambivalences,” Drutman writes. And there’s plenty of ambivalence to go around. Pew Research Center surveys have measured at least nine distinct political typologies in the United States, for instance, while Gallup surveys show that fewer than 4 in 10 people believe the two major parties “do an adequate job of representing the American people.”Matthew Shugart, a professor emeritus of political science at the University of California at Davis, contends there are effectively three major political divisions at work in the United States. There’s Democratic/Republican, of course, which splits the country roughly 50/50. There’s capitalist/socialist, which pits people on the far left such as Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) — who has called for a wholesale overhaul of the economic system — vs. virtually everybody else, left or right. But the most salient one in the post-Trump era is the democratic/authoritarian split on the right. “On this one, the pro-democratic segment extends all the way from the leftmost large-d Democrats to somewhere near the middle of the Republican Party,” Shugart wrote. On the other side is the Trumpian wing of the GOP, which has “shown itself to be completely willing to set aside democracy, and even to promote/tolerate political violence, in order to advance its political agenda.”While the anti-democratic faction in the GOP is a small slice of the country overall, it is the most powerful group within the party. Most congressional Republicans refused to acknowledge Joe Biden’s electoral victory and parroted Trump’s falsehoods about voter fraud well after they had been rejected by the courts many times over. On the day Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol — an attack that resulted in the deaths of a Capitol Police officer and four other people — a majority of House Republicans voted to overturn election results.“The fundamental threat to American democracy right now is that the Republican Party is overwhelmed by an extreme anti-system faction,” Drutman said in an interview. “You have a number of individual members who are still committed to basic democratic principles, but they don’t have the winning hand within the party.”The Republican National Committee did not respond to repeated requests for comment on these issues.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Democracy › 1NC --- Democracy --- Elections CP
[Lee Drutman, Drutman a senior fellow at New America and author of the book Breaking the Two-Party Doom Loop: The Case for Multiparty Democracy in America. 1-6-2021, "10 Ideas to Fix Democracy," Foreign Policy, js]
One cannot make sense of the current crisis of liberal democracy without understanding the seismic economic and demographic shifts that have transformed Western democracies. Today, economic opportunity is heavily concentrated in major cities. A new urban elite—much more multicultural, diverse, and cosmopolitan—is redefining cultural norms and rearranging traditional hierarchies of race and gender. Left behind are those who stayed in the rural and post-industrial hinterlands, where globalization has not been kind. Here, far-right populists recasting themselves as defenders of national greatness and a bygone order have flourished, especially among white men. The leaders of such movements are cold to the traditional values of liberal democracy, with its emphasis on diversity and tolerance and its embrace of a market capitalism that has hit these regions hardest. In the United States and Britain, Trumpism and Brexit are both clear manifestations and fierce accelerators of a dangerous us-versus-them divide that is hitting right at the heart of liberal democracy. Other countries have been spared such shocks. Nationalist or far-right parties such as Alternative for Germany, the Sweden Democrats, the Dutch Party for Freedom, and the Danish People’s Party have galvanized voters in their countries’ left-behind regions. But so far, they’ve been kept out of government, rejected by at least three-quarters of voters. The difference? The United States and Britain have first-past-the-post elections, which organize conflict around just two parties and force voters into two competing camps. Though the Brexit referendum didn’t perfectly map onto the Labour-Conservative divide at the time, it accelerated a divisive polarization that now defines British partisan politics. In an earlier period, when national politics in most Western countries was dominated by a large moderate center, two-party and multiparty systems proved equally adept in holding together a rough national consensus. But today, with urban-rural cultural conflicts driving political competition, majoritarian democracies are amplifying and escalating the zero-sum fights between progressive urban elites and a resentment-driven rural populist right, with no release valve or opportunity for a new center to emerge. Voting reform can help. The proportional democracies of northern Europe, after all, are more effectively riding out the storms of authoritarian populism. There, center-right voters have been able to support center-right parties without supporting illiberalism, and more flexible multiparty systems have facilitated new coalitions to keep illiberal forces out of power. The idea of introducing proportional representation in the United States and Britain is hardly new. What’s new is the context. Cultural, educational, and geographic divides are likely to shape politics for decades to come. A two-party system that by definition splits a country in half will reinforce and deepen identity polarization, pushing national politics even further into trench warfare. Proportional systems are far from perfect. But they allow for new and shifting coalitions that can help liberal democracies navigate these difficult circumstances. Most importantly, they avoid the binary winner-take-all conflict that so easily lets politics slip into an irresolvable zero-sum contest of us against them—a toxic polarization that even long-established democracies such as the United States and Britain may not survive.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Dead Zones
Xiao 19 (Canbo Ziao, Canbo Xiao got his Ph.D at Zhejiang University in 2021 and currently works at School of Marine Science, SYSU; Wei Fan, Ocean College, Zhejiang University, Zhoushan; Zhongzhi Yao, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Yongfa Qiang, Associate Professor, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Yiwen Pan, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Ying Chen, Professor with the Ocean College, Zhejiang University; “On the total entrained flow rate of artificial downwelling”; ScienceDirect; ; June 1 2019)-amc
