Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
AFF – State/Local › N/U – Jobs ↓

State and local jobs are decreasing

Weller PhD 2023

[Christian Weller, PhD, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Economics 2-9-2023, "Amid Strong Labor Market, State And Local Governments Struggle To Hire," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/christianweller/2023/02/09/amid-strong-labor-market-state-and-local-governments-struggle-to-hire/?sh=4ed0936e3975]

The labor market in general remains remarkably strong with all of the jobs lost during the pandemic long recovered. But, public employment is not doing so well. Parts of state and local government employment are still well below their levels before the pandemic. Governments have a difficult time attracting the talent that they need for a myriad of reasons. As a result, public services such as education, transportation, public health and others are woefully understaffed and people, businesses and communities suffer as a result. The latest data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics show a  market in the face of stiff headwinds from higher interest rates, Republican gambles with the debt ceiling and overseas risks such as the continued war in Ukraine. and the unemployment rate fell to its lowest level since 1969 with 3.4%. These top line numbers are welcome news as they show that the labor market and the economy remain fundamentally strong. But, that is not all there is. Private sector employment now exceeds its pre-pandemic level from February 2020 by 3.2 million jobs or 2.5%. But, public sector jobs, especially in state and local governments, are still below their levels from before the pandemic. State governments are missing 200,000 jobs – a decline of 3.8% relative to February 2020 — while local governments are down by 305,000 jobs or 2.1%. The initial onslaught of the pandemic decimated state and local government employment and that part of the labor market is only gradually recovering. The job losses in the public sector are widespread. Take local government employment, which is substantially larger than state government employment with 14.4 million to 5.1 million in January 2023. Jobs in education in local governments – mainly elementary and secondary schools – are down from where they were in February 2020 by 174,000 jobs, a drop of 2.2%. In comparison, non-education jobs in transportation, hospitals, administration, and everything else such as town clerks, city planning and public health, among others, are down by 131,000 jobs or 2.0%. At a time, when people, businesses and communities need more services due to greater public health needs, increased infrastructure investments, a growing economy and more attention on diversity, equity and inclusion, local governments are severely understaffed. The lack of government jobs has also larger ramifications for economic inequality. Nobody gets rich off working for state and local governments, but those jobs provide stable jobs, decent benefits and meaningful career paths. People can often achieve middle-class financial security working for state and local governments. Similar opportunities are rarer in the private sector for many groups, such as people without a college degree. Yet, the number of people without a college degree working in state government was down 2.2% in the last three months of 2022 relative to the last three months of 2019. My calculation here compares the same three months of a year to avoid seasonal fluctuations to influence the conclusions. The situation was even worse in local governments. There, the employment of people without a college degree was down 5.8% relative to pre-pandemic levels. And, in K-12 education, employment of people without a college degree was down by a whopping 12.1%. Schools are desperately lacking the support personnel necessary to make sure that children can get to school and work in clean and safe learning environments.especially towns, cities and counties, are struggling with filling open positions. This means that people, businesses and communities are getting fewer critical services and have to wait longer for those services. The problem appears especially acute with respect to K-12 education. Governments will need to find new ways to attract the personnel. This starts with higher wages, but also will need to include more and . It’s always going to be difficult for public employers to compete on salary, so they have to take full advantage of their strong benefit offerings to attract and keep workers. These can include emergency savings, more telework options and expanded paid medical and family leave. There really is no alternative since communities, businesses and people rely on critical public services.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Turns Case

Yi 2013

[Hongtao Yi, 2013, "Clean energy policies and green jobs: An evaluation of green jobs in U.S. metropolitan areas," No Publication, ]

This study evaluates employment effects of state and local clean energy policies. We find state clean energy policies have moderate positive impacts on green jobs. We find local climate policies have moderate positive impact on green jobs. State and local governments in the U.S. are actively promoting renewable energy and energy efficiency to seek economic development opportunities and create green jobs. This study evaluates the employment effects of state and local clean energy and climate policies in U.S. metropolitan areas (MSAs) in 2006. The regression analysis shows that both state and local clean energy policies have positive and statistically significant impacts on green jobs at the metropolitan level. The results from Two Stage Probit Least Squares (2SPLS) indicate that every additional state clean energy policy tool adopted is associated with 1% more green jobs in the MSA. On average, MSAs with ICLEI membership maintain 9.3% more green jobs than MSAs without ICLEI membership, Ceteris paribus. & 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. 1. Introduction The transition towards sustainable and low carbon communities requires the development and deployment of a range of new and existing energy technologies. Globally, many nation states, such as European countries, China and South Korea, consider clean energy policies as strategic pathways to enhance national competitiveness in science and technology. In the context of the U.S., the federal government had not taken a proactive role in clean energy until President Obama took office in 2008. The lack of national leadership in this policy arena has resulted in greater reliance on state and local efforts in energy efficiency and renewable energy. State governments in the U.S. have adopted renewable portfolio standards, energy efficiency resource standards and various tax incentives to stimulate the growth of clean energy industry (Rabe, 2004, 2008; Carley, 2011). At the local level, counties and cities are actively engaged in greenhouse gas emission reduction efforts through joining in ICLEI’s1 Cities for Climate Protection (CCP) movement and U.S. Conference of Mayors Climate Protection Agreement (CPA), among various other local initiatives (Francis and Feiock, 2010). In addition to environmental motivations for these policies, an important rationale for adopting these policies is to stimulate economic development through creating green jobs. In many cases, the rationales for supporting the clean energy industry are based on economic development instead of climate protection (Rabe, 2004). Despite the fact that green economic development and job creation are at the center of political rhetoric and academic discussion, much less attention has been directed to evaluating the extent to which existing clean energy policies have successfully created or maintained green jobs. Most existing literature on green jobs has focused on ex-ante forecasting of green jobs creation potential of different energy technologies (for example, Kammen et al., 2006; Wei et al., 2010) and government’s direct spending (Pollin et al., 2009). Much less work has been done to conduct ex-post evaluation of the job effects of clean energy development, especially in the context of the U.S. Also, the literature on state and local climate and clean energy policies in the U.S. has been focused on energy diversification and decarbonization, instead of employment effects (Carley, 2011; Yin and Powers, 2010; Yi and Feiock, 2010). This stream of research has been totally disconnected from the green jobs literature, leaving a significant gap in the literature. The lack of empirical evidence on the effectiveness of the state and local clean energy policies in International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives, is an international association of local governments and other levels of governments who share the commitment to the sustainable development. Energy Policy 56 (2013) 644–652 creating green jobs has not only thwarted meaningful communication in the political debates, but also affected the progress in academic understandings of this important policy area. This paper fills this lacuna by empirically examining the impact of clean energy policies at the state and local levels in stimulating and maintaining green jobs in the U.S. metropolitan areas. This study contributes to extant literature of state and local energy policies as well as green jobs studies. In the next section, extant literature on green economic development is examined. We then discuss the array of state and local policies adopted to stimulate green economic development and present the key hypotheses. Ordinary least squares (OLS) and two stage probit least squares (2SPLS) regressions are then conducted to empirically examine the influence of clean energy policies on green jobs in 361 U.S. metropolitan areas. This paper concludes with implications and suggestions for future research.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- S/L key to solve racial disparities

State and local workforce are key to building economic security for minorities.

Rose Khattar, 1-3-2022, (”Investments in the State and Local Government Workforce Will Deliver Crucial Services and Create Economic Security," Center for American Progress, )

State and local governments also make up a large part of overall employment, accounting for around 12 percent of employed people. A majority of state and local government workers are women, and in 2021, 15 percent of employed women worked in state and local governments compared with 9 percent of employed men. This makes state and local governments not only large employers of women but also more diverse than the private sector. (see Figure 1) Workers of color, particularly Black and American Indian, Aluet, and Eskimo workers, are disproportionately represented in these industries:

18 percent: Percentage of employed American Indian, Aluet, and Eskimo women working in local and state government in 2021

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- S/L key to solve racial disparities

State budget key to preventing racial disparities.

Center on Budget and Policy Priorities ’22 [nonpartisan research and policy institute that advances federal and state policies; Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “State Budgets Basics” https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/state-budgets-basics ; acc 7/23/2023 EB]

State budget decisions should matter to all of us. State budgets affect the quality of life of workers, families, and communities across the nation ― they decide the fate of roads, schools, health care, public transportation, clean air and water, and much more. Every year, state policymakers make critical choices about how to provide these services and how to ensure that state revenues are adequate to fund them. In addition to spending their own funds, states play an important role in implementing federal programs and deciding how to spend federal funds ― for example, designing the health services provided under Medicaid, or determining where to invest federal highway and public transit funds. (Both programs require states to provide a share of the funding.) And state budgets are used to distribute funds, from housing to health care to public safety, to support local communities. Budgets can change, and even save, lives. A state’s budget shows its priorities. State budgets play a critical role in addressing residents’ needs and creating opportunities for families and communities to thrive. State budgets can also reduce long-standing racial and economic disparities in access to jobs, housing, and education; many advocates say the budget is a “moral document.” This also means that everyone has a stake in state budget outcomes.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Public transportation reduces pollution and increases physical activities

US Department of Transportation 2015 ( US Department of Transportation, Reviewed August 24, 2015, “Expand Public Transportation Systems and Offer Incentives,” , acsessed 7/24/2023, BH)

Public transportation can include buses, trains, trams, trolleys, ferries, paratransit, or rapid public transportation systems. Investments in public transportation have potential traffic safety, air quality, active transportation, and accessibility benefits, thus improving associated personal health outcomes. Public transportation has substantially lower crash rates and lower crash severity than automotive travel. A 2014 study found that public transportation travel has less than half the total death rate as automobile travel per passenger mile, and public transportation passengers have about one-tenth the fatality rate per mile as automobile passengers (Litman, 2014). Public transportation uses less fuel and produces lower levels of carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOC), and carbon dioxide (CO2) per passenger mile relative to private vehicles. Public transportation also influences health because most public transportation users walk or bicycle to access public transportation. A 2005 study found that 29% of respondents to the 2001 National Household Travel Survey were able to achieve 30 minutes or more of daily exercise through walking to or from public transportation. A 2013 study noted that from 2001 to 2009, the estimated number of public transportation walkers whose public transportation-associated walking time was 30 minutes or more increased 31%, from approximately 2.6 million to 3.4 million. For older adults and persons with disabilities, paratransit services provide vital links to reaching medical and other essential services. The cost of public transportation is often lower than the costs associated with other forms of transportation (e.g., personal vehicles). Another way to expand public transportation use is to fund and improve public transportation station area planning, to ensure that it is integrated with active transportation modes and infrastructure (e.g., bicycle-sharing stations) and public transportation-oriented development. To encourage the use of public transportation, incentives may be offered to help reduce the cost to the user, including free or discounted bus, rail, or public transportation passes. Other incentives include employer-provided subsidies, reimbursements, partial payments, or pre-tax payroll reductions. Such incentives have been shown to increase public transportation use, and use of active travel options such as walking and bicycling, particularly among college students. Related Transportation and Heath Tool Indicators How can this strategy result in health benefits? Address chronic disease (e.g., asthma, diabetes, heart disease), Improve access to health-supportive resources, Improve equity, Increase physical activity, Improve safety, Reduce motor vehicle-related injuries and fatalities, Reduce transportation's contribution to air pollution How has this worked in practice? The , the first light rail transit (LRT) service in the Charlotte, North Carolina, region, provides daily service and operates for approximately 10 miles, extending from I-485 at South Boulevard to Uptown Charlotte. The Blue Line LRT service evolved from Charlotte’s 2025 Integrated Transit/Land Use Plan, which identified appropriate public transportation technologies and focused growth and development along five primary transportation corridors within the region. Further plans for fixed guideway public transportation expansion under development include extension of the Blue Line, a Gold Line streetcar system, the Silver Line Bus Rapid Transit, and the Red Line regional rail service. When complete, this system will include 25 miles of regional rail, 21 miles of light rail, 16 miles of streetcar, and 14 miles of Bus Rapid Transit, and a complementary enhanced bus public transportation network. A study of data collected before and after completion of the Blue Line found that persons who used the line for commuting reduced their in body mass index (-1.18) and their odds of becoming obese over time (81%), suggesting that LRT combined with land use strategies could improve health outcomes. Where can I learn more? developed by CDC provides information on policy, systems, and environmental improvement strategies designed to reduce health inequities and help communities incorporate the concept of health equity into public health practice. The American Public Transportation Association () provides information on meetings and conferences, government affairs and policy, a resource library, weekly newsletter, and media center to engage members on public transportation, including bus, paratransit, light rail, commuter rail, trolleys, streetcars, subways, ferries, and high-speed rail. The website includes information about the benefits of transit-oriented development, funding opportunities, research and resources.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Public Transportation provides many health benefits