Over the past decade, artificial downwelling concepts using renewable energy resources have been proposed to increase ventilation below the pycnocline (Ouchi et al., 1998; Sasaki et al., 2009; Carstens, 2008; Antonini et al., 2012, 2015, 2016; Stigebrandt et al., 2015a; Xiao et al., 2018). In these concepts, surface oxygen-rich water is transported downward into the hypoxic bottom through an erect pipe (Fig. 1). The flow discharged from the pipe outlet rises immediately because fresher and warmer surface water has a lower density than the ambient water. The resultant buoyant plume entrains ambient dense water during the upward motion, steadily losing its buoyancy. As the plume reaches beneath the pycnocline, it becomes neutrally buoyant and horizontally spreads out in a process referred to as detrainment or interleaving. A compensatory downward flow occurs far away from the discharge point to replenish the water entrained by the plume, completing a circulation below the pycnocline (Stigebrandt and Kalén, 2013; Bendtsen et al., 2013). Observation have proved that the circulation flow is tens of times greater than the initial pipe flow to increase destratification and ventilation (Stigebrandt et al., 2015a). It is therefore possible to mitigate coastal hypoxia on a relatively large scale via artificial downwelling.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Dead Zones
Liu 20 (Shuo Liu, Assistant Research Fellow with the Ocean Academy, Zhejiang University; Lige Zhao; Canbo Xiao; Dr. Wei Fan, Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Dr. Ying Chen, professor at Ocean College, Zhejiang University; Yiwen Pang, Department of Marine Science; MDPI; “Review of Artificial Downwelling for Mitigating Hypoxia in Coastal Waters”; October 13 2020; ; DOA: 7/15/23)-amc
Artificial downwelling systems, which is one of the geo-engineering-based adaptation options, are recognized as an important support for these plans and for the subsequent mitigating hypoxia in coastal waters []. Artificial downwelling, as an engineering solution to coastal hypoxia, powered by green energy, such as solar, wind, wave, or tidal energy, can develop a compensatory downward flow on a kilometer scale, favoring below-pycnocline ventilation and thus mitigating hypoxia in bottom water. This may be the most realistic alternative for mitigating hypoxia in coastal waters in the future []. Artificial downwelling transports oxygen-rich surface waters into oxygen-deficient deeper layers [], strengthen the below-pycnocline ventilation, increase the dissolved oxygen concentration in the bottom waters, and consequently mitigate bottom hypoxia. Most studies to date yielded positive results with respect to artificial ocean downwelling: (1) Well-designed artificial downwelling systems maintained stratification and did not significantly increase bottom water temperature; therefore, in stratified oceans, the thermocline remained stable and the process preserved a cold-seawater fishery habitat for acrobenthic cåommunities []; (2) levels of dissolved oxygen concentration (DO) were usually elevated in bottom waters []; and (3) concentrations of iron, methane, phosphorus, nitrogen, and hydrogen sulfide were shown to decrease in bottom waters and sediments [].
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Dead Zones
Gaines et.al 21 (Steve Gaines, director of the UC Santa Barbara Marine Science Institute, UCSB Acting Dean of Science and Acting Vice Chancellor for Research, and principal investigator for the Sustainable Fisheries Group; Phoebe Racine, Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Anna Claire Marley; Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Halley E. Froehlich, Environmental Studies, UCSB; Ian Ladner, Ilan MacAdam-Somer, and Darcy Bradley, Marine Science Institute, UCSB Marine Science Institute, University of California, Santa Barbara; “A case for seaweed aquaculture inclusion in U.S. nutrient pollution management,” July 2021, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308597X21001172)-amc
Within the U.S. GoM there is substantial suitable area for seaweed aquaculture to augment upstream pollution control with downstream nutrient assimilation to achieve HTF 2025 N and P reduction goals. Compared to terrestrial-based methods of nutrient pollution control, seaweed aquaculture could be more cost effective and potentially revenue generating. An increasingly favorable policy and regulatory environment in tandem with growing market demand and social acceptance makes seaweed aquaculture a promising tool for nutrient pollution remediation, with the potential to alter the course of nutrient pollution in the GoM and around the world. However, to minimize externalities and realize seaweed aquaculture’s nutrient assimilation potential, localized development of management practices, continual and rigorous monitoring programs, identification and development of candidate species, and the expansion of effective pollution markets will be required. Use of seaweed aquaculture for nutrient assimilation has significant conservation potential, offering a cost-effective tool for mitigating one of the most pressing anthropogenic impacts on the ocean.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Dead Zones
Gaines et.al 21 (Steve Gaines, director of the UC Santa Barbara Marine Science Institute, UCSB Acting Dean of Science and Acting Vice Chancellor for Research, and principal investigator for the Sustainable Fisheries Group; Phoebe Racine, Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Anna Claire Marley; Bren School of Environmental Science & Management; Halley E. Froehlich, Environmental Studies, UCSB; Ian Ladner, Ilan MacAdam-Somer, and Darcy Bradley, Marine Science Institute, UCSB Marine Science Institute, University of California, Santa Barbara; “A case for seaweed aquaculture inclusion in U.S. nutrient pollution management,” July 2021, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308597X21001172)-amc
A natural bio-extractant, seaweed, alongside shellfish, is one of the few available tools for removing nutrient pollution once it has entered waterways. As primary producers, seaweeds remove inorganic nutrients – including N, P, and carbon – from water to fuel growth . When seaweeds are harvested, inorganic nutrients are effectively removed from systems. Additionally, seaweeds oxygenate the water column, providing potential from and declining oxygen levels , and may be able to partially displace nuisance algae blooms . Cultivating seaweeds could draw down available nutrients, thereby limiting resources for unchecked growth of wild, nuisance algae, and potentially curbing algal blooms, which rely on exogenous nutrients to be sustained .