CDC, 2018 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Reviewed October 19, 2018, “ Public Transportation System: Introduction or Expansion Interventions Addressing Social Detriments of Health,” , accessed 7/24/2023, BH)

What is the public transportation system? Public transportation systems include a variety of transit options such as buses, light rail, and subways. These systems are available to the general public, may require a fare, and run at scheduled times. The purpose of introducing or expanding public transportation is to increase access to and use of public transit while, at the same time, reducing motor vehicle miles driven and traffic congestion.[1] Public transportation systems are often implemented at the local or regional level and can be supported by federal initiatives, such as the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act. [1, 2] Los Angeles County is one example of a region that expanded its public transportation system using local, state, and federal funding.[3, 4] What is the public health issue? Transportation systems help ensure that people can reach everyday destinations, such as jobs, schools, healthy food outlets and healthcare facilities, safely and reliably.[5] Public transportation services play an important role for people who are unable to drive, including those without access to personal vehicles, children, individuals with disabilities, and older adults.[5,6] The U.S. transportation infrastructure focuses on motor vehicle travel (e.g., passenger cars, vans, SUVs, pickup trucks, and other light trucks) and provides limited support for other transportation options.[ 7] According to the U.S. Census Bureau, in 2013 approximately 86 percent of all workers traveled to work by private vehicle, and 76 percent drove alone.[8] Also in 2013, 69 percent of urban households and 14 percent of rural households had access to public transit.[4] Although using public transportation has historically been safer than travel in passenger vehicles, passenger vehicle travel has grown more quickly than other modes of travel.[1,7,9] Motor vehicle crashes continue to be the leading cause of injury-related death for many age groups.[7,10] In 2013, motor vehicle crashes were the second leading cause of death among individuals aged 13 to 25 years.[11] CDC’s package includes evidence-based strategies to improve asthma control and reduce healthcare costs, including policy information about clean diesel transportation. Public transportation systems provide opportunities for increased physical activity in the form of walking or biking on either end of the trip (e.g., from home to bus stop or from train stop to office) and reduced motor vehicle travel.[12-15] Despite these benefits, many Americans view walking and bicycling within their communities unfavorably because of barriers such as disability, age, chronic disease, inconvenience or safety concerns about traffic and a lack of sidewalks, crosswalks, and bicycle facilities.[7,16] Many people aren’t meeting the recommendations for physical activity;[17] the lack of physical activity contributes to obesity, diabetes, heart disease, stroke, and other chronic health conditions in the U.S. [7,16] Air pollution from motor vehicles continues to contribute to adverse respiratory and cardiovascular health effects.[7,18] Nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds react with sunlight to create ozone.[19] Carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, and ozone are associated with a variety of health problems including myocardial ischemia, chest pain, coughing, throat irritation, and airway inflammation, and can worsen bronchitis, emphysema, and asthma.[20-22] Particulate matter, which is produced by engine exhaust and tire and brake wear, is associated with an increased risk of respiratory and cardiovascular disease.[23-25] What is the evidence of health impact and cost effectiveness? Public transportation systems are associated with reductions in several health risk factors such as motor vehicle crashes, air pollution, and physical inactivity. The U.S. Department of Transportation reported that public transportation (school, intercity, transit bus, light rail transit, and subway) accounted for less than one percent of transportation fatalities in 2011, while private passenger vehicles accounted for more than 75 percent of transportation fatalities.[1, 25] An analysis of the transportation fatality risk in the U.S. found that the fatality rates per billion passenger miles traveled between 2000 and 2009 were 0.11 for buses, 0.24 for urban mass transit rail trains, 0.43 for passengers on commuter rails, and 7.28 for drivers or passengers in a car or light truck.[26] For every passenger mile traveled, public transportation produces only a fraction of the harmful pollution of private vehicles: only five percent as much carbon monoxide, less than eight percent as many volatile organic compounds, and nearly half as much carbon dioxide and nitrogen oxides.[27] A systematic review examining public transportation use and physical activity found that use of public transport was associated with an additional 8 to 33 minutes of walking per day.[28] A study of the impact of adding light rail stations in Los Angeles found it to be associated with an increase in daily physical activity among residents with previously lower physical activity levels.[29] The expansion was also associated with a reduction in vehicle miles traveled and their related emissions.[27] Another study found that train commuters took an average of 30 percent more steps per day than car commuters.[30] A study of 130 U.S. cities found that each rail passenger mile represents a reduction of three to six automobile passenger miles—through direct substitution and indirectly through the creation of compact, mixed-use transit-oriented developments that foster walking and cycling and reduced automobile ownership.[31] A final study, looking at zoning for TODs, found that this type of zoning was associated with significantly higher rates of public transportation to work and active transportation to work. [32] A descriptive cost analysis examined the value of the health benefits, which included fewer traffic crashes, less air pollution and increased physical fitness, of increasing the proportion of the population that has access to public transit. The analysis estimated that if a city with a typical quality North American public transit service improved to high quality (i.e., fast, convenient and comfortable) urban rail or bus rapid transit service, the per capita annual health benefits would be $355. If improvements were made to achieve a high quality transit service with walkable, mixed-use development around stations, the per capita annual health benefits would be $541. It also estimated that for a city with a million residents, an increase in the proportion of households located in transit-oriented developments from 10 percent to 20 percent would produce nearly $71 million of total annual health benefits, and an increase from 10 percent to 40 percent would generate more than $216 million of total annual health benefits.[33] A cost-benefit analysis that examined the impact of expanding public transportation capacity by converting a lane for bus rapid transit found an association with positive net benefits to society, including travel time savings, travel cost savings, and emissions reduction.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Public transportation is important because it positively impacts public health and equity

Heaps et. al 21 Wendy Heaps, Erin Abramsohn, Elizabeth Skillen, senior policy advisors in the Office of The Associate Director for Policy and Strategy, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in Atlanta, Georgia, “Public Transportation In The US: A Driver Of Health And Equity,” Health Affairs, July 29, 2021, https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20210630.810356/

Health, functioning, and quality of life are products of the social and economic conditions in the environments where people are born, live, learn, work, play, worship, and age. Research suggests that an estimated 20 percent of a person’s health can be attributed to clinical care, whereas an estimated 30 percent can be attributed to health behaviors such as diet and exercise, and another 10 percent to the physical environment, including air and water quality, housing, and transit. The remaining 40 percent is related to social and economic factors such as education, employment, and income. Transportation is a component of the built environment, with important impacts on public health and health equity. Transportation policies, planning efforts, and infrastructure investments have historically emphasized roads over public and active transportation, contributing to health hazards and segregating communities. New or expanded public transportation options can increase access to and use of transit and can improve health outcomes by promoting better air quality, increasing levels of physical activity, decreasing injuries from motor vehicle crashes, and improving mental health. Access to public transportation may also reduce health disparities and promote health equity by increasing access to healthier food options, medical care, vital services, and employment for communities that do not have equal access to these fundamental daily necessities. Public transportation refers to a wide variety of options, including buses, streetcars, light rail, ferries, and subways that provide “regular and continuing” transportation to the public and that may incorporate private sector services such as paratransit or ride-sharing. The history of public transportation in the US has been shaped by many factors, including the Federal Aid Highway Act of 1956, also known as the National Interstate and Defense Highways Act, which emphasized the building of national highway networks. This legislation, along with the increasing availability and popularity of cars, contributed to a diminished public transportation infrastructure by shifting homes and jobs away from central urban areas to the suburbs by the early 1960s. This interstate highway system disproportionately cut through communities of color, contributing to the racial and economic segregation of cities and concentrated poverty that persist today. This brief’s primary focus is the relationship between urban public transportation and health and health equity. Access to public transportation in rural settings, although critical for health and well-being, is not addressed here because of distinct considerations such as longer distances traveled and lower population density. In addition, although private sector services, such as ride-sharing, are incorporated into some public transportation systems and can help meet certain needs, this brief is primarily concerned with the potential health and health equity impacts of urban public mass transportation on individuals and communities. This brief also highlights policy and practice interventions that may help states and municipalities better align urban public transportation and public health goals. A large and growing body of research indicates that access to public transportation can have important effects on both health and health equity. An important pathway by which public transportation improves health is through reductions in vehicle miles traveled, resulting in reduced motor vehicle crashes and reduced air pollution. Motor vehicle crashes are a leading cause of injury-related death for many age groups. More driving also contributes to more motor vehicle–related emissions, which add substantially to air pollution. Air pollution can increase cancer risk and can contribute to neurological, cardiovascular, respiratory, reproductive, and immune system damage. Most of these impacts disproportionately harm people of color and those in lower-income communities, who are more likely to be exposed to traffic and traffic-related air pollution and to live near high-polluting corridors and highways. Public transportation systems have been associated with reductions in motor vehicle crashes and significantly lower emissions per passenger mile compared with single-occupancy vehicles, although increased use of energy-efficient vehicles and other new technologies may change this calculus in the future. Public transportation may also affect health more indirectly by providing access to health-promoting services and supports, including health care itself; research has shown that lack of transportation in general can result in missed or delayed health care appointments, poorer health outcomes, and increased health expenditures. Inadequate public transportation can also increase social isolation, particularly for older populations and people with disabilities or others who do not drive. This can increase the risk for early mortality, depression, and dementia. In contrast, access to reliable public transportation can improve access to healthier food, vital services, employment, and recreational opportunities, all of which are important for health and well-being. Access to reliable public transportation also promotes physical activity when people walk to and from transit stops. Regular physical activity helps reduce the risk of developing diabetes, metabolic syndrome, heart disease, and stroke. Although chronic diseases such as these are prevalent throughout the US, low-income communities and communities of color are disproportionately affected by them.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Public transportations improve personal health

U.S. Department of Transportation NO DATE (“Expand Public Transportation Systems and Offer Incentives,” U.S. Department of Transportation https://www.transportation.gov/mission/health/Expand-Public-Transportation-Systems-and-Offer-Incentives)

Public transportation can include buses, trains, trams, trolleys, ferries, paratransit, or rapid public transportation systems. Investments in public transportation have potential traffic safety, air quality, active transportation, and accessibility benefits, thus improving associated personal health outcomes. Public transportation has substantially lower crash rates and lower crash severity than automotive travel. A 2014 study found that public transportation travel has less than half the total death rate as automobile travel per passenger mile, and public transportation passengers have about one-tenth the fatality rate per mile as automobile passengers (Litman, 2014). Public transportation uses less fuel and produces lower levels of carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOC), and carbon dioxide (CO2) per passenger mile relative to private vehicles. Public transportation also influences health because most public transportation users walk or bicycle to access public transportation. A 2005 study found that 29% of respondents to the 2001 National Household Travel Survey were able to achieve 30 minutes or more of daily exercise through walking to or from public transportation. A 2013 study noted that from 2001 to 2009, the estimated number of public transportation walkers whose public transportation-associated walking time was 30 minutes or more increased 31%, from approximately 2.6 million to 3.4 million. For older adults and persons with disabilities, paratransit services provide vital links to reaching medical and other essential services. The cost of public transportation is often lower than the costs associated with other forms of transportation (e.g., personal vehicles). Another way to expand public transportation use is to fund and improve public transportation station area planning, to ensure that it is integrated with active transportation modes and infrastructure (e.g., bicycle-sharing stations) and public transportation-oriented development. To encourage the use of public transportation, incentives may be offered to help reduce the cost to the user, including free or discounted bus, rail, or public transportation passes. Other incentives include employer-provided subsidies, reimbursements, partial payments, or pre-tax payroll reductions. Such incentives have been shown to increase public transportation use, and use of active travel options such as walking and bicycling, particularly among college students.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Public transportation can save huge amounts of carbon emissions.