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Dead Zones
OSI 19 (The Ocean Stewards Institute, membership organization that advocates for environmental policy related to the earth's oceans; Ocean Stewards Institute; “Seeding the Sea: D.O.E. Efforts in Offshore Seaweed Culture”; ; 7/19/23)--amc
Seaweed mariculture does not use earth’s arable land, freshwater, or artificial nutrients, and can potentially help absorb excess nutrients and carbon from the ocean, thereby possibly countering so-called “dead-zones” from eutrophication, and ocean acidification. If the U.S. wants to become a global leader in marine biomass production, there are some knowledge gaps to fill. This is the goal of the Department of Energy’s Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) and their . ARPA-E estimates that the U.S. is capable of producing at least 500 million dry metric tons of seaweed annually. Seaweed biomass could be applied for human consumption, feedstock for fuels and chemicals, and animal feed. This level of production could yield enough liquid fuel energy to meet nearly 10% of the nation’s annual transportation energy demand. Domestic biofuel production from seaweed could also lessen the dependence on foreign oil, while boosting our own energy security. As is, the seaweed mariculture industry cannot reach the scale, efficiency, or production costs required for a seaweed-to-fuels trade. The ARPA-E MARINER program’s approach to reaching the scale, efficiency, and production costs is through technology—developing innovative engineering, and systems level solutions for offshore seaweed culture systems. The MARINER program is supporting projects in five areas: 1) integrated cultivation and harvest system design, 2) critical enabling components, 3) computational modeling, 4) monitoring tools, and 5) breeding and genomic tools. Currently, 18 teams are working on developing the tools, technologies, and protocols for their respective project areas. Some teams are refining system designs to grow kelp while others are working with smaller tropical species and starting from scratch. Novel technologies in seeding, feeding, and harvesting are critical to reach the production scale needed to support a seaweed-to-fuels industry. A few teams are looking into using binders to attach small propagules to lines, while others are developing sewing methods for larger pieces. Nutrient-rich deep sea water is being tested as a way to achieve high growth rates with no additional external fertilizers. Modeling teams and engineers are designing ways of pumping this nutrient-rich water from under the farm, using renewable energy in “goldilocks” doses (just the right amount). Specialized autonomous ROV concepts are being formulated, to minimize production and energy costs for harvesting seaweed, with some systems looking to perform more than one task: seeding, trimming, harvesting, and transport all in a single vehicle. Farm systems will allow for deeper submersion during storms, and will be designed in ways to minimize the risks of marine mammal entanglement.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Critical Infrastructure
Collider 22, The aim of The Collider is to provide a space where researchers, founders and investors can connect with entrepreneurial talent, tech-transfer initiatives and technology. The tech-focused initiative designed to fuel digital transformation worldwide, Mobile World Capital Barcelona, powers The Collider. “Are smart grids the answer to the energy crisis?”, June 02, 2022, https://www.citationmachine.net/housing-policy-debate/cite-a-website/new //KOO
There are several key ways in which smart grids can tackle the energy crisis. With the technology available to us today, smart grids can:
Construct a thorough picture of energy use in a given area through the vast amounts of data they collect. With this information, energy providers and governments can begin to develop tools and policies to manage that energy use and to prevent overloads.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Critical Infrastructure
Department of Energy 19, he Department of Energy's Office of Electricity (OE) recognizes that our nation's sustained economic prosperity, quality of life, and global competitiveness depends on an abundance of secure, reliable, and affordable energy resources. OE leads the Department of Energy's efforts to ensure a resilient, and flexible electricity system in the United States, “The Smart Grid”, 12-16-19, https://www.smartgrid.gov/the_smart_grid/smart_grid.html//KOO
The Smart Grid represents an unprecedented opportunity to move the energy industry into a new era of reliability, availability, and efficiency that will contribute to our economic and environmental health. During the transition period, it will be critical to carry out testing, technology improvements, consumer education, development of standards and regulations, and information sharing between projects to ensure that the benefits we envision from the Smart Grid become a reality. The benefits associated with the Smart Grid include:
More efficient transmission of electricity
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Climate
[LSE, The London School of Economics and Political Science, Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment, “What is carbon capture, usage and storage (CCUS) and what role can it play in tackling climate change?,” 3-13-2023, https://www.lse.ac.uk/granthaminstitute/explainers/what-is-carbon-capture-and-storage-and-what-role-can-it-play-in-tackling-climate-change/, maizemg]
What is carbon capture, usage and storage (CCUS)? CCUS refers to a suite of technologies that enable the mitigation of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from large point sources such as power plants, refineries and other industrial facilities, or the removal of existing CO2 from the atmosphere. CCUS is expected to play a crucial role in meeting global climate targets. Leading organisations including the International Energy Agency (IEA), International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF) have all produced long-term energy outlooks that rely on a rapid expansion of CCUS in order to limit global temperature rise to 1.5°C. How does CCUS work? A CCUS application consists of three stages: capture, transport and storage (or usage) of CO2. The main methods for capturing CO2 are: post-combustion; pre-combustion; and oxy-fuel combustion. Post-combustion technology separates CO2 from the flue gas, by using a chemical solvent for instance, after the fuel is burnt. Pre-combustion methods involve converting the fuel into a gas mixture consisting of hydrogen and CO2 before it is burnt. Once the CO2 is separated, the remaining hydrogen-rich mixture can be used as fuel. Finally, oxy-fuel technology involves burning a fuel with almost pure oxygen to produce CO2 and steam, with the released CO2 subsequently captured. Post-combustion and oxy-fuel equipment can be fitted to new plants or retrofitted to existing facilities that were originally built without it. Pre-combustion methods require larger modifications to the operation of the facility and are therefore more suitable to new plants. Currently operational facilities fitted with CCUS can capture around 90% of the CO2 present in flue gas. It is technologically possible to achieve higher capture rates, and research is ongoing to reduce the costs of doing so. CO2 can also be captured directly from the atmosphere by drawing in air using fans and passing it through an environment consisting of solid sorbents or liquid solvents. This practice is more energy intensive and therefore more expensive as CO2 has a much lower concentration in the atmosphere than in flue gas. Once the CO2 has been captured, it is compressed into a liquid state and transported by pipeline, ship, rail or road tanker. CO2 can then be injected into deep geological formations, usually at depths of 1 km or more, to be permanently stored in depleted oil and gas reservoirs, coalbeds or deep saline aquifers, where the geology is suitable. Evidence suggests there is more underground storage available globally than is actually needed to meet climate targets and almost every high-emitting nation has already demonstrated having its own substantial storage resource. An alternative to permanent storage is to use the captured CO2 as an input for commercial products and services, but the climate implications of this are not clear-cut and require careful examination (discussed further below). What is the potential of CCUS for tackling climate change? CCUS can play a strategic role in global decarbonisation efforts in a number of ways. These include: (i) reducing emissions in ‘hard-to-abate’ industries (those that are particularly difficult to decarbonise); (ii) producing low-carbon electricity and hydrogen, which can be used to decarbonise various activities; and (iii) removing existing CO2 from the atmosphere. The various roles of CCUS can also help make the energy supply more diverse and flexible, in turn contributing to energy security, which has become a growing priority for governments around the world. CCUS offers the most cost-effective option in many regions for the deep decarbonisation of a number of hard-to-abate industries, including iron, steel and chemicals. Moreover, CCUS is virtually the only known technological option for achieving deep emissions cuts in cement production, an industry that produces almost 7% of the world’s emissions. As a way of producing electricity and hydrogen in a low-carbon manner, CCUS can also feed into efforts to switch a wider range of sectors away from fossil fuels. CCUS can be installed on power plants running on coal, gas, biomass or waste. The low-carbon electricity created can then replace fossil fuels as an energy source, including in personal transport, space heating and the extraction of low- and medium-temperature heat in industry. Meanwhile, hydrogen can serve as a more direct substitute for fossil fuels in combustion processes, as feedstock in industrial applications, or in long-haul transport. Growing evidence indicates that removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere will be instrumental to reaching net zero emissions globally. The latest IPCC assessment report warns that the deployment of carbon dioxide removal (CDR) technologies is ‘unavoidable’ if net zero emissions are to be achieved. However, CDR should be used to complement, not replace, wider action on carbon mitigation. Two of the main ways of removing CO2 from the atmosphere – bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and direct air carbon capture and storage (DACCS) – both share a technological foundation with CCUS. DACCS enables the capture of CO2 directly from the atmosphere while BECCS can result in CO2 removal on a net basis where the biomass is sustainably sourced.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Climate
[Drew Costly, Staff Writer covering the environment, health, science and tech. , “Biden is investing $257 million into carbon capture but environmentalists say it distracts from renewable energy solutions,” 5-17-2023, Fortune, , maizemg]
The Biden administration on Wednesday announced $251 million for carbon capture and storage projects in seven states, aiming to reducing reduce planet-warming pollution from power plants and other industrial facilities. The announcement represents a vote of confidence by the government in the nascent technology, which proponents, often from oil and gas industries, say could have a huge role in reducing emissions of greenhouse gases. Meanwhile, many environmentalists note that the technology is far from scale and argue that focusing on it distracts from established renewable energy solutions. Between the direct investments announced Wednesday, billions more earmarked from legislation and public statements by President Biden and U.S. Climate Envoy John Kerry, the government is increasing pressure on the carbon capture and storage industry to show that the technology can significantly help combat climate change. “We’re trying to get commercial lift off in the carbon management industry as a whole,” said Noah Deich, deputy assistant secretary for the Department of Energy’s Office of Carbon Management. Carbon capture and storage involves removing carbon dioxide, either from the source of pollution or from the air at large, and storing it deep underground. In some instances, the carbon dioxide is transported across states through pipelines and stored at facilities and used for other things. The projects are funded through the U.S. Department of Energy, with funds from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which set aside $12 billion for carbon management projects. The awardees include universities, one major oil corporation, and come from several states, such as Texas, Illinois, Georgia and Wyoming. The bulk of the money, $242 million, is going toward nine new or expanded large-scale carbon storage projects with capacity to hold at least 50 million metric tons of carbon dioxide, a tiny fraction of how much is put into the atmosphere. The U.S. released about 5.5 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide in 2021, according to the Environmental Protection agency. One of the awardees is BP, which is receiving $33.4 million for two sites along the Gulf Coast in Texas. The rest of funding is for three studies into how to transport carbon dioxide from power plants, ethanol facilities and other industrial operations to locations for reuse or permanent storage. Deich said that the investments complement new rules on greenhouse gas emissions from power plants announced by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The EPA said that one way power plants can bring their emissions under the new limits is by deploying carbon capture technology. Much of the cost of deploying carbon capture is the investment in the equipment to draw down the carbon dioxide, Deich said. Without somewhere to transport or store the carbon, it’s difficult for companies to justify adding the capabilities to plants. In expanding the transportation and storage options, the government investments aim at incentivizing companies to invest in carbon capture technology.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Civil Unrest › 1NC --- Civil Unrest --- Policing CP