Pei 23 – Senior Communications analysis from UCLA; 5 Environmental benefits of sustainable transportation. (February 28). Transportation. https://transportation.ucla.edu/blog/5-environmental-benefits-sustainable-transportation

Every vehicle on the road releases an average of one pound of CO2 per mile driven. Compared with driving alone, taking public transportation reduces CO2 emissions by 45%, decreasing pollutants in the atmosphere and improving air quality. It's estimated that public transportation in the U.S. saves 37 million metric tons of carbon dioxide annually, and even moderate increases in bicycle use each year could save an estimated 6 to 14 million tons .

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › Transportation Good

Transport is key to the labor market and job security.

Rodrigue and Notteboom ’20 [Jean-Paul, PhD in transport geography, Canadian scholar of transport geography; Theo, Foreign Expert/Professor at the Transportation Management College of Dalian Maritime University in China; “The Geography of Transport Systems” ; acc 7/24/2023 EB]

Contemporary trends have underlined that economic development has become less dependent on relations with the environment (resources) and more dependent on relations across space. While resources remain the foundation of economic activities, the commodification of the economy has been linked with higher levels of material flows. Concomitantly, resources, capital, and even labor have shown increasing levels of mobility. This is particularly the case for multinational firms that can  in two significant markets: Commodity market. Improvements in the efficiency with which firms have access to raw materials and parts as well as to their respective customers. Thus, transportation expands opportunities to acquire and sell a variety of commodities necessary for industrial and manufacturing systems. Labor market. Improvements in access to labor and a reduction in access costs, mainly by improved commuting (local scale) or the use of lower-cost labor (global scale). Transportation provides market accessibility by linking producers and consumers so that transactions can occur. A common fallacy in assessing the importance and impact of transportation on the economy is to focus only on transportation costs, which tend to be relatively low; in the range of 5 to 10% of the value of a good. Transportation is an economic factor of production of goods and services, implying that it is fundamental in their generation, even if it accounts for a small share of input costs. This means that irrespective of the cost, an activity cannot take place without the transportation factor and the mobility it provides. Thus, relatively small transport costs, capacity, and performance changes can substantially impact dependent economic activities. An efficient transport system with modern infrastructures favors many economic changes, most of them positive. The major impacts of transport on economic factors can be categorized as follows: . Improvements in transportation and communication favor a process of geographical specialization that increases productivity and spatial interactions. An economic entity tends to produce goods and services with the most appropriate combination of capital, labor, and raw materials. A region will thus tend to specialize in producing goods and services for which it has the greatest advantages (or the least disadvantages) compared to other regions as long as appropriate transport is available for trade. Through geographic specialization supported by efficient transportation, economic productivity is promoted. This process is known in economic theory as comparative advantages that have enabled the economic specialization of regions. Scale and scope of production. An efficient transport system offering cost, time, and reliability advantages enables goods to be transported over longer distances. This facilitates mass production through economies of scale because larger markets can be accessed. The concept of  in supply chain management has further expanded the productivity of production and distribution with benefits such as lower inventory levels and better responses to shifting market conditions. Thus, the more efficient transportation becomes, the larger the markets that can be serviced, and the larger the scale of production. This results in lower unit costs. Increased competition. When transport is efficient, the potential market for a given product (or service) increases, and so does competition. A wider array of goods and services becomes available to consumers through competition, reducing costs and promoting quality and innovation. Globalization has been associated with a competitive environment that spans the world and enables consumers to access a wider range of goods and services. Increased land value. Land adjacent or serviced by good transport services generally has greater value due to its utility. Consumers can have access to a wider range of services and retail goods. In contrast, residents can have better accessibility to employment, services, and social networks, all of which transcribes in higher land value. Irrespective of if used or not, the accessibility conveyed by transportation is impacting the land value. In some cases, due to the externalities they generate, transportation activities can lower land value, particularly for residential activities. Land located near airports and highways, near noise and pollution sources, will thus be impacted by corresponding diminishing land value. Transport also contributes to economic development through job creation and derived economic activities. Accordingly, many direct (freighters, managers, shippers) and indirect (insurance, finance, packaging, handling, travel agencies, transit operators) employment are associated with transport. Producers and consumers make economic decisions on products, markets, costs, location, prices, which are based on transport services, availability, costs, capacity, and reliability.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Extra S/L Key Transportation

State and local governments key to transportation.

Nunn, Parsons, and Shambaugh 2019

[Ryan Nunn, an assistant vice president for applied research in Community Development at the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Previously, he was a fellow in Economics Studies at the Brookings Institution and policy director for The Hamilton Project; Jana Parsons, a Research Analyst at The Hamilton Project. Previously she worked as a Research Economist at the Joint Economic Committee for Congress where she worked on health care, labor, and education policy; Jay Shambaugh, Under Secretary for International Affairs. In this position, his duties include helping to formulate Treasury’s international economic policies regarding the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, G7 and G20, exchange rate issues, climate policies and international financial regulation; “Nine facts about state and local policy”; Brookings; 1/31/19; https://www.brookings.edu/articles/nine-facts-about-state-and-local-policy/; accessed 7/23/23] CK

Policy debates often focus only on major decisions made in Washington, DC. But for many Americans, the decisions made much closer to home have just as large, if not larger, effects on day-to-day life. In important respects, the United States remains true to its original system of federalism: states and localities play a prominent role in setting policies that affect the economy more broadly. State and local government total expenditures amount to $2.9 trillion in the United States. While this is less than the federal government’s $4.3 trillion of expenditures, nearly two-thirds of federal total expenditures are transfers (either to individuals or state and local governments). This means that state and local governments have in some respects a more prominent role in decision-making than the federal government. Indeed, state and local governments make key investment decisions—about infrastructure, education, and many other areas—that help determine the long-run capacity of the entire economy. State and local governments also enact laws and regulations that define how economic activity takes place. These range from labor market rules to tax policy to environmental regulations to zoning rules. In addition, policymakers’ decisions about how to allocate resources—to education, transportation, or other public goods—are crucial to the U.S. economy. Although the federal government, either by law or by general practice, is required to do extensive analysis of the rules and regulations it makes, this is not always true at the state and local levels. The choices made across states—and sometimes local jurisdictions in the same state—often vary widely. For housing and transportation policy in particular, decisions made at the local level can have dramatic effects on how and where people choose to live and work. Mobility across states has declined sharply in the United States, and one reason appears to be that land-use restrictions in economically successful regions make it difficult for many workers to move to these locations. Similarly, transportation resources are not always efficiently allocated, making it more difficult for workers to access high-quality jobs. For the economy to grow and living standards to rise, it is crucial to have successful policy at all levels of government. A set of state and local policy proposals released in January 2019 is the latest in a series of efforts by The Hamilton Project to support broadly shared economic progress through the careful analysis of local, state, and federal policies. This document provides context for those policy proposals in the form of nine economic facts about how state and local policies matter for growth. These facts highlight how rigorous cost-benefit analysis, optimal transportation policy, and land-use rules can affect access to opportunity.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Transportation Impacts

International trade key to preventing war. Data proves.

Jackson and Nei ‘15[Mathew, Stephen, Department of Economics, Stanford University; Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), December 14; “Networks of military alliances, wars, and international trade”; ; acc 7/24/2023 EB]

To gain insight into the relationship between networks of alliances and the incidence of wars, we model the incentives of countries to attack each other, to form alliances, and to trade with each other. We first define a concept of networks that are stable against wars from a military point of view, when trade is ignored. We show that there are no (nonempty) networks of alliances that are stable, where stability requires that no country be vulnerable to defeat accounting for offensive and defensive alliances, and no country wants to add or drop alliances. This instability is suggestive of the shifting alliances and recurring wars of the 19th and first half of the 20th centuries. Wars, however, have greatly subsided in parallel with the huge increase of trade, trends that we discuss in detail below. We thus enrich the base model to include international trade, introducing a concept of a network of alliances being war-and-trade-stable, which allows countries to form alliances for either economic or military considerations. This enables the existence of networks of alliances that are stable against conflict and the addition or deletion of alliances. Trade helps in two ways: First, it provides economic motivations to maintain alliances, and the resulting denser network has a deterrent effect; second, it reduces the incentives of a country to attack trading partners. This reduces the potential set of conflicts and allows for a rich family of stable networks that can exhibit structures similar to modern trade and alliance networks. In examining the data, we find that an increase in the number of a country’s allies correlates with a lower frequency with which it is attacked, and increasing trade between two countries correlates with a lower frequency of conflict between them. We discuss below how the model fits with, and sheds light on, other data and theories, such as the advent of nuclear weapons, the Cold War, and the increase in the number of democracies. Our analysis fits firmly into the “rationalist” tradition based on cost and benefit analyses, with roots in ref. . To our knowledge, there are no previous models of conflict that game-theoretically model networks of alliances between multiple agents/countries based on costs and benefits of wars. There are previous models of coalitions in conflict settings (e.g., see ref.  for a survey). Here, network structures add several things to the picture. Our model examines group conflict (e.g., ref. ) but enriches it to admit network structures of alliances and of international trade. This allows us to admit patterns that are consistent with the networks of alliances that are actually observed, which are far from being partitions, moving the models toward matching observed patterns of wars, trade, and alliances. Moreover, as we see below both empirically and theoretically, the patterns and number of partners of a given country matter beyond group membership or overall levels of interaction. Finally, our model illuminates the relationships between international trade, stable network structures, and peace, something not appearing in the previous literature—because the previous literature that involves international trade and conflict generally revolves around bilateral reasoning or focuses on instability and armament (e.g., ref. ) and does not address the questions that we address here. The complex relationship between trade and conflict is also the subject of an active empirical literature (e.g., refs. –). The complex correlations between conflict and trade are illuminated by a model that provides structure with which to interpret some of the observations.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Transportation Impacts

Domestic trade is key to international trade.

Xie, et al ’17 [Lijuan, Shixun, and Xiaodong, School of business, Renmin University of China; Frontiers of Business Research in China, September 26; “The effect of domestic and foreign trade coordination on technological innovation: complements or substitutes?”; ; acc 7/24/2023 EB]

Foreign trade provides a broader market of raw materials and commodities for local enterprises. This makes it possible for them to allocate resources on a global scale, purchase overseas production factors with higher quality and gain markets with more extensive commodities. Generally speaking, foreign trade not only provides more convenient conditions for enterprises to carry out innovative activities, but also stimulates enterprises to obtain higher profit through continuous technological innovation. Limited by capital, talent and other factors, however, some domestic enterprises fail to enter international markets independently. In addition, the search and transaction costs to gain access to overseas resources are higher. Under this circumstance, domestic trade can act as a business synthesizer to connect domestic and foreign markets by virtue of advantages in information, services, logistics, etc. Compared to overseas markets, dominating enterprises in the field of domestic trade have a better knowledge of the demand and products in the domestic market. On the basis of this, enterprises can further access international markets and resources through other major international trade enterprises and build the bridge of “re-intermediary” between domestic and foreign markets. These enterprises can also directly engage in international trade activities and provide service support for domestic enterprises to get involved in international trade. In other words, developed domestic trade will enable international markets and resources to better integrate into the value chain of local enterprises.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Transportation Impacts

Transportation is key to domestic trade.

Rodrigue and Notteboom ’20 [Jean-Paul, PhD in transport geography, Canadian scholar of transport geography; Theo, Foreign Expert/Professor at the Transportation Management College of Dalian Maritime University in China; “The Geography of Transport Systems” ; acc 7/24/2023 EB]

The development of transportation systems takes place in a socioeconomic context. While development policies and strategies focus on physical capital, recent years have seen a better balance by including human capital issues. Irrespective of the relative importance of physical versus human capital, development cannot occur without their respective interactions, as infrastructures cannot remain effective without proper management, operations, and maintenance. At the same time, economic activities cannot take place without an infrastructure base. The highly transactional and service-oriented functions of many transport activities underline the complex relationship between its physical and human capital needs. For instance, effective logistics rely on infrastructures and managerial expertise. Because of its intensive use of infrastructures, the transport sector is an important component of the economy and a common tool used for development. This is even more so in a global economy where economic opportunities have been increasingly related to the mobility of people and freight, including information and communication technologies. A relation between the quantity and quality of transport infrastructure and the level of economic development is apparent. High-density transport infrastructure and highly connected networks are commonly associated with high levels of development. When transport systems are efficient, they provide economic and social opportunities and benefits that result in positive multiplier effects, such as better accessibility to markets, employment, and additional investments. When transport systems are deficient in terms of capacity or reliability, they can have an economic cost, such as reduced or missed opportunities and lower quality of life. At the aggregate level, efficient transportation reduces costs in many economic sectors, while inefficient transportation increases these costs. Besides, the impacts of transportation are not always intended and can have unforeseen or unintended consequences. For instance, congestion is often an unintended consequence of providing users with free or low-cost transport infrastructure. However, congestion also indicates a growing economy where capacity and infrastructure have difficulties keeping up with the rising mobility demands. Transport carries an important social and environmental load, which cannot be neglected.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Impact Modules › 2NC --- Transportation Impacts

State and local governments key to transportation, and other crucial services.