[R Trojanowicz ‘86, "Preventing Civil Disturbances: A Community Policing Approach," No Publication, js]
A community's past history, current stress, and a precipitating event can combine to produce violence, as shown by an analysis of police-community relations in previous urban disorders. In more than half the riots studied by the Kerner Commission, a police action triggered the ensuing riot, but the violence was foreshadowed by an accumulation of unresolved grievances by ghetto residents against local authorities. This history shows the importance of preventing violence. Community policing can help prevent violence by reducing the tensions between police and minorities, targeting juveniles for special attention, directly addressing the problems of social and physical disorder and neighborhood decay, and involving citizens in the police process. Evidence from foot patrol experiments in Flint, Mich. indicates that this approach can succeed in preventing riots. Address from which to obtain reference list and list of publications of the National Center for Community Policing.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Chinese Aggression › 2NC --- Chinese Aggression --- NFU CP
Susan Turner Haynes 18. (Susan Turner Haynes joined Lipscomb University as an assistant professor in 2015. Prior to her doctorate) Assistant professor of political science at Lipscomb University in Nashville, Tennessee. Spring 2018. “Dragon in the Room: Nuclear Disarmament’s Missing Player.” Strategic Studies Quarterly. pp. 25-47. //PL
The most direct solution to stopping Chinese nuclear proliferation is to have a treaty that effectively places a ceiling on Chinese strategic nuclear weapons in exchange for further reductions in US and Russian strategic (and likely nonstrategic) forces. A treaty of this sort would seemingly benefit all involved by advancing the purported disarmament goal of all three countries, lessening the security “trilemma” between the three countries, and legitimizing China’s commitment to a “lean and effective” deterrent. This is the kind of solution that most scholars recommend, and while it flows logically from the framework of US-Russian disarmament, such a posteriori reasoning is unsuitable to the Chinese context for several reasons. The first reason is that we do not know for certain the number of Chinese nuclear forces. Any disarmament proposal having to do with hard capabilities will require a certain degree of a priori knowledge. In the case of a treaty dealing with Chinese nuclear force levels, effective implementation would require the Chinese to disclose (and other signatories to verify) the number and nature of its nuclear capabilities. To date, China has been very protective of such information. According to many in China, this is because minimum deterrence requires relative opacity when it comes to the state’s nuclear capabilities—increasing transparency increases China’s vulnerability. An additional obstacle to Sino-US disarmament is the increasing irrelevance with which the Chinese view quantitative limits. From the Chinese perspective, the ongoing modernization programs of the nuclear superpowers have allowed both states to maintain the artifice of meeting disarmament obligations while retaining relative nuclear superiority. Some even argue that the focus on numbers is meant to divert international attention and provide the international community with a false sense of security.17 This has caused many in China to claim that a strict quantitative approach to nuclear disarmament is no longer sufficient.18 After all, what does it matter if there are fewer nuclear weapons if these weapons are upgraded to increase the likelihood of their use? Can one claim, as some have in China, that “the nuclear arms race has changed from one based on quantity to one based on quality?”19 If this is the case, then quantitative disarmament agreements are not enough. The proceeding analysis examines each of these obstacles, in turn, beginning with the problem of transparency. The argument here is that future disarmament negotiations between China and the United States are unlikely to resemble those between the US and Russia. We cannot begin with START, nor can we use previous negotiations as a template for a new situation. Instead, we must work diligently to uncover new conditions for cooperation. While the US may appease China by continuing to decrease its strategic weapons through bilateral agreements with Russia, other areas of concessions are likely to make more of an impact in the Sino-US nuclear dynamic, including written clarification of US intent regarding nuclear use and the use of its prompt long-range conventional weapons and restrictions on certain qualitative advancements in its nuclear force. Seeing Opportunities for Cooperation US officials are usually the first to argue that China’s opacity vis-à-vis its hard capabilities impedes disarmament cooperation. Chinese officials often counter that the US is equally opaque when it comes to intent. Even if China reveals the structure and scope of its strategic nuclear arsenal, they argue, China needs reassurance that the United States will not use its knowledge of China’s nuclear force to employ its strategic nuclear weapons or its advanced conventional weapons in a preemptive strike. Chinese leaders would thus want to have knowledge of and confidence in US nuclear intent before disclosing specific information relating to its nuclear capabilities. This is why China wants the US to sign a formal no first use (NFU) agreement, in which the US commits only to use nuclear weapons in response to nuclear attacks and not in response to large-scale conventional, chemical, biological, or cyberattacks. It would also foreclose the possibility of America providing extended deterrence to its nonnuclear allies.20 This is a move the US has never been willing to make. The closest step it took in this regard was the considerable debate that ensued around the topic under the Obama administration prior to the 2010 nuclear posture review. Ultimately, however, the US decided against adopting an NFU policy. It also rejected a more limited no first strike (NFS) policy, which would have prevented the US from carrying out a preemptive nuclear attack (usually aimed to eliminate an adversary’s nuclear capabilities or arsenal).21
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Chinese Aggression › 1NC --- Chinese Aggression --- NFU CP
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 6-29-2020, "What Are the Aims of U.S. Missile Defense?," https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/06/29/what-are-aims-of-u.s.-missile-defense-pub-82123//PL
Chinese strategists must have considered more sophisticated options than all-out nuclear retaliation in response to any rival nuclear attack. Without knowing what role theater nuclear forces play in such options—and how Beijing understands external threats to those forces—it is impossible for China and the United States and its regional allies to have a meaningful discussion about how theater missile defense systems could affect Beijing’s nuclear deterrent and whether measures can be taken to mitigate their impact. China’s future defense white papers can consider shedding more light on this issue. In this respect, the 2018 U.S. NPR report could be something of a general model (although China does not necessarily agree with the U.S. observation and evidence in this particular case): the NPR report clearly explained why the U.S. government is concerned that its theater nuclear forces are inadequate given its beliefs that Russia might use nuclear weapons in a limited way early in a conflict and that Moscow is developing new types of tactical weapons to support this doctrine. By extension, China’s clarification could also help other countries better evaluate the credibility of its NFU policy, reduce their concerns about the nuclear threat Beijing poses (which, in turn, may reduce investments in missile defense), and mitigate the risks of inadvertent escalation in a crisis. What the United States Can Do Mitigate U.S.-China differences on countering North Korean nuclear weapons. U.S. concerns about North Korea’s nuclear and missile programs remain key drivers of the development and deployment of U.S. strategic missile defense systems designed to thwart enemy missiles launched from East Asia. But U.S. decisionmakers should be aware that the ambiguity over whether U.S. strategic missile defense capabilities are aimed at North Korea or China itself contributes significantly to Beijing’s worst-case assumptions about U.S. intent. Moreover, ongoing improvements to North Korea’s nuclear and missile capabilities will likely drive the United States to augment its strategic missile defense systems, further intensifying the security trilemma between Beijing, Pyongyang, and Washington.161 At the operational level, the United States may feel it needs a high degree of confidence that even if North Korea launched every one of its ICBMs in a surprise attack, U.S. missile defense systems could intercept all of them. But U.S. policymakers should recall that Chinese strategists worry that such U.S. missile defense systems could neutralize China’s surviving nuclear weapons after a U.S. first strike, a concern heightened by China’s geographic proximity to North Korea. Despite hopes that the United States and China would find a way to cooperate more to try to convince North Korea to denuclearize, Chinese and U.S. geostrategic interests are CARNEGIE ENDOWMENT FOR INTERNATIONAL PEACE 55 increasingly diverging amid their heightened strategic rivalry, making such coordination more difficult to achieve. As a first step to mitigate such challenges, the United States and China should jointly evaluate North Korea’s nuclear and missiles capabilities and the potential threats they pose to other countries and regional stability, so as to narrow or at least shed light on the gap between Chinese experts’ generally more sanguine and U.S. experts’ typically more pessimistic assessments.162 U.S. allies, such as South Korea, can help convene and moderate such joint evaluations, giving China a stronger incentive to participate. A U.S. NFU commitment could help. The United States could help mitigate this dilemma by adopting an NFU policy toward China, or, less formally, by forging a private understanding with China on NFU. This would effectively address China’s fear of a U.S. first strike, thus substantially reducing the potential impact of U.S. missile defense on China’s nuclear deterrent and making it much easier for Washington to assure Beijing that U.S. missile defense systems cannot undermine its nuclear deterrent. China’s own NFU policy and its long-standing call for other nuclear powers to adopt such a policy means that even a U.S. declaratory policy of NFU would help address Chinese concerns about the risks of a preemptive U.S. nuclear strike. Despite the long internal debate within the United States about NFU, the potentially huge benefit of bringing Beijing and Washington closer to resolving their missile defense dispute should give one important reason for the United States to seriously consider adopting this policy toward China
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Biodiversity › 1NC --- Bio-d --- Conservation Tech CP
DiGirolamo 22[Mike DiGirolamo, Mongabay’s Audience Engagement Associate contributing audio/visual content for Mongabay's podcast and YouTube platforms., “Can conservation technology help save our rapidly disappearing species? | Problem Solved,” 6-8-2022, Mongaby – News & Inspiration from Nature’s Frontline,https://news.mongabay.com/2022/06/can-conservation-technology-help-save-our-rapidly-disappearing-species-problem-solved/, A global community‐sourced assessment of the state of conservation technology. Conservation Biology, 36(3). doi:10.1111/cobi.13871, maizemg]
Conservation technology is not new. Take camera traps, for instance. While they have not always been widely used, scientists and conservationists have increasingly been relying upon them over the past decade to detect and monitor the presence of land-based species. For all the technological innovation that made camera trap usage feasible in the 2010s, conservationists are still left with (sometimes) millions of photographs to sort through. There is also a lot of other data to catalog and analyze when information is collected via mobile apps and GIS (geographic information systems) and remote sensing. But is this happening fast enough? Scientists warn that the Earth could potentially lose as many as 500 land animals over the next 20 years (compared to the same amount that was lost over the previous century). Time, as they say, is not on our side. A study by WILDLABS published late last year names three particular pieces of conservation tech as having significant potential to aid conservationists in carrying out field monitoring work: environmental DNA (eDNA), networked sensors, and artificial intelligence/machine learning. These three technologies can streamline major logistical, labor and financial hurdles if used properly. Coupled with appropriate conservation programs, experts say high-quality population monitoring surveys of species are key to protecting our remaining biodiversity.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Biodiversity › 1NC --- Bio-d --- Conservation Tech CP