White House No Date [White House; The White House; “State and Local Government” ; https://www.whitehouse.gov/about-the-white-house/our-government/state-local-government/ ; acc 7/23/2023 EB]

Powers not granted to the Federal government are reserved for States and the people, which are divided between State and local governments. Most Americans have more frequent contact with their State and local governments than with the Federal Government. Police departments, libraries, and schools—not to mention driver’s licenses and parking tickets—usually fall under the oversight of State and local governments. Each state has its own written constitution, and these documents are often far more elaborate than their Federal counterpart. The Alabama Constitution, for example, contains 310,296 words—more than 40 times as many as the U.S. Constitution. All State governments are modeled after the Federal Government and consist of three branches: executive, legislative, and judicial. The U.S. Constitution mandates that all States uphold a “republican form” of government, although the three-branch structure is not required. Executive Branch In every state, the Executive Branch is headed by a governor who is directly elected by the people. In most states, other leaders in the executive branch are also directly elected, including the lieutenant governor, the attorney general, the secretary of state, and auditors and commissioners. States reserve the right to organize in any way, so they often vary greatly with regard to executive structure. Legislative Branch All 50 States have legislatures made up of elected representatives, who consider matters brought forth by the governor or introduced by its members to create legislation that becomes law. The legislature also approves a State’s budget and initiates tax legislation and articles of impeachment. The latter is part of a system of checks and balances among the three branches of government that mirrors the Federal system and prevents any branch from abusing its power. Except for one State, Nebraska, all States have a bicameral legislature made up of two chambers: a smaller upper house and a larger lower house. Together the two chambers make State laws and fulfill other governing responsibilities. (Nebraska is the lone state that has just one chamber in its legislature.) The smaller upper chamber is always called the Senate, and its members generally serve longer terms, usually four years. The larger lower chamber is most often called the House of Representatives, but some states call it the Assembly or the House of Delegates. Its members usually serve shorter terms, often two years. Judicial Branch State judicial branches are usually led by the State supreme court, which hears appeals from lower-level State courts. Court structures and judicial appointments/elections are determined either by legislation or the State constitution. The supreme court focuses on correcting errors made in lower courts and therefore holds no trials. Rulings made in State supreme courts are normally binding; however, when questions are raised regarding consistency with the U.S. Constitution, matters may be appealed directly to the United States Supreme Court. Local Government Local governments generally include two tiers: counties, also known as boroughs in Alaska and parishes in Louisiana, and municipalities, or cities/towns. In some States, counties are divided into townships. Municipalities can be structured in many ways, as defined by State constitutions, and are called, variously, townships, villages, boroughs, cities, or towns. Various kinds of districts also provide functions in local government outside county or municipal boundaries, such as school districts or fire protection districts. Municipal governments—those defined as cities, towns, boroughs (except in Alaska), villages, and townships—are generally organized around a population center and in most cases correspond to the geographical designations used by the United States Census Bureau for reporting of housing and population statistics. Municipalities vary greatly in size, from the millions of residents of New York City and Los Angeles to the few hundred people who live in Jenkins, Minnesota. Municipalities generally take responsibility for parks and recreation services, police and fire departments, housing services, emergency medical services, municipal courts, transportation services (including public transportation), and public works (streets, sewers, snow removal, signage, and so forth). Whereas the Federal Government and State governments share power in countless ways, a local government must be granted power by the State. In general, mayors, city councils, and other governing bodies are directly elected by the people.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Links › Trade-Off Link

The job guarantee forces state and local governments to replace their workforces.

Sturgess ’16 [Hugh, honors thesis for Bachelor’s degree in Political, Economic, and Social sciences; University of Sydney, October 12, “Would a Job Guarantee Guarantee Jobs?” ; acc 7/24/23 EB]

Forstater (2005: 252) enjoins critics of the JG to remember “the zoos, theatres, public buildings, parks, drainage systems, schools, and bridges built or repaired […] and the art, drama, oral histories, music, day care, school lunches, archeological and historical preservation” provided by the New Deal work programs. A JG, he argues, could provide the same services. There are two clear problems with this argument. Firstly, all these projects require planning and preparation that could not depend on the fluctuations of the broader labour market, and so could not be JG jobs. One cannot leave a school half-built because the workers have been offered higher paying jobs at (say) a fast food outlet. Secondly, the public sector already does all of these things, and much else besides. Many of our social needs are not currently neglected entirely but rather in degree. Public works, environmental schemes, infrastructure, the arts, education, health care, social care, and so on are provided by the government or the market, however inadequately. It seems perverse to respond to an under-provision of physical, social and cultural infrastructure by establishing an entirely different form of public-sector labour - the JG - that would use under-skilled, under-paid workers instead of well-paid and -trained workers. 50 If there is no clear distinction between the work done by the JG and that done by the mainline public sector, JG workers pose a significant threat to the employment, wages and conditions of better-paid, secure public-sector workers. As Seccareccia (2004: 33) notes, in periods of state retrenchment, there would be an enormous incentive for state and local governments to substitute low-wage JG workers for (relatively) high-wage and often organised permanent public servants. This is not a hypothetical concern. As noted in Chapter 2, anecdotal evidence suggests that some local governments substituted Jefas and WPA workers for regular public employees. During the Global Financial Crisis, states such as New South Wales and Victoria responded to the federal government’s social housing construction program by cutting their own funding for social housing, effectively shifting the cost of construction to the Commonwealth (ABS, 2012). The fact that JG workers would be paid for by the federal government but employed by third parties would be a powerful incentive for those third parties (such as state and local governments) to replace their workforces.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Links › Displacement

A job guarantee would replace existing public sector.