ITU, 22 [ITU, International Telecommunication Union (ITU), “Five ways that high-tech maps can help protect biodiversity,” 4-22-2022, ITU, https://www.itu.int/hub/2022/04/high-tech-maps-can-help-protect-biodiversity/,maizemg]
Conservation technology is helping to track and protect species on the brink of extinction. High-tech maps can predict where species will move in response to climate change, and provide a clear picture of which species are most at threat. This technology can also monitor protected land, and analyse photographic evidence about species and how they are surviving. With nearly 1 million species facing extinction, it has never been more important to know where threatened and endangered wildlife are located and how they are responding to threats, from habitat destruction to invasive species and climate change. Conservation technology is offering a solution. Using advanced tools such as remote sensing, artificial intelligence (AI) and statistical modelling, we are changing the way we protect species on the brink. Here are five ways that high-tech maps are helping to protect biodiversity: 1. Predicting where species are moving in response to climate change As the world warms, thousands of species are shifting their ranges to escape rising temperatures and precipitation patterns that have permanently altered their habitats. While these migrations are happening over many years and many generations, this is the beginning of a redistribution of the entire planet’s ecosystems – a process that could upend the delicate ecological relationships we all rely upon to survive. It is essential to predict where roaming wildlife will end up. But doing so isn’t always easy, as each species is moving in a different direction and at a different pace to avoid a different climate impact. In response, scientists and policy experts from over 20 institutions created the Spatial Planning for Area Conservation in Response to Climate Change (SPARC) tool. SPARC uses supercomputers and GIS-based mapping tools to build a global picture of the movement of all known plants, birds and mammals in response to climate change. Through it, governments can make crucial predictions about where climate change will impact species — helping them more effectively plan to conserve natural systems, even across country borders. 2. Providing a clear picture of where species are at the greatest risk of extinction, and why Using satellite data and wildlife surveys from around the world, a team of scientists created the Species Threat Abatement and Restoration (STAR) metric, which identifies what types of human activities are most harmful to wildlife and where they are happening. Each species is given a “STAR score.” The higher the score, the greater the species’ risk of extinction. For example, using the tool scientists found that the James’ Sportive Lemur — a critically endangered primate found in Madagascar — has a STAR score of 400, the highest possible on the scale. Agricultural expansion accounts for half that score; hunting makes up the other half. By determining what activities are harming a species, we also know what actions we need to avoid in order to protect it. 3. Mapping the ecosystems we cannot afford to lose Conservation International scientists recently mapped the ecosystems that we cannot afford to lose in our fight to stabilize our climate. These diverse landscapes — from mangroves to wetlands and old-growth forests — hold high concentrations of carbon collected over hundreds or even thousands of years. If these places are destroyed, all that carbon will be released into the atmosphere as climate-altering CO2. Many of these ecosystems are also among the most important biodiversity strongholds in the world. By combining the habitat ranges and SPARC climate responses of tens of thousands of birds, mammals, amphibians and reptiles with the map of irrecoverable carbon, scientists have discovered the places that are “doubly irreplaceable” for climate and biodiversity. As countries come together to establish protections for 30% of global lands and waters by 2030, these landscapes must be among the top candidates for conservation. 4. Capturing the beauty and fragility of biodiversity, one photo at a time Across every continent on Earth, biologists have installed motion-capture camera systems that have offered a glimpse of elusive and secretive animals like the snow leopard and Florida panther. These tools have become an essential part of implementing smart conservation policies guided by a real-world view of what vulnerable species are experiencing on the ground. Despite their importance, most data collected on wildlife through cameras is fragmented and difficult to process. That’s where Wildlife Insights comes in — a revolutionary technology that uses machine learning to quickly process and analyze images from motion-detector cameras, revealing information about species’ condition in near-real time. It is now simpler than ever to automatically monitor wildlife habitats on the landscape scale and track individual species on a granular level – tasks that are essential for conservation but cost-prohibitive to do manually. Perhaps most importantly, anyone can contribute to Wildlife Insights by submitting their own images, putting the power in the hands of citizens to save species. 5. Protecting the lands that wildlife need to survive Protected lands and waters like national parks and national wildlife refuges are vital to the survival of endangered wildlife. In fact, according to a new study by Conservation International, mammal diversity within protected areas is an incredible 66 percent greater than in non-protected areas. Though we think of protected lands as permanent fixtures of our landscape, research shows that they are not forever. Laws governing protected lands and waters are increasingly being altered; restrictions are relaxed, boundaries shrunk or protections eliminated entirely. This process is called protected area downgrading, downsizing and degazettement, or PADDD. In response, PADDDtracker is documenting and monitoring legal changes to public lands, showing the ways these decisions harm biodiversity and people.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Biodiversity › 1NC --- Bio-d --- Conservation Tech CP
Chiorando, 22 [Maria Chiorando, Editor for Plant Based News, Ethos “Technology Has Been Bad for Wildlife, Now It’s Powering a Push That Could Save It,” 8-29-2022, https://the-ethos.co/technology-resources-wildlife-protection/, maizemg]
The planet has been relentlessly plundered for its resources in a bid to feed humanity’s insatiable desire for progress. Now it’s time technology was used for environmental good. Humanity’s insatiable desire for technological progress is taking a heavy toll on the planet and its wildlife, with the gadgets we use daily playing a major role in environmental destruction that’s harming wild animals in many ways. In a bid to power technology, we pollute the air, and we deplete natural resources, decimating habitats as we do so. We need only look as far as the device in our hands for an example of a ubiquitous item that gobbles resources. While we may struggle to operate without our phones, mining the lithium and cobalt needed for their rechargeable batteries is an intensive process requiring unthinkable amounts of energy and water. However, while our unrelenting use of technology continues to be a force for destruction, in recent decades, sustainably-minded individuals and groups have been harnessing its power for good, adopting increasingly sophisticated solutions to protect wildlife, or conservation technologies. Conservation technologies These solutions include conservationists using established processes like camera traps, tracking tags, satellite remote sensing, acoustic sensors, and drones to track, study, and protect wild animals. For example, an initiative in Aceh, Indonesia, uses drones to monitor Sumatran elephants as they traverse vast landscapes which are often inaccessible by humans. When they get close to community farms, the drones provide an airborne warning system, alerting local Conservation Response Units, who come to the area and drive the animals away, saving them from possible death, and reducing elephant-human conflict. Newer technologies are also emerging, including computer facial recognition, data management tools, networked sensors, and artificial intelligence, which can be used to gather data about animals and their habitats, and share it with a global digital audience. These processes contribute to a better understanding of the natural world, which in turn can lead to more effective protections for its wild inhabitants. A major driver on the conservation technology scene is Wildlabs, an open-access platform for conservation technology online, ‘connecting more than 5,000 conservationists, researchers, field biologists, engineers, developers, makers, and conservation technology experts from around the world’. The hub, which aims to ‘transform how we think about tech and wildlife conservation’, was created by a coalition of animal organizations, like international wildlife conservation organization Fauna & Flora International (FFI), a major proponent of conservation technology. Other partners include Conservation International, WCS, WW,F and the Zoological Society of London. It was launched in collaboration with Google in 2015, and has provided fruitful since, with the digital exchange of global ideas prompting new innovations. Speaking around two years after its launch, Joanna Elliott, FFI’s Senior Director – Conservation Partnerships said in a press release: “Wildlabs has proved to be an extremely successful catalyst and conduit for technological innovation in conservation. “It is enabling us to mine a rich seam of ingenious new ideas that help overcome some of the many challenges we encounter in the field.” Safeguarding the future of wildlife Continuing the work of developing these ideas and technologies, at the end of 2021, Wildlabs partners in collaboration with researchers at Colorado State University and tech sector leaders Microsoft and Arm, published research conducted research to establish which innovations could carry the most promise for the future. Their assessment of the state of conservation technology was based on a survey of almost 250 users and developers in a research paper published by the Society for Conservation Biology. They concluded that this tech is more effective than traditional methods, suggesting widespread adoption is crucial. According to the researchers: “Overall, conservation technologies were consistently reported to enable new and more frequent ecological and management insights, improve the efficiency, scale, and quality of data collection, and empower conservationists to ask more useful and interesting questions of these data with increasingly powerful analytics and reporting tools.” Limits to conservation tech roll-outs However, despite exciting developments within the sector, and the potential these innovations offer, researchers admitted there are myriad factors limiting how quickly they can be rolled out. They wrote in their paper that while conservation tech ‘holds the potential to vastly increase conservationists’ ability to understand and address critical environmental challenges’ there are constraints – namely systemic ones that ‘appear to hamper its development and adoption’. Notably, survey respondents from countries with developing economies reported being held back by upfront costs, maintenance costs, and development funding, while female respondents cited being constrained by ‘development funding and perceived technical skills’, issues that must be addressed. One way to tackle them could be introducing ‘more initiatives dedicated to supporting under-resourced individuals with funding and industry-expert mentorship’ the paper said, adding that these initiatives are needed to overcome barriers and deliver sustained impact. Get behind the revolution And the importance of delivering sustained impact is paramount, according to FFI, which discussed the issue in a news update on its website in which it called for public and private sector figures to support the sector. “Protecting and restoring nature is the most pressing task facing humanity this century – and this research is further evidence of the huge contribution that technology has to play,” said the organization. “Innovations in areas like DNA sequencing and artificial intelligence are allowing us to understand the natural world and conserve wildlife in new, more efficient and often more effective ways, safeguarding species from extinction. “Now we need governments, philanthropists and the private sector – including the tech giants – to put their weight behind the technological revolution in conservation with support and funding for conservationists worldwide to use technology to protect wildlife.”