CEPR, 5-17-2018, ("More Thoughts on a Job Guarantee: What Is At Issue?," Center for Economic and Policy Research, https://cepr.net/more-thoughts-on-a-job-guarantee-what-is-at-issue/)

Jared Bernstein and I had a  earlier this week discussing the problems that a government job guarantee would address along with some of the problems which make us reluctant to endorse one. I thought it would be useful to summarize the four areas in which we have serious concerns about the economic response: 1) The number of people currently employed who would opt for a guaranteed job. Proponents of a guarantee argue that most private sector employers would improve their wage and benefit package to match the terms offered by a guaranteed job. Given the large portion of the workforce who stand to gain from a job with the terms being proposed ($15 an hour wage, plus genenefits), it isrous health care and other be possible that tens of millions of workers may see a guaranteed job as better than those on offer in the private sector. 2) The ability of the government to effectively manage a jump in the size of its workforce by at least 10 million and quite possibly two or three times this size. The issue here is whether the people doing jobs provided through the guarantee are actually doing useful work. This is not just a moral concern that people work for their pay. It will be pretty much impossible to maintain political support for a job guarantee if people employed under the program routinely come to work late, leave early, or don’t show up at all, or alternatively sit around and do nothing when they are ostensibly employed. Since by definition many of these people will have little work experience, the task will be even harder. 3) The ability to find employment that does not displace existing public or private sector employment. If the guaranteed jobs duplicate work already being done by workers in either the public or private sector, it will not, on net, create jobs. Rather, it will displace workers currently being employed. This is likely to be an especially big problem in the public sector, where state and local governments may see workers employed through the program as a way to replace higher cost public sector employees. For example, if workers in the program provide child care, they may displace workers already employed by the government doing child care. It is inevitable that some amount of work in a jobs program be duplicative, but the question is whether this amount is closer to 5–10 percent, in which case it should be manageable, or more like 70–80 percent, in which case it would be a very serious problem. The larger the program, the more serious a problem this becomes, both because it matters less with a small program and it is more difficult to find useful work for 30 million people than 10 million people. 4) The impact of the program on inflation and cost structures in the private economy. The point of the program is to guarantee all workers a decent standard of living. This will put a much higher floor on wages than is now the case. That will mean that it costs much more to go to restaurants or have your hair cut. If people want to hire someone to clean their house, mow their lawn, or look after their kids, they will have to pay considerably more than they do today. That is not a bad thing. But if the people who purchase a large amount of goods and services that depend on low-wage labor are able to push up their own pay to cover these higher costs, then we could see serious problems with inflation. These are the four areas where I see serious issues created by a guaranteed jobs program. As Jared and I argued in our piece, various experimental programs now being proposed should provide us more insights on these issues.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Uniqueness › AT: State Jobs low

2022 Data is invalid due to 48,000 worker strike in California during reporting period.

DePillis, 2023 (Lydia, U.S. Added 223,000 Jobs in December, a Slight Easing in Pace, New York Times, Jan 6, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/06/business/economy/jobs-report-december-2022.html)

December’s gains were driven by strong hiring in leisure and hospitality, which added 67,000 jobs, and health care, with 55,000. State government employment would have been significantly higher if not for a strike by 48,000 workers at the University of California. Even sectors that had been wobbling, such as retail, manufacturing, transportation and warehousing, eked out small increases.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Uniqueness › Trend (USBLS)

State and Local Jobs increasing – Best Data.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 7/7/2023 (Economic News Release, Employment Situation Summary, https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm)

Employment in government increased by 60,000 in June. Employment continued to trend up in state government (+27,000) and local government (+32,000). Overall, government has added an average of 63,000 jobs per month thus far in 2023, more than twice the average of 23,000 per month in 2022. However, government employment is below its pre-pandemic February 2020 level by 161,000, or 0.7 percent.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
JRY – State/Local Govt DA › Uniqueness › Slow Growth Now

State and Local Governments on the brink now --- growing but lagging behind other industries in job fulfillment.

Mast, and Perez 2023 (Nina, Daniel, Historic job growth in 2022 reflects strong but uneven economic recovery, Economic Policy Institute, https://www.epi.org/blog/historic-job-growth-in-2022-reflects-strong-but-uneven-economic-recovery-state-and-local-lawmakers-should-prioritize-rebuilding-the-public-sector-in-2023/)

Meanwhile, the public sector has seen much slower progress. State and local government employment is still 2.3% below pre-pandemic levels as state agencies, school districts, and local governments have struggled to fill vacancies—a result of low pay, cuts to benefits, increasing demands, and other factors. More than half of the remaining jobs shortfall is in public education jobs, a long-standing shortage exacerbated by the pandemic. Since February 2020, only four states and D.C. have fully restaffed state and local government jobs—Idaho (+2.1%), D.C. (+1.7%), North Dakota (+0.7%), Oregon (+0.2%), and Maryland (+0.2%). Meanwhile, large public-sector jobs losses have occurred in several states, with New Hampshire (-8.3%), West Virginia (-7.2%), Hawaii (-6.9%), Louisiana (-6.9%), and Ohio (-5.8%) having the largest percentage declines. State and local government employment saw very slow growth in 2022 Over the past year, specifically, state and local government employment has grown modestly but still lags private-sector job growth. Between December 2021 and December 2022, total nonfarm employment grew by 3.0%, driven mainly by employment gains in the leisure and hospitality (6.3%) and education and health (4.0%) industries. However, state and local government employment grew by only 1.6% over that period. Figure A illustrates year-over-year job growth across all 50 states and D.C., with special attention paid to professional and business services, leisure and hospitality, and state and local government. In leisure and hospitality, employment grew by more than 10% in D.C. (14.0%), Texas (11.3%), Hawaii (11.0%), and New Jersey (10.4%), but shrank by 0.5% in Alabama and Rhode Island. The South and West regions experienced the largest employment gains in 2022. Texas (5.0%), Florida (4.8%), Oregon (4.2%), and North Carolina (4.1%) saw the largest increases in total nonfarm employment over the year. In Texas, Florida, and North Carolina, employment growth was highest in leisure and hospitality, while in Oregon, leisure and hospitality growth was second only to construction. Oregon was the lone standout for state and local government employment growth in 2022 (5.3%)—no other state surpassed 4% growth and two states saw declines (Mississippi and Montana).